The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2000 12-12 CC AGENDA PKTAGENDA OF A REGULAR MEETING NATIONAL CITY COUNCIL COUNCIL CHAMBERS 1243 NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD REGULAR MEETING - TUESDAY, DECEMBER 12, 2000 - 6:00 P.M. i OPEN TO THE PUBLIC PLEASE COMPLETE A REQUEST TO SPEAK FORM PRIOR TO THE COMMENCEMENT OF THE MEETING AND SUBMIT IT TO THE CITY CLERK IT IS THE INTENTION OF YOUR CITY COUNCIL TO BE RECEPTIVE TO YOUR CONCERNS IN THIS COMMUNITY. YOUR PARTICIPATION IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT WILL ASSURE A RESPONSIBLE AND EFFICIENT CITY OF NATIONAL CITY. WE INVITE YOU TO BRING TO THE ATTENTION OF THE CITY MANAGER ANY MATTER THAT YOU DESIRE THE CITY COUNCIL TO CONSIDER. WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR PRESENCE AND WISH YOU TO KNOW THAT WE APPRECIATE YOUR INVOLVEMENT. ROLL CALL PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG BY THE CITY MANAGER, TOM MCCABE INVOCATION APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF DECEMBER 5, 2000. COUNCIL AGENDA 12/12/00 Page 2 PRESENTATIONS 1. Presentation on Paradise Creek Educational Park Conceptual Plan. (Parks & Recreation) *Refer to Item #11 INTERVIEWS/APPOINTMENTS Port Commissioner Reappointment - Jess Van Deventer PUBLIC HEARING 2. Public Hearing on Police Department request for Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Funds. (Police Department) *Refer to Item #10* CONSENT CALENDAR Consent Calendar: Consent Calendar items involve matters, which are of a routine or noncontroversial nature. All consent calendar items are adopted by approval of a single motion by the City Council. Prior to such approval, any item may be removed from the consent portion of the agenda and separately considered, upon request of a Councilmember, a staff member, or a member of the public. 3. Resolution No. 2000-160 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City awarding a contract to Geoscene Construction, Inc. for the Civic Center Drive and National City Boulevard Improvement Project. (Engineering Spec. No. 00-5) (Engineering) 4. Resolution No. 2000-161 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City, California, approving the subdivision of a vacant 61420 square foot lot into nine single-family parcels at the northwest corner of E. 16th Street and M Avenue. Applicant: Frank and Linnea Arrington. (Case File No. S-2000-2) (Planning) COUNCIL AGENDA 12/12/00 Page 3 CONSENT CALENDAR (Cont.) 5. Claim for Damages: Sorina Andrade (City Clerk) 6. Claim for Damages: Larry Williams (City Clerk) 7. WARRANT REGISTER #23 (Finance) Ratification of Demands in the amount of $1,136,425.76. NON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS 8. Resolution No. 2000-162 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the submittal of a grant application, the incurring of an obligation, the execution of a grant agreement and any amendments thereto, and any other documents necessary to secure a Code Enforcement Incentive Program (CEIP) grant from the State of California to implement a Code Enforcement Incentive Program. (Building & Safety) 9. Resolution No. 2000-163 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the submittal of a grant application, the incurring of an obligation, the execution of a grant agreement and any amendments thereto, and any other documents necessary to secure a Code Enforcement Incentive Program (CEIP) grant from the State of California to implement a Community Code Enforcement Pilot Program. (Building & Safety) 10. Resolution No. 2000-164 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the City Manager to submit the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant application to the U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance and to sign Grant Award Agreement and all grant related documents. (Police) *Refer to Item #2* COUNCIL AGENDA 12/12/00 Page 4 NON CONSENT RESOLUTIONS (Cont.) 11. Resolution No. 2000-165 Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the Mayor to execute an amendment to the Agreement between the City of National City and Schmidt Design Group to provide construction documents, conceptual design and permit processing for Paradise Creek Educational Park. (Parks & Recreation) *Refer to Item #1 ORDINANCES FOR INTRODUCTION 12. An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of National City amending Chapter 13.12 of the National City Municipal Code, pertaining to encroachment permits for installation, maintenance and removal of facilities in streets, rights -of -way and other public property. (City Attorney) 13. An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of National City establishing the salaries of the Mayor, the City Council, and the Chairman Members of the Community Development Commission. (City Attorney) WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS 14. Valley Rainbow Interconnect. (SDG&E representative to make presentation) NEW BUSINESS 15. War Memorial Bowl in Kimball Park. (Public Works) 16. Notice of Decision - Conditional Use Permit for a wireless communication facility at 2435 Sweetwater Road (Applicant: Tim Kolset, WFI for Sprint) (Case File No. CUP-2000-24) (Planning) COUNCIL AGENDA 12/12/00 Page 5 NEW BUSINESS (Cont.) 17. Notice of Decision - Conditional Use Permit for a wireless communication facility at 330 National City Boulevard. (Applicant: Gerald Moorer, JM Consulting for GTE Wireless) (Case File No. CUP-2000-11) (Planning) 18. Notice of Decision - Approval of a Conditional Use Permit to allow alcohol sales in a proposed restaurant at 2980 Plaza Bonita Road (formerly 3030 Plaza Bonita Road) (Applicant: Fancher Development Services/Nina Raey) (Case File No.: CUP-2000-26) (Planning) 19. Notice of Decision - Approval of a Coastal Development Permit to allow construction of a seven -foot tall fence and a variance to allow the fence to be located within the required setback areas at the Historic Railcar Plaza at the southeast corner of Harrison Avenue and Bay Marina Drive (Applicant: San Diego Unified Port District) (Case File Nos. CDP-2000-5, Z-2000-8) (Planning) 20. Request to use the Community Center for a Staff Forum by the County of San Diego and waiver of fees. (Public Works) 21. Request to use the Community Center for a Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment Program and waiver of fees. (Public Works) 22. Use of the Community Center by the South Bay Community Service for Safe Night Events. (Public Works) 23. Use of the Community Center by the National City Adult School Computer Class for a graduation ceremony. (Public Works) 24. Year End Audit Reports for fiscal year ended June 30, 2000. (Finance) COUNCIL AGENDA 12/12/00 Page 6 NEW BUSINESS (Cont.) - CITY MANAGER -- CITY ATTORNEY 25. Report on Tobacco Products Regulation (City Attorney) --> OTHER STAFF - MAYOR -> CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC ORAL COMMUNICATIONS (Five -Minute Time Limit) NOTE: Pursuant to State Law, items requiring Council action must be brought back on a subsequent Council agenda unless they are of a demonstrated emergency or urgent nature. ADJOURNMENT Next Regular City Council Meeting - January 9, 2000 at 6:00 p.m. - Council Chambers, Civic Center. TAPE RECORDINGS OF EACH CITY COUNCIL MEETING ARE AVAILABLE FOR SALE AND TO LISTEN TO IN THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT .METING DATE December 12 :2000 ITEM TITLE Paradise Creek Educational Park Conceptual Plan *Refer to I1 m. 11 AGENDA ITEM NO. 1 PREPARED 8V Jim Ruiz (�t. DEPARTMENT Parks & Recreation EXPLANATION In July 1999, the City entered into a contract with Schmidt Design Group to develop the Paradise Creek Educational Park Conceptual Plan (funded by a $50,000 grant from the California State Coastal Conservancy). After numerous meetings with City staff and school officials, the conceptual plan has been completed and ready for presentation to the City Council by the architect. The presentation will allow the council to make comments and recommendations on the conceptual plan. The next step will be to proceed with construction plans and specifications to be developed by the architect. This phase will be _funded from a $700,000 grant from the State. Environmental Review N/A Proposed Negative Declaration Financial Statement Account No TAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve conceptual plan; proceed with construction plans. The vegetation and soils on the 0.07 acre of salt marsh that is proposed to be disturbe during the constructionphase of the project will be salvaged in as much as it is if6tiii5ailarAliabrilizeincommENDATIoN Approval. TA TACHMENTS (listed Below) Resolution No, Environmental Initial Study A-200 (Rev. 7/80) RECOMMENDED CONDITION OF APPROVAL FOR THE DRAFT PARADISE CREEK EDUCATIONAL PARK ENHANCEMENT PLAN The vegetation and soils on the 0.07 acre of salt marsh that is proposed to be disturbed during the construction phase of the project will be salvaged for reuse, as determined upon consultation with the California Department of Fish and Game. \ 2A, City of National City Planning Department 1243 National City Blvd., National City, CA 91950 (619) 336-4310 ROGER G. POST - DIRECTOR INITIAL STUDY Project plans & Environmental Assessment Case File No.: IS-2000-7 form received on: September 15, 2000 Reference Files: Environmental Assessment form determined complete by: Andrew Hoskinson, Planning Technician Date: October 2, 2000 Initial Study completed by: Andrew Hoskinson Revised by: Andrew Hoskinson Address of Project: Project Description: Environmental Setting: Date: October 23, 2000 Date: December 6, 2000 Paradise Creek and adjacent vacant land north of 22R° Street and south of 1 r Street, east of Wilson Avenue, and west of Roosevelt Avenue. The project proposes to create .6 acre of wetland habitat, and to enhance and expand an existing City park for wetlands educational and interpretive purposes. Specifically the project plans propose the following structural improvements: a partially covered outdoor amphitheater that will seat 120 people, a 6 foot wide raised boardwalk, and two 20 foot diameter raised observation nodes. Proposed plans were developed in consultation with the United States Fish and Wildlife Service, the California Department of Fish and Game, and with funding from the California Coastal Conservancy. The project site is along a 1,500 foot length of Paradise Creek, which is disturbed and channelized to flow in a straight line. Wetland vegetation has re-established itself along the stream banks. The total site is approximately 4 acres and includes a portion of the City Public Works yard, the creek bed, and upland areas. Other adjacent uses include a school, industrial zoned businesses, as well as residential properties. Conclusion: 1) X A Negative Declaration is proposed, since Rccvckd Papc (a) There is no substantial evidence that the project may have a significant effect on the environment; or X (b) The project may result in a significant environmental impact but revisions in the plans by the applicant mitigate or avoid the effects where clearly no significant effects would occur; or 2) An EIR is required since the project may result in a significant environmental impact. RECOMMENDATION: That the decision -making body consider the proposed Negative Declaration together with any comments received during the public review process and find on the basis of the Intial Study and any comments received that there is no substantial evidence that the project will have a significant effect on the environment. ANALYSIS: There is no substantial evidence that the project will have.a significant impact on the environment based on the following discussion of potential, non -significant impacts. The analysis is partially based on a Baseline Soil and Water Assessment (08/23/00) prepared by Christopher Maxin, a Wetland Delineation (08/24/00) study prepared by Tierra Environmental Services, and a Hydrologic study (08/99) conducted by Robert Bein William Frost and Associates. BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES: A total of .07 acre (3,049 sq. ft.) of salt marsh would be temporarily impacted as a result of this project. It would be mitigated through the restoration of the same .07 acre of salt marsh and the creation of .6 acre of new salt marsh habitat (an 8.5:1 mitigation ratio). The California Department of Fish and Game has reviewed this level of mitigation and found it adequate (Letter dated November 27, 2000). This mitigation is the major part of the project, proposed as an environmental enhancement by the City. Temporary impacts to the salt marsh would result from the use of areas in the marsh for construction staging activities. The movement of heavy equipment into and out of the existing wetland would damage and potentially kill the existing vegetation by trampling it. This temporary impact to the salt marsh habitat would not be significant because of the high ratio of salt marsh habitat mitigation. The project would improve drainage on the site. Drainage from the proposed parking lot would be channeled into a settling basin before entering the marsh. No endangered or threatened animal species were identified as using the project site; however, there is the potential for use by endangered or threatened animal species because of the presence of supporting habitat. However, no plant species listed as threatened, endangered or rare currently exists within or adjacent to the project site. The project would increase the potential for use by expanding and enhancing the marsh habitat and would not have any potential adverse effects on wildlife resources as defined in Section 711.2 of the Fish and Game Code. LAND USE: The project is in conformance with the National City Land Use Code and the General Plan. The property is shown on the General Plan/Zoning Map as IC -OS (Civic Institutional, Open Space), a zoning designation that permits public educational facilities and public parks. General Plan policy further encourages Paradise Creek restoration. GEOLOGIC HAZARDS: Seismic activity typical of the region may affect the project site. Uniform Building Code standards for construction and Engineering standards for design will address concerns for safety arising from potential groundshaking. Therefore, there will be no significant geologic impacts. REMOVAL OF EXISTING CONDITIONS: In the course of creating .6 acre of upper, middle and lower salt marsh habitat, it would be necessary to temporarily impact .07 acre of existing salt marsh habitat to allow for the implementation of the proposed grading plan. The .07 acre of salt marsh would be restored at a 1:1 mitigation ratio, while the total mitigation ratio will be 8.5:1. This temporary impact to existing salt marsh is not considered significant because of the final 8.5:1 salt marsh habitat mitigation ratio. Additionally, a couple of minor hardscape areas in the existing City park would be removed and replaced with either trees or turf. LIGHT AND GLARE: A new boardwalk between 18th Street and 22"d Street would be equipped with 120V safety lighting. The lights would be spaced according to the manufacturer's specifications, and will be a maximum of 2 feet tall. The lights should also be shaded as to not light the natural habitat areas. Additionally, no lights are proposed in other park areas. The closest adjacent uses to the boardwalk between 18th Street and 22nd Street are almost 100 feet away. Therefore, the new lighting is not expected to have any adverse impacts on nearby land uses. INCREASED FLOODING: The project would be partially located in the 100-year floodplain. According to FEMA's Flood Insurance Study, the Paradise Creek 100-year water surface profile is determined more by backwater from the Sweetwater River than from water flow in Paradise Creek. So the floodplain improvements should not adversely impact the adjacent 100-year water surface elevations, because the level of the Sweetwater River, and not the creek configuration controls the water surface elevations in Paradise Creek (Robert Hein William Frost and Associates, 1999). The National City Engineering Department, as Floodplain Administer, has determined that the project does not require a Flood Hazard Area Permit. ALTERATION OF VIEWS: The proposed project is located in an urban setting, and will be built on a site that currently comprises an underutilized City park, a portion of the existing National City public works yard, and vacant land. The project would enhance the appearance of the existing City park and vacant site. All of the proposed improvements would only be visible from the properties that are located adjacent to the proposed project site. REDUCTION OF SOLAR ACCESS: There would be no adverse impact to solar opportunities for passive heating and cooling on the surrounding properties. The proposed improvements would not impact the solar access opportunities because of their low profile and distance from surrounding uses. PUBLIC FACILITIES AND SERVICES: No adverse effects on public services and facilities are anticipated. The project requires minor extension of utility services to provide lighting and water, such as for irrigation. These utilities are already provided in the project area. The City park and Paradise Creek are components of the City open space system; therefore, they are considered public facilities. The enhancement of the City park and the expansion of Paradise Creek wetland are improvements to an existing facility. TRAFFIC: The project will result in a negligible traffic increase because of the passive use of the site, and the minimal parking that will be provided. The project is a small, passive use area that does not encourage many vehicle trips. NOISE: There will be no adverse impacts from noise associated with the project. The construction of the project will result in temporary noise increases to the surrounding uses; however, the construction noise will be controlled by the City's Noise Ordinance. CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA INITIAL STUDY (General Instructions) The State of California requires cities to assess the environmental impact of all development projects before permits for such action are issued. •The attached form will assist you in presenting the environmental effects of your project. The form consists of the following sections. A. BACKGROUND INFORMATION You will be asked to give a general description of the project ar.i its environmental setting. B. ASSESSMENT OF ENVIRONmENTAL IMPACT You will be asked to respond to a series of yes/no questions. A "yes" answer will mean the project could have significant environmental effects. These answers will be reviewed by the Environmental Impact Committee to determine whether an nnvironmental Impact Report will be required. C. ' STATEMEMT OF NO SIGNIFICANT ITVIRONI4ENTAL EFFD You should complete this section only if you answer "yes" to one or more of the questions in Section B, but still believe the project will have no significant environmental effects. D. ADDITIO['IAL DATA You may be asked to answer other questions and snhtit additional information to determine whether. an EIR is required for the project. If required information is not submitted within four (4) months from receipt of written notification by the Planning Department, or an extended period of time acceptable to staff, the application and project shall be considered. withdrawn. E. CERTIFICATION You will be asked co certify the truth and accuracy of your statements. I1. ASSESSMENT OF ENVT.RO1' PirAL IMPACT Answer the following questions by placing a check in the appropriate space in Column A. Column A Column 11 Staff Analysis Specific Questions Yes Maybe No Yes Maybe No 1. Does the project significantly change the present use of the project area? (The project area includes the im- mediate location of the project, as well as more remote areas that may be directly or indirectly affected by construction and/or operation of the project.) 2 Does the project alter any unique, natural or manmade features? N& 3. Does the project affect the conser- vation of any natural or scenic re- sources or scarce natural resource:? 4. Does the project alter the biological habitat of flora, fauna or endangered species? 6. Does the.project,alter or change ex- isting features of any ocean, beach, estuary, bay or tidelands? Does the project alter the land form of topography in excess of 25 percent? 7 Will the project contribut.! to in- crease flooding? 8. Will the project' increase the possi- bility of erosion or aedi.mentat:i.on? 9. Does the project involve any geologi- cal hazards? 10. Will the project increase the possi- bility of earth slippage? 11. Will the project contribute advers- ly to the quality of air? Y v V } TTIAL STUDY (continued) B. ASSESSMENT OP ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT (continued) Column A 19.• Will the project require a change in zone, adopted community or general plan?' 20. Does the project require any variation from existing codes and ordinances? 21. Will the project significantly change the average population density of the community? 22. Will the project alter the lifestyle of the community? Column B Staff Analysis Yes Maybe No ' Yes Maybe No 23. Will the project result in overcrowding, a lack of privacy for adjoining develop- ment within the community? 24. Will the project alter or eliminate views? 25. Will the project reduce solar access or opportunities for passive heating and cooling on the site or on nearby property or result in ocher effects on climate or micro -climate? 26. Will the project result in increased light or glare? 27. Will the project alter or limit access to public facilities or recreational resources? 28. Will the project affect existing transportation systems? 29. Will the project affect the existing utility networks? 30. Will -the project affect the existing community facilities or city services? 31. Does the project involve the demolition or removal of existing improvements? V t/ V \7I cniv1PONVL,"1'hL T- ;SESSI4El'T l/Car:ENT (continual) Ce STATD4ENT OP NO SICTvz ..kAl1T ENVIRONMENTAL ETTECPS If you have answered yes to one or fore of the f i questions esti ns in mentSecalon eiE, but still think. the project will have no sig nt ts indicate your reasons below. THIS IS VERY DIPORTANT. Attach additional pages, if necessary. • • The project poses no significant environmental impacts. A significantly important section of the Enhancement Plan includes restoration and enhancement of the wetland communities found within Paradise Creek. Enhancement activities include removal of the invasive plant species found within the creek, replacement planting of native vegetation, and widening of the creek at specific locations. The area of the creek located south east of Kimball Elementary School will experience the most dramatic widening. In this location, the western creek bank will be drawn back in a gradual slope that will bring it right up to the Learning Lab steps. This widening wi. i. provide more habitat for the creek while helping to alleviate flood potential in this area. D. ADDITIONAL DATA 1 . If there are any Army Corps of Engineers or ocher Covernner,tal Agency public notices or hermit numbers applicable to this project, cite the and give dates. ACOE 404 PERMIT CDFG 1600 PERMIT RWQCR 401 CERTIFICATE 2. Estimate the amount of grading in cubic yards. S. What are the maximum heights of non -made slopes, etc. 6 FEET E. CERTIFICATION I hereby acknowledge that the -above Enviroilnental Assessment Statement is true and accurate to the best of my knowledge. Date 9)151116 CI 11510b Date Signed p K Lt- Permit Applicant Signed f/0 JUJbiJC , oNiltof pg5161v Gltp Person who couplec d this application Initial Study 2000-7: Response to Comments (CDFG) Comment 1: `Before impacts to the .07 acre of salt water marsh occur we request that you salvage all the vegetation and existing soils. The salvage material could then be used to restore the site upon completion of the project." Response to Comment 1: The vegetation and soils on the 0.07 acre of salt marsh that is proposed to be disturbed during the construction phase of the project will be salvaged for reuse, determined upon consultation with the California Department of Fish and Game. (Condition of approval to incorporate in the plan) Comment 2: "To meet the mitigation, monitoring and reporting requirements of CEQA, the 0.07 acre impact site, as well as the 0.6 acre created wetlands site, must have a management plan to establish success criteria for the restored and created wetlands." Response to Comment 2: Sections F (Monitoring), G (Maintenance), and H (Wetlands Mitigation Success Criteria) on pages 26 and 27 of the Paradise Creek Educational Park Enhancement Plan comprise the CEQA required management plan that establishes the success criteria for the restored and created wetlands areas. Comment 3: "The Department [California Department of Fish and Game] will require a Streambed Alteration Agreement, pursuant to Section 1600 et. seq. of the Fish and Game Code, with you prior to the commencement of any activity that will divert, obstruct, or change the natural flow or the bed, channel, or bank (which may include associated riparian resources) of a river, stream or lake, or use material from a streambed." Response to Comment 3: As required, the City will seek a Streambed Alteration Agreement with the California Department of Fish and Game prior to the commencement of any activity that will divert, obstruct or change the natural flow or the bed, channel or bank (which includes associated riparian resources) of the section of Paradise Creek as defined in Section A (Geographical Context) of the Paradise Creek Educational Park Enhancement Plan. Comment 4: "[T]he document should fully identify the potential impacts to the lake, stream or riparian resources and provide adequate avoidance, mitigation, monitoring and reporting commitments for issuance of the agreement [Streambed Alteration Agreement]." Response to Comment 4: The Paradise Creek Educational Park Enhancement Plan, the Environmental Assessment Form, and the Initial Study clearly illustrate the potential impacts to the riparian resources. Initial Study 2000: Response to Comments from the California Coastal Conservancy received over the phone December 6, 2000 Comment 1: The Initial Study should be changed to a proposed Mitigated Negative Declaration. The conclusion should have 1 (b) checked, not 1 (a). Response to Comment 1: The Initial Study was revised on December 6, 2000 to reflect the request, based on the need for a recommended condition of approval. Comment 2: It should be stated in the Biological Resources section that the 8.5:1 mitigation ratio is acceptable. Response to Comment 2: The Initial Study was revised on December 6, 2000 to state that the California Department of Fish and Game has reviewed the project and its stated final mitigation ratio and found it to be adequate. Comment 3: The Public Facilities and Services section should not defer the full review of the impacts to public facilities and services until a subsequent permit process. Response to Comment 3: The Initial Study was revised on December 6, 2000 to explain that there is no anticipated significant impact to public facilities or services. Comment 4: Specific Questions number 3 and 4 on the City of National City Environmental Assessment Checklist should be changed from "no significant effect" to "yes" or "maybe." They should be changed because the project does affect a wetland and because the project also alters the flora, fauna or endangered species. Response to Comment 4: The staff analysis of Specific Questions number 3 and 4 have been changed as of December 6, 2000. Number 3 was changed to "yes" based on the projects affect on a wetland. Number 4 was changed to "maybe" because no endangered species have been identified to use the site. Comment 5: The wording in the recommended condition of approval should be clarified so that the clause "as much as practical" cannot be interpreted as monetarily undesirable, in reference to salvaging the existing soil and vegetation. Response to Comment 5: The recommended condition of approval was modified on December 6, 2000 to require consultation with the California Department of Fish and Game to determine if it is practical and desirable to salvage the existing soil and vegetation. Office of the Mayor 1243 National City Blvd., National City, CA 91950 (619) 336-4526 George H. Waters - Mayor DECEMBER 1, 2000 TO: COUNCILMEMBERS FROM: MAYOR GEORGE H. WATERS SUBJECT: PORT COMMISSIONER REAPPOINTMENT Please be advised that Jess Van Deventer's term on the Port Commission will be expiring on January 2, 2001. Mr. Van Deventer has done an excellent job with the amount of revenue he has brought into the City. If there are no objections, I recommend we reappoint Mr. Van Deventer to the Port of San Diego for a term ending January 2, 2005. This item will be placed on the Council Agenda for the meeting of December 12, 2000. GEORG Mayor GHW:nu H. WATERS ® Recycled Paper City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT «EETING DATE December 12, 2000 *Refer to Item #10 AGENDA ITEM NO. 2 ITEM TITLE PUBLIC HEARING ON POLICE DEPARTMENT REQUEST FOR LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT FUNDS PREPARED BY LT. RAY ALLEN DEPARTMENT POLICE DEPARTMENT EXPLANATION Background On August 20, 2000, the National City Police Department received an application package for a federal grant known as the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Program. These grants are administered by the U.S. Department of Justice and are similar in many respects to CDBG funds in that they are awarded to local governments who have a significant amount of flexibility in deciding how the funds are to be expended. Like CDBG funding, only a general categorical description and not specific plans on how the money will be expended needs to be submitted to the federal government in order to receive the funds. Local governments, cities and counties, are eligible for Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Funds. The amount of Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Funds that each city is eligible for is based upon the population and the crime rate according to the FBI Uniform Crime Reports. National City received $178,881 in FY 1999/2000 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funding last year. Based on the same formula, the City of National City is eligible to apply for $152,252 in FY 2000/01 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funds. (cont.) Environmental Review Nt4 RkJep +v4lC Financial Statement The local match for the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award will be $15,379. There should be no fiscal impact to the budget as the Police Department intends to fund the match with Asset Forfeiture funds. cc ant STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve the Resolution. 220-409-500-598-80 131-409-500-598-8009 BOARD ! COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On December5, 2000, the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Advisory Board voted unanimously, (3 — 0) to recommend approval of the proposed Resolution. ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) L__. LLEBG Application and Award Notification. A-200 (9(60) Resolution No. COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING FY1999/00 LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT PAGE 2 The award period for the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant would cover two federal fiscal years, (October 1, 2000 — September 30, 2002). This program requires a 10 percent local cash match. It is the intent of the Police Department to fund the local match requirement with asset forfeiture funds. One of the provisions of the 1998 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant program, is that in order to receive full funding, the City of National City must comply with Section 615, of the Fiscal Year 1998 Appropriations Act: Alu — O'Hara Public Safety Officers Health Benefits Act, which requires entities which employ peace officers to provide officers who are retired or separated from service due to injury suffered as a direct and proximate result of a personal injury sustained in the line of duty while responding to an emergency situation or hot pursuit, with the same or better level of health insurance benefits that are paid by the entity at the time of retirement or separation. Currently, the City of National City does not provide such health insurance benefits to peace officers retired under the above circumstances and is therefore out of compliance with this provision. As with the case with the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award that the City of National City received last year, this will result in a 10 percent reduction of the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Award, but not a complete disqualification from receiving the funds. The reduced Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award that the City of National City will receive will be approximately $138,411. The local match for this reduced award will be approximately $15,379. The funds under this program may be used for any of the following purposes. 1. Hiring, training, and employing new law enforcement officers and necessary support personnel, paying overtime to presently employed law enforcement officers and support personnel, and/or procuring equipment, technology, and other material related to basic law enforcement functions. 2. Enhance school security and school security measures at any facility or location the local government considers to be at risk for crime. 3. Establishing or supporting drug courts. 4. Enhancing the adjudication process of cases involving violent offenders, including cases involving violent juvenile offenders. 5 Establishing multi — jurisdictional task forces which work to prevent and combat crime. 6. Establishing crime prevention programs. COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT REQUEST FOR PUBLIC HEARING FY1999/00 LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT PAGE 3 7. Defraying the cost of indemnification or insurance for law enforcement officers. The Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funds may not be used as local matching funds for Police Officers hired under the COPS Universal Hiring Program. Because this is only a two year grant, and personnel costs are usually long term, funding under this program would be more appropriate for equipment and technology purchases than for hiring officers or other personnel. The funding under this program would be ideal for meeting some of the Police Department's equipment and technology needs. Proposal The Police Department is requesting a Resolution which would authorize the appropriation of $178,881 in FY 2000/01 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funding to C.I.P. account #220- 409-500-598-8009 for the purchase of the equipment needed to install Mobile Data Computing equipment in 18 additional police vehicles. Phase 11 of the project outfitted 10 vehicles with the Mobile Data Computing equipment. The purchase of this additional equipment will allow the officers in the field to transmit completed reports to the Automated Field Reporting System. It is the Police Department's intention, if the appropriation is approved, to provide the required cash match for those expenditures with a $15,379 in asset seizure funds. Under the proposal, the requested funds and local match would be applied towards the purchase of the necessary hardware, software, software configuration and customization, as well as the necessary interfaces to the automated field reporting system, 911 and other critical law enforcement data bases. This proposal was presented to the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Advisory Board at their meeting on December 5, 2000. The Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Advisory Board voted unanimously to recommend approval of the proposed Resolution. The Police Department currently estimates the cost of purchase of the CAD/RMS at approximately $838,391 to $1,118,000. If approved, this would bring the total amount of approved funding for the project to $1,065,169. The Police Department intends to fund the balance of the project with Supplemental Law Enforcement Services Funds. The Police Department will bring requests to Council for appropriations of those funds to the project when the city receives them. The Police Department is requesting that all of the above funds be utilized for the final phases of the Computer Aided Dispatch and Records Management System (CAD/RMS). Once this project is completed, the Police Department will have a modem day CAD/RMS with the ability to provide officer safety premises history, officer safety time prompts for dispatchers, deep field submission of all police reports, and getting vehicle and person information directly from state computer files without utilizing the police dispatchers. Local Law Enforcement Block Grant - LLEBG Introduction Page 1 of 1 Application FY 2000 Local Law Enforcement Block Grants Program National City, C4 Award RFD Grant Changes Reports Correspondence !Switch to ... Grant Handbook Application was submitted on 15-SEP-00. Click here to print a copy. View Only View Application Help/Frequently Asked Questions LLEBG Home Log -Off LLEBG FY 2000 Application Date Certified : 15-SEP-00 !Date Submitted : 15-SEP-00 Jurisdiction Information Jurlsdisction: National City County. SAN DIEGO State: CALIFORNIA CDFA Number 16.592 Budget Information Eligible Award Amount: $153,790 Final Award Amount 6138,411 Match Amount $15,379 Matching Funds Description: State and Local Government Units CEO Information Tide: City Marker Name Prefix: Mr. Last Name : McCabe First Name : Tom Address: 1243 National City Boulevard National City, California, CA 91950-4397 Telephone: (619)336- 4240 Fax: (619) 336-4327 Email: cmo@ci.national- city.ca.us Program Contact Information Tide: Lieutenant Name Prefix: Mr. Last Name : Allen First Name : Raymond Address: 1200 National City Boulevard National City, CA 91950-4397 Telephone: 619-336- 4514 Fax: 619- 336-4525 Email: rayallen_92019@yahoo.com Application Details Date Agreed to Trust Fund Requirement: 30-AUG-00 Applicant is PSOHB Compliant: No Date Agreed to SPOC Requirement: 30-AUG-00 Date Agreed to SAA Review Requirement 15-SEP-00 Date Agreed to Cerdrications: 15-SEP-00 Date Agreed to Assurances: 15-SEP-00 tittps://grants. ojp.usdoj. g,ov:8004/gms_user/pisgl/llebg_main. app_read_only?p_bgid=2 12/05/00 LLEBG 2000/2001 Each unit cost 10Ea Unit Cost 12 05 2000 Current Cost 10Ea $12,140.00 Minus Cradle cost 10Ea $167.00 $1,670.00 Subtotal $10,470.00 Docking station 10Ea $680.00 $6,800.00 Pass Thru for modem 10 Ea $80.00 $800.00 Subtotal $7,600.00 L $5,930.00 TOTAL $18,070.00 Phase III Additional Units Quote $3,593.00 Difference of Cradle and dock $593.00 Subtotal $4,186.00 Phase III 18 Additional Units Cost Subtotal $75,348.00 TOTAL $93,418.00 Panasonic Laptop computers CF-27 6 Each CF-27EB6GCAMNT $4,790.00 $28,740.00 $140,228.00 Tax 7.75% $10,868.67 TOTAL $151,096.67 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT EETING DATE DECEMBER 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 3 (-ITEM TITLE RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF NATIONAL CITY AWARDING A\ CONTRACT TO GEOSCENE CONSTRUCTION, INC.FOR THE CIVIC CENTER DRIVE AND NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD IMPROVEMENTS PROJECT, SPECIFICATION NO. 00-5 PREPARED BY EXPLANATION Michael Long DEPARTMENT See attached Engineering Environmental Review z NIA Financial Statement The total cost of the project is estimated to be $1,420,000.00. Funding is avail ble through CDC Account No. 301-413-133- 1148. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Adopt the Resolution. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) 1. Resolution 2. Bid Opening Sheet 3. Bid Spreadsheet Account No. Resolution No. 2000-160 A-20® RESOLUTION NO. 2000 — 160 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AWARDING A CONTRACT TO GEOSCENE CONSTRUCTION, INC. FOR THE CIVIC CENTER DRIVE AND NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD IMPROVEMENT PROJECT (Engineering Spec. No. 00-5) WHEREAS, the Engineering Department of the City of National City did, in open session on November 22, 2000, publicly open, examine and declare all sealed bids for the Civic Center Drive and National City Boulevard Improvement Project. NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of National City hereby awards the contract for the Civic Center Drive and National City Boulevard Improvement Project to the lowest responsive, responsible bidder, to wit: GEOSCENE CONSTRUCTION, INC. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of National City that the Mayor is hereby authorized to execute on behalf of the City a contract between Geoscene Construction, Inc. and the City of National City for the Civic Center Drive and National City Boulevard Improvement Project. Said contract is on file in the office of the City Clerk. PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of December, 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor ATTEST: Michael R Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: George H. City Attorney FXPI,ANATION On November 22, 2000, nine bids were received and opened for the Civic Center Drive and National City Boulevard Improvement Project, Specification No. 00-5. The project includes rehabilitation of Civic Center Drive from Wilson Avenue to National City Boulevard and National City Boulevard from 12th to 14th Streets, including removal and replacement of sidewalks, driveways, alley aprons, curb and gutter, failed pavement sections, installation of medians on National City Boulevard, landscape improvements and decorative lighting. The Contractor will have 90 working days to complete the project. Nasland Engineering designed this project for the Community Development Commission of the City of National City. The National City Engineering Department will perform contract administration and construction management services. Invoices for services will be reviewed and approved by the Engineering Department project Engineer and submitted to CDC for payment. E.V. Constructors' (the apparent low bidder) proposal was found to be non -responsive. A detailed review of the specifications and their proposal for this project found that the proposal was non- responsive based on the following: According to Part 1, Section 2-3.1 of the Standard Specifications for Public Works Construction, 1997 Edition, "The Contractor shall perform, with its own organization, Contract work amounting to at least 50 percent of the Contract Price except that any designated "Specialty Items" may be performed by subcontract and the amount of any such "Specialty Items" so performed may be deducted from the Contract Price before computing the amount required to be performed by the Contractor with its own organization." The 1997 supplemental amendments to these standards go on to identify Specialty Items as Street lights, traffic signals, landscaping, irrigation, etc. E.V. Constructors proposal lists 62 percent of the work to be performed by others. It became apparent to staff, after review of the proposal, that E.V. Constructors grouped together all street light items as a means of designating them as one specialty item. Although this item was not marked as a specialty item within the bid proposal, it was apparent that E.V. Constructors' intended this grouping to be designated as such. This designation allowed the removal of that item prior to calculating the percentage of subcontracted work. Recalculation shows that E.V. Constructors still proposes 56 percent of the Adjusted Contract Price be perfoinied by others. It is therefore the conclusion of the staff that E.V. Constructors' proposal is non -responsive. Staff has reviewed all proposals and found the lowest responsive bidder, Geoscene Construction, Inc. qualified to perform the work. The total cost of the project is estimated to be $1,420,000.00. This amount includes the construction bid price of $1,178,344.71 plus approximately 5% ($59,000.00) for material testing and inspection and approximately 15% ($182,655.29) for contingencies. BID OPENING SPECIFICATION NUMBER: 00-5 PROJECT TITLE: CIVIC CENTER DRIVE AND NATIONAL CITY BLVD. IMPROVEMENTS OPENING DATE: WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2000 3:00 P.M. TIME: ESTIMATE: $1,380,000.00 PROJECT ENGINEER: MICHAEL LONG NO. BIDDER'S NAME (PAGE 14 OR 15) BID AMOUNT (PAGE 16) ADDITIVE BID (PAGE N/A) ADDENDA (PAGE 14) BID SECURITY (PAGE 20-CHECK) (PAGE 21-BOND) 1. E.V. Construction, Inc. 2835 Camino Del Rio S. San Diego, CA 92108 $1,120,228.89 $93,280.00 !