Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997 02-27 CC MINBook 79/Page 72 02/27/97 MINUTES OF THE ADJOURNED REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA FEBRUARY 27, 1997 The Adjourned Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of National City was called to order at 3:33 p.m. by Mayor Waters. ROLL CALL Council members present: Beauchamp, Inzunza, Zarate, Waters. Absent: Morrison. Administrative officials present: Bouse, Campbell, Dalla, Eiser, Hood, Kimble, Matienzo, McCabe, Morse, Myers, Post, Ruiz, DiCerchio, Williams. Councilman Morrison arrived in Council Chambers at 3:34 p.m. BUDGET (206-1-13) 1. SUBJECT: Financial Forecasting Workshop. Mayor Waters turned control of the meeting over to City Manager Tom McCabe to make some introductory remarks. City Manager McCabe emphasized that what the City Council would be looking at during the workshop would be a two-year financial forecast, not a budget, and not a financial plan. He explained that the difficulty with doing multi -year forecasting is that in the second year and beyond, there is no way of knowing or controlling what kinds of actions, outside the City itself, will impact the City. According to the City Manager, revenues are a critical element in developing the City's financial forecast. For that reason, the staff has researched the various revenue trends that have occurred in the past. Mr. McCabe cautioned that translating those trends into a revenue increase in the future is nothing more than a projection. Book 79/Page 73 02/27/97 The City Manager explained that the other element necessary to do a forecast is to develop some assumptions in order to have the same effect on all the years covered by the forecast. The staff has developed such assumptions, both positive and negative; general and specific. The normal assumptions that generally go into a forecasting session, according to City Manager McCabe, are current expenditures, such as supplies, fuel, utilities, etc.; and compensation, which includes staffing, salaries, benefits and intergovernmental issues, such as grants and inflation. In preparing the current forecast the following assumptions were made: General Assumptions 1. The economy is slowly rebounding. 2. Inflation will be 3% for 1997-98 and 3% for 1998-99. 3. The State will not further reduce or increase City revenues. 4. A prudent fund balance is a tool for good financial planning. Fund balance should not drop below 5% of the annual expenditure plan. 5. General Fund revenue will have to be allocated to continue grant programs when Federal or State funding terminate. Revenue Assumptions 1. Property tax revenues are projected to increase 2% in 1997-98 and 2% in 1998-99. 2. Sales tax revenue is projected to increase in future years based on data provided by the State Board of Equalization by 4.9% in 1997-98 and 4.3% in 1998-99. 3. $1.5 M of sales tax revenue is added to the General Fund in 1997-98 with the payoff of Plaza Bonita in February 1997. 4. Motor Vehicle in Lieu Fees are projected to increase in future years equal to the inflation assumption of 3%. 5. The City will continue to receive the same revenues from Prop. 172 for public safety funds. 6. No additional one-time PERS surplus revenues will be available beyond the budgeted amount in fiscal year 1996-97. 7. Pending legislative actions are not included in this forecast. Book 79/Page 74 02/27/97 Revenue Assumptions (continued) 8. No other revenue increases are forecasted for remaining revenues above what were budgeted in fiscal year 1996-97. 