Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Draft Agenda Packet - 06-01-2021 CC HA Agenda (2)
CALIFORNIA NATIONAL Mr IN CORPORATED ai INCORPORATED ALEJANDRA SOTELO-SOLIS Mayor JOSE RODRIGUEZ Vice Mayor MARCUS BUSH Councilmember RON MORRISON Councilmember MONA RIOS Councilmember 1243 National City Blvd. National City, CA 91950 619-336-4240 Meeting agendas and minutes available on the City's website at WWW.NATIONALCITYCA. GOV AGENDA OF A REGULAR MEETING - NATIONAL CITY CITY COUNCIL/ COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION — HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY ONLINE ONLY MEETING https://www.nationalcityca.gov/webcast LIVE WEBCAST COUNCIL CHAMBERS CIVIC CENTER 1243 NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA TUESDAY, JUNE 1, 2021 — 6:00 PM NOTICE: The health and well-being of National City residents, visitors, and employees during the COVID-19 outbreak remains our top priority. The City of National City is coordinating with the County of San Diego Health Human Services Agency, and other agencies to take measures to monitor and reduce the spread of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19). The World Health Organization has declared the outbreak a global pandemic and local and state emergencies have been declared providing reprieve from certain public meeting laws such as the Brown Act. As a result, the City Council Meeting will occur only online to ensure the safety of City residents, employees and the communities we serve. A live webcast of the meeting may be viewed on the city's website at www.nationalcityca.gov. For Public Comments see "PUBLIC COMMENTS" section below ORDER OF BUSINESS: Public sessions of all Regular Meetings of the City Council / Community Development Commission - Housing Authority (hereafter referred to as Elected Body) begin at 6:00 p.m. on the first and third Tuesday of each month. Public Hearings begin at 6:00 p.m. unless otherwise noted. Closed Meetings begin in Open Session at 5:00 p.m. or such other time as noted, and after announcing closed session items, convenes into a Closed Meeting. If a workshop is scheduled, the subject and time of the workshop will appear on the agenda. The Mayor and Council members also sit as the Chairperson and Members of the Board of the Community Development Commission (CDC). REPORTS: All open session agenda items and reports as well as all documents and writings distributed to the Elected Body less than 72 hours prior to the meeting, are available for review on the City's website at www.nationalcityca.gov. Regular Meetings of the Elected Body are webcast and archived on the City's website at www.nationalcityca.gov. PUBLIC COMMENTS: There are multiple ways you can make sure your opinions are heard and considered by our City Council as outlined below: Submit your public comment prior to the meeting: To submit a comment in writing, email PublicComment(c�nationalcityca.gov, provide the agenda item number and title of the item in the subject line of your email. Public comments or testimony is limited to up to three (3) minutes. If the comment is not related to a specific agenda item, 1 of 592 indicate General Public Comment in the subject line. All email comments received by 4:00 p.m. on the day of the meeting will be emailed to the City Council Members and made a part of the official record. Register online and participate in live public comment during the meeting: To provide live public comment during the meeting, you must pre -register on the City's website at https://www.nationalcityca.qov/publiccomment by 4:00 p.m. on the day of the regular meeting to join the City Council Meeting. ***Please note that you do not need to pre -register to watch the meeting online, but you must pre -register if you wish to speak. Once registered, you will receive an email with a link from Zoom to join the live meeting. You can participate by phone or by computer. Please allow yourself time to log into Zoom before the start of the meeting to ensure you do not encounter any last-minute technical difficulties. ***Please note that members of the public will not be shown on video; they will be able to watch and listen and speak when called upon. Public microphones will be muted until it is your turn to comment. Each speaker is allowed up to three (3) minutes to address the City Council. Please be aware that the Mayor may limit the comments' length due to the number of persons wishing to speak or if comments become repetitious or unrelated. All comments are subject to the same rules as would otherwise govern speaker comments at the meeting. Speakers are asked to be respectful and courteous. Please address your comments to the City Council as a whole and avoid personal attacks against members of the public, City Council, and city staff. Questions about public comment or City Council protocols? Please contact the City Clerk's Office at (619) 336-4228 or via email at Clerk(c�nationalcityca.gov. INTERPRETATION SERVICES: To use the Zoom interpretation feature you must first Pre -Register on Zoom. Once logged into Zoom to use the interpretation feature, please scroll to the bottom of the Zoom screen (where the meeting controls are), click on the interpretation icon (world), and select English as your language. If you are joining using the Zoom mobile app (cell phone, tablet, etc.), please press the ellipsis (...), then Interpretation, and then choose your language. WRITTEN AGENDA: With limited exceptions, the Elected Body may take action only upon items appearing on the written agenda. Items not appearing on the agenda must be brought back on a subsequent agenda unless they are of a demonstrated emergency or urgent nature, and the need to take action on such items arose after the agenda was posted. CONSENT CALENDAR: Consent calendar items involve matters which are of a routine or noncontroversial nature. All consent items are adopted by approval of a single motion by the City Council. Prior to such approval, any item may be removed from the consent portion of the agenda and separately considered, upon request of a Councilmember, a staff member, or a member of the public. Upon request, this agenda can be made available in appropriate alternative formats to persons with a disability in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please 2 of 592 contact the City Clerk's Office at (619) 336-4228 to request a disability -related modification or accommodation. Notification 24-hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. AVISO: La salud y el bienestar de los residentes, visitantes y empleados de National City durante el brote de COVID-19 sigue siendo nuestra maxima prioridad. El Ayuntamiento de la Ciudad de National City se esta coordinando con la Agencia de Salud y Servicios Humanos del Condado de San Diego y otras agencias para tomar medidas con el fin de monitorear y reducir la propagacion del nuevo coronavirus (COVID-19). La Organizacion Mundial de la Salud declaro el brote como una pandemic global y se han manifestado emergencias locales y estatales que resultan en la suspension de ciertas leyes de reuniones publicas, tal como la Ley Brown. Como resultado de ello, la junta del Concejo Municipal del Ayuntamiento se Ilevara a cabo solamente en linea para garantizar la seguridad de los residentes, empleados y comunidades locales que atendemos. Se podra ver una transmision en vivo de la junta en el sitio web del Ayuntamiento en www.nationalcityca.gov. Para comentarios publicos, vea la seccion "COMENTARIOS PUBLICOS" mas adelante. ORDEN DEL DIA: Las sesiones publicas de todas las juntas ordinarias del Concejo Municipal/Comision de Desarrollo Comunitario - Autoridad de Vivienda (en to sucesivo denominado Organo Electo) inician a las 6:00 p.m. el primer y tercer martes de cada mes. Las audiencias publicas inician a las 6:00 p.m., a menos que se indique to contrario. Las juntas cerradas inician en sesion abierta a las 5:00 p.m. o en cualquier otro momento que se indique, y tras anunciar los temas de la sesion cerrada, la junta se realiza como sesion cerrada. Si se programa una reunion de discusion y analisis, el tema y la hora de la misma apareceran en la agenda. La Alcaldesa y los Concejales se reunen por igual que el Presidente y los integrantes del Consejo de la Comision de Desarrollo Comunitario. INFORMES: Todos los temas e informes de la agenda de la sesion abierta, asi como todos los documentos y escritos entregados al Organo Electo menos de 72 horas antes de la sesion, apareceran en el sitio web del Ayuntamiento. Las juntas ordinarias del Organo Electo se transmiten por Internet y se archivan en el sitio web del Ayuntamiento en www. nationalcityca.gov. COMENTARIOS PUBLICOS: Hay varias formas en las que puede asegurarse de que sus opiniones sean escuchadas y consideradas por nuestro Concejo Municipal como se describe a continuacion: Envie su comentario publico antes de la sesion: Para enviar un comentario por escrito, envie un correo electronico a PublicCommentnationalcityca.qov, proporcione el numero del tema o asunto de la agenda y el titulo del tema o asunto en la linea de asunto de su correo electronico. Los comentarios o testimonios publicos se limitan a tres (3) minutos. Si el comentario no se relaciona con un tema o asunto especifico de la agenda, indique Comentario Publico General en la linea de asunto. Todos los comentarios por correo electronico recibidos antes de las 4:00 p.m. del dia de la sesion se enviaran por correo electronico a los miembros del Concejo Municipal y formaran parte del acta oficial. Registrese en linea y participe en los comentarios publicos en vivo durante la sesion: Para proporcionar comentarios publicos en vivo durante la sesion, debe registrarse previamente en el sitio web del Ayuntamiento en 3 of 592 https://www.nationalcityca.qov/publiccomment antes de las 4:00 p.m. del dia de la junta ordinaria para incorporarse a la sesion del Concejo Municipal. ***Tenga presente que no necesita registrarse previamente para ver la sesion en linea, pero debe registrarse previamente si desea hablar. Una vez registrado, recibira un correo electronico con un enlace de Zoom para integrarse a la sesion en vivo. Puede participar por telefono o por computadora. Tomese el tiempo necesario para iniciar la reunion en Zoom antes del inicio de la sesion para asegurarse de no encontrar dificultades tecnicas de ultimo momento. ***Tenga presente que las personas del publico no se mostraran en video; podran observar, escuchar y hablar cuando se les solicite. Los microfonos publicos se silenciaran hasta que sea su turno de comentar. Cada orador tiene hasta tres (3) minutos para dirigirse al Concejo Municipal. Tenga en cuenta que la Alcaldesa puede limitar la extension de los comentarios debido a la cantidad de personas que deseen hablar o si los comentarios se vuelven repetitivos o no relacionados. Todos los comentarios estan sujetos a las mismas reglas que de otro modo regirian los comentarios de los oradores en la sesion. Se pide a los oradores que sean respetuosos y corteses. Dirija sus comentarios al Concejo Municipal en su conjunto y evite ataques personales contra personas del publico, el Concejo Municipal y el personal del Ayuntamiento. ,Preguntas sobre comentarios publicos o protocolos del Concejo Municipal? Comunrquese con la Oficina de la Secretaria del Ayuntamiento al telefono (619) 336-4228, o por correo electronico a Clerk(nationalcityca.gov. SERVICIO DE INTERPRETACION: Para utilizar la funcion de interpretacion zoom primero debe registrarse previamente en el sitio web de Zoom. Una vez que haya iniciado sesion en zoom para utilizar la funcion de interpretacion, favor de desplazarse a la parte inferior de la pantalla de Zoom (donde aparecen los controles). Naga clic en el icono de interpretacion (globo terraqueo), y seleccione "Spanish" (espanol). Si esta utilizando la aplicacion movil de Zoom (celular, tableta, etc.), presione los puntos suspensivos (...), luego "interpretation" y luego el idioma. AGENDA ESCRITA: Con contadas excepciones, el Organo Electo puede tomar medidas unicamente sobre los temas que aparecen en la agenda escrita. Los temas que no aparezcan en la agenda deben aparecer en una agenda subsecuente, a menos que sean de emergencia o urgencia demostrada, y la necesidad de tomar medidas sobre esos temas haya surgido despues de haber sido publicada la agenda. CALENDARIO DE CONSENTIMIENTO: Los temas del calendario de consentimiento implican cuestiones de naturaleza rutinaria o no controvertida. Todos los temas de consentimiento se adoptan mediante la aprobacion de una sola mocion del Concejo Municipal. Antes de la aprobacion, cualquier tema puede eliminarse de la parte de consentimiento de la agenda y considerarse aparte, a peticion de un concejal, individuo del personal del Ayuntamiento o persona del publico. 4 of 592 Previa solicitud, esta agenda puede estar disponible en formatos alternativos apropiados para personas con discapacidades, en observancia de la Ley de Estadounidenses con Discapacidades. Llame al telefono (619) 336-4228 de la Oficina del Secretario del Ayuntamiento para solicitar una modificacion o adaptacion de acceso relativa a la discapacidad. Notificar 24 horas antes de la sesion permitira al Ayuntamiento hacer arreglos razonables para garantizar la accesibilidad a esta junta. 5 of 592 OPEN TO THE PUBLIC A. CITY COUNCIL CALL TO ORDER ROLL CALL PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG PUBLIC COMMENTS (THREE -MINUTE TIME LIMIT) PROCLAMATIONS AND CERTIFICATES AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS 1. Introduction of New Hire - Gabriela M. Torres, Deputy City Attorney PRESENTATIONS (FIVE-MINUTE TIME LIMIT) 2. Chamber of Commerce Economic Recovery Plan. (Chad Matkowski, President and CEO, National City Chamber of Commerce) 3. Communications Update. (Rachel McGuire, President/CEO, RMG Communications) INTERVIEWS / APPOINTMENTS 4. Appointments: City Boards, Commissions and Committees - City Council Appointment. (City Clerk) REGIONAL BOARDS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS (FIVE-MINUTE TIME LIMIT) CONSENT CALENDAR 5. Motion of the City Council of the City of National City approving the waiving of the reading of the text of the Ordinances or Resolutions that are having a Public Hearing considered at this meeting and providing that such Ordinance or Resolutions shall be introduced and/or adopted after a reading of the title only. (City Clerk) 6. Approval of City Council and Community Development Commission - Housing Authority of the City of National City Virtual Regular Meeting: April 20, 2021, and City Council of the City of National City Virtual Special Meeting April 20, 2021 (City Clerk's Office) 7. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City supporting increase broadband access to bridge the digital divie throughout the San Diego region. (City Manager) 6 of 592 8. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving City Attorney's request for authority to participate in the San Diego County Bar Association's Diversity Pledge. (City Attorney) 9. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute a Termination of a Notice of Assurances to the State of California of the Use of Property and/or the State of California's Right of Recapture for Kimball Highlands located at 1221 "D" Avenue. (Housing Authority) 10. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute a Termination of a Notice of Restriction on Real Property located at 1320 Highland Avenue. (Housing Authority) 11. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for grant coordination services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City, extending the term of the Agreement to September 30, 2023, and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement.(Engineering/Public Works) 12. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for tree planting services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City, extending the term of the Agreement to September 30, 2023, and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement. (Engineering/Public Works) 13. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute an Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities ("AHSC") Implementation and Mutual Indemnity Agreement with the Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee on Anti -Poverty of San Diego County, Inc. (MAAC Project), a 501(c)3 non-profit organization, for the City's implementation of transportation infrastructure or transit -related amenities with a total budget of $8,250,000 within the vicinity of the a proposed 400-unit affordable housing project at 233 Roosevelt Avenue in National City. (Engineering/Public Works) 14. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. 2nd Street, to increase parking turnover for customers and employees of the nearby businesses and to enhance street safety (TSC No. 2021-07). (Engineering/Public Works) 15. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of a blue curb disabled persons parking space with sign in front of 7 of 592 the residence located at 1540 Harding Avenue (TSC No. 2021-08). (Engineering/Public Works) 16. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of a Stop Control sign for the three T-intersections within the neighborhood bounded by "G" Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street (TSC No. 2021-09). (Engineering/Public Works) 17. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of red curb "No Parking" at the intersection of Earle Drive and E. 16th Street in order to enhance safety and visibility for drivers exiting Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street (TSC No. 2021-10). (Engineering/Public Works) 18. Warrant Register #42 for the period of 4/14/21 through 4/20/21 in the amount of $2,346,196.31. (Finance) 19. Warrant Register #43 for the period of 4/21/21 through 4/27/21 in the amount of $1,139,452.53. (Finance) PUBLIC HEARINGS: ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS 20. Public Hearing, second reading and adoption of an Ordinance of the City Council of the City of National City amending National City Chapter 9.52 of the National City Municipal Code regarding the Mandatory Commercial and Residential Recycling Program according to SB 1383. (Engineering/Public Works) 21. Public Hearing and adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City confirming the costs of Weed Abatement and Approving the report and account for such, after having considered any objections or protests; pursuant to National City Municipal Code Chapters 1.36 (Abatement of Public Nuisances) and 9.12 (Abatement of Weeds and other Fire Hazards). (Fire) 22. Public Hearing and adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City confirming the assessment and ordering the levy for Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) for Fiscal Year 2020/21. (Planning) NON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS 23. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City adopting the 24th Street Transit -Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) Plan. (Applicant City - Initiated) (Case File 2021-07) (Planning) NEW BUSINESS B. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION - HOUSING AUTHORITY 8 of 592 CONSENT RESOLUTIONS - HOUSING AUTHORITY PUBLIC HEARINGS: RESOLUTIONS - HOUSING AUTHORITY NON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS - HOUSING AUTHORITY NEW BUSINESS - HOUSING AUTHORITY C. REPORTS STAFF REPORTS 24. City Manager Report. (City Manager) 25. Update on City Sponsored Events. (Community Services) MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL 26. Discussion on City Council Policy No. 110 entitled "Display of Flags". (City Manager) CLOSED SESSION CLOSED SESSION REPORT ADJOURNMENT Regular Meeting of the City Council and Community Development Commission - Housing Authority of the City of National City - Tuesday - June 15, 2021 - 6:00 p.m. - Council Chambers - National City, California. 9 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Introduction of New Hire - Gabriela M. Torres, Deputy City Attorney Please scroll down to view the backup material. 10 of 592 Item # 6/1/21 Introduction of New Employee Gabriela M. Torres, Deputy City Attorney (City Attorney) 11 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Chamber of Commerce Economic Recovery Plan. (Chad Matkowski, President and CEO, National City Chamber of Commerce) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 12 of 592 Item # 06/01/21 Chamber of Commerce Economic Recovery Plan Chad Matkowski, President and CEO National City Chamber of Commerce 13 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Communications Update. (Rachel McGuire, President/CEO, RMG Communications) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 14 of 592 Item # 06/01/21 Communications Update Rachel McGuire President / CEO RMG Communications 15 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Appointments: City Boards, Commissions and Committees - City Council Appointment. (City Clerk) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 16 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Appointments: City Boards, Commissions and Committees — City Council Appointment (City Clerk) PREPARED BY: Luz Molina, City Clerk Shelley Chapel, Deputy City Clerk PHONE: (619) 336-4225 DEPARTMENT: City Clerk's Office APPROVED BY: Skeeeew (,bayee EXPLANATION: Vacancy on the Civil Service Commission was noticed in the Star News, posted on the City Hall Bulletin Boards, City Website, and City Social Media sites to advertise opening and the application acceptance period. The vacancy notice for the Civil Service Commission was posted Wednesday, April 7, 2021, and all applications were due to the City Clerk's Office by the deadline of Thursday, May 6, 2021 at 5:00 p.m. (See Explanation (Attachment A) for more information) FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. n/a ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: n/a ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conduct interviews and City Council appointment of new Commissioner. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: n/a ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Explanation Attachment B — Applications (redacted) Attachment C — City Council Policy #107 Attachment D — Boards/Commission/Committees Reference Chart 17 of 592 ATTACHMENT A The City Clerk's Office began advertising and accepting applications for Vacancies on Civil Service Commission, a City Council appointed Boards/Commissions/Committees (BCC) on April 7, 2021. In order to obtain qualified candidates, a Notice of Vacancy was advertised on the following: The City website, posted on the City Hall Bulletin Boards, and City Social Media sites to advertise openings and the application acceptance period. Deadline to submit applications to the City Clerk's Office to be considered for vacancies was Wednesday, May 6, 2021 at 5:00 p.m. All applications were received before the deadline. BCC Number of Open Seats Appointing Residency Electoral of Compensation and Term expiration for Member(s) Requirement City that seat Requirement Civil Service Commission (1) One Seat 09/30/2022 City Council Yes No None The City Clerk's Office received applications from one (1) individual for the one (1) vacancy. This vacancy is as a result of the resignation of Commissioner Fred Phun on April 7, 2021. There is a residency requirement for this seat and the applicant does live within the City boundaries. 18 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY APPLICATION FOR APPOINTMENT RECEIVED TO CITY BOARDS COMMISSIONS, AND MITTEE kjeky 20. 1 Community & Police RelationsCommission* {PR} Library Board of Trustees Parks, Recreation & Senior Citizens Advisory Board Veterans & Military Families AdvisoryCommittee''' Port Commission Civil Service art t Ceri( Planning Co nt l nal City Public Art Committee* Traffic Safety Committee Advisory Housing Committee* Applicants must be residents of the City of National City except for those marked by an asterisk (*). All applicants must be U.S. Citizens. Applicants for the Comrnunity and Police Relations Commission must pass a criminal background check prior to appointment.. Applicants for the Advisory Housing Committee must have subject matter expertise in housing -related issues. Name: )L Horne Address: (include City/Zip) Business Affiliation:leo)rx'Ic16,IVernootkrALti\ '\ Title: .t E-Fail: ryJAI SC,, D0. i 1 m Tel No: Business Address: \\L\ \ Tel. No: Ct 61L Length of Residence in National City: 1► San Diego County:1.111) Educational Background: California: Occupational Experience: _-c-A1 fr r nv-fA p4o vz ii+.rs.c ckOu l e.-2 - Professional or Technical Organization Memberships: 6coN :2_( + \ o691' a i' (i, isc } rf 'AAI I C„, r , o'., Y" t t'I'i L\ L Cy 4 - s cl !► \ r ' C rk% i I i.Y . Civic or Communt Experi nce, Membership, or, Previous Public Service Appointments: -,AA i .v\."Cr F tMc),tVuit Co r L ' gip,► ''owl '' ci..A) 'rn ie,Q, Experience or Special Knowledge Pertaining to Area of Interest: .r c _ o -!4'10 d\'':AA► "\-f ll +All r1rf.-v 't t ti r tt - 'L 4 4 aeg c. -ru...:- 4r r\L f1ct . i" .\-- t,ai'� tic . ["► Have you ever been convicted of a felony crime? No: Yes:_ misdemeanor crime? No: Yes: If any convictions were expunged disclosure is not required. Convictions are not necessarily disqualifying. Please feel free to provide an explanation or information if "Yes" was marked for the above two questions_ Date: _ 202.1 Signatu Please feel free to provide additional in rmaticn or letters of endorsement_ i= t rr7 completed form to: Office of the City Clerk, 1243 National City Blvd., National City, CA 91950 Thank you for your interest in serving the City of National City. Pursuant to the California Public Records Act, information on this form rnay{ be released to the public upon request. Rev, February 2020 co 19 of 592 Attachment C CITY COUNCIL POLICY CITY OF NATIONAL CITY TITLE: Appointments to Boards, Commissions, POLICY #107 and Committees ADOPTED: June 17,1986 AMENDED: February 2, 2021 PURPOSE To establish a procedure to serve as a guide in making appointments to various City Boards, Commissions, and Committees. The City currently has the following Boards, Commissions, and Committees to which this Policy applies: Mayor's Appointments: 1. Board of Library Trustees 2. Community and Police Relations Commission 3. Housing Advisory Committee 4. Park, Recreation and Senior Citizens Advisory Committee 5. Public Art Committee 6. Sweetwater Authority 7. Traffic Safety Committee 8. Veterans and Military Families Advisory Committee City Council Appointments: 1. Civil Service Commission 2. Planning Commission 3. Port Commission POLICY Appointment Process A. Opportunity to apply. All interested individuals shall be given an opportunity to submit applications for vacancies on City Boards, Commissions, and Committees. Incumbent Appointees are not automatically re -appointed but are required to fill out an abbreviated application provided by the City Clerk, indicating their interest in continuing to serve. B. Unexpired terms. If an incumbent Appointee was appointed to fill an unexpired term and the Appointee serves for less than one year in that position. In that case, the Council may re -appoint the incumbent without considering other applicants. C. Vacancies. When vacancies occur, the following procedure shall be followed: 1. Schedule vacancy. When a term is expiring or expires, public notice of the vacancy shall be made, inviting interested individuals to submit applications for the vacancy on a form provided by the City Clerk on the City website. 20 of 592 TITLE: Appointments to Boards and Commissions POLICY #107 ADOPTED: June 17,1986 AMENDED: February 2, 2021 2. Unscheduled vacancy. An unscheduled vacancy shall be filled according to Government Code Section 54974, which generally provides as follows: Whenever an unscheduled vacancy occurs, whether due to resignation, death, termination, or other causes, a special vacancy notice shall be posted in the office of the City Clerk, the City website, outside City Hall on the Bulletin Board and City social media platforms. Not earlier than twenty (20) days before or not later than twenty (20) days after the vacancy occurs. The City Council shall not make final appointment for at least ten (10) working days after posting the notice in designated locations. The notice's posting and application period shall be thirty (30) calendar days. However, if it finds that an emergency exists, the City Council may, fill the unscheduled vacancy immediately. According to this section, a person appointed to fill the vacancy shall serve only on an interim basis until the final appointment. 3. Government Code Section 40605, and National City Municipal Code Title 16, grants the Mayor, with the City Council's approvals, the authority to make all appointments unless otherwise explicitly provided by statute. The exceptions are: 1. Civil Service Commission 2. Port Commission 3. Planning Commission The City Council fills vacancies on these bodies. D. Implementation. Implementation of Council policy for appointment to Boards, Commissions, and Committees requires the following: 1. Per Government Code Section 54972, on or before December 31 of each year, the City Council shall prepare a list of appointments of all regular and ongoing boards, commissions, and committees appointed by the City Council. The City Clerk will prepare the list of all regular and ongoing boards, commissions, and committees appointed by the Mayor or the City Council. The list shall contain, a list of all terms that will expire during the next calendar year, the incumbent appointee's name, the appointment date, the terms expiration date, and the position's necessary qualifications. It shall also include a list of all boards, commissions, and committees whose members serve at the City Council's pleasure, and the qualifications required for each position. This Local Appointments List shall be made available to the public on the City website. 2. Notice. Placement of a public notice in the adjudicated newspaper the City uses for legal noticing advertising appointivevacancies, the City website, City Hall Bulletin Board, and City social media platforms. 21 of 592 TITLE: Appointments to Boards and Commissions POLICY #107 ADOPTED: June 17,1986 AMENDED: February 2, 2021 3. Expiration of term. All appointees will receive a letter as their terms expire asking if they would like to re -apply for the position; 4. Applications. Available on the City website and in the City Clerk's Office. Submission must be before the advertised deadline for consideration for the current appointment. All applications will be retained in the City Clerk's Office for one-year from submitting an application to be considered for other vacancies on Boards, Commissions, and Committees as marked on the application. The City Clerk's Office will notify the applicant being considered for an appointment to confirm that they are still interested in volunteering. 5. A member may only serve on one (1) Board, Commission, or Committee at a time. If applying for another position on a different Board, Commission, or Committee that applicant will forfeit the prior seat, and a vacancy will occur per policy. 6. Interviews: a. Mayor Appointments: Interviews for Mayoral appointments will be conducted by the Mayor outside of the public meeting and scheduled by the Mayor's Office. b. City Council Appointments: Interviews for the three (3) Civil Service, Planning and Port Commissions who serve at the City Council's pleasure and are appointed by the City Council as a body will be interviewed in the public forum at a City Council Meeting as described below. 7. Mayoral Appointments: The Mayor will make the motion to appoint (naming the appointee) and Councilmembers may second the motion. The City Clerk will then take a roll call vote of the City Council. A majority vote of the City Council will be required for the appointment. If, the majority of the City Council choose to deny the proposed appointment, at which point the Mayor would propose an alternative candidate from the current application pool, or could choose to reopen the application period and return to City Councils with a different applicant for consideration. If Mayor Appointment is not approved by the majority of the City Council by confirmation, that applicant is removed from the pool for that seat. The Mayor will return to a future meeting with a substitute Mayoral appointment. 8. For City Council Appointments, the Interview Process is as follows: a. The City Clerk will provide an overview of the Board, 22 of 592 TITLE: Appointments to Boards and Commissions POLICY #107 ADOPTED: June 17,1986 AMENDED: February 2, 2021 Commission and Committee (s) with current vacancy, the Mayor will introduce the applicant and the two (2) questions will be asked of each applicant on behalf of the City Council. b. Each applicant is given two (2) minutes to make a brief introduction of themselves and their qualifications to the City Council. c. Mayor and City Councilmembers will ask questions of each applicant. All applicants must be asked the same questions. d. Total time per applicant is five (5) timed minutes with a few minutes for clarification. No more than ten (10) minutes total per applicant. e. All appointments and interviews before the City Council will be scheduled as needed to fill unexpected vacancies, with every effort to be made before an individual's term expires. Interviews may take place at one meeting, with appointments made at a subsequent meeting. 9. Vacancies for City Council Appointed Positions. If the vacancy is for a Council appointed position, and there is more than one (1) applicant for a given position, the voting process will proceed as follows: Once the interviews are complete, each Councilmember votes for their choice via a written ballot provided by the City Clerk. Each Councilmember shall print and sign their name on the ballot. All ballots shall be considered a public record and open to inspection by the public. The ballots are passed to the City Clerk who announces the number of votes for each candidate. If, the appointment process is conducted via a virtual meeting the process is the same except the ballot/vote process. The City Clerk's Office will provide a Vote Sheet (a piece of paper electronically) with each applicants name to be considered. The Mayor will count to three (3) and the Council will hold their vote sheet up in front of their face to make sure it is captured on the camera during live virtual meeting. The City Clerk will tally the votes and will then confirm the votes with a verbal roll call. The applicant with the most votes is appointed. If meeting is held "in person" no changes to current process will be made for votes. In the event of a tie, each Councilmember votes again until one (1) candidate has the majority vote, and is declared to be the newly appointed. 10. Re -appointment beyond two terms. Anyone wishing to be re -appointed to any Board, Commission, or Committee, and has served two or more full terms already, 23 of 592 TITLE: Appointments to Boards and Commissions POLICY #107 ADOPTED: June 17,1986 AMENDED: February 2, 2021 must be approved by a four -fifths vote of the Council., If all five members of the Council are not present or if one member abstains or recuses their vote, the four - fifths requirement would be changed to require only a simple majority. 11. Report to Council: All applications received for vacancies no matter Mayoral Appointment or City Council Appointment will be attached to the staff report to Council. All applications will have private personal information redacted (name, street numbers and name of street address, and phone number). This redacted information is in alignment with law, Under Government Code Section 6255(a) personal contact information is exempt, and has been withheld on some documents. Personal information being withheld is in the interest of the applicant and their right to privacy which outweighs the public interest of disclosure. 12. An automatic vacancy upon becoming a Non -Resident. An unscheduled vacancy automatically occurs when a resident holding an appointment position on a City Board, Committee or Commission becomes a non-resident by moving out of National City limits. When an unscheduled vacancy occurs due to a resident becoming a non-resident, the unscheduled vacancy may be filled as follows: a. A special vacancy notice shall be posted in the Office of the City Clerk and the National City Library, and in other places as directed by the City Council, not earlier than 20 days before or not later than 20 days after the vacancy occurs. Final Appointment at a City Council Meeting, shall not be made by the Appointing Authority for at least 10 working days after the posting of the notice in the City Clerk's Office. b. The Appointing Authority may appoint the former resident to a Non- Residential position if a Non -Residential position is vacant. However, the Appointing Authority may, if it finds that an emergency exist, fill the unscheduled vacancy immediately. A person appointed to fill the vacancy shall serve only on an acting basis until the final appointment is made pursuant to this section. 13. Only City Residents may be elected to Chair, and Vice -Chair positions. To be eligible to be elected as the Chairperson of a City Board, Committee or Commission, the member must be a resident of the City. Appointing Authority Related Policy References Government Code Section 40605 Government Code section 54970, et seq. National City Municipal Code Title 16 (pending) Prior Policy Amendments: May 19, 2020 24 of 592 ATTACHMENT D BOARDS/COMMISSION/COMMITTEES BOARDS, COMMISSION AND COMMITTEES (11) TOTAL MEMBERS (51+) BOARD OF LIBRARY TRUSTEE (5 Members) CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION (5 Members) COMMUNITY AND POLICE RELATIONS COMMISSION (8 Members) PARK, RECREATION AND SENIOR CITIZENS' ADVISORY COMMITTEE (7 Members) PLANNING COMMISSION and HOUSING ADVISORY COMMITTEE (7 Members) 2 Ex Officio PORT COMMISSION (1 Member) PUBLIC ART COMMITTEE (5 Members) SWEETWATER AUTHORITY (1 Member) TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE (5 Members) VETERAN'S AND MILITARY FAMILIES ADVISORY COMMITTEE (7 Members) TERM 3 Years 5 Years 3 Years 3 Years 4 Years 3 Years 3 Years 1 Year 3 Years 4 Years RESIDENCY REQUIREMENT Yes Yes 5 Resident up to 2 Non- Resident (1) Non -Voting Member Yes Yes Yes No n/a Yes 5 Resident up to 2 Non- Resident VOTER REQUIREMENT No No No No No No No No No No MAYORAL APPOINTMENT SUBJECT TO CONFIRMATION BY THE CITY COUNCIL X X X Compensation set by Council Resolution X X X X CITY COUNCIL AS A BODY APPOINTMENT X X X COMPENSATION No No No No No No No No No No FORM 700 FILING REQUIREMENT Yes Yes Yes No Yes n/a No n/a No No MEETINGS 1 X per month 1X every other month 1X every 3 months 1X every 2 months 2X per month n/a 1X per quarter n/a 1X per month 1X per quarter REQUIRED TO REPORT TO COUNCIL ANNUALLY Yes, on or before August 31st and to the State Librarian Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes OTHER Can not be salaried employee or holds office of the City CITY COUNCIL POLICY #107 and NCMC TITLE 16 **Effective February 2, 2020 all Chair and Vice -Chairs are required to be NC Residents 25 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Motion of the City Council of the City of National City approving the waiving of the reading of the text of the Ordinances or Resolutions that are having a Public Hearing considered at this meeting and providing that such Ordinance or Resolutions shall be introduced and/or adopted after a reading of the title only. (City Clerk) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 26 of 592 Item # 06/01/21 MOTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY APPROVING THE WAIVING OF THE READING OF THE TEXT OF THE ORDINANCES OR RESOLUTIONS THAT ARE HAVING A PUBLIC HEARING CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING AND PROVIDING THAT SUCH ORDINANCES OR RESOLUTIONS SHALL BE INTRODUCED AND/OR ADOPTED AFTER A READING OF THE TITLE ONLY. (City Clerk) 27 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Approval of City Council and Community Development Commission - Housing Authority of the City of National City Virtual Regular Meeting: April 20, 2021, and City Council of the City of National City Virtual Special Meeting April 20, 2021 (City Clerk's Office) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 28 of 592 Item # 06-01-2021 APPROVAL OF MEETING MINUTES CITY COUNCIL AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION - HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY: Virtual Regular Meeting: April 20, 2021 CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY: Virtual Special Meeting April 20, 2021 (City Clerk) 29 of 592 CALIFORNIA NATIONAL On LNCOAPOEA7 EO .. MINUTES OF THE SPECIAL VIRTUAL MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY April 20, 2021 OPEN SESSION CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 3:32 p.m. by Mayor Sotelo-Solis. ROLL CALL Councilmembers present: Bush, Morrison, Rios, Rodriguez, Sotelo-Solis Administrative Officials present: Raulston, Winney, Bell PUBLIC MAY COMMENT ON OPEN AND CLOSED SESSION AGENDA ITEMS PUBLIC COMMENTS No public comments were received. , 4417 CLOSED SESSION 1. Conference with Legal Counsel — Existing Litigation: Existing Litigation under Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1) Tammy Davis v. City of National City, et al Case No. 19-CV-534-BEN-BGS 2. Conference with Legal Counsel — Existing Litigation: Existing Litigation under Government Code Section 54956.9(d)(1) Justin Perez v. City of National City Case No. 37-2019-00037384-CU-PO-CTL CLOSED SESSION REPORT AT END OF REGULAR MEETING Item 1: Pursuant to California Government Code Section 54957.1, by unanimous vote, direction was given by the City Council in the legal action title Tammy Davis, et al. v. City of National City, et al. The case involves a Section 1983 Civil Rights Act claim arising from an in custody death. Item 2: Pursuant to California Government Code Section 54957.1, by unanimous vote, direction was given by the City Council in the legal action title Justin Perez v. City of National City. The case involves a personal injury claim arising an alleged dangerous condition on City property. Page 1 of 2 30 of 592 ADJOURNMENT Next Regular City Council Meeting: Tuesday, April 20, 2021, 6:00 p.m., City Council Chambers, Civic Center — National City, California, via Zoom. The meeting adjourned at 3:36 p.m. Luz Molina, City Clerk The foregoing minutes were approved at the Regular Meeting of June 1, 2021. Mayor Sotelo-Solis ,OJe Page 2 of 2 31 of 592 CALIFORNIA -- N T'lO)NAL CHii�y /— t;J t iNCORPORA'S MINUTES OF THE VIRTUAL REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION — HOUSING AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY April 20, 2021 This meeting was conducted utilizing teleconferencing and electronic means consistent with State of California Executive Order N-29-20 dated March 17, 2020, regarding the COVID-19 pandemic. The City Council minutes are prepared and ordered to correspond to the City Council Agenda. Agenda Items can be taken out of order during the meeting. The Agenda Items were considered in the order presented. A. CITY COUNCIL CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 6:28 p.m. by Mayor Sotelo-Solis. ROLL CALL Councilmembers present: Bush, Morrison, Rios, Rodriguez, Sotelo-Solis Other Elected Officials present: Beauchamp, Molina Administrative Officials present: Raulston, Winney, Bell, Chapel, Gilman, Williams, Davis, Meteau, Denham, Duong, Vergara, Aguirre, Yano, Parra, Barrera, Valdez, and Tellez. Interpretation in Spanish provided by Carlos Diaz and Luisa Diaz de Leon. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG City Attorney Bell led the Pledge of Allegiance. PUBLIC COMMENTS Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced City Clerk Molina who summarized the process for acceptance of live public comment. Four (4) spoken public comments were heard: Peggy Walker (opposition to marijuana businesses), Clair Carter's grandmother Judy Strang (inequities in relation to marijuana business), Barbara Gordon (opposition to vaping marijuana), Kelly McCormick (concern for driving under the influence of marijuana). No written public comments received. 32 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 PROCLAMATIONS AND CERTIFICATES 1. Earthquake Preparedness Month Proclamation. Mayor Sotelo-Solis presented the Proclamation to Chief Parra and Management Analyst III, Walter Amedee who represent the National City Fire Department. AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS — No agenda items. PRESENTATIONS — No agenda items. INTERVIEWS / APPOINTMENTS 2. Appointments: City Boards, Commissions and Committees — City Council Appointment Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced City Clerk Molina who gave the report and recited City Council Policy #107 Section D8 regarding the interview process and Section D10 regarding the reappointment of a Commissioner for multiple terms. Planning Commission: One (1) vacancy for a term through March 31, 2025. The City Council considered four (4) applicants for this position. City Council conducted public interviews of three (3) applicants: Dolores Flores, William Phillips Sr., and Claudia E. Valenzuela. One applicant, Sonya Flores, was not present for a public interview. Public Comments: None ACTION: Councilmembers cast their vote virtually by holding up the name of the applicant who received their vote. Councilmember Bush voted for Claudia Valenzuela. Councilmember Morrison voted for Dolores Flores. Councilmember Rios voted for Claudia Valenzuela. Vice -Mayor Rodriguez voted for Claudia Valenzuela. Mayor Sotelo-Solis voted for Claudia Valenzuela. Claudia Valenzuela was appointed to the Planning Commission by 4-1 vote. REGIONAL BOARDS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS Councilmember Bush reported on San Diego Metropolitan Transit System's (MTS) improvements in ridership, CARES Act funding, CIP projects, and efforts to reach air emissions goals. Councilmember Morrison had nothing to report. Vice -Mayor Rodriguez reported on the League of California Cities meeting. Infrastructure funding and provisions for housing investment. Page 2110 33 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 Councilmember Rios reminded the National City Community about the recreation opportunities at our reservoirs. Also, she reported that various rebate programs are available from Sweetwater Authority via Sweetwater.org/rebate. Mayor Sotelo-Solis reported on the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) meeting and the Five Big Moves transportation plan. CONSENT CALENDER Mayor Sotelo-Solis announced that Item 5 is to be continued upon receipt of a report from National School District. Item 5 was pulled from the Consent Calendar. She thanked members of the public for registering to provide public comment on Item 5. Public Comments: None ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Bush, seconded by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez, to approve the Consent Calendar Items 3, 4, and 6 through 14. Motion carried by unanimous vote. 3. Motion of the City Council of the City of National City approving the waiving of the reading of the text of the Ordinances or Resolutions that are having a Public Hearing considered at this meeting and providing that such Ordinances or Resolutions shall be introduced and/or adopted after a reading of the title only. 4. Adopted Resolution 2021-25. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving the donation of self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBAs) and accessories to assist the City of Tecate. 5. Pulled to be continued. 6. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-26. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City: 1) accepting the work performed by Portillo Concrete Inc. for the Palm Avenue Road Rehabilitation Project, CIP No. 19-05; 2) approving the final contract amount of $1,006,975.46; 3) ratifying the release of retention in the amount of $25,318.36; and 4) authorizing the Mayor to sign the Notice of Completion for the project. 7. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-27. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City: 1) accepting the work performed by PAL General Engineering Inc. for the E. 16th Street Road Rehabilitation Project, CIP No. 19-38; 2) approving the final contract amount of $180,275.60; 3) ratifying the release of retention in the amount of $9,013.78; and 4) authorizing the Mayor to sign the Notice of Completion for the project. 8. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-28. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City: 1) accepting the work performed by Next Stage Engineering for the City Hall Ceiling Replacement project, CIP No. 19-53; 2) approving the final contract amount of $461,746.46; 3) ratifying the release of retention in the amount of $20,090.00; and 4) authorizing the Mayor to sign the Notice of Completion for the project. Page 3110 34 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 9. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-29. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City: 1) approving the following projects proposed to receive funding from the Road Maintenance and Rehabilitation Account (RMRA) through the Local Streets and Roads Funding Program as required by Senate Bill 1, the Road Repair and Accountability Act of 2017: A) National City Blvd Street Resurfacing, B) E. Plaza Blvd Street Resurfacing, C) E. 16th Street Resurfacing, and D) Mann Avenue Street Resurfacing; and 2) authorizing the establishment of a Gas Tax Fund appropriation of $1,217,771 for Fiscal Year 2021 and corresponding revenue budget for receipt of RMRA funds. 10. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-30 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City, waiving the formal bid process pursuant to National City Municipal Code Section 2.60.260 and Section 2.60.220, regarding cooperative purchasing and open market procedure respectively, and authorizing the purchasing and accessorizing of one (1) new 2021 Ford AWD Police Interceptor K8A PEG 500A in an amount not -to -exceed $63,360.25, due to a traffic collision that damaged a National City Police Department Patrol Vehicle beyond repair. 11. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-31 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City, waiving the formal bid process pursuant to National City Municipal Code Section 2.60.260 and Section 2.60.220, regarding cooperative purchasing and open market procedure respectively, and authorizing the purchasing and accessorizing of one (1) new 2021 Ford AWD Police Interceptor K8A PEG 500A in an amount not -to -exceed $67,111.33, due to a traffic collision that damaged a National City Police Department K-9 Vehicle beyond repair. 12. Investment transactions for the month ended February 28, 2021. 13. Ratified Warrant Register #36 for the period of 3/03/21 through 3/09/21 in the amount of $1,764,948.49. 14. Ratified Warrant Register #37 for the period of 3/10/21 through 3/16/21 in the amount of $407,421.46. ITEMS PULLED FROM CONSENT CALENDER 5. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving the one (1) year ratified Agreement and Authorizing the Mayor to execute the ratified Agreement with the Sweetwater Union High School District for partial funding of the School Resource Officer Program for FY 2021. The City of National City will be reimbursed $105,000 for FY 2021. Mayor Sotelo-Solis announced that Item 5 is to be continued upon receipt of a report from National School District. Public Comments: registered speakers were not heard due to item being moved to a future date. ACTION: Motion Sotelo-Solis and seconded by Councilmember Bush to move Item 5 to be heard at a future date. City Attorney Bell clarified that all discussion, including public comment, must cease until the item is brough back. Councilmember Bush withdrew his second. Councilmember Rios seconded. Councilmember Rios requested for any future items that are moved be announced at the start of the City Council meeting, as a courtesy to members of the public. Ayes: Morrison, Rios, Rodriguez, Sotelo-Solis I age 4110 35 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 Nayes: Bush Motion passed by 4 to 1 vote. Deputy City Clerk Chapel will provide notice of a date certain for this item to those who registered to speak. PUBLIC HEARINGS: ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS 15. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-32. Public Hearing and Adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City amending the previously adopted Transportation Development Impact Fee (TDIF) schedule and annual adjustment to the TDIF, pursuant to National City Municipal Code Section 4.52.100 and consistent with Government Code Section 66017, approving an adjustment to the TDIF of 2 percent, as required by the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG) for receipt of TransNet local street improvement revenues, resulting in the TDIF increasing from $2,584 per new residential dwelling unit to $2,636 per unit beginning July 1, 2021. City Clerk Molina read the title of the Resolution into the record. Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced Directory of Public Works/City Engineer Yano provided the report. Councilmembers asked clarifying questions. Staff provided responses. Mayor Sotelo-Solis declared the Public Hearing open at 7:42 p.m. Public Comments: None. ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Morrison, seconded by Councilmember Bush, to close the Public Hearing at 7:45 p.m. Motion passed by unanimous vote. ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Morrison, seconded by Councilmember Bush, to adopt the Resolution. Motion passed by unanimous vote. NON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS 16. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-33. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving the acceptance of the High -Speed Broadband in California Libraries Grant Year 6 from State Library in the amount of $135,645.71 to cover the equipment costs associated with high-speed networking upgrade at the National City Public Library. City Clerk Molina read the title of the Resolution into the record. Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced Minh Duong, City Librarian, and John Saour, IT Analyst, who provided the report and PowerPoint Presentation titled "Library Broadband Upgrade". Councilmembers asked clarifying questions. Staff provided responses. Page 5110 36 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 Public Comments: None. ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Bush, seconded by Councilmember Rios, to adopt the Resolution. Motion passed by unanimous vote. 17. Adopted Resolution No. 2021-34. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City: 1) authorizing the appropriation of $650,551.50 for Phase II — Implementation phase of Paradise Creek Mitigation at Kimball Way project, reimbursable through the Hazard Mitigation Grant Program approved by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA); 2) establishing corresponding revenue and expenditure accounts; and 3) committing to providing a local match of $216,850.50. City Clerk Molina read the title of the Resolution into the record. Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced Directory of Public Works/City Engineer Yano, who provided the report. Public Comments: None. ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Rios, seconded by Councilmember Morrison, to adopt the Resolution. Motion passed by unanimous vote. 18. Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the Mayor to execute an Amendment to the Lease and Operating Agreement between the City of National City and American Golf Corporation to increase green fees effective April 20, 2021. City Clerk Molina read the title of the Resolution into the record. Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced Acting Director of Community Services Denham, who provided the report. Gary Johnson with American Golf Corporation was available to address questions by Councilmembers. Public Comment: None. ACTION: Motion by Mayor Sotelo-Solis, seconded by Councilmember Morrison to approve the Resolution, that adopts the increase green fees with the understanding that the amount charged to the Sweetwater High School golf team remain the same as in has prior years. Councilmember Morrison made a motion for a friendly amendment to also allow National City Student golf teams Accepted by the maker of the motion. Vice -Mayor Rodriguez made a motion for a friendly amendment to keep the 91950 zip code residents to be included in the 9% rate not to be included in the increase. Maker of the motion did not accept. Mayor Sotelo-Solis made a friendly amendment to keep the 91950 zip code residents to be included in the 9% rate not to be included in the increase. Councilmember Morrison second of Page 6110 37 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 the motion accepted the friendly amendment. To include Sweetwater, Granger and National student golf teams to remain as current fee. City Attorney Bell advised Council to withdraw the motion on the floor and replace it with a motion directing staff to return to negotiating table with American Golf to address concerns that were raised by City Council. Allowing American Golf the opportunity to renegotiate. City Manager Raulston recommended that the item be returned to staff to renegotiate the Operating Agreement. Representative for American Golf commented. City Attorney commented on options to proceed. Motion was rescinded by Mayor Sotelo-Solis. ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Morrison, seconded by Councilmember Rios to refer Item back to Staff to renegotiate the Operating Agreement to include amendments as discussed, and to return to the May 4, 2021 City Council Meeting. Motion passed by unanimous vote. Public Comment: City Treasurer Beauchamp Mayor Sotelo-Solis requested for the interpretation service to continue past the two-hour mark. NEW BUSINESS 19. The Protecting the Right to Organize (PRO) Act (HR. 842). Mayor Sotelo-Solis introduced Assistant City Manager Winney who provided a summary on the Protecting the Right to Organize (PRO) Act. Public Comments: None ACTION: Motion by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez, seconded by Councilmember Bush, to request for staff to draft a letter of support for the PRO Act. Motion passed by unanimous vote. Point of Clarification requested by Assistant City Manager Winney; City Manager staff will draft letter for Mayor's signature, with City Councilmembers receiving a copy, due to the timeliness of the legislation. Mayor agreed. 20. Consider authorizing a letter of support to the Port of San Diego in support of the Maritime Clean Air Strategy Discussion Draft. Director of Community Development Vergara provided comments with regards to the Maritime Clean Air Strategy (MCAS) Discussion Draft letter of support. Public Comments: One (1) spoken public comment was heard from Danny Serrano (comment letter drafted does not address previously stated community concerns). ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Bush, seconded by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez, to provide the letter of support with the following three changes (1) strike "discussion draft" from the first line and gage 7110 38 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 add "discussion effort", (2) strike "discussion draft" from the last paragraph and add "discussion effort", (3) strike "compliance" from the second paragraph and add "environmental health". Motion passed by unanimous vote. B. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION — HOUSING AUTHORITY CONSENT RESOLUTIONS — HOUSING AUTHORITY — No agenda items. PUBLIC HEARINGS: RESOLUTIONS — HOUSING AUTHORITY — No agenda items. NON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS — HOUSING AUTHORITY — No agenda items. NEW BUSINESS — HOUSING AUTHORITY — No agenda items. C. REPORTS STAFF REPORTS Item 22 taken out of order 22. Speeding and Racing Groups Chief of Police Tellez introduced Captain Alex Hernandez who provided the report and PowerPoint presentation titled "National City Police Department Staff Report on concerns regarding Speeding and Racing Groups". Public Comment: Joan Rincon (read into the record following item # 22 at 9:51 p.m.) Received and filed report. Mayor Sotelo-Solis released the interpretation service at 9:28 p.m. 21. Urban Area Security Initiative Chief of Emergency Services Parra introduced Chief of Police Jose Tellez and Management Analyst III Walter Amedee. Chief Parra provided the report and PowerPoint presentation titled "Urban Area Security Initiative (UASI) Urban Area Working Group (UAWG)". Public Comment: None. Received and filed report. 23. HOPE Improvements for Federal Funding. City Manager Raulston provided the report and PowerPoint presentation titled "Health and Opportunity through Partnership for Equity". Page 8110 39 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 Public Comment: None. Received and filed report. 24. City Manager Report City Manager Raulston commented on the availability of COVID-19 vaccines for the community. MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL City Clerk Molina announced the vacancy on the Civil Service Commission. Applicants may apply via the City Clerk's Office. Application deadline is Thursday, May 6, 2021, 5:00 p.m. City Treasurer Beauchamp spoke about the Port of San Diego tenants, and the freight rail system. Councilmember Morrison wished to direct Staff to start the discussion regarding the possibilities and options available once the contract with American Golf Corporation ends. ACTION: Motion by Councilmember Morrison, seconded by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez, to direct Staff to begin the discussion for potential possibilities once the contract with American Golf Corporation ends. Ayes: Bush, Morrison, Rodriguez Nayes: Rios, Sotelo-Solis Motion passed by 3 to 2 vote. Councilmember Rios invited the community to Port of San Diego's virtual community workshop to discuss the future of Pepper Park. Vice -Mayor Rodriguez wished to post items for discussion regarding the city budget. ACTION: Motion by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez, seconded by Councilmember Morrison, to discuss the funding associated to sanitation and trash collection services, at the May 18, 2021, City Council meeting. Motion passed by unanimous vote. ACTION: Motion by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez, seconded by Councilmember Morrison, to discuss the funding needed for an EMT training program for fire fighters to become paramedics, within the Budget Item at the May 18, 2021, City Council Meeting. Motion passed by unanimous vote. ACTION: Motion by Vice -Mayor Rodriguez to discuss the possibilities of grant funding needed to increase civic participation and community outreach efforts during elections, within the Budget item at the May 18, 2021, City Council Meeting. Motion died for lack of a second. Mayor Sotelo-Solis announced the availability of vaccines around the community. She mentioned the invitation to present to counterparts in Puerto Rico the success of age -friendly policies in National City. Page 9110 40 of 592 City of National City — City Council Regular Meeting Minutes April 20, 2021 CLOSED SESSION CLOSED SESSION REPORT City Attorney Bell reported out on Closed Session. Item 1: Pursuant to California Government Code Section 54957.1, by unanimous vote, direction was given by the City Council in the legal action title Tammy Davis, et al. v. City of National City, et al. The case involves a Section 1983 Civil Rights Act claim arising from an in custody death. Item 2: Pursuant to California Government Code Section 54957.1, by unanimous vote, direction was given by the City Council in the legal action title Justin Perez v. City of National City. The case involves a personal injury claim arising an alleged dangerous condition on City property. ADJOURNMENT Mayor Sotelo-Solis adjourned the meeting to the next Virtual Regular Meeting of the City Council and Community Development Commission — Housing Authority of the City of National City, California to be held Tuesday, May 4, 2021, at 6:00 p.m. via teleconference. The meeting adjourned at 10:31 p.m. City Clerk The foregoing minutes were approved at the Regular Meeting of June 8, 2021. Mayor Page 10110 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City supporting increase broadband access to bridge the digital divie throughout the San Diego region. (City Manager) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 42 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City supporting increased broadband access to bridge the digital divide throughout the San Diego region. (City Manager) • PREPARED BY: Tony Winney, Assistant City Manager DEPARTMENT: an: •er's Office PHONE: (619) 33 4 40 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: At the May 10, 2021 CalCities San Diego County Division Meeting, a representative from the San Diego Regional Association of Governments (SANDAL) presented on their efforts to bridge the digital divide. This is the gap between members of society who have high quality broadband service and those who do not. This may also include the hardware and software required to access broadband. This is primarily rural and disadvantaged communities. The Federal Communications Commission defines broadband as transmission speeds of at least 25 Mbps downstream and 3 Mbps upstream. Twenty-one percent of households in San Diego County earning less than $50,000 per year do not have broadband, 17% of seniors do not have broadband and approximately 30% of students lack home Internet access. This access is crucial in learning, doing business and accessing services online. SANDAL requested adoption of a resolution by member cities supporting their efforts to expand broadband access throughout the region regardless of ability, age, income or language. The City's Legislative Platform states that the City supports "...initiatives that provide the necessary resources and funds to invest in necessary infrastructure projects such as expanded access to broadband to improve the transfer of goods and services throughout the region, to create jobs and encourage economic development." FINANCIAL STATEMENT: APPROVED: ACCOUNT NO. APPROVED: NIA ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: City staff recommends adoption of the attached resolution. BOARD 1 COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A ATTACHMENTS: Attachment A — Resolution Supporting Increased Broadband Access to Bridge the Digital Divide 43 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving City Attorney's request for authority to participate in the San Diego County Bar Association's Diversity Pledge. (City Attorney) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 44 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of theCity Council of the City of National City approving City Attorney's request for authority to participate in the San Diego County Bar Association's Diversity Pledge. PREPARED BY: Charles E. Bell, Jr., City Attorney EXPLANATION: The San Diego County Bar Association provides legal professionals with support to help em achieve their professional and personal career goals. The Diversity Pledge seeks to increase the number of unrepresented attorneys in management and Leadership within legal organizations in San Diego County. Additional information about the San Diego County Diversity Pledge can be found on its website at the following web address: https://www.sdcba.orgRpg=Diversitv-Pledge. DEPARTMENT: City ttore"y's C APPROVED BY: FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. Not Applicable APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: This action does not constitute a project under California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines Section 15378(b)(2). ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends City Council approve the City Attorney's request for authority to participate in the San Diego County Bar Association's Diversity Pledge. BOARD I COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: ATTACHMENTS: A. San Diego County Bar Association's Diversity Pledge Form B. Resolution 45 of 592 STY BAR DIVERSITY PLEDGE SIGNATORY liE CBA SAN DIEGO COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION' DIVERSITY PLEDGE: To Increase the Number of Underrepresented Attorneys in Management and Leadership within Legal Organizations in San Diego County Although San Diego County is a diverse community, that diversity is not represented at the management and leadership levels of many legal organizations relative to the demographics of our community. Clients and the public expect the San Diego legal community to reflect this diversity. We recognize that diversity is an expansive, flexible, and evolving concept encompassing a set of characteristics, experiences, and conditions (whether actual or perceived) that reflects an individual's membership in an underrepresented, underserved, or historically disadvantaged group. These characteristics include race, ethnicity, color, national origin, ancestry, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, disability, and other relevant characteristics as the context requires, as well as the intersectionality of these characteristics and other groups historically underrepresented in the legal profession. Attorneys with any of these characteristics will be referred to throughout this document as "Underrepresented Attorneys." We pledge to use our best efforts to meet the following goals: • Hiring & Retention: To hire and retain entry-level and lateral Underrepresented Attorneys who represent the diversity of the population of the County of San Diego and the surrounding region. • Promotion & Leadership: To promote Underrepresented Attorneys to management, supervisory, executive, leadership, and similar senior positions. • Engagement of Outside Counsel: To recommend the participation of Underrepresented Attorneys to staff a matter on behalf of the outside Law firm. • Participation in Legal Community Diversity Initiatives: To regularly and actively participate in diversity and inclusion events, volunteer initiatives, and diversity pathway programs organized by the San Diego County Bar Association (SDCBA), SDCBA Committee on Diversity and Inclusion, affinity bar associations, and other law -related organizations. Signing Organization Organization's Website to Link from Diversity Pledge page of SDCBA website Signature Date Name of Signee Title of Signee Please list contact name, and email for communications about this pledge. Name of contact: Email of contact: Would you like the above email address to be added to the private Diversity Pledge Listsery to foster communications amongst signatories about ideas, best practices, and questions related to the goals of the Pledge? ❑ YES ❑ NO Please sign and email this form to: oblankson@sdcba.org 46 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute a Termination of a Notice of Assurances to the State of California of the Use of Property and/or the State of California's Right of Recapture for Kimball Highlands located at 1221 "D" Avenue. (Housing Authority) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 47 of 592 MEETING DATE: CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM No. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute a Termination of a Notice of Assurances to the State of California of the Use of Property and/or the State of California's Right of Recapture for Kimball Highlands located at 1221 "D" Avenue. PREPARED BY: DEPARTMENT:. Greg Rose, Property Agent PHONE: 619-336-4266 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: The Community Development Commission -Housing Authority of the City of National City ("CDC -HA") executed a "Notice of Assurances to the State of California ("State") of the Use of Property and/or the State of California's Right of Recapture", dated as of December 15, 1986, and recorded December 17, 1986 as file number 8 - g o84 of Official Records ("Notice"). All the requirements set forth in the Notice have been satisfied; the Notice expired by its terms and is no longer of any legal force or effect; and the Notice no longer constitutes a burden, lien, or encumbrance against the real property described in the Notice. In 198 the Senior Center was built with a portion of the funds coming from the State. The Notice states that if within 10 years after the acquisition, or 20 years after completion of construction, the center ceases to operate as a Senior Center, the State can recapture its portion of the funds. Both of those dates have passed, and the center is still operating as a Senior Center. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: A+COUN • NO. There is no fiscal impact.. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: The Notice of Termination is not considered a project as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and is therefore not subject to CEQA. APPROVED: Finance nce ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Resolution. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A APPROVED: MIS ATTACHMENTS: 1. Recorded Notice of Assurances .. Termination of Notice of Assurances ,. Resolution 48 of 592 Documents provided by DataTree LLC via it's proprietary imaging and delivery system. Copyright 2003, All rights reserved. Attach No. 1 CDA 116 0 654 RECORDING RCQU STED EY 1 AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION OF THE WY OF NATIONAL CITY 1243 NATIONAL CITY BLVD. �.-- NATIONAL CITY, CALIF. 92050 _. RECORDER: I'leaa� r;aI r 7n chrci;a for reccii n,^ th a'[ached uislrument. It is being recct!te4 in cRnn,?Ciittn with a Gofretnment Agency transaction. Enter Grantee's name and address in the space above (SPACE AdDYE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE) 86 592084 1---- RECORDED In OFFICIAL RECQ1',tY' or ,AU DIEU CD '”1 Y. r. itges DEC ! T A1,1 8: 07 VERA !.. LYLE COUNTY TY �tr'.r4'ft ,I::? Ito NOTICE(F ASSURAN ES TO TUSTATEOE CALIFORNIA OF THE USE OF PROPERTY AND/OR TIM STATE OF CALIFORNIA'S RIGHT OF RECAPTIRR1: The Senior Center Bond Act enacted by the State of California provides that the State of California has a right of recapture describe;, below (Type of Project) on the property/improvements described below (Legal Description) for the period described below (Term) Type of Project: (Mark applicable section for Grantee's project) SECTION945). WELFARE AND INSTITMONSCODE O (a) A recipient of a contract for the acquisition of a facility to be used as a senior center shall assure that the facility will be used for that purpose for at least 10 years from the date of acquisition O (b) A recipient of a contract for the renovation of an existing facility to be used as a senior center shall assure the department the facility will be used for that purpose for the following periods: C (I) Not less than three years from the date the contract terminates, where the amount of the award does not exceed thirty thousand dollars (S30.000) O (2) If the award exceeds thirty thousand dollars (S30.000). the fixed period of time shall increase one year for each additional ten thousand dollars (S10.000) or part thereof. to a maximum of seventy-five thousand dollars ' $75.000 ) (3) For awards which exceed seventy-five thousand dollars (S75 000). the fixed period of time shall not be less than 10 years. (c) A recipient Of a contract for the construction of a facility to be used as a senior - center shall assure the department the facility will be used for that purpose for at least 20 years after completion of construction. 31-- vE� illo l'I 0 .its r i 0 to i Z I li 0 C 2 .o RI ro sn ill 0 X 0 73 49 of 592 Documents provided by DataTree LLC via it's proprietary imaging and delivery system. Copyright 2003, All rights reserved. Attachment No. 1 CDA 116, p.2 ITECORDING REQUESTED BY �) AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO L.- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION OF THE etre OF NATIONAL CITY 1243 NATIONAL CITY BLVD. NATIONAL CITY, CALIF. rO _ E tar Grantee's name and address in the space above 655 SECTION 9156. WELFARE AND INSTITUTIONS CODE (SPACE AbJVE TI-IIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE) (a) The State of California shall be entitled to recapture a portion of state funds from the ovne; of a facility. if within 10 years after acquisition or 20 years after completion of construction. either of the following occurs: (1) The owner of the facility :eases to be a public or nonprofit agency (2) The facility is no longer used for senior center activities (b) The amount recovered shall be that proportion of the current value of the facility equal to the proportion of state funds contributed to the original cost. site. current value of the facility shall be determined by an agreement between the owner of the facility and the State of California. or by an action in the court in the jurisdiction in which the facility is located. Legal Description (include senior center name and address. and a description of the acquisition, renovation or construction accomplished pursuant to the Senior Gaiter Bond Ati): Kimball Senior Center, 1221 "D" Avenue, National City, California 92050. Corstruction of a 5,950 sq,ft. multipurpose senior center and 95 related parking spaces ari landscaping on Lot 6 of Center City Project, in the City of National City, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof No. 8807, filed in tic Office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, February 24, 1978. Amount of Senior Center Bond Act Funds spent for the following activities: $ acquisition $ 317,626.00 $ construction renovation Term; Check the appropriate box below. If A applies. re-reco:d Notice when construction. renovation. or acquisition has been completed- Refer to Type of Project and funds spent by activity to determine term, then enter the beginning and ending dates in (h). rx a. Term has not yet begun but project is in progress- 0 b Begin: End: - 32 - SPRow A I ; 0 tol co 2 m 0 0 2 0-1 0 r :] 50 of 592 Documents provided by DataTree LLC via it's proprietary imaging and delivery system. Copyright 2003, All rights reserved. Attachment No. 1 George >1 Waterst Chairman Title STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTYOF San Diego CDA 115, p. 3 0 656 RECORDING REQUESTED DT AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY 1243 NATIONAL CITY BLVD. NATIONAL CITY, CALIF. OZWO Enter Grantee's name and address in the space above (SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE) Grantee: Community Development Commission of the City of National City, CA, a public body corporate and politic Civic Center, 1243 National City Blvd. Agency's Name Street Address National City, California 92050 Authorized Signature City/Iowa and County (619) 336-4254 Telephone Number On the 15t11 day of December in the year 19 &. before, me. the undersigned. a Notary Public in k1td for said Stag, personally appeared Gerprge H. Waters. Chairman of the Coml,tuntty Development COmunssion of the City of Nati ,nal City, C.;lifornia (or proved to me on the oath/affirmation of ) to be the person_ whose name Is subscribed to the within instrument. and acknowledged to me that he executed the same. ' rims SS pay hand and official $eat. 40io?404-e44-4-4-a4-4.4>ai•b*-4.4.4O0-#4>i, �� ~ ' OFFICIAL, SEAL ¢' "�i� -� �fr ''"�^ • .'�._ ! � DAVID L SH�LDON $ Notary Public in and for said County and State p �e:1 Notary Public i rJ.Lw.,r:t �' ``�17 Fir 15::pllt Of f,iE lrr 8 San Diego Cour... : Mv COMM Flo Aug. 22. 1988 1 +++4*444.4osa 4410i 4.-940SA, 33 - 10.63 f 0 0 COI 2 m r v, 0 0 611.1 044 r 0 t1 CI uis tj 51 of 592 Attachment No. 2 NO CHARGE ON THIS DOCUMENT PER CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 6103 Recording Requested By: National City Housing Authority When Recorded Mail To: National City Housing Authority Attention: Greg Rose 1243 National City Boulevard National City, CA 91950 TERMINATION OF NOTICE OF ASSURANCES TO THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA OF THE USE OF PROPERTY AND/OR THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA'S RIGHT OF RECAPTURE (Kimball Highlands) The Community Development Commission of the City of National City ("CDC") executed and caused that certain Notice of Assurances to the State of California of the Use of Property and/or the State of California's Right of Recapture ("Notice") to be recorded in the Office of the Recorder of the County of San Diego, State of California on December 17, 1986, as Instrument No. 86- 592084. The Community Development Commission -Housing Authority of the City of National City ("CDC -HA") is the successor -in -interest to the CDC. NOW THEREFORE, the CDC -HA hereby acknowledges and agrees that: (i) all requirements set forth in the Notice have been satisfied; (ii) the Notice expired by its own terms and is no longer of any legal force or effect; and (iii) the Notice no longer constitutes a burden, lien or encumbrance against the real property described in the Notice. CDC -HA: Community Development Commission -Housing Authority of the City of National City By: Brad Raulston, Executive Director APPROVED AS TO FORM: Charles Bell Jr., City Attorney By: Jennifer K. Gilman Deputy City Attorney 52 of 592 Attachment No. 2 ACKNOWLEDGMENT A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Diego ) ) ) On , 2021, before me, , notary public, personally appeared who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature (Seal) 53 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute a Termination of a Notice of Restriction on Real Property located at 1320 Highland Avenue. (Housing Authority) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 54 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute Termination of s Notice of Restriction on Real Property located at 1320 Highland Avenue. PREPARED BY: Greg Rose, Property Agent PHONE. 619-336-4266 EXPLANATION: The City of National City ("City11) executed a "Notice of Restriction on Real Property, dated August 24, 1987 and recorded February 1, 1988 as file no. -04 1 7 of Official Records (Notice"). The Notice has expired and is no longer of any legal force or effect; and the Notice no longer constitutes a burden, lien, or encumbrance against the real property described in the Notice. DEPARTMENT: Housiog Authority APPROVED BY: The restriction that is recorded on the property was for a defunct and expired CUP (liquor sales at the former Lucky Grocery Store at this location). FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. There is no fiscal impact. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS The Notice of Termination is not considered a project as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), and is therefore not subject to CEQA. ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Resolution. BOARD l COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A ATTACHMENTS: I. Recorded Notice of Restriction 2. Termination of Notice of Restriction 3. Resolution 55 of 592 Documents provided by DataTree LLC via it's proprietary imaging and delivery system. Copyright 2003, All rights reserved. HEN RECORDS MAIL TO: PLANNING DIRECTOR City of National City 1243 National City Boulevard National City, CA 92050-4397 1356 RECORDING REQUEST BY: LUCKY STORES, INC. /j "P.NIE P Property Owner's Name CRETTRY l'.ils7 £Rz4,hl ERSON 88 0 r, '1C Attachment No. 1 CORDED lt� FO-- OFFICIAL. Rr.C3F flf SM,ll D41 C^ rot-+,lf s,%cA. M9 FEB -1 pig t2: 19 VEi-t:, i_. ,.it 1: 1 ., .t,f;i'. i, ! . .. NOTICE OF RESTRICTION ON REAL PROPERTY; Address: 1320 Highland Avenue Assessor's Parcel # RF 4.00 MC t.Gn The real property located in the City of National City, County of San Diego, State of California described as follows: See Attached is restricted by conditions of approval of P1ap tni _Coumis$1 on �. Resolution _ No. 25-87_ issued by the City of National City. The obligations and restrictions imposed by . anning. Commission _ _ resolution no. 25-87 approving the Conditional Use Pe mit are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. A copy of the Plannin$ Commission Resolution No. 25-$7 is on file with the National City Planning Department. Dated: August 24, 1987 APPROVED AS TO FORM: G ORGE H. EISER, III City Attorney )09-07/4 ROGER G. POST PLANNING DIRECTOR \fr.: l fill 0 0 0 omit .74 „AI< r m , run Irri le pig La c t;. ls� $ 56 of 592 Documents provided by DataTree LLC via it's proprietary imaging and delivery system. Copyright 2003, All rights reserved. 