The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutCC RESO 14,575RESOLUTION NO. 14,575 RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING EXECUTION OF AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AND R.W. BECK AND ASSOCIATES FOR APPRAISAL OF STREET LIGHTING PROPERTY OF SAN DIEGO GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of National City, California, that the City Manager is hereby authorized to execute an Agreement for Consulting Engineering Services for an Appraisal of the Street Lighting Property of San Diego Gas and Electric Company located in the City of National City, California. PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of March, 1985. ATTEST: CITY CLERK M Agreement for Consulting Engineering Services for an Appraisal of the Street Lighting Property of San Diego Gas and Electric Company Located in the City of National City, California Part I - Scope of Services Paragraph A Upon receipt of an executed copy of this Agreement and upon receipt of San Diego Gas and Electric Company's ("SDG&E") Detailed Street Light Maps and SDG&E's Aged Detailed Street Light Inventory List of the street lights (properties) located in National City ("City"), R. W. Beck and Associates ("Consultant") will: 1. Proceed with the detailed examination of data and documents per- taining to the Properties. 2. Prepare valuations for the street lighting property to he acquired based on the original cost less depreciation and reproduction cost new less depreciation concepts. 3. Comment upon other recent transactions in which street lighting equipment was acquired by a municipality in California or in selected other states. 4. Prepare a valuation report in draft form setting forth the value estimates of the Properties as of December 31, 1984 (Valuation Date), together with suitable supporting data, findings and conclu- sions resulting from the foregoing studies and determinations of elements of value and submit the letter report in confidence to the City's Attorney or other designated person. 5. Meet once with the City and formalize the above draft report and formulate an opinion of the fair cash value of the Properties based upon those studies. 6. Submit 5 copies of the executed report to the City's Legal Counsel. Paragraph B When directed by the City to proceed, the Consultant will: 1. Confer with the City's legal counsel and prepare such exhibits as may he suggested by counsel in preparation for meeting with offi- cials of SDG&E. Page 2 2. Attend meetings designed to resolve differences of opinions and leading to a mutually acceptable value of the Properties. 3. Prepare written direct testimony and exhibits as required for sub- mission to the appropriate court in defense of the opinion of value. 4. Attend court sessions and testify in support of opinion of value. 5. Perform such other services as may be requested by counsel for the City, including a review of briefs. Part II - Compensation For services rendered pursuant to Part I, Paragraph A, above, the City shall pay the Consultant, upon submission of an invoice following submis- sion of the draft of the valuation report, a fee of $7,500. This cost esti- mate is predicated upon the City furnishing to the Consultant SDG&E's Aged Detail Street Light Inventory List containing information and data similar to information on Attachment 1, and SDG&E's Detailed Street Light Maps or other maps showing the location of street lights. The above cost estimate will he in effect through March 31, 1985. For services rendered pursuant to Part I, Paragraph B, above, the City shall pay the Consultant, upon submission of monthly invoices, an amount equal to the actual hours of service furnished multiplied by the product of the Consultant's established Hourly Salary Cost which includes an allowance for personnel benefits, and a factor of 2.6. In addition, the City shall reimburse the Consultant each month at cost for all out-of-pocket expenses directly chargeable to the work and for computer and reproduction facilities at the Consultant's then current rates. Part III The Consultant's Standard Provisions, Attachment 2, are made a part of this Agreement. Part IV - Special Provisions Paragraph A - Time of Performance The Consultant estimates a time requirement of approximately 75 days to provide services of Part I, Paragraph A, and preparation of the letter