Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1984 07-10 CC MINBook 64 Page 201 MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA JULY 10, 1984 The regular meeting of the City Council of the City of National City was called to order at 7:00 p.m. by Mayor Morgan. ROLL CALL Council members present: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters, Morgan. Absent: None. Administrative officials present: Bolint, Campbell, McCabe, McLean, Acting City Engineer Onley, Post. SALUTE TO THE FLAG AND INVOCATION The meeting was opened with salute to the flag led by City Manager McCabe, followed with invocation by City Manager McCabe. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Moved by Cooper, seconded by Van Deventer, the minutes of the regu1 t_ meetinc of J)Ane 26, 1984 and July 3, 1984 be approved. Carried by t..il=a:.im: us vote. PU}3T.IC ORAL COMMUNICATIONS H ROLD REYNOLDS, 635 1st St., was present and said their Neighborhood Watch signs are outdated; calling 911 or 474-5511, the response is of no value; he tries to keep the premises at 2nd & Highland in a respectable way, but people come in and break the hose and try to steal things; two weeks ago a Police Officer driving car number 18 responded 45 minutes after his (H. Reynold's) call; about midnight on July 4 at the old Safeway store (303 Highland), he saw cars parked with the hood and trunk open; he spoke to the people and asked a nieghbor to call the Police; the dispatcher said she could not help because the person who called was not the victim; no one came by; a Reserve Officer named George goes through the rubbish containers; the officer said "I'm a cop, I can pick up stuff when I want to."; the house at 625 E. 2nd St. was broken into; the owner needed a police report for his insurance company; no investigation was ever done; they are not getting any protection from the Police. Mayor Morgan asked City Manager McCabe to have the Police Chief contact Mr. Reynolds and take these complaints. PUBLIC HEARINGS The PUBLIC HEARING on APPEAL of PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVAL of PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMIT to ALLOW a SHOPPING CENTER consisting of two fast-- food drive-thru restaurants (4,400 sq. ft.) and 26,600 sq. ft. of retail and restaurant space on 2.76 acres at the SE corner of Plaza Blvd. and Grove St., Case File No. PD-2-84 (This Planned Development Permit is for a commercial center consisting of 2 fast-food, drive- thru restaurants rPopeye's Famous Fried Chicken and Del Taco], one containing a floor area of 2,400 sq. ft. and the other 2,000 sq. ft.; a commercial retail shop building with a floor area of 20,600 sq. ft. and 2 sit-down type restaurants, each containing 3,000 sq. ft.; a total of 31,000 sq. ft. of building floor area is proposed in 3 buildings on the 2.76 acre property; [See Document No. 70678]; staff recommends the project be re -designed to eliminate the proposed fast-food restaurants) was held at this time. The City Clerk reported the Certificate of Publication and Affidavit of Mailing were on file. Planning Director Post said there is a condition, as a result of a traffic study, suggesting a traffic light be installed at Grove and Plaza; there is a condition requiring a contribution from the developer of 50%; 20% will be borne by the new motel project and the remaining 30% by the City; revised conditions were submitted by the Engineering Dept.; the Planning Commission voted to approve the project as currently re- designed. The City Clerk read into the record a letter of protest from 7/10/84 Geraldine Scherkenbach: Ju]y 5, 1984 Re: Public Hearing July 10, 1984 Book 64 Page 202 "I am unable to be at this meeting on this date, so I'm writing a letter to object strongly to another commercial development eating up more of the residential area of National City. More & more people are calling it "Nasty City" because of commercial and residential intermingling. Stop before it's too late. (s) Geraldine Scherkenbach 2336 E. 13th St. National City, CA" CHUCK YABLON, 225 Stevens Ave., Solana Beach and JEFF LUBIN, 2333 Highland Ave., developers for this project, were present and displayed renderings <7.4.7 the proposed project. Mr. Yablon said they have made every of `cr ±: :.a meet the requirements of the various departments in the the elected officials in making this center an asset to the axea: they brought in an award -winning architect, and have tried for a Ss::'post Village flavor; they have agreed to provide a tremendous amount of C y improvements; they are confident about the potential for su crass of this center. DICK WILLIAMS, 539 Encinitas Blvd., Encinitas, (M Information Systems) was present and explained their site loc'e.tion research for large corporations and chain retailers, their feasibility study of this project which included the trade area (3 mile.radius from Grove & Plaza), the traffic flow, traffic problems, accessibility problems, quantity and quality of