Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2004 06-15 CC AGENDA PKT (2),Ad\��\\ VanutnnmtAl/!//ffp///� /!/%{/UIIe iaolun 1150% AGENDA OF A SPECIAL MEETING CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS CIVIC CENTER 1243 NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD NATIONAL CITY, CA TUESDAY, JUNE 15, 2004 IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE 3:00 P.M. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING ROLL CALL BUSINESS: 1. RFSOT.TTTTON NO 7004-9R• RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY STATING ITS INTENTION TO ESTABLISH THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT AND TO LEVY AND COLLECT ASSESSMENTS WITHIN SUCH DISTRICT PURSUANT TO THE PROPERTY AND BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT LAW OF 1994, PART 7 OF DIVISION 18 OF THE CALIFORNIA STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING OBJECTIONS THERETO ADJOURNMENT Adjourn to Regular City Council Meeting — Tuesday, July 6, 6:00 p.m., City Council Chambers, Civic Center Upon request, this agenda can be made available in appropriate alternative formats to persons with a disability in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Please contact the City Clerk's Office at (619) 336-4228, to request a disability -related modification or accommodation. Notification 24 hours prior to the meeting will enable the City to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this meeting. 'Ott ,SI E➢ 4➢ 1�,. i� .W NOTICE OF A SPECIAL MEETING CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS CIVIC CENTER 1243 NATIONAL CITY BOULEVARD NATIONAL CITY, CALIFORNIA 91950 TUESDAY, JUNE 15, 2004 IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING THE 3:00 P.M. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of National City will hold a special meeting on Tuesday, June 15, 2004, immediately following the 3:00 p.m. Community Development Commission regular meeting of 3:00 p.m., at the Civic Center, 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, California, 91950. The business to be transacted at said meeting will be for the City Council to consider the following: 1. RFSOT.ITTION NO 7004-9R• RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY STATING ITS INTENTION TO ESTABLISH THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT AND TO LEVY AND COLLECT ASSESSMENTS WITHIN SUCH DISTRICT PURSUANT TO THE PROPERTY AND BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT LAW OF 1994, PART 7 OF DIVISION 18 OF THE CALIFORNIA STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING OBJECTIONS THERETO Dated: June 7, 2004 NICK INZUNZA Mayor City of National City COUNCIL AGENDA STATEMENT MEETING DATE: June 15, 2004 AGENDA ITEM NO. 1 /ITEM TITLE: RESOLUTION 2004-98: RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY STATING ITS INTENTION TO ESTABLISH THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT AND TO LEVY AND COLLECT ASSESSMENTS WITHIN SUCH DISTRICT PURSUANT TO THE PROPERTY AND BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT LAW OF 1994, PART 7 OF DIVISION 18 OF THE CALIFORNIA STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING OBJECTIONS THERETO PREPARED BY: Benjamin Martinez, ,r DEPARTMENT Community Development Commission Executive Director EXPLANATION: In March 2004, the Community Development Commission Board approved an agreement with New City America for the formation of the Property Business Improvement District for the Downtown Area. As a result, several Downtown National City property owners formed a steering committee and met with New City America staff to formulate the "Downtown National City Management District Plan." In April 2004 a plan was adopted by the steering committee. Consistent with the streets and Highway Code a peti- tion drive was initiated to bring the issue to a public hearing and assessment ballot proceeding of the property owners. On June 7, 2004 the required petition threshold equaling a minimum of 50% of the weighted property owners within the proposed districts submitted petitions affirming their support for the district. On June 8, 2004 those pe- titions were submitted to the Community Development Commission staff. According to State Law, once this peti- tion threshold has been met, the City Council may initiate an assessment ballot proceeding consistent with Propo- sition 218, to determine whether or not weighted support exists for the establishment of the Downtown National City PBID. With this, Staff recommends that the Community Development Commission Board consider adopting the attached Resolution stating its intention to establish the Downtown National City Management District and to levy and col- lect assessments within such district. Environmental Review X N/A Financial Statement There will be no fiscal impact as a result of this action. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Approve Resolution No. 2004-98 stating the City Council's intention to establish for five years, "The Downtown National City Management District" (the District) and to levy and collect assess- ments against lots and parcels of real property within the District, commencing with the fiscal year 2004-05; and, Authorize the Council to cast ballots in favor of establishment of the Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District including City and CDC owned properties. ATTACHMENTS (Listed Below) Resolution No. 2004-98 1. Petition Response Report 2. Downtown National City Management District Plan 3. District Engineer's Report RESOLUTION NO. 2004 — 98 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY STATING ITS INTENTION TO ESTABLISH THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT AND TO LEVY AND COLLECT ASSESSMENTS WITHIN SUCH DISTRICT PURSUANT TO THE PROPERTY AND BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT LAW OF 1994, PART 7 OF DIVISION 18 OF THE CALIFORNIA STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE AND APPOINTING A TIME AND PLACE FOR HEARING OBJECTIONS THERETO WHEREAS, the Property and Business Improvement District Law of 1994, Part 7 of Division 18 of the California Streets and Highways Code, commencing with Section 36600, (the "Law") authorizes cities and counties to establish, for up to five years initially, property and business improvement districts ("PBID") to promote the economic revitalization and physical maintenance of business districts; and WHEREAS, the Law authorizes cities to levy and collect assessments on real property within such districts for the purpose of providing improvements and promoting activities that specially benefit real property within such districts; and WHEREAS, Articles XIIIC and XIIID of the California Constitution and Section 53753 of the California Government Code impose certain procedural and substantive requirements relating to the levy of new or increased assessments; and WHEREAS, a written petition has been submitted by property owners within Downtown National City requesting the City Council to initiate proceedings pursuant to the Law to establish the Downtown National City Management District for a five (5) year period; and WHEREAS, such petition was signed by property owners in the proposed district who will pay more than fifty percent (50%) of the assessments proposed to be levied; and WHEREAS, a Management District Plan entitled the "Downtown National City Management District Plan" (the "Management District Plan") and a District Assessment Engineer's Report has been prepared and submitted to the City Clerk, containing all of the information required by Section 36622 of the Law, including a description of the boundaries of the district, the improvements and activities proposed for the district, and the cost of such improvements and activities. Said documents are on file in the office of the City Clerk. follows: NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council declares as Resolution No. 2004 — 98 June 15, 2004 Page 2 Section 1. Pursuant to Section 36621(a) of the Law, the National City Council Members declares its intention to establish for five years, "The Downtown National City Management District" (the "District") and to levy and collect assessments against lots and parcels of real property within the District, commencing with fiscal year 2004-05. Section 2. The Council Members hereby approves the Management District Plan, on file in the office of the City Clerk. Section 3. The City Clerk shall make the Management District Plan and other documents related to the District available to the public for review during normal business hours. Section 4. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Council Members shall conduct a public hearing to establish the District and to levy and collect assessments for fiscal year 2004-05 on August 3, 2004 at 6:00 p.m. or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard, in the National City Council Chambers located at 1243 National City Boulevard. At the public hearing, the Board will consider all objections or protests, if any, to the proposed establishment of the District and the proposed assessment. Any interested person may present written or oral testimony at the public hearing. Section 5. The boundaries of the proposed District are included in the Management District Plan. See Plan for description. Section 6. The proposed activities for the District include streetscape, sidewalk, parkway and street furniture maintenance, repair and replacement including but not limited to trees, sidewalk pavement, sidewalk bollards, street furniture, trash receptacles and street lights as well as periodic landscape maintenance and steam cleaning services which benefit businesses and real property located in the District. Section 7. The assessment proposed to be levied and collected for fiscal year 2004-05 is $240,772.01. The amount to be levied and collected for subsequent years may be increased, by an amount not to exceed five percent (5%) per year in accordance with increases in the Consumer Price Index for all Urban Consumers. Section 8. The City Clerk or designee, is hereby authorized and directed to give notice of the public hearing as provided in Section 53753 of the Government Code and Article XIIID, Section 4 of the California Constitution. --- Signature Page to Follow --- Resolution No. 2004 — 98 June 15, 2004 Page 3 PASSED and ADOPTED this 15th day of June, 2004. Nick lnzunza, Mayor ATTEST: Michael Dalla, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: George H. Eiser, Ill City Attorney National City Petition Response Report 6/8/2004 @ 11:28:29 AM 5, 32 20 00 105 East 8 Street L.L.C. $1,764.62 0.73% 556 554 18 00 Ball John D;Betty J $1,195.18 0.50% 556 554 19 00 Ball John D;Betty J $569.85 0.24% 556 333 17 00 Bank Of America $4,907.21 2.04% 555 085 06 00 Beauchamp Family $187.37 0.08% 555 085 07 00 Beauchamp Family $4,258.90 1.77% 555 113 12 00 Beauchamp Family $1,569.72 0.65% 555 113 13 00 Beauchamp Family $1,133.05 0.47% 555 052 06 00 Billups Leon Jr $471.60 0.20% 556 212 01 00 Browder Joseph M $240.00 0.10% 556 212 02 00 Browder Joseph M $240.00 0.10% 556 212 03 00 Browder Joseph M $496.74 0.21% 556 212 07 00 Bryant-debrule $754.77 0.31 556 553 02 00 Chase Betty L Tr $357.75 0.15% 5F 53 03 00 Chase Betty L Tr $409.23 0.17% 556 554 16 00 City Of National City $4,415.42 1.83% 556 471 03 00 City Of National City $2,233.31 0.93% 556 471 04 00 City Of National City $575.76 0.24% 556 472 26 00 City Of National City $3,056.70 1.27% 556 471 17 00 Demeo Fred Inc $2,691.26 1.12% 556 553 09 00 Demeo Fred Inc $515.54 0.21% 556 553 12 00 Demeo Fred Inc $567.57 0.24% 556 553 13 00 Demeo Fred Inc $526.29 0.22% 556 333 15 00 Ducay Sonny V;Rosario $2,626.38 1.09% 555 030 01 00 Estolano, Mario P & $240.00 0.10% 555 030 02 00 Estolano, Mario P & $427.32 0.18% 555 030 03 00 Estolano, Mario P & $0.00 0.00% 555 030 04 00 Estolano, Mario P & $0.00 0.00% 555 030 05 00 Estolano, Mario P & $240.00 0.10% 55. 0 06 00 Estolano, Mario P & $0.00 0.00% 555 030 07 00 Estolano, Mario P & $240.00 0.10% 555 030 17 00 Estolano, Mario P & $1,089.50 0.45% 355 030 20 00 Estolano, Mario P & $4,997.45 2.08% ATTACHMENT NO. 1 National City Petition Response Report 6/8/2004 @ 11:28:29 AM 555 030 22 00 556 104 01 00 556 472 23 00 556 472 24 00 556 472 27 00 555 114 01 00 556 473 15 00 556 473 17 00 556 333 18 00 556 471 16 00 555 052 04 00 556 331 22 00 555 053 17 00 556 331 25 00 556 471 24 00 556 331 14 00 555 083 22 00 555 083 23 00 555 083 24 00 555 041 07 00 555 041 08 00 555 030 21 00 556 471 23 00 555 041 09 00 556 331 04 00 556 334 22 00 556 553 01 00 556 101 02 00 556 101 15 00 556 101 16 00 556 493 04 00 555 042 15 00 Estolano, Mario P & General Bead Jackel Donald Trust Jackel Donald Trust Jackel Donald Trust Kellogg 2002 Trust Meints Carlyle M Tr Meints Carlyle M Misako Hirota, DMD National City Chamber National Family Trust Niederfrank Dairies Inc Pacifica Harbor View Pacifica Harborview Pacifica Harborview San Diego Cemetery Southwestern Southwestern Southwestern Stewart Ellen R Trust Stewart Ellen R Trust Torres Juan;Dignora Union Bank of Ury George A Tr Ury George A Tr Ury George A Tr Ury George A Tr Voit Commercial Voit Commercial Voit Commercial Yamane Trust Yen Swan C Supportive $6,609.58 $2,485.63 $2,019.79 $527.74 $265.95 $240.00 $1,526.52 $962.08 $522.19 $1,585.34 $694.46 $1,255.39 $22,785.90 $3,133.35 $3,673.51 $2,439.68 $5,094.43 $2,989.50 $5,751.78 $694.46 $511.82 $3,644.29 $4,830.57 $511.82 $505.91 $452.14 $694.46 $1,815.33 $5,492.84 $2,276.33 $934.44 $3,104.82 $133,030.54 2.75% 1.03% 0.84% 0.22% 0.11% 0.10% 0.63% 0.40% 0.22% 0.66% 0.29% 0.52% 9.47% 1.30% 1.53% 1.01% 2.12% 1.24% 2.39% 0.29% 0.21 1.51% 2.01 0.21% 0.21 0.19% 0.29% 0.75% 2.28% 0.95% 0.39% 1.29% 55.27% 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 05 JUN-08-2004 01:09 AM •-,• wets 4'�11 WU,w MI IMil u1AW Lrr!!nut ppm NU, 9De4 20126 828238718E Mot cart 1sERICA City of National City PirnT►ON TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY TY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT °+siren sem Orem led *hers Mot Mee ordeMi int 08 au eo LOAM 10e P.01 P, A2/O2 Peet 82 owns % of Total Ae.,7nrt,enl 0,73% 81,7214.82 Yon the es, approve of Ms prepOlteri Messmer!! of 81,704.82 peroN(Q) Identified on this pin, No,! do not approve of the proposed seassament of ai.res.sa on itlr penes a) kfforitifted on this petition, or lin by on gspfssongetive PLEASE $ION AND RETURN QY MAY27, 2004 Phases FAX ropy, to: Now a City Ins. and MAIL or'igin.t to: lioN erg/ America, Ins, Downtown Nations► City P810 Fleet! 213O Columbia bia tit, sort Mtge, CA 92101-1712 alto A4vvcp 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 04 JUN-07-04 M0N 02:38 PM B6/03/2004 10:25 6192397105 FAX MO. FEW CITY *ERICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 section 36800. Streets and Highway Code, State of Cordomte) P. 02 PAGE e2 L4gat Owner; 9outhwmstem College Owner Y of Total Assessment: 0.61 % ass on 2100 655 03$ zZ 00 555 083 23 00 665 083 24 00 PKOPO gD. ES$MENT S1,848,55 $5,094.43 ;2,989.60 58,751,78 Yea, I approve of the proposed assessment of $15,682.56 on the parcel(&) Identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of 315.682,58 on the parce►(s) Identified on this petition, Norma L. Hernandez, Interim Superintendent/President Please Print Name And Title Slgrlaturo of Record Owner or, (in the ease of property o orized Repreeentath e ed by noel -Individuate) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Flamm FAX copy to! New City America, Inc. 819-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City MID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 JUN-07-2004 MON 09:27 AM SAN DIEGO LEATHER 66I04/2804 12;61 6192397,M5 NEW CITY AMERICA FAX NO, NEW CITY AMERICA amity of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to rho Aot of 1664 Sawn moo, Strikta and Hammy y Cods, 9teta or CAIUnto) Legel Owner: Biilupe Leon Jr AIM 688 052 06 00 PAGE 06 P. 01 PAGE 18 Owner % of Tots! Assesament; 0.20% ARDRESZ pR41Pgsa¢A,s6ES8UNT 616 Notional City Blvd S471.60 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $471.60 on the parcel(S) identified on this petition, No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(*) Identified on this petition. $471.60 Fog %r`e`� Please nt Noma mid Tltia Signature or R Br Representative (In die aacs of ropetiy o by non-IndMdualo) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 20D4 Please PAX copy too New City America, Inc_ 619-239-7105 and PAWL original to: New City America, Inc._ Downtown National' City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 07 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner Niederfrank Dairies Inc Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.52% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 331 22 00 724 A Ave $1,255.39 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,255.39 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,255.39 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. -.. inA'eQ4r\ (1Fo ..]PPlease Print Name and Title • Signature of Recor. owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 08 National City Petition Response Report 6/7/2004 @ 2:35:16 PM 556 332 24 00 555 113 05 00 556 332 22 00 5550811500 565 082 05 00 555 082 11 00 555 082 10 00 556 210 26 00 556 334 19 00 555 082 06 00 5562102500 555 081 09 00 555 082 0.1 00 555 082 02 00 182 03 00 555 082 04 00 556 553 04 00 555 081 17 00 555 081 10 00 Addleson Ernest J;Ellen Brock Paul R Cannon Family Trust Clark Donald M Curfan Ltd Curfan Ltd Dobbin lntervivos Trust Fulks Troy;Elisa Graham David M Harper Derrick B;Julie E Massa Laurie Rubin Jeanette Tr Rubin Jeanette Tr Rubin Jeanette Tr Rubin Jeanette Tr Rubin Jeanette Tr Sardo Living Revocable Wild Erich Ziman Allan W;Helene Opposed $1,409.83 0.59% ✓ $792.75 0.33% $375.86 0.16% ✓ $216.88 0.09% t!/ / $1,137.98 0.47%i/ $4,097.40 1.70%✓ $1,533.33 0.64%V $1,510.43 0.63%1/ $2,101.81 0.87% V $96D.23 0.40% V $1,662.72 0.69%✓ $510.24 0.21 %✓ $1,855.29 0.77%V $244.19 0.10°/I $527.88. 0.22%/ $399.68 0.17t✓ $616.95 0.26% ✓ $1,992.94 0.83% $267.23 0.11 % ✓ $22,213.61 9.23% 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 09 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Addleson Ernest J;Ellen N Living Trust Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.58% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 332 24 00 135 E 8th St $1,409.83 Yes, I approve of the prbposed assessment of $1,409.83 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,409.83 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. 4D6zese-d - OGJit%!L Please Print Name and Title t Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMtERICA PAGE 10 Legal Owner: Graham David AA BEM 558 3341900 app_Ega_,S, 305 E 8th St • Darien'%' of Total Assessment: , 0.87% $2,101.81 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $2,1o1_a1 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, ► do not approve, of the proposed assessment of $2,101.81 on the patcel(s) identified on this petition. �IJ I/I 'l - -h/ Please Print Name and Title 1 rr.•� Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE S.i(N AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. .619-239.7105 and MAIL original, to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition • 2139 Columbia St_ Sair Diego,•CA '92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 11 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Fulks Troy;Elisa APN ADDRESS Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.70% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 210 26 00 421 National City Blvd $1,692.56 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,692.56 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,692.56 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title X Signature of I cord Owner or Authorized Representative (In the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 12 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DsOWNTOVVN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY B:USINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Flighway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Massa Laurie APN 556 210 25 00 X Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.68% ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 423 National City Blvd $1,662.72 Yes, tap -rove of the propeised assessrhent-4 $1,662.72 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, 1 do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,662.72 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of properly owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 13 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of1994 Section 36600, Streets and -Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Brock Paul R Owner % of Total Assessment 0.33°/0 APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 113 05 00 25 WllthSt $792.75 x Yes, lapprove of the proposed assessmentof $792.75 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $792.75 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. k A k X Signature of ecprd Owner orAuthoei Representative . (in thecase Of property owned by,nari-individuals)" • Please Print Iineari-ci") PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City AmeriCa, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 14 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Sardo Living Revocable Trust 07-28-95 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.25% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 553 04 00 1017 National City Blvd $616.95 Yes,'I approve of the proposed assessment of $616.95 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $616.95 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Jos f7 li 54.r610 Please Print Name and Title Signature of Rt cordwner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 15 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Wild Erich APN 5550811700 ADDRESS Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.53% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 832 Hoover Ave $1,278.45 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,278.45 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,278.45 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title • Signature of Record Owner or Authorizedcepresentative (in the case of properly owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 16 City of National City PETITION. TO FORM THE. DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, StMe of California) Legal Owner: Cannon Family Trust 02-01-93 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.15% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 332 22 00 127 E 8th St. __.,_ ... $375.86 Yes, 1 approve of the proposed assessment of $375.86 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. eX No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $375.86 on the parcels) identified on this petition. (-70,,,,,;/E, cm, Ai I ) riff!? 0e-o•AVFk'S Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner dif Authaited Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals), PLEASE SIGN ARID RETURN BY MAY 27, 2:004 Please FAX copy to; New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBJD Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 17 !2004 15:21 619-477-8148 SID'S CARPET BARN PAGE 06 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets end Highway Coda. State of California) Legal Owner Rubin Jeanette Tr Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.50% APA ADDRES4 " PROPWEraaagUYIElii 655 081 09 00 822 Hoover Ave $826.67 555 082 01 00 132 W 8th St $1,855.29 555 082 02 00 128 W 8th St $244.19 555 082 03 00 817 Hoover Ave 5527.88 655 082 04 00 *no Site Address"' $399.88 Je6tM ik- t h `riasfG>✓ Please Print Name and Title Signature of record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc, 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St_ San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 18 2/2964 15:21 619-477-B140 SID'S CARPET BARN PAGE 07 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $3.853.71 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $3.053-71 on the parcel(s) Identffled on this petition. �eanee. Trz�,s Please Print Name and Title Signature of ecord Owner or Authorized Representative (In the case of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to; New City America, Inc_ Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St_ San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMiERICA PAGE 19 / 2034 15: 21 619--477-8148 SID'S CARPET BARN PAGE 03 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Aot of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Curlan Ltd vJ Owner % of Total Assessment: 2.16% ,APR ADDRESS PROPOSE() ASSESSMat 555 082 05 00 829 Hoover Ave #A $1,137.98 666 08211 00 111 W 9th St S4,097.40 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $5,235_38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition, XNo, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $5.235.3B on the parcel(e) identified on this petition. (W&) 4 �it-C-4/0A°./44t) Please Print Name and Title Signature of R - • . • ., er or Authorized Representative (In the cas of p • party owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City P13ID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AM1ERICA PAGE 20 '22/2004 15:21 S19-477-8149 SID'S CARPET BARN City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (Oursuant to the Act of 1994 Sectton 38800. Streets end Highway Code, State of Canrornia) Legal Owner: Zimah Allan W;Hetene ADDRESa 555 081 10 00 816 Hoover Ave $240.00 PAGE_ 01 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.10% PROPOSEb ASSESSIY(ENT Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. ALLA..) 70,41 Please Print Name and Title a2etu, Slgne a of - ecord Owner or Authorized Representative se of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 21 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Harper Derrick B:Julie E AFN ADDRESS Owner Wet Total Assessment: 0.3.1 % PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 082 06 00 127 W 9th St $756.59 X Yes., I approve of theproposed, assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. $756.59 No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $756.59 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. be fT c/c__ Please Print Name and Title 4 Signature of Record Oarofier or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PB1D Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/0712004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 22 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Clark Donald M APN ADDRESS 555 081 15 00 810 Hoover Ave $216.88 X Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.09% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of_ .$216,88 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $216.88 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619 239-7105 and MAIL, original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 s--/7.04 06/07/2004 14:52 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 23 City. of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT pursuant,to the Mt of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Dobbin Intervivos Trust 10-23-92 A'l`t ADDRESS 555 082 10 00 110 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.57% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT W 8th St $1,391.88 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,391,88 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,391.88 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Neale and Title. Signature of Record Owner or.At thorized Representative (in the case of property Owned by non-indiViduais) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 FROM : FROM JUAN, J, TORRES. FAX NO. : 619 482 4924 0E-1 2Gr 2004 14: 01 6187397105 NEW CM AMERICF. City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36300, Strests and Highway Code. State of California) Legal Owner: Torres Jijan:Dignora Liv;ng Trust APN ADDRESS 555 030 21 00 330 National City Blvd $3,644.29 May. 20 2004 02:Sst M P1 PAGE 02 Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.5' % PROPOSED ASStti5SM4ENI Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $3,644.29 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $3,644.29 on the parcels) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Tile Signature�r word • n r or Authorl <; : epresentative (in t�- case of property owned by non•indivlduale) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc, 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 JUN-07-2004 MON 02:12 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER 86/04/2004 12:01 6192397105 FAX NO. PEW CITY ica a ""City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN EN� IONADISTRICTCITYL PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT (Pursuant to mu Ad of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Meinte Carlyle M Tr 556 47316 00 200 E 8th St Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, 1 do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. P. 01 PAGE 02 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.63% h.. Plea = = Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative On the Case of property owned by non-individuala) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101.1712 PRQPOSE A� $1,526.52 51.526.52 $1,526.52 JUN-07-2004 NON 02:12 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO, 06/04/2084 12:01 6192397165 NEW CITY AMERICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code. State of California) P. 02 PACE 83 Legal Owner: McInts Carlyle M Tr,Meints Regina M Tr Owner % of Total Assessment 0.40% APN 556 473 17 00 ADDEEM pROPQSED ASSESSMFN'?' 9th St East $962.08 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $962_os on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. No, 1 do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. �v1 / -)t-� Please Print Name and Title nature of Record Owner or / uthorl ed Representative (in the rase of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 $06208 JUN-08-2004 01:09 AM uvu vV.vv rut one I/LCAN LGMInCR MS NU, ore 3004 19:20 U9221971r6 P!W CITY MERICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THL DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (WIu. t to the Act of 'OM s.cden WO, Seem Ind IOhw.y Cods, Owe of canny') sae rig 00 MOM P.el F, 02/02 PAGE 82 \1/ Owner % of rota: Mummer*: 0,?3% toe E eel at enagatiummemt i1,1e4.e2 Yes, t approve of the proposed aae s,ment of $1,784.a2 on the paroel(s) Identified on this petition, Net, I do not approve of the proposed emsseemt. nt of on the paroel(s) Identified on this petition. or or Authoring Reptiresn6etive (hi the oft cf property owned by ndn-Indlvldwh) PLEASE SION AND RETURN SY MAY 27r 2004 Pismo MAX copy to: New City America. Inc. 81 0.239-7105 $1,754.e2 N &t* -7.0 Ft) and MAIL *Alined to: New Downtown at�ionaal C� Arica, Peon 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 02101.1712 JUN-07-04 MON 02:38 PM 06/03/2004 10125 6192397105 FAX NO. PEW CITY AMERICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 SectIon 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) P, 02 PAGE 02 Logat Owner: Southwestom College Owner % of Tote! Assessment: 6.51% ,QPN. 555 033 21 00 555 083 22 00 555 083 23 00 555 083 24 00 PROPOSgD / SSE$SMENT 51,846,85 $5,094.43 $2,989.50 $5,751,76 Yes, f approve of the proposed assessment of $15,6$2.56 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $15,682.56 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition, Norma L. Hernandez, Interim Superintendent/President Please Print Name anTitle X Signaturo of Record Owner oruthorlaed Representative (in the case of property o++frrrffed by non-Indiv)duals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL. original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City P8ff7 Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Niederfrank Dairies Inc Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.52% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 331 22 00 724 A Ave $1,255.39 X Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,255.39 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,255.39 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title Signature of Recor owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 JUN-07-2004 MON 09:27 AN SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. P. 01 66/64/209d 12:81 6192397105 NEW CITY ANERICA -City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Aot of 1994 *cotton *Sea Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner; Billups Leon Jr 555 082 06 00 PAGE 10 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.20% ADDRRaq PRQpQ EO ASSESSMENT 616 National City Blvd $471.60 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $471.60 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve'at the proposed assessment of $471.60 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. q. gem/ 8L/1['fs Jr. P2�-�i«/L Please Print Name And Title X 18) Signature of Korn er thorized Representative (in the case of roperty o ed by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to; New City America, Inc_ 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City MID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 JUN-07-2004 MON 02:12 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. P. 03 ( 06/83/2884 16:15 6192397.105 IEW CITY AMER/C.A._,r 1-City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 30600. Streets end Highwey Code, state of Cattfomle) Legal Owner: Bryant-debn,le Joseph;Liliia Family T i ADDREM PAEE 01 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.31% PROPOr OS.ED - r 536 212 O7 00 543 National City alvd $754.77 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. $754.77 No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $754.77 on the parcels) identified on this petition. 4 4 L . 4- p I3 - Please Print Name and Title deot, Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (In the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN SY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PE3ID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 -FROM :JACK K. FRY .. Tr':'Fir: FAX NO. :619 420 1516 ner . Bryart-debrule Joseph;Cilia Family Tru May. 09 2004 04:11PM 22 Owner % of Total Assessment: ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESS 543 National City Blvd $754.77 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $754.77 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No. I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $754.77 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. LIMA. 1%11 11—CILIAULE -- %A`f F Please Print Name and Title X c .ez)4 4 —c Y Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St_ San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Misako Hirota, DMD Owner % of Total Assessment: 0 22% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 333 18 00 219 E 8th St $522.19 je.4‘4"Cej Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $522.19 on the parcei(s) identified en this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $522.19 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. frt [516160 IfirCIA( VIA) Please Print Name and Title gnature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 MAY 10 2004 22:21 NATIONAL CITY CHAMBER OF 619-477-5018 p.1 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: National City Chamber Of Commerce APN. ADDRESS Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.68% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 471 16 00 909 National City Blvd $1,645.38 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,645.38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,645.38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. �d i±k l If() / s C.L , � F �xe.t✓u fit Osjct,t-- Please Pririt Name andTitle Signature of Record OVG(ier or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 6)( City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: General Bead Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.04% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 5561040100 317 National City Blvd $2,515.55 Yes,.J approve of the proposed assessment of $2,515.55 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $2,515.55 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. U=4fi SL4 < //r. P se Pint Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 AY` 5 M6i-14-2004 FRI 02:41 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. 85/14/2804 14:26 6192397185 NEW CITY AhERICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE. DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1894 Section $8800, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner Estoiano, Mario P & Nancy P. 02 PAGE 0:2 Owner % of Total Assessment 5.77% tkeli ASS$ PROPOSED A.SSe9SMENI 556 030 01 00 3D W 2nd St 6240.00 556 030 02 00 214 National City Blvd 6427.32 555 030 03 00 225 Roosevelt Ave $0-00 555 030 04 00 233 Roosevelt Ave $0.00 555 030 05 D0 27 W Srd St $240.00 555 030 06 00 214 National City Blvd $0.00 555 030 07 00 25 W 3rd St $240.00 655 030 17 00 "no Site Address- $1,089.60 555 030 20 00 340 National City Blvd $4,997,46 555 030 22 00 310 National City Blvd $6,509.58 X Please Print Name and Title Signature Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in case of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America. Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 r?-14-2004 FRI 02:42 P11 SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. 