1357 t 1320 HIGHLAND AVENUE LEGAL DESCRIPTION Attachment No. 1 Lot 3 of Center City Project, in the City of National City, County of San Diego, State of California, according to neap thereof' No. 8807, filed in the Office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, February 24, 1978 and the east half of ten acre lot 11 in quarter section 154 of the Rancho de la Nacioa, in said City of National City, County of San Diego, State of California, according to map thereof by Morrill, No. 166. in the Office of the Recorder of said San Diego County. EXCEPTING from said east half of ten acre lot 11, the southerly 20.00 feet thereof, that portion lying within Highland Avenue and that portion thereof described as follows: Beginning at a point on the westerly line of said easterly half of 10 acre lot 11 distant thereon south 17 degrees 48' 30" east 272.59 feet from the norhtwesterly corner .of said easterly half nexng a point in the arc of a 200.00 foot radius curve concave northerly, a radial line of said curve bears south 13 degrees 51' 11" west to said point; thence easterly along the arc of said curve 122.00 feet through an angle of 31 degrees 46' 26"; thence leaving said curve south 17 degrees 55' 15" east 5.00 feet to a point in the northerly line of the southerly 2Q,00 feet of said easterly half of 10 acre lot 11; thence along said line south 72 degrees 04' 45" west 115.92 feet to said westerly line of said easterly half; thence along said line north 17 degrees 48' 30" west 37.97 feet to the point of beginning. 2 2 0 aties 0 :Sp I i 57 of 592 Attachment No. 2 NO CHARGE ON THIS DOCUMENT PER CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 6103 Recording Requested By: City of National City When Recorded Mail To: City of National City Attention: Greg Rose 1243 National City Boulevard National City, CA 91950 TERMINATION OF NOTICE OF RESTRICTION ON REAL PROPERTY (1320 Highland Avenue) The City of National City ("City") executed and caused that certain Notice of Restrictions on Real Property ("Notice") to be recorded in the Office of the Recorder of the County of San Diego, State of California on February 1, 1988, as Instrument No. 88-046127. NOW THEREFORE, the City hereby acknowledges and agrees that: (i) the Notice expired and is no longer of any legal force or effect; and (ii) the Notice no longer constitutes a burden, lien or encumbrance against the real property described in the Notice. CITY: City of National City By: Brad Raulston, Executive Director APPROVED AS TO FORM: Charles Bell Jr., City Attorney By: Jennifer K. Gilman Deputy City Attorney 58 of 592 Attachment No. 2 ACKNOWLEDGMENT A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Diego On , 2021, before me, , notary public, personally appeared who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature (Seal) 59 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for grant coordination services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City, extending the term of the Agreement to September 30, 2023, and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement.(Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 60 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for grant coordination services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City, extending the term of the Agreement to September 30, 2023, and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement. PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant. Engineer - Civil . . DEPARTMENT: Engin ,: ing ;Public Worts PHONE: 619-336-4388 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: On April 16, 2019, per City Council Resolution No. 2019-40, the City of National City ent- red in o an Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. (WCA) to provide grant coordination services in an amount not to exceed 196,000, funded by a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant. The Agreement with WCA was set to expire on March 30, 2021. Due to COVID-19, CAL FIRE has extended the performance period to allow the City to complete the activities delineated as part of this grant. Staff desires to extend the term of the Agreement with WCA to September 30, 2023, to allow them to continue providing grant coordination services to support City staff with project delivery. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: APPROVED: ACCOUNT N. APPROVED: N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: NIA ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt resolution approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for grant coordination services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A ATTACHMENTS: 1. Second Amendment to Agreement 2. Resolution 61 of 592 SECOND D AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF ATION, L CITY AND WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC. THIS SECOND AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT, EMENT, is entered into this 1st day of June, 2021, by and between the CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, a municipal corporation ("CITY"), and WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC., a California corporation (the "CONSULTANT"). NSULTANT"). RECITALS WHEREAS, on April 16, 2019, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 01 -4 } and entered into an Agreement with WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC. ("the Agreement"), wherein the CONSULTANT agreed to provide grant coordination services, including providing volunteer group workshop training, tree and site selection processing, and matched funds collections to meet the requirements of a grant from the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection. WHEREAS, the original term of the Agreement expired on March 1, 20. WHEREAS, the extended term of the Agreement expired on March 30, 2021. WHEREAS, CAL FIRE extended the performance period to allow the City to complete the activities delineated as part of .this grant. WHEREAS, the parties desire to amend. the Agreement to extend the term of the Agreement, expiring September 30, 2023. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties hereto agree: I. The Agreement entered into on April 16, 2019 shall be amended to extend the term of the Agreement, expiring September 30, 2023. 2. The parties further agree that with the foregoing exception, each and every term and provision of the Agreement dated April 16, 2019, shall remain in full force and effect. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Second Amendment to the Agreement on the date and year first above written. [Signature Page to Follow] Second A ndrnent--- Grant Coordination Page 1 of City of National City and June 2021 West Coast Ar on t , Inc. 62 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY By: - - Alejandrar . S oteio-Solis, Mayor APPROVED AS TO FORM: By: Charles E. Bell City Attorney WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION (Corporation — ,signatures of two corporate officers) By: (Name) (Print (Title) By: (Name) (Print) (Title) Second Amendment— Grant Coordination Page 2 of City of National City and June 2021 West Coast Arborists, Inc, 63 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for tree planting services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City, extending the term of the Agreement to September 30, 2023, and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement. (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 64 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June I , 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. for tree planting services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City, extending the term of the Agreement to September 30, 2023, and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement. PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer - Civil 4 . DEPARTMENT: Engi e in• Public Works PHONE: 619-336-4388 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: On May 15, 2018, per City Council Resolution No_ 2018-72, the City of National City ent- ed into an Agreement with West Coast Arborists, Inc. (WCA) to provide tree planting services in an amount not to exceed $297,500, funded by a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant. The Agreement with WCA was set to expire on March 30, 2021. Due to C VI D-1 , CAL FIRE has extended the performance period to allow the City to complete the activities delineated as part of this grant. Staff desires to extend the term of the Agreement with WCA to September 30, 2023, to allow them to continue providing tree planting services to support City staff with project delivArv. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A► ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt resolution approving a Second Amendment to the Agreement with West Coast Arborists, inc. for tree planting services for a CAL FIRE Urban and Community Forestry Grant awarded to the City of National City and authorizing the Mayor to execute the Agreement. BOARD 1 COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A ATTACHMENTS: 1. Second Amendment to Agreement 2. Resolution 65 of 592 SECOND AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT BY AND BETWEEN THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AND WEST COAST . RBRIST , INC. THIS SECOND AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT, is entered into this 1st day of June, 2021, by and between the CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, a municipal corporation ("CITY"), and WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC., a California corporation (the "CONSULTANT"). RECITALS WHEREAS, on May 15, 2018, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 201 - 2 and entered into an Agreement with WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC. ("the Agreement"), wherein the CONSULTANT agreed to plant 1,700 trees in the City of National City in an effort to help reduce greenhouse gas emissions. WHEREAS, the original term of the Agreement expired on March 1, 2020. WHEREAS, the extended term of the Agreement expired on March 30, 2021. WrIEREAS, CAL FIRE extended the performance period to allow the City to complete the activities delineated as part of this grant. WHEREAS, the parties desire to amend the Agreement to extend the term of the Agreement, expiring September 30, 2023. NOW, THEREFORE, the parties hereto agree as follows: 1. The Agreement entered into on May 15, 2018 shall be amended to extend the term of the Agreement, expiring September 30, 2023. 2. The parties further agree that with the foregoing exception, each and every term and provision of the Agreement dated May 15, 2018, shall remain in full force and effect. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Second Amenchnent to the Agreement on the date and year first above written. [Signature Page to Follow] Second Amendment — Tree Planting Page 1 of City of National City and June 2021 West Coast Arborists, I c. 66 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL NAL CITY By: Ai ja dra S t lo-Solis, Mayor APPROVED AS TO FORM: By: Charles E. Bell City Attorney WEST COAST ARBORISTS, INC., A CALIFORNIA P I ATI l` ("proration — signatures of Avo corporate officers) By: (Name) ('Print) (Title) By: (Name) (Print) (Title) Second Amendment— Tree Planting Page 2 of 2 June 2021 City of National City and West Coast Arborists, Inc. 67 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute an Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities ("AHSC") Implementation and Mutual Indemnity Agreement with the Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee on Anti -Poverty of San Diego County, Inc. (MAAC Project), a 501(c)3 non-profit organization, for the City's implementation of transportation infrastructure or transit -related amenities with a total budget of $8,250,000 within the vicinity of the a proposed 400-unit affordable housing project at 233 Roosevelt Avenue in National City. (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 68 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. !TEMTITLE; Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to execute an Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities ("AHSC") Implementation and Mutual Indemnity Agreement with the Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee on Anti -Poverty of San Diego County, Inc. (MAAC Project), a 01(003 non-profit organization, for the City's implementation of transportation infrastructure or transit -related amenities with a total budget of $8,250,000 within the vicinity of the a proposed 400-unit affordable housing project at 233 Roosevelt Avenue in National City. PREPARED BY: Roberto 'nano, Director of PublicWorks DEPARTMENT: En± g -erin and Public Works City Engineer PHONE: (619) 3 -43 3, EXPLANATION: See Attachment No. 1 and 2. APPROVED BY: FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO, to be determined if funds are awarded. APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS The Agreement has no immediate financial impact to the City and there is no commitment for additional funds to subsidize the proposed housing or infrastructure projects. If the AHSC grant is awarded, $825O,O0O would fund City transportation projects or transit projects/programs in the vicinity of the housing project. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: The grant application is not a considered a "Project" under section 15378 of the California Environmental Quality Act ("CEQA" and therefore is not subject to environmental review. ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: p FINAL ADOPTION: STAFF RE+OMMENDATION: Adopt the Resolution., BOARD 1 COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: INot applicable to the adoption of the Resolution. ATTACHMENTS 1. Explanation 2. AHSC Implementation and Mutual Indemnity Agreement 3. Resolution 69 of 592 City of National City June 1, 2021 Staff Report Explanatiort Background: Attachment #1 The State of California, the Strategic Growth Council ("SGC1') and the Department of Housing and Community Development ("HAD") issued a Notice of Funding Availability dated February 26, 2021 ("AHSC NOFA"), , under the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities ("AHSC") Program established under Division 44, Part 1 of the Public Resources Code, commencing with Section 75200. The Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee on Anti -Poverty of San Diego County, Inc., a California nonprofit public benefit corporation, doing business as MAAC Project, ("Developer") is applying for AHSC funds in response to the AHSC NOFA to provide funding for (collectively, the "Project"): (A) construction of a 400-unit r i ed- income affordable housing project located at 233 Roosevelt Avenue in the City of National City ("Housing Project"); the construction of certain housing related infrastructure (HRI Improvements"); (C) the construction of certain sustainable transportation infrastructure ("STI Improvements"); the construction of certain transit related amenities ("TRA Improvements"); and (E) program activities ("AHSC Programs"). All of which are described in more detail in the Final Application to be submitted to HCD by the Developer on or about June 8, 2021 ("AHSC Application"). The AHSC Application seeks an award in an aggregate amount not to exceed $28,250,000 in AHSC funds consisting of: (A) $2of AHSC permanent loan ("AHSC Loan") funds which will be disbursed to the Developer or it's nominee ('Partnership")for construction of the Housing Project and HRI Improvements; and (B) $8,250,000 of AHSC grant funds ('AHSC Grant") which will be disbursed for the purpose of financing or reimbursing the cost of the STI Improvements, TRA Improvements and AHSC Programs. The AHSC Loan and the AHSC Grant are collectively referred to herein as the "AHSC Financing." For the purpose of performing the obligations ("Transit Obligations"), the Developer will reimburse the City $8,250,000. The City and Developer are required to enter the attached Implementation and Mutual Indemnity Agreement ("Agreement") in order to comply with the specific AHSC Program Threshold Requirement stated in Section 106(a)12(A) of the 2019-20 AHSC Program Guidelines dated February 24, 2021 (the "Transportation City Prior Experience Threshold Requirement"}. Such section of the guidelines dictates that applicants must demonstrate prior experience by providing evidence of at least two prior projects that are similar to the proposed AHSC project in scope and size, which have been completed by the applicant, or joint applicant, during the ten (10) years preceding the application due date. Such section of the guidelines also states that applicants may demonstrate the requisite experience by using the past experience of work completed by a non -applicant so long as the applicant can provide an executed • • • • Page 1 of3 70 of 592 agreement with such non -applicant for the completion of the related to, amongst other things, comply with the Transportation City Prior Experience Threshold Requirement. The City is a non -applicant, but, will have the obligation to perform the following specific STI Improvements, and TRA Improvements included in the AHSC Application (collectively, the "Transit Obligations"): 1. Bayshore Bikeway Segment - million a. The "Bayshore Bikeway - Segment5" project (Segrnent 5) will provide over a half -mile of protected bicycle facilities along McKinley Avenue and Marina Way in the City of National City. Segment 5 will complete the final leg of the Bayshore Bikeway within National City; and enhance bicycling connections to transit and other key destinations such as the Harbor District, Navy Base San Diego, Kimball Elementary School, and several parks. Additionally, the project will provide a connection to the Sweetwater River Trail, another regional bikeway. With the completion of Segment 5, i"lational City residents will be able to access as far north as Downtown San Diego and as far south as the City of Chula Vista using only protected facilities. b. Funds will help construct protected bicycle facilities with enhanced intersection treatments for people walking and biking. Funds will also supplement the southern portion of this segment next to the Paradise Lagoon, including costs for utilizing the old abandoned National City railway, including a small trestle bridge, view overlooks, habitat enhancement and educational opportunities for nature and history signage and exhibits. 2. ath and Roosevelt Multi -Use Path - $5.75 million a. The proposed project will remove one lane of travel creating a one-way southbound roadway, remove the existing bike lanes, and add over a half - mile of context -sensitive bikeways along 8th and Roosevelt. The proposed project will construct over 2,000 feet of safe and accessible pedestrian walkways. The proposed multi -use path will also be used for the proposed NEV Shuttle Route. b. Yama St. Naval Base Connection: Yama Street leads into the "Dry side" of Naval Base San Diego where a lot of individuals work, live, shop or play on this side of the base. The 8th and Roosevelt ATP project will be building a Multi -use Path along the west side of Roosevelt, with the intention of extending this pathway to the back gate at Marna. The project would add a turn -around for the NEV shuttle, have a drop-off location at this end and would improve the pedestrian crossing and add bulb -outs to the intersection of Yama and Main Street. The project would also include the addition of a Ieft turn lane down Varna to accommodate a more efficient way to get to the Southbound 1-5 ramps. c. 8th Street Naval Base Connection: extend the proposed multi -use path and Neighborhood Electric Vehicle to the Naval Base Gate at 8th and Harbor. Page 2 of 71 of 592 Funds will also construct crossing improvements at the active BNSF railroad tracks on Harbor Drive. This project would reconstruct the at - grade crossings and crossing arms and signage in addition to extending the 14' wide multi -use path through the intersection of Harbor and 8t". This intersection would also be improved with pedestrian crossings, reconfiguration of the high-speed turning lanes and all necessary ADA requirements. 3. Neighborhood Electric Vehicle (NEV) Shuttle Route - $1,500,000 a. This project will create a new 3 5 mile shared mobility service route for community members using neighborhood electric vehicles (NEV) throughout the central region of NationalCity, including downtown, extending from the waterfront to Kimball Park, and from the 24th Street Trolley Station to the 8th Street Trolley Station. b. The shuttle service will be free for residents and will run regularly Monday thru Friday at 9 different pick-up / drop-off locations, most of which will include mini -mobility hubs (electric scooters and bikes) with Transit Smart Mobility technology. c. This improvement ent will encourage mode shift away from single -occupancy vehicular travel and towards clean and safe transportation alternatives through the implementation of shared mobility routes and smart mobility technology where none exist today. d. Funds will support extended transit operations for 5 years on 3 shuttles around National City. The City's obligations and duties under the Agreement shall be limited to developing and constructing the Transit Obligations, and for all costs and expenses related thereto. Developer shall be responsible for constructing and developing the Housing Project and the HRI I Improvements (collectively, the "Developer Obligations"), and for all costs and expenses related thereto. In connection with the AHSC Financing, Developer is required to enter into standard agreements, disbursement agreements, and regulatory agreements with HCD whereby Developer will be liable for the full and timely performance of the obligations set forth therein, including completion of the Housing Project, completion of the HRI, STI and TRA-1mprovements and funding of the AHSC Programs, as described in the AHSC Application. Page 3of3 72 of 592 Atta hm ent No. AHSC IMPLEMENTATION AND MUTUAL INDEMNITY AGREEMENT EEl" TENT THIS AHSC IMPLEMENTATION AND MUTUAL INDEMNITY AGREEMENT ("Agreement") is made and entered into as of June 1, 2021, between the City of National City ("City") and the Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee on Anti -Poverty of San Diego County, Inc., a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ("Developer", and collectively with the City, the "Parties", or individually, a "Party"), upon the basis ofthe following facts, understanding and intentions ofthe Parties: A. The State of California, the Strategic Growth Council ("SGC") and the Department of Housing and Community Development "FI L " issued a Notice of Funding Availability dated February 26, 2021 ("AHSC NOFA"), under the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities ("AHSC") Program established under Division 44, Part 1 of the Public Resources Code, commencing with Section 75200. B. Developer is applying for AHSC funds in response to the APIs C NOFA to provide funding for (collectively, the "Project"): (A) construction of a 400-unit mixed -income affordable housing project located at 233 Roosevelt Avenue in the City of National City (`Housing Project"); (B) the construction of certain housing related infrastructure ("HIRI Improvements"); the construction of certain sustainable transportation infrastructure ("STI Improvements"); (D) the construction of certain transit related amenities ("TRA Improvements"); and (E) program activities ("AHSC Programs"). All of which are described in more detail in the Final Application to be submitted to HCD by the Developer on or about June 8, 2021 ("AFISC Application"). C. The AHSC Application seeks an award in an aggregate amount not to exceed $28,250,000 in AHSC fiinds consisting of: (A) $ of AHSC permanent loan ("AHSC Loan") funds which will be disbursed to the Developer or it's nominee ("Partnership") for construction of the Housing Project and HR1 Improvements; and(B) $8,250,000 of AHSC grant fiends "AFTS Grant") will be disbursed for the purpose of financing or reimbursing the cost of the STI Improvements, TRA Improvements and AHSC Programs. The AHSC Loan and the AHSC Grant are collectively referred to herein as the "AHSC Financing." For the purpose of performing the obligations set forth in Recital F, below, Developer will reimburse the City , 5 0, 00. I. The City and Developer are required to enter into this Agreement in order to comply with the specific AHSC Program Threshold Requirement stated in Section 1 a 1 A of the 2019-20 AHSC Program Guidelines dated February 4, 2021 (the "Transportation City Prior Experience Threshold Requirement"). Such section of the guidelines dictates that applicants must demonstrate prior experience by providing evidence of at least two prior projects that are similar to the proposed AHSC project in scope and size, which have been completed by the applicant, or joint applicant, during the ten (10) years preceding the application due date. Such section of the guidelines also states that applicants may demonstrate the requisite experience by using the past experience of work completed by 1 of 73 of 592 Attachment No. a non -applicant so long as the applicant can provide an executed agreement with such non - applicant for the completion of the related to, amongst other things, comply with the Transportation City Prior Experience Threshold Requirement. E. The City owns the property that the Transit Obligations are to be performed on, and thus has sufficient "Site Control" as that term is defined in the 2019-20 AIISC Program Guidelines dated February 24, 2021. F. The City is a non -applicant, but, as set forth herein, will have the obligation to perform the following specific STI Improvements, and TRA Improvements included in the AHSC Application (collectively, the `Transit Obligations"): 1. Bayshore Bikeway Segment - 1 million a. The "Bayshore Bikeway - Segment 5" project(Segment will provide over a half - mile of protected bicycle facilities along McKinley Avenue and Marina Way in the City of National City. Segment 5 will complete the final leg of the Bayshore Bikeway within National City; and enhance bicycling connections to transit and other key destinations such as the Harbor District, Navy Base San Diego, Kimball Elementary School, and several parks. Additionally, the project will provide a connection to the Sweetwater River Trail, another regional bikeway. With the completion of Segment 5, National City residents will be able to access as far north as Downtown San Diego and as far south as the City of Chula Vista using only protected facilities. b. Funds will help construct protected bicycle facilities with enhanced intersection treatments for people walking and biking. Funds will also supplement the southern portion of this segment next to the Paradise Lagoon, including costs for utilizing the old abandoned National City railway, including a small trestle bridge, view overlooks, habitat enhancement and educational opportunities for nature and history signage and exhibits. 2. 8th and Roosevelt Multi -Use Path - $5.75 million a. The proposed project will remove one lane of travel creating a one-way southbound roadway, remove the existing bike lanes, and add over a half -mile of context -sensitive bikeways along 8th and Roosevelt. The proposed project will construct over 2,000 feet of safe and accessible pedestrian walkways. The proposed multi -use path will also be used for the proposed NEVShuttle Route. b. Yama St. Naval Base Connection: Yama Street leads into the "Dry side" of Naval Base San Diego where a lot of individuals work, live, shop or play on this side of the base. The 8th and Roosevelt ATP project will be building a Multi -use Path along the west side of Roosevelt, with the intention of extending this pathway to the back gate at Yam& The project would add a turn -around for the NEV shuttle, have a drop-off location at this end and would improve the pedestrian crossing and add bulb -outs to the intersection of Yama and Main Street. The project would of 74 of 592 Attachment No. 2 also include the addition of a left turn lane down Manna to accommodate a more efficient way to get to the Southbound 1-5 ramps. c. 8th Street Naval Base Connection: extend the proposed multi -use path and Neighborhood Electric Vehicle to the Naval Base Gate at 8t11 and Harbor. Funds will also construct crossing improvements at the active BNSF railroad tracks on Harbor Drive. This project would reconstruct the at -grade crossings and crossing arms and signage in addition to extending the 14' wide multi -use path through the intersection of Harbor and 8th, This intersection would also be improved with pedestrian crossings, reconfiguration of the high-speed turning lanes and all necessary ADA requirements. 3. Neighborhood Electric Vehicle (NEV)Shuttle Route - $1,500,000 a. This project will create a new . -mile shared mobility service route for community members using neighborhood electric vehicles (NEV)throughout the central region of National City, including downtown, extending from the waterfront to Kimball Park, and from the 24th Street Trolley Station to the 8th Street Trolley Station. b. The shuttle service will be free for residents and will run regularly Monday thru Friday at 9 different pick-up / drop-off locations, most of which will include mini - mobility hubs (electric scooters and bikes) with Transit Smart Mobility technology. c. This improvement will encourage mode shift away from single -occupancy vehicular travel and towards clean and safe transportation alternatives through the implementation of shared mobility routes and smart mobility technology where none exist today. d. Funds will support extended transit operations for 5 years on 3 shuttles around National City. G. The City can demonstrate prior experience and provide evidence of at least two prior projects that are similar in scope and size which have been completed during the ten (10) years preceding June 8, 2021, H. The City's obligations and duties under this Agreement shall be limited to developing and constructing the Transit Obligations, and for all costs and expenses related thereto. Developer shall be responsible for constructing and developing the Housing Project and the HRI Improvements (collectively, the "Developer eloper Obligations"), and for all costs and expenses related. thereto. In connection with the AHSC Financing, Developer is required to enter into standard agreements, disbursement agreements, and regulatory agreements with HCD whereby Developer will be liable for the full and timely performance of the obligations set forth therein, including completion of the Housing Project, completion of the MI, STI and TRA Improvements and funding of the ANSC Programs, as described in the AHSC Application. The AHSC Application and all standard agreements, disbursement ent agreements, regulatory agreements and any other agreements required by HCD in connection with the AHSC Financing shall be collectively referred to herein as the "AHSC Documents". of 75 of 592 Attachment No. 2 The City and Developer each acknowledge and agree that the inability or failure by either Party to fully and timely complete each Party's respective improvements required by the AHSC Documents may affect the timing and right of the other Party to receive disbursement of due the other party notwithstanding the other Party's full and timely performance of its obligations. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the recitals, covenants and agreements set forth herein, and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the Parties hereto hereby agree as follows: AGREEMENT 1, Obligations. The City shall have the sole responsibility to complete the Transit Obligations in accordance with the terms of the AHSC Documents, the approved design and construction documents and the terms of this Agreement. The Developer have the sole responsibility to complete the Developer Obligations in accordance with the terms of the ALISC Documents, the approved design and construction documents and the terms of this Agreement. Each Party will provide the other Party with copies of all requisitions for work related to their respective obligation, the notice of completion, and other documents related to their respective work that another Party may reasonably request. 2. City Indemnity. The City shall be responsible for carrying out the Transit Obligations using AHSC Grant proceeds in accordance with the AFISC Documents, including, but not limited to, any disbursement deadlines contained therein. The City shall indemnify, defend, protect, and hold harmless Developer, and Developer's affiliates, directors, officers, partners, members, agents and employees (each, a "Developer Indemnified Party") against any and all claims, actions, suits, causes of action, losses, liabilities, injuries, costs, damages and expenses (collectively, "Claims"), including, without limitation, any direct liability, damage, or expense arising out of or in connection with. the City's performance of or failure to perform its obligations to complete the Transit Obligations, in the manner, within the time periods, and to otherwise perform any covenants constituting City obligations, set forth in the AHSC Documents, including any claims, losses or liabilities of the Partnership caused by a breach or default by the City under the AITSC Documents that triggers a default under the AFISC Loan. However, in no event shall any Developer Indemnified Party be indemnified hereunder for any Claims resulting from such Party's sole negligence or willful misconduct. 3. Developer Indemnity. Developer shall be responsible for carrying out the Developer Obligations using AHSC Financing funds in accordance with the AHSC Documents, including, but not limited to, any disbursement deadlines contained therein. Developer and the Partnership shall indemnif, defend, protect, and hold harmless the City and its affiliates, cou cilme burs, officers, officials, agents and employees (each, an "City Indemnified Party") against any and all Claims, including, without limitation, any direct, indirect or consequential loss, liability, damage, or expense, arising out of or in connection with Developer' s performance of or failure to perform the Developer Obligations, in the manner, within the time periods, and to otherwise perform any covenants constituting the Developer 4of 76 of 592 Attachment No. Obligations, set forth in the AHSC Documents, including any claims, losses or liabilities of all City Indemnified Parties caused by a breach or default by the Developer or the Partnership under the AHSC Documents that triggers a default under the AHSC Financing. However, in no event shall any City Indemnified Party be indemnified hereunder for any Claims resulting from such Party's sole negligence or willful misconduct. 4. Schedule of Performance; Progress Reports. The City and Developer shall comply with a schedule of performance for the completion of their respective obligations hereunder the "Schedule of Performance") to be finalized and approved by the City Manager and President & CEO of the Developer no later than 90 days after the AHSC funds are awarded. The City and Developer each agrees to give the other Party a written quarterly status report on the progress toward the milestones on the Developer and Transit Obligations. If any Party anticipates not meeting the targeted construction and disbursement milestones as established in the AIISC Documents, that Party will promptly notify the other parties in writing and will meet the other Party to discuss the reasons why the milestone dates may not be met and what actions the delayed Party intends to take to meet the milestones or otherwise rectify the work schedule in order to maintain good standing with the tens and conditions established in the AHSC D o cuments . 5. Pelegation. Notwithstanding the obligations of each Party under this Agreement, each Party shall be entitled to enter into sub -agreements with each other or with other parties to provide any assistance or services needed for such Party to perform its obligations under this Agreement and the AFI C Documents. 6. Cost Overruns. Developer shall be responsible for paying all costs required to complete the Developer Obligations, irrespective of whether such costs exceeds the ARSC Loan and the portion of the AHSC Grant designated for the Developer Obligations. City shall be responsible for paying all costs required for the Transit Obligations irrespective of whether such costs exceed the portion of the AFISC Grant designated for the Transit Obligations. 7. Disbursement of RISC Grant Funds. The City and Developer agree that the AHSC Grant for the Transit Obligations shall be reimbursed directly to City and that the MISC Grant for the Developer Obligations shall be reimbursed directly to Developer. The Parties further agree that all of the AHSC Loan funds shall be disbursed directly to the Developer or Partnership, as applicable. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if required by the AHSC Documents, the City shall submit to Developer all draw requests for AHSC Grant funds for the costs associated with the Transit Obligations and Developer shall submit such requests to HCD and promptly disburse to the City any such funds received from HCD. The City shall apply any such proceeds received to pay the invoices submitted in connection with the draw request. 8. Implementation Agreements. In the event the AHSC Financing is received from MC, the City and Developer recognize that each Party will need additional assurances from the other Party (including assurances for the Project's lenders and investors) regarding the specific grant award before commencement of constiuction of the Project. The Parties agree to cooperate in amending this Agreement and/or entering into implementation agreements or off= 77 of 592 Attachment No. other documents necessary to provide reasonable assurances related to the disbursement of AHSC Grant funds. The Parties recognize that any such amendments to this Agreement or execution of additional agreements may require approval of the City Council and the Developer's Board of Directors. 9. Notices, All notices under this Agreement shall be in writing and sent (a) by certified or registered U.S. mail, return receipt requested, (b) overnight by a nationally recognized overnight courier such as UPS Overnight or FedEx, or (c) by personal delivery. All notices shall be effective upon receipt (or refusal to accept delivery). All notices shall be delivered to the following addresses or such other addresses as changed by any party from time to time by written notice to the other parties hereto. City: City of National City 1243 National City Boulevard National City, CA 91950 Attention: City Manager Developer: Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee on Anti -Poverty of San Diego County, Inc. 1355 Third Avenue Chula Vista, CA 91911 Attn: President & CEO 10. Events of Default. The failure of any Party to perform any action or covenant required by this Agreement which is not cured within thirty days after written notice of such failure has been delivered to the defaulting Party shall be a default hereunder; provided, however, the other Party shall not be in default if such alleged default is such that it is not capable of being cured within thirty (30) days, but corrective action is initiated within thirty days and the allegedly defaulting Party diligently and in good faith works to effect a cure as soon as is reasonably possible. 11. Termination. This Agreement shall terminate upon the earlier of: (i) completion of all obligations under the AHSC Documents; or (ii) the mutual agreement of the parties hereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the indemnity obligations set forth in Sections 2 and 3, above, shall survive termination of this Agreement. 12. Third Party .Beneficiary. The Partnership shall be a third -party beneficiary of this Agreement and shall be entitled to the rights and benefits hereunder and may enforce the provisions hereof as if it were Party to this Agreement. 134 Assignment. City hereby acknowledges and approves the assignment by Developer and the Partnership to the Housing Project's senior lender ("Construction Lender") of all of each of their respective right, title and interest in, to and under the Agreement("Collateral") as collateral security for the Partnership's obligations to Construction Lender under, and in connection with Construction Lender's loan to the Partnership. In the event Construction Lender forecloses upon the Partnership's interest in the Housing Project, the City hereby 4 of 9 78 of 592 Attachment No. agrees that Construction Lender shall have all of Developer's rights and interests under the Agreement. If this Agreement is assigned to the Construction Lender as contemplated by this Section 13, then the Construction Lender shall be an express third -per beneficiary ciary of this Section 13, and in such event the parties hereto shall not amend, modify or terminate the Agreement without Construction Lender's express written consent. 14. Miscellaneous. (a) If any Party delays in exercising or fails to exercise any right or remedy against a Party, that alone shall not be construed as a waiver of such right or remedy. All remedies of any Party against the other Party are cumulative. (b) This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of each of the Parties hereto and their respective representatives, heirs, executor, administrators, successors, and assigns. This Agreement may not be amended except by a written instrument executed by the parties hereto. (c) This Agreement shall be deemed to have been delivered and accepted in the State of California and governed exclusively by the internal substantive laws of the State of California as the same may exist at the date hereof. The parties hereto hereby agree that any action hereon between the Parties hereto and their successors in interest shall be filed and maintained at San Diego County Superior Court, and consent to the jurisdiction of said court for the purposes connected herewith. (d) Each Party hereto intends that this Agreement shall not benefit or create any right or cause of action in or on behalf of any person other than the parties hereto, except as otherwise set forth herein. (e) This Agreement may be executed in multiple counterpart copies, any one of which when duly executed, with all formalities hereof, shall be fully binding and effective as the original of this Agreement. (f) This Agreement shall be effective as of the date first written above, provided however that in the event that the parties do not receive an award of the AHSC Financing, this Agreement shall automatically terminate and be of no further force or effect. Each of the undersigned hereby executes this Agreement in the spaces provided below to evidence their respective agreement to the terms of this Agreement. [SIGNATURES ON FOLLOWING PAGE] of 79 of 592 Attachment No. CITY: City of National City By: Brad Raulston, City Manager r APPROVED AS TO FORM: Charles Bell Jr., City Attorney B. [SIGNATURES CONTINUED ON FULLOWING PAGE] of 80 of 592 Attachment No. DEVELOPER: Metropolitan Area Advisory Committee onAnti-Poverty of San Diego County, Inc., a California nonprofit public benefit corporation By:■ Name: Its: f 81 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. 2nd Street, to increase parking turnover for customers and employees of the nearby businesses and to enhance street safety (TSC No. 2021-07). (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 82 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. 2nd Street, to increase parking turnover for customers and employees of the nearby businesses and to enhance street safety (TSC No. 2021-07). PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer Civil CAA* DEPARTMENT: E PHONE: 619-336-4388 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: See attached. gl u li'c Works FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. 1N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Resolution authorizing installation of "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. nd Street, to increase parking turnover for customers and employees of the nearby businesses and to enhance safety at the street. BOARD 1 COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At their meeting on May 12, 2021, the Traffic Safety Committee approved staffs recommendation to install "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north side of E. 2nci Street. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Explanation wi Exhibit 2. Staff Report to the Traffic Safety Committee on May 12, 2021 (TSC No. 2021-07) 3. Resolution 83 of 592 EXPLANATION An area resident has requested the installation of "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of 2nd Street. The resident stated that commercial vehicles park very often and use up the available on -street parking along Highland Avenue during the day and night. The resident also mentioned that the installation of "No Truck Parking" signs would discourage trucks, semi -trucks, and/or trailers from parking adjacent to the businesses. Staff visited the site and verified that Highland Avenue is located in a mixed area with commercial businesses and residences and that commercial vehicles do park on Highland Avenue. The on -street parking spaces on the east side of the street do not have time restriction. Staff observed that there is existing "No Truck Parking" signs on the east side of Highland Avenue adjacent to 804 Melrose Street. Staff also observed that the adjacent businesses do not have sufficient off-street parking for their customers and employees. Furthermore, it should be noted that staff is evaluating opportunities to relocate truck parking to more desirable locations andor establish truck permit parking programs to minimize impacts to residents and businesses. Staff measured the amount of parking available on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. 2nd Street, with no "No Truck larking" signs. In total, there are approximately 60 feet of on -street parallel parking spaces available for three (3) vehicles. Staff also reviewed the traffic collision history for this location, which confirmed there were four 4 "reported" traffic collision within the past four years. See attached `Traffic Collision History" summary table. This item was presented to the Traffic Safety Committee on May 12, 2021. Staff sent notices to area residents inviting them to Zoom -in or call -in to the Traffic Safety Committee Meeting and/or contact staff with any questions. Staff presented the results of the site evaluation and after discussion, the Traffic Safety Committee voted to approve staffs recommendation. If approved by City Council, all work will be performed by City Public Works. 84 of 592 Location Map with Proposed Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-07) PARKING VEHICLES OVER 6 HIGH E. 2....Street 60' of proposed "No Parking Vehicles Over 6' High" signs QogIEwth NATIONAL CITY TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE AGENDA REPORT FOR MAY 12, 2020 ITEM TITLE: PREPARED DISCUSSION: REQUEST UEST TO INSTALL "NO TRUCK PARKING" SI NA E ON THE EAST SIDE OF HIGHLAND AVENUE NORTH OF E 2ND STREET TO INCREASE PARKING TURNOVER FOR CUSTOMERS AND EMPLOYEES OF THE NEARBY BY BUSINESSES, AND TO ENHANCE SAFETY AT THE STREET. Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer - Civil Engineering & Public Works Department An area resident has requested the installation of "No Truck Parking" signage on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. 2nd Street. The resident stated that commercial vehicles park very often and use up the available on -street parking along Highland Avenue during the day and night. The resident also mentioned that the installation of "No Truck Parking" signs would discourage trucks, semi -trucks and/or trailers from parking adjacent to the businesses. Staff visited the site and verified that Highland Avenue is located in a mixed area with commercial businesses and residences, and that commercial vehicles do park on Highland Avenue. The on -street parking spaces are currently on the east side of the street do not have time restriction. Staff observed that there is existing "No Truck Parking" signs on the east side of Highland Avenue adjacent to 804 Melrose Street. Staff also observed that the adjacent businesses do not have sufficient off-street parking for their customers and employees. Furthermore, it should be noted that staff is evaluating opportunities to relocate truck parking to more desirable locations and/or establish truck permit parking programs to minimize impacts to residents and businesses. Staff measured the amount of parking available on the east side of Highland Avenue, east of E. 2nd Street with no "No Truck Parking" signs. In total, there are approximately 60 feet of on - street parallel parking spaces available for three vehicles. Staff also reviewed the traffic collision history for this location, which confirmed there were four (4) reported" traffic collision within the past four years. See attachment traffic collision summary table. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: MEI DATION: Staff recommends the installation of 60 feet of "No Parking Vehicles Over 6' High" signs (R28D) on the east side of Highland Avenue, north of E. 2nd Street, in order to provide on - street parking for customers and employees of the nearby businesses, and to discourage semi -trucks from parking in this area. 86 of 592 EXHIBITS: 1. Public Request 2. Public Notice 3. Location Map 4. Photos 5. Traffic collision history 2021-07 87 of 592 CALIFORNIA N AT I 0 NA IiiircORPoRANSD PUBLIC REQUEST FORM Contact Information Name: Area resident Address: Phone: Email: Request Information Location: East side of Highland Ave, north of E. 2nd St. Request: Requesting "No Truck Parking" signs Attachments: Yes No Description: Internal UseOnly: Request Received By: Date: Received via: Counter/in-Person Telephone Assigned To: Notes: Email Fax Referral: 88 of 592 May 5, 2021 Resident/Property Owner CALIFORNIA NATI NAL cum Subject: TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE ITTEE (TSC) ITEM NO. 2021-07 REQUEST TO INSTALL 60 FEET OF "NO TRUCK PARKING" SIGNAGE ON THE EAST SIDE OF HIGHLAND AVENUE, NORTH OF E. 2ND STREET, TO INCREASE PAVING TURNOVER FOR CUSTOMERS AND EMPLOYEES OF THE NEARBY BUSINESSES, AND TO ENHANCE SAFETY AT THE STREET. Dear Sir/Madame: The City of National City would like to invite you to our next public Traffic Safety Committee Conference Cali scheduled for Wednesday, May 12, 2021, at 1:00 P.M. via Zoom. Please use the following information to call -in to the meeting during the scheduled time: Join Zoom Meeting from computer https://zoom.us/j/ 9693 5 r rd= W 1 Qn P I Fa tR nth' nNm mYxdz0g Join 'oorr '1eetiri b p on +1 8 g-900- 1 8 Meeting l D : 996 9343 8895 Passcode: 754338 If you have any questions, comments, and/or concerns, please contact the Engineering Department at 619-336-4380 and reference Traffic Safety Committee Item Number 2021-07. Sincerely, Roberto Yano, P.E. City Engineer/Director of Public Works RY:ch Enclosure: Location Map 2021-07 1234 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-6530 (619) 336-4380 Fax (619) 336-4397 engineering@na#ionalcityca.gov 89 of 592 Location Map with Proposed Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-07) VEHICLES OVER ' �II�Gr Existing 60' of red curb "No larking" 60' of proposed "No Parking Vehicles Over 6' High" signs 123,127 Highland Aire '1133 Highland Ave Pi's Cafe & Snack 133A Highland Ave - Car Audio Plus 11 PARKING vaiICLES OVER 6' HIGH I128D (CA) 10 PARKING VEHICLES OVER 6t HIGH Location of proposed "No Parking vehicles over 6' High" signs on the east side of Highland Avenue (looking south) NO PARKING VEHICLE OVER 6HIGH Highland Avenue '"Mm•mat., _ Location of proposed "No Parking vehicles over 6' High" signs on the east side of Highland Avenue (looking north) 91 of 592 Location of existing "No Truck Parking" signs on the east side of Highland Avenue, adjacent to 804 Melrose Street Location of existing No Parking vehicles over 6' High" signs on the east side of Highland Avenue (looking north) 92 of 592 Traffic Collision History (NCPD Records Division) From May 5, 2017 _• May 5, 2021, there was three (3) traffic collision on the intersection of Highland Avenue & E. 2 Street. ' VIOLA71O.N DE5 IP7ION NATIONALCTY 18 J21O9B 4/27j201S15 VC 22350 UNSAFE SPEED (BASIC SPEED LAW) (I) FfG-1 NDAVEN'UE,NC, 919 0 3 = N INFRACTION NATIONAL CIre 19C046.I 1/24/201914:3S VC 22350 UNSAFE SPEED (BASIC SPEED LAW) (I) Y 1 0 N N INFRACTION 200HIGHLAND AVENUE, NC, 91950 NATICIr ALCMTY 2005933 10/25/20200:01 VC 22350 UNSAFE SPEED (BASIC SPEED tAW) (1) 735 E 02ND STREET, NC, 91950 N o I:0 Y MISDEMEANOR hd INFRACTION NATIONAL CITY 1903535 7/5/201910:12 VC21802A RIGHT-OF-WAY,FROM STOP INTERSECTION (I) EO2ND STREET & HIGHLAND AVENUE, NC, 91950 Y 3 0 N N INFRACTION 4p 5 t 93 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of a blue curb disabled persons parking space with sign in front of the residence located at 1540 Harding Avenue (TSC No. 2021-08). (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 94 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of a blue curb disabled persons parking space with sign in front of the residence located at 1540 Harding Avenue (TSC No. 2021-08). PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer - Civll . DEPARTMENT: Engi , ring'? blic Works PHONE: 619-336-4388 -4 EXPLANATION: See attached. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. NiA ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED BY: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Resolution authorizing installation of a blue curb disabled persons parking space with sign in front of the residence located at 1540 Harding Avenue. BOARD ! COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At their meeting on May 12, 2021, the Traffic Safety Committee approved staff's recommendation to install a blue curb disabled persons parking space with sign in front of the residence located at 1540 Harding Avenue. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Explanation w/ Exhibit 2. Staff Report to the Traffic Safety Committee on May 12, 2021 (TSC No. 2021-08) 3. Resolution 95 of 592 EXPLANATION The resident of 1540 Harding Avenue has requested a blue curb disabled persons parking space in front of his residence. The resident possesses a valid disabled persons placard from the California Department of Motor Vehicles. The resident stated that it is difficult for him to find parking in front of his residence due to the high demand of parking in the area and that a disabled persons parking space in front of his residence would provide easier access to the house. Staff visited the site and observed that the resident's residence has no driveway and no garage. The slope on Harding Avenue was found to be negligible. The City Council has adopted a policy which is used to evaluate requests for disabled persons parking spaces. The City Council Disabled Persons Parking Policy requirements for "Special Hardship" cases are as follows: 1. Applicant (or guardian) must be in possession of valid license plates or placard for "disabled persons" or "disabled veterans". This condition is met. 2. The proposed disabled parking space must be in front (or side if on a corner lot) of the applicant's (or guardian's) place of residence. This condition is met. 3. The residence must not have useable off-street parking available or an off-street space available that may be converted into disabled parking. This condition is met. This item was presented to the Traffic Safety Committee on May 12, 2021. Staff sent notices to area residents inviting them to Zoom -in or call -in to the Traffic Safety Committee Meeting and/or contact staff with any questions. Staff presented the results of the site evaluation and after discussion the Traffic Safety Committee voted to approve staffs recommendation to install a blue curb disabled persons parking space with sign, since all three conditions of the City Council Disabled Persons Parking Policy for"Special Hardship" cases are met. The applicant was informed that handicap parking spaces do not constitute "personal reserved parking" and that any person with valid `disabled persons" license plates or placards may park in handicap spaces. If approved by City Council, all work will be performed by City Public Works 96 of 592 Location Map with Recommended Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-08) IM B -' I - — M Mina FARMING ONLY Proposed blue curb disabled persons parking space 1 540 1=d a rd ing v nue s "" M MrLI WAIF- 2 Valk NATIONAL CITY TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE AGENDA REPORT FOR MAY 12, 2021 ITEM TITLE: REQUEST FOR INSTALLATION OF A► BLUE CURB DISABLED PERSONS PARKING SPACE WITH SIGNAGE IN FRONT OF THE RESIDENCE CE AT 1640 HARDING AVENUE PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer — Civil Engineering & Public Works Department DISCUSSION: The resident of 1540 Harding Avenue, has requested a blue curb disabled persons parking space in front of his residence. The resident possesses a valid disabled persons placard from the California Department of Motor Vehicles. The resident stated that it is difficult for him to find parking in front of his residence due to the high demand of parking in the area and that a disabled persons parking space in front of his residence would provide easier access to the house. Staff visited the site and observed that the resident's residence has no driveway and no garage. The slope on Harding Avenue was found to be negligible. The City Council has adopted a policy which is used to evaluate requests for disabled persons parking spaces. The City Council Disabled Persons Parking Policy requirements for "Special Hardships" cases are as follows: 1. A►pplicant (or guardian) crust be in possession of valid license plates or placard for "disabled persons" or "disabled veterans". This condition is met. . The proposed disabled parking space must be in front (or side if on a corner lot) of the applicant's (or guardian's) place of residence. This condition is met. . The residence must not have useable off-street parking available or an off-street space available that may be converted into disabled parking. This condition is met. It shall be noted that disabled persons parking spaces do not constitute "personal reserved parking" and that any person with valid "disabled persons' license plates or placards may park in handicap spaces. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: OMMENDATION A' W Since all three conditions of the City Council Disabled Persons Parking Policy for "Special Hardship" cases are met, staff recommends the installation of a blue curb disabled persons parking space with signage in front of the residence at 1540 Harding Avenue. 98 of 592 EXHIBITS: 1. Public Request Form 2. Public Notice 3. Location Map 4. Photos 5. City Council Disabled Persons Parking Policy 2021-08 99 of 592 7L� C.: 1., 1 REQUEST F ,sR BLUE CUR3 DISABLED PERSONS` `iR IN e + E NAME OF D)S4PLE1? PERSON: N•AME OF REPRESENTATIVE ADDRESS: EMAIL: ,r FOR DISABLED PERSON (if different from above): 167-1-0 A-11-w h+44TLDJAL_c C1:74riv ON NUMBER: ■ VI. +• T i ...It• 1 • s Please answer the following questions, which w1 i assIst Enghh eying staf, the Traffic Safety ComimitteP,i and your Cittr Council In determining if you are qualified to have a blue ae curt isa bled person; as kk g sp ce placae in front cif your resicienitv. Please be inftDrrnee that aN hirue curb parking spaced are considerae pa wing. Therefore, any registered vehicle in possession c, a disabled persons placate! cr plate is legally llo ire i to park in the Eue 'clubsp c fCT up to n continuous hours, 11 Do you pc secs a vsilicl eisabled perso 's placard issued by the California rtrinent Motor Vehkc•;' - E if YES, please inchide a copy of the placard, which contains your name address, placard number, and exrd ira o at 22 Does your rasiclienceh have a gt.-7-ragiq If YES, is the ga Bge large e` icugh to parka vehicle, (ninfrurn of 2V lc1 ') you- . ,,�s,l .a a h12ve a driveway? If Y e lL the drivewaydrireway large enough to park a vehicle (minimum i Jr of 20' )E 12') b) Is the drivel/trey lute! ? c) Is the cri re}w a' sloped/Inclined? mm•m III writ any additionai comments here (optional). \ C.U° U IA cycz E YES' YES F.k YEE FIND ONO 474A.— •=re+R.I•acea Tam: I 100 of 592 May 5, 2021 Resident/Property Owner CALIFORNIA NATIt•NAL Subject: TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE (TSC) ITEM NO. 2021-08 REQUEST FOR INSTALLATION OF A BLUE CURB DISABLED PERSONS PARKING SPACE WITH SIGNAGE IN FRONT OF THE RESIDENCE AT 1540 HARDING AVENUE. Dear Sir/Madame: The City of National City would like to invite you to our next public Traffic Safety Committee Conference Call scheduled for Wednesday, May 12, 2021, at 1:00 P.M. via Zoom. Please use the following information to call -in to the meeting during the scheduled time: Join Zoom Meeting from computer https://zoom.us/j/99693438895?pwd=QW5lOnZPN2FaS2tRZnph\inNmYmYxdz09 Join Zoom Meeting by phone +1 0 - 00-9128 Meeting ID: 996 9343 0 Passcode: 754338 If you have any questions, comments, and/or concerns, please contact the Engineering Department at 619-336-4380 and reference Traffic Safety Committee item Number 2021.0 . Sincerely, Roberto Yam, P.E. City Engineer/Director of Public Works RY:ch Enclosure: Location Map 2021-08 1234 Nations! City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-6530 {619} 336-4380 Fax (619) 336-4397 engineering@nationalcityca.gov 101 of 592 Location Map with Recommended Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-08) M • w i L� PARKING ONLY R99 (CA) Proposed blue curb disabled persons parking space WMkt 1540 Harding Avenue -.� '"- IMM 1540 Harding Avenue Angled blue curb parking space Harding Avenue Location of proposed blue curb disabled persons parking space in front of 1540 Harding Avenue (looking west) Angled blue curb parking space Location of proposed blue curb disabled persons parking space in front of 1540 Harding Avenue (looking south) 103 of 592 DISABLED PERSONS PARKING POLICY The purpose of a disabled persons parking zone is to provide designated parking spaces at major points of assembly for the exclusive use of physically disabled persons whose vehicle displays a distinguishing license plate as authorized by the California Department of Motor Vehicles. The City Council may upon recommendation of the City Engineer, designate specially marked and posted on -street parking spaces for disabled persons pursuant to California Vehicle Code 21101, et seq. at the following facilities: 1. Government buildings serving the public such as administration buildings, public employment offices, public libraries, police stations, etc. 2. Hospitals and convalescent homes with more than -bed capacity. 3. Medical facilities and doctors' offices staffed by a maximum of five practitioners. Zones shall be located to serve a maximum number of facilities on one block. 4. Community service facilities such as senior citizens service centers, etc. 5. Accreditedvocational training and educational facilities where no of - street parking is provided for disabled persons. 6. Employment offices for major enterprises employing more. than 200 persons. 7. Public recreationalfacilities including municipal swimming pools, recreation halls, museums, etc. 8. Public theaters, auditoriums, meeting halls, arenas, stadiums with more than 300 seating capacity. 9. Other places of assembly such as schools and churches. 1 M . Commercial and/or office buildings with an aggregate of more than 50,000 square feet of usable floor space. Zone shall be located to serve a maximum number of facilities on one block. 11. Hotels catering to daily guests, maintaining a ground floor lobby and a switchboard that is operated 24 hours per day. 104 of 592 12. A hotel or apartment house catering to weekly or monthly pests and containing more than 30 separate living units. In addition, disabled persons parking spaces may be provided within all publicly owned, leased or controlled off-street parking facilities a specified in the General Requirements. C. n r l eQuire Bach disabled persons parking space shall be indicated by blue paint and a sign (white on blue) showing the international symbol of accessibility (a profile view of a wheelchair with occupant). Where installed under the above criteria the total. number of disabled persons curb parking spaces will be limited to 3% of the total number of on -street parking spaces available in the area and shall be distributed uniformly within the area. Disabled persons parking will not be installed at locations with a full-time parking prohibition. When a disabled persons parking zone is installed where a part -thee parking prohibition is in effect, the disabled persons parking zone will have the same time restrictions as the parttime parking prohibition. The cost of installing disabled persons parking will be assumed by the City on public streets and public off-street parking facilities. In establishing on -street parking facilities for the disabled there shall be a reasonable determination made that the need is of an on -going nature. The intent is to prevent the proliferation of special parking stalls that may be installed for a short-term purpose but later are seldom used. Unjustified installation of such parking stalls unnecessarily increases the City's maintenance and operations costs, reduce available on - street parking for the general public, and detract from the overall effectiveness of the disabled persons parking program. Special Hardship Cases It is not the intention .of the City to provide personal reserved parking on the public right-jof-way, especially in residential areas. However, exceptions may be made, in special hardship cases, provided all of the following conditions exists: (1) (or guardian) must be in possession of valid license plates for "disabled persons" or "disabled veterans." (2) The proposed disabled parking space must be in front of the applicant's (or guardian's) place of residence. 105 of 592 (3) Subject residence must not have useable off-street parking available or off-street space available that may be converted into disabled parking. NOTE:It must be emphasized that such parking spaces do not constitute "personal reserved parking" and that a.y person with. valid "disabled persons" license plates may park in the above stalls. ha:p 106 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of a Stop Control sign for the three T-intersections within the neighborhood bounded by "G" Avenue, between E. l9th Street and E. 22nd Street (TSC No. 2021-09). (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 107 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA► ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of a Stop Control sign for the three T-intersections within the neighborhood bounded by "G" Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street (TSC No. 2021-09). PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer Civil . . DEPARTMENT: Eng PHONE: 619-336-4388 APPROVED BY: EPLANA►TICN: See attached. ublic Works FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. [N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF IECCMMENDA►TION: Adopt Resolution authorizing installation of a Stop Control sign at the three T-intersections on "G" Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street. BOARD ! COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At their meeting on May 12, 2021, the Traffic Safety Committee approved staffs recommendation to install Stop Control signs at the three T-intersection on "G" Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Explanation wl Exhibit 2. Staff Report to the Traffic Safety Committee on May 12, 2021 (TSC No. 2021-09) 3. Resolution 108 of 592 EXPLANATION The Department of Public Works has requested the installation of Stop control signs at several "T" intersections within the neighborhood bounded by "G"Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street, in order to enhance safety at the intersections. Staff visited the site and confirmed the following "T" intersections delimitated by the area described above: • E. 19th Street and "G" Avenue; • E. 21st Street and "G" Avenue; • E. 22nd Street and "G" Avenue. Staff also confirmed that all of these intersections do not have signed or marked control. It should also be noted that the "T" intersections are located in a residential area where the streets are 2-lane local roadways with parking on both sides of the street and a posted speed limit of 25 mph. Staff recommends the installation of a Stop Control sign at all of the "T" intersections delimitated by the area described above since vehicles traveling on the minor streets must make a complete stop before attempting to enter onto the major streets that have the right of way. Staff also reviewed the traffic collision history for these intersections which confirmed there was one 1 "reported" traffic collision within the past four years, at the intersection of E. 19th Street and "G" Avenue. See attached traffic collision summary table. This item was presented to the Traffic Safety Committee miittee via Zoom platform on May 12, 2021. Staff sent notices to area residents inviting them to oom-in or call -in to the Traffic Safety Committee Meeting and/or contact staff with any questions. After the discussion, the Traffic Safety Committee approved staffs recommendation for the neighborhood bounded by "G" Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street: . Install one Stop control sign on `iG" Avenue on the north side of E. 19th Street; . install one Stop control sign on "G" Avenue on the south side of E. 21st Street; 3. Install one Stop control sign on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street; 4. Install 25 feet of red curb "No Parking" on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 19th Street. This will result in the Toss of one 1 on -street parallel parking space; 5. Install 25 feet of red curb "No Parking" on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street. This will result in the loss of one (1) on -street angle parking space; 6. Install 50 feet of double -yellow centerline on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 19th Street; 7. Install 50 feet of double -yellow centerline on "" Avenue on the south side of E. 2Ist Street; 109 of 592 8. Install 50 feet: of double -yellow centerline on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street, Installation of red curb "No Parking" striping is used to prevent vehicles from obstructing visibility of the Stop signs and centerline striping for alignment and are typical traffic engineering safety measures for implementation of Stop sign control. If approved by City Council, all work will be performed by City Public Works. 110 of 592 Location Map with Recommended Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-09) 25' of proposed Red Curb "No Parkng'' & 53) of proposed double -yellow centerline 25of proposed Red Curb "No Parkin' 8& 5O' of proposed double -yellow centerline LEGEND Proposed Stop sign R I-1 3 NATIONAL CITY TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE AGENDA REPORT FOR MAY 12, 2021 ITEM TITLE: REQUEST TO INSTALL STOP CONTROL SIGNS FOR THREE "T" INTERSECTIONS WITHIN THE NEIGHBORHOOD BOUNDED BY "G" AVENUE, BETWEEN E. 19TH STREET AND E 22ND STREET. T. PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer Civil Engineering Public Works Department DISCUSSION: The Public Works Department has requested the installation of Stop control signs at several "T" intersections within the neighborhood bounded by "O» Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street in order to enhance safety at the intersections. Staff visited the site and confirmed the following "T" intersections delimitated by the area described above: • E. 19th Street and "O'a Avenue; • E. 21 St Street and "G" Avenue; • E. 22nd Street and "G" Avenue. Staff also confirmed that all of these intersections do not have signed or marked control. It should also be noted that the "T" intersections are located in a residential area where the streets are 2-lane local roadways with parking on both sides of the street and a posted speed limit of 25 mph. Staff recommends the installation of a Stop Control sign at all of the T intersections delimitated by the area described above since vehicles travelling on the minor streets must make a complete stop before attempting to enter onto the major streets that have the right of way. Staff also reviewed the traffic collision history for these intersections, which confirmed there was one (1) "reported" traffic collision within the past four years, at the intersection of E. 1th Street and "G" Avenue. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends the following traffic safety enhancements for the neighborhood bounded by "G' Avenue, between E. 19th Street and E. 22nd Street: 1. Install one Stop control sign on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 19th Street; 2. install one Stop control sin on "G" Avenue on the south side of E. 2Ist Street; . Install one Stop control sign on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street; 112 of 592 4. Install 25 feet of red curb "No Parking" on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 1 th Street. This will result in the loss of one 1 on -street parallel parking space; 5. Install 25 feet of red curb "No Parking" on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street. This will result in the loss of one 1 on -street angle parking in space; 6. Install 50 feet of double -yellow centerline on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 1 th Street; ". Install 50 feet of double -yellow centerline on "G" Avenue on the south side of E. 215i Street; 8. Install 0 feet of double -yellow centerline on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street; EXHIBITS: 1. Public Request 2. Public Notice 3. Location Map 4. Photos 5. Traffic collision history 2021-09 113 of 592 CALIFORNIA NNU.ONAL L Cirr4rj IAr ORp OR JILTED PUBLIC REQUEST FORM Contact Information Name: Public Works Address: Phone: Email: Request Information Location: intersections of G Ave, between E. 19th St & E. 22nd St Request: Stop control sign required on these T-intersections Attachments: Yes Description: Internal Use Only: Request Received By: Date: Received via: CounterIn-Person Assigned To: Notes: TelephoneuEmail Fax Referral: 114 of 592 May 5, 2021 Resident/Property Owner CALIFORNIA - - NATIONALCVrV e a Subject: TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE T ITEM NO. 2021-09 REQUEST TO INSTALL STOP CONTROL SIGNS FOR THE THREE "T" INTERSECTIONS WITHING THE NEIGHBORHOOD BOUNDED BY "G" AVENUE, BETWEEN E. 19TH STREET AND E. 22ND STREET. Dear Sir/Madame: The City of National City would like to invite you to our next public Traffic Safety Committee Conference Cali scheduled for Wednesday, May 129 2021, at 1:00 P.M. via Zoom. Please use the following information to call -in to the meeting during the scheduled time: Join Zoom Meeting from computer https://zoom.us/j/99693438895?pwd=QW51QnZPN2FaS2tRZnphVnNmYmYxdz09 Join Zoom Meeting by phone +1 669-900-9128 Meeting ID: 996 9343 95 Passcode: 754338 If you have any questions, comments, and/or concerns, please contact the Engineering Department at 619- 0-4 80 and reference Traffic Safety Committee Item Number 2021-09. Sincerely, Roberto Yano, P.E. City Engineer/Director of Public Works RY:ch Enclosure: Location Map 2021-09 1234 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-6530 (619) 336-4380 Fax {619} 336-4397 engineering@natianalcityca.gov 115 of 592 Location Map with Recommended Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-09) 251 of proposed Red Curb "No Parking' & 50' of proposed double -yellow centerline 25 of proposed Red Curb ' No Parking" & 50' of proposed double -yellow centerline LEGEND Proposed Stop sigr i-1 Request to install Stop Control sign on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 19th Street (looking west} Request to install Stop Control sign on " " Avenue on the north side of E. 19th Street (looking north) 117 of 592 Request to install Stop Control sign on "G" Avenue on the south side of E. 21st Street looking east) Request to install Stop Control sign on "G" Avenue on the south side of E. 15t Street (looking south) 118 of 592 Request to install Stop Control sign on "6" Avenue on the north side of E. 22" Street (looking west) Request to install Stop Control sign on "G" Avenue on the north side of E. 22nd Street (looking north) 119 of 592 Traffic Collision History (NCPD Records Division) From May 3, 2017 — May 3, 2021, there was one (1) traffic collision on the intersection of G Avenue & E. 22 nd Street. There were no traffic collisions at the intersections of G Avenue & E.. 19th Street or at G Avenue & E. 21st Street F11URY NUMBER NUM8fR MT& RUN FLAG ,LNJ R U KILLED " -6 FLA4 L[V 1 NATIONAL CITY 1903950 7/26/20193:06 VC20002(A) HIT AND RUN:PR.O DAMAGE CM) 700E 22ND STREET, NC, 91950 N 0 0 Y MISDEMEANOR N MISDEMEANOR 7 4 rM 'V 4 0101 21' 120 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of red curb "No Parking" at the intersection of Earle Drive and E. 16th Street in order to enhance safety and visibility for drivers exiting Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street (TSC No. 2021-10). (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 121 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1. 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the installation of red curb "No Parking" at the intersection of Earle Drive and E. 16th Street in order to enhance safety and visibility for drivers exiting Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street (TSC No. 2021-10). PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer - ivilC I -. DEPARTMENT: En in PHONE: 619-336-4388 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: See attached. v ri • Pu r Iic Works FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FI1A►L ADOPTION: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Resolution authorizing installation of red curb "No Parking" at the intersection of Earle Drive and E. 16th Street. BOARD 1 COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At their meeting on May 12, 2021, the Traffic Safety Committee approved staffs recommendation to install red curb "No Parking" at the intersection of Earle Drive and E. 16th Street, ATTACHMENTS: 1. Explanation wi Exhibit 2. Staff Report to the Traffic Safety Committee on May 12, 2021 (TSC No. 2021-10) 3. Resolution 122 of 592 EXPLANATION An area resident has requested red curb "No Parking" at the intersection between E. 16th Street and Earle Drive to improve visibility and enhance safety for the vehicles exiting from Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street. Staff performed a site evaluation. E. 16th Street is currently 2-lanes wide and has available parking on both sides of the street. The posted speed limit on E. 16th street is 30 mph. Staff confirmed that there is 35 feet of existing red curb "No Parking" on the west side of Earle Drive, north of E. 16th Street. Staffalso confirmed that there is feet f red curb "NoParking" on the east side of Earle Drive, north of E. 16th Street, due to n existing fire hydrant. Staff confirmed that when vehicles park too close to the corner on E. 16th Street and Earle Drive t the intersection, the visibility for the vehicles that are exiting Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street is obstructed. Staff also reviewed the traffic collision history for this location which confirmed there was ore 1 "reported" traffic collision within the past four years. The NCPD report shows that crash at the intersection was due to a violation of unsafe turn in the intersection (CVC 22107). See attached "Traffic Collision History" summary table. This item was presented to the Traffic Safety Committee via Zoom platform on May 12, 2021. Staff sent notices to area residents inviting them to Zoom -in or call -in to the Traffic Safety Committee Meeting and/or contact staff with any questions. Staff presented the results of the site evaluation and after discussion the Traffic Safety Committee voted to approve staffs recommendation to install 10 feet of additional red curb "No Parking" on the east side of Earle Drive, north of E. 16th Street, to improve visibility for drivers exiting Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street. This will not result in the Ions of any on -street parking space. If approved by City Council, all work will be performed by City Public Works. 123 of 592 Location Map with Recommended Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021-10) 2945 E. 16th Street 35' of existing red curb "No Parking" MOO C7 'ofe i. tfr red • curb "No Par -Wing" with existing fire hydrant 3005 E. 16th Street 10' of proposed red curb "No Parong" ITEM TITLE: NATIONAL CITY TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE AGENDA REPORT FOR MAY 12, 2021 RE VEST TO INSTALL RED CURB "NO PARKING" AT THE JNTERSECTIONQF EARLE DRIVE AND E. 1 TH STREET IN ORDER To ENHANCE SAFETY AND VISIBILITY FOR DRIVERS WHEN EXITING EARLE DRIVE ONTO E. 16TH STREET. PREPARED Y:, Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer -- Civil Engineering & Public Works Department DISCUSSION: An area resident, has requested red curb "No Parking" at the intersection between E. 16th Street and Earle Drive to improve visibility and enhance safety for the vehicles exiting from Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street. Staff performed a site evaluation. E. 16th Street is currently 2-lanes wide and has available parking on both sides of the street. The posted speed limit on E. 16th Street is 30 mph. Staff confirmed that there is 35 feet of existing red curb "No Parting" on the west side of Earle Drive, north of E. 16th Street. Staff also confirmed that there is 20 feet of red curb "No Parking" on the east side of Earle Drive, north of E. 16th Street due to an existing fire hydrant. Staff confirmed that when vehicles park too close to the corner on E. 16th Street and Earle Drive at the intersection, the visibility for the vehicles that are exiting Earle Drive onto E. 161h Street is obstructed. Staff also reviewed the traffic collision history for this location, which confirmed there was one 1 "reported" traffic collision within the past four years. The NCPD report shows that crash at the intersection was due to a violation of unsafe turn in the intersection (CVC 22107). See attachment traffic collision summary table. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Based on evaluation of existing conditions, staff recommends the installation of 10 feet of additional red curb "No Parking" on the east side of Earle Drive, north of E. 16th Street to improve visibility for vehicles exiting Earle Drive onto E. 16th Street. This will not result in the Toss of on -street parking space. ATTACHMENTS: I. Public Request 2. Public Notice 3. Location Map 4. Photos 5. Traffic collision history 2021-10 125 of 592 CALIFORNIA c Cirr LW+CORPORAT PUBLIC REQUEST FORM Contract Information Name: Area resident Address: Phone: Email: Request Information Location: Intersection of Earle Drive & E. 16th Street Request: Extend red curb on E. 16th St, east side of Earle Dr. to improve visibility for vehicles exiting Earle Dr. onto E. 16th St. Attachments: Yes No Description: Internal Use Only: Request Received By: - Date: Received via: Assigned To: Notes: Counter/In-Person Telephone Email Fax 1Referral: 126 of 592 May 5, 2021 Resident/Property Owner -;.