residential areas, potential sources of places of business etc.; from this they developed a primary trade area; the bulk of the business for the fast-food restaurants will come from this primary trade area. Mr. Williams displayed maps indicating the primary trade areas for Popeye's Famous Fried Chicken and Del Taco, and said the primary trade area for both restaurants is East of 1-805. Discussion. Vice Mayor Waters said he is concerned about the traffic signal; he would like to see it go in ahead of the construction; when the McDonald's project was approved, there was no stipulation that they would share the cost of a signal if a problem was created; the developer of the motel project agreed to pay 20% of the cost of the traffic signal; the people in the neighborhood have to put up with a certain amount of problems from the project and those same people should not have to pay for the signal when the problems are created by the businesses. Mr. Waters inquired if there was any way McDonald's could be required to pay part of the cost of the traffic signal. City Attorney McLean said it's too late to go back and change McDonald's CUP to add a traffic signal fee, so the cost of the signal, as far as putting it on to developers, would have to be done from this moment forward; the amount put cnto this project, the motel project, and how much the City pays is a matter for Council's judgment; if Council finds that the fact of this development is causing the necessity for putting in the light, they are free to charge the cost of the signal against the project(s) they feel are responsible for the necessity; there is no obligation for the City to make a financial contribution. Discussion re maintaining the landscaping. Mr. Lubin said they plan on landscaping and irrigating and entering into an agreement to maintain it for an indefinite period of time. Discussion. Planning Director Post said a possibility might be to bring some sort of a bonding situation to cover the landscaping. Further discussion. City Attorney McLean said the jute matting is an interim measure to be sure that the bank stays stable while the plants are taking hold, not in lieu of planting; our present Ordinances require the maintenance of required landscaping. Discussion re a Covenant Running With the Land. 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 203 Mr. McLean continued, his recommendation is, to meet the concern Council is expressing, they should add to condition 16 that the developers will enter into the agreements and covenants required by the City to ensure permanent landscaping maintenance. Discussion re the signs. M. A. CLOUGH, JR., 1431 Grove, was present and said his home is about 300' from McDonald's; when they go to bed at night, they have to pull all their drapes because of McDonald's light; it lights up his whole backyard; if parking becomes a problem, will the City charge them $5.00 to park in front of their homes (sticker parking); McDonald's is now cleaning up their trash to a certain point; density in the City is getting to be too much; the City is going business mad. Discussion re a cul-de-sac on Grove St. Councilman Cooper said Council waived the fees for parking permits in the area Mr. Clough spoke of. Further discussion. GARY FARIS, 1417 Grove, was present and said he would not speak in favor of or against this project; the developers have been willing to listen; he attended the Planning Commission hearing and discussed closing times; the developer has agreed to align them with McDonald's; he thought there was an agreement that the traffic signal would be in and operating before any business opened its doors; none of the property owners are in favor of the cul-de-sac. CHUCK YABLON returned to the podium and said they have no problem with saying the traffic signal would be operational before they open for business; they would have a problem having it operational before construction is started. Discussion re making the hours of operation consistent with those of McDonald's. JEFF LUBIN returned to the podium and said they would sign an agreement that the fast-food restaurants will operate the same hours as McDonald's. Discussion re exit and entrance from Plaza. BOB ZACHARIAS, 2325 E. 14th St., was present and said he looked at the plans at the Planning Commission meeting; in the plans there were targeted spots in this shopping center for 14-18 establishments; among those was a liquor license; have liquor licenses been brought up? Mr. Lubin said there would not be any type of bar operation; the businesses listed on the drawings were possibilities and not the real tenants. Further discussion. No one else was present to speak in this regard. Moved by Van Deventer, seconded by Cooper, the Public Hearing be closed, and the CUP approved subject to all conditions, including condition #26, the operating hours to be the same as McDonald's. Councilman Dalla commended the proponents for their cooperation and willingness to deal with all of