85/14/2004 14;26 5192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA X P. 03 PAGE 03 Yes, 1 approve of the proposed assessment of $13,843.85 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $13,043.86 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. /047v VC) Please Pnnt Name and Title Signe �i of Reco Owner or Authorized Representative e case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: NOW City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. ' San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Chase Betty L Tr Owner% of Total Assessment: 0.32% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 553 02 00 1011 National City Blvd $357.75 556 553 03 00 1015 National City Blvd $426.40 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $784.16 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $784.16 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. . / C7/7"sue , / s /Z Please Print Naine and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Ball John D;Betty J Owner % of Total Assessment: 0 73% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSIVIENT 556 554 18 00 11:05 National City Blvd $1,195.18 556 554 19 00 1121 National City Blvd $569.85 X Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,765.03 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,765.03 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title ature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Kellogg 2002 Trust 08-12-02 APN 555 11401 00 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.10% ADDRESS. PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 38 W 11th St $240.00 Yes, I appraveof the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title re of Record Owner or Auth ed Representative (in the case of property owned y non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Yamane Trust Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.38% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 493 04 00 831-835 D Ave $934.44 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $934.44 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $934.44 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. INS '14406,0G 1 .uST Please Print Name and Title Ignature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE.E. DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Union Bank of California APN 556 471 23 00 ),6 Owner % of Total•Assessment: 1.99% ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 22 E 8th St. $4,830.57 Yes, I approve oT the proposed assessment of $4,830.57 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,830.57 oh the parcel(s)identified on this petition. X 011-CA L." L6i-Ci •),N- V CCf... PfeiSA (10 Pleas Print Name and Title Signature of Re (in the case rd Owner r Authorized Representative f property ned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy tb: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 05/27/2004 14:01 6294778813 PAGE 01/01 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY TY PV§tik§§ IMP: PM NTr9i:FTT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600; Streets and Hiohway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Yen Swan C �'0wner % of Total Assessment: 1.28%N,../ APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 042 15-00 510 National City Blvd $3,104.82 V Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $3,104.82 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $3,104,02 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. u> c, C re w 0it) h'et-- Please Print Mania and Title X'-1� . — _► . Signature of ecord Owner or Authorized Representative (In the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBI D Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICTv.72 (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Volt Commercial Brokerage Owner % of Total Assessment: 3.98% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 101 02 00 229 National City Blvd $1,815.33 556 101 15 00 241 National City Blvd $5,492.84 556 101 16 00 35 E 3rd St $2,276.33 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $9,584.49 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $9,584.49 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X ,j2J'iN t.4ty 04 , p4k7-Ara� Please Print Name and Title Signatof Record Owner o�uthorized Representative (in e case of property o ned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 1/ City of National City PETITION TO FORM : IE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to -the Act ,of 19.948action 36600, Sim% and:Highway-Code, State,ofCaltfomia) Legal Owtter City Of NationalCity-Community -1).Weloprnent -Ovuner%of-Taial Assessment: 2.53% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED -ASSESSMENT 556 471 03 00 921 National City Btvd $2,499.82 556 471 04 00 .929 :National Cityl3tvd. $575.76, 556 472 26 00 t 30 E 8th St $U56.70 Yes, I approverOf the prOposed asses -Solent of $6,132.28 • on the:parcelks1 identified on•this,petition. • No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of S6,132.28 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Mar-tinez Oxect4-hv D ve c+or Please Print Nettle -andriti6 Signature of Record Owner or kuthorized Representative (inttrie,caotTotprqperty-vwn • AonAndivicION PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN. BY NAY 27, 2004 PleaSe FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original. to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBED Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 Its City of National City Pt-num TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY $U$INESSII4PROVENIENT DISTRICT (pursuant bare Act 1:994,Sectiort 6601,;(4 Streets,anctHighway Code, State of.Califomia) L.egal -0Wrier: City OMOtional City APN • 556 554 16 00 x Owner % of TOtal Assessment: 1.82% ADDRESS PROPOSED, ASSESSMENT *no Site Address* $4,415.42 Yes, I approve of the proposed asseSsment of $4,415,42 on the parcel(8) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,415.42 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X Ben tams() MAr+Itlez, Execa-Five Divec+Dy- Please Print Warne and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized resentative (in the case of property oWned bytionAnclividuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBED Petition 2130 Columbia St. San. Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City. PETITION TO FORM THE -DOWNTOWN. NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 38600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Pacifica Harborview Two L P Ciwner% of Total,Aasessreent: 2.80% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 331 25 00 701 •NatiOnal-City-Blvd $3,133.35 556 471 24 00 801 NatiOnal Elivd. $3,673.51 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $6,806.86 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X No, I. db,not approve -of the proposed- assessment of $6,806.86 or the _iparceitsy identified o.n this petition. r Sle • ( cre 1 Pleasa:Print f4afi1e andlitte Signet of Record Owner, a Authorized Representative (in case of -property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN 15Y MAY 27, 20a4 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and NAIL original to: NIew City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE flCV NIOWN tilATIONAL CITY PROPERTY IS IMPRYE1VEENT DISTRICT ' (pursuant:to tiii-Attotte94-.BetfkitirfaSeatrgetsatid,-Highway Codt., 8tele,ofCalifornia) Legal Owner: Pacifica 'Harbor View Otte-L P APN 555 053 17 00 Owner %-of Total Aos.essment: 9.38% ADDRESS RROPDSED ASSESSMENT 7'00 Natiolial City Blvd- $22,785.90 Yes, iapproveef the,1300Metii'BBWOBalattt'Of $22,785,90 on the parcei(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the propOsect assessMent of $22,785.90 on the-pareel(s). identified on this petition. 5r- Preasse-Pririfgamo 'and Tito Signattt *Word dwner or Ail, ,r (irt a6e-ofproperlyownetttyrion-inctivittuals) PLEASE SIGN 'Rfit BY MAY 27, 2.004 Plea, FAX COpy to: New City America, inc. 619,239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City ArTeric0, inc. Downtown National City PMD Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 •City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY ftt/SINE$S. IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994- Section 36.000, Sirsets antlFlighwaYCode, State of California) Legal Owner: National Family Trust 05-01-00 APN ADORES§ 555 052 04 00 640 NatiOnat City Blvd $694.46 Owner-Vo af Total Asseeernent: 0.29% PROPO,SED.ASSESSIVIENT • Yes, I approve of the proPP$ed assessment of • $694.46 on the parceks)identified on this petition. No," do. nOteppnoveof the proposgikassossrnent el $694.46 on..the -parcelNidentified .on this petition. Nme and Title. _.=,---'-,A,91911•Tregigilk. „......00•Sign 0 $7 ' it% ?:idi • rieetlfaWe o proparty owne...'Nr ..44„;dim• „1„.• fiE individuals) ti,pai E 'Kt AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City•America, Inc. 6-1-9-23P-71-05 aturiVtAtt, ,origtnat to: •New City America, Inc. Downtovm,Natibnal City PBtD Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Stewart Ellen R Trust Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.50% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 041 07 00 404 .. National City Blvd $694.46 555 041 08 00 408 National City Blvd $511.82 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,206.28 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve ofthe proposed assessment of $1,206.28 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. r l2 _i27" Please Prime and Title X Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-71.05 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 ck 05/28/2004 FRI 12:47 FAX 619 336 4286 CDC OF NATIONAL CITY 1001/ool 05/28/2004 12:26 6192397106 t'EW CITY AMERICA City of National City • PAGE 01 PETITION TO FORM THE. DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Beauchamp Family Trust 08-16-82 APN 555 085 06 00 555 085 07 00 55511312 00 5551131300 ADpRESS 121 900 40 1010 Owner % of Total Assessment: 2.97% W Plaza Blvd Roosevelt Ave W Plaza Blvd National City Blvd Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. PROPOSED ASSESSMENT $187.37 $4,258.90 $1,569.72 $1,133.05 $7,149.04 No,. I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $7,149.04 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. 3-/ Please Print Name and Title Signature of R F; cr G7 /,3eu 0,o10' er or Autho . ¶ • Representative (in the case • • • petty owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 • Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 «71 05/28/2004 FRI 12:30 (JOB NO. 7545) f¢j001 05-28-2004 08:47 PLAZA MANAGEMENT 6194771719 PAGE:1 a. I. LVYs WV• JV Vi. JLIJ I LYJ ItfY I.111 1 Fw•ly\sVM City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, Stets of Caffomier Legal Owner. Ury George A Tr AEN 555 041 09 00 556 331 04 00 5563342200 666 663 01 00 Owner ►4 of Total Assessment: 0.90% AODRIPS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 41$ National City Blvd $611.82 619 National City Blvd $505.91 345 E 8th St $452.14 1001 National City Blvd $694.46 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $2,164,33 on the parcei(s) Identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $2,164.33 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Namearrd Title Signature of RIord Owner or Authorized Representative �1' 6L (In the case of property owned by non -Individuals) C�,t/`$¢ridasd " PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Piease FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. B19.239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 05-27-2004 09:02 PLAZA MANAGEMENT 6194771719 PAGE:2 u •� City of National City \sk—) PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Demeo Fred Inc Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.77% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 471 17 00 999 National City Blvd $2,691.26 556 553 09 00 A Ave__ $515.54 556 553 12 00 32 W Plaza Blvd $567.57 556 553 13 00 Plaza Blvd $526.29 ti X Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $4,300.66 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,300.66 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative Tin the case-Ofproperty ownea` non-rn�7c ivirTu 1sj PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 Rs\K 06/03/2004 13:21 FAX 6193032612 Sandy Jackel JUN-03-2004 THU 12:12 PM ShN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. 8S/63/ 2884 13; 87 G192397188 find cITY NERICA City of National PErITTON TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN OATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT' ("mem le the Act of 1994 section 36600, Streets eed mow/ clde, Mate of Cetitornto 1-81121 Owner; Jacket DonTrust 17-22.89 owner %Iof Total Assessment 1_17% Aft ADIVIEral 558 472 23 00 108 F.EMLIMINEW-MILOD: ff 8th St 5S8 472 24 00 $2,01p.79 A Ave 658 472 27 00 S527.74 A Ave S283.85 Yes, Iappy9 of the proposed assessrnant of $2.81348 on the parcel(s) Identified on INS petition. No, Ido not approve of the proposed assessment of on the permit's) identified on this petition. Sranature of Oner wor Atrlhortsad (In the toperty owned by non-Indivtduaiis) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN SY MAY gt 2004 Pleats FAX copy to: New Crly America, Imo. 519-23S-7105 end MAIL origlnal to; New City Arnerica, inc. Downtown. National City PRID Petition 2130 Cofumble St. San Die90, CA 92101-1712 .82,813.44 J on/ooi P. 02 PAGE Ed JUN-03-2004 THU 11:38 All SAN DIEGO LEATHER 06/03/2004 08:14 6192397105 FAX NO. P. 02 NNW l:l 1 Y RPL.F w City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CaTY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner Ducey Sonny V;Rosario T Owner % of Total Assessment 1.09% Ap ADDRESS PROPOSED A$SESSIRE 556 33315 00 205 E 8th St $2,626.38 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $2,626.38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. $2,625.38 Please Print Name and Idle gnature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non-indtviduels) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to:. New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia $t. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 JUN-03-2004 THU 11:38 All SAN DIEGO LEATHER D6/83/2004 BB:14 6192397105 FAX NO. NEW city RI+GK1l:R City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (Pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36800, Streets end Highway Cods. State of California) Legal Owner: Browder Joseph M Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.41% P. 03 A_al ADD . ESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 212 01 00 10 E 5th. St $240.00 555 212 02 00 509. National City. Blvd $240.00 556 212 03 00 511 National City Blvd $496.- 4 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $9 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. 6.74 $976,74 Please Print Name and Title Signs f Record Owner or Aut)Sorized Representative se of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239.7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc_ Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 JUN-03-2004 THU 03:05 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. 66/63/2864 16;47 6192397165 NEW CITY AMERIC� City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets end Highway Code, State of California) Legal Diemen sen Diego Cemetery Assn APN 5563311400 i4DDRg;y1 Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.01 % P, 02. 014126.E12.110.0§24= 607 National City Blvd $2,439.88 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $2,439.68 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition, No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $2,439.68 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. M X) r .0,10 Please Print Name and Title Siena re of 12e d Owner or Authorized Representative (iirrlt the case of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, inc. 619-239-7106 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City P13ID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 v\L\ lo� Jun 04 04 03:37p NIW.fITV City of National City p.1 amoommememesmomaammseemisa PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner. Bank Of America National Trust;Savings Owner % of Total Assessment: 2.02% ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 333 17 00 235 E 8th St $4,907.21 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. $4,907.21 No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,907.21 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. cy � four-y l Please Print an Title re Recor . Owner or A (in the . • . roperty owne Representative individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 National City Petition Response Report 6/8/2004 @ 11:15:11 AM 556 332 24 00 Addleson Ernest J;Ellen $1,409.83 0.59% 555 113 05 00 Brock Paul R $792.75 0.33% 556 332 22 00 Cannon Family Trust $375.86 0.16% 555 081 15 00 Clark Donald M $216.88 0.09% 555 082 05 00 Curlan Ltd $1,137.98 0.47% 555 082 11 00 Curlan Ltd $4,097.40 1.70% 555 082 10 00 Dobbin Intervivos Trust $1,533.33 0.64% 556 210 26 00 Fulks Troy;Elisa $1,510.43 0.63% 556 334 19 00 Graham David M $2,101.81 0.87% 555 082 06 00 Harper Derrick B;Julie E $960.23 0.40% 556 210 25 00 Massa Laurie $1,662.72 0.69% 555 081 09 00 Rubin Jeanette Tr $510.24 0.21% 555 082 01 00 Rubin Jeanette Tr $1,855.29 0.77% 555 082 02 00 Rubin Jeanette Tr $244.19 0.10% 555 082 03 00 Rubin Jeanette Tr $527.88 0.22% 555 082 04 00 Rubin Jeanette Tr $399.68 0.17% 556 553 04 00 Sardo Living Revocable $616.95 0.26% 555 081 17 00 Wild Erich $1,992.94 0.83% 555 081 10 00 Ziman Allan W;Helene $267.23 0.11% Opposed $22,213.61 9.23% City of :National. City 'PETITION TO FORM IRE DOWNTOWN:NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT OWRICT (pursuant to,the Act of 1994 Section 3.6600, Streets and F-lighway. Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Addleson •Ernest J;EitenN Living Trust APN ADDRESS 556 332 24 00 135 E 8th St Yes, iapprove, of the prOposeciess.essaterrt of $4,409,83 ori the pareeits)-identietect tilis-petitfon. -0.1m-ner TOtat-A:se-swnent: 0.58% X •PROPOSED -ASSESSMENT $1,409:83 No, cf0 not approve of te.prGp�s1ed1 assessment of $1,409 83 OFi the parcei(s) identifiacf on this petition. 6 ei Pleae-Niiit Name and`Title $ignatiira-pPlias000wpar,ctr pitiffipKiagf:Ikapraseritative tirrthe tateOpropertya*Mad hymari-intlivittuals)' PLEASE siGN'Ali/OommattYMAY 2014 Pleaao FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 antliVIALL original to: New City Arnerica, Inc. Downtown Natibnal City PBtD Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 921,01-1712 FRX NO. : 6194772066 May. 12 2004 05:09PM P1 .. +.�s.rs ■ v :� ':VitlKli: J'if'I.ii'.U1% Rt?F tTY• • -$1 SIMPRO EMENT`;pt pursuant io tfre Act o(1994 $ectior3:36600,..Stceep arrcl',High ray: Code; State'of cardomia) Legal Owner: Graham David M APN 556 33419 00 ADDRESS 305 E 8th.St Owner. % of Total Assessment: 0.87% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT $2,101.81 Yes, 1 approve of the proposed assessment of $2,101.81 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. L-7 No, I do not approveof the proposed assessment of $2,101,81 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. po is CI Ai . it4 -;� Please Print Name and Title ,wl • Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) p s, PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. .619=239-7.105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San: Diego,'CA 92101-1712 City :of 'National City FflThNT Tow. - _NAL CiTY PROPERTY': , !MIMI (OumuarIt to the Adtzef'tia41Setten 3661"-Steeetse4Hienwey_tode; stote.ottohlbEryi* Legal Owner: Brea Paur R .AlaptS Owner Wof "reetel Assessment: 0.33% EfliCtErSYSLOASSESSMENT 5551130500 25 W 1thSt.. $792.75 tainitove'Of the-titAgYeettA*041h-eht,of $742:75 on the pereettslidantifietten •No, I -do not appFeme of the •propweet-as„06eornent Of $792.75 cm the pareelcs) identified on this petition. PIes Printanti gm/Rain: Ault:large presentative 00.4tte;40010::PropertilzwyealiwiirCin-4414/1441SY: •PLEASE SIGN AND RETURNEW BAY VI, 2004 Plea5e FAX copy to: New Gity Amerita, 61-9--239-7 I Q5 Mid MAIL ortgioatAty: New City America, inc. Downtown NetOtlai City r ID Petthon 2130.Ctilumbia St. San Diogo, -921M-1712 City of National City • PETITION TO FORM THE I:OWN-TOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant-10 the Aet t9a4,-Se_ctiegt-366130, Streets and,Higtmay Code, State of California) Legal Owner:. Fulks Troy;.Ellsa APN AVDOESS Miner.% of Total Asoessrnent 0.70% PROROSEDASSESSMENT 556 210.2600 421 NatiOnal. City -Blvd $1,692.56 Yes, I approve -of thelareposed<esseasMent of $1,692.56 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,692 56 ori the parcelfs) -identified ori this petition. 1 PNI Pleepe-Printlitatne and Title $ii3naturetif Ord:.0.Wfiet-orAkitflokitetf-RepyOselltalive (in the 091e Offpdpetty:.tope-4.4y.:ectil4Oviduals). PLEASE SIGNANIXIt TIANSY MAY 27; i2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619,239-7105 and'IVIAL originarto: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City P1311) Petition 2130 Columbia St San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TOFORMTt4EGWNTOWN' -NATIONAL CffY PROPERTY RUINS& iMPRQVMELrr EflTRICT (Pursuankt01110-Aot 01994 Segli00660.0.-,Stroas,atitf141§11wav Cocrei State: of-Qafornia) f,Ogal'OArio1Or: :Massa Laurie APN 556 210 25 00 X •OWNerlo- Teitd1 At4es-ment: 063% ADDRESS. PROPOSELI. ASSESSMENT 423 Nationa1City 'MVO $1,632.72 --Yee74-00PreNp-0 '41-.0-',-a.S$6.,W.FRO-01f-64 $1,662.72 file .pfteitsY irlentittOet On.fhiSpetAiizin. No, I do not aproome of the pPoolased assessment of on, the parosig0-ittentified on- this petition. Atif y Koaii-PithetTaiti4-alid Title $1,662.72 aeazieV417/,(._ giOdature,of7ReogiitrtYweer iar-Aulhotiketr:Ropr$04-ofive (in thp cane at plppgrjxpved-by non-indiviclVats) PLEASE $ION AND RETURN BY MAY 27, Z004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Ino. 61-9-239-7105 arid MAIL Otti-gina New City America, lac. Downtown Nationateity PRO Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 .1 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE OWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the-Actof 1994 Seet(or136600; Streets and:Filphway Code, State of california) Legal Owner: Sardo Living Revocable Trust 07-2S-96 Ow.ner % of Total Assesmerit: 0 25% APN ADDRESS PROPIOSED ASSESSMENT 556 553 04 00- 1.017 National City Divd $616:95 x X Yes, I approve of the propesed-essessmentof on the parceffS-Ideritifiad thiS-Datitierl. No, t do not approve of the proposed assessment of $616.95 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. e? .9 p silt-Ne` Please Print Narrie anciTitle atureof CordOWrier Or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN Aftlai RETURN BY TVLAY 27, 2004 Please• FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619=2394105 and 1111,AIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PE5I'D Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City pUITION TO , THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY\C-1' PROPERTY 'BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT otsiRicT (pursuantio•the:ActofT994 Section-386K Streets and Highway Code; plete of California) • LegatOwner: WiFd Erich APN 555 081 17 00 Ownor % of tt•tat Asses.sment: 0.53% ADDRESS PROPOSED:ASSESSMENT 832 litycwor Ave $1,278.45 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessiment of $1,278.45 on thoparcet(s) identified OR this -petition. No, cio-not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,278A5 on the parcet(s) identified on thiS petitiort. e,..age-PrInt Nat-n-e gruzi Tide - S Sign-atticfReOtitVQ.wrIer:'OrAiifflOtke.d.?:,. orosontottve 'Orrit-welAspot:orn-pottownettbysnpwiniSWOWS) Ete PLEASE: SiGN- AND RETURN SY MAY 27, 21104 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 6t923.9:q1-05 and MAIL oriWriat to; New City Arnerica, inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 Pity -of National city porn ' ..