report. Unless otherwise advised, the Consultant will con- sider this document, when executed and one copy returned, as notice to proceed with Part I, Paragraph A, and the letter report scheduled for completion within 75 days following receipt of the data requested from the City. No time estimate can he made for those services that may be performed pursuant to Part I, Paragraph B. Page 3 Paragraph B — Qualifications to Perform Services The Consultant represents that he is qualified to furnish the services contemplated herein and as evidence thereof, warrants that one or more members of the Firm are professional engineers registered to practice in the State of California, are members of the American Society of Appraisers and that the services provided under this Agreement will be performed by them or under their direction. Paragraph C — Acceptance Provisions The City may signify its acceptance of this Agreement by returning one executed copy to the Consultant within sixty (60) days. Dated this J r1-1- day of jl'1 ;L 1, / , 1985. CITY OF NATIONAL CITY ATTEST: R. W. BECK AND ASSOCIATES By: NORMAN A. HILL Partner and Manager Sacramento Office APPROVED AS TO FORM CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE By: AGED CAMP - CA628-300 STREET LIGHT DETAIL LIST 08/10/84 21-8997-7141-01 00 LDC HR 1052500 1055003 1053590 1054000 1054500 1055003 1055500 1056000 1056500 1057000 1057500 10558000 1055500 1059000 1059500 1060001 1060500 1051000 1061500 1062000 1062500 1063000 1065500 1064000 1064500 1065000 1065500 1066000 1066500 1067000 1067500 1068000 1068500 1069000 1069500 1070000 1070500 1071000 1071500 1072000 1072500 1073000 1073500 —1074000 1074500 1075000 1075500 1076000 1076500 1077000 1077500 —107e000 RATE LAMP lUM SVC HTO FAC DEI 7H MR DE1 7M MR LS1A 7m MR DE1 7M MR LS1A 7m MR 151A 7M MR 1514 7m OV15 MR 6 LSIA 7M 0V15 MG 6 DEI 7H MR CEI 7M MR LSIA 7m MR DEI 7M MR DEI 7M MR 1S1A 7M MR DEI 2071 MG 151A 20M MG H 6 DEI 20M MG LSIA 71i MG 6 LSIA 7M MR 0 DE1 7M MR 0 1514 7M OY15 MR 6 LSIA 7M OV15 MG 116 151A 7M MG DEI 7m MG DE1 7m MG 0Sl4 7M MG LSIA 7M MG LSIA 105 TIH N 6 DEI 7M HO DEI 7m MG LSIA 105 MN U 6 1SIA SOS M0 DEI SOS MO I LSIA SOS MO DEI 50S MG I DEI 50S MG 1 LS1A 50S MO 0 151A 505 MG 1SIA SOS MO LS1A 50S MO DEI S05 MG 151A SOS MG 16 DEI 50S MO LS1A 50S MO DE1A 505 MG U 6 DEI SOS MG DEI S05 MG DEI 505 MO LSIA SOS MG LSIA 7M MR 6 DE1 SOS MG 0 DE1 505 M0 BURN POLE MR LOCATIOII 060181 610539 CURRY COMB H/0 CONCHA 85' 060181 610541 CURRY COMB WO COIICHA 425' 000069 610545 CURRY COMB Q MARTIIIGALE 5/N 060181 610545 CURRY CUM6 N/0 M4RIIIIGAIE 375' 000069 610546 CURRY COMB 11/0 MARTTIIGALE 660' 000069 610542 CURRY COMB S/0 11ARTIIIGAIE 270' 000067 511647 DEI ROY Q ROUF.UA 000066 511645 DEL ROY 2 1111U OAKS VALLEY 060181 612392 DISCOVERY 0/0 VIA VERA CRUZ 240' 060181 612393 DISCOVERY E/0 VIA VERA CRUZ 480' 000071 615341 DISCOVERY 7 MCMAHR 060181 615342 DISCOVERY N/O MCMAHR 445' 060181 613343 DISCOVERY 14/0 MCMAHR 890' 000071 613344 DISCOVERY WO MCMAHR 1290' 060181 613345 DISCOVERY NiIrO LA SOMpRA 125' 04D163 615546 DISCOVERY Hu/0 LA SOMBRA 400' 060181 613347 DISCOVERY H11/0 LA 50MBR4 685' 112080 218597 D15COVCRY ST a SAIL PIARCOS 81 112000 612394 DISCOVERY ST E/0 VIA VERA CRUZ 720' 112080 612595 DISCOVERY ST E/0 VIA VERA CRUZ 970' 000067 410037 FIREBIRD GOSIIEII 000066 419935 FIREBIRD 2 MISSIOII 000069 611126 FIREBIRD RICHIIAR 060181 617078 FUITOrl RD 11/0 BEIUIETT RD 445' 060)81 6)7079 fU11OU RD H/0 DEUIIETT RD 845' 0000/4 516592 FU11011 RD E/0 QUIET MILLS DR 450' 000074 115606 FUITOH RD N/O QUIET HILLS DR 250' 040183 615561 GLEPIIIEAIIIER DR 2 HAZEN DR 060181 615562 GLEUHEATUER DR 11/0 H4Z111 DR 250' 060181 615563 GLEIIHCATHER DR II/0 HAZEr1 DR 475' 120480 514555 G0S11ELL HY 0/0 FIREBIRD ST 7 CDS 000077 213023 GRAND AV E/0 BENT AV 170' 060181 717381 GRAM) AV 0/0 BE11i AV 360' 000077 515506 GRAIID AV E/0 DE)11 AV 540' 060181 GRAND AV E/0 DENT AV 720' 060181 GRAIID AV E/0 HMI AV 1080' 071283 717383 GRAND AV E/0 BELIT Av 1260' 000077 213024 GRA110 AV ➢ 8ENT/LIN04 VISTA OR VS DODO)) 213475 GRA110 AV H/0 1071DA VISTA DR 200' 000077 213476 GRAND AV N/0 L111DA VISTA DR 430' 060181 613302 GRAND AV H/O LIIIDA VISTA DR 630' 000077 517641 GRAND AV 0 LOS POSAS RD NH 060181 615153 GRAIID AV H/0 LOS POSAS RD 890' 000071 615129 GRAIID AV 7 PACIFIC ST 11E 040I8S 615130 GRAIID AV E/0 PACIFIC ST 150' 060181 615131 