9. No additional revenues are forecasted from the completion of the National City Marina. Expenditure Assumptions 1. Pay increases per MOU's will be factored. 2. Cost accounting of labor costs will be charged to other funds as appropriate to relieve the general fund. 3. Fringe Benefit Costs will increase by 1% for the next 2 years. 4. The PERS contribution rates over the 2 year period will remain the same. 5. The City's non -personal cost and capital outlay will increase at the same level as the inflation projection of 3%. 6. The Plaza Bonita bonds will be paid off putting back approximately $1.5M in sales tax revenues into the general fund. 7. No additional debt service will be created. City Manager McCabe reiterated that the 2-year financial forecast the Council has before it is not a budget nor a financial plan. The actual budget is forthcoming later in the year. That budget, according to the City Manager, must demonstrate that the revenues that will be coming in will off -set the expenditures that are recommended and approved by the City Council and still maintain a standard reserve. Finance Director Marylou Matienzo distributed a handout that included the following exhibits (which are attached): Exhibit A: Exhibit B: Exhibit C: General Fund 5-Year Comparison, Revenue vs. Expenditures General Fund Balance, 5-Year Comparison Actions Taken to Resolve 1991-92 Deficit, Revenue Enhancements and Expenditure Containments Exhibits (continued) Exhibit D: Exhibit E: Exhibit F: Exhibit G Exhibit H: Exhibit I: Exhibit J: Exhibit K: Book 79/Page 75 02/27/97 General Fund Revenue Projections; FY 1996-97, FY 1997-98, FY 1998-99 General Fund Expenditure Projections; FY 1996-97, FY 1997-98, FY 1998-99 General Fund Operating Transfers Projections; FY 1996- 97, FY 1997-98, FY 1998-99 General Fund Balance, 8-Year Comparison General Fund Expenditure Projections with Potential Losses of Outside Funding; FY 1997-98 and FY 1998-99 General Fund Balance; 8-Year Comparison, Potential Loss of Outside Funding General Fund Revenue/Expenditure Comparisons FY 1991-92 through FY 1998-99 General Fund Salary and Benefit Charges to Other Funds Projection, FY 1996-97, FY 1997-98, FY 1998-99 The Finance Director then made a posterboard presentation, reviewing and explaining each exhibit. At the end of her presentation, the Finance Director concluded that the City really needs to think seriously about how the gap can be bridged between revenues and expenditures because revenues are always falling behind expenditures. The Finance Director displayed three charts not included in the hand-out material (attached): Exhibit L showed the costs of reviving previously frozen personnel positions. At salary step A, with a compensation adjustment of 0%, the cost of reviving the positions would be $1.3 million. With a 5% compensation adjustment, the cost of reviving all of the frozen positions would be $1.4 million. Finance Director Matienzo expressed doubt that the City could afford to take such action. Book 79/Page 76 02/27/97 Exhibits (continued) Exhibit G1 showed compensation adjustments for a two-year period, from 0% to 4% in personnel services, and with 3% inflationary increases in non - personnel costs. Exhibit G2 showed compensation adjustments for a two-year period, from 0% to 5% in personnel services, and no inflationary increases in non - personnel costs. Finance Director Matienzo concluded her presentation. City Manager McCabe pointed out that what is obvious is that the City needs to increase revenues. The question is: How can the City accomplish that goal? He informed the Council that the individual City Departments are still "holding