„ETICT orto,stia,itt6.0*-Aavi,Toc.:ft-o- 6warstwasirayebtroma4,10. zootriw. Legal Owner Cannon Family Trutt ca-:0146 APN 556 an 0,06 ApORE'SS .1.21 - 'E743Itrai - $67646 watt' %. Of Taal Astestifent 0.15% PROPOSEDASSESSMENT rat I aPPEOtte theotipogeovaAgtrosraaavef $075-136- on the patteWide-Atittedovittils;peatori. rdo-notegettOvo of: titepeopOsedeWlsment of $8.7516 en. the pareeWittentigett on triktietitioa. ricky rn 0E 1e75- 0M-48-e-ftfitifiltmo-arpsi TitIO ignal re o eaora ner or ut •crpras (irvAlme.-4";-4s'vtilanonettozoneet lownowinginneltra} pLEASE SIG WART -,BY 4 PleassfAX espy -to: New City ASIerioa, Irc 64943,7105 and iVtittl. otittoottot NOw City Arnerioa, Downtown. National Cy MD -Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 12004 15:21 619-477-8148 SID'S CARPET BARN PAGE 06 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State. of California) Legal Owner: Rubin Jeanette Tr Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.50% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 081 09 00 822 Hoover Ave $626.67 555 082 01 00 132 W 8th St $1,855.29 555 082 02 00 128 W 8th St $244.19 555 082 03 00 817 Hoover Ave $527.88 555 082 04 00 "no Site Address* $399.68 JPtt he e r v► Trusce..,. Please Print Name and Title Signature of l ecord Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA-92101-1712 2/2004 15:21 619-477-8148 SID'S CARPET BARN PAGE 07 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $3,653.71 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $3,653.71 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Seaitet. iettb (Pt Trz4..614‹&,e___ Please Print Name and Title Signature of ecord Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 /2004 15:21 619-477-8148 SID'S CARPET BARN PAGE 03 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Curlan Ltd Owner y, of Total Assessment: 2.16% e�P! ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 082 05 00 829 Hoover Ave #A $1,137.98 555 082 11 00 111 W 9th St $4,097.40 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $5,235.38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. XNo, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $5,235.38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Co(*) Please Print Name and Title Signature of R (In the cas A-culio Zit/44J 6teik. 4dg/A ner or Authorized Representative perty owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 122/2004 15:21 619-477-8148 SID'S CARPET BARN City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Ziman Man W;Helene B APN ADDRESS 555 081 10 00 818 Hoover Ave $240.00 PACE 01 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.10% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. A—wceJ co 70(14.0 Please Print Name and Title Signs a of ' ecord Owner or Authorized Representative (i the ase of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO TOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY 1NS ,2 Pk:Mr-MEW OLSTRICT (pursuant to the•Act of 1994 Section-36600, Streets and HighwerCi ode, State oteatifornia) Legal Owner: Harper Derrick P.;Jutie E APN AlaIDRE-SS 555.082 06 00 127 OWner% siscriotaMseStinent:- 0:11% IN'tth St on the parcel(s) identified on this, petition. PRGROSEMASSESSIVIENT $756.59 $756.59 No I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $756.59 on the Pt() identified on this petition. /Prei.c . . Signature of Record- -er• or Authorized .kepreeenfative (in the case of .properfy owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FM copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7106 and NtAfL originat to: Neva City America, Inc. Downtown National City PT3t13 Petition 2130 ColUmbia St San Diego, CA 92101-1712 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of isszt Section 38600; Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owrier: Clark Donald lvt APN ADDRESS 555 0S1 15 00 81-0 Owner % of Total -Assessment: 0.09% PROPOSEDASSESSIVIENT Hoover Ave $216.88 Yas, I approve of theoppasgd ass on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $216.88 on the parceikayidentified or this petition. ,010 1474 / At_ Please Print Name and Title Signatureof Record Owner or Authorized .R enteth/e (in the case Of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND- TURN SY MAY 27, 2004 Ploao FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MALL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown Na at City PI3ID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 921:01-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMiERICA PAGE 02 National City Petition Response Report 6/4/2004 @ 3:35:11 PM 556 554 18 00 556 554 19 00 556 333 17 00 555 085 06 00 555 085 07 00 555 113 12 00 5551131300 5562120100 5562120200 556 212 03 00 556 212 07 00 556 553 02 00 556 553 03 00 556 554 16 00 .71 03 00 556 471 04 00 556 472 26 00 556 471 17 00 556 553 09 00 556 553 12 00 556 553 13 00 556 333 15 00 555 030 01 00 555 030 02 00 555 030 03 00 555 030 04 00 555 0-30 05 00 555 030 06 00 555 030 07 00 030 17 00 555 030 20 00 555 030 22 00 556 104 01 00 Ball John D;Betty J Ball John D;Betty J Bank Of America Beauchamp Family Beauchamp Family Beauchamp Family Beauchamp Family Browder Joseph M Browder Joseph M Browder Joseph M Bryant-debrule Chase Betty L Tr Chase Betty L Tr City Of National City City Of National City City Of National City City Of National City Demeo Fred Inc Demeo Fred Inc Demeo Fred Inc Demeo Fred Inc Ducay Sonny V;Rosario Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & Estolano, Mario P & General Bead $1,195.18 $569.85 $4,907.21 $187.37 $4,258,90 $1,569.72 $1,133.05 $240.00 $240.00 $496.74 $754,77 $357.75 $409,23 $4,415.42 $2,233.31 $575.76 $3,056.70 $2,691,26 $515.54 $567.57 $526.29 $2,626.38 $240.00 $427.32 $0.00 $0.00 $240.00 $0.00 $240.00 51,089.50 $4,997.45 $6,609.58 $2,485.63 0.50%1.•/ 024% . / 2.04% v 0.08%✓ 1.77°/a/ 0.65%1 0.47%✓ 0.10% ✓` 0.10% V. 0,21%✓ 0.31 %17 0.15%%, 0.17%✓ 1.83%✓ 0.93%v ' 0.24%/. 1.27%7 1.12%✓ 0.21 %✓ 0.24%/ 0.22%7 1.09%r , 0.1 O°/O/ 0.18°!°'� 0.00%` 0.00%/ 0.10%/ 0.0096/% 0.104 0.45 t 2.0890 2.75i 1.03°/0/ 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 03 National City Petition Response Report 6/4/2004 @ 3:35:11 PM 556 472 23 00 556 472 24 00 556 472 27 00 555 114 01 00 556 333 18 00 556 471 16 00 555 062 04 00 555 053 17 00 556 331 25 00 556 471 24 00 556 331 14 00 555 041 07 00 555 041 08 00 555 030 21 00 556 471 23 00 555 041 09 00 556 331 04 00 556 334 22 00 556 553 01 00 556 101 02 00 556 101 15 00 556 101 16 00 556 493 04 00 555 042 15 00 Jackal Donald Trust Jackal Donald Trust Jacket Donald Trust Kellogg 2002 Trust Misako Hirota, DMD National City Chamber National Family Trust Pacifica Harbor View Pacifica Harborview Pacifica Harborview San Diego Cemetery Stewart Ellen R Trust Stewart Ellen R Trust Torres Juan;Dlgnora Union Bank of Ury George A Tr Ury George A Tr Ury George A Tr Ury George A Tr Voit Commercial Voit Commercial Voit Commercial Yamane Trust Yen Swan C $2,019.79 $527.74 $265.95 $240.00 $522.19 $1,585,34 $694.46 522,785.90 $3,133.35 $3,673.51 $2,439.68 $694.46 $511.82 $3,729.91 $4,830,57 $511.62 $505.91 $452.14 $694,46 $1,815.33 $5,492.84 $2,276.33 $934.44 $3,104.82 Supportive $113,300.24 0.84%V.. 0.22°/dam 0.11 %,// 0.10% V".. 0.22%.%/J 0.66%✓ 0.29%✓ 9.46%V/ 1.30% �/ 1.53% i/ 1.01% 0.29%+/ 0.21%v// 1.55% �/ 2.01% ✓ 0.21 %✓ 021%v/ 0.19%✓/ 0.29%✓ 0.75%'r 2.28%// 0.95%10.39% ✓/ / 1.29% V 47.06% City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuantto the Act of /994 Section 36800, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal °Wrier: Dobbin lntervivos Trust 1.0-23-92 APN ArlDRESS: 555 082 10'00 t W 8th St Owner %-of tetal-AsSessment 0.57% PROPOSECrASSEStMENT $1,391.8a Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,391 88 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. x No, 1. .€..o not• approve of the proposed assessment of $1,391 88 on the parcel(s) identified on this petitien. / e." "S' Please Rrint'N'anie•and litre Signature of Record Owner or trioriged Representative -fin the caspof property Owned by non-indiViduals,y PLEASE SteN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc.. 619-239-7105 and .IVIALL. original: to: .5- -2- -7,4m New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Cottora St. San Diego CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 04 -FROM :JACK K. FRY .-i,gaSke ut Aril • 530.212 07 00 FAX No. :619 420 1516 May. 09 2004 04:11PM at "' "O I F DOW41:. N:NA rrxOPER 'w Bl 1 ES 3 IMPROVEMENT D1$T t 88ct�on 36800;368ts•and Highway Co.destatA of i all�orida) %> ck of; rAb4 debrule Joseph;UI!a Family Tru ADDRESS ti43 Owner 9% of Tptal . ssessm National Oily Blvd pRoPosEo dssE^ sli $754.77 .' ' Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of S764.77 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $754.77' on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. L► .1A 1%1. 4,14nri— el.r31kUle — "t" 15A Please Print Name and Title XSiignature ctf RecordOwn er Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned bynon-Indlvidunis) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to; New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBIi) Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 05 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner Misako Hirota, DMD APN ADDRESS Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.22% PROPOSED. A$SES$M ENT 556 333 18 00 219 E 8th St $522.19 •Ga r' x Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $522.19 on th.e'parcel(6) identified on this -petition. No,. I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $522.19 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title nature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 06 MAY 10 2004 22:21 NATIONAL CITY CHAMBER OF 519-477-5018 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Ad of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code. State of California) Legal Owner: National City Chamber Of Commerce AP-E ADDRESS 556 471 16 00 909 National City Blvd $1,645.38 Owner % of Total Assessment' 0.68% PROPOSED AASESSMEWT X Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of S1,645.38 on the parcel(s) Identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,645.36 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. p. 1 �c1 rfk A t . /Ev Ae_.s v (i ✓e. s Et.r' Pease Pr1 t Name an Title Signature of Record Oder or Authorized Representative (hi the case of property owned by non -individuals) / y er6 i�Ur, 31 t1 et / PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc_ 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PB1D Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 07 City of National. City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: General Bead Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.04% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 104 01 00 317 National City Blvd $2,515.55 Yes, 1 approve of the proposed assessment of $2,515.55 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $2,515.55 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. se P int Name and T e Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 08 I1h1-14-2004 FRI 02:41 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. 8fi/14/2004 14:26 61923971.05 FEW CITY 045RICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE. DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY Bf U9&SLIM MaIMPROnd YENIECN 9p19CaRICT Legal Owner: Ee►otano, Mario P & Nancy MI MN AMUR EILCIPSIMMAIIEM $240.00 666 030 01 00 30 IN 2nd St 666 030 02 00 214 Notional City Blvd 5427,32 � O 555 090 03 00 226 Roosevelt Ava 556 030 04 00 233 Roosermlt Ave 500 ‘Ai3rd St 5240.00 555 030 O6 00 27 WOO 555 030 06 00 214 National City Blvd w 3rd St $240.00 555 080 07 00 25 $1,089,G0 555 030 1t 00 *no Site Addraas' National City Ntvd $4,997.45 995 030 20 00 3d0 $8,60®,Sd 555 030 22 00 310 National City Blvd P. 02 PACE as Owner % of Total Ass ssmant 5.17°% /V/4-711c`( v� JCS Please Print Noma and Titta (in case tUre �ropropert i owned or Audl y zedrionlvtduels Representative PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PHID Petition 2130 Columbia St. Sari Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 09 r1AW-14-2004 FRI 02:42 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER OS/14/2004 14:25 6142397105 FAX NO, NEW CITY AMER/CA P. 03 PATE 03 Yea, I approve of the prvpOsed assessment of $13.943.as on the parcel(s) identified an this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $13,04$.86 on the paroel(s) Identified on this petition. f KiO Please P t Name and fitlo PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 nose FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: Now City America, Inc. Downtown National Ctty PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 10 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.32% Legal Owner: Chase Betty L Tr PROPO$ED ASSESSMENT APN ADDRESS hlatictnal City Blvd $357.75 556 553 02 00 1011 $426.40 556 553 03 00 1015 •National City Blvd X Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $784.16 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $784.16 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title zed Signature(In the case of property owned y�non-ndivid non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2.130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 11 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code. State of California) Legal Owner: Ball John D;Betty J Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.73% APN 556 554 18 00 556 554 19 00 ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 11'05 National City Blvd $1,195.18 1121 National City.Blvd $569,85 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $1,765.03 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I. do not approve of the proposed assessment of $1,765.03 on the parcet(s) identified on this petition. X �„% 4 �►. IA.0 Please Print Name and Title ature of - zcord Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04I2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 12 4:01 1619�3477,05 FRX NO. : 619 482 4924 May. 20 2004 02:33PM P1 FROMA6%.c0i F J4#t RRES. NEW CST`r J .RICF PAGE 02 ,2tttyri 4: 01 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (plater:Int to the Art 0104 section 38600, Strasta and Highway Coda, Slate of California) Legal Owner: Torres Juan:Diorama Living Trust ADDRESS 666 030 21 G0 330 National City Blvd $3,644.29 Owner % of Total AgAessrnant: 1,5' % Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $3,644 29 on the percei(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $3.644.29 on the percci(s) kientifled on this petition. Please Print Name and Title Signaturer ecord arAutho ,% apraserttetive (in t,. ease of property owned by non•Individuele) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc, S19-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St, San Diego, CA 92101.1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 13 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 38600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Kellogg 2002 Trust OB-12-02 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.10% APN ADDRESS. PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 555 114 01 00 38 w 11 th St $240.00 _ Yes, 1-approve-of the i rbposed 2tssessrnent of $240.00 on.the parcel(s). identified on this petition. X No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $240.00 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title re of ecord Owner or ; f • Representative (in the rase of property owned .y non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND. RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619.239-7105. and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/64/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 14 City of National City PETITION TO FORM CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT CT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Yamane Trust PEA ADDRESS 556 493 04 00 831-835 • D Ave $934.44 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.38% I PROPOSED ASSESSMENT Yes, t approve of the proposed assessment of $934.44 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $934.44 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. -Tt4 'j 4&OG TQu&T Please Print Name and Title gnature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 15 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner Union Bank of California Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.99% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 471 23 00 22 E 8th St. $4,830.57 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $4,83o.57 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,830.57 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X GOIICAE- Vt-ce, Pvtst de.s4-, (AA , "eL Pleas Print Name and Title Signature of Rey •rd Owner 'r Authorized Representative (in the case •f property ned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA 05/27/2004 14:01 6294778813 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY Rgp RYY I5EN s !myervEMT-9,lSYF�I T t to the ^ Te state of California) (pursuant to the Act of 1094 Section 38600.5tre91s and Highway God Legal Owner: Yen Swan C APN 555 042 15'00 mpygal 510 PAGE 16 PACE 01/01 '-Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.28% ROpOSED_ S SS ..N�, National City Blvd $3,104.82 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $3,104.82 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. SIA.)c,h C jet, Okuhta, Please Print Names end Title $3,104.02 Signature of "ecord Owner or Authorized by en Repri s i9)tive (In the case of property PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. g 19-239-7105 and MAIL original to; New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. SanDiego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 17 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Volt Commercial Brokerage Owner % of Total Assessment: 3.98% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 101 02 00 229 National City Blvd $1,815.33 556 101 15 00 241 National City Blvd $5,492.84 556 101 16 00 35 E 3rd St $2,276.33 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $9,584.49 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $9,584.49 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. mod �v Leieve4 Please Print Name and Title 4111 Signet" of Record Owner thorized Representative (in a case of property o ed by non -individuals] PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc_ Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 18 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 38600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: City Of National City Community Development Owner % of Total Assessment: 2.53% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 471 03 00 921 National City Blvd $2,499.82 556 471 04 00 929 National City Blvd $575.76. 