° Bond 2. Geoscene Const. Inc. 912 S. Andreasen Dr. Ste. 107 Escondido, CA 92029 $1,178,050.00 $77,168.00 Bond 3. Pullman Enginering, Inc. 4645 Ruffner St. Ste. P San Diego, CA 92111 $1,179,850.18 $100,000.00 Bond 4. Castillo, Inc. 480 Corporate Drive Escondido, CA 92029 $1,266,676.10 $75,790.00 Bond 5. Mesa Construction 7150 Convoy Court San Diego, CA 92111 $1,271,345.50 $96,672.00 Bond 6. Heffler Const. Inc. P.O. Box 2326 National City, CA 91950 $1,293,260.61 $95,506.00 Bond 7. Nicholas Grant Corp. 5370 Eastgate Mall San Diego, CA 92121 $1,417,778.00 $75,260.00 Bond 8. Shiva Construction 1360 Rosecrans St. #E San Diego, CA 92106 $1,521,174.00 $106,000.00 ✓ j! Bond 9. Scheidel Constracting P.O. Box 1796 La Mesa, CA 91944 $1,628,372.00 $82,680.00 Bond BID 005 November 30, 2000 Final Bid Results for: Civic Center Drive and National City Blvd. Improvements GEOSCENE CONST. INC MESA CONST. PROJECTS 2 NO. Mir.rs DESCRIPTION QTY UNIT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT 1 Mobilization 1 LS $ 63,889.00 $ 63,889.00 $ 81,909.50 $ 81,909.50 2 Traffic Control 1 LS $ 31,210.00 $ 31,210.00 $ 51,664.80 $ 51,664.80 3 Adjust Street Survey Monument to Grade 5 EA $ 336.00 $ 1,680.00 $ 570.00 $ 2,850.00 4 Clearing And Grubbing 1 LS $ 40,284.00 $ 40,284.00 $ 74,100.00 $ 74,100.00 5 Traffic Striping 1 LS $ 4,234.00 $ 4,234.00 $ 6,630.20 $ 6,630.20 6 Remove And Replace Street Section (Civic Center Dr.) 14,530 SF $ 5.17 $ 75,120.10 $ 4.00 $ 58,120.00 7 Remove And Replace Street Section (National City Blvd.) 455 SF $ 5.17 $ 2,352.35 $ 4.60 $ 2,093.00 8 Remove Existing Cobra Head Lt Standards (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 EA $ 112.00 $ 1,008.00 $ 931.40 $ 8,382.60 9 Remove Existing Street Lt Foundations (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 EA $ 112.00 $ 1,008.00 $ 931.40 $ 8,382.60 10 Adjust Manhole To Grade 22 EA $ 336.00 $ 7,392.00 $ 1,083.00 $ 23,826.00 11 Replace Type 2 Detector Loop 26 EA $ 336.00 $ 8,736.00 $ 210.90 $ 5,483.40 12 Install Curb And Gutter 3,446 LF $ 22.51 $ 77,569.46 $ 10.70 $ 36,872.20 13 Install Median Curb 945 LF $ 17.68 $ 16,707.60 $ 10.70 $ 10,111.50 14 Remove And Replace Cross Gutter 4,600 SF $ 4.87 $ 22,402.00 $ 4.10 $ 18,860.00 15 Install P.C.C. Driveway (7" Thick) 4,520 SF $ 3.58 $ 16,181.60 $ 4.20 $ 18,984.00 16 AC Overlay 1250 TON $ 54.88 $ 68,600.00 $ 51.30 $ 64,125.00 17 Cold Milling 12,700 SY $ 1.96 $ 24,892.00 $ 2.40 $ 30,480.00 18 Pavement Fabric 14,400 SY $ 1.07 $ 15,408.00 $ 1.10 $ 15,840.00 19 Concrete Sidewalk 27,590 SF $ 3.22 $ 88,839.80 $ 2.60 $ 71,734.00 20 PCC Private Walkway Behind Sidewalk 600 SF $ 3.27 $ 1,962.00 $ 2.60 $ 1,560.00 21 Alley Apron 4 EA $ 1,116.00 $ 4,464.00 $ 1,824.00 $ 7,296.00 22 Raised Walkway (Ped Ramp Detail Plan Sheet 2) 2 EA $ 1,219.00 $ 2,438.00 $ 912.00 $ 1,824.00 23 Colored Concrete Sidewalk - Light Sandblast Finish 8,000 SF $ 4.76 $ 38,080.00 $ 4.00 $ 32,000.00 24 Concrete Bollard With Chain 62 EA $ 313.00 $ 19,406.00 $ 636.70 $ 39,475.40 25 Reactive Color Treatment Paving 1 LS $ 2,550.00 $ 2,550.00 $ 2,166.00 $ 2,166.00 26 Tree Grate 12 EA $ 1,201.00 $ 14,412.00 $ 833.30 $ 9,999.60 27 Steel Header 1,510 LF $ 3.81 $ 5,753.10 $ 10.80 $ 16,308.00 28 Decomposed Granite 4,400 SF $ 0.64 $ 2,816.00 $ 3.80 $ 16,720.00 29 Directional Sign Type "A" 1 EA $ 5,690.00 $ 5,690.00 $ 3,990.00 $ 3,990.00 30 Directional Sign Type "B" 1 EA $ 5,690.00 $ 5,690.00 $ 3,990.00 $ 3,990.00 31 Replace Concrete Utility Box 18 EA $ 204.00 $ 3,672.00 $ 228.00 $ 4,104.00 32 Bauhinia Blakeana Tree - 36 Inch Box 20 EA $ 560.00 $ 11,200.00 $ 738.70 $ 14,774.00 33 Pyrus Calleryana Tree - 24 Inch Box 75 EA $ 224.00 $ 16,800.00 $ 257.60 $ 19,320.00 34 Shrubs - 5 Gallon 530 EA $ 16.00 $ 8,480.00 $ 14.40 $ 7,632.00 35 Sod 1,000 SF $ 0.45 $ 450.00 $ 1.40 $ 1,400.00 36 Fine Grade 4,120 SF $ 0.56 $ 2,307.20 $ 0.10 $ 412.00 37 Soil Amendment 960 SF $ 0.90 $ 864.00 $ 0.80 $ 768.00 38 Mulch 19 CY $ 45.00 $ 855.00 $ 56.40 $ 1,071.60 39 Irrigation System 1 LS $ 89,186.00 $ 89,186.00 $ 100,951.60 $ 100,951.60 40 Remove And Replace Storm Drain Inlet Lids 4 EA $ 392.00 $ 1,568.00 $ 611.40 $ 2,445.60 41 Replace Concrete Utility Box With Colored Concrete Lids 18 EA $ 74.00 $ 1,332.00 $ 57.00 $ 1,026.00 42 Install Root Barriers 1 LS $ 11,200.00 $ 11,200.00 $ 14,882.70 $ 14,882.70 43 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Short Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 2 EA $ 280.00 $ 560.00 $ 570.00 $ 1,140.00 44 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Long Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 1 EA $ 280.00 $ 280.00 $ 912.00 $ 912.00 45 Install Backflow Preventer and Enclosure 3 EA $ 1,411.00 $ 4,233.00 $ 1,555.00 $ 4,665.00 46 Colored Concrete Median Paving - Light Sandblast Finish 694 SF $ 9.25 $ 6,419.50 $ 4.00 $ 2,776.00 47 Class "A" Topsoil 48 49 50 51 52 53 70 22.00 $ Date Palm - 20 Foot Brown Trunk Height Street Light Pole Standard, Twin Acorn Twin Acorn Acrylic Luminares (2-150W HPS) Meter Pedestal Pole Base Foundation Street Lighting Electrical System 3 53 53 2 53 1 EA EA EA EA EA LS $ 8,960.00 $ 2,451.00 $ 1,120.00 $ 2,800.00 $ 560.00 $ 95,200.00 $ 26,880.00 $ 129,903.00 $ 59,360.00 $ 5,600.00 $ 29,680.00 $ 95,200.00 $ 10,221.20 $ 3,329.90 $ 1,491.10 $ 2,280.00 $ 456.00 $ 40,000.00 $ 30,663.60 $ 176,484.70 $ 79,028.30 $ 4,560.00 $ 24,168.00 $ 40,000.00 BASE BID TOTAL 1,178,344.71 $ 1,265,745.90 ENGINEERS ESTIMATE $ 1,380,000.00 $ 1,380,000.00 PERCENT OVER/UNDER -14.6% -8.3% Pagel November 30, 2000 Final Bid Results for: Civic Center Drive and National City Blvd. Improvements RANK CASTELLO INC. HEFFLER CO. INC. 3 4 NO. DESCRIPTION QTY UNIT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT 1 Mobilization 1 LS $ 65,757.00 $ 65,757.00 $ 42,000.00 $ 42,000.00 2 Traffic Control 1 LS $ 42,405.00 $ .42,405.00 $ 32,240.61 $ 32,240.61 3 Adjust Street Survey Monument to Grade 5 EA $ 484.00 $ 2,420.00 $ 500.00 $ 2,500.00 4 Clearing And Grubbing 1 LS $ 61,369.00 $ 61,369.00 $ 181,030.40 $ 181,030.40 5 Traffic Striping 1 LS $ 4,158.00 $ 4,158.00 $ 3,780.00 $ 3,780.00 6 Remove And Replace Street Section (Civic Center Dr.) 14,530 SF $ 6.00 $ 87,180.00 $ 5.55 $ 80,641.50 7 Remove And Replace Street Section (National City Blvd.) 455 SF $ 18.00 $ 8,190.00 $ 14.00 $ 6,370.00 8 Remove Existing Cobra Head Lt Standards (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 EA $ 110.00 $ 990.00 $ 500.00 $ 4,500.00 9 Remove Existing Street Lt Foundations (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 EA $ 110.00 $ 990.00 $ 400.00 $ 3,600.00 10 Adjust Manhole To Grade - 22 EA $ 474.00 $ 10,428.00 $ 350.00 $ 7,700.00 11 Replace Type 2 Detector Loop 26 EA $ 330.00 $ 8,580.00 $ 300.00 $ 7,800.00 12 Install Curb And Gutter 3,446 LF $ 24.80 $ 85,460.80 $ 13.25 $ 45,659.50 13 Install Median Curb 945 LF $ 21.50 $ 20,317.50 $ 11.74 $ 11,094.30 14 Remove And Replace Cross Gutter 4,600 SF $ 7.00 $ 32,200.00 $ 7.66 $ 35,236.00 15 Install P.C.C. Driveway (7" Thick) 4,520 SF $ 5.40 $ 24,408.00 $ 4.97 $ 22,464.40 16 AC Overlay 1250 TON $ 55.00 $ 68,750.00 $ 52.81 $ 66,012.50 17 Cold Milling 12,700 SY $ 1.93 $ 24,511.00 $ 2.00 $ 25,400.00 18 Pavement Fabric 14,400 SY $ 0.83 $ 11,952.00 $ 0.94 $ 13,536.00 19 Concrete Sidewalk 27,590 SF $ 3.00 $ 82,770.00 $ 3.46 $ 95,461.40 20 PCC Private Walkway Behind Sidewalk 600 SF $ 3.93 $ 2,358.00 $ 3.80 $ 2,280.00 21 Alley Apron 4 EA $ 2,167.00 $ 8,668.00 $ 2,275.38 $ 9,101.52 22 Raised Walkway (Ped Ramp Detail Plan Sheet 2) 2 EA $ 1,745.00 $ 3,490.00 $ 1,673.47 $ 3,346.94 23 Colored Concrete Sidewalk - Light Sandblast Finish 8,000 SF $ 3.94 $ 31,520.00 $ 4.34 $ 34,720.00 24- Concrete Bollard With Chain 62 EA $ 385.00 $ 23,870.00 $ 406.09 $ 25,177.58 25 Reactive Color Treatment Paving 1 LS $ 3,688.00 $ 3,688.00 $ 2,500.00 $ 2,500.00 26 Tree Grate 12 EA $ 1,274.00 $ 15,288.00 $ 709.30 $ 8,511.60 27 Steel Header 1,510 LF $ 5.60 $ 8,456.00 $ 5.66 $ 8,546.60 28 Decomposed Granite 4,400 SF $ 3.76 $ 16,544.00 $ 1.04 $ 4,576.00 29 Directional Sign Type "A" 1 EA $ 4,895.00 $ 4,895.00 $ 4,000.00 $ 4,000.00 30 Directional Sign Type "B" 1 EA $ 4,895.00 $ 4,895.00 $ 4,000.00 $ - 4,000.00 31 Replace Concrete Utility Box 18 EA $ 157.00 $ 2,826.00 $ 200.00 $ 3,600.00 32 Bauhinia Blakeana Tree - 36 Inch Box 20 EA $ 743.00 $ 14,860.00 $ 673.13 $ 13,462.60 33 Pyrus Calleryana Tree - 24 Inch Box 75 EA $ 259.00 $ 19,425.00 $ 294.62 $ 22,096.50 34 Shrubs - 5 Gallon 530 EA $ 18.00 $ 9,540.00 $ 14.06 $ 7,451.80 35 Sod 1,000 SF $ 1.21 $ 1,210.00 $ 1.00 $ 1,000.00 36 Fine Grade 4,120 SF $ 0.55 $ 2,266.00 $ 0.38 $ 1,565.60 37 Soil Amendment 960 SF $ 1.00 $ 960.00 $ 1.00 $ 960.00 38 Mulch 19 CY $ 50.00 $ 950.00 $ 62.09 $ 1,179.71 39 Irrigation System 1 LS $ 74,800.00 $ 74,800.00 $ 88,360.08 $ 88,360.08 40 Remove And Replace Storm Drain Inlet Lids 4 EA $ 2,162.00 $ 8,648.00 $ 1,205.28 $ 4,821.12 41 Replace Concrete Utility Box With Colored Concrete Lids 18 EA i $ 100.00 $ 1,800.00 $ 200.00 $ 3,600.00 42 Install Root Barriers 1 LS $ 16,034.00 $ 16,034.00 $ 7,069.44 $ 7,069.44 43 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Short Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 2 EA $ 330.00 $ $60.00 $ 3,100.00 $ 6,200.00 44 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Long Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 1 EA $ 330.00 $ 330.00 $ 6,349.86 $ 6,349.86 45 Install Backflow Preventer and Enclosure 3 EA $ 2,310.00 $ 6,930.00 $ 1,500.60 $ 4,501.80 46 Colored Concrete Median Paving - Light Sandblast Finish 694 SF $ 6.70 $ 4,649.80 $ 6.26 $ 4,344.44 47 Class "A" Topsoil 70 CY $ 36.00 $ 2,520.00 $ 31.61 $ 2,212.70 48 Date Palm - 20 Foot Brown Trunk Height 3 EA $ 5,683.00 $ 17,049.00 $ 10,119.37 $ 30,358.11 49 Street Light Pole Standard, Twin Acorn 53 EA $ 2,420.00 $ 128,260.00 $ 3,020.00 $ 160,060.00 50 Twin Acorn Acrylic Luminares (2-150W HPS) 53 EA $ 1,100.00 $ 58,300.00 $ 1,050.00 $ 55,650.00 51 Meter Pedestal 2 EA $ 2,750.00 $ 5,500.00 $ 1,800.00 $ 3,600.00 52 Pole Base Foundation 53 EA $ 550.00 $ 29,150.00 $ 560.00 $ 29,680.00 53 Street Lighting Electrical System 1 LS $ 93,500.00 $ 93,500.00 $ 41,350.00 $ 41,350.00 BASE BID TOTAL $ 1,266,676.10 $ 1,293,260.61 ENGINEERS ESTIMATE $ 1,380,000.00 $ 1,380,000.00 PERCENT OVER/UNDER -8.2% -6.3% Page 2 November 30, 2000 Final Bid Results for: Civic Center Drive and National City Blvd. Improvements NICHOLAS GRANT CORP. SHIVA CONST., INC. 6 NO. RHIVPN. DESCRIPTION QTY UNIT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT 1 Mobilization 1 LS $ 70,000.00 $ 70,000.00 $ 30,000.00 $ 30,000.00 2 Traffic Control 1 LS $ 45,000.00 $ 45,000.00 $ 50,000.00 $ 50,000.00 3 Adjust Street Survey Monument to Grade 5 EA $ 360.00 $ 1,800.00 $ 600.00 $ 3,000.00 4 Clearing And Grubbing 1 LS $ 13,700.00 $ 13,700.00 $ 100,000.00 $ 100,000.00 5 Traffic Striping 1 LS $ 3,900.00 $ 3,900.00 $ 5,400.00 $ 5,400.00 6 Remove And Replace Street Section (Civic Center Dr.) 14,530 SF $ 7.00 $ 101,710.00 $ 7.50 $ 108,975.00 7 Remove And Replace Street Section (National City Blvd.) 455 SF $ 17.00 $ 7,735.00 $ 20.00 $ 9,100.00 8 Remove Existing Cobra Head Lt Standards (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 FA $ 50.00 $ 450.00 $ 1,100.00 $ 9,900.00 9 Remove Existing Street Lt Foundations (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 FA $ 50.00 $ 450.00 $ 1,100.00 $ 9,900.00 10 Adjust Manhole To Grade 22 EA $ 875.00 $ 19,250.00 $ 500.00 $ 11,000.00 11 Replace Type 2 Detector Loop 26 EA $ 300.00 $ 7,800.00 $ 250.00 $ 6,500.00 12 Install Curb And Gutter 3,446 LF $ 36.00 $ 124,056.00 $ 14.00 $ 48,244.00 13 Install Median Curb 945 IF $ 41.00 $ 38,745.00 $ 14.00 $ 13,230.00 14 Remove And Replace Cross Gutter 4,600 SF $ 9.70 $ 44,620.00 $ 9.00 $ 41,400.00 15 Install P.C.C. Driveway (7" Thick) 4,520 SF $ 5.50 $ 24,860.00 $ 5.50 $ 24,860.00 16 AC Overlay 1250 TON $ 49.00 $ 61,250.00 $ 70.00 $ 87,500.00 17 Cold Milling 12,700 SY $ 1.85 $ 23,495.00 $ 2.90 $ 36,830.00 18 Pavement Fabric 14,400 SY $ 1.02 $ 14,688.00 $ 1.25 $ 18,000.00 19 Concrete Sidewalk 27,590 SF $ 4.20 $ 115,878.00 $ 3.50 $ 96,565.00 20 PCC Private Walkway Behind Sidewalk 600 SF $ 6.50 $ 3,900.00 $ 3.50 $ 2,100.00 21 Alley Apron 4 EA $ 2,400.00 $ 9,600.00 $ 2,400.00 $ 9,600.00 22 Raised Walkway (Ped Ramp Detail Plan Sheet 2) 2 EA $ 3,100.00 $ 6,200.00 $ 3,500.00 $ 7,000.00 23 Colored Concrete Sidewalk - Light Sandblast Finish 8,000 SF $ 5.00 $ 40,000.00 $ 4.50 $ 36,000.00 24 Concrete Bollard With Chain 62 FA $ 900.00 $ 55,800.00 $ 800.00 $ 49,600.00 25 Reactive Color Treatment Paving 1 LS $ 2,400.00 $ 2,400.00 $ 3,000.00 $ 3,000.00 26 Tree Grate 12 EA $ 675.00 $ 8,100.00 $ 1,500.00 $ 18,000.00 27 Steel Header 1,510 LF $ 6.20 $ 9,362.00 $ 8.00 $ 12,080.00 28 Decomposed Granite 4,400 SF $ 1.02 $ 4,488.00 $ 4.00 $ 17,600.00 29 Directional Sign Type "A" 1 EA $ 4,300.00 $ 4,300.00 $ 4,000.00 $ 4,000.00 30 Directional Sign Type "B" 1 EA $ 4,300.00 $ 4,300.00 $ 4,000.00 $ 4,000.00 31 Replace Concrete Utility Box 18 EA $ 150.00 $ 2,700.00 $ 300.00 $ 5,400.00 32 Bauhinia Blakeana Tree - 36 Inch Box 20 FA $ 1,000.00 $ 20,000.00 $ 1,200.00 $ 24,000.00 33 Pyrus Calleryana Tree - 24 Inch Box 75 EA $ 340.00 $ 25,500.00 $ 400.00 $ 30,000.00 34 Shrubs - 5 Gallon 530 EA $ 19.50 $ 10,335.00 $ 20.00 $ 10,600.00 35 Sod 1,000 SF $ 1.00 $ 1,000.00 $ 2.00 $ 2,000.00 36 Fine Grade . 4,120 SF $ 0.45 $ 1,854.00 $ 1.00 $ 4,120.00 37 Soil Amendment 960 SF $ 0.35 $ 336.00 $ 3.00 $ 2,880.00 38 Mulch 19 CY $ 54.00 $ 1,026.00 $ 100.00 $ 1,900.00 39 Irrigation System 1 LS $ 97,000.00 $ 97,000.00 $ 62,000.00 $ 62,000.00 40 Remove And Replace Storm Drain Inlet Lids 4 EA $ 1,900.00 $ 7,600.00 $ 1,000.00 $ 4,000.00 41 Replace Concrete Utility Box With Colored Concrete Lids 18 EA $ 102.00 $ 1,836.00 $ 100.00 $ 1,800.00 42 Install Root Barriers 1 LS $ 17,000.00 $ 17,000.00 $ 12,000.00 $ 12,000.00 43 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Short Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 2 FA $ 2,300.00 $ 4,600.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 20,000.00 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Long Side Wet Tap (Wor 44 by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 Install Backflow Preventer and Enclosure Colored Concrete Median Paving - Light Sandblast Finish Class "A" Topsoil 1 3 694 70 EA $ 3,700.00 $ EA SF CY $ 2,350.00 $ 8.50 $ 23.00 3,700.00 $ 11,000.00 $ 7,050.00 $ 5,899.00 $ 1,610.00 $ 1,500.00 $ 10.00 $ 60.00 11,000.00 $ 4,500.00 $ 6,940.00 $ 4,200.00 Date Palm - 20 Foot Brown Trunk Height Street Light Pole Standard, Twin Acorn 3 EA $ 15,500.00 $ 46,500.00 $ 12,000.00 $ 36,000.00 Twin Acorn Acrylic Luminares (2-150W HPS) Meter Pedestal 53 53 2 EA EA FA 2,300.00 $ 1,000.00 $ 2,600.00 $ 121,900.00 53,000.00 $ 5,200.00 $ 3,700.00 $ 1,750.00 $ 1,750.00 $ 196,100.00 $ ' 92,750.00 $ 3,500.00 Pole Base Foundation Street Lighting Electrical System 53 1 FA LS $ 515.00 $ 87,000.00 $ 27,295.00 $ 87,000.00 $ 700.00 $ 75,000.00 $ 37,100.00 $ 75,000.00 BASE BID TOTAL $ 1,417,778.00 $ 1,521,174.00 ENGINEERS ESTIMATE $ 1,380,000.00 $ 1,380,000.00 PERCENT OVER/UNDER 2.7% 10.2% Page 3 November 30, 2000 Final Bid Results for: Civic Center Drive and National City Blvd. Improvements RANK SCHEIDEL CONTRACTING 7 NO. DESCRIPTION QTY UNIT UNIT PRICE AMOUNT 1 Mobilization 1 LS $ 80,000.00 $ 80,000.00 2 Traffic Control 1 LS $ 40,000.00 $ 40,000.00 3 Adjust Street Survey Monument to Grade 5 EA $ 600.00 $ 3,000.00 4 Clearing And Grubbing 1 LS $ 100,000.00 $ 100,000.00 5 Traffic Striping 1 LS $ 6,000.00 $ 6,000.00 6 Remove And Replace Street Section (Civic Center Dr.) 14,530 SF $ 10.00 $ 145,300.00 7 Remove And Replace Street Section (National City Blvd.) 455 SF $ 140.00 $ 63,700.00 8 Remove Existing Cobra Head Lt Standards (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 EA $ 100.00 $ 900.00 9 Remove Existing Street Lt Foundations (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 EA $ 1,000.00 $ 9,000.00 10 Adjust Manhole To Grade 22 EA $ 550.00 $ 12,100.00 11 Replace Type 2 Detector Loop 26 EA $ 400.00 $ 10,400.00 12 Install Curb And Gutter 3,446 LF $ 12.00 $ 41,352.00 13 Install Median Curb 945 LF $ 20.00 $ 18,900.00 14 Remove And Replace Cross Gutter 4,600 SF $ 10.00 $ 46,000.00 15 Install P.C.C. Driveway (7" Thick) 4,520 SF $ 5.00 $ 22,600.00 16 AC Overlay 1250 TON $ 100.00 $ 125,000.00 17 Cold Milling 12,700 SY $ 2.10 $ 26,670.00 18 Pavement Fabric 14,400 SY $ 2.10 $ 30,240.00 19 Concrete Sidewalk 27,590 SF $ 2.50 $ 68,975.00 20 PCC Private Walkway Behind Sidewalk 600 SF $ 10.00 $ 6,000.00 21 Alley Apron 4 EA $ 3,000.00 $ 12,000.00 22 Raised Walkway (Ped Ramp Detail Plan Sheet 2) 2 EA $ 2,000.00 $ 4,000.00 23 Colored Concrete Sidewalk - Light Sandblast Finish 8,000 SF $ 7.00 $ 56,000.00 24 Concrete Bollard With Chain 62 EA $ 450.00 $ 27,900.00 25 Reactive Color Treatment Paving 1 LS $ 3,000.00 $ 3,000.00 26 Tree Grate 12 EA $ 2,100.00 $ 25,200.00 27 Steel Header 1,510 LF $ 10.00 $ 15,100.00 28 Decomposed Granite 4,400 SF $ 1.50 $ 6,600.00 29 Directional Sign Type "A" 1 EA $ 2,500.00 $ 2,500.00 30 Directional Sign Type "B" 1 EA $ 2,500.00 $ 2,500.00 31 Replace Concrete Utility Box 18 EA $ 100.00 $ 1,800.00 32 Bauhinia Blakeana Tree - 36 Inch Box 20 EA $ 750.00 $ 15,000.00 33 Pyrus Calleryana Tree - 24 Inch Box 75 EA $ 300.00 $ 22,500.00 34 Shrubs - 5 Gallon 530 EA $ 17.00 $ 9,010.00 35 Sod 1,000 SF $ 2.00 $ 2,000.00 36 Fine Grade 4,120 SF $ 0.50 $ 2,060.00 37 Soil Amendment 960 SF $ 4.00 $ 3,840.00 38 Mulch 19 CY $ 70.00 $ 1,330.00 39 Irrigation System 1 LS $ 120,000.00 $ 120,000.00 40 Remove And Replace Storm Drain Inlet Lids 4 EA $ 2,500.00 $ 10,000.00 41 Replace Concrete Utility Box With Colored Concrete Lids 18 EA $ 300.00 $ 5,400.00 42 Install Root Barriers 1 LS $ 25,000.00 $ 25,000.00 43 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Short Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 2 EA $ 1,500.00 $ 3,000.00 44 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Long Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 1 EA $ 1,500.00 $ 1,500.00 45 Install Backflow Preventer and Enclosure 3 EA $ 2,000.00 $ 6,000.00 46 Colored Concrete Median Paving - Light Sandblast Finish 694 SF $ 12.50 $ 8,675.00 47 Class "A" Topsoil 70 CY $ 100.00 $ 7,000.00 48 Date Palm - 20 Foot Brown Trunk Height 3 EA $ 10,000.00 $ 30,000.00 49 Street Light Pole Standard, Twin Acorn 53 EA $ 2,640.00 $ 139,920.00 50 Twin Acorn Acrylic Luminares (2-150W HPS) 53 EA $ 1,200.00 $ 63,600.00 51 Meter Pedestal 2 EA $ • 3,000.00 $ 6,000.00 52 Pole Base Foundation 53 EA $ 600.00 $ 31,800.00 53 Street Lighting Electrical System 1 LS $ 102,000.00 $ 102,000.00 BASE BID TOTAL $ 1,628,372.00 ENGINEERS ESTIMATE $ 1,380,000.00 PERCENT OVER/UNDER 18.0% Page 4 November 30, 2000 Final Bid Results for: Civic Center Drive and National City Blvd. Improvements NO. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Mobilization Traffic Control RANK DESCRIPTION Adjust Street Survey Monument to Grade Clearing And Grubbing Traffic Striping Remove And Replace Street Section (Civic Center Dr.) 7 Remove And Replace Street Section (National City Blvd.) 8 Remove Existing Cobra Head Lt Standards (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 Remove Existing Street Lt Foundations (Work Performed by SDGE, Contractor to Coordinate) Adjust Manhole To Grade 42 Replace Type 2 Detector Loop Install Curb And Gutter Install Median Curb Remove And Replace Cross Gutter Install P.C.C. Driveway (7" Thick) AC Overlay Cold Milling Pavement Fabric Concrete Sidewalk PCC Private Walkway Behind Sidewalk Alley Apron Raised Walkway (Ped Ramp Detail Plan Sheet 2) Colored Concrete Sidewalk - Light Sandblast Finish Concrete Bollard With Chain Reactive Color Treatment Paving Tree Grate Steel Header Decomposed Granite Directional Sign Type "A" Directional Sign Type "B" Replace Concrete Utility Box Bauhinia Blakeana Tree - 36 Inch Box Pyrus Calleryana Tree - 24 Inch Box Shrubs - 5 Gallon Sod Fine Grade Soil Amendment Mulch Irrigation System Remove And Replace Storm Drain Inlet Lids Replace Concrete Utility Box With Colored Concrete Lids Install Root Barriers QTY 1 5 1 1 14,530 455 9 9 22 26 3,446 945 4,600 4,520 1250 12,700 14,400 27,590 600 4 2 8,000 62 1 12 1,510 4,400 1 18 20 75 530 PULLMAN ENGINEERING E.V. CONSTRUCTION UNIT 1,000 4,120 960 19 1 4 18 1 LS LS EA LS LS SF SF EA EA EA EA LF LF SF SF TON SY SY SF SF EA EA SF EA LS EA LF SF EA EA EA EA EA EA SF SF SF CY LS EA EA LS NONRESPONSIVE UNIT PRICE $ 80,000.00 $ 20,000.00 $ 600.00 $ 140,615.48 $ 5,000.00 $ 6.00 $ 6.00 300.00 $ 500.00 $ 800.00 $ 400.00 $ 10.50 $ 10.00 $ 4.60 $ 4.50 50.00 2.00 $ 1.10 $ 2.40 $ 3.00 $ 1,800.00 $ 1,000.00 $ 3.15 $ 475.00 $ 7,000.00 $ 700.00 $ 2.25 $ 1.40 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 300.00 $ 700.00 $ 260.00 $ 16.00 $ 1.00 $ 0.50 $ 0.70 $ 65.00 74,471.00 $ 2,000.00 AMOUNT $ 80,000.00 $ 300.00 $ 20,000.00 $ 8,670.00 3,000.00 $ 140,615.48 5,000.00 $ 87,180 00 $ 2,730.00 $ 2,700.00 $ 4,500.00 $ 17,600.00 $ 10,400.00 $ 36,183.00 $ 9,450.00 $ 21,160.00 $ 20,340.00 $ 62,500.00 $ 25,400.00 $ 15,840.00 $ 66,216.00 $ 1,800.00 $ 7,200.00 $ 2,000.00 $ 25,200.00 29,450.00 $ 7,000.00 $ 8,400.00 $ 3,397.50 $ 6,160.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 5,400.00 $ 14,000.00 $ 19,500.00 $ 8,480.00 $ 1,000.00 $ 2,060.00 $ 672.00 $ 1,235.00 $ 74,471.00 $ 8,000.00 NONRESPONSIVE UNIT PRICE $ 54,200.00 $ 16,778.00 $ 5,400.00 $ 212.00 $ 8,670.00 $ 25,342.00 $ 4,115.00 $ 6.22 $ 15.24 $ 50.00 50.00 $ 218.00 $ 327.00 $ 10.14 $ 11.82 $ 6.86 $ 4.29 $ 57.50 $ 2.36 $ 1.02 $ 2.62 $ 2.60 $ 2,288.88 $ 1,763.00 $ 4.89 $ 340.00 $ 762.00 $ 655.00 $ 5.34 $ 0.94 4,000.00 $ 4,000.00 $ 125.00 $ 588.00 $ 210.00 $ 13.50 $ 1.36 $ 0.25 $ 0.85 $ 45.00 $ 76,500.00 AMOUNT $ 54,200.00 $ 16,778.00 $ 3,811.00 $ 125.00 $ 1,060.00 $ 8,710.00 $ 25,342.00 4,115.00 $ 90,376.60 $ 6,934.20 $ 450.00 $ 450.00 $ 4,796.00 $ 8,502.00 $ 34,942.44 $ 11,169.90 $ 31,556.00 $ 19,390.80 $ 71,875.00 $ 29,972.00 $ 14,688.00 $ 72,285.80 $ 1,560.00 $ 9,155.52 $ 3,526.00 $ 39,120.00 $ 21,080.00 $ 762.00 $ 7,860.00 $ 8,063.40 $ 4,136.00 $ 4,000.00 $ 4,000.00 $ 2,250.00 $ 11,760.00 $ 15,750.00 $ 7,155.00 $ 1,360.00 $ 1,030.00 $ 816.00 $ 855.00 $ 76,500.00 $ 15,244.00 $ 2,250.00 $ 8,710.00 43 44 Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Short Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) Install 1" Service, 1" Meter, and Long Side Wet Tap (Work by SWA, Contractor to Coordinate) 2 1 EA EA $ 2,300.00 $ 6,000.00 3 EA $ 0.00 $ 4,600.00 $ 6,000.00 $ 5,988.00 $ 6,750.00 5,100.00 $ $ 11,976.00 $ 6,750.00 1,721.00 $ 5,163.00 46 Colored Concrete Median Paving - Light Sandblast Finish 694 SF $ 3.30 $ 2,290.20 $ 8.16 $ 5,663.04 47 Class "A" Topsoil 70 CY $ 75.00 $ 5,250.00 $ 23.23 $ 1,626.10 48 Date Palm - 20 Foot Brown Trunk Height 3 EA $ 8,500.00 $ 25,500.00 $ 9,378.50 $ 28,135.50 49 Street Light Pole Standard, Twin Acorn 53 EA $ 3,300.00 $ 174,900.00 $ 3,180.58 $ 168,570.74 50 Twin Acorn Acrylic Luminares (2-150W HPS) 53 EA $ - $ - $ 1,425.00 $ 75,525.00 51 Meter Pedestal 2 EA $ 2,200.00 $ 4,400.00 $ 2,177.00 $ 4,354.00 52 Pole Base Foundation 53 EA $ 500.00 $ 26,500.00 $ 435.55 $ 23,084.15 53 Street Lighting Electrical System 1 LS $ 45,000.00 $ 45,000.00 $ 43,554.70 $ 43,554.70 BASE BID TOTAL $ 1,179,850.18 $ 1,120,228.89 ENGINEERS ESTIMATE $ 1,380,000.00 $ 1,380,000.00 PERCENT OVER/UNDER -14.5% -18.8% Page 5 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT AEETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 4 ITEM TITLE RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVING THE SUBDIVISION OF A VACANT, 61,420 SQUARE FOOT LOT INTO NINE SINGLE-FAMILY PARCELS AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF E. 16' STREET AND M AVENUE (APPLICANT: FRANK AND LINNEA ARRINGTON) (CASE FILE NO.: S-2000-2) PREPARED BY Jon Cain - Associate PlanneDEPARTm ENT Planning EXPLANATION The Council voted to approve this item at the November 28, 2000 public hearing. The attached resolution is necessary to follow through on the action. Environmental Review X N/A Categorical Exemption Financial Statement N/A STAFF RECOMMENDATION Adopt the attached resolution. �{�t- . ➢`( BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) Resolution Approved By: Finance Director Account No. A-200 19591 RESOLUTION NO. 2000 — 161 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING THE SUBDIVISION OF A VACANT, 61420 SQUARE FOOT LOT INTO NINE SINGLE-FAMILY PARCELS AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF E. 16TH STREET AND M AVENUE. APPLICANT: FRANK AND LINNEA ARRINGTON. CASE FILE NO. S-2000-2 WHEREAS, application was made for approval of a tentative subdivision map for nine single-family parcels on a vacant, 61,420 square foot lot at the northwest corner of E. 16th Street and M Avenue on property generally described as: Parcel A: Parcel 2 of Parcel Map No. 15423, in the City of National City, County of San Diego, State of California, filed in the Office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, October 24, 1988 as File/Page No. 88-542010 of Official Records. Parcel B: An easement for sewer purposes over, under, along and across the easterly 10.00 feet of Parcel 3 of Parcel Map No. 6919, in the City of National City, County of San Diego, State of California, filed in the Office of the County Recorder of San Diego County, February 22, 1978 as File/Page No. 78-070791 of Official Records. WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of National City, California, considered said application at public hearing held on September 18, 2000, and by Resolution recommended conditional approval of the application; and WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of National City considered said application at a public hearing held on November 28, 2000, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented; and, WHEREAS, at said public hearing the City Council considered the staff report contained in Case File No. S-2000-2 which is maintained by the City and incorporated herein by reference; along with evidence and testimony at said hearing; and, WHEREAS, this action is taken pursuant to all applicable procedures required by State law and City law; and, WHEREAS, the action hereby taken is found to be essential for the preservation of the public health, safety and general welfare. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of National City, California, that it hereby approves the tentative subdivision map to divide one parcel into nine single-family parcels based on the following findings: Resolution No. 2000 — 161 December 12, 2000 Page Two 1. The proposed map is consistent with the National City General Plan, since the map provides for the development of nine single-family homes in a single-family residential zone; and since the General Plan encourages the opportunities for home ownership which will be created by the project. No Specific Plan has been adopted for the project area. 2. The site is physically suitable for the proposed density of development, since the 1.41-acre lot can accommodate building pads for nine homes on lots at least 5,000 square feet in size. 3. The site is physically suitable for the proposed type of development, since the property is in an existing residential neighborhood. 4. The design of the subdivision and the proposed improvements are not likely to cause substantial environmental damage or substantially and avoidably injure fish or wildlife or their habitat, since the project is located on a disturbed site in an urban area and no unique environmental resources exist on the site. 5. The design of the subdivision and the proposed/required improvements are not likely to cause serious public health problems, since all necessary public services will be provided. 6. The design of the subdivision and the proposed/required improvements will not conflict with easements, acquired by the public at large, for access through or use of the property within the proposed subdivision, since there will be no alterations or improvements to existing easements crossing the proposed parcels. 7. The discharge of sewerage waste from the subdivision into the City of National City sewer system will not result in violation of existing requirements prescribed by the California Regional Quality Control Board pursuant to Division 7 (commencing with Section 13000) of the Water Code, as specified by Government Code Section 66474.6. 8. The subdivision has been considered by the Planning Commission with regard to its effect on the housing needs of the region, and these needs are balanced by the public service needs of the residents and available fiscal and environmental resources. 9. The design of the subdivision provides, to the extent feasible, for future passive and natural heating and cooling opportunities in the subdivision, based on consideration of local climate, topography, property configuration and other design and improvement requirements without requiring reduction in allowable density or lot coverage. Resolution No. 2000 —161 December 12, 2000 Page Three BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that based on the findings hereinbefore stated, said tentative subdivision map for division of a vacant 61,420 square foot lot into nine single- family parcels at the northwest corner of E. 16th Street and M Avenue is hereby approved subject to the following conditions: 1. Plans must comply with the 1998 editions of the California Building Code, Mechanical Code, Plumbing Code, and Electrical Code, and the California Title 24 energy and handicapped regulations. 2. A fire hydrant shall be installed in the new portion of M Avenue. The location of the new hydrant shall be determined in consultation with the Fire Department and shall comply with all City requirements. 3. A hydrology study (100 year flood) shall be submitted for the review and approval of the City Engineer. The study shall consider the area from the project site to the closest municipal storm drain outlet. 4. A grading and drainage plan shall be submitted for review and approval by the City Engineer showing all of the proposed and existing on- and off -site improvements. The plan shall incorporate the findings of the hydrology study. The plan shall be prepared in accordance with the City's standard requirements by a Registered Civil Engineer. All necessary measures for prevention of storm water pollution and hazardous material run- off to the public storm drain system from the proposed development shall be implemented with the design of the grading plan. This shall include the provision of such devices as storm drain interceptors, clarifiers, or filters. A checklist for preparation of the grading and drainage plan is available at the Engineering Department. 5. Separate street improvement plans prepared by a Registered Civil Engineer showing all of the existing and proposed improvements shall be submitted for review and approval by the City Engineer. The plans shall be in accordance with City requirements. All necessary street improvements, including curbs, gutters, sidewalks, and paving shall be constructed in accordance with City standards. 6. A soils engineering report shall be submitted for review and approval by the City Engineer. The report shall address the stability of all the existing and proposed slopes on the property. It shall also address the stability of the building pads, the criteria for new retaining wall design, the maximum allowable soil bearing pressure, and the required pavement structural sections for the proposed streets, parking areas, and driveways. The street pavement sections shall be in accordance with Regional Standard Drawing G-24 with National City modifications. Resolution No. 2000 — 161 December 12, 2000 Page Four 7. A sewer permit will be required. The method of sewage collection and disposal shall be shown on the grading/drainage plan. Any new sewer lateral in the City right-of-way shall be six inches in size with a clean -out, unless approved otherwise. A sewer stamp "S" shall be provided on the curb to mark the location of the lateral. 8. A new street light shall be installed at the corner of 16th Street and M Avenue. The street light and location shall comply with City standards and ADA requirements. The feasibility and electrical energy availability of the street light shall be verified with the Public Works Department prior to approval and installation. 9. A permit shall be obtained from .the Engineering Department for all improvement work within the public right-of-way and the drainage construction on private property. 10. A cost estimate shall be submitted with the plans. A performance bond equal to the approved cost estimate for all of the proposed grading, drainage, street improvements, and landscaping work shall be posted. Three percent (3%) of the estimated cost shall also be deposited with the City as an initial cost for plan checking and inspection services at the time the plans are submitted. The deposit is subject to adjustment. 11. All surface run-off, including landscaping adjoining the public right-of-way, shall be collected by approved drainage facilities, and directed to the street by sidewalk underdrains or a curb outlet. Adjacent properties shall be protected from surface run-off resulting from this development. 12. The property owner, or its successors and assigns shall be responsible for the maintenance, repair, or reconstruction of all irrigation and landscaping improvements installed within the public right-of-way, and shall adjust the sprinlder heads so as to prevent overspray upon the public sidewalk or streets. The proposed sprinkler heads shall be installed behind the sidewalk, and the irrigation mainline upon private property only, as required by the City. The property owner, its successors or assigns shall remove and relocate all irrigation items from the public right-of-way at no cost to the City, and within a reasonable time frame upon a written notification by the City Engineer. 13. The existing 36-inch CMP storm drain crossing diagonally on M Avenue shall be upgraded to comply with Engineering Department requirements. The grading and drainage plan shall show the construction of all new required drainage facilities, including the installation of a minimum 36-inch RCP storm drain in M Avenue with drainage inlets to convey the drainage northerly from 16s' Street. Resolution No. 2000 —161 December 12, 2000 Page Five 14. A final map is required. The final map shall meet all of the requirements of the Subdivision Map Act and the National City Municipal Codes including certification, acknowledgment, complete boundary information and monumentation. 15. The subdivider shall submit an approval letter from Sweetwater Authority stating that fire flow requirements have been met. If additional improvements are needed, the developer shall enter into an agreement for the water improvements with the Authority prior to obtaining the final map approval. 16. Separate water and sewer laterals shall be provided to each lot. 17. The developer shall bond for the monumentation, the public improvements and the on - site grading, drainage, landscaping, and other improvements through an agreement with the City prior to the approval of the final map. 18. All utility distribution facilities within the boundaries of the subdivision, and within the half street abutting the new subdivision, shall be placed underground. 19. The final map shall be recorded prior to issuance of any building permit. 20. All new property line survey monuments shall be set on private property, unless otherwise approved. 21. The final map shall use the California Coordinate System for its "Basis of Bearings" and express all measured and calculated bearings in terms of the system. The angle of grid divergence from a true meridian and the north point shall appear on the map. Two measured ties from the boundary of the property to existing horizontal control stations shall be shown. 22. The property shall be annexed into Community Facilities District no. 10 prior to the issuance of building permits. 23. Approval of the tentative map expires two (2) years after adoption of the resolution of approval at 5:00 p.m.. unless prior to that date a request for a time extension not exceeding three (3) years has been filed as provided by Section 66452.6 (e) of the California Government Code. 24. A detailed landscape and irrigation plan prepared by a California registered Landscape Architect, including plant types, method of planting, etc. shall be submitted for review and approval by the Planning Director. The landscape plan shall reflect the use of drought tolerant planting and water conserving irrigation devices. Resolution No: 2000 — 161 December 12, 2000 Page Six 25. Each lot shall have a minimum lot area of 5,000 square feet and a. minimum of fifty feet of street frontage. The final map shall be in substantial conformance with the tentative map depicted in Exhibit A, case file no. S-2000-2, dated May 4, 2000. Landscaping in the public right-of-way shall be installed in conjunction with the installation of public improvements in accordance with Exhibit C-Revised, case file no. S-2000-2, dated July 11, 2000, and as further specified in the landscape plan pursuant to condition no. 24. 26. Buildings shall be in substantial conformance with those depicted in Exhibit B, case file no. S-2000-2, dated May 4, 2000. 27. Homes shall have doors opening into the rear yard to encourage the use and maintenance of rear yard areas. 28. Mmimum 30-year shingles shall be used for roofing. 29. Final building design plans shall be submitted for Planning Commission review prior to issuance of building permits. 30. Prior to approval of the final map, the subdivider shall submit evidence to the satisfaction of the Planning Director that a Notice of Restriction on Real Property is recorded with the County Recorder. The applicant shall pay necessary recording fees to the County. The Notice of Restriction shall provide information that conditions imposed by approval of the Tentative Map, particularly conditions 26, 27, 28 and 29 are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. The Notice of Restriction shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney and signed by the Planning Director prior to recordation. 31. The tentative map shall be modified to show the new section of M Avenue intersecting 14th Street only and not 16th Street. A cul-de-sac shall be provided at the southern end of M Avenue near 16th Street. If a traffic study indicates that this requirement is not necessary or feasible, the Council may waive this condition. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this Resolution be transmitted forthwith to the applicant; and, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this Resolution shall become effective and final on the day following the City Council meeting where the resolution is adopted. The time within which judicial review of this decision may be sought is governed by the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.6. -- Signature Page to Follow -- Resolution No. 2000 —161 December 12, 2000 Page Seven PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of December, 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor AIThST: Michael R Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: George Ii $iser, III City Attorney City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE December 12, 2000 5 AGENDA ITEM NO. / ITEM TITLE CLAIM FOR DAMAGES: Sorina Andrade PREPARED BY Michael R. Dalla, CM4PARTMENT City Clerk EXPLANATION The claim of Sorina Andrade arises from an occurrence on September 8, 2000 and was filed with the City Clerk's Office on October 24, 2000 . ( Environmental Review XX N/A Financial Statement N/A >STAFF RECOMMENDATION Deny the claim, and refer to the City Attorney. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A Account No. ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below) Resolution No. N/A A-200 (9/80) City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE December 12, 2000 6 AGENDA ITEM NO. (-ITEM TITLE CLAIM FOR DAMAGES: Larry Williams PREPARED BY Michael R. Dalla, CM ARTMENT City Clerk EXPLANATION The claim of Larry Williams arises from an occurrence on July 19, 2000 and was filed with the City Clerk's Office on October 12, 2000 . Environmental Review N/A Financial Statement N/A Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Deny the claim, and refer to the City Attorney. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below) Resolution No. N/A A-200 (9/80) FETING DATE 12/12/00 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT AGENDA ITEM NO. 7 ITEM TITLE WARRANT REGISTER #23 PREPARED BY EXPLANATION ROBERT A. RABAGO DEPARTMENT FINANCE Ratification of Warrant Register #23 per government section code 37208. Environmental Review N/A Financial Statement N/A Approved By: Noce Director Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATION I recommend certification of these warrants for a total of $1,136,425.76 BOARD / COMMISSIO RECOMMENDATION ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) -1. Warrant Register #23 2. Payroll dated 12/6/00 . Workers' Comp Warrant Register dated 11/29/00 Resolution No. A-200 �9 99 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT FETING DATE December 12, 2000 8 AGENDA ITEM NO. ITEM TITLE RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE BUILDING AND SAFETY DEPARMTENT TO SUBMIT A GRANT APPLICATION TO THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FOR FUNDS TO IMPLEMENT A CODE ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE PROGRAM PREPARED BY DEPARTMENT EXPLANATION Kathleen Trees, Director See attached report. Building & Safety Environ ental Review N/A Financial Statement N/A STAFF RECOMMENDATION Adopt the resolution BOAR / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A Approved By: Finance Director Account No. ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ( Resolution No. A-200 93j Staff Report Resolution STAFF REPORT Background The Building and Safety Department first hired a housing inspector in 1995. CDBG funds were used for this purpose. The Housing Inspector inspects all single family, duplex, 3 and 4 unit rentals. The Health Department inspects all apartment complexes 5 units and above. Initially the inspector covered the north portion of the city. The Housing Inspector works with the Code Enforcement Officer, with the Police Department and with the CDC, however an ongoing coordinated effort between the Departments does not exist to the extent that the City is making a real difference in the various neighborhoods. The City also does not involve the community in the housing efforts. The paperwork required to process the code violations takes twice as long as performing the inspections. If the housing inspector could spend more time in the field, he could cover a lot more ground and move through the city faster. Solution In October 2000 the California Department of Housing and Community Development announced that it has grant money available for a Code Enforcement Incentive Program. The purpose of this grant is to help cities supplement their existing local funding for code enforcement related to housing code maintenance. The applicants must demonstrate their intent to develop relationships among all departments such as the Attorney, Building & Safety, Planning, Police, the County Health Department and the Community Development Commission. The goal of the program is to preserve affordable housing that could be lost through closure or demolition and to avoid displacement of residents. This grant requires the City to match the funds each year with 25% the first year, 50% the second year and 75% the third year. The Program The City is planning to use the increased staff to continue to move forward in systematically inspecting the rental units in the city. The additional staff will help to expedite the process. The City is asking for funds to hire an additional housing inspector, a part-time secretary to handle the large volume of paperwork generated from the inspections and a part-time Assistant City Attorney to handle the increased workload. In addition to speeding up the process, the goal of the grant is to increase the level of community involvement and to improve the relationships between staff, the tenants and owners. The goals of the program are: 1. Employ staff committed to issuing citations and civil or criminal prosecution of violators. 2. Employ staff committed to meeting with community members who are neighbors of or residents in substandard housing. 3. Employ staff committed to working with owners and engaging in voluntary compliance whenever possible. 4. Increase the number of administrative hearings and expedite the procedures. 5. Increase the City's ability to resolve code violations and to prosecute uncooperative violators. 6. Improve communication among all parties involved in the resolution of the violation. 7. Support property owners in financing building rehabilitation. 8. Support tenants in maintaining safe housing conditions. 9. Further educate the public regarding safe housing issues, tenant's rights and resources available to property owners. 10. Increase community outreach. 11. Increase housing assistance to tenants faced with impending or actual displacement. 12. Improve the permit and inspection process for repairs and rehabilitation, including providing notice of lead -safe repair procedures, expedited permit processing and/or fee waivers. 13. Increase community involvement in the code enforcement process and in the neighborhood improvement process The evaluation of the program will use records of the work accomplished and reflective staff meetings to measure the following: 1. How many houses are brought up to code. 2. How many properties owners are cited and taken to court. 3. How effectively the code enforcement process is streamlined over the life of the grant. 4. If the volume of code violations processed by the department is increased. 5. How effectively the cases are tracked using the City's database. 6. How effective the department improves its ability to provide information to tenants regarding their rights and to both tenants and landlords alike regarding resources available to them. 7. How effectively the department improves the permit and inspection processes related to repairs and rehabilitation, including expedited permit processing and fee waivers. Amount of the Grant Request The City is requesting approximately $232,000 for three years (see Attachment A). The money will be used to hire an additional housing inspector, a part-time Sr. Office Assistant to handle the large volume of paperwork generated from the inspections and a part-time Assistant City Attorney to handle the increased workload. Match Requirements If funded, the City will provide a 25% match in the first year, a 50% match in the second year, and a 75% match in the third year. The purpose of the grant is to secure funding that will support National City in developing additional staffing to increase the ability of the city to enforce building code violations, improve living conditions, and raise the quality of life for many National City residents. RESOLUTION NO. 2000 — 162 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE SUBMITTAL OF A GRANT APPLICATION, THE INCURRING OF AN OBLIGATION, THE EXECUTION OF A GRANT AGREEMENT AND ANY AMENDMENTS THERETO, AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO SECURE A CODE ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE PROGRAM (CEIP) GRANT FROM THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO IMPLEMENT A CODE ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE PROGRAM WHEREAS, the City of National City is a public entity established under the laws of California and empowered to enter into an agreement to receive State funds to promote code enforcement efforts and to commit to providing annual matching funds or reserves; and WHEREAS, the California Department of Housing and Community Development (hereinafter referred to . as the "State") is authorized to make grants to assist with code enforcement efforts; and. WHEREAS, the City wishes to obtain from the State a grant for assisting with code enforcement activities and intends to offer matching funds and resources as identified in its application. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that: 1. The City may submit to the State an application for a CEIP grant for use in the City. 2. If the application is approved, the City is hereby authorized to incur anobligation to provide matching funds or resources in any amount not less from the amount approved by the State and to enter into a grant agreement with the State for the purposes set forth in the application and approved by the State. It also may execute a contract and other instruments necessary or required by the State to govern and secure the match obligation, the performance obligation, and the state funding commitment. 3. The City is further authorized to request amendments, including, but not limited to funding increases in amounts up to amounts approved by the State, and to execute any and all documents required by the State to govern and secure these amendments. 4. The City authorizes the City Manager to execute in the name of the City, the application and the agreement, and other instruments necessary or required by the State for the making and securing of the grant, and any amendments thereto. — Signature Page to Follow — Resolution No. 2000 — 162 December 12, 2000 Page Two PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of December, 2000. George IL Waters, Mayor Al LEST: Michael R. Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: George H Eiser, III City Attorney ATTACHMENT A SUMMARY OF THE BUDGET CODE ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE PROGRAM YEAR TOTAL BUDGET GRANT CDBG OR GENERAL FUND GENERAL FUND* 1 $166,539 $124,904 $ 28,326 $13,309 2 $140,400 $ 70,199 $ 52,848 $17,351 3 $147,341 $ 36,835 $ 88,638 $21,868 TOTALS $454,280 $231,938 $169,812 $52,528 *The money in the General Fund would come from existing staff members devoting a portion of their time in a supervisory capacity. City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT cETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 9 ITEM TITLE RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE BUILDING AND SAFETY DEPARMTENT TO SUBMIT A GRANT APPLICATION TO THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FOR FUNDS TO IMPLEMENT A CODE ENFORCEMENT PILOT PROGRAM PREPARED BY PLANATION Kathleen Trees, Director EX See attached report. DEPARTMENT Building & Safety I Environmental Review X N/A Financial Statement N/A Approved By: Finance Director Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Adopt the resolution BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) Staff Report Resolution A-200 i9:99': 2000-163 Resolution No, STAFF REPORT Background The Building and Safety Department first hired a housing inspector in 1995. CDBG funds were used for this purpose. The Housing Inspector inspects all single family, duplex, 3 and 4 unit rentals. The Health Department inspects all apartment complexes 5 units and above. Initially, the inspector covered the north portion of the city. The Housing Inspector works with the Code Enforcement Officer, with the Police Department and with the CDC, however an ongoing coordinated effort between the Departments does not exist to the extent that the City is making a real difference in the various neighborhoods. The City also does not involve the community in the housing efforts. In addition, the paperwork required to process the code violations takes twice as long as performing the inspections. If the housing inspector could spend more time in the field, he could cover a lot more ground and move through the city faster. Solution In October 2000 the California Department of Housing and Community Development announced that it has grant money available for a Code Enforcement Pilot Program. The purpose of this grant is to help cities reduce the amount of substandard housing by using creative and coordinated methods of code enforcement. In addition, the cities are to use an interdepartmental approach and involve the community. The funds are to be used to develop a code enforcement team to achieve this goal. The Pilot Program Using this grant money the City proposes to develop a Code Enforcement Team and community involvement to make a difference in the selected neighborhoods. The Code Enforcement Team will consist of a Coordinator with a health background, the Housing Inspector, the Code Enforcement Officer, the Neighborhood Police, the CDC Housing Specialist, the Health Inspector, the Assistant City Attorney, a secretary and community members. At the beginning of the program the Team will identify potential "hot spots" which have a need for intervention. After the "hot spots" are identified, they will be ranked using the following criteria: 1. Age of the buildings 2. The level of crime in the area 3. The level of community involvement in the neighborhood 4. The degree of deterioration in the buildings 5. The concern for health and safety issues in the area (such as lead paint) b. Knowledge of existing substandard housing structures and abandoned buildings 7. The number of low income residents 8. The number of rentals, particularly those with absentee landlords 9. The volume of trash The Team will then present the information to the City Council and the City Council will determine which "hot spot" the Team should concentrate on first. It is expected that it will take approximately two years to make a significant impact. The Team will then proceed to the next neighborhood. The community meeting format will be used to share information, gather input from the residents, provide informal mediation, cultivate neighborhood pride, establish positive working relationships and evaluate the process. The Team will begin by holding an initial meeting using such things as door prizes to attract the citizens. It is expected that the meetings will be held on a monthly basis. The goal of the program is to have the owners implement the building repairs necessary to bring the buildings up to code. The City will use CDBG funds to install public improvements, such as street lights and purchase materials such as paint to improve the appearance of the buildings and provide a dumpster for trash removal. The tenants will agree to put some labor into the appearance of the buildings and neighborhood. The police with help with the crime in the neighborhood, the Cc de Enforcement Officer will work on the trash issues and the Attorney will provide information and prosecute when necessary. Another goal of the program is to educate the tenants on their rights as renters. Often tenants do not mention problems with the building because they fear eviction or they refuse to pay their rent until the landlord fixes the problems. Refusal to pay rent often results in eviction. The Team will empower the tenants by teaching them their rights and helping them work with their landlord to identify problems before the building deteriorates further. Retaliation by the building owners against vocal tenants will not be tolerated. In addition, the Attorney will prosecute all owners who refuse to repair their rentals. As a condition of the probation, the owner will be required to correct the code violations and in addition, relocate the tenants if necessary. The grant provides the City with a full-time housing inspector. The housing inspector will serve as a mediator between the property owner and tenants and will coordinate with the other departments. This housing inspector will provide a new style of enforcement by becoming involved in the community. The housing inspector will develop working relationships between owners and tenants so that they feel comfortable contacting the department for advice, to report problems, for mediation, for referral and any other needed assistance. The indicators of success will be: 1. The number of homes brought up to code. 2. How many property owners are cited and brought to court. 