the line" on maintenance, operations and capital outlay expenditures, and that the Department budgets are not increasing in relation to growth in the economy and the cost of living. PUBLIC ORAL COMMUNICATIONS - None. Mayor Waters stated that the workshop was for informational purposes only and no action would be taken at the meeting. ADJOURNMENT Motion by Zarate, seconded by Inzunza, to adjourn to the Next Regular City Council Meeting - March 4, 1997 - 3:00 p.m. - Council Chambers, Civic Center. Carried by unanimous vote. The meeting closed at 4:59 p.m. Book 79/Page 77 02/27/97 ADJOURNMENT (continued) The foregoing minutes were approved at the Regular Meeting of April 15, 1997. �AYOR CITY OF NATIONAL CITY /.L4. -dD ALL CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS ARE TAPE RECORDED. YOU MAY LISTEN TO THE TAPES IN THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE. COPIES OF THE TAPES MAY BE PURCHASED FROM THE CITY CLERK. EXHIBIT A Book 79/Page 78 02/27/97 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND 5-YEAR COMPARISON REVENUES VS EXPENDITURES YEAR ACTUAL REVENUES ACTUAL EXPENDITURES VARIANCE TRANSFERS VARIANCE 1995-96 1994-95 1993-94 1992-93 1991-92 16,283,028 16,190,589 16,499,553 16,469,577 15,997,921 16,292,659 16,008,193 16,777,891 18,205,813 18,173,779 (9,631) 182,396 (278, 338) (1,736,236) (2,175,858) 859,445 321,696 1,468,619 1,998,125 (1,275,919) 849,814 504,092 1,190,281 261,889 (3,451,777) NOTES: 1. Actual amounts of revenues and expenditures are based on audited financial statement. 2. 5 year comparison of revenues vs expenditures is a "stand alone" comparison without inclusion of reserve fund balance. 3. % variance change was most critical in 1991-92 but shows a deficiency decline of 21' into 1992-93 and 84% from 1992-93 to 1993-94. 4. Transfers consist of transfers of general fund money to other funds but also transfers from other funds to support the general fund. EXH: T B CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND BALANCE 5 YEAR COMPARISON YEAR FUND BALANCE ACTUAL ACTUAL INTERFUND FUND BALANCE CHANGES FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURES TRANSFERS ENDING IN RESERVE ENDING 1995-96 1994-95 1993-94 1992-93 1991-92 821, 913 800,292 27, 177 0 108,506 16,283,028 16,292,659 16,190,589 16,008,193 16,499,553 16,777,891 16,469,577 18,205,813 15,997,921 18,173,779 859,445 321,696 1,468,619 1,998,125 (1,275,919) 1,671,727 1,304,384 1,217,458 261,889 (3,343,271) 124,929 (482,471) (417,166) (234,712) 3,343,271 1,796,656 821,913 800,292 27,177 0 NOTES: 1. Fund Balance amounts are based on audited financial statements. 2. 5 year comparison of revenues vs expenditures with inclusion of reserve fund balance. 3. Changes In Reserves consist of adjustments made between designated and undesignated fund balances at year end. 4. Fund Balance Ending after Changes In Reserves represents undesignated reserves. EXHIBIT C Book 79/Page 80 02/27/97 CITY ACTIONS TAKEN TO RESOLVE 1991-92 DEFICIT REVENUE ENHANCEMENTS 1. Initiated User Fee Study in 1991-92 resulting in increased user fee. 2. Increased Transient Occupancy Tax(TOT) from 8% to 10%. 3. Increased business license base tax rates and gross cap. 4. Implemented investment strategies by using Tax Revenue Anticipation Notes creating an additional $100,000 in interest earnings. 5. Negotiated Port services reimbursements of $350,000 a year. 6. Expanded rental fees through calculation revision and utilization of a wider data base. 7. Developed new business and improvements to generate more sales taxes. 8. Contracted with independent auditors on a contingency basis in generating new revenues. 