556 472 26 00 130 E 8th St $3,056.70 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $6,132.28 X on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, 1 do not approve of the proposed assessment of $6,132.28 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. B-enijamin Mar-1ine2, ExecwhJe D+rec+or Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or uthorized Representative (in the case of property own non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 5192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 19 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner; City Of National City APN 556 554 16 00 x ADDRESS Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.82% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 'no Site Address* $4,415.42 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $4,415.42 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,415.42 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. I3.enjamfn Mar-Finea, Execuifve Direc+i- ir- Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized resentative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101.1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 20 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Pacifica hlarborview Two L P Owner % of Total Assessment: 2.80% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 331 25 00 701 National City Blvd $3,133.35 556 471 24 00 801 National City Blvd. $3,673.51 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $6,806.86 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $6,806.86 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X y..Q.er J `, 1.1 1 S (�...:) -ec re 1Ti- Please Print Name and Title Signet .rj of Record Owner oNAuthorized Representative case of property owned by non -individuals) (in PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 21 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 38600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Pacifica Harbor View One L P Owner % of Total Assessment: 9.38% APN ADDRESS 555 053 17 00 PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 700 National City Blvd $22,785,90 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $22,785.90 on the parcel(s).identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $22,785.90 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title , Signatu 0f Record Owner or Au •'orized Representative (in th > case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 22 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: National Family Trust 05-01-00 APR /ADDRESS 555 052 04 00 % 640 National City Blvd $694.46 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $694.46 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $694.46 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Plea a Print Name and Title r--- doe MIll Sign- n - . : . , p I uthorized Representative of _�.- e o property owne:'�atndividuals) SE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PSID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 Owner % of Total Assessment: 0.29% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT ki\\k� .tip 66/194/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 23 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Stewart Ellen R Trust Owner % of Total Assessment: APN 555 041 07 00 555 041 08 00 X 0.50% AD RESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 404 National City Blvd $694.46 408 National City Blvd $511.82 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Prim Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St_ San Diego, CA 92101-1712 • $1,206.28 $1,206.28 -(4 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 24 05/28/2004 FRI 12:47 FAX 619 336 4286 CDC OF NATIONAL CITY OS/28/2004 12;26 619238710E tw CITY AMERICA City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE. DOWNTOWN NATIONAL. CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section Moo, Streets end 1-9citssay Code, state of calibrate) Legal Owner: Beauchamp Family Trust 08.18.82 JOOU001 PAGE 01 Owner % of Total Assessment: 2.97% ADDRESS PROPOSEDASSESSMFIE 555 085 08 00 121 W Plaza Blvd 5187.37 555 085 07 00 900 Roosevelt Ave $4,268.9D 655 11312 00 40 . W Plaza Blvd 555 11313 00 51,es9.72 1010 National City Blvd 51,133.05 X X Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of 57,149.04 on the percelcs) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $7,149.04 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition_ f ea,(,{ G '!IG[ yf'► Pleases Print Name end Tits f o I' /jt°u G'Giodsc2 Signature of R •. , • er or Autho Representative (In the case • .. perty owned by non -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 ' Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc_ 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Otago, CA 92101-1712 05/28/2004 FRI 12;30 t.UOB NO. 75451 Q10O1 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 25 05-28-2004 08:47 PLAZA MANAGEMENT 6194771719 •LV..n'� VV. JV %++rhru.+�J ..Lw �..y, I M,NJ\L4P9 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT tout.wrt to the Act of 1894 erection 36800, Stowe end Highway Coco, seata of CWEfomlal Legal Owner. Ury George A Tr PAGE=:1 Owner % of Total Aeaeaanwnt: 0.90% MB 041 Oo 00 418 ERP QaoE.G A9 sit 55$ 3a1 04 00 National City Blvd $5/ 1,82 819 National City Blvd $505,91 556 334 22 00 346 S68 6S3 01 OD E $Qt 3t $462.14 1001 National City Blvd $694.46 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $2,104.33 on the paroer(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not eppn,ve of the proposed assessment of on the parcal(n) identified on this petition. ease Print Name -and Title ,ziee ,1 f'0 32,164.33 Signature. R ... ,74, /.40:'“%e0 9 . Owner or Atathor ... Ive r�,vsT?tc (In the case of proPetly eWned try non-IndMMvMddusIs) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 2712004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 610-239-7105 and MAIL, original to: New America, Inc_ Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 05-27-2004 09:02 PLAZAMANAGEMENT 6194771719 c)0 PAGE:2 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 26 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CIT PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 36600, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner: Demeo Fred Inc Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.77% APN ADDRESS PROPOSED ASSESSMENT 556 471 17 00 999 National City Blvd $2,691.26 556 553 09 00 A Ave $515.54 556 553 12 00 32 W Plaza Blvd $567.57 556 553 13 00 Plaza Blvd $526.29 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of $4,300.66 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,300.66 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title Signature of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (itrthe case afpropeiiyotvhe�iiy non-iriijivlCTuals)" " PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc_ 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PBID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 27 08/03/2004 13:21 FAI 6193032612 JUN-03r-2004 THU 12:12 Pl1 SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX racxei e6193/2584 13: e7 5.1933g711a5 FAX , City of National C[t; 1 PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN �NATIO PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEM�� CITY cowman! +a the Art of 19e4 seeron 3.000, Street, a NT DISTRICT' c, set, or agxe,mtey Leant Ohms JckN Doneld Trod 11-29,9 5664??2300 We47224Oa 561472 27 00 108 lr,8i11 St AAve A Ave Owh.r%Lr1 1 An ream 9ovoo1 P. 02 PAM Ed. ttr; 'QQo'_ YIEt. $2,018,T8 t627.74 r, approve of the di j 52.81dd8��parcel(*) 14ntifieonthpe No, the of approveof the proposed essessrnent of p real() fa9nttnen ars this patitiOrt seraAVItiorted seneed by n • , idu4 PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY , j', 2004 Memo FAX copy tot New CRy America, Inc, 019 239-7105 and MAIL *rig to: Naw CityAnlerioa, Inc. i Downtown'National City PSID Petition 2130 coturnble St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 frialtmet 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 JUN-03-2004 THU 11:38 AM SAN DIEGO LEATHER D6,93/2064 Be:14 6192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA FAX NO. NkW U,L I Y FIMKic.ra City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Ad of t994 SectIon 36640, Streets and Highway Code. State of Cataomfa) L.oaal Owner: Ducey Sonny V;Rosario T AIN 556 33315 00 PAGE 28 P. 02 Owner % of Total Assessment 1.0S% ADOR,P S PROPOSEDAS$S3MUNI 20S E 8th St $2,626,38 Yes, i approve of the proposed assessment of $2,026,38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No. I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $2,626.38 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. Uc.4 Please Print Name and Teo tore of Record Owner or Authorized Representative (in the case of property owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL edginal to: New City America, Ino. Downtown National City PB1D Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 JUN-03-2004 THU 11:38 NI SAN DIEGO LEATHER 06/03/2884 08:14 S192397105 NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 29 FAX NO, NEW City Avetciufy City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (Dur5410rd b the Act of 1994 S.c1Fon s5800, Shr®Is and NIgPAa3Y Code. State of California) Lege, Owner. Browder Joseph M DM 556 212 01 00 5.Re21202D) 5562120300 AD_DRES4 10 500 511 Owner % at Total Assessment: 0.11% PROPOSED ASSESSMENT E 5th St $240.00 National at), Blvd $240.00 National C►ty Blvd $490. 4 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of on the parcels) identified on this petition. No, ! do not approve of the proposed assessment of on the pareel(s) Identified on this petition. Sign rn. ft _ •,- f Please Print None end Tltte fit.. Record of- property owned by non -individuals) Representative PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 20 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 819-239.1105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc_ Downtown National City PSID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 $9 5.74 $97a.74 P. 03 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 NEW CITY AhiERICA JUN-03-2004 THU 03.05 PM SAN DIEGO LEATHER FAX NO. 86/03/2084 18: 47 6192397185 NEW CITY AMERICI '—' City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT OPur;sn it to the Ad of 1994 Scetlert 36800. Streets And Highway Code, Mete of CaWomb i) PAGE 30 P. 02 PACE.' 82 Legal Owner. San Diego cemetery Assn Owner % of Total Assessment: 1.01% Aed 566 331 14 00 ADDER 607 National City Blvd PROPOSli P, lgat Elam $2,439.08 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of S2,430.68 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No, I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $2,439.B13 on the paroei(s) identified on this petition. Please Print Name and Title X i C^ Sloe re of Roislifd owner or *AMMO MO Representative ( the ease of propel)/ owned by non -Individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please PAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7106 and MAIL original to; New City America, Inc, Downtown National City MID Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101,1712 vs\t\ (-9\ 06/04/2004 15:59 6192397105 Jun 04 04 03;37p / t .riry NEW CITY AMERICA PAGE 31 p-1 City of National City PETITION TO FORM THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT (pursuant to the Act of 1994 Section 3660D, Streets and Highway Code, State of California) Legal Owner. Bank Of America National Trust,Savings Owner % of Total Assessment: 2,02% �4PN aDDRFSs PROPOSED ASSE.5SMENT 558 333 17 00 235 E 8th St $4,907.21 Yes, I approve of the proposed assessment of S4,90721 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. No. I do not approve of the proposed assessment of $4,907,21 on the parcel(s) identified on this petition. X 1(2t35 l Qrod�fi, Y Please Print Mendan Title • re .4112b Owner or A fin the .roperty own Representative -individuals) PLEASE SIGN AND RETURN BY MAY 27, 2004 Please FAX copy to: New City America, Inc. 619-239-7105 and MAIL original to: New City America, Inc. Downtown National City PB1D Petition 2130 Columbia St. San Diego, CA 92101-1712 RECEIVED 204 Community ek Ji:' DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MANAGEMENT DISTRICT PLAN Formed Under California Streets and Highway Code Section 36600 Property Business Improvement District Act of 1994 FINAL PLAN SUBMITTED TO: THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY P.B.I.D. STEERING COMMITTEE THE CITY OF NATIONAL CITY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COMMISSION EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR BEN MARTINEZ MAYOR NICK INZUNZA AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS LUIS NATIVIDAD, RON MORRISON, FRANCISCO PARRA AND FIDELAS UNGAB PRESENTED BY: MARCO LI MANDRI, NEW CITY AMERICA INC. APPROVED APRIL 30, 2004 UPDATED MAY 24, 2004 l ATTACHMENT NO. 2 DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PROPERTY BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT MANAGEMENT DISTRICT PLAN FINAL PLAN - MAY 24, 2004 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION, EXECUTIVE SUMMARY II. ADDRESS SERIES, GENERAL STREET BOUNDARIES III. WORK PLAN AND BUDGET IV. ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY TO FUND THE SPECIAL BENEFITS V. RELEVANT ENABLING LEGISLATION, AB 1021 VI. ENGINEER'S REPORT AND RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ASSESSMENTS PAID AND SPECIAL SERVICES RECEIVED VII.. DISTRICT GOVERNANCE APPENDIX A. MAP OF THE DISTRICT B. FIVE YEAR PROJECTION OF ASSESSMENTS C. LIST OF PARCELS INCLUDED IN DISTRICT D. CERTIFIED ENGINEER'S REPORT 2 PART I EXECUTIVE SUMMARY DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY MANAGEMENT DISTRICT PLAN Statement of Purpose Ovel- the past two years, the people of San Diego County have begun to see National City in a whole new light. Long identified with the extremely successful National City Mile of Cars, the City now has the distinct identity of a municipal corporation aggressively moving forward on a number of fronts. Whether it be the visionary Marina project, the development of Filipino Village, the beautification of Highland Avenue or the creation of the Education Village in Downtown National City, more things are happening in this City than almost anywhere else in the County. Under the leadership of the Mayor and City Council, as well as the staff of the Community Development Commission, National City is in a race to re -position itself as a great City with bustling commerce, historic significance, a great urban forestry plan, strengthening of ethnic neighborhoods and experimenting with what makes Downtowns work in the 21' Century. Led by a group of significant, small and long-time business and property owners, this effort to establish a Property Business Improvement District was initiated in March 2004. With great speed and tremendous commitment, it is the intent of this district to be established and generate its first revenues by the conclusion of calendar year 2004. Such an undertaking is unprecedented but reflects the seriousness of the effort of the Downtown stakeholders to redefine themselves to the surrounding region. With the growing state budget crisis in California and its resulting impact on the cities, it is safe to assume that current National City general benefit services delivered in the Downtown business district will not increase in the future. To make the Downtown district and community better, commercial and institutional property owners must look at new ways of funding special benefit services to clean up the district as well as promote the area. Such special benefit services could include bringing a new identity to the Downtown business district, funding new gateway signs to the district, regular sidewalk sweeping, sidewalk steam cleaning, removal of bulky items, trash receptacle emptying, providing private security services above and beyond that of the National City Police Department, aiding in the coordination of homeless intervention services, proposing solutions to parking problems, initiating beautification programs, tree planting and maintenance, coming up with new marketing and promotions programs, defining greater visual linkages to the 8th Street Trolley stop as well as serving as an advocacy group of business and property owners. This proposed Downtown National City PBID or special benefits district would be funded through an assessment levied on each and every parcel in the finalized and approved boundaries in Downtown. Affected property owners have determined the exact costs of funding these special benefit services. All properties, public and private, would be included in this new assessment district. 3 In early April, a survey was mailed to every property owner within the initial study area. The area included all parcels on National City Blvd. between 2"d Street on the north, 12`h Street on the south, and along 8th Street from the Trolley Stop on the west to E Avenue on the east. There are 153 parcels in the proposed district, represented by 96 property owners. The district is approximately 34 square blocks. The database compiled by New City America, Inc. reveals the following data that would create the material basis for the apportionment of assessments throughout the district: • 1,465,301 square feet in total lot size; • 448,344 square feet in total building size; • 21,744 linear feet in total frontage The survey results were quite stunning. The results of the survey were as follows: NUMBER OF RESPONSES: Respondentsrepresented the following property variables: Lot size: Building size Linear Frontage 522,523 square feet or 35% of the total 240,713 square feet or 54% of the total 8,248 linear feet or 37% of the total Of those who responded to the survey, the following respondents, (by weight) demonstrated their support for creation of the PBID: Responses from Property Owners Who Returned PBID Survey Response Lot Size Building Size 88% Linear Frontage 77% Support Formation 76% Oppose Formation 24% 12% 23% Of those who responded, the following represent support of specific special benefits funded by the PBID: ➢ 61% had owned their property for 9 years or less; ➢ 73% were sole proprietorship or family owned properties ➢ 52% believed that National City had been portrayed negatively by the major media in the last few years; ➢ 84% believed that Downtown unsafe district;" ➢ 54% would support property owners funded special benefit security services; ➢ 54% feel their customers would not feel safe walking from the corner of 8th and National City Blvd. and the Trolley Stop; ➢ 64% would support initiation of property owner funded regular sidewalkigutter sweeping and steam cleaning services; was unsafe or "safe, however suffers an image as an 4 ➢ 70% support property owner funded special events to improve the identity of Downtown; Based upon this level of support, the Downtown National City PBID Steering Committee is presenting the following to all Downtown Property Owners for their consideration: PROPERTY VARIABLES TO BE ASSESSED: Three property variables will be used to fund the special benefit services of the district. Those variables will include: lot or parcel size, building square footage, and linear frontage. Each of these variables can be verified by County records. By law, the district can only fund special benefits, not general benefit services. Building square footage will be further categorized by "use", (retail, hotel, church, public building, office, etc). Use determines needs and therefore special benefit to be received. SERVICES TO BE FUNDED: The primary special benefits to be funded by the creation of the district will be related to maintaining order and cleanliness in the public rights of way. In addition, beautification of the Downtown will be paramount as well as creating concrete visual linkages between the Trolley stop west of the freeway and the heart of the business district at 8th and National City Boulevard. After order and beautification, district identity and promotional programs will be funded. Finally, a component for administration/corporate affairs and contingency/reserve will be included in the budget. Consistent with state legislation, the district shall remain in place for five years with provisions for annual CPI adjustments as well as annual disestablishments procedures. BENEFIT ZONES: There will be two benefit zones in the proposed district. Benefit Zones are determined by the level and frequency of services to one sector of the district, vs. another. For example, the core area parcels along National City Boulevard between 2"d and 12th, as well as 8th Street from the freeway bridge to A Avenue, will constitute Benefit Zone 1. All other parcels in the district will fall into Benefit Zone 2. ANNUAL BUDGET: The annual first year budget is anticipated to be $240,722.01. Benefit Zone 1 parcels will pay a premium due to increased services and increased benefits anticipated to be derived from the formation of the district. Building use will determine the annual building square footage costs, by Benefit Zone. The proposed building uses have been categorized as follows. Each parcel has been analyzed to determine proper category of use and therefore benefit: (Internal parking built into structure will be credited to overall building size). 