3. How effectively the code enforcement process is streamlined over the three years. 4. If the volume of code violations increases. 5. The use of technology to track the violations. 6. How much the department improves its ability to provide information to the tenants and landlords. 7. How effectively the department improves the permit and inspection process related to the repairs and rehabilitation. The Building and Safety Department currently employs one housing inspector. If the grant were to be funded, the staffing will be altered. The grant will provide the salary for the housing inspector and the City will refashion the existing position into a Coordinator for the program for 20 hours per week and housing inspection for 20 hours per week. The grant funded housing inspector will work in the "hot spots". The Coordinator will work as a community liaison and organize the program. The existing housing inspector will continue to respond to complaints and continue the program started in 1995. Working with the community and having a coordinated effort with all departments will be the key goals of the program. All involved staff will attend the community meetings to be held at a local school or church in the evening. The meetings will provide childcare and refreshments. Translators will be available. A hotline will be established to allow the citizens to register complaints, ask for assistance, share information, etc. The staff will become familiar with the residents and make site visits as required. They will carry cell phones so they can be reached by the community at all times during working hours. Amount of the Grant Request The City of National City is asking for approximately $338,000 from the state for the three years (see Attachment A). The money will allow the City to hire a Housing Inspector and provides additional money for Community meetings. The City will match this by providing a person to coordinate the program. This person will have a health background and is required spend a minimum of 20 hours per week for the three years. In addition, the City will commit $50,000 of CDBG funds to make public improvements to the neighborhoods and funds for neighborhood beautification. ATTACHMENT A SUMMARY OF THE BUDGET CODE ENFORCEMENT PILOT PROGRAM YEAR TOTAL BUDGET GRANT CDBG OR GENERAL FUND GENERAL FUND* 1 $260,782 $126,517 $ 50,000 $ 84,265 2 $243,109 $103,790 $ 50,000 $ 89,319 3 $251,132 $107,346 $ 50,000 $ 93,786 TOTALS $755,132 $337,653 $150,000 $267,370 *The money in the General Fund would come from existing staff members devoting a portion of their time to the program. These staff members would include 'h Coordinator, �/4 Sr. Office Assistant in the Building and Safety Department, 10% Building and Safety Department Director, 10% of the CDC Housing Specialist, and 10% of the Planning Code Enforcement Officer and 10% of the Neighborhood Police Team. RESOLUTION NO. 2000 — 163 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE SUBMITTAL OF A GRANT APPLICATION, THE INCURRING OF AN OBLIGATION, THE EXECUTION OF A GRANT AGREEMENT AND ANY AMENDMENTS THERETO, AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENTS NECESSARY TO SECURE A CODE ENFORCEMENT INCENTIVE PROGRAM. (CEIP) GRANT FROM THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA TO IMPLEMENT A COMMUNITY CODE ENFORCEMENT PILOT PROGRAM WHEREAS, the City of National City is a public entity established under the laws of California and empowered to enter into an agreement to receive State funds to promote code enforcement efforts and to commit to providing annual matching funds or reserves; and WHEREAS, the California Department of Housing and Community Development (hereinafter referred to as the "State") is authorized to make grants to assist with code enforcement efforts; and WHEREAS, the City wishes to obtain from the State a grant for assisting with code enforcement activities and intends to offer matching funds and resources as identified in its application. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that: 1. The City may submit to the State an application for a CEIP grant for use in the City. 2. If the application is approved, the City is hereby authorized to incur an obligation to provide matching funds or resources in any amount not less from the amount approved by the State and to enter into a grant agreement with the State for the purposes set forth in the application and approved by the State. It also may execute a contract and other instruments necessary or required by the State to govern and secure the match obligation, the performance obligation, and the state funding commitment. 3. The City is further authorized to request amendments, including, but not limited to funding increases in amounts up to amounts approved by the State, and to execute any and all documents required by the State to govern and secure these amendments. 4. The City authorizes the City Manager to execute in the name of the City, the application and the agreement, and other instruments necessary or required by the State for the making and securing of the grant, and any amendments thereto. -- Signature Page to Follow -- Resolution No. 2000 —163 December 12, 2000 Page Two PASSED and ADOPTED this 12* day of December, 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor Al1"EST: Michael R. Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: George H. Eiser, III City Attorney r--- ATTACHMENTS (Listed B City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATEDecember 12, 2000 ITEM TITLE RESOLUTION FOR POLICE DEPARTMENT REQUEST FOR LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT FUNDS ** Refer to Item #2 AGENDA ITEM NO, 10 PREPARED BY DEPARTMENT LT. RAY ALLEN POLICE DEPARTMENT EXPLANATION Background On August 20, 2000, the National City Police Department received an application package for a federal grant known as the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Program. These grants are administered by the U.S. Department of Justice and are similar in many respects to CDBG funds in that they are awarded to local governments who have a significant amount of flexibility in deciding how the funds are to be expended. Like CDBG funding, only a general categorical description and not specific plans on how the money will be expended needs to be submitted to the federal government in order to receive the funds. Local governments, cities and counties, are eligible for Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Funds. The amount of Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Funds that each city is eligible for is based upon the population and the crime rate according to the FBI Uniform Crime Reports. National City received $178,881 in FY 1999/2000 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funding {{ last year. Based on the same formula, the City of National City is eligible to apply for $152,252 in FY 2000/01 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funds. (cont.) e.Et/tC-WEs> ,this Environmental Review N/A Financial Statement The local match for the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award will be $15,379. There should be no fiscal impact to the budget as the Police Department intends to fund the match with ccoPnt No Asset Forfeiture funds. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve the Resolution. BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION 220-409-500-598=8009 131-409-500-598-8009 On December5, 2000, the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Advisory Board voted unanimously, (3 — 0) to recommend approval of the proposed Resolution. LLEBG Application and Award Notification. Resolution No, 2000-16'4 A-200 (Rev. 9/80) COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT RESOLUTION FOR FY 2000/01 LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT FUNDS PAGE 2 The award period for the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant would cover two federal fiscal years, (October 1, 2000 — September 30, 2002). This program requires a 10 percent local cash match. It is the intent of the Police Department to fund the local match requirement with asset forfeiture funds. One of the provisions of the 1998 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant program, is that in order to receive full funding, the City of National City must comply with Section 615, of the Fiscal Year 1998 Appropriations Act: Alu — O'Hara Public Safety Officers Health Benefits Act, which requires entities which employ peace officers to provide officers who are retired or separated from service due to injury suffered as a direct and proximate result of a personal injury sustained in the line of duty while responding to an emergency situation or hot pursuit, with the same or better level of health insurance benefits that are paid by the entity at the time of retirement or separation. Currently, the City of National City does not provide such health insurance benefits to peace officers retired under the above circumstances and is therefore out of compliance with this provision. As with the case with the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award that the City of National City received last year, this will result in a 10 percent reduction of the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Award, but not a complete disqualification from receiving the funds. The reduced Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award that the City of National City will receive will be approximately $138,411. The local match for this reduced award will be approximately $15,379. The funds under this program may be used for any of the following purposes. 1. Hiring, training, and employing new law enforcement officers and necessary support personnel, paying overtime to presently employed law enforcement officers and support personnel, and/or procuring equipment, technology, and other material related to basic law enforcement functions. 2. Enhance school security and school security measures at any facility or location the local government considers to be at risk for crime. 3. Establishing or supporting drug courts. 4. Enhancing the adjudication process of cases involving violent offenders, including cases involving violent juvenile offenders. 5. Establishing multi — jurisdictional task forces which work to prevent and combat crime. 6. Establishing crime prevention programs. COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT RESOLUTION ON FY2000/O1 LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT FUNDS PAGE 3 7. Defraying the cost of indemnification or insurance for law enforcement officers. The Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funds may not be used as local matching funds for Police Officers hired under the COPS Universal Hiring Program. Because this is only a two year grant, and personnel costs are usually long term, funding under this program would be more appropriate for equipment and technology purchases than for hiring officers or other personneL The funding under this program would be ideal for meeting some of the Police Department's equipment and technology needs. Proposal The Police Department is requesting a Resolution which would authorize the appropriation of $178,881 in FY 2000/01 Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funding to C.I.P. account #220- 409-500-598-8009 for the purchase of the equipment needed to install Mobile Data Computing equipment in 18 additional police vehicles. Phase II of the project outfitted 10 vehicles with the Mobile Data Computing equipment. The purchase of this additional equipment will allow the officers in the field to transmit completed reports to the Automated Field Reporting System It is the Police Department's intention, if the appropriation is approved, to provide the required cash match for those expenditures with a $15,379 in asset seizure funds. Under the proposal, the requested funds and local match would be applied towards the purchase of the necessary hardware, software, software configuration and customization, as well as the necessary interfaces to the automated field reporting system, 911 and other critical law enforcement data bases. This proposal was presented to the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Advisory Board at their meeting on December 5, 2000. The Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Advisory Board voted unanimously to recommend approval of the proposed Resolution. The Police Department currently estimates the cost of purchase of the CAD/RMS at approximately $838,391 to $1,118,000. If approved, this would bring the total amount of approved funding for the project to $1,065,169. The Police Department intends to fund the balance of the project with Supplemental Law Enforcement Services Funds. The Police Department will bring requests to Council for appropriations of those funds to the project when the city receives them. The Police Department is requesting that all of the above funds be utili7Pd for the final phases of the Computer Aided Dispatch and Records Management System (CAD/RMS). Once this project is completed, the Police Department will have a modem day CAD/RMS with the ability to provide officer safety premises history, officer safety time prompts for dispatchers, deep field submission of all police reports, and getting vehicle and person information directly from state computer files without utilizing the police dispatchers. RESOLUTION NO. 2000 —164 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO SUBMIT THE LOCAL LAW ENFORCEMENT BLOCK GRANT APPLICATION TO THE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, BUREAU OF JUSTICE ASSISTANCE AND TO SIGN GRANT AWARD AGREEMENT AND ALL GRANT RELAIEI) DOCUMENTS WHEREAS, Local Law Enforcement Block Grants are administered by the U.S. Department of Justice; and WHEREAS, the amount of Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funds that each city is eligible for is based upon the population and the crime rate according to the FBI Uniform Crime Reports; and WHEREAS, last year National City received $178,881 in Local Law Enforcement Block Grant funding; and WHEREAS, the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant award that the City will receive will be approximately $138,411, with a local match of approximately $15,379. NOW, THEREFORE, BE TT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of National City hereby authorizes the City Manager to submit the Local Law Enforcement Block Grant Application to the U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance and to sign the Grant Award Agreement and all grant related documents. A copy of the agreement is on file in the office of the City Clerk. PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of December, 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor ALLEST: Michael R Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: /. .°zr George H. Eiser, III City Attorney Local Law t ntorcement Block (irant - LL.E1311 introduction rage l oI l FY 2000 Local Law Enforcement Block Grants Program National City, CA Application Award RFD Grant Changes Reports Correspondence Grant Handbook Application was submitted on 15-SEP-00. Click here to print a copy. View Only View Application Help/Frequently Asked Questions LLEBG Home Log -Off LLEBG FY 2000 Application Date Certified : 15-SEP-00 'Date Submitted : 15-SEP-00 Jurisdiction Information Jurisdiscfbn: National City County: SAN DIEGO State: CALIFORNIA CDFA Number. 16.592 Budget Information Eligible Award Amount $153,790 Final Award Amount $138,411 Match Amount $15,379 Matching Funds Description: State and Local Government Units CEO Information Title: City Manager Name Prefix: Mr. Last Name : McCabe First Name : Tom Address: 1243 National City Boulevard National City, California, CA 91950-4397 Telephone: (619)336- 4240 Fax: (619) 336-4327 Email: cmo@ci.na ional- city.caus Program Contact Information Title: Lieutenant Name Prefix: Mr. Last Name : Allen First Name : Raymond Address: 1200 National City Boulevard Naticnal City, CA 91950-4397 Telephone: 619-336- 4514 Fax: 619- 336-4525 Email: rayallen_92019@yahoo.cam Application Details Date Agreed to Trust Fund Requirement 30-AUG-00 Applicant is PSONB Compliant No Date Agreed to SPOC Requirement 30-AUG-00 Date Agreed to SAA Review Requirement 15-SEP-00 Date Agreed to CertMcations: 15-SEP-00 Date Agreed to Assurances: 15-SEP-00 https://grants.ojp.usdoj.gov:8004/gins user/P1sgllllebg_main.app_read_anly?p_bgid=2 12/05/00 LLEBG 2000/2001 E Each unit cost 10Ea Unit Cost 12 05 2000 Current Cost 10Ea $12,140.00 Minus Cradle cost 10Ea $167.00 $1,670.00 Subtotal $10,470.00 Docking station 10Ea $680.00 $6,800.00 Pass Thru for modem 10 Ea $80.00 $800.00 Subtotal $7,600.00 J $5,930.00 TOTAL $18,070.00 Phase Ill Additional Units Quote $3,593.00 Difference of Cradle and dock $593.00 Subtotal $4,186.00 Phase III 18 Additional Units Cost Subtotal $75,348.00 TOTAL $93,418.00 Panasonic Laptop computers CF-27 6 Each CF-27EB6GCAMNT $4,790.00 $28,740.00 $140,228.00 Tax 7.75% $10,868.67 TOTAL $151,096.67 *efertoItem #1 MEETING DATE City of National City® California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 11 ITEMTITLE Resolution of the City Council of the City of National City authorizing the Mayor to amend our agreement with Schmidt Design Group to provide construction plans and specifications for Paradise Creek Educational Park. PREPARED BY Jim Ruiz EXPLANATION. DEPARTMENT Parks & Recreation This amendment is for the agreement for developing conceptual plans that was approved by the City Council on July 27, 1999 and will provide construction plans and specifi- cations for the development of Paradise Creek Educational Park. This amendment to the contract will allow the architect to work with staff to develop final plans and specifications which will then be presented to the City Council for approval. Environmental Review Financial Statement Schnmidt Design fee not to exceed $96,115. Funding from a grant of $700,000 from the State Coastal ommissi Account o.347-409-500-598--400 STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve amendment N/A BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION Approval ATTACHMENTS (Listed Below) Amendment and Scope of Work Resolution No. 2000-165 A-200 (Rev. 9/80) RESOLUTION NO. 2000 —165 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AN AMENDMENT TO THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE . CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AND SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP TO PROVIDE CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS, CONCEPTUAL DESIGN AND PERMIT PROCESSING FOR PARADISE CREEK EDUCATIONAL PARK BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of National City that the Mayor is hereby authorized to execute an Amendment to the Agreement between the City of National City and Schmidt Design Group to provide construction document, conceptual design and permit processing for Paradise Creek Educational Park. Said Agreement is on file in the office of the City Clerk. PASSED and ADOPTED this 12th day of December, 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor ATTEST: Michael R. Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: if) 44. *It George H. Eiser, lII City Attorney DEC-05-2000 13:58 SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP December 5, 2000 Mr. 3ames Ruiz, Director Parks and Recreation Department City of National City 140 East 12t,Street National City, CA 91950-3312 Re: Schedule of Completion for Construction Documents, Conceptual Design and Permit Processing for the Paradise Creek Educational Park Dear Mr. Ruiz: As requested, I am submitting this letter confirming our commitment to complete all the work described in our Scope of Work and Fee Proposal (11-13-00) within 12 months forin our Notice to Proceed from the City. Please call me if you need additional information or have any questions. Sincerely, Gary Ruyle Director of Environmental Planning SCUAROT BEsMN BROCP. NIC. ass FOURTH AVENUE SAW O!EBO, CAUFORI A 92W3 CA LIC 2138 NV UC 219 t619127.61462 fAx (6191236-STD Exhibit "B" Page 2 11/15/00 D. Perspective drawings. HOURLY OR ADDITIONAL SERVICES Hourly or any additional services which may be required as a result of the owner's prerogative or changes in the project scope, and which are outside the control of the • Schmidt Design Group, Inc. may be requested on a time and materials basis at a rate of: Principal Landscape Architect $130.00/hr. Associate Landscape Architect / Director of Environmental Planning 100.00/hr. Licensed Project Landscape Architect 85.00/hr. Project Landscape Architect 65.00/hr. Assistant Landscape Architect 55.00/hr. Drafter 45.00/hr. Clerical/Typist 35.00/hr. All lump sum and hourly fees stated herein are valid for six (6) months from the date of the Landscape Architect's signature. If this contract is not executed within that time, the Schmidt Design Group, Inc. reserves the right to revise their fees and charge at its current rates at that time. Gary Ruyle Director of Environmental Planning SCHMIDT OESIGN GROUP, INC. Exhibit "A" Page 4 Page 2 11/15/00 Total service fee, item D: SDG $9,800.00 Civil Consultant $1,500.00 Structural Consultant $750.00 Electrical Consultant $1,500.00 $13,550.00 E. Conceptual Design for Public Works Storage Yard 1. Prepare conceptual design for existing public works storage yard. The design will demonstrate how the storage yard can be integrated into the larger Paradise Creek Environmental Learning Center. Design Elements shall include, but not necessarily limited to, circulation system, conceptual grading, landscape and irrigation concepts, activity nodes and other hardscape improvements. Total service fee, item E (not to exceed estimate): $3,500.00 F. Meetings Because the number of meetings are difficult to anticipate, we propose providing this service on a time and materials basis as follows: 2. City Staff Meetings (4) 3. Pre -bid Conference (1) 4. Pre -Construction Conference (1) Total service fee, item F (not to exceed estimate): $3000.00 G. Reimbursable / Reproduction costs Total service fee, item F (not to exceed estimate): $3,000.00 Summary of Fees A. Project Start-up and Program Development B. Construction Drawings C. Permit Processing D. Construction Administration E. Conceptual Design for Public Works Storage Yard F. Meetings (billed hourly not to exceed) G. Reimbursable / Reproduction Costs (estimate) $1,000.00 $66,550.00 $5,515.00 $13,550.00 $3,500.00 $3,000.00 $3,000.00 GRAND TOTAL $96,115.00 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY'S RESPONSIBIL1T1 S A. Provide utility as -built plans indicating all wet and dry utilities that exist in the park site. B. Provide any information on other existing easements or other property encumbrances C. Promptly notify the Landscape Architect of any changes or revisions in the project. SCOPE OF SERVICES DOES NOT INCLUDE A. Changes in the scope of project or services. B. Modifications to the design based on issues unrelated to our work. C. Attendance at meetings beyond those noted on scope of work. SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP, INC. Exhibit "A" Page 3 Page 2 11/15/00 • Electrical lighting Details • Landscape Planting Plans • Landscape Planting Details • Irrigation Plans • Irrigation Details • Technical Specifications, it is anticipated that the 'Green Book' will be referenced with special provisions on the drawings 3. City Review Meeting (see Section F below) 4. 100% Submittal package: make revisions requested by the City to the previous submittal and bring the package to a 100% level. 5. City Review Meeting ((see section F below) 6. Bid/Back-check submittal: Following City comments of the 100% Submittal, make corrections, if any, to finalize the package for bidding including a Statement of Probable Construction Costs. 7. Project Administration Total service fee, item B: $66,550.00 SDG $50,150.00 Civil Consultant $3,500.00 Structural Consultant $6,500.00 Geotechnical Consultant $1,400.00 Electrical Consultant $5,000.00 C. Agency Permit Preparation and Permit Processing 1. Prepare and process ACOE Nationwide 404 permit, RWCD 401 permit, California Fish and Game 1601 permit. (Does not include application fees). Total service fee, item C: $5,515.00 D. Construction Administration / Construction Observation During bidding and construction our services are recommended to include: 1. Answer questions during the contract -bidding period. 2. Prepare landscape addendum as required. 3. Attend one pre -construction meeting (listed under meetings hourly). 4. Review submittals, shop drawings, and answer questions during construction. 5. Site observations at appropriate times during construction are recommended to ensure the quality of the construction and design intent, anticipate three () visits. • Ongoing Construction Observation (3 visits) • Irrigation inspection/Conformance to specifications/Pressure testing (2 visits) • Coverage test/Construction Completion/Pre-maintenance Punch list (I visit) • Post Construction/Final Maintenance (1 visit). 6. Prepare Final As -Built Drawings from Contractor's Redlined As-built's for City files 7. Project Administiation SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP, INC. Exhibit "A" Page 2 SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP November 13, 2000 Mr. James Ruiz, Director Parks and Recreation Department City of National City 140 East 12th,Street National City, CA 91950-3312 Re: Request for Proposal for Construction Documents, Conceptual Design and Permit Processing for the Paradise Creek Educational Park Dear Mr. Ruiz: Thank you for the opportunity to provide the following proposal for landscape architectural and permit processing services for the above referenced project. Based on the approved Enhancement Plan for the Paradise Creek Education Park, the following is my understanding of services required for the project. Scope of Work and Fee Proposal A. Project Start-up and Program Development 1. One meeting with the City Project Manager to determine the project intent, scope, budget, and timetable (see Section F below). 2: Review all data pertinent to the project including existing site plans. 3. Review City/County codes, ordinances, and policies pertaining to the proposed project design. 4. Project Administiation Total service fee, item A: $1000.00 B. Construction Drawings 1. Prepare a final CADD base plan. 2. Prepare a 75% Submittal construction document package to facilitate installation of park improvements. This package will include: • Existing Conditions/Demolition Plans • Grading & Drainage Plans • Layout and Construction Plans, indicating all construction improvements and play area equipment identification and placement. This plan will provide horizontal control (dimensioning) of all improvements • Construction Details • Playground Construction Plans and Details • Boardwalk Structural Plans and Details • Interpretive Sign Plans and Details Electrical lighting Plans SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP, INC. 2655 FOURTH AVENUE SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92103 CA LIC 2138 NV LIC 219 (619) 236-1462 FAX ThdiSkit Page 1 AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT This Amendment to Agreement is entered into this 12th day of December, 2000, by and between the City of National City, a municipal corporation, (the "CITY"), and SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP, (the "CONTRACTOR"). RECITALS A. The CITY and the CONTRACTOR entered into an Agreement on July 13, 1993, (the "Agreement") providing that the CONTRACTOR would prepare the Paradise Creek Educational Park Enhancement Plan. B. The CITY and the CONTRACTOR now wish to amend the Agreement by amending the Scope of Services thereof. NOW, THEREFORE, THE PARTIES HERETO DO MUTUALLY AGREE AS FOLLOWS: 1. That the Agreement between the CITY OF NATIONAL CITY and SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP dated July 13, 1993, is hereby amended by amending the Scope of Services thereof; as set forth in the attached Exhibits "A" and `B", attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference. 2. With the foregoing exception, each and every term and provision of the Agreement dated July 13, 1993, shall remain in full force and effect. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Amendment to Agreement on the date and year first above written. CITY OF NATIONAL CITY SCHMIDT DESIGN GROUP (Two signatures required) By: By: George H. Waters, Mayor (Name) APPROVED AS TO FORM: By: (Title) (Name) George H. Eiser, Ill City Attorney (Title) City of National City California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT miEETING DATE December 12, 2000 ITEM TITLE 12 AGENDA ITEM NO. AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 13.12 OF THE NCMC PERTAINING TO ENCROACHMENT PERMITS FOR INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF FACILITIES IN STREETS, RIGHTS -OF WAY AND OTHER PUBLIC PROPERTY PREPARED BY Rudolf Hradecky EXPLANATION DEPARTMENT City Attorney Please see attached Staff Report. EMIir a nt l Review X NIA Financial Statement There is no cost to the City. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Adopt ordinance. BOARD i COMMISSION RECOMMENATIOU N/A ATTACHMENTS fisted Below ) Ordinance Staff Report Supplemental memorandum A -too (9/ao) Account No, Resolution No., STAFF REPORT AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AMENDING CHAPTER 13.12 OF THE NATIONAL CITY MUNICIPAL CODE, PERTAINING TO ENCROACHMENT PERMITS FOR INSTALLATION MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF FACILITIES IN STREETS, RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND OTHER PUBLIC PROPERTY The attached ordinance is proposed for adoption by the City Council. It updates and improves the terms and conditions under which public utility and convenience encroachments may be installed in the public rights -of -way or public property. The impetus for the attached has been an increased level of interest by various telecommunications providers in installing conduit, cable or fiber optics in the rights -of -way. In some cases, the installers will be merely passing through the city; in others, they will also be providing services within the city. The attached ordinance covers a variety of effects and needs. It addresses ongoing street maintenance impacts caused by or associated with such installation. It allows greater flexibility to the City to require encroachments to remove or relocate when made necessary by City needs. It mandates certain actions to be taken, including the coordination of installation with other installations pending or contemplated. It also addresses, albeit not in totality, potential telecommunication conduits and cables —both aerial and underground. A separate "Telecommunications Regulatory Ordinance" will deal with the licensing and franchise aspects of those types of encroachments. However, the attached gives greater flexibility for requiring undergrounding as a condition of the encroachment permit. Authority is granted to the City Engineer to make rules and regulations necessary to further implement the ordinance. Appeals to the City Council are provided for, and an alternative appeals procedure to an administrative hearing examiner is also provided for upon the mutual election of the City and the permittee/applicant. Of primary concern is the maintenance and resurfacing of streets. Particular emphasis is placed upon the permittee's financial obligation to ensure that the public streets are maintained properly, consistent with and proportional to the impacts caused by the installation and its benefits to the permittee. The attached ordinance completely rewrites the existing Chapter 13.12 on installations in the public streets. It preserves the misdemeanor nature of non -permitted installations and encroachments on both public property and the right-of-way, making an exception for emergency repairs for work to existing installations, provided a permit is applied for by the third business day following. This proposed ordinance has been coordinated by the City Engineer with SDG&E, PacBell, Sweetwater Authority and Cox Cable. It takes into account the terms and operational concepts of the existing franchises and agreements each of these entities has with the City. TO: FROM: SUBJECT: City of National City Office of the City Attorney 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-4301 George H. Eiser, Ill • City Attorney (619) 336-4220 FAX (619) 336-4327 TDD (619) 336-1615 Mayor and City Council Senior Assistant City Attorney Reintroduction of the Encroachment Permit Ordinance DATE: December 7, 2000 On December 5th, the City Council introduced the above -referenced ordinance by title only, thus constituting a first reading. Staff indicated that additional comments were received after the agenda was prepared, and that Staff intended to meet to assess whether the nature and scope of any possible changes would be either substantive or non -substantive. Minor non - substantive or clarifying changes would still allow the passage of the ordinance. Attached to this memorandum is a highlighted text of the ordinance showing changes that were made. The ordinance is now presented to you for re -introduction. Although the highlighted changes represent clarification of the original text, it appears to be the more prudent course to now re -introduce the ordinance for a first reading, bring back for a second reading and enactment at the next Council meeting in January. The attached changes shown in highlighted text were coordinated with and concurred by SDG&E, Pacific Bell, Cox Communications and Sweetwater Authority. RUDOL'1~ HRADECKY enior Assistant City Attorney RH/gmo Attachment ® Recycled Paper ORDINANCE NO. 2000 — AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AMENDING CHAPTER 13.12 OF THE NATIONAL CITY MUNICIPAL CODE, PERTAINING TO ENCROACHMENT PERMITS FOR INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF FACILITIES IN STREETS, RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND OTHER PUBLIC PROPERTY BE IT ORDAINED by the City Council of the City of National City that the National City Municipal Code is amended as follows: Section 1. That Chapter 13.12 of the National City Municipal Code is amended in its entirety to read as follows: ENCROACHMENT PERMITS FOR INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF FAC1L1'1'1hS IN STREETS, RIGHTS -OF -WAYS AND OTHER PUBLIC PROPERTY Sections: 13.12.010 Findings, purpose and intent. 13.12.020 Definitions and uses. 13.12.030 Encroachment permits —Required. 13.12.040 Encroachment permits —Bonds and insurance. 13.12.050 Encroachment permits—Ap 'lication. 13.12.060 Encroachment permit na$a y. City Engineer. 13.12.070 Resurfacing of streets. 13.12.080 Encroachment permits —Revocation —Penalty for violation of terms. 13.12.090 Encroachment permits —Fees. 13.12.100 Nonexclusive use of right-of-way. 13.12.110 Appeal. 13.12.120 Assignment of encroachment permits 13.12.130 Safeguarding of Proprietorial Information. 13.12.140 Alternate administrative hearing procedures for appeals. 13.12.150 Violations and enforcement. 13.12.010 Findings., purpose and intent. A. The City Council finds and determines that the installation, repair, maintenance and removal of private and public facilities in the public streets, rights -of -way and other public property must be regulated in order to protect the public health, safety and welfare and provide for the orderly administration and maintenance of public roadways and other public property for the benefit of the community, while allowing reasonable accommodation and cooperative flexibility for providing necessary utility and other convenience services to the community. It is further 2000 Ordinance Encroachment Permits the intent of the City Council to require public utility providers, other public agencies and private parties who are permitted to install facilities in the public streets and rights -of -way to preserve the street surfaces and, when necessary, contribute proportionately to resurfacing and maintenance as a result of the impact and benefits caused by or obtained from their installations. B. It is not the intent of the Council to require applicants and permittees to disclose proprietary information or trade secrets applicable to their technology, systems or facilities, except to the extent reasonably necessary to evaluate the installation or operation of the facility in terms of public health and safety. C. Administration of this ordinance shall be under the direction and control of the City Manager, as further delegated to the City Engineer under this chapter. 13.12.020 Definitions and uses. NO CHANGES 13.12.030 Encroachment permits —Required. A. Except as provided in Subsection 13.12.030F, it is unlawful for any person to excavate, construct or remove improvements or facilities within, or grade or encroach upon or over, any public right-of-way or public property of the City of National City without a valid encroachment permit issued pursuant to this chapter. B. An encroachment permit shall allow only the designated permittee(s) and their authorized contractors to install, maintain or remove approved facilities within the boundaries and under the terms and conditions specified in the encroachment permit. The term of the permit may be for a specific duration, or unlimited duration conditional, however, upon the removal or relocation of the facility when necessary for reasons of the public health, safety and welfare, or convenience. No person or permittee, including a franchisee or licensee, shall assign or enlarge the scope of an approved encroachment permit to allow another person to install an additional facility within the permitted encroachment without the prior written authorization of the City Engineer or, when applicable, the City Manager or Council, which authorization shall not be unreasonably withheld or denied. C The City En ' eer shall require the benefiting entity and may al require the installer when necessary to ensure proper project control, to apply for all requisite permits. Financial obligations imposed by this chapter 13.12 shall relate primarily to the responsibility of the permittee who benefits from the installation of the facility. D. As a condition of an encroachment permit, the permittee shall be required to remove or relocate the permitted facility or encroachment at the permittee's sole expense when determined necessary by the City Engineer as an exercise of the city's police power for the public health, safety and welfare or convenience. This shall include the right of the City to regrade or realign the streets or to install its own facilities, and require the permittee to remove or relocate its facility at the permittee's expense. A permittee may also be required to pay for the cost of relocating other previously permitted encroachments when necessary to accommodate its facility. E. The permittee shall obtain any business licenses and all other permits or licenses, including construction permits, required by code, statute or regulation pertaining to the installation of the facility, and for complying with all other provisions of law and this Code, including Chapter 6.12 relating to telecommunications, notwithstanding the issuance of an encroachment permit. 2000 Ordinance 2 Encroachment Permits F. Nothing in this Chapter 13.12 shall prevent excavation for emergency repairs to public utility service connections or other work that is necessary for the immediate protection of life or property, provided a permit is applied for by the end of the third business day following the commencement of work. G. The City Engineer shall have the authority to promulgate rules and regulations necessary to implement this chapter, and to negotiate and issue annual master encroachment permits to repetitive users with due allowance for the requirements of this chapter 13.12. A "repetitive user" shall refer to any public agency, public utility or other entity with a franchise or license from the city that contemplates repetitive facility installations in the public rights of way and public property. 13.12.040 Encroachment permits —Bonds and insurance. NO CHANGES 13.12.050 Encroachment permits —Application. NO CHANGES 13.12.060 Encroachment permit City End. A. The City Engineer may issue a permit to encroach upon, within or over the public right-of-way or other public property of the City of National City only if an applicant for such a permit can demonstrate that: (1) There is a compelling need to use the City right-of-way or property for the applicant's proposed use; (2) The issuance of a permit will not be detrimental to the public health, safety and welfare; (3) The applicant is capable and will comply with all the terms, conditions, and restrictions that are incorporated in the permit; and (4) The applicant has complied with all applicable state ,=f laws, and has obtained other applicable permits and certifications required under state ' federal law. (5) The applicant has reviewed city and other public records pertaining to existing and proposed encroachments and coordinated the details of its facility installation with those facilities and permittees. B. Except with respect to proprietorial information regarding the technology of the cable, facility or customer identity or which could adversely affect an applicant's competitive advantage, the City Engineer shall have the authori to re . uire the a i i licant, as a condition of permit issuance, to disclose informati (1) The applicant's proposed methods of use of any lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the right-of-way, and pertinent technical details regarding the installation, operation and placement of the facility which is necessary to determine the impact upon the public health and safety and the venue of installation; (2) The quantity and dimensions of applicant's proposed installation of lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the right-of-way; (3) The quantity and dimensions of applicant's proposed installation of lines, wires, cables, conduits, or other equipment which will be solely used for the provision of telephone service which is currently certificated by the Public Utilities Commission of the State of California; (4) The specific date(s) applicant proposes to begin using any lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the right-of-way; 2000 Ordinance 3 Encroachment Permits (5) The location of all proposed or future installations by the applicant and all existing lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the pertinent vicinity of the applicant's proposed installation in the City of National City right-of-way; (6) The specific traffic safety and environmental measures applicant proposes to use while applicant is excavating or obstructing any right-of-way; (7) Any limitations of time applicable to the use or removal of the facilities; (8) The coordination of the proposed facility installation with anticipated or existing encroachments and other construction or improvement in the affected venue of installation. (9) Traffic and pedestrian safety and control. C. Except as to those matters specifically regulated by the Public Utilities Commission, the Federal Communications Commission, or other state or federal agency, the City Engineer shall have the authority to coordinate and prescribe conditions for the installation, use, duration and removal of the facilities and other encroachments by the permittee and its assigns. These conditions may include submittal of record drawings, U.S.A."Dig-alert" subscription, joint trench cost sharing, screening of aboveground utility cabinets, coordination of work with other agencies or projects, and full cost reimbursement for reasonable and necessary City inspection services during construction. Additionally, the City Engineer is authorized to require installation to be made underground instead of an aerial placement, when determined to be feasible by the City Engineer and as required by law, and to prohibit or restrict the placement of permanent auxiliary power generators within the right-of-way. The applicant shall be responsible for reviewing city and other public records, and contacting existing City permittees and public utility companies to determine the location of existing facilities that will impact upon or be impacted by the proposed installation, and provide any necessary assurances or provisions regarding non-interference with prior permitted facilities and encroachments. The City reserves the right to require the permittee to pay ;,^_ER costs of hiring an inspector or supervisor to oversee the work and protect the City's interests during facility installation. D. Issuance of a permit does not constitute a representation by the City that subsurface conditions are accurately reflected in the records of the City. Each permittee assumes the risk and responsibility for damage to previously installed permitted facilities. Each permittee shall be responsible for repair or reimbursement for damage to or for relocating previous installed facilities, when caused or necessitated by the installation of its facility. The permittee shall notify the City Engineer and any affected prior permittee(s) when relocation may become necessary. E. Each permit shall include a condition that the permittee shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City from all liability occasioned " s, or caused by the installation or operation of the facility, except that arising from the sole negligence or willful misconduct of the City. F. The City Engineer shall host periodic coordination meetings with potential applicants and current permittees regarding pending applications and proposed construction in the various rights of way and public places. The format of such meetings may be as provided for by existing franchise or license agreements, or as may be determined feasible by the City Engineer. The City Engineer shall not be responsible for obtaining information for any applicant, but shall make existing information available to an applicant for appropriate research and coordination. G. Whenever an exemption or exception from the requirements of this Chapter 13.12 is claimed, by an applicant or permittee under the terms of a franchise, an agreement or scope of regulatory preemption, the burden shall be on the applicant or permittee to establish the 2000 Ordinance 4 Encroachment Permits authority, sco ' e and extent of the exem u tion to th 13.12.070 Resurfacing of streets. A. In cases of major excavation into city streets, particularly where the street has been resurfaced within three years preceding the work, the ermittee may be r . uired by the City En • eer to replace al entire lane of travel rather than to just patch and repair the particular trench. This requirement is imposed in order to maintain the road surface in a smooth, steady state for the benefit of motorists, preserve the structural integrity of the affected surface, and avoid the unnecessary future expenditure of public taxes and monies. B. In situations where several excavators are or will be allowed to separately excavate trenches of minor dimension, which, when accumulated, create a major impact to the road surface, comparable to that described in subsection A, the City Engineer may require each permittee to obligate itself to pay a proportional share for resurfacing of the entire lane of travel, and, where necessary and appropriate, to post a security deposit or surety bond guaranteeing it will participate in or fund the costs of the resurfacing and related work necessary to maintain and preserve the integrity of the right-of-way. C. The provisions of this section shall apply equally to franchisees and other public agencies desiring to excavate in the public right-of-wa in National Ci as s i ecifically . rovided otherwise in the terms of a franchise Determinations made by the City Engineer under sections 13.12.070A and B shall be based on best engineering and management practice. D. Notwithstanding subsection A, permittees who benefit from the facility installation may be required to share prorata in the ongoing costs of repair and street maintenance directly caused by the proportionate impacts of the installation and maintenance of their facility in the right-of-way. 13.12.080 Encroachment permits —Revocation —Penalty for violation of terms. NO CHANGES 13.12.090 Encroachment permits —Fees. NO CHANGES 13.12.100 Nonexclusive use of right-of-way. A. Encroachment permits are non- exclusive. Any permit issued by the City under this chapter which permits the applicant to excavate, construct or remove improvements or facilities, or grade or encroach within any public right-of-way also permit the City to utilize the right-of-way for its own public purposes during the same time period as the applicant's use. The City may extend the time period of the applicant's proposed use of the right-of-way to suit the city's own public purposes. The City engineer may require the permittee to allow others to utilize the excavation for placement of their separately permitted facilities a ss4 ` i upon payment to the permittee of the proportional share of avoided expense together with any additional expense necessitated by such accommodation, provided such accommodation is feasible and does not delay or ad im i act the . ermitt 2000 Ordinance 5 Encroachment Permits B. Permittees shall not interfere with facilities installed under prior permits, unless arrangements satisfactory to the City Engineer and the prior permittee are made to protect or relocate the prior facilities at the expense of the subsequent permittee. Notwithstanding, the City shall have the right to remove, relocate or displace any previously allowed or permitted encroachment without liability to a permittee when necessitated by public emergency or the City's exercise of its police power. C. Permittees who fail to provide accurate record drawings shall be financially liable to the City for the City's construction delay costs directly caused by misidentified facility locations installed by the permittee or its contractors. 