the problems, and said it's unfortunate that we have a site that fronts on a major freeway and a major arterial that cannot be economically viable without increasing the number of fast-food places. Motion carried, by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Van Deventer, Waters. Nays: Dalla. Abstaining: Morgan. Councilman Van Deventer said we need to look at the total fast-food approach in the City; if we're going to make areas off limits for fast-food restaurants, we need to be able to state this up front. Discussion. Councilman Cooper commended the developers for all the improvements they are putting in. The PUBLIC HEARING on APPEAL of PLANNIPG COMMISSION'S APPROVAL of CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 1984-5 at the Northwest corner of 19th Street and Cleveland Avenue to ALLOW a MOTOR VEHICLE STORAGE LOT, Applicant: Triad Marine (On June 12, 1984, Council appealed a Planning Commission Notice of Decision approving CUP to allow a motor vehicle storage lot, limited to those vehicles owned and/or operated by Triad Marine and their employees at the NW corner of 19th St. and Cleveland Ave.; during Council discussion, concern was voiced regarding the type of view - obscuring enclosure to be used and the number of auto storage lots that have been approved with perimeter fencing of chain link with slats [See Document No. 70679]; staff recommends approval subject to a modification of condition number 2) was held at this time. The City Clerk reported the Certificate of Publication and Affidavit of Mailing were on file. Planning Director Post said the Planning Commission recommends approval; staff is recommending modification of one 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 204 condition: instead of going with the decomposed granite (gravel) with oil on top, there be a permanent surfacing, either asphalt or concrete. LARRY CAIRNCROSS (Triad Marine), 1668 National Ave., San Diego, was present and said Triad Marine is the tenant; Cal -Doran has the property on a long-term lease; they thought they were doing what they were supposed to do and jumped the gun; they moved their vehicles onto this site before they had all the approvals they were supposed to have; they then moved them off until Council makes a decision tonight; he is requesting approval to use gravel and oil rather than pavement; the use is an interim use on a one-year lease that can be renewed for up to five years; Cal -Doran intends to eventually use this property themselves; the gravel and oil has already been done; paving would be very expensive; gravel and oil will withstand the weight of heavy vehicles better than pavement; they contemplated storing 15 large vehicles. Discussion. Planning Director Post said 19th & Cleveland is an industrial zone; this type of use is not a permitted use, but a conditional use in that area, requiring a CUP. Discussion re the fencing. Discussion. No one else came forward to speak in this regard. Moved by Waters, seconded by Dalla, the Public Hearing be closed, the CUP approved subject to the Planning Commission's conditions, and the lot be paved with asphalt. Discussion. RUDY ORTIZ, 2830 E. Washington Blvd., Los Angeles, was present and said Cal -Doran has had this property since the early 1950's; they rent it from Al Fessman, who recently raised the rent for the total parcel; his business is growing little by little and they needed the rental income from this small piece of the area they rent; paving with asphalt is about triple the cost of decomposed granite. Discussion. Motion carried by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters, Morgan. Nays: Cooper. Mayor Morgan called a recess at 8:25 p.m. Council reconvened at 8:30 p.m. ROLL CALL Council members present: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters, Morgan. Absent: None. ADOPTION OF RESOLUTIONS Moved by Cooper, seconded by Waters, the-. Resolutions be presented by title only. Carried by unanimous vote. Resolution No. 14,373, "RESOLUTION APPROVING ISSUANCE OF A DRIVEWAY SPECIAL PERMIT (1006 E. 23rd STREET - PENA)." Moved by Van Deventer, seconded by Cooper, Resolution No. 14,373 be adopted. Carried by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters. Nays: None. Abstaining: Morgan. Resolution No. 14,374, "RESOLUTION OF AWARD OF CONTRACT OF ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 222 (22ND STREET - PROSPECT STREET TO EUCLID AVENUE)." Moved by Waters, seconded by Dalla, Resolution No. 14,374 be adopted. Discussion. Carried by unanimous vote. Resolution No. 14,375, "Resolution establishing 'No Stopping Any Time zones' on the East side of 'I' Avenue from the curb return South to the first driveway and on the South side of 13th Street from 'I' Avenue East a distance of 25 feet." Moved by Cooper, seconded by Waters, Resolution No. 14,375 be opposed. Discussion re referring this back to the Traffic Safety Committee; the problem appears to be trucks and a boat trailer parked in the area. Moved