5 APPORTIONMENT OF BUILDING USES: Building Use Code Description of Use A Retail space, hotels, motels, visitor related B Office and Commercial uses, Independent, free standing parking structures C Industrial/Manufacturing/Distribution Institutional (School, public, park Church, Tax-exempt properties D E Multi -unit housing, apartments (20 units or more) F Multi -unit housing, apartments (9 —19 units) G Multi -unit housing, apartments (2 — 8 units) H Single Family housing units (not to exceed $240 per year) I Condo units - $ 240.00 flat fee per year Approximately $146,095.30 (61%) of the assessments will be generated from parcels within Benefit Zone 1. The balance, $94,626.71 (39%) will be generated from Benefit Zone 2 parcels. COST: Downtown National City PBID First Year Costs by Property Variable PROPERTY VARIABLE ANNUAL COST ANNUAL COST BENEFIT ZONE 2 TOTAL GENERATED BY VARIABLE Lot Square Footage $ 0.0841 per square foot per year $0.0757 per square foot per year $118,053.09 (49%) Building Square Footage (range) $ 0.1485-$0.1886 per square foot per year $0.1485-$0.1697 per square foot per year $80,075.68 (33%) Linear Frontage $1.8264 per linear foot per year $1.8264 per linear foot per year $39,713.24 (17%) Single Family Home and Condo Annual Fee $ 240.00 $240.00 $2,880.00 (1%) Total Annual Budget $240,722.01 ANNUAL ADJUSTMENTS: The Board of Directors of the Management Corporation will be given the option to increase the assessments annually based upon the San Diego County regional CPI indicator or by an amount not to exceed 5% from the previous year's assessments. The Management Corporation shall have the right to shift allocations within the four categories as they feel appropriate and as long as it remains consistent with the intent of the plan. The Board shall also have the right to shift up to 10% per year from category to category, each year, as needs change with the priorities of special benefits. 6 PART II ADDRESS SERIES, GENERAL STREET BOUNDARIES LOCATION: In general, the Downtown National City PBID includes all private and public parcels within the following boundaries: Street Address Series Street Name 704-724 A Avenue 827 B Avenue 811 — 817 C Avenue 831 — 835 D Avenue 41 — 43 E. 12th St. 14 — 35 E. 3`d St. 10 E. 5th St. 22-404 E. 8th St. 419 E. 9th St. 810 — 925 Hoover Avenue 205 —1146 National City Blvd. 225 — 1133 Roosevelt Avenue 25 — 38 W. 11t11 St. 21 W. 12th St. 30 W. 2"d Avenue 21 — 27 W. 3rd Avenue 21 W. 7th St. 110-200 W.8"hSt. 111- 225 W. 9"1' St. 32 —121 W. Plaza BIvd. 7 PART III WORK PLAN AND BUDGET SERVICES: Special benefit services to be financed by the Downtown National City Boulevard Property Business Improvement District will primarily include funding the following types of services. Based upon the survey results of the property owners, and estimated costs and services, the preliminary special benefits funded by the Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District are as follows: Proposed Downtown National City PBID: 1. Public Rights of Way and Sidewalk Operations (PROWSO) ■ Sidewalk sweeping; • Beautification; ■ Decorations and banners; • Enhanced trash receptacle placement and regular emptying; • Removal of bulky items; • Tree and shrub planting and maintenance • Work with City on hazardous issues; • Maintenance of public order in the sidewalks; ■ Homeless intervention; • Equipment, supplies, tools; • Misc. 2. District Identity and Streetscape Improvement (DISI) (Predominantly in Benefit Zone 1) ■ Special events (1 per year); ■ Web site; ■ Pedestrian kiosks/sign age ■ Underwriting advertising coop for hotel and retail 3. Administration and Corporate Operations: ■ Staffing; ■ Insurance; ■ Office related expenses; • Misc. 4. Contingency/Reserve: ■ Delinquencies; • City costs; • County costs; • Hardship; ■ Reserves; 8 Consistent with state law, any property assessment district must confer a special benefit to real property owners paying into the assessment district. At times, specific parcels will derive greater benefit, due to their proximity to a "core" area. These core and peripheral parcels, will from time to time, be designated through "benefit zones." The Downtown National City PBID anticipates two benefit zones, each receiving varying degrees of special benefits funded from the assessment district. The two benefit zones are proposed as follows: Benefit Zones: The Downtown National City PBID Benefit Zones are created based upon the frequency and type of special benefit services that might be desired. For example, the core area near National City Boulevard and 8th Street may need special benefit services six days per week, have large special events and be the focus of many promotional activities. These property owners would pay for those specific special benefit services based upon the anticipated benefit to be received. Benefit Zone Zone 1 (core area) Zone 2 (peripheral area) Boundaries National City Boulevard from 2"d to 12th Street 8`h Street from the freeway bridge to A Avenue All other streets in the district not included in Benefit Zone 1 TABLE 1 - FREQUENCY OF SPECIAL BENEFIT SERVICES BY BENEFIT ZONES Special Benefit Service Benefit Zone I Frequency 6 days per week Benefit Zone 2 Frequency 4 days per week Public rights of way and sidewalk operations (PROWSO) District Identity and Streetscape Improvements (DISI) • Special Events • Holiday Decorations Through programs Once per year Seasonally Through programs None None Administration/Corporate Operations Monday — Friday Monday — Friday 9 PART IV ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY TO FUND SPECIAL BENEFITS BUDGET: The first year annual budget is projected to be $240,722.01. Annual adjustments of up to a maximum of 5% over the previous year's gross assessment amount are allowable, subject to the approval of the Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District Management Corporation. TABLE 2 — SPECIAL BENEFIT SERVICES BROKEN DOWN BY ESTIMATED COSTS PER BENEFIT ZONE PROWSO Personnel Estimated Costs Service Benefit Zone 1 Benefit Zone 2 PROWSO: ■ Sidewalk Sweeping; ■ Beautification • Decorations and banners • Enhanced trash receptacle emptying ■ Removal of bulky items ■ Reporting hazards to City; ■ Removal of bulky items; ■ Tree and shrub planting and maintenance • Maintenance of public order • Homeless intervention 6 days per week As needed As needed As needed As needed Daily As needed Weekly As needed As needed 4 days per week As needed As needed As needed As needed Daily As needed Weekly As needed As needed ESTIMATED PERSONNEL NEEDS* %z cost of Supervisor; ($ 23,040) 1 maintenance worker, full time, 40 hours per week ($27,850) 1 maintenance worker, six days per week, 48 hours ($30,720) '/z cost of Supervisor; ($23,040) 1 maintenance worker, full time, 40 hours per week ($27,850) Estimated maintenance personnel costs $81,610 $ 50,890 Total Estimated Personnel Cost $ 132,500 10 *THE PURPOSE OF THIS CALCULATION IS TO PROVIDE A MATERIAL BASIS FOR THE P.R.O.W.S.O. PERSONNEL COSTS. THE ADMINISTERING CORPORATION CAN CONTRACT OUT THESE SERVICES TO A FOR -PROFIT OR NON-PROFIT CORPORATION, OR PROVIDE THE SERVICES IN HOUSE. THESE COSTS ARE ONLY USED AS A REFERENCE, THE LINE ITEM IN THE BUDGET FOR THE P.R.O.W.S.O. PERSONNEL IS ESTIMATED TO BE $132,500.00 ANNUALLY. The basis of determining personnel costs is derived from One Source, a nationwide company that provides employees for many building management companies, as well as BIDs. One Source's rates on labor include workers comp, payroll taxes, check disbursement, health benefits, vacation and sick time. Most importantly, these are contracted employees and therefore release the management corporation of payroll and personnel related liabilities. Total overhead factor of employees, fully loaded, is about 1.6 in an overhead factor from the base wage rate. Supervisor rate was calculated at $ 12.00 per hour, and maintenance workers at $8.00 - 9.00 per hour, starting pay. We reiterate that this is simply a tool for calculating costs of maintenance personnel. The free market, and competitive bidding may produce higher and better results. It is the job of the management corporation to maximize the delivery of special benefit services to the property owners based upon various category and line items of services. The function of this crew is to deal with all services in the public rights of way, including but not limited to: sweeping, beautification, decorations, security, etc. TABLE 3 — SPECIAL BENEFIT SERVICES/P.R.O.W.S.O. NON -PERSONNEL ANNUAL COSTS INCLUDING EQUIPMENT AND MATERIALS PROWSO Equipment and Materials Estimated Annual Cost Truck lease, insurance $ 6,000 Uniforms $ 1,000 Communications $ 4,000 Supplies $ 8,000 Water $ 1,000 Dumpster costs $ 6,000 Nursery Items $ 8,000 Small Equipment $ 3,000 Miscellaneous $ 3,500 Total Estimated Annual Equipment Costs $ 40,500 Again, these services may be provided by an outside contractor, however accommodations must be made for these costs whether done in-house of to an outside contractor. In addition, this budget does not assume any grants from public agencies or foundations that could underwrite the costs of equipment. Nor does it assume that the City would pay for landscaping water related costs or dumpster removal fees, both of which could be negotiated with the CDC. 11 TABLE 4 — DISTRICT IDENTITY AND STREETSCAPE IMPROVEMENTS SUGGESTED BUDGET ITEMS Program to be funded/Both Benefit Zones Estimated First Year Annual Cost Special events (1 per year); $ 5,000 Logo Creation (First Year only) $ 1,000 Web site creation and maintenance $ 4,000 Pedestrian kiosks/signage annually $ 4,000 Total Estimated First Year Annual Costs $ 14,000 TABLE 5 — ADMINISTRATION AND CORPORATE OPERATIONS SUGGESTED ALLOCATIONS Program to be Funded Estimated First Year Annual Cost Staff (Community Advocacy, retail attraction, Corporate minutes, administration to Board) $ 26,000 Insurance $ 3,000 Office rent $ 6,000 Phone/Fax $ 1,000 E-mail Service $ 800 Office supplies $1,000 Office Equipment $ 2,000 Utilities $ 1,200 Total Estimated Annual Costs $ 41,000 TABLE 6 — SPECIAL BENEFIT SERVICES/CONTINGENCY — RESERVE ANTICIPATED NEED Program to be Funded Estimated First Year Cost County Costs (1.7% of total assessments) City costs ($500.00 per year) No -pays, (uncollected assessments) (?) Misc/Reserve (Balance of expenses) Total Estimated Annual Costs $ 12,772.01 12 TABLE 7 — TOTAL FIRST YEAR DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY SPECIAL BENEFIT SERVICES BUDGET LINE ITEMS BASED UPON SUGGESTED PROGRAMS AND ALLOCATIONS Program First Year Allocation % of Total Budget Public Rights of Way and Sidewalk Operations — Personnel and Equipment for All Benefit Zones $ 173,000.00 72% District Identity and Streetscape Improvements $ 14,000.00 6% Administrative/Corporate Operations $ 41,000.00 17 % Contingency/Reserve $ 12,722.01 5% Total Estimated First Year Costs of Programs $ 240,722.01 100% METHOD OF FINANCING: This method of financing the special services is based upon the levy of assessments on real property that benefits from proposed improvements and activities. This represents a "benefit assessment district" as defined in the California Streets and Highway Code. Assessed valuation cannot be used as the basis for special benefits assessments due to the introduction of Proposition 13 into the state constitution in 1978. There are at least four basic factors that will be used in determining individual assessments. These factors include 1) linear frontage, 2) land area and 3) building square footage, 4) building use. The assessments for the Downtown National City PBID are based upon these variables, which have been endorsed by the property owners as the most fair and equitable for apportionment of assessments to participating parcels. Linear frontage will be assessed on all sides of the parcel receiving benefit. PBID assessments would be collected annually by the San Diego County tax assessor and would appear as a line item on the annual property tax bills. The assessments are collected by the County and transferred to the City of National City. They are then transferred directly to the Downtown National City PBID Management Corporation. The funds are then allocated consistent with the previously agreed upon programs in the Management District Plan. TABLE 8 - TOTAL GROSS DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PBID PROPERTY VARIABLES Property Variables Total in District Lot Size 1,465,301 square feet Building Size 448,344 square feet Linear Feet 21,744 linear feet There are 153 parcels and 96 legal owners currently in the database of the above mentioned property variables. There are about 34 square blocks in the district. 13 Apportionment of Costs to Property Variables used in the Assessment Methodology As is common practice, various property variables fund different special benefit services in the district. We have employed an assessment methodology that we believes supports the relationship between assessments paid and benefits received. The following programs and services must confer a special benefit to real property owners to be consistent with Article XIII (d) of the state constitution. ANNUAL BUDGET: The annual first year budget is anticipated to be $240,722.01. Benefit Zone 1 parcels will pay a premium due to increased services and increased benefits anticipated to be derived from the formation of the district. Building use will determine the annual building square footage costs, by Benefit Zone. The proposed building uses have been categorized as follows. Each parcel has been analyzed to determine proper category of use and therefore benefit: (Internal parking built into structure will be credited to overall building size). TABLE 9 - DEFINITION OF BUILDING/LAND USES: Building Use Code Description of Use A Retail space, hotels, motels, visitor related B Office and Commercial uses, Independent, free standing parking structures C Industrial/Manufacturing/Distribution Institutional (School, public, park Church, Tax-exempt properties D E Multi -unit housing, apartments (20 units or more) F M Multi -unit housing, apartments (9 —19 units) G Multi -unit housing, apartments (2 — 8 units) H Single Family housing units (not to exceed $240 per year) I Condo units, $ 240.00 flat fee per year The proposed apportionment of special benefits to the various property variables are as follows: l4 • TABLE 10 — APPORTIONMENT OF SERVICES TO PROPERTY VARIABLES Program to be Funded Benefit Zone Apportioned to Variable PROWSO: • Maintenance Personnel 1 Y2 to all building square footage, ($ 81,610) 1/2 to all lot size in Benefit Zone 1 • Maintenance Personnel 2 %2 to all building square footage, ($50,890) %2 to all lot size in Benefit Zone 2 • Non -personnel, equipment 1, 2 All linear frontage, apportioned ($ 40,500) equally in both Benefit Zones DISTRICT IDENTITY AND STREETSCAPE IMPROVEMENTS: • Special events (1 per year) 1 Building square footage "a" only ( $5, 000) • Logo creation 1, 2 Building square footage a — c ($1, 000) • Web site creation/maintenance 1, 2 Building square footage a — c ($ 4,000) • Pedestrian kiosks/signage 1, 2 Building square footage a — d ($ 4,000) ADMINISTRATION AND CORPORATE 1, 2 Apportioned equally to all lot size OPERATIONS ($ 41,000) in both zones CONTINGENCY/RESERVE 1, 2 Apportioned equally to all lot size ($ 12,722.01) in both zones The assessment methodology annual costs are summed up in the following table: 15 TABLE 11 — ANNUAL COSTS PER SPECIAL BENEFIT SERVICE AND BENEFIT ZONE Benefit Zone Lot Square foot annual costs Building square foot annual costs Linear frontage annual costs Contribution to total budget 1 $0.0841 a. $0.1886 b. $0.1696 c. $0.1696 d. $0.1577 e. $0.1485 f. $0.1485 g. $0.1485 $1.8264 $146,095.30 Benefit Zone Lot Square foot annual costs Building square foot annual costs Linear frontage annual costs Contribution to total budget 2 $0.0757 a. $0.1697 b. $0.1697 c. $0.1697 d. $0.1578 e $0.1485 f. $0.1485 g. $0.1485 $1.8264 $94,626.71 Both Condos and Single family homes $ 240.00 per year per unit Approximately $146,095.30 (61%) of the assessments will be generated from parcels within Benefit Zone 1. The balance, $94,626.71 (39%) will be generated from Benefit Zone 2 parcels. CONDO FACTOR: It is unknown at this point how much future condos will contribute to the district. Since the condos are being built in mixed use or commercially zoned areas, they are not exempt from payment into the assessment district. The condo owners will derive and appreciate the special benefit services they will receive from the cleaning and beautification services in the district. Provisions will be made to avoid a property variable and unit assessment for condos. Once a parcel or parcel(s) have been converted to condos, the per unit fee will kick in, however that parcel will have its linear frontage, building square footage and lot size deleted as a variable to be assessed. For example, if a 5,000 square foot lot is converted from a parking lot to a 10 unit condo development, that parcel will be reassessed to capture the $2,400 condo assessments annually now generated from that parcel (10 x $240.00 per year). Simultaneously, the property variables of that parcel, will be eliminated from the overall PBID database so the new condo owners are not doubly assessed for their property variables and condo units. Condos and residentially utilized single family residences will pay the same flat fee per year into the district. Condos will be fully assessed once they have been constructed and parcelized. Condos under construction shall pay $240, less a 50% reduction until completed and parcelized. 