13.12.110 Appeal. NO CHANGES 13.12.120 Assignment of encroachment permits or facilities. NO CHANGES 13.12.130 Safeguarding of Proprietorial information. NO CHANGES 13.12.140 Alternative administrative hearing provisions for appeals. NO CHANGES 13.12.150 Violations and enforcement. NO CHANGES 2000 Ordinance Encroachment Permits ORDINANCE NO. 2000 — AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY AMENDING CHAPTER 13.12 OF THE NATIONAL CITY MUNICIPAL CODE, PERTAINING TO ENCROACHMENT PERMITS FOR INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF FACILI'I'mS IN STREETS, RIGHTS -OF -WAY AND OTHER PUBLIC PROPERTY BE IT ORDAINED by the City Council of the City of National City that the National City Municipal Code is amended as follows: Section 1. That Chapter 13.12 of the National City Municipal Code is amended in its entirety to read as follows: ENCROACHMENT PERMITS FOR INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF FACILII'1hS IN STREETS, RIGHTS -OF -WAYS AND OTHER PUBLIC PROPERTY Sections: 13.12.010 Findings, purpose and intent. 13.12.020 Definitions and uses. 13.12.030 Encroachment permits —Required. 13.12.040 Encroachment permits —Bonds and insurance. 13.12.050 Encroachment permits —Application. 13.12.060 Encroachment permits —Authority of City Engineer. 13.12.070 Resurfacing of streets. 13.12.080 Encroachment permits —Revocation —Penalty for violation of terms. 13.12.090 Encroachment permits —Fees. 13.12.100 Nonexclusive use of right-of-way. 13.12.110 Appeal. 13.12.120 Assignment of encroachment permits 13.12.130 Safeguarding of Proprietorial Information. 13.12.140 Alternate administrative hearing procedures for appeals. 13.12.150 Violations and enforcement. 13.12.010 Findings, purpose and intent. A. The City Council finds and determines that the installation, repair, maintenance and removal of private and public facilities in the public streets, rights -of -way and other public property must be regulated in order to protect the public health, safety and welfare and provide for the orderly administration and maintenance of public roadways and other public property for the benefit of the community, while allowing reasonable accommodation and cooperative flexibility for providing necessary utility and other convenience services to the community. It is further the intent of the City Council to require public utility providers, other public and governmental agencies and private parties who are permitted to install facilities in the public streets and rights -of -way to preserve the street surfaces and, when necessary, , contribute proportionately to resurfacing and maintenance as a result of the impact and benefits caused by or obtained from their installations. 2000 Ordinance Encroachment Permits B. It is not the intent of the Council to require applicants and pern ittees to disclose proprietary information or trade secrets applicable to their technology, systems or facilities, except to the extent reasonably necessary to evaluate the installation or operation of the facility in terms of public health and safety. C. Administration of this ordinance shall be under the direction and control of the City Manager, as further delegated to the City Engineer under this chapter. 13.12.020 Definitions and uses. A. "Facility" means and includes, without limitation, any pole, light or signal standard, traffic or irrigation controller, pipe, conduit, cable, fiber optics, manhole, duct, tunnel, trench, utility cabinet or similar appurtenance. B. "Person" means and includes any natural person, corporation, firm, agency, co- partnership or association, and the singular and plural or the masculine or feminine gender. It also includes a public utility or a public or governmental agency. C. "Public right-of-way" means and includes any public street, alley, sidewalk, driveway, curb, pavement, gutter, or parkway. D. "Improvement" means and includes any addition, alteration or modification to an existing facility. E. "Public property" includes land, easements and other facilities owned, leased by or otherwise belonging to the City of National City, other than "public rights -of -way". F. "Applicant" and "permittee" means the person or entity that is to benefit from the facility and its installation, as well as the contractor or entity doing the actual installation. G. "Encroachment" means the installation of a physical object in, on, over, or upon real property. The term shall also include the line of sight aerial passage of a beam of light or laser through the airspace over real property. It shall not include any wireless, microwave or radio transmission over real property. 13.12.030 Encroachment permits —Required. A. Except as provided in Subsection 13.12.030F, it is unlawful for any person to excavate, construct or remove improvements or facilities within, or grade or encroach upon or over, any public right-of-way or public property of the City of National City without a valid encroachment permit issued pursuant to this chapter. B. An encroachment permit shall allow only the designated permittee(s) and their authorized contractors to install, maintain or remove approved facilities within the boundaries and under the terms and conditions specified in the encroachment permit. The term of the permit may be for a specific duration, or unlimited duration conditional, however, upon the removal or relocation of the facility when necessary for reasons of the public health, safety and welfare, or convenience. No person or permittee, including a franchisee or licensee, shall assign or enlarge the scope of an approved encroachment permit to allow another person to install an additional facility within the permitted encroachment without the prior written authorization of the City Engineer or, when applicable, the City Manager or Council, which authorization shall not be unreasonably withheld or denied. C. The City Engineer shall require the benefiting entity or its duly authorized representative, and may also require the installer when necessary to ensure proper project control, to apply for all requisite permits. Financial obligations imposed by this chapter 13.12 shall relate primarily to the responsibility of the permittee who benefits from the installation of the facility. D. As a condition of an encroachment permit, the permittee shall be required to remove or relocate the permitted facility or encroachment at the permittee's sole expense when determined necessary by the City Engineer as an exercise of the city's police power for the 2000 Ordinance 2 Encroachment Permits public health, safety and welfare or convenience. This shall include the right of the City to regrade or realign the streets or to install its own facilities, and require the permittee to remove or relocate its facility at the permittee's expense. A permittee may also be required to pay for the cost of relocating other previously permitted encroachments when necessary to accommodate its facility. E. The permittee shall obtain any business licenses and all other permits or licenses, including construction permits, required by code, statute or regulation pertaining to the installation of the facility, and for complying with all other provisions of law and this Code, including Chapter 6.12 relating to telecommunications, notwithstanding the issuance of an encroachment permit. F. Nothing in this Chapter 13.12 shall prevent excavation for emergency repairs to public utility service connections or other work that is necessary for the immediate protection of life or property, provided a permit is applied for by the end of the third business day following the commencement of work. G. The City Engineer shall have the authority to promulgate rules and regulations necessary to implement this chapter, and to negotiate and issue annual master encroachment permits to repetitive users with due allowance for the requirements of this chapter 13.12. A "repetitive user" shall refer to any public agency, public utility or other entity with a franchise or license from the city that contemplates repetitive facility installations in the public rights of way and public property. 13.12.040 Encroachment permits —Bonds and insurance. Proof of a performance bond and liability insurance shall be posted by the permittee for each individual or master encroachment permit issued to ensure timely completion of work and to cover damages caused by the work to public right-of-way and property. Comprehensive general liability insurance with a minimum of one million dollars combined single limit per occurrence coverage shall be maintained throughout the term of the permit, except that the City Engineer may require a greater amount of insurance when justified by accepted risk management standards. Statutory liability provisions pertaining to permissibly self -insured entities and joint power agreements or similar agreements with the city meeting the requirements of this chapter 13.12 respecting performance and maintenance criteria may satisfy these requirements. 13.12.050 Encroachment permits —Application. Before any encroachment permit may be issued, the applicant must file with the City Engineer a written application on forms provided by the City. The permit shall be subject to all provisions contained and approved within the application, the City of National City Standard Specifications, Regional and City Standard Drawings, Special Provisions, and Design Standards, and such other conditions as may be imposed by the City Engineer based on accepted engineering practice or as shall be necessary to protect the public health, welfare and safety. 13.12.060 Encroachment permits —Authority of City Engineer. A. The City Engineer may issue a permit to encroach upon, within or over the public right-of-way or other public property of the City of National City only if an applicant for such a permit can demonstrate that: (1) There is a compelling need to use the City right-of-way or property for the applicant's proposed use; (2) The issuance of a permit will not be detrimental to the public health, safety and welfare; 2000 Ordinance 3 Encroachment Permits (3) The applicant is capable and will comply with all the terms, conditions, and restrictions that are incorporated in the permit; and (4) The applicant has complied with all applicable state and federal laws, and has obtained other applicable permits and certifications required under state and federal law. (5) The applicant has reviewed city and other public records pertaining to existing and proposed encroachments and coordinated the details of its facility installation with those facilities and permittees. B. Except with respect to proprietorial information regarding the technology of the cable, facility or customer identity or which could adversely affect an applicant's competitive advantage, the City Engineer shall have the authority to require the applicant, as a condition of permit issuance, to disclose information deemed necessary to the City's decision making process and make suitable provisions in a reasonable manner regarding: (1) The applicant's proposed methods of use of any lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the right-of-way, and pertinent technical details regarding the installation, operation and placement of the facility which is necessary to determine the impact upon the public health and safety and the venue of installation; (2) The quantity and dimensions of applicant's proposed installation of lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the right-of-way; (3) The quantity and dimensions of applicant's proposed installation of lines, wires, cables, conduits, or other equipment which will be solely used for the provision of telephone service which is currently certificated by the Public Utilities Commission of the State of California; (4) The specific date(s) applicant proposes to begin using any lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the right-of-way; (5) The location of all proposed or future installations by the applicant and all existing lines, wires, cables, conduits, and other equipment in the pertinent vicinity of the applicant's proposed installation in the City of National City right-of-way; (6) The specific traffic safety and environmental measures applicant proposes to use while applicant is excavating or obstructing any right-of-way; (7) Any limitations of time applicable to the use or removal of the facilities; (8) The coordination of the proposed facility installation with anticipated or existing encroachments and other construction or improvement in the affected venue of installation. (9) Traffic and pedestrian safety and control. C. Except as to those matters specifically regulated by the Public Utilities Commission, the Federal Communications Commission, or other state or federal agency, the City Engineer shall have the authority to coordinate and prescribe conditions for the installation, use, duration and removal of the facilities and other encroachments by the permittee and its assigns. These conditions may include submittal of record drawings, U.S.A. "Dig -alert" subscription, joint trench cost sharing, screening of aboveground utility cabinets, coordination of work with other agencies or projects, and full cost reimbursement for reasonable and necessary City inspection services during construction. Additionally, the City Engineer is authorized to require installation to be made underground instead of an aerial placement, when determined to be feasible by the City Engineer and as required by law, and to prohibit or restrict the placement of permanent auxiliary power generators within the right-of-way. The applicant shall be responsible for reviewing city and other public records, and contacting existing City permittees and public. :utility companies to determine the location of existing facilities that will impact upon or be impacted by the proposed installation, and provide any necessary assurances or provisions 2000 Ordinance 4 Encroachment Permits regarding non-interference with prior permitted facilities and encroachments. The City reserves the right to require the permittee to pay the reasonable costs of hiring an inspector or supervisor to oversee the work and protect the City's interests during facility installation. D. Issuance of a permit does not constitute a representation by the City that subsurface conditions are accurately reflected in the records of the City. Each pennittee assumes the risk and responsibility for damage to previously installed permitted facilities. Each permittee shall be responsible for repair or reimbursement for damage to or for relocating previous installed facilities, when caused or necessitated by the installation of its facility. The permittee shall notify the City Engineer and any affected prior permittee(s) when relocation may become necessary. E. Each permit shall include a condition that the permittee shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City from all liability occasioned from or caused by the installation or operation of the facility, except that arising from the sole negligence or willful misconduct of the City. F. The City Engineer shall host periodic coordination meetings with potential applicants and current permittees regarding pending applications and proposed construction in the various rights of way and public places. The format of such meetings may be as provided for by existing franchise or license agreements, or as may be determined feasible by the City Engineer. The City Engineer shall not be responsible for obtaining information for any applicant, but shall make existing information available to an applicant for appropriate research and coordination. G. Whenever an exemption or exception from the requirements of this Chapter 13.12 is claimed by an applicant or permittee under the terms of a franchise, an agreement or scope of regulatory preemption, the burden shall be on the applicant or permittee to establish the authority, scope and extent of the exemption to the reasonable satisfaction of the City Engineer. The City Engineer shall accept particular provisions from franchises and related agreements that are in substantial conformity with the various requirements of this chapter 13.12 in the administration and issuance of encroachment permits. 13.12.070 Resurfacing of streets. A. In cases of major excavation into city streets, particularly where the street has been resurfaced within three years preceding the work, the permittee may be required by the City Engineer to replace an entire lane of travel when necessitated by the scope of the installation of the facility, rather than to just patch and repair the particular trench. For purposes of this subsection A, major excavation shall be any trench cut greater than four inches (4") in width, or any point of repair that exceeds four feet by four feet (4'x 4'). The dimensions of the lane of travel shall refer to a pavement width of no less than eight feet (8') nor more than twelve feet (12'). The portion to be resurfaced shall not exceed that dimension that will create a smooth interface between the old and new pavement surfaces. This requirement is imposed in order to maintain the road surface in a smooth, steady state for the benefit of motorists, preserve the structural integrity of the affected surface, and avoid the unnecessary future expenditure of public taxes and monies. B. In situations where several excavators are or will be allowed to separately excavate trenches of minor dimension, which, when accumulated, create a major impact to the road surface, comparable to that described in subsection A, the City Engineer may require each permittee to obligate itself to pay a proportional share for resurfacing of the entire lane of travel, and, where necessary and appropriate, to post a security deposit or surety bond guaranteeing it will participate in or fund the costs of the resurfacing and related work necessary to maintain and preserve the integrity of the right-of-way. 2000 Ordinance 5 Encroachment Permits C. The provisions of this section shall apply equally to franchisees and other public and governmental agencies desiring to excavate in the public right-of-way in National City, except as specifically provided otherwise in the terms of a franchise or related agreement pertaining to street maintenance and repair. Determinations made by the City Engineer under sections 13.12.070A and B shall be based on best engineering and management practice. D. Notwithstanding subsection A, permittees who benefit from the facility installation may be required to share prorata in the ongoing costs of repair and street maintenance directly caused by the proportionate impacts of the installation and maintenance of their facility in the right-of-way. 13.12.080 Encroachment permits —Revocation —Penalty for violation of terms. A. The City Engineer is authorized to revoke an encroachment permit upon determining that the permittee has failed to comply with one or more of the material terms, conditions or restrictions incorporated in the permit or has provided materially false or misleading information to the City Engineer regarding the encroachment or its installation. B. Upon the revocation of an encroachment permit, the permittee shall immediately discontinue any work and cease and desist from further encroaching upon the public right-of- way or property of the City of National City. The permittee shall remediate the site to an as -near original condition as shall be feasible under the supervision and direction of the City Engineer in accordance with code and legal requirements in effect at the time of remediation. Installed facilities shall be removed, unless authorized to be disabled and abandoned in place when determined to be feasible by the City Engineer. C. Any permittee who violates any of the terms, conditions or restrictions of an encroachment permit and thereby materially and adversely affects the public health and safety shall be ineligible to receive another encroachment permit from the City Engineer for a period of one (1) year following the date of such determination, unless this restriction is waived by the City Engineer for good cause. 13.12.090 Encroachment permits —Fees. A. Unless otherwise specifically exempted by existing law or prior franchise, license or other contractual agreement, every person shall pay the fee established in the National City Fee Schedule prior to the issuance of an encroachment permit. B. The permit fee for any application which is not defined in the National City Fee Schedule will be determined by the City Engineer based on the following relevant factors: (1) The quantity, nature and impact of the facility proposed to be installed in the right-of-way; (2) The specific date(s) applicant intends to begin using the facility in the right-of-way, and any corresponding impacts to or upon public services; (3) The future cost to the City of any predictable impacts and accelerated degradation of the street surface caused by the proposed excavation or encroachment, as may be determined by reasonably accurate data and methodology for measuring the pavement's structural response to heavy dynamic loads, similar in magnitude and duration to those produced by moving traffic; (4) The actual or reasonably estimated cost to the City of staff time required to ensure the safety of the roadway, the coordination of the application with other applications, and proper restoration of the street surface; 2000 Ordinance 6 Encroachment Permits (5) Whether the timing of the encroachment can be coordinated with an existing or proposed excavation or encroachment in the same location by the City or another applicant without causing unreasonable delay; and (6) Any other expense that is reasonably related to the additional cost that the City may incur as the direct result of the application or as allowed under law. C. In lieu of a fee, or in consideration of special benefits conferred upon the permittee or through a cost sharing joint trench agreement, the City Engineer or City Council, as applicable, may require the permittee to provide a portion of the installed facility or conduit to the City for its future use or allocation, in order to minimize future disruption to the right-of-way. 13.12.100 Nonexclusive use of right-of-way. A. Encroachment permits are non- exclusive. Any permit issued by the City under this chapter which permits the applicant to excavate, construct or remove improvements or facilities, or grade or encroach within any public right-of-way also permit the City to utilize the right -of -way -for its own public purposes during the same time period as the applicant's use. The City may extend the time period of the applicant's proposed use of the right-of-way to suit the city's own public purposes. The City engineer may require the permittee to allow others to utilize the excavation for placement of their separately permitted facilities when justified and necessary, upon payment to the permittee of the proportional share of avoided expense together with any additional expense necessitated by such accommodation, provided such accommodation is feasible and does not delay or adversely impact the permittee. Joint trench agreements under this section shall be required prior to commencement of construction. B. Permittees shall not interfere with facilities installed under prior permits, unless arrangements satisfactory to the City Engineer and the prior permittee are made to protect or relocate the prior facilities at the expense of the subsequent permittee. Notwithstanding, the City shall have the right to remove, relocate or displace any previously allowed or permitted encroachment without liability to a permittee when necessitated by public emergency or the City's exercise of its police power. C. Permittees who fail to provide accurate record drawings shall be financially liable to the City for the City's construction delay costs directly caused by misidentified facility locations installed by the permittee or its contractors. 13.12.110 Appeal. Any person who is aggrieved by the City Engineer's decision with respect to the issuance, denial, or revocation of an encroachment permit or the imposition of a fee or condition under this Chapter may appeal to the City Council within ten (10) days after receiving notification of the City Engineer's decision. A request for appeal must be filed with the City Clerk, and a hearing before the City Council will be scheduled within a reasonable time after the filing of the appeal. 13.12.120 Assignment of encroachment permits or facilities. Assignments of encroachment permits or facilities without authorization of the City are void. Assignment shall not obviate the obligation of the assignor to perform all terms and conditions of the permit and this ordinance, notwithstanding the assignee's assumption of the same. 13.12.130 Safeguarding of Proprietorial information. Applicants subject to this ordinance shall provide all information required by the City, except that which is expressly exempted 'by the terms of section 13.12.060(B)(1). If the Applicant declares any portion of the information to be "proprietorial information", Applicant shall identify the same by notation in 2000 Ordinance 7 Encroachment Permits the applicable applications or questionnaire and provide the information to the City in a separate sealed envelope or container clearly identified as "PROPRIETORIAL INFORMATION", together with information identifying ownership. The City will thereafter either retain that information separately in a secure facility, or will return the material to the Applicant without retention of a copy after having conducted its analysis. Proprietorial information retained by the City will not be released by the City under the Public Records Act (Government Code Sec. 6250, et seq.) to any source without prior notice to the Applicant, except upon receipt of a duly authorized court order. Applicant will be offered the opportunity by the City to intervene and represent the Applicant's interests in protecting said proprietorial information on City's behalf; if the opportunity is declined, then the City shall have no further obligation to protect or defend the non -release of the designated proprietorial information or portions thereof. Any proprietorial information previously returned to an Applicant that was relied upon by the City in framing the terms and conditions of a permit shall be conclusive and binding as to Applicant and non - contestable in any subsequent administrative or judicial proceeding involving the permittee regarding that permit. 13.12.140 Alternative administrative hearing provisions for appeals. Upon the mutual election of the City Manager and the Applicant or Permittee, appeals may be determined by an administrative examiner who shall be a member of the American Arbitration Association or similar body mutually acceptable to both parties, or an Administrative Law Judge assigned by the State of California Office of Administrative Hearings. The formal rules of evidence and procedure shall not be applicable to the proceedings, except that any evidence that is relevant and probative or admissible over objection in a civil proceeding shall be admissible during the hearing. The findings and conclusions of the administrative examiner shall be based on "substantial evidence" and be presented in an administrative record, the results of which shall thereafter constitute the exhaustion of administrative remedy and be subject to judicial review by writ of mandamus under Code of Civil Procedure Section 1094.6. 13.12.150 Violations and enforcement. Violation of Sections 13.12.030 or 13.12.080B is a misdemeanor. Each day a violation exists is a separate violation, and each violation may be charged as a separate offense. Violations may be enforced by civil, criminal or administrative measures, or combination, as provided for in Title 1 of this Code. PASSED and ADOPTED this day of , 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: /44,6,2r Michael R. Dalla, City Clerk George H. Eiser, III City Attorney 2000 Ordinance 8 Encroachment Permits City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT December 12, 2000 MEETING DATE AGE A ITEM NO. 13 ITEM TITLE AN ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING THE SALARIES OF THE MAYOR, THE CITY COUNCIL, AND OF THE CHAIRMAN AND BOARD MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION PREPARED BY George H. Eiser, III EXPLANATION Financial Statement Sufficient funds are available. ATION N/A DEPARTMENT City Attorney Please see attached memo. N/A BOARD / OM iSSI N RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS Limited Below e Proposed Ordinance A-200 (9/80) Account Resolution Noe City of National City Office of the City Attorney 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-4301 George H. Eiser, Ill • City Attorney (619) 336-4220 FAX (619) 336-4327 TDD (619) 336-1615 TO: Mayor and City Council DATE: December 6, 2000 FROM: City Attorney SUBJECT: Adjustments in Compensation for Mayor and City Council and CDC Chairman and Board Members The last salary adjustment for the Mayor and City Council occurred on December 8, 1998, with the enactment of Ordinance No. 98-2152. That ordinance provided that the salaries for the Mayor, City Council, and Chairman and Board Members of the Community Development Commission shall be increased by the same percentages, on the same dates, and subject to the same conditions as the salary increases for Municipal Employees' Association Members. Accordingly, the current base monthly salary of the City Council is $779.76, the monthly salary of the Mayor is $3,645.89, and the monthly salary of the Chairman and Members of the Community Development Commission is $779.76. Pursuant to Government Code Section 36516, the Council may, by ordinance, increase its compensation by 5% per calendar year from the date of the last increase in compensation. Accordingly, the City Council may at this time increase its monthly compensation by 10%, up to $857.74. Pursuant to Government Code Section 36516.1, an elected mayor may be provided with compensation in addition to that which he receives as a councilman, pursuant to an ordinance or by a vote of the electors at a municipal election. There are no limitations imposed on the amount of the mayor's compensation. If the Mayor's compensation were increased by 10% as in the case of the City Council, the Mayor's monthly salary would be $4,010.48. Government Code Section 36516.5 provides that a change in compensation does not apply to a councilman during his term in office. However, compensation for all members of the City Council may be adjusted whenever one or more members become eligible for an increase by virtue of beginning a new term of office. As a result, adjustments to compensation of Council members have been geared to elections at which members begin a new term in office. ® Recycled Paper Adjustments in Compensation December 6, 2000 Page Two Health and Safety Code Section 34130 (part of the Community Redevelopment Law) states that the City Council may provide for the compensation of members of the Community Development Commission. There are no limits stated with respect to the amount of compensation, or with respect to the timing of any adjustments in compensation. Past practice has been for the Chair and Members of the Community Development Commission to receive the same compensation as the City Council, and for adjustments to be made at the same time as adjustments in City Council compensation. Ordinance No. 91-2000 provides that "the salary for the Chairman and each member shall hereafter be the same as that paid each member of the City Council of the City of National City." Accordingly, the compensation for the Chairman and members of the CDC, if modified, would be set at $857.74. If the City Council desires to adjust the compensation of the Mayor, City Council and CDC Chairman and Board Members, the attached ordinance should be approved for introduction. GEORGE H. EISER, III City Attorney GHE/gmo cc: City Manager Executive Director, CDC ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY ESTABLISHING THE SALARIES OF THE MAYOR, THE CITY COUNCIL, AND OF THE CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION BE IT ORDAINED by the City Council of the City of National City as follows: Section 1. That the base monthly compensation for the City Council is hereby fixed at Eight Hundred Fifty -Seven and 74/100d" Dollars ($857.74) per month, pursuant to the provisions of Sections 36516 and 36516.5 of the California Government Code. Section 2. That the base monthly salary of the Mayor is hereby fixed at Four Thousand Ten and 48/100d" Dollars ($4,010.48) per month, pursuant to the provisions of Section 36516.1 of the Government Code. Section 3. That the base monthly salary for the Chairman and each member of the Community Development Commission is fixed at Eight Hundred Fifty -Seven and 74/100d" Dollars ($857.74) per month, pursuant to the provisions of Section 34130 of the Health and Safety Code. PASSED and ADOPTED this day of December, 2000. George H. Waters, Mayor AUEST: Michael R. Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: City Attorney DEC-08-2000 09:53 SDG&E 619 654 6301 P.02 President Loretta Lynch California Public Utilities Commission 505 Van Ness Boulevard San Francisco, CA 94102 WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS 12/12/00 ITEM #14 Dear President Lynch: The National City City Council would like to express our support for the Valley Rainbow Interconnect transmission line currently proposed for our region. The additional capacity this project will provide is critical to meet the region's anticipated electricity demand in 2004. As you are aware, the dramatic increases in electricity prices during this past year have caused residents and businesses in National City, as well as throughout San Diego County, to suffer tremendous hardship. While we recognize that currently rates are capped for small customers, even that rate is too high. More importantly, however, we are very concerned with what awaits us in 2003 when the clock on these caps runs out. While we understand that the exorbitant rates we paid this year are due to a variety of factors, a lack of sufficient electricity supply to meet our region's demand is a central component. Clearly, we are in need of greater supply to not only accommodate current demand, but that which is anticipated to develop in the coming years. Without access to additional supply, San Diego County will exceed its delivery capability in the summer of 2004. The Valley Rainbow Interconnect is one of the vital elements of our region's electric facility needs which will enable SDG&E to access energy supply from other areas of the Western United States, providing 1000 megawatts of energy, enough to service 300,000 single family homes. This is a critical step toward ensuring that we have sufficient supply to meet demand, and to therefore keep downward pressure on prices. Our citizens and businesses need this project. Sincerely, George Waters, Mayor Mitch Beauchamp, Councilmember Nick Inzunza, Councilmember Ron Morrison, Councilmember Fred Soto, Councihnember TOTAL P.02 Vfl«f4 flflI0fl001 IOTfBC000fCT PROJECT OVERVIEW San Diego Gas & Electric is proposing to build a 500,000-volt transmission line that would connect Southern California Edison's Valley substation near Romoland with a future substation to be located in Rainbow, just south of the Riverside -San Diego county line. The Valley Rainbow Interconnect, when completed, would increase the reliability of electric supply for the entire region and bring a new source of energy to San Diego County. The new transmission line will provide a second interconnection between SDG&E's and SCE's transmission systems, the other is at the San Onofre substation near San Clemente. Because electricity can flow either way along the lines, both Riverside and San Diego counties will benefit from the additional reliability of the new line. Furthermore„ the Valley Rainbow Interconnect will increase the amount of energy that can be supplied to San Diego County from other areas of the Western United States. The project has been rated at 1000 megawatts, enough energy to serve the needs of 300,000 single-family homes. It is estimated that San Diego will exceed its reliable delivery capability in the summer of 2004 if the transmission line is not constructed. The California Independent System Operator is the primary agency responsible for transmission and generation planning for the state. The CAISO has determined that the Valley Rainbow Interconnect is the best alternative to meet the energy delivery needs for the region. SDG&E has been granted permission to proceed with the licensing of the transmission line. There are other government entities that must also approve the proposed project. The California Public Utilities Commission and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission will review and must approve the Valley Rainbow Interconnect before it can be built. It is anticipated that the approval process will continue through 2001 and be completed in early 2002. Numerous transmission corridors are being considered. Three primary routes have been identified with alternatives to each of them. The communities, government officials, businesses and other interested parties will have the opportunity to provide their comments on the possible routes. Public meetings will take place at various stages of the approval process. All public input will be included in the application for the final route submitted to the CPUC later this year. The schedule for the Valley Rainbow Interconnect is to identify the preferred route and submit a formal application to the CPUC in December 2000. The CPUC and other governmental agencies would conduct an in-depth review of the needs, benefits, financial impacts and affect on the environment before rendering their decisions. Upon approval by the CPUC, FERC and other agencies, SDG&E expects to begin construction in the spring of 2002. Construction of the transmission line will take approximately 18 to 24 months with completion scheduled for the spring of 2004. San Diego Gas & Electric • Post Office Box 1881 • Temecula, California 92593-1881 • 800.456.6138 VflllfV fl0I01B011J IBTfBC000[CT COMMUNITY BENEFITS The Valley Rainbow Interconnect will bring direct benefits to the regions of San Diego and Southwest Riverside counties. In addition, San Diego Gas & Electric and its employees are dedicated to improving the quality of life in the areas in which they live and conduct business. Benefits from the Valley Rainbow Interconnect include: ➢ Increased reliability of electric supply in San Diego and Riverside counties by providing an additional interconnection between SDG&E and Southern California Edison ➢ Additional source of electricity to ensure adequate supplies to San Diego and Southern Orange counties for residents and businesses. This benefit is shared by all Riverside County residents who work in San Diego County, as well as Riverside businesses that rely on San Diego County companies ➢ Improved access to competitively priced energy from the Western United States and Mexico for the entire region ➢ Potential for environmental preservation and additional open space along the transmission corridors ➢ Additional tax revenues to Riverside County from the value of the proposed transmission line In addition to the direct benefits of the Valley Rainbow Interconnect, it is anticipated that SDG&E will become an integral part of the community of Southwest Riverside County. The company has leased and will move into its Temecula office in September. Two full- time employees are working with the community and government officials to be sure that all concerns are addressed and that SDG&E continues its rich history of investing in the communities where it does business. SDG&E and its sister utility Southern California Gas Company have many employees who live in Southwest Riverside County. They have been a part of the community for many years and will continue to work towards improving the quality of life in their personal and professional endeavors. San Diego Gas & Electric • Post Office Box 1881 • Temecula, California 92593-1881 •800.456.6138 VP[LEY Bfl10fl001 IOTfBCOIIOfCT ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS San Diego Gas & Electric will consider, minimize and mitigate any impacts to the environment and communities caused by the Valley Rainbow Interconnect. SDG&E has an excellent record of being sensitive to the environment where it conducts business. SDG&E and its 3,500 employees who live in Southern California are very concerned about the environmental impacts on their neighborhoods. SDG&E works closely with the agencies and organizations that have responsibility for assessing environmental impacts to comply with all laws and regulations. The California Public Utilities Commission will be the lead agency responsible for ensuring that the Valley Rainbow Interconnection complies will all aspects of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Extensive review and studies will be conducted to assess and scrutinize every element of the project's impacts on the environment and communities. Numerous other agencies, interested parties and individuals will participate in the environmental assessment of the Valley Rainbow Interconnect. Local, state and federal government will conduct studies to determine if the project has a detrimental impact and what mitigation is appropriate. Individuals will have the opportunity to be involved with the process as well through public meetings and written correspondence. SDG&E is already working with the County of Riverside to determine what positive benefits the proposed transmission line could bring to the region. Coordination with the Riverside County Integration Plan will occur to assess if the line can assist in developing utility corridors and linkages between environmentally sensitive areas. Furthermore, the potential for open space uses that improve the quality of life for the affected neighborhoods will be analyzed. During the next year, the CEQA process will review issues including habitant and endangered species, cultural resources, visual, land use, historical, erosion control, noise, air quality, safety and others. SDG&E will work with the Southwest Riverside County neighborhoods and businesses, environmental community and government regulators to address all environmental concerns and to be sure the Valley Rainbow Interconnect benefits the region. 9 San Diego Gas & Electric • Post Office Box 1881 • Temecula, California 92593-1881 • 800.456.6138 VflLLfY flflI0fl011 IOTfRC000fCT FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS QUESTION: What is the Valley Rainbow Interconnect? ANSWER: The Valley Rainbow Interconnect is a proposed 500,000-volt transmission line that would connect Southern California Edison's Valley substation near Romoland to a new substation near Rainbow to be constructed by San Diego Gas & Electric approximately 25 miles to the south, just across the county line. QUESTION: Why does SDG&E want to build a new transmission line? ANSWER: SDG&E has proposed the project to provide a reliable source of energy for Riverside, San Diego and Southern Orange counties, and to meet the growing demand for electricity in its service territory. The line will also increase capacity and access to competitively priced energy. QUESTION: Where will the transmission line be located? ANSWER: Valley Rainbow Interconnect will be located in Southwest Riverside County, except for a few miles in San Diego County. The exact route of the line has not been determined. Its location will be the result of publicand government, as well as several environmental considerations. QUESTION: Do other agencies agree the transmission line is needed? ANSWER: The California Independent System Operator (CAISO) has determined that the Valley Rainbow Interconnect is the best alternative to meet the needs of SDG&E's growing electricity demands. The CAISO was established through deregulation legislation passed in 1996 and is the primary agency responsible for transmission and generation planning for California. Southern California Edison Company also recognizes the need for the new transmission line that will benefit the entire region. QUESTION: How does the project benefit Riverside County? ANSWER: The Valley Rainbow Interconnect will increase the reliability of electric transmission for Riverside County in addition to San Diego and Orange counties. The line will result in a second connection between SDG&E and SCE, and because electricity will flow both directions on the power lines, Riverside will have another source of energy if needed. Furthermore, the project may positively impact the environment and quality of life for Southwest Riverside County. QUESTION: Who will approve the project? ANSWER: The California Public Utilities Commission and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission are the two primary agencies that must approve the Valley Rainbow Interconnect. There will be many other local, state and federal agencies that will participate in the approval process. QUESTION: How can the general public have their concerns addressed? ANSWER: There will be many public meetings on the proposed project over the next two years. Public meetings organized by SDG&E to discuss the routing will take place in August and September 2000. The CPUC will conductformal public meetings later in the year, then again throughout the next 18 months. Written communications can be directed to SDG&E, Riverside and San Diego counties, CPUC, FERC and the CAISO — addresses are listed below. There will be many opportunities to participate in the approval process — contact Paul O'Neal at 800-456-6138. QUESTIONS: What is the project schedule? ANSWER: The CAISO unanimously approved SDG&E to proceed with the licensing of the Valley Rainbow Interconnect in May 2000. Public information meetings will continue through September 2000 with a preferred route submitted to the CPUC in December 2000. During 2001 and the first half of 2002, the CPUC, FERC and other agencies will conduct studies and reviews of the project to assess its need, benefits and impacts. If approved, construction is scheduled to begin in 2002 with the line becoming operational in Spring 2004. QUESTION: What will the power line look like when it is completed? ANSWER: The Valley Rainbow Interconnect will likely utilize two styles of towers and poles. Depending on their location, the structures will be either steel lattice towers or single pole construction. The typical height will range from approximately 150 feet to 190 feet tall and be spaced from 1000 to 1500 feet apart. The engineering has not been completed and the terrain and other conditions will dictate the final construction. QUESTION: What will be the impact on the environment from the project? ANSWER: SDG&E has an excellent reputation of being sensitive to the environment and communities where it conducts business. There will be an extensive environmental review to ensure that all laws and restrictions to protect the environment are addressed. In addition, any impacts that may result from the construction and operation of the project will be mitigated. QUESTION: Are there safety concerns from the power line? ANSWER: SDG&E will ensure that construction is conducted in the safest manner as possible. Procedures have been established and tested to be sure the facilities are able to withstand any physical elements possible in the region, including high winds and earthquakes. Right-of-way considerations will adequately address citizen concerns from exposure to electric and magnetic fields. si,G .il■llll ` A fr5 Sempra Energy company About Electric and Magnetic Fields (EMF) What is EMF? Electric and magnetic fields (EMF) are invisible lines of force that are present wherever electricity flows — around appliances and power lines, and in offices, schools and homes. Electric fields are created by voltage and shielded by most materials, such as lead, soil and concrete. Magnetic fields are created by current and are not shielded by most materials. Both electric and magnetic field strengths diminish with distance. These fields are low energy, extremely low frequency fields. They are not to be confused with high energy or ionizing radiation such as x-rays and gamma rays. Why is EMF a Concern? In recent years, concerns have been raised about the possible link of exposure to EMF and adverse health conditions. Some EMF studies have reported a weak association between estimates of exposure to magnetic fields and certain types of cancer. However, other studies have reported no effects. Laboratory experiments have shown that exposure levels typically well above those normally found in residences can produce chat K,Ca in cells, but there is We or no evidence that these changes constitute a health risk. What Conclusions Have the Experts Drawn? Hundreds of studies on this subject have been conducted throughout the world, with results that are often hard to interpret and sometimes conflicting. A number of internationally recognized scientific organizations and independent regulatory advisory groups have conducted scientific reviews of the EMF research literature.' Without exception, these major reviews have reported that the body of data, as large as it is, does not demonstrate that exposure to power -frequency magnetic fields causes cancer or other health risks, although the possibility cannot be dismissed. Most reviews recommend further research, and, appropriately, research is ongoing worldwide. I CPUC/CDHS, 1989; IRPA/INIRC, 1990; ACGIH, 1991; EPA, 1990; EPA-SAB, 1992; CIRRPC, 1991; EMHEC, 1992; NRPB, 1992; Illinois, 1992; Colorado, 1992; Case, 1992; ORAU, 1992, 1993; INSERM 1993; Danish Ministry of Health, 1993; Universities Consortium on Electromagnetic Fields, Connecticut (February 1994); National Radiological Protection Board, United Kingdom (April 1994); American Medical Association (January 1995); American Physical Society (May 1995); American Cancer Society (January 1996); Virginia Department of Health (February 1996); National Academy of Sciences (January, 1997); NIEHS Director's Report to Congress (June, 1999). Have State or Federal Exposure Standards Been Established? There are no California or Federal standards regulating environmental levels of magnetic field exposure. The panels of experts charged with recommending exposure limits for electric and/or magnetic fields have concluded that no meaningful experimental data exists on which to base standards or limits to which the public is exposed. What is SDG&E Doing? San Diego Gas & Electric is committed to providing safe, reliable and environmentally sound gas and electric service for its customers, as well as a safe work place for its employees. We share the concerns of our customers and employees over the possibility that electric and/or magnetic fields (EMF) might adversely affect health. Until research and the scientific community can provide greater direction, SDG&E will continue our efforts to inform the public and support on -going research through the following measures: • Maintaining an EMF Center staffed with informed representatives available to talk with customers and employees about EMF issues. • Conducting free home and office magnetic field measurements for customers requesting this service. • Providing objective EMF health literature to the public, and notifying customers of research milestones as this information becomes available. • Educating employees on EMF issues. • Supporting, funding and monitoring EMF research. • Implementing low-cost and no -cost measurements, where appropriate, to reduce EMF associated with new construction projects. • Participating in communication forums and regulatory proceedings to remain current on all EMF related issues. For More Information For more information on EMF, or to request a free home or office measurement of magnetic fields, please contact SDG&E at 1-800-411-SDGE (7343) or by e-mail at info a sdge.com. Escondido San Diego San County Diego Existing 230 kV Line . r Pechanga Indian Reservation To Escondido Substation City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT EETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO, ITEM TITLE War Memorial Bowl in Kimball Park PREPARED BY Burton Myers DEPARTMENT Public Works EXPLANATION The City Manager's Office received the attached letter from Alfonso Hernandez requesting that the City Council discuss the new signage for the War Memorial Bowl which is located in Kimball Park. Mr. Hernandez's concerns involve a free standing monument sign which is located in front of the War Memorial Bowl. The sign reads the following: One Side — Other Side - KIMBALL PARK BOWL AMPHITHEATER VETERANS WAR MEMORIAL VETERANS WAR MEMORIAL Mr. Hernandez spent considerable time researching the Public Records and found that the official name for the Bowl is the WAR MEMORIAL BOWL. Mr. Hernandez also had the understanding that the amphitheater facade held a plaque that reflected all of the National City residents whose lives were taken during action in World War II and the names of all National City residents that served during World War II. As a part of the bowl restoration project, two plaques were removed and refurbished. However, there were no names listed on either of these plaques. STAFF RECOMMENDATI This item is for discussion and taff is requestin• direction from BOARD I COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A City Council. ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below) Resolution No, Letter from Alfonso Hernandez, dated November 22, 2000 A-200 (9/8C) t'!TY MAR'• Tom McCabe City Manager City of National City National City, CA 91950 Dear Mr. McCabe: OO NOV 21 p: I ? 21 RECEIv Cu v OF HATIC AL CITY National City, CA November 22, 2000 I hereby respectfully request that the following item be brought forth on the agenda for discussion and appropriate action at the next City Council meeting. I am aware that the renovation of the amphitheater in Kimball Park is in progress, and a ceremony will be held on December 7, 2000, to celebrate the completion of this work, including the installation of a new plaque listing the names of National City residents killed in action during the Korean War and Vietnam Conflict. The renovation work includes a new signage that refers to the amphitheater as the "KIMBALL MEMORIAL BOWL." Therefore, I want to call the attention to the City Council that, in approving this name for the Amphitheater in Kimball Park, they in effect changed the historical record of the dedicated name of it, which is the "WAR MEMORIAL BOWL." It is understood that no one knew the correct name, but with just a little research of the historical record, the proper and correct name of the amphitheater is the "WAR MEMORIAL BOWL" in memory of the National City residents killed in action during World War II and also in memory of ALL National City residents that served during World War II (in excess of approximately 1700). The information contained in the enclosures clarifies and justifies the correct name. It is to be noted that the Honorable Judge Ira Harbison was chairman of the War Memorial Committee and that the General Public raised over $15,000, including over $1,000 from a paper drive, to assist with the total cost of the original construction project - Total $29,777.00. Due to construction delays, the proposed date for its dedication was finally set for November 11, 1947, ARMISTICE DAY (now Veteran's Day.) Therefore, since the historical records indicate the correct name of the amphitheater, and the previous participation by the General Public, the General Public should have been advised of the name change and given an opportunity for their input before approving the plans. There are still quite a few veterans and residents of that era residing in National City that participated in the War Memorial Bowl Project. In addition, it is understood that, at one time, the amphitheater facade held a plaque that reflected all the names of the National City residents whose lives were taken during action in World War II and the names of all National City residents that served during World War II. What ever happened to those plaques? I think that, by changing the name of the amphitheater, the City Council has done a great ;injustice to the memory of the National City residents killed in action during World War II, to the National City residents (veterans of World War II), to the survivors of those veterans who have since passed on, and to National City residents of that era who still reside in National City. I therefore respectfully request that the City Council of National City take the necessary and appropriate action, or actions, to rectify this great injustice, especially since National City leaders and residents of that era took the action to honor their fellow residents who honorably served during World War II and to those whose lives were taken defending our nation and preserving World Freedom. In addition, whatever action is taken, it is requested that the names of National City residents killed in action during World War II are once again included on a plaque on the War Memorial Bowl in Kimball Park. Enclosures: (1) Chronological listing of National Bowl items The National City News Article The National City News Article The National City News Article The National City News Article The National City News Article The National City News Article The National City News Article The National City News Article (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) Sincerely, a/ Alfonso Hernandez (619) 4080 7 City, City Council minutes on War Memorial of April 25, 1947 of April 25, 1947 of April 25, 1947 of April 25, 1947 of April25, 1947 of April25, 1947 of April 25, 1947 of April25, 1947 cc: Deborah Ensor, San Diego Union Tribune, 678 - 3' Avenue, Chula Vista, CA 91910 Chula Vista Star News, 321 "E" Street, Chula Vista, CA KNSD - Channel 39, 8330 Engineer Road, San Diego KGTV - Channel 10, 4600 Airway, San Diego XETV - Fox Channel 6, 8253 Ronson Road, San Diego KUSI - TV Channel 51, 4575 Viewridge Avenue, San Diego KFMB - TV Channel 8, 7677 Engineer Road, San Diego L'Ai(LCI) CHRONOLOGICAL LISTING National City, City Council Meeting minutes on War Memorial Bowl items Page 1014 of 8/6/46 War Memorial Committee requests City Council to employ an architect Page 1124 of 1/21/47 Report from Memorial Bowl Committee Page 1124 of 1/21/47 - Resolution 4298 was read R. A. Anderson selected as architect Page 1190 of 5/6/47 - Resolution 4381 Accepts plans and specs for Memorial Bowl Page 1204 of 5/27/47 - Bids on Memorial Bowl Resolution 4396 - Bid of H. H. Johnson ($29,777.00) accepted to construct War Memorial Bowl Page 1217 of 6/17/47 Warrant to pay $31.88 from War Memorial Fund vc.t. (2) IS City. Gear. SUBSCRIPTIONS IL-CiTY-WAR- •TO END -TODAY 3fiy $15,000 MayBe Turned for CODstruction of to Honor War Helves the personal euhOerip.tion drive for e National City War Memorial funII final meeting of the committee at • • stood at $14,408I1, a W. Vansant, ad tresieuier of the committee, re - A small additional met - *Mutton will result from LhD '.tett. pow *savage Wire. Judge Harbison chairman of the committee, en flood tednY ovettrt [rehab* h.e.. the iaet entw'W-- tuddY !or thmig Monk who went te,.tmte WADI lltinerinif MOM)/ who were to service during the teat War to reistribUte to the building cl the menserial. e alto inked that all out,. iMintidinf nlechboiloepald to the entire fund ;mild be turned osier to tOo, en, ter colistriietion of the hew'. Ram for the lammireal bowl MU be Promoted to the tee tonight for Must +appro.-al. Rani drawn up by the archi- tect call to the magnets of in rot me bowl In the 12ih street and D avenue corner of Mr city Larit'llie bawl Mead be %Pei, rot Obt4Ocor .1 tannic and would" Wet National City a Mice fir seheisa. veterans organisations and other =Whine te gement progrante. And *Med et en Ideal place to many. it the Wage of thoidou-4 Srt ,71.1htise, Yrd4ordatr. %Sopron! of the•rt •chnects piens tonight the inn* nifttot ieowewotodto Dement thy — to thie daynscal "ftsoldny 41.'34'34-3W icenewwalt I • 14stest PublitatIons... Back • hswei Ma are Marie thusissm nonis of int tar. ie. Aerie to ed-leiter auencest. be play* *MM. dike. mid at Cl Park breindon 04. ars 1gS . b Merit lia the -lot asebobit l'Awe the Meese of "eletwa -••• 4-dif I ISTABCrsti4* BEft 21i, • oniitirkiiirri MIIWSPAPIR NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA", FRIDAY; APIilL iS, 1947 Senate Committee ApProvesildeland_ Transfer to Oty lie state abereval of the deeding Of tidelmodg on the bay front between Notional city nod Chub e Meta to the two di** env taken MD week when the senats govesnosental and efficiency committee Bare tin bill a "do pass" gecoMmen- Matto& sascroblynam from thia dletrict, told the bill had treen approved by the souneottes 0.1 Tmeslaie and sant to the nate sena* for OPPreintl. No opposition to the Measure developed In. Me assemblir and the nate Mode comosandeo /us Veneered the rnewsUrier Pollorar- ble 2wwmtio by the *elate the nett step la the idipshog of the. bill lay °meow Warren. Stiti-amintee Red- 8, Kraft termed Meyer (11).bert E. RDA and ether members of a Pentland Cite delegation when Shey were SieTamegeto. that he would work for the passage of the measure when It came before the lost!. City Holds:Own hi Traffic Safety Contest Alterirahant the honored mot of ftrot Pima hi the latee-CID Trial* sarety contest. Lefts !nee, National Cit unfortunately dropped to second place UM week due M. the':In. Niles cif two persona. one la Na C47 and the ethos In Chula WM. The, am, 'eowrier. stride Coronado great deal V Wimp.- Mion M this carepaion and hire Nomahniel cm:eaten*. up* the *3* *r the 40: 4404 SIW 0,1Iew Tne eau iiii;se.coeista :wear hallembnie data- ed the cootalstr . W1th.twines reagisiSLK 10 11.6a bee 12.1e1 neither deept nt -Peak the National. CUT Nee 46' r*r ***?•*°°114 Ito Library arrethe logo .'"e3=3; "lthilw 23 'C'Vett hiri hat top /Iota rstriela. excellent en3°1.'4 "24k2"-4 gin Nano remains to. fourth h°0 st ter "' eeleft molt 3-k alacamath-i-disatissiod ni- Dam- m meg sta • . e inuthepUree aroma- new soliinoee of blogiaphy„ trivia bile ,, and phimeoplm. Leaven& Deemer Mid the ..y,...._,_ Cup; Cloddia. !Moineone to Laic; ww•''''-!7 Paeans, langraficent Barba; J'ad- rd. war; icy, Pn.14.-trore be Agreed• Sense s of re. Vermilion: lanklater, abode.,TheDin ( miy1 ai a !adz: Deferent,: Amseen_Daimee- r$' l'•it.-_Yratwr ofW213:-Ilorawsl, Di-2r tireet - Oat& Ora!, oadatur icensod, Mire In Double Reassure: Atemirt. Ben. sm. m- ons, he ely almmee it sow . • Bersight from Boot NW Rine: Mend and Anna; Ems. Mary Hotemo. OcintlemanD Aareelacra. Non.Plettses ()edam, Free Lance Photeerts, Peers Cities of Arnartra: re than• tiOnettinn. Home Guidance: Ool- didtm„. dia, How to Buy Inmranse: „y„.. demon, Joan of Lorraine; Loeb. Better photographic Erniane. that, Mensort_of, Certain Persons: Rarebit& Cats, -tsni mute.* *av- . Zmakares les during the peat 'rook. .Preasent standLna, of oltlos on: Conmastp. flint NotIonal City. second. then In Wm. Sin Diego. Occanatide. QM* Vista, Escon- dido and DI Cajon. , -... ,.. , • * ,,. "9 re wo a fraXigi wee -Pi...* a ., - l's*.eseoutlee .411011'rel 1, /.. IV ' slot" it :.:**s," ..L.,. • ri.... mitts= IWidde-144- asst. .41b-sosesac shew daU•seat,. Cite'. newest eroded let' loll sefirtaittee, the iieti-T-a istbsehieent to be met We tioolne. Maria preserat dam: b.rk the sais-r-fled tost..!4ifte -taw 7,.14111; litaitestribtoeci thrisaibent • the country.' , ' ' DISTRIBUTION TO START,THIS WEEK ON ATTACHMENT MANUFACTURED HERE awl"of ; National Me maoodd,d.ya4 laredbbt began thba sreek by the Western *Vim and Diabilyeling compeso wkdch to sots dis- tributor for the gaft-T-ReSt. are: Akan/num lately Ittaehroont for - - The Safe-T-11Hk nude to ord a hot Men bib as a, safety pre- caution !sesame burning Moth* aid Ironing beard cover*, be menu. o factored by the etaspsod M. lunging company et lit factory 04 siss- Cleveland avenue.," ',- John J. Wade. eu erot!wr, WillIsto I Wade and 4..- wiaktiaaaansa have orendised the ;Western Dales and Dtairlbuting company to handle the wallet of the Safe-T-Ibeet national*. 2324121Noweis0' Isisinifsegginag was' formed by flee 04,l1•CLOT, reported ; Partner They yy,.. T. City Sales Tax Brings $12,000 • In First Quarter !WA 'smartee reenme enk the one-lielf s .cent.VriaDo, asieneSted-le-AilW lag' Dian 012.200.. C. W. 'Vesssant. chi tve • • ) ,on. /MOM, Stable, Olen M. Nefs Actual - returns were isishee then weer min:hated when the Peale of a nales lax en disc-m- .14 _last _MIL Mat -Moo. ally ofliciala thought the annual m- orn would be around V0.062. There are still.. few bustmence who are delinquent garment mid. When all returns are hi the toeil may Fail the $11,000 mark. NATIONAIAITYLFOUNDERS-- HAD IMAGINATION TO SEE POSSIBILITIES OF GROWTH Chrtstin-` an Installed as President, Becord*f Directors Introduced at Anntial_Charnber of Commerce Dinner Among the mit who built National City there were some with. great. imagination, Edmund T. Price, pret.i- -d*/*tr-94-00-8410-PietrO.4.mherrceerntaimercu--txteirmarm- rd of..A.h.,iikcaLchanabes1h the_annuaL.dinnex Hew .0sdies, Headhunt: night. &We Achisins. . -.The klee .ol-the„sauseassuoial, woo loonceived by Shispoon when- hla wife asked Mae to darts, smog way , to, keep from burning her Menhir. booed. John Wade and. hIt parta.eis became intereated In it 'while they were working **h. Nielson at the Naval eleetrotslcsi - The ocar-prodoct ortil lir SOWs castrated at the Axe Retrigara- UM, dolts on SatunDef Maiming at am, an Invitation for the public to the amend orbital* Bote-T.Feest 1.,* simple me whet joss on in the ertiPP, Dr. (Moms 00. Macho attachment which can be Ofbilbt- hop halls throughout the mitten Monter of the runt* cd on any Inning board nod and to blame more interested - • - - can be removed by hand if thlt Mob/mesa confronting the - board It to be folded imny. 'whoop. of tarl Doreen's Beou The distributing company also intenda to distribute ceramic pro- duct& of the Diego nom, William Simpson and_Thog- . Shop Redecort Permits Issued For Six Homes Education Week. Obserrain-A11----- Son* Bay 'Schools III the &bah" Say awe thles Week are comtiletina • Mom for the ObaersonM atheriesa Edue0U00 weer. April,2* to May 4. fivemrafter Linton high *shoot, dip Pryor!! As preen -am ors Of Judgi r:4"42 aith '",,,„„y„".64rts,4v"u1.hrp,""4.4,l core. -.)4,h,31.?rentic, tidePalan4do6f. tenth th Pnd 0 ripodi or. Invited ter"4422,a2T"tritiadn' ceders by the. Mali mehoor cadet Mpg. The ithrtleal milmattelt aw111 pp5 Oil a detroon,rialtrat bitipa) sum,kr *31.""mpez"nmsdiiiitixr"th"',ho ylrWrts'Fli! will 'Peak be,' mers*.sei 0 AfterIcen dernocragy. hIg4Iaehmieltha. Nallettirae*Art, OCI.LY'Sprogusi"ol*. IginetPal, extended an ineiseee la ill perenta and their Mends to attend sn-opentruedie"ar!ne ;eel:KW-on -Ttresday,.-norti-m. at 11. The elementary schooli In the city will be holding enen hen.. all week 62.r Parent* sod trivial to aloft and 'am education In' so- Irern-..leii Amt.! - The som hs' Softball Tee Managers A464,4e). Seat nanneera WI *Demi the rowan bold weal Aire 34._1:as ithbibkellifC101 01010111 be'Pk _.14 Item! Ctly °MUD he bet MU At the litieland dzhool * P.F.A. Local .._I 0001 saaeUris is eons *eel one stem teas Week preserneli a Venal Host, _to , pat AM.41e4'n !d"lei' " Pre- Cruise tn'tfli Highland. although not Mbuided. Tht... Alco on the 14.4..0 liregegea at - - . as port erth• Edeboafletn Yeeeli... lob' le the featly* oltbetwe*V...*,_13 Line, .,*.......y344"/ ..,34,,,,3 /4 it, 116Ki. 1940113% l'*"..1 ',. .0 ',°°. ' ...°,44‘.,..„'-' erpliell eager bosth athlete the •itimioula 'Mimi*" aii„eli sigew., April -111... d prepirest le.treeleit of 2.312-3wwlMi creoo. - nadc.pi,* Pi Itralthireat Miner high ichaq („„ci IA ..}.0.,,in . W 1 WII hilid open ham* ".WeWl'll'3' Plillhne. *eel „dub I do, h., Ad; tlywesss and tried0. wy amea speech host of the South. By are* to dale t„ wittiaw yww,s one stapes, Per the ise.tud• • ‘4..1, . t. oserratn teedasina tee st••• OttItl The wiener sod and the -echosl diedrItrs h°11 joust nad Diego i Etr•-• d10D040,'!dtk ° 1052 .4 t-33 POOP ^singrifia fee *hoof ' and, refi4.hi01igli31.4 .t.t. tpat.„.. to tool', -th, Wet** fogginess the Mtelw,t will represent Vila c The San Vddro rlimignimf onelennt con,ention school Mil Otay 5011001 Oil altiO hold *Pen houge Vilelem the week • 1:rear Mob aw da_t;:u ter Meetlorin'the form Mocha Oreertin ahave beepplan.ere sesrde ' pooch and Emery schOMAI ins eutedlor Weasel fled toe the" ehaervince Of the 00411, Amerktan Edtmatiell Week h!,-) been net vide te itins and .othee Proona wrier isee inter - stated in the education of Dame erased., -an --ettoortudIfi. to ••d4 leondutreste.s staffs hose Insued •wiMtg,In• Winn- TenittinewwWid and in the Mouth Bay MMusil400 district" Irrilehringindeo 'TOMO- OTY RE AS PAYI CONDEM Monity-B Took Oir thc courtesy of WI, Of ct,wi• viols. apeechel were record played bark to thip 10 hog ao opporeematy _ pg-Fleed vette speakers of the Doreen', Beisetty fg NatIornt. awnue. has Woup of. :Venom) houses who Mos Permits were Dined by James thither redwawoung. A. Bird. City kulldlias mimetic: 1,...l31-1,Dercen Lane g,f ed..slx_ner had at Cerretth inr wassukuictsesksat-i roungetera are never tbo vOttnit Schafsr at 204.01 .1, blue ecillng. Nr.se Cl Tragedy Averted In Accidental Poisoning E.es of-tita Liner t in hie Ym „n n H�IIt'a ogd Itr�pylW kSfy,et tiler yfOp Mxrle itnDe th�1,y(,y_ nder.- }i' edlil• air e.pfrat;. Ti`ji-`-er city bmfam - ruin. ibx7'1Ttr+n ' Clines J time Tor the prngrnm In sous n lgr to bare nuns Vr.,,o red• O1Cyta Woidek: Iw nave nearer W.tb coati; Id Stisdmry -be- ,• ; dq, and tomorrow; May 1 acid L ; rk Halley. the coniinen.: and- to Darr. a Scrku.. Wen of 1 Gertrude Chn.U.ou n .Inuot Cm . nets d ihrr lid uei m. u amarm I Y n Mill Ifni cantina* 11f m en' a "milted YP x rf the J r e maid (t L11 d un. P 1 lrll I auVpott 9t the Ll $ ® .B 1 led of nls Your Il m Berry; conductress. ss U,r N Ut -: oyes Iluah4 ni buhneis houses •ot the ' Carnival Crowds 1 Ott Oral Thursdu t the second analFtr of heel • 91 the rite were Ordered i tees. Gloria smith, ihr r r The X and a Joint ye fOr4 ut n tit (:II lr - C Yak.' anti will of the IJrttu and Klwenlai ' oa in. w' ich 5 dawn Ps m ire ellY rednnl vt term. Genruda Kirke. t ) L :I Unud sp i. h It yr V.l H,b wilt Dr held II i the fl TTe CoordinatUig CWaW 'b( `. pco¢nm_ which e�T rraday merung. r R ad Brunt,. I t or t wise* col a��ident, slro ftmvlth }Y fatrca,'Hie, - - -fore Ute Glenn O Grp}, Hed Husker, N Of IretttK Otlstbess In S. Punc - Officers. Winded for lie Fos Alvin I.nl0, tin Hubert C H Prance. ]ifs Harry A ., i sore of a prgtnm held ones ra. Chitties ton¢mpre :nranit slat the - held Chin D mi.,. M w, Claremont mandrilN thew Wntdak; Phan rise Ed tluu¢hr L, and' lain': tier. Olaf 4toivd n<1Jumnt Sage pointed dot hue Airs; $ P. iruwetd • reuse• fees Paint in. nnttoinil aryl - At a meeting of tale War Memoriat;omlliltted " _�.. rtrlaanLa mt nit,�in i[ w'•n d 11 1 f t h 1 t en the hM41e till_ cammbntly church, Rat ]bp Anter le sbmra Iurtrini the find I the Mvlamn of highways rl fall M 24{- ghats laklni neat In tot teninanles Dna/at M ghwpYs enure, a 1 - •toil the Pearl! t11,000 ii5hl, are ran, Norman 6 tAr- a><ql Mrs. Glenn O. Gems. Ned le[ker. Alvin 4: Pinner, !. A Debber-Mrs, Alvin N, Prince. >fn. Pa)me tit u( i771.1] as; tor r1� IT Nominated `°°`"°�"" °^ Nolte; dll'f a -Y .4 Glenn, .hoer of is -cent of the stale and Mn. E. •nerd lures man .Mrs p. D. lane}. KR LTanmon{ boon. My,. Ed D.nah- , tnr. Tlie I.-Cent he stale re. • e�Dleuon, or tete seldeOl it: s* ..• (tout fen the prriodd Jit}y I W De- I (/ i)n TNiWe7 i.dor.treee Yk' • r,lnU•r •71. 104a. elrtounted to For Lion. blob speeW bta.iw �'� n-U Paint -Up Paper Sofro e) urrd }kntldn a a tip to solo- set PxGround Broken $ r �' 74;.57 .aa E&:h'di„ate on Presidency In r4I• •Mn euee tit h6nt Nil. Over 1. lva Mork city, axFR1Y. ere. b from l la ibetitdg ' he state! k Announced h e For Paradise atraiM r , Ile on Pala *Mated -1PTin: k Year < - . . weer rem • a n- tpmm;tyutlon I Oh Fos (lfund: .q. ° a' - - at:'!•kT homes added fTA3 '[a --Tile retlintll Oh gas` r.. -i0d� — Tait 3 tl;Trtl1K'MO1keI* tires of the annul clean- ,,. Nibs Church slot tin rampalglu pro- \fe; E. J. ChriNman drir Dlrkaan, r1lY admin44w- Pandtae ,Hull Passed snatch•. bSirman: annourywd. - officer, announced lhk milestone ip its tronih TUsadnr raxihe rare delves ital the with the breaking of around for „Lidart of see -addIghe Nemerlal4 id the social. 1l11 as the not alp, hire -added f sawn. ty dare lied ee the 5e In the Co0ktflefOn of taw l' `- the trecuter.N.,,'C, W. ed, wf ally n may i dozing for $ „dot, t , retorted. G( thly may tt- N' ARir 3, disc IOUs Community church. amount edy 3]t.t6 ha y,eIarn tnieka „IN ecru the Tin tail 000 building. located Qom .and null In pottageandmleyel- mm.nitY I. rather sa ' the northeast cornet of AileMe- _peons rsperues of the drive, rlmmints from trots and :nY and MO grw4. Sill areo,np Vanaant said, . and other articles that date a co/urination of SO In olden hate been plan- rta.rs aria for social events will ' n tl suing eel. Pal 9pnvitnetelY 24p pe,ipoa Chula Vista Y.F.W. 0 - — --- - tablet. It will' alr0 -hetet a- Pas- tors biddy and an office room V. Hears Talk for the' church secretary. A booth Ifety Queen for the projection machine fed I mutton meturre is beesz built b, Contestant The Rey. key Anger. pastor of • Nona 9a@<, wnMdate lop the church, turned the first 0pnd1- of National CII•', 8pfeny Iul of din at of cons: :gth- 'r stamty; the to War Memorial fund tills week} vNdele llrjpsea tinder: proubhing , e of the slats! lae to In the upkeep °, tot end- of tlN selgesIgteldlehlt of n.rlpin airerla end life eleohope X`� Centeibptiont, ,rt�({�ita••tL ter stoner . l ora for police pro- - , .. -e POP. Ohelmetb wt7dr bpl.tivrrh tection, It war esplained DY Dein. rah J:"car. n, city adminUtn.i live officer. The tideland; money was order- ed deposited. in lilt argent fund" temporarily and will later be leanrfeered to the. capital. -outlay fund: ' - fficials Install- Commanders of Cosby Post, Auxiliary Mamaa H. Cosby, Jr • IhtoL Nn. 4830 of the Veterun; of Pr.-Ngn Win. and Auxiliary. hold S. Joint Instatiatlon ceremony an the.ni-M of April 7.7 at. the Community puildinrf In City Park with t}np' Chambers. poytcommendcc of the Chula Mate .Robert _'Jrhottr•Pavit. tlldtse ;at theItbixltaUot M Post'.Wfleen white COna Willis of tm presorted !n lmprTulat rNFetatlme :ute' talk Wedneadi l ' ev- _'ho 14 • 1Pr• 4 vet cannnony. _ . BelTolu Pogo of Chula Vwlt preela<d as 1na{allfpr. o(jtm.¢ toe of sate Tre1-4 H C41 r J H.-Oclatour Mn t tYaR,O(' ai **MS ogoOolof• tt]0. Veteran.of 7 g°4: Hai parader; Pr, aenbF tin damn nder. r; m<ellof tot CI M G7lrirlca Hushes Junior Fire scam Celebration PitanS ligy' St01. t an narrower, nd nanny Robert t+rh t4V ..em!+• ere Mrs The p lyry .'curl 1 M • Neiman, notion ouunrrma ter ndan x r•udd he pen-eeit �tt . of lean-JUcbied Cosby yank iurawh, Ja_ iutanl ones self, in the, 'tin' the crmtriP.bryskll a- esie- White: pool advornte.• lies uu It I the the Pedeitrfara or the M}gnal from then CtmSrr¢ntlinale gpalt,'sr. peatr service. officer, thesd, atallne pr rers. lend•ihr :reading IAnir R: :ui.waY. with ?halt rots- of "approprGle sfrtptara s r( Worrier; rrat st potilue .nits f 1!Y Uc ina'Heti W artier: post tWtrlu- n :fat other actldenU - hl Ineiructor lien,'" tier--. pien ally bedt (trpided. The chto rchIlea leis under the Or. -I hobgwt O. Jeromestees.ew ard. P acid HaLt nder in- xani11P 0 Ithe S uthee the too Gomel e i fti Intake.}, 0 el Ward. li L.dh path chief h.di .n 300 lr the non Shaheen Cantor-. Dndet C Heffot't intake. e ;Ad Iry ore 0. OOOapSty.ntal ours a. rsenc sum, the einerrf.,10"• arbor t of Wee of the der 'I.hnm. (etc. -redacted could truly >k proua t� • Puunl time IDe-rWxreWagon y B. Tipylur. .. fatalltles thls Yter not-, a.in. each Su."1" Ih the inks. of Cora' Wdlls awn of laird ii the K-0td as the .have loldme remdar seer W.v at II; JW`71RHrar,'7peMteoa 7 Newsr ESI,�tBLiSHEtx SEP.T)=MBER 28, L$:S iQrnam VT( HFWstAtif - NATIONLL CITY. (JtLIEORNiA, FR-It.t.i .AAA) z I�-17 > Council Accepts COUNCIL CALLS FOR BIDS 1):Tarstru°stks FOR CONSTRUCTION --Or Lingo,. r xhra;a Iiol meeting MLMORIAI BOWL IN PA ``. 'Innau;'wt ihr apedxl enregltxi 'nf tbn nwnp'd ornMr., afietnmm.; Sh n hn'.k+! urr wr gird. tins' May isimitne tt tle'.7gS.e0 Construction MBe Completed in TITO lhn) althorn thet a63 Y paid. l a: ` b) the artier- i ai teoltn lid as par : For Annual Sports Jubilee in August;, 1� ♦ t •( % - p ,IZ • .1j rho• {nOctlinl tiles tit 'nrrd Pledges Still Being -Accepted for. ly a]D 7Y' t eder 1 art for IPI larni Ink ' Fund y- ■9 / } al ✓ J T n l.I by thenary.lb• il]g0]R6 (• a r t, . mphllpn of the National City. War metnpriaj-'. 1 "r"' r • n41 a111I tootle e ¢ al m 1 udl lime for .tUlt - +� '\ by depo,n in the city bunk sr r into `ports ilep-on August 00. appeared atuta,iP. )airs: aaHttMt : • wMl sees :, ra,�.nti'pt ,qY' a e < , -y fw,yt3 742V3i ill., Crt„%f . 11".: `a1'�i44,eta f� y S e Wed .I p;ra rmr •• - - 1 „� .' * i t!t"- - ]It 664 ^t nos received front thej IYe emeuruetiltn of the bowl in city parka r stilt< an a rrhnul for vehicle Li- i :round.breaklrtg ceremonies at ADrghantr ant ales defer tee Tuesday. x .: lnclle y marked the beginning [rf. a so Gef Under Way rt WllOgma, as secretary; ai- ground *sett* wort sod tacit t acrc iU.uut oilWatUon in thej the bdaatet. -of It N be ImtaYW nrila nnminatuuu for Office - viler . ry._-,_}orb for_, taw IJwta club July At Rive wry m,eered• P4 Jamnr, The-bnwt"ftP„hld�.ylaam.. IS f tool Dr uxn atsoy park •erx liyl nrr,ulent of the chub Cr.the pait. speelfieegpns tape Sampled: M : got nrrdrrtroy with a njecting f ..The tile Ill Mom orial cammt{iN-)•ff"� der r _tiles r'mi r in eh0ne OI. I The eirt.: on will be held Mai .erenlni. Y to be at pairW- gp. der the rhptrou i hiP• of _Hober i„ Member, will vote oil canal - 'I Crete and *Hl beet apprwttpe.eew efi ek •o1,100 Persona.. Al T Innlne prntram for 'In: d 5'daer" fur .firwt:vicewe t. teiMt, ter Ihtieeaeottlla- Msuppauf a nit 10r100 .rid au 11 arid Yaffe snot me f, ofleter-' c9nst tic h arelhble tad' layer as.unr.stS'and dun in Iron Comer >nd membeti of ��Nel cOn°troctlgt porkme4 caw'lae tom% k rides lug nhr kxh y m::, 1 d A buxrd q( rs oflire,. it r n old cured. - , { I. 'T ham I tine Ye a ff trees will . h<W'i Veterans 4i'ganbOtlOti�mtoa bun Ire mean)• WP WI. Pnd dip tq txrortlC-Roma And "'Tr Jurie.ls.• .. ..-__--.._:'.IApaptfn-ir-erajterlar--iM- [ m ld (axluwaU t ,wrap of Joy l'rraldrnl J urea nit s short • names eK platloasi CIU mop- - Plrmr . I talk on ihr obltetnrt of IJonism I women who .rind In tot .tfft[d' Ina Hobert,. wit-. Ito i r forces dugYit the wv MO o n . D Yeaea ut In-e local P m K - P )arts being u un c u such will for .per u 1 ec t Ot O urn t o Ana and- 1peeftlt• • it ad to bforclt JI - tall. Prim • P. ROr that Olt peiapetr atip;yapa!'( pledges to All tttW Wf ire-- Fq to eontribu4 as 11 t7tglR emlyja t4 C. W. Vehrst..i , eel10 !. to dsei. ot.tb0t Judge Kau,$ is satetN egre * to pair the MIN** In the.legt.fe. dam Yeaaaett'a ',aimed Una nett {get cllelllnal gale- vehlih lea bap. M10101 'ogre tows ;apt N- bedir Rho thew ad added 4 uy:>•m4:t will *at el4.I * hem' tot reeegMe i', twrtlwtins It appeartd 3` the. dir n0ta,M *Eaed'I pe'ddeC If ale *fa tee.MK,� Msyysaabest It. Ms'. wick 1aepmd teYiela6_zt?_ WlW.tedjrd LeM• ..... Fourth oiJury. tee lentil „,left •a. sass . Al •tbf;now first Yly *ad* a •Ilai Abend[ 14 tha i • of wealdent for 194H7 at list War YemorLt tommetaitSsel <a streesed Continued gnu-..1he home of Alvin R' Pr ore tt s f >} e part o1. dtiher7 SUMa> � b the. otter Srl of r �Poxt olh r.as tit tit[ JIWP Srabrerse dove y Instehetuw of. suslhnr officers. tit of rsialmalnln¢ Uih *hop Classes ere bang' held ;, • who Premded er !Ate In he Uon rd. Ova Paraa es f theseen. r r le t trough. be Weed on tare book . — ae Minx ham ! ceremony far t. 1 I ,wm ut tmint far pie u¢h•by theclub 1 i — __ __ !cent: � ,presiders h. rlyn N ed t )`hm Ixnttl ki 1 P rramra tie Llre'emVinyment pi' a tWmmtnt - - . • .. Cake li x Mbth tti ihr Iwrk 19r Petrol sand the Tins' ! neon tees Pion foe New City r [ kt Yrrr S 0 y' I Mary Just r •'l coal f i n I "r qtr day. Me HiR ! h Uuf ordir hoop:11. through.tug n ore ay ul ding Ordered y e Ida to aln ie. iz CornNia Satter: cl I +In Gornto U S W V �, Prepares • for _t � t tlnM1 of it It re Mc/doing of the Mc- Plana for the tom roc d oyery Tray lmltM. thisbuddln4 [e Soutar- cdmmylrathe,[turd, REwo.? Wnx Lbr rbi ru C mp r$1te to m and :or a rattan ulde l.Akbsuth mrmh l they tier. term; siercl r litttie' h t co- [ slier solved tit. na . ,, r.u. ln.n r. tr b unounct.0 t Chun nwit 'di nrrmry[mi ofThe two wi0irdJUOcoln Aerea prum4w'th.t-r-. frill. alll-LLitJ:ILI' 1g,LWf 1u,±40 1'hthp_'?sIA'Trrsyrtg4SAal-4ei8hef davP er soeWtt* .r+Ye114"d- fifbf C!nnfn nl, b?]tidil)•. dr'Tfl. -rT(Y tin annual r semi nnual q(�alr 13iuFe-fwyiailies solo attend 81atr 9.t1y..t+t:f•a1H+.u.M_xt-•n^P-Mr �—.r«IM/JlarnrreKwl'oWd'LVeI[hh•T17'r out la al Ittit, l 70 p titPa' fly al Top up nn.tine• luta the` Bakery n;Ilonwide pub- 9P¢ b e Fr i at the recreation centertm Or•ia4 i er avenue bock of the fire atatb_-j National City and the :Haut. nub nertlyd and the Rubin miller poUinui ,m nee h,r and Ilona tt run.) of %o h' 0 4dmiaalon wilt be Ira. . i,roalmele rvs. (Continued tin ' I' my space has been peer4bd. O.-realized oy the Cetroetk- i4nriAvinmAn n Safety iisf n"A I NeIWt:J C,iy .1,,u:11 moved up mt Uneoin Acres tneKhanta sad LLe b,p :n tl,r v fete runlet.. ..r.rown,people, oho eamled will of ttt till L� r BL'ISHED SEQTEMBER 281882 e•�C4aal' ,KrtcOoc tin° HtW1?Ar>o[ ' AL TALI dab President NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA: FRIDAY, MAY 30, 1947 meTHUR P• TRY L22 lime Vht notate* I. DAME/'. YtaBSRTa 1 Seca* Mee President tilISli.\T OP{Al Girt t'Uci IC UBRARY FIVE CFfftts PER COPYl- COUNCIL ACCEPTS CONTRACTOR'S QID OF S..2Skj 77-. FOR- COItNRUCTION OF' WAR MEMORIAL AMPHITHEATRE.: IN PARK: • • Plans far Bowl Coll for Completion In -Time For Dedication at City's Annual Sports Jubilee Celebration Scheduled on August 30 Completion of the National City War hlamorial bowl In time for the 12th Annual Sparta Jubilee on At 30, appeared abiigat certain this Week with the acceptance gth 't. ra to t, tieMMOIRMOMPPili tre which is to be built in the northeast corner of the city park at 12th street end D;. avenue. The bids were submitted based tin the plans approved by the War MetnddaT cote. Tarr to Head Lions Club,ergs,. one ,reepte¢ trimly Other'Methods Booths in Jubilee the ny `°'` "°"'"" • � g16,tM0 wY yala.d Iq : abamlpr; Offered on Soma trine In e delve wwea bSfsa dim ter. Named Vice President Studied io Secure Terin, as Last Year : abt �ar b.� hT the : first Hoe prealdent of Ears Sen Diego Loos club In 1144. War veteran. and his non served al City Lions duly war He tray sferied to the 11Kbnai City In the oiarine caret. In World War ardent Tor- the-T9R=4KIrnelb- M' he.rme- e-'"�" .tit Thursday night'sgager and moved his home to 1604 D avenue Baler lived in Nano+W City leers tinned were: Ar- end attended Kimball setteol be - :Her. first rice Rend- ton Ir1pHItY M San Diego ' tfe d •E. Roberts, second nL' Harry D. Smith. • Ken. Wallace T.asmt= liter: and A. 3. Oraff A_ Clhak. director. A'llltama. as. aecretery treasurer, were positions. Recede - Edward .darter member of d a year ago way aac- wesldepL Mt Is the 'I the Al Tarr Berrie! 1064 National avenue. sun In Ion and came City in tau. He at. dotal grammar sehoola ,tad Iron eyreetwa,ter In DUI. xe'radust- gmone Cohere in fort ith hit father 1n the bmlrreat emaq"b.aum- ed with the Obeli tasm- Water From S. D. °eOUif end .negr.nt ". prow,' yMM tall tot lh. eat; tea' TMttb ^teeth BParia ealloe W the bawl ea JObaW''dsi.- yL 'Robert -OM a-mtID6xr,ot.the Althoneh Min peso can not Thorne. H: Cosby, Ir.. peat No. 1'eeany tap Ire _wain supply' to 4630, Veterans of Foreign Ware, hake an emergency -loan" to afar and of the Kenneth L. Blanchard Ronal city and Chula Vlata order Peat Nc. 255.. American Legion- the Wen reerntl%'PeoPRN bl. tlae He came to san0leto from Mich-- two cities; Ban'aeso city official; Completed 25 years »wire with Iten In 1920 and' •ens associated are ,tndylna other methods' to the bank 'on March t this year, with Bonham Brothers Mortuary permit the. duce to dew Molar He- was formerly moment man- atter-at the branch bargee at 30th and university "and to Easy San. Dino. He la' a member' of the Realty board and director of the chamber of tnromrree- Roberta. seebed vitt prealdent. served )Jre past year at a director' of the Slob. He and Nebo Berta ore owners of the- Berge•hloberU Mortuary, Mien they took over hi October. 1040. tie to a World for 11 years. He Is a graduate of Id get by until Colorado rimer Fa - Albion College In Michigan. a ter beoumee avalloble. It - en member of the' Untvrnity Club learned thla week and president of the Men's Pellow, • T. B. Cosgrove. of Los Anteiea. ship club of St. Matthews church Ban Dieig s special leaf! edn.d- and a member of Southwest. tent on water mitten advbed Ledge No. 263. AP. R M. - the'. San Dim) title count. last Installation of the newly elect- week that a proposal presented by ad officers sill be .t the annual National City and Chula Vista an. dinner to be held Saturday even- thorltles. whereby water (Pam Um U.S. June 14, at the Community Olay system could be adv.peaE buitding In city park to the two cities. and later repaid when Colorado River water la Poppy ale Goes Over Top madraralkble, would ke lnasat an aerie d auuny. - =Meng of the temmuht, %gni Wei only, nine repeesenHHrea stand up and take a bow for their tin the nets, the Blanchard Post cooper/ ton in the recent Noddy l Auslhary member sold a total Of re In elide aftlba and Peppy drive. held let PrMay andg.2300 poppies. cellreln6 a gr to 051145 n.wad notate =tturday; at the city's bale{ went! sum of 6313. . . - ndltntas and eooD da- Over She top with a bang. The Thomas H. Cosby. Jr. Is a director •of ate Both the VP.W. Thomas H.IAuxlliary members sold a total of comautee and a mew- CCOaM'- Jr., Poet Moaner,- and the! 4060 Meanies for the -net amennt city-.sraghtt�.nom-. went. Kq neth.. fvt of 5.6Y230. which mean. that 6560 e.. wsa- thgtrmaa of the BlaniMid 'Unit' 250 Auxiliary mttnbees of tTie coiOMugity Ye- anlq.ChesA•fund ra5.- member.- wish- w eapreaa their[ apwlded eehtertnaaly to the drive. en this year. beartteft thank,' to all, those who an admirable record foe a city of sanlant • Hie president' made. It .IIosN4M: for. Nem- to Olga bar. er of the loco 6raoeb \thieve their IOr pm cent.reroid: Anoone. eoaeeted br the vet. Hatloeal Truss. and The Immedlal and sheering re- teens of rorelin Wao individual tt sees a charter mew sponge ge distrtbltorg Of Near oreehOe“lons will so towere* the last. '-Preeldent_cd_.�he elt.timwa yymbotet ladtlpned_by continuation of their line work • heed by heopatahsed wgar voter- In supplytnE'htnpllaltad?rlerens srss:-wu-.yrbtl4ylropie-the-sp•rits 5IU tht mpny_ttttras" P'hfeM of theta who ndoded the streets cannot otherwl» be nuDp lid Olin their warm durirtg theta - Wlih the money collected In day rsmp.ien. last year i drive. ink Cosby. Jr.. Poet contributed cigarettes main- "We were a little afraid that slum. and. other Condon Items many might' have forgotten the to the mental patients et the U.B. saerllflees of Note whoa¢. need Is Nava boggled. for the entire gull great" puled one saleslady. yete. Although unable tc. shit -It restored our faith in hunan- oereonelly with the pat Pants, they bty l flad that the wars end had knew this work was narHvoleriy not erased. Lour boy's records Of ..urn while and were happy. to callent ,eM.ff to to on. .• hate the tunas fur fhb use. b remonies.... .in Lauderbach • :v{It be Massed Cavanagh, S. J. )h School Band "she water repueated by peas tlonal'Ctty and Chula Vista be. tog Ilxtmss t U.S present time• leer; -the bee°. et San Dlgo, With QQTIg, Auxiliaries Say Cogrove named, -Laws reprdInr t+allaul. Chet+wee. pallfMd 1tw bet the p/W;wW biaatuttnedi of the trtw' last Your Cho taseaure twee Melded ii- s wiener* Tap.. oat atria o.ia:b claw wise. .tmho booth. In lire -mat .1H tenth be.reepkcd he enter a tt»t lb - the parade. C.abary.p wilt lw the !game to a veer err. with_ a the adeonee torment and of par error of lee sea» tmmne of the booth' e.w' $1i66. Preliminary., plans far the Parade and ' report an µCivil., ke H the e.sinne g of Use MC fermi erenM terra Mounded. Sewage Treatment Rate'Increased By San Diego JaNkw M be betel 4 city newel l.. tc.ntn,eL.whWWWesI.y.Whblr. *RAA•thi Mort sell be e.Yarid be-e^ae_'tpuo45y +�OVM;tq►=; radar • lid were ewidlil.ry ae : wort I. Mart. I0 dal.;afl., thaw, nseey K the tonrae-atf'feG- ooatruetlen to bcempsetA anter. PC W an (MMthe beilanliit;.C: • the tart - I. The tounmB: hi lelilhr th..t fn th% tfa5 e+BhK fa ! itul.hYtg ttw tboII fbgi; m- the'. hop, that. wl H-It..,.Ia we. ter taltardr nWeral delays. toes am.'_ pkIHteatra would. be elWr fat R.t banr0 and .v►Bebll foe•1W. . the-anmat del. holiday pvy . There be. Nit. for anoet l.t: Im 1.11• Kim 1.300 parson. 1B Cite bond,*,i winch is 91.015ed' M. allow, the. Adel dine* et another. entagar atz: bowl st a later dal. - APnekedaer.! • room Ire- tM-alwwing tof ma lag. picture* is *Wed th ill. plenn:t0.'.•, 1leeragu. e• ofrrgdm.na a.,.l', home ea...AMM ten R wMB ;,ab.klIt< hot be pOWbk tolosea4',phgnitif disposing, of pub1M property tie week t.t tnerroe N what the oum,M.bda{ oupa, very. sM.mmt. and the Bea plMt of .Sw?gt-Wtdsal witch WI Iust1.. flatT ronnoll-tvwld no mote glue ohoot;n rJ Dkk{coati e Clt sent •'Changan 'TT 19 i�#e�e'elw7aS Iar aY or lend any M lU tiler thyet � ative olntrr tnfermed tM tNq• at alert ewgy or lend: monry � .q- r'+ Out Ot the rltY treasury•of 7lndey thernobn.• 'Cy-: 'rite nor roes. p5 dean l.H01ds Ins�affai - Post Office Closed letter nnm P A Bnwra, eta pe g,eegow.afn eouprn en Yp oily manager. will be t'1L61 Pet f).U-tot of the , Paeans Ttaett.l All Day. Friday __ m lets -.aEM par Milroy ww.oafterotaria t)Ya--ferog* • r Nat Dal will 1;e obarrved present late la d121i6 per Milton m«llnk after-e0&.*In t`e4'ofne..a by the Natfonat City $optufflee. Milton local bunks and many of Unhurt- Dickson was directed M the the IroUMe of trlend.Itte be Illegal' ttta.-helots at the City 96. Friday. eouned to enter Into aetedlalwn. Chula Vine .Coma.Mty rdalred, lintenat Li. Ctaby. postmaster. with' net! plied I. see tt-a more The meetlRe was galled tee the':' mid" the plot office would be rekesynable elarse could be ar-)purple. of Ingt.nmF tent o.VW chord all day. but would be open ranged elected officers Tea will mew for . on the veinier schedule Satdday Rhode, mid increased cost of the paled of-•1M7. *. thole' WW1- tea stamp' registry -general Operation- to the reason for tfle elected —MM.—IS fbllew ^%us— tdtlycry and P.reel Proµ wlndoas heeel q_ : Vhder e_re .si glMRe RIc1,0O4 R• L-.�,-, abatis.; k _ open from t. to S p.m. and • the for the treatment of N.tronal Cny tV: W Or. . 14..r. rlret ee- eteeet . dent - ice- Th-oms. Clrk.oe, .ecynd vice-prcaatent: Lev. Caleb Betty; secretary: Pare: C. W.t Knnta treasurer: MW rilrabetlp'.: BullIvan. ludltgri F{Ira' Raymogd-.-- Flanders. hhllorl.n and' Mr. -Cahill !dudeAmen., 0e 1isment5". , lag.. 'Committee shah. C. Inelaned;^. Included: ', J*. H. C. Pegni. ,` health - Mrs, Jame. Rusk, letWa- tlon: Mrs. Kart Wel..acher.. spiritual edl*ttlm Mry Dorn thm Norrle, hwwfalitY'..Mn.by, W. Oreml f.,ptosram .'airs.. sI vin.._BCatV'—"wwsrnrwdbcsiil.:- -Pam, s. v - C. iV:--lfrwedc-boda Neehod sOlh -' ThomasMrs. TTeas CTarkHn -1„ radio and mollofl tanttarea and 7.1" Mil W. J. McCierae. publicity. Asabotlne in thebt.Wluen ceremony wee Mn. H. S. Run- --- ter. Ninth DlitrI t- pro.ident sad %went rant d honor: - .! money- order, postal magma and i-_wage In the Ban Diego dispose!' band *11,00ws opening at I am- plant. $I0 Pas for the operation Selurday. - and mahatenanm of the plant and Delivery service, with the -warp- St a0 for dmm...blies.. -Under-the than W special delivery and per. new estps Mt* 1laurtd- for nimble mans. MU be suspended operatien gad maintenonoe"toots Felder. - end 4i.06. Tor dePtecletkp,. . _ COMMENCEMENT EXERCISES' 18th and Highland School Building - FOR HIGH, JUNIOR HIGH, Arrives- _- Permit Granted 6RAMMARTSCHOOLSTSLATED tang -awaited traffic signals for San Ditto Union School tills the corner of Idth street and fin lly week took out a ormtt for con• IDshiarid avenue tare as- tired and sent be Installed In tii,lstruetlon of additional units'. at neat week or two. Delavan A lie . school which ere estimated Dickson, city- admtnlatrathe ofs to cost 460.000, fiver, ono rtwe0. - Permits were also issued by the Tilts Kim ne the screed tit ollcity bolleint In hectors orrice for Graduation strsires for :'ttl $uectttpler high school -.Wail to' -Be Built i$n.4 IrtaWIM on Hlehiand eve the construction of tour nos rue within p few monen.. The graduate.... trill be held. on Frrtlt1', Jttna Fr,,and for 237 homes.. They wire blued to 'r At CIty.Barn first agnal, at Eighth and thzh- x lama ws turned m. March 9t 3. ail Orb, . 30 J avenue. . 'I'h ,r l,,s of the �atwnal C City Junior high sthnnl oh ,. city union of a seal) around Haul Cirrus. J031 E. Itch Street. T'lulesglo .tun,-n urinrf uvl. ..f el... .,.t.....1 A ...... ..:... ... s.._.t tier city ham at filth atreet'and On Thur.eai. May 27 at inea : a' Sweetwater to Graduate 284 Students On Friday; 237 Ninth -Graders Get Diplomas On Thursday of Next Week • rr-.)r Latrtracrt ttl, i 00.4 OTT 1.1110/3PAPEt eotourint tuninra. Is. Ras opr7O' vie, reiaoen1 dell cafes in 13an Fratirloles.Sig-! All •Witnottent: niernine• arr a Marls and Sin Diego, I•being. wiled PS bring their dtios Lan Garnet. former eery lb AWLS' 'Ic0r: will Mansige the cafe 0001 The VFW_ I. rompie:Inc Pans Xay Sevitalna. daWfhter of 'tide we.4 for pot (Pr it dittnot he Owner. will assist. • to beheld Wednesday, at 6.30 Sevistos is noted for hip nag- pm.. thr Community butIllior nal Anhui dressings and FRI Poo. In city park Lure his own recipe for chop sues*. The post hos assumed do:y it says his policy 10 purchasing 'of the upkeep of the Citood Din food for his restaurants has al-lArrny plot. at the is Vitali crow= ways been "Nothing but gutran- I Very The bloilist sonon Am...• teed food, if It Ls tiht the host It' teats War 'Ir.-tan. (Parr 9, sent back to the whole,alee aritlf:rospcnotble fop the p-re of OA. Is not served herd'. Full Program Set WORK-PUSHEDi (94 MEMOREALJ otoWI IN PARKl Expect to Have - it Ready for Sports Jubilee Work is progressing raprl idly_on the War 2rIroo. r4q. - Bowl- and it poems -Probable' it will be ready for openiOB-• ceremonies eri Ju.bilee Day,' Augu*t 30, city officials and; the H. H. Jalvison ConstractiOn company agreed this week. Of the IS aecilana Or itasn..4 POUTS In which the Hood la M- ottled. lb of IlFens have been completed, and forms are toeing built by a large, wrest l",e them ready for the cement. Clif-I ford Cox, imperintrrident of the', Worthen are rays reeding the tonna for the monument and en- trance swetione ot the Win' Me• mortal Names of Nallenal CRY torn and women served dur- ing the war in the armed force4 will be oilseed on the skleivalla at the entrance. The Bowl Is located ors the.. park property at the corner MI 12th street and the mrk. When completed It: will seat about 1,000 persona. the sty Is pianning on conatitirtInk I moveable stage wt&h ran Or NATIONAL CITY, cALIFoRNIA, AUCA/S1 M, 11)17 'iFor Sports Jubilee.. • • Booths Still Open toolleallano toe hatiena Sash en Aossot 3.1 will e'se.:41-estreielor 'et nrret."41ilisokheed.r‘hlte I .ipist amino ded Weabiendar olahl.- The period Was, extended ; cantos some ortanlowthsym oni bon PM. to present the I Pileiallaits at their remaltte. Ines. tiroom see Atoned • hate More than own. heath tho park.. but earn trible i orating a booth salmi ha. I remhtgA 1.14 `4, • A- JUBILEE PRI1 I:TICKETS BEIN DISTRIBUTED Will be Araileb $,.42.,A,... ..i, ....,,......7..:.,:. . • . - 44' ' .,;' - :f: -..zt .,:.'...”-.;• , ,... • ...,„,,, , .. . , • .... .. . . . ,,f,,,,....Ad'ant..Pa- 0A, the • ", .., ..... moved Into the .open arca In Wtorkmrn are shown molting. the flalshInclonehm en forma at. the tear:Memorial final In thy parit, ennerea, wyq pmp.,ii in .. - : AU ll*tlekets are good for Si . . ;root of the bowl. 1 the Perms the first.part of this seek Sad narks:sin hare started bonding the forms for Die ...trifler to the.bowl andhd the moon. .• °IA -teg?'Pe..fie3 .Atfielf.inehfelAf The work benat done' at the i men( section. Work to bring rushed on the .Howl lo hare it completed hi time for. the- Attntral Sparta tilthilfe PritSrans Whiris will I AP FtC.S.4010hillatinft rhdlO • ,resent time will ram opt:most-I be held in the park on Aunts( 30....—.ISeesKay Photot. . . -. . ' , - : ' - t :, eaectirle.erde.trultosalreentro'"fdesarlef'ediiirt3h6etida. nanny 430 000. A little over alS..1 . . , , ' . . city during the' tor years. La Mesan Tells of Struggle to Hare "Home Building . '''''.'137*. °a l'Y'''''•-'':•••• Oh' )0` -`,I.Vcontributtl by the PeoPlel . ' ' Council to Sit As. .. od bythe thy totiraelltfrOM funds Articles. on Religious -Freedom- . . Members of the 01y- counell , . 'D - I T. - - • . dl.api.,IsailL.Pt. LAIgniudiefrilagil,„7411ltioner a balance of_ the Money ; Equalizatiiin.Boord - .. plete the structure waa vo- ' ecelyed from the federal' govern- 1 ' • . will sit a.s a hoard of notalisa• ' ' A 0219 OSCeef 4S'iderrtit It didugg AtPdfl-P.w caroalt A nent for ladelmsde. ' included in Italian Constitution ,,on 'tin Torsd.ny. • *ea'?"'141e 'Year at This Time „.. . ,...tco,„, ..,.. ,,,....... • and Thin-600y f nial woe* . .. • . • - . t Dr. Prank B. Oinlientli of ta Mega. told MegatErs of the 'latent& frontlet' 10.. ini 11.'n.0.0,. tiscl 1. 4arty's Care Has , ' club on Wednesday of the difficulties enrountertld to having reit- 1 coisiitil ',leotard'. Thetas, nlehl. doulard donne the 'find :se:it. on tliap.laY . Itt Matthew-4 Aft Iniftd.lre let National CIty t. A g4I-05.1Ntakst eatietel0 te • foul freedom incorporated Into. the mos' italsin Constitution. 