9. Conducted internal audit by the finance staff to increase revenues. EXPENDITURE CONTAINMENTS 1. Budget holdbacks of 8% FY 1991-92 & 1992-93 saving about $3.6 million. 2. Selective employee hiring freeze from FY 1991 to present. 3. No COLA's for represented employees and froze salary bands for executives and mid -managers in FY 1993-94. 4. Reduced compensation for represented employees as well as executives and mid -managers in FY 1993-94. 5. Hold -the -line budget for maintenance and operations and capital outlay items for the last 5 years. 6. Reduced and finally eliminated General Fund contribution towards Capital Improvement Program (CIP). 7. Prior year compensation adjustment implemented in 1995-96 creating a total expenditure increase of approximately 7%. EXHIBIT D Book 79/Page 81 02/27/97 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND REVENUE PROJECTIONS FY 1996-97, 1997-98, 1998-99 FINANCING SOURCE 1996-97 PROJECTED 1997-98 PROJECTED 1998-99 PROJECTED PROPERTY TAXES 934,514 953,204 972,268 SALES & USE TAXES 9,601,103 10,835,696 11,301,631 MOTOR VEHICLE IN LIEU 2,117,413 2,180,935 2,246,364 TRANSIENT LODGING TAX 600,000 540,000 540,000 FRANCHISE TAXES 707,000 757,000 757,000 BUSINESS LICENSE TAX 500,000 485,000 490,000 RESIDENTIAL RENTAL FEE 115,000 115,000 120,000 OTHER REVENUES 2,084,865 2,084,865 2,084,865 16,659,895 17,951,700 18,512,128 NOTES: 1. 1996-97 PROJECTED IS BASED ON THE CITY'S ADOPTED BUDGET. 2. AN 8t INCREASE IS PROJECTED IN TOTAL REVENUES FROM 1996-97 INTO 1997-98 MAINLY FROM THE FINAL PAYOFF OF PLAZA BONITA BONDS. 3. A 4% INCREASE IS PROJECTED IN TOTAL REVENUES FROM 1997-98 INTO 1998-99. EXHIBIT E Book 79/Page 82 02/27/97 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURE PROJECTIONS FY 1996-97, 1997-98, 1998-99 EXPENDITURE CATEGORY 1996-97 PROJECTED 1997-98 PROJECTED 1998-99 PROJECTED PERSONAL SERVICES 12,662,188 13,591,074 14,665,766 MAINTENANCE & OPERATION 2,616,263 2,694,752 2,775,596 CAPITAL OUTLAY 104,100 259,223 242,850 INTERNAL CHARGES 2,736,220 2,859,984 2,604,695 FUND TOTAL 18,118,771 19,405,033 20,288,907 NOTES: 1. 1996-97 PROJECTED IS BASED ON THE CITY'S ADOPTED BUDGET. 2. A 7.1% INCREASE IS PROJECTED IN TOTAL EXPENDITURES FROM 1996-97 INTO 1997-98 WHICH INCLUDES THE 1. PAY INCREASE REQUIRED BY THE POA MOU. 3. A 4.6% INCREASE IS PROJECTED IN TOTAL EXPENDITURES FROM 1997-98 INTO 1998-99. 4. INCLUDES AN ADDITIONAL 5% COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT FOR ALL EMPLOYEES EACH YEAR. EXHIBIT F Book 79/Page 83 02/27/97 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND OPERATING TRANSFERS PROJECTIONS FY 1996-97, 1997-98, 1998-99 EXPENDITURE CATEGORY 1996-97 PROJECTED 1997-98 PROJECTED 1998-99 PROJECTED TRANSFERS FROM: GAS TAX 700,000 700,000 700,000 PLAZA BONITA BONS 30,000 0 0 GENERAL SERVICES 29,107 0 0 INFORMATION SERVICES 116,345 0 0 MOTOR VEHICLE SERVICES 559,791 0 0 TRANSFERS TO: GENERAL CAPITAL OUTLAY (26,254) (204,600) 0 LIBRARY FUND (333,353) (375,804) (401,730) PARKS MAINTENANCE FUND (202,093) (220,434) (244,195) FACILITIES MAINTENANCE (112,962) 0 0 FUND TOTAL 760,581 (100,838) 54,075 NOTES: 1. 1996-97 PROJECTED IS BASED ON THE CITY'S ADOPTED BUDGET. 