16 TABLE 12 - DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PBID FIRST YEAR COSTS BY PROPERTY VARIABLE PROPERTY VARIABLE ANNUAL COST BENEFIT ZONE 1 ANNUAL COST BENEFIT ZONE 2 TOTAL GENERATED BY VARIABLE Lot Square Footage $ 0.0841 per square foot per year $0.0757 per square foot per year $118,053.09 (49%) Building Square Footage (range) $ 0.1485-$0.1886 per square foot per year $0.1485-$0.1697 per square foot per year $80,075.68 (33%) Linear Frontage $1.8264 per linear foot per year $1.8264 per linear foot per year $39,713.24 (17%) Single Family Home and Condo Annual Fee $ 240.00 $240.00 $2,880.00 (1 %) Total Annual Budget $240,722.01 TABLE 13 - AMOUNTS GENERATED BY DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY PBID Property Variable Total Gross Variable, Amount Generated First Year Parcel or Lot Size 1,465,301 $118,053.09 Building Square Feet 448,344 $80,075.68 Linear Frontage 21,744 $39,713.24 Single Family Home and Condo Annual Fee 12 $2,880.00 Total Assessments, First Year — Both Zones $240,722.01 17 PART V RELEVANT ENABLING LEGISLATION, AB 1021 The relevant enabling PBID legislation, which allows the property owners of Downtown National City to fund these special benefit services, is to be found in... • Section 36600 of the California Streets and Highway Code known as the Property Business Improvement District Law of 1994. (Amended in 2000, 2003) On July 20, 2001, Governor Gray Davis signed AB 1021, approving changes to the Property Business Improvement District Law of 1994, (Cal. Streets and Highway Code Sections 36600 et. Seq.) which changes several procedures involving PBIDs. The law became effective on January 1, 2002. The major change within the law is the establishment of an "Owner's Association." This Association will be a private, non-profit entity that will contract with the City to manage the PBID. It will be subject to the Brown Act (Ca. Government Code Sections 54950 et seq.) and the California Public Records Act (Cal Government Code Sections 6250 et seq.). However, the Association will not be considered as a public entity for any other purpose. Similarly, any board members or staff will not be considered public officials. Under the amended law, all property owners who do not pay assessments will be subject to penalties for delinquent payments. The amended statute also provides provisions for renewal of the PBID. If the PBID is renewed after its first term (up to five years), the funds from the prior district may be used in the renewed district only for the benefit of the parcels within the boundaries of the prior district. If no parcels from the prior district are within the renewed district, the funds must be returned to the property owners. Also, upon renewal, a district may be renewed for up to ten years. These changes clarify issues regarding PBID operations and formation and the status of the non-profit organizations that manage PBIDs in the aftermath of the court ruling in Epstein vs. the Hollywood Entertainment District. The Epstein decision classified non-profit organizations that managed PBIDs as public entities for purposes of the Brown Act. The issue has been raised that if the organizations were public entities for the Brown Act, could they also be public entities for other acts, such as the Political Reform Act. The changes in the new legislation ensure that these PBID and BID Management Corporations are not considered public entities for any California law except the Ralph M. Brown Act and the Public Records Act. Proposition 218 (Article XIII D of the state constitution) states in Section 4 (a): "No assessment shall be imposed on any parcel which exceeds the reasonable cost of the proportional benefit conferred on that parcel. Only special benefits are assessable, and an agency must separate the general benefits from the special benefits conferred on a parcel." 18 FORMATION: ■ District formation requires submittal of petitions from property owners representing at least 50% of the total assessment. The "Right to Vote on Taxes Act" (Proposition 218) requires that more than 50% of the ballots received, weighted by assessment, be in support of the District. ■ This petition support ensures that the mail ballot procedure will be successful in the formation of the district. Once the necessary threshold of petitions have been collected, the management district plan will then be submitted to the City to begin processing the public hearing. With the adoption of an ordinance of intention, the City Council will authorize the City Clerk to send out the mail ballots to all affected property owners to determine their support for the establishment of the district. • When all is said and done, the first assessments should be collected with the annual property tax bill in December 2004 with the Management Corporation receiving its first installment payment in January 2005. DURATION: ■ Pursuant to State Law, the District will have a set term. The proposed district will have a five-year life commencing January 1, 2005. After five years, the petition process must be repeated for the District to be re-established. 19 TIME LINE AS SPECIFIED BY LAW: The district must be established to take advantage of the County's tax assessment notification schedule. Mindful of that, all property related assessment districts must be established by the end of July in any calendar year, in order to have assessments levied on parcels for the upcoming fiscal year. In our case, the district must be established through an assessment ballot proceeding in late July 2004, in order to notify the County in time for the 2004-05 fiscal tax year. The first assessments would then appear on the property tax statements due in December 2004. In order to take advantage of this schedule, as well as to generate revenues in early 2005, the following time line has been adopted to ensure timely funding of special benefit programs: To work effectively, we must look at the completion date and work backwards: Date must be completed by Task to be completed July 20th, 2004 Public hearing/assessment balloting proceeding, ballots counted by weight June 8th Resolution of intent by City to establish the district May ls`-June 7`h Property owners representing 50% of the weight, based upon assessments to be levied, must sign petition endorsing the management district plan; Assessment engineer certifies plan as compliant with Proposition 218 April 30`h Finalize management district plan including special benefit services to be provided, duration of district, boundaries, benefit zones, assessment methodology, administration, etc. Initiate petition drive April 20, 2004 First rough draft Management District Plan submitted to PBID Steering Committee 20 PART VI ENGINEER'S REPORT, EXEMPTIONS, ANNUAL ASSESSMENT INCREASES AND THE DURATION OF THE DISTRICT A. Assessment Methodology Property owners in Downtown National City have emphasized that an assessment formula for a PBID be fair, balanced and commensurate with special benefits received. NEW CITY AMERICA has contracted with Ed Henning and Associates to come up with a plan that has been certified by a licensed engineer. In preparing the engineer's report for the Downtown National City PBID, the engineer concluded that the special benefit to each parcel was found to be proportional to the property variable and their apportionment. An Engineer's report for the PBID is provided in the Appendix. B. Time and Manner for Collecting Assessments: As provided by state law, the Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District will appear as a separate line item on the annual property tax bills prepared by the San Diego County Tax Assessor. Property tax bills are generally distributed in the Fall and payment is expected by lump sum or in two installments. The County Assessor shall distribute the assessments to the City who will in turn then forward them to the designated Downtown National City PBID Management Corporation pursuant to the authorization of this plan. Existing laws for enforcement of property taxes apply to the Management District assessments. The assessments shall be collected at the same time and in the same manner as for any possessory interest tax paid to the County of San Diego. These assessments shall provide for the same lien priority and penalties for delinquent payment as is provided for the possessory interest tax. The "property owner" of the possessory interest shall be any person as the owner/taxpayer on the last equalized possessory interest assessment roll or otherwise known to be the owner/taxpayer by the City Council. The City Council has no obligation to obtain other information as to the ownership of the interest, and its determination or ownership shall be final and conclusive for the purposes of this district. 21 C. Publicly Owned Parcels and Government Assessments: The Downtown National City PBID Steering Committee assumes that the City of National City, The Community Development Commission, Southwestern College, the County, the Unified School District, the State of California and any other publicly owned parcels will pay assessments for the special benefits conferred upon government owned property within the boundaries of the PBID. Article XIII D of the California Constitution, (Proposition 218), explains the basis for assessing publicly owned parcels: "Parcels within a district that are owned or used by any agency, the State of California or the United States shall not be exempt from Assessments unless the agency can demonstrate by clear and convincing evidence that those publicly owned parcels in fact receive no special benefit. D. Annual Assessment Adjustment: The PBID Management Corporation, will be granted the option of increasing the assessments annually based upon the Consumer Price Index of San Diego County or by a flat amount, not to exceed 5% per year. E. District Duration: Pursuant to State PBID Law, the Downtown National City PBID will have a duration of five years, commencing on January 1, 2005 and extending through December 31S` 2009. This is the maximum period allowable for a new PBID under state legislation. Any continuation of the District after its five-year period will require compliance with all regulations and statutes in place at the time relative to the establishment of the new PBID. 22 PART VII DISTRICT GOVERNANCE AND THE DOWNTOWN NATIONAL CITY P.B.I.D. MANAGEMENT CORPORATION A few rules and regulations should be considered by the Downtown National City PBID Management Corporation in the administration of the district. Conflict of Interest: Any stakeholder who serves on the administering corporation's Board of Directors shall recuse himself or herself from any vote in which a potential conflict of interest is apparent. Such potential conflicts include, but are not limited to, prioritizing capital improvement projects which result in special benefit to specific property owners, prioritization of services to benefit a particular owner or group of owners, hiring or selecting the relatives of Board members, etc. In addition, the Management Corporation shall aim to meet the following operational objectives for the district... • Create and manage programs that best respond to the top priorities of district property owners; • Maximize coordination of the City government to avoid duplication of services and to leverage resources; • Deliver services through a cost-effective, non -bureaucratic and easy to access organizational structure; • Provide accountability and responsiveness to those who pay through open access to Board meetings, elections to the Board and Board records. 23 APPENDIX A MAP OF THE DISTRICT 24 Downtown National City PBID Benefit Zone 1 Benefit Zone 2 APPENDIX B FIVE-YEAR PROJECTION OF THE ASSESSMENTS ASSUMING THE MAXIMUM ANNUAL INCREASE 25 Downtown National City P.B.I.D. FIVE YEAR PROJECTION OF ASSESSMENTS WITH 5% ANNUAL ADJUSTMENT Projected Budget 2005 5% 2006 5% 2007 5% 2008 5% 2009 Public Rights of Way and Sidewalk Operations $173,000.00 $8,650.00 $181,650.00 $9,082.50 $190,732.50 $9,536.63 $200,269.13 $10,013.46 $210,282.58 District Identity and Streetscape Improvements $14,000,00 $700.00 $14,700.00 $735.00 $15,435.00 $771.75 $16,206.75 $810.34 $17,017.09 Administrative/Corporate Operations $41,000.00 $2,050.00 $43,050.00 $2,152.50 $45,202.50 $2,260.13 $47,462.63 $2,373.13 $49,835.76 Contingency/Reserve $12,722.01 $636.10 $13,358.11 $667.91 $14,026.02 $701.30 $14,727.32 $736.37 $15,463.68 Total $240,722.01 $12,036.10 $252,758.11 $12,637.91 $265,396.02 $13,269.80 $278,665.82 $13,933.29 $292,599.11 6/8/04 APPENDIX C LIST OF PARCELS INCLUDED IN THE DISTRICT 26 APN;.. 555 030 01 00 555 030 02 00 555 030 03 00 555 030 04 00 555 030 05 00 555 030 06 00 555 030 07 00 555 030 08 00 555 030 09 00 555 030 10 00 555 030 11 00 555 030 12 00 555 030 13 00 555 030 14 00 555 030 17 00 5' 30 20 00 555 030 21 00 555 030 22 00 555 041 01 00 555 041 02 00 555 041 03 00 555 041 04 00 555 041 05 00 555 041 06 00 555 041 07 00 555 041 08 00 555 041 09 00 555 041 10 00 555 042 10 00 55'5042 15 00 555 042 17 00 5F '42 18 00 55o 052 04 00 555 052 05 00 555 052 06 00 555 052 14 00 Annual Assessment $240.00 $427.32 $0.00 $0.00 $240.00 $0.00 $240.00 $1,358.46 $278.41 $339.52 $270.50 $344.51 $282.92 $500.53 $1,089.50 $4,997.45 $3,644.29 $6,609.58 $878.28 $472.48 $3,616.36 $1,063.44 $570.74 $571.49 $694.46 $511.82 $511.82 $1,206.28 $1,080.70 $3,104.82 $3,458.95 $7,001.77 $694.46 $649.75 $471.60 $2,453.40 NATIONA PARCELS APN 555 052 15 00 555 053 17 00 555 054 12 00 555 081 09 00 555 081 10 00 555 081 14 00 555 081.15 00 555 081 16 00 555 081 17 00 555 082 01 00 555 082 02 00 555 082 03 00 555 082 04 00 555 082 05 00 555 082 06 00 555 082 10 00 555 082 11 00 555 083 21 00 555 083 22 00 555 083 23 00 555 083 24 00 555 085 01 00 555 085 02 00 555 085 03 00 555 085 04 00 555 085 05 00 555 085 06 00 555 085 07 00 555 113 04 00 555 113 05 00 555 113 08 00 5551131100 555 113 12 00 555113 1300 555 114 01 00 555 114 02 00 L CITY PBID TO BE ASSESSED Annual Assessment $2,361.54 $22,785.90 $6,377.83 $510.24 $267.23 $396.50 $216.88 $695.37 $1,992.94 $1,855.29 $244.19 $527.88 $399.68 $1,137.98 $960.23 $1,533.33 $4,097.40 $1,846.85 $5,094.43 $2,989.50 $5,751.78 $622.48 $240.00 $240.00 $464.11 $2,797.35 $187.37 $4,258.90 $808.87 $792.75 $1,269.33 $2,084.78 $1,569.72 $1,133.05 $240.00 $240.00 APN 555 114 03 00 5551140400 555 114 05 00 555 114 06 00 555 114 07 00 555 114 11 00 555 114 12 00 5551141300 556 101 01 00 556 101 02 00 556 101 15 00 556 101 16 00 556 104 01 00 556 104 02 00 556 104 18 00 556 210 25 00 556 210 26 00 556 210 27 00 556 212 01 00 556 212 02 00 556 212 03 00 556 212 04 00 556 212 05 00 556 212 06 00 556 212 07 00 556 331 03 00 556 331 04 00 556 331 05 00 556 331 14 00 556 331 15 00 556 331 20 00 556 331 21 00 556 331 22 00 556 331 23 00 556 331 24 00 556 331 25 00 Annual Assessment $215.59 $220.14 $452.48 $652.46 $1,151.14 $330.42 $1,594.28 $1,569.62 $1,614.58 $1,815.33 $5,492.84 $2,276.33 $2,485.63 $240.00 $1,820.45 $1,662.72 $1,510.43 $1,077.40 $240.00 $240.00 $496.74 $276.94 $419.14 $563.61 $754.77 $249.09 $505.91 $1,181.45 $2,439.68 $926.31 $748.13 $2,720.06 $1,255.39 $566.21 $715.80 $3,133.35 APN Annual Assessment 556 332 20 00 $1,764.62 556 332 21 00 $535.59 556 332 22 00 $375.86 556 332 23 00 $253.70 556 332 24 00 $1,409.83 556 333 15 00 $2,626.38 556 333 17 00 $4,907.21 556 333 18 00 $522.19 556 334 19 00 $2,101.81 556 334 20 00 $282.35 556 334 21 00 $410.30 556 334 22 00 $452.14 556 471 03 00 $2,233.31 556 471 04 00 $575.76 556 471 16 00 $1,585.34 556 471 17 00 $2,691.26 556 471 23 00 $4,830.57 556 471 24 00 $3,673.51 556 472 23 00 $2,019.79 556 472 24 00 $527.74 556 472 26 00 $3,056.70 556 472 27 00 $265.95 556 473 15 00 $1,526.52 556 473 16 00 $792.75 556 473 17 00 $962.08 556 474 01 00 $1,610.56 556 474 02 00 $739.54 556 474 21 00 $2,527.99 556 493 01 00 $1,290.96 556 493 04 00 $934.44 556 493 05 00 $240.00 556 553 01 00 $694.46 556 553 02 00 $357.75 556 553 03 00 $409.23 556 553 04 00 $616.95 556 553 05 00 $1,592.79 NATIONA PARCELS APN 556 553 09 00 556 553 12 00 556 553 13 00 556 554 16 00 556 554 17 00 556 554 18 00 556 554 19 00 556 554 20 00 556 554 21 00 L CITY PBID TO BE ASSESSED Annual Assessment $515.54 $567.57 $526.29 $4,415.42 $6,245.33 $1,195.18 $569.85 $1,205.03 $1,568.79 • APN Annual Assessment APPENDIX D ENGINEER'S REPORT 27 Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District CITY OF NATIONAL CITY - CALIFORNIA DISTRICT ASSESSMENT ENGINEER'S REPORT Prepared by Edward V. Henning, California Registered Professional Engineer # 26549 Edward Henning & Associates Phelan California June 1, 2004 1333o Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (76o) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net ATTACHMENT NO. 3 Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING DISTRICT ASSESSMENT ENGINEER'S REPORT To Whom It May Concern: I hereby certify to the best of my professional knowledge and experience that each of the identified benefiting properties located within the proposed Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District will receive a special benefit over and above the benefits conferred on the public at large and that the amount of the proposed assessment is proportional to, and no greater than the benefits conferred on each respective property. 0 Prepare. by Edward V. Henning, California Registered Professional Engineer # 26549 a Edward V. He RPE #26549 June 1, 2004 Date (NOT VALID WITHOUT EMBOSSED CERTIFICATION SEAL AND SIGNATURE HERE) Introduction This report shall serve as the "detailed engineer's report" required by Section 4(b) of Article XIIID of the California Constitution (Proposition 218) to support the benefit property assessments proposed to be levied within the Downtown National City Property Business Improvement District (Downtown National City PBID) in the City of National City, California being established for a five year period. The discussion and analysis contained within constitutes the required "nexus" of rationale between assessment amounts levied and special benefits derived by properties within the Downtown National City PBID. NOTE 1: The terminology "identified benefiting parcel" or "property" is used throughout this report pursuant to SB 919 - "Proposition 218 Omnibus Implementation Act" which clarified portions of Prop 218. It provides the Engineer and District Consultant with the ability to actually identify individual parcels which will benefit directly either in whole or in part from the proposed District funded programs and improvements and does not imply that all parcels receive assessable benefits 1 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (760) 868-9963 • (fax) (760) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink_net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Background The Downtown National City PBID is a property -based benefit assessment type district being established pursuant to Section 36600 et seq. of the California Streets and Highways Code, also known as the Property and Business Improvement District Law of 1994 (the "Act"). Due to the benefit assessment nature of assessments levied within a PBID, district program costs are to be distributed amongst all identified benefiting properties based on the proportional amount of program benefit each property is expected to derive from the assessments collected. Within the Act, frequent references are made to the concept of relative "benefit" received from PBID programs and activities versus amount of assessment paid. Only those properties expected to derive spec,-ial benefits from PBID funded programs and activities may be assessed and only in an amount proportional to the relative benefits expected to be iec.cived. The method used to determine benefits derived by each identified property within a PBID begins with the selection of a suitable and tangible basic benefit unit. For property related services, such as those proposed in the Downtown National City PBID, the benefit unit may be measured in linear feet of street frontage or parcel size in square feet or building size in square feet or number of building floors or proximity to major corridors in average linear feet, or any combination of these factors. Quantity takeoffs for each parcel are then measured or otherwise ascertained. From these figures, the amount of benefit units to be assigned to each property can be calculated. Special circumstances such as unique geography, land uses, development constraints etc. are carefully reviewed relative to specific programs and improvements to be funded by the PBID in order to determine any levels of diminished benefit which may apply on a parcel by parcel or categorical basis. Based on the factors described above such as geography and nature of programs and activities proposed, an assessment formula is developed which is derived from a singular or composite basic benefit unit factor or factors. Within the assessment formula, different factors nvy be assigned different "weights" or percentage of values. Next, all program and activity costs, including incidental costs, district administration, ancillary programs, and volunteer and comped resource and material credits are estimated. It is noted, as stipulated in Proposition 218, and now required of all pluperty based assessment districts, indirect and general benefits may not be incorporated into the assessment formula and levied on the district properties; only direct or "special" benefits and costs may be considered. Indirect or general benefit costs must be calculated and factored out of the assessment cost basis to produce a "net" cost figure. In addition, Proposition 218 no longer exempts government owned property from paying benefit assessments and these properties must be factored into the assessment roll if special benefit is determined to be conferred upon such properties. 