1. All reildcals of 'llie clIS., who 'ne:iii.ii of 'foe wear, records of ROW Center. ' • . From.Merchireth All Ports of•Cit Tickets to he used in drawings for nearly $1 In MerehatillIse will he trihutt'd throughout the •the week end..The di ings Will he held in...the narann Atkon, so As o AMMal SparbsOhibilee. Ttellots opt be. given nwwx 'few Owner, Chef • ' bee of o abrnmisaird whhatbripetl In/It-awing top the now &nutrient. me 1111-if (trowels, may appesr...•p•cfor showy - ' • ''14atstiotitkpitty at Nason.s, Or, Olgliatil returned -last month from Italy where he we. a Ineral wish' it sPpra, Ike eo.......wileid. ;., rocs A Ittrd, etty building In- A SO Packard -Bell pot With Dr. Charles Farna. 'Dr. CiisPolt1 was sent to Italy by floe before the board ' .' Iy II „aid of .1,,y 1,,, Sr lie ikiv.;,, will 1,, .,..bei.b On lerlday Ornte:SMaatos, res-I - . 4 Cl liens United for I:440014i. ' 00 petrints. II now hnmes had merchants Pt. ton chamber minticut With 90 yearS expert- r. . reinsI...tird .,,,i ho hay I thot'Annneree office. 400 Mal -nee Os chef. annonoced .that Po i V '''. • • • Fanoncipatiosti• of which' he Is.... . . -. utdourchised the Marty. Coffwe' 1 .r.W. Membership • ,--4,•,. , 'Done on Directory , „ Ar 119 /termPit..P:0 boon craw. avenite. and at tire 416, trensu , . ',-..L Ili .btly i . v:at- ago Il....• Per of pre ' -In the city hill. 5h09 at Sit Nallanitt avenue. I . ' . ' iThey were able' to secure the • -'. , • , . ,n3ed,erezt'r„ 'en:l.illmehhe' 07 teabehe.o'i„,.0,i Dr iy e Successful • •--'"'P"" of, Article II. 'lb" tf In a I Work Beillg, • lip• re the right' of freedom 0 as.: . . ,t w.., I t Itt htly thts }...tr. tr. cht1171.15ele of commerce. Li - ""*.• fr.' l''''" h°!"-/. wl,.7 w:'del neeroe d.Ilarrlson..u.erti-oe -10,1•1.•-• ono ./, his sirs ih.,F,rpo...1 Oven 150 p,,... a...•mbo., sit ',mob.. In- tine past Prolestantli F,o1 .ti•ttett, 1, in, ite,,,..., , r', 1 Ttttat •.. the ht or j•tt-Ithrt .tn 51,tine in the distribinicas of flint 'in Te.fifmfel the.rate imdiold menthe *lin '•'.' IT in tlancet ' I',Id to get *weekly permits from ' the ;Stational' C:to dinntOry And .-0, tits . ear I. Ibiti aril' econ. lkkete lii , ole!rcl!mil.; and nsts11 a cooling system. ' .of bring tlropod have *en War- ,l''''co to hold teryiee'• Aruele Diners' eihde'' 0i.V.It :' IA t.•: '''''`f 11'1' '17:8874 'f' It he'' e'll. on er'''enany' el he on in The now owner. of the Cpjf o.o. I od on 0...k,. (bit, vt...,... ..,..„.„,ri.,, , ie. whtch sets forth that !eery.. ,4101„.b„±. b,. ,..,,,.\,,,,,,. to ,,,,pc.. •...isrt TO nr.:1; of 1945 Far tile next fens dais. .•• Mop comes to National CRY frohl;11--Colay. sr. Past No. 4630. t'et. t•Ite shot{ hove nit nicht 'PI PM- tat, eointintY. PomY 141tot •••• tw- ft"•"'1' "f J'" ' rf.' '''9' "A' 4195 - • ----7'-‘----------7---------" .Vasketran, ill.. where he 100tlferan of Fut e.ort Wars to the reltIbm of AD whOge "nd tot, roadr eat rs tot.. GIS tit 19.1: S Iti t th 194G o o-oh In InIsinera for the Pad' fe0tird:lp rennnotre t.f "[bouts, In inoloiltate wim alsO ad ill. tbatse inter{ tn ttai..110- ; . • I • IS Lions, Kiwanis h k .11 I 'hod mules ttecnntpliottn*etti .1t,,, . t. - )s,1•1t. /earn. In ts 3 yeara In the /4' W•imittiff and -hones Ilat• uf the inlyniat tar thafiniti so0I :none tiett o lit ias to obtain the nidit of Man -I Rpoitir;: linos that hot. r, todo to ..petieet freely' in !tali 12, !to op pnrost•o•a;tt-• Thts wits' )ne, see (Ind !rip to.Poly ,d tie pidli !Au ,,p. • 1,4 oirli•bwr of the oRmilis`mn- intlituturn, ot.. a•-i• t.1 the tIttrtor repo -tail tilt Tint 4, ,0 On. no n$ t.., J11 atithipt to M4,1,0111t1 ant at ill,' Ninths! Cos Itli". nit,. .the Rattan poople out of thr 913.-.40o sisal tsom•''s te'e- war. Mussolint, who at that pope ,I0„,e, tests co:ono-ad littler would 'nil. -rip. rt.,:ite reporttm•t• ,a! st the mission • the Itt•os hitt:hod At, I. it • Tile dortur save at few exonotles,nouttl Poo sly PO, t ••:. l• t el D. neral Stet k ('Talk', -es-. assist In' ;hetet:: tit: tte.-ete. .t1.41 told of oosne of the tit t.ne Itheettt,i "- Battle -Set I ELI E' Itthh otte I sir' 000: • SI Tip, b"oist.sofrb,o s,i4bbe C. Krth: Ilitt 0.00 the thins sod tt00: A A Toni: Ith S. 0,A,, ha, ofreefs So000 ond who, all players went' Irina truthtbrat • tn. 'I.:a:tonal \tent.' tot Er41/%111$: will be held MA II S4.000. ciao night. oecortling "to the A perm:: loi A 0.t.taes.. tostlable infuonatlin aso • ito,,t. I Cu' IblIttl" • Tony Seaford maniaree at Fissure tshipons IIES Oh btu,Kr I3bm: I.• ovnt••••• WM). t.tot.t!iott artitus of the" floor I raps. are keeping (heir•" title. ',etas. • Misch vinder cover it Dawson Donates thro hoth plot and hate Si, nen the honor ' i',,Millp.11,, whtth coritront the Chtty• !in' 6.1, . : 1.:-1.11,11! ,i,:: ' , r . titre base • plo nty '..of weight oorr in t.. V F. W. Thi. Cttsit. IltAttart Petite- ' L -1,,,,•,,I, ....:,”..:.t) ..,:.., • • • . ,,-.9)e Ot•tverfttl hitter, Croat , cos wilt a loo OP In thorur td a II FoOon it s observations on lIIIN tr;s1:11-., !1,0.1,1, IN III. •,,,,. i .:,! ... -y ..:. . 'I.". ''''r r.. . • Books to Librdi ,.--,•.., diartiNld ,Iromorlal seivicrs conducted At Ir aintis and in .Ltaroor lior is• of the ITUrfor•LII•d •',0' l''''o- .',' ' By 20-30 Club. • . the cemetery ittaint the Nese, • Is,. hcatrit o4tacte- to' World e.P.T." dd' L'd r'' 'd.' '' ' di ' • ' ' ' "Se '. Si'" f ....s-los .4 :oda. The same watt :tart ot 11.16 I Ni.tiiiin.ii city.. 2a..30 Club ma, ,..07,..;10.1I,,,,fh.,,,,,,, 7,--.1.,„.!+;,:,;,rOp: ,I,•,.. 1:rt,;cei ,10-p,. Otint•Itti sIlpissi old_ The, ii•,,,t,t t,.,..tii ,...Stri.i.t,st. t.i,..,,.,1,.•.,o„ these uppo ,..• ••• Iot. olat Ats Ass at te.ii be pur,ed under hide fear Americans. so , b., , ... . , .,. a , . PM to t•••.,- tli.. t: n ... In it toltra, at thy par. . Or Ii .nt Charles Kfreh Presitlimc•t foorot w,,,pr‘rtLy. . •• • t•bteei two. l•-.,' ' ,,e Building Up the Va Any the meeting. the club's - i ff.,' r""t4t. uf the `-`911d ore '''''" Combine to Present r • . - • 1 Dii Tursday Au:nisi' S. at the City second Weelp. els: of our.). nitoit.Attel'Ituoicons fiyr the Community building. with • book. ahl. •pt ..t tut :sr - and a bu inrs- ono I I ed if Spanish War Veterans r Itte: , hay met be oho n .• pearefolly pagother, he as-. • • .ey calendar of cityrent. 'and t future activities Included: a 10-' Applicants for City Gala Benefit Dance ' ' ' '" Is Chief Bu*ess o 1 -D., Mat arl't TI•.• IStted it 21t10 ; tn.s.th Mee night. act for Arltl,mbrr 9 l'' poaf l.t.00s Must File 1 pp w i am pi. LolilIF enSirrnan. LItth Dem, eran• 01111.:•11141..likt Lod,. ' :. ,., . . if, MO. lieutenant governor of RI,: Lieutenant Darwin. es.itter• 0." , adjust:, tt : • , ai•• to IA., - L'. Rey. [my Ts 1101 the Officers ChM in Balboa Park . and a club brash party on AIM-, By ust 23 ar Coronado Noon Tuesday ....ini. made his off Lao 1 Snit te • uronntriim Campo tor n111 •,1. In,, 4 n . P ...r .. P.LI II. - i dila, j -.1.1.110! . our chief bm intne ' - 1 Apollt a lltsto It, tt?tte the , t to : the chttt and C W Tarim% Its' to Pie ...ht .. I ts ta I t .'••• • tar , e..•••• - tt is Aut.: i '. r. y .nv. pastor of the First 1 Rodney Smith, chairman Sr the priori „s„,,,,,,,,,.,,,,,t,„ t .rip,....,Arant ...a.,nor of the WI- - toroorrera In. 1,, A.1 •• tit b -•...nd , ... •.• !... ''.. '.'', ';' - '..t,..,k.., ot• the DWI, char dint Nettaitle City Ses,trt. 3.bne' street main.- ',tor • teettlt.n. Harm lets.a-Netwoolta 1.11-4rIrt. "P. .. ,-.,,,,„,„1, 1.,,,,,,,,n ..I t t . , ` ..I „oho. 0,... ,,,, eanotitittee reported ti-tat Plan-.1.1tould be Plitt by noth in l'a.s• o etteot.' to :1 .boadtns up humus.. 1',....tlt PI I.• ••••' ''' ": '' Th. • •'.. .P'. • '. ' ‘" ""‘... % k I of ,mr youth' ' he cantln tiee to. to . • • -,.., I. , I.S.1 J.,....,,b. doin,,,,rno. II ..1 n have been completed for an elab- orate float for the parade . . . • . rommto.t.0 Ito t: tom- ' of the ' out of the :Id not on his clod 01w add. vita city lye Sir. Henry Lief!. en El Cajontse evening- Also, as past of the l.1en•P Se0-Fishing. - Street corner near,. one of the will pine- both the processional ,darT e4enls, the. ..-•- otx{ - local theatres, a' li-year-old- girt an !tined ton, of L. Sierra,. wilt -m-St IInbn hie% school end Cvn •dam t fought Ter way free from Rot 1 1 NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, FRIDAY, AUGUST 29, 1947 • These are the trophla aide% are to be tormented ht the many enrol. of the anp®l Soria Jubilee Saturday. Mew Jewel **rennin ie shswing. DBgYor Gilbert-E_ Erna the leopbki I.e nab omit. They will be on display. at Leonard's- iliac end Jewek7 Store Celli their are _awarded... l l!odern 1•hnteeraphy Straiten _ New leathers -- Need Homes HPttsing for t about 15. new trndterremployed by the Sweep after lush school dlstilet Is bid name to Mn. Numb at Crreley voted to participate in the pry - 1' netted J'.'. M. McDonald. Mai 7-5211 of by meting It to her Wcl superintendent,. raid this at I}4p IilehWnd avenue. wek, 'The chamber of commrn'G at In order to Secure adequate Its regular directors' meeting this teacher, for both Sweetwaterhtgft week, agreed to cooperate apd-of- school and the new Chula Vista ((ass of Nurses to ed anY a tulle char man he- Isi;at. school, the Maria has.to needed to make the c¢rnnotiies a 'brhr m ❑tiding places for them to her, 'McDonald is risking that 11 National Calif. Notional Ctty• VOL. L XIV—No. 50 - C ESTABLISHED SEP_TEMBER• 28, MA man wrlr tflYeiP4 -TTENTATIVEaPEANS:MADE TO DEDICATE MEMORIAL BOWL ON,RMISTICE DAY Veterans Groups, Chamber of Commerce; ,City, Working on Plans for Parade, Ceremonies to Honor World War. Li Men Tentative'plans were underway this week CO -dedicate the National City War :Memorial Bowl on Armiitlte Dar. November 11. 1i'etcrans organizations, the city and the chamber of commerce etch approved preliminary plans for a parade and dedication 'ceremonies. Definite plans will he de- „ —'—'f.aytd until tc a:niters rev fain War emorial that the Bowl -will be entirely Names Required completed by Armi'tler Day. • 'Ihr list M name et mCn and' Tinny ennetrtirtlon work is omen o1 National CTIy who. nearly finished. hut the city and served In the termed forces der- tog World War II Is" bend remained by Mn. Ulna Bak Plwoli. dOeMwaa,eL the -weber. -'en, weemewhise- eteargedy-gtth'. veterans groups hopetohave lb. plaques, bearing_ the nemry of men and women from Naeenaf City, who-_eerced_ efurni.. Wand listing the names of all vein: War LI, in. piece on. lire. Manor! - ana whose names mW appear air by November 11, - , the Wae_er lit. ..e _ Anyone who has not turned 1VMnesdq• nigh!. the In names that should be on the Thonma 11. Cushy: Jr. post Nn. Memorial Y rile 4 dye rite 4830. Veterans of Pontlgie Wars. Paradise Valley Graduate on Sunday n ethen to the Bowl teem e In whose honor the Bowl will be On Sunday evening.. August 31. dediralcd. -s{ 0:00 pm, in the Seventh Day ,As it.at1pear3 nosy. a parpdr. Adventist chain-h, at 24th and such as Wes sponsored !a,. year Broadway. in Ran Diego, corn- by the veteran, organizvtions. mrnrenunh exerciser will bc-held will open the ceremonies, for the Paradita Valley clan of Dedication of the Ickl w0 gaduair nurses' who have corn• follow and If possible a concert: pleted their threg..Yeat course of tatnlne. , will. be- arranged for the Bowl- In - - anyoneWho knows of a house. apartment, rooms. with or 'Mho - out kitchen privileges. n11 the \Clt.iais. 1 Some of the new teachers are sn•:Ir, some are married and have children. McDonald asked that people call Cheeky 7-5171 or Ono: t V'sta anti Il41- whatever cf homier h" available. il By Four Youths Grabbed by four- youths on a • d receodonp. and Montnr Mor r, � high school mil{ i eery sex flsMnx <xturrion le/abductors abdueton after being cut and W' the evening wih Mrs. Betty pis' their an- . 1 la need for men of the n her era Week. • The store. In be knon'n as ^Mathes is at ify7 Hannay)' set. Inc, tote' former [aatlon of Dr, Floyd V. Green's oftlet, Robert Meches. son of Mr. and Mrs. Wil- lie*, Shrchea, till] be managt'. He Is- a navy veteran of World War n. ?ditched started In, the candy business In Omaha, Nebr.. In. 150J Where he operated two stores and - the Nehtanki' Cindy reeloty. ma wife lathed Mat to the bad - rune there'. 30 years no. T eynty years ago they moved to San Clegoand opened a' candy story in th$ Orpheum - bulidmg. ' For eight inn the store' was at Fourth and C in San Diego and for the pant earn yearn they have operat.0'a store on Broadrtr._. now with the U.S. Air. Porte. NA - ea offering a selection of Waal football game during t is - I mail etl ear y TleunSday morn.e Honed on Saipan.. A daughter, violin numbers n Ltnheren church, the Rev. Earl Ih San Diego. • - - Ede nor, le employed by the Clank afternoon, IS. Otlrhlaxrr. announced this Present to receive their dipto. - Earlier In the >ear Il 'was hoped' week. They will berants at the The xlrl. >v-I erreived s slash of Aetvrd p..th and Mra,?tarns. mis 4t be the follosine. thlrlrert 'frit [he Boat two tid�be comp:et d' Otani Shepherd Lutheran church °n her lay arm width re Elmer1 rtretrfo prcwldential tommenda- class members and officers' Pen- In time for the Jnbt re do- %Nrehl aro"trrhooet of San Diego,' -25 sll[ehq to done, told ©mew Uon for x31usg dd80,000 m war . bonJ d Y1 wind.' 3fsvne Ketmop; wipe. It became apparent Tut a wsatda The nett b to gathtr at the Sllity End J. P. Hoollhan. San a ire top war Years' vow, cleat font dark; - pre'ldent. Irene Xntltie: scree= 'not be ready by this NilarlAae !home of user Tp'scad, lei Y INlil Diego ate ti t n ter Curer, Veneta Kama. pap- it wSa arrteaily' decided' that i[1 strut at 11't5 a m Situ rnmplexls»ed routlts had kidnap- - 1 rdsy pelt knlfld and mau1M'hrr antl,I ern s ISst➢ed tommfarlan 2rrns Rogers, tiny won* De mo t t tTh 1 ar th 1 t iwu•tof. MNvin UrHterw,vst: Os -see.- watt'Vntll all.rr summit a e pp set to lees* a per a tattemWed kr «Iminally. aataultiFor Rebuilding the irk nvA. petty l •_lt 7 n.1 wernarr t•,'retusn a her illy su v Mre esa nv L cvv, betty Eytra [bier• nunpl.ed end ire i wog li,djlmut T p.m Those who wish to l a e E iru Jp gait. ¢rim Kane g Et peel/fired betne dsisa„trig the,ru can wake artapgtmena 'by J ors. Susie Pllnt stew Smith ifaael tlru8ure. i'nL'tny Tobtad at pT-S1TS- Elnotormcn. Maudeater Smith and ." tt'thro Taff' - Elder Adlat Este%, of Olendule. wilt nett.. r the' Commentnrieot address -and. foilow:ing the cere- mony, graduates and friends will be ellen a recrutlon en. the lean • of the nurse's _tesldrnee iv Pane • dine tatting the the thin -day holiday period. previous to the nreduition • ceremony, members-pf the -elan will Partake in a Clan Conse- cration Senlee, to be held In the Paradise Valley Sanitarium -Chap, el at 11700 peel. on'August in Ac- cumpanitd on the organ by MIN Helene ttammcpd; MissBarbara Mw Moreno, at San Diego, *lit sing. "The Lord's Prayer-. by Manatee, Mr. Marton Bourdeau, of the raeltartpm seeff, will be the speaker of the evening. - On Saturday morning, at I1:00 a m. Augult 30, the hatcalaureate Prise, Ticket - S titbs,;�...: To. Be Taken- to -Par *inherits an inked a bet* al! then Sports Jwbaer-Ilehwt *obi to the band *anal . In et[y pbftl en Saturday. Dean Si Ifasrlaod; Chamber of menuesteree seentar.y, la charge of Uekad dletr:bbtlen. weld -this seek.' The stubs Outbid be delineated -- there ?mitre d p.m, a the inter- nee will.'tetunder way short- ly after that time.. Today is the lest day In which merchants can - seethe Heinle for free dletrib-nU a to. their eustemera They can be obtained at either the chamber of commerce office or at the' efts bar.:. hi Kidnapped sermon wUl be given by Elder Miller Brackett, of Pa-udene. Music lye tits service will be giv- en by Mr. Frank Dletrek. tenor .elope, accompanied by Mlsi Vivian Erman. of San Diego, at the organ. this serelee will- also take place -In the Paradise Valley Chapel. -t Ed Porter and Lloyd Pinter brought beet the at.,. pietism from Yellowstone YSB n l.pu k tp prose the nab story they hese been tdilog around town. Ace rdi o to PIII ter the sneer*. of their fishing ten *es due to igniters. \lela tackle. Pewter claims he used a hook and ll e. but rai;s he ught Villager In. a neL Time Matt on the entire stet a for the leo fishermen wes one hoar 3o e minute* They both •w ar to 'IL and they an noted for their venally In reporting on their flsldng spedllion* OPENING OF NEW CHULA VISTA HiGH - tandy:Store. Opens on. National The grind Openhtg of H.Uenkl CTty'a new candy' store - gill. - be held Saturday, tylRlam 'A. Mach- ete, proprietor, announced this Thet ytntngeat son; Richard: Is MI At Fir arta Tit tail star Soot Tick Del Fed etb be Cl near stelL A deists!. a SF fled Fenn .claim Df ill lien i m be beet I 000fit rtcely The of Ue friers demo, sat 1 items Me 11 land I valued was s{ acerb: and * italht [tor On I Roy iLAALAtil rarest`. and f tin,w L h d "1 d - LWns , Iett the tbratee The frieml an..- ftrbulldmg and alteratlou mrr1' Blar other yoOng girl.: rail and Rill' a'iiedulyd for many buildings In I tpmtr inn); 'then the youths reitout of the dty. aeinrdme to'the per-iwarngp I the .ear. The.ttrl escaped from; Rana Issued for tunstructton work amen at 1 the car alien liar- four younc ,.by the city budding' lrupector's.ni rife,. is I men stopped In'the INN block on' office in the last week - I rontrol Ord street In Spn Cage. ' .1 These why plan such work me:; egviht Ernest Slnan, 1J30:44ti!'nlrrel., tobert Skekl0. to -remodel an. of- I,,,,,,illy heard her scream and. ran to her; tee at "II E: Eighth street. 400: 1 'A qn and took {ter to htv, home. where, Wayne Johnson, to build an ad. t to, eoi Mx rife-'oAminpolic . fin! ,ud dnlan it 2]0a slier o, -il .o: e:I nerd I .gird ti, countyont, Fie w'a..I R, Miller- tel *lei a garage to :nut el taken. to ll!e hlepit 1 la ed<Iling Ia]0 Ca e>7ur }600•' - I bold Fecrerra:.to bu11d a nutter/ halo; At .d25 Vnpl a etrts'e.;KINE Ffappy Hollow Under 14son: sal J. Newkirk to remod.i New- Management let a bulldtx-at f125 Hlgl;tand'y}y mild o a .; tee J Slerrlu to 5111C iipb lkeaitlits 'a ho liketo 's aa.. build ten E. Sixth tre . rar0ae' bad a Y the neve 1 1 g' fo t T. 301 E. Sixth street. 1] SOo l fYttDl 1 have In liar -wa new In stun for�B C. Johann, woenu an lddl., pile wi them In the way of ebmfwl. con 1 Lion' at ]a40 D. arena flab:! Clty .I 'sentence and fun when tart, sts-I and O. Kestler- to «our and re.. I cenduet IIt the -Happy Milo* Dolt Urlv.imodei a butidrnd moved unto the taw"1, td Ina Mande-. now under the man-- property at 143 W. Eighth street-nenoudi 'siemens of Beryl tad Phil Me-ISI'- 000 - Hours -Daaniel: Mn. McDaniel is al-1 • ready widely known ea BerYl - I x ttooti Hood, donetng tnst,vetot - f Another; Band (P.m. noon OI In conlunctlon Ith the delving (P.m. on *state. Inc Meium.ls also -build" to. Parade s.. i ' In old the ersl mpita In lawn, wnfch Another band ass added. to tart n a It' ere served Song with' the 'usual drive -In fare In the. Malt t'shOr an their propertY-' Being -'family' minded, the ccuule welcotitrs tanufv yrouui lebllee parade this seek, It years at rltl lead the sernon Rt parade before J :amos Prd of riding gtauns vets erppren. d by tan Anti, rlttbs and will bra i lout add EP3EMBER 2/1, 1882 rr mwsrArrst E-/ja (7) FRIDAY. OCTOCER 1 7, 1').77 .• _ FIVE CENTS PER COPY iales lose of '39 hlitir !Ida f ins senora lurks 7r-irtslionit-his iloltstirril re Mt lent • nth the PA. 'he berurre Etat . enerattriy portrays Err horst .err. ill trade 113 res.. - era/ e•: re. " Se:tort:tie In the report.. • de-1. er:SisairraltSin . tevpds. are :disk': •. SP lintrial'alEo • : , is., ftionOmitisWinlits,iduhaireY snlitilbuting ier no Small as' to the rtratohl el she arnarte.- It - . • • • hi-hese, tha Increased tn. •S."3 s " Inch raoreIng troth Outside ' \ .,,1 • ri 1." ari • .'' • •`... . • , reline ihe sole3 horn.. . • 1 kN o \Ls, ecterceermer 'moo mean U7Iion...1y na‘rita In the. end that 10 e Se';. epres itonipt ir ovine rho! on 3 \\\ iris -ester odds to the Krim tri 'k` .41 r ed.tar"IIt 't e- ' .!= 4. 1,‘ \ I (. - ‘r): T111).. dirrot eta curie from r !tat „side en„,, „„ (horse E. II !tsarina, oestrelary er the ',Etaa amber of Colornerre. ,eptee3 hands (dons ?dentate. the Iasi of ores 4.4104 sheet of roan sar- i I,,s. out thh weetk from the chamber ofilee. locluded In the 3.,-;irca,.eitfrisPP-Styrei-gdatttotorpler. of-dasosseloosatoes ad-COootattatosslaralloo., :wishes, men6„,‘„, ttn and rooted' orth';-inirriffieirdErtiferblaPArainaltSbortoshebileu-.... ;pope_ „„ which are belne mod to Chartsbers of Comentrare throolhosel Calf - or In e nem I, „en r mane hikes anti (olden; se -at ear tx, In Ansa., to repoutals for 1.1fOrnitnalOn Nollonad Caly, ohlotr dod,ylai elopmenr aye!, make uP a torso pert of the nahrertialng and publicity which the mot one nneortow thy. t,i4„, rite I-rest-rex through Chamber oellottles--115esaltay Minted:. _ ' pimeloh of Contra Creha founts Ah'il;i12';;771ls:1 Volunteer Workers Needed hi Home' f 1)10 61/1V711 talflOtOrir. ' Areas of City, (hest Chairman Says Anti-Robis Shots 1400NAMES,,, LISTED ON HONOR ROLL • Roster Published So Corrections • May Be Made Now.' Over 1,400 names of tnen,'A and- women- at -National_ Army, MavY, Marina OOP/ Coast, t.l'usrd ami Other for; - .54 ewl of the United Statta during World War TI aros-liolost Haws to glee funallhos sad frionfig his otrek In the Nal/fens] oittsr:.1 of aerates roen ger 0000rtunril sheik ari rissous•betorvtlher-A1' are finally sneered and,111MMP.....3-3,3 id at the -mires** Of :the Metrearlal Bola in City Porn; et-e7tut.„Ifek of connoineel Won Memorial wax Ant anWpoiTet1::,,A4 during the Wm. yearn 'The Itonorri'e'l roll VMS' slirted41* ennirthUllatiad seek, Maids _ Memorial fuhd and keld Inhell;h4 by (he ahem ot chine= dete=e4q under Me Ctitiof Lpfet win3er. when It: LeffenMe sow:rent that' eortednisiiken twedr.r he eterred on ttet $76.000'W MOT IR the' ntiy Mtpret le".`reke444 naps, committee tinder thd ar;„,pL Manahlia of NILE. LABS; EtRifir-I.:, Minch Wok ereer the wase.7‘,,elhsO0 wade•and fists rehtch bad sinineM uloted: throush the the tornadthee titoh-nrot" *441.010* moat aretoue disrupts Pf Pet', i . s- . .. • ...satire to base Sk•mrort call at emu CI ''°.tai4ling''619'..h14whi':'P'dfrIt • doolleattona and arsiskaa. usAa .v. nate, sanooneed this i • . home In National City itt an tall- est' Stiltialiat• th 'T°.' 14'4 in'. Cbrdada .1.0t"C°itta. latIbil2174..140,4.:%****,...16W : phleir ran be partneri nn to h., °''''' b'a' 'z*. Chirr a '''4'''' i City Host Tonight peek. . u cricased Quota aset foe this yew: ' to o‘toiot;o4ro thot ou .. P. Ith'at °X1‘3.• 't itTo I •ague members ,., .., ,v,,, b•,..!....is.• in . Mita. PlUrnb .44a. iliati Members of thari. Lions aid, sent lho. Counts threes ork deptire- ). ' 1 cl,y ,in . boo. tr, the city and meet se the 'Sene.O- Los. realist* Oil .LILL ka istidat. • • 1111 h• a venue. treen er.35e Owe,. i'"Tel. Dr -en l'eneltle thrennwee- at The LIC44. 'Yht'd IT' hh.'" "'1'°i' fm. Sale" 'Itai'l ' *thus th$ ithh•I ' trrient. 33111 lee at the lianm. f , . ,.. -oufff 3 „,,,o_„,.„ yo,„3o,.. ors, I Lewis- of Coil's/smile- Cities tOs , - .. ; " Phithaistreginbliiiiied wilthatlift'-,bdtirlst-• ../ ire7 ,a.'. Ie. van -loafs ail eirest• lidatill at iliO denmstaMilis Bialidinst,I. A stimsialitape need* ini k. .Ittii, pro'rett 1 reh !Wed rat; ttnet 1,,,,,,,,hy 1,, 3,,. ' fh4,. o„,..„‘,..o„ In -way-onnonocteel-this emelt.- - Tentler.. MM. Dare, ROorte, Term „i_f1.1ef. ;-m,,A..„,, oo„.„,4„,..,1,,,„•_ 1,, •1 - VrinChhianisher at. the .dineeer nay prceerm Minn nel..-TeerT; 770.:TlieeRPk• r . rneree, of the dept i,..,n;.4...1141,.. llinelitul- wiTl. he 7.4wIri J. Cooley': MM.::RobeeetWIlltenne'13 M Meta: Vie %puttee nt, : • The .,...A,.f,.,,),i. ,,,,,, i„, • ro,..1...O.O1)11 •Ii'tlf a rp attectoe of . the city' Vie 4014 ha the .hoidentlal nether. bfarnoripi itorwt• Az ' somi.11.0' -:. 1,-..-n,-. ssei- is s. stSt,,tiss ts, tor i'Fttirs lnotet te iStli OPeuE bn - This i iona. club. ehiettitIttpe, twet011t.: the flee pelt:- but ri,n,,ss. s r,ir..sa "he, •.'N.r,r. f`ill?T'''"-,Il ler "Te-nlih 'verde...h. will andie Butler. h Loins plersnieetish' We M;Ale iiec. .:..;.... UV .. . . ... trhe h ',hien Its a des sr ii.,.11-",l'^^"r_, '''r ce4", .re4:- Cehh''Y 'IT" ' piosed of goy htven„. Robert Wit. hener.• conetruellon - work sr elfin of. niandi.;t:Ine• 4he41e1e. it e" "'"' 'Y'lle--,4-1,`.1.4.h.f TTle- P.ronuiloneri mo3,,,,,-ALTon ,o..1rAy..y!.,3be,.33. the. Bowl. hos bees) icon Oiriel:•,': isviiiikrrieE -aro: olciantny-up.:- hal. heen infecteti hi ll,.. •Ireart .5titt,',.9t hew "rull.Cety and dile. . • • feetewee. - . : • • . •• ,ere the WU [ yCArS - WIdS ,I.i,e14..trn ,, „4, .• hm" 1,rti. tor,A., hog -La ettrinre sad -plianabLulf.,thd;T:,-,,,. . !sprain Lo nal L con • .1 MM.. E. h. Cheat man. bait been tierenits. neorly hai doss prey, llir`''..".Iv't t'l 'hf 7rd"r*i Pc- -st - nis.iNteereOori tittle me- •nits: ""'ine the h4hat hehd7. for :II": .'..c.i, 1- v.tet-Inaln! In Chula' a"1":1a. Ault' (mitt)", Aetttleg.• • • • • . , dedication rephriontes sehhh ari ochre- retain -mirth., at the cep. - I's j .._-_, a_i 'A ,,.- ../... 411e .MAtoria) sch.1:30. ctitfi! • 4 u" i''' h`4`1 '4i Ar"a°11" c''''*:";-:-'.4t. . • , • e r mss-,,-1,..--t-.4s- '..113YY- “:0s-•:,7°°r5"- - • aol MP ha . tie Of ,hF...),.. °r"'11' • . • TtrptatIvo plans for Vire &sits Atli trol.r!r'd I' -4.., igrv,-..n.!- .74-- '• -Fct Fottroar N.C.:Men • footle titane4L. in b, t'h"D. : ,than rilf. . tor - a pared. nt.:,-._:.-, ' ('+3 ISIrartatt, Novo) faloretri is erinnte" ht ‘"` el..t!' • • 'S • il..1.172.).da howsierbor • II. oblits..."1„;.a.',; - imirr live entonte. • , a, •,t th• 1;•.•.41'"Itt • 4 "hi.. a frog Iter. the'llre.WeleT. pdesient et fluters eenketi. that ehorkh..,„ . „in d „I. p.,„ Boad. •The eanitpt :.p, , for the vaccination' hero. •corina' of ilvialstirlor and ir ' .hatio Br; IStriS . lwa areert'h :14,0rh4rd J. kliarthoski; 'Alifeli.. *onionskins: Parent. Taos. - .- . la totresadifarts4 sedS ,iir: s avewsel 'swa*, and. the various 'clubs Of vt,...4. hizu .1.,,,ms,,,i ,,,,,, et I ' en?",""s" e`i"'-'',,. 'al'h'l •`"isi,',..1LI„rillite4.‘ Ur. Ini-re iefeurelen 'the the ehlt th.-t'et weellnit raetiihi3.44 . the fLac.rtatating c .,........4ni, endl• i'::11 "' l'`. "."'"3' .!."...'I:httienie,he4 tely-inst 0,0,1.1..' ilia tO have their tneenbers talkie port ,,.. ,,,,,...., ,fl. • ., ,.......1::: • Aii:-Nft'd.a: sUlsOrnd "Aar in -e- 'tn --*, 'ere-- i. I. .°1/3 *..h°'6 - iollowinif the dedkatIon • cure:•-"ilat; .. - , ,, . , ,,,,. d iv,, ti d, ,• - ' ' : ot a "tent' et•Tett. end the Nsani herr from Outstare rt to Novvro ,,,,,,,,,,,,, -!,.,..arnat..er and Girona- :'.,;;:f. - • • • • • Educators Speak - - ' .--:,',',-;:..-'4:,';,r, `:,.,.:i,.!,,,`,1'clt,',,„. k-Tr4.4.,. •„,,:, . w.,:,,,,-.4..,,,,' . =,th t.,,--. 1-6-- .ft:: -_•_4,; • • . - • ornoht address or the iadrieram of miline nutler at the national e.. t sw...1.,..4.i. ,, On- Youth Problems . .,,„, nrat ide Oro inaaked tit. thforita sk-sr?sa ref the Eirot Idertldnit ....ri;„,„ ,,,.00toL:ttor • bow, 41.4 thi- i ..... . . f I.b.a Ileventh $nteta't pialetel. . • Teleti-dt Snetrags titntt. .• , i-b.,aldhanait. m,. ,,eletaty .1.junktrot.h.,,,leld.),h6.teerher4,4,4 '7%t : te report an ioC,I VOullt Colic!). i .---- ----- - . . . . ---....-- . • ',.... i Oros taightlehted Lhe Prograrti ni ' O be So I • 3, --.. — - i #3, .. „ t. isendee bands will. march In the -".•;1. • i'' -,.t"' N"Rr'e4 C‘4 i7°1"4"he mi. paiomar Oitserialory KeStiii_- - ornarictl al its worytno fel she'rEY, • • - monies. journals and take part in the sere-- ,.... . , •,.. ':' !''•''' I"" .11'4"‘I''' elir6ii ttC"' Of: Dreams of 15-Year -Old Boy,. " -, ,I.,• ,...,,,„ thorn orninrs ohms In Nietenans :groups. •• Bay ores Sre arairkIng on plans. .'" 'sae ono. inn :M. " Astronomer Tells Lions Members .. ,Velcr4n,s' Chni,eliniting cohnsil. ' 1 throilgh OLP recently formed . al Itearkut'S addre,ung the Cann, • . . - I to take part In• the posidie mid- • ,.. I sire 4Lnirt W Lantrarrrisi -lire -ino-inpIr 1.4.1....f6), which Is bring readied for Palomar -Oh -Aar- I„., ,..„. ,,,,d,,,,,,,tkin. - _ :aqii!uner 4.1(rndattei, er,,eIntaind eathte It the !tont remelt tri.the <If [PTS) 0( 1 ts-reer-old bop pe , . a e.f OW inlInn. ,honl....- .1.atne- It t'lafatt; small Of Spite Coltroe, told, illortIlara1 of the LItteet eit•!.h.i • LI•Lort Eirtineinary 13rS•P 3 -All ' ' 'Goor'a, FlOr v. HAW. one of the grease:3s, peontot era emtronomy haai New Manager For - „„,, top) rInteoldvnt ' sl., lOr Sas , -rat •t.,•Itrotair evrnink. . . . . , ,, .... 1 e,,p; e. ...,fahana,,!,,,t. s,..,1,i,„! . a, r had.- ies .irrto, Inirtritro/ in thr ;serener when is young buy. lir.: 'ea Isiah- ',Imo) :lett. Utast - I,' • ,iratti, '..1.t- ,n1 ee a re,..et1. of e : - . - • 1, Strout Realty Co.,• L. W: Ell Le: aird Ciro h - rt'..i4h.-.... ,,,sk t ILP :collet-, !argent ' -r .-1)- T rtaitati'a. ;w.f.( po,a), oo, ..,..f ).."'Io-at i Til) us.o .5111 Op Otakollrd or), , Yr,p. M4nor Fires . ; Mr. Mary W. -.-.1heels, oho, re. •--- or fee- of f5uff tuff, ef.,,e, fi„.„..'.rep. of PA i ontr r n102.11- n In. ' Extinguished : cOrt.1)' became -Inc National City ',U.,.... E-Vr-Lnn r.7. '',.tta,.,21-.3:111arr, -I 'CI,' DI 492, 1145'. Oren ourlang ot , brunch rnarvattra. for. Lisa Strotit '• , U, ,'^-,,, Cr.,,,,,I. e-ere.e,.. ty,1 fl....."..M., ''''''',...,, Ora'.Y.at,,,Y, atOLP 11. Tilt tire drraaz tines -a one ran, r Realty Cornriony, o hat.) haa a_ _. . ...,............- ,.. sis- .., ,.... „„, „ „s ,.., c.,,,,,,,,,i, [tees , shrotashout , the tinticet .• - ...... . • i 1 -lair rnalra problem cOnftweellou • the Tflencroul City Community To Be Ghti.„0 Dogs. . chnt drive.- Arthur P. Butler. vice prtaidenl of. the Lions shah and . : etridesnon of the annual 1 unel• salting campaign. said. 1113: to gel TPt• 'It a and eerily 'Lotin-1th". 'turas-e-a to canvass the reOidentlal areas.' . .OrkItts tt,te0 htt te 061' 1 ThA, •e e ttenxtetroan Itraten clhiht ond cri-satiliallons and- InntvIdunle r• nomad at rahini. 000 of Oro' :to whams -es to work In each i,,,a.,... of the city.- TrIaLative piss ZT:tttiN 041. ti ICU ts'rorr roes. • Noon.. An', wen Sin 0 lf " T H -.LAPS L.,Nt EXTO ihritfeosos the rosSo la 000 tesati 3rat, theat halt, meh !mom ten euner mate • neelr next veer., een nem !Vote .11m ' aroatintre the Li: er Callfoinhcs, 'Komi seit tan /suit I r Mirlall it hall nerd he Jan. I 1 WEI be 9*1000 COkillitilt; the a4ttortrel ,in r.larte sill have m , hE, „iplhaosert •CEonailaals ..,,,Thr011tioner 4:411.41, Wing vtle-v O ig% Clt. 11 VttarnMeminent erstimos ei SIPSOLL $ wh ,-,F11 9r17,4 in tiorf,„..nt,ext reef t _Minty ‘,12't s,o intieh bolo. mj.tfunlori - BLED Venda F H ;i• ALU REPAI' XF.}401i .,HAP 'too Hiatit •G 7 - ELC FIX` - ttr The following list Of names of me„•and wo ineB •of National City who served in the armed fortes'dur by a committee of veterans' organizations. it is published to give everyone an opportunity to add i War Memorial in City Park, and to make any corrections in spelling of the names listed here; Please added; use Coupon No: 2 for any correction in names given incorrectly in this list. tray.. St n • Jr- N. N,.4-hf 11- .a1.w, K.r•il it ALL pI F.Aa Itln i. A,t.t:. Om", K. All•q x1.T`p•l !, .. \AK. '.14...1 AIMnW. 11'...ut I. Amu 1t.tin l', AA1MKb..4•, J. Arllia: NL-Me wary[ Al ...I. Iwoonn ''---�Iwl.e✓-roa.mt A11.n1J; tnqnI J _ • • I A.ieb.. a•J.'r, . I t.wU.. Are . . A aIM- J.� 1_ a. w-wb aaex:01. Ad41•!t IAtla IS .tM� tir>4 U Aw, lru Ater.br., ty..a. n R. v , • iI nttia .1,..n.n% K .. lrertl Ir. ArMA,1MYp.b wnqK A.w. .iM It, wuG.lew .Je•tl .. Arlow ::lup feet, 11IM . !. - A/tubT. rw,It1..n1 L, lt.r . 1:. 1ir,I ) t. • Wall. J arF - ' WIC MaK•ar fr. tet- Kii.h., II.UiJet'a IW1.Y, AIM! T, • 1W%K IrWWerrrII It K.rw.1 r:J>:A 1 1,.r. Iri.p]..hi r I. YN N.yLa h.a...Rp M. SC: .[. 114.41.t5 114,.1I t' ,1 tl • 1VIK Aid,w ]` �l11.1l.11� lRiM4 -'T. . n. ti • IN 44t.: iy....A.. 14!nrk.1014 r . t14F;y1b i.J ' 1. .. )•:, • . 14'14•�!. I:1ft 141tr t1:.411't. .. NI•..,. IM:•rq•1 ;Y.. 'hd,G4it. h"J- t •I4d..:ut.r: o,.m.T. p.. t,. h.. w: f1'• It,. ' 1nr,. "-a G.A.,. K. linlr.fl•, If..l.4 Y. '. 14NI.N.' 1r 1.1t 1,'. lvw1n4M•wwty • Irts-J..Il,. . -. 11 1 ; ti j IM:N ..: ,F h )F _4. ... i • 1r44r..r1 as lai.hy t )1 1 • I. y-' 1'It; lilt 1 nibio ?kl't 1 {t_ W. Jt; • Ib K.Kr+K,yr 0•4.: 1 , l han. . 1 krh 11 mrit f f J T Y: 1 4F.'..t.. 1) L. ' 14w- Y' a Ti Fri. [ Y.f Ir clkr. 1... 14 d , t' _ 1. i1yRii [ r' M VMK,111we1w A. IFwwRlt i..w.. G . Kai It.,,4'.'1uKr • 'x1.w_li 'UillJep. It. K . IAIt.l}> ll434, thews.:II..••u 1 ll-<a.ptul-lt . !p7.4i.S..n +' -JL.. Iwyw l::y J rwli... J•33 1envK.1.1, - rib,. II ,..n t.. l.4 .ih +J..w M. lbw is W1. . ,IG}35' • 11.14..ai 7. - Inawt » 1 1 4. oKa.a 1 1 • Wit + I.1,•!r•1 a, ' IKvI.Kf F•M., F KN 11 I..IY J I » N rr1 14t T..i..raM• 1 nth,. :4h1J'It . ^, �J 1• t' F n q L 1Yr1 ti. It, ,. I. - 11 1Y .Ii•itr. U p t t',, 1, 3J• W .i i 17•1f .l a hI..K. Tthu 1 , f I IJI I.,e II.4..1.1 r r 4.•. 7.,.. fot..l 1. 1f Whhn+. It rin.l 5. .JN1ifu M.w b )! l T. U 1 is a..• N IL' 1 '> J . K N•. 1 F..N i. .1. V n of K ,x 1i.t!4 11 1i Mr • w. ,If IJ 1• V kif ••• • LAN p'.- .J r et, 1 } a , r'I;.- 1 Ir- W l$ t u 41 sir •i t 1 . 1.. 'l, n Iry.. 1 �. t • t -'Il T {L - 4n..i.•. Nt• :. . . , I a. 1 ntw1 i"". r k w A I n , i ht [I YI 11 t -.. 1 Y t. 1 f ty 19. Y h . i. .0 ll -W I `r t 1 i 1 F N ••• ' N it H- I r, + J.n..• el .-• . .. W. J . 1,. i COUPON No. T .. MIKS LILIK EELLE PLUMB CbAmmite, Vei.,11N Con.t..rlet. Wan Ne.wi]I M i:wt1C.v. Cal,. wd6 toe- lolIs ..q n..4.1 to hnr. Mime It•,yl B,AT.(h N SenJc. Perabr1e41. ter KI-u n.RJ 11:r. • K5,4., l.0 h A. A,. J..I. Kale. mat K1 ,Nt, yr K.n.K.e N. 144.1., 1.4,1. Kyt: Wont Wapur. 11. K.K1,w•t r? Kmi, HGw. K.11rr 144, Nub K..r_.1t.ar, Kar1J, Yarl Km:4i4 1•" Anw 1 . WW1., 1.atlirA 1 -- w.-..,• 1't 8 'K .i I.,...A.f J«. law.IG., We . I.,.. W.I. 1 iwt5 A.1.1 Jw,1,.n.. J1 Lab..,, VP l ..... 1! I. 14.411V., L. t.,.Kr- La 1.a .4Je-aa.n5 f J..- 1..1 , .4, gut l.,,NII . law•ihlm! 1..67i1.4 1l1.*It OPtaaammn, J. 1n MiK. I:.wwm••n, 1u liyt, " Am IVR J.. WI__ A l.ut.)4 any. 1wu1.*Fla • IY.I.n.r, a - lr1s. J.m 1_.... PI 1_1tT ,nI, • • ! 'Inn 1yl,lt, II COUPON: NO. ! itS tILI,IE BCLLE [LtItAW, '. • CAMUNn.'v., .K' Com1lanlltt W:e ¥kr,oful IEAU I t*A.If A.eniK. _• Nanopa C•}rl Ilamt-ti .FrAr•Kll%111ed )1{: - Vle3r'0440e, U: . t ,1 1 J i,n )1 tNitnApi.. Y,}IT - IY N Ir - r 14rt.Kill 1k 40,131.81.39 r q.tlw.14 rA 1. P14 r. K•l l.r.. 1. h ,•{Pert j'1.11 N •I 14:4 et 11• - • H �. M R J 9 4 i _t 1 T. 13-,11 M1t •11 11r l y K. IL II 411' I m 7, E '1 J 1 4 1r. iFa" II1�.• iL ' .. M . 1 In , Ilu is l.: J. ; . 11. t a 1 1 - t t V li h 1 .I,•-.. U 10 ... I- th1 1 jw .Uwl'u1, •1 .. 1 •11 11 I •'w N.J L w T4M I. IJ A 1 1 ,-. G 1. 1 J' Ii •.`! 4 1.,..I1 J. I/ 1 .41Tl. llt..rt J . N 11Asir rhn:. e..l-M It. 11 II,' f. • /Malty. .41$ t !An11. 11 ;i 1$.: T. .rJ xwlly :2 ue J- ,I•fI>)JI>, th.ry. iJ.7 IIN/K4n.. JlIwIlod.A.3•T II.IT II r9..,b: 1 r u. tu.l. a A• Iw , J M .1 •K Y 11 llilKe.M-,�- ILI K Ili Uith IlNI..m. ty 1, /L.44..1f,}.Mt J'_ t11t1r..j1 y . J4.li.wa'.i�#r , ':'. L II L. Inyi4 AWL )1 MrI. flylli.'J,J:w C ¢1111bmp IUF J' IT YII. M• 11 !) 1, 11t, 11, i' Nyrl,.a�n 1 1 'It•IlE u r J.b K Jr. 111r p-l411::1I I1.' a 1_• •b 1 ,• Ilk's.. It. lInI I. N' 11J t. a aYIO J. 3110 . t 1, . - ilal4yA' 11N 1- hl'W 5a Jr •1 ,-A'+^ _l 1 r Cu. fir: \..rt,M-L • Jl Y1. N 1.•1 ha N R' Ai•1% VT - 11 tan. If,> r ft_ F'.n•4T. 1 )nn,'It. I,iJ-a_ R. i,pJ J. r'ullu,l M. _ - Waramt 11 L:rf T: rr. Kiri J. low. 114..., W. Jr. I 1.9.1 3.4. 3. 1 z.lrn l'1 M K. two.. . J w V. 11ti1,, 17 1 I?. J 9...' NY11 q P... J 1p 31, 114 It'. .1. - Slhrd +.t 1: J' ,..t t U 1K.- J ,. !. IK 17% 3 . p1. 4..$4i• C. J..:lc 14 rl•r. • I. J } r R 4......, n.....3.1.11. l: .. :it la la Jan J ..w 1 W. 1.. J.n 9.0' 1 •.. IA Nxl J.•ly.....: K..•iw% •,...1.. 4>. 1••r J.,_.,. K.wr.,,w \, - 1.4.5. U... J n.i.r..l.. I«u1•,. U 1t„ n.w.wu Y ,L 1, ti•K., J.,.r•. ,uj.' 1.l 1lbb T• Y.n.% to \ ., 1Jy�: \'tr. »n 1 1 J1: ♦w. J 11•J Ki 4•!1 ti. - M. 'rn•J. J'ir,A Mtn J 7 - L•.1FL.t. J ,., K• J sw: . II :1. A 1'I-ra. JY p.n ,Ir K. it.i'.WUM, J 1:,: IIM 1 t J Ya1t•. N. J 1J. ,1 Y - Y.ti.l,nl .1.4t....4. U .. K..' M. ARM•r, M,"l.w.' J:An.4. J•- L. - r1.>J.nr. FwM' AK ,J I.. ai. rwr. 3. w,.Nt. i•I tf. M.•8. ,. I Ian..11 . \ - IT. Vr 1 .i, 'I`..11r.n Jrn4 V.r U K 1 ,n' K: .1..'..m.a.1 JH:mw t I3r , »J.,:-..4., . Jtryl.l A3441 \. Ia. .. *...,-• J IVw... n M ,I n M•ft J J h lS, 1114. ,,Ila • Y 1 15: 1 N V( K - tt>',l.n: fan yn. 1 M J' J' tt,, u L • M.t 4ian,, J ys }I 1% K • L. .I:: 1 ,I .1I1. ll Byrd • N1.l WF.. J O n -M Ina -Ir M. h.tI I lt• IIIe. tl 1 MwnO,n. , K.}1,'r to [.' M�6113b J. At11i5 l N t: \ Lt9. h. r, I: k hrUY. KrAYA tiF_ .,y - . brim 41r1,{YI lb.,..„. . K.rst JAr K I,r lYallliR Mara[• L' J. J�n.:r. WI }.Viwq, ,I.r IAIaaR.. UIIIly11 -S ..Yanh Jai Kllrt.A.. Ka +1 M.Jt,.,., t 11..ImMU +TI w % TJn.-tl1ty 1 Rpe.e, Nuh11.4 1 �.IHIi. IL ' 13.r:.NS 4 1'nr. a b.,. 'M.a:.-1. k 3.4,.et.,... M.,M.;+,n. 1 The Publication Of . This Honor Roll Made Possible By • MArrHEWs BROS., HIGHLAND AVE,- CLEANING.& PRESSING. = c `1:17 " - RADIO CENTER POSTAL EMPI- --- - 1 - I E28Hy611gd A•ef,w . H.s...t:city 7-SEFa'. .W..fi .....Fri l.: l.r.K -.t4nM4. Kay AL a.•.ML'b,lt, 11. IV l.a 13 rl:: - 1..In{• 1. H WeLLK 1L +. 1. d 1. r. ..•.M Ir1.. .. N - M- 'Ti •]Y i, 141F11 1.44eJ Y. •T• I.J} -4.4 L 11- ILL 1 Iw •4, 41. 1 i .N. bX I41t N 4 •NMH• Iw44•.b l..r.e •N- Il.eq 40..4 T. . :.*I*, w lLs* T. '.14 w •rn J. 1 )lw f el• A'•'I .: )•..•A. )Ms,H. ft. Nal 41. • . l:e:l.rrt .1.YH1 3.,. - AJw•:q I:AN Ai '1..g.. Pal•••,• • \rn r4/ Ir HTT . .A II..I:IJ N'• ALIA. N•.W A14...t1.-j:ap.IA 1. 3,14w. Irir. Rif 0, •'An J 4_' 3. Alolt .S.- I. AII._ 4e, lha..Y r. AnM...3. •'.•..11 A 'A 43. 111•11*. R • - .1r411. • J A b4..il.♦4. al••~trr•4 �. �•:wlttJll•RR i'AMI.Y}.r,.-' 8....r. yTl:i•rt. ' M•.a 11 ,~.Tn. A. 1 -1. 14 -5-t•.•-, t4*' - - A.ni It t..il fl l M•.. t�xriyy M' ]I4 )YNY 1 . AIM .A! �: A.Yr Jle. k•J.n 0. AIALLH.• Xs= It - - Ar.s.•.-A I•}N AAM N.LIT-K,. • Ass - 11 ,ire 14. Ati.�l,.f►�'.. 3'nilriy.J-Wt. f• 34� AlostNI IL. 11a1N, 3.4n •t• s 4 ;.AJ N.3#4_ .-t5:w .r . .., • S., kLH*, i+w 14;' • • I+A ......J ,..': W wIA . . 11i . r. *um r.•y... 11. I.1y.,. Nan IS 1ta.N... '. 3. \Y '..:r..4A Jury 1 1.11..4.r .l4.' yL4.Y.aL Y\'Iw.1w lJ M. irN • 44 Jr, �N•Nr. 14..4r11 L 4, 34,,.. A.Jrlrr S 111.► 1IM ``M M.PJA J(''' •,`:+♦w+rJ:rS-r-•la•t•i+..-•..x- .•i: i:... -. - . ' Thefofowing h" tof names -of risen and women esf National t iiy'ivtio served in the'rirmeid f re`ts'durik by a conimi#tee of re: terans'' organizations. It is pubtished.to give everyone an opportunity to add an War M'enwriat in Ce arkt and to make any corrections in spelling of the names listed here.. Please_ uel added; use -Coupon y,it 2for any correction in names given incorrectly. in. this list. , • tI+IJ 1.4, •Sn,. M- XIIIiReMTNY. N. rlun KI•+ . *Hays, l K4e♦.q..t l�1...L' • 1LLN�..{{1d7yy�Iyy��,,,,,Jl 11 I11Lr o..�'ren F. MsH L.INr .y 9. , .,.k% AMS♦M. AI11.1.. \Mlle LI•r:1Vs . ..1 KsPa**A, :..0...1H . Klite. Jnps KIN4. r, 1:en. K.♦i'HI i 1Aret `•Y4..3J34 1•-ur.n 1. p.nl1 IFI...1n..J{n- Yl 144 Asia:.I14 Ka..., 4.0 4.01- C♦a4,t Y- • 4.1I... a. aNy LL lt•'I..ry lawn I4.10;'Wrl1i M Issses*:. NHS k **Haile.!)NN J.t l 11 .',1 1 y it 11u1:Rann1 3M.. 1. INA.,TA i1•t: '% 11. IILIWI M'I: J A, P': **Le 1, il.a.l t< - I.i..e.. N.....rr r,, .1fi.IHu: 1.i 1. lll Nr.. \\ill .V.)' I,.....•.r Y..- LY l...N \. - 1 Ib MT: N.lyi \.. IYdl.q '11•? , M I. n 1.. • 141 11-4 I ..• Ire hP . '•.'1 - tL.11.... St. Li. J. TI 11Yli .4 1 n rr•(. 1. N I II. J0 . 5 44• M1 Mz1:...tM 1.. • lira .r..-ri.N i1-. J.- 1...4 Ns. - i•. 1TI y 9. -. IM pa. 1•.I.JJ. 3 . . 4a Y J. N4r,1ni.' l.- . I. f!_ I. , J-.Ira. IV , llin l 3. 1111r. .Rai. ISA.441 1JN t•4 -I IRLJ•IY.^'1 r4n•1.' 1'4VNn 1,. tans. A - IN y. k.b+ 1'jlr•• ,'14t.: �y3 i .I+.I1.aa•RN1c,W i1,.4 III , ( r4�0` 4.,gblrir Ir; . t'.'•4•. 'JIp4 33, A Jn .'M3Jq l 44 1.,4 He p...I 1• .vAr' 1r. fJ...r • £. . 3.• T f!,r a N 4_ J M Pt } N 1 • a.. -3 •.ik 1 f T Y144 e• 1 le M J•44•J \', i. . 11't 11•) 4 1, •k..lr• -Ii+J.11f 13 6N 1 q l.4 -1'♦ 1 1 4 .. •Ih..w•: 9.. K' 3 VI u.q.. n. arn. a W. • M Y V... K...r.ap, .3 V'•. a • t1 IM. ' 4. N: .l. ,, 111H .J K' I 4\ flirt 1' Y1n..1. la Ls. I Hs WA"' Is N. 41 14 AL L• MII 3 a• 1 JN 1. N:.1 { 4y 4 1 I 1 1. , 1. at lr- 1 rl•e 1 4 q •1 J. .,1 T t. •la .It IA 1 r. l r,:a r. .N .* t 1ti1. AWL, AL 3, 3' i.N✓ 1.1. - 1..vr.•1 )I. 114.1144.r 1 n IF 1. 1 1 J Il • .. 1 h 1a114. Y V i 1 V 1. 1 4 1....4. •bra. 4. - .. I! - . V • COUPON. No. 1 MAS LILLIC BLLLL PLUMB {�f.y�...r�te V11i.Yy CI.YeNlrw, Was• Mmmi al N.twrul COY.. CAXI. Adlf the Ip1b*144. name to Inl: 6;NNry J.1 klr.Ee • COUPON- No, 2 • MRS LN,UE BE.U.tr PLUMB,. . C8.,. *.n. Vetr:anN 44.404110, WI, Mrmpaial. t'J'10 H0444:1-Arrmn, -. Nsl p I Cskl. •--A fume ii .rmofleelly Mlld a; elta3e _champ mr. 4441 M.rnr:,. • f...1 fa m B.anrN n/ S.nKt.' • P.po.yJ bT' 1•I:F.al . 1...•1 *ALLr 11 xJ 4' blla.In 1 4r '1.+N P )t• • 1). 112 -1 n 11. 11 =.4 JMw.-11 IRI 1. JN• 1 1.r it 'Yab .1 .._ '11ti h.p,In41, 1 14 1.4y N. 1111 J...4p .:la. .L 4.1•r 3., 1...41 .R , 3' ...i -tl r 1_ 11 I i A- I,4.44.11, V� 1 1• 1 M .. 13. • 'F 4 11.1 Il 44. 1 J -2. YNI r 3.' 11e , ..* ] 1 Y J Wi )1 r41. 1. r 11 )W W- J .: A I4 1 =+ .3 w tfw.all IJ. 31 w 4. Je li 1 J• II .lyn . , J In 1' 11 Y• Ile "a 1 - l U i:a.ro u. 4M 1.. 1 e TN. J A Tart. -- • 4 u.. T. 1 4 4. 1. L. Iy. 1 - Y', k.. 4 Hass II.' 11 11 L. A. 1 4 1- 1...“ AL: 1I 3 .p:,, 11r 1'... J 1•,K ',Lot L. ry..i....I 4, • 11 1 . ..411 t_ J 1 . 1. 1. A. r- •1:.M}I Y• 1/......1: Ita W*1 r. l J.:.i. a.uy4 b. a.f14.. Y.( .1 4 Jan:r P". anon+,•b l 12 4 11 1In N l J '1:11 1 ) x I.-..t ,3 ll 1.a.t. list.-J.listo-14 P J r ;4. 4 1 • a N i3 1 I. It- - Kil FI J I'1J1 11 1 4. tea: N 3.. .. M.4F.).•1_.' J 31.A Y -. - - J' M:N.h..nt r I. wal!..• I.•V1414 Y.a•.T N I11 HJ lr-1` ,3P J ism.1 4,1n ..1 4 N Y. 111 t+1 1Ls - a 1 4 4 .. u•111 , ) .1. W. . J M• I 1 ]UISI; 1 a4 1[ It J�rwl4..133 a+ yr• f I r.b111[. 11. J. IC l'�rrr 1 w41 .44F'A J. l \. X •t M 14 i11 M' iSts,1J tlll em 1, J It' lyl. Ii •,. N 11 x . iv..". r. .•. l 11a1 - al• Y 1A' h l J.L u. .i,s=i 11 4.14 '' A 4 JaHI f 34 11 t,r, 44I.w l-lA- t- 4.11. H \i 1 . t a u. ll r u.r.:1,a J T 1 Mt.. LoaSiti i' L [f Yr.l b. 0 ] ..Y • 1IHOL, Wa11m K. . aJl . 4 - •�1- I m4 Marrs. ..♦,. A. 4 Mr*4, fi•3 N. . 'qyL . .I.t �, A 241.w •. 1+\4IJY .I. ' Il.ati•:rir:tl:.s Tn. a.w Y. IA rk•, \\Lllun -t I a33 1•.N L f 3Jin1 rionfIass 1eses LL11 141141 11 , 4. iLs I4 11s-i 11 *Ahoy. 1 •14u. !1 <� T4 nr L 1, R 43 Y 1b311. r Q J-R IVRe•♦ . 1 A1K,44, , t 4 Y 11 1•1 IYI li 1 411.e1 .. 1.1 Y LI.H. 1. Ja;.-,., nh >n Lanai.is I•e N. .. J 4h 11 J J 1: Ls 4j. J A,' .aT , A. • A..' JW...yu♦, YYN .•nr• 1. . 1.1..YHM• Oil {a.wl.�law; • 1.ali, bn Ian..: - A4N11 ar 1 !WK..to 1.'+1 .:Jr4 L1Ky.` 4 14111r11. .1 .44.n,l•1 Ialr.rl•' Ia.M ITV .4i1, bill f4444Iri4 pMJ3 r- 1.n Last,ilLa w* . I..I.y�.. AnN. 14,1•064, 1w le.,1. J•. n, liRli, !..•Iris 1 .4, 111••m.n Lase* b 1N•..J La I Rrn ..4.e IJ•w; n.•..n 1 1J.w1M•11., 4.K 1�•.11+W. 1..+ 3.a IJAL•s% 1..., Ir.�Y• M.v j r•.P1. • Iw 41,1 .. la•1l Ia *'3'.' Lamle i2*441.r.�.n;.i r li•4•.. -*Was -t.N., 1 . Alr.wl 1 1 ..w4- la. r M..•.4"'n� Lru,M ._r.• 1 lu,T• 1.AN T. LtHarPs.• I... 110AaAA s • 1 i...r \ I+r b. 44 4 Y L I> N 1 rA-n ..IIY 1. { t 14•n.n4l 1 - N.n•4. ( "-:: tan..: LALL. *AL*. 1 [ 1.r. Vista,* I..N1: N3.w nr41 LA1,11. 10Rnhnw 1 44,Ii In 1's. RI.FLied w 1.!44..'V il.m v :.ilaAtli mn. 1L C,l. AIb• N ....R- Y. 1 Sac. N• Yd'Alu. c 11a. • 3.1 .13.lan�d•4 1It V•Alll!r[ b1111 J1. . .•Y re .In V 1'14. v Ir.l Y [.. Lq Y. 'm.. nf.0 f u Inn.'a3Ern Y N:, e..•.• :: �1VII S. 9a.�.�. J� +IV•lNt, 11.11.• ssR a., J.a1.. 4 v.ir.M1.•••••kf •Yy.a • w'.1*I y�I�44A�.1.' 'AIILIALSK !Alt.! Y ^Cris!. lthai. • Y t1 l 14•1 Singh. 1 34. N n.1.NieevrIte Y,n.•n 14.4 Y.Vjr. 1,1.1•01 V rtMK 414.4.s. J�JA.J.4.r .1 Yin.... J.A11, . Maria... N..3...I.n : Qwnr. 'P.n./ 1. 41iHln..1..4,4 J. ao'rvrdiit the'ortriedfotterclariit4'Wottd Ward has been compiled f•- tryc.ne an opportunity to add any namethat should appear on the i ne names listed here. Please use. Coupon No: 1 for any name to be • f in this list.. t1am. N No. z- : .. M•molnt • ii1 It • A. J _- \F\ bIF Sin } tI JH.- x1N .M14. keel V. J!. kl M 14M II. w » tr41 K 1R.. I4 A 0 11.06... A I.il.letV R hut^.i. Tlyya.. & kiM, tlh..r a, A41-4 Aii .n»4 AI1NMw.'1�.g1 31w.uc• r It4t4- ; k wb.c wFCIt bra\ J..4.'- .. " klnf @'IA14111 r 100.4 1..:.\...1. Ii 4 -.Ni J. 100114001 H. kl t .,.N11N1fp.IF.._. x JY tY. A t 4y1iMs R ki ie.l sr- NNMr4 A• k 1t 1j. n V. k MII 11.4.21.61 1,466.146).4. 14r. C lJllld lhty.lr J I1I6 .ta. o. e el J 106y h fr. Art lhSWI.I J.ka. J. J rl.la .1 *F'I ft: 100. J 11. V. lee11..frr )• h.0Nk. WI10 C. JMfl . MNtta», rr JJw L6.•1 pp t. It I..f. K 301..At 1 NN: J:T.. k:v.rlF 1. 4. .. aMt Jln r} kea.k.N.' ' JwR n T J.J 0-t.,:xl4 .. - J.4.h+. I�u` 1L 04664. 31 .l.. A 7 l.. . 'J. •w. 14,4T J .J n... K X • J..N+Yrt 4 0f: W ulM 3.w» J F.-, J...fJ4 1ryy�v R^14A7' Jai.h V,,f J;N .ra M .: k _ 1.1J• t�113141 !e J• •. JYIM1• M.Ik .;k. k 4Uy. "J.M . YMd. McW11. r: f17f'1..J...6 Ai 11 y1 Jr. ' i•te,e n1I4±aq ' A. Jr yr. Illp.t1 et iJ. n.q CYar5J. t It. J*F3. :0 -i :i 14 •4. Jt 1t4J. J. Alf ••e K-.- _.' 1• t4. JS.tek Ir . • C. eft4.44‘' f 4. Ir1 J 1. !'t. I'4 W I. MNIk - t t p1f ` 11 4'. t. .3 x•nL , 0144 l.. JI ., 1.34. h, , )1 R • N1M.5J N. JJ. Mt..* 'I w: • FIT,.". llr r.rr r.. _W l t1 ..R+. leaf•!. Iv' . JI 1 }ll.. At%mr ,r • N Rj.JI. II ►rl It. 4N +YYuu 'A ZA • a4.niR. 11.\Ij' 1WJ•�'. N t It, Iq MJl r 3161..r10.,IJr.. Ni. I4: MN`Ikr I. pW. 5.•1R.11 J. LINer. 11.I..•M. 1.. IHIIIf.6 hN.... 1: - M.I.X.II:. »1.. 1 n. 11•s3r. it.+W.110 r1 N HIe 01..4.(W1 rl • M1N•Y, 1A•A• A. NRUb• r e¢l. ILIA• Ih •5. r•n .aY H. 1 rap..., r woman... 1 �1 ITI.. I IJ1• • . IF. .1I.Y, Alff..l. t•alle1J n4 1.. C. I .In...•. 100,4 lW 1q•.J.h le. 1 F4 14410 'Jr. 1 F:. 4 nlR 1 11 Ilb INy.-1. Il W1 M. I 'I.M•, II.N.•f h 1 M.. 1iN .•U. i rye k 4r in 1 4111.I.. Irr N t{ rk.n T. 1T.ntw II,eWa.J�.1 - • If III{nR ..•an K. 4 f. I, N 11.11•R N, ▪ A5MM1f: 1T'l.... Y . • ' • .I.F4.4n.n. 14•t.re i4 IA.M 4•, WFm.N NuC A ' a� •I , N...1... Juan • 11.,4• i :1 Irwi.t.r. Sr7, IIRt. ._ - N X•1 % .'.., 11bp _\. IwY M ,11 l Z T 'IN..41 iavl.. J4' Ya k4t`. 1 111nV•. ..IM.M r M.i/M 11• b ...r... t - 11 .. J'I A I1- r it ..r• L' 4a*4 M re y. 1•J N „ - • tarn f1..Jr4 11•' 4.v NNDk( If kkkk 1. , fro m 1..• MAW!'" k),ql M..- yJ,F4 (( JMlJJ r. Nafrp J' .mq..J�( rrv.Nryryee • lln bRl.,.: FwMn A Yrlkk..nw4r, Y Ilikt116%; N9141w Cy Iam1FAlfe. I� r 41r ... .. I. t /M.� k•.r' (IR�41 .\. ' 1..^e1M06. w•t+1. A. YbJl1eM. l Rim Nor IiJ•kR'! f4egl •.:•IMJK J'r.....1 Y:r Mrr.1 JJ, y y.rt t4 1NI... - . IJu 'rr 14r C. 1{rM M:..r, 't Jr. FFiT1T rb1 1 '_. II a-k Y:'trT 1 ` 1.Jtmf v ...»M W. Jt - +.\•�•1 1 irU' 1): 1NN l•!w4k r :r ..-ri.. U.m:.er[9 R. - ..,.n47..It mR Y.: iW.RR n•o t N m•[ !At; ypw•4J 1 M 'I. --J^11•• 1 » ,f+n: IIJTI, xi 1.4... 4 11tf. I. 1 it... ♦ f•1. V n.id •-I I W. u4I. .4. L t la -le JN.u. 1 I KI F I .t 1.4 -. 4e U - I..*.s1 Ir.lt. C. M fn Y1.».J C. I.Hl. 111n .1.. I.. w{t.N i >IiNjryry 61064 M I.J.^ KJ J 1 L .If••N lace A fl,_•,,, 1.400 11,. . I•e.4 1 Jt- • N Ryv I'... It 'M\H• I I..YIf V..- I..w..A r,u.I iC Ya.i 'Ir J^! V. l,00 lw-; t ll'� K - ..1.1^.. } ..w..3 r :1.: i�•rw4bt LGmtYi':, Iwb.n. fla1W W. %y.n.Il•WIM W. 11. 11k•.. i.x1. 14.' ' I.41h Ju1m C- - »!.?Y: k.w^e t1. ll,ii. t4.w.N '.A. . i..I,, ... -»ry Y.11n A*. ta.e.... W. % .'NIn4.. O .lkl.! 4 J,ss b.' Ii.0. r:4MM It. »W.i.. M N •- l4 Fi•3 1 WSII*t IZ . 11rI....- ..Y..Ut. K • N U. na II. .4.FIh/ 11'11y J t'. 1+14. Jr•kw K nl., wT,r.N^J V. Nw{. J f .34:U..4, Ar RW•'I:.'.. '. Ir,r1eh1.WIY11. A M'l',H.. n.T1" 'ik. ,... 1...Ie. MN K rktr- H.. Vk l - .IN..,4...r..4 A. rt Js-I tgy K ll.ni.l.i•,I Cv itkw W,• - .R}�I•.e�� Si Jlrn' Ii.11 I0! J. 1# .Ir.. N'.Ily $-. 1.6.60..A0.10. ' 1.00410 R•t I•. IA)14.. Mt W. .1 - 14•ka4J It.- .i p.t1�..1^. R 1HM; \.ItIX.4. I..el MINS„, N. 1.0,nf IIRt.1te Y. 1,•IF.e I'pl W. .. x_ . h!.1••, N.. l'.Y.. IIh1ry I.. 11410 AM4.JW - I.ry-N 141.11 P. » M NI. V..f17. ,... 11 I:.u•, J k It, 1lunln Y 4 1): ». b1V0' TI M}a., It. V.gnJN . JMVn » f. 1'$kp n IY..(Jb A 1tt V .4•. lnl H* Y ' 1.0. u.iro NI A. , N .R,1.. 1 ! i - 111i-01 •1 nJ V N_ i s.. IY R 1 t• I IJn4. ' i a,r.i 4 i 1tli. l� n 1 V• WIIINI! i - iq..I , "'Ake.), IC..'" 1 ..J•4 k M ?• - 1\JbylI W B 1. I...if•nY. AnU Y• Ni. Y 11• Jr 1 J.1e A. IRIb•MI n44n y. N {JW4 re•Y.1.A, 11'Uf1:.1 A ]t111 V. wow... Il. • Ii11.. J.. •if . • N...Y. Ks.. ,.;feR 1.- » 1141t.w. It. '. T...uaf Y - KVt If11WAI t'_ Manln,. 3.k,• J k111MMT- M1NI1 �. IlWli,1, I.'w WI M. N13.`' psi.•'. K.Pb4p •:M•4k Y. - Jlv_Y1,111. »F1,: YU1c f 4 .. kkn..tY Canis IT - Yanle.t. Nbt.w4l.a C. • kill. It.446.1 4 Nartl4t!- P. Mp V. KI . MATV, w• • I x.nrR Inc .AA' 11,. AmrS. 1.1�I�4I_.iIi I' »ym.nl. rf.J e' Ailwl I(41^rt »414iw'p. 1n,. Jr... w a Ikf- Wfprr .4I.I' Ij.1.r •1J• l..p - law... ft .Tll . it- • JJy1K' IJ • M k tr y1.- , •V-l. 3T n 1 Jr, rJ - ., ' S. .I. 0 W N 1Uf.i - YV..M .- % mN. 4ito 1 . 11 .4 Af i 1...11. ' e1, h J' 1k 1 J.A r • 140 JM yi.. 161.4... f L• Al rr•. I. 4. M[pT.r. 1.1•4 H, \ n.d. ll P %•n.i4T. l:1ri MIIN',: J31y111 V. YanS1. J. 1J. \.(!F6U FI J .nil T ii 1 \ ti.Ji. tJ 1 J. Y•J:ka4.1.041r14.C. rA(. rr..11. V.. \ •r.. 1. V 1010.1..tw.. JiwLL D. - '�•.�`FF• "I�n4Tryl II nF! f. YV1 - WillIs.4 .J, PL•l Ury 4 II. limy- 4 f.n1.- .41R.1, I, Mr.61,l. ..Fre. Is, ' in4 }r.11141 Ja.h.•.p'. • -l•.O 115406 I- -Uite. J !r I. .UY0II . ft U: • y.1 Ito N r: n4A.h.. Ia 1 M:' l.J r. h l• r n l Made Possible. By The Followings ee i;Hw;ewf L O: POSTAL p,MPYEES 1 . p..e. u1.IC V:- Jt IlWL I 1 M J:. 'n1.i. Y.4. ll:. N1I11.ki 1NJ1. J. .IN,JA1 f •0 li,' . • Y 1.\ n sa, 4 . 1;, J t •1.". • Illk-4lg� Mwwr K.--. .4.1:• M,41 i;1.' M: K..IN .4•he W. n..4I!•.N4 U11•(.T. ' ' yJI rtJ,.. "14Y IM H. H N.4,11 tl .l A411.' Ve1WMJ.If11 w.t'VW.Tetc '15444.t. V. 1['eifgtht'. e1.I1 t IC.' ' 1,. 10.1...r I,hr} Ark., lY•lII*L J ,MK..W, • 114Ji1Ni. I..•..41 • Ni . H 11W• Wn111 U Jr, 31:011f1h 0010 It - It J y4AR. n11l.,114 M 1 -..'•,. Y la! . w.nf'. kkk0 nY.Y: U{.tr(1p �: • t.^J ,114•I It. IJ,tldy J ..1 M J-4•. fit.60, M, F4 Il.w 4•r. • J 1M11.A141k r1111I A I. 14p4 1 1 V ♦V:.l. 111. tu.,. Ma tfet,. I'. NefeccAV Jl.bt II. Jrul. ni. 1L m-w't+ \ R}'. 