2. INCLUDES THE 59 COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT FOR LIBRARY AND PARKS MAINTENANCE EMPLOYEES EACH YEAR. 3. ASSUMES THE SAME 2% INCREASE IN PROPERTY TAXES FOR THE LIBRARY AND PARKS MAINTENANCE FUNDS. EXH1 .T G YEAR FUND BALANCE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND BALANCE 8 YEAR COMPARISON REVENUES EXPENDITURES INTERFUND FUND BALANCE CHANGES FUND BALANCE BEGINNING TRANSFERS ENDING IN RESERVE ENDING 1998-99 1997-98 1996-97 1995-96 1994-95 1993-94 1992-93 1991-92 (456, 110) 1,098,061 1,796,656 821,913 800,292 27, 177 0 108,506 18,512,128 20,288,907 17,951,700 19,405,033 16,659,895 18,118,771 16,283,028 16,292,659 16,190,589 16,008,193 16,499,553 16,777,891 16,469,577 18,205,813 15,997,921 18,173,779 54,075 (100,838) 760,581 859,445 321,696 1,468,619 1,998,125 (1,275,919) (2,178,814) (456,110) 1,098,361 1,671,727 1,304,384 1,217,458 261,889 (3,343,271) 0 0 0 124, 929 (482, 471) (417, 166) (234,712) 3,343,271 (2,178,814) (456, 110) 1,098,361 1,796,656 821,913 800,292 27,177 0 NOTES: 1. 1996-97 REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES ARE BASED ON THE CITY'S ADOPTED BUDGET. 2. 1997-98 REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES INCLUDE ALL ASSUMPTIONS, A 3% POA MOU PAY INCREASE AND A 5% COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT FOR ALL EMPLOYEES. 3. 1998-99 REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES INCLUDE ALL ASSUMPTIONS AND A 5% COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT FOR ALL EMPLOYEES. EXHIBIT H Book 79/Page 85 02/27/97 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURE PROJECTIONS WITH POTENTIAL LOSSES OF OUTSIDE FUNDING FY 1997-98 AND 1998-99 1997-98 PROJECTED 1998-99 PROJECTED TOTAL GENERAL FUND 19,405,033 20,288,907 PLUS: JUDGE GRANT 52,670 52,670 MATCH FOR COPS GRANT 101,885 121,011 SUPPRESSION OF DRUG ABUSE GRANT 58,963 64,672 LOWER SWEETWATER CONTRIBUTION 79,958 83,956 SUBTOTAL 293,476 322,309 GRAND TOTAL 19,698,509 20,611,216 NOTES: 1. JUDGE GRANT ONLY PAYS FOR A PORTION OF THE SALARY AND BENEFITS. ABOVE ASSUMES CONSISTENT FUNDING LEVEL. 2. THE COPS GRANT AND PHOTO -RADAR AGREEMENT ARE EFFECTIVE THROUGH FY 1998-99. 3. ASSUMES NO LOSS IN FUNDING FOR ENGINEERING POSITIONS FUNDED BY PROP "A." 4. ASSUMES NO LOSS IN FUNDING FOR SCHOOL LIAISON POSITIONS FUNDED BY NATIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT AND SWEETWATER UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT. 5. ASSUMES NO LOSS IN FUNDING FROM CDC FOR THE LEARN -TO -SWIM, TINY TOTS, GRAFFITI CONTROL, HOUSING INSPECTION AND STREET TREE MAINTENANCE PROGRAMS. 6. ASSUMES NO LOSS IN FUNDING FROM CDC FOR THE STAFF SUPPORT AND POLICE CLERICAL POSITIONS. EXHIBIT I YEAR FUND BALANCE REVENUES CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND BALANCE 8 YEAR COMPARISON POTENTIAL LOSS OF OUTSIDE FUNDING EXPENDITURES INTERFUND FUND BALANCE CHANGES FUND BALANCE BEGINNING TRANSFERS ENDING IN RESERVE ENDING 1998-99 1997-98 1996-97 1995-96 1994-95 1993-94 1992-93 1991-92 (749,586) 18,512,128 20,611,216 1,098,061 17,951,700 19,698,509 1,796,656 16,659,895 18,118,771 821,913 16,283,028 16,292,659 800,292 16,190,589 16,008,193 27,177 16,499,553 16,777,891 0 16,469,577 18,205,813 108,506 15,997,921 18,173,779 54,075 (100,838) 760, 581 859,445 321,696 1,468,619 1,998,125 (1,275,919) (2,794,599) (749,586) 1,098,361 1,671,727 1,304,384 1,217,458 261,889 (3,343,271) 0 0 0 124,929 (482, 471) (417,166) (234,712) 3,343,271 (2,794,599) (749,586) 1,098,361 1,796,656 821,913 800,292 27,177 0 NOTES: 1. 1996-97 REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES ARE BASED ON THE CITY'S ADOPTED BUDGET. 2. 1997-98 REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES INCLUDE ALL ASSUMPTIONS, A 3% POA MOU PAY INCREASE A 5% COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT FOR ALL EMPLOYEES AND THE POTENTIAL LOSS OF FUNDING FOR CERTAIN POSITIONS. 3. 