by Dalla, seconded by Van Deventer, the motion be amended to include a specified amount (number of feet from corner) or refer this matter to the Engineering staff to find out how far back something that large would have to be in order to ensure an adequate sight distance and red curb that amount, 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 205 but not red curb the whole 25 feet. Discussion. Motion and amendment withdrawn. Moved by D111a, seconded by Van Deventer, this be referred to the Engineering staff to review the distance required to ensure safe sight distance on both legs of that intersection, and that the matter of the additional vehicles parked on that street be addressed. Moved by Cooper, seconded by Waters, the motion be amended to include while they are checking, the Business License Inspector be sent down to license those people who are operati u a business out of their home illegally. Amendment carried by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters. Nays: Morgan. Motion carried by unanimous vote. ORDINANCE FOR INTRODUCTION (FIRST READING) Moved by Van Deventer, seconded by Dalla, the Ordinance be presented by title only. Carried by unanimous vote. Ordinance No. 7/10/84-1, "Ordinance rezoning properties located between Rachael and Granger Avenues and from 18th Street to 20th Street, with the exception of the SE corner of 18th Street and Granger Avenue." ORDINANCE FOR ADOPTION Moved by Van Deventer, seconded by Dalla, the Ordinance be presented by title only. Carried by unanimous vote. Ordinance No. 1829 (7/3/84-1), "ORDINANCE AMENDING ORDINANCE NO. 1619 REGARDING APPOINTMENT TO COMMITTEE FOR HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT." Moved by Van Deventer, seconded by Waters, Ordinance No. 1829 (7/4/84-1) be adopted. Discussion. Carried, by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters. Nays: Morgan. NEW BUSINESS The Finance Director's request for RATIFICATION of WARRANT REGISTER NO. 1, dated July 3, 1984, in the amount of $137,586.84 (Warrants Nos. 84339 through 84374) was presented. Moved by Waters, seconded by Van Deventer, the bills be paid and warrants drawn. Carried, by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters, Morgan. Nays: None. The application for ON -SALE BEER AND WINE LICENSE, TYPE 41 of Craig A. MacDonald, James A. MacDonald and William R. Peavey, dba ROUND TABLE PIZZA, 1240 E. Plaza Blvd. (Building Dept. states no objections; Police Dept. recommends this license be protested on the grounds that National City Municipal Code Sections 18.16.141 and 18.16.142 require applicant to obtain a CUP; issuance of an alcoholic beverage license without an approved CUP would violate our local Ordinances; protest will be withdrawn if applicant obtains this CUP; Planning Dept. recommends protest until applicant obtains a CUP) was presented. Moved by Waters, seconded by Van Deventer, this license be protested and all stipulations of the Police Dept. be adhered to before the license is issued. Carried, by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters. Nays: None. Abstaining: Morgan. The application for ON -SALE BEER AND WINE LICENSE, TYPE 41 of Danny R. & Delia V. Ramos, dba BAYANIHAN RESTAURANT, 1479 Plaza Blvd. (Building Dept. states no objection; Police Dept. recommends this license be protested on the grounds that applicant must first acquire a CUP providing adequate information as to the means and methods applicant intends to operate his business; issuance of an alcoholic beverage license prior to issuance of a CUP would be in violation of local Ordinances; the Planning Dept. concurs with the objection of the Police Dept.) was presented. Moved by Dalla, seconded by Cooper, this license be protested on the basis of the Planning Department's and Police Department's recommendation re the CUP. Discussion re the need for applications to appear on the agenda when a CUP must be obtained. Motion carried by unanimous vote. 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 206 OTHER BUSINESS PLANNING COMMISSION - NOTICE OF DECISION Planning Commission Resolution No. 26-84 APPROVING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT to ALLOW CONSTRUCTION of a 4,000 sq. ft. AUTOMOTIVE REPAIR FACILITY on property located immediately West of 120 E. 16th St., CUP-1984-8 (...involves the proposed construction of a decorative block masonry building 18' in height, containing a total floor area of 4,000 sq. ft. on a 5,750 sq. ft. parcel; project site is presently vacant and located on the South side of 16th St. between 'B' Ave. and the alley East of National City Blvd., and between 2 properties, one of which is developed with a single -story, lawful non -conforming duplex, and the other, a parking lot serving a commercial building being used as a car club; proposed use is automotive repair; off-street parking [3 spaces] is provided specifically for that type of use; number of employees will be limited to a maximum of 6, or if a service