11Nn 4 tat liwt.4bk t 1Y. J.. t:lln•t K UIJwll. 1•In. y 10 114n1e1:1-04 1,.. K ' ' 1f a-4 11Tl. * . Hw..,11 J.4. J.. i'Ir WFI r r• • ,,,. • r 1 j N. Ilt.yytr iI • 11.41.. It I. t F1 ls. 1...4..i.111vJN Ib.B 1 M II. HJr0. .IIT 1LM•\1 JK1 M.,.- Nn'tea k.' . Talk q 11•.R. Tali. 11.. H1a1J1. 0... . ;,..x .114 JupRR - MW lW.31 et Erne. 11)e J4 4w. It o W k'tikfveJI- I1N. •A . N•. HW..f4• J,.1 J. N•1ut 3YeIat • '_ tt.rvr{ytl(.. - li...dl., 1.1.1. Jr. Centlnled on- pass -t • NedowafCire 1637 Hiyhlend Avenue - a 7-9676' 1•436ipn41 City - - erl.n*5. M. A•NI4.w T. u n n M1N.nhll •KL.1, . .wt- un...n.,..:....R. r. ml•Minl.Jq. ,•h. w. Sr. ionic; 10:6, rI N.0•144. 1I..n41 ke•fe, N.1,4i .I1, J. .., . I a.' 1. f1.nn1: W. ilt,4,n I.nn. J. . 1 0.404.0 •ll 11 tM T. Yu...m. 10),.. .In II. ,Noon \ n,.•b•. N 41( X b..k .1 1 • ••- rtt bt b 1-• q M.•tl. W 'n.^r Il 4V!»1 . tll. Ir.. MItmere IJ..fn _• N.1 11• t MK IY w N.•.•m; 1 Rw., A nF Nk^if. 116,--0 .. .. k..a.n rn111. 411 IN.YNL A11Ik ft. 16l0. 1.1ur4 I. '1.I:3, Vw.1.4N 11. Uve. Jlwtl. », Si, it- prl. Jo. It T. Nkn\y. 1000 T. h_. ;Ili^Igb14. 004 .11 Tony.. •fllrn..IR.11rrM A.-. NIm1.w. N•r E. . .l.nw: Ie1Jr C• ' Vk%1I rr. KIN r,.. '1QWI!me.*JwW r.J veer. )r1iaN Jf i11111R 04eKK nniKk. 11 110 II. • AM^ V46,0 .01 1•. NrNf6, UWC. Y• p,n 4N .l Jw A. -+ WMIM Np•1H Y..---111.nN, I+WY •-•. N,..•1. r, Il�n1i.g 34n A ttwn••.r. 40000. NLy I. A: �.v.. n4ur •J; f.1>••n.. 1.1....1 N: . Mh rn 4ett41f, A1M4Wee; e'\"'' 1001I1•4441. If., 1n4WI.• ,,Yr1. I, bbYlr, .I11 I. k.n.p.F. It' A'.pF l h.p41 It: 113111*, `I 6f A Jr. Vr,.al . It ,MIVW . 4•t1:M N1 Lr ' Ilf.ri nn:4 It. M4r.1l1; Ii - F.r1 t 4.4,.nl 111111n PF4., T.rMN Nllflll^I.. ITarll. C. " Nn11n, a1'l116.. IA.'.' :3N1.s xf.11.141., - iIfRK.C. At' • 1144N r J V 4FIRIlttfltt e J,s W, p4..bl4rt. J. 1. Record _Entry' List -: At Annual'Dog'Show.- ... Mitten dog .4pga• 6o1HMff.d IS. t4 on : -that, w111. he- the *Walton '; i1, OIIIner, Held. 14111 Anielnf •PA Bundy; Oetober e. when ' Hf- . tfin till*. khteh .re et* M!r' of •On CYAtotn4 EJ1o1Rt<d 8pe14l-. : tTClube alaie ono- innuel AA!ne: holm b 431. tP S'.p11 . -• ' ' Bore then. I?00 den hbbb,been entered ler the .Tent, eelkdllled to be0R1e i tAe IVrNt ,t lbtu .- fit 41n1p9 Defietllon bold sir•. the . West Coen this year nienftll Bede. . pd Celebrated dot 60141 li{ born Her Yetk, NW Jersey 7ten. . tt. ha\hlt.g, ihh101e.Nlaaetlfl.. tawgo \, Oren end CdIW Yond. T. oo; prgide eyed the *hen clot, with Pag will *nee nide, night. Cate- letbmins eteeei Hurrrs FRUIT COCKTAIL 35c PEAS 1 a Jr. # IC001.01 0 teen age 4T MAO.. 'Imo,. MM. Juno H: - :Mum. .,,ln It. i.bur- Yrnnr G. i&._,», N.Mne. I41.t.r. rein Pw.PT. Yltw.•t Y. MIMJ*. I'.1., ohler+:Owl M,JoW, ,,.be HIrb:N R Var4.•., Jo. k. N.0*100, U • -Meow.. Arthur V. ..... ,ere Tana 1 Vwlln_ \Yill.. I. snot IM.M .. O. re - Ali d . bloom tr 4 1•-I.IJ Yin. 4i. Rest T. A ,V.r. ,.M `41'.r N.ma 1 P. • + Jar woihr 9 ldlnk: 1nt 1.. sehl..I 0. 10.1we, - ••• IAI4Il wAre. liti. C. Momper. [remelt N, SehtmR P••Y A. T. y1 V ktt 1 nvr - ycNlwed10l. T N n 4. J Jr NJ , ,.1JI. CIW n G ' Al ,ten . Y 1 1 }r Whawrman. M pn K N 1 ) ll. Ir- \t'-, .M1.n100w.*. N.•1'. t A :thew_ Dow \\ NnWI.. Ilrrbert R ll.r.,hr t :b.1t. 14nYwln J lyre. VAAI u,`,1. c 1 It 1J T. • .. 1 VI •t 1 1 Y t w ♦ R. .t 1 el rig FroSe . hfirr41.1, .'lln. N. Sr. \nee i_ lt.ltman, ttore I Ynytl, Walter n- aelntM C•ahe Sr. .1 wl rat 1Jb.ry I...Jb AA. C. RVJk n .I Serowe. E.l,nfuo. I tree N.e.ln• . Art . J..fin K. 'Niter, [:nowt MeA.M.lpr..4 Jwt W - - :Munson. yrank Jr, SSAIto, Allen 1;.' - ��..1aak sow, 1)JJ.��WIe.1J. I. - - M it +}� viwrwai, J..4 T. {1 VI o,S 1h,tira O. Jr. Shohne a. Jaye 0. T-.n.,. - }lu.wi THE NAtioNAI,Eir NEWS Y 1 t,. J T..waW wl 11 ht)0 }11111 J. T•.rx. ltml N. \'ell . mI Moue) ;n.IWnn. JIM N Ti Mown { .. I }:. - }"le 11111 fNllwyyl TrM H. Tr,n••'•.11' *0 ". F. \`In. soft .wkr Yynt . fine 1i T•y.r I1 pY R V.wnn. Yn0N'. ,nk,; Jisn T•+•V TN yIt. lhfell. lbinaIA It. YYrul.11ee. 1 reel l.. K T n1e1 \ a..', A Mehl,. \wrq 010,1,. Thew.. Y. T•It.. 1,.1111. S. - Verwoo. R...IY.. X. MI 00. Yt..J R T fly.. xllll N' BYw1y�or.. Crown: nlyy��SMesh • - \.. 1 1 T.- IIJIetr R ` 'Wiwi) 11FIx 1 n:J Ci.n1 W.tr; 6rY Y- 0hIlll} r.JA nJ 1. . •".roc 4+ \a. • A.V. ei YII J, vAry, r.km. N lnrrlfMl 1 alerris et Theolv. N th Y. r.n•.e11Yr, N'ONer R. • 'lIni*.nl SV r I. T T . 1 ▪ Um. 1.1,6 1. Tx^r✓ ..1 t - \ olleth el . -. IMwash -J t r H yet Jf. TYnb ..lowes i. \'NI•ly.awn..-YSJ!.uy Aktrrls. J. It, , l l . 'ten. ITad1 JAW.i.. n II R. T-•.1•I. i I.r iwF .L r1.141n M N.m u.Ph.n, 1 p r Tne. I. '4. Jeer sham.. W II JIV IR. Throw.. fll\.1 It r It. Toll.i inrm I (41V t W. To It It 1 11 K. '. .Mi. root 1 Ta.,of r 1.1 n' 1II., 11 ,1nMM A. t . II Hr In d 1- N111 r.., 11 1,J� 1•IJt n. I sir I.. Jr. • Tohrol, i A.4.4.. H. A 1. It- r eta maim... "sown. . J Tysw.. liY p , It, • -t II.W N.J uT TTim..1 11.- o. du., 1 II swat. U1.1 hr S. ,hit.,:- J.r..11. Y.1o, A4aa Hr 1L • matUA 116•414 C. ' ll.s.nba.., Ri'Wn•e• -- --: .' .VhrWtier. \then tr. amlth; RPn M So. .hen, Reshot!, Wlulll. 11ib. 1 It.. !lfl, rhhoot A. w sn1. N.1WJ ,o1 ,Io.. 1_ IY•1. I. To,lnr, 1.0 wei 1y - Sheti1.11 Rwrn R. aIIi.Vp .... .Aw.ntth 11. ,3I w Wt. ,w,. It. 4. - h M.I row.. r. rh-air Ihh. it .•. T .w1.I. , 1f 1 14AV11 . h0..1 A.T4 Yn . IV. FI h. C qr 1 M `4 I.rw, R t J Jr. TI 1✓.J. .4 1 x T Ie NIA 11 J+rF YI nY T .pM,,E uh !- T.i... ` h. YN+Mw 11 1 fl_. TI lu. \INf Yl. Tow n i Weirl, Mere..., It mall 1, - . 'n.sehelsri, 1. aVl W. I ai.fr 1 . 1 1 f1, b H.f. 111 eh Mori,. t* I.W.. M 1 Shlw:.100Ir SM...Y r 1111, TI .N, bYM1, ,u 11 \4IJ" n.tart !t, MN.ew.a. Acre* A. Y-I.n trio-Iw Nllnrww. Rey h, r li'.It ten1� h n-k Mts. MMus, e. C. .Lentsr� Rowiel r- . 3wses h.'n4r U. a inn LIM*' 1 ! IMh� J r. 31irMM:' MMI.rJ Those Iw• nM4re te.IM4NVMtn Nis l , c I w Wet. N.. N. welht-a: nwY'ft.' \.tterwrit. N.dbl Jet TI'alir• Nllllanu V. t•nul\a. lghn 1. T n'..VI J-k11 lyw 1I II. s• T Ylhh J 1 \ ) 1 Is 11 h1 1 11 11, TIW, �1 N.1 Tor! lhaw flrnk M • soot AI rJ1. INYVI "Al.... n e In'. tl VN 1L Nu, 1: Tra, . ... 1,uYln N.Vdy p Il llfte J h \\ T al 11 YI T 1 ee 1 n x1n1 JN. A11u1 t 1 r I:/..11� X Yn Wurt. A 1 T Inn II II_ ,. l..l.11l. J pl! 'x'NI4.iu .klMxblttA Y.MkN.a � ..Y 'w"'Tu•3 "RIA.0g'Y methstt Tr...rY...h., wlr- _ _ amna ».aR II _.. .knew• Jae4 n: Tgn1 VeJ w+IT Vm1•pw N'h.w blmq"Nwbtet„--.=-' W fltl,. f..rruW If An t\.1 y 1 .3 _ 4l IF V. n 11,ern v. ' in OD} %The. i romN0 I bee a .deliver illy salt 1M11..I. , WI* tql NI N 1 kb... N' 4 if t N Jan it.._Calif U 1 I.kul 1. T.. - to tent N 1 1 VI R. PresenPrOlgR u 1• . ^ r. Mope% 1\ Y Nwllel N lai�t�l\�1-W *Intro p .,k Ii. NII II.rHn r: x 1 .w, N.w.M11 Y•. N M n,\PNyln•I. M. x 'PAW Retool- ve.1M.Wb 1\ b..•. W1111pn.1':' . - W I. 0Ai W Y rf:.n 1yn UIJI Toper.,rn \ dent.. }sntb i .II.1 . erg On Tf.V. n, 1.• I: 4l'hnrl R. Cede. ThnS a ylw4 - to on. fi , • Walt Agin V. Jr '.M..1N.4A GIYY t r +w Hw. ,w•. - WirlIMR) W. :%ielHO' YM 4.- t'WntITIJe r,. ` >er T.e4M. TnYw..: �' 1.11 1. M - 7,rlo,hr Welf.1J•• '}Im. loges tyre ..:''Ca `Yenw.. = 114n a..r+r.- "'"t vi w IW. seers -I` •W.1br -le a Y.: • • lvll,Mnwa, Ji.1•, 11, porlaa T espg tieing- SW. ' Nll M. llmrr. 11 i1' lira WOWS, h • T lent• Tt. aiee. . A.:. .wasamr.'. 14*101t. IL' N n' l'hirll'* V. -Joni, T •. n1F Inn rllw.' _ N'. i '. lllnw+ a .. "WIb..n 1`I,Nrir•r,-A.. Noe a*. J•elio, IT.. Wieser: flak flit Wen see., l.n.w. tf : N it Therm1.o A N•.lydaui,•Ile. = W A 1 1, M%h W 1 . • . �F AIbWW .N N11 v rm.. tit= -Ve, ere J. -.t. .. \ Vr I0rnY It.' V.., meo tlknnnl'1t, tun Banc INllq Y.I4nn Rutty. R.. W.1 W th, '..try- Well* M eta' Ikfw TAWS S AVI.n bootie A. Jr . - 'W flubs.,. 'J..he • Bons, Ia sobs A WIN whnr, ln,fn.,r 4 S'1a teas K " N'k11.y tli,.k*n A.WO100.,°1Z•A. I, W14111 .i}.I14dnemllh� }1, W4rWemShl -Ce 1.tetra lr 1Wt0b. I. n.n1u` t. k w/ Y. !,,filmy' iy :Yak N ,,o. wla. WIIV Yt. hone! Is .Y'wl• Id,k. • AIJ.h .'rw,. 31 *Woe.%.',:h1.n .1. T....n. t nr. L , 11unp. H9Yww•IY WiIN/nN.. 1..Y14 'yY11fw- i4..\. �1t... +w.•I.. R.IJr lit . .-yr •'. owho +±_.�.s-...,.w..e�k - ,y..yJi�+�. FF , .� ...• ,/h�yy..��' ? alaXir31.. %3►��.` Jpe'r<T iv 'f�•.i?t:'.tw .SK:.1 .M'q',[�!'.."n .'I • R..cord Entry; List . AyAnnuaEDog -Show Plltedl dog shoes rombined'In- to one --that .will be the si1Rtlpl.. . ai- Gilmore Yield. Los Aneelew. on •$node,. Oelobe 11... when M- . teen dohs wbteh are member* of the California California Associated Bp,elal= lF Clubs sta.e.tMlr annual ahonv} from Jager to g p.m. _ - Mom, [ha1i 3300 flogs eta**� been .' mitred Sot the omit. Mineduled., : �.�. to be one of Wee largest eithlMts' . of canine perfection -held en the, - - West Coast elite Wier.. !.Torteen Itmtea, ant celebrated deft 'Raoul'', .. ' ftom Nett York; New hiay,.%ea- . uKky, MIWi.a. 1B1nob .Mhsmlit. • loin. Oregew' and. CillflwN.. will ',,,ride. ore, the Magee rinet, with severe[ httndrtd &meanie, Nt Make_ NBIrne3t of .the abate NM' .ate teed. •spol,ranciA et Tastesdtli lade\'. Btaft0rdahlrs TelYler and do( May tree YA4414i[ . rrr r r Hraedi ,epnstnted *W W Srlth; [Betio.Cotter aPankEs. Etesglo.l' • Ditelaahunda, Dmtet-;'COMM .Dte • ('*teen hire De Arent ; .0*. fo Peking e. Boston. ferele " i Buie. Pekptr /c. Hgt. 4 Poodles, : Bulldogs. CTowehowa:uld POOdtH.: The record'' entre ast 4expect- - ' ' err W. be matched- by A record epeeist for for wbleh gle b0;' fkld; horn, of the Hollywood. -baseball dub, Mat selected as the alit. All .doss willbe benched .throu0hout the dal, "Tel said, " much Ere rt Ortarand io attend Groff Palii Or. R em Boll Voices Mel me r Salia1i i01 6. Noxious Weeds Big - Expense to State DAYLS. car..-Ogt. tl IITPI_ Rob1N1u i7nlv *+eialtr doe Cont..AlilAColitee.'of 'Agdtokuee . Wtanut, reporlilbe telle[h.3 - ,,Plot plan morel. dbr'nf the fait 'Poi Fain to fight.00Slolt wee4, ieu of ftf a Ie[' In [tie 11N. block 4se 111.en tile, the oetupNlien of t1e'1 ar n ROAR ai H, e.nt. 8und4F [bag by Amerkany , : • mwhln[. 'We 1.Ip meet.' of C*Jifesnl.S Cooper. -Nteo,d/m}'to a report Settle wen Allele end Introdlf d Plate to the norsioo 3.. othop 'had )!. .fmm Lv,ept. . ' non keen teems Mil 'tar *RoYt ^'g a Keen: Tie dim -awry e4 eta do-. .. . lolat hick I .3 b)T 'teeuned Jane 9eturd.T e)M, was mWe,bj Bfatrlic Qulesm; daughter of Yin WOE kin, "tutu} QNlroi. neigh - Miry was, aho, tool( N kreeklMO prepared .by. heT another to tLn • 'bode of Hie red.ue - Aoeofdihe to .$.me. TeartieY, fomer OMTnery et the Bran- Yalpr¢ Msr11e1. Coullei ffittled down In Sail' Yoldro. - iten.or eight were ago, state -an Itinerant, nines dorm[-[ hich he- Bed dong many' tflI35 in -Mier 'Memo. . :."'U.or.e'. 1M.mr.tn the sitar. otle diF'..*1y from a+•d 2, s}td' Iowa:." T' o:WOW ennim<utrd- Ne then stabeel.lkat he bed' imust • then*. FNn In twee. dolt,[ Woe ?o;: and--, F . bsifevt that he 'tree 'Merited Biel.. he had some .eel- --• UM: Nfmcy SemRrs geomes ail psi bulldog, Thanks Mncbk/ mown. attrgp Ira' Ohdtlen,- Iowa.' �dl.+dlT„r .ertee s.'wr ' : to ni mein of ' ledy -. for fee C.454M a .(ll*t oietl S .. oIl, -Cob'r Aecordlttg. _ • to AT -ern / art' hac0o To saw: Lei $hriners to Attend eolm/. C4nite .'[ -An0 fus'0'a0or.vYt• -Son annul d49 +how, la be betel- GJmere fi<td, Los Angeles °�io a. sotto, saes a Al Sabi Coremonies Sondes. Orr. 19,. Don atlln.' IR. Mla ladpq De[e,e ? w s r"' UST W M By JOHN READYFOR- .SHOW George B. Coulter, S. Y.:'Santa Claus', Found: Dead Sunday. OeOrge 4., Coe t Tl. knows es .R,el), J..tt. YAldrar.s. by n?' newt • stele 'thin; rtA}nta CL${V. pal. found dead leh11 'hick on lire In Imperial Volley / . ream:Miwwlow -he meted, PI . .. _ : F« aye«f miaow r« »••! JO. 3hriner- of At MAlnikah Tem.. .. pie Will learn Friday night; Oem* bee IT. for the Imper1 1- Y111y to participate in a Ceremonial. that Al Bahr Trmp(Ws. of Bah mo 1s a1Aglnr on. Saturday. Octet - beg le. The artnal cereelonlal tell take place .lt the Im9erlat County Fats Orelmda at Im9eriel.. W*ohins1M.' D. C„ where he ins In: R AnRetes PrMA • Itht al 10 0rIoOk ern/4°Yed on the edltdrlrt staff following a street parade II Centre SatnrdaS.morning- ltlt After twthe bandrem➢k the ceremonial at Al Marla bahi unapt and other mm nitored a.b}I�. Bhr1Perl well 0OLn1N for CAlr, ,11O.ld.' see0jdinc- io p04,1.4Ate and i vck acres itle-Afe•xl.an Elmer P, Bromley, who Is Asking. border Saturday night_ - - • Ih4' more divan to paitklpata The special train carrying the .e,uf Al.-. Behr e and 1?J Fireball AI Malalkah Phrinerx Imeta to. itemptea.in .the artlnontra.. '• 4Tt.ta�J?- THAT SCORE WI M I of ate W iNlinROR 'plum, TO [owe he worked In rari0*s [)lint shoes.. [Beat' went. le - Booth El- liot. where he 'became owner of a print shop and editor end pnb. !taller of a. weekly newspaperOar -!tow IA.?”..[ 1,1 :Meng 'Amtt. Ind- the bnjtod 'rhos floods of y g' I:htM.w . Tee tan- homceniden woes rettling [nit e. state.:. PrefIts from, the Ie Ai30- ?*reed ... ,kt-stet Inel,ne. tog eflter0r000 dorm[ the boors ewe ' CATO in. Smith [Atone were lane. m . ' running fro1400 so MOO a-. - 1w. .11 . wow;-N ewi.R.''NA- 'TIOHAC TITT CARPET: AHD LINOI!UM f0LRANY fro ve: momI l.r51 „teem ..t Eiticz. 63) ErMiLISHED, SERTEMBE8% 28, , Man SOT meenrArsti • e.NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, FR lartY, NOVEMBER 7 19-17.. • . • FIVE CENTS PER COPY • • 'JIMPRESSIVE CEREMONIES FOR DEDICATION .• IOF.' NATIONAL CITY WAR. MEMORIAL BOWE, 1RIG. PARADE PLANNED FOR. ARMISTICE DAY 1 Sweetwater, Chula Vista High School lands, Cadet Corps, I Dritt:Teams, and Veterans Organizations to Take Port I In Parade; Admiral Sherman to Act as Grand Marshal nr•turneit iwyriconen,parent:t,.frienelc cityandMusty officials, and'IrniiRtft i IS,. o(tirrre.: will IA.+ vial hi the dedication, eereinonieft of 'tilt Nifinimr Citl; War . l grmilrial . Th i WI op Tuesday, A rmietice Pay. - The (In>.:14 pepgrttfn ‘S;ill •hegin•t.eith a parade at IT a.m. along Na0onal avenue with . it :V.1.1111'1111 Fredrricli 4'2 Sherman. USN. I Yet.) as grand marshal I "faking ntirt in the parade will be marching units from National City and Chula - .-,•-•:;,..z ,.... i ,...- e4i4141erlitemi)Elathefloi.., . . . .• . -ni1.5p. °bowed- beelbooltered . Anternelmatele• 550additional. mbar of men and women - 'erred In la arnotiOnen dining Warier Pier IL lite* been.harned'ubt bra. drill WIWI loom Onn..nehnd. Ides. lithe Belle Pitab,•eharrran of tar entrant' amsnittele In Pegg "I" be "'Sig" i'delos.o ‘; aloha Or aitusa nu. tinnies for3be.War Melnerial,AWT gib welt, babe Will be fpliereit be flee ears , . The "lance thee hate been turned, in since the reittineJ.het Tug. eff_. .1111t11M, Menit.betell, • : .' - ' pubbehmf ,Itt thd- October /11haue•of the NatIonal!0ty hese_ aye. 'Me° v011 61,6*..Oit V014Uland ' - —gbetrlS. Puolialled. Mita 'net In yee,.. ooll••• Of•Vie .111esteatta end : Burglar Captured : d- 0.,..: d--qpr...,..5.- ...0.0., moo RIRR'30.004i2Orneen , Mona May be-. made. AbOa..35 rxerc near.. tin...anien yvt.. ... • • By N. C..Police' - e-; inel"deel lei rtliete 'lig' 104' Ilanewear IttdillflUtkifilierr '. Makes Confession The names Oh will bt. Pf4tPk *" 13hreinit.ab.16nei*ino.m.. 4r.r. -vet'!. _ War Monona Boa, which. • will veterans 18..pec, rin,c pen Will lil Va. 04 trite be • .. . ' . ,4... e • ,2!':..2,A Lured by .Motional City pollee the ". . "ral" a L114 jimiggg:11"gg.41°*t""3":giggiigignill-n '" J%e Cerointes. Tenet:. 2t-Yebp , . e, . ::,70.'....rp.----r., • with the' Nate:mei 00' era IO'r•kln yepth. shO, ADO O‘P- Lobed. catdorrireecl.itonC4aq'tandT"V4addl..trone. Aft.ihaVe "g"t • - • - • .- - •-• -or, ":5•,,. - .. . , A ...... nithl of °matter 25. ettallpted.t0 1.,gff-gs \Lfe:4--'1''' robe e: 00.ieor-M.0 Chute This ' •-: )4 r.-- '1'''' woman or, October 11. he - told . - • -e 00.4earted SitiOna City "le 3.telntella 10btel Mayer Gnarl. 'Z.. Trite. • ehy admildetrathre officer, and lodge. ha Marbibm. chairman of the Was- Maitre the stratere witb:lbe Mans and *PrelfirS4,14%A.. Judoe Harbison watt.. ashien whstels raided415.001 award a the reenialal to- men and So- ft noyeUni the avant forme duria World War The 15sal In M. In ttn:ain!a.nd '11 "do-Iftos 11"413.3gi?Sher41. . sts A wrelt to wa3e reesie3 "11e• 13* 'Educafion,Week • • • . -4e, pro.„. . • their nellonyobIlVn ChOf .1_Inyd ‘,..tiott,t. .ctii,, hi,,,,,.. uh,ow. • f•-o. U. 111.7410 14' 21."1. "I'L _ .3.4Oor 414.4 t't'a0 N'd toes- ."''''' of pq14,Y41.1-' Ninety-one ram were loomed, 4tiow.,..,,.thabk,, t..ti,,,,.,,,i towt,,a. .I. the labor a but. only four Al them had .......t.4,;,;1• .i7.i,. ii,,';1..,,..1,?..,be RI left-'4124 mechanical defect% tat re. it gi. 14'41- tubed attention The ila horn- ig.,.....‘44i; itig.fhg°4' giiit i;' 10.37 lee- b..t. tr t....,...; ;..; , ' ':411......v. -In o‘tforg, • With I nit, equip- .. • ternber' 19-. ch the t _ . ( liquor lio ""n't that Went t4r'"• ! rUan Sducanon Wteic Ant- rentresed 4/ 1,311114 1.-343o "'gig.'" iii'i; ;;,poeli.* y4r,.,.. • Aa 4x part a the cheek. shoot. cISImS • hobined re- ; liana law 2tariber • 10, ilforedi Clt- mad-3valve . eolitclefi . • being filed reale coaches- of the: anted( detects In their autos And ?meta to hoeing there Fr - waged even thouitt [belt ear% might net have been isainined be the pollee.- Chief nate. va- n -Unit: • ' Anderson. Mama M, 1(ity's Schools Hold ' 9-'c''',-“- 7,:d.;-. T.N.- -1-1':::.''.74`!t-';'1.- e- • 87 Cars Pass Safety Check or T0pht Cer ovoid la. ' maim fir be Ie. also Itnown. wa,a la ...i... finval.1 C. Only. tenor WILYIIIIU OUllenn !Open Houses DIII113(1 - - - ' . - nt' 4 motored In the Sweawatet 5.1:1- ""gtf,.'"f,t,...ik ' . . • ley near Ihrttway 101 after .1n. Jo ...;t:. Yr.-Aunty I.% Illy nonce denattlnent wartulell Con'Unued a Plea 3 riarsi W. pepae are consrleus a the de- of „tmtth,,t the "ging" f in in f tIle theirautandlilles. and are hat, Int there corrected. without. walla far roller action, Chief Baca BAWL ''The siaNy rnun ne0Ye6P- ta,nyl roirrewe If It bukry )e stale and -tine tin hove anted. ditehon dla- to cities xr‘il The Stain- - n rease lc oral I Leaie Voted A the Ionia 1...e„ LI en s, hold open :haat on vember 14- At 7 3t3 p.m. there sill be Pratta !4!‘iifor1i with conaidnity. [...calif and ,51bdra PorPgbaiPti ' 0?-3,111. may ',bit the umber. In tbel ,glaeareorna Felton n1444V1illl. .; Thrre rennnute:: ttl,!: ban • named tnanu&C in tir 0.>!ctatire of the wet-i( at -tie '.41Uni • Regard Mikkohon and Annata James rrprcrent tbe ennatinuy•- .. Ando Bub% Mr.,- lends e1fla•tsn it • A• . unlit end bends front both Oneet. 350 Names of Service Men, Women water nigh *had end from etude Vtefe hieh echoed. -toter-zinimc-.04 t3etective Sergeant g, A. ?fable on names were submitted tai late tO nig" "lima- bend ewe dri* He else coats -set to coronae tint nlne battened tot National CitY-Irt thr Past TOW months hit hat se yet coat -seed In A aer- ie; of 31 baelarim tri cnan. M- tn *hie), pellet believe he W. resporable for, Chief Lloyd W. vestitutrir • Clyde W. Yonden ot . • • ' with three? shokt. -1-St1111 en Seen made to the liat Of tern." behind_ thent. • ' men end wanes. plagues .:•-.- erdered and the names Will be The Aggigm °gut ief3.03 doPahr line of 14 Ian will be Nipped plead Sot lbe hp mom VOl`rnIU WU*/ ;Th4 names added ig the "4 peehealma waeordla barld.al 14 Men a National City, Tre ear- Adorrolble las Telerate 07 IfOreMet- Were . troierem. ineherd Anarketia Lhasa and Maas. ate andoont. tvao Ammo.. Tamar C. franiathess anith thaalela. I 3Latana. irate lb- out the length Of. the P*Onie.' 4n...1. northws oresnalsettam to the pert In the Anyylln unnesta ION Jr. pride nomrne-nota 1,fir roe who serted bl World Yelp' and Vierld 'War It, nem made by the Chamber Commerce,. City offletale hare arranged .for the dedioarlon• ?roman% at the' Hord. whieh .m11011104. go OAT' inamcdlatily fallaMITit taw free- S. Ref. Olaf, Boone sie*tby of Putati5y 2118641n a row. on Or. 41.1 laid 'Malawi City hears two Li Li lAmptFt itik.,.1 jely man " w ..- w Um Fleet Coneregoitenid- Chopin ' toiler 25 tile local Polite tRfiad • Be -... ..t oscr the district just -north In dun -to; the:war and is now ante- w'ho piiird Rs a Newer Chaplain t scone(' . Poet cirktbethreeleTh. riZeitelir. IrtetifebY.Iirbit:. of -Ihe..01ireirood lidusing abject ' . one itnuX iler.. be was seal DI' uy V.F.W. Guard . ,„„i., ,,,,,,i,.1...„, thj.,430,a, slut' ,..ntd for- him. lie entiSted ... l'ohr'e imin the area•sartalldtd-. Mee. Arthur L. Kayla a 23111 the .-Eleyen Bids Made- . . . .. . Pend plo attentried: to rasa East Sixth Seat.. was natuitA•Cii nielebt l : LtAlnri by aunt ihrtettat the Yalta' to' this weet that the body of her r uniP.s- niVIVI I wont, Nab ;hits . • and Mrs. Liaetli Schneider. zoo:- . resent the Meaty. 31.4 ON- d 5" k ThomasPortTiJr.;root•63citybythesuiteptodayPbbodypate • Alumni PI F P • For (ify Workers With First Sweehvater-Chula Vista . •o•eot • • eiiii"Lgas Ctly Pmula“ Indy vervfnu- I •II Ink.. . • j.„ , „,, ,,„ „„„„„,, ,,„ ame as High Point of Homecoming raarnranw toeln.ust,t It dmidett ..y,trt,t„ 1..tores of the r prr Itra to r1., of tueetwater Mtn id dot ace night undo it,. forn.,„ etre club tn.- tund , d„, of •Incrtlinourn .n celebretion a the at hoois „„,..„.,nniv Auden L. 5.0. 0./ I, I - - - • C. of C. Block Leaders Named lamps Webr, Of ttre teeei.Mpre ;ten fneeo- Tele centrally .6 cabnleting plats ta:Weelf fur Point am Moot worter5 eat, realon. of tho env rnr the in- .0 \L CITY, CALIFORNIA, FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 1941 ISU-HI:FILES:.,I PROTEST. ON GAME RULINGS Questions- Decision Of Referee; On • Number 01 Downs Tic:semi c'onerrustethe cor- '" reetnisiaof the official* „tie-: cidon iq at lei?t xne vital wiles of down,;"'wweetwt- ter, hitch, ttehntd , oftietala r!$tteFC Be i pMtil rcit., ed with t. 4eteaPolitt t dsaGue 1?!fre.: • :,jtterteper.aktht.tast-Was Rr]a.. ... rerhirell:r-31';:t+arm Oe,aetattt Aunt"Tu[fdoy. Barrtaalrr fag gild' a1tmM. alw were prne41i. when: the rat- iteeW+sere prm3mane .the.. bail toe a phi t a(tet • ate rune: hod ended awe: tore not: ao rlrealp• apeet fir their Ian1gaae. Cap- math" an tree dtt 04 ranead tam the oulrecha 'elwr4e Ot FIVE CENTS PER COPY 'df E.TE r_-`` MEMORIAL DEDICATED Men of Three War March. in Pored.,' loin. in' Cere Mollie. ,r,:d4ana0aaa+o .: w • '' •Emote. theme, • tPtf:� . 'x. War. Meinnrlel Bawl; sleet-(_; ell to llenor the men =amt %`• women of: tau:tnty-.tt}In.- seraed tM:'the ai�red:[otcrl` dtutne World ,W..ar` IC•`Oai` ded1-f`. ' rated m Tt iadth the ifitn9 tabs et tree end at. World War: i • The. deolhthin ems ' Pi Foams camas"• t.- an: h Rtrroi, "het, offisiblebc- .lw Ihe: mote •T' A. Mvq: al 11 PA 21at .beet. past,eAatmrnddr of the - sober winment Shea the ottic tla .. L Cllmen Pail. t7$.tl'.P.. and him sate. phatnrraphed se they' hap . lhr,stth of lmlitut a and' Play] n1 oedir nun tars MA the a ter' xaIEO gnderthe that .11id:baal lea 1Nnutea of the It of ', in the Unlieat and --gar ~late W (lilac a a3W. was s t000tt what Yru'k of lire Count o¢ _ in the "gyre It. arse almaat Pali a «nlnry. ails shah he n M' panlrh-urn niwn 'War. • not awa7 from redibtne ;er'a gtata of .4''2° - plte at the dlllaent I eOrtt n} voihrthe r worktra 'mho been ga irli mans' tYte del arresundlnt arta. Butlerbe• that Manypmatb/t rt0l . may hate bath otiprinaeied to who. hits. hoe. onmeibuttd • Iy Not Celled On ked tn. Notify inveigle Chairman "rlrtling to a.st$tement I by Arthur F. Butler, man of the local Coro- ant lef the BwMw ter unlit high a '1 �, } a In biv' Ptayep ashes* • ter era VIM Bag. the neat. etbcaeeliae Wt LSTABI_-ISHED SEP_TFMDER 28, I S82 efr-sc - ' . - 'c. cirr Hnest Al a Um Ilan D 4a AOae- ge Pi lvrsdp lucre water 3" S. Halmtrela. a natant en1ihese g» ahvaa. and ale lhh vncmural" Air S EST DRIVE LL SHORT Msonle ronfumed H x rg le +Ise th&'War Mea.pra Bowl .Tneaday following late • ,- Vice_Admtr►t P.rtaerjst:-:.0 ;, Bliermon. ul 13N.1 car a. em9yat- veteran M bah -world wee~, 9ttd`• 7,6. a lithe Pal* that�lsra. Ve?r?f%+ ace viltnea.rdthe had .aurreftree.'. of . the t at:Me t pn the„ U.s.B.a'`:, Mlsplrlt reminded llw:_tipla tally,=:7 threr,lt salad W . she bCoJ drat `Ulbeitr b bt retaIned.'Pttta .. be .h* . -'That CotarraalnrNn Chntecn.. Ir,. F W at:Ira Ittinen � B. Oof lO Er,. Peat No, lead. tchC eve en hxelph Wars Ott zhett•} _ 'ikon w tna boned Btaua tlt7r the dollies ductal* tnevsre Vetb1Nd, .attperintapd daft dedkatW the Mgwxyel*1•a. -. A xh� tpaWcc. Peep ;Yank jt. '�+` � - - • #` ` AlmlghtYs b5eaami tp the J3%*n ;: FULL U' l:htte, Ir„ prtnc%pot➢f 6wcrtwa-' let, ifld I! .14Nr Lelia' ot'. pro. tent oIII' a Dav'd Attptln W?al> dent of the Mrtraawilten Leyte= ''En the footbafl'tamt payed betmeeia .Oroavgon* Crud Bart- water lino, Iltch hahoola, at frPreekTnat# DU Nolan* It. Mt't. Mammas t serious question -ton. =• f•nntig'the otnreeentee of the. offl1btl deetlden In. ai Ieaat one r ylt®i Perin of dowrw TTt errl4s- referred. a was lale spat In shish SWalsatrr Was 114.3.4,11011 et the :y Cheat:' drii•e; the bait. The eatnrntbn of mpsy eye wltnr`tv+a ed !nf et.lgentg lil:-a in: its final Week plzy-bi-pley loa..ktpt� by a t1[; at oval. City is denrstill FaLIn Id only lyl ~Are.dO rbi+� QatiC- in hno down the team -raffled' the hbie tnatead of pununrt tat. It w mild, lta.'t done 'on a founh d�o�l��s�l� `a�n�d- the ottielala tart it ter droslfouni', ATM time element Mad Wth that bed- the fourth dine* beet allowed and.tat nary. Ali Mott Oak:Utah ::the game itahid have endeif. before Omuta sapper% of the welfare midaaM tmatm .,.fined oow.eatl and the a t of the ma_ tT 4ocert ra 4H :ot{ tl+r Stage . viotlt4 Irnye ea0Goiren. Year la itQueal:ed hear -Elora revel B 1 .N4r Aar Orahry T-P»*. ' llra Was Such ,Mdespreed III a reage_' to have a dam e6,,,e a*t.4'n the.opint that we at t hh torntnitteo ran em rtoatyrlett that the tee* of the eglieetierl. lht%eitiv.auia De;mye'UIatal by s coreuitttee qE vdyntear Oh freieug Thla aWrnwd' M. a ra lnolrldes" repU�aentbtivtf a4te` Mene m und5ly erned many ehurelies, dubs. dee and Leaf; Smith. haperietcn4cnl. irl aga30a Faycht rebel:Pal a1 fhn{a'lont, the Vice PrncIpal ationa. lndia'Wtul pohunttere t vntinalcd on poor fhel ntlghborbpod croup* and. entire memtreritatp et the - - Calub, "epopaorr of the feral Hew Exchange Club All hive bran calrcmel% In 41 , 'bugneam - • es Chart in a}n1n%tog the entire ®} ea : ilrme, d.k tll}d effbrlar or these Ieadti tin tH tonUnge throughout ol{awgt2" weR. . Ithpuah the Partatwtty t' Ia a ratan', orgunhatwv. tlatmey CBnlrlbuttd by, )beat pitato used en/hrly fox lo- rHaf pork; A ask match ,n3aL-„rtor_ h.e t4" need -tq chest not the table tort, so m}te your contrlbu- • Waal- Buffer urged. ree Injured YIK Admiral Pfederirk G_. htiernlau. Ll,d„1[„ rti.. to -ab.Wa - qn the ep.akch pIatforut t ...l:tr when he' tdadt the �IH prl adds. at': the1adtranm . i II ]'hilts I tilt War' tdvnwrlat Bowl tmn.ed tl ly behind him Ia David It, Wit,. eauul, piper visor and mCmber. tut the war Memorial wmmlllec. is the ad. "Our Cauutullon. metre frealore qf: rfllebn but the heat* era of thet'detutilenl ?Id.ltuVIM tend-tt- tlea, na all le.d.,.,' rvllgtaL .•tilt t'' I c ▪ The, /tea 'Ji ALI O s5ohW,n . toe, of: ,Mary'; C4thotla` elitircui icon ,Ube; beneaeuwt.4,1s i3.w.;" 14ekez".'9bben0Mt In-filet?-:.g Meant. sold.- 41t b tuil0R din(ak Ow.. thought' to terretifte'as, tfhadt= Wean. for. which. the men of ;_b two twee were fought Parer are - %Wh of the lent or TMS aa?o tTlnkl_ of ale the ~Vs. We nen the a(Ytb1- Melded beefnen tortdtolov em._' We are now to rewire -Wei tbd tat'''.. hkalg In. «Midi We faa{!tl Wm'! I0311' In teapardy' • the Admiral'^' Rattled, a .'_ We Unapt be Arcot Meant 1E' we 'ktap cur m ict.oil: Went tin. **are In leas Magee of iftegale. warned. lie anld• Ira Mara..tlnolly", coin to the 0*W-taere. reluatrmt- It: that we moat harm' ttplyerlat suntan training :allot youth the ready when ra ttan:4. What tonally conic tit adant--te. right li.iol olw. I� l:reds-tick J, 'I bateha acting mayor'f 7n mlermi to a Wr awn `ttn;s. the . t_. usual CITY. and 1. 1'.. at9r'alrr. Mayer of Vbuln O6tu.--tPhalea' mro - - Nara{ fieraa:.id tar d dlt i�l!l'e [h4 a ,tirethar Ph lea eneara.t - idea of interthaturs the life Of lltn Young mtn of the etruatr5 nod. New. Owners. For [Federal OHIO-al a aa` w1Jr w'Soaf co( -thin country. 1a11 I t bellcv.-n the niun.lo [Ivy .lb1 yMWu our n a1x Vern'3 Apparel �ShQliSees Na.thance mantilla .ar a > rt r�ttt.i� Iq • A trio of w..11 k W h aft t y;-0f Ta �9#®y Hight 1 1. et In the f Satgtrday Might .. tl-tee t t v.'„i. u fr rn ate 5t "H.' k f tic Horeuo sit gum. slag'Votlt the t.•,at +rah the NeUortal Exchanwe Club to 1 t W , tV sou I 1 1 I 'Y i I aI_Y •- - 7hp a O.T'_C sari t; t Igo tar belle -tot -Meg. VIKlaanei Ciuti In ey l w 'toying foe' .... l cundgated lb f' a' n M+ cny LIX. InarlA/ yf titer eh '>H.•Va<n W tin d t[wc t H u2 alb x RedudlOfl b14h Kt ad' a. i out r ly' A i1W rz t. ar a vl JDt .Ihe, al tti:, r p vh t / iguanas, tw 1' b rat tuxes, r n'.be totenge ty art Pt nlvnitate ntu?a. \f"M. Atria.- Fart i.v ,.:tl 11Ar_' 31 h nd City hem-1:1.:11 eal� Interfere the lyyat f v tlhlt 1 et er a ire fr N" Ye.ph.hte of any creel rv' n1-that Ie'Intl t Iw taint_ It1t tat , \'r I In .IfI .uritrd a Ir. Lon let of 0w - Jam Foe rm end t I t t of h 1. u laid ltfuyrtmny seheol hovel ao l tI. Pfe*oI,tloq ,af a efagrtgr front nt+tp far rairi.fd .1 It. -}I ..t ll,,.lr ~unite. art ui china our!!.^: bstul twk. Path In tr Yiu •d• nnun{rd Mg* 'jerk Ntraist M. men[ lore of 9 I f t a 3[1i'tlfi.aiSgiido„Platu nauoawl at t as nlr} tit a ttlty:t r 4 trva " .• tu}tIl11Ue ur r.f the -tu_eiceL- IIa. hegeg Secretary.,' ":l 111.1 to r' (be1g11 i i I'- I� 1 1 t At,' Rape 4-kiting bite Na tlmaal r0- of la to •r TI mar - 1 chance Club °In ''the ore»ntattod� 1! t nbb, ati to, r HP'.l 1( sr a s'ru•w t.aa tar I mh Ira t}I t r ' r'4 alfah'a of NdflDna) November Pin bi+made ant h e14t ' I t a Iq d ~ultras M s. N,ve, c relnony and i !I v n . t '. urday.. Yoyamber i rat war an- owl era I .. e ,y P II Ir, I 1 � . f nd 14cc-I to 1111c hope Iolid Il t by '-r I> by +,i u. au` La inn 1.1.13u14.4. lessening dt coipi. xdl b! Willarr p. heIrfr. of Indio.!-4' 'I Ut•e.. w'ut bNta5tu.nd III tPt1 in rn.Ilt th'iwnd= C S it \anaimet m.raberof ear hW[bnuf ;lard of i ty Vetad bi yn ; .1..1 y l I' :F r Igo fi,agl•it l:m Pur pseud tiv Jy tlf �.r •_•uR t antRA._Atrrpllnre alp W coca.-,., 'w'l nr•:. I u , u.1 I It V been n mvud Iwo t1 by Arvet Trueblpod. Vl n.lrlerll tau I (r f at vi i r 1 --d 1 imf 11 • hs ten. the Igo mat Id . ,v- •` '�%' the net!'" club.' I l .1(:.I .0 111 %I 1.1 it'DPhI \\.. :'1I � 'J taut tte ...tanr hittiC tl t r " lr .r,1• If In n.Nnen• rte-4!•e6 It( M1r•• I •• It' e•C Na, t, IA.nilIn t•rb•.}I li C K Ia nnynr. w.a. 01 3 ! d nt I mxl Cot,ryr t ° eY ' tin Jtub- n la to .t r 1•° s tnhrtr t .el t SI(I.+and ti tmI r0 d -ro W iurY tw- � si .f . \ ., 1 w,mt , a•. 1 n J mi N.M end *ris I Cu .r nw7 rcH+Io. In (q eyn d ! •Wynn• k 1 q... r y1V+. inngiJnrY Kat Yew 4Arlf. Iprhl• ..-i r_ It..• i}.m ,4 -Empl n hi +vii -t , ! ntdtr'. Id' •. .1 T. Ad1i1111 ni1M'a''Ril€ to"' l 7.Yrile I....o it I. (•I J:iki nt UH I.�-I ufL H ..Welt rnl•rt.yiU -.. lit Cranmr: re at roe \ ;on. A e t - 4 li 1 foal . pal;ni lie{1Nam 1 •I,. 14 r \t •,n 1tehlttne ttw Iw })art ]...t1'= 1 y- n}he re '-tvptt I'ar r ylf_M y- ,1.1- Jed • it ,hl..n . Jl %heal, nit trbwl} 1d i.eIl nt -It'. inthe:. 11i'..1: II' n Ili H.rnfl trails. li'- trt`vthr•t,.rrll,,.t» o ug rit*Me r Mai . , on Si. II 8 1te , - - n rn all tr4 lu. 11 .ts: kk - l tinx,p..N ?put mit-who- el' of met ]7rJnvAdr ?put tatsnJ 1111dm,ra ilhlt4mlll( 1. dealt{ i!`+ l eamC ! n+1 11 U.• H:: al ( aean J IU k.44 t lima .1I 'i it nt rprne by.-e d- 1 �. I, is air A d Oiy •-.nl+ h Itr the n'!` , rr 4 ILLII nmmle.l in rhlfhlpOHtrrt .Y'a.. -maned' et N Hri IIia11 I rr :.Inn nu..i. dNS L.Dteetath..'wlev-rn#Ytra' et s�iml h.an• m this it r In: •. rJ `I tr tJATRIi:•?t CITY NEWS ran..;Employment vJar Memorial FR IDAV nlx, 1„ tlalµm , th. BowF-DediLmted---'. Guest Speaker . Academy es u. :Le +. In' O[Me nt file Pen (prate Eor`TeartTtr Lai N %welt 'neµan C,,.ml..y o/ Ci!n,mrr:e en J , rs---- . JTo NozaYcttl-H • l7U Se.��.t1nwN-altr-o.kt'-Wu r m.. u i v nrn,ltrr i:'u(i Kim ❑ r Ir1r. H^m [L' Nli,an b lloh.r vI Ste*';" j ^•� - er11 •tl 1. .le tht-t bill- .a+.bry. (t 'ells r Yr ra alone ore,C uD ) V. Rill nu ur t. Laker. vile, wet 11e djty wr-' itJ flax: wore, tl'• if 12 , . ...mite,. r IS .rrmtD em the. aunlr.t In fwYpT-tit_irxrpietll I(m,4-• ••( Iwk I.•. •-'' nlh+ct. iJ,tdxyl,fAd._ from tea•drffxta) Mt4 of 'three 4am.a-ta.e Aead.my tiled ) lore' had brrn turned to 1 w --- !1 .b. n Olt pxttrrr n'��tl l t. .lu. Ilt t w Il• 0 lti win tti hey, a914. e „,.Uiter kilt that thryl � a-unlA ll t111ltwi •were Mn a bp.. 1.....1, MI Iehc;4r were Made bp.. 11Ihslted MCI) 1AUle.. Belle' PI.ith13 ate other nvlhbeh-nf the. • '.rrt• rat!i.enmhlllt.,. ithe tifE/Aiirm. •frH .n. n(ean• •T: rn,onitl' anti n,irddittryl tin Itw Mt. Sirs. Ieamb' h ehanmlin' • lna leer trtrvb• lfi 1 Ixq .pa ft'r.. )Y 1 4 _ . ill Ifi.wi 'Ix., n d +. yp1-Kr:ni ,htp�.dxnlilnrr. ... %Id ttx,rq,9N11t4r aiid. nrmej rent 1 :. 1 I 1 .I, 11 1: 1 i ll In !t, t • r et 4n1 t `t/tt T. Ire ta11M Allrnnnfi. Io e pal x1U bd lurntd, Into her. W. ttt'. ,i :'I lit'>llk 4lt u, - 11 ntyl It.t 411W IM(rr R, a- tlt,m ate a,' it} dIt-the ae :litlid *I12t Memorial Roister' A• 1l m (N r. ik Et tib in n ,b t i•mi Il CD 1,k- (aL bl +uai4tt dl howl and Mk!hat M'tth. 11.4 -. �- --� t ;c 1 !l- aln lit ha I. + I.i.mtt. A. 1 t , ty t (ta,flll, h l r d.;t)el 1 Wain *Ra knt wll to •be III..."Want . brinf rta5lta; QaIN II I Or n. ul!p.l .1no: t...a4 ! a..t. dtc I t.t . itoit. tt 1,rm r nr Anldrtot anl(IlwL wntip One Imp CttrelrrY Iif,' • :I h:r e1 1-II I'.. mrhJ al t im .!(• j: }'o.1.- go' K• hh.11, 1. 111an. end I to •hf.:et ,d, lie utp: t i.1i4 aa-r 1.5S Anl a yl.[a:mi-. .•!t . 'Three I no , t•' I_l. d ! 1 _tl.x 1 I hi.. wielde flee; pr.i.- tl-- ,tngsluier,,tjuvitratil. th t i l fti to -Ilit (idanY An.2412- nJ14 h.l na Hmt Ix liltvosinlvl tl: '1 Jttli Was1 tot 14 ireµ y all f+ .lt iLL+I1 ltlrJi 11..i lltl,. ' ( I• lil + Anl il„-iy And Lm III tilt -i+. In TAIL e, a and .StT •I )- 22.2teel y- emphitrettlto: 4t4' .PIT' bi ,inrlt•ari.t Phone lit r•l-iJ..- t ]Jai l,ii - tilt-n tY :•hpnt: .t).y: %tagh:r City Chamber nt .I ,nlr!roa au - , 1!t 4af11 I br E. Noted Speaker For t <? Il,trr a 11 •y Nnt Jl life A I ilt„„. P Thaler. 1nrt4 linr s1niCamer Club-Fee>r"-..hrdd . nn tale I�rr • aur . iiellllih to %bend Ilir tnia.mla-r'j:: 11 mt.^ma'.ift`I lie Cl:rn.-nq( C:nh'Q' of t t rla Viola lo Ite•1.-Lit t1 II aqd t Hmm of, the €1 Illy. t r jamlf, r xNpoi tomtit :Jn t iP'- .1 t at ttinc a t a no- te et Nnt.t .i.•akel n1 the J401l1,i:_ wiii lei -fir I( .1 t:ranl00,01 Tenn - . ...wain.. for )i !e1t2 to m k l a: t.t t a r???:Iiks mitt -atnt :i . e4 r pment. MC lf,-.ii,, lilt.. 1y. ini Nrr: w'lll he -tree txillnrs i JS .mllhtnrGr i•Iloto, lit i r .4!re ? I.,., t t It'. ..Iwak r l .1 r.tmrn e .Ii m' 1Jdta In' it-etf Run i•heto:'.. .ur ih nit a,ls r ll : -its ' ore r 11411 reken Ina I retle1100.11 in tin1 held Si art 'N, Y.nS. :I IM'..dtte for Iry.m 10 4btftln n.l.. ttenultvSIWn I k ; (ar: Ii In• _ppw,Imar..- • Tli. gr}hnr- wdl ttr Ten ITt tnrinttnrs lit 1w.fb rb,M5 2Pi1 then. -'tnt-VIeW .. .9iltretS.- mi•te?te.1- pl.:.�': plfott.vn•phr I. rnrdtails mule lee: ilte1d • •LionMake Pl ans lans -• • 4 , For Chtiitmas Party pldies are brim fntdt tta u• -I�mla rlub atliteol Cnptntmi • 111.01r 41 Tale. Im Mra( W 11 • 'tIo `Std M test tmlrsdal Dun r ' 41et-a1hp..A stJK,al proe@up%hxn-. f lerlaO. the m.:mbrra Iheyr Ajb•t Fad !Meat. P l*tWIO W patMt •• Con. Idm m.lo 'tot' .fpty;t tr/ .Itll- %ally ev1,i F,i ,1 dtrs o:Nj rd -Dinmr Ipn rrtaWidied bt:'Ihr. S9nnl.11aer'sr s Brdrr.D:e.- .Ire, Ste 1h.- ltanUArd .t'yllt(>%il,t IIerIfIe • the Tflma 1-Y?Ilynre' t\ 'Atldttaon Oroyralh rh44r60•. lit ` trvgue.q�.1F.4• .. - Iwy nntr tttu bn4 sleety !rtr; 'ye qulyd tin 'tm IpwardM::ter elarllltamin• +( ail m,tnrtt t14rint Ole lei- •d.:ttl Iha . �Iytn( vpr,S - __ « K:ofP DonceSSet IFor Tbmoirow Ntyh.t ltlrir.li). mt1,t the 1A:hi.1Yistlr I \il. lily, KJ trJll. aa} Lillie.. idle hn(d th ti regutst nlon(hiw Iblp '! n tl I etter1' 11 Srr tw,-rm-, l tii.t1W 1*ti1 Ighr beset. mryyfr br - 1CIpi l r .>furlla.. ell tr Ifl dn(1 • U•rf Id l (.nx cin vi mutt_vrttit.Y K teht ,{ k [ te., ru0.rrlld t te4.11: m .1kmar tiads: Nutt. .I Chf- If ,il•Ipih t heneell r e mPl at1 l- v'a nettnt II Adv.e.hied. iperG(i far THURSDAY, FRIDAY. SATIIRDAY . . Nor. 13, . 14,- IS . VECE 'ANIAN BEANS SV✓EET POTATOES • • Bl`.ANs l'ul 2 CO Na. I rah NOMFN''. I:•n4 tll. - \.. tl • ant _ TOMATO.f7ICE "I.ILt:f _•.. �S aft PEAS 1:4-A(RICc'--- STOVE OIL. SL VICE YbV CAN /AGAIN'CAa ' CHARLES :1 STEIN - GREELEY 7-jf1A. cxuianueE apf Betaety -whore teem APRICOTS ANr 1sPlt PHIL GE:R PHONR OSNOO • ea; ' Trailers end Chassis Made fM Os LIORSETRAILER'S,, AM., UNITS. WI.TICOR WI' "CAetrSTIRS'•.AE IIDUCID' IRIC1,- WIRL 1S9..00. RtDUCID to's49s.oO. . ACEWELDING. & iR'AILER WWW 3756 37aa Main Street :- -_- SAN 0.0.-..1.070,1.k A If Sri go mu h f!rther at.. VANS MARKETS where everyday low prices save you.plenfy! SOUP • 1„>mint PEANUTS Lltjtilndntdl ::'3�_. G� nE, I kite ' L`inila,. *,,A. te!1 t A'� CRANBERRY$AUCE l I•Ll.':'♦ ]i!v cod ._.._ 2Zc FRurr tocrrAR. .d u tie. .1 tee 12�..t .GRAPELAD£ h . L`n. ri 14e1 PRUNES=(urge Sirs) a•- I I J (•roct.,. !wed' ie'xa.• BJ..)1 t Club .. S4W off' 'EE' EJn .5 NATIONS iRlOF WHOlbdt1Nn_ CORN C79.15 MEAT. IILI,w.lx.edl.l ll stk. 'Ott » MARGARINE I 1411w:1 lit Avivkariv .:.... 11.1 an 1'.O^t I......1 MELBA. TOAST CAT FOOD DOtrx FOOD DOG FOOD iioNtts 5•n•gmr 1 TOMATO FED= • sour . SOUP 3 ,-,35 ry39, 26 141 JI KI BALL PA K BOWL IRPNITN ATER r_L_ L I 4 SIGN FRONT ELEVATION 1/2"=1'-Op C3 ;MEMORIAL • r 1 L SIGN BACK ELEVATION 112"=1'-O" (i 1 Cast -in -Place Concrete Monument "SIGN FRONT ELEVATION" "SIGN BACK ELEVATION" City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT ,ETING DATE December 12,2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 16 ITEM TITLE NOTICE OF DECISION — CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A WIRELESS COMMUNICATION FACILITY AT 2435 SWEETWATER ROAD (APPLICANT: TIM KOLSET, WFI FOR SPRINT) (CASE FILE NO. CUP-2000-24) PREPARED BY Charley Marchesano DEPARTMENT Planning EXPLANATION The applicant proposes to install wireless antennas on the roof of an existing four- story hotel. The antennas will be enclosed by a 7-foot fiberglass wall painted and textured to appear as an extension of the existing parapet wall. Equipment necessary for the operation of the facility will be located on the ground level and enclosed by an 8-foot block wall finished to match the existing building. Several trees will be relocated and several parking spaces re -striped to provide access to the new facility. The proposed project design complies with City Design Guidelines. This facility will not be visible from adjacent buildings and streets due to its stealth design. There are no lawfully permitted facilities at this site; however, an unpermitted Skytel whip antenna has been identified on the hotel roof. Skytel and Sprint have agreed to obtain permits for the antenna and co -locate behind the proposed stealth screening. The Planning Commission approved the Conditional Use Permit after holding a hearing November 20, 2000. No one spoke in opposition to the project at the public hearing. Conditions of approval require the proposed stealth design and prohibit the removal of any existing trees. CEnvironmental Review X N/A Categorical Exemption Financial Statement N/A Approved By: Finance Director Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff concurs with the Planning Commission's decision and recommends that the Notice of Decision be filed. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission approved the Conditional Use Permit. Vote: Ayes - Valderrama, Godshalk, Baca, Parra, Martinelli, Detzer Abstain - Ungab ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) 1. Planning Commission Resolution No. 25-2000 2. Location Map Resolution No. A-200 (9.99i RESOLUTION NO. 25-2000 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A WIRELESS COMMUNICATION FACILITY AT 2435 SWEETWATER ROAD. APPLICANT: TIM KOLSET, WFI FOR SPRINT. CASE FILE NO. CUP-2000-14 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of National City considered a Conditional Use Permit application for a wireless communication facility at 2435 Sweetwater Road at a duly advertised public hearing held on November 20, 2000, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented; and, WHEREAS, at said public hearing the Planning Commission considered the staff report contained in Case File No. CUP-2000-14 which is maintained by the City and incorporated herein by reference along with evidence and testimony at said hearing; and, WHEREAS, this action is taken pursuant to all applicable procedures required by State law and City law; and, WHEREAS, the action recited herein is found to be essential for the preservation of public health, safety, and general welfare. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of National City, California, that the testimony and evidence presented to the Planning Commission at the public hearing held on November 20, 2000, support the following findings: 1. That the site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape, since the wireless communication antennas and equipment area will be located on the site of the existing Sweetwater Inn. 2. That the site has sufficient access to streets and highways that are adequate in width and pavement type to carry the volume and type of traffic generated by the proposed use, since the site is served by an arterial (Sweetwater Road), and the unmanned wireless facility will generate little new traffic. 3. That the proposed use will not have an adverse effect upon adjacent or abutting properties, since the proposed antenna structure will be constructed to appear as an extension of the existing building, and since conditions of approval require the proposed equipment cabinets be adequately screened from public view. 4. That the proposed use is deemed essential and desirable to the public convenience and welfare, since the facility will enhance the availability of wireless communication service. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the application for Conditional Use Permit is approved subject to the following conditions: 1. This Conditional Use Permit authorizes a wireless communications facility, and shall conform with Exhibit A -Revised, Case File No. CUP-2000-14, dated November 2, 2000. 2. Plans submitted with any application for a building permit must comply with the 1998 California Building, Electrical, Plumbing, and Mechanical Codes, and Title 24 Energy and Handicapped Regulations. 3. The proposed fiberglass screening shall match the existing wood siding in appearance. 4. The existing whip antenna shall be removed or relocated behind the stealth screening. 5. The block wall enclosing the equipment cabinets shall match the existing building color and finish. 6. The exterior cable tray shall be painted and textured to match the existing building and shall only run to the base of the proposed addition. 7. The two existing trees to the west of the equipment area may be relocated to accommodate the reorganized parking lot, but shall not be removed. 8. Before this Conditional Use Peijuit shall become effective, the applicant and the property owner both shall sign and have notarized an Acceptance Form, provided by the Planning Department, acknowledging and accepting all conditions imposed upon the approval of this permit. Failure to return the signed and notarized Acceptance Form within 30 days of its receipt shall automatically terminate the Conditional Use Permit. The applicant shall also submit evidence to the satisfaction of the Planning Director that a Notice of Restriction on Real Property is recorded with the County Recorder. The applicant shall pay necessary recording fees to the County. The Notice of Restriction shall provide information that conditions imposed by approval of Conditional Use Permit are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. The Notice of Restriction shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney and signed by the Planning Director prior to recordation. 9. The applicant shall not object to co -locating additional facilities of other communication companies and sharing the project site, provided such shared use does not result in substantial technical or quality -of -service impairment for the permitted use. In the event a dispute arises with regard to co -locating with other existing or potential users, the City may require a third party technical study at the expense of the applicant and/or the complaining user. This condition in no way obligates the City to approve any co -location proposal if it is determined by the City not to be desirable in a specific case. 10. Any antennas, equipment or facilities that become obsolete shall be removed. 11. This permit shall become null and void if not exercised within one year after adoption of the resolution of approval unless extended according to procedures specified in Section 18.116.190 of the Municipal Code. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this Resolution be transmitted forthwith to the applicant and to the City Council. BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that this Resolution shall become effective and final on the day following the City Council meeting where the Planning Commission resolution is set for review, unless an appeal in writing is filed with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 p.m. on the day of that City Council meeting. The City Council may, at that meeting, appeal the decision of the Planning Commission and set the matter for public hearing. CERTIFICATION: This certifies that the Resolution was adopted by the Planning Commission at their meeting of December 4, 2000, by the following vote: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: PARRA, GODSHALK, VALDERRAMA, BACA, MARTINELLI, DETZER UNGAB CHAIRMAN PROJECT LOCATION EXIS11NG BUILDING ZONE BOUNDARIES - ®® LOCATION MAP 2435 Sweetwater Road CUP-2000-14 NATIONAL CITY PLANNING DRWN: 10/24/00 INITIAL HEARING: 11/20/00 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT .FETING DATE December 12, 2000 ITEM TITLE NOTICE OF DECISION — CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A WIRELESS COMMUNICATION FACILITY AT 330 NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD (APPLICANT: GERALD MOORER, JM CONSULTING FOR GTE WIRELESS) (CASE FILE NO. CUP-2000-11) PREPARED BY Charley Marchesano DEPARTMENT Planning EXPLANATION The applicant proposes to install a wireless communication facility on an existing building (Bay Theatre), currently being used as a church. Wireless antennas will be placed on the building roof and will be screened by an 8' fiberglass wall textured and painted to match the building. Equipment will be placed inside on the third floor. Access to the facility will be maintained via an exterior stairway at the rear of the building. The stairway will also be screened with materials that match the building. The proposed stealth facility is in compliance with City Design Guidelines. Access to the existing building and parking will not be effected by the project. The Planning Commission approved the Conditional Use Permit after holding a hearing November 20, 2000. There was no opposition. Conditions of approval require the removal of an existing chiller on the roof and stealth screening of the proposed antennas and stairway. AGENDA ITEM NO. 17 Environmental Review X N/A Categorical Exemption Financial Statement N/A Approved By: Finance Director Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff concurs with the Planning Commission's decision and recommends that the Notice of Decision be filed. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission approved the Conditional Use Permit. Vote: Ayes — Valderrama, Martinelli, Parra, Baca, Godshalk, Detzer Abstain — Ungab ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below) Resolution No. 1. Planning Commission Resolution No. 26-2000 2. Location Map A-200 99) RESOLUTION NO. 26-2000 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A WIRELESS COMUNICATION FACILITY AT 330 NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD. APPLICANT: GERA! D MOORER, JM CONSULTING FOR G 1'E WIRELESS CASE FILE NO. CUP-2000-11 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of National City considered a Conditional Use Permit application for a wireless communication facility at 330 National City Boulevard at a duly advertised public hearing held on November 20, 2000, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented; and, WHEREAS, at said public hearing the Planning Commission considered the staff report contained in Case File No. CUP-2000-11, which is maintained by the City and incorporated herein by reference along with evidence and testimony at said hearing; and, WHEREAS, this action is taken pursuant to all applicable procedures required by State law and City law; and, WHEREAS, the action recited herein is found to be essential for the preservation of public health, safety, and general welfare. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of National City, California, that the testimony and evidence presented to the Planning Commission at the public hearing held on November 20, 2000, support the following findings: 1. That the site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape, since the wireless facility will occupy a small portion of an existing building. 2. That the site has sufficient access to streets and highways that are adequate in width and pavement type to carry the volume and type of traffic generated by the proposed use, since the site is served by an arterial (National City Boulevard), and the unmanned wireless facility will generate little new traffic. 