GRAIID AV E/0 PACIFIC Si 225' 0601e1 615152 GRAIID AV E/0 PACIFIC ST 350' 060181 611518 GRAND AV M/0 PACIFIC ST 160' DODO)) 813448 GR4UD AV Q SAN MARCOS IL SN 030 I6S 30547 GRAND 5/0 SAIL HARMDL 200` 078783 CRA170 AV 1-4/0 SAH MARCOS BE 400E 060181 116390 GRAND AV 14/0 SAN MARC05 Bl 640E CO71ST SL 0 27545 22545 12500 22545 12500 12500 10673 9259 22545 22545 13741 22545 22545 15741 22545 25051 22545 22355 22353 22555 10673 10675 10933 22545 22545 16320 36320 25031 22545 22545 21642 18452 22545 18452 22545 22545 25652 18452 18452 18452 22545 184526 22545 18452 24969 22545 22545 22545 18452 24826 25632 22545 ATTACHMENT 1 Page 2 of 2 STREET LICHT DETAIL REPORT CODE KEY FIELD TITLE FIELD DESCRIPTION LOC NR Computer Location RATE Applicable Tariff Schedule LAMP SIZE Numeric Value = Nominal Lumen Output in Thousands Alpha Value = M = Mercury Vapor S = HPSV LUM Manufacturers Luminaire Model SVC Service M = Multiple (Secondary) S = Series BAL Ballast Type G = Regulator H = Reactor (HPSV) 0 = Series — R = Reactor (MV) X = Regulator Billed as Reactor (t• MTG Pole Type U = Wood Distribution Pole 1-9= Number of Non -Standard Poles C = Center Suspension ARM Bracket or Mast Arm Length FAC Facilities Charge if Appropriate BURN DATE Date Current Lamp Energized POLE NR Pole Number LOCATION Descriptive Location CONST Installing Construction Order Number SLO Street Light Order Number (Initiates Billing) SLR NUM Maintenance Number (Recent Addition) WFD:ca 11-08-83 • R\Vfl-2u9:•: ATTACHMLNI 2 R. %V. BECK AND ASSOCIATES PART III — STANDARD PROVISIONS III.A. Consulting Engineer's Organizations R. W. Beck and Associates is a partnership and R. W. Beck and Associates, Inc. is a corpora- tion owned and controlled by the partnership. Both entities are organized and operated under the laws of the State of Washington. It is expressly agreed that the partnership may be changed by addition or reduction in the number of the partners or redis- tribution of the partnership interests and this Agreement may be assigned to the partnership or to the corporation. The Consulting Engineer may as- sign the compensation from this Agreement to any other entity. III.B. Professional Services 1. The Consulting Engineer shall be consul- tant and advisor to the Client as an independent contractor and shall not be an employee of the Cli- ent. The Consulting Engineer shall not be an agent or representative of the Client except that the Consulting Engineer may act as the Client's agent in providing construction management services to the degree specifically authorized in Part IV - Special Provisions of this Professional Services Agreement. 2. The Consulting Engineer represents that the services furnished under this Agreement will be in accordance with generally accepted professional practices. Any estimate of cost of equipment, con- struction, ownership or operation furnished by the Consulting Engineer shall be the Consulting Engi- neer's opinion based upon its professional judgment and experience. The Consulting Engineer makes no other representation or warranty, express or im- plied. III.C. Change in Scope and Delays 1. 1f the provisions for payment in this Agreement provide for a fixed fee or a maximum pay- ment for services, such fee or maximum is for the Scope of Services described in the Agreement. If the Scope of Services is modified so that more or less work or time is required, and such modifica- tion is approved by the Client and the Consulting Engineer, the fee or maximum and the time shall be equitably adjusted. 2. In the event of delays in or failures of performance of the Consulting Engineer caused by circumstances beyond its control, the Consulting Engineer's fee or maximum and the time allowed shall be equitably adjusted, and such delays or failures shall not constitute a default or give rise co any claim against the Consulting Engineer. III.D. Relating to Payment 1. The Consulting Engineer's "Salary Costs" allow for basic salary and personnel benefits, including: life, accident and medical insurance; sick leave, holiday and vacation, pay; social secur- ity, workers' compensation, unemployment compensa- tion and pension retirement contributions; and sim- ilar employment -related costs. Basic salary per hour shall be twelve times current monthly salary for employees or current monthly drawings in lieu of salary for partners, exclusive of overtime, bonus or other profit participation payments, divided by 2,080. 