1998-99 REVENUES AND EXPENDITURES INCLUDE ALL ASSUMPTIONS, A 5% COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT FOR ALL EMPLOYEES AND THE POTENTIAL LOSS OF FUNDING FOR CERTAIN POSITIONS. 25,000,000 20,000,000 15,000,000 10,000,000 5,000,000 EXHIBIT J Book 79/Page 87 02/27/97 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND REVENUE/EXPENDITURE COMPARISONS FY 1991-92 THROUGH FY 1998-99 1991-92 1992-93 1993-94 1994-95 1995-96 1996-97 1997-98 1998-99 •REVENUES OEXPENDITURES EXPENDITURES AS A ' OF REVENUES % EXCESS/ (DEFICIENCY) 1991-92 113.6% (13.6)% 1992-93 110.5% (10.5)% 1993-94 101.7% (1.7)% 1994-95 98.9% 1.1 % 1995-96 100.1% (0.1)% 1996-97 108 . 8% (8. 8) % 1997-98 108.1% (8.1)% 1998-99 109.6% (9.6)% EXHIBIT K CITY OF NATIONAL CITY Book 79/Page 88 GENERAL FUND 02/27/97 SALARY AND BENEFIT CHARGES TO OTHER FUNDS PROJECTIONS FY 1996-97, 1997-98, 1998-99 EXPENDITURE CATEGORY 1996-97 PROJECTED 1997-98 PROJECTED 1998-99 PROJECTED JUDGE GRANT (1 OFFICER) 52,670 52,670 52,670 SCHOOL LIAISONS: FULL-TIME OFFICER 65,406 70,737 74,273 PART-TIME OFFICER 31,987 34,594 36,324 PROP A: ASSISTANT CIVIL ENGINEER 61,219 64,107 67,156 SENIOR OFFICE ASSISTANT 24,591 25,685 26,852 COPS GRANT (3 OFFICERS) : GRANT PORTION 77,000 75,000 73,000 MATCH PAID BY CDC 87,265 101,885 121,011 PHOTO RADAR CONTRACT 36,000 36,000 36,000 SUPPRESSION OF DRUG ABUSE: 1 OFFICER 54,757 58,963 64,672 HOUSING INSPECTOR 47,548 49,781 52,123 GRAFFITI CONTROL POSITION 36,899 38,599 40,383 STAFF SUPPORT POSITION 19,163 20,030 20,939 POLICE CLERICAL POSITION 34,257 35,819 37,457 STREET TREE MAINTENANCE POSITION 31,146 32,556 34,039 LEARN -TO -SWIM PROGRAM 24,000 24,000 24,000 TINY TOTS PROGRAM 18,000 18,000 18,000 LOWER SWEETWATER CONTRIBUTION 76,150 79,958 83,956 FUND TOTAL 778,056 818,383 862,855 NOTES: 1. INCLUDES THE 5' COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT EACH YEAR. 2. A 5% INCREASE IS PROJECTED IN TOTAL CHARGES TO OTHER FUNDS FROM 1996-97 INTO 1997-98. 3. A 5$ INCREASE IS PROJECTED IN TOTAL CHARGES TO OTHER FUNDS FROM 1997-98 INTO 1998-99. EXHIBIT L Book 79/Page 89 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY 02/27/97 COST OF REVIVING FROZEN POSITIONS AT "A" STEP ALL FUNDS FY 1997-98 EXPENDITURE CATEGORY COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT 0% 1% 2%1 3% 4%1 5% CITY MANAGER: 1 - MANAGEMENT ANALYST 49,821 50,273 50,726 51,178 51,631 52,084 CITY CLERK: 1- SENIOR OFFICE ASSISTANT 26,481 26,710 26,938 27,167 27,395 27,624 BUILDING & SAFETY: 1- SENIOR OFFICE ASSISTANT 26,481 26,710 26,938 27,167 27,395 27,624 ENGINEERING: 1 - TRAFFIC ENGINEER 57,789 58,321 58,854 59,386 59,918 60,450 FINANCE: 1 - SENIOR OFFICE ASSISTANT 26,481 .26,710 26,938 27,167 27,395 27,624 1 - ACCOUNTANT 39,420 39,778 40,135 40,493 40,851 41,209 FIRE: 1 - MANAGEMENT ANALYST 48,698 49,140 49,581 50,022 50,464 50,905 1 - FIRE DIVISION CHIEF 66,358 66,976 67,593 68,211 68,829 69,447 3 - FIREFIGHTERS 139,595 140,875 142,155 143,436 144,716 145,996 1 - SENIOR OFFICE ASSISTANT 26,481 26,710 26,938 27,167 27,395 27,624 PLANNING: .50 - CODE CONFORMANCE OFFICER 17,698 17,875 18,052 18,229 18,406 18,583 1 - SENIOR OFFICE ASSISTANT 26,481 26,710 26,938 27,167 27,395 27,624 PARKS & RECREATION: 1 - RECREATION CENTER SUPERVISOR 34,488 34,797 35,105 35,414 35,723 36,031 1 - SENIOR PARKS CARETAKER 32,483 32,771 33,060 33,348 33,637 33,925 1 - ASSISTANT TREE TRIMMER 32,483 32,771 33,060 33,348 33,637 33,925 1 - CHIEF PARKS CARETAKER 35,078 35,392 35,707 36,021 36,336 36,650 1 - ADMIN. SECRETARY 31,692 31,972 32,253 32,534 32,814 33,095 POLICE: 1 - ASSISTANT POLICE CHIEF 81,103 81,868 82,633 83,399 84,164 84,929 1 - POLICE SERGEANT 63,655 64,256 64,857 65,458 66,059 66,660 