- CALIFORNIA T11NALCI Subject: TRAFFIC SAFETY COMMITTEE (TSC) ITEM NO. 2021-10 REQUEST TO INSTALL RED CURB "NO PARKING" ON THE EAST SIDE OF EARLE DRIVE, NORTH OF E. 16TH STREET% IN ORDER TO ENHANCE SAFETY AND VISIBILITY AT THE INTERSECTION. Dear it Madame: The City of National City would like to invite you to our next public Traffic Safety Committee Conference Call scheduled for Wednesday, May 12, 2021, at 1:00 P.M. via Zoom. Please use the following information to call -in to the meeting during the scheduled time: Join Zoom Meeting from oputer https://zoom.us1/99693438895?pwd-QW51QnZPN2FaS2tRZnphVnNmYmYxdz09 Join Zoom Meeting by phone +1 669-900-9128 Meeting ID: 996 9343 8895 Passcode: 754338 If you have any questions, comments, and/or concerns, please contact the Engineering Department at 619-336-4380 and reference Traffic Safety Committee Item Number 2021-10. Sincerely, Roberto Yano, P.E. City Engineer/Director of Public Works RY:ch Enclosure: Location Map 2021-10 1234 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-6530 (619) 336-4380 Fax (619) 336-4397 engineering@nationalcityca.gov 127 of 592 Location Map with Recommended Enhancements (TSC Item: 2021.10) main Own *ow vow 2945 E. 16th Street 20' of existing red curb "No Parking" with existing fire hydrant 3005 E. 16th Street 10' of proposed red curb "No Parking" Location of proposed red curb "No Parking" east of Earle Drive (looking north 3005 E. 16th Street 20' of existing red curb "No Parking" due to fire hydrant Location of proposed red curb "No Parking" in front of Earle Drive (looking east) 129 of 592 Traffic Collision History (NCPD Records Division) From May 4, 2017 — May 4, 2021, there was one (1) traffic collision on the intersection of E. 16th Street and Earle Drive CM, NUM 'DATE& TIME4. LIMN NATIONAL CITY 18102090 4/27/20188:57 VC 22107 TLlRN5:UNSA EETURN AND/OR NOTURN SIGNAL () 3009E 16TH STREET, NC, 91950 N 0 0 N N INNACTIof t sir 9 1 130 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Warrant Register #42 for the period of 4/14/21 through 4/20/21 in the amount of $2,346,196.31. (Finance) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 131 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO.: ITEM TITLE: Warrant Register #42 for the period of 4/14/21 through 4/20/21 in the amount of $2,346,196.31. (Finance) PREPARED BY: Karla Apalategui, Senior Accounting Assistant DEPARTMENT: Finance PHONE: 619-336-4572 EXPLANATION: APPROVED BY: Per Government Section Code 37208, below are the payments issued for period 4/14/21 - 4/20/21. Consistent with Department of Finance's practice, listed below are all payments above $50,000. Vendor Check/Wire Amount Explanation Fordyce Construction Inc 352240 83,952.32 CIP 21-07 City Hall NSD Svcs South Bay Comm Svcs 352271 340,849.80 Housing Agreement Tri-Group Cons & Dev 352279 231,485.74 CIP 19-19 Roosevelt Smart Growth West Coast Arborist Inc 352282 85,750.00 Calfire Grant Planting — Eng/Pw FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. Warrant total $2,346,196.31. APPROVED: APPROVED: ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: This is not a project and, therefore, not subject to environmental review. ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION FINAL ADOPTION FINANCE MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Ratify warrants totaling $2,346,196.31. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: ATTACHMENTS: Warrant Register # 42 132 of 592 CALIFORNIA PAYEE ACOSTA, V ADVANCED DIESEL INJECTION, INC AETNA BEHAVIORAL HEALTH ALTA LANGUAGE SERVICES INC AMAZON ATLAS TECHNICAL CONSULTANTS BAKER & TAYLOR BEVERIDGE, M BLUE PACIFIC ENGINEERING BRINK'S INCORPORATED CALIFA GROUP CEKANDER, L COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO DELEON, MARIO DELGADO, E DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE DICK MILLER INC D-MAX ENGINEERING INC ENTERPRISE FLEET MANAGEMENT FORDYCE CONSTRUCTION INC GEOSYNTEC CONSULTANTS INC HAMEL, K HD SUPPLY CONSTRUCTION AND HDR ENGINEERING, INC. HINDERLITER DE LLAMAS HOME DEPOT CREDIT SERVICES INNOVATIVE CONSTRUCTION JUAREZ, MARCOS KREPPS, B KRONOS INC LASER SAVER INC LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE MATLOCK, J MAZICH, S MIDWEST TAPE MUNICIPAL MAINTENANCE EQUIP NATIONAL CITY ELECTRIC NV5 INC ORTIZ, LILIA PEREZ, EDUARDO PERRY MOTORS OF NAT CITY LLC PORTILLO CONCRETE INC PROJECT PROFESSIONALS CORP RAMIREZ, OMAR RODRIGUEZ, EDGAR RODRIGUEZ, VIRGINIA SAKAMOTO, C SCANLON, D NATIONAL env INCORFOILA'i'ED WARRANT REGISTER # 42 4/20/2021 DESCRIPTION LICENSE REIMBURSEMENT PARTS FOR EMERGENCY SERVICES VEHICLE EMPLOYEE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM - APRIL EMPLOYEE BILINGUAL TESTING 4-PANEL ROOM DIVIDER FOR PD - ENG/PW P1 SEWER UPSIZE PROJECT - ENG/PW BOOKS FOR FY21 REIMBURSEMENT PARAMEDIC LICENSE/ FIRE CIP 18-14 SWEETWATER BIKEWAY CONNECTION ARMORED CAR SVCS 4/1/21-4/30/21 PRONUNCIATOR ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION TRAINING REIM TRAINING MATER DEH2O20-CAMD-000077; NATIONAL CITY DUMP PARKING CITATION REFUND SUPREME TEEN CDBG SUPPLIES & MATERIALS NEW EMPLOYEE FINGERPRINT TEST RESULTS CIP 18-16 PARADISE CREEK PARK EXPANSION CIP 18-11 NC PARADISE CREEK BIOFILT PROP ENTERPRISE FLEET LEASE - ENG/PW CIP 21-07 CITY HALL NEIGHBORHOOD SVCS DUCK POND GW MONITORING - ENG/PW EDUCATION REIMBURSEMENT HIP W/STEEL TOE BOOT SIZE 9 CIP 18-11 PARADISE CREEK AT PLAZA PHASE AUDIT SVCS-TRANSACTION TAX / FINANCE COMM SRVCS MONTH SUPPLIES FOR KITS CIP 18-14 SWEETWATER BIKE PATH - ENG/PW PARKING CITATION REFUND REIMBURSEMENT PARAMEDEC LICENSE/ FIRE TELESTAFF IVR/ASPECT VOXEO SERVICE/ FIRE MOP: 45725 P2055 COMPATIBLE TONER PERSONNEL MATTER REIMBURSEMENT PARAMEDIC LICENSE/ FIRE REIMBURSEMENT PARAMEDIC LICENSE/ FIRE AUDIOVISUAL MATERIALS FOR FY21 SET KEY FOR DOOR LOCK CABIN CITYWIDE ON -SITE ELECTRICAL T&A 90414 RAINTREE COURT - ENG/PW REIMBURSEMENT FOR FOLKLORICO CLASS PARKING CITATION REFUND ELECTRICAL ISSUE CIP 19-05 PALM AVE RROAD REHAB - ENG/PW CIP 18-16 PARADISE CREEK PARK EXPANSION TRAINING REIM SLI 3 NC PARKING CITATION REFUND PARKING CITATION REFUND TRAINING REIM SUPRVSRY / PD TRAINING REIM POST / PD CHK NO 352221 352222 352223 352224 352225 352226 352227 352228 352229 352230 352231 352232 352233 352234 352235 352236 352237 352238 352239 352240 352241 352242 352243 352244 352245 352246 352247 352248 352249 352250 352251 352252 352253 352254 352255 352256 352257 352258 352259 352260 352261 352262 352263 352264 352265 352266 352267 352268 DATE 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 4/20/21 AMOUNT 60.00 1,101.99 991.66 66.00 70.69 2,727.00 1,710.51 125.50 25,003.53 302.00 1,995.00 32.57 459.00 80.00 1,275.23 160.00 44,621.72 5,012.72 15,595.10 83,952.32 2,874.00 239.44 296.53 15,844.25 2,038.03 355.20 16,602.00 10.00 125.50 110.68 59.76 7,462.72 125.50 125.50 2,495.18 750.05 1,630.00 950.00 84.00 10.00 148.00 25,318.36 15,948.03 160.16 110.00 0.44 552.10 632.04 1/2 133 of 592 CALIFORNIA °-4i PAYEE SIRSIDYNIX 774271 SMART SOURCE OF CALIFORNIA LLC SOUTH BAY COMMUNITY SERVICES STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE STINNETT, R THE BUMPER GUY INC THE NYHART COMPANY THE PUN GROUP LLP THE STAR NEWS TRANS-LANG TRI-GROUP CONSTRUCTION AND DEV U S BANK VISTA PAINT WEST COAST ARBORISTS INC WORLD OIL ENVIRONMENTAL WIRED PAYMENTS PUBLIC EMP RETIREMENT SYSTEM PAYROLL Pay period Start Date 8 3/23/2021 NATIONAL N1?iL IT INCORFOILATEn WARRANT REGISTER # 42 4/20/2021 DESCRIPTION HORIZON AUTOMATION SYSTEM MAINTENANCE BUSINESS CARDS FOR STAFF/HED HOUSING AGREEMENT MOP #45704/OFFICE SUPPLIES/HR TRAINING POST SUPER REIM REPAIR - POLICE VEHICLE GASB 75 OPEB VALUATION REPORT CITY AUDIT YR ENDED JUNE 30,2020 / FINAL STAR NEWS AD #00104277 PRINT DATE 3-19-21 INTREPRETATION SVCS - STATE OF THE CITY CIP 19-19 ROOSEVELT SMART GROWTH - ENG/PW TRAINING CRED CRD SUPERVISRY TRNG MOP 68834 PAINT SUPPLIES / NSD CALFIRE GRANT PLANTING - ENG/PW USED OIL SERVICE CHARGE SVC PERIOD 03/23/21 - 04/05/21 End Date 4/5/2021 Check Date 4/5/2021 GRAND TOTAL CHK NO DATE AMOUNT 352269 4/20/21 18,409.20 352270 4/20/21 171.80 352271 4/20/21 340,849.80 352272 4/20/21 444.78 352273 4/20/21 647.48 352274 4/20/21 439.43 352275 4/20/21 1,950.00 352276 4/20/21 8,323.00 352277 4/20/21 212.69 352278 4/20/21 295.00 352279 4/20/21 231,485.74 352280 4/20/21 1,697.84 352281 4/20/21 641.34 352282 4/20/21 85,750.00 352283 4/20/21 160.00 A/P Total 971,878.11 41521 4/15/21 268, 320.19 1,105,998.01 $ 2,346,196.31 2/2 134 of 592 Certification IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 37202, 37208, 372059 OF THE GOVERNMENT CODE, WE HEREBY CERTIFY TO THE ACCURACY OF THE DEMANDS LISTED ABOVE AND TO THE AVAILABILITY OF FUNDS FOR THE PAYMENT THEREOF AND FURTHER THAT THE ABOVE CLAIMS AND DEMANDS HAVE BEEN AUDITED AS REQUIRED BY LAW. ,/-a(-1- a4,-,5<- PHILLIP DAVIS, FINANCE BRAD RAULSTON, CITY MANAGER FINANCE COMMITTEE ALEJANDRA SOTELO-SOLIS, MAYOR -CHAIRWOMAN JOSE RODRIGUEZ, VICE -MAYOR MARCUS BUSH, COUNCIL MEMBER RONALD J. MORRISON, COUNCIL MEMBER MONA RIOS, COUNCIL MEMBER I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE FOREGOING CLAIMS AND DEMANDS WERE APPROVED AND THE CITY TREASURER IS AUTHORIZED TO ISSUE SAID WARRANTS IN PAYMENT THEREOF BY THE CITY COUNCIL ON THE lst OF JUNE, 2021. AYES NAYS ABSENT 135 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Warrant Register #43 for the period of 4/21/21 through 4/27/21 in the amount of $1,139,452.53. (Finance) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 136 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO.: ITEM TITLE: Warrant Register #43 for the period of 4/21/21 through 4/27/21 in the amount of $1,139,452.53. (Finance) PREPARED BY: Karla Apalategui, Senior Accounting Assistant DEPARTMENT: Finance PHONE: 619-336-4572 EXPLANATION: APPROVED BY: Per Government Section Code 37208, below are the payments issued for period 4/21/21 - 4/27/21. Consistent with Department of Finance's practice, listed below are all payments above $50,000. Vendor Check/Wire Amount Explanation City of San Diego 352302 101,867.70 Qtr Billing for Fire Dispatch Svcs Kaiser Foundation HP 352333 194,156.76 Grp 104220-0002 — March 2021 Perry Electric 352357 319,002.49 CIP 19-13 Citywide Ped Safety Impr FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. Warrant total $1,139,452.53. APPROVED: APPROVED: ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: This is not a project and, therefore, not subject to environmental review. ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION FINAL ADOPTION FINANCE MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Ratify warrants totaling $1,139,452.53. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: ATTACHMENTS: Warrant Register # 43 137 of 592 CALIFORNIA °- PAYEE 24 HOUR ELEVATOR INC ACE UNIFORMS & ACCESSORIES INC ADMINSURE INC AIR POLLUTION CONTROL DISTRICT ALDEMCO ALL FRESH PRODUCTS ASSI SECURITY INC AT&T AT&T BAKER ELECTRIC INC BEST WAY PRINTING BROADWAY AUTO GLASS C P RICHARDS SIGNS INC CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF TAX SERVICE CALIFORNIA ELECTRIC SUPPLY CALPERS - FINANCIAL REPORTING CITY OF CHULA VISTA CITY OF SAN DIEGO CITY OF SAN MARCOS CLF WAREHOUSE INC CODDINGTON LOCK AND SECURITY COMMERCIAL AQUATIC SERVICE INC COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO COUNTYWIDE MECHANICAL SYSTEMS COX COMMUNICATIONS CYRACOM INTERNATIONAL, INC DAY WIRELESS SYSTEMS DE LAGE LANDEN DEPT OF JUSTICE DICK MILLER INC DIVISION 8 INCORPORATED D-MAX ENGINEERING INC DPREP INC EXPRESS PIPE AND SUPPLY FERGUSON ENTERPRISES 1350 GEOSYNTEC CONSULTANTS INC GONZALES, R GOVERNMENT TRAINING AGENCY GRAINGER HANDY METAL MART HEALTH NET INC HOME DEPOT CREDIT SERVICES JANI-KING OF CALIFORNIA INC JJJ ENTERPRISES KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLANS NATI 'V IAL CIT IN'CORFOILA'i'En WARRANT REGISTER # 43 4/27/2021 DESCRIPTION CITY WIDE ELEVATOR SERVICE AND REPAIR CORRECT MN NAVY PANTS FOR FY 21/ FIRE AGREEMENT TO PROVIDE MONTHLY SERVICES ANNUAL DISTRIC FEES - NC FIRE DEPARMENT FOOD / NUTRITION COVID 19 CONSUMABLES PROVIDE SECURITY SERVICES AND REPAIRS AT&T SBC ANNUAL PHONE SERVICE FOR FY21 AT&T SBC ANNUAL PHONE SERVICE FOR FY21 CIP 19-15 CITYWIDE SAFETY LIGHTING ENHAN 5000 DOOR HANGERS OFF -SITE WINDOW TINT & REPAIR / PW FILE SETUP / FIRE SALES TAX LIABILITY PERIOD OCT-DEC 2020 MOP 45698 ELECTRIC SUPPLIES - PW 2021 REPLACEMENT CHGS FOR CITY OF NATION RESCUE SYSTEMS 1 TRAINING / FIRE QUARTERY BILLING FOR FIRE DISPATCH SVCS- RESCUE SYSTEMS 1 TRAINING / FIRE MOP 80331 AUTO SUPPLIES - PW CITYWIDE ON -SITE ELECTRONIC DOOR, LOCK CHEMICALS - CHLORINE, ACID TABLETS, AND SD SHARE OF PC REV PER GC76000-761000 OR SD SHARE OF PC REV PER GC76000-761000 OR NC DUMP BAYSHORE BIKEWAY PROJECT - ENG/P NEXTGEN REGIONAL COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEM CITYWIDE ON -SITE HVAC SERVICES, COX DATA VIDEO SERVICES FOR FY21 LANGUAGE SERVICE QUARTERLY SERVICE LEASE 20 SHARP COPIERS FOR FY21 DOJ FINGERPRINTING CIP 18-11 PARADISE CREEK WQ&C ENH- ENG/P CITY WIDE ONSITE GLASS AND WINDOW T&A 90442 ENG/PW TRAINING TUITION OIS RGNZLS CITYWIDE PLUMBING PARTS, MATERIALS TOOL MOP 45723 GENERAL SUPPLIES - PW CNC COMPLIANCE WORK - ENG/PW TRAINING POST ADV SUB OIS SUPERV TRAINING TUITION SEARCH WRNT FITCHHORN BUILDING SUPPLIES AND EQUIPMENT FY 21- PA 1-1/2 X 1-1/2 X 1/4 ANGLE / FIRE GRP# LB439F - MARCH 21 GENERAL SUPPLIES FOR FY 2021 JANITORIAL SERVICES FIRE AND SECURITY ALARM MONITORING, GRP 104220 -0002 - MARCH 2021 CHK NO 352285 352286 352287 352288 352289 352290 352291 352292 352293 352294 352295 352296 352297 352298 352299 352300 352301 352302 352303 352304 352305 352306 352307 352308 352309 352310 352311 352312 352313 352314 352315 352316 352317 352318 352319 352320 352321 352322 352323 352324 352325 352326 352328 352329 352330 352331 352332 352333 DATE 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 AMOUNT 4,047.22 1,898.10 15,745.00 460.00 4,505.91 2,013.31 210.00 10,739.62 91.17 27,846.40 2,129.62 744.00 118.07 827.00 230.99 4,460.13 1,750.00 101,867.70 3,500.00 894.10 1,612.18 2,730.72 8,047.00 7,812.50 688.50 9,120.00 325.00 2,310.82 7.15 5,577.00 2,939.63 226.00 5,318.40 13,200.00 9,588.40 249.00 146.68 240.52 3,834.25 384.00 95.00 923.72 398.66 1,428.36 587.13 3,650.77 1,424.79 194,156.76 1/3 138 of 592 CALIFORNIA °- PAYEE KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLANS KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLANS KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLANS KAISER FOUNDATION HEALTH PLANS KIMLEY HORN AND KRONOS INC KTUA LASER SAVER INC LEKOS ELECTRIC INC. LEO K9 NUTRITION MAN K9 INC MASON'S SAW NAN MCKAY AND ASSOCIATES INC NATIONAL CITY ELECTRIC NATIONAL CITY MOTORCYCLES NATIONAL NOTARY ASSOCIATION NERI LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE NV5 INC OFFICE SOLUTIONS BUSINESS O'REILLY AUTO PARTS PACIFIC STATES PETROLEUM INC PARTS AUTHORITY METRO LLC PENSKE FORD PERRY ELECTRIC PMW ASSOCIATES POLICE AND FIRE PSYCHOLOGY POWERSTRIDE BATTERY CO INC PRO BUILD COMPANY PROFESSIONAL SEARCH GROUP LLC PROJECT PROFESSIONALS CORP PRUDENTIAL OVERALL SUPPLY RANDALL LAMB ASSOCIATES INC S D TRAINING MANAGERS ASSOC SAM'S ALIGNMENT SAN DIEGO MIRAMAR COLLEGE SAN DIEGO PET SUPPLY SAN DIEGO REGIONAL PUBLIC SAN YSIDRO HEALTH SDG&E SEAPORT MEAT COMPANY SHARP REES STEALY MED GROUP SHRED IT USA SHRED -IT SITEONE LANDSCAPE SUPPLY LLC SOLARPLACARD INC SOUTH BAY COMMUNITY SERVICES SOUTHERN CALIF TRUCK STOP SOUTHWEST SIGNAL SERVICE NATI 'V IAL CIT IN'CORFOILA'i'En WARRANT REGISTER # 43 4/27/2021 DESCRIPTION GRP 104220-01,06,07 - MARCH 2021 GRP 104220-0005 - MARCH 2021 GRP 104220-03, 09 - MARCH 2021 GRP 104220 -7002 - MARCH 2021 8TH & ROOSEVELT ATP - ENG/PW KRONOS ANNUAL MAINTENANCE AND LICENSING ROOSEVELT AVE SMART GROWTH - ENG/PW MOP 04840 PRINTING PD CIP 19-14 E. 4TH ST PROTECTED LEFT TURN K9 LOKI FOOD AND EQUIP MARCH SERVICE MOP 45729 EQUIPMENT SUPPLIES AND REPAIR ONLINE TRAINING HCV ELIGIBILITY AND EXAM CITYWIDE ON -SITE ELECTRICAL SERVICE AND REPAIR FOR EMERGENCY NATIONAL NOTARY ASSOCIATION RENEWAL KIMBALL PARK CONCEPT MASTER PLAN UPDATE T&A90412 RANCHO ARROYO VILLAS G.P. FORM 1099 R ENVOLEPES FOR SECTION 8 MOP 75877 AUTO SUPPLIES - PW HYDRAULIC OIL & ENGINE OIL / PW MOP 75943 AUTO SUPPLIES - PW R&M CITY VEHICLES FY 2021 CIP 19-13 CITYWIDE PED SAFETY IMPROVE- ENG TWO DAY SUCCESSION PLANNING WKSP PRE EMPLOYMENT PSCH MOP 67839 GENERAL SUPPLIES - PW LUMBER FOR FIRE DEPT TRAINING - TEMPORARY PLACEMENT POSITION,SOA/ FIRE CIP 19-13 CITYWIDE PED SAFETY IMPR HSIP MOP 45742 LAUNDRY SERVICES - PW NCPD STANDBY POWER CONVERSION - ENG/PW TRAINING MEMBERSHIP SDTMA NAGLE WHEEL ALIGNMENT SERVICE FOR CITY TRAINING TUITION ROT LOZANO MOPO 02975 CANINE FOOD TRAINING REGIONAL ACADEMY / PD CARES ACT CDBG-CV AGREEMENT SAN DIEGO GAS & ELECTRIC FOOD NUTRITION PRE -EMPLOYMENT PHYSICAL & DMV EXAM SHRED SERVICE APRIL-2021 MONTHLY SERVICE FOR SECTION 8 MOP 69277 LANDSCAPE SUPPLIES - PW PLASTIC ACCOUNTABILITY TAGS VARIOUS CDBG AGREEMENT WITH SOUTH BAY COMMUNITY MOP 45758 GENERAL AUTO SUPPLIES - PW STREET LIGHTING SERVICE / PW CHK NO 352334 352335 352336 352337 352338 352339 352340 352341 352342 352343 352344 352345 352346 352347 352348 352349 352350 352351 352352 352353 352354 352355 352356 352357 352358 352359 352360 352361 352362 352363 352364 352365 352366 352367 352368 352369 352370 352371 352372 352373 352374 352375 352376 352377 352378 352379 352380 352381 DATE 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 4/27/21 AMOUNT 19,905.64 8,457.76 6,433.84 621.04 48,356.65 90.00 4,855.20 59.95 16,330.38 696.45 1,120.00 808.70 780.00 2,220.00 1,025.75 755.39 5,546.50 25,768.81 232.87 28.49 1,212.24 109.59 597.04 319,002.49 8,100.00 700.00 117.79 7,286.38 2,992.00 34,866.02 488.40 8,691.25 50.00 540.00 23.00 151.23 8.00 9,379.24 2,019.94 1,879.27 237.00 54.92 103.33 148.23 121.80 4,778.52 122.69 13,838.08 2/3 139 of 592 CALIFORNIA °-- NATIONAL My PAYEE STAPLES BUSINESS ADVANTAGE STC TRAFFIC SWEETWATER AUTHORITY SYSCO SAN DIEGO INC TECHNOLOGY INTEGRATION GROUP TELECOM LAW FIRM P C TERMINIX INTERNATIONAL THE COUNSELING TEAM T'S & SIGNS U S BANK USA MOBILITY WIRELESS INC VALLEY INDUSTRIAL SPECIALTIES VERIZON WIRELESS VISTA PAINT VORTEX INDUSTRIES INC VULCAN MATERIALS COMPANY WAXIE SANITARY SUPPLY WEST PAYMENT CENTER WESTFLEX INDUSTRIAL WETMORES WILLY'S ELECTRONIC SUPPLY WITMER PUBLIC SAFETY GROUP INC WSP USA INC WSP USA INC CZNCORFOILA'6'En - 1 WARRANT REGISTER # 43 4/27/2021 DESCRIPTION MOP 20468 SUPPLIES PD HSIP CITY PROTEC LEFT TURN - ENG/PW WATER BILL FOR PARKS DIVISION FY 2021 FOOD NUTRITION MIS EQUIPMENT PROFESSIONAL SERVICES / CAO ON -SITE PEST CONTROL SERVICES PEER SUPPORT ORANGE T-SHIRT PRINT / CMO CREDIT CARD EXPENSES / FIRE METROCALL PAGING FOR FY21 MOP 46453 BUILDING SUPPLIES - PW VERIZON CELLULAR SERVICES FOR FY21 MOP 68834 PAINT SUPPLIES 1 NSD CITYWIDE ON -SITE SERVICE & REPAIRS ASPHALT, TACK, 3/8 SHEET FY 21 MISCELLANEOUS JANITORIAL SUPPLIES INVESTIGATIVE SERVICE MOP 63850 GENERAL SUPPLIES - PW MOP 80333 AUTO SUPPLIES - PW MOP 00351 SUPPLIES PD CUSTOM LEATHER SHIELD / FIRE FOCUSED GENERAL PLAN UPDATE - ENG/PW NAT CITY BIKE MASTER PLAN - ENG/PW GRAND TOTAL CHK NO DATE AMOUNT 352382 4/27/21 1,118.57 352383 4/27/21 49,738.71 352384 4/27/21 13.98 352385 4/27/21 2,565.23 352386 4/27/21 2,101.59 352387 4/27/21 2,784.00 352388 4/27/21 1,135.00 352389 4/27/21 800.00 352390 4/27/21 815.63 352391 4/27/21 678.40 352392 4/27/21 672.00 352393 4/27/21 349.74 352394 4/27/21 126.25 352395 4/27/21 601.55 352396 4/27/21 21,433.96 352397 4/27/21 251.70 352398 4/27/21 1,982.68 352399 4/27/21 633.22 352400 4/27/21 274.34 352401 4/27/21 34.62 352402 4/27/21 64.68 352403 4/27/21 249.75 352404 4/27/21 14,165.05 352405 4/27/21 14,048.73 A/P Total 1,139,452.53 $ 1,139,452.53 3/3 140 of 592 Certification IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 37202, 37208, 372059 OF THE GOVERNMENT CODE, WE HEREBY CERTIFY TO THE ACCURACY OF THE DEMANDS LISTED ABOVE AND TO THE AVAILABILITY OF FUNDS FOR THE PAYMENT THEREOF AND FURTHER THAT THE ABOVE CLAIMS AND DEMANDS HAVE BEEN AUDITED AS REQUIRED BY LAW. ,/-a(-1- a4,-,5<- PHILLIP DAVIS, FINANCE BRAD RAULSTON, CITY MANAGER FINANCE COMMITTEE ALEJANDRA SOTELO-SOLIS, MAYOR -CHAIRWOMAN JOSE RODRIGUEZ, VICE -MAYOR MARCUS BUSH, COUNCIL MEMBER RONALD J. MORRISON, COUNCIL MEMBER MONA RIOS, COUNCIL MEMBER I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE FOREGOING CLAIMS AND DEMANDS WERE APPROVED AND THE CITY TREASURER IS AUTHORIZED TO ISSUE SAID WARRANTS IN PAYMENT THEREOF BY THE CITY COUNCIL ON THE lst OF JUNE, 2021. AYES NAYS ABSENT 141 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Public Hearing, second reading and adoption of an Ordinance of the City Council of the City of National City amending National City Chapter 9.52 of the National City Municipal Code regarding the Mandatory Commercial and Residential Recycling Program according to SB 1383. (Engineering/Public Works) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 142 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE June I, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Public Hearing, second reading and adoption of an Ordinance of the City Council of the City of National City amending National City Chapter 9.52 of the NationalCity Municipal Code regarding the Mandatory Commercial and Residential Recycling Program according to SB 1383. PREPARED BY: Carla Hutchinson, Assistant Engineer Civil CO'. DEPARTMENT: E PHONE: 619-336-4388 -4 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: See attached. g Public Works FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED: APPROVED: x Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Ordinance of the City Council of the City of National City amending National City Municipal Code Title 9, Section 9.52. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: ATTACHMENTS: 1. Explanation 2. Ordinance with proposed changes (clean version) 143 of 592 Explanation In September 2016, Governor Brown signed SB 1383, establishing methane emissions reduction targets in a statewide effort to reduce emissions from short-lived climate pollutants in various sectors of California's economy. The ordinance amendments are a result of residential and commercial service collection updates to address state organic recycling requirements. AB 1826 and SB 1383 authorize and require local governments to implement an organic waste recycling program to recover organic waste from all organic waste generators. The purpose of the ordinance amendments are tocodify the automation of residential green waste collection and include compostables to the commercial collection waste stream and provide a method of collection. In order to conform with legal requirements, as well as current industrial standards and city practices for recycling and solid waste services provided by the hauler, staff recommends the adoption of the ordinance amendments. On May 18, 2021, the City Council held a public hearing and introduction of the proposed Mandatory Commercial and Residential Recycling Ordinance. City Council voted 5-0 to approve the introduction / first reading of the Ordinance. The City Council did not direct any changes to the proposed Ordinance recommended by City staff. Said amendments to the National City Municipal Code Section 9.52 are now presented for the second reading and adoption. 144 of 592 Chapter 9.52 - MANDATORY MME IAL AND RESIDENTIAL RECYCLING PROGRAM 9.52.010 — Purpose. The purpose of this chapter is to: A. Establish requirements for collecting and recycling recyclable materials and collecting and processing organic materials generated from commercial facilities, multi -family dwellings, residential units, and special events. These requirements intend to accomplish the following: 1. Reduce greenhouse gas emissions associated with mining and manufacturing goods from virgin materials and associated with solid waste disposal in landfills; and 2. Protect the natural environment and human health and enhance the economy through increased recycling and organics processing activities. B. Meet the state recycling law, Assembly Bill 341 passed in 2011, and state organics recycling law, Assembly Bill 1826 passed in 2014, requirements for businesses and Multi - Family property owners that generate a specified threshold amount of Solid Waste to arrange for recycling services for that waste and requires the City to implement a Mandatory Commercial Recycling program. C. Meet the requirements of Senate Bill 1383, the Short-lived Climate Pollutant Reduction . Act of 2016, that requires CalRec cle to develop regulations to reduce organics in landfills as a source of methane. The regulations place requirements on multiple entities, including Cities, residential households, Commercial Businesses, and business owners, Commercial Edible Food Generators, haulers, Self -Haulers, Food Recovery Organizations, and Food Recovery Services to support the achievement of Statewide Organic Waste disposal reduction targets. D. Provide for enforcement for violating the requirements of this chapter; E. Establish a schedule for this chapter's implementation and enforcement. . 2. 0 - Definitions. Whenever in this chapter the following terms are used, they shall be deemed and construed to have e meaning ascribed to such respective terms in this section: "Blue Container" has the sane meaning as in 14 CCR Section 1 . a and shall be used for the purpose of storage and collection of Source Separated Recyclable Materials. 145 of 592 " alRec cle" means California's Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, which is the department designated with responsibility for developing, implementing, and enforcing SB 1383 Regulations on Cities and others). "California Code of Regulations" or "CCR" means the State of California Code of Regulations. CCR references in this ordinance are preceded by a number that refers to the relevantTitle of the CCR (e.g., "14 CCR" refers to Title 14 of CCR). "Cardboard" means post -consumer waste paper grade corrugated cardboard (#1 1), kraft (brown)paper bags, or solid fiber boxes which have served their packaging purposes and are discarded and can later be reclaimed for collection and recovery for recycling. "City" means the City of National City, a municipal corporation of the State of California, "CityCouncil" means the Mayor and City Council of the City of National City. "City Manager" means the City Manager ofthe City of National City or City Manager's designee. "Collection" means to take physical possession of solid waste materials or ree elables at residential, commercial, industrial, or governmental sites and transport it to a facility for processing, composting, transfer, disposal, or burning. "Collection vehicle or equipment" means any vehicle or equipment used to collect residential, commercial, industrial, or governmental solid waste or recyclables. "Collector" means any person who holds a valid City franchise or contracts to collect and subsequent transportation or disposal of solid waste..Acollector operates routes or provides regular service and is directly or indirectly reimbursed for collecting and disposing solid waste from residential, commercial, or industrial premises in the City..A Collector may also be referred to as a "franchisee." "Commercial ercial Business" or "Commercial" means a firm, partnership, proprietorship, joint- stock company, corporation, or association, whether for -profit or nonprofit, strip mall, industrial facility, or a multi -family residential dwelling, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(6). A Multi -Family Residential Dwelling that consists of fewer than five (5) units is not a Commercial Business for purposes of implementing this ordinance. 146 of 592 "Commercial Edible Food Generator" includes a Tier One or a Tier Two Commercial Edible Food Generator as defined in Section 9.52.020 of this ordinance or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18 2 a .and a , For this definition, Food Recovery Organizations and Food Recovery Services are not Commercial Edible Food Generators pursuant to 14 R Section 18982(a)(7). "Commercial ree clables" means recyclables from the two comnnereial subcategories of office buildings of more than. 20,000 sq. ft.), as identified in Section . .o o. "Commercial unit" has the same meaning as in Section 7.10.010 of the National City Municipal Code. "Community Composting" means any activity that composts green material, agricultural material, food material, and vegetative food material, alone or in combination, and the total amount of feedstock and Compost on -site at any one time does not exceed 100 cubic yards and 750 square feet, as specified in 14 CCR Section 1 5 (a 4 ; or, as otherwise defined by 14 CCR Section 18982(0(8). "Compostable Plastics" or "Compostable Plastic" means plastic materials that meet the ASTM D6400 standard for compostability, or as otherwise described in 14 CCR Section 1 4-.1 a (1)(A) or 1 4 t (a)(1( • "Construction and demolition waste" means the non -hazardous waste building materials, packaging and_rubblc resulting from construction, remodeling, repair, and demolition activities on housing, commercial or govermnental building, and any other structure and pavement. "Curbside collection" means collecting recyclablerecyclables from the residential waste stream from the curb or alleyway, "Designated recyclable materials" means materials that are recyclable and/or reusable within the following categories of residential, commercial (office and hospitality), and industrial as defined more specifically within each category as listed within this ordinance. "Disposal" means solid waste management through landfill disposal or transformation at a permitted solid waste facility. "Edible Food" means food intended for human consumption, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 1 a 1 . For this ordinance or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(a)(18), "Edible Food" is not Solid Waste if it is recovered and not discarded. Nothing in this ordinance or 14 CCR, Division 7, Chapter 12 requires or authorizes the Recovery of 147 of 592 Edible Food that does not meet the food sfety requirements of the California Retail Food Code. "Enforcement Action" means an act of the City to address non-compliance with this ordinance, including, but not limited to, issuing administrative citations, fines, penalties, or using other remedies. "Enforcement Official" means the city manager or city manager's designee. "Excluded Waste" means hazardous substance, hazardous waste, infectious waste, designated waste, volatile, corrosive, medical waste, infectious, regulated radioactive waste, and toxic substances or material that facility operators, which receive materials from the City and its generators, reasonably believe(s) would, as a result of or upon acceptance, transfer, processing, or disposal, be a violation of local, State, or Federal law, regulation, or ordinance, including: land use restrictions or conditions, waste that cannot be disposed of in Class III landfills or accepted at the facility by permit conditions, waste that in City's reasonable opinion would present a significant risk to human health or the environment, cause a nuisance or otherwise create or expose City to potential liability; but not including de minimis volumes or concentrations of waste of a type and amount normally found inSingle-Family or Multi -Family Solid Waste after implementation of programs for to safe collection, processing, recycling, treatment, and disposal of batteries and paint in compliance with Sections 41500 and 41802 of the California Public Resources Code. "Food Distributor" means a corapany that distributes food to entities including, but not limited to, Supermarkets and Grocery Stores, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(22). "Food Facility" has the same meaning as in Section 113789 of the Health and Safety Code. "Food Recovery" means actions to collect and distribute food for lean consumption that otherwise would be disposed of, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(a)(24). "Food Recovery Organization" means an entity that engages in the collection or receipt of Edible Food from Commercial Edible Food Generators and distributes that Edible Food to the public for Food Recovery either directly or through other entities or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(25), including, but not limited to: (J.) A food bank as defined in Section 113783 of the Health and Safety Code; (2) A nonprofit charitable organization as defined in Section 113841 of the Health and Safety Code; and, (3) A nonprofit charitable temporary food facility as defined in Section 113842 of the Health and Safety Code. A Food Recovery Organization is not a Commercial Edible Food Generator for this ordinance and implementation of 14 CCR, Division 7, Chapter 12 pursuant to 14 CCR Section 18982(0(7). 148 of 592 If the definition in 14 CCR Section 1 (a for Food Recovery Organization differs from this definition, the definition in 14 CCR Section 1 9 a (25) shall apply to this ordinance. "Food Recovery Service" means a person or entity that collects and transports Edible Food from a Commercial Edible Food Generator to a Food Recovery Organization or other entities for Food Recovery, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 1 9 2 a . A Food Recovery Service is not a Commercial Edible Food Generator for this ordinance and implementation of 14 CCR, Division 7, Chapter 12 pursuant to 14 CCR Section 18982(a)(7). "Food Scraps" means all food such as, but not limited to, fruits, vegetables, meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish, bones, rice, beans, pasta, bread, cheese, and eggshells. Food Scraps exclude fats, oils, and grease when such materials are Source Separated from other Food Scraps. "Food Service Provider" means an entity primarily engaged in providing food services to institutional, governmental, commercial, or industrial locations of others based on contractual arrangements with these types of organizations, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(a)(27). "Food -Soiled Paper" is compostable paper material that has come in contact with food or liquid, such as, but not limited to, compostable paper plates, paper coffee cups, napkins, pizza boxes, and rnilk cartons. "Food Waste" means Food Scraps, Food -Soiled Paper, and Compostable Plastics. "Franchise" means any person or private or public entity designated by the City Council as responsible for administering the collection, processing, and/or disposal of solid waste or designated recyelables. "Franchisee" means any person or business concern who has been awarded an exclusive franchise by the City to provide single-family residential and commercial business solid waste, recyclable , yard waste, and other compostables collection services. "Glass bottles and jars" means food and beverage glass containers, including container glass covered by the deposit law, and excluding household and kitchen containers such as drinking glasses, cups, and cooling and serving dishes. "Gray Container" has the same meaning as in 14 CCR Section 1 9 .2 a and shall be used for the purpose of storage and collection of Gray Container Waste. "Gray Container Waste" means Solid Waste that is collected in a Gray Container that is part of a three -container Organic Waste collection service that prohibits the placement of Organic Waste in the Gray Container as specified in 14 CCR Sections 1 984.1 a and b " or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 17402(0(6.5). 149 of 592 "Green Container" has the same meaning as in 14 Section 18982.2(0(29) and shall be used for the purpose of storage andcollection of Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste. "Grocery Store" means a store primarily engaged in the retail sale of canned food; dry goods; fresh fruits and vegetables; fresh meats, fish, and poultry; and any area that is not separately owned within the store where the food is prepared and served, including a bakery, deli, and meat and seafood departments, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(a)(30). "Hazardous waste" means all substances defined as hazardous waste, acutely hazardous waste, or extremely hazardous waste by the State of California in Health and Safety Code Sections 25110.02, 25115, and 25117 or in the future amendments to or modifications of such statutes or identified and listed as hazardous waste by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, pursuant to the Federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (42 USC Section 6901 et seq.), all future amendments thereto, and all rules and regulations promulgated. "Highway" means any street, road, alley, highway, or thoroughfare. "Hospitality's means any establishment that offers dining services, food or beverage sales. Includes taverns, bars, cafeterias, restaurants, motels, hotels, hospitals, schools, colleges, and other establishments with dining services or a restaurant or bar on their premises. "Hospitality recyclables" means aluminum, corrugated cardboard, glass jars and bottles, plastic beverage bottles, tin and bimetal cans, and white goods generated by hospitality facilities. "Industrial recyclables" means recyclables from industry/construction waste strews, as identified in Section 9..090. "Industrial . solid waste" means solid waste originating from mechanized manufacturing facilities, factories, refineries, construction and demolition projects, publicly operated treatment works, and/or solid wastes placed in commercial collection bins, "Industrial unit" includes each building and space primarily used for producing and making, processing, or warehousing goods, wares, and merchandise, including construction and demolition activity. 150 of 592 "Inert" means materials such as concrete, soil, asphalt, ceramics, earthen cooking waste, automotive safety glass, and mirrors. "Inspection" means a site visit where a City reviews records, containers, and an entity's collection, handling, recycling, or landfill disposal of organic Waste or Edible Food handling to determine if the entity is complying with requirements set forth in this ordinance, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(35). "Landfill" means a disposal system by which solid waste is deposited and compacted before burial in a specially prepared area that provides environmental monitoring and treatment. "Large Event" means an event, including, but not limited to, a sporting event or a flea market, that charges an admission price or is operated by a local agency and serves an average of more than 2,000 individuals per day of operation of the event, at a location that includes, but is not limited to, a public, nonprofit, or privately owned park, parking lot, golf course, street system, or other open space when being used for an event. If the definition in 14 CCR Section 1 a differs from this definition, the definition in 14 CCR Section 1 a)(3 8) shall apply to this ordinance. "Large venue" means a permanent venue facility that annually seats or serves an average of more than 2,000 individuals within the grounds of the facility per day of operation of the venue facility. "Litter" has the same meaning as in Section 7.41.010 of the National City Municipal Code. "Local Education Agency" means a school district, charter school, or county office of education that is not subject to the control of city or county regulations related to Solid Waste, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 1 4a4o. "Manure" means accumulated animal excrement. This includes, but is not limited to, feces and or urine, any animal bedding material, spilled feed, or soil that is mixed with feces and/or urine. "Medical waste" means any solid waste which is generated or has been used in the diagnosis, treatment, or immunization of human beings or animals, or research pertaining thereto, and shall include, but not be limited to, biohazardous and medical waste or other solid waste as defined in Chapter 12 of the County Code of Regulatory Ordinances or State and Federal law. "Metal" means recoverable aluminum, tin, and bi-metal materials such as used beverage containers, siding, and other recyclable manufactured metal items. 151 of 592 "Multi -Family Residential Dwelling" or "Multi -Family" means of, from, or pertaining to residential premises with five or more dwelling units. Multi -Family premises do not include hotels, motels, or other transient occupancy facilities considered Commercial Businesses. "Newspaper" means materials printed on newsprint. "Nuisance" means anything harmful to human health, or is indecent or offensive to the senses, and interferes with the comfortable en j o ment of life or property and affects at the same time an entire community or neighborhood, or any number of persons. However, the extent of the annoyance or damage inflicted upon the individual may be unequal, resulting from the storage, removal, transport, processing, or disposal of solid waste and/or recyclables. "Occupant" includes and means every owner, tenant, or person having the care or control of any premise s . "Odor threshold" has the same meaning as in Section ' .10. 01 of of the National City Municipal Code. ",office," for purposes of thischapter, shall mean any combination of offices or connected buildings of over twenty thousand square feet regardless of office affiliation, ownership or occupancy. This includes retail, wholesale, professional services, legal services, financial services, medical services, schools, colleges and libraries. "Office paper" means waste paper grades of white and colored ledgers. Examples include forms, copy paper, stationery, and other papers associated with desk activity. "Organic materials" means any biodegradable material identified by the City, such as yard waste, plant trimmings, food scraps, and paper that can be segregated from garbage and collected and recycled to anaerobic compost digestion or processing with other organics processing methods. Conxpostabl.e plastics and biodegradable plastics are not acceptable items for collection services. "Organic Waste" means Solid Wastes containing material originated from living organisms and their metabolic waste products, including but not limited to food, green material, landscape, and pruning waste, organic textiles and carpets, lumber, wood, Paper Products, Printing and Writing Paper, manure, biosolids, digestate, and sludges or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(46). Biosolids and digestate are as defined by 14 CCR Section 18982(a). 152 of 592 "Organic Waste Generator" means a person or entity that is responsible for the initial creation of Organic Waste, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(48). "Person" means any individual, firm, association, organization, partnership, corporation, business trust, ;joint venture, the United States, State of California, political subdivision, government agency, municipality, public corporation, or any other entity whatsoever, "Paper Products" include, but are not limited to, paper janitorial supplies, cartons, wrapping, packaging, file folders, hanging files, corrugated boxes, tissue, and toweling, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(51). (1). "Plastic beverage bottles" means plastic containers used for containing milk, juice, soft drinks, or water intended for human consumption; to be distinguished from nonfood bottles such as those containing motor oil, detergent, or other household products. "Polluted urban water runoff' means pollution, as defined herein, contained within "urban runoff' as defined in Section 1 .7 .02 0 of the National City Municipal Code. "Pollution" for purposes of this chapter, shall mean the condition caused by the presence in or on a body of water, soil, or air of any solid waste or substance derived therefrom in such quantity, of such nature and direction, or under such condition that the quality, appearance, or usefulness of the water, soil, land, or air is significantly degraded or adversely altered. "Premises" means a tract or parcel of land with or without habitable buildings or appurtenant structures. "Printing and Writing Papers" include, but are not limited to, copy, xerographic, watermark, cotton fiber, offset, forms, computer printout paper, white wove envelopes, manila envelopes, book paper, note pads, writing tablets, newsprint, and other uncoated writing papers, posters, index cards, calendars, brochures, reports, magazines, and publications, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(54). "Processing" means the reduction, separation, recovery, or conversion of solid waste. "Prohibited Container Contaminants" "Prohibited ContainerContaminants" means the following: (i) discarded materials placed in the Blue Container that is not identified as acceptable Source Separated Recyclable Materials for the City's Blue Container; (ii) discarded materials placed in the Green Container that is not identifiedas acceptable Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste for the City's Green Container; (iii) discarded materials placed in the Gray Container that are acceptable Source Separated Recyclable Materials andor Source Separated Green Container Organic Wastes to be placed in City's Green Container and/or Blue Container; and, (iv) Excluded Waste placed in any container. 153 of 592 "Putreseible wastes" mans wastes that are capable of being decomposed by microorganisms with sufficient rapidity as to cause a nuisance because of odors, gases or other offensive conditions. Material in this category includes, but is not limited to, kitchen waste, dead animals, food from containers, etc. "Radioactive waste" means any waste, which exceeds regulatory levels of activity as defined in Chapter 7 of the California Health and Safety Code. "Recyclable plastic beverage containers" shall mean those bottles marked PET 1 and HOPE (2) on the bottom of plastic beverage containers. "Recycling" means any process by which materials which would otherwise become solid waste are collected (source -separated, commingled, or as "mixed waste"), separated and/or processed, and returned to the economic mainstream in the form of raw materials or products or material which are otherwise salvaged or recovered for reuse. "Refuse" means any mixture of putrescible and nonputrescible solid and semi -solid wastes, including, but not limited to, garbage, trash, residential refuse, industrial and commercial solid waste, vegetable or animal solid, andsemi-solid wastes, and other solid waste destined for disposal sites. "Removal" mean.s the act oftaking solid wastes or recoverable material from the place of generation either by an approved collector, agent for the collector or by a person in control of the premises. "Residential recclablesf" means those specific recyclable materials from the residential waste stream, as identified in Section .5 .0 . "Residential unit" includes each building and space primarily used as a dwelling. "Restaurant" means an establishment primarily engaged in the retail sale of food and drinks for on -premises or immediate consumption, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(a)(64). "Rubbish" has the same meaning as in Section 7,10.010 of the National City Municipal Code. "SB 1383" means Senate Bill 1383 of 2016 approved by the Governor on September 19, 2016, which added Sections 39730.5, 39730.6, 39730.7, and 39730.8 to the Health and Safety Code, and added Chapter 13.1 (commencing with Section 42652) to Part 3 of Division of the Public Resources Code, establishing methane emissions reduction targets in a statewide effort 154 of 592 to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants as amended, supplemented, superseded, and replaced from time to time. "Self -Hauler" means a person who hauls Solid Waste, Organic Waste or recyclable material he or she has generated for another person* Self -hauler also includes a person who back -hauls waste, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(66). Back -haul means generating and transporting Organic Waste to a destination owned and operated by the generator using the generator's employees and equipment, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 1 a. "Single-family" means a structure containing a dwelling unit that is serviced with solid waste and recycling removal or pertaining to any residential premises With fewer than five units. "Solid waste" has the same meaning as in Section 15.80,020 of the National City Municipal Code. "Solid waste facility" means and includes a solid waste transfer or processing facility, a construction, demolition, and inert debris processing/disposal facility, a eornpostable materials handling facility, a transformation facility, an incinerator, or a disposal facility. "Solid waste management" means a planned program for effectively controlling the generation, storage, collection, transportation, processing, and reuse, conversion or disposal of solid waste in a safe, sanitary, aesthetically acceptable, environmentally sound, and economical mariner. It includes all administrative, financial, environmental, legal, and planning functions as well as the operations aspects of solid waste handling, disposal, litter control, and resource recovery systems necessary to achieve established objectives. "Source Separated" means materials, including commingled recyclable materials, that have been separated or kept separate from the Solid Waste stream, at the point of generation, for additional sorting or processing those materials for recycling or reuse in order to return them to the economic mainstream in the form of raw material for new, reused, or reconstituted products, which meet the quality standards necessary to be used in the marketplace, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 17402.5(b)(4). For the ordinance, Source Separated shall include separation of materials by the generator, property owner, property owner's employee, property manager, or property manager's employee into different containers for collection such that Source Separated materials are separated from Gray Container Waste/Mixed Waste or other Solid Waste for collection and processing. "Source Separated Blue Container Organic Waste" means Source Separated Organic Wastes that can be placed in a Blue Container that is limited to the collection of those Organic Wastes and Non -Organic I ecyclablcs as defined in the 14 CCTV Section 18982(0(43), or as otherwise defined by Section 17402(0(18.7). 155 of 592 "Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste" means Source Separated Organic Waste that can be placed in a Green Container that is specifically intended for the separate collection of Organic Waste by the generator, excluding Source Separated Blue Container Organic Waste, carpets, Non-Compostable Paper, and textiles. "Source Separated Recyclable Materials" means Source Separated lion -Organic Recyclables and Source Separated Blue Container Organic Waste. "Storage" means the interim containment of solid waste, materials, and recyclables in an approved manner. "Supermarket" means a full -line, self-service retail store with gross annual sales of two million dollars (2,OOO,OOO), or more, and which sells a line of dry grocery, canned goods, or nonfood items and some perishable items, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 18982(0(71). "Tier One Commercial Edible Food Generator" means a Commercial Edible Food Generator that is one of the following: (1) Supermarket. (2) Grocery Store with a total facility size equal to or greater than 10,000 square feet. (3) Food Service Provider. (4) Food Distributor. (5) Wholesale Food Vendor. If the definition in 14 CCR Section 1 2 a of Tier One Commercial Edible Food Generator differs from this definition, the definition in 14 CCR Section 1 ( (' shall apply to this ordinance. "Tier Two Commercial Edible Food Generator" means a Commercial Edible Food Generator that is one of the following: (1) Restaurant with 250 or more seats, or a total facility size equal to or greater than 5,000 square feet. (2) (3) (4) (5) Hotel with an on -site Food Facility and 200 or more rooms. Health facility with an on -site Food Facility and 100 or more beds. Large Venue. Large Event. 156 of 592 (6) A State agency with a cafeteria with 250 or more seats or a total cafeteria facility size equal to or greater than 5,000 square feet. (7) A Local Education Agency facility with an on -site Food Facility. "Tin and bimetal cans" means any food or beverage containers that are composed of steel with a thin coating or steel and aluminum. "To segregate waste material" means any of the following: the placement of rec elables in separate containers; the binding of recyclable material separately from the other waste material; the physical separation of recyclables from other waste material. "White goods" means kitchen or other large appliances. "Wholesale Food Vendor" means a business or establishment engaged in the wholesale merchant distribution of food, where food (including fruits and vegetables) is received, shipped, stored, prepared for distribution to a retailer, warehouse, distributor, or other destination, or as otherwise defined in 14 CCR Section 189852(0(76). "Wood wastes?' means lumber and wood products but excludes painted wood, wood treated with chemicals, and pressure -treated wood. "Yard wastes" means leaves, grass, weeds, and wood material from trees and shrubs. . .03 — Requirements for Single -Family Generators. Single -Family Organic Waste Generators shall comply with the following requirements A. Subscribe to City's Organic Waste collection services for all Organic Waste generated as described below in Section B. The City shall have the right to review the number and size of a generator's containers to evaluate the adequacy of capacity provided for each type of collection service to properly separate materials and contain materials. B. Adjust its service level for its collection services as requested by the City. C. Participate in the City's Organic Waste collection service(s) by placing designated materials in designated containers as described below, andshall not place Prohibited Container Contaminants in collection containers. 1. Single -Family Organic Waste Generators shall place Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste, including Food Waste, in the Green Container; Source Separated Recyclable Materials in the Blue Container; and Gray Container Waste in the Gray 157 of 592 Container. Generators shall not place materials designated for the Gray Container into the Green Container or Blue Container. 9.52.040 — Requirements nts for Commercial Businesses Generators. Commercial Businesses Generators shall comply with the following requirements: A. Subscribe to City's three container collection services and comply with the requirements ofthose services as described below in Section B. The City shall have the right to review the number and size of a generator's containers and collection frequency to evaluate the adequacy of capacity provided for each type of collection service for proper separation of materials and containment of materials. B. Adjust their service level for their collection services as requested by the City. C. Participate in the City's Organic Waste collection service(s) by placing designated materials in designated containers as described below: 1. Commercial Businesses Generators shall place Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste, including Food Waste, in the Green Container; Source Separated Recyclable Materials in the Blue Container; and Gray Container Waste in the Gray Container. Generators shall not place materials designated for the Gray Container into the Green Container or Blue Container. 2. Commercial Businesses Generators that are Tier One or Tier Two Commercial Edible Food Generators shall comply with Food Recovery requirements described in this ordinance. 3. Excluding Multi -Family .esi lential Dwellings, periodically inspect Blue Containers, Green Containers, and Gray Containers for contamination and inform employees if containers are contaminated and the requirements to keep contaminants out of those containers pursuant to 14 CCR Section 184.(b• 4. Annually provide information to employees, contractors, tenants, and customers about Organic Waste Recovery requirements and proper sorting of Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste and Source Separated Recyclable Materials. 5. Provide education information before or within fourteen (14) days of the occupation of the premises to new tenants that describes requirements to keep Source Separated Green Container Organic Waste and Source Separated Recyclable Materials separate from Gray Container Waste (when applicable) and the location of containers and the rules governing their use at each property. 158 of 592 6. Provide or arrange access for City or its agent to their properties during all inspections conducted in accordance with this ordinance to confirm compliance with the requirements of this ordinance. . .o o — Provisions for self -haulers. A. Nothing in this chapter shall preclude any person, commercial business, single-family residence, or special event from self -hauling recyclable materials or organic materials generated by that entity to a recycling or organics processing facility. B. Self -haulers shall: 1. Comply with the requirements in this chapter by delivering for recycling those items that local recycling facilities can recycle; self --haulers that are also food service establishments shall comply by delivering for organics processing those items that local organics processing facilities accept. 2. Provide proof of compliance with this chapter upon request by the City; proof includes but is not limited to a receipt from a recycling or organics processing facility that clearly identifies the type and quantity of material delivered. Compliance records shall consist of the following information: a) Delivery receipts and weight tickets from the entity accepting the waste. b) The mount of material in cubic yards or tons transported by the generator to each entity. c) If the material is transported to an entity that does not have scales on -site or employs scales incapable of weighing the Se1ffHauler's vehicle in a manner that altos it to determine the weight of materials received, the Self -Hauler is not required to record the weight of material but shall keep a record of the entities that received the Organic Waste. . 2.o o - Requirements for Commercial Edible Food Generators. A. Tier One Commercial Edible Food Generators must comply with the requirements of this Section commencing January 1, 2022, and Tier Two Commercial Edible Food Generators must comply commencing January 1, 2024, pursuant to 14 CCR Section 18991.3. B. Large Venue or Large Event operators not providing food services, but allowing for food to be provided by others, shall require Food Facilities operating at the Large Venue or Large Event to conxply with this section's requirements, commencing January 1, 2024. C. Commercial Edible Food Generators shall comply with the following requirements: 159 of 592 1. Arrange to recover the maximum amount of Edible Food that would otherwise be disposed. 2. Contract with, or enter into a written agreement with Food Recovery Organizations or Food Recovery Services for: i the collection of Edible Food for Food Recovery; or (ii) acceptance of the Edible Food that the Commercial Edible Food Generator self -hauls to the Food Recovery Organization for Food Recovery. 3. Shall not intentionally spoil Edible Food capable of being recovered by a Food Recovery Organization or a Food Recovery Service. 4. Allow City's enforcement official to access the premises and review records pursuant to 14 CCR Section 18991.4. 5. Keep records that include the following information, or as otherwise specified in 14 CCR Section 18991.4: a. A list of each Food Recovery Service or organization that collects or receives its Edible Food pursuant to a contract or written agreement established under 14 CCR Section 18991.3(4 b. A copy of all contracts or written agreements established under 14 CCR Section 18991.3(4 c. A record of the following information for each of those Food Recovery Services or Food Recovery Organizations: 1. The name, address, and contact information of the Food Recovery Service or Food Recovery Organization. 2. The types of food that will be collected by or self -hauled to the Food Recovery Service or Food Recovery Organization. 3. The established frequency that food will be collected or self -hauled. 4. The quantity of food, measured in pounds recovered per month, collected or self -hauled to a Food Recovery Service or Food Recovery Organization for Food Recovery. D. Nothing in this ordinance shall be construed to limit or conflict with the protections provided by the California Good Samaritan Food Donation Act of 2017, the Federal Good Samaritan Act, or share table and school food donation guidance pursuant to Senate Bill 557 of 2017 (approved by the Governor of the State of California on September 25, 2017, which added Article 13 [commencing with Section 49580] to Chapter 9 of Part 27 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Education Code, and to amend Section 114079 of the Health 160 of 592 and Safety Code, relating - o food safety, as am. n.d d, supplemented, superseded and replaced from time to time). . 2. - Requirements for Food Recovery Organizations and Services. A. Food Recovery Services collecting or receiving Edible Food directly from Commercial Edible Food Generators, via a contract or written agreement established under 14 CCR Section 18991.3(4 shall maintain the following records, or as otherwise specified by 14 CCR Section 1 91. (a)(1 . 1. The name, address, and contact information for each Commercial Edible Food Generator from which the service collects Edible Food. 2. The quantity in pounds of Edible Food collected from. each Commercial Edible Food Generator per month. 3. The quantity in pounds of Edible Food transported to each Food Recovery Organization per month. 4. The name, address, and contact information for each Food Recovery Organization that the Food Recovery Service transports Edible Food to for Food Recovery. B. Food Recovery Organizations collecting or receiving Edible Food directly from Commercial Edible Food Generators, via a contract or written agreement established under 14 CCR Section 1 991. b , shall maintain the following records, or as otherwise specified by 14 R Section 1 91.. a : 1. The name, address, and contact information for each Commercial Edible Food Generator from which the organization receives Edible Food. 2. The quantity in pounds of Edible Food received from each Commercial Edible Food Generator per month. 3. The name, address, and contact information for each Food Recovery Service that the organization receives Edible Food from. for Food Recovery. C. Food Recovery Organizations and Food Recovery Services that have their primary address physically located in the City and contract with or have written agreements with one or more Commercial Edible Food Generators pursuant to 14 CCR Section 1991.b shall report to the City it is located in the total pounds of Edible Food recovered in the previous calendar year from the Tier One and Tier Two Commercial Edible Food Generators they have established a contract or written agreement with pursuant to 14 CCR Section 18991.3(4 D. Food Recovery Capacity Planning 161 of 592 Food Recovery Services and Food Recovery Organizations. To support Edible Food Recovery capacity . planning assessments or other studies conducted by the County, City, special district that provides solid waste collection services, or its designated entity, Food Recovery Services and Food Recovery Organizations operating in the City shall provide information and consultation to the City, upon request, regarding existing, or proposed new or expanded, Food Recovery capacity that could be accessed by the City and its Commercial Edible Food Generators. Food Recovery Service or Food Recovery Organization contacted by the City shall respond to such request for information within 60 days unless the City otherwise specifies a shorter timeframe. 9. . 0 — Waiver for Generators. A. De Minimis Waivers. The City may waive a Commercial Business' obligation (including Multi -Family Residential Dwellings) to comply with some or all of the Organic Waste requirements of this ordinance if the Commercial Business provides documentation that the business generates below a certain amount of Organic Waste material as described in Section 9.52.080 A.2. below. Commercial Businesses requesting a de minimis waiver shall: 1. Submit an application specifying the services they request a waiver from and provide documentation noted in Section 9.52.080 A.2. below. . Provide documentation that either: a. The Commercial Business' total Solid Waste collection service is two cubic yards or more per .week, and Organic Waste subject to collection in a Blue Container or Green Container comprises less than 20 gallons per week per applicable container of the business' total waste; or b. The Commercial Business's total Solid Waste collection service is less than two cubic yards per week, and Organic Waste, subject to collection in a Blue Container or Green Container, comprises less than 10 gallons per week applicable container of the business' total waste. 3. Notify the City if circumstances change such that Commercial Business' s Organic Waste exceeds the threshold required for a waiver, in which case the waiver will be rescinded. 4. Provide written verification of eligibility for de minimis waiver every five years if City has approved de minimis waiver. B. Physical Space Waivers. The City may waive a Commercial Business' or property owner's obligations (including Multi -Family Residential Dwellings) to comply with some or all of the recyclable materials and/or Organic Waste collection service requirements if the City 162 of 592 has evidence from its staff, a hauler, licensed architect, or licensed engineer demonstrating that the premises lacks adequate space for the collection containers required for compliance with, the Organic Waste collection requirements. A Commercial Business or property owner may request a physical space waiver through the following process: Submit an application form specifying the type(s) of collection services for which they are requesting a compliance waiver. 2. Provide documentation that the premises lacks adequate space for Blue Containers and/or Green Containers, including documentation from its hauler, licensed architect, or licensed engineer. 3. Provide written verification to City that it is still eligible for a physical space waiver every five years if City has approved the application for a physical space waiver. C. Collection Frequency Waiver. The City, at its discretion and in accordance with 14 CCR Section 1 4.11 a ( , may allow the owner or tenant of any residence, premises, business establishment, or industry that subscribes to the City's Organic Waste collection service to arrange for the collection of their Blue Container, Gray Container, or both once every fourteen (14) days, rather than once per week. D. Review and Approval of Waivers by the City. # * - Designated recyclable materials. The following are designated reeyelables subject to this designation: A. Residential Recyclables. 1. Newspapers, 2. Plastic beverage bottles, 3. Aluminum, 4. Tin and bi-metal cans, 5. White goods (appliances), 6. Glass bottles and jars, 7. Organic materials; B. Commercial Recyclables. clables. 1. Office buildings: a. Office paper, b. Corrugated cardboard, c. Newspapers, 163 of 592 d., Aluminum, e. Organic materials, f. Other recyclables currently accepted and permitted by hauler; 2. Hospitality industry, including all restaurants and taverns: a. Plastic beverage bottles, b. Glass jars and bottles, e, White goods (appliances), d. Aluminum, e. Tin and bi-metal cans, . Organic materials, g. Other recyclables currently accepted and permitted by hauler; C. Industrial and Construction Recyclables. elables. 1. Dirt, 2. Asphalt, 3. Sand, 4. Land clearing brush, 5. Concrete, 6. Metal, 7 Rock, 8. Clean wood. 9. Other construction and demolition debris, such as rock, granite, and clean wood, and other materials currently accepted by the materials processing facility, 10. Other recyclables currently accepted and permitted by hauler; D. Yard Waste. 1. Leaves, 2. Grass, 3. Weeds, 4. Wood materials from trees and shrubs. The above list may be modified to add or delete listed items from time to time by City Council resolution. 9.52.100 - Separation of recyclable materials. 164 of 592 A. The City's designated rubbish hauler shall provide containers for designated recyclables to each of its customers to collect designated recyclables. B. Containers provided to single-family, and multi -family residences, commercial and industrial entities shall effectively segregate the designated recyclables for pickup. C. Every owner or occupant in charge of any property where rubbish, garbage, or refuse is generated shall separate all recyclable materials from other garbage and combined refuse and shall group together and place for collection such recyclable materials in the same manner as rubbish, garbage, or refuse placed for collection. Recyclable material that shall be grouped and separated from other garbage and refuse shall be established by City Council resolution. 9. 2.11 - Mandatory recycling implementation schedule. The following shall be the recycling implementation schedule within the city: A. Residential single-family B. Residential multi -family C. Yard and wood waste Effective Enforcement Date June 1, 1992 July 1, 1993 April 1, 1993 I . Commercial: office and hospitality July 1, 1993 E. Industrial January 1, 1993 9. 2.1 — Solid waste declared public nuisance — Exceptions. No solid waste shall be placed or allowed to be placed or remain upon any vacant lot, park, public or private property, street, road, highway, or alley within the limits of the City, and the same is declared to be a public nuisance, except that hone composting of yard waste and compostables as defined in this chapter is exempt from the provisions of this section. It is further unlawful for any person to deposit or place such material in any garbage or refuse container owned or used by the owner of such property unless such person first obtains the permission of the owner to do so. 9.52.130 - Collection by a franchisee. A. No person shall provide a solid waste collection service within the City except in accordance with a franchise granted by the City. 165 of 592 B, Through the granting of one or more franchises, the City Council shall provide solid waste collection services to all owners and occupiers of property within the City limits. C. The charge for such service shall be due and payable by each owner or occupier of property according to the schedule of rates and charges established, from time to time, by resolution of City Council. D. No person shall willfully fail, neglect, or refuse to pay the fees as prescribed in the schedule contained in said resolution after demanding by the contract agent. E. The franchisee will provide the billing and be responsible for collecting payments until the City accepts payment collection. Residential customers shall not be billed more than three months in advance. The franchisee shall not cancel service for nonpayment of refuse fees without written approval by the City Manager. F. Single-family residential customers may voluntarily suspend service upon vacating the residence, providing service is resumed immediately upon the residence being reoccupied. G. Multi -family residential complexes may voluntarily suspend service upon vacancy of all units within the complex, providing service is resumed immediately upon at least one unit being reoccupied. H. Commercial billing shall be monthly in arrears of service. I. A senior citizen refuse discount program will be established by the contractor for senior citizens (persons sixty-five years and older). The City Council may, from time to time, by resolution, fix the rate and payment schedule. 9.52.140 — Franchisee franchise fee. The franchisee shall pay a franchise fee in an amount determined by resolution of the City Council or established in the franchise agreement authorizing the collection of solid waste, recyclables, yard waste, and other compostables. 9.52.150—Hazardous wastes. No person shall transport or collect hazardous wastes without compliance with applicable State law. No person shall deposit, dump, spill, or otherwise allow to be placed on a County solid waste facility not designated as a hazardous waste disposal facility. . .1 — Foes for recycling. 166 of 592 A. The fees will be established by the resolution of the City Council. The City Council may, from time to time, amend such resolution. B. Residential and commercial businesses must pay the established fees for recycling unless exempted explicitly by City Council resolution. . 2.1 0 — Solid waste diversion. Franchisee shall guarantee to the City that the diversion requirements of applicable State and Federal law will be fully satisfied at all times during the term and any extended term of the franchise agreement. . 2.I80 — Documentation of recycling tonnage. The City Council may, by resolution, establish requirements and procedures for commercial businesses to submit recycling tonnage documentation to the City to comply with state reporting requirements. 9.52.190 — Inspections and investigation by the City. A. The City's enforcement official is authorized to conduct inspections and investigations, at random or otherwise, of any collection container, collection vehicle loads, or transfer, processing, or disposal facility for materials collected from generators, or Source Separated materials to confirm compliance with this ordinance by Organic Waste Generators, Commercial Businesses (including Multi -Family Residential Dwellings), s), property owners, Commercial Edible Food Generators, haulers, Self - Haulers, Food Recovery Services, and Food Recovery Organizations, subject to applicable laws. This Section does not allow the City to enter the interior of private residential property for inspection. C. The regulated entity shall provide or arrange for access during all inspections (except for residential property interiors) and shall cooperate with the City's enforcement official during such inspections and investigations. Such inspections and investigations may include confirmation of proper placement of materials in containers, Edible Food Recovery activities, records, or any other requirement of this ordinance described herein. Failure to provide or arrange for: (i) access to an entity' s premises; or ii access to records for any inspection or investigation is a violation of this ordinance and may result in penalties described. D. Any records obtained by a City during its inspections and other reviews shall be subject to the requirements and applicable disclosure exemptions of the Public Records Act as outlined in Government Code Section 6250 et seq. E. The City's enforcement official is authorized to conduct inspections or other investigations as reasonably necessary to further the goals of this ordinance, subject to applicable laws. 167 of 592 F. The City shall receive written complaints from persons regarding an entity that may be potentially non -compliant with SB 1383 Regulations, including receipt of anonymous complaints. 9.52.200 - Mandatory recycling enforcement. A. The City Manager, who is assigned to duties which include the enforcement of solid waste regulations and laws, is responsible for enforcing the provisions of this chapter. B. The City Manager shall have responsibility for enforcing all provisions of this chapter. Violation of any provision of this ordinance shall constitute grounds for issuing a Notice of Violation and assessing a fine by a City's Enforcement rcement f` icial or representative. Enforcement Actions under this ordinance are the issuance of an administrative citation and assessment of a fine according to Section 1.20.010. However, nothing herein provided shall prevent the City Manager from efforts to obtain voluntary compliance by way of warning, a notice. of violation or educational means. 168 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Public Hearing and adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City confirming the costs of Weed Abatement and Approving the report and account for such, after having considered any objections or protests; pursuant to National City Municipal Code Chapters 1.36 (Abatement of Public Nuisances) and 9.12 (Abatement of Weeds and other Fire Hazards). (Fire) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 169 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Public Hearing and Adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City confirming the costs of Weed Abatement and Approving the report and account for such, after having considered any objections or protests; pursuant to National City Municipal Code Chapters 1.36 (Abatement of Public Nuisances) and 9.12 (Abatement of Weeds and other Fire Hazards). (Fire) PREPARED BY: Robert Drew/Deputy Fire Marshal DEPARTMENT: F PHONE: 336-4558 APPROVED BY: EXPLANATION: In accordance with National City Municipal Code (NCMC), Chapter 9.12, a report of the proceedings and an accurate account of the cost of abating the nuisance on each separate property shall be filed with the City Council. Notice of the public hearing shall be served in the same manner as summons in a civil action in accordance with Article 3 (commencing with Section 415.10) of Chapter 4 of Title 5 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Pursuant to NCMC Section 1.36.100, the City Council shall consider the Report and Account at the time set for the confirmation of costs hearing, together with any objections or protests by the responsible person or other interested persons. The responsible person or other interested persons may present a written or oral protest or objection to the report and account. At the conclusion of the hearing, the City Council shall by resolution either approve the Report and Account as submitted, or as modified or corrected by the City Council. The approved costs of the abatements will be liens upon the respective lots or premises. The proposed resolution incorporates all the parcels subject to weed abatement liens pursuant to NCMC Section 1.36.110. A copy of the resolution shall be served on the responsible person, pursuant to the procedures set forth in the NCMC Section 1.36.040, no later than 15 days after the date of adoption. If the cost of abatement is waived by the Mayor and Council, the City of National City will be responsible for all costs associated with the weed abatement conducted by Fire Prevention Services. Report on file in the City Clerk's Office. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: APPROVED: Finance ACCOUNT NO. 001-12124-3561 $13,670.86 APPROVED: Nils No expenditure account. Payments to Fire Prevention Services are deducted from the above revenue account. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: This is not a project and, therefore, not subject to environmental review. ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: STAFF RECOMMENDATION: City Council by resolution approves the Report and Account as submitted or as modified or corrected by the City Council. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A ATTACHMENTS: Fixed Charges Special Assessments - Please see Exhibit "A" Complete background supportive documents filed in the Office of the City Clerk and available for review upon request. Resolution 1nyti 70 of 5921 City of National City Weed Abatement Program 2021/2022 Fixed Charge Special Assessments P,..0..,,,,,e,..iijiaggig.i.L....:10..6,„L', ...,„' All] Plit0'44:..: . k.,„oiRIT!Iiiill'il ,11.P#00tirliiiligifillitliiIIIIIIIIINNiiiitililiiiiWialliiiii$111}111 IMAICIA„NA„c#,#"0„:#1111113211180.11111liilli IP,..),9.1:11iiiiii111111111,111111,liS..A.11ilig,grici,.....Ao& 554 201 17 00 $885.28 2325 Melrose St Samaniego Samuel R 4122 Sycamore Dr San Diego CA 92105 557 380 62 00 $1,016.64 Plaza Blvd Mcdonalds Corp Po Box 182571 Columbus OH 43218 557 380 63 00 $926.58 2140 E Plaza Blvd Mcdonalds Corp Po Box 182571 Columbus OH 43218 558 220 35 00 $4,020.82 3040 E 16th St Brown Clara M 10037 Dunbar Ln El Cajon CA 92021 558 320 22 00 $2,546.94 2112 Rachael Ave Casillas Jose D / Estella V 1626G Sweetwater Rd #161 National City CA 91950 558 320 43 00 $2,540.52 Harbison Ave Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Trust 804 24th St San Diego CA 92154 559 033 03 00 $869.22 Harding Ave Welding Maria G H 727 E San Ysidro Blvd #707 San Ysidro CA 92173 563 162 32 00 $864.86 2815 Grove St Denbleyker Kenneth 2815 Grove St National City CA 91950 , -...- . - • : , :.:.,:+,;; iiiiill;KIP,:i:iilill!!NiiMRliilll l'AlglitiillliiiliulliilAilliill:loiF,mill illIVi!l!liigiVilllil!!lillicilillilIlllNii}ilillPillijiliiiMli',11illiiiii:lNii .. ...;il'IillliqiilAililll at,liql.o.a,:;;!,1,;2010,11,„1,mat(t:ollii!IvH,...,!u,J,i1.;!w.,61.:,i,,„q..)4.14,i1:illul:iJogiut,ii.doplp:,1,;;,...0,.Ed,ii,11.1L,Ab.: ItPlillilillgTgliTillilliMliillifr' lillilliiiliTillillillill[iiiill0111,11111illillillii r .1 . lilillihii i4iii.,4,i!ti;::iPil .1;4!:!Ilimo Total Parcels: 8 Total Assess: $13,670.86 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 554-201-17-00 04/06/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 04/07/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 05/05/20 Courtesy notice returned "not deliverable as addressed". 05/05/20 Sent copy of notice to forwarding address. 05/11/20 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 05/11/20 Posted property. 05/12/20 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 05/18/20 Certified notice returned "not deliverable as addressed". 05/27/20 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 07/15/20 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 07/22/20 Work order authorization signed by District Official for Admin fee. 07/24/20 The owner was mailed an Administrative bill at the contracted rates. 08/28/20 The owner was mailed a final bill. 09/30/20 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 1 172 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Samaniego Samuel R Address: 4122 Sycamore Dr San Diego. CA 92105 Parcel Number: 554 201 17 00 Date: 4/7/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: 2325 Melrose St Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round.' You arc herehy directed to abate the puhlic nuisance described above. of which you are the occupant or owner. within thirty (30) days of 4/7/2020 "Your failure to comply with this order will result in the City having your property cleaned by the City's contractor at your expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36). A $350.00 administrative fee will he charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property, (per Resolution number 94-97). Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors. Guidelines For The Abatement of Flammable \'eeetation For the protection of life and property. remove all hrush. flammable vegetation. or combustible growth which is located from thirty (30) feet to one hundred (100) feet from such a huilding or structure or to the properly line, whichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department, including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more than thirty (30) from such huilding or structure Cuttings are to be removed from the property and disposed of properly. Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground. "NOTICE REGARDING RARE, TIIRE;ATENED OR ENDANGERED SPECIES" If you have previously received a notice from the Calitomia Department of Fish and Game or the U S. Fish and Wildlife Services that rare, threatened or endangered species of fish or wildlife have occurred on your property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance, YOU MUST NOTIFY BOTH AGENCIES AND THE NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT IN WRITING AT LEAST TEN (10) DAYS PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IF THESE AGENCIES FAIL TO OBJECT OR NOTIFY YOU OF ANY ALTERNATIVE PROCEDURES WITHIN THOSE TEN (10) DAYS. YOU MAY THEN PROCEED TO CLEAR VEGETATION AS DIRECTED BY THIS NOTICE. Failure to provide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Law to penalties. National City. .Municipal Code 9.12.010 Public Nuisance Declared --In General Any oldie following conditions are herehy declared to constitute a puhlic nuisance: A. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee determines that there exists in any huilding or on any. premises combustible, hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish; or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper, poxes, shavings. or any highly flammable materials which ate so situated as to endanger life or property: or finds obstructions to or on fire escapes. stairs, passageways, doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the fire department or the egress of the occupants of such huilding of premises: or finds that the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any tire separation wall is reduced; or finds that any provision of the Uniform Fire Code is being violated. B. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stove, oven. incinerator, furnace or other heating device. electric fixture or any appurtenance thereto, or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any huilding, structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the Uniform Fire Code. to he detective or unsafe so as to create a hazard C. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or menace of tire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the puhlic service regularly engaged in preventing, suppressing or extinguishing tire or any thing or act which may obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations of the fire department or the egress of occupants in the event of tire. National City yunicipal Code 9.12.020 Public Nuisance Declared—M eeds and Other Flammable %laterialg All weeds, growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or private property are herehy declared to he a puhlic nuisance. For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the following: A. Weeds which hear seeds of a downy or wingy nature. B. Sagebrush. chaparral, and any other hrush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become. when dry. a lire menace to adjacent improved property C. Weeds which are otherwise noxious or dangerous. n Poison oak and poison ivy when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the puhlic health. E Dry grass, stubble, hrush. litter, or other flammable material which endangers the puhlic safety by creating a fire hazard in a portion of the City which has been zoned for single and multiple residence purposes. National City Municipal ('ode 1.36.1110 Public nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a puhlic nuisance in any section of this code. and/or and condition caused. maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health, safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs, injures or interferes with the reasonable of free use of property in a neighborhood. community or to any considerable number of persons. A puhlic nuisance also has the same meaning as set forth in California Civil Code Section 3479. National City, Municipal Code 1.36.061) Abatement— Anneal-- Ilcarin, Within ten (10) days from the date of posting. mailing or personal service of the required notice. the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City Council. Such appeal shall he in writing and shall he filed with the City Clerk. Ifyou should have any questions, please feel free to call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si usted tienealguna pregunta, por favor (lame al numero: 1-866-779-3774 Sii anumang kalanungan, tumaivag lang po sa numerong ito: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in puhlic safety. "You have the right to appeal this matter to the City Council within ten (10) days of the receipt of this notice 1-866-779-3774 est. 307 or htfp://fireprevention.net The appeal shall he in writin and filed with the City Clerk. (NCMC 136.050) •**Fire Prevention Services, In6. is under contract with the City of National City. 173 of 592 Fire Prevention Services*** NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Ye s HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR ABATEMENT? Ye s HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTS TO ABATE THE PROPERTY? Ye CALL ARE PREVENTION 1-866-779-3774 http://firepreventIon.net CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-T79-3774 1 http://fireprevention.net PROPERTY OWNERS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MAINTAINING HAZARD ABATEMENT ON YEAR ROUND BASIS. HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY READ THE ABATEMENT INSTRUCTIONS No WOULD YOU UKETHE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? No IF NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME SPECFIED THE OWNER WILL BE CHARGED AS35400 ADMNiSTRATIVE FEE. PWS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Ye s Yes IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND —Yes-4 INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION. 1.866-779-3774 http://fl reprevent bn. net CALL RRE PREVENTION WHEN COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://Rreprevention.net CALL FIRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-B66-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net i J IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE P$! R TO CITY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMNISTRATNE FEE MAY BE WAIVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 91950-4596 3 174 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre E. Per square foot over one acre 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate B. move -on fee $250.00 $325.00 $400.00 $450.00 $ 00.02 $ 00.10 $150.00 $150.00 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. B. C. D E. F. G. H. special inspection fee abatement lien Interest on lien (apr) release of abatement lien public notary File duplication fee Unscheduled Labor per man hour unscheduled fees $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00 10% $ 50.00 $ 20.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00 (reimbursement of cost) 4 175 of 592 OfiMill • Re -Inspection 6 177 of 592 05/11/20 Re-Inspectio . - 1/20 R spe ticpn 179 of 592 05/11/20 Re -Inspection 9 180 of 592 /11/20 Re-Inpec 181 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Samaniego Samuel R Address: 4122 Sycamore Dr San Diego, CA 92105 Parcel Number: 554 201 17 00 Date: 5/12/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: 2325 Melrose St Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. {Please maintain any and all.grasses below 3 inchesxear round) You are hereby directed to abate the public nuisance described above, of which you are the occupant or owner, within ten (10) days of 5/12/2020. ••Your failure to comply with this order will result in you being charged the administrative lee and the City having your property cleaned by the City's contractor at vour expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36). A $350.00 administrative fee will be charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property (per Resolution number 94-97). Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors. Guidelines For The Abatement of Flammable A'egetation For the protection of life and property, remove all brush. flammable vegetation. or combustible growth which is located from thirty (30) feet to one hundred (100) feet from such a building or structure or to the property line. whichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department, including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more than thirty (30) from such building or structure. Cuttings are to he removed from the property and disposed of properly. Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground. "NOTICE REGARDING FLARE, THREATENED OR ENDANGERED SPECIES" Ifyou have previously' received a notice from the California Department of Fish and Game or the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services that rare, threatened or endangered species of fish or wildlife have occurred on vour property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance. YOU MUST NOTIFY BOTH AGENCIES AND TIIE NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT IN WRITING AT LEAST TEN (10) DAYS PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IF THESE AGENCIES FAIL TO OBJECT OR NOTIFY YOU OF ANY ALTERNATIVE PROCEDURES WITHIN THOSE TEN (10) DAYS. YOU MAY THEN PROCEED TO CLEAR VEGETATION AS DIRECTED BY THIS NOTICE. Failure to provide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Law to penalties. National City Municipal Code 9.12.010 Public Nuisance Declared —In General Any of the following conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance: A. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible, hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish; or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper, poxes, shavings_ or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property: or finds ohstnictions to or on fire escapes. stairs. passageways, doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of the occupants ot'such building of premises: or finds that the effectiveness of any exit door, attic separation or any fire separation wall is reduced: or finds that any provision of the Unifom Fire Code is being violated. 13. When the Fire Chicf or his/her designee deems any chimney, smokestack, stove, oven, incinerator, furnace or other heating device, electric fixture or any appunenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any budding. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the Uniform Fire Code. to be defective or unsafe so as to create a hazard. C. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or menace of fire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in preventing, suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which may obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of occupants in the event of fire. National City \lunicipal Code 9.12.020 Public Nuisance Declared— %ecds and Other Flammable %latcrials All weeds. growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or private property arc hereby declared to he a public nuisance. For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the lidlowing. A Weeds which hear seeds of a downy or wingy nature. B. Sagebrush, chaparral, and any other brush or weeds which anain such large growth as to become, when dry. a fire menace to adjacent improved property. C Weeds which are otherwise noxious or dangerous. D. Poison oak and poison ivy when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health. F.. Dry grass, stubble. brush. litter. or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a tire hazard in a portion of the City which has been zoned for single and multiple residence purposes. National ('iti Municipal Code 1.36.010 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to be a public nuisance in any section of this code, and/or and condition caused, maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health. safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs, injures or interferes with the reasonable of Tree use of property in a neighborhood. community or to any considerable number of persons. A public nuisance also has the same meaning as set forth in California Civil Code Section 3479. National City lilunicipal ('ode 1.36.06(1 Abatement— .appeal— Ilearing Within ten (ID) days from the date of posting. mailing or personal service of the required notice, the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City Council. Such appeal shall be in writing and shall he filed with the City Clerk. If you should have any questions, please feel free to call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si usted tienealguna pregunta, por favor Ilame al numero: 1-866-779-3774 Sa anumang katanungan. tumawag tang pn sa numerong ito: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in public safety, "You have the right to appeal this matter to the City C'ouneil within ten ( Ill) days of the receipt of this notice. 1-866-779-3774 ext. 307 tor hitp://ftrcpreventiun.net The appeal shall be in venting and filed with the City Clerk. (NCMC 1 36.050) ***Fire Prevention Services. Inc. is under contract with the City of National City. Fire Prevention Services*** 11 rev. 0327/06.0424/06. 0621/06 182 of 592 m 0 tr IL it .r` ru ru r-1 O II t= O IU a 1-1 U.S. Postal CERTIFIE Domestic Mali On For delivery Informs ervice`" MAIL® RECEIPT Y ion. visit our website at www.usps.come. l ^N DI EGO , C A set 055 lCertified Mail Fee $3. C15 $ Extra Services & Fees ie^eca cox. add fee ❑ Return Receipt (rordcopy) S ❑ Return Receipt (eientronlc) $ ❑ Codified Mail Retracted Delivery S ❑ Ault Signature Required S ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery S Postage $ Total Pa $ Seem To Street at $0.555 554 %r151 7 00 Samaniego Samuel R 4122 Sycamore p2- city, Sta San Diego CA 92 4020 03 /1 183 of 592 AeS- cto 07/22/20 Inspection 184 of 592 O7/22/2OInspetiot , �'- 14 185 of 592 07/22/20 Inspection 15 186 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Owner: Samaniego Samuel R Address: 4122 Sycamore Dr San Diego, CA 92105 Authorization # 7112 Ao/4,0nicy Parcel #554 201 17 00 Job location:2325 Melrose St Authorized by: Signature: Date: '-7' u - Z)Z<) WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: cu. yds. Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round) 16 187 of 592 •G54-2oJ-202, ofkao SAN DIEGO COUNfr ASSESSOR 5 MAP SK MAP 4370 - NATIONAL AWARD HOMES UNIT NO 2 554-20, 1 too' ttj mamma= moimENEN =MIME MI MIME MIMI= III =I Ell =II NMI --M■I =■NMI ---■M --� I =MI■M =MIME■ =MIMI■MI ---■- 17 188 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-172(1 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprelention.net ADMINISTRATIVE BILL 7/24/2620 Samaniego Samuel R 4122 Sycamore Dr San Diego. CA 92105 Parcel # 554 201 17 00 Location: 2325 Melrose St Dear Samaniego Samuel R, Fire Prevention Services has been contracted b .i4ie City of National City to help reduce potential lire violations thus improving the safety of its citttens'` Your property was re -inspected on 5/27/2020 and ArrrctE�astill-be in violation of the National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. As stated in the notice, irthe ‘iolativn is not corrected prior to the deadline you will be charged an administrative fee. A final inspection was performed on the above referenced parcel. as of 7/22/2020 this parcel is in compliance with the National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. Due to the abatement not being completed by the deadline, you are being charged the administrative fee. Thus far your bill is $ 350 and if paid within fifteen (15) days of this notice no further costs will be incurred by you. Please make check payable to F.P.S.I. and please include the File # 554 201 17 00 on the check. If you have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1(158. Sincerelh, Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/ 19/06 18 189 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowing quantity sub total A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7.500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel. sized 7.501 to 15.000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel. sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel. sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. per square foot over one acre $00.02 sq. ft. I land Labor A. per square foot of area abated $0.10 sq. Ft. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 13. move -on fee $150.00 Debris Remediation (includes chipping. grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to ch. g. and or compacting $38.00 x cu.yds = 13. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) Oo,. Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of oti A. per parcel $350.00 1 $350.00 Attorney Services A. per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports. attending hearings. etc.) A. cost confirmation fee, per parcel $200.00 $275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee $50.0() 13. abatement lien $50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D. release of abatement lien $50.00 E. public notary $20.00 F. file duplication fee $50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour $50.00 I I. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 71 P APN # 554-201-17 TOTAL S 350.00 19 190 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net Final Bill 8/28/2020 Samaniego Samuel R 4122 Sycamore Dr San Diego, CA 92105 Ref: Parcel # 554 201 17 00 Dear Samaniego Samuel R, cop'y This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 7/24/2020 and we have not received payment in the amount of $350.00 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will be required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include filing an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this hill to our collection agency. Under state and local law, costs for such action will he added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services, Inc., and include the Parcel # 554 201 17 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely, Fire Prevention Services, Inc. rev.05/ 19/06 20 191 of 592 X RECORDING REQUESTED BY Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 fax (619) 445-6336 AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO Fire Prevention Services. Inc. PO Box 1720 II Cajon. CA 92022-1720 DOC# 2020-0612566 11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 Oct 09, 2020 11:31 AM OFFICIAL RECORDS Ernest J. Dronenburg, Jr., SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES: $0.00 (SB2 Atkins $0 00) PAGES. 1 NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY WHEREAS it was determined that a violation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist. and WHEREAS such violation was ordered abated on . and WHEREAS representatives of the National City Fire Department abated the violation(s) on 722/2020, and WHEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to S420.00; THEREFORE: be it known that an abatement obligation exists on the property regardless of owner until paid. The current owner of the property is Samaniego Samuel R at 4 122 Sycamore Dr. San Diego. CA 92105 described as follows: APN#5542011700 ADDRESS: 2325 Melrose St I.[GAI. DESCRIPTION: Lot 223 Tr 4370 This abatement obligation shall attach to the property, not the owner. and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the Califomia Revenue and Taxation Code Section 3712. Atter confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax bill. If not paid pursuant to State Law and State Tax Lien Law. the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. The amount of such claim shall be plus interest and other costs which may hereafter become due. This tiling does not preclude the filing of legal action for collection. Should such actions be required or determined to be appropriate, reasonable legal fees will be incurred and added to said obligation. DATED: September 30. 2020 BY: Ken1Dsborn. Fire Prevention Services, Inc.. Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Acknowledgement A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Diego On September 30. 2020 before me. R Thrasher. Notary Public. personally appeared Ken Osborn_ who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/hcr/their authorized capacity(ies). and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s). or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted. executed the instrument. 1 certify. under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. R. THRASHER oommiwon No. 2332281 > ti L NOTARY PUBLIC - CAUFORNIA UN DIEGOCOUNTY �101^'�0^ Fries Mpg 242024 (Seal) 21 192 of 592 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 5 57-3 80-62-00 11/16/20 Received citizen complaint. 11/16/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/17/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 01/04/21 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 01/04/21 Posted property. 01/05/21 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 01 / 16/21 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 01/19/21 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 01/25/21 Received signed certified return receipt. 01/26/21 Work order authorization signed by District Official. 02/25/21 F.P.S.I. crews abated the property. 02/25/21 The owner was mailed a bill at the contracted rates. 03/17/21 The owner was mailed a final bill. 03/31/21 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 22 193 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City BIsd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Nilcdonalds Corp Address: Po Box 182571 Columbus. 011 43218 Parcel Number: 557 380 62 00 Date: 11/17/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: Plaza Blvd Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all Needs. dead vegetation, trash. dehris and aril ndo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must he rem %ed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches %ear round)(This includes along sidewalks and allevs)Please remove all tree branches that exist within 6 feet from the ground. 1 ou are hereby directed ill ;Mate the public nuisance described ahove. of which you are the occupant or owner ss ithin thirty (311) dry)s of 1 I/1'/211211 •'1 inn failure to comply v%nh this order %%ill result in the C ay haying your proper() cleaned by the Cit 's contractor at v'nur expense (per National City \lunrcrpal Code ( hapter 13h) A '6351) 0(1 administrative lee a 111 he charged in addition to the contractor's Zees to clean the property (per Resolution nunlbet t)-1-1)71. \ iolations ale also sublrel t(• prosecution as misdemeanors Guidelines For the .\hatcmcnt of Flammable \ e_eladon For the plolection of Iile and property. remote all bride. flammable vegetation. or eulnhusuhlc eru\vth'ihleL is located Ifttil thirty 131 1 feet to vile hundred 11(101 lea Mon such a building of structure or to the property line. t\hlchcver is neaier, or as required hs the Fire Depanntenl. including the maintenance of grass and other %egelation more than thrrty 1311) from such budding ew structure (ulpngs are to he removed from the properly and disposed ill properly Vegetation is to he cut i%rthin two (2) inches of the ground "NO I R L It1.G \RI)I\G RARE. I IIICI..\ 11•.'\I1) ()It Psi/ -\\(;LRI ) SI'I.( IFS" If you have previously rccened a nonce from the Calitirrnta Department of Fish and Cianle or the t S f nsh and WilJlile Seri, ices that rare, threatened of endangered species of fish or tvildlile hate occurred on your property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance. YO( \1l S 1 NOTIFY [301-I1 NUFNCII-S AND (Fly NA.I IONA!. C 111 I 1121 1)EPARTM1N1 INNRII ING Al LEAST FLN 110) 1)A15 PRIOR 1O 13EUINNINCi VEGEIAI ION C'LF.\RING Il I11ESI ACIFNCIES P \11 1(11)1311 t. I OR'1IIff1 YO11 OF ANY .AI.ILRNAIIVE PROCLDURIiS WI rlIIN 111051 FEN t10) I)AYS. YOU MAY [111 5 PRO('G11) rO CI I AR VL(i[IAlION \S f)IRI ( III) It\ 11'Is NI +TIC 1. I auhr e to provide notification to these agencies may render you Kahle under Federal or State last to penalties. National ('it) %luuicjpal C'ode9.12.11111 Public \institute Declared --In Genera An) of the lirlluyt mg conditions are herd)) declined to constitute a public nmsanCe. When the Dire Chief or his/her designee determines than there cvsis u1 any building or 011 any premises eomhusiihle Inzartons or e\pioslve nlaerials o1 da,1!ct0)1 accumulations of rubbish or unnceessar\ accumulations of \vaslepaper. boxes. sha% jngs. or any highly (laminable materials tt hich are so sduateJ as to endani er life or property or Bids obstructions to or on lire escapes. ,lairs, passageways. dixirs or ytnldtlws that reasonably tend to Interfere w1111 the operations of the lire deparnneni or the egress ttl the occupants of such building of premises. or !Inds that the ellectiverress of any exit Js:or, attic separation or any lire separation all Is reduced. or finds That ant provision ill the I lndorm lire ( ode is being violated l3 When the Fire Chief or hisiher designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stove, oven. incinerator, furnace or other heating det lee. elcetne fixture rn am appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a national!) recounved standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specil icatly mentioned In the 1 ndoni1 Fire Code, lobe defective or unsale so as to create a hazard C. Wlren the Fire Chief or hi:/her designee finds any condition oliieh 111 his/her)udgrnent increases or may cause an increase id the bawd or menace nl tire to I greater degree that custonlard) recognized as norplal by persons in the public service regularly engaged 111 preventing. soppressalg or C\ungulshm;_ lire or any Mint or ail which may obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of occupants in the et enl of lire National (it,. IuniciLal ( ode 9.12.11211 Public Nuisance Declared -Al reds and Other Flammable 4lateria is \II heeds. groiung or located upon streets. sidewalks or private property are hereby declared to he a public nuisance lot the purposes tit Ibis chapter. "%feeds" shall include the tollio mg A. Vvecds which hear seeds of a down) or w ingy nature 13. Sagebrush chaparral. and any tither brush or steeds which attain stwli large growth as to hecome. when dr).:1 lire menace to adjacent llnpru%CJ property C' N ceds which ire otherwise noxious or dangerous I) ['meson oak and poiso1 ivy ahem the conditions of grow ill are such as to constitute a menace the the public health Ors crass. stubble, brush litter. or other 'laminable nlalerr,ll %%Inch endangers the public salt) by creating a lire hazard Ina portion of the City trhjch has been zoned lor single and multiple residence purposes. National ('its \lunicipal Code 1.36.010 Public \uis:mice Defined "Public Nuisance" means am condition defined tit declared to he a public nuisance in tiny section of this cude..tnJlol anti coudiuu❑ caused maintained or pcmutleJ la v\is1 which Consululcs a Ihreal Io the public's health. salety and welfare or tshieh signitieantly obstruct;. i1t_lureS or uncrferc•s tvth the reasonahle i tree use of puoperty 1 a neighborhood community or to any considerable number of persons. A public nuisance also has the same meaning as 5el torah 111 t alitornia Cisil t ode Section 3-179 National ('it\ ' Iuuicipal (:ude 1.36.0611 Abatement— .\ppeal— I tearing Within ten (10) days from the date of posting. mailing or personal see\ ice of the required notice. the (yvner or person uecups ing or controlling such lot or premises allected Ilia) appeal to the C a\ Council Such appeal shall be in writing and shall he Bled tsnh tlrc ( [t\ Clerk If you should have an) questions. please feel tree Io call This number: 1-866-"9-377-1 Si owed tjenealguna prcgunta. per favor Ilatrie 0 numer is 1-1366-779-3774 5a a miming 6atanungan. tuna wag Zang pin sa numcrong no: I-86ft-719-37"4 .S, i erely yours in public gaiety. "You have the right to nppca,lr[s platter to the Coy Council \salmi tent 10) day s of the re-ecgn of th 1-866-779-3774 ext. 307 or http://lirepretention iiet 1 he appeal shall he in vtntine and Bled %vth the Coy Clerk (NCN1C 1 36 Oil)) ***):jr,. f're\eilijilil tiers hers In; is under i'ilrrrli-t with Ili.( et % rlt \;limmn:11 I.rI% NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? 1 Ye s HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? DO YOU UNDERSTAND TIE INSTRUCTIONS FOR ABATEMENT? Ye s HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTS TOABATE THE PROPERTY? Nam♦ Ye s CALL FIRE PREVENTION 1-866-779.3774 (CALL repreventio n.ret CALL FIRE PREVENTION FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net PROPERTY OWN E0.i ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MAINTAINING HAZARD ABATEMENT ON A YEAR ROUND BASIS. HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY READ THE ABATEMENT INSTRUCTIONS WOULD YOU UKETHE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? No 1 IF NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME ' SPEC>FIED TIE OWNER WILL BE CHARGED AS350.00 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE. PWS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Ye Ye IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND —Yes-i I INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://firepreventIon.net 144\N CALL FIRE PREVENTION WHE COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION, 1-866-779-3774 http://flreprevEntbn.ret CALL FIRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-866-779.3774 http://fireprevEntion.net IF ARRANGE ME NTS ARE MADE EMIR TO CRY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMNISTRATiVE FEE MAY BE WAIVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 9195Q-4596 24 195 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. Per square foot over one acre $ 00.02 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated $ 00.10 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 B. move -on fee $150.00 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorne Services A. per parcel, per hour 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee $ 50.00 B. abatement lien $ 50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D release of abatement lien $ 50.00 E. public notary $ 20.00 F. File duplication fee $ 50.00 G. Unscheduled Labor per man hour $ 50.00 H. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) 25 196 of 592 k 01704 205 of 592 (t , e " °s 4 (\J c) L() O N II j r CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 9195(1-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Mcdonalds Corp Address. Po I;ox 182571 Columbus. 011432 18 Parcel Number: 557 380 62 00 Date: 1/5/2021 PY Location of Public Nuisance: Plaza f3Iy d Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weeds. dead s ezetation,_ trash. debris and arundo. All Liles of dead vegetation and debris must he removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all 0rasses below 3 inches Near roundliThis includes along sidewalks and allevs)Please remove all tree branches that CNist ithin 6 feet from_theg•ound. You are hereby directed to abate the public nu tisanes: desenhed who e_ of s%hrch you arc the occupant or osvtcr ss i thin ten 1 III► days of 1/5/21121 **Your I:iiIIirc to comply with this order %sill result in sou hang charged the administrative tee and the Cut) haling your propem cleaned by the Clty's contractor at sour c\pcn.c slier National City Ahuncipal Code ( haptcr 1 .361 .\ $350 00 administrative tee will he charged tit addition to the contractor s fees to clean the pmperts, Ipci Resolution nwnhcl 04-071 Mutations arc ill subject to prosecution as nnsJc:nicanors Guidelines Fur '1 he .\batenicut of Flammable %cmelation For the protection al life and properrs. remove all brush, flammable segetation or combustible growth sshich is located from thins 1301 Beet a one hundred I In(u Icct lions such a building or structure or to the property lute. whicheser is nearer, or as lequued by the Fire Department. including the maintenance of grass and other scgclatron wore than thins (3(1) from such budding nr strut:uirc ( olhnrc are to he rentosed front the properly and disposed of propene Vegetation is to he Oil sunhat Mil 122) nunc�s tyl flu ground "NO 1t(.F: 141:(;.\Itl)1\(; R.\RF, IIIRF:.%1F.\I 1)Olt F\I) \(.FIREDSI'1•:( ILS" If you have preciously received a notice from the C'aliforneI Deparintun of fish and Game or the U.S fish and VVddlifc Seri ices that rare threatened in endangered spccus of fish or wildlilc have occurred on your propert) u1 the areas 'dentilied for fuel break clearance YO11 MUST NO1IFl 13U1'f l A(1LNCljis \ND 1111 NA fIDN 11 C I I 1 f IR1 1)1 PAR IA11 Ni IN VsIt1LING AI 1 LASI I EN (I(0 I)AYS PRIOR IO BEGINNING VI GUI ATION C'LE RINCr 11 1111 SI: -\(iLNC'll'S I \IL It) t)It,1I t. I tilt NO11l.l" YOU 01 :\NY :\I I1 RNA fIVI PROCI DURL' WIII IIN T11OSF FFN 110) DAYS. YOU \t1\Y fI ILN PRCA 111) I(1 C'l 1 .\R \ 1 GI I.\ II( rN \S I)IRI t rI 1) BY I I IIS NC1 fIC I failure to puivule notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or .State Iasi to penalties. National ( its 1Itrnicipal (tide 9.12.11111 Public Nuisance• Declared-1n General Any of the follow nti conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance: \ When the I in.: C hicl or his/Itcr dcsrei sec determines that there exists in any building or on an) premises combustible. hazardous or e\plos,ve malenats u1 dam_crons .accumulations of rubbish. or unnccc,sar) accumulations ol wastepaper, boxes, shavnigs. or am highly flammable materials tshts.11 are so situated as In a udan_ci life or properly. or finds obstructions lu ot on fire escapes. stairs, passagessays, doors or scindos+: that rcasonahly tend to interfere with the operations ot the lire department or the egress of the occupants of such building tit premises. or finds that the effectiveness of any exit door. ante separation or any fire separation wall is reduced • ar finds that any pros isuun of the lira fort Dire C title is heuns violated. 13. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee deems any chinnies . smokestack. stove. oven. incinerator furnace or other heating device. electric li'ture or arts appurtenance (hereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not speciticalts mentioned m thr I ndonn Fire Code. to he defects\ c or unsalc so as to create a (hazard C When the I ire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her Judgment increases or ntay cause :at mcreass unite hazard U1 menace ol lire to a greater degree than customurils lccognized as norm:(' bs persons in the public sen ucc regularly engaged m preventing. suppressing or extinguishing tire or rots th1u: ur 110 which Wray obstruct. delas. Innder or interline ss all the operations of the tire department or Ile egress of occupants in the cs ent or tire. Nntinn:(' (ih Municipal ('ode 9.12.1120 Public Nuisance Declared— \Needs and Other Flammable \lalcriats All weeds. goosing or located upon streets. sidewalks or private propem are hcrehs declared to he a public nulsanec for the purposes uf'this chapter "weeds" shall urslude the follow nug A \Needs which hear seeds nl a downs or wings nature 13 Sagebrush chaparral. and tins other brush or weeds sshich attain such large growth as to become. when Jn a lire menace to idiaeem improved properl (. W ccds which arc others% Ise noxious or dangerous. I) Poison oak and poison usy %%hen the conditions otgrowth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health 1 Dry grass- stubble. brush. litter. or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a lite hazard in a portion ol the C u' which has heen Tuned for single and multiple residence purposes National ( ifs \lunieipal Code 1.36.11111 Public Nuisance Defined "Puhllc Nuu>anec' utcans any condition deemed or tiecltireJ to he a public nuisance u. :my sceuou otitis% code. and/ur and condition caused. maintained or permuted toe u'l sshich eonsttluteS a threat to the public's health. safety and welfare or which signrlicantlx obstructs. injures or interferes with the reasonable of tree use ot properts u1 1 neI hhulhunJ eonimunity or to ails considerable number of persons A public nuisance also has the %ante meaning as set forth in Calitiimta is d Lode Section 34 79 National City NIunicipal ( ode 1.36.06(1 %ha lenient— 1ppcal— !tearing Within ten 411)1 days ('rum the dale of pasting. mailing or personal service of the required notice, the owner or person oceupymg or cnnlrulhng such lot or premises allvetcd may appeal to the Cif) Council Such appeal shall he in writing and shall be tiled s%rth the CO Clerk. If you should base any questions. please feel free lu call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si lisle(' Iiene:daun' preKmnta, par I'asur flame al numerre 1-866-779-3774 Sa anunuulp kalanungan, niacinag lane pn sa nunuerong itu: 1-066-779-31'+4 Sincerely yours 111 public. safely. **You have tlit right to appeal t111s mailer to the Ca) C'ounerl within ten (1111 days of the record tit tlus notice. I-866-779-3774 est. 3117 or hltp://lireprevenl.net The appeal shall he in writing and filed velth the ( fly C lerk (NC'M( 13h 11`)1 `**('ire I'reventis413Seryices. Inc. is under contract with the ('sty or National Cits Fire Prevention yiu Sen'1l't'\°�" ' 14.6t m c0Er ru U.S. Postal Service' CERTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT Domestic Mail Only For da((very information, visit our website at www.usps.com°. 0 ti ' l.US 1 Certified Mall Fee ;3 55 s Extra ervices & Fees (check box, add tea et Ac ate) ru ❑ Return Receipt (naMcop,l 5 • I= ❑ Saturn Pecalpl lele - $ 0 CI ❑ Certified Mall Res $1_I 00 I 1 o ❑ Ana signature R 557 380 OR,p(Q ❑ Adult Signature F Postage $ i 5J7 380 63 00 r- °^ Mc onalds Corp Ill Total Postage an $ �7pb ox 182571 Sent To Columbus pr N Street and Apt. N City State, ZIP+4+ 44 Ufa NC 01 '05/2021 OH 43218 215 of 592 P9 Form 3900, April 2015 PSN 76a0.e2.c e-s 47 See Reverse ler lestrtu SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION • Complete items 1, 2, and 3. • Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. 557 380 62 00 557 380 53 00 Mcdoriatds Corp Po Box 182571 Cc!urnt us CH Ntc v is 432'3 IIII I II III IIIII IIIIIIII III I IIIII IIIII I 9590 9402 6101 0125 9844 36 COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY A. Signature B. Rec ❑ Agent ❑ Addressee to of Delivery D, Is delivery address different from item 1? If YES, enter delivery address befo ■ VIE 3. Service Type o Adult Signature ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery ❑ Certified Mall® 0 Certified Mali Restricted Delivery ❑ Collect on Delivery 9 nnirio nu imr+or rr nr.f r fmm ce,,,rnn mean 0 Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery 0 Signature Confirmation'," 7019 2970 0002 0 7?IIetRstr tries -Meted every 0 Retum Receipt for Merchandise 215 95��3 �^216of592 vialt vlell Restricted Delivery PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic rteturn tiecelpt - • • - • 1,1 • 4 218 of 592 E69 Jo 61-Z •-"rari ection 220 of 592 {1_ r 1%,`It " + 'r -F.' IA '.. •,,,,` * -,,r 14,,,. ',',,— 4*' , ,,,, - . .,-1.- .'• 1 .0 -1.7--, - 7 * - 1. ., , ,-01......f_ .1. A. d . • 1 4 Lb *4 -,,,a, , ,,, , ...J4,,- 0,', Is.41 3,.. - I ' t'Illlit * t ‘4" •71„..p.74r ' cii , l'4 .f. ' , I 'g 4I. ,1i-,l 1111g • 1' 4..4t.' t 1• ' 1 .4I - I 14,1 4.aes.4, ii1,4.;,e., % 0. 4 4 (q3c4,1 , , „. ., %,l1 III e e i ''' '41r44 . i, .. kl ...,:_i-«•_ . ,. lt: ' Ci. ' "Lor74,1..."'. ..1. .4•11 b 1 4. , _.-;t"ts r,, ,..4. r.yi a II • orh.s x ‘ loc. ,,, 1 i't . --;;.'1•:•tir t 11.; .4t: '6:41.. it:. ''OA:i. • ; ' -; ' 4..... '1 " "h,,t" •t,,.. 0 rey I . ' -0 - '$ - • Str i - -** • 41. 'Y' . -4 ... ., - , - ,:*--'1' ,--.%'11-- .,' • , c- ' tiki ' - ik 1 • 1 ) • , .•'' '.‘ _ •-.1 ,.„ „,•fs" — a ' 1/16/21 Final Inspection . • • • 01"- 1 EC /16/21 Final Inspection 59 230 of 592 0 U a) s+71 cn • GIMP LL N AL. 1/16/21 Final] spection 62 233 of 592 (t , 'e " �'°4y� {` .-i ``/i e. r N O L() O o'hiCt,l4fe CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization # 7363 Owner: Mcdonalds Corp Address: Po Box 182571 Columbus, 0E1 43218 Parcel #557 380 62 00 Job location:Plaza Blvd Authorized by: Signature: Date: / 6- 2 WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: cu. yds. Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire property of all weeds. dead vegetation. trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year roundXThis includes along, sidewalks and allevslPlease remove all tree branches that exist within 6 feet from the ground. 72 243 of 592 06 ASSUMED FOR THE ACCURACY OF THE DATA SHOWN. ASSESSOR'S PARCELS THIS MAP WAS PREPARED FOR ASSESSMENT PURPOSES ONLY, NO LIABILITY IS MAY NOT COMPLY WITH LOCAL SUBDIVISION OR BUILDING ORDINANCES. I0 N Lam. S441.4 tANP Nw.COR.OF ,.E EL/2 CF st$ BO AC "rst 71 2 /%� LOT 2,bS . — 5T OF. .-1 r / CLSO. a, of D za F Cy 4 ro. 1 777 Fyn r_ IMF SAN DIEGO GOUNr ASSESSOR 5 MAP BOCK 557 PG 30 'a DETAIL 'A" 1" = 20' L 4y?'N ,'f 10) '7 ZZ yY AC LOT E .1 qr.; 1 t .3 TC\ w,. 5w LO�` NEd• OF E I/2 OF BOAC LOT 2 f- _ s NE CR1 OF CIO AC t LOT 2 7,. 7c✓' O 17 7, 17 cn Cn, MAP 166 - RHO. DE LA NAC ION - POP ROS 8845,9406,17515 rh 5} or 557-38 In IT, 100' 1111W20t0 ACR CHANGES BL"TO'_^ EJvI'•1CL17 )CO 32 S4 4al0 _ 59 *045 142e2'g 4 1 we ��..,_ 6. 5�5s47 14 of: i!.y86a1'moo _Au1i1:_6.7_ 97'l076 65 44-4.0 B7 2255 — a..,.4 T T ? — *pit 1Sf1, 2 a .Coe _,V2 _580 so 49ew Y398 51 rt,' 11 4878 fin QSEC 129 L• RC. 73 244 of 592 Hand Sq. Ft.: j r "1 q0 Dump ticket: 12e)wz. ; I,�I�Io Work space for diagrams and amount of work done Tractor 5q. Ft,: Total Removal Cu. Yds.: Dump Charge: 74 245 of 592 02/25/21 Be 247 of 592 1 I M • 4 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net COPY 2/25/2021 Mcdonalds Corp Po Box 182571 Columbus. OH 43218 Parcel # 557 380 62 00 Location: Plaza Blvd Dear Mcdonalds Corp. This letter is to inform you that the Public Nuisance on the above referenced property was abated pursuant to a prior Notice to Abate and order of the City of National City. Fire Prevention Services was contracted by the City of National City to help reduce Public Nuisances and potential fire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. The abatement work on your property was performed as mandated by The National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. The charges thus far total $494.00. You will incur no further costs if this amount is paid ithin fifteen (15) days of the date of this notice. Failure to pay this bill may result in the filing of an abatement lien upon your property. Please make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services and include the Parcel # 557 380 62 00 on the check. I f you have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely, Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/ 19/06 79 250 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowinu quantity sub total A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7.500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7.501 to 15,000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel. sized 15.001 square feet to 30.000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. per square foot over one acre $00.02 sq. it. Hand Labor .A. per square foot of area abated COPY $0.10 1.A40 sq. Ft. 144.00 Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 B. move -on fee $150.00 Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $38.00 x cu.yds = B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) A. per parcel $350.00 1 $350.00 Attorney Services A. per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A, cost confirmation fee. per parcel $200.00 $275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee $50.00 B. abatement lien $50.00 C'. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D. release of abatement lien $50.00 E. public notary $20.00 F. life duplication fee $50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour $50.00 I I. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 7363 APN # 557-380-62-00 TOTAL S 494.60 80 251 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net Final Bill 3/ 17/202 i Nlcdonalds Corp Po Box 182571 Columbus. OH 43118 Ref: Parcel T 557 380 62 00 Dear \icdonalds Corp. COPY This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 2/25/2621 and we have not received payment in the amount of S4,4.00 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will be required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include filing an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this bill to our collection agency. Under state and local law. costs for such action will be added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services, Inc., and include the Parcel 557 38$ 62 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-11158. Sincerel\. Fire Pre\ ention Services. Inc. rev.05 19 06 81 252 of 592 RECORDING REQUESTED BY Fire Prevention Serx ices. inc. PO Box 1720 E.1 Cajon. CA 92022-1720 (6191 562-1058 fax (619)4 -15-63 36 .AND Vs HEN RECORDED FLAIL TO Fire Pre\ ention Ser\ ices. Inc. PO Box I -20 Li Cajon. CA 92(122-1720 C�py NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY IIEREAS it N%as determined that a iolation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist. and \\ I I I-. RFI \S such . tolation .t as ordered abated on I i26i2021. and \1 I Il RI' \ti representau.es of the National City Fire Department abated the iolation(s) on 2 25i2021. and b4 HEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to S564.00; I HEREFORE be it known that an abatement obligation exists on the property regardless of o..ner until paid. The current ot.ner of the property is \lcDonalds Corp at Po Box 182571. Columbus. OH 43218 described as follows: \i'R a 557 380 62 00 \1)1IRFSS. Plaa H1.d l I.( \I. DT.SCRIP FION. Par I 1 r 12772 This abatement obligation shall attach to the property_ not the owner. and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the California Rrn enue and Taxation Code Section 3712..After confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax hill II not r,ud pursuant to State 1 a.. and State Tax Lien La... the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. 1-he amount of such claim shall he plus interest and other costs ..hich ma. hereafter become due. This tiling does not preclude the tiling of legal action for collection. Should such actiol be required or determined to he appropriate. reasonable legal fees .\ ill he incurred and added to said obligation D-\ FED' March 31.2021 BY: Ken Osborn. Fire Prevention Ser. ices. Inc.. Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Acknowledgement A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document St.;t.: olCulilomta C taint. of San Diem On March 31. 2021 before me. R Thrasher. Notan Public. personally appeared Ken Osborn..+ho pro%ed to me on the basis of satistacton c. fdcncc to be the person(s) whose name(s) isiare subscribed to the ..ithin instrument and ackno..ledged to me that he/she.they executed the same in his her their authorized capacity(ies). and that by hisheritheir signature(s) on the instrument the person(s). or the entity upon behalf of which th. person) st acted. executed the instrument. I Lettir\ under Pt '. 1L I Y r)1 PFR.II'R1 under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. 11,1f a rtic,7tz and (Alicia seal. - I R. THRASHER Commission No. 2332281 NOTARY PUBLIC - CALIFORNIA 71 SAN 01EGO COUNTY Canmisoco Faros Atytttd24, 2024 (Seal) 82 253 of 592. SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 557-380-63-00 11/16/20 Received citizen complaint. 11/16/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/17/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 01/04/21 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 01/04/21 Posted property. 01/05/21 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 01/16/21 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 01/19/21 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 01/25/21 Received signed certified return receipt. 01/26/21 Work order authorization signed by District Official. 02/25/21 F.P.S.I. crews abated the property. 02/25/21 The owner was mailed a bill at the contracted rates. 03/17/21 The owner was mailed a final bill. 03/31/21 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 83 254 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National Cite Bled.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Mcdonalds Corp Address: Po Box 182571 Columbus. OH 43218 Parcel Number: 557 380 63 00 Date: 11/17/2020 Cer"' Location of Public Nuisance: 2140 E Plaza Blvd Instructions for Abatement: J'lease clear the entire property of all weeds. dead vegetation, trash, debris and aru ndo. All Piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the Qroperty. (Please maintain anv and all grasses below 3 inches year round)(Thic, includes along sidewalks and alleys)(Please remove all tree branches that exist within 6 feet from the ground.) 1'ou are hereby directed to abate the public nuisance described above ul v%loch you arc the occupant or owner within thirty (31» days of 11 /171211_tl +•lour failure to comply with this order will result in the tin having your property cleaned by the City's contractor at vtur expense (per National City Municipal C'odc Chapter 1 36) A S350,00 administrative fee will he charged in addition to the contractor's Ices to clean the property (per Resolution number 94-971. Violations are also suhrcct to prosecution as misdemeanors l;uidclines For fhc Abatement of flamntahle egelation For the protection of life and properly remove all brush. !laminable %egctatlun. or combustible growth which is located Irons dirty 0111 leer to one hundred ( It)01 feel Iron' such a building or structure or to the property line whichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department. including the maintenance of grass and culler vegetation more than tinny (3(1) from such building or structure Cuttings are to he removed from the property and disposed of properly Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground. "NOTICE RI . %RI)I\G KAKF:. T I(KE \TENET) OR ENDANGERED SPE( 1F:S" If you have previously received a notice from the California Department of 1 ish and (,ante or the 1 S. fish and WiJlite tier\ ices that rare. threatened or eridai gored species of fish or %vildhle have occurred on your property tit the areas 'demilied for fuel break clearance. VOLI MUST \O"Ill1' 130111 ,\GLNC'II S \ND f1IF NA I IONAI ('111 (IRI 1)1 1'ARIMENU IN WRfIINCi A1' LEAST I1TI (10) DAYS PRIOR 1'O BEGINNING VI:GETATION C'1.1:ARINCi 11- 1'1II:Sl ACiENC'IES [AIL. TOOl3.11 C f 1)I1 N(t111 1 YtllI (1[ ANY 1I 11 RNATIVL PROCEDURES WITHIN FIIOSE TEN (10) DAYS. 1'OLI MAY T IIEN PIZOC'FliD f0 ( I.I.AR VliGETATION 1S DIRE(' El I) lit 11t1S NO I I( I. I allure to pro%ide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or Slate Law to penalties National ( it% \Iunicinal ( ode 9.12.0I0 Public Nuisance Declared --In General Any of the tolltu%ing conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nlnsance When the lire Chuel or his/her designee detemunes that there exists in any budding or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish, or linnecessar) accumulations of wastepaper, boxes, shavings, or any highly 'laminable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property: or finds obstructions to or on lire escapes. stairs. passageways. doors or willdw%s that reasonably tend to interfere v%ith the operations of the lire dcpartntcni or the egress of the occupants nt'such building of premises. ui finds That the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any tire separation wall is reduced. or Iinds that an% provision of the Uniform Fire Code is being violated R. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee deems any chimney. smokestack, stove, oven, incinerator. furnace or other heating de% Ice_ electric fixture or am appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the I inform Fire Code. to he detective or unsafe so as to create a hazard C' When the Fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which tin his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard ur menace of lire to greater degree that customarily recognized as'tonna! by persons m the public service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing tire or any thing or act which may obstruct delay. hinder or interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of occupants in the es cot of lire. National ( its Municipal ('ode 9.12.020 Public \uisancc Declared -A% eeds and Other Flammable 1I:aerials All weeds, grow Wig or located upon streets, side%%alks or private property are herchy declared to he a public nuisance for the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the lolhtw ing A. Weeds w hich hear seeds of a dowry or wingy nature [3 Sagebrush, chaparral. and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth 05 lit hcconie, when dr%_ a lire menace to adjacent nnproscd property, Weeds which are otherwise nmtous or dangerous. D Poison oak and prison ivy when the conditions of growth arc such as to constitute a menace the the public health E. Dry grass. stubble. brush. litter, or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a lire hazard in a portion of the City which has been zoned for single and multiple residence purposes National (it% llnnicii,al Code 1.36.010 Public Nuisance Defined "I'uhtic Nulsancc" Means any condition defined or declared to he a public nuisance in any section of this code, and/or and condnton caused, t ouutauncd or pemtitted lit exist which constitutes a (Neat to the public's health. safety and welfare or %Ohrch significantly ohstmcts. 'inures or interferes with the reasonable o1 tree use of propern in a neighborhood, community or to any considerable number of persons A public nuisance also has the same meaning as set firth in C tdilomoa Civil Code Section 347Q National ('its Municipal (:ode 1.36.11611 Abasement—.\Ltpeal— 1lcaring Within ten (101 days from the date of posting. mailing or personal set ice of the required notice_ the owner or person occupy mg or e ountllnlg such lot ur premises allccted may appeal to the City Council Such appeal shall he nl writing and shall he tiled with the City Clerk If you should have any questions. please feel free 10 call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si usted tiencalguna preguuta. por favor Ilamc al numero: 1-866-779-3774 Sa anunuang Lalanungan. nnnasvag lang fro sa nuinerung ito: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in public safely ") ou have the right to appeal this matter to the 11ry Council within len (I(1) days ill the receipt or ths notice 1-866-779.3774 c I. 307 or hllp://lireprcvcrition.nct fhe appeal shall he in w•nriOand Tiled with the City Clerk (NCM( 136 050) ...Fire I'reventi,tn urn ire. Inv it under ,otnirart w nh the lint o1' National r'es 255.Of 592 NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Yes HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? DO YOU UNDERSTAND TEE INSTRUCTIONS FOR No-9 ABATEMENT? l Yes HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTSTO ABATE THE PROPERTY? No Yes CALL RRE PREVENTION 1-866-779-3774 htt p://fl reprevent io n. net CALL FIRE PREVENTION FOR' RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779.3774 http://fi reprevent ion. net PROPERTY OWNERS ARE RESPO N5IW [FOR MAINTAINING HAZARD ABATEMENT ON A YEAR ROUND MStS. HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY READ THE ABATEMENT INSTRUCTIONS WOULD YOU UKE THE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? If NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME SPECFIEDTIf OWNER WLL BE CHARGED A $350.00 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE. PLUS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Yes Yes Yes IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION. 1-866-779-3774 htt p://fl repreventbn. net CALL RRE PREVENTION WHEN COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-T79-3774 http://flreprevention.net CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-866-T79-3774 ht2p://fireprevention.net IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE pgK1BTO CRY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMNISTRATN E FEE MAY BE WAVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 9190-4596 85 256 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre E. Per square foot over one acre 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate B. move -on fee $250.00 $325.00 $400.00 $450.00 $ 00.02 $ 00.10 $150.00 $150.00 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee B. abatement lien C. Interest on lien (apr) D E. F. G. H. release of abatement lien public notary File duplication fee Unscheduled Labor per man hour unscheduled fees $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00 10% $ 50.00 $ 20.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00 (reimbursement of cost) 86 257 of 592 k 261 of 592 01704 266 of 592 (t , e " °s • .'"A . ! ' 'Ig. ,:;:, :kit I li, „mil • .441441. t It a '''... • 21 ', - .$ , ,, •:... _. ,,-..,_ Ai' j r ' , i : liri7it k r• V- rflAkAht 4 7.4 r • •. r CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO. ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Mcdonalds Corp Address: Po Box 182571 Columbus. Oil 43218 Parcel Number: 557 380 63 00 Date: 1/5/2021 Location of Public Nuisance: 2140 E Plaza Blvd instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weedsidead vegetation .trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dcad vegetation and debris must he removed from the proplert .(Please maintain anv and all grasses below 3 inches year round)(This includes along sidewalks and allevs)tPlcase remove all tree branches that exist within 6 feet from the ground.) You are hereby directed to abate the public nuisance described above. of which you are the occupant or owner within ten ( III) days of I/5/21121 "Your hulure to comply with this order is ill result in you being charged the administrative Ice and the Clty hasntg your propem cleaned bs the Co's contractor at sour expense Iper National City Munuctpal Code Chapter 1361 A S351 (10 adnunstratise lee will he charged in addition to the contractor's lees to clean the propem (per Resolution number 94-97) Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors Guidelines Fur fhe .Abatement of Flammable \'e_etation For he protection of life and property, remove all brush, flammable vegetation. or combustible growth it hich is located from thirty (30) feet to one hundred l In(i) Ice/ from such a building or structure or to the property line. %huchcset us nearer. or as required by the Fire Department. including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more than flinty l31)) from such building or structure Cuttings are to he removed from the property and disposed of properly Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground "NO 1ICE IIE(..1ltDI\G 1t%RE.'1IIRE:AI ENf:D Olt E\II.A\GERED SI'E( TES" If you have previously received n notice from the California Department of Fish .and Game or the U.S Fish and N ildlife Seines that rare threatened or endangered species of lish or wildlife base occurred on your property in the areas identified lint fuel break clearance- 1'OU Ml1S1 NOTI11 BOI I I .4(iLNCIES AND I IF NATIONAL C II 1" (lift DIP,\R'I'NEN I IN WRIT INC A f 1.1-AS I .1-EN t I I)1 DAYS PRIOR 10 BF(JNNIN(r VE(iETA HION CLEARING. If I I II:SE ACGI NCILS 1-AIL.10 013.11 1 1 1 1R NOTII Y Y011 Of ANY AI, IERNAIIVI PROCLDURLS \4't'IIIIN 1I1OSL ITN 11(1) DAYS. 'YOU MAY 1)Il1N PRI.X 1J l) it) C'LLAR VI G1 IATION AS DIRT (11 l) BY 1'1 ITS NO IC I failure to provide note licauon to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State I.aw to penalties National City 1luuicipal Code 9.12.11111 Public \uisance Declared —In General Any of the Billow mg conditions are hereby declared to constitute a puhhc nuisance - A. When the fire Chief or her/her designee determines that there exists tit any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish. or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. boxes. shavings. or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or propem: or finds obstructions to or on lire escapes. stairs. passageways. doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of the occupants of such building of premises. or finds that the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall rs reduced err finds that any pros rsron of the Lind -twig Fire Code is being violated. B. When the fire Chid or his/her designee deems any chimney. snutkcstaek. stove. own. incinerator. furnace or other heating device. electric fi\ture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premise; not specifically mentioned in Mc 1 nuurn, Fire Code. to he defective or unsafe so as to create a hazard C' When the Fire Chic' or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her Judgement increases or may cause an increase oI the hazard or menace of lire t.y greater degree that custontarils recognized as normal by persons in the public sen ice regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or e\tineuushine lire or any thing or do which may obstruct. delay, lutder or interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of occupants in the cyan of lire National City NIuniciUal ('ode 9.12.020 Public \uisance Declared—AAccds and (Other Flammable llaterials All weeds. growing or located upon streets- sidewalks or private propem are hereby declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the Reims -Mg A. Weeds which hear seeds of a downy or is may nature 13. Sagebrush. chaparral. and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become. %%hen dry. a tire menace to udlacent improved property C Weeds which are otherwise noxious or dangerous 1) Person oak and poison ivy when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health [ Dry grass. stubble. brush, litter. or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a tire hazard in a portion of the City which has been toned for single and Multiple residence purposes National City 1(urlll'ij1al (-ode 1.36.11111 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a public nuisance in any section of this code. and/or and condition caused. maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health, saltily and welfare or which sugnulicantly obstructs. injures or interferes with the reasonable of tree rise oI property in .1 netghhorhuut community or to any considerable number of persons A public nuisance also has the saute meaning as set forth in California C n d Code Section 3.171) %alional (ilv Iunicignl ('ode 1.36.116(I .lbatemcnt--.Appeal— !leering Within ten (11)) days liom the dale of posing!. mailing or personal ser ice of the required notice. the owner or person occupy ing or controlling such lot or prenuscs allcctcd may appeal to the City Council .Such appeal shall he in writing and shall he tiled with the City Clerk If you should have any questions, please feel tree to call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si usted tiencalguua prcgunta. por favor flame al numero: 1-866-779-3774 Se anu111a1I8 kalanungan, turnasyag Zang per sa tunnel —one ilo: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in public safety. **You has c the right to appeal this matter to the City Council within ten (10) day s of the receipt of Thus notice I-866-779-3774 ext. 307 or http:/(lireprevcnliout.net Ile appeal shall he in writing and Tiled with the City Clerk. (NCMC 136 iNil) "'Fire Preventrie4Serices. Inc. is under contract soh the City ofNational C its Fire Prevention Seri ices*" 275.of 592 U.S. Postal Service" CERTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT Domestic Mail Only For delivery information, visit our website at www.usps.come. O u 1 ty51 It" L. Extra emces t: Fees (check bar, add fee of erfeffien:41 ❑ Return w Receipt therdp1$ $ ❑ Return Receipt (ere - - $ I I , I IfJ ❑ certified Mall Res $ 0. I I l j ❑ Adult Signature R. 557 380 06,04 ❑ Adutt Signature F Postage g.l) 7 380 63 00 Total Postage an Mcdonalds Corp $ $74°Box 182571 Sent To Columbus O!-i Sti=eetettdApt N 1.05_ . trlty, fate, Z1P+44 us?' NC O1 'O5/2O21 4.52 L 276 of 592 PS Forth 3800, April 2015 PSN 7530-1212-000-9047 See Reverse for Instructions SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. I • Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. 557 380 62 00 557 380 53 00 Mcdol:atds Corp Po Box 182571 Cc!urnuus Ot-! 432 NC NC IIIIIIIIIII IIIII IIIIIIIIIII 1111111111111 9590 9402 6101 0125 9844 36 9 Aetirla hit imhor lTronefor /mm 01.101,0 lahall A. Signature X ❑ Agent ❑ Addressee D. Is delivery address different from item 1? O= If YES, enter delivery addresspet 3. Service Type o Adult Signature 0 Adult Signature Restricted Delivery ❑ Certified Mall® 0 Certified Mall Restricted Delivery ❑ Collect on Delivery ❑ Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery 7019 2970 0002 0215 95Vi9 flail vied Restricted Delivery Delivery M it estricted De 0 Retum Receipt for Merchandise 0 Signature Confirmation"' r>ol 277 of 592 PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 DoRlesu nGwl n tleC.Ct{R CZ « 5 Tr. ",:y°•• - = :4•7 — m:07, - • Airios1 , _ diadlikar' r- 4 279 of 592 E69 Jo 08E ection 281 of 592 ..,..viow" • - - - At• • - - .=!•_1-- , • Yr r pir h. A,o ^ 144,'4.-•,-;`- =-..- -- 14114 t42,4 {1, to' r 1/16/21 Final Inspection_ . 7, - f•-• • , s-4,,a• 4 , I.. • 01"- 1 EC /16/21 Final Inspection 120 291 of 592 0 U a) s+71 cn N 1/16/21 Final] spection 123 294 of 592 (t , 'e " �'°4y� {` .-i ``/i e. r ,OM' A o'hiCt,l4fe CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization # 7364 Owner: Mcdonalds Corp Address: Po Box 182571 Columbus, OH 43218 Parcel #557 380 63 00 Job location:2140 E Plaza Blvd Authorized by: 7e° j Signature: Date: l z6-2% WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: cu. yds. Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round)(This includes along sidewalks and alleys)(Please remove all tree branches that exist within 6 feet from the ground.) 133 304 of 592 06 THIS MAP WAS PREPARED FOR ASSESSMENT PURPOSES ONLY. NO LIABILITY IS ASSUMED FOR THE ACCURACY OF THE DATA SHOWN. ASSESSOR'S PARCELS MAY NOT COMPLY WITH LOCAL SUBDIVISION OR BUILDING ORDINANCES. m � -O \ n13 c NW, COR. OF _ 80 2C 2 Of. ,1 Zt.Y 5,T op. + CLSO. KIO SAN DIEGO COUNTY ASSESSOR'S MAP BOOK 557 PG 38 P1 ta: 0 t .' DETAIL "A" 1"=20' 5 \'Ly - - of rb o �c m0 c7 Oq 4 .yP _P 1; ,`i.?'41�'P .P Gp 03, SW CO-R OF A\ NE0 OF E 1/2 OF % 80 AC LOT 2 2 Cp lll MAP 166 - RHO. DE LA NAC ION - POR. QSEC 129 ROS 8845,9406,17515 55 W LI OF NE0 OF NEQ grs N. E.EOR. OF 80 PC. 1 LOT 2 1 44, C 557-38 t1 11/19/2010 ACR CHANGES a10IOLD NEWI'PCUT 300 JY v_,84 sa P .59 iybs 141sagJl 1I sr M' �j 1 5.T ;0/4 ;sv�86. /fir f OA:4.587L1D'A 45 I64•48 87122.55 1 sM,..t 1 1 z s3 MEf1 CIL-02 21J580 S7 L9{40 Z �13f� 51 sop 11 4678 eve, G. 134 305 of 592 Work space for diagrams and amount of work done . Hand Sq, Ft.: Tractor Sq. Ft,: Total Removal Cu. Yds.. , Dump ticket: Dump Charge: 136 306 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net 2/25/2021 Mcdonalds Corp Po Box 182571 Columbus, OH 43218 Parcel # 557 380 63 00 Location: 2140 E Plaza Blvd Dear Mcdonalds Corp, This letter is to inform you that the Public Nuisance on the above referenced property was abated pursuant to a prior Notice to Abate and order of the City of National City. Fire Prevention Services was contracted by the City ofNational City to help reduce Public Nuisances and potential fire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. The abatement work on your property was performed as mandated by The National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. The charges thus far total $410.00. You will incur no further costs if this amount is paid within fifteen (15) days of the date of this notice. Failure to pay this bill may result in the filing of an abatement lien upon your property. Please make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services and include the Parcel # 557 380 63 00 on the check. If you have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely, Fire Prevention Services, Inc. rev.05/19/06 136 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowing quantity sub total A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15.000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15.001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. per square foot over one acre $00.02 sq. ft. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated $0.10 600 sq. Ft. 60.00 Dozer Operation A. hourly rate B. move -on fee Copy $150.00 $150.00 Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $38.00 X cu.yds = B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) A. per parcel $350.00 1 $350.00 Attorney Services A. per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. cost confirmation fee, per parcel $200.00 $275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee $50.00 B. abatement lien $50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D. release of abatement lien $50.00 E. public notary $20.00 F. file duplication fee $50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour $50.00 H. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 7364 APN # 557-380-63-00 TOTAL $ 410.00 137 308 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net Final Bill 3/11/2021 Mcdonalds Corp Po Box 182571 Columbus, OH 43218 Ref: Parcel # 557 380 63 00 Dear Mcdonalds Corp.. COPY This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 2/25/2021 and we have not received payment in the amount of $410.00 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will be required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include filing an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this bill to our collection agency. Under state and local law, costs for such action will be added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services, Inc., and include the Parcel # 557 380 63 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely. Fire Prevention Services, Inc. re%.05. IA 06 138 309 of 592 RECORDING REQUESTED BY Fire Prevention Services. Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon. CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 fax (619) 445-6336 AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO I r Pre., ention Services. Inc. I" Bnx 1720 El Cajon. CA 92022-1720 COPY NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY 11 HEREAS it was determined that a violation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist, and %%l lrRE:AS such +iolation was ordered abated on 1/26/2021, and WHEREAS -\S representatives of the National City Fire Department abated the violations) on 2/25/2021. and WHEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to 5480.00: 111E12EPORE be it known that an abatement obligation exists on the property regardless of owner until paid. The current owner nt the nroperi) is McDonalds Corp at Po Box 182571, Columbus. OH 43218 described as follows: \TN, = 55,7 380 63 00 1l)1)RF ::S_ 2140 F Plaza Bl' d .ki'tl 1)kSC'R1P'1-if)ti. Part Tr 12772 1 his abatement obligation shall attach to the property_ not the owner. and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the California R ;.5 cn:,e and taxation Code Section 3712. After confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax hill. lino; ud pursuant to `late La++ and State Tax Lien Law. the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. The amount of such claim shall he rh - and othei hick may hereafter become due. This filing does not preclude the filing of legal action for collection. Should such a. t: he required or determined to be appropriate. reasonable legal fees will be incurred and added to said obligation. ll-\TF11] '+lath ;1. 2021 BY; Ken Osborn. Fire Prevention Services, Inc.. Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Aclmowledgement A rotary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness. accuracy, or validity of that document. -ate California (. otntt+ of San Dieso On March 31. 2021 before me. R Thrasher. Notar Public. personally appeared Ken Osborn. who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory to he the person(s) whose namets) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same i„ his 'her their authorized capacitylies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s). or the entity upon behalf of which per:on!si acted. executed the instrument_ _riit+ Antler OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. W1p1::SS hand and official seal, Commission No. 2332281 4 NOTARY PUBUC - CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO COUNTY Commission Ex Augu st ust 24, 2024 R. THRASHER (Seal) 139 310 of 592 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 558-220-35-00 07/29/20 Received citizen complaint. 07/29/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 08/05/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 09/08/20 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 09/08/20 Posted property. 09/09/20 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail, 09/17/20 Received signed certified return receipt. 09/21/20 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 09/23/20 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 09/29/20 Work order authorization signed by District Official. 10/08/20 F.P.S.I. crews abated the property. 10/19/20 The owner was mailed a bill at the contracted rates. 11 / 10/20 The owner was mailed a final bill. 11 /25/20 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 140 311 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY. C.A. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Brown Clara M Address: 10037 Dunbar I .n El Cajon, CA 92021 Parcel Number: 558 220 35 0(1 Date: 8/5/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: 3040 E 16th St Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead legetation. trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the Property. (('lease maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round)(This includes along sidewalks and alleys) l'ou are hereby directed to abate the public i n s:ince described ,bo%c or -which you ;tic the u..upant or u+uicr. within thirty (301 days of 8/S/21120. •'four failure to comply with this order vs ill result in the( it% haw lug your prnpert% cleaned by the l It) 's contractot at soil• expense tper National City `.luntcipal Code Chapter 1.3(i) A $350.00 administrative tee will he charged in ,duton to the contractor's lees to clean the puoperit mei Resolution number 94-47) Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors Guidelines Fur I he \bowmen( or Flanrmalik \ meratinu For the protection of life and property. Icniove all Mush. Il:uuntable sego:uonn. or cumhusublc gr.mmill wnr, h is located from shirty (30) feet to one hundred (1001 feet from such a building or structure or to the property line. whichever is nearer or :Is required by the 1 ilia Department including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more Man thirty (30) from such hulling or structure ('utiligs arc to be wino%ed from the property and disposed of groped\ Vegetation its to he cut within two (21 inches of the ground "•\O11(F IUL(. 1RI)1\(. It Ott . I II1ti v 11• \1•:I) Olt t \I) 1\(.1.12F:I) til'1• . IFS" If you have previously received a ounce IIuui the Califorma Ucpartnlenr of I ish and Game or the l l S l ish and V,'Jhle Services that rare. threatened or endangered species of fish or wildlife have occurred on you; property in the areas identified for rtiel break clearance 1'Ut' Mt'S 1 NO I II l 13O'rl l A(,I N(•(ES AND THE NA (ZONAL. CrIY FIRi- DEI'ARTMENT IN WRITING A f 1.1 A I I EN t I()) DAIS PRIOR I t )13F ((INNING VI (il' IA II( IN C'1 1 .1RIN(I. It 1111 SI: \(il:RCILS FAIL TO OBJECT OR N()ZIFY YOU OF ANY ALTERNATIVE PROCI 1)1 RI-S WI CIIIN 1110S1- I1 ti • 10) DAYS. 'YOI M 11' I I IFN I'ROt. I III) Ise Cl.F_Al( VLCiL IA 1 ION .\S DIRECTED B1' ltllti Nan( t:. Failure to provide notification to these ageneles may render you liable under Fedcial or State I aw to penalties Naliuual (•if% Municipal C ode 9.12.11(1 Public \(malice l)crlured--In Ccncral Any oldie following conditions ate herchs declar, d to ((institute .t public nuisance A. When the Fire Chiefor his/her designee determines that there exist., In tin\ building or on an\ insetusc, .umhustihle. hazardous of explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish: or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper haxes sha ings, or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property: or finds obstructions to or on tire escapes. stairs passageways doors or windows thin leastaurhlt tend to interfere nith the operations ol'the tire department or the egress ofthc occupants of such budding n1 premises; or finds Mai the effectiveness ul any exit door, attic scpa.,nnai or an+ lire separation wall is reduced, or finds that an: provision of the Uniform Fire Code is heing violated N. When the Fire CInd01 hisrher designee deems any :hlnme+. smokestack. stove oven, im,:niclalur Iuroave t r other heating des ice. electric future or any appurtenance thereto, or anything regulated under a natiunalll recognized .:tamlard In or upon :my budding structure or premi•.es not specifically mentioned in the Unifi rr, Fire Code, to he defective or unsafe so as to create ,I hazard C . When the Fire Chief or Itisiher designee finds :my cr•ndtf um ohidh u1 lus'hcr nitlgnrent in, „r m.:+ ::;,tne an ,nerease of the hazard to Menace of lire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the public service iegularl+ rni:i :d il1 presenting. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or ::c; which may obstruct. delay. butler ig interfere 11 ill ;tic operations fit the lice department t i the e?re s : 1 ._ i iiiis m the event of lire "+'a:iuual ( i! Municipal ( title 9.12.1120 Public \uisam. 1)ecl retl O_ etas am: tat her Flamm:114 1laterials \(I weeds. growing or located Upon streets s.ucwalks or pi vale pn,peri :tie heah\ declared kb. t rim once 1 of the purposes ,•f Mrs chapter. "weeds" shall include the following. A. Weeds svhich hear seeds ()la di or w met mom; 13. Sagebrush. chaparral. and an) :ah;r Mush or Iweils yyhich atan1 such large grov, I1. a, r.. ouie. Alen di s alit. inemice to adtaccnl improved property. C. Weeds which are otherwise noxious rr dancer„its D. Poison oak and poison ivy when the condition, of growth are such ati to CoIr5tivac .1 cu icy the tlw public health Dry grass, stubble. brush. litter or other flammable 0 llcrra' ahieh endangers Ha: nuhh. •nr. n t•s ;r.atiug 1 lire hazard in a portion ol'the City yvhich has been coned fir single and multiple :c,.dcncc pry-;,os.s National ('pis 1luuicipal ( ride 1.36.11111 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he .t public nuisance 11 ;tin set:Iiou of this .+,Je ❑ndl+,r and cnnduion caused, maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health. safety and welfare or which Nigntlioantlr uhsuuets nllwcs or u1tcrlcres with the reasonable of free use of property in a neighborhood. community or to any considci hIe nunihei of persons A public nuisance also has Ilse s:vmc meaning as set 1onli in California Civil Code Section 3479. National l its \lunicipal (ode 1.3(1.11611 .\halenlent— \vocal— Ilcariou Within ten (I()) days from the dale of posting. mailing ur personal service or the required none, the u\+ncr oI persur, ,occupying or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City Council. Such appeal shall be in writing and shall he tiled with the ( it) 1 telt If you should have any questions. please feel fret. In call this number: 1-N66-779-377.1 Si usted tiencalguna pregunia, our litsur Iltime al uumeru: I-Wm-779- 3'71 So airumallg katanunj;nn. I1n11aseag long pry sa nunn•rung use: 1-866-779-37”4 Sincerely yours in public safety. "l ou has e the right to appeal h+s matter to the (-in ( ounal within ten 110) day s or the receipt of thi I-866-779-3774 est.307 or hltp:.tircprewrnliun.ncl rite appeal shall he in writing and tiled w oh the ('ay Clerk. (NC.VIC 1. +6.050) "sr rn• Vrr, 'norm Serf ire. inn ,. nndrr r.,nrrnrl yid!! Ihr ( its of Nah,ncd t'iI4 312 of 592 NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Yes HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR ABATEMENT? Yes HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTS TO ABATE THE PROPERTY? No--� Yes GALL FIRE PREVENTION 1-866-779.3774 h tt p: // fir ep reven t io n. ne t CALL FIRE PREVENTION FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-366-779.3774 http://fireprevention.net PROPERTY OWNERS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR NIAIRffAIN4 NG HAZARD ABATEMENT ONA YEAR ROUND BASIS. HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY READ THEABATEMENT INSTRUCTIONS No WOULD YOU UKE THE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? NIo IF NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME SPECIFIED THE OWNER WILL BE CHARGED A 5350.00 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE, PLUS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Yes •Ye s IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND —Yes--N INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fi reprevention.rRt CALL FIRE PREVENTION WHEN COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779.3774 http://Rrepreventbn.net CALL FRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-866-779-3774 h ttp://fi reprevent ion. ret IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MACE EBI(38 Tp CRY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADA4NISTRATNE FEE MAY BE WAIVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 91950-4596 142 313 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowing, A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. Per square foot over one acre $ 00.02 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated $ 00.10 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 B. move -on fee $150.00 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee $ 50.00 B. abatement lien $ 50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D release of abatement lien $ 50.00 E. public notary $ 20.00 F. File duplication fee $ 50.00 G. Unscheduled Labor per man hour $ 50.00 H. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) 143 314 of 592 NOTICE TO ABATE FUBLC NUISANCE I 09/08/20 Re -Inspection 316 of 592 !i i • ]4 s 09/08/20 Re -Inspection 320 of 592 09/08/20 Re -Inspection 150 321 of 592 19 08 20 Re- ns • in CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE 'DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Brown Clara A9 Address: 10037 Dunbar Ln El Cajon. CA 9202 I Parcel Number: 558 220 35 00 Date: 9/9/21120 Location of Public Nuisance: 3040 E 16ili St Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire proper(\ of all Axeeds. dead egetation. trash. debris and ant ndo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must he removed from the proper(. jPlease maintain anv and all grasses below 3 inches \ear round)(This includes along sidewalks and alle\si You arc hereby directed to ahaie the public nu, ;lni.e described above. of which you are the occupant or owner vt ithin ten (1(1) days of 9/9/211211 '• Your failure to comply with this order will result in you being charged the admimstratitc lee and the City having your property cleaned by the C tty's contractor at sour expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 136) A %350 tin admunn.Iraute fee will he charged in addition to the contractor's lees to clean the property (per Resolution number 94-97). Violations are also subject tot prosecution as misdemeanors Guidelines For the Abatement of Flammable \ reetatiurt For the protection of Ile and property reuwte all brush. tlanun,thle tegetatiun or combustible growth wItch is located from than 1301 feet to one hundred (10(1) lees from such a building or structure or to the property line. \thicIi er is nearer, or as rcqurred by the 1 I)ep.rrtmenl. including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more than thirty 130) from such building or structure ( manes :ire to he removed from the property and disposed ol properly Vegetation is to he cut within two 121 inches of the ground. "NO El( E. Rt.(:.AIMING RARE. 11IRE.% I LNt.11 OR END %\(,I• RED SI'f.('II:s" If you have previously received a notice from the C ahloniia l)epaitrncnt of fish and Game or the 1 s I ish and Wildlife Senrees that rare threatened or endangered species of fish or wildlife have occurred on your property in the arras idenulied for Wel break clearance NO( All yrt NO II Y RO 111 AGENCIES AND THE NATIONAI CI 1 Y FIRE DEPARTMENT IN WRI'1 (NO AI 1 EAS 1 RN (101 DAYS PRIOR 10 131-GINNING VI l'cI-I Cf1ON . I !AILING IF THESE AGENCIES FAIL TO OBJECT OR NOTIFY YOU OF ANY Al TERNA FIVE PRO(.I DI'RI'S 1Afl (IIN 1 IIOSE TEN 11(1) DAYS YO1 M \1 I I ILN PROCEED fO CHAR VEGETATION AS DIRECTED I3Y TIIIS NOTICE. Failure to pnividc notification to these agencies may render you Kahle under I edcral or Slue I im to penalties \atiunal ( its %1unicij uI ( odr 9.12.11111 Public Nuisance Declared —In General Any of the following conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance A. When the 1 ire Chief or Iusrher designee deteunutes that there exists in any building or on any lucnuses combustible haiarduus or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish. or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper, boxes shavings. or ,any highly !laminable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or properly, or finds obstructions to or on lire escapes suers passageways. doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of the occupants of such building of prcmues or finds that the effectiveness oil any esn door. attic separation on any lire separation wall is reduced; on linds that any provision of the Uniform Fire Code is being 'Mated B When the I ire Chief or his/her designee deems am chimney. smokestack. stole. oven. incinerator furnace or other heating device. electric fixture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a national!) recognized standard in or upon aitt huddi ns structure or premises out specifically mentioned in the I niliirrin Fire Code. to he defective or unsafe so as to creme a heard C' When the Fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his her judgment mcre;tse:s or man cause an me ease of the hazard or menace of lire to a greater degree that customarily rccognricd as normal In persons in the public se.nice regularly engaged in preventing suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which may obstruct. delay, hinder or interfere with the operations of the lire depanment or the egress of occupants in the event of lire Naliumd ('its Municipal ('ode 9.12.11211 Public Nuisance Declared —AA eeds and Other I lanuuahle Nlalerials All weeds. growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or pro :tie progeny are hereby declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of tits chapter, "weeds" shall include the following' A N'ecds which hear seeds nt'a downy or tuna\ uuuu.i li Sagebrush. chaparral and any other brush err weeds vthtch attain such large growth as to heennre \then do a fire menace to adjacent improved proper C' Weeds which arc otherwise noxious or dangerous 1) Poison oak and poison is v when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health Dry grass. stubble. brush. litter or other flammable material which endangers the public safety M creating a lire hazard in a portion ol'the City which has hcen toned lot single and multiple residence purposes National ( its/ ►Iunicipal ( ode 1.36.11111 Public ♦insulin- Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a public nuisance in any section of nits -ode ,ouForand condition caused, mamtumed or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health safety and vveflaic or ssluch significantly obstructs intones err interferr:s with the reasonable of free use of property in a neighborhood. community or to any considerable number ol persons \ public nuisance also has the same meaning as set forth in C ahtiirma Civil Code Section 3479 National ('il\ %luuici(al ('ode 1.36.11611 Abatement— Anneal— hearing Within ten (10) days From the dine ol posting. mailing or personal serf ice of the required notice the owuci or person occupy rig or controlling_ such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City Council Such appeal shall he in writing and shall he tiled vy ith the City Clerk If you should have any questions. please feel tree to call This number: 1.X0s-779-3774 Si tided Iiencalguna pre;unla. pour favor Marto• a1 omen': 14366-779.3774 tic anunnang kalanunISan. tumuwag hang pa sa mrnteroog ilu: I-1466_'79•3774 Sincerely yours in public safety. • • l ou hay c the right to appeal this matter to the C rt. C ironed vs/ ilhn ten 1101 days of the receipt of this notice 1-866-779-3774 ext.31)7, err http://lirepre'.ention.net the appeal shall he in writingaud tiled with the( its l lent. INCMC 1.36.