2. The Consulting Engineer's "Out -of -Pocket Expenses" are those expenditures made by the Con- sulting Engineer, other than Salary Costs, costs of reproduction and computer systems and costs of Spe- cial Consultants and Subcontractors, which are di- rectly chargeable to the project and which would not otherwise have been incurred. Such expendi- tures include, but are not limited to, transporta- tion, lodging, subsistence, communications, liabil- ity and other insurance premiums when required by the Client in addition to the types and amounts currently carried by the Consulting Engineer, taxes other than those levied on the profits or net in- come of the Consulting Engineer, equipment rentals and repair, and special mailing, forms, materials and supplies required during the progress of the work. Reimbursement for out-of-pocket expenses shall be an amount equal to the cost thereof. 3. In event of the inability or failure of the Client to pay as agreed, interest commencing sixty days after the date of invoice shall be paid by the Client to the Consulting Engineer on the last day of each month on all unpaid amounts due the Consulting Engineer at the interest rate for borrowed funds then currently available to the Con- sulting Engineer at the Rainier National Bank of Seattle. III.E. Insurance The Consulting Engineer shall maintain in effect, to the extent that such insurance is avail- able at reasonable cost, employer's liability, professional liability, comprehensive general lia- bility (bodily injury and property damage) and com- prehensive automobile liability (bodily injury and property damage) insurance with respect to employ- ees and vehicles of the Consulting Engineer as- signed to the prosecution of work under this Agree- ment, with each policy having maximum limits of not less than $5,000,000, and statutory workers' com- pensation protection. Upon written request, the Consulting Engineer will supply to the Client a R. W. BECK AND ASSOCIATES PART III - STANDARD PROVISIONS description of each such insurance policy currently in effect, specifying the amount thereof. The Con- sulting Engineer will obtain and thereafter main- tain in effect, if reasonably available, such ad- ditional insurance as may be requested by the Client, the cost of which shall be reimbursed by the Client. III.F. Liability 1. The Consulting Engineer shall indemnify and hold harmless the Client and its governing board, officers, employees and servants from all sums for which it is finally determined that the Consulting Engineer has legal liability, following operation of applicable rights of contribution, arising out of acts, errors or omissions of the Consulting Engineer in furnishing services pursuant to this Agreement; provided, however, such indemni- fication and hold harmless shall not exceed the sum of the amounts paid to or on behalf of the Consult- ing Engineer as the proceeds of any applicable insurance plus the deductible amount of such insur- ance. 2. The Client shall indemnify and hold harm- less the Consulting Engineer, its partners, offi- cers, employees, subcontractors and servants from all sums for which it is finally determined the Client has legal liability, following operation of applicable rights of contribution, arising out of acts, errors or omissions of the Client relating to the construction, use, occupancy, ownership, operation, maintenance or control of facilities related to services to be performed under this Agreement. 3. The Client shall limit any and all claims of the Client against the Consulting Engineer, its partners, officers, employees, subcontractors or servants, to an amount not to exceed (a) the amounts paid to or on behalf of the Consulting Engineer as the proceeds of any applicable insur- ance plus the deductible amount of such insurance or (b) S250,000, whichever is greater. 4. In partial but specific consideration of the execution of this Agreement by the Consulting Engineer, it is agreed that for amounts neither reimbursed by nor within the deductible amount of the insurance maintained by the Consulting Engi- neer, the Client shall indemnify the Consulting Engineer, its partners, officers, employees, sub- contractors and servants against all expense or liability of any kind arising out of any claim for loss of life, bodily or personal injury, property damage or other loss from any cause related to the furnishing of the services covered by this Agree- ment, except the sole negligence of the Consulting Engineer. 