vehicle is used in conjunction with the business, a maximum of 4 employees; Lecause of the number of parking spaces being provided, the use of this structure will be limited to automotive repair, automotive related type uses, warehousing and storage only; this project originally involved a building height of 21' and a parking area enclosed within sliding gates; pursuant to protest from the owner of the adjacent duplex, the Commission took action to require a maximum height of 18' and based on protest received from the Southport Christian Center, Four Square Church regarding access to parking, fencing or gates that will obstruct access to the parking lot are prohibited; staff concurs with the Planning Commission's approval) was presented. Moved by Waters, seconded by Cooper, in favor of this CUP. Discussion. Carried, by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Cooper, Dalla, Waters. Nays: Morgan. Abstaining: Van Deventer. CITY MANAGER The City Manager requested an Executive Session on Personnel on completion of the agenda. CITY ATTORNEY - No report. OTHER STAFF The City Clerk's report on OPENING of SEALED BIDS for STREET RESURFACING PROJECT, National City Blvd., Plaza Blvd., Division St. and 24th St., Engineering Spec. No. 945 (7 bids were received: Daly Corp. - $217,603.40; V. R. Dennis Construction - $230,674.40; R. E. Hazard - $243,446.85; Palomar Grading & Paving - $221,790.60; Sim J. Harris - $257,581.88; Asphalt, Inc. - $245,444.00; A.B.C. Construction Co. - $287,771.60; Engineer's estimate - $324,411.00) was presented. Questions were raised re the Engineer's estimate. Ordered filed by unanimous vote. MAYOR Mayor Morgan said he saw the report that the Personnel Director gave to the press on the firemen's raises; he never had seen any of the figures that were in the paper; he would like to look at the chart the Personnel Director prepared. Councilman Dalla said that would require a motion; that was an item considered in Executive Session; if Council was going to have that item here, there would have to be a motion; otherwise, he doesn't have to bring it in. Vice. Mayor Waters said what the Mayor is talking about is something Council already acted on. Councilman Van Deventer said there has to be a motion. Vice Mayor Waters said he thought that was made public already. Mayor Morgan said it was released to the press. Councilman Van Deventer asked the City Attorney to rule on this; relating to the fact this was done in Executive Session and was released to the press; can that be brought forward without a motion? City Attorney McLean said the content of Executive Sessions is contemplated to be and remain confidential; secondly, any time Council gets into a discussion of what happens in 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 207 Executive Session, they run the risk of waiving their claim of confidentiality; thirdly, the conduct of the City Council and its affairs is a matter for the Council to settle among themselves, and it's not something that the staff can regulate; he had a personal opinion about what's wise and unwise about the (disclosure of the) content of Executive Sessions, but it's not law; the law of these meetings is made by the City Council; the Government Code provides that a Council can adopt the rules regarding its own procedures, and that's up to Council to do; one way that Council adopts rules is from time to time by making motions that the majority of the Council is for or against; discussions of this type; a majority has to speak on making and adopting a proper motion. Mayor Morgan said if C uncil was worried about it, he would call the next order of business. Vice Mayor Waters said we have a case where Council acted on the fire, Council acted on the employees; Council approved it right here at a Council meeting; and asked if it was public property for anyone to go in and view. City Attorney McLean said No. Vice Mayor Waters said if that's the case, there is a point of order here. City Attorney McLean said without getting into the merits, right now we have a variety of lawsuits pend- ing; suppose that it's necessary for him to tell Council about the status of one of those cases (which he has done from time to time); so there is an Executive Session and he mikes his report, and he tells Council in his judgment it's necessary that Council spend $100,000 to hire some expert engineers from New York State to help; Council says "OK, if that's what has to be done, that's what Council has to do's; Council comes back in here and somebody makes a motion "I move that we approve the attorney's recommendation to hire Engineer Jones for $100,000" and it carries; by doing that, Council certainly has not opened up the discussion in the Executive Session concerning the City's legal affairs; going beyond that point and talking about bits and pieces of it, then maybe Council is opening itself up to inquiry. Councilman Cooper asked if the City Attorney was saying Council shouldn't put that