3 - POLICE OFFICERS 161,271 162,777 164,283 165,789 167,295 168,801 3 - CRIME SCENE SPECIALISTS 118,816 119,895 120,974 122,054 123,133 124,212 1 - POLICE DISPATCHER/MATRON 40,516 40,885 41,255 41,624 41,994 42,364 PUBLIC WORKS: 1 - CARPENTER 38,069 38,413 38,757 39,102 39,446 39,791 1.50 - CUSTODIANS 38,153 38,498 38,843 39,188 39,534 39,879 1 - MAINTENANCE WORKER 31,011 31,284 31,558 31,832 32,106 32,380 1 - EQUIPMENT MECHANIC 38,997 39,351 39,704 40,058 40,412 40,765 FUND TOTAL 1,329,599 1,341,718 1,353,835 1,365,959 1,378,080 1,390,201 EXHIBIT G1 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND BALANCE 2 YEAR COMPARISON BY % ADJUSTMENTS FY 1997-98, FY 1998-99 I COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT ® 0%, NON -PERSONAL COSTS & CAPITAL OUTLAY ® 3% INCREASE YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 396,587 18,512,128 18,821,448 129,750 217,017 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 18,579,688 (73,486) 396,587 II COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT ® 1%, NON -PERSONAL COSTS & CAPITAL OUTLAY ® 3% INCREASE YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 66,637 18,512,128 19,280,450 129,542 (572,143) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 18,918,692 (64,432) 66,637 III COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT ® 2%, NON -PERSONAL COSTS & CAPITAL OUTLAY ® 3% INCREASE YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 (64,058) 18,512,128 19,528,949 110,948 (969,931) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 19,040,283 (73,536) (64,058) IV COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT ® 3%, NON -PERSONAL COSTS & CAPITAL OUTLAY ® 3% INCREASE YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 (194,758) 18,512,128 19,780,004 92,140 (1,370,494) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 19,161,883 (82,636) (194,758) V COMPENSATION ADJUSTMENT ® 4%, NON -PERSONAL COSTS & CAPITAL OUTLAY ® 3% INCREASE YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 (325,408) 18,512,128 20,033,277 73,211 (1,773,346) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 19,283,437 (91,732) (325,408) EXHIBIT G2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY GENERAL FUND BALANCE 2 YEAR COMPARISON BY % ADJUSTMENTS FY 1997-98, FY 1998-99 USTMENT e 0%, NON —PERSONAL COSTS is CAPITAL OUTLAY ® 0% INCREASE YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 720,869 18,512,128 18,353,925 151,209 1,030,281 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 18,265,978 (62,914) 720,869 DJUSTMENT 1$, NON — YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 1997-98 390,930 1,098,061 18,512,128 17,951,700 18,819,743 18,604,974 151,004 (53,857) 234,319 390,930 ADJUSTMENT ® 2$, NON — YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 260,246 18,512,128 19,068,249 132,413 (163,462) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 18,726,553 (62,962) T f v a AO. 260,246 TW^TWW S Q4 YEAR ` FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 1997-98 129,536 1,098,061 18,512,128 17,951,700 19,319,085 18,848,161 113,634 (72,064) (563,787) 129,536 MENT ® 4$, NON — YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 185,128 18,512,128 19,572,580 94,673 (780,651) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 --- --_-- 18,969,812 - --w—w - w- w�w� (81,162) • w*7nf� f V s An. (1,213) T1f/7fl O1 QO TMENT ® 5$, NON — YEAR FUND BALANCE BEGINNING REVENUES EXPENDITURE INTERFUND TRANSFERS FUND BALANCE ENDING 1998-99 (131,817) 18,512,128 19,828,219 75,541 (1,372,367) 1997-98 1,098,061 17,951,700 19,091,313 (90,265) (131,817)