(15o) ""Fire PrevenlAi&?cn ices_ Inc is under contract with the l ntx of National ( it Fire Prevention Services'"" 09/21/20 Final Inspection 153 ter. a 1r 40'- E�q __11, {4+ i y 'I Tl. �I 1 F ii . ., ' q -,t+.'��' , '"-TPA a 324 of 592 09/21/20Final Inspection 325 of 592 09/21/20 Final Inspection 326 of 592 Final Inspec 09/21/20 Fina L rto �a a- ..a r'- U.S. Postal Service'" CERTIFIE ' MAIL® RECEIPT Domestic Mail On y Far deliver informa ion. visit our website at www.us. .com'". Lit/JrLit/Jr IVAI9 11 R, 1C,eruiiec Mali Fee . j `_, e in tra ery on : Fees /doekbox. add M ❑ Reum Recalat O.sraw0Y1 S r ,. • fL 0 Reacn Raoelot talecvonlal $ ¶ li f . f 1 �n Postmark CI ❑ Codified Mao RastAli t l i l tcied Delivery S , are D 0 Adult Signature Required $ a':'::— Co Z, n'; Cl❑ Adult Signature ReeMeted Delivery S Z>r Postage N $ IT' Total Postage ru a- 0 N S Sent To street andAp: city. State. 2i PS Form 3e e58 220 35 00 Brown Clara M 10037 Dunbar Ln El Cajon 160 CA NC 331 of 592 SEN COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY • Complete items 1, 2, and 3. • Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can•return the card to you. • Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 1 558 220 35 00 Brown Clara M 10037 Dunbar Ln El Cajon CA NC 92021 III'll111I'll111111IIIIIIIIIIllIl II IIII 9590 9402 5628 9308 7910 40 A. Signature X B. Received by (Printed Name) ❑ Agent ❑ Addressee C. Date of Delivery D. Is delivery address different from item 1? ❑ Yes If YES, enter,clglivocv..addrpl,below: ❑ No SEP 17 201n 3. Service Type ❑ Adult Signature ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery ❑ Certified Mali® ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery ❑ Collect on Delivery 2. n.ririo n r.•he . rr y ..r , r...... _ .; _ _ n n r„aa,.r ,... "slivery Restricted Delivery 7019 2970 0002 0215 7169 Restricted Delivery T tover3Dt70)- 0 Priority Mail Express® ❑ Registered MaliTM ❑ Registered Mail Restricted Delivery ❑ Retum Receipt for Merchandise ❑ Signature Confirmation,. E Slonatum Contirmatiop 332 of 592 PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization t 7268 Owner: Brown Clara M Address: 10037 Dunbar l.n El Cajon, CA 92021 Parcel #558 220 35 00 Job location:3040 E 16th St Authorized by: Signature: R dew Date: / -29-2°Z0 WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: Tractor Mowing: _ sq. ft. Discing: cu. yds. sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire pro pert• or all weeds, dead vegetation. trash. debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. kPlease maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round)(1.his includes along sidewalks and alleys) 162 333 of 592 06 558-22 0 N h ISAN DIE® ITV ASSESSOR S YAP BDo11 9S8 PAGE 22 s W y HARBISON COAL A. uc I ST ALLEGHANY ST 3% 3o/L 3o/y 3e/6 3e& Soy 13/OZ /3o iz ., ®3//0:3 1 O AOa- > :. 34 v� O 77 �� l'g yZ * 217 218 219 1 220 i 221 L 224 I 225 i ? 33 O YS r X (7 2 ``3Z: Ne 220 ! % a aYc I /G yZ 17Li iS7661/13 ap s A. R �J 234 bk 30if, 232 6. of 44 21 AC 3� 230 0, 229 ASS MAP II4FD1FOR PREPARED IIJ ACCURACY OFSTHE RATA SI4OKN S ASSYFSSOR S PA RCA IS S MAY NOT COIof'LY WITH LOCAL SUBDIVISION OR BUILDING ORDINANCES 227 7 5T BOLIVAR ST P oroMAc 37. 1-=1aa' 726/2008 SM ICHANC3ES 1. OLD * GJT 220 76134 :l �3 72-25 28 5 4i 44 73, 77 05 DD 5404 2159 3527 468 55J4 MAP 15648 - H & H TOWNHOMES MAP 1748 - LINCOLN ACRES ANNEX NO 2 ROS 17635 CANC 163 334 of 592 Hand Sq. Ft.: if4Eta Dump ticket; y E'5 Work pace for diagrams and amount of work done • Tractor 5q. Ft„ Dump Charge: _I ill. O ' P1/ 'i 37e 0? Fo 164• Total Removal Cu. Yds.: 5/• 8't 1 0/02/20 Before 165 336 of 592 10/02I20 Before 166 337 of 592 10/02/20 After 168 339 of 592 1 0/02/20 After 169 340 of 592 10/02/20 After 170 a 341 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. 1Oil 8/2020 Brown Clara Nl 10037 Dunbar t_n El Cajon. CA 92021 Parcel # 558 220 35 (10 Location: 3040 E 16th St Dear Brown Clara M, P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net CQpy This letter is to inform you that the Public Nuisance on the above referenced property was abated pursuant to a prior Notice to Abate and order of the City of National City. Fire Prevention Services was contracted by the City of National City_ to help reduce Public Nuisances and potential (ire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. The abatement work on your property was performed as mandated by The National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. The charges thus far total $3.182.00. You will incur no further costs if this amount is paid within fifteen (15) days of the date of this notice. Failure to pay this hill may result in the filing of an abatement lien upon your property. Please make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services and include the Parcel ## 558 220 35 00 on the check. If you have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1058. Sincereh. Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/I9/06 171 342 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mo«inu quantity sub total A. per parcel. sized I to 7.500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7.501 to 15.000 square feet $325.00 C'. per parcel. sized 15.001 square feet to 30.000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel. sized 30.001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. per square foot over one acre $00.02 sq. it. Hand l.ahor A. per square loot of area abated Dozer Operation A. hourly rate 13. move -on fee $0.10 8.450 sq. Ft. _845.00 $150.00 $150.00 Debris Rcmediation (includes chipping. grinding. and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping. and or compacting $38.00 X 51 cu.yds = 1.938.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 1 49.00 Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) A. per parcel $350.00 1 $350.00 Attorney Services A. per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports. attending hearings, etc.) A. cost confirmation fee. per parcel $200.00 $275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee $50.00 13. abatement lien $50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) [ 0% D. release of abatement lien $50.00 E. public notary $20.00 F. file duplication fee $50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour $50.00 I. unscheduled Zees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 7268 APN # 558-220-35-00 TOTAL S 3.182.00 172 343 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net Final Bill 11/10/2020 Brown Clara M 10037 Dunbar Ln El Cajon, CA 92021 Ref: Parcel # 558 220 35 00 Dear Brown Clara M. COp!y This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 10/19/2020 and we have not received payment in the amount of $3.182.00 Ilwe do not receive payment within 10 days we will be required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include filing an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this hill to our collection agency. Under state and local law, costs for such action will he added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services, Inc., and include the Parcel # 558 220 35 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-11158. Sincerely. Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/ 19/06 173 RECORDING REQUESTED BY i ire Prevention Services, Inc. P() Box 1720 1.1 (.'ajon, CA 92022-1720 ( 6 t y) 562-1058 fax (619) 445-6336 AM) WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO I ire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 Li Cajon, CA 92022-1720 DOC# 2020-0843275 1 II II IIII II il1111I III 1111! IIIII IIN11N1 IIII IIIII INII IIII IIII Dec 29, 2020 04:55 PM OFFICIAL RECORDS Ernest J. Dronenburg, Jr., SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES $0.00 (SB2 Atkins: $0.00) PAGES: 1 NOTICE OF ABATEMENT 1.0 THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY WHEREAS it was determined that a violation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist, and WHEREAS such violation was ordered abated on 9/29/2020, and WHEREAS representatives of the National City Fire Department abated the vioiation(s) on 10/8/2020. and WHEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to $3,252.00; THEREFORE be it known that an abatement ohligation exists on the property regardless of owner until paid. The current owner of the wormy is Brown Clara M at 10037 Dunbar Ln, El Cajon, CA 92021 described as follows: \l'N 558 220 35 00 ADDRESS: 3040 E 16th St I I:( ; !L DESCRIPTION: Lot 220 Tr 1748 this abatement ohligation shall attach to the property, not the owner, and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the California It .<<:iiue and taxation Code Section 3712. After confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax bill. If not rirsuant to State Law and State Tax Lien Law, the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. The amount of such claim shall be plus i:?i rc.t and other costs which may hereafter become due. This filing does not preclude the filing of legal action for collection. Should such actions :. Ia,ircd or determined to be appropriate, reasonable legal fees will be incurred and added to saidobligation. I 1 i 1 I): Nmcmber 25, 2020 BY: Ken Osborn, Fire Prevention Services, Inc., Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Acknowledgement P notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is ('alitbrnia atta);hed, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. rocarnw of 7YEttrtriugu - t m November 25, 2020 before me, R Thrasher, Notaa Public, personally appeared Ken Osborn. who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory e‘ idicnce to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in; ltis her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the acted, executed the instrument. ! ;:,••-ai:v under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. \1'I'1' '1,SS m han and official seal. , � £ NOTARYCaurnORM -No� '5 8MOO O COUNTY taotwtwimtz Apit24,2 4 (Seal) 174 345 of 592 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 558-320-22-00 10/16/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 10/20/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 11/23/20 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/23/20 Posted property. 11/23/20 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 12/04/20 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 12/04/20 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 12/07/20 Work order authorization signed by District Official. 12/30/20 F.P.S.I. crews abated the property. 01/08/21 The owner was mailed a bill at the contracted rates. 02/09/21 The owner was mailed a final bill. 03/10/21 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 175 346 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Casillas Jose D / Estella V Address: 1 626G Sweetwater Rd # 161 National City, CA 91950 Parcel Number: 558 320 22 00 Date: 10/20/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: 2112 Rachael Arc Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire properly of all weeds dead vegetation, trash. debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the pronern. (Please maintain any and all i:rasses below 3 inches year round)(This ,includes aloha sidewalks and alleys) You arc herchy directed to ahate the public nuisance described above. of which you arc the occupant or owner, within thirty (311) days of I0/20/_021L "Your failure to comply' with this order will result in the City having your properly cleaned by the City's contractor at vour expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 1161 A.$3St1 On administrative fee will he charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property (per Resolution number 94-97) Violations are also suhiect In proseeutii ii as misdemeanors: Guidelines For The Abatement of Flammable egetatioq For the protection of lie and property. remove all brush. flammable vegetation. or combustible growth which is located from thirty (30) feet to one hundred (100) feet from such a building or structure or to the property line. whichever is nearer, or as required by the Fire Department. including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more than thirty (30) unfit such building or structure. Cuttings are to he removed from the property and disposed of properly. Vegetation is to he cut within two (21 inches of Ike ground. "NOTICE REGARDING RARE. THREATENED OR ENDANGERED SI'F:CIES" If you have prey musty received a notice from the California Department of Fish and Game or the ti S Fish and Wildlife Services that rare. threatened or endangered species of lish or wildlife have occurred on your property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance. YOU MU\'f NOTIFY BOTH AGENCIES AND THE NATIONAL CITY FIRI DFPARTMFN f IN WRITING AT LEAST"TEN t 1(1) DAYS PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IF THESE AGENCIES FAIL TO OBJECT OR NOTII-1 YOU or ANY AL TERNATIVF PROCEDURES Wf1'H1N THOSE TEN (10) DAYS. YOU MAY TIIEN PROCEED TO CLEAR VEGETATION AS DIRECTED BY THIS NOTICE failure to provide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Law to penalties. National City \lunicinal (:ode 9.12.010 Public Nuisance Declared —In General Any of the Iitllowing conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance. :1. when the Fire Chiclfor his/her designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of ruhht.h, or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. boxes. shavings. or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger Iifc or property. or liuds obstructions to or on fire escapes, stairs, passageways. doors or windows That reasonably tend to interfere w ith the operations of the fire department or the egress of the occupants of such building of premises: or finds that the clfcctivcness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced, or finds that any provision of the llnifonn Fire Code is hying violated- B. when the f ire Chief or hus!hcr designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stove. oven. incinerator. furnace or other heating device. electric fixture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specifically. mentioned in the I Inilorm Fire C.'ode. to he defective of unsafe so as to create a hazard. C. When the Fire Chief or his!her designee finds any condition which in his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or menace of lire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in presenting. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which may obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations (lithe fire department or the egress of occupants in the event of lire National Ow unicipat (ode 9.12.11211 Public Nuisance Declared —Weeds and Other Flammable \latcrialr. All weeds, growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or pits ale property are hereby declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of ihi. chapter, "'.weds' shall include the following: A weeds a hilt hear seeds of a downy or writ gy nature B. Sagehrush. chaparral. and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become. when dry, a lire menace to adjacent unproved propert Weeds which are otheni ise noxious or dangerous D. Poison oak and poison ivy %hen the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the politic health E. Dry grass, stubble. brush. litter. or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a lire hazard in a portion ofthe City which has heen zoned for single and multiple residence purposes National City Aunicipal Code 1.36.010 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a public nuisance in any section or this code. and/or said condition caused. maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health, satiny and welfare or which significantly obstructs, injures or interferes with the reasonable of free use of property in a neighborhood. community or to any considerable number of persons A public nuisance also has the same meaning as set Iiirih in California C'ic i1 Code Section 3479 National City Municipal Code 1.36.060 Abatement— Appeal— Hearing Within ten (ID) days from the date of posting, mailing or personal scniee of the required Douce. the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the C'ily Council. Such appeal shall he in writing turd shall he filed with the City Clerk 11' you should Inise any questions. please feel free to call Ittis number: 1-866-779-3774 Si listed tiencalguna prcgunla. par favor (lame al numcro: I-866-779-3774 Sa anumaiig katantnigan. tuma wag tang po sa numcrong ito: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in public safety. **You have the right to appeal Mhos matter to the City Council within ten (10) days of the receipt of thi I -866-779-3774 est.307 or blip://ftreprevcntion.net The appeal shall he in writing and filed with the City Clerk. (NC'M(' 1.36.O5r)) •••Fir,, Prevention Service.; Inc is porter contrail with the City of National C'it.. 347 of 592 NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Yes HAVE YOU CIE ABED THIS PROPERTY 51 NCE THIS NOTICE? DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR ABATEMENT? Yes HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTS TO ABATE THE PROPERTY? Yes CALL RRE PREVENTION 1-866-779-3774 http://firepreeention.net CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR RE-INSPEQION. 1-866-779-3774 http: //Ti reprevention. net PROPERTY OWNERSARE RESPONSIBLE F OR MAINTAINING HAZARD ABATEMENT ON A YEAR ROUND BASK. HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY IF YOU 00 NOT UNDERSTAND READ THE ABATEMENT Yes INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION. INSTRUCTIONS 1-866-779-3774 http://firepreventbon.net A WOULD YOU LIKE THE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? No IF NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME SPECIIED TIE OWNER WILL BE CHARGED A$350.00 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE. PWS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Yes Yes c CALL RRE PREVENTION WHEN COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 Int p://firep revent bn. net CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-666-779-3774 http://fireprevention. net IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE EMU T CRY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMNISTRATWE; FEE MAY BE WNVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 91950-4596 177 348 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre E. Per square foot over one acre 2. 3. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated Dozer Operation A. hourly rate B. move -on fee 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 dump fees (reimbursement of cost) A. B. $250.00 $325.00 $400.00 $450.00 $ 00.02 $ 00.10 $150.00 $150.00 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee B. abatement lien C. Interest on lien (apr) D release of abatement lien E. public notary F. File duplication fee G. Unscheduled Labor per man hour H. unscheduled fees $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00 10% $ 50.00 $ 20.00 $ 50.00 $ 50.00 (reimbursement of cost) 178 349 of 592 -a .4'. 41 1", A • nspection 355 of 592 �1J CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE (h ncr: Casillas Jose D / Estella V Addre,,: 1626G Sweetwater Rd # 161 National City. CA 91950 Parcel Number: 558 320 22 00 Date: 11/23/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: 2112 Rachael Ave Instructions for Abatement: Please clear (he entire property of all weeds. dead ►egetation, trash. debris and artindo. All Mites of dead vegetation and debris must be removed front the propertv1Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches near round)(This includes along sidewalks and alleys) lot! are hereby directed to abate the puhlic nuisance described above, of which you are the occupant or owner, within ten (III) days Of 1 1/23/2021) **Your failure to comply with This order will result in you being charged the administrative Ice and the City having your property cleaned by the City's contractor at ►our expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 1?6). A $350.00 administrative fee will he charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property (per Resolution number 94-97) Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors. Guidelines For The Abatement of flammable Vegetation For the protection of life and property. remove all brush. flammable vegetation. or combustible growth which is located from thirty (30) feet to one hundred (100) Iect from such a building or structure or to the property Zinc, whichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department. including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation more than thirty (3u1 horn such building or structure. ( uttings are to he removed from the property and disposed of properly Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground. "NOII( F: REGARDING RARES TIIRI: CTI:NEI) OR ENDANGERED SPF:CI EIS" If you have previously received a notice from the Calilumra Department of Fish and Game or the U.S Fish and Wildlife Services that rare. threatened or endangered species of fish or wildlife have occurred on your property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance. YOU MUST NOTIFY 13OT1I ACiENCIES AND 'rIIL NATIONAL C'rrY FIRI? IMPARTMENT IN WRITING AT LEAST TEN 1101 DAYS PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IF THESE AGENCIES FAIL TO OBJEC1 OR Nfirlf 1 YOt1 OF ANY ALTERNATIVE PR(XF.DURE_S wrmm-IIN THOSE 'TEN (10) DAYS. YOU MAY TDIEN PROCEED TO CLEAR VEGETATION AS DIRECTED 131' 1 HIS Nt)ICF. Failure to provide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or Stale Law to penalties. National City yunicipal Code 9.12.1110 Public M1uisancc Declared —in General Any of the following conditions are hereby declared to consulate a puhlic nuisance: A. When the Fire Chief' or his/her desienee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish: or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper, boxes, shavings. or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property. or finds obstructions to or on fire escapes, stairs, passageways, doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of the occupants of such budding of premises; or finds that the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced. or lindh that any provision of the (Indium fire Code is being violated. 13. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee deems any chimney. smokestack, stove. oven. incinerator. furnace or other heating device. electric tixlute or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the 1 in loon Fire Codc. to he defective or unsafe so as to create a hazard C', When the Fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her. judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or menace of fire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the puhlic service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which mas obstruct, delay. hinder or interfere with the operations atilt: tire department or the egress of occupants in the event of lire. National ( its Municipal Code 9.12.1(211 Public Nuisance Declared—W eeds and Other Flammable Materials All weeds. growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or private propertyare hereby declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of this chapter "weeds" shall include the following A. Weeds which hear seeds of a downy or wtngy nature Sagebrush, chaparral, and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become, when dry, a lire menace to adjacent improved property C. Weeds which are otherwise noxious or dangerous. D Poison oak and poison ivy when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the puhlic health. E. Dry grass, stubble. brush. litter, or other flammable material which endangers the puhlic safety by creating a lire hazard in a portion of the City which has been zoned for single and multiple residence purposes. National ('its Municipal Code 1.36.010 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to be a puhlic nuisance in any section of this code, and/or and condition caused, maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health. safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs. injures or interferes with the reasonable of free use of property in a neighborhood. community ar to any considerable number of parsons. A puhlic nuisance also has the same meaning as set forth in California Civil Codc Section 3479. National City Municipal Codc 1.36,060 abatement—.%pncal— Ilearinc Within ten (Ill) days front the date of posting, mailing or personal service of the required notice, the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City (.ouncil. Such appeal shall he in wrung and shall he filed with the City Clerk If you should have au) questions, please feel free 10 call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si usted tiencalguna pregunta. pnr fat or Ilante al nun1ero: 1-866-779-3774 Sa anumang kalanungan. Ionia oag lung pit sa numcrong ito: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in puhlic safety. *'You have the right to appeal this matter to the City Council within ten (10) days ol-the receipt of fins notice I-866-779-3774 ext. 3117 or htlp://tireprc.ention.net The appeal shall he in writing and filed with the City Clerk. (NCMC 1.36.0501 ***Fire Preventit1nervices, Inc. is under contract with the City ol'National City. Fire Prevention Services**' w .e.g',,.11V) 0,4. • ' - Mb 1 2/04 I zl!"-N*74 E69 Jo ggc ,274:--orARN • • , A CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization # 7333 Owner: Casillas Jose D / Estella V Address: 1626G Sweetwater Rd # 161 National City, CA 91950 Parcel #558 320 22 00 Job location:2112 Rachael Ave Authorized by: Signature: Date: / 'Z- 7- zazo WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: cu. yds. Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire property of all weeds dead vegetation, trash,, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round)fThis includes along sidewalks and alleys) 198 369 of 592 06 558-32 0 h SAN DIEGO COUNTY ASSESSOR'S MAP BOOK 558 PAGE 32 VAN NESS 20Th ZB/ � ) �9� a7 37 vole 1L o% .... ZZo 5 291.65 POR 350 351 V fi54 is 1.4f / Q 35i0 3 4D 356Z 91 ST z,a 10 384 41 itir 3112 -. >7-*5232:."2"., 8zo I P. u P 8a 13 3 PM 8553 nes r7 _.I k , PM17821 6-6/ 1 1 a O 357 NZ I,z 358 10 X 37' T,a _ ...,-ter 222 / 16 359 291 64 1470 52.00.E THIS IMP WAS PREPARED FOR ASSESSMENT PURPOSES ONLY NO LIABILITY IS ASSU6 3) TOR TIE ACCURACY OF THE DATA SHOWN ASSESSORS PARCELS MAY NOT COMPLY WITH LOCAL SUBDIVISION OR BUIDINO ORDINANCES 01 Vit 4,0 (17 ) ,.a. PAR 22 45 95569 r.•'rr— V#6- we.08 PM 8553 0 )Z72X1 09 PAIR 1 z 7821 21 if „.220 2 - 4LeEM4A1E S7 C aERIAro ST ® t' =100, 8/1'2007 A:T•' CHA * S ' CUT BILK OLD 320 33 I'NEW 35 S•, 71 "413 7 ' 20 '7g 4846 , 20 .37/f. 76 276¢ z8 3914478 3121 3944o f wio J79 347E 2SOfo 4/ B 3333 • L7 4t44 90 (355 14 ,Mit 91 4441 /9 ; a 8 .46/7 19 44545 97 1877 16 side 04 719 1 46847 08 1533 7 48-51 08 1550 MAP 1748 — LINCOLN ACRES ANNEX NO 2 CA1.0 CANT 199 370 of 592 Hand Sq. Ft Us0 Dump ticket: Work space for diagrams end amount of work done Tractor 5q, Ft„ Dump Charge: Total Removal Cu, Yds.: 371 of 592 372 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 Itttp://fireprevention.net 1/8/2021 Casillas Jose D / Estella V 1626G Sweetwater Rd # 161 National City, CA 91950 Parcel # 558 320 22 00 Location: 2112 Rachael Ave Dear Casillas Jose D / Estella V, This letter is to inform you that the Public Nuisance on the above referenced property was abated pursuant to a prior Notice to Abate and order of the City of National City. Fire Prevention Services was contracted by the City of National City to help reduce Public Nuisances and potential fire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. The abatement work on your property was performed as mandated by The National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. The charges thus far total $1,910.00. You will incur no further costs if this amount is paid within fifteen (15) days of the date of this notice. Failure to pay this bill may result in the tiling of an abatement lien upon your property. Please make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services and include the Parcel # 558 320 22 00 on the check. Ifyou have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely. Fire Prevention Services, Inc. rev.0 S/ 19/06 205 376 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES •l_ractor Mowing duantith suh total A. per parcel. sized 1 to 7,500 square feet S250.00 13. per parcel. sized 7,501 to 15.000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel. sized 15.001 square feet to 30.000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel. sized 30.001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. per square foot over one acre $00.02 sq. ti. Hand Labor 1, A. per square loot of area abated $0. l 0 15.600 sq. Ft. 1.560.0 Op% Dozer Operation A. hourly rate 4 $1 50.00 B. mope on fee $150.00 411.11.1 Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping. and or compacting $38.00 X cu.\ds B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) A. per parcel $350.00 1 $350.00 Attorney Services A. per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. cost confirmation fee, per parcel $200.00 $275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee $50.00 B. abatement lien $50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D. release of abatement lien $50.00 E. public notary $20.00 F. tile duplication fee $50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour $50.00 11. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 7333 APN # 558 320 22 TOTAL S 1,910.00 206 377 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 littp://fireprevention.net Final Bill 2/9/2021 Casillas .lose D / Estella V 1626G Sweetwater Rd # 161 National City. CA 91950 Ref: Parcel # 558 320 22 00 Dear Casillas Jose D / Estella V_ COPY This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 1/8/2021 and we have not received payment in the amount of $1.910.00 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will be required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include filing an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this bill to our collection agency. Under state and local law, costs for such action will he added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Seryic es, lnc., and include the Parcel # 558 320 22 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely, Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rep .05 19/06 207 RECORDING REQUESTED BY Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 fax (619) 445-6336 AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 DOC# 2021-0229236 I IIIII11IIIIIIIMIIIII11111IIIII1111IIQIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Mar 24, 2021 02:36 PM OFFICIAL RECORDS Ernest J. Dronenburg, Jr., SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES $0.00 (SB2 Atkins: $0.00) PAGES: 1 NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY WHEREAS it was determined that a violation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist, and WFIEREAS such violation was ordered ahated on 12/7/2020, and WHEREAS representatives of the National City Fire Department ahated the violation(s) on 12/30/2020. and WHEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to $1,980.00; THEREFORE be it known that an abatement obligation exists on the property regardless of owner until paid. The current owner of the property is Casillas Jose D / Estella V at 1626G Sweetwater Rd # 161, National City, CA 91950 described as follows: APN # 558 320 22 00 ADDRESS: 2112 Rachael Ave LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 384 Fr 1748 This abatement obligation shall attach to the property, not the owner, and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the California Revenue and Taxation Code Section 3712. After confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax bill. If not paid pursuant to State Law and State Tax Lien Law, the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. The amount of such claim shall he plus interest and other costs which may hereafter become due. This filing does not preclude the tiling of legal action for collection. Should such actions be required or determined to be appropriate, reasonable legal fees will be incurred and added to said obligation. DATED: March 10, 2021 BY: Ken Osborn, Fire Prevention Services, Inc.. Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Acknowledgement I A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Diego } On March 10. 2021 before me. R Thrasher. Notary Public. personally appeared Ken Osborn, who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s). or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted. executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WI .SS rly h / vA d and officia, cal. R. THRASHER I ConrniMion No. 2332281 NOTARY PUBLIC - CAUFORNIA BAN DIEGO COUNTY GtiMUn� liNimEgAlgNt24,2024 (Seal) 208 379 of 592 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 558-320-43-00 10/30/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/12/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 12/14/20 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 12/14/20 Posted property. 12/14/20 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 01/04/21 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 02/09/21 Certified notice returned "unclaimed". 01/05/21 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 01/06/21 Work order authorization signed by District Official. 02/02/21 F.P.S.I. crews abated the property. 02/03/21 The owner was mailed a bill at the contracted rates. 03/02/21 The owner was mailed a final bill. 03/17/21 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 06/01/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 209 380 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Truss Address: 804 24th St Date: 11/12/202(l San Diego, CA 92154 Parcel Number: 558 320 43 00 Location of Public Nuisance: iilarbison Ave Instructions fur Abatement: pease clear the entire Property of all ►deeds, dead vegetation, trash. debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must he removed from the propert (F lease maintain anv and all grasses below 3 inches year roundj(This includes along sidewalks and allevsj( Please remove "anv and all" combustible materials, discarded furniture and ap )lit ances trash piles of debris from entire propert\., You are hereby directed to abate the puhhe nuisance described above, of ++hick you arc the occupant or oner. o Rhin thirty 1301 days of 1 II I2/2020 **Your failure to colnpk with Iles order dull result tit the Clty had ing your properly cleaned by the C uy's contractor at y our expense (per National City Rlunicipal Code ( hapter I In) A $350 00 administrative tee %%ill he charged in addition to the contractor's lees to clean the property (per Resolution number (Zd-97) Violations are also subject 11. prosecution as misdemeanors. (.uidelines For The %basemen' of Flammable 1 egetatinn For the protection of Ole and pi open), renmvc all brush. flammable %egetanon. or combustible growth ++Inch is located from thin} (311) feet to one hundred t 100I wet from such a huilduii or structure or to the property inc.Iwhichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department. including the maintenance of grass and other vegetation IIIUIC than thirty 1301 Irons such building or structure. Cuttings arc to he removed from the property and disposed/ of properly Vegetation is to he eul s ilhin hit+ (21 Inehe> nil the ground "\O 11(F: REGARDING 11.:11i1•:, I IIItEA7I•:NI•.D OR END.%NGERED SPE( 11:S" II•you have prcutiusly received a notice from the California Department of Fish and Game or the l I.S Fish and Wildlife See ices that rare. threatened or endangered species if fish or ++rldhlc have occurred on }our property in the areas identified lift fuel break clearance. YOU MUS I NOTIFY BO1 (1 AGENCIES AND 1111 NAI ION,\i CI I \ I IRI DI -PAR I MFNT IN 'A RI fIN(1 Al I FAST FI.N (Ili) DAYS PRIOR ro BEGINNING VEGEIATION CLEARING IF !ESE AGENCIES F \II 10014.I1C1 t)R tie 1111 \ YOl I OF ANY \t IF RNA I IVF PRC)Cl OI'RFS \\ 11 I IN 11 R)SE i1 N (I (1) DAYS. YOU MAY 1 FIEN PRO( EEO TO CI.L.AR VEGF1 :\ I ION AS DIRI C VI D nY I I ITS NO I It. 1 Failure to prof ale notification to these agencies eta} render you liable under Federal or State I aw to penalties National City %Innicinal Code 9.12.010 Public \uisance Declared --tit General Any of the follow ing conditions are hereto declared to constitute a public nuisance A. When the Fire Chic) or his/her designee determines that there exists in Any building or (Milli!, premises Cunibtistihle, haiardous or explosne ntatenak or dangerous accumulations of rubbish. or unnecessary accumulations of yvastepaper. boxes. shavings, or any, highly Ilanunuhle materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property or linds obstructions to or on lire escapes, stairs. passageways. doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the lire deparimeni or the egress m1 the occupants of such build mg of premises. or finds that the etlectrtchess of any exit door, attic separation or any lire separation ++all is reduced. or finds that any pros tsion tit the 11111lornt Fire Code is being violated B. When the Fire C hrcl'or his/her designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stole. oven. incinerator, furnace or other heating device. electric I Nture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standaid in or upon arty building. structure or premises not specdically mentioned in the I mlimn Fire Code. to he defect we or unsafe so as to create a hazard C. \. hen the fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or menace of lire 10 greater degree that customarily recognized as non.nal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which nmai obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations ul'the lire department or the egress of occupants in the csent of lire ♦atiunal City Municipal ( ode 9.12.1120 Public Nuisance Declared—%ecds and Other Flammable Materials All weeds. growing or Incased upon streets. sidewalks or pm ate propert are hereh} declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the following. A Weeds which hear seeds of,' doom or w uig% mason 13 Sagebrush. chaparral. and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become, it hen dn..t lire menace to adjacent improved property Weeds ++Inch are othemisc noxious or dangerous. f) Poison oak and poison its when the condo rims of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health f)ry grass stubble brush Inter, or other tlammmah)c material witch endangers the public saleq b} creating a tiro hazard in a portion of the City which has been coned lirr single and multiple residence purposes National City wlunieinitl ( ode 1.36.010 Public Nuisance Deftncd "Puhlic Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a puhlic nuisance in any section o1 This code. and/or and condition caused. maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a Threat to she, public's health. safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs, injures or interferes with the reasonable of lice rise of proper in ,1 nctghhorhood community or to any considerable number of persons A public nuisance also has the sanie meaning as set forth in California C n d Code Section 3.179 National Cils Slunicinal Code 1.36.060 Abatement— 1opeal— 'Waring Ve'ilhin ten (10) days front the date of posting. mailing or personal ser% ice of the required nonce. the owner or person occupying. or controlling such lot or premises affected muy appeal to the Cit) Council Such appeal shall he in %+riling and shall he filed with the City Clerk II' you should hate any questions. please feel free in call this number: I-861;-779-3774 Si usied tienealguna pre unta. poi fasor flame al nu inert,: I-866-779-3774 Sit annulling katanungan. morals rig king pm sit nuntcrung itu: 1-866-719-3174 Sincerely' yours in public salcty. **You have the nil to appe20 al this matter to the City Council within ten t 101 days of the receipt of tit 381 of 592 NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Yes HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? No DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR No-0 ABATEMENT? Yes HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMEN TS TO ABATE THE PROPERTY? No Ye PROPERTY OWNERS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MAINrAINI NG MASARD ABATEMENT ON A YEAR ROUND BASIS. CALL RRE PREVENTION 1-866-779-3774 htt p://fl rep reventic; n.net +(CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net, HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND READ THE ABATEMENT Yes INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION, INSTRUCTIONS 1-866-779-3774 http://flrepreventIon.net No WOULD YOU UKETHE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? IF NOT ABATED WITHIN SPECFIED THE OWNER WILL BE CHARGED A$350.00 ADMNISTRATIVE FEE. PLUS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER Will BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Ye Cht CALL RRE PREVENTION WHEN COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 tp://fireprevaEtion.ret , CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR Yes ARRANGEMENTS. 1.866-779-3774 http://fireprefention.net IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE ESIQB T CRY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMNISTRATIVE FEE MAY BE WAIVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 91950-4596 211 382 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. Per square foot over one acre $ 00.02 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated $ 00.10 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 B. move -on fee $150.00 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee $ 50.00 B. abatement lien $ 50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D release of abatement lien $ 50.00 E. public notary $ 20.00 F. File duplication fee $ 50.00 G. Unscheduled Labor per man hour $ 50.00 H. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) 212 383 of 592 384 of 592 12/14/20 Re -Inspection' 47, 385 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 9195(1-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 1 rust Address: 804 2 ith St Date: 12/14/2020 San Diego. ('A 92154 Parcel Number: 558 320 43 00 rfIZA (- ' Location of Public Nuisance: 1-larbison Ave Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire )Lropert% of all weeds. dead %eeetation, trash. debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain anN and all Grasses below 3 inches year round)(This includes along sidewalks and allevsI( Please remove "any and all" combustible materials. discarded furniture and appliances, trash, piles of debris from entire property.) oil are hush% directed to abate the puhhc nuisance described above. of which you are the occupant or o`vner within ten (ID) days of 12/14/21120 •• 1 our failure to comply with this order w11 result In you being charged the administnuive lee and the City hat mg %our property cleaned by the Co's contractor al v our expense (per Nat tonal City Municipal ( ode ( haptei I..3tv). r1 $350.00 admuustratty e tee will he charged in addition to the contractor's Ices to clean the property (per Resoliiti"Il number 94-97), Violations are also suhfeet to prosecution as misdemeanors Guidelines For The .\batcmenl of Flammable A'elletation For the protection of life and property. remove all brush. flammable vegetation, or combustible growth %\Itch us located Irons thin) 13U) ICet to one hundred t II)n) feet Inns such a building or structine or to the pioperty line. whichever is nearer, or as required by the Fire Department, including the maintenance of grass and other %egetation Inoue thau thirty (30) front such buildng of structure Cuttings are to he removed from the properyy and disposed of properly Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground "Nod I( E REGARDING RAKE. 'HIRE %TENF:11 OK ENDANGERED SPECIES" If you have previously eceived a nonce from the C altfomia Department of Fish and Game or the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services that rare. threatened or endangered specirs of lisp or wildlife have occurred on your property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance, YOU MUST NOTIFI BOTH A(iE.NCII S AND FFIF NAFIONA(1 111 I•IRI. l)l I'ARI MFNT IN WRffIN(i Al I LAST TEN (10) DA1'S PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IT TIIESI- AGLNCI I,S FAlt. '10 Oli.li l I ( )1; Ni)'l111 1OlOi' ANY .Al IT RNA11VI PRO( LI)UR! S WITHIN !HOSE fEN 110) DAYS. YOU MAY TIIEN PROCFI•.D1()CLEAR VI ((I 1AIION •1S 1)IRI C 111) 10 I III S N( 1111 I I atlu'r: to pro toe imbrication to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Lass to penalties National ('if) Alunicipal (ode 9.12.11111 Public Nuisance Declared —In General An) of the following conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance A. When the Fire Chiefor his/her designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or cxplosiv e materials 01 dangerous accumulations of rubbish, or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. boxes. shavings. or any highly !laminable materials %Inch are so situated as to endanger lice or property, (ir linds ohsiiactions to or on lire escapes. stairs. passageways. doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the tire department or the egress of the occupants of such budding of premises. or finds Mai the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced. or finds that any provision of the Uniform Fire 1'ode is being violated B. When the fire Chieff or his/her designee deems any chimney. smokestack- stove, oven, incinerator. furnace or other heating de% ice. electric Fixture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon an) building. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the 1 milorin Fire Code. to he delecli%c or unsafe so as to create a hazard. C When the Fire Chien or his/her designee linos any condition which in his/her Judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or menace of lire to a greater dcgtee Mat customarily recognized as normal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing fire or am thin_ or .iet which may obstruct. delay, hinder or interfere with the operations of the tire department or the egress of occupants in the event of lire National Cif) Municipal Code 9.12.020 Public Nuisancelleclared—Wccds and Other Flammable Nlateriols All weeds. grow mg or located upon streets, sidewalks or private property are hereby declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the following A. Weeds which hear seeds of a dov%nv or ) ingv nature li Sagebrush, chaparral, and an) other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become w hen dn.. a fire menace to adjacent improved) properly C Weeds which are oden%Ise noxious or dangerous. 1) Poison oak and poison i'% %%hell the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health C Dry grass, stubble. brush. titter or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a lire hazard in a portion (lithe C'u% which has heen zoned for single and multiple residence purposes National City Municipal Code 1.36.11111 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a public nuisance in any section of this code. and/or and condition caused maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the puhlic's health, safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs, injures or interferes with the reasonable of Tree use of property in a ncighhothood. (.onnuunit) ua to any considerable number of persons. A public nuisance also has the sane meaning as set forth m Calili,rnia Co II Code Sequin 3479 Natii,I(rd ('ill Municipal ( ode 1.36.1)6(1 Aibatement--:\ppeal— I'earl nil Within ten 1101 days from the date of posting. mailing or personal service of the required notice, the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises allectcd may appeal to the City Council Such appeal shall be in writing and shall he filed with the City Clerk. If you should have any questions. please feel free 1u call this number: I-866-779-31'4 Si fisted tieneaIgunn preguuta, por incur (lame al nunlero: I-866-779-3774 Sa anunlana kalanungau, tunawag lang pii sa nunlerung Ito: I-866-779-3774 Snicciel' yours in public sarets. "You have the right to appeal this matter to the Coy Council within ten 1 11)1 days of the receipt of the notice I.116(i-779-3774 ext. 3117 or hit p:NI ircprevcntion.net The appeal shall ifhe in wrnins and tiled with the C'av Clerk INCH( 1.36 U501 ***Fire I'reveill loin tiers ices. inc is under contract with the OP of National Cuv 387 of 592 10215 9569 7019 2970 U.S. Postal Service"' CERTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT Domestic Mail Only For delivery information, visit our website at wvrw.usps.conr'. A L Cgrtiried Malt Fee $ 3 . 55 s 32 ;...5 Extra Services & Fees (check oox. add reef fM fare) .❑ Return Receipt t++ vA $ .'JReturn Receipt(electronic) 3 $0.00 ❑ Candled Mall Resvkted Delivery E _ i_ ❑Adult Signature Required S ,e,0 ❑ Adult Slgnmse Reertkted Dellvery riy teie; $fJ .55 $6,95 558 320 43 00 Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Tr 804 24th St 219 San Diego CA 12/14/2020 NC l 390 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization # 7350 Owner: Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Trust Address: 804 24th St San Diego, CA 92154 Parcel #558 320 43 00 Job location:Harbison Ave Authorized by: Signature: Date: /'6 - Z f WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: cu. yds. sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire ip_ppe_y of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round(This includes along sidewalks and alleysi ( Please remove "any and all" combustible materials discarded furniture and appliances. trash. piles of debris from entire property.) 220 391 of 592 06 558-32 0 10 SAN DIEGO COUNTY ASSESSOR'S MAP 800K 558 PAGE 32 uJ VAN NES 20I8 -a tow PM20228 taw >E PAR 1 PAR 2 1 1/ ?d 6 _ 0228 Inx zm/ t7= 411 `.o POR 350 351 3.0 353 (E7 11- 28, 61 Q 355 ..,ca z3S O 357 291.65 1,114 3 16 291.¢4 N70 52 00'E 354 358 359 THIS ANP WAS PREPARED FOR ASSESSLENI PURPOSES ONLY. NO I ARA ITY IS ASSUMED FOR TI C ACCURACY OF THE DATA SHOWN ASSESSOR'S PARCEL S VAT NOT COW Y WITH LOCAL SUBDIVISION OR BUILOINO ORDINANCES 5T ,3/io 42 w v4L 387 3it4 386 r IpOt: 531,0 logo V44 lea ZOAl 'w/ 10 384 lQ 1.1 V►4'.6. © n. a es. 3PF[!•i.�A vie -t4 p. 2 38 PM Rtta $ S I • 0 I • 2� PM17821 '036/ P /36F; ,010 '6566 11. 9 IP9.11n 37 V1 AO PM 6553 e a.ee 14 i, rue PM17821 Zlyy dIrl- l7. ZZo 1 AL stu4oL Sr ink CIAIIBERL Ate Sr ® ,.._100' 8/1/2007 AJrt CHA 4 S BLK OLD NEW Illm • CUT 302 33 3_4 iv 7f 137 20 r,, dx, 78 48a8 I ?O 371:f' 78 2764 28 3391h 7,9 3121 39440 w10 79 3478 1 25430, I{ 4/ B 3333 Z7 4LC4 90 1155 14 r 91 4/41 rQ :do . sY, NlA . ,461% 19 44845 97 1877 16 rSit 04 719 1 46&47 08 1533 7 48-51 08 155U I. MAP 1748 - LINCOLN ACRES ANNEX NO 2 ANC ;ANC 221 392 of 592 Hand Sp, f t,: 3/4 g l Dump ticket; i L i1S svm z,319S5 re-r. Work space for diagrams and amount of work done Tractor Sq, Ft. s _ Dump Charge: Total Removal Cu. Yds.: '2 Jai q 2- 393 of 592 C\ 0) L() o-) co / 9 :II A.! Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net 2/3/2021 Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Trust 804 24th St San Diego. CA 92154 Parcel kt 558 320 43 00 Location: Harbison Ave Dear Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Trust. This letter is to infirm you that the Public Nuisance on the aho‘c referenced property was abated pursuant to a prior Notice to Abate and order of the City of National City - Fire Prevention Services was contracted by the City of National City to help reduce Public Nuisances mid potential fire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. The abatement work on your property was performed as mandated by The National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. The charges thus far total $1.907.84. You will incur no further costs if this amount is paid within fifteen (15) days of the date of this notice. Failure to pay this hill may result in the filing or an abatement lien upon your property. Please make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services and include the Parcel k 558 320 43 00 on the check. If you have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1(158. Sincerely. Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/ 19)06 228 399 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowine quantity tiuh total A. per parcel. sized 1 to 7.500 square feet S250.00 B. per parcel. sized 7.501 to 15,000 square feet $ 325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15.001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30.001 square feet to one acre S450.00 E. per square foot over one acre S00.02 sy. tt. !land Labor 1. per square foot of area abated Uozer Operation A. hourly rate B. move -on fee So. 1O $150.00 $150.00 Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding. and/or shredding) ,A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting S38.00 x 13. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 3,-184 ,q, 11. :-18 !Hi cuJs 918,4 UI) 225.ti-I Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) A. per parcel $350.00 1 $ 35().00 Attorney Services per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings. etc.) A. cost confirmation fee, per parcel 2()().(It) S275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee S50.00 B. abatement lien S50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D. release of abatement lien S50.00 E. public notary S20,00 F. file duplication fee S50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour S50.00 1-1. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 7350 APN # 558 320 43 TOTAL S 1.907.84 229 400 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 littp://fireprevention.net Final Bill 3/2/2021 Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Trust 804 24th St San Diego. CA 92154 Ref. Parcel # 558 320 43 00 Dear Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 Trust. COPY This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 2/3/2021 and we have not received payment in the amount of S1.907.84 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will be required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include tiling an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this bill to our collection agency. Under state and local law. costs for such action will be added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prev entionServices, Inc., and include the Parcel # 558 320 43 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely, Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/ 19/06 230 401 of 592 RECORDING REQUESTED 1311 Fire Prevention Services. Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon. CA 92022-1720 (6191 562-1(158 Ia\ (619)445-6336 AND WHEN RECORDED MAI1, TO Fire Prevent ion Services. Inc. PO Box 1720 FI Cajon. CA 92022-1720 DOC# 2021-0237510 11111111111111111111110111111111111111111111111011111111111111111 Mar 26, 2021 02:12 PM OFFICIAL RECORDS Ernest J. Dronenburg, Jr., SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES SO 00 (SB2 Atkins. S0 00) PAGES 1 NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY Vd I I I -RE AS of was determined that a v iolation of Chapter 1.36 or the National City illtlniciptd Code did exist. and WI ILRREAS such violation was ordered abated on 1/6/2021. and 141IFRL 1S representatives or the National City Fire Department abated the violation(s) on 2/2/2021, and V' I IEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to $ 1977.84; '1 11E1(LFORI- he it knowtt that an abatement obligation exist:, on the propert) regardless of owner until paid The current owner ui the property is Duran Alejandro M Revocable 2016 [rust ai 8(14 24ih SI, San i)ieat), CA 92134 described as follow, s: AI'N 558 OP ,13 (1) \U1)RI.Sti I larhison Aye 1_l(r11..I)I SCRIP 1I(iN-11'IIO1N'11Ct11ot38,6 Tr 1748 This abatement obligation shrill attach to the properly. . not the owner and mawnol he extinguished by a tax sale under the Califirrni.t Revenue and Taxation Code ftt.ection 3712_ After confirmation by the ('it) Council shall hecome a special assessment un the property tax hill. II not paid pursuant to State 1 avv and State Fax Lien Law_ the property may he sold to satisfy that obligation. I he amount of -such claim shall be pill' interest and oilier costs which may hereafter become due. This tiling does not preclude the tiling orlecal action for collection. Should such action\ he required or delcrromcvl to he appropriate. reasonable legal tees will he incurred and added to said obligation. 1)A1El: March 17 2021 11Y. Ken Osborn, Fire Prevention Services. inc.. Designee !Or National City Fire Department Certificate Of Adoiow'ledgement A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is ll attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document tiurtb of Caroma County orSan Diego Ou March 17. 2021 helixes me, 12 Thrasher, Notary Public, personally appeared Ken Osborn, who proved 10 me on the basis of satisfactory evidenct to he the person(s) whose name(s) scare subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me [hat he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized eap.rcity(iesl. and that by his/hcrtheir signature(,) on the instrument. the person( s), or [he entity upon behalf or o,hieh the rer,on)s) acted. rxeeuled Mc instrument. 1 certify under PENAL 1 Y OI Pt:R11 FR1' -mkt- the laws of the Stile or Calilurnia brat the loregoing paragraph is true and correct_ WI rid and official seal. KifigLA a R THRASHER CorrnttaNcin No. 2332281 NOTARY PUBLIC - CAUFORNIA SAN DIEGO COUNTY commission Exprea August 24, 2024 1 cdI 231 402 of 592 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 559-033-03-00 10/06/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 10/07/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 11/09/20 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/09/20 Posted property. 11/09/20 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 11/20/20 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/20/20 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 11/29/03 Courtesy notice received return mail `unable to forward'. 12/02/20 Work order authorization signed by District Official for Admin fee. 12/03/20 The owner was mailed an Administrative bill at the contracted rates. 01/04/21 The owner was mailed a final bill. 02/03/21 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property, 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXHIBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 232 403 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL, CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Welding Maria G 1-1 Address: 727 E San Ysidro Blvd #707 San Ysidro. CA 12173 Parcel Number: 559 033 03 00 Date: 10/7/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: Harding AN e Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weeds. dead vegetation. trash., debris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the kropertv.il lease maintain any. and all grasses below 3 inches Year roundflThis includes alone sidewalks and alley's) You arc hereby directed to abate the public nuisance described above, of which you are the occupant or owner, within thirty (311) days o1' 10/7/2020. "Your failure in comply with this order will result in the City hav ing your property cleaned by the City's contractor at your expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 1. 36) .\ S350.0u administrative ice will he charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property (per Resolution number G4-97) Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors, Guidelines For The Abatement of Flammable \ cgctation bar the protection of life and property. remove all brush. flammable vegetation. or combustible growth which is located from nuns t301 feet to one hundred (In01 feet iron) such a building or structure or to the property line. whichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department. including the matntcnauce of grasp and other vegetation more than thin) (3(1) from such budding or structure Cuttings are to he removed from the property and disposed of properly Vegetation is to he gut within two (2) inches of the ground. "NOTICE REGARDING R.ULI•:, TIIREATE:\ED OR ENDANGERED SPECIES" If you have previously received a notice from the Calilirriva Department of Fish and Game or the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services that rare. threatened or endangered species of fish or wiIJIile have occurred on your property ur the areas identified for fuel hrcak clearance. YOU MUST NOTIFY 130'I'H AGENCIES AND Il IE NATIONAL CI I 1 1 II I DEPARTMI:N"1 IN WRITING AT LEAST TEN ( 10) DAYS PRIOR TO E31i(iINNING VEGI FA'FlON CLEARING. IF Tl IESE AGENCIES FAIL TO OR NO I II YOU OF ANY ALTERNATIVE PROCEDURES WI!IIIN'I'I-IOSL TEN (1(1) DAYS. VOL MAY THEN PROCFI:D TO CLEAR VEGETATION AS DIREC'ThD 13Y 1'Illti NOTICE. Failure to provide notification to These agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Law to penalties. National City Municipal Code 9.12.11111 Public Nuisance Declared --In General Any of the hollowing conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance. A. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosis a materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish: or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. boxes. shavings. or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property: or hinds obstructions to or on lire escapes. stairs. passageways, doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the fire department or the egress of the occupants of such building of premises. or linds that the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced: or finds that any provision of the Uniform Fire Code is being violated. 13. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee deems any chimney.. smokestack. stove. oven. incinerator. furnace or other heating device, electric fixture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the Uniform Fir: Code. to he defective or unsafe so as to create a hazard. C When the Fire ('hiertw his/her designee hinds any condition which in his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase ol'the hazard or menace of lire to a greater degree that customarily, recognized as normal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act w hich may, obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of occupants in the event of lire National City NIuniciRal Code 9.12.11211 Public ?nuisance Declared —Needs and Other Flammable la (lints All steeds. growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or pits ate property are hereby declared to he a public nuisance. For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the follow Ing. A. Weeds which hear seeds of a downy or wing. nature 13. Sagebrush, chaparral. and any, other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become. when dry. a lire menace to adjacent improved property C'. Weeds which are other Ise noxious or dangerous. D. Poison oak and poison ivy when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the public health. E. I)i % grass. stubble, brush, liner. or other flammable material which endangers the public safety by creating a tire hazard in a portion of the City which has been zoned for single and multiple residence purposes. ?National City Nunicinal Code 1.36.11111 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to be a public nuisance in any section ul'this code. and/or and condition caused. maintained or permitted to gist which constitutes a threat to the publics health. safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs. injures or interferes with the reasonable of tree use of property Ill a netghhurhood. CYymmunity or to any considerable number of persons A politic nuisance also has the same meaning as set lirth in Cali font ia Civl Code Section 3474. National ('it' Municipal Code 1.36.11611 Abatement—.tp,peal— Hearing Within ten 1 101 days from the date of posting. mailing or personal yen ice of the required notice, the corner or person occupy ing or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City Council. Such appeal shall he in writing and shall he I iled with the City Clerk. Ifyou should have any questions. please Teel free to call this number: 1-X66-779-3774 Si usled tieneaiguna prcgunla. por favor Ilan a al numeric I-866-779-3774 Sa a nuntang hatanungan. Umurwat; hang po sa nanterong ilo: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in public safety. ** Y'ou have the right to appe:t�t�ts matter to the City Council within ten (I 0) days of the receipt of thi 1-866./79-37'74 esi. 3117 or hup:lllirepresentinn.net The appeal shall he in writing and filed with the City Clerk. (NCMC 136.050) 1**i:ire Prevention SPrslrrc Inv is nnrler rtuitrnet with the ('itv nl'\at ion;,I ( 'ih NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Yes HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? No DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR ABATEMENT? Yes HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTS TO ABATE THE PROPERTY? No Yes CALL RRE PREVENTION 1-866-779-3774 http://ffreprevention., t CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention,net PROPERTY OWNERS ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MAINTAINING HAZARD ABATEMENT ON A YEAR ROUND BASIS. HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY READ THE ABATEMENT Yes INSTRUCTIONS No WOULD YOU LIKE THE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU? No 1 IF NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME SPECFIEDTHE OWNER WILL BE CHARGED A$350.00 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE. PLUS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Yes Yes { IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENRON. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net CALL RRE PREVENTION WHE COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-866-779-3774 http://freprerention.net IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE MILH TO' CITY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMINISTRATIVE FEE MAY BE WMVED. it 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 91950-4596 234 405 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. Per square foot over one acre $ 00.02 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated $ 00.10 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 B. move -on fee $150.00 4. Dehris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel $350.00 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour $200.00 7. Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel $275.00 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee $ 50.00 B. abatement lien $ 50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D release of abatement lien $ 50.00 E. public notary $ 20.00 F. File duplication fee $ 50.00 G. Unscheduled Labor per man hour $ 50.00 H. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) 235 406 of 592 NOTICE TC ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE /09/20 f®yM.7r r+s .e1MNi _Ar e-Inspeqtion 236 407 of 592 • ,' : 41' , ,_ % 4 -..4'7 . , • _ ) , • ,••••',.."N:-.14 '' e•-.; . • i ....c-` 5,:hguw•.4,4$,,,--..,•1•!:',,. ,:e•.:•-e-'' ::. --- • I.-• • •,. • .,. . . -.7t7..-,,,,..,• • 41.- , 4 ''' *. , .. ' illio1 „Iry j _ - �7,_ — __==---:---- 413 of 592 ReO spectipn 41 243 414 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE. DEPARTMENT 1243 National City 131%d : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Welding Maria G 1-1 Address: 727 E San Ysidro I31vd #707 San Ysidro. CA 92173 Parcel Number: 559 033 03 00 Date: 11/9/2020 Location of Public Nuisance: 1-larding Ave Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weedsidead vegetation. trashidebris and arundo. All piles of dead Vegetation and debris must be removed from the properly•. tPlease maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round)jThis includes along sidewalks and alleys) 1 ou .iri hereby dircctcd to abate the puhlic nuisance described above. of which you are the occupant or owner. within len 110) days of 1 I/9/211211. *'Your failure tip comply will this order will result in you being charged the administrative Ice and the City having your property cleaned by the C'ity's contractor at your expense (per National City. Municipal ('ode Chapter 1.36). A $350.00 administrative fee will he charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property (per Resolution nunmber9d-97). Violations are also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors. Guidelines For The .tatement of Flammable Vegetation For the protection of life and property. remove all hrush. flammable vegetation. or combustible growth ww Inch is located from thirty (3(1) feet to one hundred 1 1001 Ices from such a huilding or structure or to the property line. wwhichcvcr rs nearer. or as required by the Fire Department. including the maintenance ol'grass and other vegetation more Than thing (301 from such building or structure Cuttings are to be removed from the property and disposed of properly, Vegetation is to he cut within two (21 inches or the ground. "NOTICE R!':(:.1RDIN(. RARE, THREATENED OR ENDANGERED SPECIES" [(you have prey musty received a nonce from the Caitlin -Ina Department of Fish and Game or the U.S I• isle and Wildlife Services that rare. threatened or endangered species of Iish or wildlife have occurred on your property ni the areas identified for liieI break clearance. YOU MUST NOTIFY BOTH AGENCIES AND VHF NATIONAL. CITY FIRE DEI'AR1MLN'1' IN WRITING Al LLAS1 11:N (101 DAYS PRIOR T() 1314(,INNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IF TI !ESE; AGENCIES 1 \l1. TO OI3.IGCf t tR NOTIFY YOU OF ANY AI: I FRNAl1VE PROCEDURES 11 ITI IIN TI-LOSE TEN (10) DAYS. YOU MAY THEN PROCEED fO CLEAR VEGETATION AS Mall 1 D BY 11 II5 NOTICE. Failure to provide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Law to penalties. National City Municipal ('ode 9.12.1110 Public \ uisance Declared —In General Any of the following conditions arc hereby declared to constitute a puhlic nuisance A. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosi' a materials or dangerous accumulations 14 ruhhish: or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. poxes, shavings, or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life or property: or finds obstructions to or on lire escapes. stairs. passageways. doors or winndowis that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the tire department or the egress of the occupants of such budding of premises. or finds that the e1Tectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced. or finds that any provision of the ( Iniforn Fire Code is hang v iolated 13. When the Fire Chief or hislhcr designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stove. oven. incinerator. furnace or other heating device, elcctrtc fixture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the Uniform lire Code. to he detective or unsafe so as to crease a hazard. C 14 hen the Fire Chief or his(hcr designee I Inds any condition which in his/her, judgment increases or may cause an increase of the hazard or ncnacc of lire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by, persons in the puhlic service regularly engaged in preventing, suppressing or extinguishing lire or any. thing or act which may obstruct. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations oldie lire department or the egress of occupants in the event of lire. National City Municipal Code 9.12.11211 Public Nuisance Declared--N eeds and Other Flammable tlatcrials All weeds. growing or located upon streets. sidewalks or private property are hereby declared to he a puhlic nuisance. For the purposes of this chapter. "weeds" shall include the following A. Weeds which hear seats of a downy or wvingy nature H. Sagebrush. chaparral. and any other hrush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become, when dry. a lire menace to adjacent improved properly C Weeds which are otherwise noxious or dangerous 1)- Poison oak and poison ivy when the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the puhlic health. Dry grass. stubble. hrush. litter. or other (laminable material which endangers the public safety by creating a tire hazard in a portion of the City hich has been zoned tier single and multiple residence purposes. Notional (its \ltinicival (:ode 1.36.1110 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition delined or declared to he a puhlic nuisance in any section of this code. and/or and condition caused. maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health. safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs. injures or interferes with the reasonable of free use of property Ill :1 neighhrxhnud. community or to any considerable number of persons. A puhlic nuisance also has the same meaning as set Iorth in California Civil Code Section 3.179 National City \lunicipal Code 1.36.1160 Abatement — A peal— Hearing Within ten 110) days from the date of posting. mail ing or personal service of the required notice. the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises aflected may, appeal to the City Council Such appeal shall he in writing and shall he tiled with the City Clerk If you should bare any questions. please Fed free Io call this mintier: 1.866-779-3774 Si usted lienealguna oregano', par favor Ilanic al numera: 1-866-779-3774 Ma anumang katanungau. tumawrai; Iarig pu sa nunierung ito: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in puhlic safety - '•You have the right to appeal this matter to the City Council within ten (10) days of the receipt of this notice 1-866-779-3774 ext. 3117 or http://lireprevcntinn.net I'he appeal shall he in writing and tiled with the City Clerk, (NCMC 1.36.05n) ***Fire I'reventii2414erviccs, Inc. is under contract with the City afNational illy Fire I'icwaition SCI5 ices•• 415 of 592 1 • ' FC*101.t.T. " 4 "4, s ection 2970 0002 0216 Cr 0 U.S. Postal Service' CERTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT Domestic Mail Only For delivery information, visit our webslte al www.usps,com'. ° Certified Mail Fee S Extra Services & Fees (ch er* bor. ow Pea as app s, 0 Retun Recapt gwoorp9) G Reaxn Ravelpt la sc tran7G ti D cer fl ed Met ne ttleted Otlihrery (] Aden Signature Raquked S 0 Adult Signature Flastrlci d Delivery S Postage Total Postage Senr To Straw anoAp G`i t Mare. 21 t- 559 033 03 00 Welding Maria G H 727 E San ygdro Blvd #7' San Ysidro CA NC 421 of 592 SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION • Complete items 1, 2, and 3. ■ Print your name and address on the reverse so that we.can return the card to you. li • Attach this card4o the back of the mailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 5590330300 Welding Maria G F I 727 E San Ysidro Bivd *707 San Ysidro CA 92173 NC (IIIIII 0 III94IIIIII02 II 6101 IIIIIIIIII0125849 I9IIIIIIIIII 95917 A. Sigriffure D. is delivery Kldress different from item 1? ❑ Yes tt YElifienter dial*ery,gtt7 .c below: El No A ti-�-L-' IVY NOV 3 0 201r 2. Article Number (rransfpr from con.ra r�r ,n 7019 2970 0002 0216 PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 3. Service Type o Adult Signature ❑ Adult Signature Restricted Delivery ❑ Certified Mall® ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery ❑ Collect on Delivery n ( ,,liar* n., Delivery Restricted Delivery B2GG11 0 II Restricted Delivery ❑ Priority Mail Express® ❑ Registered Mall"" ❑ Registered Mall Restricted Delivery ❑ Retum Receipt for Merchandise o Signature Confirmation". 1 422 of 592 I Domestic Heturn Heceipt CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization # 7327 Owner: Welding Maria G H Address: 727 E San Ysidro Blvd #707 San Ysidro, CA 92173 Parcel #559 033 03 00 Job location:Harding Ave Authorized by: /'t • /JecLO Signature: �E6 Am,d DNzy Date: /2-2-Z-c WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: cu. yds. Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo_.A1Lpiles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year roundl( This includes along, sidewalks and alleys) 252 423 of 592 06 5AM 01EG0 COUNTY ASH SSOR.S MAP BOOR !6P PAGE 03 r ,1 0 cc a 3i ¢—i N. 4 qt 1, illitz K I i ,f_—e91 OPOR PAR 62 SBE MAP 803-37-7R (13u) AT 8 4. TN'Y e. 01 iSST CLSD$ 0.52AC. -i22z^ % zr a _ tav Zvl r. a Zb2 —0_ . /q IHIS AMP WAS PREPARED FOR A53ESSAID4T PURPOSES ONLY. NO LUBNfN 13 ASSUMED FOR TIC ACCURACY OF THE DMA SHOW* ASSESSOR'S PARCELS MAY NOT COMALY WON LOCAL 9WR3Y1310N OR 6UILaNG ORDRANOEs fA 2 0 J_ CIVIC 14777 CENTER STREET Id 0 Z 0 ce ,o I STREET STREET) DR MAP 364 — BANCROFTS RESUB MAP 348 — NATIONAL CITY REFILED ROS 10031, 10405, 10457, 12087 OC z COOLIDGE e 10/rl.cc uAS I1• PAR • SSE MAP 27etl-37-27 CHANGES B—K OLO •0JT 03) I 2t3 LI 75/Z 433 /-3 45 - -37Z 032 /2 /51/6 474345 032 2 *w;": 2 AD7/ ,' z 71 " 7` ' 4 ,77s2 031 3 ji! 5 036 / 21E 3 . 576 032 4F/7 F 79 /3in D3Gl 3 .I. Ste, -.. /J2 • 01-'5 IN415 f0 6i Pl9Z 012 ,;yi 7,:.> 1 B/i9 ', 2117 03I 5 6<7 036 j:.jaa An .2 2:e2 1,7 i'! •, ,033 0]2 3�ti _cute AN S7/0 6_24 ///,2 /S - 9 /345 032 2 20t21 DI 1666 OCT 2 7 2000 253 424 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net 12/3/2020 Vv'elding Maria G 11 727 E San Ysidro Blvd #707 San Ysidro, CA 92173 Parcel # 559 033 03 00 Location: Harding, Ave Dear Welding Maria G H. ADMINISTRATIVE BILL c+PY Fire Prevention Services has been contracted by the City of National City to help reduce potential fire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. Your property was re -inspected on 1 1/20/2020 and found to still be in violation of the National City. Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. As stated in the notice, if the violation is not corrected prior to the deadline you will he charged an administrative fee. A final inspection was performed on the above referenced parcel, as of 12/2/2020 this parcel is in compliance with the National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. Due to the abatement not being completed by the deadline. you are being charged the administrative fee. Thus far your bill is $ 350 and if paid within fifteen (15) days of this notice no further costs will he incurred by you. Please make check payable to F.P.S.I. and please include the File # 559 033 03 00 on the check. If you have any questions please callus direct at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely. Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05/ 1906 254 425 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7.500 square feet B. per parcel. sized 7,501 to 15.000 square feet C. per parcel, sized 15.001 square feet to 30,000 square feet D. per parcel. sized 30.001 square feet to one acre E. per square foot over one acre I land Labor A. per square loot of area abated Dozer Operation A. hourly rate B. move -on fee COPY $250.00 $325.00 $400.00 $450.00 $00.02 $0.10 $ 1 50.00 $150.00 Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping. and or compacting $38.00 X [3. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) A. per parcel Attornev Services A. per parcel, per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings. etc.) A. cost confirmation fee. per parcel Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee B. abatement lien C. interest on lien (apr) D. release of abatement lien E. public notary F. file duplication fee G. unscheduled Labor per man hour 11. unscheduled fees FILE # 7 327 APN # 559-033-03-0O quantity sq. It. sq. Ft. $350.00 1 $200.00 $275.00 $50.00 $50.00 10% $50.00 $20.00 $50.00 $50.00 (reimbursement of cost) TOTAL S 350.00 sub total cu.yds = $350.00 255 426 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 h t t p:// f i r e p r e v e n t i o n. n e t Final Bill 1/4/2021 Welding Maria G H 727 E San Ysidro Blvd #707 San Ysidro. CA 92173 Ref: Parcel # 559 033 03 00 Dear Welding Maria G H. MSt tti � �i This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 12/3/2020 and we have not received payment in the amount of $350.00 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will he required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include tiling an abatement lien on your property and fot arding this hill to our collection agency. Under state and local law. costs for such action will he added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services, Inc., and include the Parcel # 559 033 03 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely, Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05%19/06 256 427 of 592 RECORDING REQUESTED BY Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 • (619) 562-1058 fax (619) 445-6336 AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 DOC# 2021-0134956 11IIIIIIIII1IIBI111111111III[III1111111IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII1iIIIIIIII Feb 22, 2021 02:04 PM OFFICIAL RECORDS Ernest J. D;onenburg, Jr.: SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES_ $0.00 (S82 Atkins: $0.00) PAGES: 1 NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY WHEREAS it was determined that a violation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist, and WHEREAS such violation was ordered abated on . and WHEREAS representatives of the National City Fire Department abated the violation(s) on 12/2/2020. and WHEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to $420.00; THEREFORE he it known that an ahatcment obligation exists on the property regardless of owner until paid. The current owner of the property is Welding Maria G H at 727 E San Ysidro Blvd #707, San Ysidro, CA 92173 described as follows: AI'N # 559 033 03 00 ADDRESS: Harding Ave LEGAL. DESCRIPTiON: W 50 Ft I.ot 4 B1k 116'Fr 348 This abatement obligation shall attach to the property, not the owner, and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the California Revenue and 'taxation Code Section 3712. After confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax bill. il' not paid pursuant to State Law and State fax Lien Law. the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. The amount of such claim shall be plus interest and other costs which may hereafter become due. This filing does not preclude the filing of legal action for collection. Should such action: be required or determined to be appropriate. reasonable legal fees will be incurred and added to said obligation. f?Al'LU. February 3, 2021 BY: Ken Osborn. Fire Prevention Services. Inc.. Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Acknowledgement A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Diego ) On February 3, 2021 before me. R Thrasher, Notary Public, personally appeared Ken Osborn, who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/tbeir signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted. executed the instrument. 