2 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (760) 868-9963 • (fax) (760) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING From this, the value of a basic benefit unit or "basic net unit cost" can be computed by dividing the total amount of estimated net program costs by the total number of benefit units. The amount of assessment for each parcel can be computed at this time by multiplying the Net Unit Cost times the number of Basic Benefit Units per parcel. This is known as "spreading the assessment" or the "assessment spread" in that all costs are allocated proportionally or "spread" amongst all properties within the PBID. The method and basis of spreading program costs varies from one PBID to another based on local geographic conditions, types of programs and activities proposed, and size and development complexity of the district. PBIDs may require secondary benefit zones to be identified to allow for a tiered assessment formula for variable or "stepped -down" benefits derived. Supplemental Proposition 218 Procedures and Requirements Proposition 218, approved by the voters of California in November of 1996, adds a supplemental array of procedures and requirements to be carried out prior to levying a property -based assessment like the Downtown National City PBID. These requirements are in addition to requirements imposed by State and local assessment enabling laws. These requirements were "chaptered" into law as Article XIIID of the California Constitution and then further clarified by the Proposition 218 Omnibus Legislation in 1997 chaptered in section 53750 et seq of the California Government Code. Since Prop 218 provisions will affect all subsequent calculations to be made in laying out the final property assessment roll for the Downtown National City PBID, Prop 218 requirements will be taken into account first. The key provisions of Prop 218 along with a description of how the Downtown National City PBID complies with each of these provisions is delineated below. (Note: All section refeiences below pertain to Article XIII of the California Constitution): Finding 1. From Section 4(a): "Identify all parcels which will have a special benefit conferred upon them and upon which an assessment will be imposed" There are 153 "identified" individual parcels within the Downtown National City PBID which will all derive some level of special benefit from the proposed District programs and activities. These parcels are shown on the Boundary Map within the Management District Plan and are listed as an attachment to the Plan - identified by assessor parcel number and site address. Two benefit zones have been identified within the District which generally includes all properties along and surrounding the National City Boulevard corridor from 2d to 12th and the 8`s Street corridor from the freeway to A Avenue. 3 1333o Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (760) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Finding 2. From Section 4(a): "Separate the general benefits from the special benefits conferred on parcel(s). Only special benefits are assessable. " As stipulated by Prop 218, assessment district programs and activities confer a combination of general and special benefits to district properties, but the only program benefits which can be funded through assessments are those attributed to special property related benefits. Thus, a portion of the program costs must be considered attributable to general benefits and assigned a value. Conventional assessment engineering experience has found that general benefits within a given district typically average 10% of the total adjusted costs with a 5% deviation. (Total adjusted costs include actual proposed PBID program costs plus any additional supplemental or matching program costs as well as applied credits from sources such as start up grants, Board/Committee member service credits and specialized assessment reductions/adjustments.) There are three common methods for determining general and special benefit ratios within assessment districts: (1) The parcel by parcel allocation method (2) The program/activity line item allocation method, and (3) The composite district overlay determinant method. The vast majority of PBIDs in California have used Method #3, the composite district overlay determinant method which will be used for the Downtown National City PBID. Using empirical data from other PBIDs, a focused range for general benefits from 5-15% is used. Based on a composite of district criteria such as the shape of the Downtown National City PBID, the existence of two benefit zones, a three-four element assessment formula, the proximity all of district properties to the applicable program benefit zones, and the nature of the proposed programs and activities, a specific "overlay" value of 5% is assigned to the general benefit portion of the total adjusted costs. This leaves a value of 95% assigned to special benefit related costs. Since the total program cost is estimated at $265,572.01 (see Table 1 later in this Report), the maximum special benefit portion which can be recouped through property assessments, is $252,293.41. Remaining costs which are attributed to general benefits, will need to be derived from other sources. (e.g. public/private matching grants, startup grants, startup volunteer (audits or ongoing board member volunteer credits). 4 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (76o) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Finding 3. From Section 4(a): "(Determine) the proportionate special benefit derived by each parcel in relationship to the entirety of the. cost of public improvement(s) or the maintenance and operation expenses....» ..... or the cost of the property related service being provided. The proportionate special benefit cost for each parcel is listed in an attachment to the Management District Plan. The individual percentages (i.e. proportionate relationship to the total special benefit related program and activity costs) were computed by dividing the individual parcel assessment by the total program costs. Finding 4. From Section 4(a): "No assessment shall exceed the reasonable cost of the proportional special benefit conferred on parcel(s)." Not only are the proposed program costs reasonable due to the benefit of group purchasing and contracting which would be possible through the Downtown National City PBID, they are also considerably less than other options considered by groups like the Downtown National City PBID Formation Committee. Finding 5. From Section 4(a): "Parcels... —.that are owned or used by any (public) agency shall not be exempt from assessment" Parcels within the District that are owned by public agencies (i.e. City of National City, the Community Development Commission, Southwestern College etc) will also be assessed and at rates equivalent to private sector owned parcels. The "fair market value" of such public properties is identical to surrounding privately owned parcels and any increased values and benefits derived from PBID programs and services would be similar for either public or privately owned parcels, with or without improvements. Just as the costs and effects of blight are shared by both public and private properties, so are the rewards of clean and safe as well as district promotions and marketing programs. Since there is no compelling finding or evidence that such properties would receive less direct benefit from the proposed PBID programs and services than surrounding private parcels, the same assessment rates would be levied. Finding 6. From Section 4(b): "All assessments must be supported by a detailed engineer's report prepared by a registered professional engineer certified by the State of California". This report shall serve as the "detailed engineer's report" to support the benefit property assessments proposed to be levied within the Downtown National City PBID. 5 1333o Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (760) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Finding 7. From Section 4(c): "The amount of the proposed assessment for each parcel shall be calculated (along with) the total amount thereof chargeable to the entire district, the duration of such payments, the reason for such assessment and the basis upon which the amount of the proposed assessment was calculated." The individual and total parcel assessments attributable to special property benefits are shown on an attachment to the Management District Plan. The district and resultant assessment payments will continue for five years and may be renewed again at that time. The reasons (purposes) for the proposed assessments are outlined in the Management District Plan. The calculation basis of the proposed assessment for the PBID is attributed in part to the specific amount of Imot,erty size, building size and street frontage. Special Benefit and Assessment Analysis Step 1. Select "Basic Benefit Unit(s)" PBID assessment formulas typically are based on either property sheet frontage or parcel and building size or location, all which can affect the amount of benefit conferred on a particular parcel and the proportionate assessment to be paid. The formula may base assessments on a single factor or a combination of factors. Based on the nature of the program activities to be funded by the Downtown National City PBID, which relate to the proportionate amount of real estate (i.e. land) held in ownership, development intensity (i.e. building area) and property street frontage as well as land use, it has been determined that the assessments for the PBID will be based proportionately on a combination of parcel size, building size, land use and street frontage. In addition a flat rate will be applied to single family residential (SFR) and residential condo units located on non -residentially zoned land. The "Basic Benefit Unit" will be expressed as a function of land square footage (Basic Benefit "A" Units), building area (Basic Benefit "B" Units - further refined by land use) and linear feet of property frontage (Basic Benefit "C" Units). Based on the shape of the Downtown National City PBID, as well as the nature of the District program elements, it is determined that two benefit zones exist in which identified properties will gain a direct, albeit, proportionate degree of benefit based on the respective amount of parcel size, building size, land use and street frontage. Step 2. Quantify Total Basic Benefit Units Taking into account all identified benefiting properties, there are 1,465,301 square feet of assessable parcel land area within the District, 448,344 square feet of assessable building area and 21,744 linear feet of property street frontage. In addition, there are 12 assessable single family/condo units. Since the selected Basic Benefit Unit is based on a 6 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (760) 868-9963 • (fax) (760) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING combination of parcel area, building area and street frontage, there are, in turn, corresponding amounts of Basic Benefit Units in the PBID as shown in Step 7 herein. The target weighted revenues from each formula component were 50% for land area, 30% for building area and 20% for street frontage. The final adjusted weights are 49% for land, 33% for building area, 17% for street frontage and 1% for SFR and condo flat rates. Further, the targeted weighted revenues for each Benefit Zone were 60% for Zone 1 and 40% for Zone 2. The final adjusted weights are 61% for Zone 1 and 39% for Zone 2. Step 3. Calculate Benefit Units for Each Property. The number of Benefit Units for each identified benefiting parcel within the Downtown National City PBID was computed from data extracted from City of National City, San Diego County and third party real estate data services property and land use records. These data sources delineate current land uses, property areas and dimensions of record for each tax parcel and are listed as an attachment to the Management District Plan. While it is understood that this data does not represent legal field survey measurements or detailed title search of recorded land subdivision maps or building records, it does provide an acceptable basis for the purpose of calculating property based assessments. All respective property data being used for assessment computations has been provided to each property owner in the PBID for their review. All known or reported discrepancies or errors have been corrected. Step 4. Determine Assessment Formula For a District with a single Basic Benefit Unit with one Benefit Zone, the assessment formula would be the same for each identified benefiting property as follows: Number of Basic Benefit Units x Basic Unit Cost = PBID Assessment The Downtown National City PBID assessment is to be based on three Basic Benefit Unit factors; land square footage (Basic Benefit "A" Units), building area (Basic Benefit "B" Units) and linear feet of property frontage (Basic Benefit "C" Units). It has been determined that the assessment should be based partially on parcel size, building size and street frontage as follows: Zone 1: Assessment — [(No. of Benefit "A-1"Units x Basic "A-1" Unit Cost)] + [(No. of Benefit "B-1" Units x Basic "B-1" Unit Cost)] + [(No. of Benefit "C-1" Units x Basic "C-1" Unit Cost)] Zone 2: Assessment = [(No. of Benefit "A-2"Units x Basic "A-2" Unit Cost)] + [(No. of Benefit `B-2" Units x Basic `B-2" Unit Cost)] + [(No. of Benefit "C-2" Units x Basic "C-2" Unit Cost)] 7 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (760) 868-9963 • (fax) (760) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Note A: Benefit `B" Unit Costs vary based on land use as shown in Table 3 later in this report. Note B: Assessments for single family residential and residential condos are based on a flat fee per unit as shown in Table 3. Step 5. Estimate Total Program and Activity Costs Total estimated proposed program and activity costs are shown below in Table 1. These costs include expenses for general as well as special benefits and related programs/activities. TABLE 1 Estimated Total Year 1 Program & Activity Costs (Special+General Benefits) Program/Activ4y Public Rights of Way & Sidewalk Operations District Identity/Streetscape Improvements Year 1 $173,000.00 65.14% $14,000.00 5.27% Administration/Corporate Operations $41,000.00 1 5.44% Contingency/Reserve $12,722.01. 4.79% Misc Costs (Credits) $24,850.00 9.36% Total $265,572.01 1 100.00% Step 6. Separate General Benefits from Special Benefits and Related Costs (Prop 218) Total program and activity costs are estimated at $265,572.01 (see Table 1 above). General benefits are factored at 5% of total (see Finding 2 on page 4 of this report) with special benefits set at 95%. Prop 218 limits the levy of property assessments to costs attributed to special benefits only. The 5% general benefit cost is computed to be $13,278.60 with a resultant 95% special benefit limit computed at $252,293.41. This is the maximum amount of revenue that can be derived from property assessments from the subject PBID. The total amount of revenue proposed to be derived from PBID assessments is $240,722.01 for Year I, which is less than the special benefit limit of $252,293.41. Therefore, no Prop 218 adjustments need to be made to the proposed assessment formula. All program costs associated with general benefits will be derived from sources or credits other than PBID assessments as shown below in Table 2. 8 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (76o) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING TABLE 2 Total Adjusted Year 1 Revenue (For Special + General Benefit Programs/Activities) Funding Source I PBID Assessments I PBID Formation Pro -rated Credit/Year ($35,000 base) PBID Formation Pro -Rated Volunteer Credit/Year (50% base) Annual Board/Volunteer Credit (35% base Admin) TOTAL ADJUSTED REVENUE Subtotal Revenue $240,722.01 $7,000.00 $ 3, 500.00 $14,350.00 $265,572.01 ob 90.64% 2.64% 1.32% 5.40% 100.00% Step 7. Calculate "Basic Unit Cost" (Special Benefits Only) With a Year 1 budget of $240,720.01 (special benefit only), the Basic Unit Costs ("A", "B" and "C") from the Management Plan are: TABLE 3 Basic Unit Land Use Description Benefit Zone 1 Benefit Zone 2 "A" Cost $0.084 1/sf $0.0757/sf All except SFR and condos "B-a" Cost Retail, hotels, motels, visitor $0.1886/sf $0.1697/sf "B-b" Cost Office, commercial, pkg struc. $0.1696/sf $0.1697/sf "B-c" Cost Industrial, manufacturing $0.1696/sf $0.1697/sf "B-d" Cost Institutional, government etc $0.1577/sf $0.1578/sf "B-e" Cost Residential 20+ units $0.1485/sf $0.1485/sf "B-f' Cost Residential 9-19 units $0.1485/sf $0.1485/sf "B-g" Cost Residential 2-8 units $0.1485/sf $0.1485/sf "B-h" Cost Single family residential $240 flat rate $240 flat rate "B-i" Cost Residential Condo $240 flat rate $240 flat rate "C" Cost All except SFR and condos $1.8264/LF $1.82641LF Since the PBID is planned for a five year term, maximum assessments for future years (Years 2 through 5) must be set at the inception of the PBID. A maximum annual flat rate increase of 5% may be imposed each year, subject to approval by the PBID Board. 9 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (760) 868-9963 • (fax) (76o) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING Step 8. Spread the Assessments The resultant assessment spread calculations for each parcel within the PBID are shown in an attachment to the District Management Plan and were determined by applying the District assessment formula to each identified benefiting property. This list of all identified benefiting parcels in the PBID delineates each parcel and benefit units for property street frontage and parcel area. 10 13330 Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (76o) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net Edward Henning & Associates URBAN REVITALIZATION • FUNDING EDWARD HENNING & ASSOCIATES Edward Henning and Associates is a multi -disciplined consulting firm offering a diverse range of community development and funding services focusing on downtown bnciness districts and the unique problems and opportunities associated with center city areas. Types of services provided • Business Improvement District (BID & PBID) Formations, Modifications, Expansions, Updates • Prop 218 Assessment Engineering Analyses and Reports (Licensed Engineer) • Downtown Revitalization Plans/Redevelopment Planning and Implementation • Establish/Administer/Field Supervision for Rehabilitation Programs and Projects • Architectural Design Guidelines/ Sign Ordinances Partial list of agencies and clients represented • Town of Apple Valley • City of Berkeley • City of Buena Park • City of Culver City • City of Huntington Park • City of Huntington Beach • City of Los Angeles - Gateway to LAX - Historic Downtown Core - Hollywood District - Meirose/Fairfax — Larchmont - Los Feliz - San Fernando Valley (6 areas) - San Vicente - Wilshire Center • City of Monterey Park • City of Napa • City of Newport Beach • City of Ontario (Downtown) • City of Oxnard • City of Pasadena • Placer County (Tahoe City) • City of San Francisco (Union Square) • City of Vacaville • City of Whittier • City of Yucaipa PBID Formation (Village) BID Formation (Downtown) BID Formation Analysis (Auto Row & Entertainment Corridor) BID Formation (Downtown) BID Formation (Pacific Blvd.) BID Formation (Auto Row District) PBID Formation & Renewal (Prop 218 Compliance) PBID Formation (Prop218 Compliance) PBID Formation (Prop 218 Compliance) PBID Formation (Prop 218 Compliance) PBID Formation & Renewal BID Formation PBID Formation (Prop 218 Compliance) Private Sector PBID Formation Hybrid BID/PBID Formation BID Modification (Downtown) PBID Formation (Downtown) BID Advising BID Modification PBID Formation (Downtown) PBID Formation (Playhouse District) Citywide Tourist Improvement District (111)) PBID Formation (Downtown) PBID Formation (Prop 218 Compliance) BID Formation (Downtown) Citywide Tourist Improvement District Evaluation (TID) BID Modification (Uptown) PBID Formation & Renewal(Uptown) 11 1333o Buttemere Rd • Phelan CA 92371 • (76o) 868-9963 • (fax) (76o) 868-6490 • mred2@earthlink.net