Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1959 01-06 CC MIN233 National City, California, January 6, 1959 Regular meeting of the City Council was called to order by Mayor Hodge at 1:30 P.M. Council members present: Allen, Fessman, Hart, Hodge. Council members absent: Hollingsworth. ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICIALS present: Alston, Bird, Curran, Gautereaux, Holgate, Lill, Stockman. The meeting was opened with pledge of allegiance to the Flag, fol- lowed by invocation by Rev. Perkins. Moved by Fessman, seconded by Hart, the minutes of the regular met- ing of December 23, 1958, be approved. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. RESOLUTION NO. 7370 was read, granting a special zone variance per- mit to Mildred Ellen Cunningham, for the purpose of reducing the minimum lot area required in order to civide a parcel of real estate into two lots, the small lot to be 50 feet by 72.5 feet. Moved by Hart, seconded by Allen, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, by the following vote to wit: Ayes: Allen, Hart, Hodge. Nays: Fessman. Absent: Hollingsworth. COUNCIL JOivIAN HOLLINGSdGRTH present. RESOLUTION NO. 7371 was read, requesting the Board of Supervisors of San Diego County to make its order that the San Diego County Auditor cancel the taxes for the fiscal year 1958-1959 on property purchased by the City from Robert T. and Lurie H. Ingle. Moved by Hart, sec- onded by Allen, the resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Coun- cil present voting aye. RESOLUTION NO. 7372 was read, accepting conveyance of real property, as follows: Grant Deeds from A. C. and Virginia D. Montgomery and William E. and Paula Rae Baker; Easements from A. C. and Virginia. D. Montgomery; Richard V. and Margaret M. Ambre; Richard V. and IVZargaret Ambre. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hart, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. RESOLUTION NO. 7373 was read, approving and accepting that certain contract between City of National City and Coates, Herfurth and England dated December 23, 1958, and the Mayor is authorized and directed to execute the same for and on behalf of City of National City. Moved by Hart, seconded by Allen, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. RESOLUTION NO. 7374 was read, "RESOLUTION ADOPTING PLAT SH0ZNG EX- TERIOR BOUNDARIES OF ASSESSMENT DISTRICT (C Avenue between 15th Street 8316th Street).- Moved by Hollingsworth, seconded by Fess- man, the Resolution be -adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. 1/6/59 234 RESOLUTION NO. 7375 was read, -RESOLUTION ADOPTING PLANS AND SPEC- IFICATIONS (C Avenue between 15th Street and 16th Street.), Moved by Fessman, seconded by Hollingsworth, the resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. RESOLUTION NO. 7376 was read, 'IPRELIIVIINARY DETERMINATION OF LEGIS- LATIVE BODY UNDER SPECIAL ASSESSMENT INVESTIGATION, LIMITATION AND MAJORITY PROTEST ACT OF 1931- (C avenue between 15th Street and 16th Street)." Moved by Hollingsworth, seconded by Hart, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. RESOLUTION NO. 7377 was read, ' E3OLUTION APPROVING ENGINEER'S RE- PORT AND FIXING HEARING DATE LC Avenue between 15th Street and 16th Street).- Moved by Fessman, seconded by Hart, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. ORDINANCE NO. 'BAN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY RE- ZONING THE LOISda ILLIAMS M OR NO. 6 ANNEXATIONS,' was present- ed for the first reading, and read in full. ATTORNEY CURRAN stated he has examined the Comprehensive Multiple Liability Policy which was submitted in accordance with the award of insurance, and recommended it be given a document number and filed. Moved by Fessman, seconded by Hart, the City Attorneys recommendation be approved, that the insurance policy be given a document number and filed. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. ATTORNEY CURRAN reported on January 2nd the Mayor was served with Summons and Complaint in the Superior Court of San Diego, nction No. 230613, entitled Arthur and Anne Patterson vs City of National City et al. Attorney Curran recommended an answer be filed to this complaint and the City descent azainst the complaint. Moved by Hollingsworth,; seconded by Fessman, the recommendation of the City Attorney be ap{ roved. Carrie-, all the Council present voting aye. ATTORNEY CURRAN reported the California ,Jater & Telephone Company has executed a contract pursuant to the Resolution passed at the last meeting; the Attorney for Company stated the Company will pro- ceed to do the work of relocation on Highland Avenue between 8th and 18th Street, ATTORNEY CURRAN stated there was referred to him the matter of whether or not the City Council could legally impose as a condit- ion to the granting of a zone variance limitations on use of a par- cel of land which was separate from, but contiguous to the parcel for which the variance was brought. The basic consideration in answering this question is the rule of law that the granting of a variance is a privilege and therefore certain conditions may be imposed in granting this privilege. However, this authority is not an ultimate authority; the conditions which are imposed must have a resonable relationship to be exercised of the power by the City Council. This very problem was one of the matters which was dis- 1/6/59 235 cussed by the City Atttorneyso Department at the last meeting of the League of California Cities. The question, therefore, resolves itself into whether or not as a matter of law the condition under the circumstances stated would be reasonable. It would appear, to the City Attorney, that in this instance it would not be unreason- able for the City Council to treat these two parcels of land as a whole, and if that were done then the only question would be whether or not the condition as imposed was reasonable. CITY ATTORNEY CURRAN stated with regard to the question as to the operation of a cabinet shop on the premises known as 1831 Highland Avenue, under Ordinance No. 750 use of this particular parcel of land for the operation of a caunet shop is specifically permitted. It therefore cannot be said tie present occupant of the land is carrying on a business which is in the wrong zone, nor would there appear to be any ground for declaring this operation a nuisance. ATTORNEY CURRAN reported on the communications from the Civil Serv- ice Commission which were referred to him for clarification as to whether the Personnel Clerk and the Recreation Department are under Civil Service of National City. Attorney Curran stated he finds that by amendment to the original Givil Service Ordinance the City Council has made the Personnel Clerk a part of the City Civil Serv- ice, but the City Council has taken no such action with reference to the Recreation Department employees, so the Personnel Clerk is under Civil Service and the Recreation Department employees are not under Civil Service. ATTORNEY CURRAN sated this item is one which requires action, ad- option of policy and instructions from the City Council. In review- ing the minutes of the meeting since the adoption of the resolution which authorized the sale of the property owned by National City be- tween 4th and Division Streets, it appears there is some confusion as to the present status. The last action of the Council was to rescind the resolution which 2iad been previously adopted. Because of the questions which have been raised as to what conditions, if any, should be put on this land for sale, and more particularly be- cause of the absolute necesoity in the opinion of the City Attorney, to have the condition of sale of this property specific so there will be no question as to what any future owner of the property may or may not expect from the City, it appears we should have a clear cut determination by the City Council as to what should be elimin- ated from the resolution which was rescinded, what should be added to that resolution prior to noticing any sale of this property. Mr. Curran stated he has in mind the lengthy decisions of our Appel- late Court which indicate it is highly desirable this matter be made very specific so there will be no repercussion after any sale is made; therefore he requests specific instructions from the City Council as to What and what should not go into any new resolution regarding the sale of this property. COUNCILMAN ALLEN stated he thought the only thing the Council was interested in doing was to remove the covenants which become deed restrictions, and sell the property specifically as an R-1 Zone piece of property according 1/6/59 236 to our zoning Ordinance No. K0 now in existence. Moved by =Alen, seconded by Hart, the City Attorney be authorized to prepare a reso- lution restricting this property to an R-1 zone with all the restrict- ions imposed by our zoning Ordinance No. 750. COUNCIL7OI'vMAN HOLLIuGS- WORTH asked the Council if they would consider only selling the 37 acres east of Euclid Avenue. COUNCILMAN FESSMAN saahe would strong- ly entertain the idea of selling that portion east of Euclid Avenue, COUNCILMEN HART and ALLEN stated they wished to sell the entire 65 acres. MAYOR HODGE asked the City Attorney if this is a proper motion for the sale of the property; can a resolution be prepared that would sell the property under the motion that has been made, ATTORNEY CUR - RAN stated it is a proper motion, however it requires clarification. Mr. Curran stated as he understands it, the intent of the motion is that the property would be advertised for sale as acreage and the pot- ential buyers would be put on notice the only thing they could do with that property would be to subdivide it into R-1 lots under our subdivision regulations, and pursuant to the conditions of Ordinance No. 750. COUNCILIViAN ALLEN stated that is the motion. ATT.iR1EY CUR - RAN stated the question then is whether or not it is Ordinance No. 750 as we have it at the time of the sale, or whether it is Ordinance No. 750 as it may be hereafter amended. COUNCILMAN ALLEN stated it should be made Ordinance 750 as it may be hereafter amended. Motion carried, by the following vote to -wit: Ayes: x►ilen, Hart, Hodge. Nays: Fessman, Hollingsworth, MRS. SINGLETON, 713 E. 21st Street, was present and stated she wished to know what has been done about the street, and what they can do. Their attorney has advised them to let the City make the first move. ATTORNEY CURRAN stated their attorney has contacted him, advising he did represent Mrs. Singleton, and Mr. Curran advised him he would work and consult with him, and the investigation is being made; there is nothing further to report until the investigation is completed. COUNCILMAN HART asked if the property could not be deeded back to Mrs. Sir ;leton. ATTORNEY CURRAN stated that question will have to be determined after the investigation of the facts is completed. MARGARET LOkuE was present and stated she is unable to get any water to her property because of this problem of the Singletons. MAYOR HODGE stated it is held up awaiting a legal opinion. COMMUNICATION FROM ED BARD B. BODGE, 1315 First Street, was read, stating several months ago the property owners in this area obtained the necessary signers for a 1911 Improvement Act. It is his under- standing the general procedure is to wait your turn; however he be- lieves they should be considered as an exception as they have a water problem. COUNCILMAN ALLEN suggested the City Manager and City Engin- eer find out if this particular area is one that would come under an emergency and therefore replace some others that are not an emergency. BILLS AUDITED BY THE FINANCE COMITTEE presented: General Fund Traffic Safety Fund Park Fund Retirement Fund $21,630.20 3,280.96 613.84 1,803.98 1/6/59 237 Harbor Fund Special Street Fund Drainage Fund Payroll Fund TOTAL . . .. $ 6,423.17 1,980.00 19,418.50 82,184,68 . . . $137,335.33 Moved by Hollingsworth, secorZeJ by Allen, the bills be approved for payment, and warrants drawn fci , une. Carried, by the following vote to -wit: ryes: Allen, Fessman, Hart, Hollingsworth, Hodge. Nays: None. RESOLUTION NO. 7378 was read, authorizing the following payments from the Capital Outlay Fund: SHAV-O-DISC MANUFACTURING, $2, 307.80, for Shav-O-Disc, a Road Grader Discing Attachment; SOUTff EST SEER TOOL COMPANY, $4,975.15; for Seweroder mounted on a 4 wheel trailer. Mov- ed by Hollingsworth, seconded by Hart, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. COMMUNICATION FROM VILLIAiu SULLIVAN wasT read requesting a veteran's license for T. V. repairs. CITY TREASURER HOLGATE was present and stated she had not seen the request of Mr. Sullivan but would be glad to check it. Moved by Fessman, seconded by Hart, the communicat- ion be referred to the City Treasurer's office for a recommendation. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. CO?dMUNICATION 1'H0M PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION was read regarding request of the Pacific Telephone & Telegraph Company, stating the Commission on October 7, 1958 granted permission to all operators of overhead lights to deviate from certain provisions of Rule 84,4G4 of General Order 95. Moved by Hollingsworth, seconded by Fessman, the letter be referred to the Oft Manager and City Attorney. Car- ried, all the Council present voting aye. COIM;MUNICATION FRU SAN DIEGO COUNTY IATER AUTHORITY in regard to apportionment of water was presented. Moved by Hart, seconded by Allen, the communication be referred to the City Attorney. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. NOTICE OF MEETING of Small Craft Harbors Commission to be held Jan- uary 13th at Alameda, Calif., was read. Moved by Hollingsworth, sec- onded by Fessman, the Notice be filed. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. RESIGNATION OF ELEANOR FRENCH, Personnel Clerk, effective April 15, 1959, was read. Moved by Allen, seconded by Fessman, the resignat- ion be accepted, with regret. Carried, all the Council present vot- ing aye. IuINUTES OF SMALL CRAFT HARBORS COMMISSION'S METING at Blythe, held December 9th, waspresented. Moved by Hart, seconded by Fessman, the minutes be referred to the City Attorney for checking. Carried, all the Council present voting a:,e 1/6/59 238 COPdMUNICATION FROM THE NATIONAL FOUNDATION THE MARCH OF DINES was read, extending an invitation to -participate in their Seventh Annual March of Dimes Parade, to be held Jan. 18th at 2:00 P.M. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hart, the letter be filed. Carried, all the Coun- cil present voting aye. CITY CLERK ALSTON stated she received two Deeds of Dedication for drainage purposes from the National School District, and recommended they be referred to the Attorney to prepare the resolution of accept- ance. Moved by Fessman, seconded by Allen, the City Clerk's recom- mendation be approved. Carried, all theCouncil present voting aye. CITY CLERK ALSTON stated she received the Annual Report of financial Transactions Concerning Streets and Roads for the fiscal year 1957- 58 which will be on file in her office. CITY ENGINEER LILL reported the "FAvenue Storm Drain is installed. RESOLUTION NO. 7379 was read, authorizing the following transfer be made: from the Trust and Agency Fund to the General Fund, $13.67, balance of subdivider's deposit for engineering services as per Or- dinance No. 873, Terry Park Subdivision. Moved by Hart, seconded by Fessman, the resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. COMMUNICATION FROM SAN DIEGO FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION addressed to Mayor Hodge was read stating their hearing in Washing- ton, D. C. for a branch in the South Bay Plaza is set for January 14. They request endorsement of their application be put to the City Council with a request for a letter setting forth the need for such a facility in the South Bay Plaza. The letter should be addressed to the Federal Home Loan Bank Board, 101 Indiana Avenue, N. N., Washington 25, D. C. A suggested letter was enclosed, should the Council approve. They asked the letter not be mailed to the Home Loan Bank Board as their representative, Bruce iyllie will pick it up. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hart, such a letter be written by the City Manager and forwarded. Carried, by the following vote to - wit: Ayes: Allen, Fessman, Hart, Hollingsworth, Hodge. Nays: None. CITY MANAGER BIRD stated he has a resolution prepared which he wish- es to have favorable action upon. The reason for the resolution is primarily to transfer money from one fund to another, as a loan only; because we are going to have to consummate our negotiations with the California Water and Telephone Company in relation to the extension of our tidelands 12 inch main South of 24th Street. RESOLUTION NO. 7380 was read, authorizing the following transfer: from the Drainage Fund to the Harbor Fund, as a loan only, the sum of $20,000.00. Moved by Hart, seconded by Fessman, the Resolution be adopted. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING COMVsISSION was read regarding Application 1/6/59 239 for Conditional Exception No. 662 signed by E. M. Morrow relative to the property located at 221 Highland Avenue. Petitioner is re- questing permission to use the rear 40 feet of the property, located in an R-4 gone, in conjunction with the existing nursery. The Com- mission recommended the Exception be granted subject to the restrict- ions that the area the variance is requested for be used only for driveway to enter and leave the property and for storage of plants growing in containers, and no other materials are to be stored on that property. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hart, this Conditional Exception be granted in accordance with the recommendation of the Planning Commission, provided LMr. Peters is forced to house the man- ure he scatters cut an the vacant lot which creates a nuisance to people who live in the neighborhood. COUNCILMAN FESSMAN asked what kind of house it would be, whether canvas, corrugated iron or some sort of structure. COUNCILMAN AWN with approval of his second, Councilman Hart, amended the motion to include the manure be put under a shed. Carried, by the following vote to -wit: Ayes: Allen, Fessman, Hart, Hollingsworth, Hodge. Nays: None. COUNCILMAN ALLEN requested this be referred to the City Attorney for a resolution. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSIuN was read regarding Application for Conditional Exception No. 625 signed by aayne and R. L. B. Smith, relative to the property located at the northeast corner of 16th Street and Harbison Avenue. Petitioners are requesting permis- sion to use a 10 foot setback to a pump isla►id for a service station in a C-2 District, to place a flood light standard adjacent to prop- erty line, and to erect a three foot ten inch by twenty-two foot eight inch sign with a fourteen foot clearance under. The Commis- sion recommended the petiton be granted. Moved by Hart, seconded by Fessman, the recommendation of the Planning Commission be approved, and referred to the City Attorney for preparation of a resolution. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION regarding Application for Con- ditional Exception No. 635 signed by Frank E. and Lillie F. Mellien relative to the property located at 1625 Grove Street, was read. Petitioners are requesting permission to construct an additional two -bedroom house on the back part of their property located in an R-1 District; also permission to allow for a four foot rear yard setback instead of the required twenty-five foot. The Commission recommended the granting of the petition subject to a ten foot rear yard setback. Moved by Hart, seconded by Allen, the recommendation of the Planning Commission be approved, and referred to the City Attorney for preparation of a resolution. Carried, by the follow- ing vote to -wit: Ayes: Alien, Hart, Hodge. Nays: Fessman, Hol- lingsworth. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING Cal.13..,ICN was read regarding Application for Conditional Exception No. 636 signed by George Morgan, Jr. relative to the property located at 1611 E. 7th Street. Petitioner is requesting permission to remodel and use the existing carport as a contractor's office providing off street parking in the front and rear. Also permission to construct six foot high signs across 1/6/59 240 marquee of building with flood lights. The Commission recommended denial of this application as requested since there is no indicat- ion of a harship on the petitioner. Moved by Hart, the conditional exception be granted. Motion died for lack of a second. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hollingsworth, the recommendation of the Plan- ning Commission be approved. Carried, by the following vote to -wit: Ayes; Allen, Fessman, Holli.,svrorth, Hodge. Nays: Hart. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING C0 MIS3IuN was read regarding Application for Condition al Exception No. 637 signed by Elmer E. Mille relative to the property located at 2005 E. 8th Street. Petitioner is re- questing permission to operate a real estate business in an R-2 District; also permission to erect sufficient signs to advertise said real estate business, area of signs not to exceed 100 square feet. Since the Commissioners felt this was an economic hardship and not a land use hardship, it was their recommendation this var- iance be denied. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hollingsworth, the recommendation of the Planning Commission be approved. Carried, by the following vote to -wit; Ayes: Allen, ressman, Hart, Hollings- worth, Hodge. Nays: None. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION regarding Application for Con- ditional Exception No. 638 signed by Carol H. Dresselhaus, M. D., relative to the property located at 1830 "I. Avenue, located in an R-4 Zone, was read. Said property is located approximately 35 feet from the C-3, General Business District on Highland Avenue. The Commission recommended the application be approved, providing the existing garage is remove]. prior to the issuance of a building permit and the area indicated by cross hatching on the plot plan be blacktopped and prepared for parking prior to final inspection; to be restricted to the use of the applicant, non-transferrable and non -assignable. Moved by Fessman, seconded by 411en, the applicat- ion be denied. Motion lost, by the following vote to -wit: Ayes: Allen, Fessman. Nays: Hart, Hollingsworth, Hodge. Moved by Hart, seconded by Hollingsworth, the recommendation of the Planning Com- mission be approved, and referred to the City Attorney for prepar- ation of a resolution. Carried, by the following vote to -wit: Ayes: Hart, Hollingsworth, Hodge. Nays: Allen, Fessman. CITY PLANNER STOCKMAN said she would like to state in defense of the Planning Commission that on this particular application, it was their reason for recommending approval because doctors' offices are permissible in R-4 Zones in the City of Chula Vista and the City of San Diego, and in our proposed ordinance those offices will be per- missible in the R-4 Zones. REPORT FROM THE PLANNING COMMISSION was read regarding Application for Zone Change signed by Ruby M. Elsner relative to the property located to the rear of 1432 E. 8th Street. Petitioner is request- ing a zone change from an R-1-A, Suburban District,to an R-4, Multiple Residence District. First public hearing held October 27, 1958 and recessed to the re,,uiar meeting of November 24, 1958 to allow the petitioner addition:1 time to fulfill the petition re- quirement. Second public hc.J,,ing held of December 22, 1958. The 1/6/59 241 petitioner secured 48.3 percent of the property owners' signatures within a radius of 300 feet of the property in question, but failed to provide the additional signatures required. The Commission rec- ommended in view of the fact there was considerable objections and also that the petition lacks sufficient signatures, the request be denied. Moved by Allen, seconded by Hollingsworth, the recommend- ation of the Planning Commission be approved. Carried; ;all the " . Council .pre sent voting aye . REPORT FROM THE PLANNING CMISSION was read relative to the estab- lishment of 'on sale' liquor licenses within the City. A check with other cities was made with the results they all agreed upon the establishment of zoning regulations with buffer zones to pro- tect the residential properties. They were also in accord that once the =ning is established, strict adherence should be made to that zoning with no lenienc; _ :' ven to vcr_ ices in areas abutting residential zones. COUNCIli.� W +'E3SMJN stated he thought the rec- ommendation is very good and the Planning Commission is to be con- gratulated on their work. Loved by Fessman, seconded by Allen, those recommendations be incorporated in the proposed amendment to Ordinance 750, and also worded so that an existing on sale liquor establishment that would be non conforming, if there should be a change of ownership or transfer of license from'one licensee to another, they would be denied further use of that particular loc- ation if it was non conforming to our ordinance. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. COUNCILWOMAN HOLLINGSWORTH excused. CITY CLERK ALSTON stated we had a communication from Mr. Carpenter of the League of California Cities requesting we give him some kind of an answer before the 8th or 9th of this month on the liquor li- censes, and the Council referred it to the Planning Commission for a report from them, and Mrs. Alston stated she would like to have instructions as to what to write to Mr. Carpenter. Councilman Fessman, said he thought a copy of the Planning Commission's recom- mendation be enclosed with a letter from the City Clerk to Mr. Carpenter saying the imposed recommendations of our Planning Com- mission are some of the thincs we feel will help correct the matt- er. Recommendations from other cities might also be taken into consideration and incorporated in their legislation. It would be all right if their suggestions are good to make that a city wide proposition rather than a County and prevent centralization of these establishments within a small City. Moved by Allen, second- ed by Fessman, the City Manager and City Clerk get together and compose such a letter and enclose a copy of the report from the Planning Commission and forward it to the League of California Cities. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. CITY PLANNER STOCKMAN stated the Planning Commission has held hear- ings upon the proposed amendment to the zoning ordinance, and she has been confronted with a situation. There has been a request made once again that restrictions be made to new construction of residential use in the M-2 and M--3, light manufacturing and heavy 1/6/59 242 industrial zoning in National City. Mrs. Stockman stated she met with members of that area and they are in accord with it if pro- visions are made which would permit them to maintain their pres- ent home, to enlarge it, remodel it; also they would like consid- eration if 4An Act of Gods, such as an earthquake or wind storm, or a fire destroyed their home they would be permitted to recon- struct it. They requested the Planner prepare a short statement similar to this proposed change, stipulated to the properties in the i'I-2 wad M-3 Zones; therefore, Pars. Stockman said she would like to know if the Council feels this would be a permissible pro- ject for the City Planner to proceed with There is some cost in- volved, and other amendments to the Ordiimce which specifically are of concern to people in I e R-1 and R -2 Zoning were not grant- ed such a privilege. COUNCILMAN FES:LAN stated it would be proper for the City Planner to send two or three copies of the proposal to whoever happens to be the spokesman for any particular group and let him do the distributing; it should not be incumbent upon the City Planner to do it. Moved by Fessman, seconded by Allen, the City Planner be instructed to send a copy or two or three, through the mail to those she knows are interested and are spokes- men for this particular group of people. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. Moved by Hart, seconded by Allen, the meeting be closed. Carried, all the Council present voting aye. Meeting closed at 3:27 P.M. A.TTIi�C�. CITY CLE K CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIF. 1/6/59