Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1969 11-10 CC ADJ MIN200 MINUTES OF THE ADJOURNED MEEETIN.s CF NO7Evi3ER 4, 1969 OF THir CITY COWCIL OF THE CITY OF fATI0NAL CITY, CALIFORNIA November 10, l 5s The adjourned meeting of the City Council of the City of National City was called to order at 7:15 p.m. by Mayor Morgan. ROLL CALL Council members present: Camacho, Colburn, Reid, Morgan. Absent: Hogue. ADI4INISTRATI7E OFFICIALS present: 3ourcier, McLean, Minogue, Civil Engineer Associate Newberry, Osborn, Stockman. SALUTE TO FLAG AND IN;TOCATION Tne meeting was opened with salute to the Flag led by City Manager Osborn followed with invocation by Councilman Colburn. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Moved by Camacho, seconded by Reid, the minutes of the regular meeting of November 4, 1 6; be approved. Absent: Hogue. COUNCILbiAi4 HOGUE arrived. ADOPTIOI-I OF RESOLUTIONS Proved by Colburn, seconded by Hogue, the two resolutions be read by title. Carried by unanimous vote. RESOLUTION NO. 9970, "RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY CONSENTING TO THE INCLUSION OF A PORTION OF THE CITY OF NATICrAL CITY WITHIN ASSESSMENT DISTRICT (Improvement of Rachael Avenue - City of San Diego)." Moved by Camacho, seconded by Colburn, the resolution be adopted. Carried by unani- mous vote. RESOLUTION NO. ';71, "RESOLUTION AUTHCRIZIi'•IG CA:'ITAL OUTLAY FUI'ID EXPENDITURE (Addition tc Public Library and Beautification of El Tcyon Park)." Moved by Reid, seconded by Colburn, the resolution be adopted. Carried by unanimous vote. UNFINISHED BUSINrSS The Council considered the request of F. L. Whittington to amend Resolution No. ;927, Sec. 2(a) providing age requirements for tenants. City Attorney i4cLean stated no recommendation had been received from the Planning Commis- sion. Moved by Colburn, seconded by Reid, the request of Mr. Whittington to delete the one portion in Resolution No. ;;27, Section 2(a) providing age requirements fcr tenants be deleted. Carried by unanimous vote. COUNCILMAN C0L3URN asked the Council tc recognize the United States Marine Corps 194th birthday by sending them a letter. Mayor Morgan asked the City Manager to take care cf this. MAYOR MORGAN called a recess (at 7:20 p.m.) until the joint meeting of the City Council and Redevelopment Agency at 7:30 p.m. At 7:30 p.m. Mayor Morgan called the Council meeting to order. Council members present: Camacho, Colburn, Hogue, Reid, Morgan. Absent: None. Chairman Morgan called the Redevelopment meeting to order. Agency members present: Camacho, Colburn, Hogue, Reid, Morgan. Absent: None. HEARIi'G The joint public hearing before the City Council and the Redevelopment Agency for the City of National City on the redevelopment plan and reloca- tion program for that portion of the City of National City sometimes known as the E. J. Christman Business and Industrial ?ark, Project No. California R-127 was announced and held at this time. City Clerk Minogue and Redevelop- ment Agency Director Watts both reported the Certificates of Publication of 11/10/69 201 of the notice of hearing from the National City Star News and the San Diego Union and the Affidavits of Mailing Notices to property owners within the district were on file. Lyle Alcumbrack, 2522 National Avenue, was present and asked if the meeting could be ad-ourned as there were many people who could not get into the Chamber. Mayor Morgan instructed the people to move into the Council Chamber and stand behind the Council or wherever they could find room. City Manager Osburn explained the purpose of the hearing and procedures to be followed. City Clerk Minogue read a letter from the President of the Chamber of Commerce stating the Board of Directors unanimously went on record re -affirming their stand favoring the Redevelopment Project for the E. J. Christman Business and Industrial Park. Redevelopment Agency Director Watts read excerpts from seven letters: Security Homebuilders, Downey, California: stating there is no blight at any location within the entire project area; Lamb Chevrolet: saying they would like to expand and believe there is a need for additional land to be made available; Stanley Dodge: stating they believe the proposed plan as designed will serve a tremendous need for this community; Webster Pontiac: indicating they believe there is a need for additional land; (Lamb Chevrolet, Stanley Dodge and Webster Pontiac all indicated in their letters they have apprenticeship programs available at this time) Bill Brown Buick, Chula. Vista: stating they would like to purchase property in the area; McCune Motors: indicating they believe the project has merit and they have a need for land to expand upon; Frank Motors Lincoln Mercury: stating they have a demand for land and also have an active apprenticeship program at this time. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Redevelopment Agency Director Watts. Mr. Watts stated the plan is a composite recommendation of the Agency staff, professional consultants and City staff who worked on plans for the project area, comprising approximately 136.6 acres, as shown on the map filed with the City Clerk (document no. 43615); studies were conducted over the past year including a detailed inspection of the condition of structures in the project area; while the inspections were being made, site occupants were interviewed to analyze the potential relocation workload; a land utilization and marketability study was made by Development Research Associates for recommendation of the highest and best use of the land; planning and preliminary engineering studies were undertaken by Daniel, Mann, Johnson & Mendenhall; after there was an idea of the possible cost of this undertaking, the financial consulting firm of Stone & Youngberg was retained to analyze the feasibility of the Agency's issuing tax allocation bonds at a later date. Mr. Watts presented portions of "A Report to Accompany the Redevelopment Plan for the E. J. Christman Business & Indus- trial Park Project (document no. 43616) covering general description, selec- tion of area, structural survey, eligibility, taxes, land use, etc. City Clerk Minoue administered the oath to John McMann, President, Develop- ment Research Associates. Mr. McMann said their approach to the assignment was concerned with the types of development that could go into the project, how fast they could be absorbed, should they bring the developer in to take over the full project or use a series of individual developers; they inter- viewed a large cross section of industrial users in the South Bay area, the Port people and developers. Mr. McMann said they found a strong demand for industrial, auto commercial and retail commercial; in his opinion, this was the most viable mix of uses for this project to accomplish the Cityts goals. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Byron E. Barnes, Planning Pro- jects Director, Daniel, Mann, Johnson & Mendenhall. Mr. Barnes said they investigated the grading, drainage problems, traffic conditions and problems in th er eject; their plan was devoted to achieving the goals of the public which to improve the physical environment of the area and at the same time make it financially attractive to private developers; the plan they are rep- resentin_a to the City represents an extension of industrial development, Mr. Barnes outlined the projected land uses as shown on the map on file in the City Clerk's office (document no. 43615.) Mr. Barnes said further that early in their investigation they found if Paradise Creek was improved and 11/1O/69 202 hidden frcm view by a culvert underground they could recapture a great deal of land and eliminate the need for bridges and develoe the area to its full potential and by so doing could create an extension of Roosevelt Avenue and connect to the north. Mr. Barnes explained the alternate uses shown on the map (document no. 43515). Director Watts explained. the transportation center use: new and used auto- mobile and truck sales and services; a used car lot would not be permitted unless contiguous to and part of a new dealership; in the support area for the center they were thinking of uses such as parts shops, glass shops, car washes, and facilities that do support and: complement the automobile and truck businesses. Mr. Watts said the limited industrial area would run from very light industrial uses, excluding heavy industrial uses, churches, res- idences, uses which are obnoxious, and storage yards. Mr. Watts outlined the highway oriented zone which would permit motels, service stations, res- taurants, cocktail lounges. The business and service area, Mr. Watts con- tinued, envisions commercial enterprise of limited magnitude; permitting a discount retail operation and limited commercial uses which would support that. Director Watts said if the plan as presented were adopted, the City Council was saying in effect to the Agency staff, "We think the primary uses make sense but the private market should dictate whether or not the alter- nate uses rather than the primary uses would in fact be developed." City Clerk Piinogue administered the oath to :ton 3allard, Director of relo- cation, National City Redevelopment Agency. iir. 3allard outlined the Relo- cation Plan, A Report tc Accompany the Redevelopment Plan for the E. J. Christman 3usiness and Industrial Park Project (City Clerk's document no. 43616). Director Watts said they estimated the gross project cost for the 135 acre area would not exceed approximately 15 million dollars; they estimated pro- ceeds will be about six million dollars which results in a net cost of approximately 13 million dollars; in a community of our size, the Federal Government bears 753 of the net cost through a non -repayable, non -interest bearing grant; the community is obliged to pay for 25>3 of the estimated net cost or in this situation, a little over 3 million dollars; they investigated the possible source of funds for providing the local share of the project; a major source is the fair value that the City can claim for land the City owns in the area; the City owns approximately 18 acres exclusive of streets and they estimate the fair value of this property to be approximately $450,000.00; if the land is donated the City will receive credit for the fair value; the City has in years gone by expended money for street and drainage improvements and the actual cost of construction of the improvements is eligible for credit and the City can claim credit tc be applied to the 2d%; certain improvements are needed: outside the project area and the cost of these improvements estimated tc be approximately $5,000.00 can be claim- ed; for the perioo of time the property is owned by the Agency and off the tax rolls, there will be no tax payments made and the City can take credit for the taxes whicn would have been paid which is estimated at $175,000.00; the Redevelopment Agency has the authority by resolution of the Agency to issue ponds (tax allocation bonds) which would be the major source of funds for the local share of the project; they estimate the bonds will be sold for at least 21 million dollars and hope to sell for an even larger amount to reimburse the City for the value of land donated and other improvements which they would make; the security for these bonds would be the additional real property taxes which would be produced as a result of redevelopment; the essence of this financing proposal is the private developers who expend their money in the project would in effect be paying for the community's share of the project. City Clerki4inogue administered the oath to Terrence McCarty, Stone & Young- bert. Mir. McCarty stated his firm prepared a feasibility report on the basis of the application for loan and grant prepared by the Redevelopment Agency and presented to the Department of Housing & Urban Development. McCarty confirmed i4r. Watts' statements in regard to financing and explained it/10/6; 203 the tax allocation bonds: in tax allocation bonds tax revenue, a portion of the revenue based on what is in this project, aces to everybody that levies taxes just as if nothing ever happened; as the project develops and as the Redevelopment Agency acquires the property and resells it for higher land uses and better improvements go in, assessed values will increase; when the bonds are completely paid everything goes back to the agencies unless there is some further obligation to the City for excess contributions to the pro- ject; in that case, after the bonds were paid off the excess contributions would be paid. back to the City or whoever made the contribution. Director Watts said if this plan is approved the Agency will be charged with effectuating the plan; one of the first things would be to obtain a second appraisal of the fair value of property to be acquired; based upon the two appraisals an offer would be made to the owners; they cannot make an offer until they have the second appraisal; they were legally and morally obli- gated to provide relocation assistance to anyone who would be displaced as a result of the project; after the Agency has acquired property with im- provements on it, itts possible people who are in occupancy may wish to re- main; in that event, the Agency would have to become a landlord but the pro- perty management functioning of the Agency would be at all times limited to absolute necessity; the Agency has the ability by law to either sell the land outright or to lease; a policy decision has not been made at this time by the Agency as to whether they would lease or sell land; in either event, the disposition of land is made only after two appraisals have been made by pri- vate, independent appraisers. Mr. Watts continued in terms of the plan pre- sented this evening, they would have in excess of six acres more available for resale than is currently available to private developers because of street patterns; the plan provides for alternate uses and the tentative lo- cation of streets can be adjusted based upon proposals received from develop- ers; the redevelopment plan proposed provides for participation of property owners who will agree in writing to develop their land in accordance with the plan; the plan provides for reentry of existing businesses at other lo- cations in the area; the Agency adopted a policy resolution in which they have indicated that developers proposals creating the largest number of em- ployment opportunities will be encouraged; in addition to that, developers who will agree to develop manpower in apprentice training programs will re- ceive priority consideration as prospective buyers; plans as presented to the Agency will be reviewed by the City Planning Commission and the Agency and all development must take the form of the proposal which they recommend; an entity wishing to purchase property from the Agency to hold for specula- tion will not be permitted to purchase. Mr. Watts said they estimate an in- crease of property taxes of $600,000.00 per year after redevelopment and there will be a $200,000.00 annual increase in sales taxes upon completion of the plan. Mayor Morgan said about two years ago they said the plan would cost about 10 million dollars and now it is up to 19 million dollars and asked if the Director could recommend a method by which the project could be undertaken in phases. Director Watts said the Agency staff believes the project could be developed in two stages; they recommend the Agency adopt in principle by resolution the land use concept as has been presented this evening; they also recommend Phase I and. Phase II; Mr. Ballard displayed and explained a map (City Clerk's document no. 43614) showing land uses and alternate uses within the 79.8 acre proposed first stage of redevelopment and cited portions of the Addendum to "A Report to Accompany the Redevelopment Plan for the E. J. Christman Business & Industrial Park Project (document nc. 43616) covering land area., eligibility, relocation, etc. Mr. Watts said they estimate the cost of undertaking this project at $7,400,000.00; they should have proceeds to the Agency of approximately 3 million to arrive at a net cost of $4,400,000.00; again, the Federal Government would pay 755 of this ant. the relocation grant is 1005 reimburseable; the source of the local share is similar to the outline presented earlier; of the estimated total requirement of $1,100,000.00, the City could receive credit for land to be dcnated in the approximate amount of $436,000.00; site improvements would be in the amount of $13,700.00, receive credit for taxes not paid in 1 1/1 0/69 204 the amount of $82,000.00 which would result in a tax allocation bond issue of $563,000.00; if the issue would be feasible, they would propose to sell the bond in a larger amount so the City could be completely reimbursed for any money they have involved in the project which would include value of donated land. Mr. Watts said under this proposal they were again providing for participation of present owners; the Agency believes three property own- ers should be owner -participants and it would not be necessary for the Agency to acquire all of their property in fee; it might be necessary to acquire small portions of the property for street widening or new streets; the three owners they think could be owner -participants are: Central Savings & Loan (owns property on the north side of 24th Street between Hoover and Wilson), property owned by Mr. & Mrs. Gonzales and Fluidgenics; the disposi- tion procedures for sale of land would be very similar to those identified earlier; the plan provides for alternate uses, the tentative location of streets and re-entry of businesses in the area; the overall objectives are the same; they want to create as many employment opportunities as possible, have the land developed as scan as possible; they estimate approximately 1700 jobs might be generated in this area; increased revenue would result in an amount of about $200,000.00 per year in property taxes and approximately $100,000.00 per year from sales taxes; if they decide to proceed with Phase 1, then all of the energies of the Agency fcr the immediate years ahead would be centered around this project area; they propose the approval in principle only the development concept of the entire 136 acres. Mayor Morgan stated those who were in opposition to the plan could speak at this time. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Jesse Ramirez, 421 W. l6th Street. Yr. Ramirez said he had no quarrel with professional opinions stated; his contention was based on the stated reasons for the Redevelopment Agency when the poor people were used to get this on the ballot; some call this "social balance" but he called it National City's answer to final solu- tion; we get rid of our problems by relocating them elsewhere; the job situ- ation in National City is very critical. Cr. Ramirez said they will follow the redevelopment of this area very closely; if they must go to court, they will go to court; they will exercise all civil rights laws and finally, in the very near future they will seek recourse at the voting booths. Council- man Colbourn asked what Mr. Ramirez's objection was to the project as pre- sented. !r. Ramirez replied his protest was based on the fact that the poor people, and in particular the Mexican -American people, were used as a statis- tical base to attain this; historically, they have had quite a bit of trouble getting employment; he would. like some kind of guarantee of hiring local people first; some statistics show that 25% of industries here hire people of Mexican descent; this is in the labor force; he would like to see more Mexican -Americans in positions of management and in positions with some kind. of future; this is what he is looking for: job advancement and a chance to advance according to ones capabilities. Terrence McCarty (Stone & Youngberg) requested permission to leave the meet- ing. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Lyle Alcumbrack, 2522 National Avenue. Mr. Alcumbrack stated Mr. McCarty never said whether or net he thought the tax allocation bonds would have a ready sale on today's market. Mr. McCarty said they were talking about sale five years in the future; he did not think tax allocation bonds of any redevelopment agency as of today could sell in the open market; however, they were not talking about selling the bonds on todayts market; the tax rate is artificially high, somewhat above what it would be if free to seek its own level in the market today; tax allocation bones at 7%, even with the 55 discount permitted under State Legislature, would probably not sell. Mr. Alcumbrack stated a new (to him) figure of 19 million dollars was presented tonight; he understood an application was submitted about August of this year to Housing and Urban Renewal based on a projected figure of about 16 million; he inquired if with the new figure, the Housing & Urban Renewal would have to re-evaluate the project and would the previous feasibility studies be upgraded in proportion to this 19 million dollars. Mr. Watts replied the application to the 205 government and the presentation this evening are for the same project and the very same figures; the 13 million dollar figure in the application is a requested loan from the Federal Government; the 10 million dollar grant is the requested grant in the application; the difference between the 15 million requested and the 1; million dollars on the chart is the City's contribution of 3 million; there is no conflict between the application submitted and the presentation this evening. Mr. Alcumbrack said he talked to a gentleman in San Francisco who told him because the appraisals came in higher than antici- pated, they would have to re -appraise the application. Mr. Watts said the 1; million dollar figure was the same figure filed with the government; the reduced project presented is the suggested first phase and if the Council a.ahorizes the smaller project, additional written evidence will be submitted to HUD and they anticipate they will approve the smaller project. Mr. Alcumbrack said it looked to him like this would keep going back and forth; with inflation, the whole thing could be tied up for many years; already their property has been frozen for two years which has been a burden on property owners. IMir. Alcumbrack said he would go cn record as being opposed to the project. Kr. McCarty left the meeting. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Gaylord Henry, Suite 1230, 530 Broadway, Attorney representing the owners of the Cohu property. Mr. Henry said he was in agreement with some of the things said and in disagreement with ethers; part of his comments are based on the General Alan of 1635 which snows in the map facing Page 6 the entire property along National Avenue would be an automobile sales area; on the first plan it was indicated there would be about 34 acres for the transportation center which is the primary use now on the westerly side of National Avenue; the General : l an of 1985 says, "The highly successful automotive trade in National City is ex- pected to expand along National Avenue, and may reguire up to 43-50 gross acres...At least another 300 first-class motel units could. be added by 1.85, which would require a minimum of 7 gross acres. Ample additional space should be zoned for this purpose beyond the minimum seven acres;" speakers tonight have recommended approximately half this amount for motel units and about 2/3 of the amount mentioned in the General Plan for automobile sales use; some thought should be given to expanding the automotive area and possibly the motel area; Mr. Henry went to the map exhibited to the audience and compared its traffic pattern with the one on the map given to them upon entering the Council Chambers (Councilman Colburn left the Council Chambers). Mr. Henry said he liked the second plan better; he agreed with the gentleman who spoke just ahead of him that anything that ties up use of property in this area has tc drive property values down; you should expand the automo- tive uses and include his client's property which is now devoted to such a use (iicCunes). Mayor Morgan called a recess at 5:37 ,.ra. At 5:45 p.m. Mayor Morgan called. the Council meeting to order. Council members present: Camacho, Colburn, Hogue, Reid, Morgan. Absent: None. Chairman Dorgan called the Redevelopment meeting to order. Agency members presen-c: Camacho, Colb.;.rn, Hogue, Reid, Morgan. Absent: None. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Tom Moynahan, 2745 Wilson Avenue. Mr. Moynahan requested the Council place him in the same position as Mueller Truck Company and the plating industry that they may be able to stay in bus- iness until such a time as ?hase I1 is ready; it is his understanding in Phase II there will be a place; in ?hase I, if what they are doing now gees through, within 18 months they would be out of business. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Herman 3aca, 105 South Harbison Avenue, Chairman of the National City Chapter of the Mexican -American Politi- cal Association. Pir. 3aca said his group has never been against urban re- newal but they pretest the direction this project has taken; it will not meet the needs nor solve the problems of the community; the voters of National City voted for an industrial project and not a commercial project; 11/10/6; 205 since they do not have the personnel nor the financial resources, they can only say if this specific project is approved the voters, and especially the poor people, will not soon forget it. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Mrs. H. 3. Rockwell, 2747 L Avenue. Mrs. Rockwell said she was part owner of one building in Phase I and three buildings in Phase II; and inquired how long it would be for the Agency to acquire the property, or would the present owner be allowed to keep it and how long a period would it be held so that the property could not be improved. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to James F. Jiminez, 2222 Roosevelt Avenue. Mr. Jiminez inquired if he heard that the bonds would not seli at this time; how long a period of time would it be before it would be feasiole for the bones to be sold; and why a portion of this was not allocated for housing. City Clerk Min03ue administered the oath to Fritz Ilachant, 11020 Horizon Hills Drive, E1 Cajon. Mr. Nachant asked when the acquisition of land is made would it be by condemnation. Mayor Morgan said those in favor of the plan would new have an opportunity tc speak. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Clint Matthews, 4305 Vista Coronado Drive. Mr. Matthews said he had been involved in this industrial area almost twelve years and he represents about twenty-five property owners in the area; he was disappointed in the City Council selling the urban re- newal commission their land for 50C a foot; he inquired if that would have anything to do with the price that would be paid for their land; they feel only 1/2-1/3 enough money has been allocated tc purchase property. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath tc Peter Storton, 920 Ethel Place, President, Chamber of Commerce. Mr. Storton said at the last meeting of the 3oard of Directors of the Chamber of Commerce they reaffirmed their stand endorsing the redevelopment project as outlined this evening; they consider this a plan that will economically benefit National City. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to J. P. Dowden, 1207 Alameda, Coronado. Mr. Dowden said he owns about 50,000 sq. ft. at National Avenue in Phase I; if he was only going to be offered 50C a sq. ft. he would rather develop it himself; it was stated that second hand car lots could only be operated when contiguous with new cars; he inquire_ if that meant they would take his land for SO¢ a sq. ft. and offer it to a new car dealer at that ?rice. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Hrs. Thelma N. Hollingsworth, 330 E. 12th Street. Mrs. Hollingsworth said when Father Serra was here over 200 years ago the swamp was down there and it was still a swamp; she favored implementing the plan. Lloyd Coker, 2153 Blackmore Court, re?resenting Central Savings & Loan, was present and said Director Watts mentioned their land would not be acquired by the City; they own about 11 acres in Phase I; he inquired what would be expected of an owner who would possibly be a non -participant. Director Watts said the owner of the property in the project area would be asked to develop his property in accordance with the plan when it was developed; however, at any time the owner would be free to transfer title, to develop the property, to lease it. Mr.- Coker said they knew their land was worth more than 50C and they liked the idea they could hold on to it. City Clerk Minogue administered the oath to Hugh Rockwell, 2747 L Avenue. Ctr. Rockwell said he owns some property in Phase II; some provision should be made for owners there to know what the future holds for them; they might not be able to sell and their tenants' leases will expire. 11/10/G9 207 Mayor Morgan asked if there was anyone else tc soeak at this time. No one indicated a desire tc spear;. iMIcved by Camacho, seconded by Hogue, the hear- ing be closed. Carried by unanimous vote. Mayor Morgan announced the hear- ing before the City Council was closed. Moved by Camacho, seccnded by Reid, the hearing be closed. Carried by unanimous vote. Chairman Morgan announced the hearing before the Redevelopment Agency was closed. RESOLUTION NO. 9 72, "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY APPROVING A GENERAL iNEIGHBORHOOD RENEWAL PLAN FCR THE E. J. CHRISTMAN BUSINESS AID INDUSTRIAL PARK AREA," was presented. Moved by Hogue, seconded by Colburn, the resolution be read by title. Carried by unanimous vote. The title was read. Moved by Camacho, seconded by Hogue, the resolu- tion be adopted. Moved by Colburn, seconded by Camacho, this resolution be amended to allow a business in Phase I, if it's eliminated by the zoning ordinance and allowed in Phase II, to stay in Phase I until property in the Phase II area is available. The amendment to the motion failed by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Camacho, Colburn. Nays: Hogue, Reid, Mor- gan. The motion carried by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Camacho, Hogue, Reid, Morgan. Nays: Colburn. ORDINANCE NO. , "An ordinance of the Council of the City of National City approving the Redevelopment ;Plan and the feasibility of relocation for the E. J. Christman Business and Industrial ?ark Project I, California .R- 127," was presented for first reading. Moved by Hogue, seconded by Reid, the ordinance be presented for first reading by title. Carried by unanimous vote. The title was read. RESOLUTION NO. 9973, "A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZIiiiG THE EXECUTION CF A LOCAL GRAW-Ii1-AID AND COCPERA- TIOi1 AGREEMENT 3Y AND BETWEEN Ti— CITY OF 1.1ATIC1'IAL CITY AND THE REDEVELOP- MENT ENT AGENCY OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FOR THE E. J. CHRISTMAN 3JSII•ESS AinD INDUSTRIAL PARK I PROJECT NC. CALIFORNIA R-127," was presented. Moved by Camacho, seconded by Hogue, the resolution be read by title. Carried by unanimous vote. The title was read. Moved by Hogue, seconded 'oy Camacho, the resolution be adopted. Carried by unanimous vote. Moved by Hogde, seconded by Reid, the following Agency resolution and any other resolution be presented by title. Carried by unanimous vote. RESOLUTION NO. 53-21, "RESOLUTION OF TH R EDEYELOPMENT AGENCY CP THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY APPROVING CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH RELCCATION PAYMENTS WILL BE i4ADE FOR THE E. J. CHRISTMAII BUSINESS & INDUSTRIAL PAR.( I, PROJECT NO. CALIF. R-127." Moved by Camachc, seconded by Hogue, the resolution be adopt- ed. Carried by unanimous vote. RESOLUTION NO. 53-22, "A RESOLUTION CF THE R EDE,'ELCPMEITT AGENCY CF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF A LOCAL GRAFT -IN -AID AND CC - OPERATION AGRED,IENT 3Y AND 3ETrVEECI THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AND THE Ri3- DEELO?IjEidT AGEiCY C7 THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FOR THE E. J. CHRIST:AN BUSINESS AID INDUSTRIAL PARK I, PROJECT HC. CALIF. R-127." Moved by Hogue, seconded by Reid, the resolution be adopted. Carried by unanimous vote. Moved by Hogue, seconded by Camacho, the Council meeting be closed. Carried by unanimous vote. Moved by Camachc, seconded by Colburn, the Redevelopment Agency meeting be closed. Carried by unanimous vote. 11/10/6S The joint meeting closed at 10:30 p.m. 208 �--fZ Ci City of Nati alif. ty Clerk anal City, The foregoing minutes were approved 5y the City Council of National City at the regular meeting of November 18, 193;. ___-_1 No corrections Correction as noted below. Iayor, Cit I tional City, California 11/10/6;