3. That the proposed use will not have an adverse effect upon adjacent or abutting properties, since the proposed antenna structure will be located on the roof of an existing building and made to appear as part of the building, and since conditions of approval require the proposed equipment cabinets to be completely in the building. 4. That the proposed use is deemed essential and desirable to the public convenience and welfare, since the facility will extend the service area and strengthen local signals for GTE and its customers. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the application for Conditional Use Permit is approved subject to the following conditions: 1. This Conditional Use Permit authorizes a wireless communication facility, and shall conform with Exhibit A-2nd Revised, Case File No. CUP-2000-11, dated November 13, 2000. 2. Plans submitted with any application for a building permit must comply with the 1998 California Building, Electrical, Plumbing, and Mechanical Codes, and Title 24 Energy and Handicapped Regulations. 3. Before this Conditional Use Permit shall become effective, the applicant and the property owner both shall sign and have notarized an Acceptance Form, provided by the Planning Department, acknowledging and accepting all conditions imposed upon the approval of this permit. Failure to return the signed and notarized Acceptance Form within 30 days of its receipt shall automatically terminate the Conditional Use Permit. The applicant shall also submit evidence to the satisfaction of the Planning Director that a Notice of Restriction on Real Property is recorded with the County Recorder. The applicant shall pay necessary recording fees to the County. The Notice of Restriction shall provide information that conditions imposed by approval of Conditional Use Permit are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. The Notice of Restriction shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney and signed by the Planning Director prior to recordation. 4. The applicant shall not object to co -locating additional facilities of other communication companies and sharing the project site, provided such shared use does not result in substantial technical or quality -of -service impairment for the permitted use. In the event a dispute arises with regard to co -locating with other existing or potential users, the City may require a third party technical study at the expense of the applicant and/or the complaining user. This condition in no way obligates the City to approve any co -location proposal if it is determined by the City not to be desirable in a specific case. 5. Any antennas, equipment or facilities that become obsolete shall be removed. 6. This permit shall become null and void if not exercised within one year after adoption of the resolution of approval unless extended according to procedures specified in Section 18.116.190 of the Municipal Code. 7. The existing water chiller on the roof shall be removed prior to the installation of the wireless antennas and screening. 8. All required wireless communications equipment shall be installed completely within the building. 9. The access stairway shall be completely enclosed, painted and textured to match the existing building. Access to and from the rear exit doors shall be maintained. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this Resolution be transmitted forthwith to the applicant and to the City Council. BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that this Resolution shall become effective and final on the day following the City Council meeting where the Planning Commission resolution is set for review, unless an appeal in writing is filed with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 p.m. on the day of that City Council meeting. The City Council mpy, at that meeting, appeal the decision of the Planning Commission and set the matter for public hearit g. CERTIFICATION: This certifies that the Resolution was adopted by the Planning Commission at their meeting of December 4, 2000, by the following vote: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: PARRA, GODSHALK, VALDERRAMA, BACA, MARTINELLI, DETZER UNGAB CHAIRMAN N PROJECT LOCATION EXISTING BUILDING LOCATION MAP 330 National City Blvd CU P-2000-11 NATIONAL CITY PLANNING DRN. DATE:."-` 10/17/00 INITIAL HEARING: 11/20/00 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT _ETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 18 ITEM TITLE NOTICE OF DECISION — APPROVAL OF A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW ALCOHOL SALES IN A PROPOSED RESTAURANT AT 2980 PLAZA BONITA ROAD (FORMERLY 3030 PLAZA BONITA ROAD) (APPLICANT: FANCHER DEVELOPMENT SERVICES/ NINA RAEY) (CASE FILE NO.: CUP-2000-26) PREPARED BY Jon • - Associate Planner DEPARTMENT Planning EXPLANATION The applicant proposes to sell beer, wine, and distilled spirits at an Outback Steakhouse restaurant. The restaurant building will be constructed at the northwest corner of the Playa Bonita Shopping Center parking lot. The 6,163 square foot building will include seating for 218 with 40 additional seats in an outdoor patio dining area. The proposed Conditional Use Permit (CUP) would allow alcohol sales from 10:00 a.m. to midnight. No one spoke in opposition to the project at the public hearing. The Planning Commission voted to approve the Conditional Use Permit. Environmental Review Lr / Financial Statement N/A N/ACategorical Exemption Approved By: Finance Director Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff concurs with the decision of the Planning Commission and recommends that the Notice of Decision be filed. BOARD ! COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission voted to approve the Conditional Use Permit. Vote: Ayes — Parra, Godshalk, Valderrama, Baca, Martinelli, Detzer Abstain — i ingah ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) i. Planning Commission Resolution No. 27-2000 L.,_. 2. Location Map ___________J A-200 (9 99) Resolution No. RESOLUTION NO. 27-2000 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW ALCOHOL SALES IN A PROPOSED RESTAURANT AT 2980 PLAZA BONITA ROAD (FORMERLY 3030 PLAZA BONITA ROAD) APPLICANT: FANCHER DEVELOPMENT SERVICES/NINA RAEY CASE FILE NO. CUP-2000-26 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of National City considered a Conditional Use Permit application to allow alcohol sales in a proposed restaurant at 3030 Plaza Bonita Road at a duly advertised public hearing held on November 20, 2000, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented; and, WHEREAS, at said public hearing the Planning Commission considered the staff report contained in Case File No. CUP-2000-26 which is maintained by the City and incorporated herein by reference along with evidence and testimony at said hearing; and, WHEREAS, this action is taken pursuant to all applicable procedures required by State law and City law; and, WHEREAS, the action recited herein is found to be essential for the preservation of public health, safety, and general welfare. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of National City, California, that the testimony and evidence presented to the Planning Commission at the public hearing held on November 20, 2000, support the following findings: 1. That the site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape, since the proposed site contains ample room to house the use and provide the necessary parking. 2. That the site has sufficient access to streets and highways that are adequate in width and pavement type to carry the volume and type of traffic generated by the proposed use, since the proposed use is served by Plaza Bonita Road, an arterial street, and since the amount of traffic generated by the proposed 6,163 square foot building will be minimal relative to the estimated 12,700 daily trips on the road. 3. That the proposed use will not have an adverse effect upon adjacent or abutting properties, since the proposed use will be located over 750 feet from the nearest residential properties and since the use will be subject to conditions that limit the sale of alcohol and ensure that it remains accessory to the sale of food. 4. That the proposed use is deemed essential and desirable to the public convenience and welfare, since the facility will provide opportunities to purchase items that are often requested by consumers in a qnality restaurant setting. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the application for Conditional Use Permit is approved subject to the following conditions: 1. This Conditional Use Permit authorizes the incidental sale of alcoholic beverages in a restaurant. 2. Before this Conditional Use Permit shall become effective, the applicant and the property owner both shall sign and have notarized an Acceptance Form, provided by the Planning Department, acknowledging and accepting all conditions imposed upon the approval of this permit. Failure to return the signed and notarized Acceptance Form within 30 days of its receipt shall automatically terminate the Conditional Use Permit. The applicant shall also submit evidence to the satisfaction of the Planning Director that a Notice of Restriction on Real Property is recorded with the County Recorder. The applicant shall pay necessary recording fees to the County. The Notice of Restriction shall provide information that conditions imposed by approval of Conditional Use Permit are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. The Notice of Restriction shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney and signed by the Planning Director prior to recordation. 3. This permit shalt become null and void if not exercised within one year after adoption of the resolution of approval unless extended according to procedures specified in Section 18.116.190 of the Municipal Code. 4 With the annual renewal of the City business license, the business proprietor shall submit a statement clearly indicating total alcoholic beverage sales and total food sales. Said statement shall be subject to audit and verification by employees of the City, who are authorized to examine, audit and inspect such books and records of the license, as may be necessary in their judgment to verify that the sale of alcohol does not exceed the sale of food. All information obtained by an investigation of records shall remain confidential. 5. Exterior advertising and signs of all types, promoting or indicating the availability of alcoholic beverages, including advertising/signs directed to the exterior from within, are prohibited. Interior displays of alcoholic beverages and signs, which are clearly visible to the exterior, shall constitute a violation of this condition. 6. Alcohol sales shall be prohibited between the hours of midnight and 10:00 a.m. 7. Signs shall be posted in the patio dining area indicating that alcoholic beverages must be consumed inside the restaurant or patio area and may not be taken off -premises. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this Resolution be transmitted forthwith to the applicant and to the City Council. BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that this Resolution shall become effective and final on the day following the City Council meeting where the Planning Commission resolution is set for review, unless an appeal in writing is filed with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 p.m. on the day of that City Counc' meeting. The City Council may, at that meeting, appeal the decision of the Planning Commission and set the matter for public hearing. CERTIFICATION: This certifies that the Resolution was adopted by the Planning Commission at their meeting of December 4, 2000, by the following vote: AYES: NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: UNGAB PARRA, GODSHALK, VALDERRAMA, BACA, MARTINELLI, DETZER 01, CHAIRMAN N PROJECT SITE EXISTING MALL BUILDINGS PROPOSED RESTAURANT LOCATION MAP 3030 Plaza Bonita Rd CUP-2000-26 NATIONAL CITY PLANNING ZONE BOUNDARIES DRN. DATE: 11 /3/00 INITIAL HEARING: 11/20/00 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT .EETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 19 ITE TITLE NOTICE OF DECISION - APPROVAL OF A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW CONS 1 RUCTION OF A SEVEN -FOOT TALL FENCE AND A VARIANCE TO ALLOW THE FENCE TO BE LOCATED WITHIN THE REQUIRED SETBACK AREAS AT THE HISTORIC RAILCAR PLAZA AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF HARRISON AVENUE AND BAY MARINA DRIVE (APPLICANT: SAN DIEGO UNIFIED PORT DISTRICT) (CASE FILE NOS. CDP-2000-5, Z-2000-8) PREPARED Y Jon Cain - Associate Planner DEPARTMENT Planning EXPLANATION The applicant proposes construction of a seven -foot fence at the perimeter of the property to provide security for the Railcar Plaza project. The fence will be wrought iron painted black, and will have a curved top. The fence is proposed from 6 to 24 inches from the property lines, and will be located in the public right-of-way on the west side of the property along Harrison Avenue. The variance is needed to allow the fence in the front yard setback along Bay Marina Drive and a portion of the exterior side yard setback along Harrison Avenue. The Railcar Plaza includes special tiles in the concrete walkway around the project that are part of the public art portion of the project. If the fence were built in the setback along Harrison, some of the tiles would need to be removed. Notably, most nearby properties have buildings or fences built at or very near the front and exterior side property lines. Since the property is in the Coastal Zone and the Harbor District Specific Plan Area, it must be found in conformance with the Coastal Act, Local Coastal Program, and Harbor District Specific Area Plan. At the Planning Commission public hearing for the project, Commissioners questioned whether adequate public access was provided and added a condition that the property be unlocked and available to the public from (9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. seven days a week. The Commission voted to approve the project. Environmental Review (-Financial Statement N/A X /A Categorical Exemption Approved By: Finance Director Account No. /STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff concurs with the decision of the Planning Commission and recommends that the Notice of Decision be filed. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION The Planning Commission voted to approve the Coastal Development Permit and Variance. Vote: Ayes - Unanimous A] TACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) 1. Planning Commission Resolution no. 28-2000 2. Location Map Resolution No. A-200 19 99; RESOLUTION NO. 28-2000 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING A COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT TO ALLOW CONSTRUCTION OF A SEVEN -FOOT TALL FENCE AND A VARIANCE TO ALLOW THE FENCE TO BE LOCATED WITHIN THE REQUIRED SETBACK AREAS AT THE HISTORIC RAILCAR PLAZA AT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER OF HARRISON AVENUE AND BAY MARINA DRIVE. APPLICANT: SAN DIEGO UNIFIED PORT DISTRICT CASE FILE NOS. CDP-2000-5, Z-2000-8 WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of National City considered a Coastal Development Permit application to allow construction of a seven -foot tall fence and a variance to allow the fence to be located within the required setback areas at the Historic Railcar Plaza at the southeast corner of Harrison Avenue and Bay Marina Drive at a duly advertised public hearing held on December 4, 2000, at which time oral and documentary evidence was presented; and, WHEREAS, at said public hearing the Planning Commission considered the staff report contained in Case File No. CDP-2000-5 and Z-2000-8, which is maintained by the City and incorporated herein by reference along with evidence and testimony at said hearing; and, WHEREAS, this action is taken pursuant to all applicable procedures required by State law and City law; and, WHEREAS, the action recited herein is found to be essential for the preservation of public health, safety, and general welfare. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Planning Commission of the City of National City, California, that the testimony and evidence presented to the Planning Commission at the public hearing held on December 4, 2000, support the following findings: RECOMMENDED FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL OF THE COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT 1. That granting of the Coastal Development Permit is in conformity with and implements the Certified Local Coastal Program, the Harbor District Specific Area Plan, and Coastal Act §§30210-30214, 30220-30224, and 30252, since the project will serve to protect a public plaza; since the project will not affect public access to the coast or water -oriented recreation activities; and since conditions of approval required by the Harbor District Plan for the proposed development will be incorporated into the permit. 2. That granting of the Coastal Development Permit is consistent with all other plans and ordinances of the City, since fences are permitted in the Tourist Commercial Zone and the Variance for the project will allow the fence to be legally located in the required setback areas. 3. That granting of the Coastal Development is consistent with Chapter 5 of the Harbor District Specific Area Plan and Section 18.102 of the Land Use Code, since the proposed wrought iron fence conforms with the development standards described therein. RECOMMENDED FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL OF THE ZONE VARIANCE 1. That because of special circumstances applicable to the property, including size, location and surroundings, the strict application of Title 18 of the Municipal Code (Zoning) deprives such property of privileges enjoyed by other property in the vicinity and under the identical zone classification, since the property contains the Railcar Plaza and items of historic significance in an area undergoing redevelopment, and since the property proposed fence would provided needed security for the unique property. 2. That the requested variance is subject to such conditions which will assure that the adjustment authorized will not constitute a grant of special privileges inconsistent with the limitation upon other properties in the vicinity and zone in which such property is situated, since several adjacent properties under the same zoning contain structures built in the front and exterior side yard setbacks, and since conditions of the project will require the fencing to be removed when it is no longer necessary for security purposes. 3. That the variance does not authorize a use or activity which is not otherwise expressly authorized by the zoning regulations governing the parcel of property, since fences are permitted in the Tourist Commercial Zone. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the application for Coastal Development Permit and Zone Variance is approved subject to the following conditions: 1. This Coastal Development Permit and Zone Variance authorize the construction of a seven -foot tall wrought iron fence around the perimeter of the Railcar Plaza property and within the required front and exterior side yard setbacks. Except as required by conditions of approval, development plans shall be submitted for review and approval by the Planning Director in substantial conformance with Exhibit A, Case File No. CDP-2000-5/Z-2000-8, dated 11/16/2000. 2. An Encroachment Permit shall be obtained from the Engineering Department for construction in the public right-of-way. 3. Fire Department access must be maintained with a minimum 20-foot width. 4. In order to comply with National City Harbor District Specific Area Plan Section 3.3.3(d), the applicant/property owner shall sign and have notarized an Acceptance Form, provided by the Planning Department, acknowledging and accepting all conditions imposed upon the approval of this permit. Failure to return the signed and notarized Acceptance Form within 30 days of its receipt shall automatically terminate the Coastal Development Permit and Zone Variance. The applicant shall also submit evidence to the satisfaction of the Planning Director that a Notice of Restriction on Real Property is recorded with the County Recorder. The applicant shall pay necessary recording fees to the County. The Notice of Restriction shall provide information that conditions imposed by approval of the Coastal Development Permit and Zone Variance are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. The Notice of Restriction shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney and signed by the Planning Director prior to recordation. 5. All grading and drainage shall comply with the erosion, sedimentation, and pollution discharge requirements of National City Harbor District Specific Area Plan Section 3.3.3.10. 6. All grading within the Planning Area shall be carried out in a manner that will prevent adverse impacts to Paradise Marsh and other delineated wetlands, as well as to the upland margin habitat buffer. All grading and construction shall be consistent with National City Harbor District Specific Area Plan requirements Sections 3.3.3.11, 3.3.3.12, and 3.3.3.13. 7. The property owner shall remove the fencing when it is no longer needed for security purposes or upon request by the City of National City. Upon removal of the fence, landscaping shall be restored by the property owner. 8 The gate shall be unlocked to make the Railcar Plaza available to the public between 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. seven days a week. A sign indicating the days and hours that the Railcar Plaza is open shall be conspicuously posted on the property. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that copies of this Resolution be transmitted forthwith to the applicant and to the City Council. BE IT FINALLY RESOLVED that this Resolution shall become effective and final on the day following the City Council meeting where the Planning Commission resolution is set for review, unless an appeal in writing is filed with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 p.m. on the day of that City Council meeting. The City Council may, at that meeting, appeal the decision of the Planning Commission and set the matter for public hearing. CERTIFICATION: This certifies that the Resolution was adopted by the Planning Commission at their meeting of December 4, 2000, by the following vote: AYES: UNGAB, PARRA, GODSHALK, VALDERRAMA, BACA, MARTINELLI, DETZER. NAYS: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: CHAIRMAN N PROJECT LOCATION LOCATION MAP 840 Bay Marina Drive CDP-2000-5 Z-2000-8 NATIONAL CITY PLANNING DRN. DATE: 11 /29/00 INITIAL HEARING: 12/4/00 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT EETING DATE December 12 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 20 /ITEM TITLE Request to Use the Community Center for a Staff Forum by the County of San Diego and Waiver of Fees PREPARED BY Burton Myers DEPARTMENT Public Works EXPLANATION The County of San Diego, Health and Human Services Agency is requesting to use the North room and Kitchen of the Community Center on January 18, 2001 to hold its annual All Staff Forum. They are expecting 300 people from 7:30 a.m. until 12:30 p.m.. The County is also requesting waiver of fees. Costs: Building $351.80 Custodial 122.87 Kitchen 50.00 Total: $524.67 This group does not fit into any acceptable category of use listed in the Council adopted "Rules and Regulations for the Use of the National City Community Center". Since they are not a National City based organization, the rules state that this use requires Council approval. Environmental Review Financial Statement N/A Loss of $524.67 if waiver of fees. approved. STAFF RECOMMENDATI Council decision on use of BOARD t COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A nd waiver of fees. Account No. ATTACHMENTS (Listed Below I Resolution No. Application for use of the Community Center Letter from the County of San Diego dated November 29, 2000 A-200 (9/80) APPLICATION FOR USE OF THE NATIONAL CITY COMMUNITY BUIL1]INC TO ALL APPLICANTS: It is strongly recommended that the applicant requesting use of the facility attend the City Council meeting, when the Rem is going to be discussed in order to answer any questions posed by the City Council. Please refer to the attached copy of "Rules and Regulations." County of San Diego Name of Organization Health and Human Services Agency, South Region Business Address 690 Oxford Street, Chula Vista, CA 91910 Name of Applicant Betty A. Morell, Deputy Director Address Telephone Number ( 619) 409-3302 (day) ( ) n/ a (evening) Type of Function All Staff Forum Date Requested January 18 , 2001 Decorating Time 7 30 (am/pas). to 8 : 30 (am✓ ' Function Time 8:30 fan(Pro) to 12:30 (aselpm) Use of Kitchen Facility X yes no Use Time 7 : 30 (am/p to 8 : 30 (am�at) Clean-up 11:45 (am/p to 12:30 (am/pm) Number of Participants .00 Will Admission be charged? No_ If yes, Amount $ Will this event be used as a fund raising event? No Will alcohol be served? No ABC Permit Submitted? n/ a. Certificate of Insurance attached? Yes Special configuration of tables or chairs required? Yes -(If yes, attach sketch) Special equipment required? No (If yes, attached list) Copy of Rules & Regulations provided? Yes Initial I CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED A COPY OF THE RULES Sr. REGULATIONS FOR THE COMMUNITY CENTER, AND I AGREE FOR MY ORGANIZATION TO CONFORM TO ALL OF ITS PROVISIONS. Applicant recognizes and understands that use of the City's facility may create a possessory interest subject to property taxation and that Applicant may be subject to the payment of property taxes levied on such interest. Applicant further agrees to pay any and all property taxes, if any assessed during the use of the C' 's facility pursuant to Sections 107 and 107.6 of the Revenue and Taxatio odes against Applicant's possessory interest in the City's facility. Signature of Applicant Di te. Nov-08-00 09:33A P.0'2 CITY OF NATIONAL CITY PUBLIC PROPERTY USE HOLD HARMLESS AND INDEMIFICATION AGREEMENT Persons requesting use of City property, facilities or personnel arc required to provide a minimum of $1,000,000 combined single limit insurance for bodily injury and property damage which includes the City, its officials, agents and employees named as additional insured and to sign the Hold Harmless Agreement. Certificate of Insurance must be attached to this permit. Organization County of San Diego, Health and Human Services Agency, South Region Person is charge of activity Betty A. Morell, Deputy Director Address 690 Oxford Street, Chula Vista Telephone 619/409-3302 City facilities and/or property requested National City Community Center Date(s) of use January 18, 2001 HOLD HARMLESS AGREEMENT The undersigned hereby agree(s) to hold the City of National City harmless and indemnify the City of National City from and against all claims, demands, costs, losses, damages, injuries, litigation and liability arising out of or related to the use of public property by permittee's agents, employees or contractors. Signature of Applicant Official Title Certificate of Insurance Approved by Name & Title Rev. 1/21/00 2 12/04/2000 16:30 619-409-3304 SOUTH REGION HO PAGE 02 STEVEN A. ESCOBOZA INTERIM DIRECTOR BETTY A MOREL!. DEPUTY DIRECTOR November 29, 200 Mary Lee Augustin Department of Pub Works City of National Ci 2100 Hoover Aven e National City, CA • 1950 �Cy lnig f c4un tae$u HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES AGENCY SOUTH REGION 690 OXFORD STREET, SUITE A, CHULA VISTA, CA 91911 {619) 409-3302 • FAX (619) 409-3304 Dear Ms. Augustin Thank you for tent from 7:30 a.m. to 1 Diego, Health and Forum". Approxim Enclosed is the a Insurance for proc National City Corn As a governmenta usage of the Cente January 21, 1999, that time. We a understanding that advise us accordin 0CAUFORMA CHILDREN oERV/CEB axes %moosOME ROAD SAN DEGO. CRSVS0 tSSS) E50440 D CHICKENS SERVICES 10oaAV MARINAORNE NATIONAL CITY. GA S10E0 (S10) 0Sd8Tn 0 FUSUC HEALTH NURSING ADvARRSTRAiloN P.O.P.OBOX SEEM SAN OIEOO. CA SEI S59222 MRa0p.u9s NO OXFORD STREET CHULA Minn, CA o1911 0 PADRE** S RVICEs ma) a0931Ts O FAMo.v RE8OURNE CENTER SUITE E avesSo PUBLIC MEALTN CENTER sure N (09).094110 tively reserving the National City Community Center for January 18, 2001, :30 p.m. As per our discussion on November 8, 2000, the County of San uman Services Agency, South Region will be holding its annual "Alf Staff tely 300 staff will be attending this event. plication for use of the Center and a copy of the required Certificate of ssing. I am in receipt of the Rules and Regulations for the Use of the unity Center and fully understand ail requirements. agency, we are requesting the fee be waived for costs associated with , e.g., access to the main hall and kitchen, as well as custodial services. On ur initial Ail Staff Forum was held at your Center and the fee was waived at respectfully requesting that the fee be waived once again. It is our his request is at the discretion of the National City Council and that you will ly of their decision. If you have any que.tions, please call me at 819/409-3302. We appreciate your cooperation and timely response in t is request. Sincerely, ELIZA FLOR Health and Human /ef Enclosures S, Administrative Secretary ervices Agency, South Region AEETING DATE City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT December 12, 2000 21 AGENDA ITEM NO. (-ITEM TITLE Request to Use the Community Center for a Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment Program and Waiver of Fees PREPARED BY Burton Myers DEPARTMENT Public Works EXPLANATION The South County Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment program is requesting to use the south room of the Community Center from 2:30 p.m. until 4:30 p.m. for the following dates: March 6th, April 17th, April 25th, May 9th, and May 15th. This program supports begininning teachers during their first two years in the teaching profession. The program pairs experienced teachers with begininng teachers, with the National School District being an active member in the program. Costs: Building: $469.00 Custodial: $335.10 Total: $804.10 (for the 5 dates) As this is not an acceptable category of use according to the Council adopted "Rules and Regulations for the Use of the National City Community Center", Council approval is required. Waiver of fees is also being requested. Environmental Review Financial Statement Loss of $804.10 if waive STAFF RECOMMENDA Council decision for use of tale Center and waiver/of fees. BOARD I COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS ( Listed Below ) L_, Application for use of the Community Center Letter from the Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment Consortium dated November 27, 2000 Resolution No. A-200 (9/80) APPLICATION FOR USE OF THE NATIONAL CITY COMMUNITY BUILDING TO ALL APPLICANTS: It is strongly recommended that the applicant requesting use of the facility attend the City Council meeting, when the Item is going to be discussed in order to answer any questions posed by the City Council. Please refer to the attached copy of "Rules and Regulations." Name of Organization South County BTSA Consortium Business Address 601 Elm Avenue, Imperial Beach, CA 91932 Name of Applicant Marsha Buckley -Boyle, Director Address 601')Elm Avenue, Imperial Beach, CA 91932 Telephone Number (619 ) 575-5835 (day) (619 ) 227-5061 (evening) Type of Function Various BTSA meetings/trainings Date Requested Please see attached list of dates/times Decorating Time (am/pm) to (am/pm) Function Time (am/pm) to (am/pm) Use of Kitchen Facility yes xx no Use Time (am/pm) to (am/pm) Clean-up (am/pm) to (am/pm) Number of Participants Will Admission be charged? No If yes, Amount $ Will this event be used as a fund raising event? No Will alcohol be served? No ABC Permit Submitted? Certificate of Insurance attached? Will be mailed-. directly to the City. Special configuration of tables or chairs required? (If yes, attach sketch) Special equipment required? (If yes, attached list) Copy of Rules & Regulations provided? yeS Initial I CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED A COPY OF THE RULES & REGULATIONS FOR THE COMMUNITY CENTER,, AND I AGREE FOR MY ORGANIZATION TO CONFORM TO ALL OF ITS PROVISIONS. Applicant recognizes and understands that use of the City's facility may create a possessory interest subject to property taxation and that Applicant may be subject to the payment of property taxes levied on such interest. Applicant further agrees to pay any and all property taxes, if any assessed during the use of the City s facility pursuant to Sections 107 and 107.6 of the Revenue and Taxation Code against Applicant's possessory interest in the City's facility. SigliatureofApplicant � �G ' Date CITY OF NATIONAL CITY PUBLIC PROPERTY USE HOLD HARMLESS AND INDEMIFICATION AGREEMENT Persons requesting use of City property, facilities or personnel are required to provide a minimum of $1,000,000 combined single limit insurance for bodily injury and property damage which includes the City, its officials, agents and employees named as additional insured and to sign the Hold Harmless Agreement. Certificate of Insurance must be attached to this permit. Organization South County BTSA Consortium, Person is charge of activity Marsha Buckley -Boyle, Director Address 601 Elm Avenue, Imperial Beach, 919�lephone (619) 575-5835 City facilities and/or property requested National City Community Center Date(s) of use Please see attached HOLD HARMLESS AGREEMENT The undersigned hereby agree(s) to hold the City of National City harmless and indemnify the City of National City from and against all claims, demands, costs, losses, damages, injuries, litigation and liability arising out of or related to the use of public property by permittee's agents, employees or contractors. Signature of Applicant Certificate of Insurance Approved by Rev. 1 /21 /00 -iF4r/m) Official Title b/ Date Name & Title 2 Dec Os 00 O1:14p p.2 SOUTH COUNTY BTSA CONSORTIUM DATES FOR NATIONAL CITY COMMUNITY CENTER March 6, 2001 - Year 1 Support Provider Meeting 3:00 p.m. - 6:30 p.m. Set-up for 45 people (tables and chairs) April 17, 2001- Year 2 CFASST Training 3:00 p.m. - 6:30 p.m. Set-up for 30 people (tables and chairs) April 25, 2001 Year 2 Academy 2:30 p.m. - 6:30 p.m. Set-up for 80 people (tables and chairs) May 9, 2001- Year 1 Support Provider Meeting 2:30 p.m. - 6:30 p.m. Set-up for 45 people (tables and chairs) May 15, 2001 Year 2 Academy 3:00 p.m. - 6:30 p.m. Set-up for 80 people (tables and chairs) Dec 05 00 02:43p p.1 beginning teacher S up N o rt Baps OS St-ne rt+ 601 Elm Avenue, Imperial Beach, CA 91932 * Office: (619) 575-5835 * Fax: (619) 575-5830 November 27, 2000 City of National City ATfN: City Council 1243 National City Blvd. National City, CA 91950 Dear City Council: As director of the South County BTSA Consortium, I am requesting use of your Community Center for the BTSA (Beginning Teacher Support & Assessment) program. This is a program supporting Beginning Teachers during their first two years in the profession. Experienced teachers are paired with Beginning Teachers as peer coaches. Dr. Ellen Curtin of National School District, as an Advisor to the BTSA Consortium suggested we use your facility for these meetings. National School District is an active participant in our Consortium. South Bay Union, Coronado Unified, San Ysidro, and Lemon Grove School Districts are the other members of our Consortium. National School District currently has over 25 Beginning Teachers in our program. We hold several trainings each month. Currently, clue to construction, school modernization, and after -school programs, we are no longer able to hold our trainings at school sites. Therefore, we are asking for permission to hold trainings in your facility on the following dates from 2:30 p.m. - 6:30 p.m.: March 6`", April 17th and 25`", and May 9t and 15t. We would also like to request a waiver of fees. Thank you for your time and consideration. If you have any further questions, please feel free to contact me directly at (619) 575-5835. Sincerely, Marsha Buckley -Boyle Y BTSA Director South County Consortium City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT 22 FETING DATE fPePmher, 12,E AGENDA ITEM NO. (-ITEM TITLE Use of the Community Center by the South Bay Community Service for Safe Night Events PREPARED BY Burton Myers DEPARTMENT Public Works EXPLANATION The South Bay Community Services is requesting the use of the North Room and the kitchen for three "Safe Night" events. The event dates are January 13th from 12:00 p.m. to 11:00 p.m., March 23rd, and June 22nd from 12:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. Safe night events are a program to divert youths from the streets into a creative type environment. The majority of the youths are National City residents. Approximately 120 participates are expected. Councilman Beauchamp, the Parks and Recreation Department and County Probation help to promote this program. This is an acceptable category of use according to the Council adopted "Rules and Regulations for the Use of the National City Community Center. Environmental Review Financial Statement X NIA Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDA Council decision of use ft ity e -ter. BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION J N/A ATTACHMENTS (Listed Below) Resolution No. Application for use of the Community Center A-200 (9/80) APPLICATION FOR USE OF THE NATIONAL CITY COMMUNITY BUILDING TO ALL APPLICANTS: It is strongly recommended that the applicant requesting use of the facility attend the City Council meeting, when the Item is going to be discussed in order to answer any questions posed by the City Council. Please refer to the attached copy of "Rules and Regulations." Name of Organization South Bay Community Services Business Address c/o Shiela Zamora - NCPD/Peter Moranda 336-8337 Name of Applicant Mitch Beauchamp Address p_o Box 985. National City, CA 91951-0985 Telephone Number (619 ) 477-5333 (day) (619 ) 477-0295 (evening) Type of Function Safe Night Date Requested Sat. January 13; Fri. March 23; Fri. June 22, 2001 Decorating Time (am/pm) to (am/pm) Function Time 12:00 (am l) to 9 : 00 (arn ) Use of Kitchen Facility X yes no Use Time (am/pm) to (am/pm) Clean-up (am/pm) to (am/pm) Number of Participants /06- i 2- v Will Admission be charged? nO If yes, Amount $ Will this event be used as a fund raising event? no Will alcohol be served? no ABC Permit Submitted? Certificate of Insurance attached? Special configuration of tables or chairs required? (If yes, attach sketch) Special equipment required? (If yes, attached list) Copy of Rules & Regulations provided? Initial I CERTIFY THAT I HAVE RECEIVED A COPY OF THE RULES & REGULATIONS FOR THE COMMUNITY CENTER, AND I AGREE FOR MY ORGANIZATION TO CONFORM TO ALL OF ITS PROVISIONS. Applicant recognizes and understands that use of the City's facility may create a possessory interest subject to property taxation and that Applicant may be subject to the payment of property taxes levied on such interest. Applicant further agrees to pay any and all property taxes, if any assessed during the use of the City's facility pursuant to Sections 107 and 107.6 of the Revenue and Taxation Code against Applicant's possessory interest in the City's facility. Signature of Applicant Date CITY OF NATIONAL CITY PUBLIC PROPERTY USE HOLD HARMLESS AND INDEMIFICATION AGREEMENT Persons requesting use of City property, facilities or personnel are required to provide a minimum of $1,000,000 combined single limit insurance for bodily injury and property damage which includes the City, its officials, agents and employees named as additional insured and to sign the Hold Harmless Agreement. Certificate of Insurance must be attached to this permit. Organization Person is charge of activity Address Telephone City facilities and/or property requested Date(s) of use HOLD HARMLESS AGREEMENT The undersigned hereby agree(s) to hold the City of National City harmless and indemnify the City of National City from and against all claims, demands, costs, losses, damages, injuries, litigation and liability arising out of or related to the use of public property by permittee's agents, employees or contractors. Signature of Applicant Certificate of Insurance Approved by Rev. 1/21/00 Official Title Date Name & Title 2 City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT ,EETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 23 INTEM TITLE Use of the Community Center by the National City Adult School Computer Class for a Graduation Ceremony PREPARED BY Burton Myers DEPARTMENT Public Works EXPLANATION The National City Adult School Computer Class is requesting use of the North Room of the Community Center to hold a graduation ceremony on Friday January 19, 2001 from 6:00 p.m. until 9:30 p.m. They are expecting approximately 300 people. Councilman Beauchamp, who is the Futures Foundation Director, is sponsoring this event. This is an accpetable category of use according to the Council adopted "Rules and Regulations for the Use of the National City Community Center. Environmental Review X N/A Financial Statement Account No. STAFF RECOMMENDATI Council decision on use of t ommunity Center BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION N/A ATTACHMENTS Listed Below) Resolution No. A-200 (9180) City of National City, California COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT FETING DATE December 12, 2000 AGENDA ITEM NO. 24 ITEM TITLE YEAR END AUDIT REPORTS FOR FISCAL YEAR ENDED JUNE 30, 2000 PREPARED BY EXPLANATION Marylou Matienzo DEPARTMENT Finance Transmitted herewith is the City of National City's year end Audited Financial Statement for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2000, prepared by Calderon, Jaham & Osborn, the City's external auditors. The auditors have conducted their examination of the combined financial statements — combining individual funds and account group financial statements in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards and, accordingly, included such tests of the accounting records and such other auditor's procedures as considered necessary in the circumstances. Environmental Review N/A Financial Statement Not applicable. Approved By: Finance Director Account No.. STAFF RECOMMENDATION We recommend that Council receive and file report. 7 77''7 BOARD / COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION ATTACHMENTS (Listed Below 1 Resolution No. 1. Year End Audited Financial Statement. A-200 : 99) City of National City Office of the City Attorney 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, CA 91950-4301 George H. Eiser, Ill • City Attorney (619) 336-4220 FAX (619) 336-4327 TDD (619) 336-1615 TO: Mayor and City Council FROM: City Attorney SUBJECT: Tobacco Products Regulation 12/12/00 ITEM #25 DATE: December 6, 2000 INTRODUCTION At the December 5 City Council meeting, a number of citizens expressed their opposition to a retail store which sells tobacco products located at the southeast corner of 30th Street and Highland Avenue. Questions were raised as to why the store was allowed to locate in such proximity to Sweetwater High School, and as to how this situation could be prevented. BACKGROUND The store in question is permitted at its present location as a matter of right. No city ordinance regulates the location of businesses selling tobacco products. Therefore, in order for the store to legally open its doors, its owners were required only to obtain a business license. When the ordinance regulating the sale of tobacco products was enacted in April of this year, one type of regulation presented for consideration was to impose distance limitations on businesses selling tobacco products; however, such a regulation was not enacted. EXISTING REGULATIONS The regulations that were enacted in April added Chapter 9.38 to the National City Municipal Code, restricting the sale, display and promotion of tobacco products to minors. Chapter 9.38 includes the following restrictions: 1. For businesses located within 1,000 feet of any school, playground, recreation center or facility, childcare center or library, tobacco products may not be displayed and a tobacco advertising display may not be located, within two feet of any candy, snack or non-alcoholic beverage display. These prohibitions do no apply to businesses where access to the premises by persons under 18 years of age is restricted by law, or to displays which are not accessible and not visible to patrons, or to displays that are located above, behind or below a sales counter and are not accessible to patrons. ® Recycled Paper Tobacco Products Regulation December 7, 2000 Page Two 2. Self-service displays of tobacco products are prohibited. 3. Distribution of free tobacco products or promotional items is are prohibited, except in enclosed areas where minors are not permitted. 4. Every business which deals in tobacco products is required to post conspicuously, a sign stating that the sale of tobacco products to persons under age 18 is prohibited by law. In addition, existing State law prohibits or restricts sales or display of tobacco products, as follows: 1. Sales or furnishing of tobacco products to minors is unlawful. (Penal Code Section 308). 2. Single item or unsealed tobacco package sales are unlawful. (Penal Code Section 308.2). 3. Coin operated cigarette vending machines are prohibited, except in bars. (Business and Professions Code Section 23039). 4. The State may require tobacco vendors, upon notification, to post signs advising that the sale of tobacco to minors is unlawful. (Business and Professions Code Section 22952). 5. Unsolicited delivery of tobacco products to residences is unlawful. (Penal Code Section 308b). POSSIBLE ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS In addition to the existing City and State regulations discussed above, the Council may wish to enact the following measures: 1. Prohibit tobacco sales altogether within 1,000 feet of schools, public parks and playgrounds and other youth oriented venues. (NOTE: Although residential areas could be included, the net effect would most likely ban tobacco sales citywide, which is probably legally unsupportable and for that reason, no reference to residential areas is suggested in any proposed ordinances). Tobacco Products Regulation December 7, 2000 Page Three 2. As an alternative toNumber 1, impose distance restrictions on businesses engaged primarily in the sale of tobacco products, e.g., where more than a specified percentage of the business's floor area is devoted to sale and display of tobacco products. 3. Require tobacco products, smoking implements and cigarette papers to be kept in a locked display case. 4. Ban tobacco vending machines throughout the City. This will impact only bars and taverns licensed for consumption of alcohol and beer, since tobacco vending machines are already banned in all other stores. (However, this will have no impact on minors whose presence is banned from those establishments). 5. Require retail facilities selling tobacco products to be specially licensed to sell tobacco. 6. Prohibit smoking in an increased number or classes of establishments on a citywide basis (types of venues to be determined). 7. Prohibit outdoor advertising of tobacco products within a specified distance of schools, parks, etc. This option was considered by the City Council at the time the City's indoor advertising restrictions were enacted. At that time, this Office brought to the Council's attention a recent decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which invalidated state and local restrictions on outdoor tobacco adverting. The decision, Lindsey v. Tacoma -Pierce County Health Department, (195 F.3d 1065), (9th Circuit, Nov. 19, 1999), held that the Federal Cigarette Labeling and Advertising Act (FCLAA), as amended by the Public Health Cigarette Smoking Act of 1969 (PHCSA), 15 U.S. Code Section 1334, preempted state law requirements or prohibitions on advertising of tobacco products labeled in accordance with Section 1332 of the FCLAA. Since all cigarette packages sold today are labeled with this legend, the net effect is a virtual prohibition on local advertising restrictions. (The restrictions on advertising enacted by the City Council in April attempted to distinguish the holding in Lindsey by addressing indoor advertising only). Several cities in San Diego County had previously enacted tobacco advertising bans. The Lindsey decision may affect those ordinances and the provisions of Business and Professions Code Section 22961 (bans outdoor tobacco advertising within 1,000 feet of schools and public playgrounds). The Ninth Circuit decision was not appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. Accordingly, in California the Lindsey decision is binding. Tobacco Products Regulation December 7, 2000 Page Four The portion of the FCLAA that was analyzed in Lindsey is the following preemption provision: No requirement or prohibition based on smoking and health shall be imposed under State law with respect to the advertising or promotion of any cigarettes the packages of which are labeled in conformity with the provisions of this chapter. (Section 1334(b)). The Lindsey court held that an outdoor advertising ban enacted by the Tacoma -Pierce County Health Department was preempted by the clear and express language of the FCLAA because it created a requirement or prohibition based on smoking and health with respect to the advertising or promotion of any cigarettes. However, it may be possible to enact an outdoor tobacco advertising ban based on justification other than "smoking and health", such as protecting minors from advertising that encourages them to buy a product that is illegal for them to use. GEORGE H. EISER, IH City Attorney GHE/gmo