The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutPolice Dept. & Institute for Public Strategies commentsTO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: National City Police Department Memorandum Chief Adolfo Gonzales Sergeant Graham Young May 27, 2011 Conditional Use Permit (CUP-2011-16) for the sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits at Valero Gas Station— 10 Osborne Street, National City. This Conditional Use Permit application is for a Type 21 ABC License at 10 Osborne Street, in National City. The application indicated that the applicant would like to sell beer, wine and distilled spirits. There is no mention of a restricted time period of sale; therefore they would have to comply with State regulations of selling alcohol from the hours of 6:00 a.m. to 2:00 a.m. To the best of my knowledge, there is no other gas station that has a Type 21 ABC license in National City that would allow them to sell "distilled spirits." On May 25, 2011, I conducted a site survey of the proposed location the proximity to other ABC licensed establishments within a quarter mile of the location. I found during this site survey that there is one other Type 21 License located directly across the street — 110 Liquor Store. The location of the gas station next to the on ramp of northbound and southbound Interstate 5 is a concern for drinking and driving once a sale has been made, especially for the request for selling distilled spirits. Currently the City of National City has a total of 100 "On -sale" and "Off -sale" alcohol selling establishments. This equates to 11.7 alcohol selling establishments per square mile within the City. The Department of Alcohol Beverage Control, (ABC) has only four enforcement personnel to cover regulation enforcement operations in the geographic area south of the Interstate 8, leaving municipal agencies to conduct enforcement of ABC regulations situated in their own jurisdictions. Until the end of the current budget crisis and the Police Department can hire enough officers to facilitate a dedicated unit to police and regulate establishments possessing an ABC license, it makes regulating these ABC Licensed businesses extremely difficult and a burden on regular patrol units. Respectfully Submitted, Sergeant Graham Young National City Police Department 16 South Bay community changeproject' s„k •a?3 vi5%L 65 �� 1`:5: A Program of The Institute For Public Strategies Environmental Scan National City Valero 10 Osborn Street National City, CA 91950 Scan Completed: 04/25/2011 schools 10 Osborn St. Natio:tai City, CA 91950 :: GB�tc.1 t�Htis Saboa Elementary School '>'. ': - •:;;:::;.::: 1044 Sarth Atith Street. San Diego; CA 16103 263-atn'1 Intec.ly Charter School >:- 701 National City Boulevard, National Ci6y. CA {S1.6:f 336003 'Evey yea: 1 have seen mare than happy with the invo:•:sment. demeanor.... i= ENT AL SCHOOL 833 E Ave.. I3ationai City, CA ifi151336-740t} ...... . "I casnch *Tait uritii this year is aver so I can switch my kids school...." South Re:trort Community nmunity School 300 National City 13a iie>.ard "=110. Naticnai City.. CA 161 470-6211 ; ...... _ Cesar Chrriez.Eiet?tentary School �.aCI c ;:+ti A?NI1 C:I aot co., nia �a �. Local Fs3ys Schools-,::.:fc •: .,as.r.r.;::-....— e::iirfsss a? S ciiicy5iie:e;e.Y - Eii::??:c 3a>.•. i i•- This establishment is applying for a type 21 license (off sale general/package store) which authorizes the sale of beer, wine and distilled spirits for consumption off the premises where sold. The business is located on the southeast side of Osborn Street (before it turns into National City Blvd to the south) and within 100 feet west of Interstate 5. The area is situated between a large residential community to the east, mixed business district to the south, military installation to the west, and mixed industrial/residential area to the north. Within 50 feet of the business are Shell Gas Station (north), One Ten Liquor and Market (south) which is a type 21 license, a paint and body shop (across/diagonal the street southeast), a residential neighborhood (east). 32nd Street U.S. Naval Station is 1/8th mile west. There is a constant flow of vehicular traffic, including mass transit. Funded by the San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency, Alcohol and Drug Services 303 H Street Suite 390 Chula Vista, CA 91950 Phone: 619.476.9100 Fax: 619.476.9104 www.publicstrategies.org 17 Sough Bay community change project A Program of The Institute For Public Strategies Census Tract Data for 114.00 (ABC, 2009) ..................................... Census :Tract;; 114.00 (Business Address Tract per U.S. Census 2000) 38.00 (Immediate Adjoining Census Tract: North of tract 114.00) 36.03 (Immediate Adjoining Census Tract: Northeast of tract 114.00) 118.01 (Immediate Adjoining Census Tract: East of tract 114.00) 3 5 3 3 5 0 2 2 ...................................... BC Off Sale ....................................:: ...................................... ....................................... ifference ................................ ............................... .............................................. .............................................. (Equation is # of ...............:..:....:....:.................... Allowable<minus # .................................................. ................................................. .................................................. of Actual n) -2 +5 +1 +1 The allowable number of alcohol of sale license for census tract 114 is three (3); however, five (5) off -sale licenses have been issued. The establishment would be the sixth (6) alcohol off -sale license granted for the tract; three (3) more than currently allowed. Pictured Above: 10 Osborn Street, National City, CA 91950 Funded by the San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency, Alcohol and Drug Services 303 H Street Suite 390 Chula Vista, CA 91950 Phone: 619.476.9100 Fax: 619.476.9104 www.publicstrategies.org 18 South Bay: community: change project A Program of The Institute For Public Strategies The closest residence is 33 Osborn Street, approximately 50 feet from the front of the establishment's property. Integrity Charter School (kindergarten — 8th grade) is half a mile away and the closest school to the establishment. Residential Area: 50 feet east of the establishment. i..1•' �•j: {:�. :+ Y�I,.U.y\f•)^Y.•K��;%Y..�....�:I:::�::�i i':..:�}�.?:: iii:"'::C;Y+ {fc�{:'-::-.'-:fri{7.•r•.;?;�x;:•':,•}t�:.:`::y*Al Business: 50 feet south of the establishment. Funded by the San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency, Alcohol and Drug Services 303 H Street Suite 390 Chula Vista, CA 91950 Phone: 619.476.9100 Fax: 619.476.9104 www.publicstrategies.org 19 South Bay; community change project A Program of The Institute For Public Strategies Transportation and Business: Interstate 5 is 100 feet west of establishment. Shell gas station is 50 feet north. Area is busy thorough fare for mass transit, business and personal vehicles traveling between I-5, 32" U.S. