Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC ORD 2012-2372 Amend Title 18 Adopting Land Use Code Amendment and Official Zoning Map Amendment Repealing Ordinance 2011-2362ORDINANCE NO. 2012 — 2372 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AMENDING TITLE 18 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE APPROVING AND ADOPTING A LAND USE CODE AMENDMENT AND OFFICIAL ZONING MAP AMENDMENT, AND REPEALING ORDINANCE 2011-2362 WHEREAS, on May 16, 2011, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 14-2011, recommending that the City Council approve the Comprehensive Land Use Update, including the Land Use Code amendments; and WHEREAS, litigation has been filed challenging the validity of the Planning Commission's recommendations in Resolution 14-2011, and any actions "based on" that resolution, which Plaintiffs contended at oral argument included the amendments to the General Plan, the Land Use Code, and the Downtown Specific Plan; and WHEREAS, the City now desires to take further action to eliminate any uncertainty over the validity of the Planning Commission's resolution and the City Council's subsequent approvals concerning the Comprehensive Land Use Update to avoid costs and further litigation, and to further provide maximum opportunities for public review and public participation in City actions concerning the Comprehensive Land Use Update; and WHEREAS, the Comprehensive Land Use Update includes a General Plan Update; a Land Use Code Amendment; a Downtown Specific Plan Amendment; a Climate Action Plan; and five conceptual development proposals, namely, Street Conversions/Community Corridors, Senior Village Expansion, Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan, Kimball Park Master Plan, and El Toyon Park Master Plan; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of National City adopted a General Plan Update, including a land use map; adopted a Downtown Specific Plan including the Specific Plan Map amendment; adopted a Climate Action Plan; and adopted, in concept only, five development proposals, including Street Conversions/Community Corridors, Senior Village Expansion, Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan, Kimball Park Master Plan, and El Toyon Park Master Plan, and the associated Water Supply Assessment at a duly noticed public hearing held on January 24, 2012, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented; and WHEREAS, the General Plan establishes general land use policies for the planning area, and the Land Use Code (Title 18 Zoning of the Municipal Code) establishes specific land use regulations and development standards to implement the policies of the General Plan; and WHEREAS, the General Plan Land Use Map establishes the general distribution of land uses throughout the planning area, and the Official Zoning Map, which comprises part of Title 18 of the Municipal Code, identifies the specific zones that apply within and implement each General Plan land use designation; and • • • WHEREAS, the proposed Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, would implement the General Plan Update through zone classifications that establish the permitted uses on each parcel of land, the intensity of development allowed, and the standards for development; and WHEREAS, at a duly noticed public hearing held on January 9, 2012, the Planning Commission reviewed and considered the staff report contained in Case File No. 2011-17 GPA, ZC, SPA, IS, along with evidence and testimony presented at said hearing; and WHEREAS, at said hearing, the Planning Commission reviewed and considered the proposed Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, along with all evidence and testimony presented at said hearing, and along with the Environmental Impact Report prepared to assess project impacts of approving the Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, together with any comments received; and WHEREAS, prior to said hearing, the City sought out and incorporated public input throughout the preparation of the General Plan Update and the Land Use Code Update. As part of the public outreach and participation efforts, the City held a total of 23 public workshops, community meetings, and other public engagement events at different locations throughout the City, in addition to public hearings before the Planning Commission and City Council; and WHEREAS, at said hearing, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 2-2012 recommending that the City Council adopt the Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, and said resolution was transmitted forthwith to the City Council; and WHEREAS, a duly noticed public hearing was held by the City Council on January 24, 2012, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented, including the recommendation of the Planning Commission, as well as the information contained in the Environmental Impact Report prepared to assess the potential environmental impacts resulting from approval of the Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended. NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of National City, California, does ordain as follows, that the above recitals are true and correct and are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in full. FURTHER, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of National City does ordain as follows, that the oral and documentary evidence presented to the City Council at the public hearing held on January 24, 2012, support the following Findings of Fact. 1. The City Council has reviewed and considered Planning Commission's recommendations on the Land Use Code (Zoning) and associated Zoning map contained in Planning Commission Resolutions 20-2011 and 2-2012. 2. The Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, reflects the desired future vision of the City that was expressed by the community through the public participation process over the course of more than two years of development of the General Plan Update and the Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map Amendments. Ordinance No. 2012-2372 2 February 7, 2012 Official Zoning Map Amendment Land Use Code Amendment and 3. The Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, is in the public interest since it would meet the current needs of the community by providing for the types of land uses that are necessary and desirable to the community. 4. The Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, is consistent with and implements the land use policies of the General Plan and the land use designations of the General Plan. 5. The Land Use Code and Official Zoning Map, as amended, are deemed essential and desirable to the public health, safety, and general welfare of the community since specific land use regulations, development standards, and the designations of locations and distribution of land uses are necessary to reduce conflicts and insure compatibility. 6. The environmental impacts of the Zoning and Zoning Map amendments were addressed in the Comprehensive Land Use Update EIR (SCH No. 2010051009). That the testimony and evidence presented to the City Council at the public hearing held on January 24, 2012 and the City Council hearing for the second reading of this Ordinance, support the Findings of Fact, Statement of Overriding Considerations, and the MMRP attached hereto as Exhibit "E-1" and Exhibit "G". The City further finds and certifies that there has been no change to the proposed project or substantial changes in circumstances or new information that would warrant subsequent or supplemental environmental analysis in accordance with CEQA, including Public Resources Code section 21166 and CEQA Guideline sections 15162 and 15163. FURTHER, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of National City does ordain as follows, that Title 18 of the Municipal Code is hereby amended to read as set forth in Exhibit "B-1". FURTHER, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of National City does ordain as follows, that the proposed Official Zoning Map is hereby approved and adopted as the Official Zoning Map of the City of National City, and is attached hereto as Exhibit "B-3" and incorporated herein by reference. FURTHER, THEREFORE, the City Council of the City of National City does ordain as follows, that Ordinance 2011-2362 is hereby repealed in its entirety. ATTEST: PASSED and ADOPTED this 7th day of February012. CA Michael R. Dalla, City Clerk Ordinance No. 2012-2372 February 7, 2012 3 Ron Morrison, May PROVED TO FO z ✓ dia Gacittia Silva City Attorney Land Use Code Amendment and Official Zoning Map Amendment Passed and adopted by the Council of the City of National City, California, on February 7, 2012 by the following vote, to -wit: Ayes: Councilmembers Morrison, Natividad, Rios, Sotelo-Solis, Zarate. Nays: None. Absent: None. Abstain: None. AUTHENTICATED BY: By: RON MORRISON Mayor of the City of National City, California City Clerk of the Cit of National City, California Deputy I HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing ordinance was not finally adopted until seven calendar days had elapsed between the day of its introduction and the day of its final passage, to wit, on January 24, 2012 and on February 7, 2012. I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT said ordinance was read in full prior to its final passage or that the reading of said ordinance in full was dispensed with by a vote of not less than a majority of the members elected to the Council and that there was available for the consideration of each member of the Council and the public prior to the day of its passage a written or printed copy of said ordinance. I FURTHER CERTIFY that the above and foregoing is a full, true and correct copy of ORDINANCE NO. 2012-2372 of the City Council of the City of National City, passed and adopted by the Council of said City on February 7, 2012. By: City Clerk of the City of National City, California Deputy Exhibit "B-1" TITLE. 18 ZONING (LAND USE CODE) Ordinance No. 2012-2372 Adopted February 7, 2012 Effective March 8, 2012 DIVISION 1 GENERAL PROVISIONS CHAPTER 18-10 — UNDERSTANDING THE LAND USE CODE Sections 18.10.010 Purpose 18.10.020 Applicability 18.10.030 Authority, Relationship to the General Plan, Specific Plans, and Design Guidelines 18.10.040 Responsibility for Administration 18.10.050 Interpretation of Land Use Code Provisions 18.10.060 Rules of Measurement CHAPTER 18-11 — NON -CONFORMING USES, STRUCTURES, AND PARCELS Sections 18.11.010 Purpose 18.11.020 Continuance 18.11.030 Enlargements and Alterations 18.11.040 Substitution of Nonconforming Uses 18.11.050 Partially Destroyed Structures 18.11.060 Religious Institutions 18.11.070 Single -Family Dwellings 18.11.080 Nonconforming Parking Facilities 18.11.090 Nonconforming Signs 18.11.100 Termination 18.11.110 Exemptions CHAPTER 18-12 — PERMITS AND APPLICATIONS Sections 18.12.010 Permit Application and Review 18.12.020 Decision Processes for Planning Applications 18.12.030 Ministerial Decision Process 18.12.040 Discretionary Decision Process 18.12.050 Noticing and Public Hearings 18.12.060 Appeals 18.12.070 Site Plan Review 18.12.080 Minor Use Permits 18.12.090 Home Occupation Permits 18.12.100 Sign Permits 18.12.110 Conditional Use Permits 18.12.120 Variances 18.12.130 Planned Development Permits 18.12.140 Zoning Amendments 18.12.150 General Plan and Specific Plan Amendments 18.12.160 Historic Properties 1 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 2 ZONING DISTRICTS AND ALLOWABLE LAND USES CHAPTER 18-20 — ZONING MAP Sections 18.20.010 18.20.020 18.20.030 CHAPTER 18-21 Sections 18.21.010 18.21.020 18.21.030 18.21.040 18.21.050 Purpose Zones and Zoning Map Prohibited Land Uses — RESIDENTIAL ZONES Purpose Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements Accessory Uses General Development Standards Second Units CHAPTER 18-22 — COMMERCIAL ZONES Sections 18.22.010 Purpose 18.22.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.22.030 Accessory Uses 18.22.040 General Development Standards 18.22.050 Uses to be Adequately Housed in Completely Enclosed Buildings CHAPTER 18-23 — WESTSIDE MIXED -USE ZONES Sections 18.23.010 18.23.020 18.23.030 Purpose Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements General Development Standards CHAPTER 18-24 - MIXED -USE CORRIDOR AND DISTRICT ZONES Sections 18.24.010 18.24.020 18.24.030 18.24.040 18.24.050 18.24.060 18.24.070 18.24.080 18.24.090 Purpose Mixed Use Zones General Provisions Building Form and Placement Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements Accessory Uses Building Frontage Standards Parking Requirements Civic Space Standards 2 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-25 — INDUSTRIAL ZONES Sections 18.25.010 Purpose 18.25.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.25.030 Accessory Uses 18.25.040 General Development Standards 18.25.050 Uses to be Adequately Housed in Completely Enclosed Buildings CHAPTER 18-26 - INSTITUTIONAL ZONE Sections 18.26.010 Purpose 18.26.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.26.030 General Development Standards CHAPTER 18-27 — OPEN SPACE ZONE Sections 18.27.010 Purpose 18.27.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.27.030 General Development Standards CHAPTER 18-28-OPEN SPACE RESERVE ZONE Sections 18.28.010 Purpose 18.28.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements CHAPTER 18-29 — OVERLAY ZONES Sections 18.29.010 Purpose 18.29.020 Overlay Zone Designations 18.29.030 Coastal Zone (CZ) 18.29.050 Height Limit Restriction Overlay Zone (H) 18.29.060 Mobile Home Park Overlay Zone (MHP) 18.29.070 Floodway (-FW), Floodway Fringe (-FF-1), and Floodway Fringe -Shallow Flooding (-FF-2) Zones 3 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 3 CHAPTER 18-30 Sections SPECIFIC USE REGULATIONS 18.30.010 Purpose 18.30.020 Applicability 18.30.030 Adult -Oriented Businesses 18.30.040 Automobile Impound and Storage Yards 18.30.050 Sale of Alcoholic Beverages and Live Entertainment 18.30.060 Auto Body and Paint Shops 18.30.070 Child Day Care Centers 18.30.080 Family Day Care Homes 18.30.090 Condominium Conversions 18.30.100 Conversions to Nonresidential Use 18.30.110 Emergency Shelters 18.30.120 Hazardous Waste Facilities 18.30.130 Helicopter Operations 18.30.140 Mobile Homes and Similar Temporary Structures 18.30.150 Outdoor Display or Sale of Merchandise 18.30.160 Outdoor Storage 18.30.170 Recycling Collection Facilities 18.30.180 Scrap Metal Processing 18.30.190 Service Stations and Convenience Stores with Gasoline Pumps 18.30.200 Sidewalk Cafes 18.30.210 Small Wind Energy Systems 18.30.220 Telecommunications Facilities 18.30.230 Tobacco Specialty Shops 18.30.240 Urban Agriculture 18.30.250 Veterinary Hospitals and Clinics 18.30.260 Neighborhood Corner Stores 18.30.270 Motels 18.30.280 Markets that Sell Seafood 18.30.290 Bed and Breakfast Inns 18.30.300 Solar Energy Systems 18.30.310 Tattoo and Body Piercing Establishments 18.30.320 Pawn Shops and Businesses Engaged in Secondhand Dealing and/or the Purchase and Selling of Gold and Other Precious Metals 18.30.330 Payday Lenders 18.30.340 Medical Marijuana Dispensaries 18.30.350 Auto Body Uses 18.30.360 Fast Food Eating Places 4 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 4 GENERAL DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS CHAPTER 18-40 — GENERAL STANDARDS Sections 18.40.010 Purpose 18.40.020 Applicability 18.40.030 Performance Standards for All Development and Land Uses CHAPTER 18-41 — SITE PLANNING STANDARDS Sections 18.41.010 18.41.020 18.41.030 18.41.040 CHAPTER 18-42 Sections Purpose Non -Residential Site Planning Standards Multi -Unit Residential Site Planning Standards Common Usable Open Space Requirements — BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS 18.42.010 Purpose 18.42.020 Projections into Setbacks and Courts 18.42.030 Accessory Structures 18.42.040 Screening Mechanical Equipment and Elevator Housing 18.42.050 Commercial and Institutional Building Design Standards 18.42.060 Industrial Building Design Standards 18.42.070 Residential Building Design Standards CHAPTER 18-43 Sections 18.43.010 18.43.020 18.43.030 18.43.040 18.43.050 18.43.060 18.43.070 18.43.080 18.43.090 18.43.100 — FENCES AND WALLS Purpose Screening Requirements Parking Lots Materials, Construction, and Maintenance Maximum Height Prohibited Fences Entry Arbors Openings in View -Obscuring Fences Special Fences Traffic Visibility Triangles 5 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-44 — LANDSCAPING Sections 18.44.010 Purpose 18.44.020 Applicability 18.44.030 Definitions 18.44.040 Landscape Plan 18.44.050 Requirements 18.44.060 Plant Materials 18.44.070 Turf Lawn 18.44.080 Soils and Mulching 18.44.090 Minimum Percentage of Net Lot Area to be Landscaped 18.44.100 Statuary Structures and Other Lawn Art 18.44.110 Landscape Location Requirements 18.44.120 Tree Preservation 18.44.130 Landscaping Work Included in Building Permit Inspections 18.44.140 Traffic Visibility Triangles 18.44.150 Maintenance Required 18.44.160 Certain Trees a Public Nuisance 18.44.170 Nonconforming Landscaping 18.44.180 Public Utilities 18.44.190 Water Efficient Landscape Regulations CHAPTER 18-45 - OFF-STREET PARKING AND LOADING Sections 18.45.010 Purpose 18.45.020 Requirements — General 18.45.030 Off -site Facilities 18.45.040 Site Plan Review Required 18.45.050 Off -Street Parking Requirement by Land Use 18.45.060 Westside Specific Plan Parking Requirements 18.45.070 Parking for Commercial Vehicles 18.45.080 Opportunities for Reduced Parking 18.45.090 Parking for Disabled Persons 18.45.100 Parking Lot Design Standards 18.45.110 Loading Requirements 18.45.120 Bicycle Parking CHAPTER 18-46 — OUTDOOR LIGHTING Sections 18.46.010 Purpose 18.46.020 Applicability 18.46.030 General Standards 18.46.040 Lighting Plan Requirements 18.46.050 Security Lighting 18.46.060 Accent Lighting 18.46.070 Lighting Standards for Uses with 50 Feet of Residential Zones 18.46.080 Parking Lot Lighting 18.46.090 Lighting of Outdoor Performance Sport and Recreational Facilities 18.46.100 Lighting for Multi Unit Attached Residential Projects 18.46.110 Standards for Single Family Residential Uses 6 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-47 — SIGNS AND OUTDOOR ADVERTISING DISPLAYS Sections 18.47.010 Purpose 18.47.020 Site Plan Review and/or Sign Permit Required 18.47.030 Unlawful Display of Signs or Banners Prohibited 18.47.040 Definitions 18.47.050 Design and Maintenance 18.47.060 Permanent Signs Permitted in All Zones 18.47.070 Large Permanent Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.080 Large Permanent Signs in Shopping Centers 18.47.090 Small Permanent Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Institutional, Mixed -Use, and Multi -Family Zones 18.47.100 Pole -Mounted or Freestanding Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.110 Roof -Mounted Signs 18.47.120 Revolving Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones 18.47.130 Temporary Signs Permitted in All Zones 18.47.140 Projecting Signs in Commercial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.150 Vehicle Signs 18.47.160 Public Assembly Use Signs 18.47.170 Mural Type Signs in Commercial and Mixed -Use Zones 18.47.180 Digital Advertising Display (DAD) Signs 18.47.190 Flags, Banners, and Pennants 18.47.200 Signs Prohibited in All Zones 18.47.210 Master Sign Program 18.47.220 Removal from Abandoned Site or Building 18.47.230 Nonconforming Signs 18.47.240 Constitutional Severability 18.47.250 Non -Commercial Speech 18.47.260 Sign Regulations by Zone and Type 18.47.270 Signs for Special Uses CHAPTER 18-48 — DENSITY BONUS AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING INCENTIVES Sections 18.48.010 Purpose 18.48.020 Definitions 18.48.030 Density Bonus 18.48.040 Concessions, Incentives, and Development Standards 18.48.050 Application Requirernents and Review 18.48.060 Density Bonus Housing Agreement DIVISION 5 CHAPTER 18-50 — GLOSSARY 7 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 1 GENERAL PROVISIONS CHAPTER 18-10 — UNDERSTANDING THE LAND USE CODE Sections 18.10.010 Purpose 18.10.020 Applicability 18.10.030 Authority, Relationship to the General Plan, Specific Plans, and Design Guidelines 18.10.040 Responsibility for Administration 18.10.050 Interpretation of Land Use Code Provisions 18.10.060 Rules of Measurement CHAPTER 18-11 - NON -CONFORMING USES, STRUCTURES, AND PARCELS Sections 18.11.010 Purpose 18.11.020 Continuance 18.11.030 Enlargements and Alterations 18.11.040 Substitution of Nonconforming Uses 18.11.050 Partially Destroyed Structures 18.11.060 Religious Institutions 18.11.070 Single -Family Dwellings 18.11.080 Nonconforming Parking Facilities 18.11.090 Nonconforming Signs 18.11.100 Termination 18.11.110 Exemptions CHAPTER 18-12 — PERMITS AND APPLICATIONS Sections 18.12.010 Permit Application and Review 18.12.020 Decision Processes for Planning Applications 18.12.030 Ministerial Decision Process 18.12.040 Discretionary Decision Process 18.12.050 Noticing and Public Hearings 18.12.060 Appeals 18.12.070 Site Plan Review 18.12.080 Minor Use Permits 18.12.090 Home Occupation Permits 18.12.100 Sign Permits 18.12.110 Conditional Use Permits 18.12.120 Variances 18.12.130 Planned Development Permits 18.12.140 Zoning Amendments 18.12.150 General Plan and Specific Plan Amendments 18.12.160 Historic Properties 8 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-10 — UNDERSTANDING THE LAND USE CODE Sections 18.10.010 Purpose 18.10.020 Applicability 18.10.030 Authority, Relationship to the General Plan, Specific Plans, and Design Guidelines 18.10.040 Responsibility for Administration 18.10.050 Interpretation of Land Use Code Provisions 18.10.060 Rules of Measurement 18.10.010 PURPOSE A. Purposes of this Title 1. Promote and protect the public health, safety, welfare and general prosperity of the city; 2. Implement the general plan; 3. Encourage the most desirable and appropriate use of land for open space, residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, and other purposes, including the most desirable mix and intensity of uses and density of population throughout the city; 4. Ensure the orderly and adequate provision of infrastructure, facilities, and services such as streets. sidewalks, water, sewer, schools, and other public improvements; 5. Encourage the most appropriate use and occupancy of buildings; 6. Promote good planning and design; 7. Provide standards that include: the use and intensity of use of structures and land for residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, or other purposes: population density; the location, height, bulk and size of buildings and other structures; yards, courts, and other private and public open spaces: parking and loading; signs; the division of land; and grading. 18.10.020 APPLICABILITY A. Limitations on Land Use Except as otherwise provided: 1. No building or part thereof or other structure shall be erected, altered, added to or enlarged, nor shall any land, building, structure or premises be used, designated or intended to be used for any purpose or in any manner other than those uses listed in this title as permitted in the zone in which such building, land, or premises is located. 2. No building or part thereof or structure shall be erected, nor shall any existing building be altered, enlarged or rebuilt or moved into any zone, nor shall any open space be encroached upon or reduced in any manner, except in conformity with the standards and regulations of this title. B. Application of Provisions The provisions of this title shall apply to all structures or land owned, operated or controlled by any person, corporation, or governmental agency, unless specifically excepted by ordinance or by applicable state or federal regulations. 9 Title 18 Zoning 18.10.030 AUTHORITY. RELATIONSHIP TO THE GENERAL PLAN, SPECIFIC PLANS, AND DESIGN GUIDELINES A. Statutory Authority This title is adopted pursuant to the provisions of the Planning Law, Title 7 of the Government Code of the state. B. Relationship to the General Plan The Land Use Code is the primary tool used to implement the goals and policies contained within the general plan. All matters governed by this title shall substantially conform to the purposes. intent or provisions of the general plan. Any recommendations for zone changes, if found to be not in conformance with the general plan and its phrasing, should not be permitted unless it is also found that the general plan is in error or in need of change. In this situation, the general plan must also be amended to maintain consistency between the general plan and zoning. C. Relationship to Specific Plans Specific plans are designed to meet the requirements of the State Government Code and National City's General Plan. All uses, buildings, or structures located within a specific plan area shall comply with the provisions of the applicable specific plan. Where such provisions conflict with zoning regulations, the requirements of the adopted specific plan shall take precedence over the Land Use Code. In instances where the specific plan is silent, the Land Use Code shall prevail. D. Relationship to Design Guidelines The City's design guidelines are intended to supplement the general design and development regulations located in Chapter 4 of this Land Use Code. Conformance to the design guidelines is strongly encouraged, but not mandatory. The design guidelines represent the City's preferences and provide examples of appropriate, quality design that positively contribute to the character of the community, but they are not intended to preclude alternatives or restrict imagination. In the event there is a conflict between Chapter 4 of this Land Use Code and the design guidelines, the regulations in Chapter 4 shall prevail. 18.10.040 RESPONSIBILITY FOR ADMINISTRATION This Land Use Code shall be administrated by: the City Council, the Planning Commission, and the City Manager or his/her designee in compliance with Title 18 of the Municipal Code. 18.10.050 INTERPRETATION OF LAND USE CODE PROVISIONS A. Purpose This Section provides rules for resolving questions about the meaning or applicability of any part of this title. The provisions of this Section are intended to ensure the consistent interpretation and application of the requirements of this Land Use Code and the General Plan. B. Rules of Interpretation 1- Authority. The City Manager or his/her designee shall have the responsibility and authority on a staff level to interpret the meaning and applicability of all provisions and requirements of this title. 2. Language. a. Terminology. When used in this title, the words "shall," "will," "is to," and "are to" are always mandatory. "Should" is not mandatory but is strongly recommended; and "may" is permissive. The present tense includes the past and future tenses; and the future tense includes the present. 10 Title 18 Zoning b. Number of days. Whenever a number of days is specified in this title, or in any permit, condition of approval, or notice issued or given as provided in this title, the number of days shall be construed as calendar days, unless business days are specified. Time limits will extend to the following business day where the last of the specified number of days falls on a day that the City is not open for business, except as otherwise provided for by other state and federal laws, regulations, and agencies. c. Number of months. Whenever a time limit in this title is specified in months, the number of months shall be deemed to be consecutive months. 3. Calculations and rounding. Where provisions of this Land Use Code require calculations to determine applicable requirements, any fractional/decimal results of the calculations shall be rounded as provided by this Section. a. Residential density and number of lots/parcels. For example, the RS-1 zoning district allows a minimum lot area of 10,000 square feet for new subdivisions. Therefore, a parcel of 38,000 square feet could be subdivided into a maximum of three parcels, if approved by the review authority (38,000 /10,000 =3.8, which would be rounded down to 3). Refer to Section 18.10.060(C) for rules regarding fractions. 4. Conflicting requirements. Any conflicts between requirements of this title, or between this title and other regulations, shall be resolved as follows. a. Land Use Code provisions. In the event of any conflict between the provisions of this title, the most restrictive requirement shall control. b. Development agreements or specific plans. In the event of any conflict between the requirements of this title and standards adopted as part of any development agreement or specific plan, the requirements of the development agreement or specific plan shall control. c. Other regulations. In the event of any conflict between requirements of this Land Use Code and other regulations of the City, the most restrictive requirement shall control as determined by the City. d. Private agreements. It is not intended that the requirements of this Land Use Code shall interfere with, repeal, abrogate or annul any easement, covenant, or other agreement that existed when this Land Use Code became effective. This Land Use Code applies to all land uses and development regardless of whether it imposes a greater or lesser restriction on the development or use of structures or land than an applicable private agreement or restriction, without affecting the applicability of any agreement or restriction. The City shall not enforce any private covenant or agreement unless it is a party to the covenant or agreement. e. General Plan. See Section 18.10.030 (B). 5. Internal cross-references. When a provision of this Land Use Code refers to a requirement elsewhere, the subject of the cross reference is assumed to be another chapter, Section, or subsection of this title, or another provision within the same Section or chapter, unless the title of another document is provided. 6. Zoning map boundaries. See Chapter 18.20 (Zoning Map). 7. Allowable uses of land. See Chapters 18-21 through 18-26 for allowable land uses by zoning district. C. Procedures for Interpretations 1. Whenever the requirements of this title are subject to interpretation generally, or as applied to a specific case, the City Manager or his/her designee shall issue a determination, or refer the matter to the Planning Commission for interpretation. 2. Request for interpretation. The request for an interpretation or determination shall be filed with the City and shall include all information required by the City. 3. Referral of interpretation. The City Manager or his/her designee has the option of forwarding any determination of the meaning or applicability of any provision of this title directly to the Planning Commission for consideration. 4. Findings, basis for interpretation. The issuance of an interpretation shall include findings stating the basis for the interpretation. The basis for an interpretation may include technological changes or new 11 Title 18 Zoning industry standards. The issuance of an interpretation shall also include a finding documenting the consistency of the interpretation with the General Plan, and any applicable Specific Plan. 5. Record of interpretations. a. Interpretations shall be written and quote the provisions of this title interpreted, and the applicability in the particular or general circumstances that caused the need for interpretations; and b. This title shall be amended to reflect interpretations made as soon as is practical. Until an amendment can occur, the City Manager or his/her designee shall maintain a complete record of all interpretations indexed by the number of the chapter or Section that is the subject of the interpretation. 18.10.060 RULES OF MEASUREMENT A. Purpose The purpose of this Section is to explain how various measurements referenced in this title are to be calculated. B. Applicant Responsibility For all calculations, the applicant shall be responsible for supplying drawings illustrating the measurements that apply to a project. These drawings shall be drawn to scale and of sufficient detail to allow easy verification upon inspection by the City. C. Fractions When calculating a maximum requirement, round down to nearest whole number. When calculating a minimum requirement, round up to nearest whole number. D. Measuring Distances 1. Measurements are the shortest distance. When measuring a required distance, such as the minimum distance between a structure and a lot line, the measurement is made at the closest or shortest distance between the two objects. 2. Distances are measured horizontally. Distances are measured along a horizontal plane unless otherwise specified. 1 Measurements involving a structure. Measurements involving a structure are made to the closest wall of the structure, unless otherwise specified. 4. Measurements between uses. When measuring the distance between two different uses, the measurement is calculated from closest lot line to lot line. E. Measuring Height 1. General. Height shall be considered the vertical distance from the highest point of any structure to the ground level directly below, except as otherwise provided in this Section. 2. Measuring building height on sloped lots. Height shall be measured from any point on top of the building to a line directly below which connects to opposite perimeter walls, or other perimeter support systems, at the lower of natural or finished grade. All parts of a building, except for allowed projections specifically listed in this Land Use Code, shall comply with maximum height limits. 3. Measuring the height of buildings located near retaining walls. If any portion of a building lies within the setback area of a lot and the base of the retaining wall is at a lower elevation than the building, the height of the building shall be calculated from the base of the retaining wall (at the lower of natural or finished grade) rather than from the base of the building wall. 4. Measuring the Height of Combined Fences and Retaining Walls. When a fence is constructed on top of or within one foot of the face of an above -ground retaining wall, and located in a required yard, the 12 Title 18 Zoning F. Measuring Lot Width and Depth 1. Lot width. Minimum lot width shall be measured at the front setback line, or from the front property line is there is no required setback, as determined by the zoning of the parcel. 2. Lot depth. Lot depth is measured along an imaginary straight line drawn from the midpoint of the front property line of the lot to the midpoint of the rear property line or to the most distant point on any other lot line where there is no rear lot line. G. Determining Floor Area Floor area is the horizontal area (expressed in square feet) of all floors included within a building or buildings, according to the following rules: 1. Included in floor area. Floor area is deemed to include: a. The floor of atrium and lobby areas b. Enclosed and roofed storage and equipment spaces c. Enclosed and roofed halls, stairways, and elevator shafts d. Enclosed and roofed porches and balconies e. Portions of basements and attics that meet Building Code height requirements for living space f. The actual floor space of mezzanines, interior balconies, and lofts 2. Excluded from Floor area. Floor area does not include: a. Unenclosed balconies, decks, porches, and stairs b. Substandard height portions of attics and basements c. The area within a building adjacent to, and in an imaginary horizontal plane with, interior balconies, mezzanines, or lofts. H. Determining Floor Area Ratio Floor area ratio (FAR) is the ratio of the floor area of all principal and accessory buildings on a lot to the lot area. To calculate FAR, floor area is divided by lot area, and typically expressed as a decimal. For example, if the floor area of all buildings on a lot totals 20,000 square feet, and the lot area is 10,000 square feet, the FAR is expressed as 2.0. I. Determining Lot Coverage Lot coverage is the ratio of the footprint of all structures on a lot to the lot area, typically expressed as a percentage. The footprints of all principal and accessory structures, including garages, carports and roofed porches, shall be summed in order to calculate lot coverage. The following structures shall be excluded from the calculations: 1. Unenclosed and unroofed structures; porches, landings, balconies, and stairways less than three feet in height. 2. Unenclosed and unroofed decks less than eighteen inches in height- 3. Eaves and roof overhangs projecting up to four feet from a wall. 4. Trellises and similar structures that do not have solid roofs. 5. Swimming pools and hot tubs that are not enclosed in roofed structures. 6. Trash enclosures. 7. Solar collectors. 13 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-11 - NON -CONFORMING USES, STRUCTURES, AND PARCELS 18.11.010 Purpose 18.11.020 Continuance 18.11.030 Enlargements and Alterations 18.11.040 Substitution of Nonconforming Uses 18.11.050 Partially Destroyed Structures 18.11.060 Religious Institutions 18.11.070 Single -Family Dwellings 18.11.080 Nonconforming Parking Facilities 18.11.090 Nonconforming Signs 18.11.100 Termination 18.11.110 Exemptions 18.11.010 PURPOSE Within the zones established by this title, there exist uses, structures and lots which were lawful before the Land Use Code was adopted or amended. but which would be prohibited under the terms of this title or future amendment to this title. It is the intent of this title to permit these nonconforming uses to continue until they are terminated, but not to encourage their expansion. To avoid undue hardship, nothing in this Chapter shall be deemed to require a change in the plans, construction, or designated use of any building where a building permit has been issued prior to the effective date of the Land Use Code, provided such permit construction is diligently carried to completion. 18.11.020 CONTINUANCE Any lawful nonconforming use existing at the time of adoption of the Land Use Code may be continued, provided such use is continually maintained and occupied. A nonconforming use in either a conforming building or a nonconforming building, structure, or portion of either shall neither be extended to any portion of the building or structure not so used nor be enlarged or extended to any other portion of the lot not actually so occupied at the time said use became nonconforming, except as otherwise provided in this chapter. 18.11.030 ENLARGEMENTS AND ALTERATIONS A. Changes to Non -Conforming Uses No existing building or premises designed, arranged, intended, or devoted to a use not permitted in the zone in which such building or premises is located shall be enlarged, extended, reconstructed or structurally altered, except: 1. Work done in any period of twelve months on ordinary structural alterations or replacements of walls, fixtures or plumbing not exceeding twice the building's assessed value, according to the assessment thereof by the county assessor for the fiscal year in which such work is done, shall be permitted. 2. These provisions shall not prevent the expansion, increase in capacity, modernization or replacement of such public utility buildings, structures, equipment, and features as are used directly for the delivery of or distribution of the service; provided, however, that all setback requirements of the zone in which the site is located shall be maintained and there shall be no enlargement of the site. 3- A single-family detached dwelling may be reconstructed or remodeled in accordance with the standards of the existing structure, i.e., in the same building location on the lot, the same size of the existing structure, and the same height as the existing structure; however, different materials and architectural details may be used. 4. A nonconforming use located in the Westside Specific Plan area that substitutes another nonconforming use in compliance with Section 18.11.040 may expand, enlarge, reconstruct, or structurally alter the footprint of the existing building or structure for that substituted nonconforming use up to 20 percent within the existing parcel in which it is located, subject to first obtaining a conditional use permit. 14 Title 18 Zoning 18.11.040 SUBSTITUION OF NONCONFORMING USES A. Conversion of Non -Conforming Uses A nonconforming use may not be converted to any use except to a specifically permitted use in the zone of the parcel on which it is located; except that conversion of a lawful nonconforming use to a nonconforming use found by the Planning Commission to be a lawful nonconforming use on another site within the same zone may be allowed where a conditional use permit therefore has been approved; provided, that this shall in no way extend the abatement provisions contained in this Chapter. The exception stated in this paragraph of allowing a conversion of a lawful nonconforming use to another nonconforming use within the same zone does not apply to nonconforming uses located within the Westside Specific Plan area. B. Nonconforming uses located within the Westside Specific Plan area 1. A nonconforming use located on a parcel or parcels located within the Westside Specific Plan may not be converted to any use except to a specifically permitted use in the zone of the parcel or parcels on which it is located, except as follows: a. A nonconforming use may be converted to any use which is specifically permitted in the allowable uses for any of the zones identified in Appendix A of the Westside Specific Plan. 2. A nonconforming use that converts to another nonconforming use from Appendix A may enlarge and alter their footprint to the extent allowed in Section 18.11.030. C. Nonconforming Uses in the CA Zone In the CA zone where there exists commercial retail shopping facilities which became nonconforming at the time of the adoption of the Land Use Code, such facilities may continue to lease commercial space to uses typical of such facilities but not otherwise permitted in the CA zone. 18.11.050 PARTIALLY DESTROYED STRUCTURES A. Nonconforming Buildings or Structures that Become Damaged A nonconforming building or structure which is damaged or destroyed by fire, explosion, or natural disaster may be restored and the occupancy or use of such structure or part thereof existing at the time of such partial destruction may be continued or resumed provided: 1. Such restoration results in an equal or lesser degree of nonconformity; 2. The total cost of such restoration for structures other than single-family detached dwellings does not exceed one-half the replacement cost of the structure at the time of such damage (the replacement cost will be calculated by the department of building and housing); 3. Such restoration is started within a period of one year and is carried out diligently to completion; 4. Such damage or destruction of structures is not intentionally caused by the owner. 18.11.060 RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS Religious Institutions of a permanent nature which became nonconforming al the time of adoption of the Land Use Code may be continued, reconstructed, structurally altered, extended or enlarged subject to plans approved by the Planning Commission for any reconstruction, alteration, extension or enlargement and provided such reconstruction, alteration, extension or enlargement conforms with all other provisions of this title; and provided, further, that said extension. reconstruction, alteration or enlargement shall not be extended to additional property beyond the parcel(s) upon which the nonconforming use exists. 15 Title 18 Zoning 18.11.070 SINGLE FAMILY DWELLINGS A. Nonconforming Single -Family Dwellings Single-family dwellings which became nonconforming uses at the time of adoption of the Land Use Code or of amendments to the code may be continued, reconstructed, structurally altered, extended or enlarged in conformance with the following: 1. Enlargement or extension of a single-family detached dwelling shall conform to the standards of the zone which applies to the property. If a proposed enlargement or extension, except in the coastal zone, results in more than two thousand five hundred square feet of floor area and/or more than four bedrooms, parking facilities shall be provided for the increase but not for any existing deficiency in such facilities. Parking facilities required as a result of this Section may be provided in a garage, carport, or surface space. 2. No increase in parking over that previously provided shall be required for reconstruction of a nonconforming single-family residential use destroyed or partially destroyed by natural disaster, but may be permitted, in conformance to development standards of the zone which applies to the property. 18.11.080 NONCONFORMING PARKING FACILITIES A. Use Made Nonconforming by Off -Street Parking Requirements 1. Any use, excluding a single-family detached dwelling, which is nonconforming only because of changes made in the off-street parking requirements by the adoption of the Land Use Code, or any amendment thereto, may be expanded, increased or modified, or converted to a conforming use, and no addition to or change in the off-street parking facilities shall be required except as identified below. 2. If the existing off-street parking facilities are not sufficient to comply with the requirements of this title after such expansion, increase or modification, additional parking facilities shall be added. 3. The capacity of said facilities shall equal the difference between the off-street parking facilities this title would require for such use as expanded, increased or modified, and the off-street parking facilities as required for such use before said expansion, increase or modification. 4. This shall not apply to entertainment and public assembly type uses which shall provide the full amount of parking otherwise required. 5. Any additional off-street parking facilities provided under these conditions shall be developed pursuant to the provisions of Chapter 18-45 (Off -Street Parking and Loading). 6. Any modification of off-street parking requirements permitted by this Section shall not be construed to extend the termination date of the subject nonconforming use, as specified by this title. 18.11.090 NONCONFORMING SIGNS A. Nonconforming Sign Regulations 1. In cases where the area of signs existing as a lawful nonconforming use on a property exceeds the total allowable area for permitted signs, no additional signs shall be permitted on the property. If the size or configuration of a parcel or building is changed by the subdivision or splitting of the property or alterations to the building or parcel, property identification signs and outdoor advertising signs on the resulting properties shall be required to conform to the sign regulations applicable to the newly created parcel or parcels, at the time such change becomes effective. 2. In the event a use of any site or building is vacated, terminated or abandoned, for any reason, for a period of more than one ninety consecutive days, the owner or person in possession of the property shall be responsible for the removal of all signs on the property, building or wall, or for having the copy thereon painted out, immediately upon notice from the City. 3. Nonconforming signs shall be removed or made conforming when the business or property changes occupancy or ownership. 16 Title 18 Zoning 18.11.100 TERMINATION A. Violation of Title Any of the following violations of this title shall immediately terminate the right to operate a nonconforming use, except as otherwise provided in this title: 1. Changing a nonconforming use to a use not permitted in the zone; 2. Increasing or enlarging the area, space, or volume occupied by or devoted to such nonconforming use: 3. Addition to a nonconforming use of another use not permitted in the zone- B. Discontinuance A nonconforming use or structure shall become discontinued, except when extended as otherwise provided in this title, when it is: 1. Succeeded by a conforming use; 2. Discontinued and not re-established within a period of twelve or more consecutive calendar months; 3. Discontinued and not re-established within a period of eighteen or more nonconsecutive calendar months in a twenty-four month period. C. Termination by Operation of Law The following conditions will result in a termination of nonconforming signs. 1. Termination by abandonment. Any nonconforming sign, the use of which is discontinued for a period of ninety (90) days, regardless of any intent to resume or not to abandon such use, shall be deemed to be abandoned and shall not thereafter be re-established. Any period of such discontinuance caused by government actions, strikes, material shortages or forces of nature, and without any contributing fault by the nonconforming user, shall not be considered in calculating the length of discontinuance for purposes of this Section. 2. Termination by change of business. Any nonconforming sign advertising or relating to a business on the premises on which it is located shall be terminated upon any change in the ownership or control of such business. 3. Termination by damage or destruction. Any nonconforming sign damaged or destroyed, by any means, to the extent of thirty-five (35) percent of its replacement cost new shall not be restored but shall be terminated. 4. Termination by going out of business/closure of business. No sign that is accessory to a principal nonconforming use or structure shall continue after such principal use or structure shall have ceased or terminated, unless it shall thereafter conform to all the regulations of the zoning district in which it is located. 5. Termination due to lack of repair. Failure to keep a nonconforming sign in good repair within one year after notification by the City shall constitute abandonment and subject to termination. D. Affirmative Termination by Amortization 1. The City Council of the City of National City may order a nonconforming use to be terminated within a reasonable amount of time, upon recommendation of the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission shall conduct a public hearing after 10 days' written notice to the nonconforming user. If the nonconforming user has not made a substantial investment in furtherance of the use, or if the investment can be substantially utilized or recovered through a currently permitted use, the order may require complete termination of the nonconforming use within a minimum of one year after the date of the order. If the nonconforming user has made a substantial investment in furtherance of the use, or if the investment cannot be substantially utilized or recovered through a currently permitted use, the order may require the complete termination of (he nonconforming use within a longer reasonable amount of time. Nonconforming uses that are determined 10 be an imminent threat to the public health or safety may be terminated immediately, pursuant to Chapter 1.36 of this Municipal Code. In 17 Title 18 Zoning a. The total cost of land and improvements; b. The length of time the use has existed; c. Adaptability of the land and improvements to a currently permitted use; d. The cost of moving and reestablishing the use elsewhere; e. Whether theuse is significantly nonconforming; f. Compatibility with the existing land use patterns and densities of the surrounding neighborhood; g. The possible threat to public health, safety, or welfare; and h. Any other relevant factors. The term "nonconforming use" when used in this Section shall include nonconforming uses, nonconforming structures, and nonconforming lots, consistent with the intent of this title. This amortization Section does not apply to any lawful nonconforming residential uses. Failure to comply with the City Council's order to terminate a nonconforming use shall constitute a violation of this chapter and is a public nuisance subject to abatement in accordance with Chapter 1.36 of this Code. 2. That a notice of exemption shall be filed indicating that this amendment to the Municipal Code is exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act, because it can be said with certainty that there is no possibility that the action will have a significant effect on the environment as it does not have a direct effect on any property or environmental consequence. E. Unlawful uses and structures Uses and structures that did not comply with the applicable provisions of this Land Use Code or prior planning and zoning regulations when established are violations of this Code and are subject to the provisions of Title 1 of the Municipal Code (Administration and Enforcement). This Section does not grant any right to continue occupancy of property containing an illegal use or structure. The activity shall not be allowed to continue unless/until permits or entitlements required by this Land Use Code and the Municipal Code are first obtained. 18.11.110 EXEMPTIONS A. Historic Structures Nonconforming structures of historical significance may be altered or enlarged with a building permit approval granted by the City Manager or his/her designee, without conforming to current setback provisions; provided the historic structure: 1. Has been certified to be an historic resource by the City, County, or State, or in the National Register of Historic Places; or 2. Is to be altered or enlarged as an authentic replica of the original structure. B. Single-family Dwellings Single-family dwellings are exempt from the provisions of Section 18.11.100 as follows: 1. Height. An existing single-family dwelling that is nonconforming only because it exceeds the height limit of the applicable zone, shall not be required to comply with the provisions of this title. 2. Setbacks. Where a single-family dwelling or a detached accessory structure, is nonconforming only by reason of substandard setbacks, the provisions of this title shall not apply; provided that any structural alteration of a nonconforming structure shall not increase the degree of nonconformity, and any enlargements shall comply with the setback requirements of the applicable zoning district. 3. Parking. A single-family dwelling that is nonconforming with respect to the parking requirements of this Land Use Code is exempt from requirements of this title that would otherwise require compliance with the parking requirements of this Land Use Code. 18 Title 18 Zoning C. Destroyed Nonconforming Dwelling Units 1. Where the City Manager or his/her designee determines that a nonconforming single- or multi -family dwelling unit has been involuntarily damaged or destroyed by accident (e.g., fire, explosion, etc.) or natural disaster (e.g., earthquake, etc.). the unit may be reconstructed or replaced with a new structure using the same development standards applied to the damaged or destroyed structure (e.g., building footprint, building height, density standards. number of dwelling units, setbacks, and floor area); provided: a. The applicant provides documentation, satisfactory to the review authority, supporting the claim that the damage or destruction occurred involuntarily; b. No expansion of the gross floor area or number of dwelling units occurs: c. The replacement structure: i. Is in compliance with the current Building Code, and ii. Would not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or welfare or materially injurious to the properties or improvements in the immediate vicinity of the replacement structure; d_ A Building Permit is issued no later than 12 months after the date of destruction, and construction is diligently pursued to completion. 2. If the preceding requirements are not met, the replacement structure shall comply with all of the regulations of the applicable zoning district in effect on the date of application for the required Building Permit. D. Seismic Retrofitting Alterations, reconstruction, or repairs otherwise required by law (e.g., City adopted Building, Electrical, Plumbing Codes) shall be allowed. Reconstruction required to reinforce unreinforced masonry structures or to comply with Budding Code requirements shall be allowed without cost limitations; provided, the retrofitting and Code compliance are limited exclusively to compliance with earthquake safety standards and other applicable Building Code requirements. E. Nonconforming Upon Annexation Nonconforming uses or structures. or both, which are lawfully existing at the time the property on which they are located is annexed to the City, and which do not conform to the regulations of the subject zoning district following annexation, shall be deemed legal nonconforming uses or structures, or both, and shall, upon annexation, be subject to the provisions of this Chapter. F. Nonconforming Due to A Lack of A Conditional Use Permit 1. Conformity of uses requiring Conditional Use Permits. A use that becomes nonconforming only because it is a use that would be required by this Land Use Code to have Conditional Use Permit approval shall be deemed conforming, but only to the extent that it previously existed prior to adoption of the Land Use Code (e.g., maintain the same site area boundaries, hours of operation, etc.). 2. Previous Conditional Use Permits in effect. A use that was authorized by a Conditional Use Permit prior to adoption of this Land Use Code, but is identified in this Land Use Code as a use that is not allowed in its current location, may continue, but only in compliance with the original Conditional Use Permit. G. Previous Permits A use or structure which does not conform to the current regulations of the subject zoning district, but for which a Building Permit, or a permit or entitlement approved in compliance with this Land Use Code, was issued and work substantially completed before the applicability of this Land Use Code, may be completed; provided, the work is diligently pursued to completion. Upon completion these uses or 19 Title 18 Zoning structures, or parts thereof, shall be deemed to be legal nonconforming and shall thereafter be subject to the provisions of this Chapter. H. Public Acquisition Nonconforming due to public acquisition. Whenever any structure or parcel is rendered nonconforming within the meaning of this Chapter by reason of a reduction in a required parcel area, reduction of off- street parking facilities, or setbacks occurring solely by reason of dedication to, or purchase by, the City for any public purpose, or eminent domain proceedings, which result in the acquisition by the City or any agency authorized for the eminent domain proceedings of a portion of the property, the structure or parcel shall not be deemed nonconforming within the meaning of this Chapter. CHAPTER 18-12 — PERMITS AND APPLICATIONS 18.12.010 Permit Application and Review 18.12.020 Decision Processes for Planning Applications 18.12.030 Ministerial Decision Process 18.12.040 Discretionary Decision Process 18.12.050 Noticing and Public Hearings 18.12.060 Appeals 18.12.070 Site Plan Review 18.12.080 Minor Use Permits 18.12.090 Home Occupation Permits 18.12.100 Sign Permits 18.12.110 Conditional Use Permits 18.12.120 Variances 18.12.130 Planned Development Permits 18.12.140 Zoning Amendments 18.12.150 General Plan and Specific Plan Amendments 18.12.160 Historic Properties 18.12.010 PERMIT APPLICATION AND REVIEW An application for a permit or other land use matter shall be filed with the Planning Division in accordance with the following provisions: A. Authority to File an Application The following persons are deemed to have the authority to file an application: 1. The record owner of the real property that is the subject of the permit or other matter; 2. The property owner's authorized agent; or 3. Any person who can demonstrate a legal right, interest, or entitlement to use the real property subject to the application; 4. The application of a redeveloper who is seeking to redevelop the property involved, and who is a party to an existing disposition and development agreement with the community development commission. B. Applications — Acceptability of Signatures If signatures of persons other than the owners of the property making the application are required or offered in support of, or in opposition to, an application, they may be received as evidence of notice having been served upon them of the pending application, or as evidence of their opinion on the pending issue, but they shall in no case infringe upon the free exercise of the powers vested in the City as represented by the Planning Commission and the City Council. 20 Title 18 Zoning C. Application Form and Subrnittal Items The City Manager or his/her designee shall prescribe the form in which applications are made for administrative or discretionary approvals and maintain a list specifying the materials and information to be submitted with each application for a permit or other matter filed in accordance with the Land Use Code. The list may be revised as needed to comply with revisions to local, state, or federal law, regulation, or policy. D. Submittal Requirements The application shall be made on a form provided by the City Manager or his/her designee and shall be accompanied by the materials, information, fees, and deposits that are required on the date the application is filed, unless otherwise specified by the Land Use Code or state law. E. Evaluation The application shall be deemed complete when the department processing the application has determined that the application includes all of the information, materials, fees, and deposits required. The City may, in the course of processing the application, request that the applicant clarify, simplify, or provide in alternate format or medium, the information required for the application. F. Filing Fee All filing fees required to be paid upon the filing of any application shall be set forth from time to time by City Council resolution. G. Applications - Filing Applications filed pursuant to this title shall be numbered consecutively in the order of their filing, and shall become a part of the permanent official records, and there shall be attached thereto and permanently filed copies of all notices and actions, with certificates and affidavits of applicable posting, mailing or publication. H. Applications - Withdrawal Any applicant may withdraw an application at any time, provided the withdrawal is in writing and notification of public hearing has not been mailed. Any public hearing for which notification has been given shall be convened, at which time withdrawal of the application may be acknowledged and filed. 18.12.020 DECISION PROCESSES FOR PLANNING APPLICATIONS Applications for permits or other matters identified in this Land Use Code shall be acted upon in accordance with one of the decision processes depicted in Table 18.12.020 (Decision Processes for Planning Applications). Table 18.12.020 is provided for convenience of reference only and does not define, describe, or limit the scope, meaning, or intent of any provision of the Land Use Code. This table describes the City of National City's processes only and does not describe other decision processes that may be required by other agencies, such as the State Coastal Commission. Subdivision procedures are identified in Title 17. 21 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.12.020 Decision Process for Planning Applications Application Type Role of Review Authority Planning Division Planning Commission City Council Ministerial Applications Interpretations (See Section 18.10.050 (C)) Decision Appeal Appeal Appeal Minor Site Plan Review Decision Appeal Minor Use Permit Decision Appeal Appeal Home Occupation Permit Decision Appeal Appeal Sign Permit Decision Appeal Appeal Discretionary Applications Conditional Use Permit Variance Recommend Decision Appeal Recommend Decision Appeal Planned Development Permit Recommend Decision Appeal General Plan Amendment Recommend Recommend Decision Zoning Ordinance Amendment Recommend Recommend Decision Zoning Map Amendment Recommend Recommend Decision 18.12.030 A. Purpose MINISTERIAL DECISION PROCESS Ministerial review is conducted at the staff level and is intended to ensure compliance with the regulations established in the Land Use Code. B. Decision An application for an administrative permit may be approved, conditionally approved, or denied by a staff person designated by the City Manager without a public hearing. C. Notice of Application A notice of application is only required for minor use permits pursuant to Section 18.12.080_ D. Notice of Decision 1. The designated staff person shall mail notice of the decision to: a. The applicant. b. Any person who requested notice of the approval or denial of the application from the staff person. 2. Such notice shall contain a brief statement of the reason or reasons for the approval or disapproval. 22 Title 18 Zoning E. Appeal to the Planning Commission The decision of the designated staff person is final and conclusive unless, within 30 days after mailing the notice of decision, the applicant or other interested party files a written letter of appeal with the Planning Division in accordance with Section 18.12.060(B). F. Appeal to the City Council The decision of the Planning Commission shall become effective and final 30 days following such action unless, within such period of time the applicant or other interested party files a written letter of appeal with the Planning Division in accordance with Section 18.12.060(C). 18.12.040 DISCRETIONARY DECISION PROCESS A. Purpose A discretionary permit is a permit or permit modification granted following determinations that require the exercise of judgment and deliberation, as opposed to merely determining that the permit request complies with a set of standards. B. Decision As identified in Table 18.12.101, depending on the permit type. the decision to approve or deny a discretionary permit or action is either made by Planning Commission or the City Council. C. Environmental Review All discretionary decisions by the Planning Commission and City Council require findings prescribed in the California Environmental Quality Act and ordinances adopted pursuant thereto, in addition to all other requirements. D. Planning Commission Decision 1. When a discretionary application is to be decided by the Planning Commission pursuant to Section 18.12.020, a hearing shall be held in accordance with Section 18.12.050. 2. Waiver of Appeal Period. Before the close of the public hearing, an applicant may request that the appeal period be waived in accordance with Section 18.12.060(D). Notwithstanding any action of the Planning Commission to grant a waiver of appeal, the City Council may set the matter for a hearing. 3. If the appeal period is riot waived, the decision of the Planning Commission shall become effective and final 30 days following such action, unless, within such period of time the applicant or other interested party files a written letter of appeal with the Planning Division requesting an appeal before the City Council. 4. Within such 30 days, a copy of the Planning Commission resolution granting or denying such application shall be transmitted to the City Council unless an appeal is filed. If no appeal is filed, the City Council may set the matter for a public hearing. E. City Council Decision 1. When a discretionary action is to be decided by the City Council pursuant to Section 18.12.020, a hearing before the Planning Commission shall occur first in accordance with Section 18.12.050. 2. Once the Planning Commission has made a recommendation on the action, a hearing shall be scheduled before the City Council pursuant to Section 18.12.050. 3. The City Council's decision is final and effective upon the rendering of the decision. 23 Title 18 Zoning F. Expiration 1. If a discretionary permit is not exercised within the time permitted by this chapter, such permit shall be deemed null and void. The exercise of such rights shall be commenced within the time permitted by the resolution granting such permit. If no time is specified, then for all purposes such time for the exercise of right shall be deemed to be a period of one year from and after the adoption of the resolution granting such permit. 2. The granting body, upon good cause shown by the applicant, may extend the time permitted by this chapter for the exercise of such rights, for a period of not to exceed one year. 3. An additional extension of time may be granted by the granting body where the applicant, after a public hearing, which shall be noticed as provided in Section 18.12.050 (Noticing and Public Hearings), shows, to the reasonable satisfaction of such body, that the exercise of such rights was prevented by causes outside of the applicant's control. Such time extensions shall be for reasonable periods of time, not exceeding one year for each such extension. 4. Requests for extensions of time within which to exercise the rights under a discretionary permit shall be made prior to the expiration date thereof. Such requests shall be in writing and, where the Planning Commission is the granting body, shall be filed with the secretary of the commission. Where the City Council is the granting body, such written requests shall be filed with the Planning Division. Upon the filing of such a written request, the time for the exercise of rights under the permit shall be deemed automatically extended until the granting body determines whether or not the request is to be granted, but in no event shall such automatic extension be for a period longer than thirty days, except as hereinafter provided. 5. Where the granting body is the City Council, if no action is taken upon such request within a period of thirty days after the filing thereof, the same shall be deemed denied. 6. Where the granting body is the Planning Commission, and the commission either denies the request or fails, within a period of 30 `days, to take action thereon, the same shall be deemed denied, unless within 10 days after such request has been denied by the commission, or within 10 days after the expiration of the 30 day period, an appeal is filed, in writing, with the Planning Division. 7. Where an appeal is taken from the commission's action or inaction, the expiration date for the permit shall be automatically extended for a period of 30 days after the filing of such written appeal with the Planning Division. if the Council fails to act upon the request within said 30 day period, the same shall be deemed denied. G. Violations The following shall be considered violations of Title 18: 1. Commencement or continuation of an activity which requires approval of a discretionary permit pursuant to this title, not including lawful nonconforming uses, established prior to enactment of regulations that require a discretionary permit for the activity. 2. Any violation of a condition of approval of a discretionary permit. 18.12.050 NOTICING AND PUBLIC HEARINGS A. Public Hearing Defined A public hearing is a noticed public session to receive original evidence or testimony on applications regulated by this title. These are held by the Planning Commission and City Council. B. Scheduling For all proposals to be heard by the Planning Commission, the City Manager or his/her designee shall set the date for public hearing and give the required notice. For all appeals of Planning Commission decisions and all other matters requiring public hearings by the City Council, the City Clerk shall set dates for public hearings and give required notices. The date of the hearings shall be not less than 10 days nor more than 45 days from the time of the filing of such verified application or the adoption of a resolution or the making of a motion to set the public hearing. 24 Title 18 Zoning C. Notice - Generally Notice of time and place of public hearings shall be given in the following manner: 1. A notice of any public hearing upon a proposed amendment to this title, or to the zoning map, shall be given by at least one publication in a newspaper of general circulation in the city not less than 10 days before the date of the public hearing. 2. Notice of public hearing to consider a variance, conditional use permit, planned development permit, or reclassification of any property shall be given by mailing a written notice not less than 10 days prior to the date of such hearing to the applicant, and to owners of property within a radius of 300 feet of the exterior boundaries of the property to be changed, using for this purpose the name and address of such owners and properties, as shown on the latest adopted San Diego County tax roll, and other persons on request 3. In the event that the number of owners to whom notice may be sent pursuant to this Section is greater than one thousand, notice may be given at least ten days prior to the hearing by either of the following procedures: a. By placing a display advertisement of at least one-fourth page in a newspaper having general circulation within the area affected by the proposed ordinance or amendment; or b. By placing an insert with any generalized mailing sent by the City to property owners in the area affected by the proposed ordinance or amendment, such as billings for City services. D. Notice - Additional Requirement For Conditional Use Permits For The Sale Of Alcoholic Beverages In addition to notice required pursuant to this Section, written notice for a public hearing on a conditional use permit for the sale of alcoholic beverages shall be provided as specified in Section 18.30.050 of this title. E. Notice - Required Wording Such public notice of hearings on zone reclassifications, amendments, variances, planned development permits, or conditional use permits shall consist of the words "Notice of Proposed Change of Zone Boundaries or Classification" or "Notice of Proposed Variance", "Notice of Proposed Planned Development Permit", or "Notice of Proposed Conditional Use Permit," as the case may be, setting forth the description of the property under consideration. the nature of the proposed change or use, and the time and place at which the public hearing, or hearings, on the matter will be held. F. Hearing Rules The Planning Commission may establish rules governing the conduct of its proceedings. G. Continuation of Hearing If, for any reason, testimony on any case set for public hearing cannot be completed on the date set for such hearing, the person presiding at such public hearing may, before adjournment or recess thereof, publicly announce the time and place at which the hearing will be continued, and no further notice is required. H. Testimony A summary of all pertinent testimony offered at public hearings held in connection with an application filed pursuant to this title and the names of persons testifying shall be recorded and made a part of the permanent files of the case. 25 Title 18 Zoning I. Planning Commission Recommendation 1. For applications requiring a final decision by the City Council, the Planning Commission shall first hold a public hearing on the matter. For such hearing, the Commission shall recommend to the City Council approval or denial of the request, including the reasons for the recommendation. 2. Upon receipt of the recommendation from the Planning Commission, the City Council shall hold a public hearing. 3. The City Council may approve, modify, or disapprove of the recommendation of the Planning Commission; provided that any modification of the proposed amendment by the City Council not previously considered by the Planning Commission during its hearing shall first be referred to the Planning Commission for report and recommendation, but the Planning Commission shall not be required to hold a public hearing thereon. Failure of the Planning Commission to report within 40 clays after the reference shall be deemed to be approval of the proposed modification. J. Hearing Body Decision The hearing body responsible for making a final determination on a matter pursuant to Section 18.12.020, be it the Planning Commission or City Council, shall announce its findings by formal resolution, and said resolution shall recite, among other things, the facts and reasons which, in the opinion of the hearing body, make the granting or denial of the permit or action necessary to carry out the provisions and general purpose of this title, and shall order that the permit or other action be granted, denied, or modified subject to such conditions or limitations that it may impose. K. Notice of Decision Not later than seven days following the adoption of a resolution ordering that a permit or other action be granted or denied, a copy of said resolution shall be mailed to the applicant and to any other parties requesting notice of the action. The resolution shall also be filed with the City Clerk. L. Effective Date of Decision 1. The decision of the Planning Commission shall become effective and final 30 days following the adoption of the resolution, unless, within such period of time, the applicant or other interested party files a written letter of appeal. Within such 30 days, the Planning Commission resolution shall be transmitted to the City Council who may set the matter for a public hearing. 2. If the appeal period is waived in accordance with Section 18.12.060(D), then the decision of the Planning Commission shall become effective and final immediately upon adoption of the resolution. 3. The decision of the City Council shall become effective and final immediately upon adoption of the resolution. M. Refiling Procedure Where an application has been denied by a hearing body and that action has become final, no new application for substantially the same request shall be accepted for a period of one year after the effective date of the denial, unless that hearing body specifies in its decision that the denial is without prejudice. 18.12.060 APPEALS A. Effect of Filing The filing of a notice of appeal pursuant to this Section stays all proceedings until a decision on the appeal is rendered. 26 Title 18 Zoning B. Appeal of Staff Decisions 1. Whenever a permit or other action has been denied at a staff level, an aggrieved person may file a written appeal with the Planning Division within 30 days after the mailing of a notice of decision. 2. The Planning Division, upon receipt of an appeal, shall set the matter for a hearing before the Planning Commission as soon as is practical in accordance with the public hearing procedures outlined in Section 18.12.050. The appealing party shall be given at least 10 days notice of the time and place of such hearing. 3. At the time set for such hearing, the Planning Commission shall give the appealing party a reasonable opportunity to be heard on the matter, and may require reports from any City department. After the hearing, the Planning Commission shall affirm, disaffirm, or modify the decision appealed. 4. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish shall be paid at the time of filing the appeal. C. Appeal of Planning Commission Decisions 1. Whenever a permit or other action has been denied by the Planning Commission, an aggrieved person may file a written appeal with the Planning Division within 30 days after the public hearing in which such decision was rendered. 2. The Planning Division shall notify the City Clerk of the appeal and the City Clerk shall notice and schedule a public hearing before the City Council in accordance with Section 18.12.050. The appealing party shall be given at least 10 days notice of the tirne and place of such hearing. 3. At the time set for such hearing, the City Council shall give the appealing party a reasonable opportunity to be heard on the matter, and may require reports from any City department. After the hearing, the City Council shall affirm, disaffirm, or modify the decision appealed. The decision of the City Council shall be final and conclusive. 4. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish shall be paid at the time of filing the appeal. D. Waiver of Appeal Period For permits and actions to be decided by the Planning Commission. before the close of the public hearing. an applicant may request that the appeal period be waived. The Planning Commission shall grant the request only after determining for the record that there are no interested persons who object to the waiver and that the applicant has waived all rights to appeal. If the appeal period is waived, the Planning Commission's decision becomes effective immediately upon adoption of the resolution. 18.12.070 SITE PLAN REVIEW A. Purpose Site plan review is a ministerial action established to ensure compliance with the Land Use Code and to attach conditions as necessary to ensure such compliance. B. Applicability and Requirements Prior to or concurrently with the submission of building plans for plan check or application for issuance of a building permit for any building to be erected in any zone wherein site plan review is required by this title, accurately dimensioned architectural drawings and plot plans for all proposed construction shall be submitted to the Planning Division for approval. The site plan or plot plan shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary to determine compliance with the Land Use Code. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. 27 Title 18 Zoning C. Plan Review 1. The Planning Division shall review all plans submitted and shall endorse its approval on a copy thereof, if it determines that the plan shows: a. Compliance with this title and all other applicable City ordinances; b. Desirable site layout and design; c. Utility of open areas; d. Adequate landscaping; e. Compatibility with neighboring property; f. Compliance with the General Plan or an adopted specific plan; g. Incorporation of any mitigation measures stipulated in a certified environmental impact report or negative declaration for the project, if applicable. 2. If the department determines that the plans thus submitted do not conform or adequately provide for one or more of such provisions, it shall endorse its disapproval thereof, together with a statement of the provisions of this chapter with which such plans do not conform. 3. When referred to the engineering department, fire department, building department, or other City agency by the Planning Division, such departments shall evaluate such plans as to compliance with all applicable City ordinances and standards and may require additional plans to be submitted and approved prior to final approval of such plans. The conditions of approval of development plans by the Planning Division may include the recommendations of other City department heads required to be made by the terms of this chapter. D. Issuance of Permit No building permit, certificate of occupancy, or any other permit listed shall be issued until the approvals required by this Section have been obtained. E. Preliminary Site Plan Review 1. Site plans may be submitted for preliminary review prior to submission of building plans for plan check, or application for issuance of a building permit for any building to be erected in any zone wherein site plan review is required by title. 2. A fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of submittal, which amount will be deducted from the building permit fee paid at the time building permits are issued. 18.12.080 MINOR USE PERMITS A. Purpose Minor use permits provide a ministerial process for reviewing land use activities that are allowed in the applicable zoning district, but require administrative review in order to evaluate the compatibility of the proposed use with surrounding uses and the suitability of the use to the site. B. Applicability A minor use permit is required to authorize proposed land uses identified by Chapter 2 (Zoning Districts and Allowable Land Uses) as being allowable in the applicable zoning district subject to the approval of a minor use permit. C. Notice of Application 1. The designated staff person shall mail notice of the application no later than 10 days after an application has been deemed complete to: a. The applicant. 28 Title 18 Zoning b. The owners of any real property, as shown on the latest equalized property tax assessment roll of the San Diego County Assessor, located within 300 feet of the boundary of the property that is the subject of the application. D. Contents of the Notice of Application 1. The notice of application shall include the following information: a. A general description of the proposed project, including, when applicable, the type of permit requested, project name, square footage of proposed construction, and number of residential units proposed. b. The location and size of the property that is the subject of the application. c. The name, telephone number, and City address of the designated staff person to contact for additional information. d. An explanation that a minor use permit is an administrative process whereby the decision to approve, conditionally approve, or deny the proposed development will be made by the Planning Division without a public hearing. e. An explanation of the process to appeal the decision. E. Requests for Notice of Decision Persons who wish to receive notice of the approval or denial of the application may request this information from the staff person. The request must be received no later than 10 business days after the date on which the notice of application is mailed. F. Application Requirements An application for a Minor Use Permit shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary to determine compliance with the Land Use Code. It is the responsibility of the applicant to provide evidence in support of the findings required by this Section. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing_ G. Findings and Decision The Planning Division may approve or deny an application for a Minor Use Permit. The designated staff person shall record the decision and the findings on which the decision is based. The Planning Division may approve a minor use permit only after first finding all of the following: 1. The proposed use is allowed within the applicable zoning district and complies with all other applicable provisions of this Land Use Code; 2. The proposed use is consistent with the General Plan and any applicable specific plan; 3. The design, location, size, and operating characteristics of the proposed activity would be compatible with the existing and future land uses in the vicinity; 4. The site is physically suitable for the type, density, and intensity of use being proposed, including access, utilities, and the absence of physical constraints; and 5. Granting the permit would not constitute a nuisance or be injurious or detrimental to the public interest, health, safety, convenience, or welfare, or materially injurious to persons, property, or improvements in the vicinity and zoning district in which the property is located. H. Issuance of Permit and Duration 1. Upon the approval of an application, the Planning Division shall authorize the issuance of a minor use permit, with or without conditions, and one copy of which shall be forwarded to: a. The applicant; b. The Building Official; c. Any other department or agency the Planning Division considers affected by the issuance of the permit; and 29 Title 18 Zoning d. The Division files for permanent retention. 2. Minor use permits shall be in effect for the duration of the use, or for a time period specified in the conditions of approval, or until the time a revocation of the permit is effectuated on the basis of non- compliance with the terms of the permit. I. Conditions of Approval In approving a Minor Use Permit, the Planning Division may impose any conditions deemed reasonable and necessary to ensure that the approval would comply with the findings required by this Section. 18.12.090 HOME OCCUPATION PERMITS A. Purpose A home occupation permit is a ministerial process to ensure that an occupation conducted within a dwelling is compatible with the character of the area in which the dwelling is located and that it is clearly a secondary use to the primary residential use of the dwelling. B. Applicability Home occupations are permitted in residential zones as identified in Chapter 2 Section 18.21.020 provided that they first receive a home occupation permit. C. Application Requirements 1 An application for a home occupation permit shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary to determine compliance with the Land Use Code. 2. It is the responsibility of the applicant to provide evidence in support of the findings required by this Section. 3. Any applicant for a home occupation permit who is not the legal owner of the subject real property shall provide a written statement from the legal owner consenting to the application. 4. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. D. Findings and Decision 1. The Planning Division may approve or deny an application for a home occupation permit. The designated staff person shall record the decision and the findings on which the decision is based. The Planning Division may approve a Home Occupation Permit only after first finding all of the following: a. There is no display of merchandise: b. No stock in trade nor commodity is sold upon the premises; c. The home occupation shall not result in the reduction of required off-street parking; d. Home occupations, except for urban agricultural uses permitted by Chapter 3 Section 18.30.240 (Urban Agriculture), shall be conducted within an enclosed structure on the premises; e. No person other than the resident is engaged in the home occupation on the premises; f. The resident shall not rent space to others in association with a home occupation; g. All sales of products and the performance of all service or work that requires the presence of a partner, employee, or customer shall take place off the premises: h. No mechanical equipment is used except that which is normally necessary for housekeeping purposes; i. No signs or advertising for the home occupation is placed on the premises and other advertising does not identify the address of the premises; j. Materials or products associated with the home occupation are stored in an enclosed structure on the premises and shall not exceed 1,000 cubic feet for the entire premises or any more restrictive limitations by the Building or Housing Division or County Health Department. 30 Title 18 Zoning k. Only one vehicle For business -related purposes is permitted on the premises or on any adjacent residentially zoned area. This vehicle may not exceed a one ton carrying capacity and may not be a tow truck. I. The home occupation shall be consistent with permitted residential uses, shall not create any conditions that amount to a public nuisance, and shall not be detrimental to the neighborhood by causing increased noise, traffic, lighting, odor, or by violating any applicable laws or ordinances; m. A business license is procured. 2. Additional stipulations can be placed on the permit by the City Manager or his/her designee. E. Issuance of Permit and Duration 1. Upon the approval of an application, the Planning Division shall authorize the issuance of a home occupation permit and one copy of which shall be forwarded to: a. The applicant; b. Any other department or agency the Planning Division considers affected by the issuance of the permit; and c. The Division files for permanent retention. 2. The occupation shall be limited to those activities specifically described on the permit, and subject to the conditions described in this Section or as stipulated on the permit; 3. A home occupation permit shall be in effect for the duration of the horse occupation unless a revocation of the perrnit is effectuated. 4. If it is determined or found by the City Manager or his/her designee that the home occupation authorized causes a disturbance or nuisance to the abutting neighborhood, it shall be reviewed by the Planning Commission and may be declared null and void, and any business license issued shall be subject to cancellation. 18.12.100 SIGN PERMIT A. Purpose The purpose of a ministerial sign perrnit is to ensure conformance with the Sign and Outdoor Advertising Display regulations in Chapter 4 and any applicable Master Sign Program or Specific Plan. B. Applicability A sign permit is required for the installation or alteration of any sign, except those specifically exempt by this Section. C. Exemptions from a Sign Permit 1. The following signs may be installed without a sign permit, provided that they meet the requirements listed below: a. Changing the copy of a sign or maintenance of a sign that does not involve structural or electrical changes: b. Interior signs; except for theater lobby signs; c. Public utility and safety signs that are required by law; d. Signs that are required by law, other than public utility and safety signs, provided that they do not exceed the minimum dimensions required by the law; e. Signs required by the Fire Department to designate fire lanes; f. Temporary real estate signs that are not illuminated. Only one such sign is permitted to face on each street adjacent to the property. Such signs may be single- or double-faced and are limited in size to four square feet or less on property in residential zones, and 10 square feet or less on property in commercial zones; 31 Title 18 Zoning g. Nameplate identification signs and combination name plates and address signs with letters that do not exceed three inches in height, are not illuminated, and do not exceed four square feet in area; h. Construction site signs that are not illuminated; i. Window signs; j. Tablets, memorials, and cornerstones that are built into the walls of a building, and provide information such as the name of the building and the date of construction; k. Incidental residential signs that provide warnings such as "no parking," "watch dogs," "private property," and "security service" that are not illuminated, do not exceed 1 square foot in area each, and do not project over a public right-of-way. No more than three of these signs shall be allowed per premises; I. Bulletin boards, provided they do not exceed 16 square feet in area, do not project over a public right of way, and are not illuminated; m. Temporary on -site banners, streamers, and pennants. D. Application Requirements Applications for sign permits shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary to determine compliance with the Land Use Code. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. E. Building Division Review If placement of a sign requires a Building Permit, the Building Division will review the plans for compliance with California Building Code requirements. F. Decision and Findings 1. The Planning Division may approve or deny an application for a sign permit. The designated staff person shall record the decision and the findings on which the decision is based. The sign permit may be approved once the following findings are made: a. The proposed sign is architecturally and aesthetically compatible with the major structures on the subject site and adjacent sites and is compatible with the character of the neighborhood and general environment; b. Granting the application is in conformance with the goals, policies, and objectives of the General Plan and the purpose and intent of any applicable specific plan, and the purposes of this Land Use Code and would not constitute a grant of special privilege inconsistent with the limitations on other properties in the vicinity and the same zoning district; and c. Granting the application would not be detrimental or injurious to property or improvements in the vicinity of the subject site, or to the public health, safety, or general welfare. G. Issuance of Permit and Duration 1. The sign permit may be issued after all approvals have been obtained and all required fees have been paid. 2. If the work authorized under a sign permit has not been completed within six months after date of issuance, the permit shall become null and void. 3. Before the expiration date of a sign permit, a permittee may submit a written application for an extension of time. The City Manager or his/her designee may extend a sign permit for a period not exceeding six months if the City Manager or his/her designee determines that, based on evidence provided by the permittee, circumstances beyond the control of the permittee prevented completion of the work. 4. A sign permit may not be extended more than two times. 32 Title 18 Zoning 5. Upon successful completion and inspection of the work authorized under a sign permit, the sign permit shall be in effect for the duration of the use for which the sign is intended, or for a time period specified in the permit, or until the time a revocation of the permit is effectuated based on non- compliance with the terms of the permit. 18.12.110 CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS A. Purpose The granting of a conditional use permit is a discretionary action that authorizes permitted uses subject to specific conditions because of the unusual characteristic or need to give special consideration to the proper location of said uses in relation to adjacent uses, the development of the community, and to the various elements of the General Plan. It is the purpose of this chapter to set forth the findings necessary for such discretionary action. B. Applicability A conditional use permit is required to authorize proposed land uses identified by Chapter 2 (Zoning Districts and Allowable Land Uses) as being allowable in the applicable zoning district subject to the approval of a Conditional Use Permit. C. Application Requirements An application for a Conditional Use Permit shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary to determine compliance with the Land Use Code. It is the responsibility of the applicant to provide evidence in support of the findings required by this Section. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. D. Conditional Use Permits Defined "Conditional use permits," as the term is used in this Section, shall be the same as those conditional use permits described in Section 65901 of the Government Code. E. Findings and Decision 1. The Planning Commission may approve or deny a conditional use permit through a public hearing process. Before any conditional use permit is granted, the applicant shall show the existence of the following facts: a. The proposed use is allowable within the applicable zoning district pursuant to a conditional use permit and complies with all other applicable provisions of the Land Use Code; and b. The proposed use is consistent with the General Plan and any applicable specific plan; and c. The design, location, size, and operating characteristics of the proposed activity would be compatible with the existing and future land uses in the vicinity; and d. The site is physically suitable for the type, density, and intensity of use being proposed, including access, utilities, and the absence of physical constraints. e. Granting the permit would not constitute a nuisance or be injurious or detrimental to the public interest, health, safety, convenience, or welfare, or materially injurious to persons, property, or improvements in the vicinity and zone in which the property is located; and f. The proposed project has been reviewed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act. 2. The decision of the Planning Commission is appealable to the City Council in accordance with Section 18.12.060. 33 Title 18 Zoning F. Conditions Conditions may be imposed upon the granting of any conditional use permit so as to render the proposed use as compatible as possible with other uses in the immediate surrounding area, and to accomplish the purpose of this chapter. G. Acceptance of Conditions Before any conditional use permit granted pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall become effective, the applicant shall file a written statement, in the form to be prescribed by the City Attorney, with the Planning Division, acknowledging and accepting all of the conditions, if any, imposed upon such conditional use permit_ H. Revocation 1. Conditional use permits may be subject to revocation in the time and manner as set forth in this Section. Whenever the City Manager or his/her designee finds that any of the following facts exist, with reference to a conditional use permit, he/she may recommend to the Planning Commission or City Council, whichever body granted the permit, that the conditional use permit be revoked: a. That the conditional use permit was obtained by fraud; or i. That the use authorized by such conditional use permit has ceased, or has been suspended, for any reason, for a period of six months or more; or ii. That the conditional use permit is being exercised in a manner contrary to any law or conditions of approval imposed upon such conditional use permit; or iii. That any use or uses pursuant to such conditional use permit is being, or has been, exercised in a manner detrimental to public peace, health, safety, or welfare, or in a manner to constitute a public nuisance. b. Upon receipt of such recommendation, the granting body shall expeditiously set and conduct a public hearing upon such matter after having given notice in the manner set forth in Section 18.12.050. At the time and place of such hearing, the body conducting such hearing shall determine whether any one of the facts, set forth in Section 18.12.110.H.1.a are present. If, as a result of the evidence produced at such hearing, the body conducting the hearing determines that any one of such facts are present, it shall revoke the conditional use permit. c. If the revocation proceeding is conducted before the Planning Commission, the decision of the Commission shall be subject to an appeal to the City Council in the time and manner as set forth in Section 18.12.060. In the absence of such appeal from a commission decision, its decision shall be final and conclusive. The action of the City Council, either upon an appeal or as a conducting body, shall be final and conclusive for all purposes. I. Modification Any condition imposed upon the granting of a conditional use permit may be modified or eliminated, or new conditions may be added; provided that the original granting body, the Commission or the Council, first conducts a public hearing thereon, in the same manner as required for the granting of the same. No such modification shall be made unless the Commission or Council finds that such modification is necessary to protect the public interest and/or adjacent or abutting properties; or, in case of deletion of an existing condition, that such action is necessary to permit reasonable operation and use under the conditional use permit. 18.12.120 VARIANCES A. Purpose Variances are discretionary actions meant to provide adjustments in the application of this title to avoid practical difficulties and unnecessary hardships with respect to a particular piece of property which is not enjoying the privileges commonly enjoyed by other properties in the same vicinity and zone. A practical 34 Title 18 Zoning difficulty or unnecessary physical hardship may result from the size, shape, or dimensions of a site, or because of the location of existing structures on the site, or from setbacks or building lines, or from geographic, topographic, or other physical conditions on the site or in the immediate vicinity. B. Applicability A variance may be considered for any applicant who is trying to establish a use that is expressly permitted in the zone that governs his/her property, but a hardship associated with the land deprives the property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the vicinity within the same zone and prevents the applicant from being able to fully comply with the development standards of this Land Use Code. C. Application Requirements An application for a variance shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary support of the findings required by this Section. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. D. Development Standards Except for the provision(s) of this title which are the subject of a zone variance approval, all other provisions of this title shall apply. E. Findings and Decision Before any zone variance is granted by the Planning Commission through a public hearing process. the applicant shall show compliance with the following: 1. Variances from the terms of this title shall be granted only when, because of special circumstances applicable to the property, including size, shape, topography, location or surroundings, the strict application of this title deprives such property of privileges enjoyed by other property in the vicinity and under identical zoning classification. 2. Any variance granted shall be subject to such conditions as will assure that the adjustment thereby authorized shall not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity and zone in which such property is situated. 3. A variance shall not be granted for a parcel of property which authorizes a use or activity which is not otherwise expressly authorized by the zone regulation governing the parcel of property. F. Conditions of Approval Conditions of approval may be attached to the granting of a variance to render such variance compatible with adjacent uses and properties and in accord with the general intent and purpose of this title, and to prevent the granting of a special privilege inconsistent with the limitations placed upon other properties and uses similarly situated. G. Acceptance of Conditions Before any zone variance granted pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall become effective, the applicant shall file a written statement, in the form to be prescribed by the City Attorney. with the Planning Division, acknowledging and accepting all of the conditions, if any, imposed upon such zone variance. 35 Title 18 Zoning 18.12.130 PLANNED DEVELOPMENT PERMITS A. Purpose The purpose of these procedures is to: 1. Establish a review process for development that allows an applicant to request greater flexibility from the strict application of the regulations than would be allowed through a variance process; 2. Encourage imaginative and innovative planning to achieve a more preferable development than what would be achieved by strict conformance with the regulations; 3. Ensure, through the imposition of conditions of approval, a more efficient use of open space, separation of pedestrian and vehicular traffic, increased project amenities, compatibility with the surrounding neighborhood, and conformance to the achievable capacity of community utilities and improvements. 4. Consider a planned development as a comprehensive unit rather than an aggregation of separate buildings on unrelated lots. B. Applicability A planned development shall consist of not less than two acres and the area must be under one ownership or the subject of an application filed jointly by all the owners of the property included. C. Application Requirements An application for a Planned Development Permit shall contain any specific information required by the City Manager or his/her designee necessary to support the findings required by this Section. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. D. Dwelling Units If a planned development contains residential units, the number of residential units shall not exceed the number otherwise allowed unless a density bonus is approved consistent with the provisions of Government Code Section 65915. In no case shall the right-of-way of any public or private street, sidewalk, public or semi-public parking area, or adjacent pedestrian walk be included in the allowable lot area per dwelling unit. Two or more dwelling units may be attached or combined into a single structure. E. Special Lot Sizes, Setback, and Height Requirements 1. Reductions in lot sizes may be approved, provided that acceptable land is designated as permanent open space and/or usable recreation space. The land area of each permanent open space area shall equal or exceed the total of all lot reductions. 2. Special setback and height requirements may be established for a planned development based on design and relation of buildings to each other and the surrounding areas. F. Development Regulations Reductions in lot sizes may be approved, provided that acceptable land is designated as permanent open space and/or usable recreation space. The land area of each permanent open space area shall equal or exceed the total of all lot reductions. G. Findings and Decision A planned development permit may be approved or conditionally approved by the Planning Commission through a public hearing process only if all of the following findings are made: 1. The proposed development is consistent with the General Plan; 2. The proposed development will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; 36 Title 18 Zoning 3. The proposed development will comply with the regulations of the Land Use Code; 4. The proposed development, when considered as a whole, will be beneficial to the community; 5. Any proposed deviations pursuant to this Section are appropriate for this location and will result in a more desirable project than would be achieved if designed in strict conformance with the development regulations of the applicable zone. 6. The proposed project has been reviewed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act. H. Conditions of Approval Conditions of approval may be attached to the granting of a planned development permit to render such planned development compatible with adjacent uses and properties and in accord with the general intent and purpose of this title. I. Acceptance of Conditions Before any planned development permit granted pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall become effective, the applicant shall file a written statement, in the form to be prescribed by the City Attorney, with the Planning Division, acknowledging and accepting all of the conditions, if any, imposed upon such zone variance. 18.12.140 ZONING AMENDMENTS A. Purpose The zoning map or Land Use Code may be amended whenever public necessity, general welfare, convenience, or sound planning principles require. B. Initiation Zoning amendments may be initiated by: 1. The application of an owner or the agent of such owner seeking an amendment, supplement to, or change of the regulations prescribed for his property, or the reclassification of his property; 2. The application of an entity authorized to exercise the power of eminent domain over property subject to amendment; 3. The application of a redeveloper who is seeking to redevelop the property involved, and who is a party to an existing disposition and development agreement with the community development commission; 4. Minute action of the City Council; 5. Minute action of the Planning Commission. C. Application Any person desiring to initiate a zoning change shall address his/her request on a form prescribed by the City Manager or his/her designee. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. D. Decision No decision on a zoning amendment shall be rendered by the Planning Commission or City Council until they have, respectively, found that the amendment, if adopted, would be consistent with the General Plan and has been reviewed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act. 37 Title 1 B Zoning 18.12.150 GENERAL PLAN AND SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENTS A. Purpose The General Plan Map, General Plan, and any specific plan may be amended whenever public necessity, general welfare, convenience, or sound planning principles require, in the manner prescribed in Sections 65350 through 65362, and 65450 through 65457 of the Government Code of the state. B. Initiation Amendments to the General Plan Map, General Plan, or any specific plan may be initialed by: 1. The application of an owner or the agent of such owner seeking an amendment, supplement to, or change of the regulations prescribed for his/her property, or the redesignation of his/her property. 2. The application of an entity authorized to exercise the power of eminent domain over property subject to amendment; 3. The application of a redeveloper who is seeking to redevelop the property involved, and who is a party to an existing disposition and development agreement with the community development commission; 4. Minute action of the City Council; 5. Minute action of the Planning Commission. C. Application Any person desiring to initiate a change in the General Plan Map, General Plan, or any specific plan shall address his/her request on a form prescribed by the City Manager or his/her designee. A nonrefundable fee in such amount as the City Council shall from time to time establish by resolution shall be paid to the finance officer at the time of filing. D. Decision The Planning Commission shall recommend approval, approval with modifications, or denial of the application through a public hearing pursuant to Section 18.12.050. The City Council, after receiving such recommendation, shall hold a public hearing pursuant to Section 18.12.050 and render a final decision. E. Limitations on General Plan Amendments General Plan amendments shall occur no more frequently than four times during any calendar year unless otherwise specified in Government Code Section 65358. 18.12.160 HISTORIC PROPERTIES A. Intent and Purpose It is the intent and purpose of this Section to protect, preserve and, where damaged, restore National City's historic resources by: 1. Establishing a procedure whereby properties of historical significance are identified and appropriate notice is provided in the event demolition, significant alteration, or conversion is proposed. 2. Protecting the educational, cultural, economic, and general welfare of the public, while employing regulations that are consistent with sound historical preservation principles and the rights of private property owners. B. Designation of Historic Properties 1. A list of historic properties shall be maintained and periodically updated. 2. Changes to the historic properties list may be initiated by resolution of the City Council or on the verified application of the owner(s) of the property to be designated or their authorized agents. 38 Title 18 Zoning 3. Any application or resolution that proposes changes to the historic properties list shall be accompanied by an evaluation of the historic character of the property and shall be reviewed by the Planning Division. 4. The Planning Division, after reviewing such application for completeness, shall notify the Historical Society of the proposed changes to the historic properties list. Any comments or recommendations provided by the Historical Society must be received within 20 days of the notice of proposed changes. 6. Once the Planning Division has completed review of the application and considered any comments or recommendations from the Historical Society, it shall prepare a report and recommendation to the Planning Commission. 7. The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the proposal and shall provide a recommendation to the City Council. 8. The City Council shall hold a public hearing and may approve, modify and approve, or deny the proposed changes to the historic properties list. C. Review of Ministerial Permits 1. The Building Official or designee shall review each request for a non -discretionary building or demolition permit to determine if it involves any structure identified on the list of historic properties. If a property proposed for demolition or significant alteration or conversion is determined to be on the historic properties list, the Building Official or designee shall withhold issuance of the permit for a period of 30 days. 2. The Building Official shall immediately notify the Planning Division and the City Council of the pending permit. 3. Within five days. the Planning Division shall provide notice to the Historical Society of the pending permit and may request comments and recommendations. Any comments or recommendations provided by the Historical Society must be received within 20 days of the notice of pending permit. 4. Once the Planning Division has reviewed the permit application and considered any comments or recommendations from the Historical Society, it shall provide a recommendation to the City Council. The recommendation may include approval of the permit, no recommendation, recommendation that the permit be denied, or a request for additional time to evaluate the permit. 5. The City Council, at its sole discretion, may approve the permit, deny the permit if a finding is made that such permit may result in an adverse effect on the public welfare, or withhold the issuance of the permit until such time as all alternative measures are thoroughly evaluated. D. Review of Discretionary Permits All discretionary permits involving a historic resource shall be reviewed in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act. 39 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 2 ZONING DISTRICTS AND ALLOWABLE LAND USES CHAPTER 18-20 — ZONING MAP Sections 18.20.010 18.20.020 18.20.030 Purpose Zones and Zoning Map Prohibited Land Uses CHAPTER 18-21 - RESIDENTIAL ZONES Sections 18.21.010 18.21.020 18.21.030 18.21.040 18.21.050 Purpose Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements Accessory Uses General Development Standards Second Units CHAPTER 18-22 — COMMERCIAL ZONES Sections 18.22.010 Purpose 18.22.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.22.030 Accessory Uses 18.22.040 General Development Standards 18.22.050 Uses to be Adequately Housed in Completely Enclosed Buildings CHAPTER 18-23 — WESTSIDE MIXED -USE ZONES Sections 18.23.010 18.23.020 18.23.030 Purpose Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements General Development Standards CHAPTER 18-24 — MIXED -USE CORRIDOR AND DISTRICT ZONES Sections 18.24.010 18.24.020 18.24.030 18.24.040 18.24.050 18.24.060 18.24.070 18.24.080 18.24.090 Purpose Mixed Use Zones General Provisions Building Form and Placement Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements Accessory Uses Building Frontage Standards Parking Requirements Civic Space Standards 40 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-25 — INDUSTRIAL ZONES Sections 18.25.010 Purpose 18.25.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.25.030 Accessory Uses 18.25.040 General Development Standards 18.25.560 Uses to be Adequately Housed in Completely Enclosed Buildings CHAPTER 18-26 - INSTITUTIONAL ZONE Sections 18.26.010 Purpose 18.26.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.26.030 General Development Standards CHAPTER 18-27 - OPEN SPACE ZONE Sections 18.27.010 Purpose 18.27.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.27.030 General Development Standards CHAPTER 18-28 - OPEN SPACE RESERVE ZONE Sections 18.28.010 Purpose 18.28.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements CHAPTER 18-29 — OVERLAY ZONES Sections 18.29.010 Purpose 18.29.020 Overlay Zone Designations 18.29.030 Coastal Zone (CZ) 18.29.050 Height Limit Restriction Overlay Zone (H) 18.29.060 Mobile Home Park Overlay Zone (MHP) 18.29.070 Floodway (-FW), Floodway Fringe (-FF-1), and Floodway Fringe -Shallow Flooding (-FF-2) Zones 41 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-20 — ZONING MAP 18.20.010 Purpose 18.20.020 Zones and Zoning Map 18.20.030 Prohibited Land Uses 18.20.010 PURPOSE This section identifies the zones that apply to property within the City and adopts the City's zoning map, National City is organized into zones that implement the General Plan, which are identified on the zoning map. 18.20.020 ZONES AND ZONING MAP A. Official Zoning Map The Official Zoning Map of the City is a zoning regulation within the context of and adopted pursuant to this title. B. Zone Boundaries - Determination in Cases of Uncertainty The location of zone boundaries may be determined by the rules for interpretation pursuant to this title. C. Zone Boundary Changes - Procedure Changes in the boundaries of the zones shall be made by ordinance adopting an amended Official Zoning Map. D. Pre -Zoning of Unincorporated Lands 1. Areas outside of City limits, but within National City's sphere of influence are unincorporated lands and governed by the County of San Diego until such time as those areas are annexed into the City. These areas have been pre -zoned with City zones to identify the regulations that would apply once the land is annexed into the City. 2. Pre -zone changes may be initiated and heard, in the manner provided for zone changes in this title, prior to the effective date of annexation to be effective upon annexation. E. Effect of Specific Plans Lands within an adopted specific plan are governed by the zoning regulations of that specific plan. If the requirements of any specific plan are either more restrictive or less restrictive than the zoning regulations of this title, the requirements of the specific plan shall take precedence. If the specific plan is silent with regard to a development standard that is addressed within the provisions of this title, the provisions of this title shall apply. Specific plans referred to in this title shall be adopted in compliance with the procedural requirements of the California Government Code. F. Zone Classifications Established The following zone classifications are established and applied to the City as shown on the Official Zoning Map. 42 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.20.020 Zone Classifications Zone Classification Symbol Zone Classification General Plan Land Use Designation Residential RS-1 Large Lot Residential Low Medium Density Residential RS-2 Small Lot Residential Low Medium Density Residential RS-3 Medium -Low Density Multi -Unit Residential Medium Density Residential RS-4 Residential Single -Family Specific Plan (Westside) RM-1 Medium Density Multi -Unit Residential Medium Density Residential RM-2 High Density Multi -Unit Residential High Density Residential RM-3 Very High Density Multi -Unit Residential High Density Residential Commercial CA Commercial Automotive Commercial Automotive CL Limited Commercial Specific Plan (Westsid) CS Service Commercial Service Commercial Mixed -Use MCR-1 Mixed Commercial -Residential Specific Plan (Westside) MCR-2 Mixed Commercial -Residential (Smart Growth Area) Specific Plan (Westside) MXC-1 Minor Mixed Use Corridor Minor Mixed Use MXC-2 Major Mixed Use Corridor Major Mixed Use MXD-1 Minor Mixed Use District Minor Mixed Use MXD-2 Major Mixed Use District Major Mixed Use Industrial.' IL Light Industrial Industrial IM Medium Industrial Industrial IH Heavy Industrial Industrial Institutional Institutional r Institutional Open Space OS Open Space Open Space OSR Open Space Reserve Military M rMilitary Milita San Diego Unified Port District UPD Port Master Plan San Diego Unified Port District Specific Plan —1 SP Specific Plan Specific Plan 18.20.030 Prohibited Land Uses Land uses not specifically allowed in a zone are prohibited in that zone; in addition, the following are specifically prohibited. A. In all zones, no structure of a temporary nature shall be used as a residence, neither temporarily nor permanently, including: 1. Boats [except in marinas] 2. Camper shells [except in recreational vehicle parks] 3. Mobilehomes [except in mobilehome parks] 4. Recreational vehicles [except in recreational vehicle parks] 5. Shacks 6. Sheds 7. Shipping containers 8. Storage units 43 Title 18 Zoning 9. Tarpaulins 10. Tents [except in recreational vehicle parks] 11. Trailers [except in recreational vehicle parks] 12. Buildings or structures of a temporary nature B. In all zones, the following shall not be used for temporary or permanent sleeping areas: 1. Attics 2. Basements 3. Cellars 4. Decks 5. Game rooms 6. Garages 7. Non-residential buildings 8. Patios 9. Porches 10. Rooftops C. In all zones, outdoor storage is prohibited except as specifically allowed by the zone. D. In all zones, outdoor storage or parking of the following is prohibited unless specifically allowed by the zone: 1. Boats within any required front, side, exterior, or street setback 2. Camper shells within any required front, side, exterior, or street setback 3. Mobile homes [except in mobile home parks] 4. Recreational vehicles within any required front, side, exterior, or street setback 5. Trailers within any required front, side, exterior, or street setback (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 44 Title 18 Toning CHAPTER 18-21 — RESIDENTIAL ZONES 18.21.010 Purpose 18.21.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.21.030 Accessory Uses 18.21.040 General Development Standards 18.21.050 Second Units 18.21.010 PURPOSE This section lists the land uses allowed within the residential zones. The purposes of the individual residential zones and the manner in which they are applied are as follows: A. Large Lot Residential (RS-1) The purpose of the RS-1 zone is to provide for areas of single-family detached residences on large lots (ten Thousand square feet minimum and a density of up to five dwelling units per acre). B. Small Lot Residential (RS-2) The purpose of the RS-2 zone is to provide for areas of single-family detached residences on small lots (five thousand square feet minimum and a density of six to nine dwelling units per acre). C. Medium -Low Density Residential (RS-3) The purpose of the RS-3 zone is to provide for low-rise, medium -low density (10 to 15 units per acre) single-family attached and multiple family residential areas. The RS-3 zone is intended to retain characteristics found in the single-family zones, such as private yards and patios and privately maintained open space. D. Residential Single -Family (RS-4) The purposes of the RS-4 zone are to provide for areas of single-family attached and detached homes on minimum lot sizes of 2,500 square feet; and provide for small lot single-family development within the Westside Specific Plan area. The RS-4 zone permits one attached or detached single-family dwelling for each full two -thousand five -hundred square feet of lot area provided there is no more than one single family residence for each 2,500 square feet of lot area. It also allows for the continuation of the existing mixture of housing types and encourages infill with single-family zones on vacant properties and where existing parcels may be further subdivided as provided herein. E. Medium Density Multi -Unit Residential (RM-1) The purpose of the RM-1 zone is to provide for low-rise, medium density (16 to 23 dwelling units per acre) multiple family residential areas. The RM-1 zone is a transitional zone between higher density residential uses and lesser intensity single-family areas. F. High Density Multi -Unit Residential (RM-2) The purpose of the RM-2 zone is to provide for low- to mid -rise, high density (24 to 48 dwelling units per acre) multiple family residential. G. Very High Density Multi -Unit Residential (RM-3) The purpose of the RM-3 zone is to provide for mid- to high-rise, very high density (49 to 75 dwelling units per acre) multiple family residential. 45 Title 18 Zoning 18.21.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS A. Residential Land Uses 1. Table 18.21.020 identifies the uses of land allowed in each residential zone. 2. Table 18.21.020 does not apply to the RS-4 zone. See Appendix A, Land Use Table, within the Westside Specific Plan for the list of permitted uses in the RS-4 zone. 3. Within the RS-4 zone, existing multi -family and duplexes may continue as a permitted use. Existing churches and religious services may continue as a permitted use whereas new churches and religious facilities and expansions to existing churches and religious facilities are permitted pursuant to approval of a conditional use permit. Parks and open space are permitted uses. TABLE 18.21.020 Allowed Land Uses Residential Zones Land Use Permit Required By District Specific Use Regulations RS-1 RS-2 RS-3 RM-1 ;RM 2 RM-3 Accessory structure (incidental to primary use and not a second unitL P C P P P P P Animal husbandry -- -- -- -- -- Section 8.32 Bed & breakfast inn (B&B) C C C C C C Section 18.30 290 Family day care home, small P P P P P P Section 18.30.080 Family day care home, large M M M M M M Section 18.30.080 Convalescent services/hospice (in home care only) P P P P P P Dormitory (Accessory to a school) -- -- -- -- C C Dwelling unit, single detached P P P P P P Dwelling unit, single attached — -- P P P P Dwelling unit, multiple -- -- P P P P Home occupation (accessory use) P P P P P P Section 18.12.090 Neighborhood corner store M M M M M M Section 18. 30.260 Open space reserves P P P P P P Parks, passive recreation P P P P P P Parks, active recreation C C C P P P Plant nursery C -- -- — -- Public assembly C C C C C C Public safety facili y C C C C C C Rectory (accessory to religious facility) C C C C C C Renewable energy infrastructure (accessory) P P P P P P Section 18.30.210/18.30.300; California Building Code Rooming or boarding house (accessory) C C C C C C Second unit (accessory) P P P P P P Transitional / supportive housing P P P P P P Utility facilities, minor P P P P P P Utility facilities, major C P C C C C C Urban agriculture P P P P P Section 18.30.240 P Permitted C Conditional Use Permit M Minor Use Permit (Ministerial) -- Not permitted 46 Title 18 Zoning 18.21.030 ACCESSORY USES A. Home Occupations A home occupation permit granted by the Planning Division pursuant to Chapter 1 Section 18.12.090 (Home Occupation Permits) shall be required. The home occupation shall comply with the provisions included within the definition as provided in the Glossary. B. Roomers and Boarders In a dwelling unit occupied as a private residence, one or two rooms may be rented and table board provided for a maximum of two paying guests in all residential zones. Renting to more than two paying guests in a private residence is considered a rooming or boarding house and is subject to approval of a conditional use permit. C. Limitations on Accessory Uses and Structures 1. Accessory uses and structures are prohibited without a permissible main building. 2. Each accessory structure is allowed no more than one half bath. D. Recreational Facilities Recreational facilities serving a multi -unit residential development may be permitted. Typical facilities include: 1. Swimming pools, gymnasiums/fitness centers, and hut tubs/spas. 2. Tennis, badminton, volleyball, croquet, and similar courts; 3. Playgrounds, sitting areas, and picnic/barbeque areas. 18.21.040 GENERAL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Development standards for residential zones are set out in Table 18.21.040 (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 47 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.21.040 Development Standards Residential Zones Development Requiremen By Zoning District Primary Structure Minimum Setbacks Front Side -Interior Side -Exterior Rear RS-1 RS-2 RS 3 : RS 4 RM-1 RM 2 RM-3 20' 20' 15' 10715(a) 15' 10' 10' 5' 5' 5' 3/0(b) 5' 5' 5' 10' 10' 5' 10'(a) 5' 5' 10' 25' 25' 10' 15' 5' 5' 5' Accessory Structure Minimum Setbacks Front Side -Interior Side -Corner Rear 20' 20' 15' 10/15'(c) 15' 10' 10' 5' 5' 5' 3' 5' 5' 5' 5' 5' 5' 10' 5' 5' 5' 5' 5' 5' 3' 5' 5' 5 Detached Building Separation 5' 5' 5' 6' 5' 5 5' Number of Detached Buildings 3 3 3 3 Minimum Lot Area 10,000SF 5,000SF 5,000SF 2,500SF 5,000SF 5,000SF 5,000SF Minimum Street Frontage (Standard) Minimum Street Frontage (Lots on the bulb of a cul-de-sac) 60' 36' 50' 36' 50' 36' 25' 15' 50' 36' 50' 36' 50' 36' Maximum Density One du per lot One du per lot One du per 2,900 SF of lot area One du for each 2,500SF of lot area One du per 1,900 SF of lot area One du per 900 SF of lot area One du per 580 SF of lot area Minimum Usable Open Space N/A N/A N/A N/A See Section 18.41.040 Maximum Lot Coverage 75% 75% 75% N/A 75% 75% 75% 95' Maximum Height, Primary Structure 35' 35' 35' 35' 45' 65' Maximum Stories, Primary Structure 2 2 3 3 4 6 9 Maximum Height, Accessory Structure 25 25 25 25 45' 65' 95' Shall not exceed the number of stories or height of the primary structure. Shall not exceed the allowed maximun height of accessory structures in adjacent zone within 100-feet of the adjacent zone. Maximum Area (total), Accessory Structures — Excluding up to 400 SF of covered parking Greater of 300 SF or 30% of floor area of primary structures Greater of 300 SF or 30% of floor area of primary structures Greater of 300 SF or 30% of floor area of primary structures None None None None 48 Title 18 Zoning Notes (a) Stoops and porches may extend into the front yard up to the front property line or in the case of a corner parcel to the side property line_ Garages shall maintain a 15' front yard setback. (h) A zero foot minimum side yard, tor one side yard on the parcel, is permitted provided that there is a six foot separation to the adjacent residential structure and that there is a minimum three-foot side yard setback on the opposite side. (c) Except for stoops and porches, accessory structures shall not be located in the front yard setback. Porches or stoops should be at least six feet deep. 18.21.050 SECOND UNITS A. Purpose The purpose of this section is to provide regulations for the establishment of accessory dwelling units in the residential zones. Accessory dwelling units help advance the city's growth and planning policies by: 1. Accommodating new housing units while preserving the character of existing neighborhoods; 2. Allowing efficient use of the city's existing housing stock and infrastructure; 3. Providing housing options and choices that respond to varying income levels, changing household sizes and lifestyle needs; and, 4. Providing a means for residents —particularly seniors, single parents, younger singles and younger couples, and empty nesters —to remain in their homes and neighborhoods, and obtain and preserve income. security, companionship, and assistance. B. Development Standards 1. Shall be permitted on properties with only one single-family residence on the lot or constructed in conjunction with a single-family residence; 2. Shall not be allowed where the City Manager or his/her designee determines that roadways, public utilities or services are inadequate; 3. Shall not be allowed on lots that exceed the allowed number of dwelling units; 4. The development standards for accessory structures shall apply to second units, except that the setback requirements for primary structures shall apply and the floor area shall not exceed the maximum area allowed for accessory structures, but in no case shall exceed 1,200 square feet. C. Architectural Compatibility A second dwelling unit shall incorporate the same or substantially similar architectural features with respect to roof pitch, compatible building materials, colors, and design details of the primary dwelling unit. D. Parking One off-street parking space, in addition to that which is required by this code for the primary residence shall be provided. Parking spaces include garages, carports, or uncovered parking. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 49 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-22 — COMMERCIAL ZONES 18.22.010 Purpose 18.22.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.22.030 Accessory Uses 18.22.040 General Development Standards 18.22.050 Uses to be Adequately Housed in Completely Enclosed Buildings 18.22.010 PURPOSE A. Purposes The general purposes of commercial zones are to: 1. Provide areas in which business may be conducted, goods sold and distributed, public and private services rendered, and such other activities provided which are related to the function of commercial development; 2. Ensure compatibility of the various commercial areas with adjacent land uses; 3. Implement the General Plan by concentrating the locations of intensive commercial uses. B. Commercial Automotive (CA) The purpose of the Commercial Automotive (CA) zone is to provide for automobile and truck sales and services and sales and services that support such uses. Uses may also include alternative fuel vehicle sales, services and related supplies, and rental car facilities. C. Limited Commercial (CL) The purposes of the Limited Commercial (CL) zone are to: 1. Provide for small scale, limited convenience retail shopping facilities at the neighborhood level, typically including food and convenience stores, small retail and service shops, professional offices, and artisan activities such as studios, galleries. production space, and small performance venues_ The sale of all merchandise shall be retail only. 2. Ensure that the character of the CL zone will be compatible with and will complement the surrounding residential area. D. Service Commercial (CS) The purpose of the Service Commercial (CS) zone is to provide for intensive commercial activities; specialized service establishments; light manufacturing, wholesaling, and distribution uses that operate in a dean and quiet manner; and supporting and complimentary uses. 18.22.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS Table 18.22.020 identifies the uses of land allowed in each commercial zone. This table does not apply to the CL zone. For a list of allowable uses in the CL zone, please refer to Appendix A of the Westside Specific Plan. 50 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.22.020 Allowed Land Uses Commercial Zones Land Use Zone Specific Use Regulations CA CS Auto towing dispatch (accessory to service station) P Alcohol, sales for off -site consumption (accessory to retail sales) C Section 18.30.050 Alcohol, sales for on -site consumption (accessory to eating place) C Section 18 30.050 Car wash, automatic and full service P Car wash, manual C Civic, fraternal, community, and cultural facilities C Commercial recreation, indoor C Commercial recreation, outdoor C Convenience store (accessory to service station) M Section 18.30.190 Eating place, dine -in (accessory) P Eating place, dine -in P Eating place, drive-thru/take-out C Games of skill or amusement, maximum of four machines (accessory) P Gasoline service station C Section 18.30.190 Goods and services, retail P Offices P OH -street parking and loading facilities (accessory) P Open space reserves P Parking garage P Pawn shops C Section 18.30.330 Payday lenders C Section 18.30.320 Public assembly C Public safety facilities P Research and development P Recycling facility, small (accessory) P Section 18.30.170 Recycling facility, mobile C Section 18.30.170 Renewable energy infrastructure (accessory) P Section 18.30.210/ 18.30-300, CBC Storage building (accessory) P Tattoo parlors and body piercing establishments C Section 18.30.310 Telecommunications facilities C Section 18.30 220 Utility facilities, minor P Utility facilities, major C Vehicle body and paint shop C Section 18.30.060 Vehicle, outdoor storage (a) C Section 18.30.160 Vehicle parts and accessories sales P Vehicle, repair or service (minimum 7,500 square foot lot) P Vending machines (accessory) P Section 18.30.150 (E) Warehouse and distribution facility P Wrecked vehicle storage, maximum 60 days (accessory) P P Permitted C Conditional Use Permit M Minor Use Permit -- Not permitted New automobile and truck sales, leasing, and rentals. Used auto and truck sales when part of a new vehicle dealership and located on contiguous land. Service and repair of trucks and automobiles when 51 Title 18 Zoning provided by new vehicle dealer on contiguous property. Sale of vehicle parts and accessories when provided by new vehicle dealership on contiguous property. P Sale or rental of campers, camper trailers, vacation trailers, self-propelled mobile homes, boats, and other sporting and pleasure equipment which is substantial in size- This activity must be incidental to the principal activity of the automobile and/or truck dealership. P 18.22.030 ACCESSORY USES A. Commercial Uses in Hotels and Motels Accessory uses and services incidental to the principal use may be permitted; and accessory businesses intended for the convenience or necessity of the guests of the principal use, including bars, cafes, restaurants. lunchrooms, coffee shops, gift shops. florists, barbershops, beauty shops, news and tobacco shops, travel and car rental agencies, business centers, valet service (agency for laundering, cleaning, and pressing of clothing), letting of space for professional offices, operated in conjunction with the uses permitted in this section and not as a separate enterprise, and located on the same premises may be permitted, provided there shall be no entrance to such accessory uses except from the lobby or the interior of a principal building or buildings or patio. B. Storage Buildings and Garages Storage buildings and garages incidental to principal uses on the same premises are permitted. C. Sale of Gasoline The sale of gasoline may be permitted as an accessory use in any zone where gasoline service stations are permitted, subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. D. Auctions Auctions, in conjunction with used furniture or antique sales, may be permitted subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. E. Games of Skill or Amusement 1. In the commercial and mixed -use zones, games of skill or amusement. as an incidental or accessory use, shall be limited to four machines per establishment, two of which may be multiple -player machines. 2. Bowling alleys shall be limited to thirty games of skill or amusement as an incidental use. All such machines shall be located in the main concourse of the facility within the line -of -sight of a supervising adult employed by the business proprietor, whom shalt be continuously present at all times that machines are being used. 3. The use of games of skill or amusement as an incidental or accessory use may be permitted within an existing establishment only if a conditional use permit is granted. 4. Limitations on location of games of skill and amusement. a. No games of skill and amusement accessible for use by minors shall be maintained, operated, conducted or used, nor kept for such purposes, in or on the premises of any establishment whose primary business is the sale of alcoholic beverages. This shall not prohibit the operation of amusement machines in a bona fide establishment with an on -sale liquor license or restaurants which are not licensed to sell alcoholic beverages. 52 Title 18 Zoning b. No games of skill and amusement shall be maintained, operated, conducted or uses, nor kept for such purposes, within any place which is closer than three hundred feet from any public or private school which conducts classes for any grades from kindergarten to twelfth grade. 53 fitle 18 Zoning F. Catering Services Catering services for retail food preparation and party supplies may be permitted; provided said use is conducted in conjunction with a permitted restaurant, retail store, or commercial office; and further provided that the wholesaling or warehousing of merchandise does not occur in the operation of the catering business. 18.22.040 GENERAL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Development standards for commercial zones are set forth in Table 18.22.040. Refer to the Westside Specific Plan for additional requirements in the CL zone. TABLE 18.22.040 Development Standards Commercial Zones Development Standard Zone CA CL CS Minimum Lot Area 15,000 SF 5,000 SF 1 5,000 SF (b)(c) Minimum Street Frontage 50' 50' 50' td) Minimum Setbacks Front Side, Interior Side, Exterior Rear When adjacent to a residential zone 0' 10' 0' 0 0710'(e) 0' 0' 10' 0' 0' 5' 0' 20 feet from adjacent zone boundary N/A 20 feet from adjacent zone boundary Maximum Height/Stories When adjacent to Residential Zone 50' and 3 stones 50' and 3 stories 50' and 3 stories Shall not exceed the allowed maximum height in the adjacent zone within 100-feet of the adjacent zone N/A Shall not exceed the allowed maximum height in the adjacent zone within 100-feet of the adjacent zone Maximum Floor Area Ratio 1.5 0.6 1.5 Lot Coverage 80% N/A 80% Notes: (b) Automobile service stations shall have a minimum lot area of 15,000SF (c) Automobile and truck repair facilities shall have a minimum lot area of 7,500SF (d) Automobile service stations shall have a minimum street frontage of 100'. (e) 10' if adjacent to an existing single-family or multi -family development without commercial/office uses- 18.22.050 USES TO BE CONDUCTED IN ENCLOSED BUILDINGS All uses shall be conducted in enclosed buildings; provided, however, that businesses such as auto and truck dealers, landscape nurseries, gas stations, sidewalk cafes/outdoor dining, and similar uses that customarily include outdoor use, may be permitted outside of a completely enclosed building. This section shall not restrict incidental loading, parking, property maintenance, or special promotions as provided by this title. 54 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-23 — WESTSIDE MIXED -USE ZONES (MCR-1 AND MCR-2) 18.23.010 Purpose 18.23.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.24.030 General Development Standards 18.23.010 PURPOSE The purpose of the MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones is to provide an area within the Westside Specific Plan area for either commercial or multi -family residential development or a commercial and multi -family development constructed on a single parcel or as components of a single development on an assemblage of parcels. 18.23.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS The uses permitted in the MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones are listed in Appendix A of the Westside Specific Plan. 18.23.030 GENERAL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS The development standards for the MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones are identified in Table 18.23.030. Refer to the Westside Specific Plan for additional requirements in the MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones. TABLE 18.23.030 Development Standards MCR-1 AND MCR-2 Zones Development Standard Zone MCR-1 MCR-2 Minimum Setbacks Front 10' 10' Side, Interior 0'/10'(a) 0'/10'(a) Side, Exterior 10' 10' Rear 5 5 Minimum Distance Between Buildings 0'/10'(a) O'/10'(a) Minimum Density 24 du/acre 24 du/acre Maximum Density 24 du/acre 45/60 du/acre (b) Minimum Dwelling Unit Size 600 SF 600 SF Maximum Height/Stories 3 stories and 50' 5 stories and 65' Common Usable Open Space (c) 300 SF/du 300 SF/du Private Usable Open Space (c) 75 SF/du 75 SF/du Maximum Floor Area Ratio 0.6 0.6 Notes: (a) 10' if adjacent to single-family or multi -family development without commercial/office uses (b) Maximum density if 45 dwelling units per acre in the MCR-2 Civic Center Drive District and 60 dwelling units per acre in the MCR-2 Transit Oriented Development District. (c) Required for each unit over three units. 55 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-24 - MIXED -USE CORRIDOR AND DISTRICT ZONES 18.24.010 Purpose 18.24.020 Mixed -Use Zones 18.24.030 General Provisions 18.24.040 Building Form and Placement 18.24.050 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.24.060 Accessory Uses 18.24.070 Building Frontage Standards 18.24.080 Parking Requirements 18.24.090 Civic Space Standards 18.24.010 PURPOSE The purpose of the mixed -use corridor and district zones is to create vibrant. mixed -use places that support a dynamic economy, affordable housing and environmental sustainability along major roadways. The mixed -use zones establish standards relating to building form and placement, building frontages, land use, parking, civic spaces, and streets. These standards are intended to create transit -oriented development with high quality architecture, pedestrian -oriented streets. a variety of housing options, accessible civic spaces, and a fine-grained mixture of land uses and activities. These standards differ from conventional zones by de-emphasizing land use regulations and instead focusing on physical form and building design. The mixed -use corridor and district zones implement policies relating to neighborhood design in the Land Use and Community Character Element of the National City General Plan. 18.24.020 MIXED -USE ZONES A. Mixed -Use Corridor, Minor (MXC-1) The MXC-1 zone supports the creation of mixed -use corridors at a scale compatible with adjacent single-family residential neighborhoods. Development in the zone is intended to create a pedestrian - oriented development that enhances, the quality of life within the corridor and for adjacent residential neighborhoods. Buildings in the zone are built at or near front property lines to create a well-defined public realm. Parking areas are de-emphasized by being located adjacent to or behind buildings. Multi -family residential and mixed -use buildings provide a diversity of housing choices for existing and new residents. Commercial uses provide goods and services for residents and jobs for the community. B. Mixed -Use Corridor, Major (MXC-2) The MXC-2 zone supports the creation of mixed -use corridors that function as important activity centers within the community. Development in the zone is intended to create vibrant places at an urban scale. Buildings in the zone are built to the property lines to create a dearly defined street edge with building frontages that are active and inviting for pedestrians. Residents in mixed -use buildings with housing above retail support commercial establishments within the corridor. High quality architectural design and a distinctive sense of place make the zone an attractive destination to work, shop, and play for residents and visitors. C. Mixed -Use District, Minor (MXD-1) The MXD-1 zone supports the creation of mixed -use districts at a scale compatible with adjacent single-family residential neighborhoods. New development within the zone may be oriented towards an existing public street or a new street or civic space within the development site. A mixture of land uses within the zone will support a neighborhood feel and increase the ability for workers and residents to walk to destinations. New streets established in the zone support a pedestrian -oriented 56 Title 18 Zoning environment and accommodate all modes of transportation. New civic spaces required for large redevelopment projects create a lively focal point within the district that functions as a gathering place for residents and workers within the district. D. Mixed -Use District, Major (MXD-2) The MXD-2 zone supports the creation of mixed -use districts that serve as primary activity centers within the city. These activity centers will function as 24-hour neighborhoods for residents, workers, and visitors. Housing, employment, retail, and recreational uses located within close proximity to one another will reduce dependence on the automobile. Urban -scale development will contribute to a lively, dynamic, and unique sense of place. Streets established in the zone support a pedestrian - oriented environment and accommodate all modes of transportation. New civic spaces required for large redevelopment projects will reinforce the urban design character of the district and provide a gathering place for residents, workers, and visitors. 18.24.030 GENERAL PROVISIONS The requirements of this Chapter (Mixed -Use Corridor and District Zones) take precedence over the regulations found elsewhere in Title 18. In the event of a conflict between this Chapter and another portion of the Land Use Code, the provisions of this Chapter shall govern. 18.24.040 BUILDING FORM AND PLACEMENT A. Purpose This section establishes standards for building form and placement, including building height, bulk, mass, and parking placement within the mixed -use corridor and district zones. B. Intent The intent of these standards is to ensure excellence in site planning and building design in order to create a vibrant and well-defined public realm that is pedestrian -friendly and supportive of a sustainable way -of -life. The images below illustrate the intent of these standards. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 57 Title 18 Zoning Mixed -Use Transit Corridor, Minor (MXC-1) Development in the MXC-1 zone shall comply with the standards in Table 18.24.040A (MXC-1 Zone Building Form and Placement). TABLE 18.24.040A MXC-1 Zone Building Form and Placement Development Standard Minimum Maximum Street Wall 75% 100% Building Setbacks Street 0' 15- 1sl and 2nd story None - 3`d story Other 0' None Other, adjacent to residential zone Same as adjacent residential zone None Building Stepbacks 3`d story stepback from 2'd story street wall 8' None 3`d story stepback from 2nd story walls adjacent to RS zone 15' None Building Volume Height None 50' and 3 stories Height, adjacent to residential zone None Same as adjacent zone (within 50 feet) Floor area ratio, mixed use (a) None 2.0 Floor area ratio, single use None 1.0 Residential Density (net rights -of -way) None 48 du/acre Parking Setback Adjacent to Street (b) 40' None Notes: (a) Mixed use shall be defined as both vertical mixed use (e.g., residential or office above ground floor commercial) and horizontal mixed use (e.g., residential and commercial uses in separate buildings located on a single parcel or site). A mixed use developmen that is primarily residential shall contain a minimum of 10 percent commercial floor area. A mixed use development that is primaril commercial shall contain a minimum 20 percent residential floor area. (b) Does not apply when parking is not visible from any point six feet above finish grade along property lines adjacent to public rights -of -way. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 58 Title 18 Zoning Building Setback Standards in the MXC-1 Zone 0 ft. min. 40% lot depth ruin. for 50% of lot depth 0 ft. min FRONT STREET 0 ft. mitt. 40% lot depth min. for 50% of 1 lot width Building Volume Standards in the MXC-1 Zone 3 stor es 50 ft. rnax Parking Setback Standards in the MXC-1 Zone 15 ft rnax_ 15ft. max. t See { note FRONT STREET No max. 0 ft min. 59 Property Line Parking Placement Property tine No nun. Property Line Building Placement Title 18 Zoning C. Mixed -Use Corridor, Major (MXC-2) Standards Development in the MXC-2 zone shall comply with the standards in Table 18.24.040B (MXC-2 Zone Building Form and Placement). TABLE 18.24.040B MXC-2 Zone Building Form and Placement Development Standard Minimum Maximum Street Wall 75% 100% Building Setbacks Street 0, 10' — 1'l and 2ntl story None — 3`d story Other 0' None Other, adjacent to residential zone Same as adjacent residential zone None Building Stepbacks 5`" story stepback from 4`h story street wall 8' None 3td 4th and 5ff' story stepback from 2" story walls adjacent to RS zone 15' None Building Volume Height None 65' and 5 stories Height, adjacent to residential zone None Same as adjacent zone (within 50 feet) Floor area ratio, mixed use (a) None 3.5 Floor area ratio, single use None 2.5 Residential Density (net rights -of -way) None 75 du/acre Parking Setback Adjacent to Street (b) 40' None Notes: (a) Mixed use shall be defined as both vertical mixed use (eg., residential or office above ground floor commercial) and horizontal mixed use (e.g., residential and commercial uses in separate buildings located on a single parcel or site). A mixed use developmen that is primarily residential shall contain a minimum of 10 percent commercial floor area_ A mixed use development that is primaril commercial shall contain a minimum 20 percent residential floor area. (b) Does not apply when parking is not visible trorn any point six feet above finish grade along property lines adjacent to public rights -of -way. 60 Title 18 Zoning Building Setback Standards in the MXC-2 Zone max SIDE STREET 0ft. min 0 rt. max. [t FRONT STREET Building Volume Standards in the MXC-2 Zone 8 ft. min_ No max. See note 5 stories 65 ft. max. [3] Property line Parking Setback Standards in the MXC-2 Zone 0 ft. min 15C% of lot depth 0 k min. S0% of lot depth FRONT STREET 61 Property Line Building Placement Property Line Parking Placement Title 18 Zoning D. Mixed -Use District (MXD-1) Standards Development in the MXD-1 zone shall comply with the standards in Table 18.24.040C (MXD-1 Zone Building Form and Placement). TABLE 18.24.040C MXD-1 Zone Building Form and Placement Development Standard Minimum MaXtrrium Street Wall 75% 100% o Building Setbacks Street 0 15' — 1 si and 2"d story None — 3`d story Other 0' None Other, adjacent to residential zone Same as adjacent residential zone None Building Stepbacks 3r° story stepback from 2nd story street wall 8' None 3`d story stepback from 2nd story walls adjacent to RS zone 15' None Building Volume Height None 50' and 3 stories Height, adjacent to a residential zone None Same as adjacent zone (within 50 feet) Floor area ratio, mixed use (a) None 2.0 Floor area ratio, single use None 1.0 Residential Density None 48 du/acre Parking Setback Adjacent to Street (b) 40' None Notes: (a) Mixed use shall be defined as both vertical mixed use (e.g.. residential or office above ground floor commercial) and horizontal mixed use (e.g., residential and commercial uses in separate buildings located on a single parcel or site). A mixed use developmen that is primarily residential shall contain a minimum of 10 percent commercial floor area. A mixed use development that is primarily commercial shall contain a minimum 20 percent residential floor area. (b) Does not apply when parking is not visible from any point six feet above finish grade along property lines adjacent to public rights -of -way. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 62 Title 18 Zoning Building Setback Standards in the MXD-1 Zone SIDE STREET I 15 ft !max 15 ft. max 10 rf1ONT STREET See note [21 Building Volume Standards in the MXD-1 Zone loft. min. 3 stories 50 ft. max. Property Line Arterial or Collector Frontage Building Placement — — — — Arterial or Collector Frontage Parking Setback Standards in the MXD-1 Zone 0 ft. min. 0 ft. mi SO ft_ or 50% w f of lot • dimension • from property 1. line• whichever l,.------ N I is greater 50 ft. or 50'% of lot dimension from property ' i line. whichever is greater FRONT STREET 63 Property Line — Arterial or Collector Frontage Par king Placement Title 18 Zoning E. Mixed -Use District, Major (MXD-2) Standards Development in the MXD-2 zone shall comply with the standards in Table 18.24.040D (MXD-2 Zone Building Form and Placement). TABLE 18.24.040D MXD-2 Zone Building Form and Placement Development Standard Minimum Maximum Street Wall 75% 100% Building Setbacks Street 0' 10' — 1't and 2na story None — 3rd story Other 0 None Other, adjacent to residential zone Same, as adjacent residential zone None Building Stepbacks 5th story stepback from 4`' story street wall 8' None 3a, 4`h, andstory story stepback from 2nd story walls adjacent to RS zone 15' None Building Volume Height None 65' and 5 stories Height, adjacent to residential zone None Same as adjacent zone (within 50 feet) Floor area ratio, mixed use (a) None 3.5 Floor area ratio, single use None 2.5 Residential Density (net rights -of -way) None 75 du/acre Parking Setback Adjacent to Street (b) 40' None Notes: (a) Mixed use shall be defined as both vertical mixed use (e.g., residential or office above ground floor commercial) and horizontal mixed use (e.g., residential and commercial uses in separate buildings located on a single parcel or site). A mixed use development that is primarily residential shall contain a minimum of 10 percent commercial floor area. A mixed use development that is primarily commercial shall contain a minimum 20 percent residential floor area. (b) Does not apply when parking is not visible from any point six feet above finish grade along property lines adjacent to public rights -of -way. 64 Title 18 Zoning Building Setback Standards in the MXD-2 Zone FRONT STREET Building Volume Standards in the MXD-2 Zone 5 stories 65 ft. max. 8 ft, min. Property Line — — — Arterial or Collector Frontage Building Placement [2] — — — — Arterial or Collector Frontage See note [I] Parking Setback Standards in the MXD-2 Zone SO ft or 50% 1 of lot n- 1 dimension from property tine, whichever is I greater 50 ft or SO% of lot dimension from property line, whichever is greater FRONT STREET 65 Property Line — — — Arterial or Collector Frontage Parking Placement Title 18 Zoning 18.24.050 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS A. Purpose This section identifies permitted uses within the mixed -use zones. B. Permitted Land Uses Land uses permitted in the mixed -use zones shall be as specified in Table 18.24.050 (Allowed Land Uses — Mixed -Use Zones). TABLE 18.24.050 Allowed Land Uses Mixed -Use Zones Land Use Permit Required by Zone Specific Use Regulations MXC-1 (a) MXC-2 MXD-1 MXD-2 Alcohol, sales for off -site consumption (accessory to retail sales) C C C C Section 18.30.050 Section 18.30.050 Alcohol, sales for on -site consumption (accessory to eating places) C C C C Animal boarding/kennel, small (setback 150 feet from single-family residential zones) C C C C Bar/nightclub C C C C Section 18.30.050 Bed & breakfast inn (B&B) C C C C Car wash, automatic and full service P P P P Car wash, manual C C C C Civic, fraternal, community, and cultural facilities P P P P Commercial recreation, indoor P P P P Commercial recreation, outdoor M M M M Convalescent / nursing home / hospice P P P P Child day care center M P M M M Section 18.30.070 Family day care home, small (accessory) P P P Section 18.30.080 Family day care home, large (accessory) M M M M Section 18.30.080 Convenience store (accessory to gas service station) P P P P Section 18.30.190 Dormitory (accessory to school) C C C C Dwelling unit, single detached (b) P P P P Dwelling unit, single attached (b) P P P P Dwelling snit, multiple (b) P P P P Eating places, dine in P P P P Eating places, drive-through/take-out C C C C Farmer's market C C C C Gasoline service station C C C C Section 18.30.190 Goods and services, retail P P P P Guidance/social assistance services C C C C Heliport/helistop (accessory) -- -- C C Home occupation (accessory) P P P P Hospital -- -- C C Hotel, motel, and related services P P P P Section 18.30.270 Maintenance yards C C C C Medical offices/clinics and laboratories P P P P Offices P P P P 66 Title 18 Zoning Open space reserves P P P P Parking garage P P P P Parks (passive and active recreation) P P P P Pawn shops C C C C Section 18.30.330 Payday lenders C C C C Section 18.30.320 Private/public educational institutions, schools C C C C Public assembly C C C C Public safety facilities P P P P Rectory (accessory to religious facility) P P P P Recycling facility, small (accessory) P P P P Section 18.30.170 Recycling facility, mobile C C C C Section 18.30.170 Renewable energy infrastructure (accessory) P P P P Section 18.30.210/ 18.30.300, California Building Code Sidewalk cafe (accessory) P P P P Section 18.30.200 Storage building (accessory) P P P P Tattoo parlors and body piercing establishments C C C C Section 18.30.310 Telecommunication facilities, commercial C C C C Section 18.30.220 Tobacco specialty shops -- -- C C Section 18.30.230 Transitional/supportive housing (b) P P P P Urban agriculture P P P P Section 18.30.240 Utility facilities, minor P P P P Utility facilities, major C C C C Vending machines (accessory) P P P P Section 18.30.150 Veterinary clinics/hospitals C C C C Section(E) 18.30.250 P Permitted C Conditional Use Permit M Minor Use Permit (Ministerial) -- Not permitted Notes: (a) Visitor serving, tourist commercial, and recreational uses are prioritized in the coastal zone_ (b)Residential uses are not permitted in the coastal zone west of 1-5. 18.24.060 ACCESSORY USES A. Commercial Uses in Hotels and Motels Accessory uses and services incidental to the principal use may be permitted; and accessory businesses intended for the convenience or necessity of the guests of the principal use, including bars, cafes, restaurants, lunchrooms, coffee shops, gift shops, florists, barbershops, beauty shops, news and tobacco shops, travel and car rental agencies, business centers, valet service (agency for laundering, cleaning, and pressing of clothing), letting of space for professional offices, operated in conjunction with the uses permitted in this section and not as a separate enterprise, and located on the same premises may be permitted, provided there shah be no entrance to such accessory uses except from the lobby or the interior of a principal building or buildings or patio. B. Storage Buildings and Garages Storage buildings and garages incidental to principal uses on the same premises are permitted. 67 Title 18 Zoning C. Recreational Facilities Recreational facilities serving the customer or patron of a principal use may be permitted. Typical facilities include: 1. Swimming pools, gymnasiums/fitness centers, and hot tubs/spas; 2. Tennis, badminton, volleyball, croquet, and similar courts; 3. Playgrounds, sitting areas, and picnic/barbeque areas. D. Sale of Gasoline The sale of gasoline may be permitted as an accessory use in any zone where gasoline service stations are permitted, subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. E. Auctions Auctions, in conjunction with used furniture or antique sales, may be permitted subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. F. Games of Skill or Amusement 1. In the commercial and mixed -use zones, games of skill or amusement, as an incidental or accessory use, shall be limited to four machines per establishment, two of which may be multiple -player machines. 2. Bowling alleys shall be limited to thirty games of skill or amusement as an incidental use. All such machines shall be located in the main concourse of the facility within the line -of -sight of a supervising adult employed by the business proprietor, whom shall be continuously present at all times that machines are being used. 3. The use of games of skill or amusement as an incidental or accessory use may be permitted within an existing establishment only if a conditional use permit is granted. 4. Limitations on location of games of skill and amusement. a. No games of skill and amusement accessible for use by minors shall be maintained, operated, conducted or used, nor kept for such purposes, in or on the premises of any establishment whose primary business is the sale of alcoholic beverages. This shall not prohibit the operation of amusement machines in a bona fide establishment with an on -sale liquor license or restaurants which are not licensed to sell alcoholic beverages. b. No games of skill and amusement shall be maintained, operated, conducted or uses, nor kept for such purposes, within any place which is closer than three hundred feet from any public or private school which conducts classes for any grades from kindergarten to twelfth grade. G. Catering Services Catering services for retail food preparation and party supplies may be permitted; provided said use is conducted in conjunction with a permitted restaurant, retail store, or commercial office; and further provided that the wholesaling or warehousing of merchandise does not occur in the operation of the catering business. 18.24.070 A. Purpose BUILDING FRONTAGE STANDARDS This section identifies permitted frontage types for each mixed -use zone and establishes design standards that apply to each frontage type. 68 Title 18 Zoning B. Frontage Types Defined Frontage types refer to the design and function of street -facing wall building facades. Frontage types define the way a structure engages the street and provides a transition between the public and private realm. C. Permitted Frontage Types 1. MXC-1 and MXC-2 Zones. Exterior building walls in the MXC-1 and MXC-2 zones facing a street shall feature a permitted frontage type as shown in Table 18.24.070 (Building Frontage Types). 2. MXD-1 and MXD-2 Zones. Exterior building walls in the MXD-1 and MXD-2 zones facing a collector or arterial street shall feature a permitted frontage type as shown in Table 18.24.070 (Building Frontage Types). Within the MXD-1 and MXD-2 zones, frontage type requirements do not apply to building walls facing other types of streets. TABLE 18.24.070 Building Frontage Types in Mixed -Use Zones Mixed Use Zones MXC-1 & MXD-1 MXC-2 & MXD 2 Porch P See Note (a) Stoop P See Note (a) Lightcourt P See Note (a) Dooryard P See Note (a) Forecourt P See Note (a) Shopfront P P Gallery P Arcade — P Lobby — P rvotes: (a) Permitted only for exterior building walls fronting one or more existing single-family home. D. Residential Transitions 1. Required frontage types. The portion of a building facing and located across a street from one or more detached single family home shall feature either a porch or a stoop frontage type. 2. Distinct volumes. Frontages as required by Subsection (1) above shall read as a series of distinct volumes, each no greater than 50 feet in width. Variation in building color, breaks in the horizontal plane, architectural detailing, and other similar methods may be used to comply with this requirement. Unarticulated facades are not permitted. E. Frontage Type Standards Frontage types shall comply with the following standards. 1. Porch. a. Porch defined. A porch is a covered but unenclosed projection from the front wall of a structure generally surrounding the main entry to a dwelling unit. b. Dimensions. A porch shall comply with the following dimension standards: i. Depth: 8 feet minimum 69 Title 18 Zoning ii. Width: 12 feet minimum iii. Height: 8 feet minimum from finished floor to ceiling c. Maximum elevation. The elevation of a porch floor shall not exceed 4 feet from adjacent grade. d. Maximum fence height. The height of a fence located at the front sidewalk shall not exceed 48 inches from adjacent grade. e. Open sides required. Full or partial enclosure of porches greater than 42 inches in height is prohibited. Porch and Fence Standards: Section View min: Porch and Fence Standards: Plan View 12 ft. min. 70 Title 18 Zoning 2. Stoop_ a. Stoop defined. A stoop is an uncovered unenclosed elevated platform projecting from the front wall of a structure providing access to the ground level of a building. b. Dimensions. A stoop shall comply with the following dimension standards: i. Depth: 6 feet minimum ii. Width: 4 feet minimum c. Maximum elevation. The elevation of a stoop floor shall not exceed 6 feet from adjacent grade. d. Maximum fence, handrail, or wall height. The height of a fence, handrail, or wall surrounding a stoop shall not exceed 42 inches as measured from the stoop floor. e. Open sides required. Full or partial enclosure of stoops greater than 42 inches in height is prohibited. Stoop Standards: Section View 3ft. max. Stoop Standards: Plan View 71 Title 18 Zoning 3. Lightcourt. a. Lightcourt defined. A Lightcourt is a sunken front yard area that buffers residential uses from adjacent sidewalks. b. Maximum depth. The lower level of a building accessed by a Lightcourt shall be no more than six feet below adjacent grade. c. Maximum stoop elevation. The maximum elevation of the stoop portion of a Lightcourt shall not exceed six feet from adjacent grade. Lightcourt Standards: Section View 4 ft. max. 6 ft. max. Lightcourt Standards: Plan View 72 Title 18 Zoning 4. Dooryard. a. Dooryard defined. A dooryard is a garden or terrace in the front yard area elevated from the adjacent sidewalk. b. Maximum garden or terrace elevation. The maximum elevation of an elevated garden or terrace shall be three feet from adjacent grade. c. Open sides required. Full enclosure of an elevated garden or terrace is prohibited. Dooryard Standards: Section View Dooryard Standards: Plan View 73 Title 18 Zoning 5. Forecourt. a. Forecourt defined. A forecourt is an open area partially surrounded by building walls that opens to a public sidewalk. b. Minimum dimensions. The area of a forecourt surrounded by building walls shall comply with the following dimension standards: i. Depth: 6 feet minimum ii. Width: 20 feet minimum, 50 feet maximum c. Maximum elevation. The elevation of a forecourt floor shall not exceed six feet from adjacent grade. d. Minimum transparency. The minimum area of a forecourt's street -facing walls consisting of transparent windows shall be 40 percent for residential uses and 60 percent for commercial uses. Forecourt Standards: Section View 6 ft. max. Forecourt Standards: Plan View 20 ft. min. 50 ft max 6 ft. min. 74 Title 18 Zoning 6. Shopfront. a. Shopfront defined. A shopfront is a building facade that consists primarily of transparent glass with access to a commercial space located at street level. b. Minimum transparency, ground floor. A minimum of 65 percent of the street -facing walls of a ground floor shopfront shall consist of transparent windows or doors with views into the building c. Minimum Transparency, upper floors. A minimum of 40 percent of the streety-facing walls of upper floors shall consist of transparent windows or doors. d. Ground floor doors. A minimum of 80 percent of the area of any door providing access to ground floor commercial uses shall consist of transparent glass. e. Upper floor window proportions. Facade openings and windows on upper stories shall be vertically proportioned, with a greater height than width. The height -width ratio of windows and openings shall be no less than 1.5:1. f. Ground and upper floor windows. The percentage of building faccade consisting of windows shall be greater on the ground floor than on upper floors. g. Awning and canopy dimensions. An awning or canopy attached to the exterior of a shopfront shall comply with the following dimension standards. i. Maximum projection from building wall: 8 feet, or two-thirds of the sidewalk width, whichever is greater. ii. Minimum 8 feet clearance above sidewalk. h. Awning and canopy location. Awnings and canopies may be permitted along storefronts and doors only. i. Doors and windows. Doors and windows shall not open or project into the public right-of-way. Shopfront Standards: Section View 8 ft. or 2/3 of the sidewalk width, whichever is greater Shopfront Standards: Plan View 8 ft. or 2/3 of the sidewalk width, whichever is greater 75 Title 18 Zoning 7_ Gallery a. Gallery defined. A gallery is a storefront with a covered walkway supported by columns or arches that may project over a sidewalk or walkway. b. Minimum transparency_ A minimum of 60 percent of the primary frontage of a gallery shall consist of transparent windows or doors with views into the building. c. Minimum dimensions. A gallery shall comply with the following minimum dimension standards: i. Minimum dimensions of 12 feet wide, 6 feel deep, and 10 feet high ii. Maximum 3 feet distance between curb face and edge of gallery column or arch. d. Doors and windows. Doors and windows shall not open or project into the public right-of- way. Gallery Standards: Section View Gallery Standards: Plan View 12 ft. min. 6 ft. f min. 3 ft. max. 76 Title 18 Zoning 8. Arcade a. Arcade defined. An arcade is a shopfront with a habitable upper story that projects over a sidewalk supported by columns or arches. b. Minimum transparency, ground floor. A minimum of 60 percent of the street -facing ground floor frontage of an arcade shall consist of transparent windows or doors with views into the building. c. Minimum transparency, upper floors. A minimum of 40 percent of the upper floors of the street - facing frontage of an arcade shall consist of transparent windows or doors. d. Minimum dimensions. An arcade shall comply with the following minimum dimension standards: i. Minimum dimensions of 12 ft. wide, 10 ft. deep, and 10 ft. high ii. Maximum 3 ft. distance between curb face and edge of arcade e. Doors and windows. Doors and windows shall not open or project into the public right-of-way Arcade Standards: Section View 10 ft. €nin. 7, 10 ft. min. Arcade Standards: Plan View 77 Title 18 Zoning 9. Lobby. a. Lobby defined. A lobby is a building facade that includes transparent glass with access to a lobby space located at street level. b. Minimum transparency. The minimum area of a lobby's street -facing walls consisting of transparent windows shall be 40 percent for residential uses and 60 percent for commercial uses. c. Maximum elevation. The elevation of a lobby floor shall not exceed three feet from adjacent grade. d. Entrances. Entrance may be inset or flush with building facade e. Doors and windows. Doors and windows shall not open or project into the public right-of-way. Lobby Standards: Section View Lobby Standards: Section View 78 Title 18 Zoning F. Commercial Service Location and Screening 1. Service activities associated with commercial uses shall be setback a minimum of 15 feet from any property line abutting a parcel occupied by a detached single family home. 2. Outdoor storage, trash collection, and loading areas shall located and screened from view such that they are not visible from any parcel occupied by a detached single farnily home. G. Noise Generating Activities Outdoor dining, amplified music, and other noise -generating activities as determined by the Director shall be setback a minimum of 150 feet from the property line of any parcel occupied by a detached single- family home. 18.24.080 PARKING REQUIREMENTS A. Purpose This section establishes parking standards that apply to the mixed -use zones. B. Required On -Site Parking Off-street parking shall be provided pursuant to Chapter 18.45. C. Parking Structures All multi -story parking structures shall be lined with commercial, retail or residential uses on the ground floor at street frontages, except for the pedestrian and vehicular entries into the parking structure. D. Parking Buffers 1. Surface parking lots abutting a public sidewalk or street shall provide a landscaped buffer a minimum of two feel in width and three feet in height along the perimeter of the parking lot abutting the sidewalk or street. 2. A landscaped buffer at least three feet in width and six feet in height shall be provided for any surface parking lot abutting a residential zone. 79 Title 18 Zoning Landscaped Parking Buffer Standards Residential Zone E. Parking Costs Parking Lot Street 1. The payment of parking costs shall be separate from rent payments or purchase prices for all uses located within the mixed -use zones. 2. All places of employment within the mixed -use zone shall offer a parking cash -out program that allows employees to receive either owner -subsidized free parking or a cash payment equal to the value of the parking subsidy. F. Alley Access For new development on property adjacent to a rear alley, vehicle and service access to the property shall be provided only through the rear alley. G. Driveways 1. New driveways comply with the following standards. a. Dimensions. Driveways shall comply with the dimension standards shown in Table 18.24.080B (Driveway Dimension Standards). b. Number. No more than one driveway approach shall be provided for every 50 feet of street frontage. c. Proximity. A new curb cut providing access to a driveway from a public street shall be separated a minimum distance of 35 feet from any other curb cut. d. Parking. Parking spaces shall not be located along the sides of a driveway. (Reminder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 80 Title 18 Zoning 2. The Community Development Director may approve exceptions to the driveway requirements in ALLEY FRONT STREET Subsection 1 above in the case of shared or joint use of driveways and parking lots. Vehicle Access Standards 18.24.090 CIVIC SPACE STANDARDS A. Purpose This section establishes requirements and standards for civic spaces in the MXD-1 and MXD-2 zones. Civic spaces are areas within neighborhoods where people can gather, interact and enjoy access to recreational and open space amenities. B. Applicability Any commercial or mixed -use redevelopment project on a site 5 acres or greater in the MXD-1 or MXD-2 zones shall include a publically accessible civic space consistent with the standards established in this section. C. Types of Civic Spaces Permitted types of civic spaces in the MXD-1 and MXD-2 zones are greens, squares, plazas, and playgrounds, as defined in Section E (Standards for Specific Types of Civic Spaces), below. 81 Title 18 Zoning D. General Standards The following standards apply to all civic spaces and new development adjacent to civic spaces. 1. The on -site parking of vehicles within a civic space is prohibited. 2. All areas with playground equipment shall be visible from the street edge. 3. All sides of a civic space shall front either a public street, the primary frontage of a building, or a natural physical barrier such as a hillside or creek. 4. All building walls fronting a civic space shall feature a frontage type permitted within the applicable zone as specified in Section 18.24.070 (Building Frontage Standards). 5. Quasi -public activities, such as outdoor seating serving a restaurant, are permitted to occupy no more than 25 percent of the area of a civic space. 6. Civic spaces shall be designed and located so as to be clearly visible from one or more public streets. 7. All civic spaces shall front onto a public street for a minimum distance of 50 feet. E. Standards for Specific Types of Civic Spaces Specific types of civic spaces within the MXD-1 and MXD-2 zones, when required by Subsection B (Applicability) above, shall comply with the following standards. 1. Green. A green shall comply with the following standards. a. The size of all greens shall be a minimum of 0.5 acres and a maximum of 5 acres. b. All greens shall front on a minimum of one public street. c. Permitted improvements include playgrounds, ball parks, picnic shelters, benches, pergolas, bandstands and other similar improvements. d. Landscape within parks shall feature lawns generally unobstructed with limited trees naturalistically arranged and a maximum 50 percent irrigated turf. e. Hardscape within greens shall be limited to the minimum needed for circulation and amenities. f. No more than 10 percent of a green shall be covered with impervious surfaces. 2. Square. A square shall comply with the following standards. a. The size of all squares shall be a minimum of 0.5 acres and a maximum of 3 acres. b. All squares shall front on a minimum of three public streets. c. Permitted improvements within squares include paths, benches, pergolas, public art, fountains, gazebos, bandstands, small structures such as kiosks and restrooms and other similar improvements. d. Landscape within squares shall include lawns and trees formally arranged and a maximum 10 percent irrigated turf. e. Hardscape within squares shall feature Square Plan Illustratiun pathways and amenities formally arranged around a central point of interest. No more than 25 percent of a green shall be covered with impervious surfaces. 82 Green Plan Illustration Title 18 Zoning 3. Plaza. A plaza shall comply with the following standards. a. The size of all squares shall be a minimum of 0.25 acres and a maximum of two acres. b. All plazas shall front on a minimum of one public street. c. Permitted improvements within plazas include paths, benches, planters, seatwalls, fountains, gazebos, pergolas, bandstands, small structures such as kiosks and restroorns, and other similar improvements. d. Landscape within plazas shall be primarily pavement, trees formally arranged and a maximum ten percent irrigated turf. e. Hardscape within plazas shall feature pavement with distinctive materials and pattern. No more than 25 percent of a plaza shall be covered with impervious surfaces. 4. Playground. A playground shall comply with the following standards. a. The size of all playgrounds shall be a minimum of 0.1 acres and a maximum of one acre. b. All playgrounds shall front a minimum of one public street. c. Permitted improvements include paths, benches, shade structures, playground equipment, drinking fountains, restroom facilities, fences as required and other similar improvements. d. Adventure play or creative playgrounds are permitted. e. Landscape within playgrounds shall be accessible softscape, trees arranged for shading of play area and benches, and a maximum ten percent irrigated turf. f. Hardscape within playground shall be the minimum needed for circulation and play opportunities. No more than 25 percent of a playground shall be covered with impervious surfaces. 83 Plena — Plan Illustration Playground — Plan Illustration Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-25 — INDUSTRIAL ZONES 18.25.010 Purpose 18.25.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.25.030 Accessory Uses 18.25.040 General Development Standards 18.25.050 Uses to be Adequately Housed in Completely Enclosed Buildings 18.25.010 PURPOSE This section lists the land uses allowed within the industrial zones and provides basic standards for site layout and budding use. The purposes of the individual industrial zoning districts and the manner in which they are applied are as follows: A. Light Industrial (IL) The IL Light Industrial zone is intended to accommodate warehousing operations, storage, office, and research and development facilities and establishments engaged in the manufacturing, assembling, packaging, treatment and processing of products other than those that which may be obnoxious or offensive to adjacent residential and business districts due to reason of odor, dust, smoke, gas, noise, vibration or other nuisances. B. Medium Industrial (IM) The IM Medium Industrial zone is designed to provide for the development of medium manufacturing and industrial uses that operate without excessive noise, dust, odor or other nuisances and yet may be objectionable to other non -industrial uses. C. Heavy Industrial (IH) The IH Heavy Industrial zone is intended to provide for manufacturing facilities and industries that may be obnoxious by reason of emission of odor, dust, smoke, gas, noise, vibration or similar causes and therefore require isolation from many other kinds of land uses. 18.25.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS Table 18.25.020 identifies the uses of land allowed in each Industrial zone_ (Reminder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 84 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.25.020 Allowed Land Uses Industrial Zones Land Use Zone Specific Use Regulations IL IM IH Animal boarding/kennel, small C C C Assembly and light manufacturing/processing P P P Automotive impound and storage yards C C C Section 18.30.040 Auto towing dispatch (accessory to service station) P P -- Building supplies and equipment, sales and rental P P P Cemetery/mausoleum/crematory -- C C Commercial recreation, indoor C -- -- Eating places, dine -in (accessory) P P P Emergency shelter P -- -- Section 18.30.110 Gasoline service station C C Section 18.30.190 Goods and services, retail sales (accessory) P P P Heavy manufacturing/processing -- C Industrial equipment/machinery, sales and rentals P P P Medium manufacturing/processing -- P P Offices (accessory) P P P Offices P M M Open space reserves P P P Outdoor storage C C C Section 18.30.160 Pawn shops C -- -- Section 18.30.330 Payday lenders C -- -- Section 18.30.320 Plant nursery P P C Parking, structure/ Fleet P P P Personal storage facilities (mini -warehouses) P P Public assembly C -- -- Public safety facilities P P P Recycling facilities, small (accessory) P P -- Section 18.30.170 Recycling facilities, mobile C C -- Section 18.30.170 Renewable energy infrastructure (accessory) P P P Section 18.30.210/ 18.30.300; California Building Code Renewable energy infrastructure P P P Section 18.30.210/ 18.30.300; California Building Code Research and development P P P Scrap metal processing -- -- C Section 18.30.180 Sixty day storage of wrecked vehicles P P P Storage facility, self (mini -warehouses) P P P Tattoo parlors and body piercing establishments C -- -- Section 18.30.310 Telecommunication facilities, commercial C C C Section 18.30.220 Trade schools P C C Trucking and transportation terminal -- C P Urban agriculture C -- . Section 18.30.240 Utility facilities, minor P P P Utility facilities, major P P P Veterinary hospitals and clinics M M -- Section 18.30.250 Waterfront related industries P P P Wholesaling, warehousing, and distribution P P P P Permitted C Conditional Use Permit M Minor Use Permit (Ministerial) -- Not permitted 85 Title 18 Zoning 18.25.030 ACCESSORY USES Accessory uses and the conditions of their use are set out in subsections A through C below. A. Storage Buildings and Garages Storage buildings and garages incidental to principal uses on the same premises are permitted. B. Sale of Gasoline The sale of gasoline may be permitted as an accessory use in any zone where gasoline service stations are permitted, subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. C. Auctions Auctions, in conjunction with used furniture or antique sales, may be permitted subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. 18.25.040 GENERAL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS TABLE 18.25.040 Development Standards Industrial Zones Development Standard Zone IL , IM IH Minimum Lot Area 5,000 sq. ft. (al 5,000 sq. ft. (a) 5,000 sq. ft. Minimum Street Frontage 50' (b) 50' (b) 50' Minimum Setbacks Street Other When adjacent to a residential zone, 20' from the adjacent zone boundary 10' 10' 10' 0' 0' 0' Maximum Height 35' and 3 stories 60' and 4 stories 60' and 4 stories When adjacent to a resider ial zone, the maximum height shall not exceed the maximum height in the adjacent zone within 100-feet of the adjacent zone boundary. Architectural features and mechanical equipment may exceed the maximum height by an additional 10 ft. Maximum Floor Area Ratio 2 2 2 Maximum Lot Coverage 60% 80% 80% Notes (a) Automobile service stations shall have a minimum lot area of 15,000 square feet. (b) Automobile service stations shall have a minimum street frontage of 100 feet. 18.25.050 USES TO BE ADEQUATELY HOUSED IN COMPLETELY ENCLOSED BUILDINGS All uses in the Industrial zones shall be housed in completely enclosed buildings; provided, however, that businesses such as lumber yards, building material yards, gas stations, recycling facilities, metal processing yards, vehicle storage, storage lots, and similar uses that customarily include outdoor use, may be permitted outside of a completely enclosed building when screened from public view. 86 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-26 — INSTITUTIONAL ZONE 18.26.010 Purpose 18.26.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.26.030 General Development Standards 18.26.010 PURPOSE The purpose of the Institutional (I) zone is to provide for a wide range of institutional and accessory uses including public, quasi -public. and private facilities that address health, safety, educational, cultural, and welfare needs of the community and neighborhoods. Allowed uses include educational facilities, government offices and courts, community centers, libraries, museums and cultural centers, hospitals and medical centers, retirement communities, public safety facilities (i.e., fire and police stations), neighborhood gardens and community farms, public utilities, and similar uses. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 87 Title 18 Zoning 18.26.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS Table 18.26.020 identifies the uses of land allowed in the institutional zone. TABLE 18.26.020 Allowed Land Uses Institutional Zone Land Use Permit Required Specific Use Regulations Animal husbandry P Section 8.32 Caretaker's residence (accessory) M Cemetery / mausoleum P Child day care center P Section 18.30.070 Civic, fraternal, community, and cultural facilities P Commercial recreation, indoor (accessory) P Convalescent / nursing home / hospice P Detention facility C Dormitory (accessory to school) C C Farmers' markets Fraternity or sorority house C Government offices P Guidance/social assistance services P Heliport1helistop (accessory to hospital) C Hospital P C Maintenance buildings/ yards Medical offices / clinics and laboratories P Military installations P Open space reserves P Parking, structure/ fleet P Parks (passive and active recreation) P Private/public educational institutions, schools P Public assembly C Public safety facilities P Public utilities, minor P Public utilities, major C Renewable energy infrastructure (accessory) P Section 18.30.210/ 18.30.300; California Building Code Storage yards and buildings (accessory) P Section 18.30.160 Telecommunication facilities, commercial C Section 18.30.220 Urban agriculture P Section 18.30.240 P Permitted C Conditional Use Permit M Minor Use Permit (Ministerial) -- Not permitted 88 Title 18 Zoning 18.26.030 GENERAL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS Design regulations for the Institutional zone are set out in Division 4, unless specified in this Chapter. TABLE 18.26.030 Development Standards Institutional Zone Zone Front Yard Interior Side =Yard Rear Yard Exterior Side Yard Rear Yard Abutting Alley or PubljC Park Minimum Lot Area Maximum Building Height FAR 10' 0' (a) 0' (a) 5' 5' 5,000SF 65' and 5 stories (b) 3.0 Notes: (a) Or, when adjacent to a residential zone, the interior side or rear yard setback shall be the same as the interior side or rear year setback required in the residential zone. (b) When adjacent to a residential zone, the maximum height shall not exceed the maximum height in the adjacent zone within 100-feet of the adjacent zone boundary. CHAPTER 18-27 — OPEN SPACE ZONE 18.27.010 Purpose 18.27.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.27.030 General Development Standards 18.27.010 PURPOSE The purpose of the Open Space (OS) zone is to provide for public and private improved and unimproved open space. Allowed land uses include urban agriculture and recreational areas such as parks, golf courses, athletic fields, playgrounds, community gardens and farms, recreational trails, nature and wildlife preserves, marshes and wetlands, water bodies, public utility areas, flood control channels, and other scenic and open space areas. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 89 Title 18 Zoning 18.27.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND STRUCTURES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS Table 18.27.020 identifies the uses of land allowed in the open space zone TABLE 18.27.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements Open Space Zone Land Use Permit Required Specific Regulations Use Animal husbandry P Section 8.32 Caretaker's residence (accessory) M Cemetery! mausoleum P Child day care center P Section 18.30.270 Civic, fraternal, community, and cultural facilities P Commercial recreation, indoor (accessory) P Convalescent ! nursing home / hospice P Detention facility C Dormitory (accessory to school) C Farmers' markets C Fraternity or sorority house C Government offices P Guidance/social assistance services P Heliport/helistop (accessory to hospital) C Hospital P Maintenance buildings/ yards C Medical offices / clinics and laboratories P Military installations P Open space reserves P Parking, structure/ fleet P Parks (passive and active recreation) P Private/public educational institutions, schools P Public assembly C Public safety facilities P Public utilities, minor P Public utilities, major C Renewable energy infrastructure (accessory) P Section 18.30.210/ 18.30 300; California Building Code Storage yards and buildings (accessory) P Section 18-30.160 Telecommunication facilities, commercial C Section 18-30.220 Urban agriculture P Section 18.30.240 P Permitted C Conditional Use Permit M Minor Use Permit (Ministerial) -- Not permitted 90 Title 18 Zoning 18.27.030 GENERAL DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS The maximum FAR in the open space zone is 0.25 and the maximum height limit is 35'. CHAPTER 18-28 — OPEN SPACE RESERVE ZONE 18.28.010 Purpose 18.28.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements 18.28.010 PURPOSE The intent of the open space reserve zone is to provide a use category to preserve and protect public and private open space lands, salt marsh and coastal wetlands, water areas, uninhabited agricultural lands, flood control channels, and other scenic or biological open space areas by restricting development in such areas. 18.28.020 ALLOWED LAND USES AND PERMIT REQUIREMENTS Table 18.28.020 identifies the uses of land allowed in the open space reserve zone. TABLE 18.28.020 Allowed Land Uses and Permit Requirements Open Space Reserve Zone Aquaculture P Specific Use Regulations; Wildlife reserves or sanctuaries P Bay access Bikeways, paths, and trails Open space reserves (land and water) Public utilities, minor P P P Permitted 91 Title 18 Zoning CHAPTER 18-29 — OVERLAY ZONES 18.29.010 Purpose 18.29.020 Overlay Zone Designations 18.29.030 Coastal Zone (CZ) 18.29.040 Height Limit Restrictions Overlay Zone (H) 18.29.050 Mobile Home Park Overlay Zone (MHP) 18.29.070 Floodway (-FW), Floodway Fringe (-FF-1), and Floodway Fringe -Shallow Flooding (-FF-2) Zones 18.29.010 PURPOSE The purpose of overlay zones is to provide supplemental regulations that have been tailored to specific geographic areas of the City. Overlay zones are applied in conjunction with a base zone and modify or add to the regulations of the base zone to address specific issues such as development within the Coastal Zone, special height restrictions, or supplemental processing requirements. 18.29.020 OVERLAY ZONE DESIGNATIONS Overlay zones are designated on the Zoning Map as indicated below: A. Coastal Zone (CZ) The Coastal Zone designates all properties located within the coastal zone subject to the development standards and specific requirements of the Local Coastal Plan. B. Height Restriction (H) The Height Limit Restriction Overlay Zone places a restriction on allowable building height, lower than otherwise permitted by the City's development regulations. C. Mobile Home Park (MHP) The Mobile Home Park Overlay Zone identifies where mobile home parks are permitted in the City and establishes standards for the development of new mobile home parks and the preservation of existing mobile home parks. 18.29.030 COASTAL ZONE (CZ) A. Purpose The intent and purpose of the coastal zone is to identify and give notice that properties within this zone are affected by the City's local coastal program. The purpose of the Coastal Overlay Zone is to protect and enhance the quality of public access and coastal resources. B. Applicability When any property bears on the zoning map of the City, in addition to its zone designation, the symbol CZ, the provisions of this chapter shall apply. C. Regulations In addition to meeting the requirements of the underlying zone, any use on a property bearing the symbol CZ on the zoning map must in addition meet the provisions of the City's local coastal program_ 92 Title 18 Zoning 18.29.050 HEIGHT LIMIT RESTRICTION OVERLAY ZONE (H) A. Applicability Whenever any property bears, on the zoning map of the City, in addition to its zone designation, the symbol "H" followed by a numerical figure, the provisions of this chapter shall apply insofar as height limitations for any buildings or structures located, or to be located, upon such property are concerned. B. Formula No building or structure shall be erected upon any property in any zone, which property bears on the zoning map the symbol "H" together with a numerical figure following, exceeding a building height, of a distance measured in feet, equal to the numerical figure following the symbol "H." 18.29.060 MOBILE HOME PARK OVERLAY ZONE (MHP) A. Purpose The purpose of the MHP overlay zone is to provide for appropriate locations for mobile home parks to be established, maintained, and protected. This overlay zone provides for a greater range and choice of housing types, recognizes the potential for higher standards offered by mobile home design and technology, and is intended to create attractive mobile home parks that will preserve and enhance the character of surrounding areas. This zone also sets forth procedures for the conversion of an existing mobile home park to another use and is intended to minimize the adverse impacts of displacing mobile home park tenants whenever an existing mobile home park or portion thereof is converted to another use. B. Applicability When any property bears on the zoning map of the City, in addition to its zone designation, the symbol MHP, the provisions of this section shall apply. C. Permitted Uses 1. New mobile home parks are subject to conditional use permit approval. 2. Accessory structures limited to awnings, cabanas, storage cabinets, renewable energy infrastructure, fences or windbreaks, carports, garages, and porches are permitted. 3. Accessory uses such as recreational facilities, parks and open space, playgrounds, clubhouses, laundries, community centers, and similar uses are permitted; provided, that such uses are designed for and limited to use by residents of the mobile home park and their guests and that such uses are not authorized on the individual mobile home lots within the mobile home park. 4. Minor utility facilities are permitted; major utility facilities require conditional use permit approval. 5. Home occupations are permitted subject to the approval of a home occupation permit pursuant to Section 18.12.090. 6. Small family day care homes are permitted subject to Section 18.30.080. 7. Large family day care homes are permitted subject to the approval of a minor use permit and provided they comply with Section 18.30.080. D. Development Standards 1. Mobile home parks shall comply with the maximum density of the applicable general plan designation and underlying zone and all other development standards of the underlying zone (unless otherwise constrained by Section 18000 et seq. of the Health and Safety Code) with the exception of the following: a. The front yard setback shall be a minimum of 25 feet. b. The interior side yard setback shall be a minimum of ten feet. 93 Title 18 Zoning 2. When located on a lot adjoining another residential use, mobile home parks shall be permanently screened from such adjoining property by a fence or wall and suitable landscaping, adjacent to or opposite the other residential use. E. Discontinuance Procedures 1. The application for discontinuance of a mobile home park shall be accompanied by: a. A relocation plan to provide for the tenants who will be displaced by the discontinuance of the property as a mobile home park or the conversion of mobile home spaces to other uses. b. A phasing plan indicating the timing and manner in which the existing mobile home units will be discontinued. 18.29.070 FLOODWAY (-FW), FLOODWAY FRINGE (-FF-1), AND FLOODWAY FRINGE - SHALLOW FLOODING (-FF-2) ZONES A - STATEMENT OF PURPOSE. It is the purpose of this chapter to promote the public health, safety and general welfare, and to minimize public and private losses due to flood conditions in specific areas by provisions designed to: 1. Protect human life and health; 2. Minimize expenditure of public money for costly flood control projects; 3. Minimize the need for rescue and relief efforts associated with flooding and generally undertaken at the expense of the general public; 4. Minimize prolonged business interruptions; 5. Minimize damage to public facilities and utilities such as water and gas mains, electric, telephone and sewer lines, streets and bridges located in areas of special flood hazard; 6. Help maintain a stable tax base by providing for the second use and development of areas of special flood hazard so as to minimize future flood blight areas; 7. Ensure that potential buyers are notified that property is in an area of special flood hazard; and 8. Ensure that those who occupy the areas of special flood hazard assume responsibility for their actions. B - METHODS OF REDUCING FLOOD LOSSES. In order to accomplish its purposes, this chapter includes methods and provisions to: 1. Restrict or prohibit uses which are dangerous to health, safety and property due to water or erosion hazards, or which result in damaging increases in erosion or flood heights or velocities; 2. Require that uses vulnerable to floods, including facilities which serve such uses, be protected against flood damage at the time of initial construction; 3. Control the alteration of natural floodplains, stream channels and natural protective barriers, which help accommodate or channel floodwaters; 4. Control filling, grading, dredging, and other development which may increase flood damage; and 5. Prevent or regulate the construction of flood barriers which will unnaturally divert floodwaters or which may increase flood hazards in other areas. C - WARNING AND DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY. The degree of flood protection required by this chapter is considered reasonable for regulatory purposes and is based on scientific and engineering considerations. Larger floods can and will occur on rare occasions. Flood heights may be increased by man-made or natural causes. This chapter does not imply that land outside the areas of special flood hazards or uses permitted within such areas will be free from flooding or flood damages. This chapter shall not create liability on the part of the city, any officer or employee thereof, the state of California or the Federal Insurance Administration, Federal Emergency Management Agency for any flood damages that result from reliance on this chapter or any administrative decision lawfully made thereunder. 94 Title 18 Zoning D - ABROGATION AND GREATER RESTRICTIONS This chapter is not intended to repeal, abrogate or impair any existing easements, covenants or deed restrictions. However, where this chapter and another chapter, easement, covenant or deed restrictions conflict or overlap, whichever imposes the more stringent restriction shall prevail. E - DEFINITIONS Unless specifically defined below, or in this Title, words or phrases used in this chapter shall be interpreted so as to give them the meaning they have in common usage and to give this chapter its most reasonable application. 1. "Accessory use" means a use which is incidental and subordinate to the principal use of the parcel of land on which it is located. 2. "Adversely affects" means, for purposes of this chapter, that the cumulative effect of the proposed development when combined with all other existing and anticipated development will increase the water surface elevation of the base flood more than one foot at any point. 3. "Alluvial fan" means a geomorphologic feature characterized by a cone- or fan -shaped deposit of boulders, gravel, and fine sediments that have been eroded from slopes, transported by flood flows, and then deposited on the valley floor, and which is subject to flash flooding, high velocity flows, debris flows, erosion, sediment movement and deposition, and channel migration. 4. "Apex" means the point of highest elevation on an alluvial fan, which on undisturbed fans is generally the point where the major stream that formed the fan emerges from the slope. 5. "Appeal" means a request for a review of the floodplain administrator's interpretation of any provision of this chapter. 6. "Area of shallow flooding" means a designated AO or AH zone on the Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM). The base flood depths range from one to three feet; a clearly defined channel does not exist; the path of flooding is unpredictable and indeterminate; and, velocity flow may be evident. Such flooding is characterized by ponding or sheet flow. 7. "Area of special flood hazard" —see "Special flood hazard area." 8. "Base flood" means a flood which has a one percent chance of being equaled or exceeded in any given year (also called the "one hundred year flood"). Base flood is the term used throughout this chapter. 9. "Basement" means any area of the building having its floor subgrade—i.e., below ground level —on all sides. 10. "Building" —see "Structure_" 11. "Development" means any man-made change to improved or unimproved real estate, including but not limited to buildings or other structures, mining, dredging, filling, grading, paving, excavation or drilling operations, or storage of equipment or materials. 12. "Encroachment" means the advance or infringement of uses, plant growth, fill, excavation, buildings, permanent structures or development into a floodplain which may impede or alter the flow capacity of a floodplain. 13. "Exception" means a grant of relief from the requirements of this chapter which permits construction in a manner that would otherwise be prohibited by this chapter. 14. "Existing manufactured home/mobile home park or subdivision" means a manufactured home park or subdivision for which the construction of facilities for servicing the lots on which the manufactured homes/mobile homes are to be affixed (including, at a minimum, the installation of utilities, the construction of streets, and either final site grading or the pouring of concrete pads) is completed before the effective date of this chapter. 15. "Expansion to an existing manufactured home/mobile home park or subdivision" means the preparation of additional sites by the construction of facilities for servicing the lots on which the manufactured homes/mobile homes are to be affixed (including the installation of utilities, the construction of streets, and either final site grading or pouring of concrete pads) 16. "Flood, flooding or floodwater" means a general and temporary condition of partial or complete inundation of normally dry land areas from the overflow of inland or tidal waters, and/or the unusual and rapid accumulation or runoff of surface waters from any source. 95 Title 18 Zoning 17. "Flood Boundary and Floodway Map (FBFM)" means the official map on which the Federal Emergency Management Agency or Federal Insurance Administration has delineated both the areas of special flood hazards and the floodway. 18. "Flood Hazard Boundary Map" means the official map on which the Federal Emergency Management Agency or Federal Insurance Administration has delineated the areas of flood hazards. 19. "Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM)" means the official map on which the Federal Emergency Management Agency or the Federal Insurance Administration has delineated both the areas of special flood hazards and the risk premium zones applicable to the community. 20. "Flood Insurance Study" means the official report provided by the Federal Insurance Administration that includes flood profiles, the Flood Insurance Rate Map, the Flood Boundary and Floodway Map, and the water surface elevation of the base flood. 21. "Floodplain or flood -prone area" means any land area susceptible to being inundated by water from any source see "Flooding." 22. "Floodplain administrator" means the individual appointed to administer and enforce the floodplain management regulations. This individual shall be the city engineer of the city. 23. "Floodplain management" means the operation of an overall program of corrective and preventive measures for reducing flood damage and preserving and enhancing, where possible, natural resources in the floodplain, including but not limited to emergency preparedness plans, flood control works, floodplain management regulations, and open space plans. 24. "Floodplain management regulations" means this chapter and other zoning ordinances, subdivision regulations, building codes, health regulations, special purpose ordinances (such as grading and erosion control) and other applications of police power which control development in flood -prone areas. The term describes federal, state or local regulations in any combination thereof which provide standards for preventing and reducing flood loss and damage. 25. "Floodproofing" means any combination of structural and nonstructural additions, changes or adjustments to structures which reduce or eliminate flood damage to real estate or improved real property, water and sanitary facilities, structures and their contents. 26_ "Floodway" means the channel of a river or other watercourse and the adjacent land areas that must be reserved in order to discharge the base flood without cumulatively increasing the water surface elevation more than one foot. Also referred to as "regulatory floodway." 27. "Floodway encroachment lines" means the lines marking the limits of floodways on federal, state and local floodplain maps. 28. "Floodway fringe" means that area of the floodplain on either side of the "regulatory Floodway" where encroachment may be permitted. 29. "Fraud and victimization," as related to subsection Z (Conditions for exceptions) of this chapter, means that the exception granted must not cause fraud on or victimization of the public. In examining this requirement, the planning commission will consider the fact that every newly constructed building adds to government responsibilities and remains a part of the community for fifty to one hundred years. Buildings that are permitted to be constructed below the base flood elevation are subject, during all those years, to increased risk of damage from floods, while future owners of the property and the community as a whole are subject to all the costs, inconvenience, danger, and suffering that those increased flood damages bring. In addition, future owners may purchase the property, unaware that it is subject to potential flood damage, and can be insured only at very high flood insurance rates. 30. "Functionally dependent use" means a use which cannot perform its intended purpose unless it is located or carried out in close proximity to water. The term includes only docking facilities, port facilities that are necessary for the loading and unloading of cargo or passengers, and ship building and ship repair facilities, and does not include long-term storage or related manufacturing facilities. 31. "Habitable floor" means any floor usable for living purposes, which includes working, sleeping, eating, cooking or recreation, or a combination thereof. A floor used only for storage purposes is not a "habitable floor." 32. "Hardship," as related to subsection Z (Conditions for exceptions) of this chapter, means the unusual hardship that would result from a failure to grant the requested exception. The planning commission requires that the exception be unusual and peculiar to the property involved. Mere economic or financial hardship alone is not exceptional. Inconvenience, aesthetic considerations, physical handicaps, personal preferences, or the disapproval of one's neighbors likewise cannot, as a rule, qualify as an exceptional hardship. All of these problems can be resolved through other means without granting an exception, even 96 Title 18 Zoning if the alternative is more expensive, or requires the property owner to build elsewhere or put the parcel to a different use than originally intended. 33. "Highest adjacent grade" means the highest natural elevation of the ground surface prior to construction next to the proposed walls of a structure. 34. "Historic structure" means any structure that is: a. Listed individually in the National Register of Historic Places (a listing maintained by the Department of Interior) or preliminarily determined by the Secretary of the Interior as meeting the requirements for individual listing on the National Register; b. Certified or preliminarily determined by the Secretary of the Interior as contributing to the historical significance of a registered historic district or a district preliminarily determined by the Secretary to qualify as a registered historic district; c. Individually listed on a state inventory of historic places in states with historic preservation programs which have been approved by the Secretary of Interior; or d. Individually listed on a local inventory of historic places in communities with historic preservation programs that have been certified either by an approved state program as determined by the Secretary of the Interior or directly by the Secretary of the Interior in states with approved programs. 35. "Levee" means a man-made structure, usually an earthen embankment, designed and constructed in accordance with sound engineering practices to contain, control or divert the flow of water so as to provide protection from temporary flooding. 36. "Levee system" means a flood protection system which consists of a levee, or levees, and associated structures, such as closure and drainage devices, which are constructed and operated in accord with sound engineering practices. 37. "Lowest floor" means the lowest floor of the lowest enclosed area, including basement. An unfinished or flood resistant enclosure, usable solely for parking of vehicles, building access or storage in an area other than a basement area (see "Basement") is not considered a building's lowest floor, provided that such enclosure is not built so as to render the structure in violation of the applicable nonelevation design requirements of this title. (Note: This definition allows attached garages to be built at grade. Below grade garages are not allowed as they are considered to be basements) 38. "Manufactured home" or "mobile home" means a structure, transportable in one or more sections, which is built on a permanent chassis and is designed for use with or without a permanent foundation when connected to the required utilities. The term "manufactured home" does not include "recreational vehicles" or "travel trailers." 39. "Manufactured home/mobile home park or subdivision" means a parcel (or contiguous parcels) of land divided into two or more manufactured home lots for sale or rent. 40. "Mean sea level" means, for purposes of the National Flood Insurance Program, the National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD) of 1929 or other datum, to which base flood elevations shown on a community's Flood Insurance Rate Map are referenced. 41. "New construction" for floodplain management purposes means structures for which the "start of construction" commenced on or after the effective date of floodplain management practices adopted by this community, and includes any subsequent improvements to such structures. 42. "New manufactured home/mobile home park or subdivision" means a manufactured home/mobile home park or subdivision for which the construction of facilities for servicing the lots on which the manufactured homes/mobile homes are to be affixed (including, at a minimum, the installation of utilities, the construction of streets, and either final site grading or the pouring of concrete pads) is completed on or after the effective date of the ordinance codified in this chapter. 43. "Obstruction" means and includes, but is not limited to, any dam, wall, wharf, embankment, levee, dike, pile, abutment, protection, excavation, channelization, bridge, conduit, culvert, building, wire, fence, rock, gravel, refuse, fill, structure, vegetation or other material in, or along, across or projecting into any watercourse which may alter, impede, retard or change the direction and/or velocity of the flow of water, or due to its location, its propensity to snare or collect debris carried by the flow of water, or its likelihood of being carried downstream. 44. "One hundred year flood" see "Base flood." 45. "Principal structure" means a structure used for the principal use of the property as distinguished from an accessory use. 46. "Public safety and nuisance," as related to subsection Z (Conditions for exceptions) of this chapter, means that the granting of an exception must not result in anything which is injurious to the safety or 97 Title 18 Zoning health of an entire community or neighborhood, or any considerable number of persons, or unlawfully obstructs the free passage or use, in the customary manner, of any navigable lake, or river, bay, stream, canal or basin. 47. "Recreational vehicle" means a vehicle which is: a. Built on a single chassis; b. Four hundred square feet or less when measured at the largest horizontal projection; c. Designed to be self-propelled or permanently towable by a light -duty truck; and d. Designed primarily not for use as a permanent dwelling but as temporary living quarters for recreational, camping, travel, or seasonal use. 48. "Regulatory floodway" means the channel of a river or other watercourse and the adjacent land areas that must be reserved in order to discharge the base flood without cumulatively increasing the water surface elevation more than one foot. 49. "Riverine" means relating to, formed by, or resembling a river (including tributaries), stream, brook, etc. 50. "Sheet flow' —see "Area of shallow flooding." 51. "Special flood hazard area (SFHA)" means an area having special flood or flood -related erosion hazards, and shown on a FBHM or FIRM as Zone A, AO, A1—A30, AE, A99 and AH. 52. "Start of construction" means and includes substantial improvement and other proposed new development, and means the date the building permit was issued, provided the actual start of construction, repair. reconstruction, rehabilitation, addition, placement, or other improvement was within one hundred eighty days from the date of the permit. The actual start means either the first placement of permanent construction of a structure (other than a manufactured home) on a site, such as the pouring of slab or footings, the installation of piles, the construction of columns, or any work beyond the stage of excavation; or the placement of a manufactured home on a foundation. Permanent construction does not include land preparation, such as clearing, grading, and filling; nor does it include the installation of streets and/or walkways; nor does it include excavation for a basement, footings, piers or foundations or the erection of temporary forms; nor does it include the installation on the property of accessory buildings, such as garages or sheds not occupied as dwelling units or not part of the main structure. For a substantial improvement, the actual start of construction means the first alteration of any wall, ceiling, floor, or other structural part of a building, whether or not that alteration affects the external dimensions of the building. For a structure (other than a mobile home) without a basement or poured footings, the "start of construction" includes the first permanent framing or assembly of the structure or any part thereof on its piling or foundation. For mobile homes not within a mobile home park or mobile home subdivisions, "start of construction" means the affixing of the mobile home to its permanent site. For mobile homes within mobile home parks or mobile home subdivisions, "start of construction" is the date on which the construction of facilities for servicing the site on which the mobile home is to be affixed (including. at a minimum, the construction of streets, either final site grading or the pouring of concrete pads, and installation of utilities) is completed. 53. "Structure" means a walled and roofed building that is principally aboveground. This includes a gas or liquid storage tank or manufactured/mobile home. 54. "Substantial damage" means damage of any origin sustained by a structure whereby the cost of restoring the structure to its before damaged condition would equal or exceed fifty percent of the market value of the structure before the damage occurred. 55. "Substantial improvement" means any reconstruction, rehabilitation, addition or other proposed new development of a structure, the cost of which equals or exceeds fifty percent of the .market value of the structure before the "start of construction" of the improvement. This term includes structures which have incurred "substantial damage," regardless of the actual work performed. The term does not, however, include either: a. Any project for improvement of a structure to correct violations or to comply with state or local health, sanitary, or safety code specifications which have been identified by a local code conformance official and which are solely necessary to assure safe living conditions; or b. Any alteration of a "historic structure" provided that the alteration will not preclude the structure's continued designation as a "historic structure." 56. "Violation" means the failure of a structure or other development to be fully compliant with the community's floodplain management regulations. A structure or other development without the elevation 98 Title 18 Zoning certificate, other certifications, or other evidence of compliance required in this chapter is presumed to be in violation until such time as that documentation is provided. 57. "Water surface elevation" means the height, in relation to the National Geodetic Vertical Datum (NGVD) of 1929 (or other datum, where specified), of floods of various magnitudes and frequencies in the floodplains of coastal or riverine areas. 58. "Watercourse" means a lake, river, creek, stream, wash, arroyo, channel or other topographic feature on or over which waters flow at least periodically. Watercourse includes specifically designated areas in which substantial flood damage may occur. F - LANDS TO WHICH CHAPTER APPLIES. This chapter shall apply to all areas of special flood hazards within the jurisdiction of National City. G - BASIS FOR ESTABLISHING THE AREAS OF SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD. The areas of special flood hazard as shown on the special flood hazard map as floodway (FW), floodway fringe (FF-1), and floodway fringe -shallow flooding (FF-2) zones and conforming with the areas of special flood hazard identified by the Federal Insurance Administration (FIA) of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) in the Flood Insurance Study (FIS) for National City dated August 4, 1988, and accompanying Flood Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs) and Flood Boundary and Floodway Maps (FBFMs), dated August 4, 1988, and all subsequent amendments and/or revisions, are adopted by reference and declared to be a part of this chapter. This FIS and attendant mapping is the minimum area of applicability of this chapter and may be supplemented by studies for other areas which allow implementation of this chapter and which are recommended to the planning commission by the floodplain administrator. The study, FIRMs and FBFMs are on file at the office of the floodplain administrator at 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, California, 91950. H - COMPLIANCE. No structure or land shall hereafter be constructed, located, extended, converted or altered without full compliance with the terms of this chapter and other applicable regulations. Violation of the requirements (including violations of conditions and safeguards established in connection with conditions) shall constitute a misdemeanor. Nothing herein shall prevent the city from taking such lawful action as is necessary to prevent or remedy any violation. I - INTERPRETATION. In the interpretation and application of this chapter, all provisions shall be: A. Considered as minimum requirements; B. Liberally construed in favor of the city; and C. Deemed neither to limit nor repeal any other powers granted under state statutes. J - SEVERABILITY. This chapter and the various parts thereof are declared to be severable. Should any section of this chapter be declared by the courts to be unconstitutional or invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the chapter as a whole, or any portion thereof other than the section so declared to be unconstitutional or invalid. K - FLOODWAY ZONE (FW) ESTABLISHED. There is established, on the special Flood hazard map, a designated floodway zone. The FW zone shall be applied to those areas of special flood hazard designated as floodways on the "Flood Boundary and Floodway Map" of the Flood Insurance Study. 99 Title 18 Zoning L - FLOODWAY FRINGE ZONE (FF-1) ESTABLISHED. There is established, on the special flood hazard map, a designated floodway fringe zone. The FF-1 zone shall be applied to those areas of special flood hazard designated as floodway fringe on the "Flood Boundary and Floodway Map" of the Flood Insurance Study, but excluding areas of shallow flooding designated AO or AH on the Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM). M - FLOODWAY FRINGE —SHALLOW FLOODING ZONE (FF-2) ESTABLISHED. There is established, on the special flood hazard map, a designated floodway fringe -shallow flooding zone. The FF-2 zone shall be applied to those areas of special flood hazard designated as floodway fringe on the "Flood Boundary and Floodway Map" of the Flood Insurance Study, and designated as areas of shallow flooding AO or AH on the Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM). N - STANDARDS APPLICABLE TO ALL AREAS OF SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD. In all areas of special flood hazards including the FW, FF-1 and FF-2 zones, the following standards are required: 1. Anchoring. a. All new construction and substantial improvements shall be adequately anchored to prevent flotation, collapse or lateral movement of the structure resulting from hydrodynamic and hydrostatic loads, including the effects of buoyancy. b. All manufactured/mobile homes shall meet the anchoring standards of subsection Q. 2. Construction Materials and Methods. All new construction and substantial improvements shall be constructed: a. With materials and utility equipment resistant to flood damage; b. Using methods and practices that minimize flood damage; c. With electrical, heating, ventilation, plumbing, and air conditioning equipment and other service facilities that are designed and/or located so as to prevent water from entering or accumulating within the components during conditions of flooding; and if d. Within Zones AH or AO, so that there are adequate drainage paths around structures on slopes to guide flood waters around and away from proposed structures. 3. Elevation and Floodproofing. (See subsection E definitions for "new construction," "substantial damage" and "substantial improvement.") a. Residential construction, new or substantial improvement, shall have the lowest floor, including basement: i. In an AO zone, elevated above the highest adjacent grade to a height exceeding the depth number specified in feet on the FIRM by at least one foot, or elevated at least three feet above the highest adjacent grade if no depth number is specified; ii. In an A zone, elevated at least one foot above the base flood elevation, as determined by the city; iii. In all other zones, elevated at least one foot above the base flood elevation. Upon the completion of the structure, the elevation of the lowest floor including basement shall be certified by a registered professional civil engineer or surveyor to be properly elevated. Such certification or verification shall be provided to the floodplain administrator. b. Nonresidential construction shall either be elevated to conform with subsection 3(a) of this section or together with attendant utility and sanitary facilities: i. Be completely floodproofed below the elevation recommended under subsection 3(a) of this section so that the structure is watertight with walls substantially impermeable to the passage of water; and ii. Have structural components capable of resisting hydrostatic and hydrodynamic loads and effects of buoyancy: and iii. Be certified by a registered professional civil engineer that the standards of this subsection 3(b) of this section are satisfied. Such certification shall be provided to the floodplain administrator. c. All new construction and substantial improvements with fully enclosed areas below the lowest floor (excluding basement) that are usable solely for parking vehicles, building access or storage, and which 100 Title 18 Zoning are subject to flooding shall be designed to automatically equalize hydrostatic flood forces on exterior walls by allowing for the entry and exit of floodwaters. Designs for meeting this requirement must exceed the following minimum criteria: i. Be certified by a registered professional civil engineer; or ii. Be certified to comply with a local floodproofing standard approved by the Federal Insurance Administration, Federal Emergency Management Agency; or iii. Have a minimum of two openings having a total net area of not less than one square inch for every square foot of enclosed area subject to flooding. The bottom of all openings shall be no higher than one foot above grade. Openings may be equipped with screens, louvers, valves or other coverings or devices provided that they permit the automatic entry and exit of floodwaters. d. Manufactured homes shall also meet the standards in subsection 3(c) of this section and subsection Q. 4. Storage of Material and Equipment. a. The storage or processing of materials that are, in time of flooding, flammable, explosive, or could be injurious to human, animal or plant life is prohibited. b. Storage of other material or equipment may be allowed if not subject to major damage by floods and firmly anchored to prevent flotation or if readily removable from the area within the time available after flood warning. 0 - STANDARDS FOR UTILITIES. 1. All new and replacement water supply and sanitary sewage systems shall be designed to minimize or eliminate: a. Infiltration of floodwaters into the systems; and b. Discharge from the systems into floodwaters. 2. On -site waste disposal systems shall be located to avoid impairment to them, or contamination from them during flooding. P - STANDARDS FOR SUBDIVISIONS. 1. All preliminary subdivision proposals shall identify the flood hazard area and the elevation of the base flood. 2. All subdivision plans will provide the elevation of proposed structure(s) and pad(s). If the site is filled above the base flood elevation, the final first floor and pad elevations shall be certified by a registered professional civil engineer or surveyor and provided to the floodplain administrator. 3. All subdivision proposals shall be consistent with the need to minimize flood damage. 4. All subdivision proposals shall have public utilities and facilities such as sewer, gas, electrical and water systems located and constructed to minimize flood damage. 5. All subdivisions shall provide adequate drainage to reduce exposure to flood hazards. Q - STANDARDS FOR MANUFACTURED HOMES/MOBILE HOMES. 1. All manufactured homes that are placed or substantially improved, within Zones A1-30, AH and AE on the Flood Insurance Rate Map, on sites located: a. Outside of a manufactured home park or subdivision; b. In a new manufactured home park or subdivision; c. In an expansion to an existing manufactured home park or subdivision; or d. In an existing manufactured home park or subdivision on a site upon which a manufactured home has incurred "substantial damage" as the result of a flood, shall be elevated on a permanent foundation such that the lowest floor of the manufactured home is elevated at least one foot above the base flood elevation and be securely anchored to an adequately anchored foundation system to resist flotation, collapse and lateral movement. 2. All manufactured homes to be placed or substantially improved on sites in an existing manufactured home park or subdivision within Zones Al 30, AH and AE on the Flood Insurance Rate Map that are not subject to the provisions of subsection A of this section shall be elevated so that either: a. The lowest floor of the manufactured home is at least one foot above the base flood elevation; or 101 Title 18 Zoning b. The manufactured home chassis is supported by reinforced piers or other foundation elements of at least equivalent strength that are no less than thirty-six inches in height above grade and shall be securely anchored to an adequately anchored foundation system to resist flotation, collapse and lateral movement. 3. All mobile homes/manufactured homes shall be anchored to resist flotation, collapse or lateral movement by providing over -the -top and frame ties to ground anchors. Specific requirements shall be that: a. Over -the -top ties be provided at each of the four corners of the mobile home, with two additional ties per side at intermediate locations, with mobile homes less than fifty feet long requiring only one additional tie per side; b. Frame ties be provided at each corner of the home with five additional ties per side at intermediate points, with mobile homes less than fifty feet long requiring only four additional ties per side; c. All components of the anchoring system be capable of carrying a force of four thousand eight hundred pounds; and d. Any additions to the mobile home shall be similarly anchored. R - STANDARDS FOR RECREATIONAL VEHICLES. All recreational vehicles placed on sites within Zones A1-30, AH and AE on the community's Flood Insurance Rate Map will either: 1. Be on the site for fewer than one hundred eighty consecutive clays; 2. Be fully licensed and ready for highway use —a recreational vehicle is ready for highway use if it is on its wheels or jacking system, is attached to the site only by quick disconnect type utilities and security devices, and has no permanently attached additions; or 3. Meet the permit requirements of subsection T of this chapter and the elevation and anchoring requirements for manufactured homes in subsection Q(1)(a). S - FLOODWAYS (FW ). Located within areas of special flood hazard established in subsection G are areas designated as floodways to which the following provisions apply: 1. Encroachments, including fill, new construction, manufactured homes, substantial improvements, and other development, shall be prohibited unless certification by a registered professional civil engineer is provided demonstrating that encroachments shall not result in any increase in flood levels during the occurrence of the base flood discharge. 2. If subsection S(1) is satisfied, all new construction, substantial improvements, and other new development shall comply with all other applicable flood hazard reduction provisions of subsections N through S and require approval of a conditional use permit pursuant to Title 18 of the National City Municipal Code. (Ord. 2107 § 1 (part), 1996) T - ESTABLISHMENT OF DEVELOPMENT PERMIT. A development permit shall be obtained concurrently with or before issuance of any building, grading, conditional use, planned development, or planned unit development permit, or site plan approval, and before construction or development begins within any area of special flood hazard established in subsection G. Application for a development permit shall be on forms furnished by the floodplain administrator and may include, but not be limited tor plans in duplicate drawn to scale showing the nature, location, dimensions and elevation of the area in question; existing or proposed structures, fill, storage of materials, drainage facilities; and the location of the foregoing. Specifically, the following information is required: 1. Identify and describe the work to be covered by the permit for which application is made; 2. Describe the land on which the proposed work is to be done by lot, block, tract, house and street address; or similar description that will readily identify and definitely locate the proposed building or work; 3. Indicate the use or occupancy for which the proposed work is intended; 4. Be accompanied by plans and specifications for proposed construction; 102 Title 18 Zoning 5. Be signed by the permittee or his authorized agent who may be required to submit evidence to indicate such authority; 6. Proposed elevation in relation to mean sea level of the lowest floor (including basement) of all structures in AO zone elevation of highest adjacent grade and proposed elevation of lowest floor of all structures; 7. Proposed elevation in relation to mean sea level to which any structure will be floodproofed, if required in subsection N(3)(c); 8. All appropriate certifications listed in subsection V(5) of this chapter; 9. Description of the extent to which any watercourse will be altered or relocated as a result of the proposed development; 10. Give such other information as reasonably may be required by the floodplain administrator, including but not limited to: a. A typical valley cross-section showing the channel of the stream, elevation of land areas adjoining each side of the channel, cross -sectional areas to be corrupted by the proposed development and higher water information, b. Locations and elevations of streets, water supply, sanitary facilities, photographs showing existing land uses and vegetation upstream and downstream, soil types and other pertinent information, c. Profile showing the slope of the bottom of the channel or flow line of the stream; K. Evidence of prior or concurrent approval of any conditional use permit which may be required by subsection V for alteration of watercourses. U - DESIGNATION OF THE FLOODPLAIN ADMINISTRATOR. The city engineer is appointed to administer, implement and enforce this chapter by granting or denying development permits in accord with its provisions. V - DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE FLOODPLAIN ADMINISTRATOR. The duties of the floodplain administrator shall include, but not be limited to the following: 1. Permit Review. Review all development permits to determine that: a. Permit requirements of this chapter have been satisfied; b. All other required state and federal permits have been obtained; c. The site is reasonably safe from flooding; and d. The proposed development does not adversely affect the carrying capacity of the areas where base flood elevations have been determined but a floodway has not been designated. 2. Review and Use of any Other Base Flood Data. When base flood elevation data have not been provided in accordance with subsection G, the floodplain administrator shall obtain, review and reasonably utilize any base flood and floodway elevation data available from a federal or state agency or other source, in order to administer subsections N through S, inclusive. Any such information shall be submitted to the city for adoption. 3. Information to be Obtained and Maintained. a. Obtain and record the actual elevation (in relation to mean sea level) of the lowest habitable floor (including basement) of all new or substantially improved structures; b. For all new or substantially improved flood -proofed structures: i. Verify and record the actual elevation (in relation to mean sea level); and ii. Maintain the floodproofing certifications required in subsection 3(a),(b), and (c) of subsection N, part 2 of subsection P, and part 1 of subsection S; c. Maintain for public inspection all records pertaining to the provisions of this chapter. 4. Conditional Use Permit Required. In alteration or relocation of a watercourse, a conditional use permit shall be required by the planning commission. Such permit shall include the following conditions: a. Notification of adjacent communities and the California Department of Water Resources prior to alteration or relocation; b. Submission of evidence of such notification to the Federal Insurance Administration, Federal Emergency Management Agency; c. Assurance that the flood carrying capacity within the altered or relocated portion of said watercourse is maintained; 103 Title 18 Zoning d. The new channel shall be completed before the old channel is abandoned. 5. Documentation of Floodplain Development. Obtain and maintain for public inspection and make available as needed the following: a. Certification required by subsection N(3)(a) (floor elevations); b. Certification required by subsection N(3)(b) (elevation or floodproofing of nonresidential structures); c. Certification required by subsection N(3)(c) (wet floodproofing standard); d. Certification of elevation required by subsection P(2) (subdivision standards); e. Certification required by subsection S(1) (floodway encroachments). 6. Remedial Action. Take action to remedy violations of this chapter as specified in subsection H. 7. Base Flood Elevation changes due to physical alterations: a. Within 6 months of information becoming available or project completion, whichever comes first, the floodplain administrator shall submit or assure that the permit applicant submits technical or scientific data to FEMA for a Letter of Map Revision (LOMR) b. All LOMR's for flood control projects are approved prior to the issuance of building permits. Building Permits must not be issued based on Conditional Letters of Map Revision (CLOMR's). Approved CLOMR's allow construction of the proposed flood control project and land preparation as specified in the "start of construction" definition. Such submissions are necessary so that upon confirmation of those physical changes affecting flooding conditions, risk premium rates and floodplain management requirements are based on current data. 8. Changes in corporate boundaries: Notify FEMA in writing whenever the corporate boundaries have been modified by annexation or other means and include a copy of a map of the community clearly delineating the new corporate limits. W - MAP DETERMINATION. The boundaries of the FW, FF-1 and FF-2 zones shall be determined by the scale contained on the special flood hazard map. Where interpretation is needed to the exact location of said boundaries (for example where there appears to be a conflict between a mapped boundary and actual field conditions), the planning commission shall make such determination in accordance with this Title based upon: 1. The recommendation of the floodplain administrator; and 2. A review of the Flood Hazard Boundary Maps adopted by reference and declared to be a part of this chapter; and 3. Technical evidence which may be presented by the applicant. The regulatory flood elevation for the point in question shall be the governing factor in locating the boundary on land. The person contesting the location of the boundary shall be given a reasonable opportunity to appeal the interpretation as provided in subsection X. X - APPEALS. The planning commission shall hear and decide appeals when it is alleged there is an error in any requirement, decision or determination made by the floodplain administrator in the enforcement or administration of this chapter. Appeals may be filed and shall be processed in the same manner as for site plan review as provided in this Title. Y - EXCEPTIONS. 1. Applications for exceptions from the terms of this chapter shall be submitted and processed in the same manner as conditional use permits, as provided in this Title. 2. In passing upon such applications for exceptions, the planning commission shall consider all technical evaluations, all relevant factors, standards specified in other sections of this chapter and the: a. Danger that materials may be swept onto other lands to the injury of others; b. Danger to life and property due to flooding or erosion damage; c. Susceptibility of the proposed facility and its contents to flood damage and the effect of such damage on the individual owner and future property owners; d. Importance of the services provided by the proposed facility to the community; 104 Title 18 Zoning e. Necessity to the facility of a waterfront location where applicable; f. Availability of alternative locations for the proposed use which are not subject to flooding or erosion damage; g. Compatibility of the proposed use with existing and anticipated development; h. Relationship of the proposed use to the comprehensive plan and floodplain management program for that area; i. Safety of access to the property in times of flood for ordinary and emergency vehicles; j. Expected heights, velocity, duration, rate of rise, and sediment transport of the floodwaters expected at the site; and k. Costs of providing governmental services during and after flood conditions, including maintenance and repair of public utilities and facilities such as sewer, gas. electrical and water systems, and streets and bridges. 3. Any applicant to whom an exception is granted shall be given written notice over the signature of a community official that: a. The issuance of an exception to construct a structure below the base flood level will result in increased premium rates for flood insurance; and b. Such construction below the base flood level increases risks to life and property. c. A copy of the notice shall be recorded by the floodplain administrator in the office of the San Diego County Recorder and shall be recorded in a manner so that it appears in the chain of title of the affected parcel of land. 4. The floodplain administrator will maintain a record of all exception actions, including justification for their issuance, and report such exceptions issued in its biennial report submitted to the Federal Insurance Administration, Federal Emergency Management Agency. Z - CONDITIONS FOR EXCEPTIONS. 1. Generally, exceptions may be issued for new construction and substantial improvements and other proposed development to be erected on a lot of one-half acre or less in size contiguous to and surrounded by lots with existing structures constructed below the base flood level, providing items in subsections N through U, inclusive, of this chapter have been fully considered. As the lot size increases beyond one-half acre, the technical justification required for issuing the exception increases. 2. Exceptions may be issued for the repair or rehabilitation of "historic structures" (as defined in subsection E of this chapter) upon a determination that the proposed repair or rehabilitation will not preclude the structure's continued designation as a historic structure and the exception is the minimum necessary to preserve the historic character and design of the structure. 3. Exceptions shall not be issued within any mapped regulatory floodway if any increase in flood levels during the base flood discharge would result. 4. Exceptions shall only be issued upon a determination that the exception is the "minimum necessary," considering the flood hazard, to afford relief. "Minimum necessary" means to afford relief with a minimum of deviation from the requirements of this chapter. For example, in the case of exceptions to an elevation requirement, this means the planning commission need not grant permission for the applicant to build at grade, or even to whatever elevation the applicant proposes, but only to that elevation which the planning commission believes will both provide relief and preserve the integrity of this chapter. 5. Exceptions shall only be issued upon: a. A showing of good and sufficient cause; b. A determination that failure to grant the exception would result in exceptional hardship to the applicant; and c. A determination that the granting of an exception will not result in increased flood heights, additional threats to public safety, extraordinary public expense, create nuisances, cause fraud on or victimization of the public as identified in subsection E of this chapter, or conflict with existing local laws or ordinances. 6. Exceptions may be issued for new construction, substantial improvement, and other proposed development necessary for the conduct of a functionally dependent use provided that the provisions of subsections Z(1) through (5) are satisfied and that the structure or other development is protected by methods that minimize flood damages during the base flood and does not result in additional threats to public safety and does not create a public nuisance. 105 Title 18 Zoning 7. Upon consideration of the factors of subsection Y and the purposes of this chapter, the planning commission may attach such conditions to the granting of exceptions as it deems necessary to further the purposes of this chapter. AA - FEES. 1. A nonrefundable fee as established in the fee schedule adopted by the city shall be paid to the city at the time of filing an application for a development permit pursuant to subsection T. 2. A nonrefundable fee as established in the fee schedule adopted by the city shall be paid to the city at the time of filing an appeal pursuant to subsection X. 3. A nonrefundable fee as established in the fee schedule adopted by the city shall be paid to the city at the time of filing for an exception pursuant to subsection Y. 106 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 3 CHAPTER 18.30 Sections: SPECIFIC USE REGULATIONS 18.30.010 Purpose 18.30.020 Applicability 18.30.030 Adult -Oriented Businesses 18.30.040 Automobile Impound and Storage Yards 18.30.050 Sale of Alcoholic Beverages and Live Entertainment 18.30.060 Auto Body and Paint Shops 18.30.070 Child Day Care Centers 18.30.080 Family Day Care Homes 18.30.090 Condominium Conversions 18.30.100 Conversions to Nonresidential Use 18.30.110 Emergency Shelters 18.30.120 Hazardous Waste Facilities 18.30.130 Helicopter Operations 18.30.140 Mobile Homes and Similar Temporary Structures 18.30.150 Outdoor Display or Sale of Merchandise 18.30.160 Outdoor Storage 18.30.170 Recycling Collection Facilities 18.30.180 Scrap Metal Processing 18.30.190 Service Stations and Convenience Stores with Gasoline Pumps 18.30.200 Sidewalk Cafes 18.30.210 Small Wind Energy Systems 18.30.220 Telecommunications Facilities 18.30.230 Tobacco Specialty Shops 18.30.240 Urban Agriculture 18.30.250 Veterinary Hospitals and Clinics 18.30.260 Neighborhood Corner Stores 18.30.270 Motels 18.30.280 Markets that Sell Seafood 18.30.290 Bed and Breakfast Inns 18.30.300 Solar Energy Systems 18.30.310 Tattoo and Body Piercing Establishments 18.30.320 Pawn Shops and Businesses Engaged in Secondhand Dealing and/or the Purchase and Selling of Gold and Other Precious Metals 18.30.330 Payday Lenders 18.30.340 Medical Marijuana Dispensaries 18.30.350 Auto Body Uses 18.30.360 Fast Food Eating Places 18.30.010 PURPOSE This chapter provides site planning, development, and/or operating standards for certain land uses that are allowed by Chapter 2 and for activities that require special standards to mitigate their potential adverse impacts. The standards for specific uses in this chapter supplement and are required in addition to those in Chapter 2 and Chapter 4. In the event of any conflict between the requirements of this chapter and those of Chapters 2 and 4, the requirements of this chapter shall control. 107 Title 18 Zoning 18.30.020 APPLICABILITY The land uses covered by this chapter shall comply with the provisions of the sections applicable to the specific use, in addition to all other applicable provisions of this Land Use Code. The uses that are subject to the standards in this chapter shall be developed in compliance with the requirements of Chapter 2. 18.30.030 ADULT ORIENTED BUSINESSES A. Purpose 1. It is the purpose of this chapter to establish reasonable and uniform content -neutral regulations to decrease blight and crime by either dispersing adult -oriented businesses, or by shifting part of the burden of regulating such businesses to the private sector by placing them in locations which minimize the negative secondary effects of such businesses. 2. It is the intent of this chapter that these regulations be utilized to serve the substantial interest of the city in preventing problems of blight and deterioration which accompany and are brought about by adult -oriented businesses, which allowing reasonable alternative locations for those businesses. 3. In enacting this chapter, the City Council is relying upon the experiences of the City of National City and upon the experiences and studies of other municipalities concerning the deleterious effects of adult -oriented businesses, which this chapter is intended to curtail. B. Definitions It is the purpose of this section to provide clear and concise definitions of those words, terms and phrases most commonly utilized in the regulations and provisions of this chapter in order to assist in the uniform interpretation of such regulations and provisions and to insure uniformity in their application. It is intended that the following words, terms and phrases, whenever used in this chapter, shall be construed as defined in the following subsections, unless from the context a different meaning is specifically defined and more particularly directed to the use of such words, terms or phrases. 1t is also intended that those definitions and interpretations set forth in Section 1.04.010 and the Glossary shall be used for purposes of uniformity of interpretation and application of the regulations and provisions of this chapter but only where they do not conflict with any definitions or interpretation set forth in this chapter. 1. "Specified anatomical areas" means and includes any of the following: a. Less than completely and opaquely covered human genitals, pubic region, buttocks, anus or female breasts below a point immediately above the top of the areolae; or b. Human male genitals in a discernibly turgid state, even if completely and opaquely covered. 2. "Specified sexual activities" means and includes any of the following: a. The fondling or other touching of human genitals, public region, buttocks, anus or female breast: c. Sex acts, normal or perverted, actual or simulated; or d. Masturbation, actual or simulated; or e. Excretory functions as part of or in connection with any of the activities set forth in this subsection. 3. "Adult bookstore" is an establishment that devotes more than fifteen percent of the total floor area utilized for the display of books and periodicals to the display and sale of the following: a. Books, magazines, periodicals or other printed matter, or photographs, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, compact discs, digital video discs, slides, tapes, records or other forms of visual or audio representations which are characterized by an emphasis upon the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas; or b. Instruments, devices or paraphernalia which are designed for use in connection with specified sexual activities. 108 Title 18 Zoning c. An adult bookstore does not include an establishment that sells books or periodicals as an incidental or accessory part of its principal stock -in -trade and does not devote more than fifteen percent of the total floor area of the establishment to the sale of books and periodicals. 4. "Adult motion picture theater" is an establishment, with a capacity of fifty or more persons, where, for any form of consideration, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, compact discs, digital video discs, slides or similar photographic reproductions are shown, and in which a substantial portion of the total presentation time is devoted to the showing of material which is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis upon the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas for observation by patrons. 5. "Adult mini -motion picture theater" is an establishment, with a capacity of more than five but less than fifty persons, where, for any form of consideration, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, compact discs, digital video discs, slides or similar photographic reproductions are shown, and in which a substantial portion of the total presentation time is devoted to the showing of material which is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis upon the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas for observation by patrons. 6. "Adult motion picture arcade," to include without limitation a peep show, is any place to which the public is permitted or invited wherein coin or slug -operated or electronically, electrically or mechanically controlled still or motion picture machines, projectors, or other image -producing devices are maintained to show images to five or fewer persons per machine at any one time, and where the images so displayed are distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on depicting or describing specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas. The image -producing device or peep show device shall also include any other device by or through which electronic, video, photographic, cinematic, digital, or computer -generated images depicting specified anatomical areas or specified sexual activity defined by this section are or can be reflected or projected onto an external screen or be internally projected, generated or reflected onto a screen that is an integral part of the device itself. 7. "Adult drive-in theater" means an open lot or part thereof, with appurtenant facilities, devoted primarily to the presentation of motion pictures, films, theatrical productions and other forms of visual productions, for any form of consideration, to persons in motor vehicles or on outdoor seats, and presenting material distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on matter depicting, describing or relating to specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas for observation by patrons. 8. "Adult cabaret" is a night club, bar, restaurant, cabaret or similar establishment which may serve food or alcoholic or non-alcoholic beverages, or both, and which, for consideration, regularly features live performances or films, motion pictures, video cassettes, compact discs, digital video discs, slides or other photographic reproductions which are distinguished or characterized by an emphasis upon the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or the exposure of specified anatomical areas for observation by patrons or attendees. 9. "Adult motel" is a motel or similar establishment offering public accommodations for any form of consideration which provides patrons with closed-circuit television transmissions, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, compact discs, digital video discs, slides or other photographic reproductions which are distinguished or characterized by an emphasis upon the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas. 10. "Adult theater" is a theater, concert hall, auditorium or similar establishment, either indoor or outdoor in nature which, for any form of consideration, regularly features live performances which are distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on specified sexual activities or by exposure of specified sexual activities or by exposure of specified anatomical areas for observation by patrons. 11. "Adult model studio" is any establishment open to the public where, for any form of consideration, one or more persons display or expose any portion of specified anatomical areas to be observed, sketched, drawn, painted, sculptured, photographed, videoed or be similarly viewed or depicted by any person, other than the proprietor, who pays a consideration to either the proprietor, an employee of the proprietor or the model. This definition shall also include, without limitation, a "lingerie modeling establishment." a. This definition shall not apply to any school of art which is operated by an individual, firm, association, partnership, corporation or institution which meets the requirements established in the Education Code of the state of California for the issuance or conferring of, and is in fact authorized thereunder to issue and confer a diploma. 109 Title 18 Zoning 12. "Sexual encounter establishment" is an establishment, other than a hotel, motel or similar establishment offering public accommodations, which, for any form of consideration, provides a place where two or more persons may congregate, associate or consort in connection with specified sexual activities or the exposure of specified anatomical areas. This definition does not include an establishment where a medical practitioner, psychologist, psychiatrist or similar professional person licensed by the state of California engages in sexual therapy. a. For the purposes of this chapter, sexual encounter center shall include massage or rap parlor and other similar establishments. 13. "Body painting studio" is an establishment or business which provides the service of applying paint or other substance whether transparent or nontransparent to or on the human body when such body is wholly or partially nude in terms of specified anatomical areas. 14. "Massage parlor" is an establishment where, for any form of consideration, massage, alcohol rub, fomentation, electric or magnetic treatment, or similar treatment or manipulation of the human body is administered, unless such treatment or manipulation is administered by a medical practitioner, chiropractor, acupuncturist, physical therapist or similar professional person licensed by the state of California. This definition does not include an athletic club, health club, school, gymnasium, reducing salon, spa or similar establishment where massage or similar manipulation of the human body is offered as an incidental or accessory service. 15. "General motion picture theater" is a building or part of a building intended to be used for the specific purposes of presenting entertainment as defined in this chapter, or displaying motion pictures, slides or closed circuit television pictures before an individual or assemblage of persons, whether such assemblage be of a public, restricted or private nature, except a home or private dwelling where no fee, by way of an admission charge, is charged; provided, however, that any such presentations are not distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas in that any such depiction or description is only incidental to the plot or story line. 16. "Legitimate or live theater" is a theater, concert hall, auditorium or similar establishment which, for any fee or consideration, regularly features live performances which are not distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on the depiction or description of specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas in that any such depiction or description is only incidental to the primary purpose of the performance. 17. "General bookstore" is an establishment engaged in the buying, selling and/or trading of new and/or used books, manuscripts and periodicals of general interest. A general bookstore does not include an establishment that is encompassed by the definition of adult bookstore. 18. "School" is an institution of learning for minors, whether public or private, which offers instruction in those courses of study required by the California Education Code or which is maintained pursuant to standards set by the State Board of Education. This definition includes a nursery school, kindergarten, elementary school, junior high school, senior high school or any special institution of learning under the jurisdiction of the State Department of Education, but it does not include a vocation or professional institution or an institution of higher education, including a community college. 19. "Establishing an adult -oriented business," as used in this chapter, means and includes any of the following: a. The opening or commencement of any such business as a new business; b. The conversion of an existing business, whether or not an adult -oriented business, to any of the adult -oriented businesses defined in this chapter; or c. The addition of any of the adult -oriented businesses defined herein to any other existing adult - oriented business; or d. The relocation of any such business. 20. "Transfer of ownership or control," as used in this chapter, means and includes any of the following: a. The sale, lease or sublease of an adult -oriented business; b. The transfer of securities which constitute a controlling interest in such business, whether by sale, exchange or similar means; or c. The establishment of a trust, gift or other similar legal device which transfers the ownership or control of such business, except for transfer by bequest or other operation of law upon the death of the person possessing such ownership or control. 110 Title 18 Zoning 21. "Sale and display of paraphernalia and literature commonly associated with the use of narcotics and controlled substances (headshops)" is an establishment or place where more than fifteen percent of the floor area in any room is used for the sale and display of such paraphernalia and literature, including but not limited to cocaine and sniffing kits, glass mirrors for cutting cocaine, snorting spoons and tubes, strainers to sift cocaine, water pipes (bongs), everyday items with special removable tops that have been converted to conceal narcotics and drugs, including simulated beer cans, oil cans and plastic photograph film vials, "roach clips" (for holding marijuana cigarettes), or books and magazines extolling the use of narcotics or controlled substances. Such a place is an adult -oriented business. This definition does not limit licensed pharmacies in selling and displaying paraphernalia that is medical equipment prescribed by licensed medical practitioners. 22. A "private viewing room" is an area separated from the sales or display area of the establishment by a curtain, wall, door, shade or similar obstruction thus allowing the private viewing of video tapes, compact discs, digital video discs, movies, transparencies, films or projectable motion pictures by customers at the establishments. 23. "Video cassette, compact disc, digital video disc sales and rentals --adult" is the same as "adult bookstore." 24. "Video games --adult" are coin -operated electronic game machines having visual displays and animation that depict in any manner, any sort of activity characterized by exposure of "specified anatomical areas" or "specified sexual activities." 25. "Sexually oriented business" is any business in which: a. Specified sexual activity occurs or specified anatomical areas are exposed, or both, by a patron, attendee, employee or independent contractor for any form of consideration paid or furnished to the owner, proprietor, an employee of the owner or proprietor, or to an independent contractor at the location or premises; or b. Material distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on matter depicting, describing or relating to specified sexual activity or specified anatomical areas, or both. is displayed, sold or provided for consideration on a regular basis. 26. "Consideration," as used in this chapter, means a payment or transfer of money or other thing of value exceeding a total of one cent to an owner or proprietor, an employee of the owner or proprietor, or to a performer, independent contractor or entertainer at the establishment, without regard to: a. Any donative intent of the payer, transferor or donor; b. The time of payment or transfer; or c. Whether the payment or transfer was for admission to the establishment or for merchandise, food or beverage displayed or sold at or on behalf of that establishment. 27. "Lingerie modeling establishment" means an establishment where, for consideration and for viewing by a patron at that establishment, a person either: a. Wears and displays undergarments, lingerie, underwear and similar articles of intimate apparel which cover those areas which constitute specified anatomical areas; or b. Changes from one costume into another in the presence of a patron or patrons and thereby exposes one or more specified anatomical areas to that patron or patrons. This definition shall not, however, be construed so as to apply to a commercial retail or wholesale establishment that principally and customarily sells clothing and related wearing apparel and where specified anatomical areas are not exposed to customers during demonstration displays of merchandise for sale. C. Prohibitions 1. No person or entity shall own, establish, operate, control or enlarge or cause or permit the establishment, operation, enlargement or transfer of ownership or control, except pursuant to Section 18.30.030(F), of any of the following adult -oriented businesses if such adult -oriented business is or would be within 1,500 feet of another adult -oriented business, within 1,500 feet of any school or public park within the city, or within 1,000 feet of any residentially zoned property in the city: a. Adult bookstore; b. Adult motion picture theater; c. Adult mini -motion picture arcade (peep shows): d. Adult arcade; 111 Title 18 Zoning e. Adult drive-in theater; f. Adult cabaret; g. Adult motel; h. Adult theater; i. Adult model studio; j. Body painting studio; k. Massage parlor; I. Any sexually oriented business; m. Adult video games; n. Adult video cassette sales and rentals; o. Sexual encounter establishments: p. Lingerie modeling establishment. 2. An establishment listed in this section shall not be established, operated, enlarged or transferred unless the provisions of the zone in which the site or proposed site is located permit such a use. The conduct of such establishment and the use of premises shall otherwise comply with the Land Use Code and all other applicable regulations. 3. Nothing in this chapter prohibits the location of adult -oriented businesses within retail shopping centers in all commercial and major mixed -use zones wherein such activities will have their only frontage upon enclosed malls or malls isolated from their direct view from public streets, parks, schools, churches or residentially zoned property. 4. Massage parlors, and sexual encounter establishments shall be permitted only upon the prior issuance of a conditional use permit. 5. The location of an adult -oriented business listed in Subsection C1 [with the exception of Subsections (C)(1k) and (C)(1o)1 within any new or existing retail center, as specified in Subsection C3, shall not require a conditional use permit. D. Measure of Distance The required minimum distance between any two adult -oriented businesses shall be measured in a straight line, without regard to intervening structures, from the closest exterior structural wall of each such business. The distance between any adult -oriented business and any public school, public parks or residential zoned land shall be measured in a straight line, without regard to intervening structures, from the closest exterior structural wall of the adult -oriented business to the closest property line of the public school, public park or residential zone. E. Development and Maintenance Standards All adult -oriented businesses hereafter commenced shall, in addition to compliance with the Land Use Code, comply with these specific requirements: 1 _ Signs. Except for theater marquee signs, changeable copy signs, temporary signs and small permanent signs are not permitted. In addition to the requirements of Section 18.62.020 for permit approvals, all sign permits shall be subject to review and approval by the Planning Commission. 2. Exterior Painting. Buildings and structures shall not be painted or surfaced with garish colors or textures or any design that would simulate a sign or advertising message. 3. Advertisements, displays of merchandise, signs or any other exhibit depicting adult -oriented activities placed within the interior of buildings or premises shall be arranged or screened to prevent public viewing from outside such buildings or premises. 4. No outdoor loudspeakers or other outdoor sound equipment advertising or directing attention to an adult -oriented use is allowed. 5. Upon order of the City Manager, graffiti appearing on any exterior surface of a building or premises, which graffiti is within public view, shall be removed, and that surface shall be restored within seventy-two hours of notification to the owner or person in charge of the premises. 6. All exterior windows that are visible to the public must be opaquely covered. 112 Title 18 Zoning F. Exceptions 1. Nothing in this section prohibits the transfer of principal ownership or control of adult -oriented uses permitted under Subsections 18.30.030(C) 3 or 18.30.030(C) 5. 2. Notwithstanding any other provision of this code to the contrary, the provisions of this chapter shall be applicable to all land within the City, including all redevelopment project areas now in existence or hereafter established. G. Other Regulations, Permits or Licenses 1. Effect. The provisions of this chapter do not waive or modify any other provision of this code. Adult - oriented businesses shall comply with all applicable provisions of law and this code. 2. Reference. This list is not all-inclusive and is inserted here for reference only; other applicable regulations include, but are not limited to the following chapters: H. Protection of Minors Adult -oriented business shall not allow the admission of minors and shall otherwise comply with Chapter 10.62. An attendant shall be present at all times during hours of operation to deny admittance to minors. I. Private Viewing Rooms It is unlawful for any person or entity which is subject to the regulations of this chapter, and which sells or rents prerecorded video tapes, movies, transparencies, films, projectable motion pictures or equipment used for showing any or all of these items, to offer or allow the viewing of these materials in private viewing rooms, as defined in Subsection B-22. J. Constitutional Severability The City Council declares that the invalidity of any section or portion of this chapter shall not affect the validity of any other remaining section or portion; that the City Council would have adopted each of those remaining portions notwithstanding any later declared invalid. If any portion determined to be invalid can be severed or be judicially interpreted in a way that could harmonize it with the remaining provisions, then it may either be severed or be judicially interpreted and, as interpreted, be applied so as to give full purpose, meaning and effect to the remaining provisions of this chapter. 18.30.040 AUTOMOBILE IMPOUND AND STORAGE YARDS A. Conditional Use Permit -Required Any application for a permit to establish an automobile impound and storage yard shall be subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. The permittee must be a successful bidder of a contract with the City to participate in the assignment of service calls on police -impounded automobiles. No permit shall be granted to premises located east of National City Boulevard. This section does not apply to storage only yards. See Section 18.30.160 (Outdoor Storage) for storage only regulations. B. Yard Area Requirements The conditional use permit shall require, for its issuance, that the proposed storage area meet the following criteria: 1. The storage area shall be in a building or enclosed by a solid fence or wall at least eight feet in height. The construction and maintenance of a required fence shall be in accordance with Section 18- 43. 2. No sign, picture, transparency. advertisement or mechanical device which is used for the purpose of or does advertise or bring to notice any person or persons, or article or articles of merchandise, or 113 Title 18 Zoning any business or profession, or anything that is to be or has been sold, bartered or given away, shall be placed or maintained, or caused to be maintained, upon the outward face of such fence or wall. 3. The storage area must contain a gross surface of not less than 10.000 square feet nor more than 15,000 square feet devoted to the storage of wrecked vehicles. 4. The storage area, including driveways and access roads, shall be surfaced with asphalt cement, or decomposed granite with oil. 5. The storage area shall be served by drainage facilities adequate to prevent the accumulation of standing water. The City Engineer shall determine the adequacy of proposed drainage facilities. 6. Gates in the fence or wall surrounding the storage area shall be constructed of new material, the same height as the fence or wall. No gate shall swing outward. All gates shall be kept closed except when vehicles or pedestrians are exiting or entering the premises. As an alternative to closing all gates, an interior screening fence may be erected so as to prevent public view of the contents of the storage yard during times when the gates are open. 7. A four -foot setback from dedicated streets is required. The setback area and the parkway area shall be landscaped with trees, shrubs, or other ground cover in accordance with Section 18-44 and adopted guidelines. 8. Exterior floodlighting, when used, shall be directed away from adjacent property and streets. All lights shall be shielded in such a manner that the light there from will fall only on the same premises upon which such light source is located. 9. A conditional use permit shall not be granted for an area visible from a freeway unless all wrecked vehicles can be stored out of sight of adjacent freeways. C. Rules of Operation The conditional use permit shall require, for its issuance and continued validity, that permitted storage operations be conducted pursuant to the following rules: 1. Stripping of automobiles, removal of parts, and dismantling, salvaging or junking shall be prohibited; provided, however, that the permittee may remove articles required to be removed to permit scrapping of the impounded vehicles. Removed parts may be accumulated for thirty days on the licensed premises. 2. All inflammable liquids shall be removed from any unregistered or scrapped vehicle. 3. Stored material and vehicles shall be so arranged that reasonable inspection of all parts of the premises can be made at any time by fire, health, police, planning and building authorities. 4. Trash containers shall be installed and maintained on the premises, and the premises shall be kept free of trash at all times. 5. Wrecked vehicles shall be disposed of in an expeditious manner, and no vehicle shall be retained in storage in excess of three months from the date of impoundment. Upon recommendation of the chief of police of the City or order of a court of competent jurisdiction, the City Council may extend the storage time. 6. No article shall be piled higher than the enclosing fence or wall, or nearer than two feet to the enclosing fence or wall. D. Conditional Use Permit -Expiration A conditional use permit granted under the provisions of this title will expire upon the revocation, expiration, or cancellation of a permittee's contract with the City. E. Conditional Use Permit -Revocation for Violation Violation of any requirement of this title is grounds for revocation of a conditional use permit. 114 Title 18 Zoning 18.30.050 SALE OF ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AND LIVE ENTERTAINMENT A. Conditional Use Permit -Required A conditional use permit is required for the sale of alcoholic beverages, whether for on -site or off -site consumption. B. Conditional Use Permit -Additional Notice Required In addition to notices required pursuant to Section 18.12.050 (Noticing and Public Hearings), written notice for a public hearing on a conditional use permit for the sale of alcoholic beverages shall be provided to owners and occupants of property within a radius of 660 feet of the exterior boundaries of the property where the sale of alcoholic beverages is proposed. C. Community Meeting -Required Prior to the public hearing, the applicant shall hold a community meeting to inform residents of a proposal for the sale of alcoholic beverages. The applicant shall provide to the Planning Division documentation of the meeting and input received. D. Distance Requirements Establishments where alcoholic beverages are sold for on or off -site consumption shall be located as follows: 1. Liquor stores, or other businesses where the principal use involves the sale of alcohol for off -site consumption, shall be: a. A minimum of 660 feet from any public school (kindergarten through twelfth grade) within the boundaries of the City; and b. A minimum of 500 feet apart. 2. Bars and cocktail lounges or other establishments where the sale of alcoholic beverages for on -site consumption is the principal use, shall be: a. A minimum of 660 feet from any public school (kindergarten through twelfth grade) within the boundaries of the City; and b. No less than 1,000 feet apart. 3. Restaurants where the sale of alcoholic beverages for on -site consumption is accessory or incidental to the principal use shall be a minimum of 660 feet from any public school (kindergarten through twelfth grade) within the boundaries of the City; except that this distance requirement shall not apply to restaurants (other than fast-food restaurants with drive -through service) where at least thirty percent of the floor area of the building is comprised of seating area. 4. Private clubs or lodges, bowling alleys, theaters and other establishments where the sale of alcoholic beverages is accessory or incidental to the principal use shall be: a. A minimum of 660 feet from any public school (kindergarten through twelfth grade) within the boundaries of the City; and b. No closer than 500 feet apart. This limitation shall not apply to restaurants. 5. No minimum distances from schools or other uses are required for grocery stores, convenience stores or other retail establishments involving the sale of alcohol for off -site consumption as an accessory use. E. Measure of Distance For the purposes of Section 18.30.050(D) (Distance Requirements): 1. The distance between any two establishments that sell alcoholic beverages shall be measured in a straight line without regard to intervening structures from the closest exterior structural walls of the establishments. 115 Title 18 Zoning 2. The distance between any establishment selling alcohol and a school shall be measured in a straight line, disregarding intervening structures, from the closest exterior structural walls of the establishment to the closest property line of the school. F. Additional Standards for the Sale of Alcohol at Restaurants or Public Eating Places Restaurants or public eating places shall conform to the following, additional standards: 1. Alcoholic beverage sales shall be incidental to food service. 2. There shall be no sale of alcoholic beverages after midnight unless otherwise specified by the conditional use permit. The conditional use permit may further restrict the times when alcoholic beverages may be sold. G. Live Entertainment 1. Live entertainment shall be limited to a single entertainer performing musical work (piano bars, etc.) except as provided below. 2. Additional entertainers, dancing, audience participation, karaoke, or other live entertainment may be authorized by a conditional use permit in zones where live entertainment is permitted. 3. Live entertainment specified in Subsection B of this section may be permitted by a resolution of approval for a conditional use permit for the sale of alcohol in zones where live entertainment is permitted. 18.30.060 AUTOMOTIVE BODY AND PAINT SHOPS Automobile painting with accessory body and fender work shall be conducted entirely within a building. The hours of operation shall be between seven a.m. and seven p.m., except where the building adjoins a residential area the hours of operation shall be restricted to between eight a.m. and six p.m. Monday through Saturday. (Accessory body work shall be defined as "only that work required in the preparation for complete auto repaint") 18.30.070 CHILD DAY CARE CENTERS A. Purpose The purpose of establishing child day care center regulations is to implement State law with regard to the provision of child care centers as defined by the California Health and Safety Code to ensure compatibility of such uses with surrounding uses and properties and to avoid any impacts associated with such uses. B. Applicability Day care centers are permitted as set forth in Chapter 2 subject to the requirements of this section. C. Site Location 1. Child day care facilities are encouraged to be located near schools, trolley stops, major bus stops, and close to employment centers in order to reduce commute trips and improve air quality. 2. All child care facilities shall have direct access to a public street with adequate access to a collector or arterial street system. 3. A new child care facility must be located at least 600 feet away from an existing child day care center. D. Operation and Development Standards 1. The applicant must obtain all licenses and permits required by State law for operation of the facility and shall keep all Stale licenses and permits valid and current. 2. The center shall meet all zoning standards applicable to the site. 116 Title 18 Zoning 3. Indoor and outdoor play areas that satisfy the requirements of the State shall be provided. The outdoor play area shall be adjacent to the center and accessible through the center itself. The outdoor play area shall be screened and enclosed by a natural barrier, wall, or fence a minimum of five feet in height. If adjacent to a single-family residential zone, the separating barrier shall be of solid construction. The outdoor play area shall be designed to reduce noise impacts on adjacent properties. 4. Parking shall not be located in any required front yard setback and an adequate on -site loading/unloading area shall be provided that can be easily accessed from the child day care center without crossing any driveways or streets. Clearly designated pedestrian walkways should be provided. 5. All child day care centers shall comply with the City's noise regulations as set forth in Title 9. 6. The drop off and pick up of children from vehicles shall only be permitted on the site's driveway or parking area. A facility with access from an arterial street, as designated by the General Plan, must provide a paved drop-off/pick-up area designated with on -site parking and maneuvering to allow vehicles to pick-up/drop-off children and exit the site without backing out onto the arterial street. 7. Any additional conditions regarding safety and access deemed necessary or desirable by the City Engineer, Fire Marshal, or Building Official must be met. 18.30.080 FAMILY DAY CARE HOMES A. Purpose The purpose of this section is to implement the California Health and Safety Code provisions regarding day care homes, both large family and small family. B. Applicability Family day care homes are permitted as set forth in Chapter 2 subject to the requirements of this section. C. Site Location Properties used for large family day care homes, as defined by the California Health and Safety Code, shall not be located closer than 300 feet from any other large family day care home. D. Operation and Development Standards 1. The family day care home must be the residence of the day care provider. 2. The day care home must be clearly incidental and secondary to the use of the property for residential purposes. 3. Hours of operation shall be less than 24 hours a day. 4. The day care home shall comply with all municipal and state laws and regulations regarding single- family residences and day care homes. 5. Noise must be maintained in compliance with the City's noise regulations as set forth in Title 9. 6. The provider shall comply with all applicable regulations of the City's Fire Department regarding health and safety requirements as they relate to day care hoes and shall contain a fire extinguisher and smoke detector device. 7. All State licensing standards must be met and the provider shall keep all State licenses and permits current. 8. The day care home shall be maintained to retain the appearance of a home consistent with the general character of the neighborhood. 9. Large family day care homes shall provide at least one off-street parking space per employee of driving age not living in the home. The residential driveway approach is acceptable for this parking requirement provided that it does not conflict with a required drop-off/pick-up area and does not block the public sidewalk or right-of-way. 10. Indoor and outdoor play areas that satisfy the requirements of the State shall be provided. The outdoor play area shall be screened and enclosed by a natural barrier, wall, or fence a minimum of 1 1 7 Title 18 Zoning 18.30.090 CONDOMINIUM CONVERSIONS The conversion of existing apartments, hotels and motels, and other rental properties to condominiums, community projects, or stock cooperatives may be permitted if the following conditions are satisfied: A. Permit A conditional use permit is required and the following findings shall be made: 1. The proposal is consistent with housing element goals and objectives; 2. Plans and reports submitted by the applicant, along with conditions of approval, show that necessary upgrading will be completed prior to the sale of any unit; B. Tentative and Parcel Maps A conversion shall comply with requirements for tentative and final parcel maps. C. Subdivision Map Act Requirements of the state Subdivision Map Act will be satisfied, specifically with regard to requirements for notice to tenants and right of tenants to exclusive contract for purchase in condominium, community apartment or stock cooperative projects. D. Physical Elements Reports 1. At the time of submitting the conditional use permit application required in Subsection A of this section, the applicant shall submit a report or reports on the status of the physical elements of the project, including the condition and remaining useful life of building foundations and walls, roofs, electrical systems, plumbing systems, mechanical systems, recreational facilities, parking and other paved areas and drainage facilities. These reports shall be prepared by California licensed structural or civil engineers or private home inspectors and they shall include a detailed evaluation of the existing physical elements, a recommendation on their status including any necessary repairs or replacement, either immediate or in the future, and a certification of the findings. The reports shall also specifically address or include the following: a. Measures that should be taken to improve sound attenuation between units (except for projects built after July 1,1979 in compliance with the Building Code); b. Structural pest report; c. Building history report identifying the date of construction of all elements; d. Characteristics of the building not in compliance with currently applicable building or housing codes, and with codes in effect at the time of construction; e. The need for smoke detectors in individual units, as well as for other on -site fire protection systems maintained by the homeowners association. 2. The Planning Commission, or City Council on appeal, shall review these reports to determine the need to repair or replace any existing physical elements as a condition of approving the proposed conversion. E. Other Materials Any other materials required by the Planning Division to provide evidence in support of the above conditions shall be submitted before the conditional use permit application is determined complete. 118 Title 18 Zoning 18.30.100 CONVERSIONS TO NONRESIDENTIAL USE A. Generally A structure or building intended or designed to be used as a dwelling unit may be used in the commercial and industrial zones for a permitted commercial or industrial use, subject to the provisions of this chapter. B. Approval Approval of the location and plans by the Planning Commission is required. C. Removal of Residential Facilities All facilities for living, sleeping, cooking, and dining shall be permanently removed except for employee dining facilities. D. Compliance with Zoning Regulations All other provisions of this title shall be complied with. E. Building Occupancy The structure or building shall not be used or occupied until after the issuance of a certificate of occupancy by the building official. Any change of occupancy shall comply with all requirements of the building code of the City and this title. F. Dwelling Unit of Historical Character When application is made for approval to convert a dwelling unit of recognized historical character, the Planning Commission may deny a permit on grounds of unsuitability of the proposed use. G. Dwelling Unit Used as a Place of Assembly A dwelling unit or any portion thereof shall be permitted to be converted and/or used as a place of assembly as defined by this title only by the issuance of a conditional use permit. H. Design and Aesthetics In the approval of any plans for the conversion of a residential structure for any of the uses permitted under this chapter, the Planning Commission shall take into consideration the architectural design of the structure, as well as the aesthetic quality of the structure and the property. 18.30.110 A. Purpose EMERGENCY SHELTERS This section establishes standards for the development and operation of emergency shelters where permitted by right as set forth in Chapter 2. B. Permitted Use In compliance with SB 2 effective January 1, 2008, emergency shelters shall be allowed as a permitted use without the need for a conditional use permit and are exempt from CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act). C. Limitations on Location 119 Title 18 Zoning 1. Eligible locations. A new facility shall be a permitted use in the Light Industrial (IL) zone only. 2. Separation between emergency shelters. A new emergency shelter shall not be closer than 300 feet to another emergency shelter as measured between property lines. D. Lighting Adequate external lighting shall be provided for security purposes to ensure fully lit parking, gathering and waiting areas. E. Building Design Standards 1. Number of beds. An emergency shelter shall contain a maximum of 1 bed per 150 square feet of sleeping area not to exceed 50 beds and shall serve no more than 50 persons. 2. Client waiting areas. Emergency shelters shall have an interior, enclosed client waiting and intake area large enough to accommodate the number of persons equal to 25 percent of the number of beds. The area shall be based on space required for seated persons. Any exterior overflow waiting area shall be fenced, screened, gated, and covered and shall riot obstruct sidewalks or driveways. 3. Client gathering areas. Emergency shelters shall have an interior multipurpose area separate from the sleeping area. The multi -purpose area shall be provided with space equal to at least ten square feet per bed, but not be less than 250 square feet. The multipurpose area shall have an exterior gathering area equal to at least 50 square feet per bed and shall be fenced, screened, and landscaped. F. Facility Operating Standards 1. On -site management. The facility shall maintain a management plan. The management plan must document that management and staffing is sufficient for adequate control of the facility. The management plan shall include descriptions of: a. On -site management b. Staffing levels and qualifications c. Client services offered and case management d. Behavior guidelines including no drug or alcohol use e. Facility Maintenance f. Emergency Plan g. Security Plan 2. Vehicle parking. The number of off-street parking spaces shall be calculated based on the amount of office space at the facility plus one parking space per ten beds. The square footage of office space shall be used to determine the number of spaces per the standards specified in Section 18.45 (Parking and Loading Requirements). 3. Length of stay. Temporary shelter shall be available to residents for a maximum of six months. 4. Hours of operation. The emergency shelter shall only accept clients between the hours of 7:00am and 8:00pm. 18.30.120 HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITIES A. Definition 1. "Hazardous waste facility" shall be defined as specified by the California Health and Safety Code and San Diego County Hazardous Waste Management Plan. B. Approval Hazardous waste facilities may be permitted only in the Medium Industrial (IM), Heavy Industrial (IH) zones and shall require approval of a conditional use permit. Data, policies, criteria and procedures contained in the San Diego County Hazardous Waste Management Plan shall be utilized for evaluation of 120 Title 18 Zoning applications for hazardous waste facilities. The siting criteria, the conditional use permit procedure and the fair share policies of the plan shall be utilized in making decisions on such applications. C. Grant Conditions Before any conditional use permit may be granted for a new hazardous waste facility project or for modification of an existing facility, in addition to the conditions required by Section 18.12.110, it shall be found that the proposed facility is in compliance with the following siting criteria documents of the County of San Diego Hazardous Waste Management Plan: 1. Section E, entitled "Local and Regional Facility Needs", of Chapter IX, entitled "Siting and Permitting of Hazardous Waste Facilities" (Pages IX-35 through IX-37); 2. Appendix IX -A, entitled "Siting Criteria for Evaluating Hazardous Waste Management Facility Siting Proposals in San Diego County'; and 3. Appendix IX-B, entitled "General Areas for Siting Hazardous Waste Management Facilities". D. Information Requirements An application for a conditional use permit for a hazardous waste facility project shall provide information required by the planning director to show conformance with procedural requirements of Article 8.7 of the California Health and Safety Code. Such information may include but shall not be limited to documentation from the state office of permit assistance regarding procedures required for approval of the proposed facility. E. Related Permit Requirements All applicable zoning, subdivision, conditional use permit and variance decisions made by the City shall be consistent with the siting criteria documents of the County of San Diego Hazardous Waste Management Plan listed in Subsection C, above. 18.30.130 HELICOPTER OPERATIONS A. Purpose The purpose of this section is to provide rules and regulations governing the conduct of the operation of helicopters and related facilities within the city. B. Conditional Use Permit No person shall operate or maintain a heliport or helistop without first obtaining a conditional use permit and demonstrating that the facility will comply with FAA regulations. C. Temporary Heliport or Helistop Permits 1. No person shall operate a helicopter to or from any property within the city other than a heliport or helistop approved by the City (except in cases of an emergency situation); provided, however, that the landing and takeoff of helicopters at places other than approved heliports and helistops may be authorized for specifically designated and limited times. Such authorization shall not exceed a thirty - day period. 2. Every application for a temporary heliport or helistop permit shall include the following: a. Copy of application for state approval; b. Copy of application for Federal Aviation Administration approval; c. Written approval of landowner or duly authorized agent or representative; d. Certificate of insurance. 121 Title 18 Zoning 18.30.140 MOBILE HOMES AND SIMILAR TEMPORARY STRUCTURES A. Use as Dwelling — Restrictions A mobile home shall not be used for living or sleeping purposes except when located in an approved mobile home park or unless it meets the criteria for factory built housing in State law as defined by Civil Code Section 18.007. B. Restrictions A mobile home, modular structure, or other temporary structure shall not be used as a business or other commercial use in any zone except that a modular structure may be used as a temporary office or classroom for a period of no longer than one year, subject to the issuance of a temporary use permit. This prohibition shall not apply to any former landfill site which is subject to the regulatory order or directive of a regulatory agency, due to the existence on the site of hazardous materials as defined by Section 25260 of the California Health and Safety Code. C. Mobile Home Park — Conditional Use Permit The development of a mobile home park shall require the issuance of a conditional use permit to ensure that such development will be compatible with existing and permitted uses in the adjacent areas. The conditions of approval may include, but shall not be limited to, external traffic circulation, screening walls and plantings, park layout and design (including architectural design), lot size and shape, landscaping, signs, parking, usable open space and recreation areas, and service buildings. D. Mobile Home Park — Screening When located on a lot adjoining another residential use, mobile home parks shall be permanently screened from such adjoining property by a fence or wall and suitable landscaping, adjacent to or opposite the other residential use. 18.30.150 OUTDOOR DISPLAY OR SALE OF MERCHANDISE A. Outdoor Display or Sale of Merchandise Prohibited — General The outdoor display or sale of merchandise on public or private property is unlawful, except as provided in this section. Merchandise is displayed outdoors when it is placed to the exterior of a building or structure. B. Permitted Displays in Commercial, Mixed -Use, and Industrial Zones 1. In commercial, mixed -use, and industrial zones, service stations, auto dealers, recreational vehicle sales lots, nurseries, licensed Flower shops, grocers and neighborhood corner stores limited to the sale of fresh produce and flowers, and building material yards may display merchandise outdoors only on the same site approved for the business. 2- Other businesses in commercial, mixed -use, and industrial zones shall not display or sell merchandise outdoors except pursuant to a determination by the Planning Division that the display would be customary with that type of business and consistent with or comparable to the types of uses. C. Special Promotions 1. Except as allowed by Subsection B all other businesses in the commercial, mixed -use, and industrial zones are permitted to have special promotions at which outdoors display and sales will be allowed, limited to a maximum of three consecutive days each, including all set-up and takedown time. No 122 Title 18 Zoning 2. Special promotions involving outdoor display of merchandise which are to last more than three days, or would involve more than two such sales in any calendar year, are not allowed unless City Council approval in accordance with Chapter 15.60 is first obtained. All sales shall be limited to the site approved for the business. 3. No business shall conduct a special promotion with an outdoor display on a property unless the business has a permanent business address on that property. This restriction shall not apply to sales conducted entirely indoors. D. Seasonal Sale of Christmas Trees and Pumpkins 1. The seasonal sale of Christmas trees and pumpkins outdoors is permitted only in commercial and mixed -use zones on property developed with a commercial use or on vacant property in a commercial or mixed -use zone. 2. Displays and sales of Christmas trees and pumpkins are limited to thirty-five days respectively, including installation and removal of all related materials. A business license shall be obtained each year prior to setting up displays. E. Outdoor vending machines Outdoor vending machines are allowed in all commercial and mixed -use zones. Outdoor vending machines shall: 1. Be located along the front facade of a building or against a structure designed to accommodate them; 2. Occupy not more than ten percent the length of the wall facing the street or access drive, or 20 feet, whichever is less; 3. Not obstruct private pedestrian walkways; a minimum of 44 inches shall be kept clear of obstructions, or more if pedestrian traffic volume warrants. They are not allowed on public sidewalks. 18.30.160 OUTDOOR STORAGE A. Enclosure All outdoor storage, in any zone, which occupies a volume of more than 60 cubic feet and is visible from any abutting public street, or which abuts property used for residential purposes, shall be enclosed by a view -obscuring fence or wall at least six feet high. All gates provided for ingress and egress in any required fence or wall shall be at least six feet in height and shall be of view -obscuring construction. B. Stacking Stored Materials — Height Limitation Merchandise, materials, equipment, or other goods, other than neatly stacked lumber in lumberyards, shall be stacked in outdoor storage areas to a height no greater than that of any building, wall, fence, or gate enclosing the storage area. For scrap metal processing yards, see Section 18.30.180. C. Posting Signs or Devices Prohibited No sign, picture, transparency, advertisement, or mechanical device which is used for the purpose of or which does advertise or bring to notice any person or persons, or article or articles of merchandise, or any business or profession, or anything that is to be or has been sold, bartered or given away shall be placed or caused to be placed or to be maintained or caused to be maintained upon the outward face of any gate, fence or wall enclosing any outdoor storage area. D. Storage in Yard Setback Prohibited No storage shall be permitted in any required front or side yard setbacks adjacent to a public street or highway. 123 Title 18 Zoning E. Materials Storage During Construction During construction and sixty days thereafter, property in said project area may be used for the storage of materials, excluding batch plants, used in the construction of the individual buildings in the project and for the contractor's temporary office. F. Areas Designated for Storage Except as specified herein, no other areas shall be used for outdoor storage. Areas designated for storage or which are otherwise restricted to vehicular passage shall be indicated on the plot plan and be so maintained. .AII areas of the yard open to vehicular passage shall be paved. G. Specific Storage Regulations in Commercial, Mixed -Use, and Industrial Zones In the commercial, mixed -use, and industrial zones, the following regulations shall apply: 1. The storage of all materials or wastes which might cause fumes or dust, or which constitute a fire hazard, or which may be edible by or otherwise attractive to insects or rodents, unless said materials or wastes are stored outdoors in closed containers, is prohibited. 2. The storage of corrosive materials is permitted subject to the provisions of the City fire code. 3. Activities involving the storage of fire and explosive hazard materials shall be conducted in accordance with the City fire code. 4. Toxic or dangerous materials shall be stored in a manner that insures against their escape from the premises to the detriment of public safety, health or welfare. 5. No material, equipment, or goods of any kind shall be stored on the roof of any building in any zone. 6. In the industrial zones, the storage or materials, liquids, or wastes upon any lot in such form or manner that they may be transferred or flow off said lot by natural causes or forces is prohibited. 7. Shipping containers and truck trailers shall not be used for storage purposes in any zone, except pursuant to a temporary use permit as approved by the City Council. H. Rubbish Storage 1. Rubbish and solid waste shall be disposed of by public facilities, when available. Liquid wastes shall be promptly and properly disposed of in a manner acceptable to the City and to the San Diego Metropolitan Sewer District. Where public facilities are not provided for disposal, rubbish and solid waste shall be contained in rodent proof, nonflammable, waterproof storage containers with close - fitting lids. When liquid wastes are of such a character as to be unacceptable in the public sewer system, such wastes shall be stored in suitable containers or tanks until transfer. Such containers or tanks shall comply with the City fire code and other applicable regulations in this title. 2. All storage and disposal facilities shall be screened from all public view. In the residential, commercial, mixed -use, and institutional zones such screening shall be of solid masonry construction with sturdy gates of view -obscuring design. Location and accessibility shall be subject to site plan review. 3. Any building or structure or portion of building or structure used for storage of rubbish -and waste shall contain an approved floor drain connected to the public sewer system_ 18.30.170 RECYCLING COLLECTION FACILITIES A. Purpose It is the intent and purpose of this chapter to establish reasonable regulations for establishment of recycling collection facilities to encourage and facilitate the recycling of glass, aluminum, plastic and nonaluminum metal beverage containers in a safe and convenient manner. 124 Title 18 Zoning B. Definitions For the purpose of this chapter, the following words shall have the following meanings: 1. Igloos. An "igloo" is a small, moveable collection bin or container occupying no more than 40 square feet each. 2. Mobile recycling unit. A "mobile recycling unit" means an automobile, truck, trailer or van, licensed by the Department of Motor Vehicles, which is used for the collection of recyclable materials. A mobile recycling unit also means the bins, boxes or containers, other than igloos, transported by trucks, vans, or trailers, and used for the collection of recyclable materials. 3. Recyclable material. "Recyclable material" is reusable material including aluminum, nonaluminum metal, glass and plastic beverage containers, which are intended for reuse, remanufacture, or reconstitution for the purpose of using the altered form. Recyclable material as described in this section does not include paper, refuse, motor oil or other hazardous materials. 4. Recycling collection facility. A "recycling collection facility" is a center for the collection of recyclable materials from the public by donation, redemption or purchase. A certified recycling facility means a recycling facility certified by the California Department of Conservation as meeting the requirements of the California Beverage Container Recycling and Litter Reduction Act of 1986. A recycling facility does not include storage containers located on the premises of a commercial or industrial use used solely for the collection of recyclable materials generated by that use. Recycling collection facilities include the following: a. Reverse vending machines; b. Igloos; c. Mobile recycling units. 5. Reverse vending machine. A "reverse vending machine" is an automated mechanical device which accepts at least one or more types of empty beverage containers including aluminum and nonaluminum metal cans, glass and plastic bottles, and issues a cash refund or a redeemable credit slip with a value not less than the container's redemption value as determined by the state. A reverse vending machine may sort and process containers mechanically; provided that the entire process is enclosed within the machine. In order to accept and temporarily store all four container types in a proportion commensurate with their relative redemption rates, and to meet the requirements of certification as a recycling facility, multiple grouping of reverse vending machines may be necessary. A "bulk reverse vending machine" is a reverse vending machine that is larger than 50 square feet; is designed to accept more than one container at a time; and will pay by weight instead of by container. 6. Small recycling facility. A small recycling facility is defined as an igloo or reverse vending machine. C. Types of Facilities Permitted 1. Reverse vending machines, igloos, and mobile recycling units may be permitted subject to conformance with all of the following: a. Location within the MXC-1, MXC-2, MXD-1, MXD-2, CS, IL, and IM zones; b. Location within convenience zones designated by the State of California Department of Conservation, Division of Recycling; c. Certification or application for certification by the State of California; d. Required permits, as described in Subsection D; e. Operation and design standards, as described in Subsection E; f. No recycling collection facility shall be permitted if it is found that the facility or its operation will have a detrimental effect on public health, safety, or general welfare. D. Permits Required 1. Site plan review. Small recycling facilities, as defined in Subsection B, shall require site plan review approval. 2. Conditional use permit. Mobile recycling units, as defined in Subsection B, shall require conditional use permit approval. E. Operation and Design Standards 125 Title 18 Zoning 1. Reverse vending machines shall comply with the following standards: a. Established in conjunction with a commercial use or community service facility which is in compliance with the zoning, building, and fire codes of the City: b. Located within 30 feet of the entrance to the commercial structure and shall not obstruct pedestrian or vehicular circulation; c. Not occupy parking spaces required by the primary use; d. Except for bulk reverse vending machines, occupy no more than 50 square feet of floor space per installation, including any protective enclosure, and be no more than eight feet in height; no more than four reverse vending machines at the site; bulk reverse vending machines shall occupy no more than 300 square feet of floor space per installation, including any protective enclosure; e. Constructed and maintained with durable waterproof and rustproof material; f. Clearly marked to identify the type of material to be deposited, operating instructions, and the identity and phone number of the operator or responsible person to call if the machine is nonoperative; g. Have a sign area of a maximum of four square feet per machine, exclusive of operating instructions; h. Maintained in a clean, litter -free condition on a daily basis; i. Illuminated to ensure comfortable and safe operation if operating hours are after dusk; j. Installation of all wiring required in accordance with the National Electrical Code, latest edition. 2. Igloos shall comply with the following standards: a. Established in conjunction with an existing commercial use or community service facility which is in compliance with the zoning, building, and fire codes of the City; b. Occupy an area no larger than 200 square feet; c. Set back at least ten feet from any front property line and shall not obstruct pedestrian or vehicular circulation; d. Accept only glass, metal, and plastic containers; e. No power -driven processing equipment used; f. Containers constructed and maintained with durable, waterproof and rust -proof material, covered when site is not attended, secured from unauthorized entry or removal of material, of a capacity sufficient to accommodate materials collected and collection schedule; g. All recyclable material stored in containers, and materials not left outside of containers at any time; h. Maintained free of litter and any undesirable materials; i. Not be located within 50 feet of a residentially zoned property; j. Operation of attended facilities located within 100 feet of a property zoned or occupied for residential use only during the hours of 9:00am and 7:00pm; k. Noise levels not exceeding 60dBA as measured at the property line of residentially zoned or occupied property, and otherwise not exceeding 65dBA; I. Location of containers for the 24 hour donation of materials at least 100 feet from any property zoned or occupied for residential use unless there is a recognized service corridor and acoustical shielding between the containers and the residential use; m. Labeling of containers to identify the type of material which may be deposited, identification of the facility with the name and telephone number of the facility operator and the hours of operation, and display of notice stating that no material shall be left outside the recycling enclosure or containers; n_ Signing permitted as follows: i. Identification signs with a maximum of four square feet, in addition to informational signs required in Subsection E(2)(m), above; ii. Signs consistent with the character of the location; iii. Directional signs, bearing no advertising message, installed with the approval of the City Manager or his/her designee if the facility is not visible from the public right-of-way; iv. Authorization from the City Manager or his/her designee for increase in the number and size of signs upon finding that it is compatible with adjacent businesses. o. Required landscape area not occupied or interfered with; 126 Title 18 Zoning p. No occupation of parking spaces on the site unless deemed necessary and authorized by the City Manager or his/her designee; no additional parking spaces required for customers of an igloo collection facility located at the established parking lot of a host use; one space of host use permitted to be occupied by an attendant, if needed. 3. Mobile recycling units shall comply with the following standards: a. Established in conjunction with an existing commercial use or community service facility which is in compliance with the zoning, building, and fire codes of the City; b. No larger than 350 square feet and occupy no more than three parking spaces not including space that will be periodically needed for removal of materials or exchange of containers; c. Set back at least ten feet from any front property line and shall not obstruct pedestrian or vehicular circulation; d. Accept only glass, aluminum, nonaluminum, and plastic containers; e. No power -driven processing equipment used; f. Containers constructed and maintained with durable waterproof and rustproof material, covered when site is not attended, secured from unauthorized entry or removal of material, and of a capacity sufficient to accommodate materials collected and collection schedule; g. All recyclable materials stored in containers or in the mobile unit vehicle, and not left outside of containers at any time; h. Maintained free of litter and any other undesirable materials; mobile facilities, at which truck or containers are removed at the end of each collection day, swept at the end of each collection day; i. Noise levels not exceeding 60dBA as measured at the property line of residentially zoned or occupied property, and otherwise not exceeding 65dBA; j. Not to be located within 50 feet of a residentially zoned property; k. Operation of attended facilities located within 100 feet of a property zoned or occupied for residential use only during the hours of 9:00am and 7:OOpm; I. Location of containers for the 24 hour donation of materials at least 100 feet from any property zoned or occupied for residential use unless there is a recognized service corridor and acoustical shielding between the containers and the residential use; m. Labeling of containers 10 identify the type of material which may be deposited; identification of the facility to identify the name and telephone number of the facility operator and the hours of operation, and display of a notice stating that no material shall be left outside the recycling enclosure or containers; n. Signing permitted as follows: i. Identification signs with a maximum of four square feet, in addition to informational signs required in subsection E(3)(m), above; ii. Signs consistent with the character of the location; iii. Directional signs, bearing no advertising message, installed with the approval of the City Manager or his/her designee if the facility is not visible from the public right-of-way; iv. Authorization from the City Manager or his/her designee for increase in the number and size of signs upon finding that it is compatible with adjacent businesses. o. Required landscape area not occupied or interfered with; p_ No additional parking spaces required for customers of a mobile recycling unit located at the established parking tot of a host use; one space of the host use permitted to be occupied by the attendant, if needed; q. Area clearly marked to prohibit other vehicular parking during hours when the mobile unit is scheduled to be present; r. No reduction of available parking spaces below the minimum number required for the primary host use unless a parking study shows that existing parking capacity is not already fully utilized during the time the recycling facility will be on the site; reduction in available parking spaces in an established parking facility then permitted as follows: i. For a commercial host use: Number of Parking Spaces Available 0-25 26-35 127 Maximum Reduction 0 2 Title 18 Zoning 36-49 3 50+ 4 ii. For a community facility host use, a maximum of four spaces reduction will be allowed when not in conflict with parking needs of the host use. F. Additional Requirements Additional requirements may be required as conditions of permit approval. 18.30.180 SCRAP METAL PROCESSING A. Regulations Generally Scrap metal yards, scrap or used metal sales, and scrap metal processing shall be operated in accordance with the provisions of this section. This shall not relieve the operators of scrap metal processing uses from complying with all City regulations, laws, and ordinances. B. Site Plan Review Required All scrap metal processing uses shall be subject to site plan review. C. Salvage or Junk Storage Restrictions The storage of salvage or junk shall not be placed or allowed to remain outside of the enclosed yard area. It may be stored above the height of the fence or wall, provided such storage is not within ten feet of an exterior lot line. Nonmetallic salvage or processing not clearly incidental to the principal use shall not be allowed. D. Fences and Walls - Required The entire premises shall be enclosed by fences and walls of uniform height in relation to the ground upon which they stand. Such fences or walls shall be a minimum of eight feet high and shall not exceed 15 feet in height. E. Fences and Walls — Materials All fences and walls open to view from any street shall be constructed of the following materials: 1. Metallic panels, at least .024 inches thick, painted with a baked -on enamel or similar permanent finish. All fences constructed with metallic panels exposed to view from the exterior side shall have an interior face of solid wood not less than two inches thick from the ground to the top of such fence; 2. Masonry; 3. Other materials comparable to the foregoing if approved by the Planning Division. F. Fences and Walls — Construction Standards All fences and walls shall be constructed in a workmanlike manner and shall consist solely of new materials, unless the director of planning approves the substitution of used materials where, in his opinion, such used materials will provide the equivalent in service, appearance, and useful life. G. Fences and Walls — Painting All fences and walls, excluding masonry and approved permanent finish panels, shall be painted a uniform complimentary color, excluding black, which blends with the surrounding terrain and improvements, and shall be maintained in a neat, orderly condition at all times. Such fence or wall shall 128 Title 18 Zoning contain no painted signs or posters except as approved by the director of planning. In all cases, colors shall be subject to approval by the director of planning. H. Standards for Structures Any structures which are used as part of the yard boundaries and/or are exposed to view from a street frontage shall be subject to painting, maintenance and sign requirements for fences and walls as provided in Section 18-43. The Planning Division may approve other appropriate architectural treatment. I. Paving of yards Areas designated for storage or which are otherwise restricted to vehicular passage shall be indicated on the site plan and shall be so maintained. All areas of the yard open to vehicular passage shall be paved J. Landscaping 1. Along each street frontage, all required setbacks and the adjacent street parkways shall be fully landscaped. 2. A permanent automatic irrigation system shall be provided which satisfactorily irrigates all planted areas. 3. All landscaped areas shall be continuously and properly maintained in good condition. K. Painting and Maintenance All equipment, structures, etc.. extending above the height of exterior fences shall be continuously maintained and painted in a neat and orderly fashion. L. Storage and Combustibles Containers approved by the City Fire Department shall be provided for the storage of combustible materials removed from scrap autos delivered to the site. M. Litter Prohibited The entire site shall be continuously maintained to prevent accumulations of weeds, rubbish. litter, or combustible waste. Any incidents of rat or vermin harborage shall be promptly corrected. N. Performance Standards All salvage operations shall comply with the performance standards for air pollution, noise, vibration, and glare as set forth in Section 18.40.030 and Title 7 of the Municipal Code. 18.30.190 SERVICE STATIONS AND CONVENIENCE STORES WITH GASOLINE PUMPS A. Conditional Use Permit Required The development and construction of all service stations shall be subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. B. Frontage The site shall have a minimum of 100 feet of frontage on a dedicated street. C. Minimum Site Area The minimum site area shall be 15,000 square feet, 129 Title 18 Zoning D. Site Planning Standards 1. Bay doors of service stations and automotive maintenance and repair facilities should not be visible from the major street, whenever possible. 2. Fuel pump islands and canopies should be screened by the main building structure. The convenience store should be placed at the street frontage with display windows along the sidewalk, to encourage pedestrian use. 3. Curb cuts shall be limited to one per street for corner locations, or two per street for mid -block locations. 4. Curb cuts on the same street shall be spaced at least 25 feet apart. E. Screening When a service station adjoins a residential zone along a rear or side lot line, a masonry screening wall, not less than five feet and no more than six feet in height, shall be erected along such adjoining lot line. F. Building Fronts 1. All building materials and designs shall be consistent with the general standards for commercial businesses. Metal buildings are not permitted. 2. The design of stand-alone gas stations and convenience stores should conform to the dominant existing or planned character of the surrounding neighborhood or development. This can be accomplished through the use of similar forms, materials and colors. 3. The design of a facility that occupies a pad or portion of a building within a larger commercial center should be designed to reflect the design elements of that center. 4. All sides of a building visible from the street shall express consistent architectural detail and character. G. Pump Island Canopies and Other Buildings and Structures All structures on the site (including kiosks, car wash buildings, pump island canopies, and screen walls) shall be architecturally consistent with the main structure, including roof design, color, materials, and architectural details. H. Landscaping — Generally Ten percent of the gross site area shall be devoted to landscaping. I. Open Area — Surfacing All open areas, not included in landscaped areas shall be paved. J. Use Regulations The operation of all service stations shall be in accordance with the following regulations: 1. Uses permissible at a service station do not include body or fender work or automobile painting unless they are permissible uses within the particular zone. Dismantling of automobiles for the purpose of selling parts is prohibited. 2. All repair work being conducted shall be within a structure which shall be attached to the existing service station facility. 3. Adequate facilities for such repair shall be available. 4. No outdoor storage of disabled vehicles, vehicles under repair, automobile parts, or repair equipment shall be allowed at any time. 5. Major repairs shall be conducted only between the hours of seven a.m. and seven p.m. 130 Title 18 Zoning 6. Operations outside permanent structures shall be limited to the dispensing of motor fuels and servicing of tires, batteries and/or automobile accessories. K. Gasoline Pumps as an Accessory Use This section shall have no effect on the installation and operation of a gasoline pump or pumps, or lube oil drums which are used solely to service the motorized equipment of commercial, manufacturing or industrial use of the land upon which the pump or drum is installed; provided, however, that the pump or drum shall not be installed or operated on any parcel of land not included within the land of the permissible principal use. L. Sale of Gasoline as an Accessory Use 1. The sale of gasoline as an accessory use to a permitted use shall require the issuance of a conditional use permit. 2. The sale of gasoline as an accessory use will be allowed only in zones in which the sale of gasoline as a principal use is allowed. M. Sale of Non -automotive Products at Service Stations The sale of nonautomotive products in service stations is permitted as follows: 1. Such products must be displayed within an enclosed permanent building. 2. The display area shall be a maximum of 216 cubic feet, except that a conditional use permit may be issued to authorize additional areas of display, where such use is otherwise permitted by this title. The sale of any alcoholic beverages is prohibited, regardless of the display area, unless specifically authorized by a conditional use permit. N. Lighting 1. General. All lighting shall be directed away from adjoining properties and streets and shall be so shielded and adjusted that the light is directed to fall only on the same premises upon which the light source is located. 2. Canopy Lighting. a. Lights shall not be mounted on the top or sides of the canopy. The sides shall not be illuminated in any manner. b. Fuel pump canopies shall not be internally illuminated. Light fixtures shall be completely recessed into the canopy so that the light source is concealed. O. Enhanced Vapor Recovery Systems (EVR) As required by AST Executive Order VR-401-B adopted by State of California Air Resources Board, as of April 1, 2009, all gasoline dispensary facilities with underground storage tanks must upgrade to an Enhanced Vapor Recovery System (EVR) Phase IL All EVR Systems, including pipes that and other components that extend beyond/above the tank, shall be screened from view. 18.30.200 SIDEWALK CAFES A. Purpose Sidewalk cafes make a significant contribution to the quality of public spaces and community life. They provide an active street frontage that is lively and dynamic. They are natural locations for social interaction. The purpose of this section is to provide procedures for and standards to encourage the establishment of sidewalk cafes wherever permitted. 131 Title 18 Zoning B. Permit Requirements A sidewalk cafe shall require the approval of a minor use permit and an encroachment permit by the City Council. C. Review Authority A sidewalk cafe may be approved by the Planning Division if it is determined that the proposed cafe is in conformity with all of the requirements of this section. An encroachment permit must thereafter be obtained from the City Council. D. Limitations and Requirements 1. Where permitted. A sidewalk cafe may be permitted only in a zoning district that allows indoor restaurants, and then only if the sidewalk cafe is situated adjacent, as specified below, to an indoor restaurant and the sidewalk cafe's operation is incidental to and a part of the operation of such adjacent indoor restaurant. a. A sidewalk cafe may be located on the public sidewalk immediately adjacent to and abutting the indoor restaurant which operates the cafe, provided that the area in which the sidewalk cafe is located extends no farther along the sidewalk's length than the actual sidewalk frontage of the operating indoor restaurant and all other applicable provisions of this section are fulfilled. b. The service of alcoholic beverage to customers using the sidewalk cafe is prohibited. 2. Sidewalk clearances. A sidewalk cafe may be permitted only where the sidewalk is wide enough to adequately accommodate both the usual pedestrian traffic in the area and the operation of the proposed cafe. A sidewalk cafe shall not occupy more than 50 percent of the sidewalk's width at any point and not less than eight consecutive feet of sidewalk width at every point shall be kept clear and unimpeded for pedestrian traffic. 3. Outdoor furniture. All tables and chairs comprising a sidewalk cafe shall be set back not less than two feet from any curb and from any sidewalk or street barrier, including a bollard, and shall not be situated within eight feet of any designated bus stop. All outdoor dining furniture, including tables, chairs, umbrellas, and planters, shall be movable. All outdoor furniture must be of commercial quality to withstand the wear of outdoor use; plastic tables and chairs are riot permitted. Outdoor furniture should be complimentary to the adjoining indoor business design and make a positive contribution to the street environment. Umbrellas must be secured with a minimum base of not less than 60 pounds. Outdoor heaters, music, or speakers are prohibited. 4. Signage. No signing shall be allowed at any outdoor cafe except for the name of the establishment on an awning or umbrella fringe. 5. Food and beverages. A sidewalk cafe may serve only food and nonalcoholic beverages prepared or stocked for sale at the adjoining indoor restaurant. 6. Service requirements. The outdoor preparation of food and busing/server stations are prohibited at sidewalk cafes. The presetting of tables with utensils, glasses, napkins, condiments, and the like is prohibited. All exterior surfaces within the cafe shall be easily cleanable and shall be kept clean at all times by the permittee. Trash and refuse storage for the sidewalk cafe shall not be permitted within the outdoor dining area or on adjacent sidewalk areas and the permittee shall remove all trash and litter as they accumulate. The permittee is responsible for maintaining the outdoor dining area, including the sidewalk surface and furniture and adjacent areas in a clean and safe condition. 7. Hours of operation. Sidewalk cafes may only operate between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 10:00 pin. and shall be setback a minimum of 150 feet from the property line of any parcel occupied by a detached single-family residence. Tables, chairs, and all other furniture used in the operation of an outdoor cafe shall be removed from the sidewalk and stored indoors at night and whenever the cafe is not in operation. E. Power to Suspend Operation of Sidewalk Cafe The City shall have the right and power, acting through the City Manager or his/her designee, to suspend the operation of a sidewalk cafe at any time because of anticipated or actual problems or conflicts in the 132 Title 18 Zoning use of the sidewalk area. Such problems and conflicts may arise from, but are not limited to, scheduled festivals and similar events, or parades or marches, or repairs to the street or sidewalk, or from demonstrations or emergencies occurring in the area. To the extent possible, the permittee shall be given prior written notice of any time period during which the operation of the sidewalk cafe will be suspended by the City, but any failure to give prior written notice shall not affect the right and power of the City to suspend the cafe's operation at any particular time. F. Findings and Conditions In connection with granting approval for a minor use permit for a sidewalk cafe, the Planning Division shall make findings that the proposed operation meets the limitations of this section and may impose conditions in granting its approval as deemed are needed to ensure that the proposed operation will meet the operating requirements and conditions set forth in this section and to assure that the public safety and welfare will be protected. 18.30.210 SMALL WIND ENERGY SYSTEMS A. Purpose The intent of the section is to allow for the limited use of wind turbines or windmills throughout the city for the purpose of small scale generation of electricity to serve the needs of a home, institutional or open space land use, or business. These provisions are intended to ensure that such facilities are well designed, carefully sited, and operated in a manner that will not pose a nuisance or hazard to the general public or nearby neighbors. In addition, these provisions are intended to preserve and protect public health and safety without significantly increasing the cost or decreasing the efficiency of small wind energy systems. B. Definitions 1. "Roof peak" is the highest point of a roof excluding any architectural feature such as a cupola, parapet, turret, tower, elevator shaft enclosure, or similar architectural embellishment. 2. "Small wind energy system" means a wind energy system consisting of a single wind turbine, tower, and associated control or conversion electronics providing electricity for a home, accessory dwelling unit, multi -family residential building, or small business. 3. "Total Height" means the vertical distance from ground level to the tip of a fully extended wind turbine blade at its highest point. 4. "Tower" means a freestanding structure that supports a wind turbine. 5. "Wind Energy System" means equipment that converts and then stores or transfers energy from the wind into usable forms of energy and includes any base, blade, foundation, generator, nacelle, rotor, tower, transformer, turbine, vane, wire, or other component used in the system. 6. "Wind Turbine" means the mechanical and electrical conversion components mounted at the top of a tower in a wind energy system. C. Small Wind Energy System Standards A small wind energy system shall be a permitted use in all zoning districts subject to the following requirements: 1. Lot size and maximum height. a. Small mono -pole wind energy systems shall be subject to the height limit of the underlying zone. One mono -pole wind energy system is permitted for each half -acre or portion thereof not to exceed three. Wind turbine systems shall comply with the FAA height regulations and Coastal Zone requirements. b. Roof -mounted wind energy systems shall be allowed on any lot size with a total height limit of ten feet above the peak of the roof and located the furthest distance from adjacent residences. 2. Setbacks. 133 Title 18 Zoning a. A wind tower shall be set back a distance equal to the total height to the top of a fully extended blade from any public right-of-way or overhead utility lines and all property lines. b. No part of the wind system structure, including guy -wire anchors, may extend closer than accessory building setbacks of the appropriate zone to the property lines of the installation site. 3. Access. All ground mounted electrical and control equipment shall be secured to prevent unauthorized. access and the tower shall be designed and installed so as not to provide step bolts or a ladder readily accessible to the public for a minimum height of eight feet above the ground. 4. Noise. Small wind energy systems shall comply with the Noise Ordinance of the National City Municipal Code. 5. Approved Wind Turbines. Small wind turbines must be approved by the Emerging Technologies program of the California Energy Commission or any other small wind certification program recognized by the American Wind Energy Association. 6. Appearance. a. The wind generator and lower shall be painted in subdued tones of white, silver, light grey, or light blue or the manufacturer's original paint or finish shall be permitted if it complies with the subdued tones identified herein or should be designed and painted a color that blends with the surrounding natural or manmade features. b. Where mounted on a building, the installation shall be well integrated with the architecture of the building. 7. Safety precautions. a. A wind energy system shall be equipped with manual and automatic overspeed controls to limit the rotational speed of the blade within the design limits of the rotor. b. All wind towers shall have lightening protection. c. If a wind tower is supported by guy wires, the wires shall be clearly visible to the height of at least six feet above the guy wire anchors. d. The minimum distance between the ground and any part of the rotor blade system shall be 15 feet. e. A six feet high fence with a locking gate shall be placed around the system's tower base. D. Permits 1. Small roof mounted wind energy systems are an accessory use permitted in all zoning districts. No small wind energy systems shall be erected, constructed, or installed without first receiving a building permit from the appropriate City authority. A building permit shall also be required for any modification to an existing small wind energy system. 2. Small mono -pole wind energy systems and meteorological towers shall not be erected, constructed, or installed without first receiving a conditional use permit and a building permit from the appropriate City authorities. A building permit shall also be required for any modification to an existing system. 18.30.220 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES A. Purpose The purpose and intent of this section is to provide a uniform and comprehensive set of standards for the development, siting, and installation of wireless telecommunications facilities and antenna installation. These regulations are intended to protect and promote the public health, safety, and welfare of the residents of National City and to preserve community character and protect aesthetic quality in accordance with the guidelines and intent of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 and to encourage siting in preferred locations to minimize aesthetic impacts and to minimize the intrusion of these uses into residential areas. B. Commercial Telecommunications Facilities 1. Telecommunication facilities are subject to a conditional use permit and design review and shall comply with all applicable provisions of this section. 134 Title 18 Zoning 2. Design guidelines for commercial facilities. To the greatest extent possible, commercial telecommunication facilities shall be sensitively designed and located to be compatible with and minimize visual impacts to surrounding areas, including public property. To this end, each facility shall comply with the following design guidelines. a. Innovative design solutions that minimize visual impacts should be utilized; stealth solutions where facilities are not detectable are especially encouraged. i. A good faith effort in achieving co -location shall be required of the host entity. Requests for utilization of facility space and response to such requests shall be made in a timely manner and in writing and copies shall be provided to the City. Co -location is not required in cases where the visual impacts are found to be substantial, the facility cannot reasonably accommodate additional facilities, or where good faith lease arrangements fail. ii. All properties found suitable for co -location and multiple users shall be designed to promote facility and site sharing. To this end telecommunication facilities and necessary appurtenances, shall be shared by site users, when in the determination of the Planning Commission, as appropriate, this will minimize overall visual impacts to the community. b. Telecommunication facilities shall be as small as possible and the minimum height necessary without compromising reasonable reception or transmission- c. Antennas and their support structures should be located on the rear half of property or structures when reasonable transmission and/or reception would not be impaired and when visual impacts would be reduced, unless no other feasible alternative location exists. d. Telecommunication facilities and appurtenances should not be situated between the primary building on the parcel and any public or private street adjoining the parcel. e. Telecommunication facilities should be located and designed to avoid blocking and/or substantially altering scenic views. f. Building mounted telecommunication facilities are encouraged rather than telecommunication towers. g. Building mounted telecommunication facilities should be integrated with existing structures. h. Telecommunication facilities should be designed and painted a color that blends with the surrounding natural or manmade features. i. Telecommunication facilities and appurtenances shall be screened by existing and/or proposed structures and landscaped to the extent possible without compromising reception and/or transmission. j. The design of fencing, landscaping, and other screening for telecommunication facilities shall be integrated and compatible with surrounding improvements. k. Multiple telecommunication facilities of reduced heights are encouraged to cover a service area where the visual impacts would be less than a single larger and more visually obtrusive tower. I. Co -location of commercial telecommunication towers and the use of the same site by multiple carriers is encouraged where feasible and found to be desirable. m. Monopoles or guyed/lattice towers are discouraged except where satisfactory evidence is provided demonstrating that a self-supporting tower is needed to provide the height and/or capacity necessary for the proposed facility and visual impacts would be minimized. n. All utility lines serving the facility shall be under -grounded. o. Each commercial telecommunication facility shall be installed in a manner that will maintain and enhance existing native vegetation. Suitable landscaping to screen the facility shall also be installed where necessary. p. All major commercial telecommunication facilities, other than government owned facilities, shall be prohibited in residential zones. q. All major commercial telecommunication facilities shall be located at least 75 feet from any habitable structure, except for a habitable structure on the property in which the facility is located. 3. Commercial transmission towers are prohibited. 4. Telecommunication facilities shall conform to the requirements of the FCC. C. Amateur Radio and Citizen's Band Antennas Amateur radio and citizen's band antennas shall comply with the following regulations, and all other applicable requirements of this section. 135 I itle 18 Zoning 1. The following amateur radio and citizen band facilities require Site Plan review only: a. An antenna facility that is not within the public view provided the facility otherwise complies with all other applicable provisions of this section. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to prove that the proposed facility will not be in public view. b. No more than one ground mounted antenna per parcel, not to exceed 30 feet in height setback a distance equal to the height of the facility from the property line. c. No more than one building mounted antenna per parcel, not to exceed 12 feet in height above the highest part of the building. D. Receive -Only Television and Radio Antennas Receive -only TV and radio antennas shall comply with the following regulations, and all other applicable requirements of this section. 1. The following facilities require Site Plan Review only provided they comply with Subsection E: a. An antenna that is not within the public view provided the facility otherwise complies with all other applicable provisions of this section. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to prove that the proposed facility will not be in public view. b. Ground mounted facility that is a satellite dish one meter (3.28 feet) or less in diameter. c. Building mounted facility that is a satellite dish one meter (3.28 feet) or less in diameter. E. Development Criteria for All Facilities Each antenna and other telecommunications facility, including exempt facilities, shall comply with the following requirements. 1. The antenna shall be accessory to the primary use of the property which is not a telecommunications facility. 2. No more than one citizen band, amateur radio, receive only TV or radio antenna tower is allowed per parcel. 3. Telecommunication facilities shall not be located within any setback area required by the applicable zoning district. 4. Antennas and appurtenances should not be installed between the primary structure and any private or public street adjoining the parcel unless sufficiently screened, and no other feasible alternative exists. 5. No portion of an antenna array shall extend beyond the property lines of the subject parcel, unless the affected property owner has given written consent to the encroachment and the consent has been recorded at the San Diego County Recorder. Any consent given under this condition shall set forth a procedure by which the consent may be terminated. 6. The facility shall be as small as possible and the minimum height necessary without compromising reasonable reception and/or transmission. 7. All hardware such as brackets, turnbuckles, clips, and similar items subject to rust or corrosion shall be protected by galvanizing or paint. 8. Satellite dishes shall be painted a color that blends with their surroundings. 9. Satellite dishes shall not be used as a sign or contain any advertising copy 10. Facilities shall be screened by existing and/or proposed structures and landscaping to the extent possible without compromising reception and/or transmission. 11. Each facility shall comply with all Federal, State, and City codes, including FCC and FAA standards. F. Permit Requirements A telecommunications facility shall require conditional use permit approval in compliance with this section, if not considered an amateur radio and citizen's band antenna pursuant to Subsection C or exempt pursuant to Subsection D. 1. Conditional use permit required. a. A conditional use permit is required for all commercial telecommunication facilities. The review authority for conditional use permits is the Planning Commission. 136 Fitle 18 Zoning b. Application requirements for commercial facilities. In addition to the conditional use permit application requirements, the following information shall be submitted when applying for a telecommunications facility: i. A narrative description of the proposed facility, including the type of facility, type of technology and consumer services that provider will provide to its customers; ii. Area development, service area, and network maps; Alternative site or location analysis; iv. Title reports; and v. Visual impact analysis, including photo montages, field mock ups, line of site sections, and other techniques shall be prepared by or on behalf of the applicant which identifies the potential visual impacts of the facility, at design capacity. Consideration shall be given to views from public areas as well as from private properties. The analysis shall assess visual impacts of the facility, and shall identify and include all technologically feasible mitigation measures. c. Exceptions. Exceptions to the requirements of this section may be granted through conditional use permit approval by the Planning Commission. G. Abandonment Upon abandonment of a telecommunication facility, the facility shall be removed by the applicant and/or property owner and, where applicable, the site shall be restored to its natural condition. 18.30.230 TOBACCO SPECIALITY SHOPS Tobacco specialty shops, where permitted pursuant to the Land Use Code, shall not be located within 1,000 feet of any school, playground, recreation center or facility, childcare center or library in the City of National City. 18.30.240 URBAN AGRICULTURE A. Purpose The purpose of urban agriculture is to ensure that urban garden areas are appropriately located and protected to meet needs for local food production, community health, recreation, community education, garden -related job training, environmental enhancement, preservation of green space, and community enjoyment. B. Definitions 1. "Coldframe" means an unheated outdoor structure consisting of a wooden or concrete frame and a top of glass or clear plastic, used for protecting seedlings and plans from the cold. 2. "Community farm" is an area of land larger than one -acre managed and maintained by an individual or group of individuals to grow and harvest food and horticultural products for shareholder consumption or for sale or donation. Shareholders may arrange to work on the farm in exchange for a share of the crops and/or pay for a portion of the crop in advance. A community farm may be a principal or accessory use. Sale and donation of food and horticultural products grown in the community farm may occur onsite. 3. "Greenhouse" means a building made of glass, plastic, or fiberglass in which plants are cultivated. 4. "Home garden" means a garden maintained by one or more individuals who reside in a dwelling unit located on the subject property. Food and horticultural; products grown in the home garden may be used for personal consumption or for donation or sale. On -site sales are not permitted. A home garden is an accessory use to a principal residential use. 5. "Hoophouse" means a structure made of PVC piping or other material covered with translucent plastic, constructed in a "half -round" or "hoop" shape. 137 Title 18 Zoning 6. "Neighborhood garden" is an area of land, one acre or less, managed and maintained by an individual or group of individuals to grow and harvest food and horticultural products for personal or group consumption, for sale or donation. A neighborhood garden may be divided into separate garden plots for cultivation by one or more individuals or may be farmed collectively by members of the group. Sale and donation of food and horticultural products grown in the neighborhood garden may occur on -site. A neighborhood garden may be a principal or accessory use. 7. "Rooftop garden" means any garden on the roof of a building. Besides the decorative benefit, roof plantings may provide food, temperature control, hydrological benefits, architectural enhancement, habitats or corridors for wildlife, and recreational opportunities. C. Permitted Primary Uses Cultivation of edible vegetables, flowers, herbs, fruits and other plants in the ground, in raised beds, and in greenhouses which may have occasional sales of items at the site. Sale of nonagricultural times is prohibited. D. Permitted Accessory Uses 1. Only the following accessory uses and structures shall be permitted in both neighborhood gardens and community farms: a. Open space associated with and intended for use as garden areas. b. Signs limited to identification, information and directional signs, including sponsorship information where the sponsorship information is clearly secondary to other permitted information on any particular sign, in conformance with the regulations of the signage sections. c. Benches, bike racks. raised/accessible planting beds, compost bins, picnic tables, seasonal farm stands, fences, garden art, rain barrel systems, and children's play areas. d. Buildings, restroom facilities with composting toilets, and planting preparation houses. e. Off-street parking and walkways, in conformance with the regulations of Chapter 4. f. Tool sheds and shade pavilions. 2. Only the following accessory uses shall be permitted on community farms: a. Greenhouses, hoophouses, coldframes, and similar structures used to extend the growing season. b. Buildings limited to barns, restroom facilities with composting toilets, and planting preparation houses. c. Cold storage. d. Packing facilities. e. Market stands. E. Supplemental Regulations Uses and structures shall be developed and maintained in accordance with the following regulations: • 1. Location. Buildings associated with a community farm or neighborhood garden shall be set back from property lines of a Residential District a minimum distance of ten feet, 2. Height. No building or other structure shall be greater than 16 feet in height. 3. Building Coverage. The combined area of all buildings, excluding greenhouses and hoophouses, shall not exceed 15 percent of the garden site lot areas for community farms and five percent for neighborhood gardens. Buildings and other structures may not exceed 12 feet in height. 4. Parking and walkways. Off-street parking shall be permitted only for those garden sites exceeding 15,000 square feet in lot area. Such parking shall be limited in size to 15 percent of the garden site lot area and must be surfaced in accordance with the parking section of this Land Use Code. Walkways shall be paved in accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). 5. Signs. Signs shall not exceed four square feet in area per side and shall not exceed six feet in height. 138 Title 18 Zoning 6. Farm Stands. Farm stands that sell produce grown on site shall be removed from the premises or stored inside a building on the premises during that time of the year when the garden is not open for public use. 7. Interior fences. Fences around individual garden plots is permitted but not required. Interior fences shall be open and shall not exceed four feet in height. 8. Exterior fences. Fences located on the perimeter of a community farm or neighborhood garden shall not exceed six feet in height, shall be at least 50 percent open if they are taller than four feet, and shall be constructed of wood, chain link, or ornamental (tubular) steel. For any garden that is 15,000 square feet in area or greater and is in a location that is subject to design review and approval by the regulating authority, no fence shall be installed without review by the City Planning Division. 9. Operating rules. The garden management shall have an established set of operating rules addressing the governance structure of the garden, hours of operation, maintenance and security requirements and responsibilities; a garden coordinator to perform the coordinating role for the management of the community gardens; and, must assign garden plots according to the operating rules established for that garden. The name and contact number/address of the garden coordinator and a copy of the operating rules shall be kept on file with the City Planning Division. 10. Hours of Operation. Retail sales and all other public use of the farm shall begin no earlier than 7:OOAM and end by 7:OOPM every day of the week. F. Certain Activities Prohibited 1. Use of insecticides made from synthetic chemical materials is forbidden. 2. Use of synthetic herbicides and weed killers is prohibited. 3. Composting of animal parts is prohibited. 4. Production of intoxicating or poisonous plants is forbidden. 5. Use of chemical rodenticides, except for those that are acceptable under organic regulations. 6. Water, fertilizer, and other organic materials shall not drain onto adjacent property. 7. Use of barbed wire is prohibited. G. Procurement of Water 1. Procurement of water from public supplies should be negotiated between the Sweetwater Authority and the individual or organization conducting agricultural activities on the site. 2. Use of private sources of water, such as water delivered through a hose from a spigot attached to a participant's house, is permitted. 3. Use of onsite rainwater (i.e., rain barrels) shall be permitted providing it is not maintained for human consumption. 4. The use of water for irrigation shall be in conformance with Chapter 4, Section 18.44.190 (Water Efficient Landscape Regulations) of this Land Use Code. H. Toxic or Flammable Chemicals 1. Gasoline used for the operation of lawnmowers or other combustion engine -driven gardening machinery must be kept in sealed containers in locked, ventilated structures. 2. No flammable materials or other chemical except the permitted chemicals mentioned above may be used or stored for an urban agriculture land use. I. Machinery Tractors, lawnmowers, and other farm -related machinery may be used and stored a long as they are in good working order and do not create a nuisance as defined elsewhere in the Municipal Code J. Prevention of Growth of Poisonous or Injurious Weeds 1. Parties using or otherwise occupying urban agriculture land uses are responsible for preventing the growth of those weeds defined as poisonous or injurious. 139 Title 18 Zoning 2. Invasive species as defined by the California Native Plant Society and San Diego County American Society of Landscape Architects are not permitted and shall be promptly removed from the site. K. Handling and Preparation of Food for Sale Refer to County Health Department for rules regarding food and food establishments. These rules are to apply where parties involved in agriculture activities seek to sell food onsite. L. Soil Dangers and Toxicity 1. Prior to implementing neighborhood gardens and community farms and before any food products may be grown in topsoil, such soil should be tested for contaminants that would render it unsuitable for cultivation, including, but not limited to: lead and other toxic heavy metals; industrial solvents; gasoline; perciorethylene; and other chemicals that can be transmitted to people via soil contact or consumption of foods grown in such soil. 2. Area of dry, loose soil that may be moved by wind should be covered by mulch or plastic or otherwise confined. M. Rooftop gardens. For multi -unit residential buildings and residential care facilities, rooftop gardens are highly encouraged. Rooftop gardens are also permitted on nonresidential buildings. Rooftop gardens can be grown in containers or as a "green roof system". A rooftop must be structurally capable of supporting the additional weight of a rooftop garden and the people who use them. Rooftop gardens should: 1. Be accessible to all residents of a residential building. 2. Have access to water. 3. Be provided with a storage area for equipment, material, and gardening tools. 4. Have a minimum safety enclosure of 42 inches in height. 5. Be provided with shade if used by the elderly. 6. Be provided with a composting bin or bins. 18.30.250 VETERINARY HOSPITALS AND CLINICS A. Restriction on Types of Animals Served Veterinary clinics shall be limited to serving only those kinds of small domesticated animals or household pets commonly maintained in residence with man. B. Conditional Use Permit Required Veterinary hospitals or clinics shall be subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. In addition to complying with the provisions of a Conditional Use Permit, such uses shall: 1. Be located no closer than 100 feet to any residential zone, or to any restaurant, hotel or motel; 2. Show that adequate measures and controls have been taken to prevent offensive noise and odor; 3. Not allow the incineration of refuse or animal carcasses on the premises; 4. Not be operated as a kennel. 18.30.260 NEIGHBORHOOD CORNER STORES A. Purpose The Neighborhood corner store is established largely to serve adjacent residential neighborhoods. The corner store allows for a small convenience store. 140 Title 18 Zoning B. Applicability 1. Neighborhood corner stores are permitted in all residential zones, but limited to the following corner sites: a. Intersections of an arterial streets with an arterial street: b. Intersections of an arterial street with a collector street; c. Intersections of a collector street with a collector street. 2. The Circulation Element of the General Plan identifies the locations of all arterial and collector streets. C. Definition A small retail business (3,000 sq. ft. maximum) located in a residential area established for the sale of convenience goods limited to food, groceries, non-alcoholic beverages, toiletries, cleaning products, magazines and newspapers, indoor vending/ATM machines, lottery tickets, over-the-counter medication, and any other products determined by the City to be of the same general character as those listed here. The space devoted to the sale of non-food items shall be limited to 10 percent of the gross floor area. Corner stores are strongly encouraged to provide fresh produce. Outdoor vending machines are not permitted. A corner store may include a single residential unit. A corner store may be accessory to a residential unit. D. Permitted Locations Neighborhood corner stores are permitted in residential zones at intersections of collector and/or arterial streets. E. Setbacks 1. Front and corner side setback. Buildings shall be located between zero feet and ten feet from the front and/or corner side property line. 2. Side/rear setbacks. A corner store shall meet the minimum standards for setbacks of the residential zoning district that it is located. F. Parking Parking is allowed in rear yards but may be permitted in side yards by conditional use. Use of on street parking to meet the parking requirements of corner stores is permitted; however, the number of on street parking spaces used to meet the parking requirements may not extend further than 20 feet beyond the edge of the corner store parcel. G. Architectural standards 1. Building Footprint. The building footprint for any individual nonresidential building shall not exceed 3,000 square feet. The maximum length of building frontage is 75 feet. 2. Building Character. New buildings and renovations to existing buildings shall be harmonious with the character of nearby residential neighborhoods. 3. Drive -through Facilities. Drive through facilities are not permitted. 4. Outdoor Uses. Outdoor uses such as seating and display of fresh produce and flowers may be established consistent with Section 18.30.150 (Outdoor Display of Merchandise). Outdoor display of produce and flowers is limited to a maximum length of 15 percent of the front facing building facade or 15 percent if the facade facing a parking lot. Produce and flowers shall not obstruct the flow of pedestrian traffic. 141 Title 18 Zoning H. Performance standards 1. Lighting. Lighting for the neighborhood corner store shall be appropriately shielded to not negatively impact the residential neighborhood. 2. Hours of operation. Neighborhood corner stores are only permitted to operate between the hours of 7:00am to 10:O0pm. A neighborhood corner store shall be allowed to operate so that neighboring residents are not exposed to offensive noise, especially from traffic, routine deliveries or late night activity. 3. Noise. All neighborhood corner stores shall comply with the noise standards contained in Title 12. No amplified sound including music shall be audible to neighboring residents. 4. Sale of beer, wine, and alcohol prohibited. Neighborhood corner stores are not permitted to sell beer, wine, or other alcohol. Neighborhood corner stores shall not be permitted to apply for a conditional use permit to sell beer, wine, or other alcohol. 18.30.270 MOTELS A. Construction or expansion Any proposal for the construction or expansion of a motel in any zone shall comply with the following standards: 1. All motels shall have a manager's apartment. 2. Kitchen or kitchenette facilities are prohibited in all but the resident manager's unit. 3. All motels shall be located on lots that are at least 20,000 square feet in size and the minimum number of units provided shall be twenty. 4. Motel rooms shall be at least 300 square feet in size including the bathroom. 5. A swimming pool at least 525 square feel in size shall be provided on all sites. 6. On -site parking shall be provided in accordance with Chapter 4. 7. Landscaped areas shall be provided per Chapter 4. 18.30.280 MARKETS THAT SELL SEAFOOD Markets that sell fresh or frozen seafood that are less than 25,000 square feet in area shall be located a minimum distance of 300 feet from any residentially zoned properties. A conditional use permit shall be required for all markets that sell fresh or frozen seafood. This section shall not apply to manufacturers' of prepackaged frozen products. 18.30.290 BED AND BREAKFAST INNS A. Conditions for operating a bed and breakfast inn 1. Permitted in any residence listed on the City's list of historic properties subject to the issuance of a conditional use permit. 2. Operated as an accessory use to the owner's residential use. The bed and breakfast inn shall be operated by the owner of the property only. 3. Check-in/check-out time shall be between 9:00a.m. and 8:00p.m. only. 4. Breakfast shall be the only meal served to guests. 5. No long-term rental of rooms shall be permitted. The maximum stay for guests shall be seven days. 6. No cooking racilities shall be allowed in the guest rooms. 7. If the use at any time becomes unduly intrusive to the neighborhood, the permit may be revoked at the discretion of the Planning Commission. The decision of the Planning Commission shall be final. 8. The historic character of the structure shall be maintained. 9. Bed and breakfast inns shall comply with all applicable adopted City fire and building codes. 10. The number of rooms permitted in the bed and breakfast inn shall be specified in the conditional use permit. 142 Title 18 Zoning B. Design requirements The following design requirements shall apply to all bed and breakfast inns: 1. Parking shall be provided at a ratio of one off-street parking space for each guest room plus two spaces for the owner's unit. In addition, one space shall be provided for each employee of the shift of maximum employment. 2. One sign shall be permitted subject to approval of the Planning Commission at the time of the conditional use permit consideration. Such sign shall be compatible with the historic character of the structure in design, color and materials. The sign shall not exceed twelve inches wide by sixteen inches long and shall be mounted at a maximum height of four feet. Modification of the sign, at a later time, shall be subject to approval of the City Manager or his/her designee in accordance with site plan review. 3. Bed and breakfast inns shall comply with the design regulations for the underlying zone in which the site is located. 4. Bed and breakfast inns shall be subject to the provisions of site plan review. C. Preliminary Departmental Review Prior to submittal for a conditional use permit to operate a bed and breakfast inn, the applicant may request that the Building Official, or his/her designee, and the Fire Marshal, or his/her designee, conduct an inspection of the proposed bed and breakfast inn. After such inspection the applicant will be notified of the findings of the preliminary inspection and given a tentative list of modifications that will be required for the structure as conditions of the conditional use permit. Upon submission of the conditional use permit application and review by the departments, the above list may be added to or deleted from. The Planning Commission shall consider the findings of the Director of Building and Safety and the Fire Chief when considering the conditional use permit. 18.30.300 SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS Solar collectors are permitted outright as an accessory use to any principal use subject to the following standards: Solar collectors are not considered as "reflective roofing materials" and there is no limit to the specific percentage of roof coverage. A. Allowed Height of Solar Energy Systems 1. Single-family: Except within the coastal zone, photovoltaic solar energy systems may extend up to five feet above the height limit in the zoning district. Solar water or swimming pool heating systems may extend up to seven feet above the height limit in the zoning district; 2. All other properties: Except within the coastal zone, photovoltaic solar energy systems may extend up to five feet above the roof surface on which they are installed, even if this exceeds the maximum height limit in the district in which it is located. Solar water or swimming pool heating systems may extend up to seven feet above the roof surface on which they are installed even if this exceeds the maximum height limit in the district in which it is located. B. Side & Rear Yard Setbacks 1. Excluding solar collector panels, solar energy system equipment may be installed within the required side and rear yard but shall not be closer than three feet to any property line. C. Visibility of Solar Energy Systems 1. Excluding solar collector panels, their necessary support structure, and conduit, solar energy systems shall not be visible from the public right-of-way adjacent to the front property line. 2. Solar collector panels, their necessary support structure, and conduit, shall be installed in the location that is the least visible from abutting streets directly facing the subject property so long as installation 143 Title 18 Zoning 3. Solar collector panels, not located on the rooftop of a primary structure, garage, or accessory structure on lots adjacent to RS-land RS-2 zones shall be limited to a maximum height of six feet. Solar collector panels located in all other zones shall comply with the maximum height permitted for an accessory structure in said zone. D. Solar collectors on historic properties 1. Add solar panels on roof surface or roof surfaces not visible from a public street or park. However, solar shingles may be added to a roof surface visible from a public way if low or non -reflective shingles are used. 2. Place solar panels or other solar devices on a non -character -defining roofline of a non -primary elevation (not readily visible from public streets). Run solar panels and devices parallel to the original roofline. 3. Set solar panels and solar devices back from the edge of a flat roof to minimize visibility. Panels and devices may be set at a pitch and elevated, if not highly visible from public streets. 4. Select solar panels, solar devices, mechanical equipment and mounting structures with non -reflective finishes such as an anodized finish. 5. Where permitted, paint mechanical equipment attached to the building fascia the same color as the fascia in order to blend into the building. 6. Locate detached arrays of solar panels and solar devices at a historic site in the rear or side yard if the arrays are not highly visible from the public streets or public parks and do not detract from other major character defining aspects of the site. The location of detached solar arrays should also consider visibility from adjacent properties, which shall be reduced to the extent possible while still maintaining solar access. 7. Use solar devices in non -historic windows, walls, siding or shutters that do not face public streets. 8. Use solar panels and solar devices that are similar in color to roof materials, if available. 18.30.310 TATTOO PARLORS AND BODY -PIERCING ESTABLISHMENTS A. Restrictions 1. No tattoo or body piercing establishment shall be located within one -mile of another such establishment. 2. Tattoo parlors and body -piercing establishments shall be located no less than 1,000 feet from a church, school, or playground. 3. Tattoo parlors and body -piercing establishments shall be no closer than 250 feet from a residential zone. 4. No tattoo and body -piercing establishments shall be located east of Interstate 805. 5. A conditional use permit is required. 18.30.320 PAWN SHOPS AND BUSINESSES ENGAGED IN SECONDHAND DEALING AND/OR THE PURCHASE AND SELLING OF GOLD AND OTHER PRECIOUS METALS A. Restrictions 1. No pawn shops and businesses engaged in secondhand dealing and/or the purchase and selling of gold and other precious metals shall be located within 2,000 feet of another such business. 2. Pawn shops and businesses engaged in secondhand dealing and/or the purchase and selling of gold and other precious metals shall be no closer than 250 feet from residential zones. 3. No pawn shop or businesses engaged in secondhand dealing and/or the purchase and selling of gold and other precious metals shall be located east of Interstate 805. 4. A conditional use permit is required. 144 Title 18 Zoning 5. A pawn shop or businesses engaged in secondhand dealing and/or the purchase and selling of gold and other precious metals which provides payday lending is not exempt from the regulations of payday lenders. 18.30.330 PAYDAY LENDERS A. Restrictions 1. No more than 12 payday lending establishments shall be allowed within National City. 2. Payday lenders shall be located within shopping centers of 50,000 square feet or more and within a multi -tenant building. 3. A conditional use permit is required. 4. A pawn shop which provides payday lending is not exempt from these regulations. 18.30.340 MEDICAL MARIJUANA DISPENSARIES A. Prohibition 1. Medical Marijuana Dispensaries are prohibited. B. Definitions 1. For purposes of this section, "Medical Marijuana Dispensary" shall mean a facility where marijuana is made available for medical purposes in accordance with Section 11362.5 of the California Health and Safety Code. 2. For purposes of this section, "Marijuana" shall have the same meaning as the definition of that word in Section 11018 of the California Health and Safety Code. 18.30.350 AUTO BODY USES A. General Operation and Maintenance 1. A separate Business License shall be required of all autobody businesses operating within the City. 2. An Integrated Maintenance and Operational Plan (IMOP) shall be required of all new autobody businesses. The IMOP shall be maintained on site and provided upon request. The plan shall be in addition to, and complementary with, California's required Injury and Illness Program (IIP). 3. All autobody activities shall be conducted entirely within a building. All sanding, mixing and other pre - painting activities, as well as painting activities, are prohibited to be performed outside of a building, B. Air Pollution 1. Separate spray booths and mixing rooms shall be required. Paint spray booths shall include appropriate ventilation and filtration systems, as well as exhaust filters and/or overspray arrestors. 2. Low -volatile organic compound (VOC)-content paints shall be utilized for all painting processes (e.g., pretreatment coating, primer, paint). 3. All relevant federal, state and/or local air quality authority permits shall be required for new and renewing businesses. All such permits shall be kept current and copies provided with the application for or annual renewal of a City business license. 4. Emissions shall be at least 98% efficient in accordance with the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP), Subpart HHHHHH, or current standard in place at the time of application. 145 Title 18 Zoning C. Hazardous Materials 1. Where possible, hazardous materials, such as used oil, used oil filters, antifreeze, solvents and other materials, shall be recycled. During storage prior to recycling, all waste fluids shall be stored in separate containers. 2. All flammable or combustible materials shall be stored a minimum of 50 feet from the front property line. All such storage shall comply with the adopted Uniform Fire Code. 3. Prep stations or work areas which allow sanding, mixing and other pre -painting activities shall be separated from open work areas. All such prep stations shall be located within separate and properly ventilated areas of the facility where hazardous materials can be controlled. 4. Where practical, floor drains shall not be installed in spray booth areas. If floor drains are necessary, a control system shall be installed that captures and contains waste streams. 5. Floor drains cannot connect to stormwater or sanitary sewer systems near any spray booth areas, hazardous material storage areas (e.g., mixing rooms), or hazardous waste storage areas. 6. All new autobody facilities shall use reusable cloth rags and towels. Rags and towels for disposal shall be stored in a marked container and disposed of at an approved facility. 7. All waste streams, including paints, solvents and automobile fluids, shall be separated and clearly labeled. All containers shall remain closed except when adding or removing waste. D. Parking and Site Layout 1. Parking for auto body uses shall be provided at a ratio of one parking space per 500 square feet of gross floor area. All such parking area shall be located at the rear of the property. 2. Separate ingress and egress shall be provided for new auto body uses. Driveways shall be designed so that vehicles exiting the property may do so in a forward direction. 3. Auto body uses shall be located a minimum of 500 feet from schools or residential properties, as measured from property line to property line. 4. Vehicle access doors (e.g. bay doors, garage doors, roll -up doors) shall be located at the rear of the property. In the case of a corner lot or non -vehicular right-of-way, other methods of screening may be used. 5. Queuing in front of vehicle entry doors shall be provided for no more than four cars. Vehicles in the queue shall not block traffic flow on the property. The queuing area shall be a minimum of 24 feet wide and a maximum of 104 feet long. 6. All vehicle loading and unloading areas shall be located behind the building. E. Noise 1. All repair activities shall be in accordance with Title 12 (Noise Control) of the National City Municipal Code. F. Vehicle Storage 1. All new auto body uses shall provide a minimum of 500 square feet and a maximum of 2,000 square feet of vehicle storage area. 2. Vehicle storage time shall not exceed 30 days. Vehicles awaiting repair shall be stored in a designated storage area and shall not be stored in parking or other open areas. 3. No vehicles shall be stored on adjacent streets or within the public right-of-way. G. Security and Fencing 1. All vehicle storage areas shall be screened from adjacent properties. 2. Fencing or screening shall be solid and decorative in nature, and shall be a minimum of six feet high and a maximum of eight feet high. 146 Title 18 Zoning H. Pollution Prevention 1. No hazardous materials shall be released into any groundwater system. Waste disposal systems including, but not limited to, discharge pits, dry wells, cesspools, septic system drain fields or shallow injection wells are prohibited. 2. Floor drains shall connect to a holding area or separator to collect waste, which shall be disposed of separately. 3. A Storm Water Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) shall be required for all new autobody businesses. The SWPPP shall be consistent with Chapter 14.22 of the National City Municipal Code and shall be available at any time for review by city inspectors. 18.30.360 FAST FOOD EATING PLACES Fast food eating places shall be located a minimum of three hundred feet from any residential zoned properties. 147 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 4 GENERAL DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT REGULATIONS CHAPTER 18-40 — GENERAL STANDARDS 18.40.010 Purpose 18.40.020 Applicability 18.40.030 Performance Standards for All Development and Land Uses CHAPTER 18-41 - SITE PLANNING STANDARDS 18.41.010 Purpose 18.41.020 Non -Residential Site Planning Standards 18.41.030 Multi -Unit Residential Site Planning Standards 18.41.040 Common Usable Open Space Requirements CHAPTER 18-42 - BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS 18.42.010 Purpose 18.42.020 Projections into Setbacks and Courts 18.42.030 Accessory Structures 18.42.040 Screening Mechanical Equipment and Elevator Housing 18.42.050 Commercial and Institutional Building Design Standards 18.42.060 Industrial Building Design Standards 18.42.070 Residential Building Design Standards CHAPTER 18-43 - FENCES AND WALLS 18.43.010 Purpose 18.43.020 Screening Requirements 18.43.030 Parking Lots 18.43.040 Materials, Construction, and Maintenance 18.43.050 Maximum Height 18_43.060 Prohibited Fences 18.43.070 Entry Arbors 18.43.080 Openings in View -Obscuring Fences 18.43.090 Special Fences 18.43.100 Traffic Visibility Triangles CHAPTER 18-44 - LANDSCAPING 18.44.010 Purpose 18.44.020 Applicability 18.44.030 Definitions 18.44.040 Landscape Plan 18.44.050 Requirements 18.44.060 Plant Materials 18.44.070 Turf Lawn 18.44.080 Soils and Mulching 18.44.090 Minimum Percentage of Net Lot Area to be Landscaped 18.44.100 Statuary Structures and Other Lawn Art 18.44.110 Landscape Location Requirements 18.44.120 Tree Preservation 148 Title 18 Zoning 18.44.130 Landscaping Work Included in Building Permit Inspections 18.44.140 Traffic Visibility Triangles 18.44.150 Maintenance Required 18.44.160 Certain Trees a Public Nuisance 18.44.170 Nonconforming Landscaping 18.44.180 Public Utilities 18.44.190 Water Efficient Landscape Regulations CHAPTER 18-45 - OFF-STREET PARKING AND LOADING 18.45.010 18.45.020 18.45.030 18.45.040 18.45.050 18.45.060 18.45.070 18.45.080 18.45.090 18.45.100 18.45.110 18.45.120 Purpose and Intent Requirements, General Offsite Facilities Site Plan Review Required Off -Street Parking Requirement by Land Use Westside Specific Plan Parking Requirements Parking for Commercial Vehicles Opportunities for Reduced Parking Parking for Disabled Persons Parking Lot Design Standards Loading Requirements Bicycle Parking CHAPTER 18-46 - OUTDOOR LIGHTING 18.46.010 Purpose 18.46.020 Applicability 18.46.030 General Standards 18.46.040 Lighting Plan Requirements 18.46.050 Security Lighting 18.46.060 Accent Lighting 18.46.070 Lighting Standards for Uses with 50 Feet of Residential Zones 18.46.080 Parking Lot Lighting 18.46.090 Lighting of Outdoor Performance Sport and Recreational Facilities 18.46.100 Lighting for Multi Unit Attached Residential Projects 18.46.110 Standards for Single Family Residential Uses CHAPTER 18-47 - SIGNS AND OUTDOOR ADVERTISING DISPLAYS 18.47.010 Purpose 18.47.020 Site Plan Review and/or Sign Permit Required 18.47.030 Unlawful Display of Signs or Banners Prohibited 18.47.040 Definitions 18.47.050 Design and Maintenance 18.47.060 Permanent Signs Permitted in all Zones 18.47.070 Large Permanent Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.080 Large Permanent Signs in Shopping Centers 18.47.090 Small Permanent Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Institutional, Mixed -Use, and Multi -Family Zones 18.47.100 Pole -Mounted or Freestanding Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.110 Roof -Mounted Signs 18.47.120 Revolving Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones 18.47.130 Temporary Signs Permitted in All Zones 18.47.140 Projecting Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 149 Title 18 Zoning 18.47.150 Vehicle Signs 18.47.160 Public Assembly Use Signs 18.47.170 Mural Type Signs in Commercial and Mixed -Use Zones 18.47.180 Digital Advertising Display (DAD) Signs 18.47.190 Flags, Banners, and Pennants 18.47.200 Signs Prohibited in All Zones 18.47.210 Master Sign Program 18.47.220 Removal from Abandoned Site or Building 18.47.230 Nonconforming Signs 18.47.240 Constitutional Severability 18.47.250 Non -Commercial Speech 18.47.260 Sign Regulations by Zone and Type 18.47.270 Signs for Special Uses CHAPTER 18-48 - DENSITY BONUS AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING INCENTIVES 18.48.010 Purpose 18.48.020 Definitions 18.48.030 Density Bonus 18.48.040 Concessions, Incentives, and Development Standards 18.48.050 Application Requirements and Review 18.48.060 Density Bonus Housing Agreement CHAPTER 18-40 GENERAL STANDARDS 18.40.010 Purpose 18.40.020 Applicability 18.40.030 Performance Standards for All Development and Land Uses 18.40.010 PURPOSE This chapter expands upon the standards of Chapter 2 by addressing details of site planning, building design, landscaping, parking and loading, outdoor lighting, and signs and outdoor advertising displays. These standards are intended to ensure that all development produces an environment of stable and desirable character, is compatible with existing and future development, and protects the use and enjoyment of neighboring properties, consistent with the General Plan. 18.40.020 APPLICABILITY The requirements of this chapter shall apply to existing and new development and land uses and shall be considered in combination with the standards for the applicable zone in Chapter 2 and Specific Use Regulations in Chapter 3. 1f there is conflict, the standards in Chapter 3 shall control. 18.40.030 PERFORMANCE STANDARDS FOR ALL DEVELOPMENT AND LAND USES A. Purpose This section provides performance standards that are designed to minimize various potential operational impacts of land uses and development within the city, and promote compatibility with adjoining areas and land uses. B. Applicability The provisions of this section apply to all new and existing land uses, in all zones, unless an exemption is specifically provided. 150 Title 18 Zoning C. Noise No use shall be established nor any activity conducted which violates the standards of the Noise Control Ordinance --Title 12 of the Municipal Code. D. Air emissions Other than as permitted by the County of San Diego Air Pollution Control District, no visible dust, gasses, or smoke shall be emitted. E. Combustibles and explosives The use, handling, storage, and transportation of combustibles and explosives shall comply with the Uniform Fire Code and California Code of Regulations Title 19. F. Dust Activities that may generate dust emissions (e.g., construction, grading, commercial gardening, and similar operations) shall be conducted to limit the emissions beyond the site boundary to the maximum extent feasible. Appropriate methods of dust management shall include the following, subject to approval by the Building Division. 1. Water all active construction areas twice per day and use erosion control measures to prevent water runoff containing silt and debris from entering the streets and storm drain system; 2. Cover trucks hauling soil, sand, and other loose material; 3. Pave, water, or apply non -toxic soil stabilizers on unpaved access roads and parking areas; 4. Sweep and collect (i.e., vacuum) paved access roads and parking areas daily; and 5. Sweep and collect (Le., vacuum) streets daily if visible material is carried onto adjacent public streets. 6. Hydroseed or apply non -toxic soil stabilizers to inactive construction areas; 7. Enclose, cover, water, or apply non -toxic soil binders to open materials stockpiles; 8. Limit traffic speeds on unpaved roads to 15 mph; 9. Install sandbags or other erosion control measures to prevent silt runoff to public roadways; 10. Replant vegetation in disturbed areas within ten days after project completion; 11. Install wheel washers for all exiting trucks, or wash off the tires or tracks of all trucks and equipment leaving the site; 12. Install wind breaks, or plant trees/vegetation at windward sides of construction areas, or avoid removing existing vegetation which acts as a windbreak; 13. Suspend excavation and grading activity when winds (instantaneous gusts) exceed 20 mph or dust clouds cannot be prevented from extending beyond the site; and, 14. Limit area subject to excavation, grading, and other construction activities at any one time. 15. Limit access to the construction sites, so tracking of mud or dirt on to public roadways can be prevented 16. Projects that have significant construction period exhaust emissions shall reduce fleet average emission rates. Developers or contractors shall provide a plan for approval by the City or SDAPCD demonstrating that the heavy-duty (>50 horsepower) off -road vehicles to be used in the construction project for more than an accumulated 40 hours, including owned, leased and subcontractor vehicles, will achieve emission standards similar to in -use equipment that meets CARB certified Tier II standards. G. Ground vibration No ground vibration shall be generated that is perceptible without instruments by a reasonable person at the property lines of the site, except for vibrations from temporary construction or demolition activities, and motor vehicle operations. 151 Title 18 Zoning H. Light and glare 1. Outdoor fighting shall comply with the requirements of Chapter 18-46 (Outdoor Lighting). 2. Any operation or activity producing glare shall be conducted or shielded so as not to cause illumination in residential zones in excess of five -tenths footcandles. Flickering or intrinsically bright sources of illumination shall be controlled so as not to be a nuisance in residential zones. 3. Illumination levels shall be measured with a photoelectric photometer having a spectral response similar to that of the human eye, following the standard spectral luminous efficiency curve adopted by the Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA). I. Liquid waste No liquid shall be discharged into a public or private body of water, sewage system, watercourse, or into the ground, except in compliance with applicable regulations of the Regional Water Quality Control Board. J. Odor 1. No obnoxious odor or fumes shall be emitted that are perceptible without instruments by a reasonable person at the property line of the site. For mixed -use buildings, commercial uses that emit odors, such as restaurants and nail salons, shall be properly ventilated to as not to impact adjoining residential uses. 2. No use shall be established nor any activity conducted which violates the standards of the Odor Control Ordinance --Title 7.08—Environmental Conditions of the Municipal Code. K. Radioactivity, electrical disturbance or electromagnetic interference None of the following shall be emitted: 1. Radioactivity, in a manner that does not comply with all applicable State and Federal regulations; or 2. Electrical disturbance or electromagnetic interference that interferes with normal radio or television reception or with the function of other electronic equipment beyond the property line of the site; or that does not comply with all applicable Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and other applicable State and Federal regulations. CHAPTER 18-41 — SITE PLANNING STANDARDS 18.41.010 Purpose 18.41.020 Non -Residential Site Planning Standards 18.41.030 Multi -Unit Residential Site Planning Standards 18.41.040 Common Usable Open Space Requirements 18.41.010 PURPOSE The purpose of this Chapter is to provide guidance and standards for site planning for nonresidential and multi -unit residential development in order to enhance safety, convenience and attractiveness for walking, transit use and bicycling; provide safe access to businesses and minimize pedestrian conflicts; and foster an attractive, quality environment to foster community pride and attract desired development and uses. 18.41.020 NON-RESIDENTIAL SITE PLANNING STANDARDS These standards apply to those areas in the city that will be developed as commercial use without a residential component (mixed -use) or areas where only a commercial use is permitted. This section considers two basic types of development: freestanding buildings and multi -tenant strip developments including mini -malls. 152 Title 18 Zoning A. Shopping Center Development 1. When shopping centers are set back from the street with parking in front, 30% of the street frontage shall be lined with buildings. 2. Parking lots for shopping centers should provide vehicular connections to adjacent commercial projects. 3. Pedestrian walkways for shopping centers should provide pedestrian connections to adjacent uses. 4. Access drives for commercial centers should be located at least 200 feet apart and at least 100 feet from any major intersection. Access drives should be located a minimum of ten feet from property lines unless a shared drive is provided. 5. For neighborhood -serving and convenience retail centers and office and institutional developments, the first row of parking which is perpendicular to an access drive from a street shall be set back at least 40 feet from the sidewalk to provide adequate queuing distance from the street and for pedestrian safety. Larger community or regional retail centers may require significantly more setback area as determined by the Engineering Division. B. Freestanding or "Pad" Buildings 1. Except for drive-through/drive-in establishments, parking for freestanding retail or "pad" buildings fronting a public street shall be located a maximum of 20 feet from the property line. Freestanding buildings adjacent to a public street are discouraged from being separated from the sidewalk with parking. 2. The building entry shall be accentuated with architectural details and landscaping. 3. Freestanding restaurants may provide outdoor seating at the building entry. C. Drive -Through Businesses 1. Minimum vehicular queuing distance shall be established through the conditional use permit process. 2. Drive through business aisles shall have a minimum interior turning radius of 25 feet for any curves. 3. A drive -through window or lane shall not be placed between the right-of-way or internal drive and the associated building unless a ten foot wide landscape strip extending the entire length of the drive - through queuing is installed and maintained with a minimum three foot height continuous hedge and ornamental trees spaced a minimum of 20 feet on center. D. Industrial Site Planning Standards Planning standards for industrial buildings and business parks include the following: 1. Services areas shall be located at the sides or rear of buildings. Service areas located at the exterior side of buildings shall be screened from view by a combination of screen walls, landscaping, and/or portions of the building. 2. Loading areas must be designed so that trucks will not need to back in from the public street onto the site. 3. Parking for visitors shall be convenient to the main entrance. 4. Emphasis shall be placed on the building entry. 5. Buildings should be oriented so as to provide space for plazas and courtyards. 6. Outdoor storage and equipment shall be screened from public right-of-ways. E. Pedestrian Walkways 1. A pedestrian walkway within a retail center, office, industrial or institutional development shall be a minimum of five feet wide. Pedestrian walkways immediately adjacent to and perpendicular to parking stalls shall be a minimum of six feet wide. 2. Materials for pedestrian walkways may include concrete, concrete pavers, brick, stone or combination thereof or materials as approved by the Planning Division. 153 Title 18 Zoning 3. A pedestrian walkway shall provide direct pedestrian access from peripheral sidewalks to the sidewalks that front on -site buildings and building entrances. 18.41.030 MULTI -UNIT RESIDENTIAL SITE PLANNING STANDARDS A. Pedestrian Access 1. Unit entries adjacent to a street. Multi -unit projects should be designed with each unit adjacent to a street having its primary pedestrian entrance from the street sidewalk, or as forecourt projects with at at least the primary building entrance having access to the street sidewalk. Where individual units have access to the street sidewalk, private "front yard" outdoor space may be differentiated from the public right-of-way by a porch, or small yard (i.e., patio) enclosed by a low wall or fence not to exceed 42 inches in height. 2. Pedestrian walkways shall be provided to every unit entry. 3. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 4450, et seq., of Chapter 7 of Title 1 of the Municipal Code, containing requirements for facilities necessary to assure access and usability for the physically handicapped, in all multi -unit residential projects the following provisions shall apply: a. Safe, convenient, well -drained pedestrian access to dwelling units, parking lots, and service areas, by provision of walks, steps or stepped ramps, so constructed as to assure reasonable durability and economy of maintenance, shall be required. b. Pedestrian walkways shall be a minimum of 36 inches in width. c. Pedestrian walkways shall be graded or ramped to no steeper than a one -to -twelve slope. 154 Title 18 Zoning 18.41.040 A. Purpose COMMON USABLE OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS The purpose of this section is to prescribe standards for the development of open space areas provided for the exclusive use of the occupants of a multi -unit residential building. B. Standards 1. For projects of three units or more, common usable open space shall be required in a minimum amount of 300 square feet per dwelling unit. 2. Private usable open space may be substituted for such common usable open space but may not exceed 100 square feet per unit. Each square foot of private usable open space shall be considered equivalent to two square feet of required common usable open space, and may be so substituted, subject to the minimum requirements for actual common usable open space. All units shall be provided with at least 60 square feet of private usable open space. 3. Both common and private usable open space provided at ground level may be provided in the interior side yard and rear yard setback areas, within courts, and within exterior side yard setback areas to within five feet of the property line. 4. Private usable open space provided above the first floor may be located in the front setback area to within 12 feet of the front property line. 5. A minimum of 40 percent of the required common usable open space shall be provided outdoors. 6. Common usable open space areas shall have no dimension less than 20-feet. 7. Private usable open space areas shall have no dimension less than 5-feet. 8. See the Westside Specific Plan for other open space requirements related to the MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones. CHAPTER 18-42 - BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS 18.42.010 Purpose 18.42.020 Projections into Setbacks and Courts 18.42.030 Accessory Structures 18.42.040 Screening Mechanical Equipment and Elevator Housing 18.42.050 Commercial and Institutional Building Design Standards 18.42.060 Industrial Building Design Standards 18.42.070 Residential Building Design Standards 18.42.010 PURPOSE The purpose of standards for building design and materials is to focus efforts on good design in order to create a quality image for the city, making new buildings and building additions compatible with their surroundings, encourage reinvestment, and improve the city's economic vitality. These standards apply to those areas in the city that will be developed as a commercial or institutional use without a residential component (mixed -use) or areas where only a commercial or institutional use is permitted. 18.42.020 PROJECTIONS INTO SETBACKS AND COURTS A. Requirements -- General Every required front, side, and rear setback shall be open and unobstructed from the ground to the sky, unless otherwise provided. In addition to permitted accessory buildings and structures, the following structures may be erected or projected into any required setback: 1. Fences and walls may be erected or projected into any required setback as provided in this section. 2. Cornices, belt courses, sills, eaves, or other similar architectural features (other than bay windows or vertical projections) may project into a required interior side setback not more than two inches for 155 Title 18 Zoning 3. Eaves may project into a required interior side setback not more than four inches for each one foot of width of such side setback, provided the width of such side setback is not reduced to less than two and one-half feet. Eaves may also project into any other required setback, passageway or other open space not more than 30 inches, provided the width of an exterior side setback is not reduced to less than two and one-half feet. 4. Chimneys may project into a required setback, passageway or other required open space not more than two feet, provided the width of any required side setback is not reduced to less than three feet. 5. Fire escapes may project into any setback not more than four feet. 6. Open unenclosed stairways or balconies, not covered by a roof or canopy, may project into a required rear setback not more than four feet, and into a required front setback, exterior side setback side or other required open space not more than 30 inches, provided the width of an exterior side setback is not reduced to less than two and one-half feet. 7. Open, unenclosed porches, platforms or landing places, including access stairways, not covered by a roof or canopy, which do not extend above the level of the first floor of the building, may project into any required setback passageway or other open space not more than four feet, provided that in no event shall any such porch, platform or landing place be more than four feet above the adjacent natural ground level. 8. A one-story unenclosed breezeway, not over five feet in width, extending from a main residential building to an accessory parking or other accessory structure, may project into a required rear or exterior side yard setback a distance not to exceed the required setback of the accessory structure. 9. Awnings or canopies without enclosing walls or screening may be attached to the exterior walls of a residential structure provided that: a. Such awnings or canopies do not extend more than four feet into a required front setback and have no vertical support within the setback or space; b. Such awnings or canopies do not extend more than 30 inches into a required side setback, rear setback, or other required open space, but in no event nearer than 30 inches to an interior lot line; c. Where such awnings or canopies project into a required front or side setback or other required open space, they may extend only over the windows or doors to be protected and for 12 inches on each side thereof. 10. Entry arbors, either freestanding or as part of a fence as provided for in this section. 18.42.030 ACCESSORY STRUCTURES A. Conditions Accessory structures and uses may be developed as permitted in this title, provided they are located on the same lot or parcel of land, and are incidental to and do not substantially alter the character of the principal permitted use. B. Alteration No accessory structure shall be structurally altered, converted, enlarged or maintained for the purpose of providing a second dwelling units unless such accessory structures are made to conform to all regulations of this title for new structures. C. Westside Specific Plan Accessory structures in the RS-4 Zone shall maintain a three foot setback from the side lot line and the rear lot line and a minimum of six feet between structures, but shall not be located in the front yard setback required except as provided by this title. 18.42.040 SCREENING MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT AND ELEVATOR HOUSING 156 Title 18 Zoning A. Standards Applicable to All Zones 1. All mechanical equipment located at ground level shall be enclosed within a permanent noncombustible enclosure subject to the approval of the building official, and subject to all yard and setback regulations. 2. All elevator housing and mechanical equipment located on the roof of any building shall be screened from adjacent views and contained within a completely enclosed penthouse or portion of the same building having walls and roofs with construction and appearance similar to the building served by the equipment and other appurtenances. 18.42.050 COMMERCIAL AND INSTITUTIONAL BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS A. Applicability This section provides standards for commercial buildings including retail, service, office, and institutional buildings in any zone where they are permitted. B. Commercial Retail Buildings 1. Large format retail or anchor stores. a. Ground floor facades that face public streets shall have arcades, pergolas or galleries; display windows, accentuated entries or entry pavilions; awnings; raised planters; or special corner treatments such as towers, turrets, angled corners with parapets, or similar architectural treatments on at least 60 percent of the total facade length. b. Facades greater than 120 feet in length measured horizontally shall incorporate wall plane projections or recesses having a depth of at least two percent of the length of the facade and extending at least 25 percent of the length of the facade. c. A minimum of 25 percent transparency (clear vision glass) is required on the ground floor of a large format retail or anchor store. 2. Freestanding or "pad" buildings. a. Freestanding retail buildings fronting a sidewalk shall be provided with sufficient display windows meeting the transparency requirements identified in Subsection E below. b. Freestanding retail or "pad" buildings within centers (multi -tenant strip developments) that do not front on a public street shall exhibit a minimum of a 50 percent window to 50 percent wall on al least three building facades. 3. Retail shops/multi-tenant development. a. Buildings facades within a multi -tenant development must provide a repeating pattern that shall include at least one of the following elements at horizontal intervals of no more than 30 feet: i. Color change; ii. Texture change; iii. Material change; or iv. Structural bay expression through a change in plane no less than 12 inches in width such as an offset, reveal, or project rib. b. Retail storefronts set back from a street with parking in front shall provide a minimum 60 percent transparency through the use of clear vision windows and doors when located along a sidewalk, building arcade or gallery. c. Doors and windows mounted flush with the wall surface shall not be used unless in conjunction with an arcade or covered walkway. Doors and windows shall be set back in their wall openings to reveal the thickness of the wall when an arcade or covered walkway is not provided. C. Building Aesthetics and Materials 1. Articulation is required to reduce the mass and scale of large monolithic commercial buildings. Articulation is required on at least three sides of a building's facade by use of color, changes in 157 Title 18 Zoning 2. Any side of an office, commercial and institutional building visible from or adjacent to residential areas or residentially zoned lands shall be treated in the same manner as the street facing facade. 3. For buildings that front on a public right-of-way, internal private street or private drive intended to function as a street, the following minimum standards for transparency or clear vision glass are required: a. Ground floor retail: 60 percent. b. Upper story retail: 40 percent. c. Ground floor office or institutional: 50 percent. d. Second floor office or institutional: 35 percent. 4. Rooflines. a. Both single and multi -tenant buildings shall have variations in the roorlines and roof features that are consistent with the buildings mass and scale. Roofs shall meet at least two of the following requirements: i. Decorative parapets that are a minimum of three feet in height. ii. A three-dimensional cornice treatment a minimum of 12 inches in height. iii. Overhanging eaves that extend at least two feet beyond the building facade. iv. Three or more roof planes. v. Any other treatment that in the opinion of the Planning Division, meets the intent of this section. 5. Exterior facades of new buildings should be constructed of materials which will withstand the abuses of weathering and possible defacing due to vandalism. These materials should be easily maintained and attractive from any distance. In the commercial and mixed -use zones, the exteriors of all buildings or accessory structures shall be constructed of stucco, masonry, architectural concrete masonry units, pre -cast concrete, rock, and/or wood or wood simulated siding; provided, however, that all buildings or structures shall have an integrated color or painted exterior. a. Metal for use as a primary exterior building material is not permitted. The use of metal is permitted only as an accent material and may not exceed ten percent of each building facade face. b. Building fronts shall incorporate and present either a finished parapet or overhang to the street. c. All roof edges shall be finished with facia and/or combination fascia gutter. d. Finished soffits are required. e. The use of decorative materials to enhance the aesthetic appearance of the building or structure shall be required on any portion of the building or structure abutting upon a public street. 6. The exterior walls of all buildings or structures constructed within the commercial and mixed -use zones shall be of new material; provided, however, that quality used materials such as rock, red brick, or decorative masonry may be permissible. Other forms of architectural treatment of used materials may be approved by the Planning Division. 7. Color. a. The use of colors on the exterior of a building shall be limited to an appropriate and complementary palette. b. Large areas of intense white color shall be avoided except on rooftops. c. The color palette chosen for a building should be compatible with the colors of adjacent buildings except where existing buildings strongly diverge from these standards. d. Fluorescent or neon colors shall be avoided. 8. Accessory structures shall have compatible architectural details, design elements, and roof designs as the primary structure. 9. Trash and recycling enclosures. a. Standards are found in Title 7, Section 7.10.080 (Enclosures required). b. Enclosures shall be provided with receptacles for both rubbish and recyclable materials. c. Enclosures shall be constructed with a roof. 158 Title 18 Zoning D. Prohibited Exterior Wall Materials The following materials are prohibited as a primary exterior wall material: 1. Unfinished concrete and concrete block, except split -face concrete block or slump block. 2. Corrugated metal, standing seam metal, or other metal wall materials. 3. Reflective mirror -type glass. 4. Plywood, including T-11 or similar wood products. 5. Imitation "rock work" veneer. 6. Corrugated fiberglass. 7. Asphalt shingles. 8. Plastic or plastic laminates. E. Prohibited Roofing Materials The following materials are prohibited for use as a roofing material: 1. Corrugated metal. 2. High contrast or brightly colored glazed tile, except where desirable for accent purposes. 3. Highly reflective surfaces. 4. Aluminum sheet metal. 18.42.060 INDUSTRIAL BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS A. Building Aesthetics and Materials 1. Long unbroken building facades shall be avoided. Facades with varied front setbacks shall be required. 2. Warehouses shall avoid blank front and exterior side wall elevations on street frontages through the use of building indentations and architectural details. 3. Building entrances to industrial use buildings shall be enhanced with architectural elements and landscaping for emphasis. 4. Materials. a. All buildings and structures shall be constructed of metal, stucco, masonry, architectural concrete masonry units, pre -cast concrete, rock, and/or wood or wood simulated siding, and shall have an integrated color or painted exterior. b. 30 percent, including doors, of the gross area, to a 12 foot height, of any building or structure abutting on the front or exterior side yard of a lot shall be constructed of, or surfaced with, glass, stone, wood, brick, and/or decorative masonry as architectural treatment to increase the aesthetic appearance of the building. On a corner lot, if the treatment required on the exterior side yard is concentrated on the corner of the building or structure and is located nearest the corner of the intersecting streets, the percentage of required area for decorative purposes may be reduced on the exterior side yard to ten percent. c. Where the end use of any building or structure prohibits the use of decorative materials in either the front or exterior side of any building or structure or it is not economically feasible to use decorative materials, a color combination of the exterior surface of integrated or painted finish may be permitted, subject to site plan review. d. The exterior walls of all buildings or structures in the industrial zones shall be of new material; provided, however, that quality used materials such as rock, red brick, or decorative masonry may be permissible. Other forms of architectural treatment of used materials may be approved by the Planning Division. e. Metal buildings shall have the architectural appearance of conventionally built structures and an exterior surface that includes stucco, plaster, glass, stone, wood, brick, decorative masonry, or wood sheathing. 5. Trash and recycling enclosures a. Standards are found in Title 7, Section 7.10.080 (Enclosures required). 159 Title 18 Zoning b. Enclosures shall be provided with receptacles for both rubbish and recyclable materials. c. Enclosures shall be constructed with a roof. 18.42.070 RESIDENTIAL BUILDING DESIGN STANDARDS A. Multi -Unit Residential Building Design Standards 1. The exterior design, height, and bulk of multi -unit projects should not negatively impact adjacent lower density residential areas. 2. Fagade and roof articulation. A structure with three or more attached units should incorporate wall and roof articulation to reduce apparent scale. Changes in wall planes and roof heights, and elements such as balconies, porches, arcades, dormers, and cross gables can avoid a barracks -like quality. Long flat walls and roofs shall be avoided. Secondary hipped or gabled roofs covering the entire mass of a building are preferred. 3. Scale. Because multi -unit projects are usually taller than one story, their bulk can be imposing on surrounding uses. Structures with greater height may require additional setbacks at the ground floor level and/or upper levels. 4. Balconies porches or patios as part of multi -unit structures are required. These elements shall be used to break up large wall masses, offset floor setbacks, and add human scale to structures, and increase neighborhood safety by providing opportunities for "eyes on the street". Individual unit entrances within a multi -unit project shall have individual covered porches. 5. Trash and recycling enclosures. a. Standards are found in Title 7, Section 7.10.080 (Enclosures required). b. Enclosures shall be provided with receptacles for both rubbish and recyclable materials. c. Enclosures shall be constructed with a roof. 6. Laundry facilities. For multi -unit residential projects containing nine units or more that do not provide a washer and dryer for each unit, the following laundry facilities shall be provided: one washer and one dryer for each 20 dwelling units. The minimum requirement shall be one washer plus one dryer for multi -unit residential projects containing nine to 20 dwelling units. 7. Storage space. In all multi -unit residential projects, a storage space of not less than 150 cubic feet for each unit plus 50 cubic feet for each additional bedroom more than one. The cubic feet utilized by mechanical equipment (e.g., water heater, furnace, etc.) may not be included in the cubic footage requirement. A bedroom closet shall not be included in the cubic footage requirement. B. Mobile Homes 1 Factory -Built Housing 1. Definition. Factory -built housing includes modular housing and residential structures certified under the National Mobile Home Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974 and as defined in 798.3 of the Civil Code. All factory -built housing and the lot on which it is placed shall comply with all applicable provisions of Title 18 of the National City Municipal Code and the Design Guidelines. 2. Eligibility. A mobile home shall not be located on a permanent foundation, on a private lot, unless it: a. Was constructed after September 15, 1971, and was issued an insignia of approval by the California Department of Housing and Community Development or was constructed after July 1, 1976, and was issued an insignia of approval by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development; and, b. Has not been altered in violation of applicable codes. 3. Criteria. Mobile homes placed on a permanent foundation system, on a private lot, shall: a. Be occupied only as a residential use type; b. Meet all requirements for the zone in which located; c. Be attached to a foundation system in compliance with all applicable building regulations and Section 18551 of the Health and Safety Code; d. Have a minimum width of 20 feet; 160 Title 18 Zoning e. Be covered with an exterior material customarily used on conventional dwellings and approved by the planning division pursuant to site plan review. The exterior covering material shall extend to the ground, except that when a solid concrete or masonry perimeter foundation is used, the exterior covering material need not extend below the top of the foundation; f. Have a roof consisting of shingles or other material customarily used on conventional dwellings; g. A mobile home may be required to have a porch, eaves or roof with eaves when it is determined, pursuant to site plan review, it is necessary to have it compatible with the dwellings in the area. 4. Foundation system. The most recently adopted California Building Code specifies regulations for the mobile home foundation system. These regulations provide: a. Foundation system definition. A "foundation system" is an assembly of material constructed below, or partly below grade, not intended to be removed from its installation site, which is designed to support the structure and engineered to resist the imposition of external natural forces; b. That mobile home foundation systems be designed in accordance with the provisions of the most recently adopted California Building Code, and local soil conditions. Design conditions for roof, wind, and seismic loads applicable to permanent building foundations shall be applicable to the mobile home foundation system; c. The mobile home shall be installed in accordance with installation instructions provided by: d. The manufacturer of the mobile home, or. e. A California -licensed architect or engineer for an individual mobile home where manufacturer's installation instructions are not available; f. That both the foundation system and connection of the mobile home to the foundation system shall be capable of withstanding the design loads and concentrated loads identified in the installation instructions; g. A foundation system plan shall be provided in addition to the installation instructions. The foundation system plan may be: i. Provided by the mobile home manufacturer either as a part of, or separate from, the installation instructions, ii. Provided by the installation contractor, iii. Required to be signed by a California -licensed architect or engineer; iv. A foundation system plan approved by the California Department of Housing and Community Development will be accepted. 5. Utility connections. The mobile home electrical, gas, water and drain connections shall be made permanent in a mariner applicable to permanent buildings. Gas shut-off valves, meters and regulators shall not be located beneath the mobile homes. 6. Surrender of registration. Prior to occupancy, the owner shall request a certification from the Planning Division that a certificate of occupancy be issued pursuant to Section 18551 (b) (2) of the California Health and Safety Code. Thereafter, for an existing mobile home, any vehicle license plate, certificate of ownership and certificate of registration issued by a state agency is to be surrendered to the appropriate state agencies. 7. Park and school fees. Mobile homes placed on a permanent foundation shall be subject to local park and school fees in the same manner as conventional single-family dwellings. 8. Modification of criteria. Modification of the criteria set forth in this section may be granted by the Planning Division if the site plan review finds that such modification will not be detrimental to the public interest or surrounding residents or properties. No such modification may be granted from Subsections 3a, 3b, and 3c of this section. 9. Additions. Additions to a mobile home placed on a permanent foundation shall be made in accordance with all applicable laws, codes, and ordinances enforced by the City, and installation instructions provided by (site plan review required): a. The manufacturer of the mobile home; or, b. A California -licensed architect or engineer; or, c. A building addition plan approved by the California Department of Housing and Community Development. C. Single Family Infill Standards 161 Title 18 Zoning 1. Architectural considerations. a. New single family projects should incorporate the distinctive architectural characteristics of surrounding development, for example: window and door detailing, decoration, materials, roof style and pitch, finished -floor height, porches, bay windows, dormers, chimneys, balconies, shutters, decorative molding, and similar architectural details. b. Rooflines of building additions shall be constructed to integrate the addition with the existing building. Contrasting rooflines which emphasize the separate construction of the addition, such as shed roofs extending from the wall of a structure with a hip or gable roof are prohibited. c. Exterior materials, window details, and colors of building additions should match those of existing structures. d. Roof pitches in common use in the residential neighborhood are gable and hip. New residential construction and additions should incorporate roofs which are compatible with the existing neighborhood style. Minimize the use of flat roofs unless the surrounding context suggests their use, or the structure being added on to has a flat roof. e. Walls should be of either wood or simulated wood clapboard or stucco where the style and context would allow it. Brick or stone is recommended as an accent material. Clay file is also a very suitable material for roofs and accents, but very shiny glazed roof tile should be avoided. f. If concrete block is used for exterior wall construction, it shall receive a finish coat of stucco. g. While two-story construction is considered acceptable in single -story neighborhoods, the structure should incorporate both vertical and horizontal variations in the wall planes in order to reduce the overall bulk of the project and develop a smaller scale to be compatible with adjacent single story structures. h. The use of any roof mounted equipment is highly discouraged for single family units. If alternatives are not feasible, equipment must be screened from view in a manner which blends with the architectural style of the house, including use of materials and colors. 2. Site design considerations. a. New development should continue the functional, on -site relationships of the surrounding neighborhood. For example, in many older neighborhoods, common patterns that should be continued are entries facing the street, front porches, and parking at the rear. b. Front setbacks for new single family development in existing neighborhoods should be either: i. Equal to the average setback of all residences and buildings on both sides of public streets within 100 feet of the property lines of the new project or ii. Equal to the average of the two immediate adjacent buildings. c. In cases where averaging between two adjacent existing buildings is chosen, the new building may be averaged in a stepping pattern. d. Side yard setbacks in the neighborhood create a certain rhythm along the street. New projects or additions should be respectful of the open space pattern created by these setbacks. CHAPTER 18-43 -- FENCES AND WALLS 18.43.010 Purpose 18.43.020 Screening Requirements 18.43.030 Parking Lots 18.43.040 Materials, Construction, and Maintenance 18.43.050 Maximum Height 18.43.060 Prohibited Fences 18.43.070 Entry Arbors 18.43.080 Openings in View -Obscuring Fences 18.43.090 Special Fences 18.43.100 Traffic Visibility Triangles 18.43.010 PURPOSE 162 Title 18 Zoning The purpose of this Chapter is to establish regulations for fences and walls. The intent is to enhance the aesthetic appearance of property by providing standards relating to the quality of design materials; to create buffers between different land uses; and to protect the public health, safety, and welfare. 18.43.020 SCREENING REQUIREMENTS A. Between Land Uses 1. Where the side or rear setback of a commercial or industrial use abuts a residential zone, those side or rear setbacks of the commercial or industrial use shall be screened from the residential zone by an opaque fence or wall with a minimum six feet and a maximum height not to exceed eight feet. 2. Where the side or rear setback of a multi -family residential use abuts a single family residential zone, those side or rear setbacks of the multi -family residential use shall be screened from the single- family residential zone by and opaque fence or wall with a minimum six feet and a maximum height not to exceed eight feet. 18.43.030 PARKING LOTS A. Screening 1. Parking lots shall be screened from adjacent residential zones and adjacent streets with a five- to six- foot high fence or wall within a five foot wide landscape buffer. 2. The screening requirements for parking lots may be waived when the parking lot serves the structure or use to which the parking is accessory. 3. Required screening shall be continuous, broken only for access driveways and walkways. 18.43.040 MATERIALS, CONSTRUCTION, AND MAINTENANCE A. Fences and Walls 1. All fences and walls shall be constructed of new or good used material, and all fences and walls shall be kept in good repair and adequately maintained. Any dilapidated, dangerous, or unsightly fences or walls shall be removed, unless otherwise required, or repaired. 2. All masonry walls shall conform to the requirements of the California Building Code. All masonry walls require a building permit. 3. Wood fencing must be constructed using pressure -treated wood posts set in concrete footings. 4. Vinyl fencing is permitted 5. Chain link fences. Chain link fencing of minimum nine -gauge wire and three and one-half inch by five inch mesh with two and one-half inch by five -sixteenths inch redwood slats may be used in screening residential or industrial areas. 18.43.050 MAXIMUM HEIGHT A. Fences and Walls 1. Fences and walls not exceeding eight feet in height and hedges may be located in setback areas; provided, that if located in any front setback or exterior side setback of any corner lot, they shall not exceed four feet in height, except that a residentially developed property in a residential zone may have a fence, wall or hedge not exceeding six feet in height within the exterior side setback of a corner lot. 2. Fences, walls and hedges over four feet in height shall not be permitted in the rear setback area of a reversed corner lot where such reverse corner lot abuts a front setback of the key lot at the rear. 3. The height of retaining walls contributes to the allowable height of fences and walls; provided, that within interior side setbacks and rear setbacks, the required height of screens or protective fences 163 Lille 18 Zoning 4. Masonry walls shall not exceed a height of eight feet. Masonry walls that include a retaining wall shall not exceed a maximum height of six feet for the masonry wall and two feet eight inches for the retaining wall. 5. Up to 30 percent of the length of a fence may exceed the height limits specified in this section by up to six inches. 18.43.060 PROHIBITED FENCES A. Materials 1. The use of barbed wire, electrified fence, concertina or razor wire fence in conjunction with any fence, wall, or hedge, or by itself within any zoning district, is prohibited in residential and commercial zones unless required by law or regulation of the City, the State, or the Federal Government. 2. The use of barbed wire above six feet in height is only allowed in industrial zones except for front and exterior side yards. 3. In the Westside Specific Plan area, the use of chain link, barbed wire and razor wire fencing shall be prohibited. 18.43.070 ENTRY ARBORS A. Requirements Arbors may be placed freestanding, or at entrances along fences within required front and exterior side setbacks, subject to the following standards: 1. The height of the arbor shall not exceed ten feet. 2. The width of the arbor shall not exceed six feet between centerlines of the supports. 3. A maximum two -foot overhang is permitted on each side of the center of the supports. 4. The depth of the arbor shall be no more than two feet six inches. 5. A minimum six-foot eight -inch vertical clearance above grade is required. 6. Supports shall not exceed six inches by six inches (horizontal dimensions). 7. The arbor shall not be enclosed on any side other than where attached to a building or by an entry gate that is part of an allowed fence. 8. Arbors may encroach into the entire width of the required front or exterior side setback. 18.43.080 OPENINGS IN VIEW -OBSCURING FENCES A. When Allowed 1. With the approval of a site plan, the Planning Division may allow view -obscuring fences to have visual openings, for security surveillance. Such openings shall not exceed 24 inches in width and the aggregate of openings shall not exceed 15 percent of the linear length of the fence along any side of an enclosed area. 2. Upon recommendation of the chief of police, the Planning Division or Building Division may require that security openings be provided in view -obscuring fences constructed after the effective date of the ordinance codified in this section. 18.43.090 SPECIAL FENCES A. Conditions and Restrictions Special fences are subject to review and approval by the Planning Division. Staff may impose reasonable conditions or restrictions including, but not limited to, neighbor notification, setbacks and landscape screening as staff deems necessary to secure the purpose of this title and to assure compatibility of the 164 Title 18 Zoning special fence with adjoining properties and those in the general vicinity, and may require guarantees and evidence that such conditions are being, or will be, complied with. B. Types Special fences include, but are not limited to the following: 1. Recreation area fence. Fences not to exceed 12 feet in height may be located near or around tennis courts, badminton courts, batting cages, golf courses/driving ranges, basketball or volleyball courts and similar play areas, providing that all parts of the fence over six feet are made of open -wire construction or other corrosion -resistant material; 2. Security fences. Fences not to exceed eight feet in height may be located near and around industrial, industrial or research uses where required for security purposes. screening, or containing and protecting hazardous materials; 3. Swimming pool fences. Fences required for swimming pools are governed by Chapter 15.40 of the Municipal Code. Swimming pool fences are subject to Building Official approval. 4. Wood fence posts greater than eight inches in width or depth; 5. Front yard fence posts with more than two attached lights. In no event shall such posts exceed four feet in height plus a two -foot -high light fixture; 6. Chain link fencing in residential areas is permitted in the side and rear yards with vinyl -coating and landscape screening. Chain link fencing shall not exceed six feet in height in these areas. Chain link fencing in front yards in residential areas is not permitted; 7. Gates exceeding four feet in width for pedestrian use or 14 feet in width for driveway use; 8. Other structures which in the opinion of the review authority are of a similar nature. 18.43.100 TRAFFIC VISIBILITY TRIANGLES A. Sight Requirements 1. Also known as a "Sight Visibility Triangle", each corner or reversed corner lot in the commercial and industrial zones shall maintain a yard area conforming to the traffic visibility triangle requirements as defined in Table 18.43.100, except that a single supporting column, for a cantilevered roof or second story, having a diameter of eight inches or less may be located in the triangle area. 2. A visibility triangle is the area encompassed by the triangle formed by projecting lines of a specified distance from the point of intersection of the front and side street edges of pavement and a straight line connecting the termini of said projected lines. Within the area comprising the triangle, no tree, fence, wall, shrub, or other physical obstruction higher than three feet above the official grade lot line grade shall be permitted. 3. The following traffic visibility triangles shall be established for the following intersection types as identified in Table 18.43.100 below: TABLE 18.43.100 Traffic Visibility Triangles Classification of Intersection Types Distance Measurements from Point of Intersection of Front and Side Lot Lines Driveway or Alley with any street As provided by Caltrans and AASHTO stopping sight distance criteria Local -- Local 25' Local -- Collector 25' Driveway — Collector or Arterial Street 30' 165 Title 18 Zoning Collector -- Arterial Arterial -- Arterial 30' 30' CHAPTER 18-44 - LANDSCAPING 18.44.010 Purpose 18.44.020 Applicability 18.44.030 Definitions 18.44.040 Landscape Plan 18.44.050 Requirements 18.44.060 Plant Materials 18.44.070 Turf Lawn 18.44.080 Soils and Mulching 18.44.090 Minimum Percentage of Net Lot Area to be Landscaped 18.44.100 Statuary Structures and Other Lawn Art 18.44.110 Landscape Location Requirements 18.44.120 Tree Preservation 18.44.130 Landscaping Work Included in Building Permit Inspections 18.44.140 Traffic Visibility Triangles 18.44.150 Maintenance Required 18.44.160 Certain Trees a Public Nuisance 18.44.170 Nonconforming Landscaping 18.44.180 Public Utilities 18.44.190 Water Efficient Landscape Regulations 18.44.010 PURPOSE The purpose of this Chapter is to provide property owners with standards in landscaping their properties. These standards will be used by the Planning Division, Planning Commission, and City Council when reviewing plans for landscaped areas. These standards are also intended to provide direction for the design, installation, and maintenance of water efficient landscaping as directed by California State law. 18.44.020 APPLICABILITY These standards shall be used when preparing landscape and irrigation plans for all multi -family residential, commercial, industrial, and institutional projects. Projects with a total landscaped area of 500 square feet or less, private yard areas for single-family dwellings, and registered historic sites shall be exempt from requirements for water efficiency identified in this Chapter. These standards shall not apply to revegetation plans that will be reviewed individually by staff and all appropriate State and Federal agencies. 18.44.030 DEFINITIONS A. Definitions Used in this Chapter "Landscaping" means the use of architectural and horticultural materials to provide control of erosion, dust, weeds, and accumulation of litter in a manner complementary to the purpose of adding natural environmental quality to the premises. "Landscaping" includes the planting and maintenance of some combination of trees, shrubs, ground cover, vines, flowers, lawns or other planting materials, other than weeds, providing shade, visual screening, aesthetic enhancement, soil conservation, and the removal or reduction of fire hazards, rodent harborages, vermin, and disease -bearing creatures. In 166 Title 18 Zoning 2. "Landscaping maintenance" includes sufficient irrigation, fertilization, pruning, trimming and training, and all other reasonable acts necessary to keep plants in a healthy vigorous condition. "Maintenance" also includes removal of weeds, dead materials and accumulated litter, rubble or other foreign substances; and reseeding, and replacement of dead plants and planting where necessary to restore a landscaped area to the level of coverage required of a new installation. 18.44.040 LANDSCAPE PLAN A. Requirements A detailed landscape plan shall be submitted as part of a site plan review. The landscape plan shall include, but not be limited to, the following items: 1. The landscape plan shall be drawn at the same scale as the plot or site plan or at a minimum scale of one inch to 20 feet. 2. The landscape plan shall locate and identify existing and proposed buildings, walls, fences, walks, drives, utilities, etc. 3. Proposed plant location, spacing, size, species (common and botanical name). 4. Existing and proposed contours on -site and 100 feet beyond the site at intervals not to exceed two feet. 5. Height and type of construction of wall or fence, including footings. 6. Provide the types and amounts of soil amendments (additives mixed with the soil) used per 1,000 square feet. 7. Significant site details to resolve specific site conditions, such as tree wells to preserve existing trees or culverts to maintain existing natural drainage patterns. 8. Planting and staking details in drawing form to ensure proper installation and establishment of proposed materials. 9. Identification of existing trees proposed to be saved including individual tree caliper size and species. Clearly reference on the plan the total number of trees proposed to be preserved, caliper of tree saved, and number of trees requested for credit consideration. 10. Identification of tree protection method for trees proposed to be preserved. 11. Identification of existing trees over two -and -one-half inch caliper proposed to be removed. 12. Identification of grass and other groundcover or proposed seed mix and the amount in pounds to be used per 1,000 square feet and method of planting. 13. Prepare calculations for the total number of parking spaces and number of parking lot shade canopy trees required to be placed within the interior of the parking area. 14. Prepare calculations for the square footage of the 20 percent landscape area requirement. The 20 percent required landscape area shall be clearly denoted on the landscape plan. 15. For sites with existing buildings and parking that are proposed for expansion, label the net percent increase and calculated landscape requirement. 16. An irrigation and planting plan shall be submitted that meets the requirements of the Water Efficient Landscape Regulations of this Chapter. 17. Each landscape plan shall be prepared by a California licensed landscape architect, licensed landscape contractor, certified nurseryman, or other professional determined by the City to be qualified. 18.44.050 REQUIREMENTS A. General 1. Where on -site landscaping is required by this Chapter as part of a project, all landscaping work shall be included in such permit. Such landscaping shall not be considered complete until approved by the Planning Division. 167 Title 18 Zoning 2. Notwithstanding other provisions of this title requiring on -site landscaping, all buildings erected hereafter shall have the surrounding courts, yard areas, open -space areas, and public street parkways, that are otherwise unimproved, landscaped in accordance with Section 18.54.030. This shall include centrally controlled mechanical irrigation systems. 3. New single-family and two-family residences shall be landscaped with a minimum of: a. Complete landscaping of all slopes steeper than 3:1; b. Turf or suitable ground cover on all other ground area lying between the curb, or edge of roadway, within adjoining streets and the rear line of the rearmost main building and the area between the main building and the rear property line on reversed corner lots; c. This required landscaping shall include irrigation systems meeting the guidelines of this Chapter. All street parkways and slopes more than three feet in height shall have permanent centrally controlled mechanical irrigation systems. 4. All street parkways and slopes more than three feet in height shall have permanent centrally controlled mechanical irrigation systems. 5. Street trees shall be installed within the parkway of public streets at a ratio of one per 30 linear feet of frontage and may not interfere with effective street lighting. Tree selection and tree location shall be approved by the Planning Division. 18.44.060 PLANT MATERIALS A. Requirements 1. Landscaping shall include a variety of trees, shrubs, and groundcover. 2. Plant materials shall conform to or exceed the plant quality standards of the latest edition of American Standard for Nursery Stock published by the American Association of Nurserymen, or the equivalent. 3. Plant materials shall be sized and spaced to achieve immediate effect and shall not be less than a 15-gallon container for trees, five gallon container for specimen shrubs, and six inch pots for mass planting, unless otherwise approved by the regulating authority. 4. Plant materials shall be selected for low water demand and drought tolerance; use of appropriate native species; adaptability to the National City environment; the geological and topographical conditions of the site; ability to provide shade; and, soil retention capability. 5. Plants having similar water use shall be grouped together in distinct hydrozones. 6. Deciduous trees shall be used to shade buildings and parking lots in summer and allow for passive solar heating of buildings in winter. 7. Street trees shall be planted at a rate of one tree for every 30 linear feet of right-of-way. The review authority may modify this requirement depending on the chosen tree species and its typical spread at maturity. 8. Shrubs. A minimum of two, five gallon shrubs shall be provided for every six feet of distance along street frontages. 18.44.070 TURF LAWN A. Restrictions 1. Turf lawn is the landscape element which requires the most water and maintenance; therefore, the use of turf must be limited to functional areas such as playgrounds, entertainment areas, picnic areas, employee areas, play areas, etc. 2. Turf shall not exceed 20 percent of the total landscaped area. Decorative cool season turf shall not exceed 15 percent of the landscaped area. 3. Turf shall not be used in parking lot islands or strips. 4. Turf may not be planted in areas with a width of less than six feet. 18.44.080 SOILS AND MULCHING A. Requirements 168 Title 18 Zoning 1. A minimum of one -foot depth of uncompacted soil shall be provided for water absorption and root growth in each planted area. 2. Soil shall be prepared and/or amended to be suitable for the landscaping to be installed. 3. A minimum of two to three inches of mulch such as ground bark or other composted organic material shall be added in each non -turf area to the soil surface after planting. Any plant type that is intolerant to mulch shall be excluded from this requirement. 4. If a weed control barrier is needed, only porous fabrics shall be used under mulches. 5. Gravel or crushed rock for use as mulching is not permitted, 18.44.090 MINIUMUM PERCENTAGE OF NET LOT AREA TO BE LANDSCAPED The minimum area of each site to be landscaped with trees, shrubs, groundcover, or turf lawn shall be twenty percent of the net site area, except for a reduction approved by the City Manager or his/her designee due to lot size, sites with existing development, or for lots with zero setback requirements. 18.44.100 STATUARY STRUCTURES AND OTHER LAWN ART Statuary structures and other lawn art shall be limited to a maximum of three structures and shall not exceed four feet in height and two feet in depth unless otherwise determined by the Planning Division. Staff may impose reasonable conditions or restrictions including, but not limited to, neighbor notification, setbacks and landscape screening as staff deems necessary to secure the purpose of this title and to assure compatibility of the statuary structures and other lawn art with adjoining properties and those in the general vicinity. and may require guarantees and evidence that such conditions are being, or will be, complied with. 18.44.110 LANDSCAPE LOCATION REQUIREMENTS A. Provisions Landscaping shall be provided in all areas of a site subject to development with structures, grading, or the removal of natural vegetation, as follows: 1. Setbacks. The setback and open space areas required by this Land Use Code, and easements for utilities and drainage courses shall be landscaped except where: a. Occupied by approved structures; b. Occupied by required paved areas; c. A required single family dwelling residential setback is screened from public view; or d. They are retained in their natural state, and the review authority determines that landscaping is not necessary to achieve the purposes of this Chapter. 2. Unused areas. Any area of a project site riot intended for a specific use, including a commercial pad site intended for future development, shall be landscaped unless retained in the natural state, and the review authority determines that landscaping is not necessary to achieve the purposes of this Chapter. 3. Areas adjacent to side or rear property lines. A parking area for a nonresidential use or multi -unit residential project shall provide a perimeter landscape strip at least eight feet wide where the parking area adjoins a side or rear property line. The requirement for a landscape strip may be satisfied by a setback or buffer area that is otherwise required to be eight feet or greater. Trees shall be provided within the landscape strip at the rate of one for each 30 linear feet of landscaped area. 4. Areas adjacent to buildings. When a parking area is located adjacent to a nonresidential structure, a minimum eight -foot wide landscape strip shall be provided adjacent to the structure, exclusive of any building entries, or areas immediately adjacent to the wall of the structure that serves as pedestrian accessways. Landscape strips shall be planted with a combination of canopy trees, ornamental trees, shrubs, perennials, ornamental grasses, and groundcover. 169 Title 18 Zoning 5. Areas adjacent to residential use. A parking area for a nonresidential use or multi -unit residential project adjoining a residential use in an RS Zone shall provide a landscaped buffer with a minimum ten foot width between the parking area and the common property line bordering the residential use. A solid, continuous decorative masonry wall or fence and landscape buffer shall be provided along the property line, except for approved access points. to address land use compatibility issues (e.g., nuisance noise and light/glare), as determined by the review authority to be necessary. Trees shall be provided at the rate of one for each 30 linear feet of landscaped area. 6. Parking lot landscape requirements. a. A minimum of one shade canopy tree shall be required for every seven parking spaces in a parking lot for all zones. b. All of the required parking lot trees shall be placed within the parking lot envelope, described as the area including the parking lot surface and extending a minimum of eight to ten feet from the edge of the parking lot. c. Landscape areas within the parking lot island shall be planted with a combination of required canopy trees, ornamental trees, shrubs, perennials, ornamental grasses, and groundcover. d. A minimum of two thirds of the required trees shall be placed within the interior of the parking area. A maximum of one third may be placed within the ten foot landscape area that surrounds a parking lot. e_ A parking area for a nonresidential use adjacent to a public street shall be designed to provide a minimum ten foot wide landscape planting strip between the street right-of-way and the parking lot. f. A parking area for a residential use except for dwelling or duplex, shall be designed to provide a landscaped planting strip between the street right-of-way and parking area equal in depth to the setback required by the applicable zoning district. g. The landscaping shall be designed and maintained to screen vehicles from view from the street to a minimum height of three feet, but shall not exceed any applicable height limit for landscaping within a setback or traffic visibility triangle. Screening materials may include a combination of plant materials, earth berms, solid decorative masonry walls, raised planters, or other screening devices which meet the intent of this requirement. h. All landscaping including canopy tree placement shall be dispersed throughout the parking lot in order to balance and soften the large areas of pavement and help direct traffic flow within the lot. i. A permanent underground irrigation system shall be provided for all landscaped areas. 7. Paved areas. Paving within the required front and exterior setbacks in the residential zones is prohibited, except for driveways, walkways, and porches approved through site plan review or as part of a landscaping plan 18.44.120 TREE PRESERVATION A. Site Plan Requirements, Maintenance, and Credits 1. All trees over eight inches caliper shall be identified on the site plan and landscape plan with notations of trees to be preserved and trees to be removed. 2. Trees intended to be preserved shall be noted with a unique symbol on the site plan and be protected during construction through the use of construction fencing at or beyond the drip line of the tree or trees to be preserved. 3. Trees to be preserved shall be considered for credit only if they are located on the developed portion of the site. To obtain credit consideration, the preserved trees shall be of a high quality and at least two -and -one-half inches caliper. 4. The following credits will be considered for high quality trees that are preserved: a. 2-1/2" to 7.99 inches: one tree b. 8-inches to 11.99 inches: two trees c. 12 inches and over: three trees 5. To protect and encourage the continued health and vitality of the preserved trees, the ground within the drip line shall be maintained in the existing natural state. Storage of soils, construction equipment or other rnaterials during or after construction within the tree dripline is prohibited. 170 Title 18 Zoning 6. If preserved trees die within three years after construction, the property owner shall replace with the number of trees that would have been required had the tree preservation credit not been provided. Said trees shall be replaced within 30 days of written notice from the City or within an extended time period as specified in said notice, 7. The minimum number of required trees shall not be reduced by less than 50 percent through the use of approved tree credits, unless the Planning Commission determines that during the site plan review existing vegetation intended to be preserved would provide adequate landscaping, shading, buffering or screening comparable to that required under this Chapter. 18.44.130 LANDSCAPING WORK INCLUDED IN BUILDING PERMIT INSPECTIONS Where on -site landscaping is required by this title as part of a project for which a building permit is also required, all landscaping work shall be included in such permit. Such landscaping shall not be considered complete until inspected, certified for compliance, and approved by the Planning Division. The City Fire Department is authorized to annually inspect all properties for adequacy of landscaping maintenance as a part of its annual weed abatement program. Conditions of inadequate landscaping maintenance that cannot be abated pursuant to the weed abatement provisions of the California Health and Safety Code, which nonetheless constitute unsightly or otherwise detrimental conditions, shall be reported to code enforcement for enforcement under this title. 18.44.140 TRAFFIC VISIBILITY TRIANGLE Refer to Table 18.43.100, Traffic Visibility Triangle, for regulations on landscaping. 18.44.150 MAINTENANCE REQUIRED A. Property Owner Responsibilities 1. It shall be the responsibility of each property owner to adequately maintain the landscaping of private property and the adjoining public street parkway landscaped, except street trees. All landscaping shall be properly maintained. Trees located within public street parkways will be pruned and trimmed by City forces and not by private property owners. 2. All trees, shrubs, plants, and other landscaping of parking lots, including interior landscaped areas, setbacks, and parkways shall be periodically and systematically watered, weeded, fertilized, and maintained in a healthy, growing condition. Dead growth should be promptly replaced so as to maintain the designed planting scheme. 3. Landscaping --pruning or trimming. All growth in landscaped areas should be controlled by pruning, trimming or otherwise so that: a. It will not interfere with the maintenance or repair of any public utility; b. It will not restrict pedestrian or vehicular access; c. It will not constitute a traffic hazard because of reduced visibility. 18.44.160 CERTAIN TREES A PUBLIC NUISANCE Any tree or shrub growing or standing on private property in such a manner that any portion thereof interferes with utility poles, lines, wires or electroliers lawfully erected, constructed or maintained along any public street, sidewalk, or intersection or with any person or persons lawfully using the same, or any such tree which has become diseased or weakened in such a manner as to be dangerous to persons lawfully using the streets or sidewalks, or any such tree which has roots that pose a hazard to pedestrians using a sidewalk constitutes a public nuisance. The Public Works Department shall cause notice to be served upon such property owner directing that such public nuisance be abated or removed within seven days after said notice is served. The Public Works Department is authorized to abate or cause to be abated such public nuisance by trimming, pruning, cutting or removing all or such portion of such tree, shrub or plant as may be necessary to eliminate such interference, obstruction or condition. Whenever it is necessary for the Public Works Department to direct the use of City employees to abate, remove, or cause to be abated or removed, public nuisances as contained in this section, he/she shall determine the cost of the work performed by City employees and bill the property owner the cost of the work performed. 171 Title 18 Zoning 18.44.170 NONCONFORMING LANDSCAPING All properties, now landscaped, which are inadequately maintained shall be brought into compliance with this Chapter upon not less than 90 days' from the date of a written notice from the City. All properties not now landscaped shall be landscaped whenever a building permit for structures valued $10,000 or more is issued for the site. All other properties or portions of properties, not landscaped shall be kept free of rubbish, litter, debris, unused merchandise, unused building materials, machinery or vehicular paraphernalia not essential to the occupancy of the premises. 18.44.180 PUBLIC UTILITIES No species of trees or large shrubs shall be planted under overhead lines or over underground utilities if its growth might interfere with the installation or maintenance of any public utilities. 18.44.190 WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPE REGULATIONS A. Purpose The purpose of this section is to provide property owners with standards in landscaping their properties. These standards will be used by the Planning Division, Planning Commission, and Director or Parks and Recreation when reviewing plans for landscaped areas. These standards are also intended to provide direction for the design, installation, and maintenance of water efficient landscaping as directed by California State law. 1. Promote the values and benefits of landscapes while recognizing the need to utilize water and other resources as efficiently as possible. 2. Establish' a structure for planning, designing, installing, maintaining, and managing water efficient landscapes. 3. Promote the use, when available, of tertiary treated recycled water, for irrigating landscaping. 4. Use water efficiently without waste by setting a maximum applied water allowance (MAWA) as an upper limit for water use and reduce water use to the lowest practical amount. 5. Encourage water users of existing landscapes to use water efficiently and without waste. B. Definitions The following definitions shall apply to this section: 1. "Automatic irrigation controller" means an automatic timing device used to remotely control valves that operate an irrigation system. Automatic irrigation controllers shall schedule irrigation events using either evapotranspiration (ETo) (weather -based) or moisture sensor data. 2. "Building permit" means a permit to engage in a certain type of construction at a specific location. 3. "Certified landscape irrigation auditor" means a person certified to perform landscape irrigation audits by an accredited academic institution, a professional trade organization, or other accredited certification program. 4. "Developer" means a person who seeks or receives permits for or who undertakes land development activities who is not a single-family homeowner. Developer includes a developer's partner, associate, employee, consultant, trustee, or agent. 5. "Director" means the development services director or anyone to whom the director has designated or hired to administer or enforce this section_ 6. "Discretionary permit" means any permit requiring a decision -making body to exercise judgment prior to its approval, conditional approval, or denial. 7. "Estimated total water use" (ETWU) means the estimated total water use in gallons per year for a landscaped area. 172 Title 18 Zoning 8. "ET adjustment factor" (ETAF) means a factor that when applied to reference ETo, adjusts for plant water requirements and irrigation efficiency, two major influences on the amount of water that is required for a healthy landscape. 9. "Evapotranspiration" (ETo) means the quantity of water evaporated from adjacent soil and other surfaces, and transpired by plants during a specified time period. 10. "Reference evapotranspiration" means a standard measurement of environmental parameters which affect the water use of plants. ETo is given in inches per day, month. or year and is an estimate of the ETo of a large field of four -inches to seven-inch tall, cool season turf that is well watered. Reference ETo is used as the basis of determining the MAWA so that regional differences in climate can be accommodated. 11. "Grading" means any importation, excavation, movement, loosening, or compaction of soil or rock. 12. "Hardscape" means any durable surface material, pervious, or non -pervious. 13. "Homeowner -provided landscaping" means landscaping installed either by a private individual for a single-family residence or installed by a California licensed contractor hired by a homeowner. 14. "Hydrozone" means a portion of the landscape area having plants with similar water needs. A hydrozone may be irrigated or non -irrigated. 15. "Invasive plant species" means species of plants not historically found in California that spread outside cultivated areas and may damage environmental or economic resources. 16. "Irrigation audit" includes an in depth evaluation of the performance of an irrigation system conducted by a certified landscape irrigation auditor. An irrigation audit may include, but is not limited to, inspection, system tune up, system test with distribution uniformity or emission uniformity, reporting overspray or runoff that causes overland flow, and preparation of an irrigation schedule. 17. "Irrigation efficiency" means the measurement of the amount of water beneficially used divided by the water applied. Irrigation efficiency is derived from measurements and estimates of irrigation system characteristics and management practices. 18. "Landscaped area" means an area with outdoor plants, turf, and other vegetation. A landscaped area may include a water feature either in an area with vegetation or that stands alone. A landscaped area may also include design features adjacent to an area with vegetation. A landscaped area does not include the footprint of a building, decks, patio, sidewalk, driveway, parking lot, or other hardscape. A landscaped area also does not include an area without irrigation designated for non -development such as designated open space or area with existing native vegetation and areas dedicated for food production. 19. "Landscape Manual" means the Water Efficient Landscape Design Manual, approved by the City of National City that establishes specific design criteria and guidance to implement the requirements of this section. 20. "Low head drainage" means a sprinkler head or other irrigation device that continues to emit water after the water to the zone in which the device is located has shut off. 21. "Low volume irrigation" means the application of irrigation water at low pressure through a system of tubing or lateral lines and low volume emitters such as drip lines or bubblers. 22. "Maximum applied water allowance" (MAWA) means the maximum allowed annual water use for a specific landscaped area based on the square footage of the area, the ETAF, and the reference ETo. 23. "Mulch" means an organic material such as leaves, bark, straw, or inorganic mineral materials such as rocks, gravel, or decomposed granite left loose and applied to the soil surface to reduce evaporation, suppress weeds, moderate soil temperature, or prevent soil erosion. 24. "Overspray" means the water from irrigation that is delivered outside an area targeted for the irrigation and makes contact with a surface not intended to be irrigated. 25. "Pervious" means any surface or material that allows the passage of water through the material and into underlying soil. 26. "Plant factor" means a factor when multiplied by the ETo, estimates the amount of water a plant needs. 27. "Recycled water" means waste water that has been treated at the highest level required by the California Department of Public Health for water not intended for human consumption. 28. "Recreational areas" means areas of active play or recreation, such as parks, playgrounds, sports fields, golf courses, school yards, picnic grounds, or other areas where turf provides a playing surface or serves other recreational purposes. 173 Title 18 Zoning 29. "Runoff' means water that is not absorbed by the soil or landscape to which it is applied and flows from the landscaped area. 30. "Special landscaped area" means an area of the landscape dedicated to edible plants, an area irrigated with recycled water, or an area dedicated as turf area within a park, sports field, or golf course where turf provides a passive or active recreational surface. 31. "Standard Urban Strom Water Mitigation Plan" (SUSMP) means a plan designed to reduce pollutants and runoff flows from new development and significant redevelopment. 32. "SUSMP Manual" means the manual prepared for implementation of SUSMP requirements, and available for reference at the City's Development Services Department and on the City's website. 33. "Storm Water Management and Discharge Control" means regulations contained in Chapter 14.22 of the Municipal Code enacted to reduce the effects of polluted discharge on water of the state, to secure benefits from the use of storm water as a resource, to ensure compliance with the San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) and applicable state and federal law. 34. "Subsurface irrigation" means an irrigation device with a delivery line and water emitters installed below the soil surface that slowly and frequently emit small amounts of water into the soil to irrigate plant roots. 35. "Tertiary treated recycled water," means water that has been through three levels of wastewater treatment including filtration and disinfection, but not intended for human consumption. 36. "Transitional area" means a portion of a landscaped area that is adjacent to a natural or undisturbed area and is designated to ensure that the natural area remains unaffected by plantings and irrigation installed on the property. 37. "Turf' means a groundcover surface of mowed grass. 38. "Water feature" means a design element where open water performs an aesthetic or recreational function. A water feature includes a pond, lake, waterfall, fountain, artificial streams, spa, and swimming pool. Constructed wetlands used for onsite wastewater treatment or storm water best management practices are not water features. 39. "WUCOLS III" means Water Use Classification of Landscape Species and refers to the Department of Water Resources 1999 publication or the most current version. C. Applicability 1. All new industrial, commercial, institutional, or multi -family residential development with a total landscaped area less than 2,500 square feet shall provide the following: a. Install on -site landscaping and below grade automatic irrigation system in accordance with the landscape manual. b. Landscaping shall be installed in all areas not utilized for structures, parking, drainage, and hardscape. c. Drought tolerant landscaping and water efficiency in accordance with this section and the landscape manual is encouraged. d. Parkways, between the curb and the sidewalk, bordering the development shall be provided with ground cover, shrubs, and at a minimum one 15 gallon street tree every 40 linear feet. 2. All new single-family and two-family residences with a total landscaped area less than 5,000 square feet shall provide the following: a. Install on -site landscaping and below grade automatic irrigation systems in accordance with the landscape manual. b. Landscaping shall be installed on all areas not used for structures, driveways. drainage, and hardscape. c. Drought tolerant landscaping and water efficiency for all new landscaping consistent with this section is encouraged. d. Parkways, between the curb and the sidewalk, bordering the development shall be provided with groundcover, shrubs, and at a minimum one 15 gallon street tree every 40 linear feet. 3. For all other projects that exceed the landscape area identified in 18.44.190(C)(1) and (C)(2) of this section shall apply to the following projects when a building permit or a discretionary permit is required: a. A project for an industrial, commercial, institutional, or multi -family residential use with a total landscaped area equal to or greater than 2,500 square feet. 174 Title 18 Zoning b. Developer installed residential and common area landscapes where the total landscaped area for the development is equal to or greater than two thousand five hundred square feet. c. A new single-family residence with homeowner provided landscaping, where the landscaped area is equal to or greater than 5,000 square feet. d. A model home that includes a landscaped area. e. A public agency project that contains a landscaped area equal to or greater than 2,500 square feet. f. A rehabilitated landscape for an existing industrial, commercial, institutional, public agency, or multi -family use where a building permit or discretionary permit is being issued, and the applicant is installing or modifying two thousand five hundred square feet or more of landscaping. 4. This section shall not apply to the following: a. A registered local, state, or federal historical site. b. An ecological restoration project that does not require a permanent irrigation system. c. A mined land reclamation project that does not require a permanent irrigation system. d. A botanical garden or arboretum, open to the public. e. Any single-family residence that is being rebuilt after it was destroyed due to a natural disaster, such as a fire. earthquake, or hurricane. D. Administration and Enforcement 1. The director shall administer and enforce this section_ 2. The director shall provide guidance to applicants on how to comply with the requirements of this section. E. Landscape Documentation Package 1. Building permit applications for projects shall submit and have approved a landscape documentation package to the development services department prior to issuance of a building permit. A minimum of three percent of the construction cost to install the landscaping and irrigation improvements shall be submitted as a deposit to review the landscape documentation package. The developer shall be billed for actual costs incurred by the City, including actual labor charges and consultant fees, less the amount of the deposit. In addition to the fee, the landscape documentation package shall contain the following. a. A soils management report and plan that complies with Subsection F. b. Planting and irrigation plans that comply with Subsection G. c. A water efficient landscape worksheet that complies with Subsection H. d. A grading plan that complies with Subsection I, below, and Chapters 14.22 (Storm Water Management and Discharge Control) and 15.70 (Grading) of the Municipal Code. F. Soils Management Report 1. The soils management report as required by Section 18.44.190 (E)(1)(a), above shall be prepared by a licensed landscape architect, licensed civil engineer, licensed architect, or other landscape professional appropriately licensed by the state, and shall contain the following information: a. An analysis of the soil for the proposed landscaped areas of the project that includes information about the soil texture, soil infiltration rate, pH, total soluble salts, sodium, and percent organic matter. b. Recommendations about soil amendments that may be necessary to foster plant growth and plant survival in the landscaped area using efficient irrigation techniques. c. Proposed soil amendments and mulch as follows: i. The report shall identify the type and amount of mulch for each area where mulch is applied. Mulch shall be used as follows: • A minimum two-inch layer of mulch shall be applied on all exposed soil surfaces in each landscaped area except in turf areas, creeping or rooting ground covers or direct seeding applications where mulch is contraindicated. • Stabilizing mulch shall be applied on slopes. 175 Title 18 Zoning • The mulching portion of seed/mulch slurry in hydro -seeded applications shall comply with Subsection F(1), above. • Highly flammable mulch material shall not be used. • The report shall identify any soil amendments and their type and quantity. 2. When a project involves mass grading of a site, the soils report shall be submitted with the certificate of completion required by Subsection S. G. Planting and Irrigation Plan 1. The planting and irrigation plans required shall be prepared by a licensed landscape architect, licensed civil engineer, licensed architect, or other landscape professional appropriately licensed by the state. The plans shall: a. Include the MAWA for the plans, including the calculations used to determine the MAWA. The calculations shall be based on the formula in Subsection K. b. Include the ETWU for the plans, including the calculations used to determine the ETWU. The calculations shall be based on the formula in Subsection L. c. Include a statement signed under penalty of perjury by the person who prepared the plan that provides, "I am familiar with the requirements for landscape and irrigation plans contained in the City of National City Water Efficient Landscape Regulations (LUC Chapter 4 Section 18.44.190). I have prepared this plan in compliance with those regulations. I certify that the plan implements those regulations to provide efficient use of water." d. Demonstrate compliance with best management practices identified in Municipal Code Chapter 14.22, including the Storm Water Management, Discharge Control Ordinance and Standard Urban Stormwater Mitigation Plan (SUSMP). e. Demonstrate compliance with state and City requirements for defensible space around buildings and structures, and avoid the use of fire prone vegetation. 2. The planting plan shall meet the following requirements: a. The plan shall include a list of all vegetation by common and botanical plant name, which exists in the proposed landscaped area. The plan shall state what vegetation will be retained and what will be removed. b. The plan shall include a list of all vegetation by common and botanical plant name which will be added to each landscaped area. Invasive plant species shall not be added to a landscaped area. The plan shall include the total quantities by container size and species. If the applicant intends to plant seeds, the plan shall describe the seed mixes and applicable purity and germination specifications. c. The plan shall include a detailed description of each water feature, including the type and surface area of all water features that will be included in the landscaped area. The water feature shall utilize a recirculating water system. d. The plan shall be accompanied by a drawing showing the specific location of all vegetation, retained or planted, the plant spacing and plant size, natural features, water features, and hardscape areas. The drawing shall include a legend listing the common and botanical plant name of each plant shown on the drawing. e. All plants shall be grouped in hydrozones, and the irrigation shall be designed to deliver water to hydrozones based on the moisture requirements of the plant grouping. A hydrozone may mix plants of moderate and low water use or mix plants of high water use with plants of moderate water use. No high water use plants shall be allowed in a low water use hydrozone. The plan shall also demonstrate how the plant groupings accomplish the most efficient use of water. f. The plan shall identify areas permanently and solely dedicated to edible plants. g. The plan shall demonstrate that landscaping when installed and at maturity will be positioned to avoid obstructing motorists' views of pedestrian crossings, driveways, roadways, and other vehicular travel ways. if the landscaping will require maintenance to avoid obstructing motorist's views, the plan shall describe the maintenance and the frequency of the proposed maintenance. 176 Title 18 Zoning h. The plan shall avoid the use of landscaping with known surface root problems adjacent to a paved area, unless the plan provides for installation of root control barriers or other appropriate devices to control surface roots. i. Plants in a transitional area shall consist of a combination of site adaptive and compatible native and/or non-native species. Invasive species shall not be introduced or tolerated in a transitional area. The irrigation in a transitional area shall be designed so that no overspray or runoff shall enter an adjacent area that is not irrigated. j. Where applicable, the plan shall identify passive and active recreational areas. k. Parkways, between the curb and the sidewalk, bordering the development shall be provided with ground cover, shrubs, and at a minimum one 15 gallon street tree every 40 linear feet. 3. The irrigation plan shall meet the following requirements: a. The plan shall show the location, type, and size of all components of the irrigation system that will provide water to the landscaped area, including the controller, water lines, valves, sprinkler heads, moisture sensing devices, rain switches, quick couplers, pressure regulators, and backflow prevention devices. b. The plan shall show the static water pressure at the point of connection to the public water supply and the flow rate in gallons, the application rate in inches per hour, and the design operating pressure in pressure per square inch for each station. c. The irrigation system shall be designed to prevent runoff, overspray, low -head drainage and other similar conditions where irrigation water flows or sprays onto areas not intended for irrigation. The plan shall also demonstrate how grading and drainage techniques promote healthy plant growth and prevent erosion and runoff. d. The plan shall identify each area irrigated with recycled water. e. The plan shall provide that any slope greater than 25 percent will be irrigated with an irrigation system with a precipitation rate of seventy-five hundredths inches per hour or less to prevent runoff and erosion. As used in this section, 25 percent grade means one foot of vertical elevation change for every four feet of horizontal length. An applicant may employ an alternative design if the plan demonstrates that no runoff or erosion will occur. f. The plan shall provide that all wiring and piping under a paved area that a vehicle may use, such as a parking area, driveway or roadway, will be installed inside a PVC conduit. g. The plan shall provide that irrigation piping and irrigation devices that deliver water, such as sprinkler heads, shall be installed below grade if they are within 24 inches of a vehicle or pedestrian use area. The director may allow on -grade piping where landform constraints make below grade piping infeasible. h. The plan shall provide that only low volume irrigation shall be used to irrigate any vegetation within 24 inches of an impermeable surface unless the adjacent impermeable surfaces are designed and constructed to cause water to drain entirely into a landscaped area. i. The irrigation system shall provide for the installation of a manual shutoff valve as close as possible to the water supply. Additional manual shutoff valves shall be installed between each zone of the irrigation system and the water supply. j. The irrigation system shall provide that irrigation for any landscaped area will be regulated by an automatic irrigation controller using either evapotranspiration or soil moisture sensor data. k. The irrigation system shall be designed with a landscape irrigation efficiency necessary to meet the MAWA. I. The plan shall describe each automatic irrigation controller the system uses to regulate the irrigation schedule, and whether it is a weather -based system or moisture detection system. The plan shall depict the location of electrical service for the automatic irrigation controller or describe the use of batteries or solar power that will power valves or an irrigation controller. m. Parkways, between the curb and the sidewalk, bordering the development shall be provided below grade irrigation. H. Water Efficient Landscape Worksheet The water efficient landscape worksheet required by section 18.44.190(E)(1)(c) shall be prepared by a licensed landscape architect, licensed civil engineer, licensed architect, or other landscape professional appropriately licensed by the state, and shall contain the following: 177 Title 18 Zoning 1. A hydrozone information table that contains a list of each hydrozone in the landscaped area of the project and complies with the following requirements: a. For each hydrozone listed, the table shall identify the plant types and water features in the hydrozone, the irrigation methods used, the square footage, and the percentage of the total landscaped area of the project that the hydrozone represents. b. The plant types shall be categorized as turf, high water use, moderate water use, or low water use. 2. Water budget calculations, which shall meet the following requirements: a. The plant factor used shall be from WUCOLS III. A plan that mixes plants in a hydrozone that requires a different amount of water shall use the plant factor for the highest water using plant in the hydrozone. b. Temporarily irrigated areas shall be included in the low water use hydrozone. Temporarily irrigated as used in this section means the period of time when plantings only receive water until they become established. c. The surface area of a water feature, including swimming pools, shall be included in a high water use hydrozone. d. The calculations shall use the formula for the MAWA in Subsection K and for the ETWU in Subsection L. e. Each special landscaped area shall be identified on the worksheet and the area's water use calculated using an ETAF of 1.0. I. Grading Plan The required grading plan shall comply with the Municipal Code Chapters 14.22 (Storm Water Management and Discharge Control) and 15.70 (Grading). See the SUSMP Manual for implementation guidelines for Chapter 14.22 to reduce runoff and the discharge of pollutants. The grading plan shall be prepared by a California licensed civil engineer, and shall comply with following requirements: 1. The grading on the project site shall be designed for the efficient use of water by minimizing soil erosion, runoff, and water waste, resulting from precipitation and irrigation. 2. The plan shall show the finished configurations and elevations of each landscaped area including the height of graded slopes, the drainage pattern, pad elevations, finish grade, and any storm water retention improvements. J. Irrigation Schedule The irrigation schedule shall be prepared by a licensed landscape architect, licensed civil engineer, licensed architect or other landscape professional appropriately licensed by the State, and shall provide the following information: 1. A description of the automatic irrigation system that will be used for the project. 2. The irrigation schedule shall consider irrigation run times, emission device, flow rate, and current reference evapotranspiration so that applied water meets the estimated total water use. Total annual applied water shall be less than or equal to maximum applied water allowance (MAWA). Actual irrigation schedules shall be regulated by automatic irrigation controllers using current reference evapotranspiration data or soil moisture sensor data. 3. Overhead irrigation will be scheduled between 4:00 p.m. and 9:00 a.m., unless weather conditions prevent it. Operation of the irrigation system outside the normal watering window is allowed for auditing and system maintenance. 4. The parameters used for setting the irrigation system controller for watering times for: a. The plant establishment period. b. Different seasons during the year. c. Established landscaping and temporarily irrigated areas. d. Irrigation uniformity or efficiency setting. 5. The consideration used for each station based on the following factors: a. The days between irrigation. b. Stations run time in minutes for each irrigation event, designed to avoid runoff. 178 Title 18 Zoning c. Number of cycle starts required for each irrigation event, designed to avoid runoff. d. Amount of water to be applied on a monthly basis. e. The root depth setting. f. The plant type setting. g. The soil type. h. The slope factor. i. The shade factor. j. Application rate setting. k. Irrigation uniformity or efficiency setting. K. Maximum Applied Water Use 1. A landscape project subject to this section shall not exceed the MAWA. The MAWA for a landscape project shall be determined by the following calculation: MAWA = (ETo)(0.62)[0.7 x LA + 0.3 x SLAI. 2. The abbreviations used in the equation have the following meanings: a. MAWA = Maximum Applied Water Allowance in gallons per year. b. ETo = Evapotranspiration in inches per year. c. 0.62 = Conversion factor to gallons per square foot. d. 0.7 = ET adjustment factor for plant factors and irrigation efficiency. e. LA = Landscaped area includes special landscaped area in square feet. f. 0.3 = the additional ET adjustment factor for a special landscaped area (1.0 - 0.7 = 0.3). g. SLA = Portion of the landscaped area identified as a special landscaped area in square feet. L. Estimated Total Water Use 1. An applicant for a project subject to Section 18.44.190 shall calculate the ETWU for each landscaped area and the entire project using the following equation: ETWU = (ETo)(0.62)(PF x HA/IE + SLA). 2. The abbreviations used in the equation have the following meanings: a. ETWU = Estimated total water use in gallons per year. b. ETo = Evapotranspiration in inches per year. c. 0.62 = Conversion factor to gallons per square foot. d. PF = Plant factor from WUCOLS. e. HA = Hydrozone Area in square feet. Each HA shall be classified based upon the data included in the landscape and irrigation plan as high, medium, or low water use. f. IE = Irrigation Efficiency of the irrigation method used in the hydrozone. g. SLA = Special landscaped area in square feet. 3. The ETWU for a proposed project shall not exceed the MAWA. M. Adjustment to Landscaped Area for Non -Vegetated Area Rock and stone or pervious design features, such as decomposed granite ground cover that are adjacent to a vegetated area may be included in the calculation of the MAWA and ETWU provided the features are integrated into the design of the landscape area and the primary purpose of the feature is decorative. N. Regulations Applicable to Use of Turf on Landscaped Areas The following regulations shall apply to the use of turf on a project subject to Section 18.44.190: 1. Only low volume or subsurface irrigation shall be used for turf in a landscaped area when either of the following occurs: a. On a slope greater than 25 percent grade where the toe of the slope is adjacent to an impermeable hardscape. b. Where any dimension of the landscaped area is less than eight feet wide. 2. On a roadway improvement project, commercial, industrial, institutional, or multi -family project, no turf shall be allowed on a center island median strip or on a parking lot island. 3. A ball field. park, golf course, cemetery, and other similar use shall be designed to limit turf in any portion of a landscaped area not essential for the operation of the facility. 179 Title 18 Zoning 4. No turf shall be allowed in a landscaped area that cannot be efficiently irrigated to avoid runoff or overspray. O. Projects with Model Homes A person who obtains a permit to construct a single family residential development that contains a model home or homes shall provide a summary of this section to each adult visitor that visits a model home. If an adult visitor is accompanied by one or more adults during the visit only one set of written materials is required to be provided. Each model home shall provide an educational sign in the front yard of the model home visible and readable from the roadway that the home faces that states in capital black lettering at least two inches high on a white sign, 'THIS MODEL HOME USES WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPING AND IRRIGATION." P. Recycled Water 1. A person who obtains a permit for a project that is subject to this section shall use recycled water for irrigation and decorative water features when tertiary treated recycled water is available from the water purveyor who supplies water to the property. 2_ A person using recycled water shall install a dual distribution system for water received from the water purveyor. Pipes carrying recycled water shall be purple. 3. A person who uses recycled water under this section shall be entitled to an ETAF of 1.0. 4. This section does not excuse a person using recycled water from complying with all state and local laws and regulations related to recycled water use. Q. Landscaping and Irrigation Installation A person issued a landscape approval for a project shall install the approved landscaping and irrigation system before final inspection of the project. R. Landscaping and Irrigation Maintenance 1. A property owner using water on property subject to a landscape approval shall prepare a maintenance schedule for the landscaping and irrigation system on the project. The schedule shall provide for (1) routine inspection to guard against runoff and erosion and detect plant or irrigation system failure; (2) replacement of dead, dying and diseased vegetation; (3) eradication of invasive species; (4) repairing the irrigation system and its components; (5) replenishing mulch; (6) soil amendment when necessary to support and maintain healthy plant growth; (7) fertilizing, pruning, and weeding and maintaining turf areas; and (8) maintenance to avoid obstruction of motorists' view. The schedule shall also identify who will be responsible for maintenance. 2. After approval of a landscape plan, the owner is required to: a. Maintain and operate the landscaping and irrigation system on the property consistent with the MAWA. b. Maintain the irrigation system to achieve efficiency that meets or exceeds the MAWA. c. Replace broken or malfunctioning irrigation system components with components of the same materials and specifications, their equivalent or better. d. Ensure that when vegetation is replaced, replacement plantings are representative of the hydrozone in which the plants were removed, and are typical of the water use requirements of the plants removed, provided that the replaced vegetation does not result in mixing high-water use plants with low-water use plants in the same hydrozone. 180 Title 18 Zoning S. Certificate of Completion Each person issued a landscape approval shall submit: 1. A signed certificate of completion, under penalty of perjury, on a form provided by the City of National City within ten days after installation, that includes the following: a. A statement verifying that the landscaping and irrigation were installed as allowed in the approved landscape and irrigation plan, all recommended approved soil amendments identified in the soil management report were implemented, the installed irrigation system is functioning as designed and approved, the irrigation control system was properly programmed in accordance with the irrigation schedule, and the person operating the system has received all required maintenance and irrigation plans. b. "As -built" plans submitted by the landscape design professional of record showing the changes when there have been significant changes to the landscape plan during the installation of landscaping or irrigation devices or irrigation system components. c. Signature by the landscape design professional of record. 2. An irrigation schedule that complies with Subsection J that describes the irrigation times and water usage for the project. 3. A landscaping and irrigation system maintenance schedule that complies with Subsection R. 4. A soil management report that complies with Subsection F if the applicant did not submit the report with the landscape documentation package. T. Waste Water Prevention No person shall use water for irrigation that results in runoff, low head drainage, overspray or other similar condition, water flows onto adjacent property, non -irrigated areas, structures, walkways, roadways, or other paved areas. CHAPTER 18-45 - OFF-STREET PARKING AND LOADING 18.45.010 Purpose 18.45.020 Requirements, General 18.454.030 Offsite Facilities 18.45.040 Site Plan Review Required 18.45.050 Off -Street Parking Requirement by Land Use 18.45.060 Westside Specific Plan Parking Requirements 18.45.070 Parking for Commercial Vehicles 18.45.080 Opportunities for Reduced Parking 18.45.090 Parking for Disabled Persons 18.45.100 Parking Lot Design Standards 18.45.110 Loading Requirements 18.45.120 Bicycle Parking 18.45.010 PURPOSE A. Intent of this Chapter 1. Provide for the establishment of accessory off-street parking and loading facilities incidental to new uses and to major alterations and enlargements of existing uses, in order to prevent or to progressively alleviate traffic congestion and shortage of curb space; 2. Prescribe minimum off-street parking and loading requirements for the various structures and uses irrespective of the districts in which they occur; 3. Ensure that off-street parking and loading facilities are designed, developed and maintained in a manner that will assure their usefulness, provide for public safety, and, where appropriate, insulate surrounding uses from their impact. 18.45.020 REQUIREMENTS — GENERAL 181 Title 18 Zoning For any structure or use hereafter constructed, established, substantially altered, increased in intensity of use, or changed in, off-street parking and loading facilities conforming to the requirements of this Chapter shall be provided on the same lot as the main building or structure or on contiguous property. A. Required for New or Moved Structures Parking and loading facilities shall be provided for all structures and uses hereafter constructed, established, or moved to new sites. B. Additional Facilities for Altered Structures — Requirements 1. Additional parking and loading facilities need not be provided where any structure is renovated or repaired, provided said structure is not increased in intensity of use or changed to a use requiring additional facilities. 2. Parking and loading facilities shall be provided in accordance with the requirements for an equivalent new structure where any such structure is in any way structurally altered to the extent of more than twice the latest assessed valuation prior to the alteration. (This provision applies to existing structures which, upon the effective date of the National City Land Use Code, are nonconforming as to parking and loading. The "latest assessed valuation" requirement is identical to the requirement for all nonconforming structures under the nonconforming provisions.) C. Increase in Intensity of Use 1. For the purpose of this Chapter, an increase in the intensity of use of any structure or premises shall mean the addition of dwelling units, employees, gross floor area, sealing capacity, or any other unit of measurement specified in this title as a basis for determining required parking and loading facilities. 2. When the intensity of use of any structure or premises, excluding single-family detached dwellings, is increased by less than 50 percent, parking and loading facilities shall be provided for the increase but not for any existing deficiency in such facilities. 3. When the intensity of use is increased by more than 50 percent, excluding single-family detached dwellings, parking and loading facilities shall be provided for the entire structure or premises. 4. When consecutive increases in intensity of use amount to a total increase of more than 50 percent, parking and loading facilities shall be provided far the entire structure or premises. Consecutive increases shall be figured from the effective date of the National City Land Use Code or from the time of the initial construction or establishment, whichever is more recent. 5. When a single-family detached dwelling is increased or expanded to more than 2,500 square feet of floor area and/or more than four bedrooms, off-street parking facilities shall be provided for the increase but not for any existing deficiency in such facilities. Parking facilities required as a result of this Chapter may be provided in a garage, carport, or surface space. D. Change in Use When the use of any structure or premises is changed to a different use, parking and loading facilities shall be provided for the different use, in compliance with the provisions of this section for increase in intensity of use. E. Permitted Facilities Any off-street parking or loading facility which is permitted but not required by this title shall comply with all regulations in this Chapter governing the location, design, improvement, operation and maintenance of such facilities. F. Reduction of Existing Facilities 182 Title 18 Zoning Accessory parking and loading facilities in existence on the effective date of the National City Land Use Code, or authorized and subsequently established under a building permit issued prior to said effective date, shall not be reduced below, or if already less than, shall not be further reduced below, the requirements for an equivalent new structure or use. All such facilities shall be continued for as long as the structure or use served is continued, or until equivalent facilities are substituted in conformance with the requirements of this title. In no case, however, shall it be necessary to continue parking or loading facilities in excess of those required by this title for equivalent new structures or uses. 18.45.030 OFFSITE FACILITIES A. Offsite Facilities — Recorded Agreements 1. Where required parking or loading facilities are provided on a lot other than the lot on which the structure or use served is located, as a prerequisite to the issuance of a building permit or certificate of occupancy, the property owners for which the facilities are required to be provided shall record an agreement, approved by the City Attorney as to form and content, in the Office of the County Recorder as a covenant running with the land for the benefit of the city. The agreement shall provide that said facilities shall be continued so long as the structure or use they intended to serve is continued. 2. Said agreement shall remain in effect until satisfactory evidence has been submitted to the Planning Division either that other parking or loading facilities meeting the requirements of this title have been provided or that the structure or use served has been removed or changed so as to no longer require said facilities. Upon submission of such evidence, the Planning Division shall remove the restriction from the property. B. Offsite Facilities — Certificate of Occupancy for Building or Structure Being Served 1. Any certificate of occupancy for the structure or use referred to in Section 18.43.030(A) shall be valid only while such parking facilities are continued and shall bear a notation to that effect. 2. Each such certificate shall be continuously displayed in a conspicuous place in the building, or, if there is no building, on the premises. The City Manager or his/her designee shall keep a record of each off -site parking or loading facility and shall periodically inspect such facilities to ensure their continuation. 3. If such facilities are not continued, the certificate of occupancy for the structure or use served by the facilities shall be automatically canceled. The Building Official shall notify the person having custody of said structure or use of the cancellation of the certificate and the reasons therefore. The structure or use shall not thereafter be occupied or used until the required facilities are again provided in accordance with the provisions of this title and a new certificate is issued. C. Requirements --General Where there is a combination of structures or uses on a lot, the total number of parking stalls and loading facilities required shall be the sum of the individual requirements of the various structures or uses on the premises. D. Unspecified Uses — Determination of Parking Requirements Parking requirements for structures and uses not specified in Section 18.45.050 shall be determined by the Planning Commission based on the requirements for the most comparable structure or use specified. 18.45.040 SITE PLAN REVIEW REQUIRED 183 Title 18 Zoning All parking facility improvements shall comply with the provisions of Chapter 1 Section 18.12.070 (Site Plan Review). Improvements subject to review include, but are not limited to, driveways, access to streets and alleys, arrangement of parking stalls, aisles and maneuvering areas, signs and traffic -control devices, striping, surfacing, lighting, landscaping, screening, pedestrian walkways, fire access ways, obstructions, traffic flow and protective barriers. 18.45.050 OFF-STREET PARKING REQUIREMENTS BY LAND USE The off-street parking and loading spaces as required by this section shall be completed and made available for use, including curb break and driveway installed to the established grade of the street, prior to the occupancy of the building served. A. Off -Street Parking Schedule Each land use shall be provided the number of parking spaces required as determined in Table 18.45.050. In addition, the following information shall be used to determine off-street parking requirements. 1. Floor area. Where Table 18.45.050 establishes a parking requirement based on the floor area of a use in a specified number of square feet (e.g., 1 space per 250 square feet), the floor area shall be construed to mean gross floor area. 2. Fractions. Where application of the requirements in Table 18.45.050 results in a fractional requirement, a fraction of 0.5 or greater shall be increased to the next higher number and a fraction of less than 0.5 shall be reduced to the next lower number. (Remainder of Page Intentionally Left Blank) 184 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.45.050 Schedule of Off -Street Parking Requirements by Land Use Uses and Structures Minimum Parking Spaces Required (Unless Otherwise Specifed} Residential Uses Dwelling, single detached (RS-1 zone) 2 covered spaces, plus one additional uncovered space per bedroom greater than four bedrooms or one additional uncovered space for dwellings greater than 2,500 SF, whichever is greater Dwelling, single detached (all other RS and RM zones, except within the Westside Specific Plan area) One covered space and one uncovered space, plus one additional uncovered space per bedroom greater than four bedrooms or one additional uncovered space for dwellings greater than 2,500 SF, whichever is greater. Dwelling, single attached 1.5 spaces ger dwelling unit in a garage or carport Dwelling, multiple 1.3 spaces per 1-bedroom dwelling unit plus 1.5 spaces per 2- bedroom or more unit, and conveniently located guest parking of'' space per unit for 20 units or less, plus'/< space for each unit over 20. Half of the required guest parking spaces may include parking spaces on dedicated public streets along the sides of the streets that are ad'acent to the site. Fraternity, Sorority House, or Dormitor 1.5 spaces for each sleeping room Mobile Home Parks 2 spaces per unit Rectory 1 garage space per bedroom Roorning or boarding house 1 space per guest room Second dwelling unit 1 space in addition to primary residence parking requirements Senior Housing 1 s ace er unit lus 1 guest space for each 10 units RS-4 (Westside Specific Plan): Units greater than 1,200 square feet 2 spaces per unit RS-4 (Westside Specific Plan): Units less than 1,200 square feet 1.7 spaces per unit Commercial and Office Uses Banks and financial institutions 3 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Offices, administrative, clerical, and professional • First 5,000 square feet • 5,000 to 10,000 square feet • 10,000 to 30,000 square feet • 30,000 to 100,000 square feet • Over 100,000 square feet Number of required parking spaces varies depending on the amount of floor area as identified in the column to the left. • 1 space per 200 square feet floor area • 1 space per 250 square feet floor area • 1 space per 300 square feet floor area • 1 space per 350 square feet floor area • 1 s ace er 400 square feet floor area Offices, medical/dental office or outpatient clinic, veterinary hospitals and clinics 1 space per 300 square feet floor area Lodging — Hotel, motel, bed and breakfast inn 1 for each guest bedroom, plus 1 for the manager's unit Restaurant, bar, nightclub, pool hall, bowling alley, or similar establishment 10 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Gasoline service station 1 space per 1,000 square feet of lot area; less the footprint of any convenience store area, plus 3.3 spaces per 1,000 square feet of convenience store area Commercial recreation, indoor 2.5 s aces er 1,000 s uare feet floor area Retail sales 1 for each 250 square feet of floor area Personal services 1 s ace per 300 square feet of floor area Shopping centers with multi le tenants 1 space per 200 square feet floor area Vehicle repair or service, including car wash 1 space per 500 square feet floor area Vehicle sales or rental (new and used) 1 space per 500 square feet floor area plus one per every 2,500 square feet outdoor display area Theater/auditorium, stadium/sports arena 1 s ace er 5 seats Mausoleum/crematory 25 s aces er 1,000 square feet of seating area CI- zone (Westside Specific Plan): Office 2.9 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area CL zone (Westside Specific Plan : Retail 16 s aces per 1,000 square feet floor area CL zone (Westside Specific Plan). Industrial 2 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area 185 Title 18 Zoning Mixed -Uses in the MXD and MXC Zones Non-residential uses Minimum: 2 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Residential — studio, 1 bedroom, and 2 bedroom units Minimum. 1 space per unit Residential — 3 or more bedroom units Minimum 1_5 spaces per unit MCR Zones in the Westside Specific Plan Residential units greater than 1200 square feet 1.5 spaces per unit Residential units less than 1200 square feet 1 space per unit Office uses 2.9 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Retail uses 3.6 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Industrial uses 2 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Industrial Uses Industrial manufacturing and processing uses, waterfront related industry, wholesaling, warehousing, and distribution 1 space for each 1,000 square feet of floor area Industrial/building supplies and equipment, sales and rentals 1 space per 800 square feet floor area Research and development 1 space per 400 square feet of floor area Recycling facilities 2 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Animal boarding/kennel 1 space per 500 square feet floor area Trucking and transportation terminal 2 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area plus 1 space for every 2 fleet vehicles Institutional Uses Hospital or other inpatient medical institution 1 space per 3 beds, excluding bassinets Civic, fraternal, community, and cultural facilities 1 space per every 200 square feet of floor space open to the public plus 1 space per each 300 square feet of administrative office area Public/religious assembly, fraternal lodge or club, banquet fall!facilities, and similar establishments 1 space for every 35 square feet of seating area Convention center 1 space per 50 square feet floor area Child day care center, preschool, or nursery school 2 spaces per 1,000 square feet floor area Schools, elementary and middle 1.5 spaces per classroom plus area one space for each 300 square feet of office area Schools, high 1 space per each 150 square feet of classroom area plus one space for each 300 square feet office area Schools, trade, college/university, business, adult education 1 space per 40 square feet of classroom area plus 1 space per 300 square feet of office area Open Space/Agriculture Neighborhood and community farms Minimum 2 parking spaces, plus one additional space for every acre of garden site lot arca over 2 acres. Each garden site that includes a farm stand shall provide 1 additional space for every 250 feet of floor area and outdoor display space. 186 Title 18 Zoning 18.45.060 WESTSIDE SPECIFIC AREA PLAN PARKING REQUIREMENTS A. Shared parking for mixed use in MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones Shared parking may be considered where 50 percent of the parking may be shared between daytime uses (commercial and office) and nighttime uses (residential). B. Joint parking arrangements Joint parking arrangements may be developed on -site or within an off -site parking lot or parking structure located within 500 feet of the property line of the development. C. Tandem parking 1. Two -car tandem garages are permitted within the RS-4 zone. A two -car tandem garage shall measure a minimum of ten feet wide by 38 feet long. A tandem parking space within a parking structure shall be a minimum of 8.5-feet wide by 36-feet long. 2. A maximum of 25 percent of multi -family development may be provided with tandem parking spaces. 3. Tandem parking is permitted when a mechanical lift parking device is used. See subsection 18.45.100.G. 18.45.070 PARKING FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLES In addition to the parking spaces required by Table 18.45.050, for owners, occupants, employees, customers, or visitors of structures and uses, one parking space shall be provided for each commercial vehicle used in connection with the operation of any structure or use. Parking spaces for accessory vehicles shall be provided within an open or enclosed parking facility on the same lot as the structure or use to which the vehicles are accessory. 18.45.080 OPPORTUNITIES FOR REDUCED PARKING A. Transportation Demand Management Program (TDM) The Planning Commission, appealable to City Council, may approve a reduction in off-street parking spaces otherwise required by the strict application of this section, subject to conditions it deems appropriate, when the applicant has demonstrated to the City's satisfaction that, due to the TDM program, that the spaces proposed to be eliminated for the subject development are unnecessary and that the reduction will not adversely affect the site or the adjacent area. A TDM program shall include, at a minimum, the following components: 1. A projected reduction in parking demand expressed as a percentage of overall parking demand and the basis for such reduction; 2. The TDM program actions to be taken by the applicant to reduce the parking demand; 3. A requirement by the applicant to periodically monitor whether the projected reductions are being achieved; and 4. A commitment and plan whereby the applicant shall provide additional parking spaces in an amount equivalent to the reduction should the TDM program not result in the projected reduction in parking demand. B. Proximity to Transit The Planning Commission, appealable to City Council, may approve a reduction in off-street parking spaces otherwise required by the strict application of this section, subject to conditions that it deems appropriate, when the subject development is conveniently accessible to a transit station. The transit station must either exist or is programmed for completion within the same time frame as the completion of the subject development. In addition, the subject development shall be located within a quarter -mile radius (1,320 feet) of the transit station. Such reduction may be approved when the applicant has proven 187 Title 18 Zoning that the parking spaces proposed to be eliminated are unnecessary based on the projected parking demand resulting from the proximity to the transit station and such reduction in parking spaces will not adversely affect the site or the adjacent area. Parking may be reduced to no more than two parking spaces per 1,000 square feet of commercial floor area and multi -unit residential parking requirements may be reduced to no more than space for studio, one -bedroom, and two -bedroom units and two spaces for three -bedroom units. C. Shared Parking The Planning Commission, appealable to City Council, encourages parking lots for different structures or uses, or for mixed -uses, to be shared. At the applicant's request, a reduction in off-street parking spaces otherwise required by the strict application of this section, subject to conditions it deems appropriate, when the applicant has demonstrated to the review authority's satisfaction that, due to the shared parking approach, that the spaces proposed to be eliminated for the subject development are unnecessary and that the reduction will not adversely affect the site or the adjacent area. Uses that are sharing the parking facility shall be a maximum of 500 feet from the closest parking space in a lot providing the shared spaces. D. Adjacent On -Street Parking The Planning Commission, appealable to City Council, may approve a reduction in off-street parking spaces otherwise required by the strict application of this section, subject to conditions it deems appropriate, when the applicant has demonstrated to the City's satisfaction that the spaces proposed to be eliminated for the subject development are unnecessary and that the reduction will not adversely affect the site or the adjacent area. A reduction in parking spaces will only be allowed for adjacent on -street parking when said spaces are located along the public street frontage shared with the building's facade. For example, if a building fronting a public street measures 100 linear feet and four parking spaces are located adjacent to the 100 linear feet of frontage, the parking reduction may be four spaces. Fractions of spaces will not be permitted to count towards the reduction allowance. E. Car -sharing The Planning Commission, appealable to City Council, may approve a reduction in off-street parking spaces otherwise required by the strict application of this section, subject to conditions it deems appropriate, when the applicant has demonstrated to the City's satisfaction that the spaces proposed to be eliminated for the subject development are unnecessary and that the reduction will not adversely affect the site or the adjacent area. A reduction of one parking space for each car sharing vehicle space leased by a car sharing program may be allowed for every 60 dwelling units in a multi -unit residential development. F. Motorcycle Parking Spaces Parking lots with 40 or more spaces may replace regular spaces with motorcycle spaces. One regular space may be replaced for each 40 required spaces. Motorcycle spaces shall be a minimum size of four feet by eight feet. Although more spaces may be provided, a maximum of two -and -one-half percent of the total parking space requirement based on the strict application of this section may be motorcycle parking spaces provided in lieu of automobile parking space. Motorcycle parking spaces shall be located within 100 feet of a building entry. 18.45.090 PARKING FOR DISABLED PERSONS A. California Vehicle Code Properly posted and identified off-street parking stalls reserved for disabled persons shall be provided pursuant to California Vehicle Code Section 21107.8 et seq. or the most recently adopted Chapter 11 of 188 Title 18 Zoning the California Building Code. Such parking stalls shall be included in the minimum number of parking stalls required by this Chapter. 18.45.100 PARKING LOT DESIGN STANDARDS A. Setbacks 1. Parking facilities may occupy any portion of a lot, except and as provided by this section. 2. Parking facilities shall not extend into any required yard that adjoins a street lot line. 3. Where a parking facility is on a lot not in a residential zone but which adjoins a residential zone along the same street, the parking facility shall not be located closer to the street lot line than would be permitted on the adjoining residential zone lot or 20 feet, whichever is less. The street setback provided by this provision shall extend for a distance of at least 50 feet from the adjoining residential zone. 4. All required yards separating off-street parking areas from street lot lines shall be landscaped in accordance with this chapter, except multi -unit residential projects of eight units or less. 5. All parking stalls in an open parking facility shall be setback from any dwelling unit wall on the same lot if the wall contains doors or windows which are on the same or approximately the same level as the parking facility. The setback shall be at least ten feet in width, at least one-half the width of which shall be unpaved. B. Minimum Dimensions: Stalls, Back -Up Areas, and Aisles All parking stalls for a standard size car shall measure no less than nine feet wide and 18 feet long. All two-way aisles providing access to parking stalls, including compact parking spaces, shall provide a minimum back-up and maneuvering distance of 12 feet for each space. In no instance may a two-way aisle measure less than 18 feet in width. All one-way aisles providing access to parking stalls, including compact parking spaces, shall provide a minimum back-up and maneuvering distance of 12 feet for each space, but in no instance may a one-way aisle measure less than 12 feet width. The following diagrams illustrate the minimum layout of parking stalls, back-up space, and drive aisles. The minimum back-up area for two-way aisles is 24-feet. All aisles shall be adequate to provide safe and efficient access to and from parking spaces, based on minimum standards administered by the City Traffic Engineer. Two feet shall be added to the width of the stall for stalls abutting a building. fence, or other obstruction. 189 Title 18 Zoning Parking Lot Design Standards Dimensions No tes!-, Than 1S' 18' 12' 12' 18' o i = LLJ 74TO Standard Size Car Minimum Stall, Back -Up, and Two -Way Aisle Dimensions 16' Min. 2,4° No Less than 18' 16' 12' 12' 24' Total Compact Size Car Minimum Stall, Back -Up, and Two -Way Aisle Dimensions 18' \,/\'‘,/ No 1.ess Than 17 Standard Size Car Minimum Stall, Back -Up, and One -Way Aisle Dimensions No Less Than 12' Compact Size Car Minimum Stall, Back -Up, and One -Way Aisle Dimensions 190 Title 18 Zoning C. Parking Stalls — General Provisions 1. Parking stalls --openings. All parking stalls shall open directly on a maneuvering or turnaround area, an access driveway, or an aisle leading to an access driveway, and shall be individually and continuously accessible. 2. Parking stalls --location. All parking stalls shall be so located and free of obstructions that parking can be accomplished in a continuous forward movement and unparking can be accomplished with not more than one backing movement and one forward movement. 3. Vertical clearance. Each parking space shall have a vertical clearance of at least seven feet. D. Driveways and Aisles — General Provisions 1. Access to streets or alleys. a. Access driveways shall be provided between each parking facility and a public street or alley. Lots should not have access from predominantly residential streets, except when the lot is serving a residential use. Residential driveways shall be permitted only on an arterial street where no other access to the property exists. b. One-way driveways and driveways serving a single-family residence shall have a minimum width of 12 feet; except for driveways leading to a single car garage or parking space where the City Manager or his/her designee may authorize a lesser width. c. Two-way driveways between a street and private parking facilities shall have a minimum width of 18 feet. Two-way driveways between a street and public parking facilities shall have a minimum width of 24 feet. Two-way driveways within a parking facility connecting separated areas of parking spaces shall have a minimum width of 18 feet, or as otherwise required by this section. d. Where access is available from any adjoining or abutting alley to any lot proposed for residential or mixed use development in the commercial zones, access to the required residential parking facility shall be from that alley when appropriate to avoid access to commercial collector or arterial streets. 2. Internal circulation --generally. All parking facilities, except those serving not more than two dwelling units, shall be arranged so that: a. Any vehicle entering a public street can do so traveling in a forward motion; b. A vehicle entering the parking facility shall not be required to enter a street to move from one location to any other location within the parking facility or premises. 3. Internal circulation --serving not more than two dwelling units. Parking facilities serving not more than two dwelling units shall be arranged so that any vehicle entering a street can do so traveling in a forward motion where: a. The parking facility is served by a single access driveway that is less than 20 feet in width and more than 100 feet in length; b. The access driveway opens upon an arterial street. 4. Vehicle maneuver restrictions. All parking facilities, except those serving not more than two dwelling units, shall be arranged so that parking maneuvers can be accomplished without driving, maneuvering, or encroaching into or upon any public right-of-way, walkway, or unpaved landscaped area within or adjoining the parking facility. 5. Parking facilities --Driveway vertical clearance. The minimum vertical clearance for driveways shall be 13 feet six inches to allow for the passage of emergency vehicles, or as required by the City Fire Department, whichever is greater. 6. Parking facilities --aisles, approach lanes, and maneuvering areas for two-way traffic. For two-way traffic within parking facilities, all aisles, approach lanes and maneuvering areas shall have a minimum width as specified in this section or as required by the City Fire Department for emergency access, whichever is greater. 7. Parking facilities --one-way aisles --width. One-way aisles shall have a minimum width of 12 feet or as specified in this section, whichever is greater. 8. Parking facilities --one-way aisles --directional markings. One-way aisles shall have directional markings to indicate one-way circulation. 191 Title 18 Zoning 9. Parking facilities --entrances and exits. a. The location and design of all street or alley entrances and exits for off-street parking facilities shall be subject to the approval of the City Engineer, to insure traffic safety. b. Each exit to a parking lot shall be constructed and maintained so that any vehicle leaving the parking lot shall be clearly visible to a person reaching a point ten feet from the edge of the approach to the driveway nearest to him, when the vehicle is at a point distant ten feet from the property line within the parking lot. Exits from parking lots shall be clearly posted with stop signs. Appropriate bumper guards, entrance and exit signs, and directional signs shall be maintained where needed. Upon a finding that parking facilities cause imminent hazard upon adjoining public streets, the City Engineer may order the placement and maintenance of such guards and signs. Failure to comply with any such order may be grounds for a finding of a public nuisance. 10. Vertical clearance. The minimum vertical clearance for driveways shall be 13 feet six inches to allow for the passage of emergency vehicles, or as required by (he City Fire Department, whichever is greater. E. Compact Car Parking 1. In the industrial, institutional zones, commercial, and mixed -use zones (except retail uses) 25 percent of the parking stalls required by the schedules set out in this section may be allocated to compact car spaces. No compact parking spaces shall be permitted for retail uses and guest and visitor parking. 2. For residential multifamily use, one parking space may be compact in size for every ten parking spaces required. 3. All parking spaces provided in excess of the number required by Table 18.45.050 set out in this section may be allocated to compact car spaces. 4. All parking facilities constructed, installed or modified to incorporate compact car spaces shall comply with the provisions of this section. Design features subject to review shall include, but are not limited to, specific findings of good circulation, adaptability to balance of parking lot, easy identification and adequate signs and pavement markings. The design of such signs and markings shall be subject to approval of the Planning Division. 5. Maintenance of parking facilities pursuant to this section shall also include maintenance of all special compact car signs and pavement markings shown on approved site plans or otherwise required by this section. 6. The dimensions of compact car parking stalls, back-up areas, and drive aisles shall be as indicated in the diagrams in Section 18.45.100(B). F. Dimensions for Garage or Carport Areas and Openings 1. A one -car garage or carport shall contain an unobstructed interior parking area of a minimum of 11 feet wide by 19 feet deep. A two -car garage or carport shall contain an unobstructed interior parking area of a minimum of twenty feet wide by nineteen feet deep. 2. A garage for more than two cars shall contain a minimum area of nine feet by 18 feet for each additional car. 3. A single -car garage door or opening to a single space carport shall be a minimum of eight feet wide; a two -car garage door or opening to a two -space carport shall be a minimum of 16 feet wide. For larger parking garages or carports serving multifamily residential or nonresidential development, openings shall be increased in width by at least one foot if a column, post, or similar obstruction is located within at least three -and -one-half feet of the opening to the stall. G. Mechanical Lift Parking Mechanical lifts for vertical storage of vehicles are permitted in the Downtown and Westside Specific Plan areas. Each vertically stacked space shall count as one space. Mechanical lifts shall be completely enclosed or fully screened from street view and adjacent residential zones. Vertically stacked vehicles are exempt from the seven foot vertical clearance requirement. All mechanical parking equipment must be designed, installed, constructed, and maintained so as to be reasonably safe to life, limb, and adjoining 192 Title 18 Zoning property and must be reviewed by the City Manager or his/her designee prior to installation or construction. H. Motorcycle Parking Each motorcycle parking space shall measure at least four feet wide and 32 square feet in total area. Motorcycle parking spaces shall be located within 100 feet of a building entry. I. Pedestrian Walkways 1. All parking facilities shall have safe, unobstructed, convenient, well -drained pedestrian access by provision of walks, steps or stepped ramps, so constructed as to assure reasonable durability and economy of maintenance. 2. Pedestrian walkways shall be a minimum of five feet in width. Pedestrian walkways located immediately adjacent to and perpendicular to a parking stall shall be a minimum of six feet. 3. The preferred gradient for pedestrian walkways is no greater than five percent. Pedestrian walkways shall not exceed a gradient of 12 percent. Pedestrian walkways between five percent and 12 percent gradients shall be provided with handrails. 18.45.110 LOADING REQUIREMENTS A. General Provisions 1. On the same premises with every building, structure or part erected and occupied in the commercial or industrial zones, there shall be provided and maintained, on the lot, adequate space for standing, loading and unloading services, in order to avoid undue interference with public use of the streets or alleys. 2. Such space, unless otherwise adequately provided for, shall include one 12 foot by 50 foot loading space with a 14 foot height clearance for every 20,000 square feet or fraction thereof of building floor area, or for every 20,000 square feet or fraction thereof of land use. 3. All loading facilities shall be improved in accordance with the requirements established for parking facilities by this section. 4. Required loading facilities shall be used exclusively for the loading and unloading of vehicles concerned with the transportation of goods or materials. Loading facilities shall not be used to satisfy the stall requirements for parking facilities, nor shall they be used for the sale, display, rental or repair of motor vehicles. 5. Loading facilities shall be screened as provided in this section except that all loading berths exceeding 25 feet in length which are located within 50 feet of a residential zone shall be enclosed or screened from the residential zone by a solid masonry wall not less than six feet nor more than eight feet in height. 6. No interior landscaping of loading areas shall be required. 7. All loading facilities shall be arranged so that any vehicle utilizing the facility may enter a street traveling in a forward motion. 8. Each loading berth shall open directly upon a maneuvering or turnaround area, an access driveway, an aisle leading to an access driveway, or an alley, and shall be easily accessible. 9. All access driveways serving loading facilities shall conform to the requirements established in this section for parking facility access driveways, but in addition shall be located so that any street entrance or exit to or from the loading facility is at a point at least 50 feel from the nearest point of intersection of any two streets and at least 30 feet from any lot in a residential district. B. Number of Spaces Required The following loading and unloading spaces shall be provided and maintained as specified below for the use to which the property is devoted. Fractional requirements are omitted. Encroachment of the loading space on a public right-of-way is not permitted. 193 Title 18 Zoning 1. Retail and wholesale markets, warehouses, hotels, hospitals, laundry and dry cleaning establishments and other places where large amounts of goods are received and shipped, no loading space is required for a building less than 10,000 square feet in gross floor area. 2. For such buildings with 10,000 to 40,000 square feet in gross floor area, one off-street loading space shall be required. 3. For such buildings with greater than 40,000 square feet in gross floor area, one off-street loading space is required for each 40,000 square feet in total gross floor area. 18.45.120 BICYCLE PARKING A. Number of Spaces Required The following minimum off-street bicycle parking facilities shall be required for all new or expanded developments. Calculation of bicycle parking facilities shall be based on the off-street vehicle parking spaces required prior to consideration of any vehicle parking reduction measures. Fractional requirements up to one-half shall be omitted. One-half or over shall require one space. Calculation of bicycle parking facilities for mixed use land uses shall be based on the individual use as identified in Table 18.45.120A, below. TABLE 18.45.120A Bicycle Parking Requirements by Land Use Use Required Number of Bicycle Parking Spaces Multi -family Residential 1 for every 10 vehicle parking spaces Senior Housing 1 space for every 20 dwelling units Health Care Facilities 1 space for every 10 vehicle parking spaces Retail Commercial, Public and Civic 1 space for every 20 vehicle parking spaces Public Assembly, Health Clubs, Hotels, Private Clubs and Lodges 1 space for every 10 vehicle parking spaces Business, professional, and corporate office 1 space for every 10 vehicle parking spaces Industrial 1 space for every 10 vehicle parking spaces B. Bicycle Parking Design 1. Bicycle parking facilities shall be installed in a manner which allows adequate spacing for access to the bicycle and the locking device when the facilities are occupied. Space allowances shall be 30 inches wide and six feet long per bicycle and include a five foot maneuvering space behind the bicycle. At least seven feet of vertical clearance is required. 2. The facilities shall be located on a hard dust -free surface, such as asphalt or a concrete slab. 3. Bicycle parking facilities shall be located in view of building entrances or in view of windows and/or security personnel stations. At least 50 percent of required bicycle parking must be located within 50 feet of a customer entrance, and the remainder must be located within 100 feet of any entrance. 4. Bicycle spaces shall be separated from sidewalks, motor vehicle parking spaces or aisles by a fence, wall, or curb, or by at least five feet of open area, marked to prohibit motor vehicle parking. C. Required Shower Facilities All news buildings and additions to existing buildings that result in a total floor area as shown in the following table are encouraged to provide employee showers and dressing areas for each gender as shown in the following Table 18.45.120E 194 Title 18 Zoning TABLE 18.45.120B Required Number of Showers Land Use Number of Showers Required for Specified Building Floor Area 1 Shower for Each Gender 1 Additional Shower for Each Gender Office Use (Business, professional) 50,000 to 149000 square feet Each 100,000 square feet over 150,000 Retail trade and services 100,000 to 299,999 square feet Each 200,000 square feet over 300,000 Industrial/Manufacturing 50,000 square feet or more N/A CHAPTER 18-46 — OUTDOOR LIGHTING 18.46.010 Purpose 18.46.020 Applicability 18.46.030 General Standards 18.46.040 Lighting Plan Requirements 18.46.050 Security Lighting 18.46.060 Accent Lighting 18.46.070 Lighting Standards for Uses with 50 Feet of Residential Zones 18.46.080 Parking Lot Lighting 18.46.090 Lighting of Outdoor Performance Sport and Recreational Facilities 18.46.100 Lighting for Multi Unit Attached Residential Projects 18.46.110 Standards for Single Family Residential Uses 18.46.010 PURPOSE A. Intent and Purpose of this Chapter 1. To provide reasonable restrictions and limitations upon the use of lighting in or near the residential zones of the City so as to prevent lighting from creating a nuisance to residents within said residential zones. It is recognized that lighting is widely used in commercial or industrial zones for the purpose of advertising and security and that such lighting is essential to the conduct of many commercial or industrial enterprises. 2 The City acknowledges that protective security lighting in residential zones constitutes a deterrent to crime and an aid in law enforcement and contributes generally to the safety of those persons residing in such residential zones. It is further accepted that properly controlled lighting in residential areas used for landscaping and highlighting of architectural features of buildings and structures enhances and promotes the aesthetic condition of the property and the general welfare of the area. 3. It is equally recognized that lighting, by virtue of its intensity, brightness, direction, duration and hours of operation, can constitute a nuisance to adjacent residential dwellers. The purpose and intent of this section is to establish outdoor lighting standards that reduce the impacts of glare, light trespass, overlighting, skyglow, and poorly shielded or inappropriately directed lighting fixtures and that promote safety and energy conservation. 4. It is the intent of the City to adopt this section to encourage the continued and appropriate use of lighting for the purposes set forth in this section, but to require that said lighting be regulated and controlled in a mariner so as to avoid the creation of a public nuisance in residential areas_ All outdoor lighting in National City shall be regulated by this Land Use Code and by the State of California Title 24 Energy Efficiency Standards for outdoor lighting requirements. 195 Title 18 Zoning 18.46.020 APPLICABILITY A. New Uses, Buildings, and Additions Unless specifically exempted elsewhere in this Chapter, the provisions of this Chapter shall apply to all outdoor lighting for proposed new land uses, developments, buildings, structures, or building additions that require a permit. B. Non -Conforming Uses, Structures, or Lots Whenever a nonconforming use, structure or lot is abandoned for a period of one year and then recommenced or changed to a new use, then any existing outdoor lighting shall be reviewed and brought into compliance with the provisions of this Chapter as necessary for the entire building, structure or premises, to the maximum extent possible as determined by the Planning Division. 18.46.030 GENERAL STANDARDS A. Outdoor Lighting Fixtures All outdoor lighting fixtures shall be designed, shielded, aimed, located, and maintained to shield adjacent properties and to not produce glare onto adjacent properties or roadways. Parking lot light fixtures and light fixtures on buildings shall be full cut-off fixtures. B. Street Lighting Street lighting shall be provided in accordance with the requirements of the National City Standards Manual. C. Prohibited Lighting Flashing, revolving, intermittent exterior lighting or internally illuminated signs are prohibited. High intensity light beams, such as, but not limited to, outdoor searchlights, lasers, or strobe lights shall be prohibited. D. Lighting for Safety In all multiple family residential, commercial, or industrial developments, all sites shall be well lit so as to provide safe pedestrian and vehicular access and to eliminate dark areas. 18.46.040 LIGHTING PLAN REQUIREMENTS A. Exterior Lighting Plan The applicant shall submit to the Planning Division sufficient information, in the form of an overall exterior lighting plan, to enable the director to determine that the applicable provisions will be satisfied. The exterior lighting plan shall include, at a minimum, the following information: 1. Manufacturer specification sheets, cut sheets or other manufacturer provided information for all proposed lighting fixtures. 2. The proposed location, mounting height, and aiming point of all exterior lighting fixtures. 3. If building elevations are proposed for illumination, drawings shall be provided for all relevant building elevations showing the fixtures, the portions of the elevations to be illuminated, the luminance levels of the elevations, and the aiming point for any remote light fixture. If only architectural lighting below five foot-candles is proposed, this section or any portion of it may be waived by the director. 4. A brief written narrative which describes the objectives of the lighting. 196 Title 18 Zoning 5. Photometric data, Color Rendering Index (CRI) of all lamps (bulbs), and other descriptive information of the fixtures, and, if applicable or required, designation as Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) "cut-off' fixtures. 6. A computer generated photometric grid showing foot-candle readings every ten feet within the property or site, and ten feet beyond the property lines at a scale specified by the director. !so foot- candle contour line style plans may be substituted for the photometric grid. 7. For exterior lighting installations within 50 feet of upper level living units, horizontal and vertical projection of photometric data is required. 8. If needed to review proposed exterior lighting installations, the director may require additional information following the initial lighting plan submittal, including but not limited to: a. Landscaping information that indicates mature tree size; b. Shrubbery and other vegetation in order to evaluate the long-term and seasonal effectiveness of lighting or screening of lighting. 18.46.050 SECURITY LIGHTING A. Defined For the purposes of this section, security lighting is defined to include the following: lighting intended to reduce the risk (real or perceived) of personal attack and lighting intended to discourage intruders, vandals, or burglars, and to protect property. B. Shielded and Aimed All security lighting fixtures shall be shielded and aimed so that illumination is directed only within the owner's property boundaries and not cast on other areas. In no case shall lighting be directed above a horizontal plane through the top of the lighting fixture, and the fixture shall include shields that prevent the light source or lens from being visible from adjacent properties and roadways. The use of general floodlighting fixtures shall be prohibited unless it meets the shielding requirements of this section. C. Vertical Surfaces Security lighting may illuminate vertical surfaces (e.g. building facades and walls) up to a level eight feet above grade or eight feet above the bottoms of doorways or entries, whichever is greater. D. Pole -Mounted Security lighting fixtures may be mounted on poles located no less than ten feet from the perimeter of the property boundary. E. Site Perimeters Security lights intended to illuminate a perimeter (such as a fence line) shall include motion sensors and be designed to be off unless triggered by an intruder located within five feet of the perimeter. The zone of activation sensors must be within the property boundaries of the property wishing to be illuminated. F. Timers and Photocells Security lights shall combine timers with dusk -to -dawn photocells to ensure lights are on only when it is dark. G. Requirements In addition to the application materials set forth in the general provisions of this sction, applications for security lighting installations shall include a written description of the need for and purposes of the security lighting, a site plan showing the area to be secured and the location of all security lighting 197 Title 18 Zoning fixtures, specifications of all fixtures, the horizontal and vertical angles in which light will be directed, and adequate cross -sections showing how light will be directed only onto the area to be secured. 18.46.060 ACCENT LIGHTING Architectural features may be illuminated by uplighting, provided that the light is effectively contained by the structure, the lamps are low intensity to produce a subtle lighting effect, and no glare or light trespass is produced. For national flags, statues, public art, or other objects that cannot be illuminated with down lighting, upward lighting may only be used in the form of two narrow -cone spotlights that confine the illumination to the object of interest. 18.46.070 LIGHTING STANDARDS FOR USES WITHIN 50 FEET OF RESIDENTIAL ZONES A. For Uses within 50 Feet of Residential Zones 1. Lighting poles shall be no taller than 20 feet. 2. Lighting fixtures shall be aimed and shielded in a manner that shall not direct illumination on adjacent residential zones. Fixtures shall be of a type or adequately shielded to prevent glare from normal viewing angles. 3. At the discretion of the review authority and, where feasible, additional landscaping may be used to provide light screening between commercial zones and residential zones to help prevent light trespass. Where landscaping is used for light screening, the director shall take into consideration the applicable landscaping standards, the design standards, the creation of excessive shadows or dark spaces, and views into and out of a site. 18.46.080 PARKING LOT LIGHTING A. Standards 1. Parking lots shall comply with the standards of this Chapter in addition to the other requirements of this title. 2. Parking lot lighting shall be designed to provide for uniform lighting throughout the facility with no dark patches or pockets. 3. Parking lot lighting shall be designed to provide sufficient lighting to identify parking features and provide pedestrian safety. 4. In order to direct light downward and minimize the amount of light spilled into the dark night sky, all lighting fixtures serving parking lots, shall be full cut-off fixtures as defined by the Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA). 5. The maximum permissible mounting height of all parking lot lighting shall be 30 feet unless otherwise specified in this Chapter. 18.46.090 LIGHTING OF OUTDOOR PERFORMANCE, SPORT AND RECREATIONAL FACILITIES A. Events and Special Activities 1. Lighting levels and pole heights for outdoor performance, sports, and recreation facilities shall not exceed by more than five percent of the Illuminating Engineering Society of North America published standards for the proposed activity. 2. Where playing fields or other special activity areas are to be illuminated, lighting fixtures shall be specified, mounted, aimed and shielded so that their beams fall within the primary playing area and immediate surroundings, and so that no direct illumination is directed off the site. 3. The main lighting shall be turned off as soon as possible following the end of the event. The main lighting shall not remain on longer than 30 minutes following the end of the event. Where feasible, a low level lighting system shall be used to facilitate patrons leaving the facility, cleanup, nighttime 198 Title 18 Zoning 18.46.100 LIGHTING FOR MULTI -UNIT ATTACHED RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS In all multi -unit attached residential developments, light fixtures for walks, steps, parking areas, driveways, onsite streets, and other facilities shall be provided in keeping with the type of development and at locations to assure safe and convenient nighttime use. Fixtures shall be designed in keeping with the project and shall be properly shaded to screen the windows of habitable rooms from the direct rays of light. All outdoor lighting shall be so shielded and adjusted that the light is directed to fall only on the same premises upon which the light source is located. All outdoor security and safety lighting shall be installed in accordance with the standards in this Chapter. 18.46.110 STANDARDS FOR SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USES A. Standards 1. Protective security lighting, landscape lighting or architectural highlighting, properly directed and shielded, may be operated at all hours of the night. 2. Luminaires providing outdoor lighting and permanently mounted to a residential building or to other buildings on the same lot are allowed. 3. Motion sensors with integral photo -control area and high -efficacy dust -to -dawn lighting are encouraged. 4. Permanently installed luminaires in or around swimming pools, water features, or other locations subject to Article 680 of the California Electrical Code need not be high -efficacy luminaires. 5. Lighting for single family residential uses shall be directed to fall only on the same premises upon which the light source is located. 6. Floodlighting is discouraged, and if used, must be shielded to prevent: a. Disability glare for drivers or pedestrians; b. Light trespass beyond the property line; and c. Light above a horizontal plane. 'Wallpack' type fixtures are not permitted. CHAPTER 18-47 - SIGNS AND OUTDOOR ADVERTISING DISPLAYS 18.47.010 Purpose 18.47.020 Site Plan Review and/or Sign Permit Required 18.47.030 Unlawful Display of Signs or Banners Prohibited 18.47.040 Definitions 18.47.050 Design and Maintenance 18.47.060 Permanent Signs Permitted in all Zones 18.47.070 Large Permanent Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.080 Large Permanent Signs in Shopping Centers 18.47.090 Small Permanent Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Institutional, Mixed -Use, and Multi -Family Zones 18.47.100 Pole -Mounted or Freestanding Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.110 Roof -Mounted Signs 18.47.120 Revolving Signs in Commercial and Industrial Zones 18.47.130 Temporary Signs Permitted in All Zones 18.47.140 Projecting Signs in Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, and Institutional Zones 18.47.150 Vehicle Signs 18.47.160 Public Assembly Use Signs 18.47.170 Mural Type Signs in Commercial and Mixed -Use Zones 18.47.180 Digital Advertising Display (DAD) Signs 199 title 18 Zoning 18.47.190 18.47.200 18.47.210 18.47.220 18.47.230 18.47.240 18.47.250 18.47.260 Flags, Banners, and Pennants Signs Prohibited in All Zones Master Sign Program Removal from Abandoned Site or Building Nonconforming Signs Constitutional Severability Non -Commercial Speech Sign Regulations by Zone and Type 18.47.010 PURPOSE The purposes of this Chapter are to: aid in the identification of properties, land uses, and enterprises; improve traffic safety by reducing visual distractions and physical obstructions and hazards; enhance the general appearance and aesthetics of the urban environment; and protect the natural beauty of the city's open space. 18.47.020 SITE PLAN REVIEW AND/OR SIGN PERMIT REQUIRED A. Site Plan Review and/or Sign Permit Approval Signs allowed by this Chapter may not be installed until a site plan review and/or sign permit is conducted and approved (see Chapter 1 Section 18.12.100) and a finding of compliance is made with the design criteria identified in this Chapter by the Planning Division. Signs that are not consistent with the design criteria outlined in this Chapter may not be installed. This determination may be appealed pursuant to the provisions of Section 18.12.060. B. Considerations Site plan review and/or a sign permit shall be limited to considerations of the location, installation or placement, size, public safety and sight distance, view blockage, and comparable matters, and not to the content of the message conveyed by the sign or banner, except when the publication of such message is unlawful. C. Exempt Signs Site plan review and sign permits are not required for exempt signs pursuant to Section 18.12.100 (c). 18.47.030 UNLAWFUL DISPLAY OF SIGNS OR BANNERS PROHIBITED A. Except as provided in this Chapter and in Section 18.12.100, it is unlawful for any person or entity to install, maintain, or allow the installation or maintenance of a sign or banner as defined in this Chapter in any zone. B. The reference to a specific prohibition in this Chapter shall not affect the validity and effect of the general prohibition set forth in this Chapter or its application regulating the uses of property outlined throughout the remainder of the Land Use Code. nor shall it affect Chapter 10.54 prohibiting the maintenance of graffiti as a public nuisance. C. This Chapter shall not apply to any governmental agency or to any regulatory sign prescribed or required by federal or State law or local ordinance. D. Nothing in this Chapter is intended to authorize the installation of a sign or banner without the permission of the owner or occupant of that property. E. Within this Chapter, all regulations shall refer and apply only to "on -site" displays of signs and banners. When a regulation is made applicable to an "off -site" display. it shall be so designated. Unless so designated, off -site displays are prohibited. Off -site displays include "sign spinners". 200 Title 18 Zoning 18.47.040 DEFINITIONS A. As used in this Chapter, and in addition to the definitions in the Glossary, the following definitions or concepts shall be applicable: 1. "Banner" is any flexible material, such as cloth, plastic, vinyl, paper, cardboard or thin metal, with or without a "message", attached outdoors to a building, structure or mounting device, or attached indoors to a building, structure or mounting device so as to be visible from the exterior of a building, or structure. The term "banner" includes a pennant, flag, or bunting. 2. "Billboard" means a sign which directs attention to a business, community service or entertainment not exclusively related to the premises where such sign is located. 3. "Bunting" is a form of banner that is typically presented and displayed in a folded or gathered fashion or combination. It may include a display in combination with a flag or banner. Depending on the format of the display, the term may be synonymous with banner. 4. "Business premises" refers to specific business occupancy within a building or upon a parcel of land, typically having a specific address and discrete entrance(s) and exit(s) so as to maintain a specific business identity and location. 5. "Changeable copy sign" refers to a sign displaying a "message" that is changed by means of moveable letters, slats, lights, light emitting diodes, or moveable background material. 6. "Directional sign" is any individual sign used to provide directions to pedestrians and vehicular traffic. It shall not include a grouping or mosaic of individual signs that are arranged in such a manner as to constitute a larger sign. 7. "Flag" is a form of "banner" that is mounted and displayed outdoors on a pole. 8. "Freestanding sign" means a sign which is permanently supported on the ground by one or more uprights, braces, poles, or other similar structural components that are not attached to any building. This category includes both monument and pole signs. 9. "Frontage" when used as a measurement reference of a building or business premises, shall refer to the distance between the two most distant corners of a building measured in a straight line along the building face bordering the adjoining street. See Glossary pertaining to frontage when made applicable to a parcel of land. It shall also refer to the elevation of a building that abuts or adjoins a private or public right-of-way or parking lot. 10. "Height" means the distance measured vertically from grade to the highest point or portion of the object to be measured or height limited. 11. "Illuminated sign" means a sign whose message is made readable by internal or external lights or light emitting diodes, typically during hours of darkness. 12. "Install" or "installation" includes but is not limited to the act by which a sign is constructed or placed on land or a structure, or the act of attaching, painting, printing, producing, or reproducing, or using any other method or process by which a visual message is presented or placed upon a surface. 13. "Message" means any form of visual communication presented on any type of media_ It is not material whether the communication has any logical, practical, literary, or artistic significance or not. It includes any form or combination of letters, graphics, symbols or designs. The term is not intended to include mono -color paint applied to the exterior, trim, fascia, or other architectural elements of a building for protection against the elements. 14. "Monument sign" means a low -profile freestanding sign supported by a structural base or other solid structural features other than support poles and may contain signage on more than one side. 15. "Mural" or "mural -type sign" means a sign painted on the exterior wall of a building consisting of graphics or images, either alone or in combination with letters. 16. "Off -site" or "off -site sign" refers to a sign or banner that promotes or advertises goods, services or activities located or offered on a business premises or parcel that is separate from the parcel where the sign is located, even if the two sites or parcels are contiguous to each other. 17. "On -site" or "on -site sign" refers to a sign or banner that prornotes or advertises goods, services, or activity located or offered on the business premises or parcel of property where the sign is located. 18. "Outdoors" means a location on undeveloped property or to the exterior of a building or structure. 19. "Outdoor advertising" refers to the placement of a message on signs or banners located outdoors, or located indoors in a manner such that the message is visible from the exterior of a building or structure. 201 Title 18 Zoning 20. "Parcels" or "property" or similar references or descriptions shall refer to parcels defined or delineated by assessor parcel numbers maintained by the County tax assessor or as defined in the Glossary of this Code. 21. "Pennant" is a banner with three sides. 22. "Permanent sign" means a sign that is solidly attached to a building, structure, or the ground by means of mounting brackets, bolts, welds, or other combination of attachment methods, thereby rendering the sign non -moveable or difficult to reposition without the use of machinery, cutting devices, or mechanical devices. See also "temporary sign." 23. "Pole sign" means a permanently mounted, freestanding sign which is supported above the ground by one or more uprights, braces, poles, or other similar structural components. 24. "Projecting sign" is any sign which projects beyond a building face and uses a wall or vertical element of a building as its main source of support. A projecting sign includes a double-faced sign that is installed more or less perpendicular to the face of a building so as to allow a message to be viewable from either side. A projecting sign does not include signs that are installed along the face of a building and that are completely attached to the face of a building. 25. "Rooftop or roof -mounted sign" means a sign that extends above the ridgeline of the roof of a building or a sign attached to any portion of the roof of a building. 26. "Shopping center" shall mean a group of commercial buildings as defined in the Glossary. 27. "Sign" as used in this Chapter, shall generically refer to any medium through which a message is conveyed which is placed outdoors in any zone or is visible to the exterior of a commercial or industrial building or structure. It shall include a banner and any of the following: a. Any advertising display defined in Section 9.32.010. b. Any message painted, printed, or otherwise produced or affixed on or to: c. The exterior of a building or structure; d. A rigid or semi -rigid material or surface, such as wood, metal, or plastic, attached to a building, structure, or pole or which is itself free-standing; or e. An inflatable balloon or, other three-dimensional object that is tethered or fastened to a building, structure, pole, or the ground. 28. "Temporary sign" means a sign that is easily moveable and which is not attached to a building, structure, or the ground in such a manner as to be rendered a permanent sign. 29. "Visible to the exterior" refers to the placement of a sign or banner within the interior first eight feet of a commercial or industrial building or structure in such a manner so that it or its message is readily visible on an immediately contiguous public right-of-way, parking lot, or parcel. To be visible does not require that the message be understandable or readable. 18.47.050 DESIGN AND MAINTENANCE A. Uniform Building, Electrical and Mechanical Code compliance --Required No sign shall be installed that does not comply with the applicable Uniform Building, Mechanical and Electrical Codes adopted by the City. Permits for installation shall be obtained, when required, prior to any installation, from the director of building and safety. B. Maintenance All signs and their supporting structures and components shall be maintained in a state of safe condition and good repair. Signs shall be "face washed" at least once a year. Electrically energized components must bear the seal of approval of an approved testing laboratory. Broken faces and burned -out lamps, bulbs, or tubes must be replaced within thirty days from the date of notification from the City. 202 Title 18 Zoning 18.47.060 PERMANENT SIGNS PERMITTED IN ALL ZONES The following signs shall be permitted in all zones. Site plan review shall not be required. A. Permanent Signs 1. Size. The display on any parcel of any single sign, flag, or banner that is less than six square feet in area is permitted, except when a home occupation permit has been issued for a residential parcel, this exemption shall not apply, and that property shall be subject to all the requirements of this Chapter. 2. Restrictions. No signs shall be placed in the public right-of-way nor shall they obstruct the free flow of traffic. B. Directional Signs Directional signs which do not exceed a total of three square feet in size per sign and total area combined does not exceed nine square feet. C. Freestanding or Monument Signs. A maximum of two freestanding or monument signs not to exceed a total of one hundred square feet, are permitted for single-family subdivisions, multi -family developments, or mobile home parks. D. Official Flags Up to three official flags of the Unites States, the State of California, or other states of the nation, counties, municipalities, and official flags of sovereign nations. Proposals for more than three flags require a sign permit and site plan review. If flags are to be displayed on vertical flagpoles, these poles shall be permanently installed with appropriate building permits. Flags of nationally or internationally recognized organizations and corporate or business flags are only permitted if displayed in conjunction with the United States flag. The Flag Code of the United States shall be observed at all times. 18.47.070 LARGE PERMANENT SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, MIXED -USE AND INSTITIONAL ZONES A. Specifications and Restrictions Except in shopping centers, large permanent signs (those exceeding 25 square feet in area) may be installed on or along the face of a building in commercial, and commercial uses in a mixed -use zone, industrial or institutional zones, subject to the following specifications and restrictions: 1. Signs shall be limited to one sign per business premise per frontage along a street, freeway, or parking lot. 2_ Sign area on the primary frontage shall not exceed 30 percent of the area of the building face or four square feet of sign for each linear foot of building face along that frontage, whichever is greater. 3. Sign area on a secondary frontage shall not exceed 15 percent of the area of the building face or two square feet per linear foot of secondary frontage, whichever is greater. 4. The sign face shall not be located, such as by a cabinet, deep lettering, or architectural feature, more than 18 inches from a building face unless an exception is approved pursuant to site plan review. 203 Title 18 Zoning 18.47.080 LARGE PERMANENT SIGNS IN SHOPPING CENTERS Large permanent signs for businesses within a shopping center shall be limited to one per business premises per frontage on a common walkway, parking lot, driveway, alleyway, street. or freeway. The size and placement of these signs shall conform with the standards specified by Subsections 18.47.070 as well as standards that may be applied through any required City Council or Planning Commission approval, including but not limited to a conditional use permit, planned development permit, specific plan, or variance. 18.47.090 SMALL PERMANENT SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, INSTITUTIONAL, MIXED -USE, AND MULTI -FAMILY ZONES A. Permanent Signs Less than 25 Square Feet Any permanent sign measuring less than 25 square feet and not described elsewhere in this Chapter shall be considered a small permanent sign that shall only be permitted in commercial, industrial. and institutional zones and commercial uses in a mixed -use zone as follows: 1. Small permanent signs shall be permitted only in windows or along the face of a building. 2. The total area of all small permanent signs and any allowable small temporary signs combined shall not exceed ten percent of the wall or elevation on which the sign is placed. 18.47.100 POLE MOUNTED OR FREESTANDING SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, MIXED -USE, AND INSTITIONAL ZONES A. Requirements Pole -mounted or freestanding signs are permitted in the commercial and industrial zones and commercial uses in a mixed -use zone, subject to the following requirements: 1. Pole signs or freestanding signs shall be limited to one sign per frontage on street, freeway, or parking lot, and may include a cluster sign identifying individual businesses on the parcel(s). 2. The total area of any sign installed along the primary frontage shall not exceed four square feet per lineal foot of property on the primary frontage. 3. The total area of any sign installed along each secondary frontage shall not exceed two square feet per lineal foot of property on the secondary frontage. 4. Sign structures shall not be placed within the required setback area, except that projecting signs may protrude into or overhang a maximum distance of one-half of the setback. 18.47.110 ROOF MOUNTED SIGNS. Roof -mounted signs are not permitted. 18.47.120 REVOLVING SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL ZONES Signs that revolve shall be restricted to those that rotate 360 degrees and no more than eight revolutions per minute. Revolving signs shall be permitted only in commercial and industrial zones. 18.47.130 TEMPORARY SIGNS PERMITTED IN ALL ZONES. A. Temporary Signs on Construction Sites Temporary signs on construction sites having the following specifications shall be permitted in all zones: 1. The maximum total area for signs at single-family residential construction projects shall be 20 square feet per street frontage. 204 Title 18 Zoning 2. The maximum area of signage at other construction projects shall be 50 square feet per street frontage. 3. For any request for square -footage exceeding the limits set forth in Subsections A.1. and A.2., a temporary use permit is required, the granting or denial of which shall be based solely on objective criteria such as time, location, and size. 4. All signs must be removed prior to and as a condition of the final inspection and approval of the project. B. Temporary Signs on For Sale or For Lease Property A maximum of two temporary signs on currently for sale or for lease property may be installed on developed or undeveloped property in all zones, with the following requirements and specifications for the sign: 1. The maximum area of signage allowed by this section per parcel per street frontage in commercial, industrial, mixed -use, multi -family, or institutional zones shall be 50 square feet. 2. The maximum area of signage allowed by this section per parcel per frontage in single-family residential zones is six square feet. 3. These signs shall not be lighted. 4. Signs shall be removed within ten days following the lease or sale of the premises on which the sign is displayed. C. Temporary Off -site Signs Prohibited Temporary off -site signs are prohibited in all zones, unless otherwise provided herein and by State law. D. Temporary Signs For Events Additional temporary signs erected due to an event are permitted as follows: 1. Commercial/industrial/multi-family/mixed-use/institutional zones. a. One or more temporary signs, each of which is 32 square feet or less in area, shall be permitted per parcel. b. Temporary signs, except flags and banners, shall not be fastened directly to the exterior wall or face of any building. Such signs may be displayed in windows or on display boards, provided the combined total area of all signs does not exceed ten percent of the area of the building face upon which the signs are mounted. (See Section 18.47.190 for restrictions on flags and banners.) c. Such signage is permitted on a temporary basis as defined hereinafter, in addition to other sign allotment per site. 2. Single-family residential zones. a. One or more temporary signs, each of which is six square feet or less in area, shall be permitted per parcel. b. A parcel that is a corner lot can also have up to two signs greater than six square feet or less in area, but less than or equal to 16 square feet in area per parcel. c. Permission of the property owner or occupant where the sign is placed shall be required. d. No temporary signs are permitted in the public right-of-way. e. Removal. If the signage was erected for an event, such signage shall be removed within ten days after the event. 18.47.140 PROJECTING SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, MIXED -USE, AND INSTITIONAL ZONES A. Conditions A projecting sign may be permitted in all commercial, industrial, mixed -use, and institutional zones, subject to the following conditions: 205 Title 18 Zoning 1. Projecting signs shall not project over any public right-of-way, including streets or alleys, except as provided in Subsection D below. 2. The maximum height of projecting signs shall be 12 feet, and may project above any eave or parapet of less than 12 feet in height, but may not project inward over any such eave or parapet. 3. The maximum area of a projecting sign shall be 32 square feet. 4. Projecting signs may project over street parkways and required setback areas a maximum of one-half of the street parkway or setback width. For the purpose of this section, "street parkway" is defined as that part of the public street right-of-way lying between the front property line and the edge of the roadway. 5. No more than one projecting sign shall be placed on each street frontage per business premises. 6. A projecting sign shall be permitted only in lieu of a freestanding or marquee sign, and may not be utilized in addition to a freestanding or marquee sign. 7. Projecting signs shall be supported so as to appear to be an architectural and integral part of the building. The sign shall be free of any extra bracing, angle iron, guy wires, or cables. 18.47.150 VEHICLE SIGNS A. Permitted Vehicle Signs 1. Advertising signs on buses and taxis. 2. Signs on automobiles and trucks that are painted on or attached flat against the vehicle to identify or advertise the associated business, provided that the vehicle is primarily used for the business and not parked on public streets. 18.47.160 PUBLIC ASSEMBLY USE SIGNS On property used for public assembly, one wall mounted sign not to exceed 20 square feet in area per street frontage or parking lot frontage, and one freestanding changeable copy directory sign not to exceed six feet in height and 20 square feet in area per street frontage or parking lot frontage shall be allowed; provided, however, that the signs shall be architecturally related to the structure to which they are appurtenant. No more than two wall -mounted signs plus no more than two freestanding signs shall be permitted. 18.47.170 MURAL TYPE SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL AND MIXED -USE ZONES Mural -type signs not exceeding 110 square feet in area shall be allowed in commercial zones and for commercial uses in mixed -use zones in lieu of a fixed sign. 18.47.180 DIGITAL ADVERTISING DISPLAY (DAD) SIGNS A. Purpose The use of digital advertising display technology (also known as a message center display or electronic reader board) for on -premises advertising signage can be an enhancement to the city as a whole, provided that sufficient standards are established to regulate daytime/nighttime illumination, prohibit movement, flashing, and other animation that may distract motorists, and allow for reasonable height and size requirements that balance the need for visibility with overall city aesthetic concerns, and; 206 Title 18 Zoning The need for establishing design and operational standards for digital advertising displays for digital advertising signage will ensure that they do not create adverse effects on adjacent uses, for motorists, or conflict with Amber light or other digital emergency response signage, and; The Federal Highway Administration in a 2007 ruling stated that digital billboards are permissible adjacent to and visible from federal highways. B. Applicability Digital advertising display signs are allowed in commercial, mixed -use, and industrial zoned areas along highways and arterial roadways (as defined by the General Plan Circulation Element) with approval of a sign permit provided all the conditions identified below are met. C. Requirements 1. The maximum height of the sign structure containing the digital advertising display shall be subject to the same height restrictions as contained in Section 18.47.260 of the Land Use Code. 2. For properties that front on arterial roadways, the electronic message display component of the sign structure shall not exceed 80 square feet in area per sign face. 3. For properties that front on highways, the electronic message display component of the sign structure shall not exceed 250 square feet in area per sign face. 4. No more than one digital advertising display sign shall be permitted on a site. The electronic message display may be single -faced or double-faced. 5. The electronic message display shall be an electronic LED (Light Emitting Diode) screen. 6. The pixel pitch of the LED electronic message display shall be no greater than 25mm; 20mm or less is preferred, especially for arterial roadways. 7. Each DAD sign shall be provided with encapsulated LED's for weather protection. 8. The DAD may be programmed to allow changeable messages, provided that any image shall be displayed for a minimum of 8 seconds, and transitions between slides shall not exceed one second. Fading in or out, or scrolling of text shall be permitted as transitions. 9. Each DAD shall include a photometric sensor that will adjust the intensity of the sign for daytime and nighttime viewing. The nighttime intensity shall be limited to 0.3-foot candles (over ambient levels) as measured at a preset distance as established by the Lewin Report as prepared for the Outdoor Advertising Association of America (OAAA). The City may modify or further restrict the intensity of any DAD display should the lighting create a distraction to drivers or an adverse effect on nearby residential property. 10. The electronic message display shall not be operated between the hours of midnight and 6:00 am. 11. The electronic message display shall not result in unacceptable light intensity and glare impacting surrounding property. 12. All new digital advertising display signs not attached to a building shall be mounted on one support column only. 13. Digital advertising display signs are permitted to be located on the wall of a building provided the sign does not obscure any of the building's windows, architectural features, or other architectural details. 14. No digital advertising display sign may be placed within one -mile of another DAD on the same side of a highway. No more than 2 DAD signs are permitted per freeway. 15. Digital advertising display signs are limited to on -premise signs only. No digital display signs may be placed within 1,000 feet of another DAD sign on the same side of an arterial roadway. 16. An existing billboard sign may be refurbished with a digital advertising display sign provided it does not exceed the area of the existing billboard and in all other respects meets the requirements of this Chapter. 207 Title 18 Zoning 17. Cabinetry shall include solid welds and voltage protection. 18. Exterior cabinetry consisting of sheet metal or fabricated metal construction is not permitted. 19. The electronic message display shall be maintained in good operating condition and external appearance at all times. 20. Solar powered DAD signs are encouraged_ 21. A DAD shall be subject to all other sign face size restrictions as contained in this Chapter. 18.47.190 FLAGS, BANNERS, AND PENNANTS A. Regulations 1. Permit required. All banners require the approval of the Planning Division. In order to obtain approval, see application and drawings required at the City Planning Division. 2. Minimum standards. Flags and banners may be displayed on automobile sales lots without time limitation or site plan review provided that: a. The displays are properly maintained; b. Displays are limited to the perimeter of the lot; c. Displays do not exceed a height of 25 feet above the ground; d. Displays may not be used in place of a permanent sign. 3. Flags, banners, and pennants may be displayed on other commercial and industrial uses for a cumulative period of 60 days within each calendar year. The time limit commences when a banner permit is issued by the planning director. The 60-day period may be divided into two occasions per calendar year, provided the total display time does not exceed 60 days per calendar year. A banner permit fee and an administrative fee in an amount representing the anticipated City enforcement costs in causing the applicant to remove flags or banners shall be paid to the City Treasurer at the time of application for site plan review. The administrative fee shall be refunded upon the verified removal of the flag or banner by the specified deadline. 4. The following shall apply to all displays of flags, banners, and pennants: a. Must be removed by the owner or occupant within 15 days after a determination by the City Manager or his/her designee that the display is improperly maintained or the flag or banner is tattered or worn. b. Shall not be larger than 40 square feet. c. Shall not be displayed in lieu of a permanent sign. d. Shall not be placed on a roof, placed in required yard areas, or landscaped areas. e. Must be compatible with the primary building's appearance. f. Violation of the time limits shall render the site ineligible for issuance of a permit for display of a banner for a period of one year from the date that the violation is abated. g. The restrictions of this section shall also apply to signs and banners located within the first eight feet of the interior of commercial or industrial premises when such sign or banner is visible to the exterior. 18.47.200 SIGNS PROHIBITED IN ALL ZONES A. Prohibited Signs Notwithstanding Section 18.47.030 the following signs are strictly prohibited in all zones: 1. Signs that obstruct any window, door, or opening used or required as a means of regular ingress and egress, legal light and ventilation, as a fire escape or other emergency access or escape. 2. Signs placed on public property or within the public street right-of-way. 3. Signs placed on property without permission of the property owner or occupant. 4. Signs on fences. 5. Except as provided in otherwise in this Chapter, signs on vacant or unimproved land. 6. Any sign whose intensity of illumination or size, shape, or location interferes with the safe operation of a vehicle or creates distraction to the operator of a motor vehicle on adjoining public streets. 208 Title 18 Zoning 7. Animated and flashing signs exceeding the following limits or restrictions: a. Flashing signs are limited to a maximum illumination equivalent to incandescent bulbs of sixty watts per bulb maximum. and shall not flash more than sixty times per minute. "Chasers" are prohibited. b. High intensity neon lights, tubes, or flashing lights exceeding sixty watts are prohibited on animated or flashing signs. c. Rotating beacon -type lighting elements on signs are prohibited. 8. Temporary or permanent off -site signs, including billboards, are prohibited except where otherwise provided by State law or in Section 18.47.180. 9. Inflatable signs and displays, unless authorized pursuant to a temporary use permit. 10. Signs mounted on motor vehicles that are in violation of Section 7.20.150 or signs exceeding 25 square feet mounted on motor vehicles parked for more than eight hours in any 24-hour period on private property. 11. Off site temporary signs, mobile billboards on public streets (excepting buses, taxicabs, and business vehicles with an advertisement or display of its owner). 12. Mobile billboard advertising. Mobile billboard advertising includes any vehicle or wheeled conveyance which carries, conveys, pulls, or transports any sign or billboard for the primary purpose of advertising. Mobile billboard advertising upon any street or other public place within the city in which the public has the right of travel is prohibited. Any vehicle which displays an advertisement or business identification of its owner, so long as such vehicle is engaged in the usual business or regular work of the owner and not used merely, mainly, or primarily to display advertisements; buses; and taxicabs are exempt from this prohibition. 18.47.210 MASTER SIGN PROGRAM A. Purpose and Applicability The purpose of the Master Sign Program provisions is to provide a coordinated approach to signage for National City's business districts, which include the Harbor District, Downtown, Mile of Cars, and Plaza Bonita. The development of a master sign program is optional, but strongly encouraged for these areas. B. Approval A Master Sign Program shall require the approval of the Planning Commission and the City Council. C. Design Standards Master Sign Programs shall feature a unified and coordinated approach to the materials, color, size, type, placement and general design of signs proposed for a project or property. D. Effect of Master Sign Program All subsequent signs proposed for a development or property subject to an approved Master Sign Program shall comply with the standards and specifications included in the Master Sign Program. 18.47.220 REMOVAL FROM ABANDONED SITE OR BUILDING When the use of any parcel or building is vacated, terminated, or abandoned for any reason for a period of more than 120 consecutive days, the owner or person in possession of the property shall be responsible for the physical removal of all signs on the property, building or wall(s), and for painting over the surface so as to obliterate any painted or printed signs on the building so that the copy is not visible, within 30 days following notice from the City. Removal, painting out, or obliteration shall be performed in a manner that does not create a blighting influence. 209 Title 18 Zoning 18.47.230 NONCONFORMING SIGNS Any sign that is made nonconforming by enactment of Ordinance 2001-2192 may continue to be maintained or displayed subject to the provisions of 18.11.090 regarding the continuance and abatement of nonconforming signs. 18.47.240 CONSTITUTIONAL SEVERABILITY The City Council declares that the judicial invalidity of any subsection or portion of this Chapter shall not affect the validity of any other remaining section or portion; that the City Council would have adopted each of those remaining portions, notwithstanding any later declared invalidity. If any provision determined invalid under the preceding sentence can either be judicially severed or interpreted in a way that could harmonize it with the remaining provisions, then it may be severed or interpreted and applied so as to give full purpose, meaning, and effect to the remaining provisions of this Chapter. 18.47.250 NON-COMMERCIAL SPEECH Anywhere that commercial signage is allowed, non-commercial signage is allowed subject to the same restrictions as those set forth for commercial signage, but not in addition to such allowance. 18.47.260 SIGN REGULATIONS BY ZONE AND TYPE The following table summarizes the types of signs that shall be permitted within the zoning designations listed below. Signs are not permitted in public rights -of -way unless otherwise noted in Table 18.47.260 below. TABLE 18.47.260 Sign Regulations by Zone and Type Sign Type Use or Zone Location Max(mum Size and Height Other Regulations Permanent Signs less than 6SF All (except home occupation) -- 6 square feet -- Directional Sign All -- 3 square feet per sign and a combined total of 9 square feet -- Official Flags (United States, California, other state or nation, county, municipality or sovereign nation) All -- -- Maximum of three flags; must be on permanently installed poles; organizations, corporations and business flags prohibited Building Mounted Greater than 25SF Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use One sign per building premises per frontage on a street, parking lot or freeway. Primary frontage: 30% of the area of the building face or 4 square feet of sign for each linear foot of building face along the frontage, whichever is greater. Secondary Frontage: 15% of the area of the building face or 2 square feet per linear foot of secondary frontage, whichever is greater. May not extend more than 18" from building face. Internally illuminated light box or cabinet signs not permitted. Building Mounted Greater than 25SF Shopping Centers, MXD-1 One sign per business premises Primary frontage' 30% of the area of the building May not extend more than 18' from building face. 210 Title 18 Zoning Sign Type Use or Zone Location Maximum Size and Height Other Regulations and MXD-2 (except residential buildings) per frontage along a common walkway, parking lot, driveway, alleyway, street or freeway. face or 4 square feet of sign for each linear foot of building face along the frontage, whichever is greater. Secondary Frontage. 15% of the area of the building face or 2 square feet per linear foot of secondary frontage, whichever is greater. Internally illuminated light box or cabinet signs not permitted. Building Mounted Less than 25SF Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, Institutional, Multi -Family Windows or along the face of a building 10% of the wall or elevation on which the sign is placed or 25SF, whichever is less. May not extend more than 18" from building face. Internally illuminated light box or cabinet signs not permitted. Freestanding/Pole Mounted Commercial, Industrial, MXD- 1 and MXD-2 (except residential buildings), Institutional One sign per building premises per frontage on a street, parking lot or freeway. Not permitted in required setbacks Primary Frontage: 4 square feet per lineal foot Secondary Frontage. 2 square feet per lineal foot Cluster signs identifying individual businesses on a parcel are permitted. Roof -Mounted All zones Not permitted. Not permitted Not permitted. Revolving Commercial, Industrial Same as Freestanding/Pole Mounted 360 degree rotation only and maximum of 8 revolutions per minute Projecting Sign Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use, Institutional One sign per street frontage per business premise. May extend into or overhang no more than one half of the setback or street parkway distance. A sign may not extend beyond the street curb. Area: 32 square feet Height: 12 feet Permitted only in lieu of a freestanding or marquee sign. Must be an integral component of building. Decorative brackets permitted Public Assembly Signs All One wall -mounted sign per street or parking lot frontage plus one freestanding sign per street frontage. One wall mounted sign not to exceed 20 square feet in area and one freestanding sign not to exceed 6 square feet in height and 20 square feet in area. No more than 2 wall - mounted signs and no more than 2 freestanding signs shall be permitted. Temporary Signs, Construction Sites All -- Single Family Residential, MXC-1 and MXC-2: 20 square feet per street frontage Other: 50 square feet per street frontage Temporary use permit required. Shall be removed in ten days following sale or lease of the premises. Temporary Signs, Event All Window display or display boards permitted only. Commercial, industrial, mixed -use or multi- family, institutional: One or more each of which is 32 square feet or less in area Single Farnily For commercial, industrial, mixed -use or multi -family, may not be fastened to exterior wall or building face (except flags and banners). 211 Title 18 Zoning Sign Type Use or Zone Location Maximum Size and Height Other Regulations Residential. one or more limited to 6 square feet or less in area per parcel except corner lots are permitted up to two signs greater than 6 square feet or less in area per parcel, but less than or equal to 16 square feet in area per parcel. Temporary Off -Site Signs Prohibited in all zones Prohibited in all zones Prohibited in all zones Prohibited in all zones Mural Signs Commercial -- 110SF or 25% of the wall of a building, whichever is less. Permitted in lieu of a fixed sign. Must be coated with anti -graffiti coating. Window Signs Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use -- 15% of the area of a window or 12SF, whichever is less. -- Awning, Canopy or Marquee Commercial, Industrial, Mixed -Use -- Awning or canopy: 50% of the total area of the awning or canopy Marquee. 75% of the total area of the marquee Internally illuminated or backlit awning signs not permitted Building Arcade Hanging Sign (also known as suspended or blade sign) Commercial, Mixed -Use One per tenant. Must be perpendicular to face of building. Area. 6 square feet; Width: No more than 60% of arcade. Clearance: No less than 8' above finished grade. Internal illumination not permitted 18.47.270 SIGNS FOR SPECIAL USES For institutional, educational, regional commercial or other large campus -style uses — including but not limited to hospitals, schools and colleges, or shopping malls — signs may exceed the design guidelines as prescribed in this chapter with the approval of the Planning Commission. Approval may be either through a discretionary development process (PD, CUP, etc) for new construction or through the Approval of Plans process for existing facilities. CHAPTER 18-48- RESIDENTIAL DENSITY BONUS AND AFFORDABLE HOUSING INCENTIVES 18.48.010 Purpose 18.48.020 Definitions 18.48.030 Density Bonus 18.48.040 Concessions, Incentives, and Development Standards 18.48.050 Application Requirements and Review 18.48.060 Density Bonus Housing Agreement 18.48.0.010 PURPOSE A. Intent and Purposes of Section The intent and purposes of this Chapter are to: 1. Implement the policies of the General Plan's Housing Element for developing affordable housing for households with very low, low, and moderate incomes. 212 Title 18 Zoning 2. Encourage affordable housing units to be developed citywide and designed to be consistent with the surrounding neighborhood. 3. Implement the provisions of State Government Code Section 65915. 18.48.020 DEFINITIONS A. Section Definitions Within this Chapter, the following definitions shall apply: 1. "Additional incentives" means any regulatory concessions or incentives which would result in identifiable cost avoidance or reductions that are offered in addition to a density bonus, as also specified in California Government Code Subsections 65915. 2. "Density bonus" means a density increase of up to thirty-five percent over the otherwise maximum residential density allowable by the applicable zoning designation, pursuant to State Government Code Section 65915, as amended from time to time. 3. "Density bonus units" means those residential units granted pursuant to the provisions of this Chapter that exceed the otherwise allowable maximum residential density for the development site. 4. "Development standard" shall have the meaning given that term by Government Code Section 65915. 5. "Financial Pro Forma" means a financial report for density bonus projects that shall include identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions achieved through any requested incentives or concessions, as well as evidence that the cost reduction allows the developer to provide affordable rents or affordable sales prices. 6. "Housing development" for the purpose of this Chapter means construction projects consisting of five (5) or more residential units, including single-family, multi -family, and mobile homes for sale or rent. 7. "Lower income household" means households whose income is no more than 80 percent of the area median income of San Diego County, as established and amended time to time by Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937, pursuant to Section 50079.5 of the California Health and Safety Code. 8. "Maximum residential density" means the maximum number of residential units permitted by the City's General Plan Land Use Element and Land Use Code at the time of application, excluding the provisions of this Chapter. In calculating the required number of dwelling units affordable to moderate, lower, or very low income households, any decimal fraction resulting from the applicable percent of the total units shall be rounded to the next larger whole number. 9. "Moderate income household" means households whose income does not exceed 120 percent of the area median income of San Diego County, as established and amended time to time by Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937, pursuant to Section 50093 of the California Health and Safety Code. 10. "Non -restricted unit" means all units within a housing development as defined in this section, excluding the target units. 11. "Target unit" means a dwelling unit within a housing development that will be reserved for sale to or rent to, and affordable to, very low, or moderate income households, or qualifying residents. 12. "Very low income household" means households whose income is no more than 50% of the area median income of San Diego County, as established and amended time to time by Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937, pursuant to Section 50105 of the California Health and Safety Code. 18.48.030 DENSITY BONUS A. In applications for projects meeting the minimum threshold of five units or more, the density bonus provisions set forth in Government Code Section 65915, as amended from time to time, shall apply. B. It is the intent of this Chapter to ensure that all projects applying for the concessions and incentives of this Chapter provide for affordable housing units that are comparable in size, design, and quality to the market units in the same project. The City Manager or his/her designee, unless otherwise specified, shall have the discretion and authority to enforce this provision during the application process. 213 Title 18 Zoning 18.48.040 CONCESSIONS, INCENTIVES, AND DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS A. Requests for Incentives and Concessions In applications for projects meeting the minimum threshold of five units or more, concessions and incentives including reductions in site development standards, modifications of zoning code or architectural design requirements, and other incentives or concessions defined in Government Code Section 65915(1) may be requested, consistent with the parameters enumerated below. B. Financial Pro Forma The applicant shall provide a financial pro forma demonstrating to the City that the requested concession or incentive results in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions to the project pursuant to California Government Code Section 65915(I)(1). C. Development Standards Applicants may seek a waiver or modification of development standards that will have the effect of precluding the construction of a residential development meeting the criteria of Government Code Section 65915 at the densities or with the incentives or concessions permitted by that section. D. Financial Incentives Nothing in this section requires the City to provide direct financial incentives for the residential development, including but not limited to the provision of publicly owned land, waiver of fees, off -site improvements, or dedication requirements. 18.48.050 APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS AND REVIEW A. Application Conference Prior to submitting an application, an applicant proposing a housing development pursuant to this section shall schedule a pre -application conference with appropriate Planning and/or Housing Division staff. The applicant should provide the following information: 1. A brief description of the proposed development, including at a minimum the total number of units, total number of target units, and total number of density bonus units proposed. 2. The combined general plan/zoning designations and assessor parcel number(s) of the project site. 3. A vicinity map and preliminary site plan, drawn to scale, including building footprints, driveway and parking layout. 4. If an additional incentive(s) is requested, the application should describe why the additional incentive(s) is necessary to ensure affordability of the target units and density bonus units proposed! 5. The developer/applicant should also submit the project pro -forma, outlining revenue sources, expenses, and projected profit. B. Application/Processing Requests for a density bonus and/or additional incentive(s) pursuant to this section shall be submitted to the Planning Division and processed pursuant to procedures in Chapter 1 for approval of a conditional use permit and concurrently with any other application(s) required for the development. In addition, applications shall include the following: 1. A description of any requested density bonuses, incentives, concessions, waivers or modifications of development standards, or modified parking standards. 2. Identification of all affordable units qualifying for the project for a density bonus, and level of affordability of all affordable units. 214 Title 18 Zoning 3. For all incentives and concessions. a financial pro forma demonstrating that the requested incentives and concessions result in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions is required. 4. For waivers or modifications of development standards: evidence that the imposition of the development standards for which a waiver is requested will have the effect of precluding the construction of the residential development at the densities or with the incentives or concessions permitted by Government Code Section 65915. 5. Any financial pro forma submitted to comply with this section may not include the lost opportunity cost of any affordable units (i.e., the revenue that would have been generated had the units been rented or sold at market rate) and may include as an additional cost only those additional expenses that are required solely because of the proposed construction of the affordable units. The pro forma shall also include: a. The actual cost reduction achieved through the incentive or concession; and b. Evidence that the cost reduction allows the developer to provide affordable rents or affordable sales prices. 6. The City may retain a consultant to review the financial report (pro forma). The cost of the consultant shall be borne by the applicant with the following exception: if the applicant is a non profit organization, the cost of the consultant may be paid by the City upon prior approval of the City Council. C. Findings for Approval Before any density bonus and/or additional incentive is granted, the approving authority shall make the following findings: 1. The residential development is eligible for a density bonus and any concessions, incentives, waivers, modifications, or reduced parking standards requested. 2. The residential development conforms to all standards for affordability included in this Chapter. 3. Any requested incentive or concession will result in identifiable, financially sufficient, and actual cost reductions based upon appropriate financial analysis and documentation if required by conditional use permit. 4. If a waiver or modification is requested, the applicant has shown that the imposition of the development standards sought to be waived or modified will have the effect of physically precluding the construction of the development at the densities or with the incentives or concessions otherwise permitted by this Chapter. D. Findings for Denial - Concessions, Incentives, Waivers, Modifications. 1. Concessions or incentives. The City may deny one or more requested concessions or incentives if, based on substantial evidence, the City makes either of the following findings: a. The concession or incentive is not required in order to provide for affordable housing costs, as defined in Section 50052.5 of the Health and Safety Code, or for rents for the targeted units to be set as specified in Section65915(c); or b. The concession or incentive would have a specific adverse impact, as defined in Government Code Section 65598.5(d)(2), upon public health and safety or the physical environment, or on any real property that is listed in the California Register of Historical Resources, and for which there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific adverse impact without rending the development unaffordable to very low, low, and moderate income households. 2. Waivers and modifications. The City may deny one or more requested waivers or modifications if the City makes either of the following findings: a. The waiver or modification would have a specific adverse impact, as defined in Government Code Section 65598.5(d)(2), upon public health and safety, or the physical environment, and for which there is no feasible method to satisfactorily mitigate or avoid the specific adverse impact; or b. The waiver or modification would have a specific adverse impact on any real property that is listed in the California Register of Historical Resources. 215 Title 18 Zoning E. Deed Covenant Approval of a density bonus and/or additional incentive(s) pursuant to this section shall require the recordation of a deed covenant recorded against the property to ensure the target unit(s) is maintained for affordability for the time period required prior to Final Map recordation or prior to the issuance of a building permit, if no subdivision of property is involved. F. Appeal Procedure The decision of the Planning Commission to approve or deny a request for a density bonus, additional incentive(s), and/or waivers or modifications of development standards pursuant to this section may be appealed to the City Council pursuant to procedures for appeal of other discretionary permit applications that are concurrently considered, or I if no other discretionary permit applications are concurrently considered, the decision of the Planning Commission may be appealed pursuant to procedures specified in Chapter 1 Section 18.12.110 (Conditional Use Permits) of the Land Use Code. 18.48.060 DENSITY BONUS HOUSING AGREEMENT A. Agreement with the City Applicants/developers requesting a density bonus shall enter into a Density Bonus Housing Agreement with the City. The terms of the draft agreement shall be approved by the Executive Director of the Community Development Commission of the City of National City or his designee. B. Recordation Following execution of the Agreement by all parties, the completed Density Bonus Housing Agreement, or memorandum thereof, shall be recorded with the County of San Diego Recorders Office, and the conditions therefore filed and recorded on the parcel or parcels designated for construction of target units and a copy of the recorded document shall be provided to the City. Recordation of the Agreement shall occur prior to recordation of a Final Map or prior to issuance of building permits, whichever occurs first. The Density Bonus Housing Agreement shall be binding to all future owners and successors in interest during the term of the Agreement, unless rescinded by the City upon completion of terms of the Agreement. C. Provisions of Agreement The Density Bonus Housing Agreement shall include at least the following: 1. The total number of units approved for the housing development, including the number of target units. 2. A description of the household income group to be accommodated by the housing development, as outlined in Section 18.47.050 of this chapter, and the standards for determining the corresponding affordable rent or affordable sales price and housing cost. 3. The location, unit sizes (square feet), and number of bedrooms of target units. 4. Tenure of use restrictions for target units of at least ten or 30 years, in accordance with Section 18.47.050 of this chapter. 5. A schedule for completion and occupancy of target units. 6. A description of the density bonus, additional incentive(s) or equivalent financial incentives being provided by the City. 7. A requirement to submit to the Executive Director of the Community Development Commission of the City of National City or his designee for review and approval of an Affirmative Marketing Plan, which details the actions the developer/applicant shall take to provide information and otherwise attract eligible persons to the available housing units without regard to race, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, familial status, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, handicap, age, or any other category which may be defined by law now or in the future. 216 Title 18 Zoning 8. A description of remedies for breach of the Agreement by either party. The City may identify tenants or qualified purchasers as third party beneficiaries under the Agreement. 9. Other provisions to ensure implementation and compliance with this section. 10. Provision allowing payment of fee by applicant to the City to recover their administrative expenses. D. For -Sale Housing Developments In the case of for -sale housing developments, the Density Bonus Housing Agreement shall provide for the following conditions governing the initial sale and use of target units during the applicable use restriction period: 1. Target units shall, upon initial sale, be sold to eligible very low, low, or moderate income households at an affordable sales price and housing cost, or to qualified residents (i.e., maintained as senior citizen housing) as defined by this Chapter. 2. Target units shall be initially owner -occupied by eligible very low, low, or moderate households, or by qualified residents in the case of senior citizen housing. 3. Target units, if later rented by the owner, shall be made available to eligible very low, low, or moderate income households at an affordable rent or to qualified residents (i.e., senior citizens) as defined by this Chapter. 4. The initial purchaser of each target unit shall execute an instrument or agreement approved by the City restricting the sale or rental of the target unit in accordance with this Ordinance during the applicable use restriction period. Such instrument or agreement shall be recorded against the parcel containing the target unit and shall contain such provisions as the City may require to ensure continued compliance with this Chapter and the State density bonus law. E. Rental Housing Developments In the case of rental housing developments, the Density Bonus Housing Agreement shall provide for the following conditions governing the use of target units during the use restriction period: 1. The rules and procedures for qualifying tenants, establishing affordable rent, filling vacancies, and maintaining target units for qualified tenants; 2. Property owners shall be required to verify tenant incomes on an annual basis and maintain books and records to demonstrate compliance with this Chapter. 3. Property owners shall be required to submit an annual report to the City, which includes the name, address, household size, and income of each household occupying target units, and which identifies the bedroom size and monthly rent or cost of each target unit. 4. Property owners shall be required to allow a City representative to inspect each unit annually at a minimum to ensure that units are being maintained to local Code and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Housing Quality Standards. 217 Title 18 Zoning DIVISION 5 CHAPTER 18-50 GLOSSARY Generally For the purpose of carrying out the provisions of this title, the words, phrases, and terms included herein shall be deemed to have the meaning ascribed to them in this Chapter. Abut or Abutting "Abut" or "abutting" means the same as "adjoining" and "contiguous". Access "Access" means the place or way by which pedestrians and vehicles shall have safe, adequate and suitable ingress and egress to a property or use as required by this title. Accessory building or structure "Accessory building or structure" means a subordinate building or structure, the use of which is incidental to that of and separate from the main building or primary structure and is located on the same lot. Administrative services "Offices, administrative, clerical or public contact services that deal directly with the citizen, together with incidental storage and maintenance of necessary vehicles. Typical uses include federal, state county and city offices." Accessory Use "Accessory use" is a use conducted on the same lot as the principal use or structure to which it is related, except that where specifically provided in the parking and loading regulations, accessory off-street parking or loading need not be located on the same lot; and, a use which is clearly incidental to and customarily found in connection with such principal use, and which is either in the same ownership as such principal use or is maintained and operated on the same lot substantially for the benefit or convenience of the owners, occupants, employees, customers, or visitors or the principal use_ Addition "Addition" means the result of any work that increases the volume of an existing structure or replaces a demolished portion. Compare "alteration" and "structural alteration". Adjacent "Adjacent" refers to two or more lots or parcels of land separated only by an alley, or located in close proximity to each other; or two or more objects that lie near or close to each other. Compare "adjoining". Adjoining "Adjoining" refers to two or more lots or parcels of land sharing a common boundary line, or two or more objects in contact with each other. Synonyms are "contiguous" or "abutting." Adult Day Health Care Center "Adult day health care center" means a facility for seniors which provides care, protection and activities on a less than twenty -four-hour basis under the supervision of professional staff. The establishment shall be licensed by the state and conducted in accordance with state requirements. Advertising For definitions relating to advertising, see Sign -Related definitions. Agent of Owner "Agent of owner" means any person who can show certified written proof that he is acting for the property owner. 218 Title 18 Zoning Agricultural or Agriculture "Agricultural" or "agriculture" means the use of land for agricultural purposes, including farming, dairying, pasturage, apiculture, horticulture, floriculture, viticulture, and animal and poultry husbandry, and the necessary accessory uses for handling, treating or storing the produces; provided, however, that the operation of any such accessory use shall be secondary to that of the normal agricultural activity. Air Contaminant "Air contaminant" means particulate matter, dust, fumes, gas, mist, smoke, vapor, or any combination thereof having or tending to have a deleterious effect on human beings, vegetation, animals or property. Alley "Alley" means a public or private right-of-way, other than a street or highway, permanently reserved as a means of providing secondary vehicular access to abutting properties. Alteration "Alteration" means any work on a structure that does not result in any addition to the structure_ Compare "addition" and "structural alteration". Amendment "Amendment" means a change in the wording, context or substance of this title, or a change in the zoning maps, which are part of this title when adopted by ordinance of the city council in the manner prescribed by law. Anchor "Anchor". A large store, such as a department store or supermarket, that is prominently located in a shopping mall to attract customers who are then expected to patronize the other shops in the mall. See also "Large Format Retail". Animal boarding/kennel, small The provision of temporary shelter and care for small animals on a commercial basis. Small animals include domesticated animals or household pets commonly maintained in residence with humans. Animal Hospital For a definition of "Animal Hospital," see "Veterinary Hospital". Animal Husbandry "Animal husbandry" is the care and breeding of domestic agricultural animals such as chickens and other fowl and horses. Arcade "Arcade". A covered walkway composed of a succession of arches supported by columns. Architectural Projection For this definition, see "Projection, Architectural". Area "Area" means the same as "net area", unless otherwise specified. Area, Net "Net area" means that area of a lot or parcel of land exclusive of public alleys, highways or streets; or proposed public facilities such as alleys, highways, or streets or other necessary public sites when included within a proposed development project; or other public or private easements where the owner of the servient tenement does not have the right to use the entire surface of the land. 219 Title 18 Zoning Articulation "Articulation". The degree or manner in which a building wall or roofline is made up to distinct parts or elements. A highly articulated wall will appear to be composed of a number of different planes, usually made distinct by their change in direction (projections and recesses) and/or changes in materials, colors, or textures. Assembly Building "Assembly building" means a building or a portion of a building used for gathering for such purposes as deliberation, worship, auditorium, church or chapel, dance floor, lodge rooms, conference rooms, dining rooms, drinking establishments, exhibit rooms, or lounges. Assembly and Light Manufacturing/Processing Assembly, light manufacturing, and processing uses have no objectionable environmental influences by reason of the emission of odor, heat, smoke, noise, and vibration and do not use explosive or petroleum materials. Such uses may include manufacturing, printing, assembling, processing, repairing, bottling, or packaging of products from previously prepared materials (excluding the assembly of large equipment and machinery); manufacturing of electrical and electronic instruments, devices and components, furniture, tools, clothing and shoes, toys and novelties, renewable energy infrastructure; artist studios;, dyeing and cleaning plants, except large-scale operations; and any other limited manufactured/processing use which is determined by the City to be of the same general character as the uses listed here. Assisted Living Facility "Assisted living facility" means a complex that is designed to accommodate primarily the elderly but may accommodate others, with staff personnel and programs to assist residents with many activities of daily living. Units may or may not have kitchens, but meals are provided in a central location. Units usually rent on a monthly basis. Auto body Uses A building or portions of a building where painting and interior and body modifications or repairs are performed on motor vehicles and trailers, including associated floor space used for offices, parking or showrooms. This includes shops that specialize in collision repair work; customization work on the body and interior of vehicles for aesthetic purposes or for the physically disabled, or other customers with special requirements; painting for post -collision. refurbishment or customization; and restoration of classic and antique vehicles. Automobile, Abandoned "Abandoned automobile" means any motor vehicle which is required to be registered by the California Vehicle Code when operated upon a highway and whose registration has been expired for a period of six months or more. However, a motor vehicle stored within a permitted building or structure shall not be considered to be an abandoned automobile. Automobile and Trailer Sales Area "Automobile and trailer sales area" means an open area, other than a street, used for the display, sale or rental of new or used automobiles or trailers and where no repair work is done except minor incidental repairs of automobiles or trailers to be displayed, sold or rented on the premises. Automobile Dismantling Yard or Automobile Wrecking Yard "Automobile dismantling yard" or "automobile wrecking yard" means any premises used for the dismantling or wrecking of vehicles required to be registered under the California Vehicle Code, including the buying, selling or dealing of such vehicles or the integral parts or component materials thereof, or the storage, sale or dumping of dismantled, partly dismantled or wrecked inoperative vehicles. "Automobile dismantling" shall not include the incidental storage of inoperative or disabled vehicles in connection with a legal operation of an automobile repair garage, automobile body and fender repair shop, or automobile impound yard. See "scrap metal processing" 220 Title 18 Zoning Automobile Impounding Yard "Automobile impounding yard" means facilities maintained by a permittee, on contract with the city, for the temporary storage of vehicles legally removed or impounded by a peace officer from public or private property as prescribed by law. Automobile Parking For definitions relating to Automobile Parking, see "Parking Lot" and Parking -Related Definitions. Automobile Repair, Major "Major automobile repair" means repair involving removal of heads, pans, transmissions; repairing, replacing, or overhauling of engines, motor transmissions; repairing or replacing driving mechanisms, steering mechanisms, differential assemblies; and repairing or replacing any other major automotive part or parts. Automobile Repair, Minor "Minor automobile repair" means the sale, installation, and servicing of tires, batteries. automotive accessories and replacement items, engine tuneup, replacing points and plugs, carburetor overhaul; brake replacement and drum turning; alignment work, wheel balancing; replacing shock absorbers; air conditioning service; washing and lubricating services; steam cleaning; and supplying other incidental customer services and products. Automobile Service Station "Automobile service station" means a retail place of business engaged in the sale of motor fuels and in supplying goods and services generally required in the operation and maintenance of automotive vehicles and the fulfilling of motorist needs. These shall include free restroom facilities for service station customers, and may include any of the items included under "major automobile repair" or "minor automobile repair". Automobile Wrecking For a definition of "automobile wrecking," see "automobile dismantling, or wrecking yard". Awning "Awning" means a temporary shelter supported by an exterior wall of a building and of a type which can be retracted, folded or collapsed against the face of the supporting building. Balcony "Balcony" means an unroofed platform enclosed by a railing or parapet projecting from the wall of a building for the private use of tenants or for exterior access to the above -grade living units. When a balcony is roofed and enclosed with operating windows, it is considered part of the room it serves. Bar/Nightclub "Bar/Nightclub" includes restaurants with dancing after dinner hours, cocktail lounges, bars, establishments that provide live entertainment, and similar uses. Basement For a definition of "basement," see the Uniform Building Code. Batching Plant "Batching plant" means a plant for the manufacture or mixing of concrete, cement, and concrete and cement products, including any apparatus and uses incident to such manufacturing and mixing. Bed and Breakfast Inn "Bed and breakfast inn" means a residential building containing a specified number of guest rooms occupied by a specific number of persons, which provides living units and limited refreshments for transient guests, and which is managed and occupied by the owner of the property. 221 Title 18 Zoning Bedroom "Bedroom" means a private room intended for or capable of being used for sleeping, separated from other rooms by a door, having a window and closet/storage nook, and accessible to a bathroom without crossing another bedroom. Beginning of Construction "Beginning of construction" means demolition, elimination and removal of an existing structure preparatory to new construction, or the incorporation of labor and materials in the foundation of a building or buildings. Billboard or Outdoor Advertising Structure For definitions relating to billboards or outdoor advertising structures, see sign -related definitions in Section 18-47. Block "Block" means the land adjoining one side of a street between two consecutive junctions of said street with streets, railways, rights -of -way, or waterways crossing or meeting said side of said street. Body Piercing Body piercing" means penetrating the skin to make a hole, mark, or scar that is generally permanent in nature to place jewelry or objects of metal or plastic on any area for cosmetic purposes. "Body piercing" does not include practices that are considered medical procedures or the puncturing of the outer perimeter or lobe of the ear using a pre -sterilized, single -use stud and clasp ear piercing system. Bona Fide Public Eating Place "Bona fide public eating place" means a place which is regularly and in a bona fide manner, used and kept open for the serving of meals to guests for compensation and which has suitable kitchen facilities connected therewith, containing conveniences for cooking an assortment of foods which may be required for ordinary meals, the kitchen of which must be kept in a sanitary condition with the proper amount of refrigeration for keeping of food on said premises and must comply with all the regulations of the local department of health. "Meals" mean the usual assortment of foods commonly ordered at various hours of the day; the service of such food and victuals only as sandwiches or salads shall not be deemed a compliance with this requirement. "Guests" mean persons who, during the hours when meals are regularly served therein, come to a bona fide public eating place for the purpose of obtaining, and actually order and obtain at such time, in good faith, a meal therein. Nothing in this section, however, shall be construed to require that any food be sold or purchased with any beverage. Buildable Area "Buildable Area" Means the same as "net area" Building For a definition of "building," see the Uniform Building Code. Building Bulk "Building bulk" means the size of buildings or other structures and their relationships to each other and to open areas and lot lines. Regulations controlling bulk include maximum height, maximum lot coverage, maximum floor area ratio, minimum size of yards and setbacks, shape of buildings or other structures, the area of the lot upon which a residential building is located, and the number of dwelling units or rooms within such building in relation to the area of the lot. Building Height For a definition of "building height," see the Uniform Building Code. Building Line "Building line" means a line established by law or agreement usually parallel to the property line beyond which a structure may not extend. 222 Title 18 Zoning Building Lot Coverage See "Lot Coverage." Building, Main or Primary "Main building" means any building in which is conducted the principal use of the building site on which it is situated. In any residential zone, any dwelling shall be deemed to be a main building on the building site on which it is located. Building Site "Building site" means: 1. The ground area of one lot; or 2. The ground area of two or more lots when used in combination for a building or permitted group of buildings, together with all open spaces as required by this title. See "lot". Bulk Distributing Station, Hazardous Materials "Hazardous materials bulk distributing station" means any distributing station for hazardous materials where there is located a loading rack and which is not an integral part of a refinery, natural gasoline plant, or crude petroleum producing or pipeline operation. Cabaret "Cabaret" means a cafe, restaurant, bar or other public establishment that serves food or alcoholic or nonalcoholic beverages, or both, where entertainment is regularly provided by paid or unpaid performers or musicians, or dancing is regularly allowed to the accompaniment of recorded or live music or rhythmic sound. Camper Fora definition of "camper," see "Recreational Vehicle". Compare "mobile home". Camp, Tourist For this definition, see "Tourist Camp". Camp, Youth For this definition, see "Youth Camp". Canopy "Canopy". A roof -like projection extending horizontally from a structure, usually made of metal, over a sidewalk or driveway for protection from sun or rain. Car For definitions relating to cars, see "motor vehicle", "vehicle", and other automobile -related definitions. Carport "Carport" means an accessory structure or portion of a principal structure, consisting of a roof and supporting members such as columns or beams, unenclosed from the ground to the roof on at least two sides, and designed or used for the parking or temporary storage of motor vehicles of owners or occupants of the structure to which it is accessory. Car Wash, automatic An "automatic car wash" means a building or portion thereof containing facilities for washing vehicles, using conveyorized and/or mechanized equipment where the washing of the vehicle is performed by the equipment. Car wash, full service 223 Title 18 Zoning A "full service car wash" means a building or portion thereof containing facilities for washing vehicles, using conveyorized and/or mechanized equipment where the washing of the vehicle is performed by the equipment and an employee or employees of the facility assist in performing other services such as cleaning, drying, vacuuming, waxing, detailing, or similar services on the vehicle. Car Wash, manual A "manual car wash" means a building or portion thereof containing self-service facilities where the washing of the vehicle is performed by the customer. Cellar For a definition of "cellar," see the Uniform Building Code. Cemetery "Cemetery" means land used or intended to be used for the burial or interment of the dead and dedicated for such purposes, including columbariums, crematories, mausoleums and mortuaries when operated in conjunction with and within the boundary of such cemetery. Certificate of Occupancy "Certificate of occupancy" means a required document issued by the department of building and housing prior to the occupation or use of vacant land, except for agricultural uses, or prior to occupation or use of buildings erected or structurally altered. Child Day Care Center "Child care center" means any child care facility of any capacity, other than a child day care home, in which less than 24-hour per day nonmedical care and supervision are provided to children in a group setting.. Circus and/or Carnival "Circus" and/or "Carnival" means a temporary outdoor amusement center, bazaar or fair, either involving use of special purpose equipment or conducted by professional operators, or both, and where activities include such things as rides, exhibitions, food service, sales, or small-scale games. City Council See Chapter 2.04. City Manager See Chapter 2.01. Civic, fraternal, community, and cultural facilities A facility operated entirely on a public or nonprofit basis for the purpose of providing education, information, training, and/or entertainment of a civic or cultural nature. Such facilities include, but are not limited to, libraries, museums, and community centers. Clinic "Clinic" means any facility used for the care, diagnosis and treatment of sick, active, infirm or injured persons and those who are in need of medical, dental or surgical attention, but who are not provided with board or room, or kept overnight on the premises. "Clinic" includes dental clinic, health clinic, medical clinic and doctors' offices, and may include laboratory facilities in conjunction with normal clinic services. Club, Country "County club" means a private club organized and operated for social purposes and possessing outdoor recreational facilities, such as golf courses, tennis courts or polo grounds. Club, 224 Title 18 Zoning A "club' means any building or premises used by an association of two or more people united by a common interest or goal, whether incorporated or unincorporated, organized for some common purpose. but not including a group organized solely or primarily to render a service customarily carried on as a commercial enterprise. College and university facilities "Educational institutions of higher learning which offer a course of study designed to culminate in the issuance of a degree." Colonnade "Colonnade'. See arcade Commencement, Land Use Activity "Commencement" of any land use activity as provided for by this title is the date of beginning of such activity after all required city permits and approvals have been given. Where a use or premises require an occupancy permit, commencement shall not be recognized before that permit is issued. Any land use activities begun prior to commencement as defined above are, for the purposes of this title, not commenced. Commercial "Commercial" refers to any activity on or use of land which involves the buying, selling, processing. or improving of things not produced on the land and having financial gain as the primary aim of the activity or use, whether or not such activity or use is for hire or on account of the buyer, seller, processor, or improver. Commercial Recreation (indoor) "Commercial recreation (indoor)" refers to indoor recreational facilities that are operated as a business and open to the general public for a fee. Such uses may include, but are not limited to, gyms/health clubs, bowling alleys, martial arts, dance and exercise studios, skating rinks, batting cages, indoor swimming pools, boxing studios, indoor climbing walls, and similar uses. Commercial Recreation (outdoor) "Commercial recreation (outdoor)" refers to outdoor recreational facilities that are operated as a business and open to the general public for a fee. Such uses may include, but are not limited to, sports fields, golf courses/driving ranges, miniature golf, outdoor swimming pools, skate parks, court games, and similar uses. Communication Equipment Building or Use "Communication equipment building or use" means a building or lot housing electrical and mechanical equipment necessary for the conduct of a public communications business with or without necessary personnel. Community Center "Community center" means a neighborhood building for social, recreational, and cultural activities. Community Farm "Community farm" means an area of land larger than one -acre managed and maintained by an individual or group of individuals to grow and harvest food and horticultural products for shareholder consumption or for sale or donation. Shareholders may arrange to work on the farm in exchange for a share of the crops and/or pay for a portion of the crop in advance. A community farm may be a principal or accessory use. Conditional Use "Conditional use" means a use which requires a special degree of control because of characteristics peculiar to it, or because of size, technological processes or type of equipment, or because of the exact location with reference to surroundings, streets and existing improvements or demands upon public 225 Title 18 Zoning facilities. Such control is to ensure that the particular use at the particular site on which such use is proposed to be located is compatible with other existing or permitted uses surrounding the site. Condominium Development "Condominium development" means a structure and appurtenant premises divided in ownership by the existence of condominiums as now or hereafter defined by state law, and includes instances where ownership is so divided following prior single ownership of the entire structure and premises, as well as new structures and premises so divided in ownership. Construction Yard "Construction yard" means an area on or immediately adjacent to a major construction or demolition site used on a temporary basis for the parking and storage of equipment used in the project, and the storage and preparation of materials and other items used in the project. Such yard may include construction offices and such shops as are necessary for work on the immediate project. Contiguous "Contiguous" means the same as "adjoining". Convalescent services "A use providing bed care and in -patient services for persons requiring regular medical attention, such as nursing homes, but excluding facilities providing surgical or emergency medical services, facilities providing care for alcoholism, drug addiction, mental disease or communicable disease." Convenience Establishments "Convenience establishments" means small establishments designed and intended to serve the daily or frequent trade or service needs of the surrounding population. Such establishments include grocery stores, variety stores, drugstores, coin -operated laundry and dry cleaning establishments, beauty shops, barber shops, and medical and dental offices. Specifically excluded are automobile service stations and repair garages, and drive-in eating and drinking establishments. Corner Lot For this definition, see "Lot, Corner". Cornice "Cornice". An ornamental molding that finishes or crowns the top of a building. wall, arch or similar structure. Court "Court" means an area on the same lot with a building which is bounded on two or more sides by the exterior walls of a building or buildings on the same lot. Courtyard Housing "Courtyard Housing" means a group of three or more detached or attached one-story dwellings located on a single lot, and having a common court or yard. Each dwelling unit will have a separate entrance on the ground floor. Coverage See "Lot Coverage." Curb Level "Curb level" means the level of the established curb in front of the building measured at the center of such front. Where no curb level has been established, the city engineer shall establish such curb level or its equivalent. 226 Title 18 Zoning Dairy "Dairy" means any premises where three or more cows or goats or any combination thereof equaling three or more animals are kept or maintained for the purpose of producing milk or milk products. Decibel "Decibel" is a unit which describes the sound pressure level or intensity of sound. The sound pressure level in decibels is twenty times the logarithm, to the base ten, of the ratio of the pressure of the sound to a reference pressure of 0.0002 microbars. Density "Density" means the number of dwelling units that may be constructed per acre or per square foot of lot area. Department Store "Department store" means a store or group of shops under unified management selling a variety of merchandise groups, normally including clothing, appliances, hardware, and furniture. Depth of Lot For this definition, see "Lot Depth". Development "Development" means the design, construction and related use of real property in any manner requiring compliance with this code. Disposal Facility A "disposal facility" provides permanent containment or destruction of waste materials. Landfills and incinerators are examples of disposal facilities. Dock "Dock" means a landing pier for boats; a wharf, a structure supported by piling or floats in such a manner as to allow free flow of water beneath said structure and in which any buildings constructed thereon are incidental to the use of said structure as a wharf or landing pier. Dormitory "A dormitory is a living facility accessory to a learning center designed to house students. A dormitory may be located on the same property as the learning center (college, university, boarding school, nursing school, or similar learning center) or may be located within one -quarter mile radius of the learning center." Drive -Through Restaurant or Drive -Through Eating Place "Drive -through restaurant" or "drive -through eating place" means any commercial establishment serving food or drinks, making provisions encouraging consumption of food or beverages off -site. Drive -through restaurants or eating places may also provide areas for indoor consumption. Driveway "Driveway" means a private road, the use of which is limited to persons residing, employed or otherwise using or visiting the parcel on which located. Dump "Dump" means an area devoted to the disposal of refuse and salvage, including incineration, reduction, or the dumping of ashes, garbage, combustibles or non -combustibles, or offal. Duplex "Duplex" means a building containing two dwelling units meant for residential occupancy which are attached by a common wall. 227 Title 18 Zoning Dwelling "Dwelling" means a building or portion thereof designed or used exclusively for residential occupancy. For the purposes of this title, dwellings do not include hotels, motels, roominghouses, nursing homes, rest homes, university -owned or university -leased housing or institutions. See also "residential building". Dwelling, Group "Group dwelling" means two or more single detached, single attached, or multiple- dwellings or apartments located on the same lot. Dwelling, Mobile Home For a definition of "mobile home dwelling," see "mobile home".. Dwelling, Multiple "Multiple dwelling" means the same as multi -unit residential dwelling. Dwelling, Single Detached "Single detached dwelling" means a detached building containing one dwelling unit meant for residential occupancy. Dwelling, Single Attached "Single attached dwelling" means a building containing two dwelling units meant for residential occupancy which are attached by a common wall. Dwelling Unit "Dwelling unit" means one or more rooms with private kitchen and bathroom facilities, designed for occupancy for living and sleeping purposes. Easement, Private Road For this definition, see "Private Road Easement" in the Glossary. Educational Institution "Educational institution" means any elementary school, junior high school, high school, or college or university, either public or private, giving general academic instruction in the several branches of learning. Efficiency Unit For this definition, see "Studio Unit" in the Glossary. Electric Distribution Substation "Electric distribution substation" means the assembly of equipment which is part of a system for the transmission of electric power, which receives electric energy at a very high voltage from its source of generation, by means of a network of high voltage lines, and where, by means of transformers, said high voltage is transformed to a lower subtransmission voltage for the purpose of supplying electric power to large individual customers, or interconnections with other power -producing agencies or electric distribution substations for transformation to still lower voltage for distribution to smaller individual use. Emergency shelter "Emergency shelter" is defined in Section 50801(e) of the Health and Safety Code and includes housing with minimal supportive services that is limited to occupancy of up to six months. No individual or household may be denied emergency shelter because of an inability to pay. Essential Services "Essential services" means the erection, construction, alteration, or maintenance by public utilities or municipal or other governmental agencies of underground or overhead gas, electrical, steam or water transmission systems, including poles, wires, mains, drains, sewers, pipes, conduits, cables, fire alarm boxes, police callboxes, traffic signals, hydrants, and other similar equipment and accessories in connection therewith reasonably necessary for the furnishing of adequate service by such utilities or 228 Title 18 Zoning municipal or other governmental agencies or for the public health or safety or general welfare, but not including any buildings, electrical substations, or water storage tanks. Explosive Material "Explosive material" means any chemical compound mixture or device, the primary and common purpose of which is to function by explosion with substantially simultaneous release of gas and heat, the resulting pressure being capable of producing destructive effects. Facade "Facade". The exterior face of a building which is the architectural front, sometimes distinguished from other faces by elaboration of architectural or ornamental details. Family Day Care Home, Large "Large family day care home" means a home that provides family day care for 7 to 14 children, inclusive, including children under the age of 10 years who reside at the home, or as set forth in Section 1597.465 of the California Health and Safety Code and as defined in regulations. Family Day Care Home, Small "Small family day care home" means a home that provides family day care for eight or fewer children, including children under the age of 10 years who reside at the home, or as set forth in Section 1597.44 of the California Health and Safety Code and as defined in regulations. Family Foster Care Home "Family foster care home" means a family residence in which twenty -four-hour full-time care is provided for not more than six foster children (persons under eighteen years of age) and the dwelling unit is licensed by the state. Farm Stand A "Farm stand" is a temporary or permanent structure used for the display and sale of agricultural products. Fast Food Eating Place "Fast food eating place" means any retail food establishment that primarily provides short order food services for on -site dining or take-out service, where such food and beverage is served on paper, plastic, or other disposable containers, and including drive in and drive through restaurants where ready -to -eat foods are served primarily to be consumed off the premises. This definition includes all self-service restaurants, except cafeterias, sit-down pizza parlors, and donut shops. Fence "Fence" means a freestanding structure of metal, masonry, composition or wood, or any combination thereof, resting on or partially buried in the ground and rising above ground level, and used for confinement, privacy, protection, screening or partition purposes. Fenestration. "Fenestration" is the number, design, and arrangement of exterior windows. Final Map "Final map" means a map prepared in accordance with the land division regulations and with any applicable provisions of the Subdivision Map Act, designed to be recorded with the county recorder. Fire Protection "Fire protection" means such fire hydrants and other protective devices as required by the chief of the fire department. 229 Title 18 Zoning Floor Area "Floor area" means the sum of the gross area of each floor of a building, excluding mechanical space. cellar space, elevators and stair bulkheads, open balconies, open porches, open breezeways, open terraces, and required parking. Floor Area Ratio "Floor area ratio" means the total floor area on a lot divided by the lot area. For example, a building containing twenty thousand square feet of Floor area on a zoning lot of ten thousand square feet has a floor area ratio of two. Free Standing Retail "Free standing retail" means a single retail sales facility of up to 20,000 square feet in size that is situated independently on a building lot and for which associated parking serves exclusively that facility. Freeway "Freeway" means a divided highway for through traffic with full control of access and with grade separations at intersections, and declared to be such in compliance with the California Streets and Highways Code. Frequency "Frequency" means the number of times that a displacement completely repeats itself in one second of time. Frequency may be designated in cycles per second or hertz (Hz). Frontage "Frontage" means all property fronting on one side of a street between intersecting or intercepting streets, or between a street and right-of-way, waterway, end of dead-end street, or city boundary measured along the street line. An intercepting street shall determine only the boundary of the frontage on the side of the street which it intercepts. Frontage Road For this definition, see "Service Road" in the Glossary. Front Yard For this definition, see "Yard, Front" in the Glossary. Future Street or Alley For this definition, see "Street or Alley. Future" in the Glossary. Games of Skill or Amusement "Games of skill or amusement" means any machines, devices or apparatus, the operation or use of which is permitted, controlled, allowed or made possible by the deposit or placement of any currency, plate, disc, slug or key into any slot or crevice, for the purpose or use as a game or amusement of any description the use for the purpose of which is not prohibited by any law of the state. Garage, Private For a definition of "private garage," see "parking garage, private". Garage, Public For a definition of "public garage," see "parking garage, public". Garage, Repair "Repair garage" means a structure or portion thereof, other than a storage or parking garage, designed or used for repairing, equipping or servicing motor vehicles. Such garages may also be used for housing, storage or sale of motor vehicles. 230 Title 18 Zoning Garage, Storage "Storage garage" means a structure or portion thereof designed and used exclusively for the storage of motor vehicles, and within which temporary parking may also be permitted. General Plan "General plan" means a comprehensive declaration of purposes, policies and programs for the development of the city and including, where applicable, diagrams, maps and text setting forth objectives, principles, standards, and other features, and which have been adopted by the city council. Goods and Services, Retail Retail goods include commercial establishments that provide physical goods, products or merchandise directly to the consumer, where such goods are typically available for immediate purchase and removal from the premises by the purchaser. Typical uses include, but are not limited to, apparel, household appliances, computers and electronics, books and stationary, gifts and souvenirs, paint and wallpaper, pets, plants, groceries and baked goods, hardware, hobby and crafts, sports equipment or similar products. Services include establishments or places of business primarily engaged in the provision of frequent or recurrent needed services of a personal nature. Typical uses include, but are not limited to, beauty shops, barbershops, nail salons, animal grooming establishments, shoe, jewelry, or watch repair, coin -operated Laundromats, dry cleaners and tailors, travel agencies, insurance agencies, banks and credit unions, printing and copy businesses, photographic studios, or similar businesses. Retail goods and services do not include the sale and service of vehicles, industrial -type equipment, heavy machinery, or other similar uses. Government Service Agency "Government service agency" means a government service facility providing direct services to the public wherein large aggregations of people are probable, especially those such as employment offices, public assistance offices, motor vehicle registration and licensing services and similar activities commonly accustomed to having sizeable assemblages of people queueing, tarrying, biding or waiting for service, whether pedestrian or vehicular. Grade For a definition of "grade," see the Uniform Building Code. Gradient "Gradient" means the rate of vertical change of a ground surface expressed as a percentage figure and determined by dividing the vertical distance by the horizontal distance. Guidance/social assistance services "A use providing counseling, guidance, recuperative, or similar services for persons requiring rehabilitation assistance as a result of mental illness, alcoholism, detention, drug addiction, or similar conditions for only part of a 24-hour day." Hazardous Waste Facility "Hazardous waste facility" shall be defined as specified by the California Health and Safety Code and the San Diego County Hazardous Waste Management Plan. Health Facility, Long -Term "Long-term health facility" means an institution or premises licensed by the state and used for the housing and care of the ambulatory, aged or infirm, and offering or providing lodging, meals, nursing, dietary or other personal services, but not including the care and treatment of persons with contagious or communicable diseases or persons insane or addicted to narcotics or alcohol. There shall be no surgery, physical therapy, or other similar activities such as are customarily provided in hospitals. Also called rest homes; convalescent homes; homes for the aged; veterans' homes; institutions for the feebleminded, cerebral palsied and the like; plus other similar names signifying long-term care, which is personal and, at most, nursing help, rather than medical or surgical care. See also "hospital". (Note: A senior citizens' project or housing -for -the -elderly project is to be distinguished from a long-term health facility in that the 231 Title 18 Zoning senior citizens' project or housing is primarily of a residential character with only incidental nursing facilities while a nursing home is primarily designed and used for the care of convalescent or ill persons.) Heavy Manufacturing/Processing "Heavy manufacturing/processing" includes uses that process or treat materials for the fabrication of large base -sector products. Assembly of large equipment and machines is included in this category as well as manufacturing uses that typically produce noise, dust, or other pollutants capable of harming or annoying adjacent uses. Such uses include manufacturing and processing of plastics and synthetic resins; rubber products; soaps, bleaching products, and other disinfectants; large scale laundry and dry cleaning facilities; industrial chemicals; paint and lacquer; fish, vinegar, and other food products with offensive odors (except slaughterhouses); steel mills; petroleum chemical sales; organic chemical research; and other uses that are found by the City to be of the same general character to those listed here. Helicopter "Helicopter" means a rotary -wing aircraft which depends, for its support and motion in the air, principally upon the lift generated by one or more power -driven rotors that rotate on a substantially vertical axis. Heliport "Heliport" means an area of land or water or a structural surface which is used or intended for use for the landing and takeoff of helicopters, and any appurtenant areas which are used or intended for use for heliport buildings and other heliport facilities. Helistop "Helistop" means the same as a heliport, except that no refueling, maintenance, repairs or storage of helicopters is permitted. Highway For definition, see "Freeway". Home, Convalescent "Convalescent home" means the same as "long-term health facility". Home Garden "Home garden" means a garden maintained by one or more individuals who reside in a dwelling unit located on the subject property. Food and horticultural; products grown in the home garden may be used for personal consumption or for donation or sale on —site. A home garden is an accessory use to a principal residential use. Horne Occupation "Home occupation" means an occupation carried on within the main building by the occupant of the dwelling as a secondary use, in connection with which there is no display, no stock in trade nor commodity sold upon the premises, no person employed, and no mechanical equipment used except that which is normally necessary for housekeeping purposes. Homeless Shelter "Homeless shelter" means the same as "Emergency Shelter", Hospice A program that provides care for clients in the last stages of a terminal illness within the client's home or a horne-like facility. Hospital "A facility providing medical, psychiatric or surgical service for sick or injured persons, primarily on an in- patient basis, and including ancillary facilities for out -patient and emergency treatment, diagnostic services, training, research, administration and services to patients, employees, or visitors." 232 Title 18 Zoning Hospital, Long -Term Convalescent, Or Nursing And Convalescent "Long-term convalescent hospital" or "nursing and convalescent hospital" means the same as "long-term health facility". Hospital, Psychiatric "Psychiatric hospital" means the same as "special hospital". Hotel A building in which lodging is provided and offered to the public for compensation, and which is open to transient guests for less than 30 days. No room rentals shall be provided on an hourly basis. The hotel may include facilities available to the general public, such as meeting and dining facilities and limited goods and services, provided these are an integral part of the hotel operations. Household Pet "Household pet' means any domesticated animal commonly maintained in residence with humans. Improvement, Public "Public Improvement" means such street work and utilities as may be installed on land to be used for public or private streets, highways, alleys, pedestrian ways, ways, and easements, as are necessary for the general use and safety of the landowner and the public. Such street work and utilities may include necessary monuments, street name signs, guardrails, barricades, safety devices, fire hydrants, grading, retaining walls, storm drains and flood control channels and facilities, erosion control structures, sanitary sewers, street lights, street trees, traffic warning devices (other than traffic signals), and such other facilities as may be required by this title. Incidental Use "Incidental use" means the same as "accessory use". Industrial Park "Industrial park" means a special or exclusive type of industrial area designed or equipped to accommodate a community of industries, or approved under the procedure for planned development. Institution An "Institution" is a non-profit or quasi -public use, or institution such as a library, public or private school, hospital, or municipally owned or operated building, structure or land used for public purposes. Institution, Health For definitions relating to health institutions, see "clinic", "long-term health facility", and "hospital". Institution, Philanthropic For this definition, see "Philanthropic Institution". Inundation "Inundation" means ponded water or water in motion of sufficient depth to damage property due to the presence of the water or due to deposits of silt. Junk or Salvage Yard "Junk or salvage yard" means any premises used for the keeping or storage of junk, including but not limited to iron and scrap metals, paper, rags, glass, wood and similar materials, and includes the dismantling of machinery or the storage or keeping for sale of parts and equipment resulting from dismantling or wrecking operations on said property or elsewhere. "Junk or salvage yard" also includes the baling of cardboard, cardboard boxes, paper and paper cartons. Compare "automobile dismantling, or wrecking yard" and "scrap metal processing". 233 Title 18 Zoning Kennel "Kennel" means any place where three or more clogs are kept for breeding purposes and where the pups are sold to any other person; or where dogs are received for care or for boarding by the day, week or month, or for longer periods of time. Kitchen "Kitchen" means any room or space within a building designed, intended to be used, or used for the cooking or the preparation of food. Landscaping "Landscaping" means the use of architectural and horticultural materials to provide control of erosion, dust, weeds, and accumulation of litter in a manner complementary to the purpose of adding natural environmental quality to the premises. "Landscaping" includes the planting and maintenance of some combination of trees, shrubs, groundcover, vines, flowers, lawns or other planting materials, other than weeds, providing shade, visual screening, aesthetic enhancement, soil conservation, and the removal or reduction of fire hazards, rodent harborages, vermin, and disease -bearing creatures. In addition, the combination or design may include natural features such as rock and stone, and structural features such as pools, art work, screens, walls, fences and benches. See also "fence" and "screening" as defined in the Glossary. Landscaping Maintenance "Landscaping maintenance" includes sufficient irrigation, fertilization, pruning, trimming, training, and all other reasonable acts necessary to keep plants in a healthy vigorous condition. Maintenance also includes removal of weeds, dead materials and accumulated filter, rubble, or other foreign substances; and reseeding, and replacement of dead plants and planting where necessary to restore a landscaped area to the level of "coverage" required of a new installation. Large Format Retail "Large format retail" is a single retail sales facility that has greater than 20,000 square feet of gross floor area and is contained in a single building. Loading Berth "Loading berth" means a space within a loading facility, exclusive of driveways, aisles, maneuvering areas, ramps, columns, landscaping areas, office and work areas, for the temporary parking of a commercial vehicle while loading or unloading goods or materials, and which abuts upon a street, alley, or other appropriate means of access. Loading Facility "Loading facility" means an area, either open or enclosed, or partially enclosed within a structure or portion thereof, designed or used for the temporary parking of commercial vehicles while loading or unloading goods or materials. Lot The following shall constitute a legal building site: 1. A parcel of land which is shown on a final subdivision map recorded in the office of the county recorder, pursuant to the provisions of the Subdivision Map Act; or 2. A parcel of land, the dimensions or boundaries of which are defined by a duly recorded record of survey map; or 3. A parcel of land shown on the approved lot split map on file in the city engineering department; or 4. A parcel of land which is shown on an approved parcel map recorded in the office of the county recorder; or 5. A parcel of land not described as in subsections 1, 2, 3, and 4 of this definition and legally subdivided prior to the adoption of this National City Land Use Code. 234 Title 18 Zoning Lot Area "Lot area" means the total area, measured on a horizontal plane, included within the lot lines of a lot or parcel of land. Lot, Corner "Corner lot" means a lot or parcel of land situated at the intersection of two or more streets or highways, which streets or highways have an angle of intersection, measured within the lot or parcel of land, of not more than one hundred thirty-five degrees. Lot Coverage "Lot coverage" means that percentage of a lot which, when viewed directly from above, would be covered by a structure or structures, or any part thereof, excluding projecting roof eaves. Lot Depth "Lot depth" means the horizontal distance between the front and rear lot lines, measured in the mean direction of the side lot lines. Lot Frontage For a definition of "lot frontage," see "frontage". Lot, Interior "Interior lot" means a lot other than a corner lot or reversed corner lot. Lot, Key "Key lot" means the first interior lot to the rear of a reversed corner lot and not separated by an alley. Lot Line "Lot line" means the property line bounding the lot. Lot Line, Front "Front lot line" means a line separating an interior lot from a street or highway, or a line separating the narrower street frontage of a corner lot from the street or highway. In the case of a corner lot with equal frontages on intersecting streets, the front lot line shall be the continuation of the street line with the greatest number of lot frontages in the block. Lot Line, Rear "Rear Lot Line" Means a lot line which is opposite and most distant from the front lot line and, in the case of an irregular, triangular, or gore -shaped lot, a line ten feet in length within the lot, parallel to and at the maximum distance from the front lot line. Lot Line, Side "Side lot line" means any lot boundary line not a front lot line or a rear lot line. Lot, Reversed Corner "Reversed corner lot" means a corner lot, the side street line of which is substantially a continuation of the front lot line of the first lot to its rear. Lot, Through "Through lot" means a lot having frontage on two parallel or approximately parallel streets. Lot Width "Lot width" means the horizontal distance between the side lot lines measured at right angles to the lot depth at a point midway between the front and rear lot lines. Maintenance and service facilities 235 1 itle 18 Zoning A facility supporting maintenance, repair, vehicular or equipment servicing, material storage, and similar activities, including corporation yards, equipment service centers and similar uses having characteristics of commercial services or contracting or industrial activities. Major Highway For definition, see "Freeway". Maps For definitions relating to maps, see "final map", "parcel map" "Subdivision Map Act", "tentative map", and "zoning map" in the Glossary.. Mass "Mass". Three dimensional form; the visual impact of a building's height, depth, and length. Massage and Massage Parlor 1. Massage. See Section 10-79. 2. Massage Parlor. See Sections 18.30.030. Marquee "Marquee" means a fixed shelter used only as a roof and extended over a building line, and which is entirely supported by the building to which it is attached. Compare "awning" and "canopy" in the Glossary. Medical Office / Medical Clinic A facility providing medical, psychiatric, or surgical services for sick or injured persons exclusively on an out -patient basis, including emergency treatment, diagnostic services, training, administration and services to out -patients, employees or visitors. Medium Manufacturing/Processing Includes uses that have moderately objectionable environmental influences by reason of the emission of odor, heat, smoke, noise, or vibration. Such uses include the manufacture of food products, drugs, pharmaceuticals and the like; wineries, distilleries, and large breweries; lumber yards and wood products; leather products; plastics; paper products and packaging material; floor coverings; stone, clay, glass, and concrete activities and products; manufacturing of textile products; metal fabrication and welding; vehicle manufacture, railroad equipment; and any other uses found by the City to be of the same general character of those listed here. Merchandise "Merchandise" means any tangible object of nominal or value greater than one cent including, but not limited to, all manufactured products. food, goods and flowers, but excluding "newspapers". Microbrewery A pub or restaurant that also produces and sells beer on the premises. Generally, a microbrewery produces fewer than 10,000 barrels of beer and ale a year. Military installations Military facilities of the federal and state governments. Mini -warehouse / self -storage "Mini -warehouse" (also know as self storage facilities) means a building used for private rental of space for temporary storage of household goods and materials other than storage by commercial "household goods storage" businesses and except "warehouses." Mixed Use The term "mixed use" shall be defined as a combination of commercial and residential uses or structures, designed and built on a single lot or parcel, or as components of a single development. 236 Title 18 Zoning Mobile Home A "mobile home" is defined by Section 798.3 of the California Civil Code. Mobile Home Park "Mobile home park" means an area of land where two or more mobile home sites are rented or leased, or offered for rent or lease, to accommodate mobile homes used for human habitation. Mobile Home Site "Mobile home site" means that portion of a mobile home park set aside and designated for the occupancy of a mobile home and including the area set aside or used for parking or structures, including awnings, cabanas or ramadas which are accessory to the mobile home. Model Home "Model home" means a dwelling or residential building having all of the following characteristics: 1. Said dwelling is constructed upon a proposed lot previously designated as a model home site by the planning commission in a subdivision for which the commission has approved or conditionally approved a tentative map but for which a final map has not yet been recorded; 2. The proposed lot upon which the model home is constructed is recognized as a legal building site for the duration of the model home permit; 3. No certificate of occupancy for such dwelling has been issued by the director of building and housing; 4. Where applicable, temporary access to such dwelling is permitted over future streets previously restricted to public access; and, 5. Said dwelling is intended to be temporarily utilized as an example of the dwellings which have been built or which are proposed to be built in the same subdivision. Motel Any building or group of buildings containing guest rooms for overnight visitor accommodations and not more than 30 days. No room rentals shall be provided on an hourly basis. The motel may include facilities available to the general public, such as dining facilities, provided these are an integral part of the motel operations. Motor Vehicle "Motor vehicle" means a self-propelled device used or intended to be used for the transportation of freight or passengers upon a street or highway, excepting a device moved by human power or a device used exclusively upon stationary rails or tracks. See also "recreational vehicles" and automobile -related definitions, plus "accessory vehicle", "commercial vehicle" and "vehicle". Multi -Unit Residential "Multi -Unit Residential" is a residential structure containing three (3) or more residential dwelling units. Neighborhood Corner Store A small convenience store not more than 3,000 square feet established in a residential zone pursuant to Chapter 3 Section 18.30.260. Neighborhood Garden "Neighborhood garden" is an area of land, one acre or less, managed and maintained by an individual or group of individuals to grow and harvest food and horticultural products for personal or group consumption, for sale or donation. A neighborhood garden may be divided into separate garden plots for cultivation by one or more individuals or may be farmed collectively by members of the group. Neighborhood garden group members may or may not reside on the subject property. Sale and donation of food and horticultural products grown in the neighborhood garden may occur on -site. A neighborhood garden may be a principal or accessory use. Net Area 237 Title 18 Zoning For this definition, see "Area. Net". Nonconforming Structure "Nonconforming structure" means a structure which was lawfully erected prior to the adoption of the ordinance codified in this title but which, under the provisions of this title, does not conform to the standards of coverage, yards, height of structures. or distances between structures prescribed in the regulations for the zone in which the structure is located. Nonconforming Use "Nonconforming use" means a use of a structure or land, which was lawfully established and maintained prior to the adoption of the ordinance codified in this title, but which, under the provisions of this title, does not conform with the use regulations for the zone in which it is located. Nursing Home "Nursing home" means the same as "long-term health facility". Office An establishment providing direct, "over-the-counter" services to consumers and office -type facilities occupied by businesses providing professional services and/or engaged in the production of intellectual property. This includes, but is not limited to such uses as accounting, auditing, and bookkeeping services, advertising agencies, travel reservation centers, architectural, engineering, planning, and surveying services, real estate and related services, legal services, art and design services, computer software and hardware design, counseling services, data processing services, detective agencies, insurance companies, telemarketing, management and public relation services, photography studios, writer and artist offices, postal facilities, administrative and clerical services, or public contact offices of a government agency, and banks and financial institutions. Open Space, Common Usable "Common usable open space" means recreational or leisure space for the shared use of residents of a multi -unit development with no dimension less than 20-feet and may include gardens, playgrounds, courtyards, swimming pools, sitting areas, court games, recreation rooms, exercise rooms or gyms, spas, community rooms, lawn/turf used for open play, ponds, fountains, atriums, picnic areas, rooftop gardens or green roofs, or similar uses or facilities. Open Space, Private Usable "Private usable open space" means an outdoor recreational or leisure space devoted to the exclusive use of a unit with no dimension less than 5-feet, including the following: patio, porch, and balcony. Open Space, Usable Roof Area "Usable roof area open space" means that part of a roof which is usable by all residents of the building, is accessible to all residents by a passageway from the buildings, is enclosed by parapet or ground rails adequate for the safety_of the occupants, has no dimension less than twenty feet, and is developed for active or passive recreational use. Outdoor Advertising Display "Outdoor advertising display" means any card, paper, cloth, metal, glass, wooden or other display or device of any kind placed for outdoor advertising purposes on the ground or on.any tree, wall, rock, structure, or other object. Outdoor Advertising Structure For definitions relating to outdoor advertising structures, see sign -related definitions. Outdoor Storage "Outdoor storage" means storage of goods and materials outside of any building or structure, but not including storage of a temporary or emergency nature. 238 Title 18 Zoning Overlay Zoning / Overlay Zone "Overlay zoning is a regulatory tool that creates a special zoning district, placed over an existing base zone(s), which identifies special provisions in addition to those in the underlying base zone. The overlay district can share common boundaries with the base zone or cut across base zone boundaries. Regulations or incentives are attached to the overlay district to protect a specific resource or guide development within a special area." Pad, Building "Building pad" means the area occupied by a building or buildings on a building site, including the open area contiguous to and surrounding such buildings and having a slope not greater than ten percent. Building pads shall be exclusive of required front yards. Parapet "Parapet". The part of a wall which rises above the edge of a roof. Parcel For a definition of "parcel," see "lot". Parcel Map "Parcel map" means a map showing the division of land, as described in the California Subdivision Map Act, and prepared in accordance with the provisions of this title and the Subdivision Map Act. Pergola "Pergola". An open framework over a walkway or path, which is usually designed to be covered in climbing plants; a walk framed by columns or posts and covered by cross members. Park (active recreation) "Park (active recreation)" means a piece of land that is not part of a residential development, which is developed with such uses as sports fields, court games, skate parks, swimming pools, and other recreational uses that have the potential to generate a lot of noise. Park (passive recreation) "Park (passive recreation)" means a piece of land that is not part of a residential development, which is generally kept in a natural state and contains sitting areas, picnic areas, trails, and other recreational activities that do not generate a significant amount of noise. Parking Facility "Parking facility" means an area other than a street or other public way, either open or enclosed within a structure or portion thereof, designed or used for the parking of motor vehicles. Parking Facility, Accessory "Accessory parking facility" means a parking facility which is accessory to a structure or use on the same lot or another lot, and may include both required or permitted parking stalls. Parking Garage, Private, or Carport, Private "Private parking garage" or "private carport" means a detached accessory building or portion of a main building assigned for the parking or temporary storage of automobiles of the occupants of the premises. Parking Garage, Public "Public parking garage" means a structure or portion thereof designed or used for the parking of motor vehicles and some or all of whose parking stalls are nonaccessory. Commercial or public parking garages may include accessory off-street parking stalls limited to such stalls which are accessory to other structures or uses on the same lot. Parking Lot 239 Title 18 Zoning "Parking lot" means an open area, other than a street, used or designated to be used for temporary storage of vehicles, and which is available for either public or private use, whether free, for compensation, as an accommodation for clients or customers, or for private use. Parking Lift, Mechanical A "mechanical parking lift" is an automated parking lift contained entirely within a parking lift rack structure for parking 2 or more vehicles. The parking lift rack structure is two or more tiers high and is erected indoors or outdoors. Parking spaces for a mechanical parking lift are considered tandem spaces. Parking Space or Stall "Parking space" or parking stall" means a permanently surfaced space within a parking facility, exclusive of driveway, aisles, maneuvering or landscaped areas, ramps, columns, office and work areas, for the parking of one motor vehicle. Parkway "Parkway" means the space located between the street curb and the property line_ The parkway may include a sidewalk and a landscape strip, a sidewalk, or a sidewalk with a cut-off for a street tree. Patio Structure "Patio structure" means an attached roofed structure open on one or more sides, whose principal use shall be for indoor -outdoor living and recreation. Pawn Shop A "pawn shop" is a business that offers secured loans to people, with items of personal property used as collateral. Payday Lender A payday lender is an establishment that provides monetary loans to borrowers that must be paid in full, usually at a high interest rate, when the borrowers receive their next pay check. Pedestrian Way "Pedestrian way" means a right-of-way for pedestrians, free from vehicular traffic and including access ramps, stairs, and mechanical lifts and routes through buildings which are available for public use. Performance Standards For provisions regarding "performance standards", see Section 18-4, Title 7, and Title 12 and specific definitions dispersed throughout this chapter. Petroleum Bulk Plant "Petroleum bulk plant" means any premises used for the wholesale distribution and storage of gasoline, oil or petroleum products, but not including the storage of liquid petroleum gas, a tank farm, or connection to a pipeline constituting, in effect, a petroleum terminal. Pet Grooming "Pet Grooming" is a personal service establishment that, for a fee, trims, cleans or curries domestic pets such as dogs and cats and which may sell pet supplies. This term shall not include establishments which board pets or provide pet day care. Pet Shop "Pet shop" means any store, department of any store, or place of business where dogs, cats, monkeys, birds, reptiles, or any other animals are kept for sale, for hire, or are sold. Philanthropic Institution "Philanthropic institution" means a nonprofit, charitable institution devoted to the housing, training or care of children, or of aged, indigent. handicapped or underprivileged persons, but not including the following: office buildings, except as an accessory to and located on the same lot with an institutional activity, as 240 Title 18 Zoning listed above; hospitals, clinics or sanitariums, correctional institutions; institutions or homes for the insane or those of unsound mind; lodging houses or dormitories providing temporary quarters for transient unemployed persons; organizations devoted to collecting and salvaging new or used materials; or organizations devoted principally to distributing food, clothing or supplies on a charitable basis. Planning Commission. For this definition, see Chapter 2.28. Planning Division The "Planning Division" is a unit of City government responsible for reviewing land development proposals, ensuring compliance with the City's General Plan, Land Use Code, Local Coastal Program Land Use Plan (PDF), Local Coastal Program Implementation (PDF), State Subdivision Map Act, California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and other applicable local and state regulations. The Planning Division also provides staff support to the Planning Commission, and recommends and implements changes to the land use section of the Land Use Code. Postal facilities Postal services, including post offices, bulk mail processing or sorting centers, operated by the United States Postal Service. Principal Permitted Use "Principal permitted use" means the primary allowed land use. Where more than one use is located within a single place, the principal use is that activity to which the greatest amount of floor and/or ground space is devoted. All other activities are "accessory uses." An accessory use that is clearly subordinate and incidental to a permitted use is a component of that permitted use. Private Road Easement "Private road easement" means a parcel of land not dedicated as a public street but intersecting or connecting with a public street, or another private street, for which a private easement for road purposes has been proposed or granted to the owners of property contiguous or adjacent thereto, and for which an instrument creating the easement has been duly recorded and filed with the county recorder. Projection, Architectural "Architectural projection" means anything attached to and extended outside the outer face of the exterior wall of a structure and not intended for shelter or occupancy. Property Line 'Property line" means a line separating parcels of real property having separate legal descriptions, but not including a building line. Public Assembly "Public Assembly" means an institution, such as a church or lodge, that people regularly attend to participate in or hold religious services, public meetings, or other similar activities. This term does not carry a secular connotation and includes the buildings or other locations in which the religious services of any denomination are held. Public Safety Facilities Facilities for conduct of public safety and emergency services, including police and fire protection services and emergency medical and ambulance services. Public Utility Service Center "Public utility service center" means any building or premises used for the administration of public utility repair, maintenance and installation crews, including parking for vehicles not to exceed one and one -half - ton rated capacity, but not including warehouses or storage yards. Public Utility Service Yard 241 Title 18 Zoning "Public utility service yard" means any building or premises used for the office, warehouse, storage yard, or maintenance garage of a public utility, including microwave repeater stations when incorporated as a part of the service yard use. See also "communication equipment building" and "telephone repeater station". Public Way "Public way" means any street, alley, pedestrian way, channel, viaduct, subway, tunnel, bridge. easement, right-of-way, or other way in which a public agency has a right of use. See also "Street or Public Street" and "Freeway". Quarry "Quarry" means any place on a lot or parcel of land where dirt, soil, sand, gravel, rock, clay, decomposed granite, or other similar material is removed by excavation or otherwise. "Quarry" includes mining operations for the removal of ores, precious stones, or other solid minerals, but shall not include excavation and removal of materials from a lot or parcel of land preparatory to construction of a building for which a building permit has been issued and remains in full force and effect, provided that such excavation is confined to that necessary for such building construction, but in no event shall more than five thousand cubic yards of soil or other excavated materials be removed from the premises; or excavation, on a lot, parcel of land or subdivision, necessary to grading, building construction or operation on the premises, where a building permit is not in full force and effect, provided that such grading is necessary to prepare a site for a lawful use permitted thereon, but in no event shall more than five hundred cubic yards of soil or other excavated materials be removed from such premises. Railroad facilities Railroad yards, equipment servicing facilities and terminal facilities. Real Estate Sales Office "Real estate sales office" means a sales office established and maintained in one model home as approved by the planning commission, or in a single-family dwelling on a recorded lot previously designated as a model home site by the planning commission and serving temporarily as an example of houses in the same subdivision, and subject to the provisions of this title. Rear Lot Line For this definition, see "Lot Line, Rear". Rear Yard For this definition, see "Yard, Rear". Recreational Vehicles 1. Recreational vehicles include the following: a. Boats and boat trailers, including boats, floats, and rafts, plus the normal equipment to transport the same on a highway; b. Campers, which are structures designed primarily to be mounted upon a motor vehicle and with sufficient facilities to render same suitable for use as a temporary dwelling for camping travel, recreational and vacation purposes; c. Full tent trailers, which are canvas folding structures mounted on wheels and designed for travel and vacation use; d. Motorized homes, which are portable dwellings designed and constructed as an integral part of a self-propelled vehicle: e. Travel trailers, which are vehicular portable structures built on a chassis and designed to be used as temporary dwellings for travel, recreational and vacation uses permanently identified as a travel trailer by the manufacturer. 2. See also "mobile home" and "motor vehicle". Recreation, Commercial 242 Title 18 Zoning "Commercial recreation" means recreation facilities operated as a business and open to the general public for a fee. Recreation, Private, Noncommercial "Noncommercial private recreation" means clubs or recreation facilities operated by a nonprofit organization and open only to bona fide members of such nonprofit organization. Recreation. Public "Public recreation" means publicly owned or operated recreation facilities. Recreation Room or Building "Recreation room or building" means a room, contained in either a main building or an accessory building, designed to be utilized primarily for games, the pursuit of hobbies, social gatherings, and such activities. Such a room may contain such plumbing fixtures as are utilized in a bar or for hobby activities. Such a room in a single-family or two-family dwelling, or in an accessory building appurtenant to a single-family or two-family dwelling, may not include facilities for the cooking and preparation of food. However, in a multiple residential use or in an accessory building appurtenant thereto, a recreation room which is for the common use of all the dwelling units therein may contain facilities for the cooking and preparation of food. Rectory "A rectory is the residence of one or more leaders of a religious institution of any denomination and may also function as the administrative offices of the religious institution. A rectory is also known as a presbytery, parsonage, or manse. Recyclables or Recyclable Materials "Recyclables" or "recyclable materials" means plastic bottles, plastic containers, glass bottles, glass jars, newspapers, aluminum and/or metal cans, and any other material designated by the city as a recyclable material in Chapter 9.52. Renewable energy infrastructure Renewable energy infrastructure is equipment used to generate electricity or heat from renewable or low - carbon sources. Renewable energy infrastructure includes, but may not be limited to, solar power, wind power, electric vehicle charging stations, and similar facilities and devices. Repair Garage For this definition, see "Garage, Repair". Research and Development "Research and development" means a laboratory facility that is primarily used for scientific research. This use can include the design, development, and testing of biological, chemical, electrical, magnetic, mechanical, and/or optical components in advance of product manufacturing. This use does not involve the fabrication, mass manufacture, or processing of the products. Residential Building "Residential building" means a building or portion thereof designed or used for human habitation. Residential Care Home "Residential care home" means a state authorized, certified, or licensed home serving six or fewer mentally disordered or otherwise handicapped persons or dependent or neglected children, and providing care on a twenty -four -hour -a -day basis. as defined in Section 5116, California Welfare and Institutions Code. Residential Density "Residential density" means the average number of families living on one acre of land in a given area. Net residential density is determined by dividing the total number of families in a defined area by the total acreage of all parcels of land within the area that are used for residential and accessory purposes. Gross 243 Title 18 Zoning residential density is obtained by dividing all land in a defined area used for residences, streets, local schools, local parks, and local shopping facilities into the total number of families in said area. Rest Home "Rest home" means the same as "long-term health facility". Restoration is initiated "Restoration is initiated" means that, at a minimum, a Building Permit application has been issued. Retail Sales or Retail Store "Retail sales" or "retail store" means the sale of goods, merchandise or commodities for consumption or use by the purchaser. Right -of -Way "Right-of-way" means an area of land reserved for public or private easements. Roadway "Roadway" means that portion of a right-of-way for a street, highway or alley designed or used for accommodating the movement of vehicles. Rooming or Boarding House A private residence which is rented out to more than two paying guests. Rubbish "Rubbish" means refuse and waste material, whether combustible or noncombustible, not included within the definition of garbage as herein defined, including but not limited to paper, rags, leaves, glass, cans, ashes, tree and vine trimmings. It shall not include plaster, rock sand, dirt, automobile frames or fenders, or waste material pertaining to building operations, construction or repair. It shall not mean discarded water heaters or furniture. Salvage Yard For this definition, see "Yard, Salvage". Satellite Television Antenna "Satellite television antenna" means a device or instrument designed or used for the reception of television or other electronic communications signals broadcast or relayed from an earth satellite. It may be a solid, open -mesh or bar -configured structure, typically eight feet in diameter, in the shape of a shallow dish or parabola. Scale "Scale". The measurement of the relationship of one object to another object. The scale of a building or the scale of a building's components can be described in terms of its relationship to a human being. A building's scale can range from intimate or pedestrian -scale to monumental. Intimate or pedestrian -scale refers to the portions of a building that are around 8 to 10 feet in height above the ground plane. A monumental scale is used to present a feeling of grandeur. Building types which commonly use a monumental scale usually include banks, churches, and civic buildings. Soffit "Soffit". The finished underside of an eave. School, Elementary and High "Elementary school" and "high school" mean institutions of learning which offer instruction in the several branches of learning and study required to be taught to the public schools by the Education Code of the state. "High school" includes junior and senior high schools. 244 Title 18 7oning School, Trade, Vocational, Business or Professional "Trade school," "vocational school," "business school" or professional school" means an institution of learning which offers specialized instruction as preparation for entrance into, or as supplementary training in, a specific field or endeavor. Such institutions include, but are not limited to, secretarial schools, barber schools, modeling schools, language schools. electronics schools, dancing schools, and art schools. Scrap Metal Processing "Scrap metal processing" means the recovery of metals from salvage for consumption by primary metals industries, using cutting, shredding, and melting processes. "Scrap metal processing" includes the preparation of such salvaged metals for reshipment. "Scrap metal processing" does not include wrecking yards, junkyards, or any similar use where metals are stored or sold as secondhand or used materials. Nonmetallic salvage or processing not clearly incidental to the principal use shall not be allowed. Screening "Screening" means solid walls, solid fences. or dense living hedges for the purpose of concealing from view the area behind such structure or hedge. See also "fence" and "landscaping". Second Unit "Second unit" is a small, self-contained residential unit built on the same lot as an existing primary residence or built in conjunction with a primary residence. It provides complete independent living facilities for one or more persons. Second units are also referred to as "accessory dwelling units", "in-law apartments", "granny flats", "ancillary apartments" or "carriage houses". Second units may be attached to or detached from the primary residence. Refer to Chapter 2 Section 18.21.050 for second unit regulations. Senior Citizens' Housing For this definition, see "Senior Housing". Senior Housing "Housing for the elderly" or "senior housing", also called "elderly housing and senior citizen housing" means a project specially designed for elderly persons and providing living unit accommodations. Senior housing may also include spaces for common use by the occupants in social and recreational activities and, when needed, incidental facilities and space for the project residents. Setback "Setback" means a horizontal distance determining the location of a building with respect to a street, zone boundary line, or another use. Where the term "setback" is used in conjunction with a modifying word or words, such as "parking area," the setback shall, in its application, include but not be limited to building. Shared Parking Parking spaces shared by more than one user or land use. Shopping Center "Shopping center" means a group of commercial establishments planned and developed, owned or managed as a unit, with off-street parking and loading provided on the property, and related in its location, size, and type of shops to the trade area which the unit serves. Sidewalk "Sidewalk" means that portion of a thoroughfare, other than a roadway, set apart by curbs, barriers, markings or other delineations for pedestrian travel. Sidewalk Cafe The outdoor seating portion of an eating or drinking establishment such as a restaurant, coffeehouse, or cafe. Sidewalk cafes must conform to the regulations set forth in Chapter 3 Section 18.30.200. Side Yard 245 Title 18 Zoning For this definition, see "Yard, Side". Sight Visibility Triangle Refer to "Traffic Visibility Triangle". Site, Building For this definition, see "Building Site". Skilled Nursing Facility "Skilled Nursing Facility" means an institution, or part of an institution, that provides licensed, skilled nursing care and related services for patients who require 24-hour medical, nursing or rehabilitative services. Sloping Terrain "Sloping terrain" means any ground surface having a rate of incline or decline of greater than a ten - percent gradient. Solar Array A "solar array" is an electrical Solar collector A "solar collector" is any of source of energy. device consisting of a large array of connected solar cells several devices that absorb and accumulate solar radiation for use as a Solar Energy System (1) Any solar collector or other solar energy device, certified pursuant to State law, along with its ancillary equipment, whose primary purpose is to provide for the collection, storage, and distribution of solar energy for space heating, space cooling, electric generation, or water heating. (2) Any structural design feature of a building, whose primary purpose is to provide for the collection, storage, and distribution of solar energy for electricity generation, space heating or cooling, or for water heating. Specific Plan "Specific plan" means a definite statement, adopted by ordinance, of policies, standards, and regulations, together with a map or description defining the location where such policies, standards, and regulations are applicable. Stall, Parking For a definition of "parking stall". Storage, Outdoor For a definition of "outdoor storage". Story For a definition of "story," see the Uniform Building Code. Street or Public Street "Street" or "public street" means any public thoroughfare other than an alley or walk. Where a subdivision has been recorded containing lots which abut only on an alley or walk, the alley or walk may be considered to be a street. Street, Collector "Collector street" means a street (including the principal access streets of a subdivision) which carries traffic from local streets, either directly or by way of other existing or proposed collector streets, to a major or secondary highway. 246 Title 18 Zoning Street Line "Street line" means the boundary line between a street and the abutting property. Street, Local "Local street" means any street, other than a collector street, major or secondary highway or freeway, providing access to abutting property and serving local, as distinguished from through, traffic. Street or Alley, Future "Future street or alley" means any real property which the owner thereof has offered for dedication to the city for street or alley purposes but which has been rejected by the city council subject to the right of the council to rescind its action and accept by resolution at any later date and without further action by the owner all or part of said property as a public street or alley. Street, Private "Private street" means a private road easement that the director determines to be adequate for access and which conforms to such dimensional and improvement standards as are adopted by the commission. Street, Side "Side street" means a street which is adjacent to a corner lot and which extends in the general direction of the line determining the depth of the lot. Structural Alteration "Structural alteration" means any change in the supporting members of a building, such as foundations, bearing walls, columns, beams, floor or roof joists, girders, or rafters, or changes in roof or exterior lines. Structure "Structure" means anything constructed or erected which is supported directly or indirectly on the earth, but not including any vehicle which conforms to the California State Vehicle Act. "Structure" includes any building or accessory building which can be used for the housing, shelter, or enclosure of persons, animals, chattels, or property of any kind, plus fences, walls, billboards, platforms, towers, panels and signs. Structure, Accessory For this definition, see "Accessory Structure". Subdivision Map Act "Subdivision Map Act" means the Subdivision Map Act of the state. Studio or Efficiency Unit "A studio or efficiency unit" means a dwelling that combines kitchen, living, and sleeping rooms into one room. Substantial conformance "A determination in which a revision to a development that was approved through a permit or tentative map complies with the objectives, standards, guidelines, and conditions, for that permit or tentative map." Supportive housing Supportive housing is defined in Section 50675.14 of the Health & Safety Code and has no limit on the length of stay, is linked to onsite or offsite services, and is occupied by a target population as defined in Health & Safety Code Section 53260 (i.e., low income persons with mental disabilities, AIDS, substance abuse or chronic health conditions or persons whose disabilities originated before the person turned 18). Services typically include assistance designed to meet the needs of the target population in retaining housing, living and working in the community, and/or improving health and may include case management, mental health treatment, and life skills. Tattoo 247 Title 18 Zoning The terms "tattoo refers to any method of placing designs, letters, scrolls, figures, symbols or any other marks upon or under the skin of a human with ink or any other substance, resulting in the coloration of the skin by the aid of needles or any other instrument designed to touch or puncture the skin. Tattoo and Body Piercing Establishment A "tattoo and body piercing establishment" is an establishment that provides a service for tattoos and body piercing as defined in this Section. See "tattoo" and "body piercing". Telecommunications Facility/ Wireless Telecommunications Facility A facility consisting of any commercial antenna, monopole, microwave dish, and/or other related equipment necessary for the transmission and/or reception of cellular, personal communication service, and/or data radio communications. Tandem Parking "Tandem parking" is where vehicles park nose -to -end or are stacked vertically. Tandem parking shall only be permitted in the Westside and Downtown Specific Plan areas. See definition for "parking lift, mechanical". Telephone Repeater Station "Telephone repeater station" means a building used for housing amplifying equipment along aerial or underground telephone cable routes. See also "public utility service center" and "public utility service yard" Temporary Use For this definition, see "Use, Temporary". Tentative Map "Tentative map" means a map made for the purpose of showing the design of a proposed subdivision and the existing conditions in and around it, and need not be based upon an accurate or detailed final survey of the property. Tentative Map, Revised "Revised tentative map" means a map involving a revised arrangement of the streets, alleys, easements or lots within property for which a tentative map has been previously approved, or a modification of the boundary of the property. Termination, Land Use Activity "Termination" or "cessation" of a land use activity occurs when premises are, from outward appearance, vacated, abandoned, inoperative or disused for a consecutive period of thirty days or more, or when electric service has been discontinued by the occupant or the premises are barricaded, padlocked or otherwise closed to all entry; or when the holder of city permits or licenses advises city. agencies that a use has terminated or ceased. Texture "Texture". Variations in the exterior facade described in terms of the roughness of the surface material and the patterns inherent in the material or the patterns in which the material is placed. Threshold Concentration or Threshold Limit Value For definitions, see "odor threshold concentration" and "odor threshold limit value" _ Tideland "Tideland(s)" means that area designated by the state legislature to be the jurisdiction of the San Diego Unified Port District. Tobacco specialty shop 248 Title 18 Zoning "Tobacco specialty shop" means any business, the primary use of which is the sale of tobacco products or tobacco related paraphernalia. A business shall be determined a tobacco specialty shop when more than forty percent of its retail floor area is devoted to the display and sales of tobacco products and/or paraphernalia. Townhouses or Townhomes "Townhouses" means attached buildings, each containing a single dwelling unit and each located or capable of being located on a separate lot. Trailer For definitions relating to trailers, see "recreational vehicles". Trailer, Utility "Utility trailer" means a vehicle designed to be drawn by a motor vehicle for the purpose of transporting cargo, but not including any recreational vehicle or mobile home. The vehicle shall not exceed two thousand pounds in weight. Compare "mobile home" and "recreational vehicles". Traffic Visibility Triangle "Traffic visibility triangle" is a triangular area that defines a zone necessary for the clear view by the driver of a motor vehicle or a bicyclist of oncoming cross -street motor vehicle, bicycle or pedestrian traffic or of a traffic control device, and includes street intersection visibility triangles, alley intersection visibility triangles, and public access driveway visibility triangles for all land uses. A visibility triangle is the area encompassed by the triangle formed by projecting lines of a specified distance from the point of intersection of the front and side street edges of pavement and a straight line connecting the termini of said projected lines. Within the area comprising the triangle, no tree, fence, shrub, or other physical obstruction higher than three feet above the official grade lot line grade shall be permitted. Transient "Transient" means any person who exercises temporary occupancy by reason of concession, permit, right of access or license under the provision of Civil Code Section 1940(b). Transitional housing "Transitional housing" is defined in Section 50675.2 of the Health & Safety Code as rental housing for stays of at least six months but where the units are re -circulated to another program recipient after a set period. Transitional housing may be designated for a homeless individual or family transitioning to permanent housing. This housing can take several forms, including group housing or multifamily units, and may include supportive services to allow individuals to gain necessary life skills in support of independent living. Trash Enclosure A "trash enclosure" is a wall surrounding a trash bin or bins and accessible by a gate of sufficient width to allow the bin to be removed and which is constructed in a manner and of materials that blend architecturally and aesthetically with the main structure. A trash enclosure shall not be considered in the calculations for lot coverage. See also Title 7. Travel Trailer For this definition, see "Recreational Vehicles". Trucking and Transportation Terminal A "trucking and transportation terminal" is an establishment which provides the movement of goods/products from one location to another, where trucks/tractors are dispatched from a central location to haul goods/products from one location to another or to many other locations. A transportation facility may also include parking, refueling, and accessory uses including but not limited to an office, convenience goods and services, maintenance, and repair of vehicles. Urban Agriculture 249 Title 18 Zoning "Urban agriculture" is the cultivation, processing, and distribution of edible vegetables, flowers, herbs, fruits, and other plants. Use "Use" means the purpose for which land or structures are arranged, designed or intended, or for which either land or structures are, or may be, occupied or maintained. "Use" includes construction, establishment, maintenance, alteration, moving onto, enlargement, operation or occupancy. Use, Accessory For this definition, see Accessory Use". Use, Conditional For this definition, see "Conditional Use". For provisions regarding conditional use permits, see Chapter 18-2. Use, Principal "Principal use" means the main or primary purpose for which a structure or lot is designed, arranged or intended, or for which either may be used, occupied or maintained under this title. Use, Temporary "Temporary use" means a use of land or structures not intended to be of permanent duration and regulated by Chapter 15.60. Utility Building "Utility building" means a separate building on the same lot with the main building or a portion of an accessory building designed or intended for use as a washhouse, laundry room, or any similar purpose. Plumbing facilities are permitted but the building shall not be designed nor equipped for cooking or preparation of food. Utility Facilities, Major Generating plants, electrical switching facilities and primary substations, refuse collection or disposal facilities, water and wastewater treatment plants and similar facilities. Utility Facilities, Minor Facilities which are necessary to support principal development and involve only minor structures such as lines and poles which are necessary to support principal development. Utility Trailer For this definition, see "Trailer, Utility". Variance For a definition of "variance" and provisions regarding variances, see Chapter 18.10. Vehicle "Vehicle" means a device or craft that is designed or used to transport people or cargo. Vehicles include automobiles, trucks, boats and other watercraft, campers, motor homes and other recreational vehicles, trailers, and motorcycles. A semi -trailer truck and farm equipment shall not be included in the definition of a vehicle for the purpose of this Land Use Code. Vehicle, Accessory "Accessory vehicle" means any motor vehicle used in connection with the operation of any structure or use. Vehicle, Commercial 250 Title 18 Zoning "Commercial vehicle" means a vehicle which when operated upon a highway is required to be registered as a commercial vehicle by the California Vehicle Code, and which is used or maintained for the transportation of persons for hire. compensation, or profit, or designed, used or maintained primarily for the transportation of property. Vehicle, Recreational For definitions relating to recreational vehicles, see "Recreational Vehicles" Vehicle queuing "Vehicle queuing" is the length of a drive aisle necessary to allow for the movement of vehicles within a parking lot to a drive -up window service or other drive -through services without impeding the flow of traffic on -site and off -site. Vehicle Storage Yard, Commercial "Commercial vehicle storage yard" means the storage, for compensation or consideration, of more than one motor vehicle, recreational vehicle, or unoccupied mobile home on a parcel of land for a period of time exceeding seventy-two hours. A commercial vehicle storage yard shall comply with the provisions of Chapter 18.40.040 (Automobile Impound and Storage Yards) and Chapter 18.40.070 (Outdoor Storage). Premises used for the sale, lease, or rental of motor vehicles, recreational vehicles, or mobile homes shall not be governed by this section. Vehicular Access Rights "Vehicular access rights" means the right or easement for access of owners or occupants of abutting lands to a public way other than as pedestrians. Vending machine A "vending machine" is a device which dispenses a product or service, either for sale or for free, and which is activated entirely by the receiver of the product or service, including ice machines; food and beverage vending machines; purified, distilled or spring water vending machines; movie vending machines; and, newspaper racks or similar. Vending machines do not include motor fuel pumps. Veterinary Clinic "Veterinary clinic" means a treatment center serving only those kinds of small domesticated animals or household pets commonly maintained in residence with man. Veterinary Hospital "Veterinary hospital" means an establishment where more than six domestic animals are kept for observation, diagnosis, and medical care. Walk "Walk" means any right-of-way for pedestrians, including sidewalks and inner -block walks. Walkway Any path or way, which is some manner, is specifically designated exclusively for pedestrian travel. Warehouse A "warehouse" is a building used for storage of goods or materials other than stock in trade of businesses on the premises or for goods stored in conjunction with permitted distribution type businesses operated on the premises or goods or materials manufactured on the premises. Warehouse includes the storage of impounded goods and materials, dead storage, and storage of in -transit commodities. It does not include miniwarehouses or self storage facilities. Waterfront Related Industry Includes waterfront uses and activities including small boat marinas; ship berthing; supportive commercial and recreational businesses; boat and other water vehicle sales, leasing, rentals, and service/repair; freight handling; any use operated and maintained by the San Diego Unified Port District as part of the 251 Title 18 Zoning marine terminal; and any other use determined by the City to have the same general character as those uses listed here. Water Supply "Water supply" means such water system supply and distribution facilities as are necessary to provide a reliable and adequate water supply for private use and public fire protection services. Wholesale Store or Sales "Wholesale store" or "wholesale sales" means a business establishment engaged in selling to retailers or jobbers, rather than consumers. Wind Energy System "Wind energy system" means equipment that converts and then stores or transfers energy from the wind into usable forms of energy and includes any base, blade, foundation, generator, nacelle, rotor, tower, transformer, turbine, vane, wire, or other component used in the system. Yard "Yard" means an open space, other than a court, on a lot or parcel of land, unoccupied and unobstructed from the ground upward, except as otherwise provided in this title. Yard, Front "Front yard" means an open space extending the full width of the lot measured between the building closest to the front lot line, which open space is between a building and the front lot line, unoccupied and unobstructed from the ground upward except as specified elsewhere in this title. Yard, Front, Least Depth. 1. "Front yard least depth" means the shortest distance, measured horizontally between any part of a building other than parts herein excepted, and the front lot line. 2. Such depth shall be measured from the front lot line; provided, however, that if the proposed location of the right-of-way line of such street as adopted by the city differs from that of the existing street, then the required front yard least depth shall be measured from the right-of-way line of such street as adopted; or said building shall comply with the official setback lines as adopted by the city. Yard, Rear "Rear yard" means an open space between a building and the rear lot line, unoccupied and unobstructed from the ground upward and extending across the full width of the lot, except as specified elsewhere in this title. Yard, Rear, Least Depth "Rear yard least depth" means the shortest distance, measured horizontally, between any part of a principal building other than parts hereinafter excepted, and the rear lot line. Yard, Side "Side yard" means an open space extending from the front yard to the rear yard between a building and the nearest side lot line, unoccupied and unobstructed from the ground upward, except as specified elsewhere in this title. A side yard on the street side of a corner lot shall be known as an exterior side yard. Yard, Side, Least Width 1. "Side yard least width" means the shortest distance, measured horizontally, between any part of a building other than parts herein excepted, and the nearest side lot line. 2. Such width shall be measured from the nearest side lot line and, in case the nearest side lot line is a side street lot line, from the right-of-way line of the existing street; provided, however, that if the proposed location of the right-of-way line of such street as adopted by the city differs from that of the existing street, then the required side yard least width shall be measured from the right-of-way of such street as adopted; or said building shall comply with any applicable official setback lines. 252 Title 18 Zoning Zone "Zone" means a portion of the territory of the city within which certain uniform regulations and requirements or various combinations apply under the provisions of this title. Zoning Map "Zoning map" means the designated official map or maps which show the location and boundaries of the districts established by this title and which are referred to as the "zoning map" and incorporated as a part of this title. The zoning map, together with everything shown thereon and all amendments thereto, are as much a part of this title as if fully set forth and described in context. 253 Title 18 Zoning CORONAD A en .utme of me CM, !wells 'm1 eN6n lee ILnnna Arco Boundary t�rcdn Aoes) h suyccl ro Corm, of Son O0oo kr^d aD, .c.e13 reoLeolicnr anti ru_M1 time or Irvl lcnd a Inlc the Clle ma aen.e,Im wl„ ono de ly.nfpnl lem..pars be in a tc& upon ennp.pnn of lore rnopedes D i E G O Maliarwl Clly.Bre.R6p0M_el Legend ESesiden?ioi Rsl Large L0• Rel. RS 2 Small eat Res. RS3 Medeen. Lov, Dee Muli-Unit Res RMI eleclum Den. elellilenil Per. FA42 n,ph Der. v.ulliUrnl Res. vary Hgh De'. Null ilnil Pe, Mixed -Use MYC-I Mlnoi Mbed-tee Corr doi _M%DI Minor Maed-Use Delccl _ AMC-2 M1lalor mired-J:e 20,15 r _ FA%P2 MajOr M1+00-USE 001 0? i.ommerciol en Commercal AO'cmal've 8 ; 6 Semee 2ammerdm Industrial It eghnnSUIIlal 0 Mc du, Indof11t01 _IH Hc0Wnaus1+al Institutional I Intlity tonal Open Space men SDaa CSe ones 5oace Reserve MiIla'y AI IAif r_ry Downtown Specific Plan El I I Aarllicnnl<. Deaalnp enl mre. Westside Specific Plan [ 1 PS-4 Residenliol_ingle Family MC, I M0IIL'Jle Camrnncee FReaidenlioll24 du/ae re.DI _ MCP-2 Ma:IFJse Canrmelciuk0esitlenlla1145 d0/ac moil CL L relied Commercial IC CINC Insefutlanol Harbor District Specific Plan Rol., to Inc Harbor Di.lc15pecllic Arco Plan Port Master Plan i Refer 10 the Pa- Muster Plor DI lee Son Diego UnAwa Port Detect OYCrICys MUDe 2ncelnl 'one 1-4 1H height Re0'0ict on fit In fee -I he. „ • !Will. Mobileltome Pork Base Layers `--_-�NationalC a Plconng Plea Boundcoy L..m,J Nnsonal Baananr. ceenes Roods Rauraad Official Zoning Map NAlFONAL Ctiy jaN Exhibit "B-3" Exhibit "E-1" Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations Comprehensive Land Use Update Environmental Impact Report (SCH #2010051009) Prepared for: City of National City 1243 National City Boulevard National City, CA 91950 Contact: Ray Pe Prepared by: The Planning CenterjDC&E 750 W. Fir Street, Suite 405 San Diego, CA 92101 Contact: Brooke Peterson May 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS I . INTRODUCTION 1-1 2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION 2-1 3. FINDINGS OF SIGNIFICANT EFFECTS 3-1 4. FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES 4-1 5. STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS 5-1 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS TABLE OF CONTENTS I INTRODUCTION This document contains the proposed CEQA Findings (pursuant to CEQA Guidelines` Section 15091) and the Statement of Overriding Considerations (pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15093). Chapter 1, Introduction, pro- vides background information as to the purpose of the documents. Chapter 2, Project Description, provides a description of the project being adopted. This includes the proposed project described in the DEIR, modified in the Final EIR (including the City's proposed Mitigation Measures), and any modifications incorporated the City prior to project approval. Chapter 3, Findings Regarding Significant Environmental Effects, nukes written findings for each of those significant effects from the project, accompanied by a brief explanation of the rationale for each finding. Chapter 4, Project Alternatives, provides a brief discussion of other alternatives that were evaluated in the environmental impact report (EIR). Finally, Chapter 5, Statement of Overrid- ing Considerations, is provided to balance, economic, legal, social, technologi- cal, or other benefits, including region wide or statewide environmental bene- fits, of a proposed project against its unavoidable environmental risks when determining whether to approve the project.. Mitigation measures are referenced in the mitigation monitoring and report- ing program (MMRP) adopted concurrently with these findings and will be effectuated through the process of implementing the project. Except as otherwise noted, the findings reported in the following pages in- corporate the facts and discussions of environmental impacts that are found in the Final environmental impact report (Final EIR) for the National City Comprehensive Land Use Update, May 2011, as fully set forth therein. These findings constitute the decisionmakers' rationale and support for their deci- sion under the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). For each of the significant project or cumulative impacts associated with the project, the following information is provided: California Code of Regulations, Title 14, 15000 et seq. CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS IN FRODUCTION • Description of Significant Effect. A specific description of each signifi- cant environmental impact identified in the Final EIR (e.g. Impact AQ- la); • Proposed Mitigation. Mitigation measures or actions that are proposed for implementation as part of the project (e.g. MM AQ-1a); • Finding. The findings made are those allowed by Public Resources Code Section 21081 (PRC) and CEQA Guidelines Section 15091. For impacts found to be significant, one of three specific findings is made, in accor- dance with the statement of acceptable findings provided in Section 15091 of the State CEQA Guidelines; and • Rationale for Finding. A summary of the reasons for the decision. The MMRP for the Comprehensive Iand Use Update is included as Chapter 6.0 of the Final EIR, presented for adoption together with these Findings of Fact and Statement of Overriding Considerations. The custodian of the documents and other materials which constitute the Record of Proceedings is the City Clerk, located at 1243 National City Blvd., National City, CA 91950. The Record of Proceedings consists of the following documents, at a minimum: • The Notice of Preparation (NOP) and all other public notices issued by the City of National City; ♦ Comment letters received on the NOP; • The Draft EIR for the Comprehensive Land Use Update and all technical appendices (January 2010); • All comments submitted by agencies, organizations, or members of the public during the 48-day comment period on the Draft EIR; • All comments and correspondence submitted to the City of National City with respect to the project, in addition to timely comments on the Draft FIR; I-2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS INTRODUCTION • The Final EIR for the Comprehensive Land Use Update, including comments received on the Draft EIR, responses to those comments, changes made to the Draft EIR, and technical appendices; • The MMRP for the project; • All findings and resolutions adopted by the City in connection with the Comprehensive Land Use Update and all documents cited or referred to therein; • All reports, studies, memoranda, maps, staff reports, or other planning documents relating to the project prepared by the City, consultants to the City, or responsible or trustee agencies with respect to the City's compliance with the requirements of CEQA and with respect to the City's action on the Comprehensive Land Use Update; • All documents submitted to the City by other public agencies or mem- bers of the public in connection with the Comprehensive Land Use Up- date, up through the certification of the Final EIR; • Matters of common knowledge to the City, including, but not limited to, federal, state, and local laws and regulations; • Any other materials required for the record of proceedings by Public Re- sources Code Section 21167.6, subdivision (e). I-3 2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION I. OVERVIEW The City proposes a Comprehensive Land Use Update (CLUU) to update the current City of National City General Plan and portions of the current Mu- nicipal Code. The Comprehensive Land Use Update also includes five devel- opment proposals. Specifically, the proposed Comprehensive Land Use Up- date project includes two primary components: (1) revisions to the City's Planning documents, including a comprehensive update of National City's General Plan, an update to the Land Use Code (Municipal Code Title 18), a Climate Action Plan, and amendments to the Downtown Specific Plan and Local Coastal Program to ensure consistency with the General Plan; and (2) five individual development projects as follows: Street Conver- sions/Community Corridors; Senior Village Expansion; Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan; Kimball Park Master Plan; and El Toyon Park Master Plan. 1I. COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE A. General Plan The overall purpose of the National City General Plan Update is to create a policy framework that articulates a vision for the city's Long-term physical form and development, while preserving and enhancing the quality of life for National City's residents. The key components of this project include broad community goals for the future of National City, policies for meeting those community goals, and specific actions that would help implement the poli- cies. The General Plan component of the proposed project contains the fol- lowing Elements: + Land Use and Community Character ♦ Circulation ♦ Safety ♦ Noise and Nuisance 2- I CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION • Conservation and Sustainability ♦ Open Space and Agriculture • Health and Environmental Justice • Education The goals, policies, and actions in the General Plan are intended to guide de- velopment and conservation in National City through the horizon year in 2030. The goals and policies contained in the General Plan are then imple- mented through various other actions, such as specific plans, zoning, and or- dinances which are more detailed and specific. 1. Major Components of the General Plan The following provides a summary of the major components of the General Plan Update. a. General Plan Update Content and Organization The City developed the Draft General Plan update within the context of state requirements and the issues and needs unique to the City of National City. The proposed General Plan update contains the following elements: ♦ Land Use and Community Character. This Element designates the general distribution and general location for specific uses of the land, in- cluding population density and building intensity, for residential, com- mercial, mixed use, industrial, public facilities, and open space, and estab- lishes policies to enhance the aesthetic and cultural value of the commu- nity. • Circulation. This Element demonstrates the general location and extent of existing and proposed major streets and other transportation facilities, including major thoroughfares, transportation routes, terminals, and roadways. This element is correlated with the Land Use Element to pro- vide adequate pedestrian, bicycle, rail and transit, motor vehicle, sea ports, airport transportation, and emergency access to serve both new and existing land uses. This Element plans for a balanced multimodal transportation network that meets the needs of all users of streets, roads, and highways for safe and convenient travel that is suitable to the context 2-2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION of National City. Although parking is not identified as a mandatory is- sue to cover, it is addressed in this element of the General Plan. • Safety. This Element provides information about risks in National City due to natural and human -made hazards, and contains goals, policies and implementation measures designed to protect the community and its property from seismic and other geologic hazards, flooding and dam or levee inundation, crime and public safety, fire hazards, and hazardous materials. This Element also addresses emergency response and disaster preparedness. • Noise and Nuisance. This Element identifies and addresses noise prob- lems, quantifies current and projected noise levels and contours from a variety of sources, and includes policies that establish compatibility guidelines for different land uses and minimize exposure of community residents to excessive noise and nuisance. • Open Space and Agriculture. This Element details plans and measures for the comprehensive and long-range preservation, conservation and managed production of open space resources, such as cultural and histori- cal resources, agricultural land, and outdoor recreation, such as parks, trails, and scenic vistas. Agriculture is addressed in terms of "urban agri- culture" considering that National City is almost fully developed. • Conservation and Sustainability. This Element addresses the conserva- tion, development, and utilization of natural resources, including water and its hydraulic forces, forests, soils, rivers and creeks, wildlife habitat, sensitive vegetation, mineral deposits, and other natural resources. Since National City is highly urbanized, many of these topics do not apply. Therefore, this Element focuses mainly on infrastructure such as water supply, sewer, drainage, electric, and gas systems. Although not typically included in this element, these items are addressed here to emphasize con- servation and sustainability through reducing water and energy consump- tion and improving water quality. Additionally, the General Plan poli- cics address global warming. Although the State has not developed spe- cific guidelines on this topic yet, the National City Draft General Plan addresses climate change issues. 2-3 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJFCT DESCRPIION • Health and Environmental Justice. This optional Element addresses public health issues and their relationship to the built environment. • Education. This optional Element addresses schools, opportunities for the City to partner with school districts, educational programs for people of all ages, libraries, child care, communication, and community partici- pation. b. General Plan Update Goals, Policies, and Actions The General Plan sets out a long-range vision and comprehensive policy framework for how the city should grow and develop, provide public ser- vices, and improve the quality of life within National City over the next 20 years. Only 2.7 percent of the planning area remains vacant; therefore, the General Plan policies focus on reinvestment in existing neighborhoods and directing additional development and redevelopment near transit stations, within urban and community centers, and along transit corridors. By en- couraging development in these areas, established residential neighborhoods will be preserved and growth managed consistent with regional policy rec- ommendations established by the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG). Each Element of the General Plan contains background information and a series of goals, policies, and implementation measures. The goals, policies, and implementation measures provide guidance to the City on how to direct change and manage its resources over the next 20 years. c. General Plan Land Use Designations The General Plan defines various land use designations by their allowable uses, population densities, and building intensities. The land use designations described in the proposed General Plan establish the types and intensity or density of uses allowed within the City. In the proposed General Plan, standards of building intensity for residential uses are stated as the allowable range of dwelling units per gross acre. This means that, generally the number of allowable units on a parcel can be calcu- 2-4 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROIECT DESCRIPTION lated by multiplying the number of acres by the allowable density. Standards of building intensity for non-residential uses are stated as floor area ratios (FAR) based on nct square footage. Density Bonus: Consistent with the State Density Bonus Law (California Government Code Section 65915 et seq.), a developer, upon request, shall be granted a density bonus, incentive(s), concession(s), and/or modification of development standard(s) if the developer proposes to build a qualified project satisfying criteria set forth in the City's Density Bonus Ordinance. This ap- plies to both the residential and mixed -use designations. The following sections describe the proposed land use designations for the General Plan. i. Low -Medium Density Residential This designation allows for up to nine dwelling units per gross acre or 33 per- sons per gross acre. This designation provides for single family detached and secondary residential units (accessory dwelling units), and compatible uses. ii. Medium Density Residential This designation allows for 9 to 23 dwelling units per gross acre or 33 to 83 persons per gross acre. This designation provides for a variety of moderate intensity residential uses including detached and attached single-family and multi -family housing, and compatible uses. This designation is typically lo- cated in transitional areas between high density residential uses and lesser in- tensity single-family areas and is intended to retain private yards and patios and other characteristics of single family residential uses. iii. High Density Residential This designation allows for 23 to 75 dwelling units per gross acre or 83 to 269 persons per gross acre. This designation provides for multi -family housing at densities greater than other residential designations. This designation pro- vides for condominiums, townhomes, triplexes, fourplexes, multi -family resi- dential units, group quarters, senior housing, and compatible uses. 2-5 CITY OF NATIONAL. CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION iv. Minor Mixed -Use This designation allows for an FAR of 2.0 for the entire building for mixed - use developments (including dwelling unit floor area) and a maximum of 48 dwelling units per gross acre or 172 persons per gross acre. This designation allows for an FAR of 1.5 for single -use developments. This designation gen- erally occurs in a linear fashion along bus routes and provides transitional links between residential neighborhoods and more intense activity centers. It is intended to facilitate redevelopment and transit -oriented design opportuni- ties in developed areas in a manner that is compatible with surrounding resi- dential areas. It provides for a variety of uses including low-rise attached sin- gle-family or multi -family residential development, retail, restaurants, per- sonal services, professional and administrative offices, public and quasi -public uses, and similar compatible uses. The minor mixed -use designation is characterized by high -quality, compact, smart -growth design that promotes a quaint, small-town, village -like feel. A comfortable and attractive pedestrian environment is promoted through the use of street trees; awnings, canopies, or arcades; outdoor seating; clearly - marked crosswalks; and small courtyards or plazas. Bicycle facilities are also provided. Buildings are placed close to the street, parking lots are de- emphasized, and driveway cuts are limited. Building facades include details that add visual interest, distinctiveness, and human scale. v. Major Mixed -Use This designation allows for an FAR of 3.5 for the entire building mixed -use developments (including dwelling unit floor area) with a maximum of 75 dwelling units per gross acre or 269 persons per gross acre. This designation allows for an FAR of 3.0 for single -use developments. This designation gen- erally occurs along major transportation corridors, at major intersections and activity centers, and near transit stations. It facilitates redevelopment and transit -oriented design opportunities at higher intensities than those allowed in the minor mixed -use designation. It provides for a variety of uses including low to mid -rise multiple -family dwellings, retail, restaurants, personal ser- 2-6 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION vices, professional and administrative offices, public and quasi -public uses, and similar compatible uses. The major mixed -use designation is characterized by higher density and inten- sity development intended to increase transit ridership and transform signifi- cant activity centers into popular destinations. The major mixed -use areas have an urbanized, community center -type character. Ground -floor commu- nity -serving commercial and retail development is emphasized along with multi -family apartments and condominiums. The major mixed -use areas have a comfortable, multi -modal environment with qualities such as inviting street lamps; outdoor seating; pedestrian plazas; attractive street trees; buildings that face onto sidewalks with wide storefront windows and appealing architectural details; bicycle facilities; and convenient access to transit stops and stations. vi. Commercial Automotive This designation allows for an FAR of 1.0. This designation provides for new and used automobile and truck sales and services and sales and services that support and complement such uses. Other land uses may include alternative fuel vehicle sales, services and related supplies and rental car facilities. Addi- tional compatible uses may be permitted pursuant to a use permit. vii. Service Commercial This designation allows for an FAR of 1.5. This designation provides for in- tensive commercial activities and specialized service establishments. Light manufacturing, wholesaling, and distribution uses are restricted to those that can be operated in a clean and quiet manner. viii. Industrial This designation allows for an FAR of 2.0. This designation provides for em- ployment intensive uses, light manufacturing, business parks, research and development, technology centers, corporate and support office uses, "green" industry, recycling facilities, supporting retail uses, auto, truck and equipment sales and related services (i.e. auto service and repair), large format retail, stor- age facilities, warehousing and distribution, and other compatible uses. 2-7 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PP.OJFCT DFSCRIPTION ix. Institutional This designation allows for an FAR of 3.0. This designation provides for a wide range of public institutional and auxiliary uses including public, quasi - public, and private facilities. Allowed uses include wastewater treatment fa- cilities, water tanks, electrical substations, cemeteries, worship facilities, edu- cational facilities, community centers, libraries, museums and cultural centers, government offices and courts, medical and retirement centers, public safety facilities (i.e. fire and police stations), and similar compatible uses. x. Open Space This designation allows for an FAR of 0.25. This designation provides for both public and private improved and unimproved open space. Allowed land uses include urban agriculture and recreational areas such as parks, golf courses, athletic fields, playgrounds, neighborhood gardens and community farms, and recreational trails. Open space not used for active and passive rec- reation, such as nature and wildlife preserves, marshes and wetlands, water bodies, public utility areas, flood control channels, and other scenic and open space areas, are also included. xi. Military Reservation This designation identifies lands under the jurisdiction of the United States military. Permissible land uses are governed by the US Navy. xii. San Diego Unified Port District This designation identifies land that is under the jurisdiction of the San Diego Unified Port District. Permissible land uses are governed by the Port Master Plan. xiii. Specific Plan This designation denotes areas that are covered by an adopted specific plan. Land uses are identified within the adopted specific plan. As of the writing of the General Plan, there are three adopted specific plans in National City: the Downtown Specific Plan, the Harbor District Specific Area Plan, and the Westside Specific plan. For additional information on these specific plans see the Specific Plan Land Use Designation in the Draft General Plan. 2-8 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION xiv. Floodplain This designation identifies the 100-year floodplain limits for the Sweetwater River and Paradise Creek. These areas are subject to annual review. B. Land Use Code The City has developed the Draft Land Use Code update within the context of State Law (Government Code Section 65800) and the issues and needs unique to the City of National City. The Land Use Code comprises Title 18 of the National City Municipal Code. The following outlines the contents and organization, provides a summary of the major revisions and compo- nents, and describes the proposed zoning classifications associated with the Draft Land Use Code update. 1. Land Use Code Contents and Organization The proposed Land Use Code update includes six major sections: • General Provisions. This chapter describes the overall authority and purpose of the land use code including the jurisdiction, statutory author- ity, purpose and intent, applicability and authority, and responsibility for administration. This chapter defines the rules of interpretation of Land Use Code provisions and rules of measurement identified in the provi- sions. This chapter also outlines the administrative responsibilities and permitting process applied by the City and identifies the regulations and process for non -conforming uses and parcels. These provisions are pro- vided in Chapter 1 of the Draft Land Use Code. • Zoning Districts and Allowable Land Uses. This chapter includes the zoning map and detailed descriptions of each zone, including the purpose of each zone, allowed land uses and permit requirements, permitted ac- cessory uses, prohibited uses, and general development standards. Zon- ing descriptions address residential, commercial, mixed -use, industrial, in- stitutional, and open space uses. These provisions are provided in Chap- ter 2 of the Draft Land Use Code. 2-9 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECI DESCRIP I ION • Specific Use Regulations. This chapter identifies regulations for specific uses which are supplementary provisions intended to clarify the general requirements with respect to certain potentially incompatible uses. These provisions are provided in Chapter 3 of the Draft Land Use Code. • General Design Standards. This chapter identifies the general standards and design provisions governing all uses and structures, regardless of the zone in which they are located in the city. These regulations are in addi- tion to regulations and standards otherwise specified in the specific zone descriptions or elsewhere in the Land Use Code. Uses and structures identified include accessory structures, fences, walls and hedges, landscap- ing, off-street parking and loading, outdoor lighting, signs and outdoor advertising displays, site design, and building design standards. These provisions are provided in Chapter 4 of the Draft Land Use Code. • Glossary. This chapter defines the terms used in the Land Use Code and are provided in Chapter 5 of the Draft Land Use Code. 2. Proposed Land Use Revisions The following details the complete list of proposed changes to the Land Use Code (Title 18): • The Land Use Code has been reorganized into five chapters: • 1.0 - General Provisions • 2.0 - Zoning Districts and Allowable Land Uses • 3.0 - Specific Use Regulations • 4.0 - General Design Standards • 5.0 - Glossary • Applicability, administrative procedures, and other sections that apply globally to National City regulatory processes have been removed from Title 18 of the National City Municipal Code and will be moved to Ti- tle 1. • Nuisance/code compliance issues have been removed from Title 18 of the National City Municipal Code and will be moved Title 7. 2-10 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION ♦ All definitions for terms contained within the Land Use Code have been moved to Chapter 5 - Glossary. ♦ Rules of Measurement have been added in Chapter 1 - General Provi- sions for consistency in calculating distances, height, etc. • Permitting Processes within Chapter 1 - General Provisions have been revised to: • Add a minor conditional use permit, which can be reviewed and ap- proved at the staff level. The minor conditional use permit is appeal- able to the Planning Commission. • Modify review of I Iistoric Property permits. The National City His- torical Society will be given notice of these applications, but will not be deemed responsible for making a report and recommendation to the City Council. • Zoning Designations have been revised to be consistent with General Plan land uses as follows (and described further in the zone descriptions listed in Section 5c below): • The Single -Family Estate (RS-E) zone has been eliminated • The zones and associated development standards for the Two -Family (RT) and Single -Family Extendible (RS-3) zones have been eliminated and replaced with a new Single -Family High (RS-3) zone. Specifically, the proposed RM-3 zone has been expanded to include uses beyond senior housing. • The Multi -Family Medium High (RM-2) and Multi -Family High (RM- 3) zone standards and development regulations have been changed to be consistent with Draft General Plan 2030 designations. • Four new mixed -use zones have been added to the Land Use Code as described in detail in Section 5c. below (MXC-1; MXD-1; MXC-2; MXD-2). These zones apply form -based zoning standards and devel- opment regulations. 2-II CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPIION • 0.5 FAR bonus increases for mixed -use developments have been added and will apply to both horizontal and vertical mixed -use. • The Tourist Commercial (CT) zone has been eliminated from the Land Use Code except within the Harbor Specific Plan. • The Limited Commercial (CL) zone has been eliminated and replaced by mixed -use zones. • The Medium Commercial (CM) zone has been eliminated. • The General Commercial (CG) zone has been eliminated and replaced by mixed -use zones. • The Shopping Center Commercial (CSC) zone has been eliminated and replaced by mixed -use zones. • The Heavy Commercial (CH) zone has been incorporated into the proposed Service Commercial (CS) zone and the intensity of allowable industrial -type uses has been reduced. Further, the CH development regulations have been modified to include a proposed height limit of 50 feet and three stories. (No existing height limit). The Commercial Automotive (CA) zone has been expanded to allow for other commercial and office uses pursuant to a conditional use permit (CUP). CA zone development regulations modified to permit used car sales with a minimum lot size of one acre. The CA develop- ment regulations have been modified to change the existing height limit from 13 stories to a proposed height limit of 50 feet and three sto- ries and increase the existing FAR from 1.0 to a proposed FAR of 2.0. • The Light Manufacturing/Residential (MLR) zone has been elimi- nated. • The Tidelands Manufacturing (MT) zone has been eliminated and re- placed with the Port Master Plan zone. • The Civic Institutional (IC) and Private Institutional (IP) zones have been consolidated into one institutional zone (I). 2-12 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRINIION • Most overlay zones have been removed. Existing overlay zones that will remain include the Coastal Zone, Height Limit, and Planned Develop- ment (within the Harbor Specific Plan). A Mobile Home overlay zone has been added. • Specific use regulations for Emergency Shelters (Chapter 3, Specific Use Regulations, Section 18.30.) have been changed to be consistent with State law (Senate Bill 2 [2006]). In particular, emergency shelters shall be allowed as a permitted use in the Light Industrial (IL) zone without the need for a conditional use permit and are exempt from CEQA. • Transitional and supportive housing has been added as an allowable use in all residential zones pursuant to SB 2. • Urban Agriculture has been added as an allowable use in residential, mixed -use, industrial, institutional, and open space zones, subject to limi- tations (Chapter 3, Specific Use Regulations, Section 18.30.240). • Neighborhood Corner Store has been added as an allowable use in resi- dential zones subject to limitations and a minor use permit (Chapter 3, Specific Use Regulations, Section 18.30.260). ♦ Outdoor Display or Sale of Merchandise (Chapter 3, Specific Use Regula- tions, Section 18.30.150) has been revised to include fresh produce as an acceptable outdoor display for corner stores and grocers. • Allowable uses and development standards for residential zones have been revised to include standards for accessory dwelling units pursuant to a minor use permit. • Guest houses have been eliminated as an allowable use from the land use code and replaced with second unit provisions. 3. Land Use Code Zones Each zone classification is described below. ♦ Large Lot Residential (RS-1). The purpose of the RS-1 zone is to pro- vide for areas of single family detached honies on large lots (ten thousand square feet minimum and a density of up to 5 dwelling units per acre) and 2-13 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION secondary residential units (accessory dwelling units), and compatible uses. • Small Lot Residential (RS-2). The purpose of the RS-2 zone is to pro- vide for areas of single-family residences on small lots (5,000 square feet minimum and a density of 6 to 9 dwelling units per acre) and secondary residential units (accessory dwelling units), and compatible uses. • Medium -Low Density Multi -Unit Residential (RS-3). The purpose of the RS-3 zone is to provide for areas of low population density (10 to 15 units per acre) single-family attached and multiple family residential areas and community services appurtenant thereto. The purpose of the RS-3 zone is intended to retain the fundamental characteristics to be found in the single-family zones (i.e., private yards and patios, privately main- tained open space, and privacy and self -containment of dwelling units). • Residential Single -Family (RS-4) (Westside Specific Plan). The purposes of the RS-4 zone are to provide for areas of single-family attached and de- tached homes on minimum lot sizes of 2,500 square feet; and provide for small lot single-family development within the Westside Specific Plan area. The RS-4 zone permits one attached or detached single-family dwelling for each full two -thousand five -hundred square feet of lot area provided there is no more than one single-family residence for each 2,500 square feet of lot area. It also allows for the continuation of the existing mixture of housing types and encourages infill with single-family zones on vacant properties and where existing parcels may be further subdi- vided as provided herein. • Medium Density Multi -Unit Residential (RM-1). The purpose of the RM-1 multi -unit residential zone is to provide for areas of multi -unit at- tached residential development allowing for a density of 16 to 23 dwell- ing units per acre. This designation provides for a variety of moderate in- tensity residential uses including detached and attached single-family and multi -family housing, and compatible uses. This designation is typically located in transitional areas between high density residential uses and lesser intensity single-family areas and is intended to retain private yards and patios and other characteristics of single family residential uses. 2-14 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION • High Density Multi -Unit Residential (RM-2). The purpose of the RM-2 multi -unit residential zone is to provide for areas of multi -unit at- tached residential development allowing for a density 24 to 48 dwelling units per acre. This designation provides for condominiums, town - homes, triplexes, fourplexes, multi -family residential units, group quar- ters, senior housing, and compatible uses. • Very High Density Multi -Unit Residential (RM-3). The purpose of the RM-3 multi -unit residential zone is to provide for areas of multi -unit attached residential development allowing for a density of 49 to 75 dwell- ing units per acre. This designation provides for condominiums, town - homes, triplexes, fourplexes, multi -family residential units, group quar- ters, senior housing, and compatible uses. • Commercial Automotive (CA). The purpose of the Commercial Auto- motive (CA) Zone is to provide for new and used automobile and truck sales and services and sales and services that support and complement such use. Other land uses may include alternative fuel vehicle sales, ser- vices and related supplies, and rental car facilities. Adaptive reuse of va- cant buildings/dealerships is encouraged. Additional compatible uses may be permitted pursuant to a use permit. • Limited Commercial (CL) (Westside Specific Plan). The purposes of the Limited Commercial (CL) zone are to provide for small scale, limited convenience retail shopping facilities at the neighborhood level, typically including food and convenience stores, small retail and service shops, professional offices, and artisan activities such as studios, galleries, pro- duction space, and small performance venues; and to ensure that the character of the CL zone will be compatible with and will complement the surrounding residential area. The sale of all merchandise shall be re- tail only. • Service Commercial (CS). The purpose of the Service Commercial (CS) Zone is to provide for intensive commercial activities, specialized service establishments, and other compatible uses. Light manufacturing, whole- saling, and distribution uses are restricted to those that can be operated in a clean and quiet manner. 2-15 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION • Mixed Commercial -Residential (MCR-1) and Mixed Commercial - Residential, Smart Growth Area (MCR-2) (Westside Specific Plan). The purpose of the MCR-1 and MCR-2 zones is to provide an area within the Westside Specific Plan area for either commercial or multi -family residen- tial development or a commercial and multi -family development con- structed on a single parcel or as components of a single development on an assemblage of parcels. • Mixed -Use Transit Corridor, Minor (MXC-1). The purposes of the MXC-1 zone are to: 1) support the creation of mixed -use corridors in Na- tional City at a scale compatible with adjacent single-family residential neighborhoods; and 2) create a pedestrian -oriented development that en- hances the quality of life within the corridor and for adjacent residential neighborhoods. Buildings in the MXC-1 zone are built at or near front property lines, parking areas are de-emphasized, multi -family residential and mixed -use buildings provide a diversity of affordable housing choices, and commercial uses provide goods and services for local residents and supply quality jobs. • Mixed -Use Transit Corridor, Major (MXC-2). The purposes of the MXC-2 zone are to: 1) support the creation of mixed -use corridors that function as important activity centers within the community; and 2) cre- ate vibrant places at an urban scale. Buildings in the MXC-2 zone are built to the property lines and mixed -use buildings with housing above retail support commercial establishments within the corridor. • Mixed -Use District, Minor (MXD-1). The purposes of the MXD-1 zone are to: 1) support the creation of mixed -use districts in National City at a scale compatible with adjacent single-family residential neighborhoods; and 2) facilitate the redevelopment of large sites currently occupied by automobile -oriented land uses. New development within the MXD-1 may be oriented outwards towards an existing public street, or inwards towards a new street or civic space within the development site. A mixture of land uses within the MXD-1 zone support a neighbor- hood feel and increase the ability for workers and residents to walk to destinations. New streets established in the MXD-1 zone support a pe- 2-I6 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJFCT DESCRIPTION destrian-oriented environment and accommodate all modes of transporta- tion. New civic spaces required for large redevelopment projects create a lively focal point within the district. • Mixed -Use District, Major (MXD-2). The purpose of the MXD-2 zone is to support the creation of new mixed -use districts that serve as primary activity centers within National City. Housing, employment, retail, and recreational uses located within close proximity to one another are in- tended to reduce dependence on the automobile. New streets established in the MXD-2 zones support a pedestrian -oriented environment and ac- commodate all modes of transportation. New civic spaces required for large redevelopment projects reinforce the urban design character of the district and provide a gathering place for residents, workers, and visitors. • Light Industrial (IL). The IL zone is intended to accommodate ware- housing operations, storage, office, and research and development facili- ties and establishments engaged in the manufacturing, assembling, pack- aging, treatment, and processing of products other than those that which may be obnoxious or offensive to adjacent residential and business dis- tricts due to reason of odor, dust, smoke, gas, noise, vibration, or other nuisances. • Medium Industrial (IM). The IM zone is designed to provide for the development of medium manufacturing and industrial uses that operate freely of excessive noise, dust, odor, or other nuisances and yet may be objectionable to other non -industrial uses. The IM zone is located west of Interstate 5. • Heavy Industrial (IH). The IH zone is intended to provide for manu- facturing facilities and industries that may be obnoxious by reason of emission of odor, dust, smoke, gas, noise, vibration, or similar causes and therefore require isolation from many other kinds of land uses. The IH zone is located west of the Interstate. • Institutional (I). The purpose of the I zone is to provide for a wide range of public institutional and auxiliary uses including public, quasi - public, and private facilities, most of which are provided in the General 2-17 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION Plan Elements established as a response to the health, safety, educational, cultural, and welfare needs of the city. Allowed uses include wastewater treatment facilities, water tanks, electrical substations, cemeteries, educa- tional facilities, community centers, community gardens and farms, li- braries, museums and cultural centers, government offices and courts, medical and retirement centers, public safety facilities (i.e., fire and police stations), and similar compatible uses. ♦ Open Space (OS). The purpose of the OS zone is to provide for both public and private improved and unimproved open space. Allowed land uses include urban agriculture and recreational areas such as parks, golf courses, athletic fields, playgrounds, community gardens and farms, and recreational trails. Open space not used for active and passive recreation is also permissible, such as nature and wildlife preserves, marshes and wetlands, water bodies, public utility areas, flood control channels, and other scenic and open space areas. C. Climate Action Plan The following provides a summary of the major components of the Climate Action Plan. The Climate Action Plan for National City is a stand-alone document containing analysis as well as policies and programs to minimize greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in National City. This proposed Climate Action Plan has been drafted to aid CEQA review, including CEQA Guide- lines Sections 15064.4, 15126.4, 15130, 15150, 15183, and 15183.5. The pro- posed Climate Action Plan contains the following components: • New Programs. This section includes a list of potential new programs, policies, and actions to reduce GIIG emissions in National City to 1990 levels by 2020. This list will be based on best practices currently in place by other jurisdictions and other research conducted in sustainability planning. • Detailed Greenhouse Gas Analysis. This section includes a detailed GHG analysis of the selected potential policies, actions, and programs, 2-18 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION and proposed land use and zoning maps using two main modules of the "ICLEI - Local Governments for Sustainability" model. This detailed analysis utilizes data specific to National City, including local energy use coefficients and regional growth forecasts. D. Amendments to the Downtown Specific Plan The Comprehensive Land Use Update includes revisions to the Downtown Specific Plan to maintain consistency between the General Plan and the exist- ing Specific Plan. The Downtown Specific Plan is proposed to be amended to make the following revisions: • Land Use. Revise Chapter IV to specify permitted uses in each develop- ment zone based on the 'preferred land uses,' the `restricted or prohibited land uses,' the design guidelines, and the general guidelines that describe the desired character for the development zones in the proposed Land Use Code. • Review Process. Revise Section V-2 to clarify thresholds that would trigger the project review process. New construction, addition of square footage, loss of non -conforming use, or abandonment of non -conforming use would trigger project review. • Review Process. Revise Section V-4 to amend exemption findings to be consistent with the Community Development Commission (CDC) adopted policy (Resolution No. 2005-54, Section 6). The adopted policy states that the CDC may consider and approve an exemption from the development standards based on one of the following findings: 1. The project does not exceed the floor area ratio limit for the site; or 2. The project includes a significant public amenity that would other- wise not be required, including more than 15 percent of affordable housing units or commercial rental space that is 25 percent below the market rate; or 2-19 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPIION 3. The project makes a significant contribution to off -site public space in Downtown National City, such as street improvements, public plazas, public park improvements, and other improvements that are called for in the Downtown Specific Plan. • Revise the Specific Plan Development Zone (DZ) Boundaries per the following amendments. • Designate the area west of Roosevelt Avenue and north of 8th Street as DZ 1B. • Designate the area west of Hoover Avenue and north of 9'h Street as DZ 1B. • Designate the area west of Coolidge and north of Plaza Boulevard as DZ 1B. • Designate west of National City Boulevard, south of 8t Street, north of Plaza Boulevard, and east of Roosevelt Avenue, as DZ 7. • Designate the area west of National City Boulevard, south of 12'h Street, north of Civic Center Drive, and east of Roosevelt Avenue, as Institutional. • Designate the area east of A Avenue, south of Plaza Boulevard, north of 11'I Street, and west of mid -block, as DZ 5A. • Designate the area south of 4`h Street, west of A Avenue, north of 6th Street, east of alley/mid-block, as DZ 3. • Designate the area south of 6'h Street, west of C Avenue, north of 76 Street, and east of alley/mid-block to the east of National City Boule- vard, as DZ 3. • Designate the area east of Roosevelt Avenue, south of Civic Center Drive, north of 16'h Street, and west of alley, as DZ 12B. • Designate the area west of National City Boulevard, south of Civic Center Drive, north of 16`h Street, and east of alley, as DZ 12A. • Designate the civic uses east of National City Boulevard, south of 126 Street, north of 16`h Street, and west of D Avenue, as Institutional. 2-20 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION • Designate Kimball Park as Open Space. • Maximum Allowed Development. Replace Table 7 in Chapter IV, page 31 with the Land Use and Standards table in Section 5 of the adopted Na- tional City Downtown Specific Plan Consistency Review Application Requirement and Procedures. Specifically, the amendment would clarify language by revising "potential allowed development" to "maximum al- lowed development (as specified in the Land Use and Standards table)," and to correct associated calculation errors. • Non -Conforming Uses. Revise the Specific Plan text to add clarifying language addressing nonconforming uses. • Build -To Lines. Revise the Specific Plan to define build -to lines. • Minimum Development Intensity. Revise the Specific Plan to require a minimum development standard of 50% of the maximum allowed devel- opment. • Development Standards. Revise the Specific Plan to specify standards for features including but not limited to parking stall dimensions, court- yards, and outdoor spaces. • Exhibits. Revise the Specific Plan to accurately reflect development zone language. E. Amendments to the Local Coastal Program The Comprehensive Land Use Update includes revisions to the Local Coastal Program to maintain consistency between the General Plan and the existing Local Coastal Program. The Local Coastal Program is proposed to be amended to make the following revisions: For the Local Coastal Program area located west of Interstate 5: • Change the area designated Tourist Commercial located north of 24'h Street to Minor Mixed -Use Corridor (MXC-1), but not permitting resi- dential in that area. 2-21 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROIECI U E S C R I P ( I O N • Remove the Planned District overlay from the Tourist Commercial area within the Harbor Specific Plan. • Change the Tidelands Manufacturing zone to reflect the adopted Port Master Plan land uses. • Make minor changes to permitted land uses within the industrial zones. For the Local Coastal Program area located east of Interstate-5: • Rezone two parcels from Commercial Automotive (CA) and Heavy Commercial (CH) zones to Minor Mixed -Use Corridor (MXC-1). • Rename the Heavy Commercial (CH) zone to Service Commercial (CS). • Make minor changes to the permitted land uses and development stan- dards in the commercial automotive (CA), service commercial (CS), and light industrial (IL) zones. • Allow additional land uses a in the commercial automotive (CA) zone pursuant to a use permit. • Allow homeless shelters by right in the light industrial (IL) zone to com- ply with Senate Bill 2. F. Comprehensive Land Use Update Projected 2030 Buildout Projected buildout of the Comprehensive Land Use Update includes all pro- ject components described in Sections A through E and G of this chapter and Chapter 3, Project Description, Sections 1 and II of the Draft EIR. Based on the methodology described in Chapter 3.0, Section I.G of the EIR, the pro- jected 2030 buildout of the City includes the following (approximately): • 5,091 new dwelling units • 20,362 new residents • 2,642,494 square feet of new retail/office space • 3,179,109 square feet of new industrial space 2-22 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION The Planning Area is largely built out with little new land available for devel- opment. The new dwelling units and retail/office and industrial facilities would replace existing buildings. Areas of change would occur mainly in the mixed -use zones, including those identified in the Westside Specific Plan, Downtown Specific Plan, and Harbor Specific Plan areas as contained within the draft Land Use Element. Areas with increased densities above existing conditions may see substantial growth. Specifically, this can be attributed predominately to the change from single -use commercial to mixed -use with the addition of high density residential use. Existing and proposed single- family residential areas are unlikely to be affected. G. Development Proposals 1. Street Conversions/Community Corridors The City of National City proposes to modify portions of the circulation network to enhance the pedestrian environment and safety and increase rec- reational open space, consistent with the objectives for the Comprehensive Land Use Update. The proposed modifications include: 1) closing short se- lected street segments located throughout the city; 2) converting those street segments to pocket parks or future redevelopment areas; and 3) designating key roadways as community corridors. Construction is estimated to start six months following project approval in July 2011. Construction of the seven individual sites would be phased with construction commencing on three sites in the first two quarters and one site in the last quarter. The duration of con- struction would be approximately three months. Based on this schedule, con- stntction on the first phase would occur January -March 2012, construction on the second phase would occur April -June 2012, and construction on the third phase would occur July -September 2012. The proposed project includes seven (7) specific sites located within the City of National City as listed below: • Site 1: Hoover Avenue • Site 2: West Avenue 2-23 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DESCRIPTION • Site 3: Hoover Avenue south • Site 4: 12th Street • Site 5: F Avenue • Site 6: Kimball Way • Site 7: Q Avenue • Community Corridors. The Community Corridors component of the project proposes to establish street design standards intended to calm traf- fic and increase pedestrian safety. The street design standards are applied to arterials, collectors, and local streets and arc intended to increase the comfort of walking and/or bicycling on these roads through traffic calm- ing measures such as on -street parking, bulb -outs, or glorietas; strcetscape improvements such as landscaping, street trees, and medians; pedestrian enhancements such as wider sidewalks and street furniture; and bicycle improvements such as designated bicycle lanes and bike rack facilities. The proposed street typology is proposed to be applied to arterials, col- lectors, and local streets throughout the City including, but not limited to, portions of 4th Street, 8`h Street, Plaza Boulevard, Civic Center Drive, 15th Street, 16th Street, 18`h Street, 22"' Street, 30th Street, Wilson Avenue, Coolidge Avenue, Roosevelt Avenue, National City Boulevard, D Ave- nue, Highland Avenue, Newell Street, and Palm Avenue. 2. Senior Village Expansion The proposed Senior Village Expansion project is a 7.10-acre site, located southwest of Kimball Way, east of D Avenue, and north of the existing Sen- ior Village complex. The Senior Village Expansion project proposes to ex- pand the existing Senior Village multi -family residential complex to add a total of 200 senior residential units, comprised of 160 one -bedroom units (550 square feet) and 40 two -bedroom units (700 square feet). The new structures would low-rise (up to four stories) with a maximum height of 60 feet and a proposed density of 71 dwelling units to the acre. The proposed project also includes the relocation and new construction of the existing 10,000 square foot Senior Center structure and the construction of a 15,000-square-foot 2-24 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROIECT DESCRIPTION medical office structure. The proposed project proposes to revise the surface parking spaces to 200 and construct a new parking structure with 225 spaces for a net increase of 165 parking spaces. 3. Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan The proposed Las Palmas Park Vision and Concept Plan project is located at the site of the existing Las Palmas Park and National City Municipal Golf Course. The Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan project provides the framework and future design of a new park at the location of the existing Las Palmas Park and National City Municipal Golf Course. The Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan project proposes to replace the existing park and golf course with 65 acres of recreation uses, pub- lic gathering space, edible landscaping, family -oriented commercial, and natu- ral open spaces. Specifically the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Con- cept Plan project includes: + 1.5 acres of soccer field area. ♦ 12,000 square feet of expanded play ground. • 8,400 square feet of skate park. • 550 linear feet of new trails (5,500 square feet). • 0.62 acres of dog park/run. • 4 acres of community garden plots. ♦ 41.5 acres of passive open space including a lake/irrigation pond. • 162 additional parking spaces to serve the park recreational uses. • Interior improvements to community center and pool house. • 40,000 square feet of new commercial uses on 4.62 acres including 198 parking spaces to be located on the existing driving range in the south- western portion of the project site. • Construction activities are anticipated to include 21,700 cubic yards of cut for the proposed lake/irrigation pond and to grade for level ball 2-25 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROJECT DISCRIPTION fields, the balance of which would be retained on site; and 500 cubic yards for new parking area which would be retained on site. Construc- tion is anticipated to start January of 2013 and would occur for a dura- tion of five years. 4. Kimball Park Master Plan The proposed Kimball Park Master Plan project is located at the site of the existing Kimball Park, adjacent to the National City city hall and library. The Kimball Park Master Plan project provides the framework and future design to expand the existing Kimball Park. The Kimball Park Master Plan project proposes to expand the existing park with new parking areas, edible landscaping, and natural open spaces. Specifically the Kimball Park Master Plan project includes: • 39 new parking spaces (6,700 square feet). • Grading to allow for 0.85 acres of new community garden plots. Cut and fill associated with grading activities would be balanced on -site. • Recreational trail along Paradise Creek • Vegetation enhancements within Paradise Creek to improve natural habi- tat. • Connection to the street to park conversion. 5. El Toyon Park Master Plan The proposed El Toyon Park Master Plan project is located at the site of the existing El Toyon Park. The El Toyon Park Master Plan project provides the framework and future design to expand the existing El Toyon Park. The El Toyon Park Master Plan project proposes to expand the existing park with new active recreation, passive recreation, edible landscaping, irrigation, light- ing, and new community -oriented structures. Specifically the El Toyon Park Master Plan project includes: • 6,000 square feet of expanded playground. 2-26 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS PROIECT DESCRIPTION • 15,000 square feet joint use facility to include a 8,500-square-foot fire sta- tion and 5,500-square-foot community center. • 1.0 acre of community garden plots. • 1,985 linear feet of additional trails. • 0.38 acres of dog run. • 0.87 acres of additional picnic area. • Demolition of 8,200 square feet of existing structure to be replaced with proposed join use facility. • Removal of 19,200 square feet (475 cubic yards) of existing asphalt and subgrade to be maintained on -site. 111. REQUIRED APPROVALS Project approval will require the following actions by the City of National City: • Approval of the Comprehensive Land Use Update, including: • Approval of the General Plan Update • Approval of City Municipal Code Amendments including the Land Use Code Update (Title 18) • Approval of the Climate Action Plan • Approval of the Downtown Specific Plan Amendments • Approval of the Local Coastal Program Amendments • Approval of the Street Conversions/Community Corridors • Approval of the Senior Village Expansion • Approval of the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan • Approval of the Kimball Park Master Plan • Approval of the El Toyon Park Master Plan 2-27 3 FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS A. Overview The Final EIR identified several significant environmental effects that could directly result from the implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Up- date. Direct and cumulative significant unavoidable adverse impacts would occur in the following resource areas: ♦ Air Quality (Direct and Cumulative); ♦ Transportation and Circulation (Direct and Cumulative); and ♦ Utilities and Service Systems (Cumulative only). Direct significant impacts in the following resource areas have been reduced to less -than -significant levels through the implementation of feasible mitiga- tion measures: ♦ Biological Resources; ♦ Hazards and Hazardous Materials; ♦ Hydrology and Water Quality; ♦ Land Use; and ♦ Noise. Implementation of the project would have less -than -significant impacts or no impacts on the following resources (without mitigation): ♦ Aesthetics; ♦ Agricultural Resources; ♦ Cultural Resources; ♦ Geology, Soils, and Mineral Resources; ♦ Population and Housing; ♦ Public Services and Recreation; and ♦ Greenhouse Gas Emissions. These impacts are outweighed by overriding considerations, as set forth in Chapter S. 3-I CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT F NV'IRONMENTAI. FF FECTS B. Findings on Significant Environmental Effects These findings have been prepared for the adoption of the proposed project as described in the DEIR and modified in the Final EIR (including the City pro- posed mitigation measures). These modifications include revisions to the General Plan discussed in Response to Comments 3-5, 3-6, and 7-10, and revi- sions discussed in Final EIR Chapter 3. The proposed project as modified in the Final EIR is summarized in Chapter 2 of this document. Revisions have been made to incorporate mitigation measures into the Land Use Code with adoption of the Comprehensive Land Use Update as below noted in this document. No changes have been made to the Climate Action Plan or De- velopment Proposals since release of the DEIR. 1. Air Quality For a full discussion of air quality impacts and the goals, policies, implemen- tation measures, and "Regulatory Framework" incorporated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.3 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. Impact AQ-1: Buildout of land uses under the proposed Regulatory Changes (including the Senior Village Expansion, and Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan) would result in a higher growth rate of vehicle trips and assumed vehicle miles traveled than population growth in the SDAPCD Clean Air Plan. This would conflict with regional planning efforts to attain ambient air quality standards. Future updates to the RAQS/SIP would use SANDAG projections that include updated General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. Although clean air planning efforts (in terms of con- trol measures) can be adjusted to meet the plan objective and take into ac- count the effects of the General Plan and Land Use Code land use assump- tions, these projections are not included in the current RAQS/SIP. (See DEIR pages through 4.3-32 through 4.3-43, as modified in the Final EIR.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.3-32 through 3-2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS 4.3-43 and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation is feasible. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding No additional feasible mitigation is available for the air quality impacts that would conflict with regional planning efforts to attain ambient air quality standards. Clean air planning efforts can be adjusted to take into account the effects of the General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. How- ever, these projections are not included in the current RAQS/SIP. Future updates to the RAQS/SIP would use SANDAG projections that will include updated General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. Until the RAQS/SIP is updated, the project's impact on air quality would be significant and unavoidable. Impact AQ-2: Construction activity during buildout of the proposed Regu- latory Changes would generate exhaust and fugitive particulate matter emis- sions that would affect local and regional air quality. (See DEIR pages 4.3-43 through 4.3-54.) 3-3 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in the General Plan and DEIR pages and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15 and 4.3-34 through 4.3-41, as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following Mitigation measures into the project: Mitigation Measure AQ-2a: Dust Suppression. The following enhanced dust control measures shall be required by the City as part of the project entitle- ment process in order to control fugitive dust emissions during construction and shall be incorporated into Title 9, Health and Sanitation, of the Munici- pal Code. These measures are in addition to SDAPCD regulatory require- ments that are currently required for construction activity. • Limit traffic speeds on unpaved roads to 15 mph. • Install sandbags or other erosion control measures to prevent silt runoff to public roadways. • Replant vegetation in disturbed areas as quickly as possible. • Limit access to the construction sites, so tracking of mud or dirt on to public roadways can be prevented. If necessary, use wheel washers for all exiting trucks, or wash off the tires or tracks of all trucks and equipment leaving the site. • Suspend excavation and grading activity when winds (instantaneous gusts) exceed 20 mph or dust clouds cannot be prevented from extending beyond the site. Mitigation Measure AQ-2b: Exhaust Emission Controls. Projects that have significant construction period exhaust emissions shall reduce fleet average emission rates. Developers or contractors shall provide a plan for approval by the City or SDAPCD demonstrating that the heavy-duty (> 50 horse- power) off -road vehicles to be used in the construction project for more than an accumulated 40 hours, including owned, leased and subcontractor vehicles, 3-4 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIG NIFICANI ENVIRONMENTAL EF- F E C T S will achieve emission standards similar to in -use equipment that meets GARB certified Tier II standards. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding The Mitigation Measures AQ-2a and 26 are required for any construction activity and would reduce construction -related emissions related to Impact AQ-2 to less than significant. Additionally, mitigation may be required at the project level, but without having specific construction information (i.e. loca- tion, equipment, project design, etc), specific mitigation cannot be applied. For this reason, air quality impacts during construction would be less than significant with Mitigation Measures AQ-2a and 2b. Impact AQ-3: The higher intensity buildout of the Regulatory Changes would increase population and vehicle travel at a rate greater than anticipated in regional clean air planning efforts. This could conflict with regional efforts to reduce unhealthy ozone and particulate matter concentrations in the re- gion. Future updates to the RAQS/SIP would use SANDAG projections that include updated General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. Although dean air planning efforts (in terms of control measures) can be ad- 3-5 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS justed to meet the plan objective and take into account the effects of the Gen- eral Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions, these projections are not included in the current RAQS/SIP. (See DEIR pages 4.3-43 through 4.3-54.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.3-34 through 4.3-41 and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation is feasible. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations arc within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding No additional feasible mitigation is available for the air quality impacts that would conflict with regional planning efforts to attain ambient air quality standards. Clean air planning efforts can be adjusted to take into account the effects of the General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. How- ever, these projections are not included in the current RAQS/SIP. Future updates to the RAQS/SIP would use SANDAG projections that include up- dated General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. Until the 3-6 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENI AL EF FECTS RAQS/SIP is updated, the project's impact on air quality would be significant and unavoidable. Impact AQ-4: The project would also result in a cumulatively considerable contribution to a cumulative air quality impact. As described above, in Im- pacts AQ-1 through AQ-3, the Regulatory Changes and Development Pro- posals would result in a significant and unavoidable air quality impact. (See DEIR pages 4.3-54 through 4.3-55 Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.3-34 through 4.3-41 and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation is feasible. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding No additional feasible mitigation is available for the air quality impacts that would conflict with regional planning efforts to attain ambient air quality standards. Clean air planning efforts can be adjusted to take into account the 3-7 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS effects of the General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. How- ever, these projections are not included in the current RAQS/SIP. Future updates to the RAQS/SIP would use SANDAG projections that include up- dated General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. Until the RAQS/SIP is updated, the project's impact on air quality would be significant and unavoidable. Impact AQ-5: As described above, in Impacts AQ-1 and AQ-3, the Regula- tory Changes and Development Proposals would result in a cumulatively con- siderable contribution to a significant cumulative impact to regional air qual- ity. (See DEIR pages 4.3-59 through 4.3-61, as modified in the Final EIR.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.3-34 through 4.3-41 and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation is feasible. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. - (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. 3-8 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS Rationale for Finding No additional feasible mitigation is available for the cumulative air quality impacts that would conflict with regional planning efforts to attain ambient air quality standards. Clean air planning efforts can be adjusted to take into account the effects of the General Plan and Land Use Code land use assump- tions. However, these projections are not included in the current RAQS/SIP. Future updates to the RAQS/SIP would use SANDAG projections that in- clude updated General Plan and Land Use Code land use assumptions. Until the RAQS/SIP is updated, the project's cumulative impact on air quality would be significant and unavoidable. 2. Biological Resources For a full discussion of biological resources impacts and the goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" incorporated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.4 of the Cotnpre hensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR, including revised Policy OS-2.21 which includes provisions for working with the California Department of Fish and Game to establish appropriate plant palettes and up to 100 foot buffers for creek corridors, ca- nals and drainage ditches that support riparian resources. Impact 13I0-1: Up to 1.2 acres of Diegan Coastal Sage Scrub (DCSS), located within the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site, will be impacted as a result of site redevelopment. Because the DCSS area of the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site supports habitat that is theoretically suitable for the federally -listed California Gnatcatcher, it may be necessary to obtain "take" authorization from the USFWS if this species is present on the project site. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- I Revisions to Policy OS-2.2 were based upon policy considerations and are not relied upon to reduce or avoid a significant environmental impact. 3-9 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has revised the following miti- gation measure to increase the size of the construction buffer to 500 feet, and lengthen the period during which site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation would not be permitted and incorporated the revised measure into the project. (See Comment 3-6 and Response to Comment 3-6.) Mitigation Measure BIO-1: In order to reduce or avoid impacts to special status birds, and ensure project compliance with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3511, and 3513 of the California Fish and Game Code, site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation within 500 feet of any known migratory songbird nesting location will not be permitted during the spring/summer songbird breeding season, defined as from January 156 to August 31' of each year. Limiting activities to the non - breeding season will minimize chances for the incidental take of migratory California gnatcatcher. In order to determine presence/absence of California gnatcatchers, protocol surveys of suitable areas of habitat (DCSS) on -site are required. These must be completed by an approved biologist in possession of a Section 10(a) Recovery Permit for this species. Should it be necessary to conduct brushing, grading, or other habitat -removal activities during the songbird breeding season, a pre -construction nesting survey of all areas within 500 feet of the proposed activity will be required. If active nests are present on -site, the nests shall be monitored until the birds have fledged and left the nest, prior to the commencement of construction activities. The results of the pre -construction survey will be provided in a report to the City and the wildlife agencies for concurrence with the conclusions and recommendations. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such 3- I 0 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANI ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-1 would reduce impacts on DCSS, which provides habitat for special status birds, to a less -than -significant level by limiting site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation, within 500 feet of any known migratory songbird nesting location, in accor- dance with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3511, and 3513 of the California Fish and Game Code, and by requiring a protocol survey of DCSS for California gnatcatcher, and a pre -construction survey of DCSS for active bird nests on the project site. If active nests are found, they would be monitored until the birds have fledged, prior to com- mencement of construction activities. This Mitigation Measure would ensure potential impacts on DCSS would be less than significant. Impact BIO-2: Up to 1.2 acres of DCSS, located within the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site, will be impacted as a result of site redevelopment. These areas will be impacted by renovations to the Butterfly Garden and the expansion of the existing International Community Founda- tion Center (ICF) Garden. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the `Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final FIR. The City has revised the following miti- gation measure to increase the size of the construction buffer to 500 feet, and lengthen the period during which site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation would not be permitted and incorporated the revised measure into the project. (See Comment 3-6 and Response to Comment 3-6.) 3-II CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E E - FECTS Mitigation Measure BIO-2: Impacts to DCSS, located within the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site, shall require mitigation at a minimum 2:1 ratio. Therefore, impacts to 1.2 acres of DCSS will require 2.4 acres of mitigation. This mitigation could occur on -site, via habitat creation and restoration in the Butterfly Garden and/or other areas of the site. In or- der for on -site habitat creation and restoration to be acceptable as DCSS miti- gation, these activities would need to occur pursuant to a City and resource agencies (CDFG, USFWS) approved Revegetation Plan. The Revegetation Plan would be implemented by the City and would require a methodology for how to establish DCSS in that area. The Revegetation Plan would be re- quired to comply with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act. Site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation within 500 feet of any known mi- gratory songbird nesting location will not be permitted during the spring/summer songbird breeding season, defined as from January 15i° to August 31' of each year. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off —site, via the securement of 2.4 acre - credits of DCSS in an approved mitigation bank. If the DCSS is found to be occupied by California Gnatcatcher, a higher mitigation ratio would be re- quired. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, 3- 12 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-2 would reduce impacts on DCSS to a Tess -than -significant level by requiring mitigation at a minimum 2:1 ratio, either on- or off -site. For on -site mitigation, a City and resource agencies (CDFG, USFWS) approved Revegetation Plan would be required for the minimum 2.4 acres of mitigation. For off -site mitigation, a minimum 2.4 acres of mitigation credit would be required in an approved mitigation bank. A higher mitigation ratio would be required if the California gnatcatcher is found in the affected DCSS (see Mitigation Measure BIO-1, requiring proto- col surveys for California gnatcatcher). This Mitigation Measure would en- sure potential impacts on DCSS would be less than significant. Impact BIO-3: Up to 0.8-acre of Disturbed Freshwater Wetland (DFWW), located in the existing golf course in the center of the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site, will be impacted by creek restoration ac- tivities. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the 'Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure BIO-3: Impacts to the DFWW shall require mitigation at a minimum 3:1 ratio in the following manner: at least 1:1 shall consist of wet- lands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restora- tion/enhancement. For example, impacts to 0.8 acre of DFWW would re- quire 2.4 acres of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site, via habitat creation and restoration activities in the on - site drainage. It should be noted that if these habitat restoration activities would result in any significant impacts, these impacts would be required to be 3-13 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS analyzed and mitigated. Significant impacts associated with habitat restora- tion activities could include dredging in jurisdictional waters or wetlands, the removal of native vegetation, noise impacts to native wildlife during site preparation. In order for habitat restoration to be acceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Resource Agency - approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Such a plan would be implemented by the City and it would specify methodology for habitat creation and restora- tion. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the securement of 2.4 acre -credits of FWW in an approved mitigation bank. Regulatory Agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on - or offsite restoration, although on -site mitigation is encouraged. If on -site mitigation is not available, offsite mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-3 would reduce impacts on DFWW to a less -than -significant level by requiring mitigation at a minimum 3:1 ratio, either on -site, or off -site within the same drainage basin. Off -site mitigation may be provided by securing a minimum 2.4 acres of mitigation 3-14 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECT5 credit would be required in an approved mitigation bank. A City and re- source agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) approved Wetland Mitigation Plan would be required for the 2.4 acres of mitigation. This Mitigation Measure would ensure potential impacts on DFWW would be less than signifi- cant. Impact BIO-4: Up to 0.1-acre of NVC, located in the middle of the existing golf course on the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site, will be impacted by creek restoration activities. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure BIO-4: Impacts to wetlands habitats, such as Non - Vegetated Channel (NVC) located in the middle of the existing golf course on the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site, generally require mitigation at a 3:1 ratio. At least 1:1 of this typically must consist of wetlands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.1-acre of NVC would require 0.3-acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site, via habitat creation and restoration activities in the on -site drainage. In order for these activities to be acceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be sub- ject to a City and Resource Agency approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Al- ternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the securemcnt of 0.3 acre - credits of NVC in an approved mitigation bank. The Regulatory Agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on - or off -site restoration, although on -site mitigation is encouraged. If onsite mitigation is not available, offsite mitigation within the same drainage basin is requi red. Finding 3-15 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure B104 would reduce impacts on NVC to a less -than -significant level by requiring mitigation at a 3:1 ratio. The 0.3 acres of mitigation required, may be provided on -site, through habitat crea- tion or restoration activities, or off -site, within the same drainage basin. A City and resource agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) approved Wetland Mitigation Plan would be required. This Mitigation Measure would ensure potential impacts on NVC would be less than significant. Impact BIO-5: Up to 0.1 acre of Disturbed Southern Coastal Salt Marsh (DSCSM), within Paradise Creek in the southern portion of the Kimball Park Master Plan site, will be impacted as a result of creek improvements and grad- ing and construction of a trail along Paradise Creek. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: 3-16 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - F E C F S Mitigation Measure BIO-5: Impacts to DSCSM, within Paradise Creek in the southern portion of the Kimball Park Master Plan site, require mitigation at a minimum 3:1 ratio. At least 1:1 of this ratio shall consist of wetlands crea- tion; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.1-acre of DSCSM shall require 0.3-acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site, via the res- toration of Paradise Creek, including the daylighting of the portion of the creek that is currently underground. The project's current conceptual design shows approximately 3.9 acres as being available for Paradise Creek im- provements. In order for these improvements to he acceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Resource Agency - approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off - site, via the securement of 0.9 acre -credits of SCSM in an approved wetland mitigation bank. The Regulatory Agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) typi- cally allow applicants to propose either on- or offsite restoration, although on -site mitigation is encouraged. If on -site mitigation is not available, offsite mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations arc within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding 3-17 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICAN I ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-5 would reduce impacts on DSCSM to a less -than -significant level by requiring mitigation at a minimum 3:1 ratio. A minimum 1:1 of this ratio must consist of wetlands creation. Mitigation may be provided site, on- or off -site within the same drainage ba- sin, or off -site through securing credit in an approved mitigation bank. A City and resource agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) approved Wetland Mitigation Plan would be required for the 0.3 acres of mitigation. This Miti- gation Measure would ensure potential impacts on DSCSM would be less than significant. Impact BIO-6: Up to 0.3-acre of Disturbed Freshwater Wetland (DFWW), within Paradise Creek on the Kimball Park Master Plan site, will be impacted as a result of creek improvements and grading and construction of a trail along Paradise Creek. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure BIO-6: Impacts to wetlands habitats, such as DFWW lo- cated within Paradise Creek on the Kimball Park Master Plan site, require mitigation at a 3:1 ratio. At least 1:1 of this ratio shall consist of wetlands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.3-acre of DFWW shall require 0.9-acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site. The project site has approximately 3.9 acres available for Paradise Creek improvements. In order for these improvements to be acceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Resource Agency -approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the se- curement of 0.9 acre -credits of FWW in an approved wetland mitigation bank. The Regulatory Agencies (USAGE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on- or off -site restoration, although on -site miti- 3-I8 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS gation is encouraged. If on -site mitigation is not available, off -site mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-6 would reduce impacts on DFWW to a less -than -significant level by requiring mitigation at a minimum 3:1 ratio. A minimum 1:1 of this ratio must consist of wetlands creation. Mitigation may be provided site, on- or off -site within the same drainage ba- sin, or off -site through securing credit in an approved mitigation bank. A City and resource agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) approved Wetland Mitigation Plan would be required for the 0.9 acres of mitigation. This Miti- gation Measure would ensure potential impacts on DFWW would be less than significant. Impact BIO.7: The Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan will impact jurisdictional wetlands and waters through the grading and landscap- ing of DFWW and NVC located within the existing golf course. Mitigation 3-19 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure BIO-7: Because the proposed Las Palmas Park and Facili- ties Vision Concept Plan project will impact state wetlands and State and fed- eral "waters," it may be necessary to obtain certain regulatory agency permits as a condition of project approval. To that end, it is required that the appli- cant provide to the City proof of notification of the ACOE and CRWQCB regarding Clean Water Act Section 404/401 Permits, or evidence that such notification is not required. Also required prior to project approval shall be proof provided to the City that the applicant has obtained a 1600-series Streambed Alteration Agreement with the CDFG, or proof that such an agreement is not required. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including 'provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-7 would reduce impacts to fed- eral and state jurisdictional wetlands and waters (i.e., DFWW and NVC) to a 3-20 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS RFGARDING S I G N I F I C A N 1 ENVIRONMENTAL E F• FECTS less -than -significant level by requiring that the applicant provide to the City proof of notification of the ACOE and CRWQCB regarding Clean Water Act Section 404/401 Permits, or evidence that such notification is not re- quired. Also required prior to project approval shall be proof provided to the City that the applicant has obtained a 1600-series Streambed Alteration Agreement with the CDFG, or proof that such an agreement is not required. This Mitigation Measure would ensure potential impacts on DFWW and NVC would be less than significant. Impact BIO-8: The Kimball Park Master Plan will impact jurisdictional wet- lands and waters through grading and bank improvements of DFWW and DSCSM along Paradise Creek, in the southeastern portion of the site. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.4.1 through 4.4- 8, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has revised the following miti- gation measure to increase the size of the construction buffer to 500 feet, and lengthen the period during which site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation would not be permitted and incorporated the revised measure into the project. See Comment 3-6 and Response to Comment 3-6. Mitigation Measure BIO-8: Mitigation for wetland impacts associated with improvements to Kimball Park will require a 1:1 ratio of wetlands creation and 2:1 ratio of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.3 acre of DFWW would require 0.9 acre of mitigation and impacts to 0.1 acre of DSCSM would require 0.3 acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur onsite, via the restoration of Paradise Creek or offsite through contribution to an approved mitigation bank. Because the proposed Kimball Park Master Plan project will impact State wet- lands and State and federal "waters," it will likely be necessary to obtain cer- tain regulatory agency permits as a condition of project implementation. To that end, it is required that the applicant provide to the City proof of notifi- 3-21 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAI EF- FECTS cation of the ACOE and CRWQCB regarding Clean Water Act Section 404/401 Permits, or evidence that such notification is not required. Also re- quired prior to project approval shall be proof provided to the City that the applicant has obtained a 1600-series Streambed Alteration Agreement with the CDFG, or proof that such an agreement is not required. (b) In order to reduce or avoid impacts to special status birds, and ensure pro- ject compliance with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3511, and 3513 of the California Fish and Game Code, site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation within 500 feet of any known migratory songbird nesting location will not be permitted during the spring/summer song bird breeding season, defined as from January 15th to August 31" of each year. Limiting activities to the non -breeding season will minimize chances for the incidental take of migratory songbirds. Should it be necessary to conduct brushing, grading, or other habitat -removal activities during the songbird breeding season, a pre -construction nesting sur- vey of all areas within 500 feet of the proposed activity will be required. If active nests are present on -site, the nests shall be monitored until the birds have fledged and left the nest, prior to the commencement of construction activities. The results of the pre -construction survey will be provided in a report to the City and the wildlife agencies for concurrence with the conclu- sions and recommendations. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. 3-22 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure BIO-8 would reduce impacts on DFWW and DSCSM to a less -than -significant level by requiring a 1:1 ratio of wetlands creation and 2:1 ratio of wetlands restoration/enhancement. The applicant will be required to provide to the City proof of notification of the ACOE and CRWQCB regarding Clean Water Act Section 404/401 Permits, or evidence that such notification is not required. Also required prior to pro- ject approval shall be proof provided to the City that the applicant has ob- tained a 1600-scries Strcambed Alteration Agreement with the CDFG, or proof that such an agreement is not required. Impacts to special status birds would be avoided or reduced by limiting construction activities such as sire brushing, grading, or vegetation -removal activities to non -breeding seasons, or, if it is necessary to conduct such activities during breeding season, by re- quiring pre -construction nesting surveys which would be provided to the City and wildlife agencies for concurrence. Active nests, if found, would be monitored until birds have fledged, prior to commencement of construction activities. This Mitigation Measure would ensure potential impact on DFWW and DSCSM would be less than significant. 3. Hazards and Hazardous Materials For a full discussion of hazards and hazardous materials impacts, and the goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" incorporated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.7 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. Impact HAZ-1: There are a number of sites in National City that arc in- cluded on a list of hazardous material sites compiled pursuant to Government Code Section 65962.5 (Appendix E) or that need further investigation. Sev- 3-23 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - F E C T S eral of the sites have reported releases to the ground, resulting in soil and groundwater contamination, and are subject to various State and federal laws and regulators, including the CERCLA, US EPA, DTSC, and RWQCB. Re- development of sites with existing soil or groundwater contamination could potentially pose a significant hazard to the public or the environment through releases of hazardous materials into the environment. Although the risk of significant hazard to the public or the environment from redevelop- ment of sites with existing soil or groundwater contamination can be reduced by General Plan policies, it cannot be completely eliminated. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.7.1 through 4.7- 7, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure HAZ-1: Implementation of a new General Plan Policy S-8.4 would require proposed development to determine the applicability of preparing a Hazardous Materials Management Plan (HMMP), stormwater pollution prevention plan (SWPPP), Standard Urban Storm Water Mitigation Plan, (SUSWMP), Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Program (JURMP), stormwater Best Management Practices, and additional site -specific assessment including research, file reviews, and or Phase I Environmental Assessments. General Plan Policy S-8.4, as stated above, has been drafted for adoption by the City Council as part of the proposed Comprehensive Land Use Update project. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. 3-24 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Implementation of Mitigation Measure I-IAZ-1 would reduce impacts related to hazards and hazardous materials by implementing new General Plan Pol- icy S-8.4. This policy would require proposed development to determine the applicability of preparing a Hazardous Materials Management Plan (HMMP), stormwater pollution prevention plan (SWPPP), Standard Urban Storm Wa- ter Mitigation Plan, (SUSWMP), Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Program (JURMP), stormwater Best Management Practices, and additional site -specific assessment including research, file reviews, and or Phase I Envi- ronmental Assessments. Therefore, implementation of Mitigation Measure HAZ-1 would ensure Impact I IAZ-1 is less than significant. 4. Hydrology and Water Quality For a full discussion of hydrology and water quality impacts and the goals, policies, implementation measures, and "Regulatory Framework" incorpo- rated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.8 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. Impact IIYDRO-1: Buildout under the Regulatory Changes could poten- tially result in stormwater volume in excess of storm drainage system capac- ity. (See DEIR pages 4.8-66 through 4.8-72, as modified in the Final EIR.) Mitigation 3-25 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR Table 4.8-6 and DEIR pages 4.8-1 through 4.8-13, as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measures into the project: Mitigation Measure HYDRO-1: National City shall incorporate into its Gen- eral Plan a policy to regularly assess the adequacy of its storm sewer system to accommodate 100-year storm flows and develop and implement a prioritized plan to address identified capacity deficiencies to the maximum extent possi- ble (MEP). General Plan Policy CS-5.3 is drafted for adoption by the City Council as part of the Comprehensive Land Use Update as follows: • The City shall regularly assess the adequacy of its storm sewer sys- tem to accommodate 100-year storm flows and develop and imple- ment a prioritized plan to address identified capacity deficiencies to the maximum extent possible (MEP). Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding 3-26 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS Mitigation Measure HYDRO-1 would reduce impacts related to storm drain- age system capacity through a General Plan policy to regularly assess the ade- quacy of its storm sewer system to accommodate 100-year storm flows and develop and implement a prioritized plan to address identified capacity defi- ciencies to the MEP. Therefore, implementation of Mitigation Measure HYDRO-1 would ensure Impact HYDRO-1 is less than significant. Impact HYDRO-2: As it is not possible to determine whether implementa- tion of stormwater management practices would be adequate to accommodate 100-year storm flows on the Senior Village Expansion project site, the place- ment of occupied development within a Special Flood I-Iazard Area could raise the base flood elevation or redirect flood flows, resulting in flooding and damage either on- or off -site under project and cumulative conditions. The Senior Village expansion would also expose people or structures to a signifi- cant risk of loss, injury or death involving flooding, including flooding as a result of the failure of a levee or dam. (See DEIR pages 4.8-66 through 4.8-72, and 4.8-81 through 4.8-86, and 4.8-94, as modified in the Final EIR.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR Table 4.8-6 and DEIR pages 4.8-1 through 4.8-13, as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measures into the Senior Village Ex- pansion project: Mitigation Measure HYDRO-2a: National City shall undertake a detailed hydrological study to assess the effects of proposed development on base flood elevations on the project site and in the surrounding area and to identify a range of measures sufficient to accommodate 100-year flood flows on site. Measures to accommodate flood flows could include creek modification and stormwater management BMPs such as bio-swales, retention ponds, and rain gardens. 3-27 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING S IGN I F I CAN I ENVIRONMFNTAI EF- FECTS Mitigation Measure HYDRO-2b: National City shall incorporate feasible measures identified in the detailed hydrological study into the final project site design so as to ensure that, at a minimum, base flood elevation would not rise either on- or off -site. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measures HYDRO-2a and HYRDO-2b would reduce impacts related to potential flooding as a result of the Senior Village Expansion by requiring a detailed hydrological study to assess the effects of proposed devel- opment on base flood elevations on the project site and in the surrounding area and to identify a range of measures sufficient to accommodate 100-year flood flows on site. Feasible measures identified in the detailed hydrological study would be included in the final project site design to ensure that, at a minimum, base flood elevation would not rise either on- or off -site. There- fore, implementation of Mitigation Measures HYDRO-2a and HYDRO-2b would ensure Impact I IYDRO-2 is less than significant. Impact HYDRO-3: The placement of commercial structures proposed as part of the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan within a Spe- 3-28 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS cial Flood Hazard Area could raise the base flood elevation or redirect flood flows, resulting in flooding and damage either on- or off -site under project and cumulative conditions. The Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Con- cept Plan would also expose people or structures to a significant risk of loss, injury or death involving flooding, including flooding as a result of the failure of a levee or dam under project and cumulative conditions. (See DEIR pages 4.8-66 through 4.8-72, 4.8-81 through 4.8-86. and 4.8-94 through 4.8-95, as modified in the Final EIR.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the `Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR Table 4.8-6 and DEIR pages 4.8-1 through 4.8-13, as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measures into the Las Palmas park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan project: Mitigation Measure HYDRO-3a: National City shall undertake a detailed hydrological study to assess the effects of proposed development on base flood elevations on the project site and in the surrounding area and to identify a range of measures sufficient to accommodate 100-year flood flows on site. Measures to accommodate flood flows could include creek modification and stormwater management BMPS such as bio-swales, retention ponds, and rain gardens. Mitigation Measure HYDRO-3b: National City shall incorporate feasible measures identified in the detailed hydrological study into the final project site design so as to ensure that, at a minimum, base flood elevation would not rise either on- or off -site. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. 3-29 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS RFGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMFNTAL EF- FECTS ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final FIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measure HYDRO-3a and HYDRO-3b would reduce impacts re- lated to potential flooding as a result of the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan by requiring a detailed hydrological study to assess the effects of proposed development on base flood elevations on the project site and in the surrounding area and to identify a range of measures sufficient to accommodate 100-year flood flows on site. Feasible measures identified in the detailed hydrological study would be included in the final project site design to ensure that, at a minimum, base flood elevation would not rise either on - or off -site. Therefore, implementation of Mitigation Measures HYDRO-3a and HYDRO-3b would ensure Impact HYDRO-3 is less than significant. 5. Land Use For a full discussion of land use impacts and the goals, policies, implementa- tion measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" incorporated into the pro- ject to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.9 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. Impact LU-1: Potential impacts associated with conflicts with adopted habi- tat conservation or natural community conservation plan could occur as a result of the Regulatory Changes and Development Proposals. Mitigation 3-30 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the `Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.9.1 through 4.9- 7, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the fol- lowing mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure LU-1: The inclusion of policies to the General Plan re- lated to development review would reduce impacts associated with conflicts with the MSCP in the vicinity of the Planning area. The addition of Policy OS-2.7 would ensure that potential impacts to biological resources are care- fully evaluated prior to approval of development projects. The addition of Policy OS-2.8 would ensure that development is consistent with all federal, State and regional regulations for habitat and species protection. General Plan Policy OS-2.7 and OS-2.8 as stated in the Draft General Plan are as follows: • OS-2.7: Ensure that potential impacts to biological resources are carefully evaluated prior to approval of development projects. ♦ OS-2.8: Ensure that development is consistent with all fed- eral, State and regional regulations for habitat and species protection. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, 3-31 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF FECTS make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measure LU-1 would reduce impacts associated with conflicts with an adopted habitat conservation or natural community conservation plan through the inclusion of General Plan Policies OS-2.7 and 2.8. These policies would ensure that potential impacts to biological resources are carefully evaluated prior to approval of development projects and that development is consistent with all federal, State and regional regulations for habitat and spe- cies protection. Therefore, implementation of Mitigation Measure LU-1 would ensure Impact LU-1 is less than significant. 6. Noise For a full discussion of noise impacts and the goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" incorporated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.10 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. Impact NOI-1: Construction noise could adversely affect sensitive receptors adjacent to the Senior Village Expansion project, components of the Las Pal- mas Park Facilities Concept Plan, Kimball Park Master Plan, and El Toyon Park Master Plan. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.10-8 through 4.10-15, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure NOI-1: Implement Construction Noise Reduction Measures. Title 12 of the Municipal Code shall be amended to include the following standard construction noise reduction measures. 3-32 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS • Equipment Sound Attenuation. All noise -producing construction equipment and vehicles using internal combustion engines shall be equipped with mufflers, air -inlet silencers where appropriate, and any other shrouds, shields, or other noise -reducing features in good operating condition that meet or exceed original factory specification. Mobile or fixed "package" equipment (e.g. arc welders, air compressors) shall be equipped with shrouds and noise control features that are readily avail- able for that type of equipment. • Use of Electrical Equipment. Electrically powered equipment shall be used instead of pneumatic or internal combustion powered equipment, where feasible. • Distance from Sensitive Receptors. Material stockpiles and mobile equipment staging, parking, and maintenance areas shall be located as far as practicable from noise -sensitive receptors. • Construction Traffic Speeds. Construction site and access road speed limits shall be established and enforced during the construction period. • Use of Noise -Producing Signals. The use of noise producing signals, including horns, whistles, alarms, and bells, shall be for safety warning purposes only. • Use of Public Address or Music Systems. No project -related public ad- dress or music system shall be audible at any adjacent sensitive receptor. • Noise Complaint Process. The on -site construction supervisor shall have the responsibility and authority to receive and resolve noise com- plaints. A clear appeal process to the owner shall be established prior to construction commencement that will allow for resolution of noise prob- lems that cannot be immediately solved by the site supervisor. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. 3-33 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measure NOI-1 would reduce potential construction noise impacts on sensitive receptors adjacent to the Senior Village Expansion project, com- ponents of the Las Palmas Park Facilities Concept Plan, Kimball Park Master Plan, and El Toyon Park Master Plan, through implementation of standard construction noise reduction measures. Title 12 of the Municipal Code will be amended to include these measures. Therefore, implementation of Mitiga- tion Measure NOI-1 would ensure Impact NOI-1 is less than significant. Impact NOI-2: The proposed Regulatory Changes could result in the con- struction of sensitive land uses where known vibration sources already exist and ground vibration from conventional railroad trains or light rail trains passing through the Planning Area could exceed the guidelines set forth by the FTA if new buildings housing sensitive uses were constructed within ap- proximately 100 feet of the tracks. Because vibration impacts from railroads are based on site -specific characteristics, it can not be determined whether future development under the Regulatory Changes would result in significant impacts. Each site would need to be evaluated for geotechnical conditions and whether or not a potential for groundborne vibration is likely to occur. If potential for groundborne vibration is found, mitigation measures would be required. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.10-8 through 3-34 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS 4.10-15, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measure into the project: Mitigation Measure NOI-2: Implementation of new General Plan Policy NN- 1.10 would require a study to demonstrate that ground borne vibration issues associated with rail operations are adequately addressed for new development within 100 feet from the centerline of the railroad tracks. General Plan Policy NN-1.10 as stated in the Draft General Plan is as follows: • NN-1.10: Require a study to demonstrate that ground borne vibration issues associated with rail operations are ade- quately addressed for new development within 100 feet from the centerline of the railroad tracks. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measure NOI-2 would reduce potential impacts on sensitive land uses associated with ground vibration from conventional railroad trains or light rail trains through implementation of new General Plan Policy NN- 1.10. This policy would call for a study to demonstrate that ground borne 3-35 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS vibration issues associated with rail operations are adequately addressed for new development within 100 feet from the centerline of the railroad tracks. Therefore, implementation of Mitigation Measure NOI-2 would ensure Im- pact NOI-2 is less than significant. Impact NOI-3: Because vibration impacts are based on site -specific charac- teristics, it can not be determined whether future construction under the Regulatory Changes would result in significant impacts. Each site would need to be evaluated for geotechnical conditions and whether or not a poten- tial for groundborne vibration is likely to occur. If potential for groundborne vibration is found, mitigation measures would be required. Therefore, im- pacts related to groundborne vibration from construction under the Regula- tory Changes would be significant before mitigation. Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, described in DEIR Section 4.10 and the `Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.10-8 through 4.10-15, and as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measure into the project. Mitigation Measure NOI-3: Detailed "Crack Survey." Prior to approval of final site design, any project proponent that would propose driving pilings or performing an action that could cause substantial vibrations shall perform a detailed "crack survey" before the startup of construction activities. If pile driving would be the source of these vibrations, pre foundation pile holes should be pre -drilled to the extent feasible to minimize the number of ham- mer strikes required to seat the pile. The survey may be done by photo- graphs, videotape, or visual inventory, and should include inside as well as outside locations. All existing cracks and walls, floors, driveways, etc., should be documented with sufficient detail for comparison after construction to determine whether actual vibration damage has occurred. If damage is found, the project application would be required to compensate for such damages. Finding 3-36 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations arc within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measure NOI-3 would reduce potential impacts related to ground - borne vibration from construction by requiring.a detailed `crack survey" for any project proposing an action that could cause substantial vibrations. The survey would be required prior to approval of final site design and before the startup of construction activities. If damage is found, the project applicant would he required to compensate for such damages. Therefore, implementa- tion of Mitigation Measure NOI-3 would ensure Impact NOI-3 is less than significant. 7. Transportation and Circulation For a full discussion of transportation and circulation impacts and the goals, policies, implementation measures, and "Regulatory Framework" incorpo- rated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.13 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. Impact TRANS -I: The standard established for Planning Area roadway level of service is LOS D; however, modifications to the Planning Area road- way network proposed in the Regulatory Changes and the development pro- 3-3/ CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS posals are projected to result in LOS E or F on 34 roadway segments in 2030 under buildout conditions. The impacted roadway segments and projected 2030 level of service are listed in Table 4.13-7 of the Draft EIR. This includes the following roadway segments: (1) Wilson Avenue, between Civic Center Drive and 18th Street, (2) Wilson Avenue, between 18th Street and 22nd Street, (3) Wilson Avenue, between 22nd Street and Mile of Cars Way, (4) Hoover Avenue, between 8th Street and 18th Street, (5) Roosevelt Avenue, between Division Street and 4th Street, (6) Roosevelt Avenue, between 4th Street and 8th Street, (7) Roosevelt Avenue, between 8th Street and Plaza Boulevard, (8) D Avenue, between Plaza Boulevard and 16th Street, (9) Palm Avenue, between Division Street and 4th Street, (10) Palm Avenue, between 4th Street and 8th Street, (11) Palm Avenue, between 8th Street and Plaza Boulevard, (12) Palm Avenue, between Plaza Boulevard and 16th Street, (13) Division Street, between D Avenue and Highland Avenue, (14) 4th Street, between National City Boulevard and D Avenue, (15) 4th Street, between Palm Avenue and Euclid Avenue, (16) 4th Street, between Euclid Avenue and Harbison Avenue, (17) 8th Street, between National City Boulevard and D Avenue, (18) Plaza Boulevard, between Coolidge Avenue and Hoover Ave- nue, (19) Civic Center Drive, between Harbor Drive and Wilson Avenue, (20) Civic Center Drive, between Wilson Avenue and National City Boulevard, (21) 16th Street, between Wilson Avenue and National City Boulevard, (22) 16th Street, between L Avenue and Palm Avenue, (23) 16th Street, between Palm Avenue and Euclid Avenue, (24) 16th Street, between Euclid Avenue and Harbison Avenue, (25) 18th Street, between Wilson Avenue and National City Boulevard, (26) 18th Street, between National City Boulevard and D Avenue, (27) 18th Street, between D Avenue and Highland Avenue, (28) 18th Street, between Highland Avenue and L Avenue, (29) 18th Street, between L Avenue and Palm Avenue, (30) 18th Street, between Palm Avenue and New- ell Street, (31) 18th Street, between Newell Street and Euclid Avenue, (32) 18th Street, between Euclid Avenue and Rachael Avenue, (33) 22nd Street, between Wilson Avenue and Hoover Avenue, (34) 22nd Street, between Iloover Avenue and National City Boulevard. (See DEIR pages 4.13-46 through 4.13-69, as modified in the Final EIR.) 3-38 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS INDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR Table 4.13-12, and 4.13- 6 through 4.3-10, and pages 4.13-46 through 4.13-69, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation is feasible. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding 3-39 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS No feasible mitigation is available for the 34 roadway segments projected to result in LOS E or F in 2030 under buildout conditions. Mitigation Measures are considered infeasible for these roadway segments because they would be inconsistent with the project objectives, they would be inconsistent with the City's policies in the General Plan of promoting alternate modes of transit, and they would result in additional environmental impacts to other modes of transit as well as impacts associated with construction. As discussed on DEIR page 4.13-67, the City evaluated potential mitigation measures for these roadway segments as detailed in Table 4.13-7 and determined they would be infeasible. 24 out of the 34 significantly impacted roadway segments have been designated Community Corridors. As described above and in the project description, the Community Corridors are intended to increase walking and bicycling through traffic calming measures, pedestrian enhancements, and bicycle improvements. Potential mitigation measures would require the re- moval of these improvements, which would not accomplish the project objec- tives, nor the General Plan policies associated with promoting alternate mod- es of transportation, and would result in impacts to these other non -vehicular modes of transit. Such potential mitigation measures would be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4t 957) For these reasons, mitigation at these intersections is considered infeasible. 3-40 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS The remaining 10 roadway segments are currently built to the limits of the existing Right -Of -Way. To widen these roadways further, sidewalks would need to be removed or reduced in width, which would result in impacts to non -vehicular modes of transit (pedestrians and bicyclists). Recent revisions in planning and environmental law recognize the importance of planning for multiple modes of transportation, which provide for the needs of all users (including pedestrians, bicyclists, mass transit riders, and motorists (See AB 1358 [2008]; SB 375 [2008].). As such, these mitigation measures are also con- sidered infeasible due to policy considerations. Another option for roadway widening would involve the expansion of current Right -Of -Way through ad- ditional property acquisition. Property acquisitions, however, are considered environmentally, financially, and socially infeasible. Property acquisition would require demolition of existing buildings which would generate addi- tional environmental impacts associated with air quality, noise, GIIGs, solid waste, and traffic as well as continuing to promote vehicular use. Further- more, widening of these roadway segments would also create a less pedestrian oriented environment and would thus create additional impacts to this alter- native mode of transportation. Such potential mitigation measures would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4`h 957) For these rea- sons, mitigation measures at these intersections are considered infeasible." Therefore, Impact TRANS-1 would he significant and unavoidable. Impact TRANS-2: By 2030, foreseeable growth in the San Diego region could result in substandard LOS on two roadway segments in jurisdictions adjacent to the Planning Area. Sweetwater Road from Plaza Bonita Center Way to Willow Street in San Diego County is projected to operate at LOS F, while LOS on Broadway from State Route 54 to E Street in Chula Vista is projected to be substandard. Growth in the Planning Area would generate traffic volume which could contribute to the deterioration in the perform- ance of these roadway segments. (Sec DEIR pages 4.13-46 through 4.13-69.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR Table 4.13-12, and 4.13- 1-41 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS 6 through 4.3-10, and pages 4.13-46 through 4.13-69, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation required. As part of the County of San Diego's Draft General Plan, Sweetwater Road between National City city limits (Plaza Bonita Center Way) and Willow Street has been identified as a roadway segment where LOS E or F is acceptable, since adding travel lanes would result in adverse environmental impacts. As part of ongoing multi -jurisdictional programs such as Regional Arterial Management System (RAMS) and Traffic Light Synchronization Program (TSLP), the cities of National City and Chula Vista and Caltrans will con- tinue to implement coordinated traffic signal timing along the National City Boulevard/Broadway Avenue corridor to improve traffic flow and progres- sion. These implementation measures will ensure that impacts associated with increased congestion levels are less than significant. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. (X) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdic- tion of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding No mitigation is required for Impact TRANS-2. The County of San Diego's Draft General Plan has identified Sweetwater Road between National City city limits (Plaza Bonita Center Way) and Willow Street as a roadway seg- 3-42 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS ment where LOS E or F is acceptable, since adding travel lanes would result in adverse environmental impacts. In addition, ongoing multi -jurisdictional programs such as Regional Arterial Management System (RAMS) and Traffic Light Synchronization Program (TSLP) will continue to implement coordi- nated traffic signal timing to improve traffic flow and progression. These implementation measures will ensure that Impact TRANS-2 is less than sig- nificant. Impact TRANS-3: Even with implementation of RTP improvement actions and National City General Plan Policies, the addition of traffic expected from buildout of the Comprehensive Land Use Update, the Senior Village Expan- sion, the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan, the El Toyon Park Master Plan, and other reasonably foreseeable projects in San Diego County would cause six freeway segments on I-5 and one segment on 1-805 that currently operate at acceptable LOS D or better to drop to unacceptable LOS E or F in 2030. These impacts are considered significant. Additionally, with the addition of traffic expected from implementation of the Compre- hensive Land Use Update and other reasonably foreseeable projects in San Diego County, the volume to capacity ratio on one freeway segment on 1-5, five segments on I-805, and four segments on SR-54 that currently operate at unacceptable LOS E or F would increase by more than 0.01 in 2030. The contribution of traffic associated with buildout of the Comprehensive Land Use Update to these impacts is considered significant. (See DEIR pages 4.13- 69 through 4.13-78.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the `Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR Table 4.13-12, and 4.13- 6 through 4.3-10, and pages 4.13-69 through 4.13-78, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional feasible mitigation is available. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: 3-43 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. (X) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdic- tion of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding No feasible mitigation is available for the six freeway segments on I-5 and one segment on I-805 that are projected to drop to unacceptable LOS E or F in 2030. Nor is there feasible mitigation for the one freeway segment on I-5, five segments on I-805, and four segments on SR-54 that currently operate at un- acceptable LOS E or F and are projected to increase volume to capacity ratio by more than 0.01 in 2030. The SANDAG 2050 RTP is the forum for di- rectly addressing impacts to CMP roadway performance in San Diego County. This planning initiative is ongoing, and it is anticipated that the Draft 2050 RTP described above, including further improvements to the CMP roadway network, will be adopted by the SANDAG Board of Direc- tors in 2011. However, at this time there is no feasible plan to address im- pacts to the 16 CMP roadway segments listed in Table 4.13-11. Therefore, Impact TRANS-3 would be significant and unavoidable. 8. Utilities and Service Systems For a full discussion of utilities and service systems impacts and the goals, policies, implementation measures, and "Regulatory Framework" incorpo- rated into the project to avoid and lessen impacts, see Chapter 4.14 of the Comprehensive Land Use Update Draft EIR and any revisions contained in Chapter 3 of the Final EIR. 3-44 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANE F N V I R O N M E N I A L EF- FECTS Impact UTILS-1: There is currently no feasible plan to expand landfill ca- pacity to meet the projected needs of San Diego County beyond 2016. As implementation of the Regulatory Changes, the Senior Village Expansion Project, the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan, and the El Toyon Park Master Plan would generate additional solid waste requiring dis- posal in landfill after 2016 and compounding existing landfill constraints, the Regulatory Changes, the Senior Village Expansion Project, the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan, and the El Toyon Park Master Plan would all contribute to a significant cumulative impact. (See DEIR pages 4.14-53 through 4.14-60.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described on DEIR pages 4.14-36 through 4.14-40, 4.14-45 through 4.14-46, as modified in the Final EIR. No additional mitigation is feasible. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. (X) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdic- tion of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding 3-45 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF FECTS No feasible mitigation is available for Impact UTILS-1 because there is cur- rently no feasible plan to expand landfill capacity to meet the projected needs of San Diego County beyond 2016. Since implementation of the Compre- hensive Land Use Update would generate additional solid waste requiring disposal in landfill after 2016, Impact UTILS-1 would be a significant and un- avoidable cumulative impact. Impact UTILS-2: Development and redevelopment under the Regulatory Changes, the Senior Village Expansion Project, the Las Palmas Park and Fa- cilities Vision Concept Plan, and the El Toyon Park Master Plan would result in the generation of more wastewater than accounted for in the 2010 SSMP, and consequently existing and projected capacity deficiencies in the sewer system could potentially be exacerbated with implementation of the Regula- tory Changes (See DEIR pages 4.14-75 through 4.14-80, as modified in the Final EIR.) Mitigation The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, implementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described on DEIR pages 4.14-60 through 4.14-63, 4.14-70, as modified in the Final EIR. The City has also incorporated the following mitigation measures into the project: Mitigation Measure UI'ILS-2: The City of National City should conduct hydraulic modeling analysis to assess the impacts of the additional wastewater that would be generated with implementation of the Regulatory Changes and revise or re -prioritize the Recommended Capital Improvement Program con- tained in the SSMP as necessary in order to ensure that the City's wastewater collection system would have sufficient capacity to accommodate growth in the planning area, including the Development Proposals, through 2030. General Plan Policy CS-5.4 is drafted for adoption by the City Council as part of the Comprehensive Land Use Update as follows: ♦ The City shall conduct hydraulic modeling analysis to assess the im- pacts of the additional wastewater that would be generated with im- 3-46 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT FNVIRONMENIA L EF- FECTS plementation of the Regulatory Changes and revise or re -prioritize the Recommended Capital Improvement Program contained in the SSMP as necessary in order to ensure that the City's wastewater col- lection system would have sufficient capacity to accommodate growth in the planning area, including the Development Proposals, through 2030. Finding The City Council of the City of National City hereby finds that: (X) Changes or alterations have been required in, or incorporated into, the project to avoid or substantially lessen the significant environmental effect as identified in the Final EIR. ( ) Such changes or alterations are within the responsibility and jurisdiction of another public agency and not the agency making the finding. Such changes have been adopted by such other agency or can and should be adopted by such other agency. ( ) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives identified in the Final EIR. Rationale for Finding Mitigation Measure UTILS-2 would reduce potential impacts associated with wastewater capacity deficiencies by requiring the City of National City to conduct hydraulic modeling analysis. The City would assess the impacts of the additional wastewater that would be generated with implementation of the Regulatory Changes and revise or re -prioritize the Recommended Capital Improvement Program contained in the SSMP as necessary in order to ensure that the City's wastewater collection system would have sufficient capacity to accommodate growth in the planning area, including the Development Pro- posals, through 2030. Therefore, Mitigation Measure UI'ILS-2 will ensure that Impact UTILS-2 is less than significant. 3-47 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENIAL E F- FECTS C. Findings on Less Than Significant Effects The City finds that impacts to the following resources would be less than significant prior to mitigation for the reasons discussed in the DEIR and the FEIR: • Aesthetics; • Agricultural Resources; • Cultural Resources; ♦ Geology, Soils, and Mineral Resources; ♦ Population and Housing; ♦ Public Services and Recreation; and • Greenhouse Gas Emissions. D. Findings on Mitigation Measures Suggested in Comment Letters Several comment letters suggested revisions to the project as proposed. Re- sponse to Comments in the Final EIR addressed the feasibility of these sug- gested revisions. (See Final EIR Chapter 5.) Some of these revisions have been incorporated into the project (See Response to Comment 3-5 and 3-6), whereas other suggestions would not reduce or avoid impacts, or were already included in the project as proposed (see Response to Comments 4-2, 5-6, 5-7, 5-9, 5-10, 7-14, 7-20, 8-7, 8-10, 8-11, 8-12, 8-13, 8-14), or were determined to be infeasible (7-13. 7-14, 7-19, 7-20, 8-4, 8-5, 8-6, 8-7, 8-15). For the reasons dis- cussed in the Final EIR, many of these suggested revisions were determined to be infeasible and are summarized below: Revisions suggested in Comment 7-13: The comment suggests as mitiga- tion (1) "decreasing total vehicle trips and VMT", and (2) by "reducing the proximity of sensitive land uses to sources of emissions (i.e. freeways and ma- jor corridors). As discussed under Response to Comment 7-13: 3-48 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECtS As discussed under Response to Comment 5-6, the proposed General Plan Circulation Element, and DEIR Section 4.13, a number of poli- cies have been proposed to help reduce VMT. However, the com- ment does not provide any additional suggestions for how such a re- quirement could be implemented. The City does not have direct con- trol over VMT. While the City has proposed a number of policies to reduce trip generation and VMT, trip generation is ultimately con- trolled by the will of individual drivers. As to the second suggested measure, the proposed General Plan al- ready contains several policies which address the suggestion. There- fore additional related policies would not reduce or avoid impacts. [See Policies HEJ-2.3, LU-3.6, and HEJ-2.1]." For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 7-13, the City finds, for die reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions suggested in Comment 7-14, 8-4, and 8-5: The comments sug- gests the following revisions: 1. Prohibiting the siting of sensitive land uses within 500 feet from the centerline of a freeway and strengthen HEJ Policy 2.1 by removing the "where feasible" qualification. While Policy HF.J-2.3 contains some exceptions for smart growth and other related developments, such exceptions are necessary to provide suf- ficient flexibility' and to balance other competing planning and environ- As discussed under OPR's 2003 General Plan Guidelines, "given the long- term nature of a general plan, its diagrams and text should be general enough to allow 3-49 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F- F E C T S mental considerations. While air quality is an important consideration, the City has to balance other factors and risks, such as fire risks, flood risks, geologic hazards, hazardous materials, biological impacts, aesthetic impacts, agricultural resources, hydrology and water quality, land use, noise, population and housing, public services and recreation, utilities, GHG emissions, cultural resource impacts, as well as local impacts versus regional impacts- These factors will be considered at the time specific pro- jects are proposed. Eliminating these exceptions is considered infeasible because it would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsis- tent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and en- sure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See Cali- fornia Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4t 957) Furthermore such a revision would place air quality above consideration of other resource areas and could result in increased impacts to other re- sources areas and would therefore not be environmentally superior (i.e. forcing development away from transportation corridors increasing GHG emissions, or forcing development into flood zones or fire zones...)." Furthermore, even CEQA recognizes that there will be times in which mitigation measures are infeasible. As discussed under CEQA Guidelines Section 15126.4 "An EIR shall describe feasible measures which could minimize significant adverse impacts."" Elimination of "where feasible" would place restrictions on project specific development even more stringent than those required by CEQA itself. Furthermore, such a restriction without "where feasible" could potentially result in a taking of private property. Lastly, the commenter's suggested policy revision would result in a high number of non -conforming uses and could lead to an increase in urban a degree of flexibility in decision -making as times change." (Office of Planning and Research 2003 General Plan Guidelines, page 14.) 3-50 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS decay and blight in those areas. Such conditions could preclude reinvest- ment in these areas which could prevent installation and maintenance of ventilation systems, air filters/cleaners and other effective measures to minimize existing air quality problems and other existing environmental conditions (i.e. earthquake retrofits, etc...). 2. Require a 1000-foot buffer'hetwcen uses and industrial facilities. See previous response "1". Unlike the freeway buffer, there are a number of different types of Industrial facilities that have different air pollutant characteristics. Even the California Air Resources Board's Advisory Guidelines on Land Use recommend different buffers for different indus- trial facilities (i.e. distribution centers, rail yards, ports, refineries, chrome platers...) To require a 1000 foot buffer would provide the City insuffi- cient flexibility to tailor such buffers to specific proposed facilities and the specific conditions on site. Site specific buffer distances will be con- sidered at the time specific projects are proposed and parcel specific/ pro- ject specific information can be assessed. Furthermore, such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4`h 957) 3. Repeat HEJ Policy 2.1 in LU Policy 3.6. As discussed under Response to Comment 7-4, these policies are already included in the proposed General Plan. Projects are reviewed for consis- tency with the whole General Plan, not individual elements. It is there- fore unnecessary to repeat every policy in the Health and Environmental Justice Element or the Land Use Element. Furthermore, repeating poli- cies throughout the General Plan could result in future complications when the General Plan is being amended. For example, a policy could be 3-51 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS amended in one section, but similar revisions could be missed in another section. While this is not related to an environmental issue, such revisions will be forwarded to the decision makers for their consideration. 4. Strengthening Policies C-1.1, C-4.1 to C-4.7 by incorporating stronger language and/or mandates. A. Policy C-1.1 See response to "1" above. Additionally, it is infeasible to "mandate" transit oriented development, mixed -use and infill projects (Policy C-1.1). The City does not own many of the parcels throughout the City. The decision to build projects, such as mixed use developments, is largely at the will of the individual property owner. Similarly, as discussed on General Plan page 1-16, implementation of the General Plan can take time and is dependent upon limited resources and policy considerations which prioritize programs. Mandating such development would also re- move the needed flexibility to prioritize programs and is therefore con- sidered infeasible. However, it is important to note that General Plan policies should not be reviewed in a vacuum. Projects are analyzed for consistency with the General Plan as a whole. As noted in Response to Comment 5-6, the General Plan already contains policies which require development of multi -modal transportation facilities with certain types of new development projects. Further, the commenter is requesting man- dates that are more restrictive that the California Air Resources Board (CARB) Guidelines. Current draft General Plan policies are consistent with suggested CARB guidelines. Furthermore, such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsistent with the project objectives (one of the project ob- jectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize im- plementation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy con- siderations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4`h 957) 3-52 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS B. Policy C-4.1 See response to "1" above. Furthermore, the City does not have legal au- thority to mandate specific work hours. C. Policy C-4.2 See response to "1" above. Furthermore, the City does not have legal au- thority to mandate commuter programs. However, please see Response to Comment 5-6 for discussion of alternative modes of transit, including General Plan Implementation measure PT-10 (Commuter Benefits Pro- gram). D. Policy C-4.3 The policy already "[r)equires new uses to provide adequate bicycle park- ing and support facilities." It is unclear how the commenter believes this policy should be further revised. Therefore, this suggestion would not reduce or avoid impacts. - E. Policy C-4.4 See response 4(B) on Policy C-4.2 above. F. Policy C-4.5 See response 4(B) on Policy C-4.2 above. G. Policy C-4.6 The Policy currently states "prioritize attention to transportation issues around schools to reduce school -related vehicle trips. It is unclear how the commenter would revise this policy. It is also important to note that these General Plan policies do not exist in a vacuum. All of the goals and policies have been proposed as part of a comprehensive system. As noted in both the General Plan and the DEIR, the City is already in the process of implementing the safe routes to school program (see General Plan page 3-60, 4-16; DEIR page 4.13-30). Furthermore, many of the street closures and park renovations are designed to "provides a community center that 3-53 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECIS is integrated into the adjacent neighborhoods and schools...." (see DEIR pages 3-11, 3-71, 3-74, and 3-77). Therefore such a revision would not re- duce or avoid significant impacts. H. Policy C-4.7 See response to "1" above. 5. Strengthen National City Climate Action Plan by: A. Policy A2.h.1. by supporting transit options first, including a functional light rail transit system in the San Diego County urban core. See also Response to "1" above. Further, the City does not have ju- risdiction over the light rail transit system and future system im- provements and investments. Further to support "transit options first" as the commenter suggests would preclude certain other activi- ties that may be immediately necessary (maintenance, repair, emer- gencies, planned improvements) therefore, the City can not exclu- sively prioritize transit first. Furthermore, such a policy would pre- clude roadway improvements that are designed to foster alternative modes of transit such as the proposed street closures and community corridors in the General Plan. Furthermore, such a policy would preclude construction of relatively minor changes to roadways that have low- costs and large benefits. Such a policy lacks sufficient flexi- bility and could result in the creation of additional impacts by pre- cluding consideration of the circulation system as a whole.' Such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would he incon- sistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is As discussed in CEQA Guidelines Appendix G, Section XVI, projects are to consider impacts to "the performance of the circulation system, taking into accoun all modes of transportation, including mass transit and non -motorized travel and rele- vant components of the circulation system, including but not limited to intersections, streets, highways and freeways, pedestrian and bicycle paths, and mass transit." 3-54 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL EF- FECTS "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implemen- tation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy con- siderations. (Sec California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4`h 957) Furthermore, the land use plan identified in the draft General Plan is consistent with the Regional Transportation Plan (RTP). The City of National City is a member agency of SANDAG and wants to en- sure that General Plan and Climate Action Plan policies are consis- tent with the RTP and as such, must allow for an integrated system rather than exclusively prioritizing one project or infrastructure in- vestment over another. B. Policy A2.b.2. by implementing a bike master plan for a bi- cycle corridor: It is important to understand that while the City has taken a number of steps to implement the General Plan, including the Land Use Code and the Climate Action Plan. Implementation of the General Plan will take time and will occur over the lifetime of the plan, as discussed further on General Plan page 1-16 (see also Government Code Section 65400). It is not feasible to provide every implementa- tion measure for the General Plan, or every potential municipal code revision at this time. However, in 2011, the City adopted a Bike Master Plan. Furthermore, SANDAG has also recently adopted the San Diego Regional Bicycle Plan (May 2010) (see DEIR page 4.13-9). Therefore the suggested revision would not reduce or avoid signifi- cant impacts. C. Policy B3.a.1. by adopting a 100 percent Clean Vehicle Re- placement Policy for the City fleet and contracted fleet ser- vices (see also Policy CS-1.4). 3-55 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT FNVIRONMENTAI F F- FFCTS See also Response to "1" above. Further, it is infeasible to require the city to adopt a 100 percent clean vehicle replacement policy. It is necessary for the City to maintain discretion regarding its vehicle re- placement policy based on economic availability and best available vehicle technology (e.g. fire engines). The City can not commit at this time to a 100 percent replacement policy. Furthermore, such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be incon- sistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implemen- tation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy con- siderations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.41 957) For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 7-14, 8-4 and 8-5, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considera- tions, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alterna- tives identified in the Final EIR. Revisions suggested in Comment 7-19 and 8-6: The comments suggests the following revisions: 1. GPU Policies S-7.1 and S-7.2 may be changed to "require" as opposed to merely "promote" use of BACT and may be extended to apply to all industrial facilities, not just City operations: As discussed in Response to Comments 7-19 and 8-6: While the City will promote hazardous waste minimization, it will not always be possible to "require" this for both existing and new fa- cilities. Feasibility would need to be evaluated on a project -by -project 3-56 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS NDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F- F E C T S basis and the City would need to be able to demonstrate financial feasibility. This area is heavily regulated and in many instances the City is preempted by Federal law. Policies S-7.1 and S-7.2 have been changed to add "where feasible" so as to use BACT to the extent fea- sible. 2. Periodic review and reevaluation of BACT every few years would mitigate potential impacts: The comment suggests that Best Available control technology dis- cussed in Policy S-7.1 be reviewed "every few years." It is important to note that the contents of a General Plan are governed by Gov- ernment Code Sections 65300 et seq. The City has provided a num- ber of implementation measures, including the proposed Land Use Code, however it is not possible to draft every potential ordinance and implementation measure that will be implemented over the life- time of the project at this time. Government Code 65400 contem- plates implementation of a General Plan as an ongoing process which includes an annual report on implementation (see also General Plan Implementation Measure ME-14). The level of detail recommended by the commenter will be considered in future ordinances (as noted under Implementation Measure PT-23), however it is not possible to adopt this level of detail for the full General Plan and complete the project within a "reasonable period of time" (see CEQA Guidelines Section 15364). For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 7-19 and 8-6, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considera- tions, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alterna- tives identified in the Final EIR. 3-57 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAI. EF- FECTS Revisions Suggested in Comment 7-20 and 8-7: As discussed in Response to Comment 7-20 and 8-7: This comment focuses on the Health and Environmental Justice Element of the proposed General Plan and is not related to the DEIR. Furthermore, existing lead based paint is not an impact of the proposed project but is part of baseline conditions (see Response to Comment 7-7 for greater details). The comment further suggests the failure of the DE1R to mention the City's Housing Rehabilitation Program or threat of lead -based paint exposure during redevelop- ment. The Housing Rehabilitation Program is no longer in exis- tence. Furthermore, exposure to and removal of lead -based paint is governed by federal regulatory requirements. As discussed on DEIR page 3-17, "the proposed project does not stand alone from a regula- tory perspective. Development within the City must comply with other federal, State, and local regulations." Existing regulations pro- vide for the safe removal of lead based paint (see 15 USC $2682; 40 CFR Part 745). Lead based paint removal is required for "[r]enovations in target housing` or child -occupied facilities..." (40 CFR Part 745.82). This includes the requirement that parties remov- ing lead based paint be properly trained and certified to ensure that the work is performed safely (see 40 CFR Part 745.80).5 See also Cali- fornia regulations related to lead based paint removal under 14 Cal. "The term "target housing" means any housing constructed prior to 1978, except housing for the elderly or persons with disabilities (unless any child who is less than 6 years of age resides or is expected to reside in such housing for the elderly or persons with disabilities) or any 0-bedroom dwelling. In the case of jurisdictions which banned the sale or use of lead -based paint prior to 1978, the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, at the Secretary's discretion, may designate an earlier date." (15 USC § 2681(17)-) s These requirements are summarized by the EPA at: http://www.epa.gov/compliance/resources/newsletters/civil/enfalert/1 eadpaint. pdf 3-58 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - F E C T S Code Regs. Section 1532.1. There are numerous additional lead based paint programs in California.' For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 7-20 and 8-7, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions Suggested in Comment 8-10: The comment suggests the follow- ing revisions: Amend Goal CS-6: Energy utilities sufficient to meet existing and future demand, and facilities and maintenance practices that arc effi cient-and sensitive to the natural and urban landscape achieve 1990 emissions by 2020 and 80% below 1990 ghg emissions by 2050. As discussed in Response to Comment 8-10: In addition, the Climate Action Plan is part of the proposed project and states on page 3-2: "National City has adopted a reduction target of 15 percent below 2005/2006 baseline emission levels by the year 2020 [equivalent to 1990 levels by 2020], with additional reduc- tions by the year 2030, for both community -wide and gov- ernment operations." As discussed on DEIR page 3-17, "the proposed project does not stand alone from a regulatory b See 17 Cal. Code Regs. 33001 et seq., 17 Cal. Code Regs. 35001 et seq., 17 Cal. Code Regs. 37000 et seq., 17 Cal. Code Regs. 38001 et seq., 22 Cal. Code. Regs. 69100 et seq. 3-59 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS perspective. Development within the City must comply with other federal, State, and local regulations." The DEIR notes that the suggested GHG reduction targets already exist through AB32 and Executive Order S-3-05. It is therefore not necessary to repeat these requirements in this goal in the General Plan. Furthermore, the existing goal is intended to be broader than the recommended revision. Specific targets should not be included in a General Plan goal. Desired targets are identified in Section 5 of the General Plan (Indicators). This section lists several ways that the City can measure its progress towards reaching its goals and policies. Measuring greenhouse gas emissions is one of the indicators and fu- ture emission inventories will allow the City to identify if emissions targets will be met. CEQA only requires a reduction in impacts in comparison to exist- ing conditions (CEQA Guidelines Section 15125(a).) The suggested revisions are therefore not necessary from a CEQA perspective as ex- isting conditions are beyond the scope of the EIR to fix (see Watson- ville Pilots Association v. City of Watsonville (2010) 183 Cal. App. 4th 1059). For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 8-10, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions Suggested in Comment 8-11: The comment suggests the follow- ing new goal: 3-60 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F• FECES New Goal: Meet 50% of citywide electricity needs with clean energy by 2020. As discussed in Response to Comment 8-11: As noted on DEIR page 4.14-103 "In the third quarter of 2010 SDG&E provided 10.5% of its electricity from renewables." This figure was recently updated after the publication of the DEIR; SDG&E produced 11.9% of their electricity from renewable energy sources in 2010 (18% average statewide).14 As also noted on DEIR page 4.15-6 the State has already enacted a renewable portfolio re- quirement. The enacting statutes were recently amended to require 33% of electricity generation from retail sales to be produced from renewable sources by 2020 (see Senate Bill X1 2 [2011». Further, the City has limited control over how energy is produced for the City. As noted in the previous response, CEQA only requires a reduction in impacts in comparison to existing conditions (CEQA Guidelines Section 15125(a).) The suggested revisions are therefore not neces- sary from a CEQA perspective as existing conditions are beyond the scope of the EIR to fix (see Watsonville Pilots Association v. City of Watsonville (2010) 183 Cal. App. 4th 1059). For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 8-11, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions Suggested in Comment 8-12: The comment suggests the follow- ing revisions to Policy CS-7.3: 3-6I CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - F E C I S Amend Policy CS-7.3: Policy CS-7.3: Consistent with the California Public Utilities Commission's California Long Term Energy Effi- ciency Strategic Plan, strive to achieve zero net energy use for new residential development by 2020 and zero net energy use for new commercial development by 2030. As discussed in Response to Comment 8-12: As noted in Response to Comment 8-10, the Climate Action Plan al- ready contains a policy which calls for the reduction of GHG emis- sions to 1990 levels by 2020 (i.e. below baseline levels). Furthermore, and EIR is to address the impacts based upon the whole of the pro- ject, not individual components (such as residences and commercial space). (See Big Rock Menu Prop. Owners Ass'n v. Board of Supervisors (1977) 73 Ca1.App.3d 218, 277; see also No Oil, Inc. v. City of Los An- geles (1987) 196 Ca1.App.3d 223, 235 [analysis required for the project as a whole, not the various components thereof.).) Furthermore, it may also not be possible to ensure that every indi- vidual residential project or commercial project has a zero net energy use. For example, it may not always be economically feasible to re- quire affordable housing to fully offset their energy consumption. Similarly, it may not be possible to require 100% offset of energy use for new commercial development, which will depend upon the spe- cific nature of the project and parcel. The suggested revision would provide insufficient flexibility to account for the needs of specific projects at the time they are proposed. Such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effec- tive and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See 3-62 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 CaLApp.4`h 957) For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 8-12, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions Suggested in Comment 8-13: The comment recommends the following revisions to Policy CS-7.4: Amend Policy CS-7.4: E..plo_„ p_og_am to ....outage load shifting to off peak hours and explore demand response solutions. Develop a plan that will result in peak load shifting and demand response action that will reduce loads on the grid of at least 50% by im- plementing the State of California's preferred loading order for energy use. As discussed in Response to Comment 8-13: The language proposed in the draft General Plan addresses shifting peak Load electricity demand. However the policy as currently pro- posed in the comment simply refers to reducing "loads on the grid" by 50% rather than peak load. Furthermore, the comment does not explain how such a plan could be implemented by the City. The "load order" discussed in the comment refers to energy effi- ciency, demand response, renewable, and distributed generation.' As California Energy Commission, Implementing California's Loading Order for Electricity Resources, July 2005. Available at: 3-63 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS discussed in the DEIR and the previous response to comments, many of these suggestions are already being implemented through existing programs. For example, there are numerous programs to increase en- ergy efficiency and renewables, as discussed in DEIR chapters 4.14 and 4.15 (including energy efficient building standards). • However, the City has limited abilities to control peak electricity demand; most of the measures proposed by the City are more passive in nature, as discussed in the DEIR (i.e. constructing efficient build- ings). A majority of the tools necessary to control peak Toad demand are actively controlled by utility companies, the California Public Utilities Commission, and the California Energy Commission. For example, the utility companies control "demand response" by im- plementing programs in which the utility can shut off specific equipment to an agreed upon level, cycling air conditioning, or use dynamic pricing and demand bidding during periods of peak electric- ity load. The City does not have control over such contracts or the equipment. Furthermore, peak Toad demand is not something that should be as mechanically assigned as suggested in the comment (i.e. 50%). The determination of what percentage to reduce peak load is dependent upon a number of factors that are ultimately determined by the util- ity companies and other governmental agencies. In some instances the utility companies may seek to increase/ shift demand depending upon the source of electricity and pricing. Such a policy could inter- fere with these considerations. Furthermore, such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting http://waw.energy.ca.gov/2005publ ications/CEC-400-2005-043/CEC-400-2005- 043.PDF 3-64 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Soci- ety v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957) For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 8-13, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions Suggested in Comment 8-14: The comment suggests the follow- ing amendment to policy CS-7.5: Policy CS-7.5: Promote availability of a variety f t Is and r.ervice., for : plcmcnting „ ..d .- ,abl„ ..,-I..d:,... C:..,...,.:..g d: uditin,.effi or:..d _ts _..d Lusiness Achieve 20% reduction in home energy use by 2015; 40% reduction by 2020. As discussed in Response to Comment 8-14: Please see Response to Comment 8-10 and 8-11. As noted in those re- sponses existing conditions (and existing building) are beyond the scope of the EIR to fix. Please however note that the Climate Action Plan contains a number of policies to decrease energy demand from existing buildings (see Climate Action Plan page 4-2). Furthermore, such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting 3-65 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL E F - FECTS General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Soci- ety v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957) For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 8-14, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. Revisions Suggested in Comment 8-15: The comment suggests the follow- ing amendment to Policy CS-7.7: Policy CS-7.7: Encourage LEED certification for all new municipal, _ial a., t :n,t..s._:..I buildints i., tt.e e:ty Require LEED Gold or equivalent for all city new or significantly remodeled buildings and require LEER Silver or equivalent for new signifi- cantly remodels of private sector building construction. As discussed in Response to Comment 8-15: The City supports the concept of energy efficiency and LEED certi- fication (or equivalent) for new development as evidenced by Gen- eral Plan Policy CS- 7.7 (Climate Action Plan A1.b.2, B1.a.3). How- ever, a policy to require all new public buildings to meet LEED standards is not appropriate at the programmatic level and does not retain the flexibility needed to address the variety of project specific differences that will arise under the General Plan- The City supports the full spectrum of LEED certification programs and understands that individual projects will conform to their own unique set of is- sues (including financial, technological) to ensure that the appropri- ate degree of energy efficiency design is incorporated into individual 3-66 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS REGARDING SIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTAL FF FECrs building construction. The commenter is referred to DEIR Chapters 4.14 and 4.15 for more detailed discussion energy efficiency require- ments for existing and proposed facilities. Furthermore, such a suggestion would provide insufficient flexibility and would be inconsistent with the project objectives (one of the project objectives is "Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies."). This suggested is also infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Soci- ety v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4`h 957) For the suggested revisions discussed in Comment 8-15, the City finds, for the reasons discussed above: (X) Specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations, including provision of employment opportunities for highly trained workers, make infeasible mitigation measures or project alternatives iden- tified in the Final EIR. E. Findings on Recirculation The City finds that none of the revisions in the Final EIR, or information or comments submitted before the close of the public hearing would trigger the need to recirculate the EIR. F. Findings on the Custodian of Records The City finds that the Custodian of Documents and other materials upon which the decision is based is the City Clerk, located at 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950. 3-67 4 FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES A. Overview Chapter 5 of the Draft EIR discusses a reasonable range of alternatives to sat- isfy Section 15126.6 of the CEQA Guidelines, which states that an "EIR shall describe a range of reasonable alternatives to the project, or to the location of the project, which would feasibly attain most of the basic objectives of the project but would avoid or substantially lessen any of the significant effects of the project." As such, the alternatives discussed within Chapter 5 meet most of the proposed project objectives and would either avoid or reduce some of the significant effects of the proposed project. In addition, as required by CEQA, the No Project Alternative is included in the analysis. All four alter- natives have been qualitatively analyzed at a level that provides sufficient in- formation about the environmental effects of each alternative for comparative purposes and to allow for informed decision -making. The alternatives identified for the Comprehensive Land Use Update are: • Existing General Plan Alternative (No Project Alternative) • Distributed Growth Alternative • Centralized Growth Alternative Additional alternatives to the Development Proposals component of the Comprehensive Land Use Update are: • Existing Street Conversions/Community Corridors Alternative (No Pro- ject Alternative) • Reduced Street Conversions/Community Corridors Alternative • Existing Senior Village Expansion Alternative (No Project Alternative) • Reduced Senior Village Expansion Alternative • Existing Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative (No Project Alternative) • Reduced Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative • Existing Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative (No Project Alternative) ♦ Reduced Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative • Existing El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative (No Project Alterna- tive) • Reduced El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative 1-I CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES Alternatives considered and rejected from further comparison because they did not meet several of the main project objectives, did not reduce a signifi- cant environmental impact, or were infeasible, include the following: • Low Density Alternative B. CEQA Project Objectives and Section Criteria The CEQA project objectives and purpose for the Comprehensive Land Use Update are described in Chapter 3, Project Description and listed below. Ob- jectives are numbered 1 through 13 for ease of reference within this chapter. 1. Focus future development and redevelopment along major and minor transit corridors, within urban and community centers, and near transit stations. 2. Increase the walkability of the city through compact and mixed -use transit oriented development. 3. Enhance and expand the system of pedestrian paths, open space pedes- trian connections, and bicycle trails to efficiently link neighborhoods, schools, parks, and employment centers to each other. 4. Enhance existing residential neighborhoods by increasing access to park and recreational space. 5. Increase access to fruits and vegetables through urban agriculture and the creation of community gardens. 6. Enhance community character through good urban design, public art, scenic and historic preservation, high quality architecture, landscape, and gateways and entry -points. 7. Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementa- tion and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and poli- cies. 4-2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT A L I E R N A l I V 5 8. Provide adequate infrastructure, using best management sustainability practices and measures, to meet the demand of growth and develop- ment. 9. Improve living conditions and public health for National City residents by eliminating harriers to physical activity and increasing access to rec- reational opportunities. 10. Maintain a vibrant economy by supporting a diversity of business and employment opportunities. 11. Reduce environmental justice inequities by promoting the removal of undesirable and unhealthy concentrations of incompatible land uses and providing an equitable distribution of public amenities. 12. Improve the quality of life for National City residents and the region by providing a better jobs/housing balance. 13. Provide a General Plan Update that complies with the applicable legal requirements, including the Government Code (Government Code Sec- tions 65300 et seq.). C. Alternatives 1. Environmentally Superior Alternative The DEIR determined that the proposed project would be the environmen- tally superior alternative. The proposed project was discussed in DEIR Chap- ter 3. The proposed project (Comprehensive Land Use Update) includes two primary components: (1) revisions to the City's Planning documents, includ- ing a comprehensive update of National City's General Plan, an update to the Land Use Code (Municipal Code Title 18), and a Climate Action Plan, and amendments to the Downtown Specific Plan and Local Coastal Program to ensure consistency with the General Plan; and (2) five individual development projects as follows: Street Conversions/ Community Corridors; Senior Vil- lage Expansion; Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan; Kimball Park Master Plan; and El Toyon Park Master Plan. 4-3 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVE S Finding The City Council for National City finds that the proposed project identified in the DEIR (as modified in the FEIR) would be the environmentally supe- rior alternative. (See DEIR pages 5-35 through 5-36.) Because the project being adopted is the environmentally superior alternative, additional findings are not necessary. Nevertheless, additional grounds for infeasibility for the remaining alternatives have been provided below. Facts in Support of Finding Identification of the environmentally superior alternative involves weighing and balancing all of the environmental resource areas by the City. It is the City's primary concern to improve the health and safety of its resi- dents, associated with Air Quality, Greenhouse Gases, alternate modes of transit, and a jobs/housing balance. Further, the regional impacts to air pollu- tion, potential conversion and loss of agricultural and biological resources, traffic congestion, and GHG would be substantially improved under the Comprehensive Land Use Update when compared with the Existing General Plan (No Project) and Distributed Growth Alternatives. Though impacts to local vehicular travel and level of service were reduced under the Distributed Growth Alternative, the Comprehensive Land Use Update balances the in- creased impacts to vehicular travel with an improvement to regional air qual- ity, provision of alternative modes of transportation, and GHGs. Though impacts to regional air quality, provision of alternative modes of transporta- tion, and GHGs would be further improved under the Centralized Growth Alternatives it would result in greater localized impacts not only to vehicular travel but local air quality and GHGs thereby impacting the health of its resi- dents. Therefore, the environmentally superior alternative is the proposed Comprehensive Land Use Update project as it best balances regional and local impacts. (See DEIR Chapter 5 for further details.) 4-4 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROIECT ALTERNATIVES 2. Alternative 1: Existing General Plan Alternative (No Project Alter- native) Evaluation of the CEQA-required No Project Alternative compares the im- pacts of the proposed project against the impacts of not approving the project. This alternative emphasizes lower densities within National City than the proposed project and disperses densities throughout the City. No land use changes associated with the five Development Proposals would move for- ward. Instead, any future development in these areas would be what is cur- rently allowed under the existing General Plan and Zoning map. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the No Projcct Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding When compared against the proposed project, the No Project Alternative would result in greater environmental impacts on aesthetics, air quality, bio- logical resources, cultural resources, hydrology and water quality, land use, public services and recreation, utilities and service systems, and greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs). In addition, the No Project Alternative would not meet most of the project objectives (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 9, 11, 12 and 13). Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infea- sible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4th 957.) (See DEIR Chapter 5 for greater details.) 3. Alternative 2: Distributed Growth Alternative Alternative 2 disperses densities more evenly within National City. This al- ternative would accommodate higher densities than the Existing General Plan Alternative, but lower densities than the Centralized Growth Alternative. As described in greater detail below, the Distributed Growth alternative would replace "Major Mixed Use" land use designations in the proposed General Plan with the existing General Plan's "General Commercial" land use designa- tion along Plaza Blvd, East 8`I' Street, and along Highway 54. Additionally, 9-5 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES this alternative would replace "Low -Medium Density' land use designations in the proposed General Plan with a `Medium Density Residential" designa- tions in the northwest corner and the east side of the City. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Distributed Growth Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding Although the Distributed Growth Alternative would reduce impacts on aes- thetics, population and housing, and public services and recreation, this alter- native does not achieve objectives 1, 2, and 9 which are targeted to encourage development along transit corridors, urban and community centers, and near transit stations and to increase walkability through compact and mixed -use transit -oriented development and improve public health by eliminating barri- ers to physical activity. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4th 957.) (See DEIR Chapter 5 for greater details.) 4. Alternative 3: Centralized Growth Alternative Alternative 3 concentrates higher densities in centralized locations at nodes of major arterials and transportation centers and limits growth along corridors throughout the city and outside the centralized locations. This alternative would accommodate higher densities than the Existing General Plan and Dis- tributed Growth Alternatives. As described in greater detail below under the Centralized Growth Alternative, the maximum density in the "Major Mixed - Use District" areas would increase to 80 dwelling units an acre and the FAR' would increase to 4.0. "Minor Mixed Use" land use designations in the pro- posed General Plan would be replaced with a "Medium Density" land use Floor -area ratio (FAR) is defined as the floor area of the building divided by the total project site area. FAR includes all floors of a building but does not count on -site, covered parking. 4-6 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES designation along 186 Street. Under this alternative "Low -Medium Density" land use designations in the proposed General Plan would be replaced with "Medium Density Residential" designations on the west side of the City just east of National City Boulevard. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Centralized Growth Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding Although the Centralized Growth Alternative would reduce regional impacts on greenhouse gas emissions, air quality, and transportation and circulation, this alternative would increase local impacts on air quality; geology, soils and mineral resources; noise; public services and recreation; transportation and circulation; and utilities and service systems. While the Centralized Growth Alternative reduces regional GHG, air quality, and transportation and circu- lation impacts, the increase in local impacts would negatively impact National City citizens. Because of the increased local impacts, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations including too high of den- sities, provision of adequate infrastructure, and preservation of community character. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) (See DEIR Chapter 5 for greater details.) 5. Alternatives Considered But Rejected (Low Density Alternative) The Low Density Alternative would substantially reduce the overall density of the project 2030 buildout within the Planning Area. This alternative would revise the Comprehensive Land Use Update General Plan Land Use Map to replace "Major Mixed Use" land use designations in the proposed General Plan with the existing General Plan "General Commercial" land use designa- tion and eliminate residential as an allowed use; reduce the maximum allow- able density within the "High Density Residential" land use designation in the proposed General Plan with a "Medium Density Residential" designations in all areas of the City; and revise Sections 18.140.010-058 of the Land Use Code 4-7 CITY OF NATIONAL. CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES update to remove residential as an allowed use. Additionally, this alternative would eliminate all proposed development in potential jurisdictional waters from the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan and Kimball Park Master Plan projects. (See DEIR pages 5-42 through 5-44.) Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Centralized Growth Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Low Density Alternative would reduce the projected 2030 buildout within the Planning Area. As discussed in the previous discussion of "Dis- placed Growth" on DEIR pages 5-33 through 5-35, an alternative such as this with substantially reduced density and growth would have increased region wide impacts and would therefore not be environmentally superior. While this would reduce significant impacts to local traffic to less than significant, it would fail to meet the following project objectives as identified in Chapter 3.0 and is therefore rejected as infeasible: • Focus future development and redevelopment along major and mi- nor transit corridors, within urban and community centers, and near transit stations. • Increase the walkability of the city through compact and mixed -use transit oriented development. • Improve living conditions and public health for National City resi- dents by eliminating barriers to physical activity and increasing ac- cess to recreational opportunities. • Improve the quality of life for National City residents and the region by providing a jobs/housing balance. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant 4-8 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4th 957.) (See DEIR Chapter 5 for greater detail.) D. Development Proposals Alternatives 1. Existing Street Conversions/Corntnunity Corridors (No Project) Al- ternative The Existing Street Conversion/Community Corridors Alternative would provide for elimination of both the Street Conversions and Community Cor- ridors components and existing project site conditions would remain. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Existing Street Con- versions/Community Corridors Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Existing Street Conversion/Community Corridors Alternative would result in a potential reduction in impacts to on -street parking from the Street Conversions and traffic impacts from the Community Corridors associated with below Level of Service D levels. While this Alternative would reduce environmental impacts as identified above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Enhance the pedestrian environment and promote walkability. • Calm traffic and create complete streets. • Enhance pedestrian and bicycle safety and access. • Improve quality of life through functional and attractive streetscape. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) 4-9 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROIECT A t T E R N A I I V F S 2. Reduced Street Conversions/Community Corridors Alternative The Street Conversion/Community Corridors Alternative would provide for elimination of the Community Corridors component from the Street Con- versions/Community Corridors project. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Reduced Street Con- versions/Community Corridors Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Reduced Street Conversion/Community Corridors Alternative would result in a potential reduction in traffic impacts from the Community Corri- dors associated with below LOS D levels. While the Reduced Street Conversion/Community Corridors Alternative would reduce environmental impacts as identified above associated with char- acteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Enhance the pedestrian environment and promote walkability. • Cahn traffic and create complete streets. • Enhance pedestrian and bicycle safety and access. • Improve quality of life through functional and attractive streetscape. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also he infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) 3. Existing Senior Village Expansion (No Project) Alternative The Existing Senior Village Expansion Alternative would provide for elimi- nation of the Senior Village Expansion including 200 residential units, reloca- tion and new construction of the existing 10,000-square-foot Senior Center 4-I0 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJFCT AITFRNATIVFS structure, a 15,000-square-foot medical office structure, and a parking struc- ture. Existing project site conditions would remain. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Existing Senior Village Expansion Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Existing Senior Village Expansion Alternative would result in the elimi- nation of 200 new residential units, 15,000-square-foot medical office, and a parking structure. While this Alternative would eliminate environmental impacts related to flood hoards as well as short-term air quality, noise, and transportation construction -related impacts, as identified above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: ♦ Meet the community's need for additional affordable housing units. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also he infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) Furthermore, re- duced density would increase regional impacts, and would therefore not be environmentally superior. (See DEIR discussion of displaced growth starting on page 5-33.) 4. Reduced Senior Village Expansion Alternative The Reduced Senior Village Expansion Alternative would provide for the reduction of 100 fewer new residential units associated with the Senior Village Expansion project. Finding CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROIECT ALIERNATVFS The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Reduced Senior Vil- lage Expansion Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Reduced Senior Village Expansion Alternative would have the following reduction in impacts: • It would eliminate the flood hazard impacts from the Senior Village Ex- pansion associated with building in the 100-year floodplain. While the Reduced Senior Village Expansion Alternative would eliminate environmental impacts related to flood hazards as well as decrease short-term air quality, noise, and transportation construction -related impacts, as identi- fied above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Meet the community's need for additional affordable housing units. • Create a dense, compact, and walkable senior housing complex that can be more easily served by transit to provide access to local and regional destinations. • Minimize the costs of development through infill development to more efficiently use scarce developable land. • Reduce the impacts to resources and infrastructure through efficient infill development. • Redesign Senior Village to better use large expanses of inefficient surface parking lots. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4th 957.) Furthermore, re- duced density would increase regional impacts, and would therefore not be environmentally superior. (See DEIR discussion of displaced growth starting on page 5-33.) 4-17 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT Al T ERN ATIV ES 5. Existing Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan (No Pro- ject) Alternative The Existing Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative would provide for elimination of the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan including: • 1.5 acres of soccer field area. • 12,000 square feet of expanded play ground. • 8,400 square feet of skate park. • 550 linear feet of new trails (5,500 square feet). • 0.62 acres of dog park/run. ♦ 4 acres of community garden plots. • 41.5 acres of passive open space including a lake/irrigation pond. • 162 additional parking spaces to serve the park recreational uses. • Interior improvements to community center and pool house. • 40,000 square feet of new commercial uses including 198 parking spaces. Existing project site conditions would remain. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Existing Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Existing Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative would result in the elimination of significant environmental impacts. While this Alternative would eliminate environmental impacts related to biological resources and traffic, as well as decrease short -tern air quality, noise, and transportation construction -related impacts, as identified above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: ♦ Minimize costs of development by using city -owned lands to eliminate land acquisition costs. 4-13 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECI AITERNATIVES • Increase revenue sources through the redevelopment of land. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Ca1.App.4th 957.) 6. Reduced Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alterna- tive The Reduced Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative would provide for elimination of the 40,000 square feet of new commercial uses from the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan project. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Reduced Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Reduced Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Alternative would have the following reduction in impacts: • Reduce the significant and unavoidable traffic impacts to the intersection at Grove Street and Sweetwater Road from the Las Palmas Park and Fa- cilities Concept Plan project associated with the construction of 40,000 square feet of commercial uses and associated vehicle trip generation. While the Reduced Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Al- ternative would significantly reduce environmental impacts related to traffic as well as decrease short-term air quality, noise, and transportation construc- tion -related impacts, as identified above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Minimize costs of development by using city -owned lands to eliminate land acquisition costs. 4-14 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES • Increase revenue sources through the redevelopment of land. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) 7. Existing Kimball Park (No Project) Master Plan Alternative The Existing Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative would provide for elimi- nation of the Kimball Park Master Plan including: • 39 new parking spaces (6,700 square feet). • Grading to allow for 0.85 acres of new community garden plots. • Recreational trail along Paradise Creek. • Vegetation enhancements within Paradise Creek to improve natural habi- tat. • Connection to the street to park conversion shown in Figures 3-6 and 3-12. Existing project site conditions would remain the same. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Existing Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Existing Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative would result in the elimi- nation of significant environmental impacts. While this Alternative would eliminate environmental impacts related to biological resources, as well as short-term air quality, noise, and transportation construction -related impacts, as identified above associated with characteristics of the development pro- posal, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objec- tives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Better integrate the existing community center into the adjacent neighborhood, provide a community linkage along Paradise Creek 4-15 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROIECT ALTERNATIVES through and between the park and other community and neighborhood destinations. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) 8. Reduced Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative The Reduced Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative would provide for elimi- nation of the Paradise Creek Improvements from the Kimball Park Master Plan project. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Reduced Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Reduced Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative would have the follow- ing reduction in impacts: ♦ Eliminate the biological impacts along Paradise Creek from the Kimball Park Master Plan associated with encroachment into jurisdictional wet- lands and degraded natural habitat. While the Reduced Kimball Park Master Plan Alternative would eliminate significant environmental impacts related to biological resources as well as decrease short-term air quality, noise, and transportation construction -related impacts, as identified above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objective as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0; • Better integrate the existing community center into the adjacent neighborhood, provide a community linkage along Paradise Creek through and between the park and other community and neighborhood destinations. 4-16 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 CaLApp.4th 957.) 9. Existing El Toyon Park Master Plan (No Project) Alternative The Existing El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative would provide for elimination of the El Toyon Park Master Plan including: • 6,000 square feet of expanded playground. • 15,000 square feet joint use facility to include an 8,500-square-foot fire sta- tion and 5,500-square-foot community center. • 1.0 acre of community garden plots. • 1,985 linear feet of additional trails. • 0.38 acres of dog run. • 0.87 acres of additional picnic area. • Demolition of 8,200 square feet of existing structure to be replaced with proposed join use facility. Existing project site conditions would remain the same. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Existing El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Existing El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative would result in the elimination of environmental impacts. While this Alternative would elimi- nate environmental impacts, as well as short-term air quality, noise, and transportation construction -related impacts, as identified above associated with characteristics of the development proposal, it would fail to meet the following project objectives as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Provide a new fire station/community center that is integrated into the adjacent neighborhoods and school, offers a community linkage through 4-17 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJECT ALTERNATIVES and between the park, school, and other community and neighborhood destinations, and allows joint use of facilities with adjacent school sites. Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) 10. Reduced El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative The Reduced El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative would provide for elimination of the 15,000-square-foot joint use facility from the El Toyon Park Master Plan project. Finding The National City City Council hereby finds that specific economic, legal, social, technological, or other considerations make the Reduced El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative infeasible. Facts in Support of Finding This Reduced El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative would have the follow- ing reduction in impacts: • Eliminate the temporary noise impacts from the El Toyon Park Master Plan associated with the demolition of the existing 8,2000-square-foot structure and construction of the 15,000 joint use facility. While the Reduced El Toyon Park Master Plan Alternative would signifi- cantly reduce environmental impacts, as identified above associated with char- acteristics of the development proposal, as well as decrease short-term air quality and transportation construction -related impacts, it would fail to meet the following development proposal project objective as identified in Draft EIR Chapter 3.0: • Provide a new fire station/community center that is integrated into the adjacent neighborhoods and school, offers a community linkage through and between the park, school, and other community and neighborhood destinations, and allows joint use of facilities with adjacent school sites. 4-18 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS FINDINGS ON PROJFCT AITFRNATIVES Because of the inability to meet project objectives, this alternative would also be infeasible based upon policy considerations. (See California Native Plant Society v. City of Santa Cruz (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 957.) E. Summary Finding Based on the alternatives discussion provided in the Draft EIR and the infor- mation above, the City Council determines that the proposed project is the environmentally -superior alternative that meets the project objectives listed in draft EIR (included above). The proposed project will seek to focus future development and redevelopment around transit and within urban and com- munity centers; increase walkability through compact and mixed -use transit oriented development; enhance and expand the system of pedestrian paths, open space pedestrian connections, and bicycle trails; enhance existing resi- dential neighborhoods by increasing access to park and recreational space; increase access to fruits and vegetables through urban agriculture and the crea- tion of community gardens; enhance community character through good urban design, public art, scenic and historic preservation, high quality archi- tecture, landscape, and gateways and entry -points; provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies; provide adequate infrastructure, us- ing best management sustainability practices and measures, to meet the de- mand of growth and development; improve living conditions and public health for National City residents by eliminating barriers to physical activity and increasing access to recreational opportunities; maintain a vibrant econ- omy by supporting a diversity of business and employment opportunities; reduce environmental justice inequities by promoting the removal of undesir- able and unhealthy concentrations of incompatible land uses and providing an equitable distribution of public amenities; and improve the quality of life for National City residents and the region by providing a better jobs/housing balance. 4- I 5 STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS Development under the proposed project would result in significant and un- avoidable adverse impacts on air quality, transportation and circulation, and utilities and service systems. There are no feasible mitigation measures within the responsibilities and jurisdiction of the City that would reduce these im- pacts to a level of less than significant. The Final EIR has identified unavoidable significant impacts. Section 15093(6) of the State CEQA Guidelines specifies that when the decision of the public agency approves a project that will result in the occurrence of sig- nificant impacts that are identified in the EIR but are not avoided or substan- tially lessened, the agency must state in writing the reasons to support its ac- tion based on the completed EIR and/or other information in the record. Accordingly, the City adopts the following Statement of Overriding Consid- erations. The City recognizes that significant and unavoidable impacts would result from the implementation of the proposed project. Having (1) adopted all feasible mitigation measures; (2) rejected the alternatives to the project dis- cussed above; (3) recognized all significant, unavoidable impacts; and (4) bal- anced the benefits of the proposed project against the significant and unavoid- able effects (including consideration of region -wide benefits), the City finds that the benefits outweigh and override the significant unavoidable effects for the reasons stated below. Any one of the reasons for approval is sufficient to justify approval of the proposed project. These reasons summarize the benefits, goals, and objectives of the proposed project. The substantial evidence supporting the various benefits can be found in the preceding findings and elsewhere in the Record of Proceedings (including the DEIR and FEIR). These overriding considera- tions of economic, social, environmental, and other benefits outweigh envi- ronmental costs and justify approval of the proposed project and certification of the EIR. Implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Update would further benefit the City of National City, as follows: 5-I CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS Economic Benefits 1. The project would promote a vibrant economy by supporting a di- versity of business and employment opportunities. 2. The project would allow for an increase in retail, commercial, and office space, which would provide opportunities to increase sales tax revenue and offer services to residents not currently available. 3. The project would allow for the future development of up to an ad- ditional 2,642,494 square feet of new retail/office space and 3,179,109 square feet of new industrial space. 4. The project would result in an increase in property taxes through re- development of underutilized and vacant parcels that would allow for compact residential and commercial development. Social Benefits 1. The project would result in reduced environmental justice inequities by facilitating and promoting the removal of undesirable and un- healthy concentrations of incompatible land uses and providing an equitable distribution of public amenities. 2. The project would encourage mixed -use development. This would achieve the goal of walkability and an improved quality of life for National City residents and the region by providing a better jobs/housing balance. 3. The project would allow for the future development of up to an ad- ditional 5,091 new dwelling units. 4. The project would implement Paradise Creek as an important source of neighborhood pride and enjoyment by improving habitat, con- necting it to the adjacent neighborhoods, and providing recreational opportunities. Environmental Benefits 5-2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS STATEMENT or OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS 1. The proposed project is environmentally superior to the existing General Plan, as discussed in DEW Chapter 5. 2. The project would result in reductions to regional air quality, traffic congestion, and greenhouse gases through the reduction in vehicle miles traveled and increase in resource and energy efficiency. 3. The project would establish the planning framework to improve traffic and pedestrian circulation to enhance mobility. 4. The project would enhance Paradise Creek as a public amenity and natural resource. 5. The proposed project would focus growth within those parts of the City designated "Town Center" and "Mixed -Use Transit Corridor" by SANDAG in their Smart Growth Concept Map, thereby reduc- ing regional impacts, as discussed on DEIR pages 5-33 through 5-35.) Other Benefits 1. The project would improve the health, safety, and quality of life for residents and visitors through access and proximity to transit and services, provision of infrastructure for alternative mode of transpor- tation, increased walkability and enhanced streetscape, access to parks and other recreational opportunities, and access to healthy fruits and vegetables through urban agriculture. Implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Update (including the De- velopment Proposals) would help fulfill the Guiding Principles of the General Plan Update: • Recognize the importance of linking land use and transportation plan- ning. • Improve the overall quality of life within National City. • Seek opportunities to improve public health and safety. 3 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDFRATIONS ♦ Emphasize the importance of schools and education. • Provide a framework for sound economic development strategies. Implementation of the Comprehensive Land Use Update would help fulfill objectives of the Regulatory Changes and Development Proposals compo- nents of the project: Regulatory Changes Objectives • Focus future development and redevelopment along major and minor transit corridors, within urban and community centers, and near transit stations_ • Increase the walkability of the city through compact and mixed -use tran- sit oriented development. ♦ Enhance and expand the system of pedestrian paths, open space pedes- trian connections, and bicycle trails to efficiently link neighborhoods, schools, parks, and employment centers to each other. • Enhance existing residential neighborhoods by increasing access to park and recreational space. • Increase access to fruits and vegetables through urban agriculture and the creation of community gardens. • Enhance community character through good urban design, public art, scenic and historic preservation, high quality architecnire, landscape, and gateways and entry -points. ♦ Provide an effective and flexible framework to maximize implementation and ensure progress towards meeting General Plan goals and policies. • Provide adequate infrastructure, using best management sustainability practices and measures, to meet the demand of growth and development. • Improve living conditions and public health for National City residents by eliminating barriers to physical activity and increasing access to rec- reational opportunities. 5-4 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS SLATENIEN T OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS • Maintain a vibrant economy by supporting a diversity of business and employment opportunities. • Reduce environmental justice inequities by promoting the removal of undesirable and unhealthy concentrations of incompatible land uses and providing an equitable distribution of public amenities. • Improve the quality of life for National City residents and the region by providing a better jobs/housing balance. • Provide a General Plan Update that complies with the applicable legal requirements, including the Government Code (Government Code Sec- tions 65300 et seq.). Development Proposals Objectives • Allow for the creation of additional green spaces and pocket parks. • Enhance the pedestrian environment and promote walkability. • Reduce neighborhood cut -through traffic. • Calm traffic and create complete streets. • Enhance pedestrian and bicycle safety and access. • Improve quality of life through functional and attractive streetscape. • Meet the community's need for additional affordable senior housing units. • Provide easily accessible and integrated health care services to serve the concentrated senior population within the Senior Village complex. • Develop Senior Village into a major senior housing community focus area that is strategically located to provide access to amenities that meet senior needs, such shopping, health care, parks, and civic and community centers. • Create a dense, compact, and walkable senior housing complex that can be more easily served by transit to provide access to local and regional destinations. 5 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATION S • Minimize the costs of development by using city -owned lands to elimi- nate land acquisition costs. • Minimize the costs of development through infill development to more efficiently use scarce developable land. • Reduce the impacts to resources and infrastructure through efficient infill development. • Redesign Senior Village to better use large expanses of inefficient surface parking lots. • Integrate Senior Village into the Paradise Creek Enhancement Project to provide a community linkage through the project site. • Meet the community's needs for additional park and recreation facilities by expanding existing community parks, adding recreation facilities, and adding or expanding programming. • Improve community and neighborhood access to Las Palmas Park. • Provide improved or new recreational amenities. • Provide a community center that is integrated into the adjacent neighborhoods and school, offers a community linkage through and be- tween the park, school, and other community and neighborhood destina- tions, and allows joint use of facilities with adjacent school sites. • Increase revenue sources through the redevelopment of land_ • Reduce energy and water use through the redesign and reprogramming of park uses. • Improve community health through the provision of more active recrea- tional uses and community gardens. • Improve community and neighborhood access to Kimball Park. • Better integrate the existing community center into the adjacent neighborhoods and schools, provide a community linkage along Paradise Creek between the park and other community and neighborhood desti- nations. 5-6 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINDINGS OF FACT AND STATEMENT OF OVERRIDING CONSIDERATIONS S I ATE ME NT OF OVERRIDING C ONS IDE RAT IONS • Better use under -serving park areas through redesign and introduction of new facilities. • Improve community and neighborhood access to El Toyon Park. • Provide a new fire station/community center that is integrated into the adjacent neighborhoods and school, offer a community linkage through and between the park, school, and other community and neighborhood destinations, and allow joint use of facilities with adjacent school sites. For the reasons described above, the benefits of the proposed Comprehensive Land Use Update outweigh its unavoidable adverse environmental effects, and consequently, the adverse environmental effects are considered "accept- able" in accordance with Section 15093(c) of the State CEQA Guidelines. 7 Exhibit "G" MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM This chapter provides a Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) for the National City Comprehensive Land Use Update in combination with the annual report required by Government Code 65400 (CEQA Guidelines Section 15097(b)). The purpose of the MMRP is to ensure the implementation of mitiga- tion measures identified as part of the environmental review for the project. The MMRP includes the following information: ♦ A list of mitigation measures; ♦ The party responsible for implementing the mitigation measures; ♦ The timing for implementation of the mitigation measure; ♦ The agency responsible for monitoring the implementation; and ♦ The monitoring action and frequency. The City of National City must adopt this MMRP, or an equally effective program, if it approves the Comprehensive Land Use Update with the mitigation measures that were adopted or made conditions of project approval. 6-1 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM Party Responsible Implementation Agency Responsible for Monitoring Monitoring Mitigation Measures for Implementation Timing Monitoring Action Frequency Air Quality AQ-1: The proposed Comprehensive Land Use Update includes numerous policies aimed at reducing vehicle travel through land use planning, encouraging alternatives modes of transportation and use of project level review to reduce air pollutant emissions from vehicle travel. Development Services Department Ongoing and during subsequent project - level CEQA review City of National City 11Q-24: Dust Suppression. The following enhanced dust control measures shall be required by the City as part of the project enti- dement process in order to contra] fugitive dust emissions during construction and shall be incorporated into Title 9, Health and Sanitation, of the Municipal Code. These measures are in addition to SDAPCD regulatory requirements that apply to construction projects. • Limit traffic speeds on unpaved roads to 15 mph. • Install sandbags or other erosion control measures to prevent silt runoff to public roadways. ♦ Replant vegetation in disturbed areas as quickly as possible. • Limit access to the construction sites, so cracking of mud or dirt on to public roadways can be prevented. If necessary, use wheel washers for all exiting trucks, or wash off the tires or tracks of all trucks and equipment leaving the site. Suspend excavation and grading activity when winds (instantane- ous gusts) exceed 20 mph or dust clouds cannot be prevented from extending beyond the site. Development Services Department 6-2' The City's Municipal Code will be revised within 24 months (Condition of ap- proval for interim applicable projects prior to adoption of the ordinance.)s City of National City Verification of policy implementa- tion and project - specific mitigation measures. Draft and adopt ordinance to amend the City's Municipal Code Ongoing Once CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Party Responsible Implementation Agency Responsible for Monitoring Monitoring Mitigation Measures for Implementation Timing Monitoring Action Frequency ,AQ-2b: Exhaust Emission Controls. Projects that have signiti- Development Services Department The City's Municipal City of National City Draft and adopt Once cant construction period exhaust emissions shall reduce fleet aver- Code will be revised ordinance to amend age emission rates. Developers or contractors shall provide a plan within 24 months the City's Municipal for approval by the City or SDAPCD demonstrating that the (Condition of ap- Code heavy-duty (>50 horsepower) off -road vehicles to be used in the proval for interim construction project for more than an accumulated 40 hours, in- applicable projects eluding owned, leased and subcontractor vehicles, will achieve prior to adoption of emission standards similar to m-use equipment that meets CARS the ordinance.) certified Tier II standards. AQ t: The proposed Comprehensive Land Use Update includes numerous policies aimed at reducing vehicle travel through land use planning, encouraging alternatives modes of transportation and use of project level review to reduce air pollutant emissions from vehicle travel. AO-4: The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, imple- mentation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.3-34 through 4.3-41 and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15, as modified in the Final EIR. Development Services Department Development Services Department Ongoing and during subsequent project - level CEQA review Ongoing and during subsequent project - level CEQA review City of National City City of National City Verification of policy implementa- tion and project: specificmitigation measures Verification of policy implementa- tion and project - specific mitigation measures Once Once AQ : The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, imple- mentation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" described in DEIR pages 4.3-34 through 4.3-41 and 4.3-1 through 4.3-15, as modified in the Final EIR. Development Services Department Ongoing and during subsequent project - level CEQA review City of National City Verification of policy implementa- tion and project. specific mitigation measures Once Biological Resources 6-3 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL ER MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures BIO-1: In order to reduce or avoid impacts to special status birds, and ensure project compliance with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3511, and 3513 of the Cali- fornia Fish and Game Code, site brosking, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation within 500 feet of any known migratory songbird nesting location will not he permitted during the spring/summer songbird breeding season, defined as from January 15,1 to August 31j, of each year. Limiting activities to the non - breeding season will minimize chances for the incidental take of migratory California gnatcatcher. In order to determine pres- ence/absence of California gnatcatchers, protocol surveys of suit- able areas of habitat (DCSS) on -site are required. These must be completed by an approved biologist in possession of a Section 10(a) Recovery Permit for this species. Should it be necessary to conduct brushing, grading, or other habitat -removal activities dur- ing the songbird breeding season, a pre -construction nesting sur- vey of all areas within 500 feet of the proposed activity will be required. If active nests are present on -site, the nests shall be mo- nitored until the birds have fledged and left the nest, prior to the commencement of construction activities. The results of the pre - construction survey will be provided in a report to the Ciry and the wildlife agencies for concurrence with the conclusions and rec- ommendations. BIO-2: Impacts to DCSS shall require mitigation at a minimum 2:1 ratio. Therefore, impacts to 1.2 acres of DCSS will require 2.4 acres of mitigation. This mitigation could occur on -site, via habitat creation and restoration in the Butterfly Garden and/or other areas of the site. In order for on -site habitat creation and restoration to be acceptable as DCSS mitigation, these activities would need to occur pursuant to a City and resource agencies r,CDFG, USFWS) approved Revegetation Plan. The Revegetation Plan would he implemented by the City and would require a methodology; for how to establish DCSS in that area. The Revegetation Plan would be required to comply with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act. Sire brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation within Party Responsible for Implementation City of National City/Project De- veloper for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan Implementation Timing Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits Agency Responsible for Monitoring City of National City De- velopment Services De- partment Monitoring Action Perform site in- spections,revieW protocol survey reports, and pre - construction survey reports to verify compliance; submit pre -construction survey report to City of National City, CDFG, and LISFWS for concur- rence with conclu- sions and recom- mendations; submit periodic reports as required. If active nests are found, submit periodic monitoring reports. Monitoring Frequency Once or if nesting birds found, peri- odic monitor- ing until fledg- lings have left the nest City of National City/Project De- veloper for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan 6-4 Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan pro- jects City of National City Submit Revegeta- don Plan to City of National City, CDFG and USFWS for approval, re- view; review peri- odic revegetation plan reports; per- form site inspec- tions to verify compliance Periodically, as defined in the Revegetation Plan CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING RROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures 500 feet of any known migratory songbird nesting location will not be permitted during the spring/ summer songbird breeding season, defined as from January 15,h to August 31,, of each year. BIO-3: Impacts to the DFWW shall require mitigation at a mini- mum 3:1 ratio in the following manner: at least 1:1 shall consist of wedands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands resto- ration/enhancement. For example, impacts to 0.8 acre of DFWW would require 2.4 acres of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site, via habitat creation and restoration activities in the on -site drainage. It should be noted that if these habitat restoration activities would result in any sig- nificant impacts, these impacts would be required to be analyzed and mitigated. Significant impacts associated with habitat restora- tion activities could include dredging in jurisdictional waters or wetlands, the removal of native vegetation, noise impacts to native wildlife during site preparation. In order for habitat restoration to be acceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Resource Agency -approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Such a plan would be implemented by the City and it would spec- ify methodology for habitat creation and restoration. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the securement of 2.4 acre - credits of FWW in an approved mitigation bank. Regulatory Agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on- or offsite restoration, although on -site mitiga- tion is encouraged. Hon -site mitigation is not available, offsite mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. Party Responsible for Implementation City of National City/Project De- veloper for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan pro- jects 6-5 Implementation Agency Responsible for Timing Monitoring Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits for construction of Las Palmas Park and facilities Vision Con- cept Plan City of National City Monitoring Action Submit Wetland Mitigation Plan to City of National City, USACE, CDFG, and RWQCB for ap- proval, review. For on -site mitigation, review periodic revegetation plan reports; perform site inspections to verify compliance. For offsite mitiga- tion, submit report verifying acquisition of approved mitiga- tion bank credits. Monitoring Frequency Periodically, as defined in the Wetland Miti- gation Plan; or once, for ac- quisition of mitigation bank credits for offsite mitigation. CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures • I0-4: Impacts to wetlands habitats, such as Non -Vegetated Channel (NVC) located in the middle of the existing golf course on the Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan site„ generally require mitigation at a 3:1 ratio. At least 1:1 of this typi- cally must consist of wetlands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.1-acre of NVC would require 0.3-acre of mitigation. Mitiga- tion for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site, via habitat creation and restoration activities in the on -site drainage. In order for these activities to be acceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Resource Agency - approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the securement of 0.3 acre -credits of NVC in an approved mitigation hank. The Regulatory Agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on - or off -site restoration, although on -site mitigation is encouraged. If on -site mitigation is not available, offsite mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. BIO-9: Impacts to Disturbed Southern Coastal Salt Marsh (DSCSM) , within Paradise Creek in the southern portion of the Kimball Park Master Plan site, require mitigation at a minimum 3:1 ratio. At least 1:1 of this ratio shall consist of wetlands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restora- tion/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.1-acre of DSCSM shall require 0.3-acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site, via the restoration of Paradise Creek, including the daylighting of the portion of the creek that is currently underground. The project's current conceptual design shows approximately 3.9 acres as being available for Paradise Creek improvements. In order for these improvements to be ac- ceptable as wetlands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Resource Agency -approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the securement of 0.0 acre -credits of SCSM in an approved wetland mitigation bank. Party Responsible for Implementation City of National Ciry/Project De- veloper for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan pro- jects. Implementation Timing Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits for construction of for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan pro- jects. Agency Responsible for Monitoring City of National City Monitoring Action Submit Wetland Mitigation Plan to City of National City, USACE, CDFG, and RWQCB for ap- proval, review. For on -site mitigation, review periodic revegetation plan reports; perform site inspections to verify compliance. For offsite mitiga- tion, ;submit report verifying acquistion of approved mitiga- tion bank credits, Monitoring Frequency Periodically, as defined in the Wetland Miti- gation Plan; or once, fur ac- quisition of mitigation bank credits for offsite mitigation. City of National City/Project De- veloper for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan pro- jects. 6-6 Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits City of National City Submit Wetland Mitigation Plan to City of National City, USAGE, CDFG, and RWQCB for ap- proval, review. For on -site mitigation, review periodic revegetation plan reports; perform site inspections to verify compliance. For offsite mitiga- tion, submit report verifying acquisition Periodically, as defined in the \Vetland Miti- gation Plan; or once, for ac- quisition of mitigation bank credits for offsite mitigation, CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTINGPROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures The Regulatory Agencies (USACE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on- or offsite restoration, al- though on -site mitigation is encouraged. If on -site mitigation is not available, offsite mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. $IO-6: Impacts to wetlands habitats, such as DF1(W located within Paradise Creek on the Kimball Park Master Plan site„ re- quire mitigation at a 3:1 ratio. At least 1:1 of this ratio shall consist of wetlands creation; the remaining 2:1 may consist of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.3-acre of DFWW shall require 0.9-acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur on -site. The project site has approximately 3.9 acres available for Paradise Creek improve- ments. In order for these improvements to be acceptable as wet- lands mitigation, they would need to be subject to a City and Re- source Agency -approved Wetland Mitigation Plan. Alternatively, mitigation could occur off -site, via the securement of 0.3 acre - credits of FWW in an approved wetland mitigation bank. The Regulatory Agencies (USAGE, CDFG, RWQCB) typically allow applicants to propose either on- or off -site restoration, although on -site mitigation is encouraged. If on -site mitigation is not avail- able, off -site mitigation within the same drainage basin is required. Party Responsible for Implementation City of National City/Project De- veloper for Kimball Park Master Plan Implementation Agency Responsible for Timing Monitoring Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits City of National City/CDFG Monitoring Action of approved mitiga- tion bank credits. Submit Wetland Mitigation Plan to City of National City, USACE, CDFG, and RWQCB for ap- proval, review. For on -site mitigation, review periodic revegetation plan reports; perform site inspections to verify compliance. For offsite mitiga- tion, submit report verifying acquisition of approved mitiga- tion bank credits. Monitoring Frequency Periodically, as defined in the Wetland Miti- gation Plan; or once, for ac- quisition of mitigation bank credits for offsite mitigation. BIO-7: Because the proposed Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vi- sion Concept Plan project will impact state wetlands and State and federal "waters," it may be necessary to obtain certain regulatory agency permits as a condition of project approval. To that end, it is required that the applicant provide to the City proof of notifica- tion of the ACOE and CRWQCB regarding Clean Water Act Sec - ion 404/401 Permits, or evidence that such notification is not required. Also required prior to project approval shall he proof provided to the City that the applicant has obtained a 1600-series Streambed Alteration Agreement with the CDFG, or proof that such an agreement is not required. City of National City/Project De- veloper for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan 6-7 Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits for construction of for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan pro- jects. City of National City Provide copies of CWA 404/401 and/or Fish and Game Code 1600 permits, or proof that such permits are not required Once prior to issuance of each demoli- tion, grading or building permit. CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL ER M I T I G A T I O N MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures (a) Mitigation for wetland impacts associated with improvements to Kimball Park will require a 1:1 ratio of wetlands creation and 2:1 ratio of wetlands restoration/enhancement. Therefore, impacts to 0.3 acre of DFWW would require 0.9 acre of mitigation and im- pacts to 0.1 acre of DSCSM would require 0.3 acre of mitigation. Mitigation for impacts to these habitat -types could occur onsite, via the restoration of Paradise Creek or offsite through contribu- tion to an approved mitigation bank. Because the proposed Kimball Park Master Plan project will im- pact State wetlands and State and federal "waters," it will likely be necessary to obtain certain regulatory agency permits as a condition of project implementation. To that end, it is required that the applicant provide to the City proof of notification of the ACOE and CRWQCB regarding Clean Water Act Section 404/401 Per- mits, or evidence that such notification is not required. Also re- quired prior to project approval shall be proof provided to the City that the applicant has obtained a 1600-series Streambed Alteration Agreement with the CDFG, or proof that such an agreement is not required. (b; In order to reduce or avoid impacts to special status birds, and ensure project compliance with the Federal Migratory Bird Treaty Act and Sections 3503, 3503.5, 3511, and 3513 of the California Fish and Game Code, site brushing, grading, and/or the removal of vegetation within 500 feet of any known migratory songbird nesting location will not be permitted during the spring/summer song bird breeding season, defined as from January l5th to August 31 st of each year. Limiting activities to the non -breeding season will minimize chances for the incidental take of migratory song- birds. Should it be necessary to conduct brushing, grading, or other habi- tat -removal activities during the songbird breeding season, a pre - constriction nesting survey of all areas within 500 feet of the pro - Party Responsible for Implementation City of National City/Project De- veloper for Kimball Park Master Plan 6-8 Implementation Tirning Prior to issuance of demolition, grading or building permits for Kimball Park Master Plan Agency Responsible for Monitoring City of National City Monitoring Action (a) Provide copies ofCWA 404/401 and/or Fish and Game Code 1600 permits, or proof that such permits are hot required (b) Perform peri- odic site inspec- tions to verify compliance; submit preconstruction survey reports to City, CDFG and USFWS for concur- rence with conclu- sions and recom- mendations; if ac- tive nests are pre- sent, submit peri- odic monitoring reports Monitoring Frequency (a)Once for permits or evidence that permits are not re- quired; And (b) If nest- ing birds found, peri- odic moni- toring until fledglings have left the nest CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR M 'TIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures posed activity will be required. If active nests are present on -site, the nests shall be monitored until the birds have fledged and left the nest, prior to the commencement of construction activities. The results of the pre -construction survey will he provided in a report to the City and the wildlife agencies for concurrence with the conclusions and recommendations. Party Responsible for Implementation Implementation Agency Responsible for Timing Monitoring Monitoring Action Monitoring Frequency Hazards and Hazardous Materials HAZ-1: Implementation of a new General Plan Policy S-8.4 shall require proposed development to determine the applicability of preparing a Hazardous Materials Management Plan (HMMP), stormwater pollution prevention plan (SWPPP), Standard Urban Storm Water Mitigation Plan, (SUSWMP), Jurisdictional Urban Runoff Management Program (JURMP), stormwater Best Man- agement Practices, and additional site -specific assessment including research, file reviews, and or Phase I Environmental Assessments. City of National City Concurrent with Development Services project approval Department Verification of policy implementa- tion. Once Hydrology and Water Quality I-iYDRO-1: National City shall incorporate into its General Plan Policy CS-5.3 to require the City to regularly assess the adequacy of its storm sewer system to accommodate 100-year storm flows and develop and implement a prioritized plan to address identified capacity deficiencies to the MEP, HYDRO-2a: National City shall undertake a detailed hydrological study to assess the effects of proposed development on base flood elevations on the project site and in the surrounding area and to identify a range of measures sufficient to accommodate 100-year flood flows on site. Measures to accommodate flood flows could include creek modification and stormwater management BMPS such as bio-swales, retention ponds, and rain gardens, HYDRO-2b: National City shall incorporate feasible measures identified in the detailed hydrological study into the final project site design so as to ensure that, at a minimum, base flood elevation would not rise either on- or off -site. City of National City Project Developer for Senior Vil- lage Expansion 6-9 Concurrent with Development Services project approval Department During project re- Development Services view, prior to issu- Department ance of demolition, grading, or building permits for the Sen- ior Village Expan- sion Verification of policy implementa- tion. Undertake detailed hydrological study to assess effects of proposed develop- ment on base flood elevations; and perform periodic site inspections to verify implementa- tion of any required measures (BMPs) from the hydrologi- Once Once prior to issuance of demolition, During con- struction pe- riod CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING P R O G R A M TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures HYDRO-3a: National City shall undertake a detailed hydrological study to assess the effects of proposed development on base flood elevations on the project site and in the surrounding area and to identify a range of measures sufficient to accommodate 100-year flood flows on site. Measures to accommodate flood flows could include creek modification and stormwater management BMPS such as bio-swales, retention ponds, and rain gardens. 1-{ DRO-3b: National City shall incorporate feasible measures identified in the detailed hydrological study into the final project site design so as to ensure that, at a minimum, base flood elevation would nut rise either on- or off -site. Party Responsible for Implementation Implementation Timing Agency Responsible for Monitoring Monitoring Action cal study. Monitoring Frequency Project Developer for Las Palmas Park and Facilities Vision Concept Plan During project re- view, prior to issu- ance of demolition, grading, or building permits Development Services Department Perform periodic site inspections to verify compliance During con- struction pe- riod Land Use LL,1-1: The inclusion of policies to the General Plan related to development review would reduce impacts associated with con- flicts with the MSCP in the vicinity of the Planning area. The addi- tion of Policy OS-2.7 would ensure that potential impacts to bio- logical resources are carefully evaluated prior to approval of devel- opment projects. The addition of Policy OS-2.8 would ensure that development is consistent with all federal, State and regional regu- lations for habitat and species protection. Noise City of National City Concurrent with project approval Development Services Department Verification of policy implementa- tion. Once NOI-1: Implement Construction Noise Reduction Measures. Title 12 of the Municipal Code shall be amended to include the follow- ing standard construction noise reduction measures. • Equipment Sound Attenuation. All noise -producing construc- tion equipment and vehicles using internal combustion engines shall be equipped with mufflers, air -inlet silencers where appro- priate, and any other shrouds, shields, or other noise -reducing features in good operating condition that meet or exceed original factory specification. Mobile or fixed "package" equipment (e.g. Ciry of National City 6-10 The City's Municipal Code will be revised within 24 months (Condition of ap- proval for interim applicable projects prior to adoption of the ordinance.) Development Services Department Draft and adopt ordinance to amend the City's Municipal Code Once CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures arc welders, air compressors) shall be equipped with shrouds and noise control features that are readily available for that type of equipment. • Use of Electrical Equipment. Electrically powered equipment shall be used instead of pneumatic or internal combustion pow- ered equipment, where feasible. • Distance from Sensitive Receptors. Material stockpiles and mobile equipment staging, parking, and maintenance areas shall be located as far as practicable from noise -sensitive receptors. • Construction Traffic Speeds. Construction site and access road speed limits shall be established and enforced during the con- struction period. • Use of Noise -Producing Signals. The use of noise producing signals, including horns, whistles, alarms, and bells, shall be for safety warning purposes only. • Use of Public Address or Music Systems. No project -related public address or music system shall he audible at any adjacent sensitive receptor. • Noise Complaint Process. The on -site construction supervisor shall have the responsibility and authority to receive and resolve noise complaints. A clear appeal process to the owner shall he established prior to construction commencement that will allow for resolution of noise problems that cannot be immediately solved by the site supervisor. Party Responsible for Implementation Implementation Agency Responsible for Monitoring Monitoring Timing Monitoring Action Frequency NOISE-2: Implementation of new General Plan Policy NN-1.10 Development Services Department Prior to project ap- City of National City Verification of would call for a study to demonstrate that ground borne vibration proval policy implementa- issues associated with rail operations are adequately addressed for tion. new development within 100 feet from the centerline of the rail- road tracks. Once NOISE-3• De!oiird "Crack Survey." Prior to approval of final site design, any project proponent that would propose driving pilings or performing an action that could cause substantial vibrations shall perform a detailed "crack survey" before the startup of con - Development Services Deparuent 6-11 The City's Munici- pal Code will be revised within 24 months (Condition City of National City Draft and adopt ordinance to amend the City's Municipal Code Once CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND R E° O R T I N G PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Mitigation Measures stniction activities. If pile driving would he the source of these vibrations, prc foundation pile holes should be pre -drilled to the extent feasible to minimize the number of hammer strikes required to seat the pile. The survey may be done by photographs, video- tape, or visual inventory, and should include inside as well as out- side locations. All existing cracks and walls, floors, driveways, etc., should be documented with sufficient detail for comparison after construction to determine whether actual vibration damage has occurred. If damage is found, the project application would be required to compensate for such damages. Transportation and Circulation Party Responsible for Implementation Implementation Agency Responsible for Monitoring Monitoring Timing Monitoring Action Frequency of approval for in- terim applicable projects prior to adoption of the or- dinance. TRANS-1: The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, im- plementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" de- scribed in DEIR Table 4.13-12, and 4.13-6 through 4.3-10, and pages 4.13-46 through 4.13-69, as modified in the Final EIR. Development Services Department Ongoing and during subsequent project - level CEQA review City of National City TRANS-2: No mitigation required. As part of the County of San Diego's Draft General Plan Update, Sweetwater Road is planned as a four -lane facility in 2030. This would reduce im- pacts to a less -than -significant level in 2030. Between National City city limits (Plaza Bonita Center Way) and Willow Street has been identified as a roadway segment where LOS E or F is ac- ceptable, since adding travel lanes would result in adverse envi- ronmental impacts. As part of ongoing multi-jutisdictional programs such as Re- gional Arterial Management System (RAMS) and Traffic Light Synchronization Program (TSLP), the cities of National City and Chula Vista and Caltrans will continue to implement coordinated traffic signal tuning along the National City Boulevard/Broadway Avenue corridor to improve traffic flow and progression. These implementation measures will ensure that impacts associated with increased congestion levels are less than significant. Development Services Department 6-12 Ongoing City of National City Verification of policy implementa- tion and project - specific mitigation measures. Verification of policy implementa- tion Ongoing Ongoing Utilities and Service Systems CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE UPDATE FINAL EIR MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM TABLE 6-1 MITIGATION MONITORING AND REPORTING PROGRAM (CONTINUED) Party Responsible Implementation Agency Responsible for Monitoring Monitoring Mitigation Measures for Implementation Timing Monitoring Action Frequency TRANS-3: The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, im- Development Services Ongoing and during City of National City Verification of Ongoing plementation measures, and the "Regulatory Framework" de- Department subsequent project- policy implementa- scribed in DEIR Table 4.13-12, and 4.13-6 through 4.3-10, and level CEQA review lion and project - pages 4.13-69 through 4,13-78, as modified in the Final EIR. specific mitigation measures, UTILS-1: The project includes self mitigating goals, policies, im- plementation measures, and the `Regulatory Framework" de- scribed on DE1R pages 4.14-36 through 4.14-40, 4.14-45 through 4.14-46, as modified in the Final EIR. UTTT S-1. Adopt a new General Plan policy to require the City of National City shall conduct hydraulic modeling analysis to assess the impacts of the additional wastewater that would be generated with implementation of the Regulatory Changes and revise or re - prioritize the Recommended Capital Improvement Program con- tained in the SSMP as necessary in order to ensure that the City's wastewater collection system would have sufficient capacity to accommodate growth in the planning area, including the Devel- opment Proposals, through 2030. Development Services Department Development Services Department 6-13 Ongoing and during subsequent project - level CEQA review Adoption of the General Plan City of National City Verification of policy implementa- tion and project - specific mitigation measures. City of National City Perform hydraulic modeling analysis to assess the im- pacts of additional wastewater and revise or repriori- tize recommended Capital Improve- ment Program. Ongoing Once