1 certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WT'ilatT,6S iriv h u1' `i d official seal. R. THRASHER ' Cavort No. 2332281 . / a 01100 COUNTY (Seal) 257 428 of 592 SUMMARY REPORT FOR APN 563-162-32-00 10/19/20 Received citizen complaint. 10/19/20 Initial inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 10/20/20 Mailed 30 day courtesy notice to the owner. 11/23/20 Re -inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 11/23/20 Posted property. 11/23/20 Mailed 10 day final notice to the owner, certified mail. 12/04/20 Final inspection was made, property was found to be in violation. 12/04/20 Verified ownership information with County of San Diego. 12/07/20 Work order authorization signed by District Official. 12/30/20 F.P.S.I. crews attempt to abate the property, found compliant. 01/07/21 Certified notice returned "unclaimed". 01/08/21 The owner was mailed an Adminitrative bill at the contracted rates. 02/09/21 The owner was mailed a final bill. 03/10/21 A Notice of Abatement was filed on the property. 05/21/21 The list of Fixed Charge Special Assessments [EXI-llBIT "Al and the City Clerk's "NOTICE OF PUBLIC CONFIRMATION OF COSTS HEARING" was served upon the property owner by means of Regular Mail, Certified Mail and Posting upon the property. 258 429 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: Denhle\ker Kenneth Parcel Number: 563 162 32 00 Address: 2815 (iro\ e St Date: 10/20/2020 National Cit), CA 91950 Location of Public Nuisance: 2815 Grote tit Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire properft of all weeds. dead vegetation, trash, dehris and arundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must he removed from the properts. (Please maintain am and all grasses below 3 inches Year round)(This includes along sidewalks and allevs1(Bougan ilia bush encroaching sidewalk:, You are hereby directed to abate the public nuisance described above, of which you are the occupant or owner, within thirty (301 days of 11U2111211211 "Your failure to comply with this order is dl result in the City having your property cleaned by the City's contractor at tour expense Ipet National C my Municipal C'odc Chapter I Zhu A $350 00 administrative lee will he charged in addition to the contractor's Dees 10 dean the property (per Resolution number 94-971 Violations arc also subject lit prosecution as misdemeanors Guidelines Fur I'he Abatement of Flammable \ cgctation for the protection of life and propeny. remote all brush, flammable vegetation, or combustible growth which is located Iron thirty (30) leer to one hundred (100) leer Inns such a building or structure or to the property lute, whichever is nearer. or as required by the Fire Department, including the maintenance ol grass and other vegetation more than tlun% (3(1) Rom such building or structure Cuttings arc to be removed from the propem and disposed of properly. Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches of the ground "\OT1( E. REGARDING K 1KE, IIIRE:1I ENLD OR F:\1.1\GI•:RF:D til'ECI F:1" If you have previously received a notice from the California Department of Fish and (lame or the V.S Fish and Wildlife Services that rare, threatened or endangered species ol Iish or wildlife have occurred on your property in the areas identified lox fuel break clearance. YOU MUST NOITFY BOfli AGI.NC•IFS AND 1 (11 NATIO?AI CI 11- I IRI DEPARTMI N I IN WRITING AT LEAST 1 EN 1 10) DAYS PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING IF TFIFSE A(jENCIL S FAII. ID OBJE(- I OR NCI I If \ VOL' ()1- ANY ALITRNATIVF. I'I(OC FDI -RES WI I'I IIN I IIOSE TEN (10) DAYS. YOU MAY TIIEN PROCEED TO CLEAR VE(il rATION AS DIREC I ED I3l I Ills NOTICE Failure to provide notification to Ihcsc agencies may render you Kahle under Federal or State Law to penalties National Pitt 1lunicinal ('ode 9.12.010 Public Nuisance Declared --In General Any of the lollo%%ing conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance A When the I ire C heel or hisItcr designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of rubbish. or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. boxes. shavings. or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger hie or property. or linds obstructions to or on lire escapes. stairs. passageways, doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the Lire department or the egress of the occtipants of such building of premises. or finds that the elTecti.cness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced. or linds that any pro% isual of the llnilorm Fire Code is hang violated B N hen the Fire Chief or has her designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stove. oven, incinerator. furnace or other heating de% ice, electric fixture or any appurtenance thereto, or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the [Hnili,mi Fire Code. to he defective or unsafe so as to create a hazard C N hen the fire Chief or fusilier designee finds any condition which in husfier Judgment increases or may cause an increase oldie hazard or menace of lire to a greater degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which nta% ohsiruct delay. hinder or Interfere w tilt the operations of the tire department or the egress of occupants in the event of Tire. \aiiunal tits tlunrcinal ( udc 9.12.0211 Public \uisancr Declared—%%rrds and Other Flammable 'Materials All weeds. crowing ur located upon streets. sidewalks or prat ate property are hereby declared to he a public nuisance For the purposes of this chapter "weeds" shall include the following A \'feeds which hear seeds of a downy ur %tangy nature 13 'sagebrush chaparral and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become. sshen dry, a lire menace to adjacent unproved propcny Weeds which are otherwise noxious or dangerous I) Nation oak and poison n y when the conditions o1 growth are such as to const0ute a menace the the public health F I)n grass. stubble. brush. litter. or other flammable material tvhteh endangers the public safety by creating a Tire hazard ui a portion (tithe City which has been toned lin single and multiple residence purposes National (ilv Municipal ('ode 1.36.11111 Public Nuisance Defined "Public !nuisance" me nos am condition dclined or declared to he a public nuisance in any section of this code, and.or and condition caused. maintained or pemutted to east which constitutes a threat to the public's health. safety and welfare or stInch signilicanlly obstructs. injures or interferes ssnh the reasonable of lice use of propertx in .1 neighborhood, cannnunrt% or Ise an% considerable number of persons :\ public nuisance also has the same meaning as set forth in California Civil Coale Section 3474 National City %Iunicinal Code 1.36.1(611 %batemcnl— Amaral— Dearing Within ten 110) days Irons the date of purling. mailing or personal service ol the required nonce, the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises ullccled may appeal to the City Council Such appeal shall he in wiring and shall he tiled with the City Clerk If you should have any questions, please feel free to call this number: 1-866-779-3774 Si usted licnealt;una pregunta. por favor flame al nuntcro: I-866-779-3"74 Sa anumang katanungan. aumawag lane pit sa nomernng ion: 1-866.7'9-3774 Sincerely yours in public safety "You have the right to appeajAkis matter to the C'ny Council within ten (1(11 days of the receipt of this notice 1-866-779-3774 eti. 3117 or htip:/rfrrepresention.nct The appeal shall be in writi6gInd tiled with the City Clerk (NCMC 1 36 050) ••'Fin• Preventinn ‘idsn,loec. In, is nniler rontrart uoh the i'ii ntNati inal i'rtt 430 of 592 NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT COMMON QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS ARE YOU THE CURRENT OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY? Yes 1 HAVE YOU CLEARED THIS PROPERTY SINCE THIS NOTICE? No DO YOU UNDERSTAND THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR ABATEMENT? Yes 1 HAVE YOU MADE ARRANGEMENTS TO ABATE THE PROPERTY? No —So Yes PROPERTY OWNERS ARE RESPONSIBIEFOR MAINTAINI NG HAZARD ABATEMENT ON A YEAR ROUND BASIS. (CALL RRE PREVENTION 1-866-779-3774 ttp://flreprevention.net f CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR .I RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net HAVE YOU THOROUGHLY IF YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND READ THE ABATEMENT EYes INSTRUCTIONS CALL FIRE PREVENTION. INSTRUCTIONS 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention.net WOULD YOU UKETHE CITY TO ABATE THE HAZARD FOR YOU?' IF NOT ABATED WITHIN TIME SPECFI ED TI* OWNER WLL BE CHARGED A$350.00 ADMFIISTRATIVE FEE. PLUS FIRE PREVENTION WLL ABATE. THE OWNER WILL BE BILLED FOR ALL COSTS Ye Yes — CALL RRE PREVENTION WHEN COMPLETED FOR RE -INSPECTION. 1-866-779-3774 http://fireprevention. net CALL RRE PREVENTION FOR ARRANGEMENTS. 1-866-77 9-37 74 http://flreprevention.net IF ARRANGEMENTS ARE MADE Pi31GB TO CITY ABATING HAZARD, THE ADMNISTRATIV E FEE MAY BE WAIVED. 333 E. 16th Street : National City, CA : 91950-4596 260 431 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES 1. Tractor Mowing A. per parcel, sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel, sized 7,501 to 15,000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel, sized 15,001 square feet to 30,000 square feet $400.00 D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.00 E. Per square foot over one acre $ 00.02 2. Hand Labor A. per square foot of area abated $ 00.10 3. Dozer Operation A. hourly rate $150.00 B. move -on fee $150.00 4. Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping, and or compacting $ 38.00 B. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) 5. Administrative Fee (failure to comply with final notice) A. per parcel 6. Attorney Services A. per parcel, per hour 7, Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. Cost confirmations fee, per parcel $350.00 $200.00 $275.00 8. Miscellaneous Fees A. special inspection fee $ 50.00 B. abatement lien $ 50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D release of abatement lien $ 50.00 E. public notary $ 20.00 F. File duplication fee $ 50.00 G. Unscheduled Labor per man hour $ 50.00 H, unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) 261 432 of 592 NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE 'i` 11123120 Re -Inspection 436 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd : NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 FINAL NOTICE TO ABATE PUBLIC NUISANCE Owner: f)enhleyker Kenneth Parcel Number: 563 162 32 00 Address: 2815 Grove St late: 11/23/2020 National Cit),. C'A 91950 Location of Public Nuisance: 28I5 Grove Si instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation, trash, debris and arundo..411 piles of dead vest etation and debris must he removed from the property. (Please maintain anv and allgrasses below 3 inches year round)[This includes along sidetyalks and alleysJjBouganvilla hush encroachingsidewalkl You are hereby directed to ahate the public nuisance described above, of which you are the occupant or owner, within ten (111) days of 1 I/23(21120 **Your failure to comply with this order will result in you being charged the administrative fee and the City having your property cleaned by the City's contractor at your expense (per National City Municipal Code Chapter 1.36). A $350.00 administrative lee will he charged in addition to the contractor's fees to clean the property trier Resolution number 94-97) Violations ate also subject to prosecution as misdemeanors. Guidelines For The Abatement of flammable Veletation For the protection of lite and property. renloxe all brush. flammable vegetation, or combustible growth which is located from thirty (30) loci to one hundred (1001 feet Pram such a building or structure or to the property line. whichever is nearer, or as required by the Fire Department, including the maintenance of grass and other segctaton inure than thirty (30) from such buikhng or structure. Cuttings arc to he removed from the property and disposed of properly. Vegetation is to he cut within two (2) inches attic ground "NOTICE REGARDING RAKE. THREA-TENED OK ENDANGERED Sl'EC'I4:S" If you have previously received a notice Irom the California Department of Fish and Game ur the U.S Fish and Wikllrlc Services that rare. threatened of endangered species of lish nr wildlife have occurred on your property in the areas identified for fuel break clearance. YOU MUST NOTIFY BOTIi AGENCIES AND TIIF NATIONAL l I 11 FIRE- i)ILPART MEN I IN WRITING AT LEAST TEN (10) DAYS PRIOR TO BEGINNING VEGETATION CLEARING. IF TiIESE AGENCIES FAIL. TO 013)1:C I NOTIFY YOU Of ANY Al 1 ERN.ATIVI: PROCEDURES WITHIN THOSE TEN (10) DAYS, YOU MAY THEN PROCEED TO ('TEAR VEGETATION AS DIRE(. 1.1 U )JY 11(IN NOIICI!' I ulure to provide notification to these agencies may render you liable under Federal or State Law to penalties. National Cits Municipal Code 9.12.010 Public NtliSiiIICe Declared --In General Any of the following conditions are hereby declared to constitute a public nuisance. A. When the Fire Chief or his/her designee determines that there exists in any building or on any premises combustible. hazardous or explosive materials or dangerous accumulations of ruhhish: or unnecessary accumulations of wastepaper. boxes, shavings. or any highly flammable materials which are so situated as to endanger life nr properly: or finds obstructions to or on tire escapes. stairs, passageways. doors or windows that reasonably tend to interfere with the operations of the fire department or the egress of the occupants of such building of premises: or finds that the effectiveness of any exit door. attic separation or any lire separation wall is reduced. or finds that any provision of the Uniform Fire Code is hcing y totaled B. When the Fire Chief or his/her Designee deems any chimney. smokestack. stove. oven. incinerator. furnace or other heating device. electric fixture or any appurtenance thereto. or anything regulated under a nationally recognized standard in or upon any building. structure or premises not specifically mentioned in the t infirm Fire Code. to he defective or unsafe so as to create a hazard. C. When the fire Chief or his/her designee finds any condition which in his/her judgment increases or may cause an increase (tithe hazard or menace of fire to a greaser degree that customarily recognized as normal by persons in the public service regularly engaged in preventing. suppressing or extinguishing lire or any thing or act which may ubstnict. delay. hinder or interfere with the operations of the lire department or the egress of occupants in the event afire. National tits !1Itmicip:rl (..:udc 9.12.021) Public Nuisance UeeIarcd--\1 eeds and Other Flammable %latcrials All weeds. growing ur located upon streets, sidewalks or private property are hereby declared to he a puhlic nuisance I or the purposes of this chapter. "oceds" shall include the litllosvmg, A Weeds which hear seeds of a downy or w•ingy nature B. Sagehnish, chaparral. and any other brush or weeds which attain such large growth as to become. when dry. a fire menace to adjacent improved propert' Weeds winch are otherwise noxious or dangerous. I). Poison oak and poison my w hen the conditions of growth are such as to constitute a menace the the puhlic health. E. Dry grass. stubble, knish, litter. or other flammable material which endangers the puhlic safety by creating a fire hazard in a portion of the City which has been zoned for single and multiple residence purposes National Cits \unicipal Code 1.36.0111 Public Nuisance Defined "Public Nuisance" means any condition defined or declared to he a puhlic nuisance in :any section of this code, and/or and condition caused. maintained or permitted to exist which constitutes a threat to the public's health, safety and welfare or which significantly obstructs. injures or interferes with the reasonable of free use of property in a nctuhborhood. community' or to any considerable number of persons. A puhlic nuisance also has the same meaning as set forth in Cahfomta Civil Code Section 3479. National Cits Municipal Code 1.36.116(1 Abatement--Anneal--Hearing Within ten (10) days from the date of posting. mailing or personal service of the required notice. the owner or person occupying or controlling such lot or premises affected may appeal to the City Council. Such appeal shall he in writing and shall he filed with the City Clerk Hypo should base any questions. please feel free to call this number: I-866-779-3774 Si usted lienealguna pregunta, par favor (lame al numbro: 1-866.779-3774 Sa antimang katanungan, ttnnasvag tang po set uumerung inn: 1-866-779-3774 Sincerely yours in puhlic safety **You have the right to appeal this matter to the City Council within ten (10) days of the receipt of this notice. 1-866-779-3774 est. 307 or http://ffrepreventiou.nct The appeal shall he in writing and tiled with the City Clerk (NCMC 1.36.050) ***Fire Prevcntu2n78erviccs. Inc. is under contract with the City of National City. Fire Prevention wen ices*** 04 N Fire Prevention Services P. O. Box 1720 El Cajon,_CA 92022-1720 FIRST NO , "'= /1- SECOND { w' IMPORTANT WEED & HAZARD RETURNEE _ ABATEMENT NOTICE INSIDE 11 i i 111 i 11 DJEG( nor 7rrM't use rcnss .ems 7019 2970 0002 0215 9460 RECEIVED JAN 0 7 2021 Owner: Denbleyker Kenneth Parcel Number: 563 1 Address: 2815 Grove St Date: 11/23/2020 NI I XIS �. S l National City, CA 91950 Location of Public Nuisance: 2815 Grove St Instructions for Abatement: Please clear the entire Dronerty oIaLLwt 1000 i i 11 i 91950 U.S.LETTERE PAID EL CAJON. CA 92020 AMOUN'r20 en OR R2304E105192-36 ;_0012j-311 ZZ RETURN TO SENDER UNCL AIMED LINABLE TO FORWARD c: 92822172020 *2204-81498 �I{II'111'I��Illlll'1111"Ilt'!I{!I"ll'I'!�ilE{li{f` 445 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY FIRE DEPARTMENT 1243 National City Blvd.: NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950-4596 WORK ORDER AUTHORIZATION Authorization # 7336 Owner: Denbleyker Kenneth Address: 2815 Grove St National City. CA 91950 Parcel #563 162 32 00 Job location:2815 Grove St Authorized by: (0 no(ck e5'C4 r-1 r f (S Signature: Date: /a/7 / a v WHEN SIGNED THIS DOCUMENT ALLOWS RIGHT OF PASSAGE ONTO PRIVATE PROPERTY FOR THE PURPOSE OF FIRE VIOLATION / PUBLIC NUISANCE REDUCTION OR REMOVAL. METHOD OF CLEARING Entire Parcel Fire Break Hand Cutting: sq. ft. Removal: cu. yds. Tractor Mowing: sq. ft. Discing: sq. ft. CREW INFORMATION Crew Date Type: Type: Type: Type: Notes: Please clear the entire property of all weeds, dead vegetation trash, debris andarundo. All piles of dead vegetation and debris must be removed from the property. (Please maintain any and all grasses below 3 inches year round)(This includes along sidewalks and alleys)(Bouganvilla bush encroaching sidewalk) 275 446 of 592 06 RANGES i'itmmo== 55 P^i@, :q 2m as �9o,3&z%m�� NN O1 Nd O � V Y Mq�� 4 q kyhN9 V O p =y2 L q `h rvv; Y „.) N N N CV K1 y n ti eNNNNNNN N N M LI '2 2y VISTA SO L INCOLN WAY CT ti•. x 1 , YGY Rn• - 5e3'. ,1 IS 5HT. ZOF2 THIS MAP WAS PREPARED FOR ASSESSMENT PURPOSES ONLY NO LIABILITY IS ASSUMED FOR THE ACCURACY OF THE DATA SHOWN. ASSESSOR'S PARCELS MAY NOT COMPLY WITH LOCAL SUBDIVISION OR BUILDING ORDINANCES_ e SHT1 tNTERSTATE 805 • POR 117N 2.115 r- SEE DETAIL •yza•a, •x- " POR 148 \ f• H W Y„ - OP _ n . M 17411 . acis - Td 1 5 •$YIYa+ s �rr+•ss•e UN "O/ » sT W.1.1.23 YI Pass NATIONAL CITY MAP 1745 - L1 NCOLN ACRES ANNEX MAP 1740- LINCOLN ACRES ROS 14305, 14511 , 21189 563 —16 SHT 20F2 1'.100 vtaa ` .POR 148 M1745 eh ti Ya� `A"_�Poa. 148 s M 1745 et DETAIL SCALE =� 276 447 of 592 12/30/20 Compliant 448 of 592 12/30/20 Compliant 278 449 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://fireprevention.net ADMINISTRATIVE BILL 1/8/2021 Denbleyker Kenneth 2815 Grove St National City. CA 91950 Parcel # 563 162 32 00 Location: 2815 Grove St Dear Denbleyker Kenneth. Fire Prevention Services has been contracted by the City of National City to help reduce potential lire violations thus improving the safety of its citizens. Your property was re -inspected on 12/4/2020 and found to still be in violation of the National C it Municipal Code Chapter 1.36. As stated in the notice, if the violation is not corrected prior to the deadline you will be charged an administrative fee. Due to the abatement not being completed by the deadline. you are being charged the administratk e fee. Thus far your bill is $ 350 and must be paid within fifteen (15) days of this notice. Please note the above referenced property is still in violation and is subject to abatement and additional charges. Please make check payable to F.P.S.I. and please include the File # 563 162 32 00 on the check. Ifyou have any questions please call us direct at (619) 562-1058. Sincerely. Fire Prevention Services. Inc. http://fireprevention.net rev .05/ l 9/06 279 450 of 592 NATIONAL CITY SCHEDULE OF FEES Tractor Mowinu A. per parcel. sized 1 to 7,500 square feet $250.00 B. per parcel. sized 7.501 to 15.000 square feet $325.00 C. per parcel. sized 15,001 square Meet to 30,000 square feet $400.0O D. per parcel, sized 30,001 square feet to one acre $450.0O E. per square foot over one acre $00.02 I land Labor A. per square foot of area abated Dozer Operation A. hourly rate 13. move -on fee quantity sub total $0.10 scq. Ft. $150.00 $150.00 Debris Remediation (includes chipping, grinding, and/or shredding) A. per cubic yard of material prior to chipping. and or compacting $38.00 X cu.yds - 13. dump fees (reimbursement of cost) Administrative Fee (failure to comply by deadline of notice) \. per parcel $350.00 1 $350.00 Attorney Services A. per parcel. per hour Assessment Fees (includes preparing reports, attending hearings, etc.) A. cost confirmation fee. per parcel $200.00 $275.00 Miscellaneous Fees Per Parcel A. special inspection fee $50.00 I3. abatement lien $50.00 C. Interest on lien (apr) 10% D. release of abatement lien $50.0O E. public notary $20.00 I . file duplication fee $50.00 G. unscheduled Labor per man hour $50.00 1-1. unscheduled fees (reimbursement of cost) FILE # 7336 APN # 563 162 32 TOTAL S 350.00 280 451 of 592 Fire Prevention Services, Inc. P.O. Box 1720 : El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 : fax (619) 445-6336 http://firepre‘ention.net Final Bill 2/9/2(121 Denhleyker Kenneth 2815 Grove St National City. CA 91950 Ref: Parcel # 563 162 32 00 Dear Denhleyker Kenneth. COPY This is a reminder of the letter we sent you on 1/8/2021 and we have not received payment in the amount of $350.00 If we do not receive payment within 10 days we will he required to seek appropriate action to collect these monies. This action may include tiling an abatement lien on your property and forwarding this hill to our collection agency. Under state and local law. costs for such action will he added to your total amount. Please tender a check to us immediately to avoid any further action. Make your check payable to Fire Prevention Services, Inc., and include the Parcel # 563 162 32 00 on the check. Should you need to discuss this matter you may contact us at (619) 562-1(158. Sincerer. Fire Prevention Services. Inc. rev.05 19:06 281 452 of 592 RECORDING REQUESTED BY Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 (619) 562-1058 fax (619) 445-6336 AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO Fire Prevention Services, Inc. PO Box 1720 El Cajon, CA 92022-1720 DOC# 2021-0229237 1IIIIII II IIII III IIII IIIII IIII In1111111III IIIIIIIII1111 I Mar 24, 2021 02:36 PM OFFICIAL RECORDS Ernest J Dronenburg, Jr., SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER FEES: $0.00 (SB2 Atkins: $0.00) PAGES: 1 NOTICE OF ABATEMENT TO THE CURRENT OWNER OF RECORD AND ANY FUTURE OWNERS/PURCHASERS OF THE HEREIN DESCRIBED PROPERTY WHEREAS it was determined that a violation of Chapter 1.36 of the National City Municipal Code did exist, and WHEREAS such violation was ordered abated on 12/7/2020, and WHEREAS representatives of the National City Fire Department abated the violation(s) on 1 2/30/2020, and WHEREAS the charge for such abatement amounted to $420.00; THEREFORE be it known that an abatement obligation exists on the property regardless of owner until paid. The current owner of the property is Denbleyker Kenneth at 2815 Grove St, National City, CA 91950 described as follows: APN tt 563 162 32 00 ADDRESS: 2815 Grove St LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 57 Tr 1740 This abatement obligation shall attach to the property, not the owner, and may not be extinguished by a tax sale under the California Revenue and Taxation Code Section 3712. After confirmation by the City Council shall become a special assessment on the property tax hill. If not paid pursuant to State Law and State Fax Lien Law, the property may be sold to satisfy that obligation. The amount of such claim shall he plus interest and other costs which may hereafter become due. This filing does not preclude the filing of legal action for collection. Should such actions he required or determined to be appropriate. reasonable legal fees will he incurred and added to said obligation. DATED: March 10. 2021 BY: Ken Osborn, Fire Prevention Services, Inc., Designee for National City Fire Department Certificate Of Acknowledgement A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the identity of the individual who signed the document, to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accuracy, or validity of that document. State of California County of San Diego ) On March 10, 2021 before me R Thrasher, Notary Public, personally appeared Ken Osborn, who proved to inc on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies). and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted. executed the instrument. 1 certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WI SS my h. s/.nd offici.seal. ilii[t� : Carmtlalon No. 2332261 > (Seal) /IOTARY PUBLIC - CALIFORNIA SAN OIE00 COUNTY CaNnialon Woo Augusta, 2024 282 453 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Public Hearing and adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City confirming the assessment and ordering the levy for Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) for Fiscal Year 2020/21. (Planning) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 454 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO.: ITEM TITLE: Public Hearing and adoption of a Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City confirming the assessment and ordering the levy for Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) for Fiscal Year 2020/21. PREPARED BY: Martin Reeder, Principal Planner DEPARTMENT: Comm Development APPROVED BY: PHONE: 619-336-4421 Armando _ - ara, Director EXPLANATION: The City formed the Mile of Cars Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 in 1995 to provide for the maintenance, operations, and servicing of certain improvements in the District, including landscaping, signage, and lighting. Each year, the City Council considers the adoption of a resolution to allow the District to continue operating with funding through a special tax levy on properties within the District. The resolution would confirm the assessment and order the levy on behalf of the District for Fiscal Year 2021/22 based on the Engineers Report that identifies the assessment to be levied and the work program to be conducted by the Mile of Cars Landscape Maintenance District. The Mile of Cars Association has approved the scope of work, the proposed assessment, and the District budget. There are no changes or additions to the maintained improvements for the coming fiscal year. The proposed total assessment of $155,463.48 is the same as the prior year's total assessment. The City's consultant and City administrative costs are paid from the District's assessment funds. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: Assessment funds received from the County Tax Collector are transferred to account 195-0000-3007 for distribution to the Mile of Cars Association, less City inistrative costs. APPROVED: FINANCE ACCOUNT NO. APPROVED: MIS ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: This activity is not a project as defined in Section 15378 of the California Code of Regulations; therefore, no further action is required under the California Environmental Quality Act. ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION FINAL ADOPTION Not applicable. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution confirming the assessment and ordering the levy. BOARD 1 COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Engineer's Report. 2. Resolution. 455 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY Fiscal Year 2021/22 Engineer's Report For: Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) March 2021 Prepared by: MNBS helping communities fund tomorrow nbsgov.com 1 Corporate Headquarters 32605 Temecula Parkway, Suite 100 Temecula, CA 92592 Toll free. 456 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 (MILE OF CARS) 1243 National City Boulevard National City, CA 91950 Phone - (619) 336-4241 Fax - (619) 336-4239 CITY COUNCIL Alejandra Sotelo-Solis, Mayor Jose Rodriguez, Vice Mayor Marcus Bush, Councilmember Mona Rios, Councilmember Ron Morrison, Councilmember CITY STAFF Brad Raulston, City Manager Tony Winney, Deputy City Manager Martin Reeder, Principal Planner DISTRICT STAFF Leslie Larranaga-Britt, Executive Director NBS Pablo Perez, Project Director Adina McCargo, Project Manager John Egan, Assessment Engineer 2 457 of 592 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1, Engineer's Letter 1 2. Overview 2 2.1 Introduction 2 2.2 Description of the District Boundaries 2 2.3 Description of Improvements 2 2.4 Description of Maintenance 3 3. Estimate of Costs 4 3.1 District Budget 4 3.2 Reserves 4 4. Assessment Diagram 6 5. Assessments 7 5.1 Method of Apportionment 7 5.2 Maximum Annual Assessment Rates 11 5.3 Assessment Roll 12 3 458 of 592 1. ENGINEER'S LETTER WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of National City (the "City"), State of California, directed NBS to prepare and file a report presenting plans and specifications describing the general nature, location and extent of the improvements to be maintained, an estimate of the costs of the maintenance, operations and servicing of the improvements for the City's Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) (the "District") for Fiscal Year 2021/22. The report includes a diagram for the District, showing the area and properties proposed to be assessed, an assessment of the estimated costs of the maintenance, operations and servicing the improvements, and the net amount upon all assessable lots and/or parcels within the District in proportion to the special benefit received and WHEREAS, the assessment for each parcel is in compliance with the Proposition 218 Omnibus Implementation Act and Section 4 of Article XIII D of the California Constitution. The Fiscal Year 2021/22 assessment is not proposed to increase by more than the 10% annual increase approved at formation of the District over the Fiscal Year 2020/21 maximum assessment. NOW THEREFORE, only special benefits are assessed and any general benefits have been separated from the special benefits for purposes of this report. The following assessment is made to cover the portion of the estimated costs of maintenance, operation and servicing of said improvements to be paid by the assessable real property within the District in proportion to the special benefit received: Summary of Assessment Fiscal Year 2021/22 Amounts Annual Budget $169,665.40 (Less) General Benefit Contribution by the City (14,201.92) Annual Assessment' $155,463.48 1) Amount shown is prior to truncating and rounding. Refer to Assessment Roll in Section 5.3 for final total figure. I, the undersigned, respectfully submit the enclosed Engineer's Report and, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, the assessments herein have been prepared and computed in accordance with the assessment methodology adopted and approved by the City Council at the time of District formation. N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 4 John Egan, Assessment Engineer 459 of 592 2. OVERVIEW 2.1 Introduction The City formed the District in 1995 to provide maintenance services to benefit certain parcels in the City. The levies are made pursuant to the provisions of the Landscaping and Lighting Act of 1972, Part 2 of Division 15 of the California Streets and Highway Code (the "Act"). The City designated the Mile of Cars Association as the entity that maintains and administers the improvements and services funded by the District. The Engineer's Report (the "Report") describes the District and the annual assessment per parcel for Fiscal Year 2021/22, which is based on the historical and estimated costs to maintain the improvements and provide the services that benefit parcels within the District. The word "parcel," for the purposes of this Report, refers to an individual property assigned its own Assessor's Parcel Number by the San Diego County Assessor's Office. The San Diego County Auditor - Controller uses Assessor's Parcel Numbers and specific Fund Numbers to identify on the tax roll, properties assessed for special district benefit assessments. Following consideration of public comments at a noticed public hearing, and following review of the Report, the City Council may confirm the Report as submitted, and may order the levy and collection of assessments for Fiscal Year 2021/22. If approved, the assessment information shall be submitted to the County Auditor -Controller, and included on the property tax roll for each benefiting parcel for Fiscal Year 2021/22. 2.2 Description of the District Boundaries The District's improvements are generally located along National City Boulevard and bounded by 18th Street to the north and 33rd Street and State Route 54 (SR 54) to the south. 2.3 Description of Improvements A general description of the improvements to be maintained under these proceedings is described as follows, but, shall not be limited to: 1. Median Improvements Landscape planting and irrigation Colored concrete hardscape Lighting system Graphic panels, banners and signage Painted crosswalks Identification sign at 23rd Street and McKinley Avenue M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 5 460 of 592 2. Frontage Improvements Improvements to parkways on both sides of National City Boulevard between 18th Street and 33rd Street Landscape planting and irrigation Colored concrete sidewalks and mow curbs Street furniture 2.4 Description of Maintenance The maintenance of the improvements shall include the furnishing of services and materials for the ordinary and usual maintenance and servicing of the improvements, including but shall not be limited to: 1. General Plant Maintenance Mowing, trimming, pruning and weeding Watering, including water usage Fertilizing Plant replacement Periodic skinning of palm trees 2. Maintenance of Irrigation System Adjustment of timers Repair/replacement of worn-out, stolen or malfunctioning equipment 3. Periodic restriping of decorative crosswalks 4. Periodic repainting of metal benches and trash receptacles 5. Periodic repainting and repair of light poles, graphic panels, signage and other miscellaneous equipment 6. Maintenance of electrical system Bulb replacement Repair/replacement of worn out or malfunctioning equipment Electrical energy charges 7. Litter removal 8. Trash pick-up 9. Other repairs of damage caused by vandalism and/or traffic accidents M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 6 461 of 592 3. ESTIMATE OF COSTS 3.1 District Budget The cost of servicing, maintaining, repairing and replacing the improvements as described in the Description of Maintenance are summarized in the table below. Estimated expenditures are shown along with the incidental expenses to be funded by the District. The following table summarizes the components that make up the Fiscal Year 2021/22 estimate of costs for the District: Description Median Frontage Improvements Improvements Total Maintenance Costs 1. Lawn planting care 2. Median planting care 3. Palm tree maintenance 4. Water usage 5. Refurbishment of graphic panels 6. General maintenance of electrical system/lights 7. Electrical usage 8. Refurbishment of decorative crosswalks 9. Reserves Total Cost of Annual Maintenance: Incidental Expenses A. Administration B. Other contractual obligationsili C. Engineering D City expenses E. Consultant fees F. County collection fees Total Incidentals: $0.00 21,863.06 7,500.00 13,836.67 20,000.00 3,046.11 15,000.00 250.00 250.00 $81,745.84 $3,750.00 4,950.00 0.00 2,750.00 250.00 2.30 $11,702.30 $42,678.29 0.00 7,500.00 13,836.67 0.00 0.00 0.00 250.00 250.00 $64,514.96 $3,750.00 4,950.00 0.00 2,750.00 250.00 2.30 $11,702.30 $42,678.29 21,863.06 15,000.00 27,673.34 20,000.00 3,046.11 15,000.00 500.00 500.00 $146,260.80 $7,500.00 9,900.00 0.00 5,500.00 500.00 4.60 $23,404.60 Total Estimated Annual Cost: $93,448.14 $76,217.26 $169,665.40 (Less) General Benefit Contribution&2 : ($7,937.52) ($6,264.40) ($14,201.92) TOTAL ANNUAL ASSESSMENT(3): $85,510.62 $69,952.86 $155,463.48 (1) (2) (3) Includes legal, accounting and advertising. General benefit contribution will be funded from other sources and is not being paid from annual assessments. Amounts shown are prior to truncating and rounding. Refer to Assessment Roll in Section 5.3 for final total figure. 3.2 Reserves The City may establish and collect reserve funds for the District in order to pay for the maintenance and servicing of the improvements prior to December 10 of the fiscal year, or whenever the City expects to receive its apportionment of special assessments and tax collections from the County, whichever is later. N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 7 462 of 592 The fund may be allowed to accumulate in anticipation of any unforeseen expenses not included in the yearly maintenance costs. The following table details the current and projected reserve balances: Reserve Balance Reserve Collection/Reduction Reserve Balance Projection 12/31/2020(1) for FY 2021/22 6/30/2022 $98,249.00 $500.00 $98,749.00 (1) A portion of the amount shown ($2,284) is reserve funds held by the City. The remaining portion of reserve funds is held by the District. Z NBS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 8 463 of 592 4. ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM The Assessment Diagram sets forth (a) the exterior boundaries of the District and (b) the lines of each lot or parcel of land within the District. The Assessment Diagram further identifies each lot or parcel by a distinctive number or letter. For a detailed description of the lines and dimensions of any lot or parcel, reference is made to the County Assessor's Map applicable for the next fiscal year, which map shall govern for all details concerning the lines and dimensions of such lots or parcels. The following pages provide a copy of the Amended Assessment Diagram for the District. M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 9 464 of 592 FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE cITY CLERK OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY R AS DAY of 1990_ CITY CLERK CITY or NATIONAL Q7Y STATE OF CALIFORNIA RECORDED tN THE OFFICE CF THE SUPFRMITENDENT OF STREETS OF IRE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY THIS DAY OF , t996. SUPERINTENDENT OF STREETS CITY OF NATIONAL aTY STATE OF CALIFORNIA AN ASSESSMENT WAS LET'IET/ 0Y THE CITY COUNCIL ON 11$ LOTS. PIECES. AND PARCELS OF LAND SHOWN ON Ws ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM. 5A10 ASSESSMENT WAS LEVIED 0T1 THE DAY OF 1990: SAID ASSESSMENT DfAGRAM AND TIE ASSESSMENT ROLL WERE RECDROED IN THE OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT OF STREETS OF SAOIO CITY OH 104E DAY OF 1996. REFERENCE IS MADE TO THE ASSESSMENT ROLL RECORDED N THE OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT OF STREETS FOR THE EXACT AMOUNT OF EACH ASSESSMENT LEVIED AGAINST EACH PARCEL OF LAND SHOWN oN THR ASSESSIENT DIAGRAM. CITY 511211 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY STATE OF CALIFORNIA FILED THIS DAY OF 1996, AT THE HOUR OF O'CLOCK _.M. 1N BOOK __Of MAPS OF ASSESSMENT AND COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICTS IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF THE COUNTY Of SAN DECO, CAL0FORNIA. COUNTY RECEROER COUNTY OF SAN DEGO STATE OF CALIFORNIA AMENDED ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM OF LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO.1(MILE OF CARS) CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO STATE OF CALIFORNIA 2D1 560-20]-01 560-20N-0O EXTERIOR DOUIIOARY CF DISTRICT REVISED 8-1-96 REVISED 6-11-97 REVISED 6-19-02 REVISED 6-09-03 REVISE) 5-26-04 ta0 0 100 200 000 400 SHEET 1 OF 3 SHEETS 190' 560-303—Dl N ONCOU OF EACH PARCEL IS BASED SHOWN CURRENT COUNTY ASSESSOR'S FOOT. MAPS ER SHOWN PARCEL TO THE NEAREST FOOT. REFER TO ASSESSOR'S PARCEL MAPS FOR PROPERTY DIMENSIONS NOT SHOWN. NASLAND ENGINEERING 540 9. 6N mamma . lt7REGY1RG • LA00 PIARmHG 4010 RORner llreel. 5** Olye, C.Rfeenle, PJ.III • 010-2*g—'ln0 10 NOTE: ORIGINAL SHEET SIZE 18" x 26' 465 of 592 N.E. JOB No. 105-148 AMENDED ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM OF LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. 1 (MILE OF CARS) CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO STATE OF CALIFORNIA 560-330-03 591' NATIONAL BOULEVARD 562-021-01 100' 502-021-07 160' 562-340-fig TRANSPORTATION AVENUE 502-031-1 t Ida' 362-031-as 110' W2-349-70 0 100 I 1 1 562-090-06 270' Di NATIONAL 1e+ 562-340-47 EXTERIOR 50VN0A6 Of 1:110TH1GT REVISED 8-1-96 REVISED 6-11-97 REVISED 6-19-02 REVISED 6-09-03 REVISED 5-26-04 0 100 200 } sou SHEET 2 OF 3 SI1L± I 562-100-44 lay 562--100-13 135• BOULEVARD 436' 562--340-48 \J 400 1HL iial/ACE OF EA7I Pf61� IS HASP) 1JPON MpRRRENT EOON TO THE YNEARESTF001. APREFEROSWIM TO 615ESSOAS PARER HAPS 60R PROaERT? 041E1119045 HOT SM0'MN. NASLAND ENGINEERING CISO. E21011166Rmo0 • 0ORFCTe0 • 1.4140 KLANRINO 1740 IMR1ur Street, inn INe=e. Cn6lernie. 92111 • 610-222-7770 11 NOTE: ORIGINAL SHEET SIZE 18' x 266' 466 of 592 N.E. JOB No. 105-148 AMENDED ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM OF LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE DISTRICT NO. i (MILE OF CARS) CITY OF NATIONAL CITY 562-160-07 300' 562-190-32 562-190-33 92' 127 30d 562-340-09 209' 562-150-13 TORrATION AVENUE 562-25i-52 20 COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO STATE OF CALIFORNIA 562-25r-36 16T NATIONAL CITY i3oULEVARD 230 562-220-13 1 562-252-15 330' EXTERIOR 80UNDARv OF DISTRICT 562-321•-07 152` 249. 562-330-35 N ONTACE OF EAG1 PARCEL 13 a 5i0 UPON CURRENT COUNTY ASSESSOR'S VAR'S AND VOW HEREON M RR FOTSO s OT s D11*4 5 100 100 SOD 700 SOD 3 SHtt i 3 OF 3 SHEETS REVISED 8-1-96 REVISED 6-11-97 REVISED 6-19-02 REVISED 6-09-03 REVISED 5-26-04 NASLAND ENGINEERING Mil. ENGINEERING - 9L01tLYING - URD PLINRIOG 1710 Rolfe.' gown. Sae Clete. California. P2)11 • e10-Zo2-*+m 12 NOTE: ORIGINAL SHEET SIZE 18' x 26' 467 of 592 N.E. JOB No. 105-f48 5. ASSESSMENTS The actual assessments for Fiscal Year 2021/22, apportioned to each parcel as shown on the latest equalized roll at the County Assessor's office, are listed and submitted at the end of this section. The description of each lot or parcel is part of the records of the County Assessor of the County of San Diego and such records are, by reference, made part of this Report. 5.1 Method of Apportionment The law requires and the statutes provide that assessments, as levied pursuant to the provisions of the Act, must be based on the benefit that the properties receive from the improvements to be maintained. The statute does not specify the method or formula that should be used in any special assessment district proceedings. The responsibility rests with the Assessment Engineer, who is appointed for the purpose of making an analysis of the facts and determining the correct apportionment of the assessment obligation. The figures in section 5.1 are derived from a Special v. General Benefit Analysis performed in Fiscal Year 2013/14. 5.1.1 IDENTIFY THE BENEFIT First, it is necessary to identify the benefit that the improvements to be maintained will render to the properties within the boundaries of the District. The improvements significantly improve the visual appearance of the streetscape, making the Mile of Cars a more enjoyable and desirable location for customers. The special signage and lighting provide a unifying theme, benefiting all of the properties within the District. The District's improvements and services provide benefits to both those properties within the District boundaries and to the community. The benefit conferred to property within the District will be referred to as an "aesthetic benefit." The aesthetic benefit provided by the district improvements and services are supported by the City's General Plan (the "Plan") and the Citywide Goals and Policies regarding Land Use and Community Character for its districts. The Plan states a desire to, "have the community character integrated and to ensure that physical forms, patterns, and aesthetic features advance the City's desire for a higher quality of life." The aesthetic benefits provided by the improvements and services support the following City policies outlined in the Plan: Policy LU-5.3: Recognize the diverse needs of the City's business districts through the development of policies, design guidelines, and implementation measures specific to the unique requirements of each district. Policy LU-5.4: Allow for adaptive reuse of vacant car dealerships and the establishment of new compatible uses along the Mile of Cars. Policy LU-5.9: Encourage members of the business community to participate in implementing actions to improve business districts. Policy LU-5.10: Assist the business community in evaluating the City's marketing and development potential and in identifying development strategies that are beneficial to the public and private sectors. M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 13 468 of 592 Policy LU-9.1: Design developments along mixed -use and "community corridors" for the comfort and enjoyment of pedestrians and bicyclists. This includes features such as street trees, placing buildings close to the street, de-emphasizing parking lots and garages, limited driveway cuts, traffic -calming features, clearly defined street crossings, adequate lighting, and street furnishings where appropriate. Policy LU-9.4: Encourage an overall high -quality streetscape design, where feasible, that promotes narrow roadways, bike lanes; on -street parking, minimal curb cuts; enhanced crosswalks; appropriate sidewalk widths, landscaped medians and parkways; street trees, planters, and wells; street lighting; street furniture; way finding; enhanced paving; public art; and other features that contribute to the desired character for the City, where appropriate. Policy LU-11.2: Identify gateways at major entrances to the City using such features as buildings, street trees, welcome signs, decorative lighting, archways, and other design techniques to announce the gateway. Policy LU-11.4: Recognize, maintain, and enhance the character and identity of residential neighborhoods and business districts. Policy LU-11.7: Encourage residential and businesses to clean and maintain their properties and public spaces to further a sense of ownership and community pride. Policy LU-11.8: Require the sensitive placement, screening, and/or treatment of utility meters, boxes, valves, vaults, switches, plumbing, wiring, fences, etc. to eliminate or minimize the aesthetic impact to the neighborhood. Policy LU-11.9: Encourage the improvement of existing signage to help promote a more attractive street scene in business districts. The Plan states these policies are important because a positive community image and quality community design instills a sense of pride and well-being in the community. The aesthetic benefit attained as a result of the services and improvements provided by the District is detailed below. 5.1.2 AESTHETIC BENEFIT The aesthetic benefit relates to an improvement in the District's visual appearance as a result of the District improvements and services. The beautification of property within the District can best be described as the ability for the property within the District to develop and operate at the property's highest and best use. Properties within the District receive the following aesthetic benefits as a result of the District's improvements and services: Uniform and up-to-date streetscape and median and frontage improvements create cohesion throughout the District from 18th Street to SR 54. This District cohesion enhances the experience for all stakeholders. The improvements and services enhance the community identity of the Mile of Cars area, which will lead to a stronger and healthier street corridor. The image of the Mile of Cars area is improved by maintaining the median and frontage improvements. The District revitalizes and beautifies the Mile of Cars area. This revitalization encourages new business development and existing business retention and expansion which overall reduces vacancies and increases lease rates for property, more specifically, the auto dealerships located within the District. M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 14 469 of 592 The streetscape improvements encourage an increase in activity throughout the District. The Mile of Cars area becomes more pedestrian -friendly, thus improving activity for residents and businesses alike. Upgraded median and frontage amenities provided by the District enhance the appearance, desirability, and experience of the properties directly fronting the improvements provided throughout the District. The streetscape improvements add aesthetic value to property adjacent to the improvements, but the improvements also make the property appear more stable and prosperous. The aesthetic benefit received by properties within the District assists each property in developing and operating at its highest and best use. 5.1.3 SEPARATION OF GENERAL BENEFIT Section 4 of Article XIIID of the California Constitution provides that once a local agency which proposes to impose assessments on property has identified those parcels that will have special benefits conferred upon them and upon which an assessment will be imposed, the local agency must then "separate the general benefits from the special benefits conferred," and only the special benefits can be included in the amount of the assessments imposed. General benefit is an overall and similar benefit to the public at large resulting from the improvements and services to be provided. The District improvements and maintenance services, which are more fully presented in Section 2 of this Report, will be provided within the District boundaries only. There will be no improvements or maintenance services provided by the District outside of the District boundaries. The District provides aesthetic benefits to the properties within the District. However, it is recognized that the District also provides a level of benefit to some property and businesses within close proximity to the District, as well as visitors and individuals passing through the District. Vehicular and pedestrian traffic from property within and outside of the District, as well as individuals passing through the Mile of Cars area, will be able to enjoy the improvements and maintenance services. Therefore, it is necessary to quantify the general benefits created as a result of the District improvements and services. A Special v. General Benefit Analysis was performed in Fiscal Year 2013/14 to quantify said general benefits. 5.1.4 QUANTIFICATION OF GENERAL BENEFIT As previously mentioned, general benefit is an overall and similar benefit to the public at large resulting from the improvements and services which are funded by the assessment revenue. The District improvements and maintenance services will be provided within the District boundaries only. There will be no improvements or maintenance services provided by the District outside of the District boundaries. General benefits accrue to individuals "walking through" the District and to vehicles "passing through" the District. Individuals walking through the District are typically people who live in close proximity and whose origin or destination neither begins with nor ends at a parcel within the District. Any walking that begins with or ends at a parcel within the District are considered part of the special benefit for those parcels within the boundaries of the District. Vehicles passing through the District are those vehicles whose origin or destination neither begins with nor ends at a parcel within the District. Any vehicle trips that begin with or end at a parcel within the District M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 15 470 of 592 are considered part of the special benefit for those parcels within the boundaries of the District. For the purposes of this analysis, it was determined that the general benefit quantification should be focused on vehicle trips passing through the District because National City Boulevard is a major thoroughfare which connects and provides access to SR 54. To quantify and separate the amount of general benefit received by the general population as a result of the improvements and services provided by the assessment revenue, it has been determined that general benefits accrue mainly to vehicles "passing through" the District. Meaning, any vehicle using the City's streets that lie within the boundaries of the District that is coming or going to a parcel within the District ultimately is not part of the "general public" benefitting from the proposed improvements and services. Accordingly, the separation of general benefits from special benefits will be measured by that estimated portion of vehicle trips "passing through" the District. In order to determine the estimated portion of the vehicle trips "passing through" the District, trip generation data was collected for each parcel within the boundaries of the District using San Diego County assigned land use codes and property characteristics. Each land use code was categorized and located in the ITE Trip Generation Manuals — 2nd Edition. Using the property characteristics and data gathered from the ITE Trip Generation Manuals, the estimated amount of Average Daily Trips (ADT) was calculated for each parcel within the boundaries of the District. The ADT were then added together for each parcel within the boundaries of the District to arrive at a total amount of vehicle trips generated by the District, which equaled 13,385 ADT. The total average vehicle trips were then compared to the average vehicle trip generation data detailed in the City of National City Comprehensive Land Use Update (Transportation and Circulation) for the streets running through the District, which equaled 14,825 ADT. The comparison concluded that 90.29% of all vehicle trips passing through the District were coming or going to a parcel within the boundaries of the District, hence 90.29% of all vehicle trips passing through the District are designated as benefiting from the special benefits provided by the District. As a result, 9.71% of all vehicle trips passing through the District are general in nature and hence, do not receive any special benefit from the District. Pursuant to the Special v. General Benefit Analysis performed in Fiscal Year 2013/14, 9.71% of the benefits of the services are considered general benefit. Accordingly, 90.29% of the benefit from the improvements and services are considered to provide special benefit to the properties within the District and thus are subject to the assessment. 5.1.5 APPORTIONMENT OF COSTS In further making the analysis, it is necessary that the property owners receive a special and direct benefit distinguished from that of the general public. In this case, an in-depth analysis was performed and several factors are being used in the final method and spread of assessment. All of the improvements are intended to be of direct benefit to properties within the District. These improvements require significantly more maintenance than normally provided by the City. It is therefore appropriate that the properties receiving the benefit be assessed for the additional cost. Lineal frontage was assigned as the assessment variable by the original assessment engineer because all of the special aesthetic benefits received by properties within the District from the improvements and services provided, using revenues from the annual assessment levy, can be quantified best by identifying M N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 16 471 of 592 the lineal frontage of the property along National City Boulevard. Lineal frontage is a tangible property characteristic that clearly ties the aesthetic benefits received by parcels within the District to the amount of frontage of each property, which is where the aesthetic benefit is to be received and realized. The improvements and maintenance services being provided to and enjoyed by the parcels within the District provide an aesthetic benefit not provided to any parcels outside of the District boundaries. The annual assessment is based upon a parcel's lineal frontage unless otherwise identified by the original assessment engineer, as previously approved by property owners at the formation of the District. There are generally two categories of improvements to be maintained by the District — the median improvements and the frontage improvements. The median improvements benefit all properties within the District. The improvements to the parkway (referred to herein as Frontage Improvements) benefit those properties which they abut. The specific method of spreading the assessment is described below: 5.1.6 MEDIAN IMPROVEMENTS 1. The total cost for maintenance of the Median Improvements is apportioned to all parcels in the District and is based on the frontage of each parcel along National City Boulevard. 2. Parcel 32 (APN 562-220-11) does not have frontage on National City Boulevard, but receives some benefit from median improvements and maintenance services benefiting properties within the boundaries of the District. As a result, the original assessment engineer determined that the parcel received a lower level of benefit and therefore assigned 100 frontage feet of benefit to the parcel. 5.1.7 FRONTAGE IMPROVEMENTS 1. The total cost for maintenance of the Frontage Improvements is apportioned to all parcels in the District and is based on the frontage of each parcel along National City Boulevard. 2. Parcel 32 (APN 562-220-11) does not have frontage on National City Boulevard. As such, Parcel 32 receives no benefit from the frontage improvements. 3. The frontage of each parcel is determined from current Assessor's maps for the County of San Diego, State of California. All frontage dimensions have been rounded to the nearest foot. 5.2 Maximum Annual Assessment Rates The maximum annual assessment to be levied on all properties within the District in any fiscal year shall be subject to an annual escalation of up to 10% based upon actual and anticipated expenditures. N BS City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 17 472 of 592 The following table shows the historical maximum annual assessment rates. Fiscal Year Percentage Increase Maximum Frontage Rate Per Frontage Foot Maximum Median Rate Per Frontage Foot Total Maximum Rate Per Frontage Foot'l) Total Actual Rate Per Frontage Footle' Actual Percentage Increase 1996/97 N/A $3.29 $6.43 $9.72 $9.72 N/A 1997/98 10% 3.62 7.07 10.69 10.69 9.98% 1998/99 10% 3.98 7.78 11.76 11.09 3.74% 1999/00 10% 4.38 8.56 12.94 11.07 -0.18% 2000/01 10% 4.82 9.41 14.23 11.51 3.97% 2001/02 10% 5.30 10.35 15.66 10.52 -8.60% 2002/03 10% 5.83 11.39 17.22 11.03 4.85% 2003/04 10% 6.41 12.53 18.95 11.25 1.99% 2004/05 10% 7.05 13.78 20.84 11.56 2.76% 2005/06 10% 7.76 15.16 22.93 11.68 1.04% 2006/07 10% 8.54 16.68 25.22 12.37 5.91% 2007/08 10% 9.39 18.35 27.74 13.72 10.91% 2008/09 10% 10.33 20.18 30.52 14.79 7.80% 2009/10 10% 11.36 22.20 33.57 16.19 9.47% 2010/11 10% 12.50 24.42 36.93 16.87 4.20% 2011/12 10% 13.75 26.86 40.62 15.75 -6.64% 2012/13 10% 15.12 29.55 44.68 15.80 0.32% 2013/14 10% 16.64 32.51 49.15 15.49 -1.96% 2014/15 10% 18.30 35.76 54.07 15.15 -2.19% 2015/16 10% 20.13 39.33 59.46 15.11 -0.26% 2016/17 10% 22.15 43.27 65.42 15.86 4.96% 2017/18 10% 24.36 47.60 71.96 15.69 -1.07% 2018/19 10% 26.80 52.36 79.16 16.38 4.40% 2019/20 10% 29.48 57.59 87.07 16.76 2.32% 2020/21 10% 32.43 63.35 95.78 17.23 2.80% 2021/22 10% 35.67 69.69 105.36 17.23 0.00% (1) Rates are truncated. The annual assessment shall not exceed the maximum assessment, unless the appropriate Proposition 218 proceedings are conducted by the City to authorize an increase beyond the maximum assessment amount. The actual combined annual assessment rate for Fiscal Year 2021/22 is $17.24, which remains the same as Fiscal Year 2020/21. 5.3 Assessment Roll The proposed Fiscal Year 2021/22 District assessment roll is listed on the following page. NBSCity of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) 18 473 of 592 City of National City Landscape Maintenance District No. 1 (Mile of Cars) Assessment Roll Fiscal Year 2021/22 APN Owner Frontage (Feet) Levy Misc. Adjustments Total 560-203-03-00 FUENTES FRANK SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 08-13-96 291 5,015.65 (0.01) 5,015.64 560-204-02-00 CAPPS DIANE L & BALL 1998 TRUST 140 2,413.03 (0.01) 2,413.02 560-204-04-00 BALL JOHN D II 190 3,274.82 0.00 3,274.82 560-210-01-00 HATTON RONNIE & HATTON PAM 125 2,154.49 (0.01) 2,154.48 560-210-04-00 LTC PROPERTIES LLC 165 2,843.92 0.00 2,843.92 560-210-40-00 BALL JOHN D & BALL 1998 TRUST 211 3,636.78 0.00 3,636.78 560-210-41-00 BALL JOHN D & BALL 1998 TRUST 50 861.79 (0.01) 861.78 560-210-42-00 LTC PROPERTIES LLC 30 517.07 (0.01) 517.06 560-261-08-00 BALL JOHN D & BALL 1998 TRUST 270 4,653.70 0.00 4,653.70 560-271-07-00 BALL JOHN D & BALL 1998 TRUST 75 1,292.69 (0.01) 1,292.68 560-271-09-00 BALL AUTOMOTIVE GROUP & FIRST AMERICAN TRUST FSB TR 50 861.79 (0.01) 861.78 560-271-14-00 BALL JOHN D & BALL 1998 TRUST 95 1,637.41 (0.01) 1,637.40 560-271-15-00 BALL JOHN D & BALL 1998 TRUST 100 1,723.59 (0.01) 1,723.58 560-330-03-00 S K R B L P 591 10,186.43 (0.01) 10,186.42 560-393-03-00 PNJ PROPERTIES L L C 140 2,413.03 (0.01) 2,413.02 560-393-04-00 FALK PROPERTIES N C L L C 480 8,273.24 0.00 8,273.24 562-021-01-00 POLAKOFF GARY & DIANE 2401 TRUST 100 1,723.59 (0.01) 1,723.58 562-021-07-00 DIAZ LUIS J & MARIA G 2004 FAMILY TRUST 01-28-04 160 2,757.74 0.00 2,757.74 562-031-13-00 BALL JOHN II 110 1,895.95 (0.01) 1,895.94 562-031-14-00 BALL JOHN II 160 2,757.74 0.00 2,757.74 562-090-06-00 WEBSTER GEORGE H SECOND LIVING NON -MARITAL TRUST 270 4,653.70 0.00 4,653.70 562-100-13-00 BALL JOHN II 135 2,326.85 (0.01) 2,326.84 562-100-14-00 WEBSTER GEORGE H SECOND LIVING NON -MARITAL TRUST 135 2,326.85 (0.01) 2,326.84 562-150-13-00 GEN 3 PROPERTIES ONE L L C 209 3,602.31 (0.01) 3,602.30 562-160-07-00 GEN3 PROPERTIES TWO LLC 300 5,170.78 0.00 5,170.78 562-180-32-00 GEN3 PROPERTIES TWO LLC 82 1,413.34 0.00 1,413.34 562-180-33-00 GEN3 PROPERTIES TWO LLC 127 2,188.96 0.00 2,188.96 562-220-11-00 MAG 100 30TH STREET LLC 100 943.30 0.00 943.30 562-220-13-00 MCCUNE MOTORS & MCCREDIE TOD C TRUST 03-28-96 (55%) 230 3,964.26 0.00 3,964.26 562-220-31-00 MCCUNE MOTORS & MCCREDIE TOD C TRUST 03-28-96 (55%) 155 2,671.57 (0.01) 2,671.56 562-220-32-00 FRANK REAL PROPERTIES II LP 314 5,412.08 0.00 5,412.08 562-251-37-00 C V VENTURES L L C 202 3,481.65 (0.01) 3,481.64 562-251-38-00 C V VENTURES L L C 167 2,878.40 0.00 2,878.40 562-252-16-00 ERM FAMILY TRUST 11-19-91 & ERM RUDY JR SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST 05-17-19 330 5,687.85 (0.01) 5,687.84 562-321-07-00 S O C PROPERTIES L L C 182 3,136.94 0.00 3,136.94 562-321-08-00 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY 148 2,550.91 (0.01) 2,550.90 562-330-43-00 54/NATIONAL SELF STORAGE L L C 40 689.43 (0.01) 689.42 562-330-47-00 NATIONAL CITY BLVD STORAGE LLC 192 3,309.29 (0.01) 3,309.28 562-330-48-00 NATIONAL CITY BLVD STORAGE LLC 133 2,292.37 (0.01) 2,292.36 562-340-09-00 WESTCOTT REVOCABLE TRUST 10-28-14 & PARADISE DEBRA J 300 5,170.78 0.00 5,170.78 562-340-47-00 MOSSY IMPORTS L L C 164 2,826.69 (0.01) 2,826.68 562-340-48-00 MOSSY IMPORTS L L C 436 7,514.86 0.00 7,514.86 562-340-49-00 ESCONDIDO DEVELOPMENT PROPERTIES L L C 291 5,015.65 (0.01) 5,015.64 562-340-50-00 FALK DEBORAH PROPERTIES/PERRY MOTORS/NATIONAL CITY L 300 5,170.78 0.00 5,170.78 562-340-69-00 FRANK REAL PROPERTIES I L P 290 4,998.42 0.00 4,998.42 562-340-70-00 FRANK REAL PROPERTIES I L P 300 5,170.78 0.00 5,170.78 Total 46 Accounts 9,065 $155,463.25 ($0.25) $155,463.00 19 474 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City adopting the 24th Street Transit -Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) Plan. (Applicant City -Initiated) (Case File 2021-07) (Planning) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 475 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City adopting the 24th Street Transit -Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) Plan. (Applicant City -Initiated) (Case File 2021-07) PREPARED BY: Martin Reeder, AICP PHONE: 619-336-4313 EXPLANATION: DEPARTMENT: Commevelopment APPROVED BY: Director of Communi 1 -velopment The TODO Study Area encompasses approximately 760 acres of existing developed land in the City of National City and within approximately one mile of the 24th Street Transit Center. The study area is in the southwest corner of the City and is bound by Plaza Boulevard to the north, State Route 54 to the south, Interstate 5 to the west and Highland Avenue to the east. The plan analyzes land uses and provides an expanded vision for the area with land use and mobility recommendations. This vision includes an enhanced streetscape, new opportunities for public spaces, transit -supportive land uses, and improved mobility and parking options. The attached background report describes the plan in more detail. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. N/A APPROVED: APPROVED: ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: Addendum to the 2012 Land Use Update Final Environmental Impact Report (EIR) ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: X Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the 24th Street Transit -Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) Plan. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: The Planning Commission voted to recommend adoption of the TODO Plan. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Background Report 2. TODO Summary Pamphlet 3. Draft TODO Plan 4. Public comment from 5/17/2021 Planning Commission meeting 5. Planning Commission Resolution 2021-04 6. City Council Resolution 476 of 592 BACKGROUND REPORT Staff Recommendation Staff is recommending that the City Council adopt the 24th Street Transit -Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) Plan. Overview The TODO Study Area encompasses approximately 760 acres of existing developed land in the City of National City and within approximately one mile of the 24th Street Transit Center. The study area is in the southwest corner of the City and is bound by Plaza Boulevard to the north, State Route 54 to the south, Interstate 5 to the west and Highland Avenue to the east. The plan analyzes land uses and provides an expanded vision for the area with land use and mobility recommendations. This vision includes an enhanced streetscape, new opportunities for public spaces, transit -supportive land uses, and improved mobility and parking options. Key Project Goals • Develop housing and parking policies that support increased housing choices • Identify projects that improve connectivity through the area and across 1-5 • Create Smart Growth and Complete Streets opportunities • Continue development of conceptual plans for the D Avenue Complete Street Project • Explore opportunities for a multi -use path along the Metropolitan Transit System right-of-way and/or Hoover Avenue Smart Growth — the plan supports a compact, efficient, and environmentally -sensitive urban development pattern. It focuses future growth and infill development close to jobs, services, and public facilities to maximize the use of existing infrastructure and preserve open space and natural resources. Complete Streets — the plan identifies street improvements that accommodate and take into consideration the safety of all users, including people who walk, ride a bike, take transit, or drive a car. Westside Specific Plan — the plan preserves and builds upon the Westside Specific Plan (adopted in 2010) and identifies areas to expand housing opportunities, adds design standards for development adjacent to existing residential uses and proposes potential development options to transition non -conforming industrial warehouse uses to mixed - use and community -serving uses that are compatible with existing residential uses. In ATTACHMENT 1 477 of 592 addition, this plan addresses opportunities at and near the transit center site, and with recent investments in Paradise Creek, seeks to strengthen the connection between the creek, transit station and Kimball Park with mobility enhancements and land uses that support access to open space, last mile connectivity and the benefits of living next to this great resource for the city. Project Funding Project Funding for the TODO plan was provided through a Smart Growth Incentive Program Planning Grant from the San Diego Association of Governments. The amount of the grant was $500,000, which was matched with another $60,000 in City contributions. The grant was extended for six months in order to allow more time for public input, but the grant expires on June 5, 2021. Therefore, any action to adopt the TODO plan would need to happen this evening. California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) CEQA Guidelines section 15164 authorizes the lead agency to prepare an addendum to a previously approved Environmental Impact Report (EIR), provided that no substantial changes are made. The CEQA consultant for the project prepared such an addendum and found that the TODO Plan would not result in any new or substantially more significant impacts than those examined in the previous EIR. Furthermore, the plan does not result in any land use changes or any substantial changes to the environment. Planning Commission Hearing Although no approval is technically required from the Planning Commission for plans such as this (other examples are the Homefront to Waterfront and INTRAconnect plans), it was prudent that the Planning Commission provide comment and make a recommendation to the City Council on adopting the plan. This is primarily due to the Commission being involved in discussions and reports on TODO early on. The Planning Commission held a hearing on May 17, 2021, at which time they reviewed the draft TODO Plan. Commissioners asked questions of staff and the consultant team on CEQA, incompatible uses, funding, potential projects, and traffic impacts. Three community members submitted comments to the Planning Commission (Attachment 4), sharing concerns related to viability of the plan, public participation in the process, flooding in the Westside area, and environmental justice. The Commission ultimately made a recommendation to the City Council that the TODO Plan be adopted. 2 478 of 592 Summary It is important to note that plans such as TODO (along with recent transit -focused projects such as Homefront to Waterfront and INTRAconnect) do not create any land use changes or regulations, but rather provide recommendations for future development. Any land use changes would require separate discretionary approval and CEQA analysis. The upcoming Focused General Plan Update is considering changes both to land use (rezoning) and code regulations (permit requirements) based on the TODO recommendations. Staff is recommending adoption of the TODO Plan. Options 1. Adopt the TODO Plan; or 2. File the Report 3 479 of 592 TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY The information presented in this summary pamphlet highlights the key mobility and land use recommendations identified in the TODO. The final document includes additional mobility improvements, parking strategies, land use concepts, environmental justice strategies, and implementation measures. PLEASE VISIT THE CITY'S WEBSITE TO VIEW THE COMPLETE DOCUMENT AND LEARN MORE. www.NationalCityCA.gov • www.24thStTODO.com COMMUNITY OUTREACH PROCESS GOALS: + Transparent planning process + Ensure public input is reflected in the planning output OUTREACH: + Link community members with project communication channels + Inform stakeholders + Convey project goals + Project Website (www.24thStreetTODO.com) = -= + Project Fact Sheet + Public Outreach Plan + Council Briefings + Public Hearings 4 Virtual15 Stakeholder Workshops Meetings 2 Surveys 190 WHAT THE COMMUNITY SAID: Increase housing availability Reduce displacement Improve walking conditions Allow mixed use Support environmental justice Improve biking conditions Survey Responses Focus development on the station area Support culture + the arts Increase transit connections Improve open space + access Increase healthy food options Improve the streetscape 4 ATTACHMENT 2 Key Project Goals 24th St TODO Study Area • I,1 pla?a 6tivd �2 \ 6tr 5 !Station 760 Acres Develop housing and parking policies that support increased choices Identify projects that improve connectivity through the area and across 1-5 Create Smart Growth and Complete Streets opportunities o- National City San Diego �Li cn oln�t, v Acres ` Chula Vista PLAN RECOMMENDATIONS ► Continue development of conceptual plans for the D Avenue Complete Street Project Explore opportunities for a multi -use path along MTS right-of-way and/or Hoover Avenue The TODO project revolves around the 24th Street Transit Center where the Blue Line Trolley and multiple bus routes converge, connecting the community to local and regional employment centers and other major destinations. The mobility recommendations focus on safe street crossings and dedicated spaces for people to ride bicycles, strengthening connections to the 24th Street Transit Center, regional bike network, and local destinations. The land use recommendations complement the existing transit services, help activate public spaces, and increase opportunities for a variety of housing options. New development along with investments in bicycle and pedestrian facilities can establish a livelier environment, activating the public realm and providing "eyes on the street." Together, these changes would help improve connections and provide residents and visitors with safe and comfortable transportation options. I4.Rn of SQ21 Mobility Improvements + Street Sections + Plans 22nd Street, from Wilson Avenue to D Avenue v 24th Street, from National City Boulevard to Highland Avenue •••••••••,••�,•a atrrlurfll• Hoover Avenue, from 22nd Street to 33rd Street ...................••••••. 3oth Street, from Hoover Avenue to Highland Avenue CIVIC CENTER DR 27TH ST National City Middle School 06 HST Sweetwater Union High School 30TH ST 1 Sweetwater River of a 54 3AV ONV1H9IH I NATIONAL CITY CHULAVISTA 500 1,000 i Ft —•—•• Project Boundary Transition Blocks * Transit Center Intersection Improvement F---. Regional Bikeway ,.•.,- I Street -Focused Development Neighborhood Corner/Anchor 1, Signalized Intersection W Improvement — — Trolley I ' 1 Open Space Connection ,—,. Mixed Use Corridor (..) 1-5 Crossing Enhancement Intersection Improvements 6t .1; 1 ADVANCE STOP BAR r CURB EXTENSION PEDESTRIAN COUNTDOWN SIGNAL _ HIGH VISIBILITY CROSSWALK ADA ACCESSIBLE/ CURB RAMP NO RIGHT -TURN cr-ON RED LEAD PEDESTRIAN INTERVAL Land Use Recommendations ❑2 Paradise Creek Gateway: Beautify Paradise Creek with activities and a mix of land uses on each end of the Creek at the 24th St. Station and on West Ave. Neighborhood Corners: Provide neighborhood gathering spots that are easy and safe to walk to and a place for shops, restaurants, and other activity at the corner. Mixed -Use Corridors: Connect the East and West neighborhoods ofTODO with a greater mix of uses that lead to transit and a safe and pleasant walking and biking environment. Transition Blocks: Blocks behind the Mile of Cars can change overtime to include new buildings and uses that match more closely with the residential neighborhood. Activate Hoover Ave: Make Hoover Ave. a better street to walk and bike along with active land uses on each side and a connection to the Bayshore Bikeway. 481 of 592 The City of National City TRANSIT ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT April 27, 2021 6 ATTACHMENT 3 482 of 592 Acknowledgments City Council MayorAlejandra Sotelo-Solis Vice Mayor Jose Rodriguez Councilmember Marcus Bush Councilmember Mona Rios Councilmember Ron Morrison Planning Commission Maria Dela Paz, Chair Ricardo Sanchez, Vice Chair Claudia E. Valenzuela Luis Natividad William Sendt DitasYamane Damian Roman City Manager's Office City Manager Brad Raulston Assistant City ManagerTonyWinney City Staff Martin Reeder, Principal Planner Jose Lopez, Deputy City Engineer Community Members Many thanks to all the community members who attended the community workshops and participated in the development of this plan. Consultant Team CR Associates (formerly Chen Ryan Associates, Inc.) Citythinkers, Inc. RED Office Harris & Associates Neri Landscape Architects ffAI/a�l/et This project was funded by a TransNet Smart Growth Incentive Grant. CAL II FOR NIA NATIONAL car r7VCORPORP.T'E:) 7 483 of 592 01 02 03 Table of Contents Introduction 1.1 Project Purpose & Goals 1.2 TODO Vision 1.3 Community Outreach Process Existing Conditions 2.1 Project Context 2.2 Existing Conditions 2.3 Environmental Justice Mobility 9 9 11 IS 19 28 3.1 Mobility Concepts & Goals 3o 3.2 Intersection Crossing Enhancements 32 3.3 Interstate 5 Crossing Enhancements 34 3.4 22nd Street 36 3.5 �4cn Street 40 3.6 Hoover Avenue 42 3.7 3o`h Street 44 3.8 D Avenue 46 3.9 Bicycle Network Modifications 48 3.10 Vehicular Network Modifications 5o 3.11 Mobility Hubs & NEV Shuttles 52 04 05 Land Use & Design 4.1 Land Use Concepts & Goals 4.2 Land Use Recommendations 4.3 Design Standards Implementation 55 56 64 5.1 Site Opportunities & Constraints 67 5.2 Development Prototypes 72 5.3 Parking Strategies 8o 5.4 Mobility Infrastructure Implementation 8o Appendices A. Mobility Existing Conditions B. Urban Form Existing Conditions C.TOD Feasibility Study D. Mobility Technical Report E. Project Surveys & Outreach Summaries 8 TRANSIT DEVELOP MFN 484 of 592 LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1-1: Project Study Area 8 Figure 3.-2: io-Minute Neighborhood Concept i0 Figure 3.-3: Surveys & Project Website xs Figure 3.-4: Survey Responses 14 Figure 2-2: Vicinity Map 18 Figure 2-2: Existing Land Use Distribution z9 Figure 2-3: Existing Land Uses 21 Figure 2-4: Existing Block Patterns 22 Figure 2-5: Representative Streets 23 Figure 2-6: Representative Buildings 24 Figure 2-7: Pedestrian Opportunities and Constraints 26 Figure 2-8: Bicycle Opportunities and Constraints 26 Figure 2-9: Transit Opportunities and Constraints 27 Figure 2-ao: Vehicular Opportunities and Constraints 27 Figure 3-3.: Mobility Framework 3z Figure 3-2: High Visibility Crosswalk, Advance Stop Bar, ADAAccessible Curb Ramps, Pedestrian Countdown Signal 32 Figure 3-3: ADA Accessible Curb Ramps, Pedestrian Countdown Signal 32 Figure 3-4: Signalized Intersection Improvement Locations 33 Figure 3-5: 1-5 Crossing Enhancement Locations 34 Figure 3-6: I-5 Undercrossing Enhancements at lgth Street 35 Figure 3-7: 22nd Street Overview Map 36 Figure 3-8: 22nd Street, from Wilson Avenue to Hoover Avenue 37 Figure 3-9: 22nd Street, from Hoover Avenue to National City Boulevard 38 Figure 3-1o: 22nd Street, from National City Boulevard to B Avenue 39 Figure 3-11: 24th Street Overview Map 40 Figure 3-12: 24th Street, from F Street to Highland Avenue 41 Figure 3-13: Hoover Avenue Overview Map 42 Figure 3-14: Hoover Avenue, from 24th Street/Mile of Cars Way to 33rd Street 43 Figure 3-15: 3oth Street Overview Map 44 Figure 3-16: 3oth Street, from Hoover Avenue to National City Boulevard 45 Figure 3-17: D Avenue Overview Map 46 Figure 3-3.8: Bicycle Facilities 49 Figure 3-19: Vehicular Modifications 51 Figure 3-2o: Mobility Hubs and NEV Shuttle Routes 53 Figure 4-1: Land Use Framework Map 56 Figure 4-2: Example of development adjacent to open Space 57 Figure 4-3: Active uses on each end of the Creek 57 Figure 4-4: Example of a "galleria" of active educational and retail uses that lead to the station 57 Figure 4-5: Example of a Multi -Use Path along a Creek 57 Figure 4-6: Paradise Creek Gateway Concept Illustrative 58 Figure 4-7: Example of Creek Restoration crossing West Ave 9 485 of 592 Figure 4-8: Paradise Creek Gateway Plaza at County Building & Transit Station S9 Figure 4-9: Hoover Ave. Transition Area 6o Figure 4-10: Example of an Active Street Corner 6o Figure 4-11: Narrow Buildings in Front of Business Park Uses 6o Figure 4-12: National City Blvd. / "Mile of Cars" 61 Figure 4-13: Mixed -Use Corridor along 22nd and 24th Streets 61 Figure 4-14: Transition between Commercial Automotive and Residential 62 Figure 4-15: Mixed -Use Corridor along 22nd and 24th Streets 62 Figure 4-16: Key Intersection/ Corners on Highland Ave. 63 Figure 4-17: Example of an Active Corner 63 Figure 4-18: Existing Residential next to Industrial in Westside Area 65 Figure 5-1: Ribbon Screen: Typical Unit Floor Plan and Section 72 Figure 5-2: Ribbon Screen: Example Location 72 Figure 5-3: Ribbon Screen: Typical Parking Layout 72 Figure 5-4: Ribbon Screen: Example Elevation 72 Figure 5-5: Transition Block: Example Site Layout 73 Figure 5-6: Adaptive Reuse: 3D View showing reuse of a masonry warehouse for educational use 74 Figure 5-7: Adaptive Reuse: 3D View showing reuse of mechanic garage for grocery/ market 75 Figure 5-8: Adaptive Reuse: 3D View showing reuse of mechanic garage for "mom and pop" retail uses 76 Figure 5-9: Pencil Towers: Conceptual 3D View showing how towers may be sited within block development 77 Figure 5-1o: Bungalow Courts: Conceptual 3D View 78 Figure 5-11: Bungalow Courts: Conceptual Site Plan 78 Figure 5-12: Corner Infill: Conceptual example of activated street corner 79 Figure 5-13: Grant Competitive Areas 8i LIST OF TABLES Table 5-1: Prevalent Site Opportunities and Constraints 67 Table 5-2: Grant Funding Sources 82 Table 5-3: Intersection Enhancements 83 Table 5-4: Roadway Enhancements 84 10 486 of 592 Page Intentionally Left Blank 11 487 of 592 01 Introduction 1.1 Project Purpose & Goals 1.2 TODO Vision 1.3 Community Outreach Process 1.4 Community Input 12 488 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION City of San Diego t D15\Q� 5 Zag�Nd pia 1 00° • t San Diego Bay t 1 1 1 1 1 tI� 1' City of National City City of Chula Vista Figure 1-1: Project Study Area 13 pg 8 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 489 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION 1.1 PROJECT PURPOSE & GOALS The TODO Study Area encompasses approximately 760 acres of existing developed land in the City of National City and within approximately one mile distance from the 24th Street Transit Center. The study area is in the southwest corner of the City, and is bound by Plaza Blvd. to the north, SR-54 to the south, 1-5 to the west and Highland Avenue to the east. A map of the study area is show in Figure 1-1 on the preceding page. The plan analyzes land uses and provides an expanded vision for the area with land use and mobility recommendations. This vision includes an enhanced streetscape, new opportunities for public spaces, transit -supportive land uses, and improved mobility and parking options. KEY PROJECT GOALS + Develop housing and parking policies that support increased housing choices + Identify projects that improve connectivity through the area and across 1-5 + Create Smart Growth and Complete Streets opportunities + Continue development of conceptual plans for the D Avenue Complete Street Project + Explore opportunities for a multi -use path along MTS right-of-way and/or Hoover Avenue Smart Growth —the plan supports a compact, efficient, and environmentally -sensitive urban development pattern. It focuses future growth and infill development close to jobs, services, and public facilities to maximize the use of existing infrastructure and preserve open space and natural resources. Complete Streets —the plan identifies street improvements that accommodate and take into consideration the safety of all users, including people who walk, ride a bike, take transit or drive a car. Westside Specific Plan — the plan preserves and builds upon the Westside Specific Plan (adopted in 2oso) and identifies areas to expand housing opportunities, adds design standards for development adjacent to existing residential uses and proposes potential development options to transition non -conforming industrial warehouse uses to mixed -use and community -serving uses that are compatible with existing residential uses. In addition this plan addresses opportunities at and near the transit center site, and with recent investments in the Paradise Creek, seeks to strengthen the connection between the creek, transit station and Kimball Park with mobility enhancements and land uses that support access to open space, last mile connectivity and the benefits of living next to this great resource for the city. 1.2 TODO VISION The 24th Street Transit Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) Plan envisions a 10-minute neighborhood formed by a Golden Triangle of connecting land uses, streets and public spaces with: + Paradise Creek connecting the 24th St. Transit Station to the San Diego Bay and Downtown National City; + D Ave. as a Main Neighborhood Connector between Plaza Blvd & 24th Street; + 22nd St. as a Major East-West Bicycle and Pedestrian Connection from the transit station to the neighborhoods and; + Mobility Improvements and Land Use Recommendations that anchor the area to the City and the greater San Diego Region The following represents some of the key elements of the Vision: + Strengthen pedestrian connections to the transit station (especially along 22nd St) + Add more trees and vegetation + Increase safety and add traffic calming + Add open space/parks within new developments + Increase pedestrian and bike facilities + Increase opportunities for affordable housing and a mix of land uses + Improve the area immediately around the Transit Center DRAFT FOR PUBLIC RE\ 490 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION PROPOSED FRAMEWORK - 10-MINUTE NEIGHBORHOOD Figure 1-2: io-Minute TO "it Neighborhood Concept 0 o�itiatit II JP tJ% Cent��1.. P�eS�n Plata Blvd r L 24tn ..r S`Nee� rqo� A 10-minute neighborhood is a place designed with all those things one might need close - by. A place with safe, clean and affordable housing choices, access to parks and open space, healthy food options, education and healthcare all within a safe, convenient and accessible walking and bicycling distance so that residents have most of all they need to live a productive and healthy life in their neighborhood. Legend: n CREEK BAYSHORE BIKEWAY & SWEETWATER TRAIL GREEN STREET LINEAR PARK/ OPEN SPACE CONNECTION NODE 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 15 491 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION 1.3 COMMUNITY OUTREACH PROCESS As part of the planning process for the TODO, a Public Outreach Plan (POP) was created with input from City staff, the consulting team, and key community stakeholders. The POP outlined a detailed approach for conducting an integrated technical planning and public participation process in support of the project goals. The POP outlined the overall approach to and goals for public outreach, stakeholder interviews, target audiences, time -frames, activities, and roles and responsibilities of the project team and community partners. The results of these activities provided meaningful input from the breadth and diversity of city's residents, employers, property owners, community groups and other interested stakeholders. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION GOALS The goal of public outreach was to share project information, solicit feedback, identify community issues or concerns that the project team should consider, and inform the development and selection of recommendations. Specific goals included: + To provide a transparent planning process + To inform stakeholders so they understand the project need, purpose, benefits, process, and opportunities to become engaged and provide feedback + To convey project goals and key messages, clearly, accurately, coherently and consistently + To engage more closely with key stakeholders in the study area through one-on-one interviews that provide a format for focused conversation and feedback + To design and implement engaging activities to provide clear and easily accessible opportunities for community input about the priorities of projects and recommendations contained in the Transit Oriented District Overlay + To facilitate seamless coordination of the public participation process with the technical planning process to ensure public input is reflected in the planning output + To link community members with project communication channels to promote ongoing project awareness and communication The following represents the key outreach events and components: + Project Website (www. 24t h St re etTO D O. c o m ) + Project Fact Sheet + Public Outreach Plan + 2 Online Surveys (igo completed) + 4 Virtual Workshops + 15 Meetings with Stakeholders + Additional Community Presentations + Council Briefings/ Public Hearings 24th Street TODO { Transit Oriented Development Overlay 16 Figure 1-3: Surveys & Project Website DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 492 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS AND TARGET AUDIENCE The target audience for outreach efforts for the TODO POP includes the City of National City as a whole and the residents and employers located in the study area. The outreach effort and approach endeavored to involve community members of all backgrounds and interests, including those who are primarily Spanish-speaking community members, by providing bilingual communication and involvement materials and by using a variety of outreach methods. One approach that worked well, especially given the restrictions in place during the COVID-19 pandemic, was one-on-one interviews and meetings. Key stakeholder representative groups (primarily consisting of community organizations, property owners and representatives of property owners) were engaged through one-on-one or small group meetings and interviews. This format facilitated more in-depth and informal conversation, breaking down the barriers we often experience with online webinars and large virtual meetings. The one-on-one interviews also helped the project team identify issues, concerns, and opportunities that factored into the TODO analyses and Plan recommendations and allowed the City to base decisions upon authentic community input and to demonstrate responsiveness to future needs. A summary of the meetings and events, webinar recordings, copies of the surveys and presentations as well as all input received is included in the Appendix to this plan. EVENTS AND ACTIVITIES Due to COVID-19 restrictions on group gatherings, planned pop-up events at the 24th Street Transit Station, Fenton Shopping Center, and the library in late March 2020 were canceled. In lieu, the project team hosted additional virtual events, one-on-one meetings and one additional survey which was distributed online and in paper format. At the request of some community members and partners, additional one-on-one and group stakeholder interviews were conducted to provide stakeholders more opportunity to learn and provide input. A total of 15 stakeholder meetings were held, including with MTS, UCSD, property owners, and community organization representatives, such as the Environmental Health Coalition, Olivewood Gardens, and Paradise Creek Educational Center. An additional land use focused survey was added to the outreach effort (English and Spanish). This survey was made available on the project website and in paper copies upon request. Local community organizations assisted in publicizing and distributing the survey in order to increase the outreach to members of the community with limited Internet access. Phase I — Project Initiation and Existing Conditions (Winter/Spring 2020) + Project Website: www.24thStreetTODO.com + Project Fact Sheet (English and Spanish) + Online Survey#1 (English and Spanish) + Six (6) Stakeholder Interviews with a focus on property owners + Public Event #1 (Virtual Workshop) - Took place the evening of May 27, 2020 The purpose of this event was to: • share work completed to date • discuss land use and mobility opportunities • collect input on what types of land uses are needed • identify where to focus mixed -use development • identify where to focus mobility improvements • discuss potential mobility trade-offs Phase II — Develop and Refine Recommendations (Spring -Fall 2020) + Nine (9) Stakeholder Interviews with a focus on community organizations and partners + Online Survey#2 (English and Spanish) + Public Event #2 (Virtual Workshop) —Took place in the evening of July 28, 2020. The purpose of this event was to: • present the work completed to date • discuss initial draft recommendations 17 pg 12 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 493 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION + Public Event #3 (Virtual Workshop) —Took place in the evening of October 28, 2020. The purpose of this event was to: • share land use survey results • present Transit -Oriented Development Feasibility and prototype concepts • discuss California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Process Phase III —TODO Plan Development and Adoption (Winter/Spring 2021) + Public Event #4 (Joint Virtual Meeting of City Council/ Community Development Commission & the Housing Advisory Committee) — Took place in the evening of January 26, 2021. The purpose of this event was to: • provide a project overview and brief City Council and Housing Advisory Committee Members • present land use and mobility recommendations + Planning Commission Hearing (Virtual Meeting) - Spring 2021 + City Council Hearing (Virtual Meeting) - Spring 2021 1.4 COMMUNITY INPUT Throughout the planning process, multiple "touch points' with community stakeholders and organizations provided opportunities to engage on topics of the plan and gather a breadth of input. The feedback, concerns and suggestions that stakeholders offered were thoroughly documented and they informed the development of this plan, providing meaningful guidance and focus to the planning effort. Detailed summaries of the meetings and events, webinar recordings, surveys and presentations are included in Appendix _ of this plan. The following are some of the highlights and themes of the input received: SURVEYS Two surveys were made available online on the project website (www.24thStreetTODO.com) and in paper format (English and Spanish). Both surveys were advertised through the City of National City and project email distribution lists, the project website, and during the public events/ workshops. The first survey was initially intended to be open from late January 2020 through the end of April 2020. However, it remained open through early June 2020 due to canceled in -person outreach events resulting from COVID-19. The second survey was open from late August 2020 through the end of September 2020. Seventy-seven (77) unique surveys were submitted for the first survey and one -hundred thirteen (113) unique surveys were submitted for the second survey. The main topics covered in the surveys were: + What types of housing is needed and where it should be located + What land uses are most important + Areas that are perceived as comfortable or uncomfortable for walking and biking, and why + Transit station access + Land use concepts + Transit -oriented development concepts + Environmental justice 18 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 494 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION Key Takeaways: + A majority of respondents identified housing as a priority for the TODO, and prefer it be located near the existing transit station and community infrastructure (such as schools and parks) and away from freeways and polluting uses (such as industrial); + A preference for affordable housing, family housing and townhomes; + A desire to see mixed -use and public spaces the near the transit station and existing commercial; + People enjoy walking in safe areas (such as Kimball Park and Paradise Creek) and in areas with wide and ample sidewalks, good lighting and safe street crossings; + People feel uncomfortable walking in areas with poor lighting, dangerous street crossings and high speed automobile traffic; + People feel uncomfortable biking in areas close to high-speed automobile traffic and where they are too close to traffic; + Two of the top obstacles to transit ridership identified in the survey were that the existing routes do not meet needs and that the distances to reach the transit station are too far; + A majority of respondents (70%) agreed that there should be greater activation of the northern blocks of the Paradise Creek (between 18th St and 16th St., Hoover Ave. and National City Blvd. with more housing, retail, an educational campus, and/or mixed -uses; + Support for adding mixed -use along Hoover Ave. provided that housing is away from polluting industrial; + Support for changing the blocks along 22nd St. and 24th St. at National City Blvd., to allow mixed -use provided that the Mile of Cars is not negatively impacted; + There was interest in promoting a more pedestrian - oriented and safe environment for corner retail along Highland Ave; + A range of interest was expressed in promoting greater environmental justice in the TODO area through a variety of goals, with the primary goals being focused on affordable housing, access to parks and open space, and a safer and more pleasant pedestrian environment. One comment that stood out was "it would be great for the community to see more green streets and accessibility to all, especially in Highland. More walkable and safe space to lift the community. Access by different modes of transportation and a safe space for mix use, restaurants, and people to just walk and spend time out. It already behaves sort of urban, but it lacks the accessibility, feel, and space that modern urban spaces have." 35 3 2 70 I5I— L 02- Where should new housing be located within the TODO Study Area? (Mark all that aPPIY) New t11e exigible tr 3raiS il'atl{vl Near SYIlstirl9 M1tear *elk)! 14018 cornmerclal • tiro- the. Fifer @u istmg Other fieewaya to tits 3. What do you think about encouraging devebpment and activation of the northern end of the creek (the blocks between 18th St and 16th St, Hoover Ave and National City Blvd)? This could be a site for more housing, an educational campus. retail and a mix 35 37% 10 25 70 15 10 0 Strongry Agree 3391, Agree u•+ iTII. Neutral Orsagree Strongly Orueree Other/Comment Figure 1-4: Survey Responses Summaries of the meetings and events, webinar recordings, copies of the surveys and presentations as well as input received were posted on the project website and made available in English & Spanish. Paper copies were made available upon request to the City Project Manager. 19 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 01 INTRODUCTION ONE-ON-ONE STAKEHOLDER INTERVIEWS The City of National City, its consulting team and key stakeholders representative of property owners in the Transit Oriented District Overlay study area participated in six (6) one-on-one interviews that took place during the course of two months, from October 3, 2019 to November 14, 2019. The purpose of the interviews was to identify key opportunities and challenges related to the development of the transit district area. Subsequent to the first round of interviews, an additional nine (9) one-on-one stakeholder meetings were held with key stakeholders representative of public agencies, non-profit organizations and additional property owners with interests in the Transit Oriented District Overlay study area. The meetings took place during the course of two months, from June 2020 to July 2020. The purpose of the follow-up interviews was to learn about the goals, opportunities, and challenges facing key community organizations and partners, and to discuss land use and mobility concepts within the study area. The discussions were open ended and specific to each stakeholder's interests. The following summarizes the key points discussed or recommended by the various representatives: Key Takeaways: + Location: The TODO area is a desirable and central location, with great property access and visibility; + Culture: There was an expressed desire to support diversity of culture and arts in the area; + Westside / Old Town: The Westside Specific Plan has resulted in some implementation challenges (setback, floor area ratio, and height requirements make development difficult); + Improved Connections: There is a desire for improved connections to the 24th Street Transit Station, Paradise Creek and Kimball Park, with 22nd St. as a major connector. Specific mobility issues were identified, including the need for improved access across 1-5 to Pepper Park and the Sweetwater Bike Path, pedestrian crossings that are audible and visual, more bike racks on 8th Street, more bike facilities, and sidewalk repairs on D Avenue and 27th Street. The intersection of 24th Street and Highland Avenue was identified as a concern for pedestrian mobility and the potential for a bridge across 1-5 was mentioned on several occasions. There is interest in enhancing and activating Hoover Avenue with streetscape improvements and to find better use of parking lots; + Public Participation and Environmental Justice: Environmental Health Coalition representatives expressed a need for greater community engagement and public noticing of the project and future participation opportunities were discussed. Slowing the project schedule and overall process was recommended. Documentation of baseline issues related to Environmental Justice and an existing land use inventory and assessment was requested. Affordable Housing, displacement and gentrification were voiced as Environmental Justice topics that should be addressed or considered to help respect the existing demographic group and ensure their needs are met; + 24th St. Transit Center Site: Discussion with MTS and UCSD representatives focused on opportunities at the 24th St. Transit Center site. AB1486 impacts what MTS can do with the site. The legislation envisions all transit sites need to include affordable housing, and the concept of a "ribbon" building prototype was discussed that could wrap a parking structure with housing and an active ground floor. The potential for expanded educational uses (such as a UCSD Extension facility) were considered. Preserving bus operations is a priority and is one of the key considerations for any site redevelopment; + Healthy Food: Access to healthy foods was a theme and the concept of re -purposing warehouses for grocery stores or produce markets was discussed and supported. Olivewood Gardens is interested in advancing their "Kitchenistas" program through access to a commercial community kitchen that could potentially be used as a food distribution; + Housing: There was general support for expanding additional housing opportunities in the study area. The area surrounding the 22nd Street and National City Boulevard intersection was identified as a suitable location for additional housing. The concept of housing along Hoover Avenue south of Mile of Cars/24th Street was generally supported. The TODO should also propose strategies to facilitate implementation of Accessory Dwelling Units (ADU) and support retention of single-family homes in the Westside; + Habitat: Opposition was voiced by a representative of the Paradise Creek Education Center to any additional structures closer to the Creek. The concept of a pedestrian/bicycle bridge connecting Hoover Avenue across the Creek was discussed and opposed due to concerns to habitat disruption and creating hazardous conditions for low flying birds (Brown Pelican); 20 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 496 of 592 01 INTRODUCTION + Open Space: Open space opportunities include + Flexibility: Several property owners expressed a a plaza near the 22nd Street and Wilson Avenue need for greater development flexibility as market intersection. The southeast corner of this intersection demands continue to shift during COVID-19. could be an opportunity to further restore the Creek habitat and also create a plaza; + Flooding: The flooding issues experienced along 18th Street near the Creek were raised as an issue that persists. The potential for closing 18th Street to vehicular traffic to facilitate more natural draining into the Creek was discussed as likely infeasible due to the importance of this roadway for vehicular connections such as 1-5 ramps. Other strategies are needed to address flooding; PUBLIC EVENTS / VIRTUAL WORKSHOPS The City of National City hosted four virtual workshops in support of the 24th Street Transit Oriented Development Overlay (TODO) project. Due to ongoing public health concerns related to COVID-19, the workshops were hosted virtually via Zoom and live streamed on Facebook Live. Spanish translation was provided for some of the workshops. The workshops were advertised via the City of National City email distribution list, City website, and City social media platforms, as well as the project website (www.24thStreetTODO.com), project email distribution list, and project Facebook page. Thirty-five (35) to Fifty-three (53) unique viewers participated through Zoom, while additional viewers streamed on Facebook Live. A copy of the workshop presentation and recording of each webinar were made available on the project website following each meeting. The virtual workshop format consisted of a webinar presentation by project team panelists, followed by open discussion. Zoom participants were able to respond to a series of live polling questions and had the opportunity to share thoughts with all attendees through the chat feature, or request to speak. The Q & A feature allowed participants to submit questions directly to the panelists, with responses provided through text or by panelists speaking to the group. A detailed summary of the workshop polling questions, chat and Q&A comments and responses, as well as a summary of verbal feedback is provided for each of the four workshops in Appendix E of this plan. The following are some of the highlights of the four workshops: Key Takeaways: + A desire to see more housing and mixed use; + A focus on the 24th St. Transit Station and a desire for a greater mix of uses and public open spaces in the immediate area of the station; + An interest in improving connectivity in the area, with the greatest priority being safety near known collision locations and a potential bridge connection across 1-5 to the Bay and Pepper Park; + Concern related to gentrification and displacement; + A need for more affordable housing; + An awareness of the key mobility challenges in the area, focusing on safety, traffic, walkability, bicycle facilities, parking, and mobility hubs; + Concerns related to locating residential next to polluting industrial uses; + A commitment to preserving the Westside Specific Plan. 21 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 497 of 592 02 Existing Conditions 2.1 Project Context & Location 2.2 Existing Conditions 2.3 Environmental Justice 498 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS 2.1 PROJECT CONTEXT The TODO is located in the City of National City. National City is in a premier location within the heart of the greater San Diego metropolitan area, approximately five miles south of Downtown San Diego and eleven miles north of the Mexican border (Refer to Figure 1-1, Regional Location). It encompasses 9.2 square miles and is bordered by the City of San Diego to the north and east, the San Diego Bay to the west, and the City of Chula Vista to the south. National City is San Diego County's second oldest city and was incorporated on September 17, 1887. It has a long and rich history. The land that National City now occupies was originally home to the Jamacha Tribe of the Diegueno Indians and was later used by Spanish soldiers to graze horses. It was part of the 26,000-acre El Rancho de la Nacion Spanish land grant. In 1868, the Kimball brothers purchased vast areas of the city and cleared the lands, built roads, constructed the city's first wharf and brought the first railroad into town. The Kimballs were also responsible for opening the first post office and the first library in National City. The city is well know for its role in the automotive industry and its "Mile of Cars." National City's automotive heritage began in 1go4 when Ralph Granger bought the first car in the city and Clarence and William Hunt opened the first auto dealership. Auto sales have been a staple of the city ever since and the "Mile of Cars" has an undeniable presence in theTODO study area in particular.' 23 The City's population (as of 2019) is approximately 61,394 people2. National City is an urbanized and diverse residential, commercial, and industrial area with a majority Hispanic Population (more than 6o%)2. National City is a charter city, and features a council/ manager form of government consisting of four elected council members, and a separately elected mayor. Figure 2-1: Vicinity Map PACIFIC OCEAN TIJUANA, MEXICO 1. National City General Plan 2. U.S. Census: https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/nationalcitycitycali ornra 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 499 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS 2.2 EXISTING CONDITIONS The TODO study area displays many of the characteristics desired to support aTransit-Oriented Community. The existing grid network of streets and compact blocks and a network of pedestrian and bicycle infrastructure in some areas of the study area support a walking environment. The area is served by light rail at the 24th Street station and multiple bus routes along major north -south and east -west corridors (such as National City Blvd. and Mile of Cars Way/24th Street). A mix of uses, from single-family to multi -family residential, commercial automotive, commercial retail, industrial and institutional offer several opportunities for employment, housing, and retail. Existing zoning in select areas permits densities that support transit and enable new mixed -use development to occur. The 24th Street Transit Center is one of two light rail transit centers in National City (the other is on 8th St.) and serves as the main transit hub for the City of National City.The Blue Line Trolley provides service to a mix of uses in the immediate area, including employment uses, the Mile of Cars, residential neighborhoods, the Adult Education Center, and retail/ shopping. Despite the multitude of uses around the transit center, mobility improvements to facilitate walking and bicycling to the transit station are much needed. The TODO study area contains a diverse mix of uses but lacks infrastructure, public amenities, and additional commercial service options to function as a complete neighborhood that promotes alternative modes of transportation and that is a desirable and attractive place to walk and bike. The National City Boulevard corridor (or Mile of Cars), is a primary commercial corridor that bisects the study area north -south. It is within comfortable walking distance of the transit station and yet it is dominated by automotive uses, and appropriate crossings are not in place to encourage the safe movement of walkers or cyclists. Today, the Mile of Cars acts as a barrier, separating the east and west neighborhoods of the TODO area and impeding easy flow of residents from the east side of the area to the 24th St. Transit Center. Figure 2-2: Existing Land Use Distribution COMMERCIAL/ OFFICE SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ▪ MULTI -FAMILY RESIDENTIAL ▪ LIGHT INDUSTRIAL TRANSPORTATION ▪ EDUCATION/ INSTITUTIONAL 24 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 500 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS LAND USE A preliminary assessment of existing land uses in the TODO study area demonstrates a rich mix of uses, with significant potential to add more uses, such as housing, commercial and mixed -use. The area immediately surrounding the transit station encompasses "Old Town National City" or the Westside, an area with established residential uses interspersed with industrial and commercial uses that were allowed to be "co -located," resulting in land use incompatibility challenges that the Westside Specific Plan (adopted in 2o2o) seeks to resolve. To the south of the station, an established area of light industrial (primarily warehousing and business park uses) covers approximately 120 acres on both sides of Hoover Avenue leading to the southern boundary of the City at SR-54 and the Sweetwater River. Residential uses (single-family houses and multi -family apartments) blanket most of the eastern half of the study area, with National City Blvd. and Highland Ave. acting as the two primary commercial corridors and "edges" of the residential neighborhoods (see figure 2-3). Significant civic uses exist in the area, most notably, Sweetwater Union High School and Olivewood Elementary to the south, National City Middle School to the north, and Kimball Elementary to the west. The Paradise Creek and newly constructed expansion to the Paradise Creek Educational Park mark the heart of the TODO, providing a direct link between the 24th St. Transit Center and Kimball Park, the National City Library and City Hall (all which are just outside the TODO study area but within walking distance). The significant presence and enhancement of the Paradise Creek cannot be understated. It serves as a major resource for habitat conservation and much needed open space, and it provides a natural connection between the TODO, the City and regional resources (such as the San Diego Bay, the Sweetwater Trail, Bayshore Bikeway and Sweetwater Marsh Natural Wildlife Refuge). URBAN FORM Urban form relates to the physical attributes, patterns and shape of our urban environment. The Planning Area has many of the urban form characteristics and qualities that make for a successful urban village. A tight -knit, fine-grained grid network of streets, blocks and lots offer several opportunities to make the area a more pedestrian, bicycle and transit - friendly neighborhood. However, some challenges must be addressed. Despite good transit access, the plan area remains a predominantly auto -oriented area with significant barriers to pedestrian and bicycle movement. Connectivity at the city-wide scale is good, with easy access to freeways and major arterials, and a connecting street grid. However, barriers to access and connectivity exist at the smaller scale, especially between developments and across major arterials, such as National City Blvd., Highland Avenue, 24th Street and 3oth Street. Moreover, the plan area is defined by several warehouse, light industrial and auto repair and dealership sites that do not relate well to each other or their context and do not contribute positively to streets in the area. Inconsistent land uses, along with vacant and under-utilized lots, result in gaps in development that diminish a clear definition of the public realm. While small, single-family residential lots are at the heart of the study area, large- scale, consolidated land holdings with industrial warehouses, "big -box" commercial, and auto -related uses surround the transit area and residential, resulting in a disconnect between the residents in the area and the streets that service the transit station. In addition, most commercial buildings do not face directly to the street with positive street frontage and active facades. Industrial uses do not need to disappear, however. Along the 1-5 freeway, they may serve as a buffer to potential mixed -use further east, such as along Hoover Ave. And focus may be shifted toward improving areas that do support better walkability, such as the Paradise Creek, 22nd St. and D Avenue which together form a "Golden Triangle" of connecting land uses and mobility enhancements (described in the introduction vision statement). 25 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 501 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS 00 1,000 Fe Public Facilities, Utilities, Open Space and Agriculture ■ Open Space Parks ■ Recreation I. Intensive Agriculture ■ Education Transportation, Communications, Utilities Institutions Residential, Commercial and Industrial Single Family Residential ■ Mobile Homes ▪ Multi -Family Residential ■ Shopping Centers ■ Commercial and Office In Light Industry Figure 2-3: Existing Land Uses 26 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 502 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS BLOCK AND LOT PATTERNS Blocks and lots in the study area vary in size, orientation and shape. Most ofthe blocks accommodate a diversity of land uses and buildings types. Most blocks have alley access, with the exception of blocks south of Mile of Cars Way and z4th Street. Residential lots in the area are deep and narrow, which allow for front and back of house uses and accessory buildings and spaces. Where combined, lots support large-scale buildings and uses, such as warehouses and auto -repair. The shift in the grid that is caused by natural open space areas (such as the Paradise Creek and a few sloped areas) results in irregular blocks and lots, providing unique development opportunities at key intersections and gateways in the community. Figure 2-4: Existing Block Patterns Thefollowing are typical blocks in thestudyarea and some of their defining characteristics (all blocks are shown to equal scale): r IMO 270' Residential Blocks 0 Ln J IL ■ mr IF 600' IL_ INMI a 1?i 111(1 1,250' 200' to 1,500' rj d NOS 1 sr 200' to 500 r "Superblocks" pg 22 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 27 Industrial Blocks 503 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS STREETS Streets make up a significant portion of the planning area. A majority of the streets in the station area are commercial streets that support high -moving automobile traffic but do not provide a streetscape environment that supports walking and bicycling. Land uses on either sides of these streets are predominantly auto -oriented, and multiple gaps in development (such as parking lots and service yards) contribute to a sense of emptiness and a lack of human scale. This is in contrast with residential streets in the area, which accommodate slow moving traffic and offer greater pedestrian comfort. The following are typical streets in the study area and some of their defining characteristics: Figure 2-5: Representative Streets • narrow street with 1 lane of travel in each direction • on -street parking on both sides • mostly one -to -two-story residential buildings with front yards and fences • mix of non-contiguous and contiguous sidewalks • presence of landscape and trees • wide street with 2 lanes of travel in each direction • bike lane on both sides, south of 30th St. • on -street parking on both sides • mostly single -story industrial warehouse and business park uses • presence of landscape and trees • contiguous sidewalks National City Blvd. "Mile of Cars" • wide street with 2 lanes of travel in each direction and planted median with center turn lane pocket • on -street parking on both sides • mostly single -story commercial and auto -oriented uses on both sides with multiple gaps in development and parking lots fronting the street • street signage and identity markers • contiguous sidewalks • wide street with 2 lanes of travel in each direction and center turn lane • on -street parking on both sides • continuous bike lane on one side • mostly one -to -two-story strip commercial and auto - oriented uses on both sides with gaps in development and parking lots fronting the street • transit route with contiguous sidewalks 28 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 504 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS BUILDINGS Buildings in the study area range in use and size from single-family homes to large-scale warehouses. Industrial buildings are typically set back from the street with loading docks, service areas and parking in the front yard. They are one to two stories in height and have few, if any, windows and architectural articulation. Retail is predominantly clustered at Mile of Cars Way and Hoover Avenue and dotted along Highland Avenue in the format of narrow, one-story commercial storefronts, fronting the street and with a variety of colors and signage but otherwise minimal architectural features. There are a few special use buildings (such as churches, schools and even a farm) that stand out from their context. A majority of single-family houses have positive frontage elements (such as front porches and stoops), with garages tucked beside or behind the house. Multi -family residential is in the format of two story walk-up apartments with parking provided in surface lots. The following are typical buildings in the study area: Figure 2-6: Representative Buildings Industrial warehouse --� Residential single-family pg 24 24th StreetTODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW Industrial office park Residential multi -family Special use/ church 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS 30 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 506 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS EXISTING MOBILITY CONDITIONS Early in the TODO project, a multimodal existing conditions analysis was undertaken to document the current state of mobility. The analysis covered metrics related to demand, connectivity, quality, and safety. The findings are depicted in Figures 2-7 to 2-10 for each travel mode and summarized in this section. Pedestrian Existing areas with greater likelihood for active transportation trips were found to be concentrated around the National City Boulevard and i8th Street intersection, and generally the area north of Mile of Cars Way/24th Street and south of Civic Center Drive. The higher pedestrian and bicycle activity is due to the mixture of multi -family residential land uses, places of employment, and transit stops near one another. The strong street grid and short blocks help maximize connections and minimize trip distances, benefiting all travel modes. Both Interstate 5 and State Route 54 A create barriers to pedestrian and bicycle travel. The freeways have limited crossing opportunities and, where present, can be uncomfortable environments for active transportation users. * hluldple Pedestrian Collisions class 1 -Nuld-Use Path Low PEQE Intersection --- Paradise Creek Park Expansion Project — No Sidewalk / la,w PEQE Segment !Egli Active Transportation Propensity Freet ayCnrssirrg Smar <:n, 111 Opportunity Areas Pedestrian -involved collisions were found to be most concentrated at signalized intersections along the corridors that carry the greatest levels of vehicular traffic, including Mile of Cars Way/24th Street and Highland Avenue. The safety and quality of the environment at signalized intersections could benefit from providing high visibility crosswalks with advance stop bars. Lead pedestrian intervals were another feature identified for consideration. Bicycle The existing bicycle facilities provide a strong base to build from. The Bayshore Bikeway and Sweetwater Bikeway are components of the regional bicycle network that provide comfortable connections to facilities and destinations beyond the study area. Like pedestrians, the existing development patterns have resulted in a well- connected roadway network that offers parallel route options and short block spacing. This provides bicyclists with the opportunity to utilize alternative routes with minor trip disruptions. .+1 8 1ooSt i llrist 50.0 1.000 Feel ®� 1 ti Naldk yea" Figure 2-7: Pedestrian Opportunities and Constraints 0 500 1.000 Feel O Multiple Bicycle Collisions _ Dedicated Bike Facility (Class — level of Traffic Smss 4 High Arrive Transportation Propensity ayCrning Smart Gmwth Opportunity Area. PJ , 31 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 507 of 592 Figure 2-8: Bicycle Opportunities and Constraint 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS Several ofthe main arterials currently exhibit high posted speed limits and high vehicularvolumes.These conditions are typically uncomfortable for most people to bicycle within without a facility that is physically separated from vehicles. Even with routes parallel to the arterials as an option, considerations need to be made at locations where bicycle facilities intersect with arteria Is. The bicycle collision analysis indicated collisions along arterials were largely concentrated at signalized intersections. Continuing the trend of applying green paint and bike boxes at intersections will help give bicyclists priority and increase their visibility to motorists. Transit The TODO area is well -served by transit, with stops for eight bus routes and the Blue LineTrolley.The 24th Street Transit Center is a hub, with stops for the Blue LineTrolley and three bus routes and has the greatest transit ridership in the area. Outside of the 24th Street Transit Center, the bus stops on the four legs of the Highland Avenue and 28th Street intersection (Routes 13 and 929) experienced the greatest ridership. Improving multimodal access to the 24th Street Transit Center and transit stops throughout the study area is important to maintain and increase transit ridership. Previous planning efforts have identified community shuttles or circulators as one method to better connect community members to destinations and other transit services. Vehicular Throughout the TODO area, vehicular operations were generallyfound to be acceptable underexisting conditions. Only three segments operate at LOS F, no segments at LOS E, and one segment at LOS D.The three locations with sub -standard operations are along roadways with built out environments and limited options for widening (Mile of CarsWay, 18th Street, and Plaza Boulevard). Additionally, widening roadways is generally not supported within built out communities and can deteriorate the comfort and mobility for active transportation users. Existing vehicular volumes along four -lane segments of Hoover Avenue and 3oth Street indicate the roadway is overbuilt. Road diets along these corridors provide opportunities to further enhance mobility for other travel modes. 1102 UlaS5 os CHKCe te \4a•St 24th Street Transit center 500 1.0,00 Feat 01 51 �Itly� 1.111E rrItne. Transit Stop nigh Ridership Transit Stop ( 911 I'4 klilc K'alkshcd room Transit Stop, nal Figure 2-9: Transit Opportunities and Constraints ao 3Auto Collisions Community Corridor - Sm., Conversion 10aily Traffic Volume — Ruadaur Segment — Iiaeess Capacity Available 0 500 1.000 Feet Figure 2-3.o: Vehicular Opportunities and Constrai is ii 32 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 508 of 592 0 2 EXISTING CONDITIONS 2.3 ENVIRONMENTALJUSTICE The City of National City General Plan has a Health and Environmental Justice Element (HEJ) which establishes policies and guidance for the fair treatment and meaningful participation of people of all races, cultures, and incomes with respect to the development, adoption, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies. The primary purpose of the HEJ is to "identify public health risks and environmental justice concerns and improve living conditions to foster the physical health and well-being of National City's residents" (City of National City 2011 General Plan, pg 3-214). The persistent health impacts of land use patterns affecting the TODO area (such as continued co - location of industrial uses with residential uses and the presence of polluting sources, such as Interstate 5) highlight how critical it is for forward planning to respond with policies, zoning solutions and design standards that address environmental justice. While this plan will not result in zoning changes, the mobility improvements and land use recommendations of the TODO plan center around the following key environmental justice priorities: + Prevent (or at a minimum slow) gentrification and displacement of existing residents and businesses; + Promote compatible land uses and transition non -conforming uses through the adaptive reuse of existing structures; + Expand access to transit, open space, a mix of land uses, healthy food options, and education; + Improve the safety and convenience of walking and biking environments to support a greater diversity of mobility choices in the area and facilitate greater connectivity to transit; + Propose development prototypes that offer a greater diversity of housing options and affordable housing opportunities; + Establish an implementation process through which community stakeholders remain engaged with and have the opportunity to influence land use decisions in the TODO area. ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE The way we design and build the human environment has a profound impact on both public health and environmental justice. Planning decisions related to transportation systems, density and intensity of uses, land use practices, and street design influence: how much we walk, ride a bicycle, drive a car, or take public transportation; the level of our stress; the types of food we eat; and the quality of our air and water— all factors which affect our health. How does the TODO promote Environmental Justice? Mobility - Section 3 of the plan establishes tangible and implementable mobility enhancements. These include measures to improve pedestrian and bicycle safety and facilitate access to transit through safe crossings, expansion of the pedestrian and bicycle network and identification of mobility hubs and NEV shuttle routes all to significantly expand mobility choices for residents and businesses in the TODO area. Land Use - Section 4 of the plan identifies several land use recommendations focused on expanding a mix of uses to strengthen the connection between new development and transit in the area and provide opportunities for more housing, commercial and employment uses near transit. Section 4.3 enumerates key design standards to address co - location and compatibility. Implementation - Section 5.2 of the plan identifies development prototypes that address key challenges in the TODO area, such as access to open space, affordable housing and displacement, buffers and transitions, right -sizing of infill development, strengthening of neighborhood nodes and co - location of industrial with residential. Examples include adaptive reuse of industrial warehouses in the area for educational uses, healthy foods markets, and small businesses. 33 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 509 of 592 03 Mobility 3.1 Mobility Concepts & Goals 3.2 Intersection Crossing Enhancements 3.3 Interstate 5 Crossing Enhancements 3.4 22nd Street 3.5 24th Street 3.6 Hoover Avenue 3.7 30th Street 3.8 D Avenue 3.9 Bicycle Network Modifications 3.10 Vehicular Network Modifications 3.11 Mobility Hubs & NEV Shuttles 510 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.1 MOBILITY CONCEPTS & GOALS The TODO project revolves around the 24th Street TransitCenter where the Blue LineTrolley and multiple bus routes converge, connecting the community to local and regional employment centers and other major destinations. The study area exhibits many additional characteristics that support convenient travel by all transportation modes. The strong street grid maximizes connections and shortens trip distances, allowing for convenient trips by foot or bicycle while also benefiting transit operations and drivers. The Bayshore Bikeway and the Sweetwater River Bikeway are existing regional bicycle facilities that run along the perimeter of the study area. These attributes, along with the presence of the 24th Street Transit Center and associated service offerings, all contribute to a strong foundation to build from and further enhance multimodal transportation. The area currently has a diverse mixture of land uses, with a range of housing types close to shopping, jobs, schools, parks, and other civic uses. This mixture supports the potential for trips to begin and end within or near the study area. The land use concepts previously presented are intended to further support a diverse neighborhood, by increasing the variety of housing options and supporting the potential for small-scale neighborhood shops. With these opportunities in mind, as well as findings from the Mobility Existing Conditions Report and input heard from community members over the course of the project, the following goals were crafted to guide future mobility enhancements: MOBILITY GOALS + Improve connections to the 24th Street Transit Center, regional bike network, and local destinations + Identify opportunities to improve active transportation connectivity across Interstate 5 + Continue the D Avenue Complete Streets improvements + Build on the Westside Specific Plan and General Plan Community Corridor concept + Enhance the public realm for all travel modes Figure 3-1 demonstrates how the goals were carried forward, establishing a mobility framework. Each of the following components are further discussed throughout this Chapter: • Intersection Crossing Enhancements • Interstate 5 Crossing Enhancements • 22nd Street • 24th Street • Hoover Avenue • 30th Street • D Avenue • Bicycle Network Modifications • Vehicular Network Modifications • Mobility Hubs & Neighborhood Electric Vehicle (NEV) Shuttles pg 30 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 35 511 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM Bicycle Frarisewesk (lass I/1V Fablitics — Class II/111 Fecalsries e24th Stlece Tnaniii Station PEDESTRIAN FRAMEWORK a2Iih Streit Transit Sin Whieolair Network Modilicationa • • • • Road Dict • ••• T-W.ek Thflic •••• Cloxd to Vdockl ..... .... ..... . • • 7fo5s • • • • 20.8` ...v..- ....... v: .•• 14, -,. X gl, i VEHICULAR FRAMEWORK eNth Street 'Iumit Mobdity I [Lan NEV Route Lusting Tranil Ki.1( Figure 3-1: Mobility Framework 36 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 512 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.2 INTERSECTION CROSSING ENHANCEMENTS Intersections are where two or more roads or paths meet. They provide important connections that allow people to travel from one route to another. People that walk, bicycle, and drive all rely on intersections during their daily travel. Safety is an important consideration at intersections due to the different directions of travel and different movements, such as turning, heading straight, and walking across the intersection. The following features should be provided at all signalized intersections to help improve safety for all roadway users: + High visibility crosswalks — Emphasize the crossing area in a way that is easy for approaching drivers to see during daylight and at nighttime; + Advance stop bars — Encourage drivers to stop further back from the crosswalk to create additional space between vehicles and pedestrians; + ADA accessible curb ramps —Assist people with disabilities and those pushing wheeled devices (ex., strollers or carts) to move between the sidewalk and the street; and + Pedestrian countdown signals— Inform people how many seconds remain before the signal turns to red so that a pedestrian knows when not start crossing an intersection. PEDESTRIAN COUNTDOWN SIGNAL Figure 3-2: High Visibility Crosswalk, Advance Stop Bar, ADA Accessible Curb Ramps, Pedestrian Countdown Signal The specific features recommended at each location are identified in the Mobility Technical Report provided in Appendix D. A new traffic signal is recommended at the intersection of National City Boulevard and 22nd Street to help people walking and bicycling cross National City Boulevard and get to and from the 24th Street Transit Center, commercial areas, and recreational resources. The intersection should consist of the features identified above to maximize safety for all travelers. Figure 3-4 shows the location of all signalized intersections within the TODO study area. Additional features that may be provided at intersections on a case -by -case basis include: + No right -turn on red —Signage restricting vehicles from turning right on red; + Lead pedestrian interval (LPI) — Give people walking a 3-5 second head start to cross the intersection before the traffic signal turns green for vehicles; and + Curb extensions —Shorten the crossing distance for people walking and increase their visibility to drivers, while encouraging drivers to make slower turns. 'CURB /EXTENSION NO RIGHT -TURN ON RED LEAD PEDESTRIAN INTERVAL Figure 3-3: ADA Accessible Curb Ramps, Pedestrian Countdown Signal 37 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 513 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM e 24th Street Transit Station • Signalized Intersection New Traffic Signal 220 S. ®*eolCa°wal • � 26th gt i1 • �• 0• 1 28 30th St d • •• L o 5 1 ...„ rJ \ I 1 5 ,\ - 00011,8...... Ghu1a v SW . \, r m 0 500 1,000 Feet Figure 3-4: Signalized Intersection Improvement Locations 38 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 514 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.3 INTERSTATE 5 CROSSING ENHANCEMENTS Freeways commonly create barriers in communities by limiting connections from one side to the other. In National City, Interstate 5 separates most of the City's residential neighborhoods from the waterfront. The few crossing locations generally have freeway on- or off -ramps, resulting in high volumes of vehicles and uninviting environments for people that walk and ride bicycles. The following changes to 28th and zgth Streets are recommended to improve the freeway crossing experience and enhance the connection to the waterfront: + Convert 18th Street from one-way travel to two- way travel for vehicles between McKinley Avenue and Wilson Avenue; + Turn igth Street into a car -free space, exclusively for the use by people that walk, ride bicycles and other non -motorized transportation devices such as scooters, strollers, and wheelchairs; + Incorporate artwork, lighting, and other amenities to make the area a comfortable and inviting public space; and + Use landscaping and other features to capture stormwater and beautify the area Another concept for consideration is a bridge crossing over Interstate 5, between Mile of Cars Way/ Bay Marina Drive and the 24th Street Transit Center open only to people walking and riding bicycles. This concept was widely supported by community members. The City owns the undeveloped parcel just north of Bay Marina Drive and west of Interstate 5. Development of this property by the City and/or a private entity could include a landing for the bridge west of the freeway, while the transit center property could be considered east of the freeway. Figure 3-5 identifies the Interstate 5 crossing enhancement locations. 0 0- m 0 0 0 24th Street Transit Station ■ • ■ • 19th Street Greenwav Potential 1-5 Bridge • 0 a 39 I 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW Figure 3-5: 1-5 Crossing Enhancement Locations 515 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM Figure 3-6: 1-5 Undercrossing Enhancements at igth Street 40 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 516 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.4 22ND STREET 22nd Street provides a direct connection to the 24th Street Transit Center, Paradise Creek, Paradise Creek Apartments, and the recently completed Paradise Creek Park . Future increases in transit services will also encourage additional transit use, likely increasing the number of people accessing the transit center. This corridor also has the potential for additional residential or mixed -use developments as future property redevelopment occur. These important resources and future considerations make 22nd Street a critical link for people that walk and ride bicycles. 22nd Street Improvement Objectives: + Enhance access to transit, recreational resources, and commercial areas + Improve the safety and comfort of people walking and riding bicycles + Widen sidewalks to increase landscaping opportunities and enhance the public realm + Provide opportunities to capture stormwater runoff through bioswales and other features 22nd Street Enhancements: + Wide, landscaped sidewalks with pedestrian scale lighting + Angled parking along north side of 22nd Street from Wilson Avenue to Hoover Avenue + 2-way cycle track along the south side of 22nd Street from Wilson Avenue to B Avenue + Multi -use path along the south side of 22nd Street from B Avenue to D Avenue and continued through the property to F Avenue (if redevelopment occurs) + Green conflict paint at driveway locations + Additional curb extensions at the 22nd Street intersections with Wilson Avenue, Hoover Avenue , and National City Boulevard + New traffic signal with high visibility crosswalks, advance stop bars, ADA accessible curb ramps and pedestrian countdown signals at the intersection of National City Boulevard and 22nd Street 11 v •••♦ 04°' 7 L hs1 2 `� 201 o L y i 2\st 1I •* • •<° I. • • • • 24th Street Transit Station ■N•■ 22nd Street Project Figure 3-7: 22nd Street Overview Map 41 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 517 of 592 AT-SIDEWALK- 5' ANGLED PARKING+TRAVEL LANE 36' CURB TO CURB (54'� 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM TRAVEL LANE BUFFER LANEBIKE 1._ BIKE LANE+ 5IDEWALK.4' 11' 3' Figure 3-8: 22nd Street, from Wilson Avenue to Hoover Avenue 42 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 518 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM SIDEWALK-- PARKING-4-TRAVEL LANE 5' B' 12' 4, TRAVEL LANE CURB TO CURB 14E1 12' 4' BUFFER 4, 4' BIKE LANE 6' 4, BIKE 16 SIDEWALK4. LANE 5' Figure 3-9: 22nd Street, from Hoover Avenue to National City Boulevard pg 38 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 43 519 of 592 FSIDEWALK-Ai- PARKING TRAVEL LANE T 2' TRAVEL LANE CURB TO CURB j4 J 12' PARKING 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM Figure 3-io: 22nd Street, from National City Boulevard to B Avenue MULTI USE PATH - I O' 44 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 520 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.5 24TH STREET 24th Street/Mile of Cars Way provides vehicular access to Interstate 5 and offers a connection across the freeway. The roadway is fronted by a variety of uses, such as office, commercial/retail, automotive dealerships, light industrial, and residential properties, making it an important link for all travel modes. Multiple schools are also located just off the corridor. Vehicular demand is greatest between Interstate 5 and National City Boulevard, while pedestrian and bicycle activity and transit ridership tend to be greater east of National City Boulevard near the residential neighborhoods and schools. 24th Street Improvement Objectives: + Improve multimodal safety + Maintain vehicle throughput near the freeway + Calm traffic through the residential neighborhoods + Improve access to existing driveways 24th Street Enhancements: + From National City Boulevard to Highland Avenue, remove one vehicle travel lane in each direction and add a center left -turn lane + Buffered bike lanes along each side of 24th Street + Green conflict paint at driveway locations + Maintain on -street parking adjacent to the curb + Curb extensions at the intersection with Highland Avenue + Bike box on the approaches to National City Boulevard (westbound only), DAvenue, and Highland Avenue (eastbound only) CD o{ Cats " M��e 2tstst 0 ` . • 20i st ..``� 0. * is 1 L � W 24th Street Transit Station ■ ■ ■ • 24th Street Project I. S Figure 3-11: 24th Street Overview Map 45 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW eSIDEWALK-a��PARKING- . LANE 5' TRAVEL LANES CENTER LANE LEF11URN LANE 11' 10' CURB TO CURB [64' 1 11° 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM FI� BIKE JI BUFree_I 4 LANE ---I"- PA or ING 3" 5' 8' --4' SIDEWALK' 5' Figure 3-12: 24th Street, from F Street to Highland Avenue 46 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 522 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.6 HOOVER AVENUE Hoover Avenue connects to both the Sweetwater and Bayshore Bikeways, and existing employment areas and residential developments. Future land uses may allow for mixed use developments as well, which could add residential units to the area and further increase activity along the corridor. Hoover Avenue also intersects with 22nd Street, connecting to the 24th StreetTransit Center and Paradise Creek Park. Hoover Avenue Improvement Objectives: + Improve multimodal safety + Enhance access to the Sweetwater and Bayshore Bikeways + Improve access to existing driveways + Maintain on -street parking Hoover Avenue Enhancements: + Remove one vehicle travel lane in each direction and add a center left -turn lane + One-way cycle tracks along each side of Hoover Avenue + Green conflict paint at major driveways + Bike box on the approaches to Mile of Cars Way/24th Street Figure 3-13: Hoover Avenue Overview Map 0 ■ ■ 22�d S` 1 CaIsWaY tJ;t1e of • • Zglh S‘ • • • • Zs0Sk • • • a. • L• L � • • • • 331 6 S� e24th Street 'Transit Station •••• 1 looser Avenue Project 24fh Sl 47 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 523 of 592 1rt I■t;� SIDEWALK- BIKE LANE SLIPPER 5' S' 3' pARKIN "� —=TRAVEL LANE s• 1T' 4- HOOVER AVE CENTER TPA VEL LANE LEFT -TURN LANE 10' 11' CURB TO CURB C64') 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM PARKING 4.BUPEER BIKEIDEWAY., LAW 3' 5' 5' Figure 3-14: Hoover Avenue, from 24th Street/Mile of Cars Way to 33rd Street 't� � i�!!1lIIlIIIIIII 4 • 1 48 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 524 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.7 3oTH STREET 3oth Street fronts Sweetwater High School and serves as a connection to the Sweetwater and Bayshore Bikeways. These locations result in higher levels of pedestrian and bicycle activity. Future redevelopment of the former swap meet site may further increase active transportation demand and the need to safe and comfortable facilities in the area. 3oth Street Improvement Objectives: + Improve multimodal safety + Enhance access to Sweetwater High School, the Sweetwater and Bayshore Bikeways, and planned Hoover Avenue cycle track + Serve as a future connection to the planned Sweetwater Road cycle track + Improve access to existing driveways 3oth Street Enhancements: + Remove one vehicle travel lane in each direction and add a center left -turn lane, from Hoover Avenue to Highland Avenue + Two-way cycle track along the north side of 3oth Street, from Hoover Avenue to Highland Avenue + Maintain on -street parking between the cycle track and vehicle travel lane + Maintain pedestrian crossing features at F Avenue la MI WI �a '. Zg\h 5� d 30th Street Project , \ •ii._••000_1,111•••16••••••1171111111111111.tk o L .✓✓� 1 �, +'.1 ram. ,~. `\ • l 2 s. C/ 1 ;..1..f..5....t. .......\\ r•.r..r..r•.r ICitV Figure 3-15: 3oth Street Overview Map 49 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 525 of 592 .-SIDEWALK-1F AKE LANE 5' LANEBlIfFER1 PARKING 8' TRAVEL LANE 4 CENTER !RAVEL LANE LEFT -TURN LANE 12' 11' 12' CUR& T4 CURB 164'- 68' ) 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM Jr- PARKING-' SIDEWALK4 8' S' EXISTING PEDESTRIAN CROSSING Figure 3-16: 3oth Street, from Hoover Avenue to National City Boulevard 50 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 526 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.8 DAVENUE D Avenue has received several transportation enhancements in recent years, including bike lanes, bike boxes, as well as curb extensions and a roundabout just outside the study area. The lush, landscaped walkways further add to the environment. The corridor connects residential neighborhoods to many important community resources, including multiple schools, Kimball Park, and the downtown area. D Avenue Improvement Objectives: + Enhance access to Kimball Park + Improve multimodal safety at intersections + Encourage a non -motorized connection to the Sweetwater Bikeway D Avenue Enhancements: + Replace center left -turn lane with turn pockets and add bike lanes in each direction from 16th Street to 18th Street + Bike lane along D Avenue, from 3oth Street to the southern terminus + Add bike boxes on D Street at the intersections with 16th Street (northbound), 3oth Street (north - and southbound), + Consider curb extensions at D Street intersections with 18th Street, 22nd Street, 24th Street, and 3oth Street •••• D Accnuc Pruicct • • 1 • • ! • -n 1 N • 32. 0 ! • 1 • \ 100S1 • 1 • ` 2stst • 1 ✓ 1 • `t • ' • • 1 lath St. • '1 • 1 • 1. • '� • • i • A thSt • i • • ;2 1 . • 6'1 • lath St. � On St • • d. • O \ It ..0'.... ▪ we. 1 Q ,`14St .26 51 24th StreetTODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW Figure 3-17: D Avenue Overview Map 527 of 592 52 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.9 BICYCLE NETWORK MODIFICATIONS The bicycle facilities recommended in the previous sections along 22nd Street, 24th Street, 3oth Street, Hoover Avenue, and D Avenue will complement the existing network and additional planned facilities in the area identified in the City's current planned bicycle network. The following graphic identifies the planned and existing bicycle facilities within the study area and adjacent connections. Bayshore Bikewa Pepper Park �F Pier 32 Marina +P 53 24th StreetTODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 529 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM t i • r, 14thSt T. 0 o 0 D° 15thSt`. 1 ..01 • • 1 • • I. • ♦ . • • • •' • • • • <, • qr • 1ti • ` • • • , 2• L N • • • • • • • • • 1 ` '1• 1.-- \ • —Ado' p�2agtv• d 1lthst 4 r, 1lthst 1 Certes \3s 1. �`C 0 500 1,000 Feet I 1 rr—rr_ rr vi St ,Vp St 1.00 • •♦•* ■ • i1 • • • M�1e of • • • • • • • ass`Na\I o• o• ,2.,• v • • � .�. • r •0. • ..•. 1lstst • • • lath st ro 120 St Existing Proposed Class I - Bike Path Class II - Bike Lane Class III - Bike Route Class IV - Cycle Track Multi -Use Path • • f • • •• • 7 •a • • • • ♦ * • • •/, • • • •• • •••• 1 ••1�#♦ • • • • ` isf X • • • • • • 1 t, ♦••••4 X 4 ; .' tX •• •• a .% r' t•r��r s\ lk - • • err • ••• • • • •••• • • • • • • • • • O } •• • • r`. cP Figure 3-3.8: Bicycle Facilities 54 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 530 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.10 VEHICULAR NETWORK MODIFICATIONS As part ofthe TODO development, Circulation Element roadways were analyzed under existing and future conditions. The analysis informed an understanding of opportunities for multimodal enhancements that would not result in traffic congestion. The following vehicle infrastructure modifications are recommended: + 18th Street, from McKinley Avenue to Wilson Avenue — convert to two-way travel + lgth Street, from McKinley Avenue to Wilson Avenue — restrict vehicle access + 22nd Street and National City Boulevard intersection — install traffic signal + 24th Street, from National City Boulevard to Highland Avenue — remove one travel lane in each direction and add a center left -turn lane + 3oth Street, from Hoover Avenue to Highland Avenue — remove one travel lane in each direction and add a center left -turn lane + Hoover Avenue, from Mile of Cars Way to 3oth Street— remove one travel lane in each direction and add a center left -turn lane + Hoover Avenue, from 3oth Street to 33rd Street — add a center left -turn lane Future traffic signal optimization is also recommended to maintain or enhance intersection operations. The goal of signal optimization is to improve coordination and communication among traffic signals along corridors, and to accommodate the recommended bicycle facilities and pedestrian improvements. Signal optimization would improve traffic flow and increase vehicle throughput at intersections by reallocating green times to serve future vehicle demand at each intersection approach, which would reduce greenhouse gas emissions that result from idling vehicles. The City of National City's General Plan currently includes a policy to encourage traffic circulation improvements through synchronized signals or Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS), which are comparable to the operations and goals of signal optimization. Figure 3-19 displays the Circulation Element designated roadways and locations where road diets (lane reductions) and access modifications are planned. 55 p� 5u 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 531 of 592 r co 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM h\ ,.,•, p1aZagWd s•' '\ / % 12thSt\ / \ / Center 0' ' 1 Cw\c \ � 4thst: .� _•.� I co15ihSt : i"�• � ▪ m ✓''' 16th \ Oh St \ 1 e X j igLP lath St m 1 \ o \ \ .y • N \ \s $ 20ih St A. ♦�`i. 21st Si 1 ♦ 9 `' f I. \ *A S;_W \ v m , , \ `. L \ (O \ Cats \ \ ._ lJi�\e cE s\ i- 111 \ \•' \) : lath St 90th St \ \ '''' • \X c-). to ••� \ .-' 0. \ �•.� �,s•'_ .`••`. 33tdSt t /� ,,A ,` ".••• ...• •••• *wow. ••••••• •••••••••••• a. •• do..• \ J i �` ' 03-- atiola vista ,. ' Gh Q24th Street Transit Station Vehicular Network Modifications • • ■ • Road Diet • ■ ■ ■ Two -Way Traffic ■ ■ ■ ■ Closed to Vehicles Figure 3-3.g: Vehicular Modifications 56 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 532 of 592 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM 3.11 MOBILITY HUBS & NEV SHUTTLES A mobility hub is a location where different travel options come together to offer opportunities for multimodal trips. This concept is encouraged at the regional level through SANDAG's 5 Big Moves, with mobility hubs identified as one of the five key strategies envisioned to enhance the movement of people and goods throughout the region. A mobility hub can improve the experience for existing travelers and help entice others to make multimodal trips by providing additional supporting services and features. Convenient and comfortable access for all modes of travel is critical to realizing the potential of a mobility hub area. The scale and features of a mobility hub are dependent on the context of location. The 24th Street Transit Center and surrounding area include many characteristics well -suited for a mobility hub, such as the multiple transit offerings and surrounding residential and employment density that support multimodal trips. The 24th Street Transit Center includes transit stops for the Blue Line Trolley and three bus routes (13, g61, and 967). Drivers and people that walk or ride bicycles to and from the station further add to the activity. Multimodal access to the 24th Street Transit Center can largely be addressed through the improvements previously identified throughout this chapter, including the 22nd Street and Hoover Avenue bicycle facilities, the intersection and Interstate 5 crossing enhancements, and traffic signal optimization improvements. The transit station site itself may be redeveloped in the future, which could bring a mix of residential, commercial/retail, office, and/or additional educational uses to the area that would further increase multimodal demand. Features and services that may be considered or expanded at the transit center could include: + Enhanced transit waiting areas + High speed Internet + Trip planning informational kiosks + Passenger/rideshare loading zones + Shared -use devices such as car, E-bike, bike, and scooters + Electric vehicle charging stations + Microtransit or NEV Shuttles + Package lockers pg 52 24th StreetTODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 533 of 592 National City has considered microtransit or small Neighborhood Electric Vehicle (NEV) shuttles a possible transit enhancement for the western part of the City. Previous plans including the Homefront to Waterfront Plan, INTRAConnect Plan, and Naval Base San Diego Parking and Traffic Congestion Relief Plan identify potential NEV shuttle routes and stops for consideration that fall within theTODO study area. The following graphic depicts the potential NEV shuttle routes and stops recommended from these efforts. The shuttle stops could be enhanced to micro - mobility hubs by including additional features that support multimodal trips. Bike parking, shared -use device parking, and trip planning informational kiosks are examples of features that may be best suited within the context of these micro hubs. Potential micro -mobility hub locations include: + 16th Street and National City Boulevard + 18th Street and Wilson Avenue + 18th Street and Highland Avenue + 3oth Street and Highland Avenue 03 MOBILITY & PUBLIC REALM ® 24d. Suet, Tmnu, Station K Mobility flubs W M Rowe Eximing Tmnrii Rw,c A L Figure 3-2o: Mobility Hubs and NEV Shuttle Routes 58 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 534 of 592 04 Land Use & Design 4.1 Land Use Concept and Goals 4.2 Land Use Recommendations 4.3 Design Standards 59 535 of 592 4.1 LAND USE CONCEPTS & GOALS The overarching land use goal of the TODO is to strengthen the connection between new development and transit in the area. The City's General Plan calls for land uses that promote Smart Growth in the area (National City General Plan, Goal LU-2). Much of the TODO study area is categorized as a SANDAG Smart Growth Opportunity Area, which is an identified location within the region that can support a mix of uses, infill development and transportation investments. The potential for Smart Growth in and around the 24th St. Transit Center is among the strongest in the city. TheTODO study area includes SANDAG designated Smart Growth Areas (SGA's) NC 2, 3 and 8, which are intended to support Town Centers and Mixed -use Transit Corridors. Town Centers support low to mid -rise residential, office and commercial with some employment, drawing people from the immediate area. Mixed -use Transit Corridor Areas support concentrated residential and mixed -use development along a lineartransit corridor with a variety of low-, mid- and high-rise buildings, with employment, commercial and retail businesses and drawing people from nearby communities (SANDAG Smart Growth Concept Map, South County Subregion, 2016). Land uses on and around the 24th Street Transit Station itself can support a greater mix and intensity of uses to leverage the infrastructure of the station and to boost transit ridership. Investments in the area around the Paradise Creek and Paradise Creek Park might help make the creek and park accessible to a wider cross-section of the area and the city and provide a key open space connection between the transit station and the north side of the study area. And new development along with investment in bicycle and pedestrian facilities on Hoover Avenue can establish a more active and positive frontage to the street, activating the public realm and providing "eyes on the street."Together, these changes would help build a more cohesive and strong relationship between development in the area and transit infrastructure, the transit station, and ultimately transit riders. 60 04 LAND USE The TODO land use concept centers around the following key recommendations: + Build Upon the Westside Specific Plan Concept of Securing the Ongoing Viability of Residential Uses + Increase Opportunities to add Housing Near Transit + Strengthen the Transit Station + Support Corner Infill on Highland + Reinforce the Westside and Paradise Creek Open Space Connection with Active Land Uses at each End + Activate Hoover Ave. with Mixed -Uses + Complete and Extend the Existing Mixed - Use Corridors in the Area + Allow for a Gradual and Deliberate Transition in Land Use from Commercial Automotive to Residential in the Neighborhoods Behind the Mile of Cars SMART GROWTH Smart Growth is a widespread planning concept that informs planning across all levels, from state to regional and local levels. A fundamental goal of Smart Growth is to promote infill development (or development in existing urban areas), where transit and community infrastructure investments can be focused to best serve existing populations and leverage the benefits of existing resources. 536 of 592 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI OLD LAND USE 4.2 LAND USE RECOMMENDATIONS Legend rz r - M ixe d -Use CoastalZone ..—.._.. Project Boundary Po rt o f Sa n Diego Hoover Ave. 0verlay Transition Bloc k0verlay Highland Ave. Node Overlay We stsid a Specific Pla n Figure 4-1: Land Use Framework Map pg 56 24th StreetTODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 61 537 of 592 04 LAND USE LAND USE RECOMMENDATION #i - PARADISE CREEK GATEWAY DISTRICT Paradise Creek Gateway Objectives: + Reinforce the Westside and Paradise Creek open space connection with active, mixed -use anchors at each end of the creek + Encourage placemaking at each end of the Paradise Creek Educational Park with a public open space near the Transit Station and a restored creek at the north blocks crossing West Ave. + Revitalize the Westside and open -up opportunities for reinvestment in key focal areas of the neighborhood + Support a Mobility Hub at the 24th St. Transit Station Paradise Creek Gateway Recommendations: + Mixed -Use at the Transit Station Site with a potential for expanded educational uses + Mixed -Use on the blocks bound by Hoover Ave., National City Blvd., 16th and 18th St. + Mixed -Use on the blocks bound by Hoover Ave., Roosevelt Ave., 18th and 22nd St. + Vacated West Ave. and Extend Creek Restoration in this Location Figure 4-3: Active uses on each end of the Creek Figure 4-4: Example of a "galleria" of active educational and retail uses that lead to the station Figure 4-2: Example of development adjacent to open Space 62 Figure 4-5: Example of a Multi -Use Path along a Cree DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 538 of 592 04 LAND USE 12th Street Civic Center Dr SEE FIGURE 4-7 FOR ENLARGED PLAN OF PARADISE CREEK GATEWAY MIXED -USE DOWNTOWN hnlneet Mahar Sanitarium SEE FIGURE 4-8 FOR ENLARGED PLAN OF PARADISE CREEK GATEWAY PLAZA Sweetwater Marsh National Wildlife Refuge Community Center 1 6t1;treet 18th Street lash Street 24th Street N.C. Middle School Sweetwater High School 1. Mixed Use Block w/ Major Active Open Space 2. Multi Use Urban Trail (Bike and Pedestrian) 3. Improved Pedestrian and Bike Connection 4. Node I Corner Mixed Use & Placemaking 5. Restored and Revitalized Creek 6. Proposed Pedestrian Bridge Legend: (-3 Existing Trail Creek E - - Proposed Multi Use Trail Figure 4-6: Paradise Creek Gateway Concept Illustrative 63 pj 5 . 