chart up. City Attorney McLean said he was not telling Council what to do, he was, as Council's lawyer, advising what the legal boundaries are in short form; this is a question that governmental lawyers can wrestle with for a long, long time about where the privilege starts and ends; he was telling Council that they were playing with fire when they start bringing out a part of Executive Session thinking that everything else that they didn't want to talk about isn't going to be talked about. Councilman Van Deventer said he is concerned about what Mr. McLean is saying and also they have not dealt with the Police Dept. yet; Council has not finalized a budget for them, and to lay that out to public record would be totally improper, and he thinks any action should go in the form of a moticn. Councilman Cooper suggested the Personnel Director bring the chart into Executive Session tonight. Mayor Morgan said he has already seen that chart; he doesn't need to see it. Councilman Dalla inquired what the purpose is of doing it tonight. Mayor Morgan said he gave figures to the press that he (Mayor Morgan) had never seen. Vice Mayor Waters said it is a case where a member of Council read a newspaper about what took place in general and those figures (cited) are not the figures that he understood he was involved in; how would they have to straighten this out with the general public without exposing what took place in Executive Session; this is a case where figures were talked about and he hasn't even said that, or hasn't agreed on it, but yet he's quoted as saying so and so. City Attorney McLean said from the lawyer's point of view, and staying away from policy as much as he could because it's none of his business, he believes the present structure of the government of N.C. contemplates that Council would take the question up with the City Manager, who is the chief appointing authority; if Council were dissatisfied with the conduct of any employee under the direction of the City Manager; if Council was dissatisfied with the City Attorney, Council deals directly with him, or the City Manager; he believed the concept was Council starts with the Manager and 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 208 communicates to him their dissatisfaction with the behavior of any particular public employee, and there are procedures to deal with that which normally don't involve public decision. Councilman Dalla said this is an idea that wasn't thought out particularly well; there were on -going negotiations; the Mayor has achieved some success here, because it's going to appear to a lot of people that Council was afraid to reveal something; he (Councilman Dalla) is more willing to risk that ridicule than to risk the integrity of an Executive Session because Council needs that in order to function. CITY COUNCIL Councilman Van Deventer inquired if there was a limit to the number of cars a property owner can have on his property. Planning Director Post replied if they are parked on a paved surface, it is probably alright; the Code does not specify any number. Mayor Morgan requested he check out 1406 'K' Ave. Councilman Van Deventer said Council approved the PSI Steel project on 18th between Haffey and Cleveland and they were supposed to do landscaping, paving,•lights, etc.; this needs to be checked. Councilman Dalla said about 3 weeks ago a motion was made for the City Treasurer to come back with some procedures and guidelines for investments; he has written the City Treasurer a memo in this regard; he would like the City Clerk to communicate with the City Treasurer on behalf of the Council. Councilman Dalla said Council approved a temporary storage yard for NASSCO (SOCAL) and said he did not know who was using it, but it needed to be brought up to some standards. Councilman Dalla spoke of the West side, saying it was time to start looking at off-street parking in relation to the uses there; they are parking all over the street; the area is zoned industrial, but it is in transition and should be looked at. Moved by Dalla, seconded by Morgan, the Planning Director be directed to look into the requirements for off-street parking on the West side. Carried by unanimous vote. Mayor Morgan called an Executive Session for Personnel at 9:06 p.m. Council reconvened at 9:37 p.m. ROLL CALL Council members present: Cooper, Dalla, Van Deventer, Waters, Morgan. Absent: None. Moved by Waters, seconded by Van Deventer, the benefits and pay bands for mid -management and executives be approved as modified. Carried by unanimous vote. Mayor Morgan said he was not really sold on the bands. ADJOURNMENT Moved by Dalla, seconded by Waters, the meeting be adjourned to 4:00 p.m., July 17, 1984. Carried by unanimous vote. The meeting closed at 9:38 p.m. 7/10/84 Book 64 Page 209 The foregoing minutes were approved at the regular meeting of the City Council on July.17, 1984. Corrections No Corrections CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA 7/10/84