5. The Client and the Consulting Engineer shall not be liable to each other in any event for consequential damages, including but not limited to: interest (except as otherwise provided); loss of anticipated revenues, earnings or profits; in- creased expense of operations; or loss by reason of shutdown or non -operation due to late completion or otherwise. 6. In the event of any payment of any kind by or on behalf of either party to this Agreement un- der the provisions of this paragraph entitled "Liability" to or on behalf of the other party, the paying party shall be subrogated to the extent of the amount of such payment to all rights and reme- dies of the other party against any third party regarding any matter to which such payment is per- tinent. III.G. Suspension or Termination of Services The Client or the Consulting Engineer may suspend or terminate any or all services covered in this Agreement at any time upon written notice in which event the Client shall pay the Consulting Engineer upon submission of invoices for all services rendered and expenses incurred to the effective date of such suspension or termination. III.H. Construction Contractor's Performance and Safety The Consulting Engineer shall not be responsible: for safety on the Client's premises or project site, except for the safety of personnel of the Consulting Engineer, its Special Consultants and Subcontractors; for providing or assuring a safe place for the performance of the construction contractor's work; for safety precautions, programs or equipment; for construction means, methods, techniques, sequences or procedures; or for the construction contractor's failure to perform the work in accordance with the Contract Documents. III.I. Disposition of Documents 1. Upon completion of the services provided under this Agreement, the Consulting Engineer shall deliver to the Client one copy of all Reports, Spe- cifications and Contract Documents and one trans- parency of each of the Drawings. The originals of all Reports, Specifications, Drawings and Contract Documents shall be retained by the Consulting Engineer and upon request by the Client, the Con- sulting Engineer will furnish copies to the Client at actual cost of duplication and mailing. If such Reports, Specifications, Drawings or Contract Docu- ments or reproductions thereof, or any other items III-2 N R. W. BECK AND ASSOCIATES PART III — STANDARD PROVISIONS relating to the services of the Consulting Engineer are changed in any way or used by the Client for any other project or purposes, the Client shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the Consulting Engineer from all loss, damage, liability or ex- pense arising out of such changes or use. 2. All computer programs, computer code and documents related thereto ("computer software") developed by or used by the Consulting Engineer in conjunction with the Consulting Engineer's work hereunder shall remain the sole and exclusive prop- erty of the Consulting Engineer, and the Client shall have no right or title to or interest in such computer software. In the event the Consulting Engineer releases any such computer software to the Client, the Client shall protect the confiden- tiality of such computer software and shall not release or divulge such computer software to any other person or organization or let any other per- sons or organization use such computer software. In the event Client uses any such computer software or allows such computer software to be used by others, the Client shall indemnify and hold harm- less the Consulting Engineering from all loss, damage, liability or expense arising out of such use. II1.J. Equal Opportunity The Consulting Engineer will not knowingly discriminate against any employee or applicant for employment because of age, race, color, religion, sex, national origin, marital or veteran status or physical handicap. The Consulting Engineer will take affirmative action to the end that applicants are employed, and that employees are treated during employment, without such discrimination. III.K. Severability and Headings 1. If any part of this Agreement, including, but not limited to, any provision, paragraph, clause, phrase or words, is found to be in conflict with applicable laws, such part shall be inopera- tive, null and void insofar as it is in conflict with said laws, but the remainder shall be given full force and effect. 2. The descriptive headings used in this Agreement have been inserted for convenience of reference only and shall in no way modify or re- strict any of the terms ■nd provisions of this Agreement. III.L. Notice All notices relating to this Agreement shall be in written form delivered in person or by Express Hail, Registered or Certified United States Mail, postage prepaid, to the Consulting Engineer or to the Client to the attention of its chief executive officer at the last business address of the principal office of the addressee known to the sender. - END OF PART III - 11I-3 ATTACHMENT 3 R. H. Beck and Associates CURRENT RANGE OF HOURLY SALARY COSTS Effective May 1, 1984 Current Range of Hourly Grade Title Salary Costs(*) 1 Clerk, Stenographer, Aide $ 5.58 - $17.84 2 Assistant Secretary, Assistant Fieldman, Assistant Draftsman, Assistant Draftsvoman; Senior Clerk, Senior Stenographer, Senior Aide 6.55 - 15.00 3 Assistant Programmer, Assistant Technician, Assistant Designer, Accounting Clerk; Secretary, Fieldman, Draftsman, Draftsvoman 7.70 - 17.79 4 Assistant Engineer, Assistant Analyst, Assistant Scientist, Assistant Economist, Assistant Statistician; Programmer, Technician, Designer, Assistant Accountant; Senior Secretary, Senior' Fieldman, Senior Draftsman, Senior Draftsvoman 9.04 - 20.69 5 Engineer, Analyst, Scientist, Economist, Statistician; Senior Programmer, Senior Technician, Senior Designer, Accountant; Supervising Secretary, Supervising Fieldman, Supervising Draftsman, Supervising Draftsvoman 10.61 -- 24.34 6 Senior Engineer, Senior Analyst, Senior Scientist, Senior Economist, Senior Statistician; Supervising Programmer, Supervising Technician, Supervising Designer, Supervising Accountant; Senior Supervising Secretary 12.43 - 28.54 7 Supervising Engineer, Supervising Analyst, Supervising Scientist, Supervising Economist, Supervising Statistician 14.55 - 33.38 8 Principal Engineer, Principal Analyst, Principal Scientist, Principal Economist, Principal Statistician 17.27 - 39.67 9 Executive Engineer, Executive Analyst, Executive Scientist, Executive Economist 20.62 - 47.18 10 Partner, Executive Engineer, Executive Analyst, Executive Scientist, Executive Economist 30.51 - 43.17 11 Partner, Executive Engineer, Executive Analyst, ( Hourly Salary` Executive Scientist, Executive Economist ( Costs of ( Partners range 12 Partner, Executive Partner, Chief Consulting Engineer, ( from $37.21 - Chief Design Engineer ( $57.09 as ( provided by 13 Managing Partner, Chief Engineer ( Partnership ( action. (•) - Including allowance of 29Z for personnel benefits. _ Dote: The above "Range of Hourly Salary Costs" is that currently in effect for the Firm and may be modified, taking into account the demand for tine difi.Erent grades of ;.ersvnne2 ar..d ellrnges im 3be+sss1'af lavistg_ APPRAISAL ►trrltlr.Mct of IJ 0W O. Sr►NC/R, AssOCtATE R. V. BECK AxD ASSOCTATES July 1911, (With Special Ref to Arprmi.als of Electric oletributlon Properties) i em .apinyed l'y R. V. Peck and Associate.. Pneino.r. end Con- adltanta, with k 1 office. and V•atern ..atonal Office in Seattle, VAAhInptnn. R. V. Peck and Ammoniate. maintain. a Central R.Rlnn 'lflic• In D.nve►, Colorado: and branch office. In Cnl,amha., Mehra...a: PMhenit, ArI[nn*l orlandn, elorlde: Wellesley, Ma.aarhuartta; Indian- apAlt., Indiana: Minnraroll., Mlnnranta and S mrnto, California. Thllrr arc rrreently cpprntlmat.ly 550 Penton., employed by R. V. Perk and Ammnelate. In Its nine office*. Theme employer. Include ens! of all dlaclrllnr■ .ngarinp In all types of con.nitinr and dralRn aerv- Irta for ruhlle I,t111ty ellrnt.. Cnn.ultlnp Service*, the dlvl.nn In ,Mich I have Men rmploy►d for 20 yearn, include. management etndlee, ;eilndfe •nalneerinp ■arv•ya and reports, eyaten planning and npera- tlAnel etudle., budgeter) control advice, f►aplblllty reporte and finenrtng studies, syate, load and reenuree studies, otility con- trlet., rate studies, regulatory ttm mia.fon ratter., tearsunity plan- AINR mud development and en Important ..Resent of the Plre'■ ennauttlnp ertivltlew hen heen in the field of utility velu.tion and report t•.tl- enhy for tam end other purpose.. Utility epprateel work le perform.d udder the supervielon of three peranna In the fire, all of whin are rr6fe.s(o19.1 en.in►•r., repleterel In I atate., and have m•mher- .hlp In the Aneriean Society of Apprai.rrat Mr. Cordon P. Jorgensen of our Phoenie Office, Mr. Robert C. Taylor of the V.11e.ley Office arwl ry.elf of the Seattle Office. since 1955 1 have ►ri mged 1n or supervised in ever** of IO0 utility apprcleAle in 22 elate. with an apgreget• arprelsed value in eaten* of SI.0 billion. All of these eppratacle have h.en to the f101d of public utilities mod gone were related to wore than ono tyre ,t utility rroretty. Snore of them• utility appraisals have been pre- -4ted for the Central SrrviN• Ad.in(atretlnn of the United Statea Cniternmentl Mint. 1959 I have been on an approved list of CSA utility epbtataers. .1 Am a student of civil enpineerinp et the Univerelty of Veal,- lARton, '1 pursued a court.* In hydraulic* and received formal edncetton In hy(1reullre, hydraulic machinery, tine! and IrrlyatInn structure deill►n and Realm.), recelvina a A.S. D•Rree In Civil Enpine.rinp In 141'0. I have been r►Rlstered a* a profesalonal Civil engineer in the Stele of V.shlatton mince 195A and am currently replat►red also ma a prbfesaiooal en►Ineer In Ar(rona, Alaska, Florida, Minnesota, Oregon, IU4alt, Ma.eachueetta And Virpinta. 1 have been a m•ahrr of tA. Median Snelety of Civil ?nRI- nSere einCe I940 and here indicated a cr.elalty interest In hydraulics sad power. ruhlitatinn. 1n lb... ten field* are mailed to me p•rind- Itally and I have r.c.Iv.d "Tr,tnsaetlrne annually alnr! 1949. "Trans- atttonm" contains nn-.rnue technical parr. and dt.cu..tnna In all -2- ►ollnvlop satlafartory completion of an •leht-hone •va.ln.- tinn, I attained mr current 'rode of S.nlnr M►mAer of the M.rir.n Society of Appraiser., which membership enable. me to receive the hl-.nnthly t.,blir.tlnm "Technlral Yeluatlnn" and the "App►■l..1 .nA Vail uatlnn Manul" vhlrh rntrently tnnalsta Of wino enl,.m.s, unrh of which la directly related to public utility appraisal procedure end ethical conduct of member.. I entered the employ of R. V. Reck end Aegoefetee In /ebru.ry 195) and have horn contlnun„aly employed by R. V. Rock end Aesocletee mince that ditto. Prlrf project Arecriptlone which follow are r.rent electric utility appraisal esaflnmenta In which I have participated .o an employer of R. V. Peek and Aasnclet•a. Year Leeatlen Owner 1013 DMRhton, MAe Pall River electric Co. 101A 1971 197A 1975 1916 19)6 1976 1176 1976 1917 1977 1977 Till River, MA' Sem.ra.t, MAe Chapel M111, MC Fitchburg, MA' Page, AZ Caine.ville, rt. Quonset, RI Remark, tM Redding, CA Bushnell, 11. Quincy, ►L Lynn, MA/ 197A Online, MM 197R Pranklin, MAm Montano electric Co. Pall R1+er Electric Co. Vele. of North Carolina PltehhurR ca. A Electric Light Arlrnn. Ibhlie Servlre Co. City of CaIn•a.ilte U.S. Government City of Newark Pacific Cam and Electric Co. Bushnell Electric Pepartmnnt Quincy Electric Department Maaa.chumetts Electric Co. Callon Electric neparte.nt Maaaachu.etta Electric Co. Appreiae1 Property Tatra Property Tato. Property Tav►s Acquisition - Tntel Client Auseasore of M Rhtnn Aa.►asore of Pell River Assessor* of $omerect Connne ra Uti!. Corp. Property A f Co. *few Pitch M,rR Acquisition Town of Peg. - Partial Property Recording Sale - Partial Rate Paa• Ac'ulaltIon - Partial Property RrtnrdlnR Property RrtnrdlnR Property Yaw City of CAlee.vtlle Con. Sore. Adak. City of Newark City of Peddlnp Cite of !nehmell City of Ninny As■.*.ore of Lynn Property City of ...cording Gallup Property A - Arrrala.d fnr ad valorem tea p ron.ee In behalf of the Franklin -3- tear 197,1 1978 1979 Location owner N a, NY Niagara -Mohawk rover Corp. SprinRfitld, VT Central V►r..nnt rub. Sera. Co. Renton Cdleon Co. 1979 /ltchhnre Cs* 4 Electric Light 1079 Rev Redford Ca. and Cd1.on Light Co. 1079 Vbltefleld, 1R1• Pub. Serv. Co. of New Hampshire Somerville, MA" fItchburg, MAa Thisbury, NA' 19RO Lynn, MA• 1911 Somerville, MA" 1981 Starke, PL I9RI Nevtonl itA• 19R1 fernpn.11np Reach, FL 19111 Harrt.en- burgl VA 19R1 Harrlann- hurs. VA I9R1 ►ranklin, NH 6 6 Towne 19R7 Anchorage, AR Ma,.schiaette Electric Co. Roston Gilson Co. Starke Electra Department Roston Ldleon Co. florid. Public Utlittle. Co. ArPrafeal Client Aelulalttoo rartlal Aequlaltlnn - Partial Property Tries Property Co. Tame. Property late. Property Taus Property Tates Virginte ►lettrlt and Power Co. Shensndnah Valley Electric Coop. Pub. Sere. Co. of Nev Ilmnpahlre Chugach ►leetrle Ai.anelatInn 19R1 Mew Redford, MAa Co*..nnvaalth Elec- tric Cn. I9A1•1D MA Municipal Light Department 19711 19A) 14113 I9A7 Nine), MAa Quincy, MAe Springfield, MAR Ithl to 'mot, NM Masaschneette Electric Co. New England Paver. Co. ve.tern Maaa.el.u- .efts Elec. Co. Alb. Ser.. Co. of New Metlen Property Taee, Property Recording Property Tate. Acquisition - Partial Acquisition - Partial Acquisition - Partial Property Tatra Aeiol.itIon - Partial Property Tapes Sale - Partlal Property Tare. Property Yates Property Tries Acgnleitlon ' - Partiai Town of M Town of Springfield A000000va of Sn*ervIlle A f rttehharg Apa...nr. of P... h u r 7 Selectmen of Vhltelleld Asn.ssore of Lynn A.ariaors of Snm•rvllip City of Starke A f Newton City of I dins Reach barriannhnrR Elec. row... HurtIannhurg ►ice. Cowes. Select•►n of Town* Municipal Light end rower A Mew Redford Town of if Asvasors of Quincy A f Rinser, Apa►aanrp of Sprinpfl.ld Cr•.nty of Ina Alanns Since I989 T have teatlfl.d In 10 ra.e. in which utility valu- atlnna were at (rev. Tana. rases pertaining to electric dlatrf...t1on property are a. fnllnwat In 1973 I testified before the State of Vaehington, loard of Tait Appeals, In behalf of the a..easore of eight Vsahingtnn At lassie wall the wanner In whlrh the perennal property of all 0111- ties vas centrally valued, d and egaall►ed by the M psi1went of Revenue. To 197h, I testified In the County Court, St. live.ne. County, Now Tnrk In behalf of the Town of MA.nene In s..ppnrt of •r appraisal of the electric utility prnp•rtle. of Mlaaara-Mohawk Power Cnoonny located within the Town of M In 197R, 1 testified In the Superior Court, State of Callfor- n1e, for Santa Cr,., Co.inty in behalf of Santa Con Count7. The te.tf- wnn7 sine isaed upon •7 snslyalt of the franchise tacos payable hi Pacific Cos and Electric Company to Sant. Crime County. Tn 1979. 1 testified before the Cnodewn.tlnn Cnewlu.tnn of the Stat. of Mew York. St. lavrenre Cnnnty Court In support of or eppralsal of the etertrlc dl.trthutlon property of Niagara-Mnhsv* Paver Corporation nerving the Town of M , New York. lee was in 1970, I teetlfl►d before the State of Vermont, Pnhlle Sere - board ((locket Nn. 4199) Io a condemnation ertlnn. The trstimnoy i..a►d upon wy analysts of the value of the electric distribution property iocat►d In And nerving the Inhabitant. of Springfield, Ver- mont. in 1941, I testified before the Maasachneett. Appellate Tat Rnsrd In behalf of the board of Aaa..aors, Soeerville, M huaette In purport of •y appraisal of the electric dlatrlhntion property with - In the City. 1 io 191i1, 1 testified hfore the Mew N.upahlre Stet• Hoard of Tat Appeala In behalf of the Roiled* of Selectee.. of Franklin, • - land, Peehrnke pod ►Ittvtlltaw, Wow fawpahire in support of we appral- ala of the hydrnel•rtrlr, tranamlaalon and diatrlhutlon properties within those Cities and Tonna, in 1911, 1 teatlfed before the Alaska Public itt111ties Demote - *inn In behalf of the City of Anchorage In support of uy analyst. of value of toatomers facilities to be eschanied with Ch,,s.eh rlertrlc A.soelptlon. In 1911, T testified before the Mee.acbn.aft. Appellate Tar board 1n behalf of the board of Aase.anra, Q•.Iney, Maseachn In auppnrt of •T aprralaai of the electric tranamis.lnn and dt.trihotlnn property within the City. • - a•.w.....A r... ..1 .eta..• ..• ... In 1..0.411 .9 N.. ATTACHMENT 5 January 28, 1083 Client List for Street Lighting Valuations Mr. Farhad Mansourian Marin County — Director of Public Works Traffic Engineering Division Post Office Box 4186 Civic Center San Rafael, California 94913 Mr. Arnold C. Joens, Director Public Works Department City of Salinas City Hall — 200 Lincoln Salinas, California 93901 Mr. Harry W. Montgomery Director of Public Works City of Stockton City Hall Stockton, California 95202 Mr. Jim Onderek City of Marysville City Hall 526 "C" Street Marysville, California 95901 Porter Goltz, Esq. County of San Mateo 590 Hamilton Street Redwood City, California 94063 Mr. Ron Hurlbut Director of Public Works City of Fairfield 1000 Webster Street Fairfield, California 94533 Mrs. Artie Wingfield City of Fresno 2101 "G" Street Fresno, California 93706