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 539 of 592 Shipyard relic (typ.) — To Bayshore bikeway To Paradise Creek Educational Park Bike lanes W. 18TH STR ET Riparian trees & shrubs Farmer's market Figure 4-7: Example of Creek Restoration crossing West Ave. MIS Station o�n CAI Fr-40' Enhanced paving al intersection 2-way cycle track Existing wayfinding signage Enhanced paving at plaza 04 LAND USE Vine arbor (typ.) Plaza Water steps at Paradise Creek W. 17th Street - Greenway to the Creek Palms Plaza Broad headed street trees Residential courtyard W. 22ND STREET Existing decorative light Kiosk Seat wall Existing trees Cart Decorative light to mirror existing /To Mile of Cars Way NTS ED ccess to County -- property Bridge over creek Creek trail Figure 4-8: Paradise Creek Gateway Plaza at County Building & Transit Station 64 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 540 of 592 OLD LAND USE LAND USE RECOMMENDATION #2 - HOOVER AVE. ACTIVATION Hoover Ave. Objectives: + Combine Mobility improvements with flexibility in land uses for increased street activation + Provide for new affordable housing without displacement of existing business park uses and existing residential neighborhoods + Address co -location of residential with light industrial uses with design standards and additional analysis Hoover Ave. Recommendations: + Mixed -Use residential permitted through a Conditional Use or Minor Use Permit + Mixed -Use residential conforms to design standards in Section 5 of this plan + Residential orients to the street and away from freeway and existing commercial and light industrial uses + Corners are activated with local -serving amenities (such as retail, food and beverage related uses, outdoor seating, gyms, and other active spaces) + Building entrances face the street and provide direct pedestrian access from the street Figure 4-9: Hoover Ave. Transition Area Figure 4-io: Example of an Active Street Corner Figure 4-ii: Narrow Buildings in Front of Business Park Uses Hoover Ave. pg 60 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW New Mixed -Use 65 Existing Parking Existing Business Park 541 of 592 LAND USE RECOMMENDATION #3 - MIXED -USE CORRIDORS Mixed -Use Corridors Objectives: + Connect the East and West neighborhoods of TODO with a greater mix of uses that lead to transit + Allow for a gradual build -out of a mixed -use corridor along National City Blvd. as the area transitions overtime + Provide for a more active mix of uses facing Kimball Park Mixed -Use Corridor Recommendations: + Mixed -Use residential permitted through a Conditional Use or Minor Use Permit at zznd and 24th St. + Mixed -Use residential permitted facing Kimball Park + Mixed -Use residential conforms to design standards in Section 5 of this plan + Residential orients to the street and builds a consistent "street edge" that provides a pleasant walking environment 04 LAND USE Figure 4-12: National City Blvd. / "Mile of Cars" The Mile of Cars is a significant revenue generator for the city, yet it is also a barrier to transit access from the eastern neighborhoods of the study area Figure 4-3.3: Mixed -Use Corridor along zznd and 24th Streets 66 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 542 of 592 04 LAND USE LAND USE RECOMMENDATION #4-TRANSITION BLOCKS Transition Blocks Objectives: + Build the edge between the Mile of Cars and residential neighborhoods with transition development + Protect stable residential neighborhoods while preserving the viability of the Mile of Cars + Add housing without displacing existing residential Transition Blocks Recommendations: + Mixed -Use residential permitted through a Conditional Use or Minor Use Permit + Mixed -Use residential conforms to design standards in Section 5 of this plan + Residential orients to the street and to internal courtyards and away from existing commercial and light industrial uses + Alleys and parking access aisles are used as landscaped buffers between new development and existing auto -oriented uses + Building entrances face the street and provide direct pedestrian access from the street Figure 4-14 depicts a plan diagram example, showing location and orientation of new residential uses next to existing commercial automotive uses with setbacks, buffers, orientation and screening to address land use compatibility. I Figure 4-14: Transition between Commercial Automotive and Residential RESIDENTIAL BUFFER ZONE LEGEND I � Property Line Landscape Parking Circulation Single Family Residential Multi -Family Residential Figure 4-15: Mixed -Use Corridor along 22nd and 24th Streets III Existing R • sidential Street Existing Commercial Automotive Uses Industrial 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 67 Street 543 of 592 LAND USE RECOMMENDATION #5 - CORNER ACTIVATION ON HIGHLAND Corner Activation Objectives: + Encourage safe and comfortable pedestrian flow from residential neighborhoods to key corners of the Avenue where retail activation may be focused + Provide for neighborhood "gathering spots" with outdoor seating and areas for socialization + Encourage key intersections to act as Gateways to the neighborhood with visible markers and placemaking elements Corner Activation Recommendations: + New Developments on 18th & Highland / 24th & Highland are designed and built to engage the street corner and provide active uses on the corner + Parking areas are focused to the rear and side of the lot with pedestrian spaces and circulation prioritized at the front and corner of the lot + Art, signs, seating, cafe tables and landscape enhancements are focused on the street corner 04 LAND USE Figure 4-16: Key Intersection/ Corners on Highland Ave. 68 Figure 4-3.7: Example of an ActiyP rnrr1Pr I DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REV 544 of 592 OLD LAND USE 4.3 DESIGN STANDARDS Through the thoughtful design of buildings and open spaces, future development in the TODO will result in a dynamic, environmentally sustainable and visually rich urban environment that supports transit ridership, social interaction, community pride and a sense of place and safety. The following design guidelines provide guidance on public realm design, site design, and building architecture in the TODO. New or substantially modified projects will be evaluated based on conformance with overall design principles Plazas Pedestrian plazas (either within the interior of a development or at building street corners) should be provided where possible to help activate street corners, provide a foreground to building entrances, and create gathering spaces for the community. + Gateways Gateways into the district should be highlighted at key intersections in the community. Gateways should incorporate any or all of the following elements: a) Distinct building forms b) Accentuated building corners and frontages c) Dedicated entry court, public plaza, public art d) Unique signs, landscape features and lighting e) A change in materials, a corner plaza or entry feature + Parking Parking areas should be designed to minimize their visual impact on the surrounding neighborhood and avoid conflicts with pedestrian circulation. Where possible, parking should be placed in the development's interior and not along street frontages (either in a structure, motorcourt or behind buildings) Parking lots shall be screened from street views with landscaped buffers (such as trees and planting beds). + Building Orientation Buildings should be oriented and sited to maximize street frontages, natural light and ventilation, and to create well-defined open spaces and common areas in the development. + Site Access Provide dedicated, direct and identifiable pedestrian access from the street into the project. Projects should define and emphasize building entrances with accent colors, enhanced paving, awnings or overhangs. Entrances should be human in scale, well -lighted and inviting to pedestrians. + Pedestrian Circulation Provide an interconnected network of paths, walkways, corridors and paseos that create a safe and pleasant pedestrian environment and integrate the development with the surrounding neighborhood. Circulation should connect residential dwelling units with common areas, commercial office with retail and the street, and provide multiple point of access. + Safety Encourage self -policing and discourage crime by incorporating Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) strategies in building and site design. These include natural surveillance, territorial reinforcement, natural access control and target hardening strategies. E;J 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 69 545 of 592 + Building Transparency The ground level of all mixed -use buildings should provide glazing for a minimum 6o% of the street facade of the building facing into the active use areas of the project. + Co -Location and Compatibility Where new mixed -use residential abuts existing light industrial uses (such as auto dealerships), the following design strategies should be followed to minimize potential impacts: a) Orient buildings away from industrial properties and highways and limit the amount of windows, doors and common spaces that open to adjacent industrial uses. b) Provide clear demarcations between public and private areas, as well as residential and non-residential uses, with separate building entrances, building and landscape design features, building separations, access control or a change in levels and materials. c) Provide landscape buffers and patio walls to reduce noise impacts and protect the privacy of residential units along high -traffic streets and intense uses. d) Attenuate noise through the use of berms, planting, setbacks and architectural design rather than with conventional wall barriers for developments next to transit, trolley, highways or other potential noise -generating uses. e) Use open spaces, such as pedestrian plazas, paseos, greenways and courtyards, to serve dual functions as valuable community space and buffers between different uses. f) Minimize the impact of light industrial uses by screening areas associated with heavy work and services, truck traffic, deliveries, and storage areas ofthe industrial use. Where possible, access to these areas should be separate and away from adjacent properties. OLD LAND USE Figure 4-18: Existing Residential next to Industrial in Westside Area 70 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVI 546 of 592 05 Implementation 5.1 Site Opportunities 5.2 Development Prototypes 5.3 Parking Strategies 5.4 Mobility Infrastructure Implementation 547 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION 5.1 SITE OPPORTUNITIES & CONSTRAINTS The TODO project included a TOD Feasibility Analysis and site feasibility testing intended to uncover the prevalent site features that exist in the study area today and devise potential development prototypes to address challenges and opportunities in the area (see Appendix C). Multiple sites in the study area exhibit a range of site characteristics, underlying zoning and environmental constraints and resulting scale impacts that must be evaluated when considering development potential. Table 5-1 below highlights some of the defining features used to evaluate site development opportunities in the TODO Study Area. SITE FEATURE OPPORTUNITIES ■ CONSTRAINTS Lot Size Deep lots provide opportunity for parking to be tucked behind active uses of the development fronting the street. Corner lots maximize frontage and facilitate access. Wide lots facilitate housing with dwelling units facing interior common open space and natural light and ventilation. Small lots (less than 10,000 square feet) constrain multi -family and mixed -use development and may impede efficient layouts for parking and dwelling units. Large lots (greater than 1 acre) may require additional access drives and roadways to facilitate circulation and access through the site. The prevalence of small lots in the study area may require lot assembly, which can make new development costly and requires time. Access and Parking A street grid and compact blocks, combined with alleys, make the area accessible and well-connected. Parking access from alleys reduces the need for access aisles and provides design efficiencies. Small and narrow Tots constrain parking and may restrict access to vehicles, pedestrians, light, air and open space opportunities. Blocks without alley access may require a consolidation of lots or easements between adjacent parcels. The mix of land uses in the area facilitate an active, 24/7 Adjacencies community that offers a range of neighborhood amenities within walking distance. Sites near industrial and automotive uses may require extraordinary design and construction measures to address the impacts of adjacent uses. Topography The relatively flat topography of the study area facilitates new development without significant grading and sitework. Some sensitive areas in the study area may require grading, soil remediation and site improvements to address flooding and contamination (e.g. the Paradise Creek area, areas south of 30th St.). Infrastructure Infrastructure in the area generally supports new development, with minimal to no offsite improvements required to water, sewer, dry utilities and telecommunication facilities. Storm drainage and water quality remain challenged by flooding of areas around the Paradise Creek. 72 Table 5-1: Prevalent Site Opportunities and Constraints DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 548 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION A diversity of development opportunities are plausible for the TODO study area. As demonstrated above, properties in the TODO exhibit a range of site characteristics, they are of varying size and geometry and they represent varying constraints and opportunities. To assist in evaluating the opportunities, sites are grouped by the following seven categories or groupings: + Transit Station Given the current demand for housing, its proximity to major employment centers and its relative ease of access, the 24th Street Transit Station is a good candidate for more intense uses. The site topography is relatively flat, it is well -served by bus routes, it connects well to existing and planned bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure and it faces the Paradise Creek and Park. The National City Adult Education Center directly south of the site offers an existing active use that, coupled with other uses (such as housing, more educational uses, and retail), may help fulfill a greater development capacity of the site and bring "eyes" on the space for 24/7 activation. TRANSIT STATION The transit center site may provide the ultimate TOD opportunity, with the ability to orient uses and buildings to the station and to capture transit riders as they arrive/depart the area with additional active uses. Other opportunities include the potential for a Public/Private Partnership with educational institutions (such as the Sweetwater Union School District, UCSD and trade schools) or with market rate and affordable housing developers, among other groups. As publicly owned land, the site may also be a good candidate for grants and subsidies to help finance new development. Any development proposed for the site will need to address the impacts from highway noise and contaminants, as this is an existing condition that has impacted the community negatively for decades. Notwithstanding these constraints, TOD development on the transit site may help fulfill the city's General Plan vision of the site as a major gateway to the city (National City General Plan Figure LU-5). With education and a mix of supporting uses on and near the site, the 24th St. Station can also continue to grow as the city's connection point to employment opportunities in the city, region and beyond. + Parking Lots Parking lots dominate the southwest quadrant of the TODO study area, with more than 50% of that area devoted to automobiles. Large expanses of paving contribute to the urban heat island effect and to significant increases in urban runoff (https://www.epa. gov/heatislands). Recent studies demonstrate that low-income communities of color are disproportionately affected by urban heat, which compound underlying medical conditions PARKING LOTS 73 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 549 of 592 (often also attributable to their physical living environment). Moreover, large expanses of paved and undeveloped areas erode the walking environment. Inactive, visually barren, and unbuilt street edges increase perceived walking distances and encourage speeding, making the pedestrian environment less safe and unpleasant. Parking lots also represent a significant amount of land area devoted to storage that might be made available for new development. Since lots are typically large in size and mass graded with minimal slopes to accommodate drainage, they make excellent sites for new development. Assuming the parking can be either eliminated, reduced, or replaced, new development does not need to displace existing viable commercial, industrial or residential uses on the site. A possibility also exists to line street frontages with new development, creating a more active and engaging street environment that supports all modes of transportation (walking, cycling, transit and cars). As the TODO area develops, parking lots may well be the first places that "fill in" with a mix of uses and spaces that complement existing uses and add new uses that the area needs. New buildings can treat stormwater and add greenspace and trees on -site, reducing the amount of impervious surfaces that currently dominate the area and contribute to the heat island effect. Vehicles can be tucked away, hidden behind new development, and buildings can approach the street, reclaiming streets as places for people, not just cars. + Infill Lots Infill lots may be defined as properties of 20,000 square feet or smaller in size, surrounded on two or more sides with existing development. Access is often restricted to one street frontage and, in some instances, may include alley access. Infill lots pose several challenges to development, as site size, constrained access, parking and adjacent uses often restrict how much and what 05 IMPLEMENTATION can be built on the site. However, the TODO study area contains several infill lots that present opportunities to increase small-scale residential, such as bungalow courts, duplex and fourplex, accessory dwelling units, townhomes and even walk-up apartments. This two and three-story density fits well with the single-family scale of many single-family areas in the study area, and development at this scale can often result in a more diverse and rich tapestry of development than large-scale, monolithic development encompassing entire blocks. + Corner Lots With a street grid and a network of compact blocks, The TODO study area includes multiple corner lots. Corner lots offer excellent development potential because buildings can front on more than one street, giving the site multiple opportunities for pedestrian and vehicular access, natural light, ventilation and views. Corner lots are also attractive for commercial and mixed -use development, as a street corner provides maximum visibility and can often serve as a gateway marker to an area. Corner lots with existing aging and under- performing commercial and industrial uses may be good first candidates for TOD mixed -use development. Mixed -use and housing can offer a higher and better economic use of those sites in the long-term. 74 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 550 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION Corner lots are often located at key intersections in the community. i8th St. is a pedestrian and bike corridor that connects residential neighborhoods to parks, schools and transit. As 18th St. crosses other corridors, such as Highland Ave., those corners serve as important community anchors. While existing zoning in most instances may allow mixed -use, the co -location of residential with auto -oriented uses should be considered and may present a challenge to corner lot development. The high speed, congestion and presence of automobile traffic on streets surrounding major corners lots of the study area should also be considered when evaluating the feasibility of development there. + Large Lots While small-scale infill development prevails in the areas north of the 24th Street Station, areas to the south are characterized by large lot development. Existing commercial and industrial uses include primarily warehousing and distribution centers, business park office uses, fitness related uses, and automotive supply and repair uses, with a few manufacturing uses (such as plastics, sandblasting, aircraft supply and military related supply uses). Auto dealerships along the National City Blvd. Mile of Cars and the National City Swap Meet make up another large section of large lots in the southern areas of the TODO. With lot sizes greater than 1 acre, these large lots may be considered attractive for large- scale development of multi -family residential, mixed -use, commercial and additional industrial. However, from one-on-one interviews with property owners in the area, the prevailing opinion is that the existing commercial and industrial uses in the area (primarily along Hoover Ave.) are perceived as viable economic uses, and the near -term (and for some properties also mid-term) outlook for redevelopment is not strong in this area. The Swap Meet and Auto Dealerships also provide viable economic uses and tax revenue, making them less attractive for wholesale redevelopment and turnover to other uses. However, assuming a long-term outlook for automotive sales and the ability to achieve a greater compatibility between commercial and light industrial uses and residential uses, there is potential for a mix of uses to be introduced incrementally and deliberately over time to large lots in this area. The wholesale redevelopment of large parcels can often have unintended, negative consequences for an area, from gentrification and displacement to colocation challenges and impacts to hours of operation, truck circulation routes, noise, and other factors affecting the livability of the area. These impacts must be considered and may be addressed through design and thoughtful, incremental placement of uses in focused areas of the lot. If new uses are brought to large lots, they should be concentrated in areas away from the highway, heavy industry, and truck routes. Street and circulation improvements should be coordinated with private investments in large lots for maximum benefit to the larger area and community. A shared parking strategy should be explored to maximize the efficiency of existing parking and leverage existing resources. 75 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 551 of 592 + Warehouses Both large and small infill lots in the TODO study area support warehouses of varying building types, sizes and uses. Industrial, pre - manufactured "Butler" buildings dot the area alongside concrete masonry and tilt -up concrete structures with varying businesses within their walls (from welding and plating to fitness and beauty studios). The impacts from colocation of warehouses adjacent to single-family homes is well documented in the Westside Specific Plan and remains an important and relevant concern for the study area. In 2011, the city commissioned a report that establishes a methodology for ranking non -conforming, polluting properties in the area . This report was used as a basis for development of an Amortization Program to transition warehouse and industrial properties in the Westside Specific Plan area. While the City has an amortization program designed to phase out these businesses, only two businesses have successfully completed the amortization process, with one simply relocating to another location within the study area. This data demonstrates that land use and enforcement alone cannot solve the challenges of colocation of industrial with residential. Additional strategies are needed to work in hand with the amortization program. One bold, yet ill-defined, strategy that should be explored further is the adaptive reuse of warehouse buildings for at least three compatible and desirable commercial uses in the TODO study area: education and job training, small- scale mom and pop retail, and grocery. Current planning best practices advocate for land uses and transit -oriented development that results in greater access to healthy foods, health care, education and a mix of neighborhood serving uses. Adaptive reuse of warehouses can provide unique opportunities to fulfill these needs in the community at a scale that is consistent with the existing small, walkable, neighborhood scale of the area. 05 IMPLEMENTATION + Paradise Creek Blocks The Paradise Creek, Paradise Creek Educational Park and Paradise Creek Apartments together set the stage for development of a Paradise Creek Gateway District. Enhancements to this area form a beautiful and unique gateway to the city and to the 24th Street Transit Station. As a major open space connection, the creek links transit infrastructure, education, jobs, commerce and residents to the wider city, Kimball Park, Civic Center, the Sweetwater Marsh and San Diego Bay. Several properties alongside the Paradise Creek offer ripe opportunities for new investment in the area to support a greater mix of uses, pedestrian enhancements, green infrastructure, and public open spaces. Existing properties turn their back on the creek, neglect their environment and fail to maximize their potential to create a livable and highly connected neighborhood that embraces the restored creek as an important natural asset to the area. While direct frontages on the creek may not always be possible, all properties along the Paradise Creek should connect with the creek in a meaningful way. Moreover, the potential to stitch together existing and future land uses with the creek and transit infrastructure will reinforce a strong sense of place and continue to build an authentic identity for the area. 76 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 552 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION 5.2 DEVELOPMENT PROTOTYPES To evaluate the development feasibility of candidate sites described above, several development prototypes are proposed. The prototypes enumerated below represent a range of opportunitiesfortheTODO study area and include a variety of building types and scales, from accessory dwelling units to bungalows, fourplexes, walk-up and mixed -use apartments, high-rises and one-story commercial buildings. In most instances, residential was considered the predominant land use, with commercial as secondary uses. The prototypes analyzed do not represent an exhaustive and comprehensive list of development opportunities, but a representative sample of potential developmentfortheTODO area. Fora more detailed design, analysis and financial proforma of the prototypes, see TOD Feasibility Analysis - Appendix C to this plan. RIBBON SCREENS Ribbon Screens are a mixed -use development prototype proposed for underused parking lots and wide landscaped setbacks fronting key streets in the study area. Where development of the street edge and activation of the public realm is desired, Ribbon Screens can instigate the transformation of key transportation corridors in the study area. This prototype can be deployed along wide stretches of street frontages to help screen parking lots, commercial, and industrial uses from the street. Ribbon screens work on "skinny" sites, with lot depths as shallow as 14 feet. They can variate in height, length and depth depending on site opportunities and neighborhood context. A "walk-up" model may include three stories with ground floor retail, shopkeeper units or live -work units. Parking is maintained in the rear of the lot, "tucked under" the building. In areas where noise and other impacts from the street and adjacent land uses are a concern, Ribbon Screen buildings may be designed with residential units facing inward and screened from the street, as shown on figures 5-1 to 5-4. As a near -term development prototype, Ribbon Screens provide activation and enhancement of the public realm with the addition of small-scale retail and housing, without displacing existing uses or precluding larger -scale infill development as uses and properties transition over the mid and long-term. IT lypiceiunite. rmcalunita Figure 5-2: Ribbon Screen: Typical Unit Floor Plan and Section Figure 5-2: Ribbon Screen: Example Location 11111111i— In. More. L • J ,,.. ko„ Figure 5-3: Ribbon Screen: Typical Parking Layout 77 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW Figure 5-4: Ribbon Screen: Example Elevation 553 of 592 Key Issue: Affordability & Displacement Ribbon Screens are designed to fit within the first 20 feet of the lot depth, in the place of landscaped setbacks, parking and vacant areas of the site fronting the street. In this way, this development prototype does not displace existing uses and buildings but adds new development potential incrementally. The Ribbon Screen prototype is one way to add much needed housing in the study area without displacing existing uses. Its compact footprint and ease of construction, along with smaller unit size, make this an affordable housing alternative to larger -scale monolithic development. TRANSITION BLOCKS In an area with a great mix of land uses and building types, transitions are needed between intense uses (such as commercial automotive and industrial) and residential uses (especially single-family neighborhoods). Several blocks in the TODO study area include entire blocks of existing commercial automotive and Tight industrial uses that back up to single-family housing blocks. As those properties transition overtime, opportunities exist to implement housing on the side of the property that faces existing residential, with buffers and screening that facilitate the transition from the commercial use to the new residential use and the residential street. These "transition blocks" accommodate multi- family residential of a scale and design that may be made consistent with the scale of the residential neighborhoods behind. By grouping units into four to eight-plex configurations facing courtyards, the scale and rhythm of development may mimic the existing single-family homes in the area. Buffers, setbacks, screening and landscape will be required between the new residential use and existing commercial uses while those uses transition over time to mixed -use and other uses (see Figure 5-5). 05 IMPLEMENTATION Figure 5-5: Transition Block: Example Site Layout Key Issue: Buffers And Transitions By building the rear portion of commercial blocks in the study area with multi -family residential, we provide a buffer and transition between the commercial uses and residential neighborhoods along major corridors of the study area (such as National City Blvd.) Transition Blocks stabilize eroding residential edges of the single-family neighborhoods in the study area and complete both sides of residential streets (such as A Street). This prototype anticipates four to eight-plex units oriented around courtyards. Parking access is provided from the rear of the site, creating an additional buffer to the adjacent commercial use with ample space for landscaped setbacks, screen walls and a row of trees to screen the new residential use. 78 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 554 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION ADAPTIVE REUSE Adaptive reuse of industrial and commercial warehouses and structures is a development strategy that many cities have embraced in recent years. A wave of industrial warehouse conversions to loft apartments hit Downtown San Diego in the early 2000's.The rapid proliferation of micro -breweries and the beer industry in San Diego saw a second wave of conversions in neighborhoods such as North Park, Barrio Logan, and across the county, from Downtown Vista, to Downtown Chula Vista, for example. In these examples, the transition in use was driven by market forces that puts pressure on gentrification of those neighborhoods. In the TODO study area, Adaptive Reuse has the potential to be more about community building. As a development strategy, it should respond less to market forces and more to facilitating compatible uses that provide many of the services neighborhoods lack. With this in mind, the prototypes shown below demonstrate the potential conversion of industrial and commercial buildings for education and job training, grocery and healthy foods, and small-scale retail uses (see Figures 5-6 through 5-8). N Solo ti Key Issue: Co -Location of Residential & Industrial Adaptive Reuse is an attractive and viable alternative to full-scale demolition of non- conforming structures. In neighborhoods such as the Westside Specific Plan area or "Old Town National City," the co -location of industrial uses next to residential is a persistent condition that contributes to ongoing impacts to the health and safety of residents and businesses in the area. While the Westside Specific Plan proposes sharp measures (such as the amortization of non- conforming uses), it focuses almost exclusively on land use as a solution. Land use changes can take decades. Adaptive Reuse can serve as an interim measure that can be implemented sooner. qq, LEGEND 0 ADD OUTDOOR SEATING 0 REPLACE EXISTING OPENINGS Q ADD SOLAR SHADING DEVICE 10 ADD OPENINGS TO STREET ELEVATION 0 ADD MEZZANkNELEVEL TOCREATE MORE SPACE • EDUCATIONAL USE SOCIAL USE CIRCULATION STAFF USE PARKING Figure 5-6: Adaptive Reuse: 3D View showing reuse of a masonry war79ehouse for educational use 1 I 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 555 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION LEGEND O 0 ADD FENCING BETWEEN BOTH BUSINESSES • PUBLIC USE ACTIVATION OF COURTYARD THROUGH JUCIERY STAND STAFF USE FOOD VENDORS Q EXTENSION OF MARKET OUTSIDE ACTIVATION OF STREET CORNER THOUGH SHADED SEATING Figure 5-7: Adaptive Reuse: 3D View showing reuse of mechanic garage for grocery/ market DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 556 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION LEGEND O ADD FENCING BETWEEN BOTH BUSINESSES • ACTIVATION THROUGH FOOD VENDORS ▪ ADDITION Of MORE GREENERY la ARTISTIC{ CRAFT MAKER BARBER SHOP PET SUPPLY O EXTENSION OF RETAIL TO STREET FRONT ' REPAIR SHOP O CREATE STALLS FOR COMMUNITY BUSINESSES Figure 5-8: Adaptive Reuse: 3D View showing reuse of mechanic garage for "mom and pop" retail uses 1 J r> 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 557 of 592 PENCIL TOWERS "Pencil" Towers were explored as a prototype to test their viability in the study area and compare the prototype to lower density models. High- rise residential towers rarely work financially in markets outside of Downtown San Diego or other employment centers, such as Mission Valley, Sorrento Valley and University City because the high costs of high-rise construction often require above market rents, putting most residential units in the luxury category. Current zoning in the TODO area does not support towers, with a maximum building height of 65 feet allowed. Nonetheless, it is a worthwhile exercise to study their potential for two reasons. First, the availability of land and its desirable location in the city and region make this prototype attractive in the long-term. Pencil Towers can be designed to fit comfortably within existing parking lots without displacing existing uses. They also work on larger lots when Ribbon Screens or other "phase 1" uses populate the block edges and towers are sited internal to the block. The compact floorplate, coupled with smaller units, enables a more efficient use of land and a greater concentration of residential density close to transit. Second, trade-offs can be obtained in exchange forthe additional height needed for towers. These may include the provision of more open space, public plazas, community spaces, affordable housing, and mixed -use (among other potential community benefits). The concentration of density in select areas of the TODO means more of the single-family residential areas can be protected from increased development pressures. A detailed financial analysis of Pencil Towers is provided in Appendix C — RED Report. 05 IMPLEMENTATION Key Issue: Open Space "Pencil Towers" or high-rise buildings with a limited footprint and small floorplates offer the opportunity to preserve open spaces on a site for public and recreational use. By building vertically instead of horizontally, less surface area of a site is covered by buildings and may be used for green/ open space areas. Aside from the Paradise Creek and Paradise Creek Educational Park, the TODO study area lacks greenspace and recreation area. Given the cost and time required to deliver public parks, the provision of greenspace within private development may be a viable alternative if that space is made available to the greater public as well as to residents of the development. Open space and landscaped areas of a site may also serve a dual function as buffers and screening of residential uses from existing commercial and industrial uses. Figure 5-9: Pencil Towers: Conceptual 3D View showing how towers may be sited within block development 82 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 558 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION "TINY HOMES" & BUNGALOW COURTS Key Issue: "Right Sizing" Infill Development Tiny Homes and Bungalow Courts offer the advantage of greater density withoutthe visual and scale impacts. Since dwelling units are often single -story and may be detached, they can easily match the scale and size of surrounding single-family homes. In a compact configuration and with reduced setbacks, as much as eight to ten bungalows may fit within a standard 7,45o square foot site (See Figure 5-3.3.). This is a density of more than 5o dwelling units per acre. While such a density is often associated with multi -story apartment buildings, with this prototype, the height does not need to exceed two stories. The "Tiny Home" concept has gained popularity in the last decade, especially among millennials craving an urban lifestyle and greater choice. Loosely defined as homes under 50o square feet and often associated with small lots or split lots, Tiny Homes offer economy, sustainable living and a greater connection to community by giving young professionals and families greater choices in housing location, size and cost (Anne Wyatt, Planning, February 2o16). Because they are small, may be factory built, and come in various styles, Tiny Homes can easily fit, unnoticed within the side and back yards of single-family neighborhoods. While size excludes families, this prototype may serve the needs of seniors, students and single military personnel in theTODO area. Similar and perhaps more efficient, Bungalow Courts are a proven housing typology from the early loth century that consists of six to as much as twelve attached or detached "bungalows or cottages" arranged along an internal paseo or landscaped court, typically all fitting within a standard single-family lot Figure 5-io: Bungalow Courts: Conceptual 3D View vl or combination of two or more single-family lots. Bungalow Courts offer a "single-family lifestyle," with separated, individual units with private yards and porches, yet in a communal arrangement with shared access and a common courtyard or paseo (see Figures 5-zo and 5-zz). Recent state legislation and corresponding local programs have renewed a focus on Accessory Dwelling Units or Second Units as one way to help address our affordable housing crisis through small-scale densification of primarily single-family neighborhoods. Accessory Dwelling Units advance the city's growth and policies by accommodating new housing units while preserving the character of existing neighborhoods, allowing efficient use of the city's existing housing stock and infrastructure. They provide housing options and choices that respond to varying income levels, changing household sizes and lifestyle needs. Adding Tiny Homes and Bungalow Courts to this mix will further these goals and provide greater diversity of housing stock that is compatible and "right sized" for existing infill neighborhoods. . • . ALLEY BUNGALOW COURT 10 Bungalows 14 Parking Spaces (Tandem) LEGEND Property Line Landscape Parking Circulation 1 BED Residential 2 BED Residential Carport 83 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW Figure 5-ii: Bungalow Courts: Conceptual Site Plan 559 of 592 CORNER INFILL Street corners are a terrible thing to waste. This is why one of the prototypes includes Corner InfiII development, which looks at opportunities across multiple intersections of the TODO study area and identifies design and development opportunities to enhance and mark the corner with active and vibrant uses, attractive features and greater intensity of building massing and forms to really celebrate corners in the area. As mentioned in Table 5-1 above, access to a site is a critical development feature and corners provide excellent access, as they enable a project to have two street frontages and great visibility. While all of the development prototypes discussed here work on street corner lots, our focus here is on Corner Infill development for some of the major mixed -use corridors, such as Highland Avenue, i8th St. and 24th St. For these areas, opportunities exist to mark the street corners with active ground floor uses (such as retail), a corner plaza or widened sidewalk, greater transparency with storefronts and breezeways and distinct architectural forms (such 05 IMPLEMENTATION as chamfers, rounded corners, vertical elements or marquee signs). The building typology explored here is "stacked flats," with ground floor commercial uses and residential above. The format is similar to the Ribbon Screens prototype, but located on more compact and contained corner sites where two frontages must be addressed. Key Issue: Strengthening Neighborhood Nodes Corner Infill emphasizes the street corner as a neighborhood node, a focal point of intensity, vibrancy, activation and gathering. While several intersections in the TODO study area function as key nodes, their vibrancy stems primarily from automobile traffic, not pedestrian activation. Corner Infill development has the potential to strengthen these nodes as pedestrian spaces, drawing from surrounding single-family neighborhoods to the west and east. Special design features and community amenities should be considered in the development of these nodes. Figure 5-12: Corner Infill: Conceptual example of activated street corner 84 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 560 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION 5.3 PARKING STRATEGIES Parking can pose a significant barrierto development due the high costs associated with constructing it, especially in urban, built out environments. The following parking strategies should be considered to help facilitate development and make better use of land. SHARED PARKING AGREEMENTS Shared parking agreements are a parking management strategy that can be used where adjacent land uses have peak periods of parking demand at different times of the day. Under such an arrangement, the adjacent land uses would share the same parking supply rather than each providing their own. This approach enables a smaller supply of parking to service the same quantity of parking demand by using it more efficiently. This can be feasible within the 24th Street TODO area where residential and employment land uses are adjacent to each other because peak parking demand for residential land uses and employment land uses are complementary. Residential parking demand peaks occur typically in the evening and overnight during weekdays, and all day on weekends. Peak parking demand at office and light industrial employment sites typically conforms to weekday traditional hours of business and can be non-existent on weekends. CENTRALIZED NEIGHBORHOOD PARKING (With Parking In -Lieu Fee for Development) Centralized neighborhood parking paired with a developer in -lieu fee program is a strategy a city can use to allow developers to meet parking requirements while also maximizing land use efficiency. Instead of requiring developers to meet their parking requirements onsite, this measure would allow developers to pay a fee used to finance a centralized neighborhood parking area. The fee is calculated and assessed based on a financial analysis which determines a fair way of allocating the cost of constructing and operating the centralized parking supply among all the anticipated developments. This strategy reduces the spatial constraints imposed by the parking requirements on the site making it more feasible for developments to be constructed 24th StreetTODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW to their maximum allowed densities. The centralized location of the parking also enables more efficient utilization by taking advantage of 'shared parking' opportunities created by the mix of adjacent land uses with complementary parking demand peaks. UNBUNDLED PARKING / REDUCED OR ELIMINATED PARKING REQUIREMENTS WITHIN TRANSIT PRIORITY AREAS Reforms of minimum parking requirements are occurring in many urbanized areas throughout California. The City of San Diego recently passed an ordinance (5142.o528) eliminating parking requirements for multi -family developments within Transit Priority Areas (half mile areas surrounding major transit stops, which include San Diego Trolley stations). The ordinance also requires the cost of any onsite parking that is provided within developments inside of Transit Priority Areas to be unbundled from the cost of purchasing or renting the property. When parking is unbundled, the user of the parking pays the cost of the parking directly (sparing any non -users from sharing the costs). This removes a formidable mechanism in place which skews transportation decision making in favor of driving. When paired with onsite amenities which improve mobility alternatives and/or reduce driving demand, this can significantly reduce an area's overall parking demand. This strategy is feasible within the 24th StreetTODO area, which includes the 24th Street Transit Center and shares many other similar urban characteristics to City of San Diego Transit Priority Areas. 5.4 MOBILITY INFRASTRUCTURE IMPLEMENTATION The TODO area's transportation infrastructure, land use patterns, and demographics exhibit characteristics that are competitive for a variety of grant funding sources. Figure 5-13 on the following page depicts grant competitive areas consisting of designations related to SANDAG Smart Growth Opportunity Areas, CalEnviroScreen percentile rankings, SB 535 Disadvantaged Communities, AB 155o Low -Income Communities, and Transit Priority 85 Areas. 561 of 592 Figure 5-13: GrantCompetitive Areas SANDAG Smart Growth Opportunity Areas Transit Priority Areas Smart Growth Concept Areas Existing/Planned Urban Ccnter 111 own Cencer 111 i(ed Ilse Transit Corridor 05 IMPLEMENTATION CalEnviroScreen Percentile Rankings ......- , , , ,.....„ 1 , , ........_....,_ \ 4 \ vis,su tat.st 88% CalEnviroScrcen Percentile Scores uuu.„ lt 82% ‘." 86% \ 62% .‘ 73% 4,,, _ ou--- ,or----- -- - \ '--- Alaiiiirik \ is Mks of f nvininmentslIkalth ItizardAssessment(1011) SB 535 Disadvantaged Communities & AB 1550 Low -Income Communities 5 ' i I i5. ......'1, i t L. ,501:1 I F SB 535 Disadvantaged &immunities 2nd AB - 1550 Loa -Income Communities AB 1550 Low -Income Communities within a U2 mik of a SB 535 Disadvantaged Community k 86 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 562 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION Table 5-2 below identifies some of the grant sources applicable to the TODO area. These sources may be pursued to help cover the cost of project implementation. Table 5-2: Grant Funding Sources PROGRAM ADMINISTERING AGENCY ELIGIBLE PROJECTTYPE EXAMPLES TransNet Smart Growth Incentive Program SANDAG Infrastructure projects that support smart growth development in Smart Growth Opportunity Areas Active Transportation Grant Program SANDAG Bicycle and pedestrian facilities Active Transportation Program California Transportation Commission/Caltrans Capital projects that encourage an increased use of active modes of transportation Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program (AHSC) Strategic Growth Council and Department of Housing and Community Development Bicycle and pedestrian facilities connecting to an affordable housing project Urban Greening California Natural Resources Agency Bicycle and pedestrian facilities Transformative Climate Communities (TCC) Strategic Growth Council and Department of Conservation Bicycle and pedestrian facilities; bike share programs Clean Mobility Options Air Resources Board Infrastructure projects; bike share programs Sustainable Transportation Equity Project (STEP) Air Resources Board Bicycle and pedestrian facilities Transit and Intercity Rail Capital Program (TIRCP) CaISTA and Caltrans Division of Rail and Mass Transportation First/last mile improvements; bicycle and pedestrian facilities Local Partnership Program California Transportation Commission Bicycle and pedestrian facilities Local Streets and Roads (LSR) Program California Transportation Commission Complete Streets components; safety projects; bicycle and pedestrian facilities Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) Caltrans Local Assistance/FHWA Safety projects; bicycle and pedestrian facilities State Transportation Improvement Program (STIP) California Transportation Commission Bicycle and pedestrian facilities 87 pg 82 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 563 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION Tables 5-3 and 5-4 summarize the recommended intersection and roadway mobility enhancements presented throughout this document. Table 5-3: Intersection Enhancements z ao uE 0 J w Z Q a�z wOlD a u �n W u Q z • a > O Q cn w -J m l7 Z u Q w Z ti ce O 5in z 0 in m Z c W X u w '�•M Wilson Ave & 22nd St S, E, W S, E Wilson Ave & Mile of Cars Wy/24th St N, S, W N, S, W N, S, W Coolidge Ave & i4th St E, W Coolidge Ave & 3.7th St E, W Hoover Ave & 22nd St All NE All SW, SE Hoover Ave & Mile of Cars Wy/24th St All All All Roosevelt Ave & Plaza Blvd All All National City Blvd & Plaza Blvd All All W National City Blvd & 3.2th St All All National City Blvd & Civic Center Dr N, W N, W N, W National City Blvd & a6th St All All All National City Blvd & i8th St All All National City Blvd & 22nd St All N, S SW All All All All All National City Blvd & Mile of Cars Wy/24th St All All National City Blvd & 28th St E, W All All All National City Blvd & 3oth St E, W All All D Ave & 16th St NE, SE All All All All S DAve &18thSt All All D Ave & 24th St All All All All E, W NW N, S D Ave & 3oth St All All All F Ave & 24th St N Highland Ave & i6th St All All All Highland Ave & i8th St All All Highland Ave & igth St N, W Highland Ave & 2ist St All All All Highland Ave & 24th St All All E Highland Ave & 3oth St NW, SW W All All SW NW, SW 88 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIE 564 of 592 05 IMPLEMENTATION Table 5-4: Roadway Enhancements mon a VEHICULAR MODIFICATIONS BICYCLE MODIFICATIONS 1 Hoover Ave, from Mile of Cars Way to 28th St Remove one travel lane in each direction; install center left -turn lane Install one-way cycle track in each direction; provide green conflict paint at driveways and through intersections Hoover Ave, from 28th St to 3oth St As adjacent properties redevelop, install center left -turn lane; provide on -street parking As adjacent properties redevelop, install one-way cycle track in each direction; provide green conflict paint at driveways and through intersections; as an interim improvement, install Class III Bike Route sign and in -pavement Sharrow markings Hoover Ave, from 3oth St to 33rd St Install center left -turn lane Install one-way cycle track in each direction; provide green conflict paint at driveways and through intersections 18th St, from McKinley Ave to Wilson Ave Convert to two-way travel N/A igth St, from McKinley Ave to Wilson Ave Close to vehicular traffic Re -purpose the right-of-way as a public space intended for non -motorized travel 24th St, from National City Blvd to Highland Ave Remove one travel lane in each direction; install center left -turn lane Install buffered bike lanes in each direction; provide green conflict paint at driveways and through intersections 3oth St, from Hoover Ave to Highland Ave Remove one travel lane in each direction; install center left -turn lane Install two-way cycle track along the north side of the roadway; provide green conflict paint at driveways and through intersections 89 pg 84 24th Street TODO - DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW 565 of 592 Appendices A. Mobility Existing Conditions B. Urban Form Existing Conditions C. TOD Feasibility Study D. Mobility Technical Report E. Surveys & Outreach Summaries 566 of 592 Martin Reeder From: Joan Rincon <jrincon@mail.com> Sent: Thursday, May 13, 2021 4:21 PM To: Planning Commission Subject: May 17 Planning Comm, Public comment on item.3, 24th Street TODO Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Completed CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking links, especially from unknown senders. You will be glad to hear that I do talk about things other than cannabis. I want to say a little abouth 24th Street TODO. At the last meeting many of my snottiest comments related to the problem of not completing development projects in National City. So I ask this question about TODO: How are we going to get the good things in this plan built? This gives me an chance to say something that is both truthful and nice. I have communicated with Martin Reeder and Planning staff since fall 2018 many times. Without exception each person has been gracious, professional, generous with time, knowledgable, welcoming and enthusiastic about helping a new person learn as much as possible. !know for a fact that many developments are stalled in National City simply because a developer refuses to put a shovel in the ground. For example, when I asked Mr. Reeder what was going on with the vacant lot next to the library, he told me accurately that everything was greenlighted on the City's end, and the developer would not get started because of profitability concerns. I called them up and verified this was true. Whatever shortcomings this City has are not the fault of our Planning Department. 1 come back to the question, how will we get the good things built? I particularly like the housing aspects of this plan. I worry that we are seeing a trend of mixed use projects not geting built because they are reliant on the commercial space for much of the profit, yet we have an excess of commercial storefront in National City, Some people I know have real concerns about how this plan treats the Mile of Cars, and I agree. I also ask you to give full attention to any comments by Mr. Godshalk, because he has put a lot of consideration into this. My main point for tonight is, how will we get anything built? That is beyond the Planning Department's responsibility. But once things are approved they seem to disappear into an abyss. I am not aware of any part of the City pushes these things and keeps them on track. What this City needs is some kind of group devoted to getting forward movement of things that exist on paper.I don't want to look back on TODO in ten ysars and find that nothing has changed. So I ask all of you on this Commission, please help come up with an idea for a mechanism to push good things forward. Please consider putting that on the agenda for a future meeting, and let's see if we can get some forward momentum that continues where the traditional planning process leaves office. -Joan Rincon, National City ATTACHMENT 4 91 567 of 592 Martin Reeder From: Ted Godshalk <paradisecreek@me.com> Sent: Monday, May 17, 2021 12:27 PM To: Planning Commission; Ted Godshalk Subject: Public comments for Item 3 May 17, 2021 CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking links, especially from unknown senders. Planning Commission, The process for the TODO plan has been carried out with very little public engagement. I encouraged the Planning Department early on to hold off until the public could gather and discuss this in detail. That was not done and the plan shows it. I will address several problems with this planning effort. The plan's "green ambitions," need much closer examination. Mr. Billy Fleming, professor of landscape architecture recently said something that can be applied here. He said, "We don't need playful design proposals. We need... prototypes for the resilient futures we've been promised." He and I are critical of plans that cram many people into small spaces. COVID has highlighted this. In relation to my personal connections to the area, I have two specific criticisms. First, the ideas in pages 57 to 59 involve Paradise Creek. As a director with the non-profit group that started the Educational Park in 1993, I have worked to protect Paradise Creek and have seen this work be a stimulus for the removal of the toxic City Dump, expansion of park space, and the building of affordable apartments. TODO's plan directs its focus upstream north of 18th Street. While the page 59 designs are a start, I believe that the flooding has worsened at 18th St. between Hoover and National City Blvd. to the point where a planned retreat out of the flood plain is required for all buildings and streets. 18th Street is not the only way through to freeways. Cars and buses can certainly pass through on 16th and 22nd. The folly of National City's earlier approval of buildings in the flood plain can be reversed. Let's really restore Paradise Creek, keep it a public space and open it up to natural flood control, habitat restoration, and walking and bike paths, instead of the design called out. Secondly, as a resident of the westside of I-5, I have studied the bike path plan on pages 34 and 35. encourage you to reject the plan to close the 19th Street underpass to traffic and build a bike path and mini -park. There needs to be more traffic circulation analysis before determining the best way to connect bike paths in Old Town to the Bayshore Bikepath. The roadway can contain a two way bike path without anymore than one car lane in one direction. A mini -park should be built on McKinley Ave near the apartment complex there and along the Bayshore Bikepath that will run there. In the daylight, the children of the area will have the open space they need. The problems with the plan in tonight's agenda are numerous and significant. Do not create dangerous conditions for motorists and bikers by making one underpass a two-way street. We experienced this when Cal Trans constructed the Earthquake retrofit on the overpass. Big -rig trucks use this street in both directions, primarily to 1-5. Do not create a hazard by narrowing the street and then connecting back to the very busy Wilson Avenue and the proposed one-way 92 568 of 592 McKinley Ave. Do not make this project about park space. National City and Cal Trans has provided minimal cleanup of the homeless camps under the freeway here. City crews have never maintained the underpasses. Trash and graffiti have accumulated over the years. This somewhat inaccessible path and mini -park may increase police calls to the area. The lowest point in the underpass currently floods, is impassable during rains, and has a dry weather runoff/ groundwater problem. While the appearance of the concrete walls is horrendous, a better plan can improve the area and not bring in new issues. This element should be rejected tonight. Thank you, Ted Godshalk 93 569 of 592 Martin Reeder From: Danny Serrano <dannys@environmentalhealth.org> Sent: Monday, May 17, 2021 3:12 PM To: Planning Commission Subject: RE: Agenda #3 (24th Street TODO Plan) - EHC's Comments Attachments: 5_17_2021_24thSTTODO_EHC Comments_Agenda_3 NC PC.pdf CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking links, especially from unknown senders. Dear Chair Dela Paz: EHC is always pleased to collaborate with City staff on environmental justice efforts. EHC and the City have a long history of working together to improve the health and environment of our communities. EHC believes that the City values environmental justice which is evident from past planning efforts such as the City's Westside Specific Plan, the City's amortization program, and the City's Health and Environmental Justice Element. We are writing to you today to share EHC's perspective about the proposed TODO project. EHC's goal is to ensure the very best outcomes for the existing residents within the TODO project's footprint, particularly within Old Town. EHC has attended all workshops to date and has actively engaged with City staff. The purpose of our attached letter is to reiterate that none of the comments that EHC has consistently made over the course of more than a year have been properly addressed. We urge the City to engage in collaborative public participation strategies and address the concerns EHC and community members have raised for over a year. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, DANNY SERRANO, AICP CAMPAIGN DIRECTOR Environmental Health Coalition I Environmental Health & Justice Campaign 2727 Hoover Avenue, Suite 202, National City, CA 91950 Cell (619) 850 1527 Email: dannys@environmentalhealth.org EHC WEB I EHC TWITTER I EHC FACEBOOK EMPOWERING PEOPLE • ORGANIZING COMMUNITIES • ACHIEVING JUSTICE EHYIROHIEKTAL •RE11[TI1[ ALITIDN S40Yaa rsofEJ 110E4 Ma;itl�ry (r#t�r�.uti�r. AUGUST 20, 2020 94 570 of 592 tt ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH COALITION May 17, 2021 Maria Dela Paz Chair Planning Commission City of National City 1243 National City Blvd. National City, CA 91950 10 EARS 2727 HOOVER AVE., SUITE 202 NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950 (619)474-0220 ENVIRONMENTALHEALTH.ORG Via: P1cPubComment@nationalcityca.gov RE: May 17, 2021 Planning Commission Hearing — Environmental Health Coalition's (EHC) Comments and Concerns — Agenda #3 (24th Street TODO Plan) Dear Chair Dela Paz: EHC is always pleased to collaborate with City staff on environmental justice efforts. EHC and the City have a long history of working together to improve the health and environment of our communities. EHC believes that the City values environmental justice which is evident from past planning efforts such as the City's Westside Specific Plan, the City's amortization program, and the City's Health and Environmental Justice Element. We are writing to you today to share EHC's perspective about the proposed TODO project. EHC's goal is to ensure the very best outcomes for the existing residents within the TODO project's footprint, particularly within Old Town. EHC has attended all workshops to date and has actively engaged with City staff. The purpose of this letter is to reiterate that none of the comments that EHC has consistently made over the course of more than a year have been properly addressed. Enclosed is a copy of our last comment letter submitted during the Planning Commission/City Council Workshop on January 26, 2021. We urge the City to engage in collaborative public participation strategies and address the concerns EHC and community members have raised for over a year. Thank you for your time and consideration. Please contact Danny Serrano/Campaign Director at dannys@environmentalhealth.org for any additional information. EMPOWERING PEOPLE. ORGANIZING COMMUNITIES. ACHIEVING JUSTICE. EMPODERANDO ALA GENTE. ORGANIZANDO LAS COMUNIDADES. LOGRANDO LA JUSTICIA. 95 571 of 592 Sincerely, Diane Takvorian Executive Director DannySerrano Campaign Director Enclosed: EHC's 1/26/2021 Letter to City Council 96 572 of 592 IRENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH COALITION January 26, 2021 40 :ARS 2727 HOOVER AVE .,SUITE 202 I NATIONAL CITY, CA 91950 I (514)474-0220 I ENVIRONMENTALHEALTH.ORG Mayor Sotelo-Solis and City Council City of National City 1243 National City Blvd. National City, CA 91950 Via: clerk@nationalcityca.gov RE: January 26, 2021 TODO Workshop — Environmental Health Coalition's (EHC) Comments and Concerns Dear Mayor Sotelo-Solis and City Council: EHC is always pleased to collaborate with City staff on environmental justice efforts. EHC and the City have a long history of working together to improve the health and environment of our communities. EHC believes that the City values environmental justice; this is evident from past planning efforts such as the City's Westside Specific Plan, the City's amortization program, and the City's Health and Environmental Justice Element. We are writing to you today to share EHC's perspective about the proposed TODO project. EHC's goal is to ensure the very best outcomes for the existing residents within the TODO project's footprint, particularly within Old Town. EHC has attended all three workshops to date and has actively engaged with City staff. The purpose of this letter is to provide EHC's initial comments on the materials that were posted on the City's webpage on 1/21/2021. In summary, we continue to be concerned about the TODO project's lack of specific metrics and requirements for affordable housing; its potential to intensify and/or create new land use incompatibilities; its potential to displace current residents; and the overall lack of adequate information provided to enable meaningful input from the community. EHC offers the following recommendations for avoiding these impacts, and we urge the City Council to modify the proposed plan and incorporate policy direction to address these concerns. 1. Public outreach is severely inadequate. Three more workshops/webinars are needed: Although the City's project team has had many workshops, interviews, and surveys in 2020, the public outreach effort and the information shared with the community has been severely lacking. EHC provided constructive recommendations in our 7/26/2020 letter (enclosed) to improve public participation and ensure meaningful engagement, however these do not appear to have been incorporated. EMPOWERING PEOPLE. ORGANIZING COMMUNITIES. ACHIEVING JUSTICE. EMPODERANDO A LA GENTE. ORGANIIANDO LA5 (OMUNIDADES. LOGRANDO LA JUSTILIA. 97 573 of 592 2. Specific project information has not been available to the public: The scale of changes proposed throughout the TODO project area is substantial and would drastically change the vision and quality of life for these communities. While the City's 1/26/2021 staff report materials that were posted on 1/21/2021 do finally show the location of proposed up -zoned parcels and what the existing land use capacities are for those parcels, it does not include other details as to how this is a departure from existing/adopted planning documents' visions, goals, policies and was available only 5 days prior to today's workshop. EHC requests that the City address EHC's previous comments along with updated project information through a series of at least three additional workshops in order to have robust and informative public dialogue. Please note that the public outreach plan for this project, released nearly one year after the project started, clearly states that a public notice will be provided three weeks prior to the 1/26/2021workshop. Public notice was provided about today's workshop and its materials just last Thursday, 1/21/2021 (5 days ahead of tonight's workshop). We are also not aware of any significant efforts to get the word out about this event other than posting the information online. 3. Protections against gentrification/dislocation must be included and required for any additional densities associated with the TODO project. The City needs to describe and show trends related to gentrification/dislocation that would result from implementation of this plan. Since the Westside is primarily renter occupied and includes low AMIs, the City should describe how the TODO project impacts the dominant population of residents. The 1/26/2021 staff report does not discuss what requirements, if any, future project applicants would have to achieve to be able to apply for these additional densities. It is clear that the City is attempting to provide incentives to the development community in an effort to incentivize change on a faster pace within the City's environmental justice communities. This would be a huge windfall for the development community and property owners but would likely be at the expense of existing residents that overwhelming rent and do not own property and who have long endured land use incompatibilities. This project needs to identify what protections the City will provide to mitigate gentrification and how the City's Amortization Program would be incorporated. EHC recommends that the City evaluate the City of San Diego's recent "Complete Communities" program adopted in 2020 and consider incorporating similar strategies that tie increased densities to clear requirements for very low, low and moderate income housing units. This approach should also be considered in areas outside of the TODO footprint area that are located near existing/future transit as part of the Focused General Plan update in an effort to better distribute the amount of density SANDAG has asked the City to accommodate in its General Plan through the RHNA process. 4. Potential to intensify and/or create new land use incompatibilities must not be allowed. The proposed Plan does not acknowledge that the project area is already significantly burdened with some of the highest levels of pollution and land use incompatibilities in the County. Locating a significant increase in housing adjacent to industrial uses and I-5 is very concerning 98 574 of 592 and would lead to more housing/industrial co -location issues already prevalent throughout the western areas of the City which is exactly what EHC and local residents have been trying to reverse for decades. Revisions must be incorporated into the TODO project to resolve this through clear guidelines incorporating buffer zones and other requirements. Because of the very limited time provided to review the City's 1/26/2021 staff report, below are EHC's initial comments on Land Use Concepts #1 - #5. As discussed above, the City must hold at least three additional workshops to hear from the community on the various land use concepts and provide the necessary information to have the dialogue. Land Use Concept #1: • Adding 246 dwelling units next to the 1-5 freeway will compromise resident health because it would expose future residents to excessive amounts of air pollution. • Adding 570 units in areas that do not currently allow housing and/or that only allow a minimum amount of housing, needs to be discussed with the community. What are the existing land uses in and around these parcels (e.g., industrial uses), what are the specific requirements for affordable housing, what are the "reinvestments" in the creek area, how would this change the existing vision for the area, specifically how would Old Town residents benefit from this proposal etc? Land Use Concept #2: • Adding housing (652 dwelling units) next to industrial uses in an industrial area would expose future residents to a disproportionate amount of pollution, the very land use situation the community has been working to reverse in Old Town for decades. For example, EHC's office is located in this area and is adjacent to two hazardous waste related companies. The City must not reverse its commitment to environmental justice by allowing residential uses and children in this area next to hazardous waste companies. Land Use Concept #3: • Adding 1,145 dwelling units in areas that don't previously allow housing needs to be discussed with the community. What are the existing land uses in and around these parcels (e.g., industrial uses), what are the specific requirements for affordable housing, what are the "reinvestments" in the area, how would this change the existing vision for the area, specifically how would existing residents benefit from this proposal etc? Land Use Concept #4: • Adding 1,443 dwelling units in areas that don't previously allow housing needs to be discussed with the community. What are the existing land uses in and around these parcels (e.g., industrial uses), what are the specific requirements for affordable housing, what are the "reinvestments" in the area, specifically how would existing 99 575 of 592 residents benefit from this proposal, how would this change the existing vision for the area, what would be the rules to "build an edge"? Land Use Concept #5: • If this area is only allowing an additional 27 units, how is it going to encourage pedestrian flow from residential neighborhoods to key corners of the avenue where retail activation may be focused? It's not clear what the design parameters might be; are there any proposed? In closing, EHC has reviewed the 1/26/2021 staff report but has not had sufficient time to discuss it with local community residents that would be most affected by it. In addition, none of EHC's previous comments have been properly addressed. We urge the City Council to engage in collaborative public participation strategies and address the concerns EHC and community members have raised for the past year. Thank you for your time and consideration. Please contact Danny Serrano/Campaign Director at dannys@environmentalhealth.org for any additional information. Sincerely, Diane Takvorian Danny f Serrano Executive Director Campaign Director Enclosed: EHC's 7/26/2020 Letter to City Staff 100 576 of 592 tt ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH COALITION July 26, 2020 Brad Raulston City Manager City of National City 1243 National City Blvd. National City, CA 91950 10 EARS 2727 HOOVER AVE., SUITE 202 NATIONAL CITY, CA. 91950 (619)474-0220 ENVIRONMENTALHEALTH.ORG Via: braulston(c�nationalcityca.gov RE: 24T1' Street TODO Project — EHC's Initial Comments and Concerns Dear Mr. Raulston: We would like to meet with you discuss the City's 24a' Street TODO project (Project) in the near future. Below are some of the main comments we raised with during our interview with City staff and the consulting team on June 15, 2020 that we'd like to discuss with you. Please note that Andrew Prescott from the Chen Ryan and Associates project team provided responses on 6/22/2020 via email to some of our responses; we have responded to that feedback in our comments below as well. • Extend the project timeline and create a transparent public outreach effort: o The community was not aware of the project: Per the City's website, "Community Outreach" began in October 2019; however, EHC only found out about the Project during the City's first webinar (Webinar #1) and survey #1 on the day of the meeting (5/27/2020) through a local stakeholder. It's our understanding that the City did not actively reach out to EHC to invite us to participate even though we have been working with the Old Town community for decades on land use andmobility related projects. The release of the webinar and survey caught many community members by surprise as well and is indicative of the limited outreach effort done to date. o EJ outreach strategies were not utilized: National City's Westside is a disadvantaged community and residents are often harder to access and need ample time to learn about public events in order to be able to plan for and participate effectively. EMPOWERING PEOPLE. ORGANIZING COMMUNITIES. ACHIEVING JUSTICE. EMPODERANDO ALA GENTE. ORGANIZANDO LAS COMUNIDADES. LOGRANDO LA JUSTICIA. 101 577 of 592 o Outreach in the time of COVID-19 must be intentional: It is our understanding that the project is scoped for three workshops and six pop-up events per the SANDAG/City contract; however, City staff mentioned that because of COVID - 19 that they are revising their outreach efforts as they go along. They said that they won't release a public outreach plan but are willing to try to put target dates for future events online and then confirmed dates as they go along per our request. We understand that COVID-19 has created some challenges to outreach and could require additional changes in the future; however, government and private agencies have had ample time to adapt and should be able to schedule and implement community participation events. Detailed public outreach goals and plans should be shared with the public accompanied by an invitation for public comment. We are reiterating our request that a detailed scope of work, project description, timeline and schedule be uploaded to the project website (in English/Spanish) ASAP so that the public can be informed about and be partners in developing the outreach plan. After receiving public input on the outreach plan, the City should post a final version online along with an email eblast, mailer and other communication strategies at least two weeks prior to the next public participation opportunity. o No shortcuts for public outreach: We understand the urgency to complete the Project to meet SANDAG's timelines, but this should not be at the expense of having a broad and transparent public outreach effort. Our National City environmental justice community deserves better. We understand that staff is in the process of requesting an extension from SANDAG to push the project deadline into 2021; we hope that staff takes advantage of additional time to create greater transparency and trust with the community. EHC would be happy to support that request. o Community concerns must be addressed: Shortly after Webinar #1 held on 5/27/2020, City staff presented the results of the event along with the surveys received at the City Council on 6/2/2020. Staff mentioned, during their response to Council comments, that although a lot of great feedback was provided, no major issues were received. EHC believes that, had the City coordinated Webinar #1 and the survey with an effective outreach effort, additional stakeholders (e.g., residents of the Westside Specific Plan area, EHC staff, etc) would have been able to participate and provide several concerns (e.g., existing conditions report, public outreach strategy, greater transparency, and need to study environmental justice issues). Therefore, staff's report of a lack of significant issues presented on 6/2/2020 was not accurate and is rather indicative of a deficient outreach effort to 102 578 of 592 date. We feel that this issue should be communicated to the public and City Council and that the fix should be an effective outreach effort as discussed above. o Conduct effective outreach BEFORE Webinar #2: It's our understanding, that Webinar #2 has been pushed back to July 28 (vs. the end of June) to allow for additional interviews and to better advertise the event. As mentioned above, our request is that the City post a detailed project description, timeline and outreach plan on the project website to gain public input prior to subsequent workshops andsurveys. Given the status of the project deliverables thus far, we believe that it is much too soon to have a subsequent Webinar or survey. Andrew Prescott indicated that staff is scheduling interviews with MTS, Olivewood Gardens, UCSD, Kimball Elementary, and Paradise Creek Educational Center. And, we understand that staff has met with other stakeholders as well. Please include a summary of each of the interviews (and any comment letters received from stakeholders) to the project website as well prior to subsequent workshops/surveys etc. • Revise and recirculate the draft Existing Conditions Report to address land use and environmental justice issues and public input prior to subsequent workshops. o The Draft Existing Conditions Report is inadequate and must address EJ issues. On 6/15/2020, the Project team and City staff mentioned that they are working on edits to the Existing Conditions report and that it is likely to be completed by the end of June 2020. Due to the deficient public outreach effort and draft Existing Conditions Report, EHC feels that a quick turnaround time on the Report is not feasible. The Draft Existing Conditions Report (May 2020) should be revised to: • Address community input; • Include land use information (existing allowable densities/intensities) from which to understand the future delta/change in any proposed overlay; • Address Environmental Justice baseline information such as: Health and EJ Element policies, description of the EJ community's demographic information, CalEnviroscreen 3.0 (CES 3.0), AB 617 Community Air Protection Program information, and air quality baseline information. • Describe and show how the project area is already significantly burdened with some of the highest levels of pollution and land use incompatibilities so that any plans should help to improve this situation, not worsen it for its residents. • Describe and show trends related to gentrification/dislocation since the Westside is primarily renter occupied and includes low AMIs. 103 579 of 592 Andrew Prescott's 6/23/2020 email mentions that the Existing Conditions report will be revised to address the CalEnviroScreen map and summary and include a discussion of the City's Environmental Justice Element. Andrew's email did not address the other comments EHC raised on this Report thus far and restated above. EHC hopes that the environmental justice analysis in the Existing Conditions Report is thorough and addresses the issues raised in this letter vs the addition of "a paragraph here and there" per the project team on 6/15/2020. EHC is happy to meet with City staff and collaborate on this effort. Preparing baseline data is an extremely critical part of any planning effort because it is the basis from which to inform policy. When it is not done adequately, it can lead to policies that don't reflect the needs of the local community and then often leads to project challenges, delays etc. • Release the TOD Feasibility Study prior to Webinar #2 to give the community time to review it only after EHC's comments above have been addressed. o Release TOD Feasibility Study several weeks prior to presenting it at future events and only after comments raised in this letter have been addressed. The project team indicated that the amortization program is a great albeit very slow tool and are looking at ways to promote the adaptive reuse and/or revitalization of industrial uses through land use incentives (e.g., the overlay). However, the project team mentioned that the proposed densities will not likely be that much different/higher and that they are aware of trying to avoid gentrification. It's our understanding that the TOD Feasibility Study would show the main areas to be included in the overlay zone and the market feasibility of accomplishing increased densities/intensities. However, EHC does not believe, for reasons stated above, that the City is ready to discuss the TOD Feasibility Study and/or its recommendations with the public because of the lack of public outreach and deficiencies with the existing conditions reports. Please address those issues first prior to releasing the TOD Feasibility Study and discussing it at future workshops. Once these issues have been addressed, then EHC would like to collaborate with the City on the Feasibility Study prior to its release to the public. 104 580 of 592 Thank you for your time and consideration. Please contact Diane Takvorian/Executive Director at Diane@environmentalhealth.org or Danny Serrano/Campaign Director at dannys@environmentalhealth.org for any additional information. Sincerely, Diane Takvorian Executive Director Campaign Director 105 581 of 592 RESOLUTION NO. 2021-04 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, RECOMMENDING ADOPTION TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY THE 24TH STREET TRANSIT -ORIENTED DEVELOPMENT OVERLAY (TODO) PLAN. APPLICANT: CITY -INITIATED. CASE FILE NO. 2021-07 WHEREAS, the TODO Plan analyzes land uses and provides an expanded vision for the area with land use and mobility recommendations, including enhanced streetscape, new opportunities for public spaces, transit -supportive land uses, and improved mobility and parking options; and, WHEREAS, this approach will develop key project goals, including the development of housing and parking policies that support increased housing choices, identify projects that improve connectivity through the area and across Interstate-5, create Smart Growth and Complete Streets opportunities, continue development of conceptual plans for the D Avenue Complete Street Project, and explore opportunities for a multi -use path along the Metropolitan Transit System right-of-way and/or Hoover Avenue; and, WHEREAS, on May 15, 2018, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2018-70 authorizing the filing of an application for Smart Growth Incentive Program (SGIP) grant funds through Transnet for multiple City projects, including the TODO Plan; and, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council adopt National City's TODO Plan, funded by a $500,000 Transnet SGIP grant with matching funds in the amount of $60,000 provided by the City; and, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this Resolution be transmitted forthwith to the applicant and to the City Council. ATTACHMENT 5 106 582 of 592 CERTIFICATION: This certifies that the Resolution was adopted by the Planning Commission at their meeting of May 17, 2021, by the following vote: AYES: Dela Paz, Sanchez, Yamane, Sendt, Roman, Natividad, Valenzuela NAYS: None. ABSENT: None. ABSTAIN: None. 107 583 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: City Manager Report. (City Manager) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 584 of 592 Item # 06/01/21 City Manager Report (City Manager) 585 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Update on City Sponsored Events. (Community Services) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 586 of 592 Item # June 1,2021 UPDATE ON CITY SPONSORED EVENTS (Community Services) 587 of 592 The following page(s) contain the backup material for Agenda Item: Discussion on City Council Policy No. 110 entitled "Display of Flags". (City Manager) Please scroll down to view the backup material. 588 of 592 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 1, 2021 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE: Discussion on City Council Policy No. 110 entitled "Display of Flags". (City Manager) PREPARED BY: Brad Raulston PHONE: 619-336-4256 EXPLANATION: DEPARTMENT: City Manager APPROVED BY: At the May 18th, 2021 City Council Meeting, staff was directed by the City Council to bring Policy No. 110 entitled "Display of Flags" for discussion. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: ACCOUNT NO. N/A ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: N/A ORDINANCE: INTRODUCTION: FINAL ADOPTION: APPROVED: APPROVED: Finance MIS STAFF RECOMMENDATION: N/A BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: N/A ATTACHMENTS: 1. City Council Policy No. 110 — Display of Flags 589 of 592 CITY COUNCIL P CITY OF NATIONAL CITY P To establisb guidedims governing the flying of tho fofl.owng 15 flgs; United Statera.of erica. State-- of .Clfmia City ofNatiota City litavy 'ohm .Corps AitH.Forct 'llnitutd Mmti. Na Air tota'Retired. World WAr 11, Commomontivt: I(o.toa War V6teraus - Vietnam Vetixs The City. of' aitionitti City . obsOtves the. fbtiowing..protiocfol. *iill.reoppot to the dig. 'ay of the, na.. 1) tale clipplayd from utirisv, touttset leasproporly 1 2.) Willbeladistod brio 0.1cmered-coreolonicasiy.;. togsv:411.:not b.o.a4.01 *1104. the. wo Tor is: iltiotnelit,Uctpt. wbvt.alvall-wather ilagis. &playa 4) ThoCity • pneris auth.otized to. display at Citytedings--ther.:Ukkited States .ftag: At. ha stefin.,.accorame .with the ro1e4.04forth.below.04 tch tixns as e..rresideutof the Unied Sttes, the-Clovtitior of th6 So* of Califortila,. or _a requo.aby the 04y Managr and torietirthe..e: by the Myor with mtificatiot to. the City Gotinatchadtg the riot :ay,41161)10..C.4 •Covatil, ir.teeting prosoribe suela Itati.ort. 590 of 592 CITY COUNCIL P OLIO( .CITY OF 'NATIONAL CITY Thirty ;days 01°174 the.. doRth ftv..Pmsklt Traor Ptostdmti. b) Tea day' f.iona day.of deathOA Vice4Prostamt,: Chief 4-atict- of gip United . Stalesiu a 'Speaket. :of to 140,160 Itepos,entaivet... 'Tho. day- -of deft and. ,ott 141e: fotlowlog day fot -a United. Statos. .Senato. Roprapptidive, the 'Ociv:ornorof thz..:State cf Caljfernh,. and any viewed .officiaa ofthe City 'ofNti,-.Qnal:Ci On. to do scavvorldng. d.ay t 461 to -:of ititornitoa. for emplo.:1,0o.of the :City tf. Natiotila City ) Thefa.gs: vcill be flownat 11alfRpisuifforlth following 64.ys: 0) P0404 Officers' Menlotial 1) May. 1.:$.;utlet.§: that de&is als.o Arind Form.p. Dity..(traso to. gurist), :46 odal Day,: last im ynaIse to t1Q_on... 4) PartotPayleptember 1.1,, suiviWO:gOrpt, d) ?,tr1HaroRetritnibranotDa Deoembo :„: gntio:to .ttolset. e) Nationd Pirofightors . Day, rOUItkIg otat.t.; ip,: Ootobtz, .VP106 a. SurldaY (sunvise to. 81431.st),, tion: flg :the .i1ag at a statis. w1i be holgol. to the-.. pekalk tor 'art ia..:;4114: 1'4.0i:towered, to te,titi,thistaffpo§itiorti .6); cOri, flie.13:Dited ‘$tato, 1:61atootealifor:01.40Mitiv..-, qty K-0mA iflags wifl bettow-rt: 24 bouts,„ 7 klay$_a week, 04elat 4). the ease:...of ittlezettt weather., •The hours 7) .13,01.1oca.#000.s. T,3iiiitecl.SX2tCS. fld. t at: . of .C1:41-!1brniet 'the hoIias Thted beiow1 hi additie 1-to.!K: other 'flas -on_ port* 'bolidays as 1istdbe1iw Itotgoratiol.DAy. jarlutt 20th Pap. 2 of 591 of 592 ITV CITY NATIONALAPTY OOiTETh 3UIY14, 1987 A N b). l?tosidnt Day Mondayin Fobruaxy 6) Armed Foroes Day — .Saturdy in May (CoremorfiAl 114:10!will Itioft. a Kimball Bowl) d):. Motiorial, Day 'Pi- tirtai1t Monday Etii Ma' (Clerottwini al. flap:will:be. fibwri.atKiniball. 'Bowl) o) DAY mi-.Panie.14. .(Gotomonal.flugs wW bellown at :Kmball t 0100 liteptaddtoe Day —.AO 4 :(Cermnaliteil flag$- Bow) .Ibbr Day P Monk in:S.6.p.teAttbei- 1i), ..(difdrata ,Aclinis$1611.1)4y-----Sp.*iiibt.- PaiticaDay ,-.Septariber .11.:(Ceveroditi_!flag will 1.:io,110.- 1.6.0.00:130A) S) Votiorohs.'.1) ay Novrnbr 1 1 (Q0ovionirit.fitugs wffl be flowatKtrnbU 3330:1) k) Per11 Harbor Day --i-:December '7 (Ceranorilalitagswtlib flwn at Kiufl Bo*.1) 11). :Mer dAys..that viay be pre1airnd:by the .1?rpsidilt fthe tilted.'S'te 8) ThelalowIng .dcpartmontp: ;aro onpomiblo for raisiug lowexing faga-tit.the 4044.10eatiorm • Ltt8.. P:41tna.$:..Padc-w. :Jo itsqn. Las Pirnas Mnkpa PO!**PubTh Workm Deutiriit. 1)) Lbr417 Pubth Works E Depart:04. Works Dpormr4 d), ?dim Dcvartrriot—i Woilts.. Dp. Inept ) Pire,l)vOtinnt Otaons-'#:31, tad Ili 34) D• Kitobail BONN' -- Ptite Wbrks:"PettatImentr. mb411.-Xecreation_Caitero-r...Pabrio WorkaDepatnient. Page 3 of 3 592 of 592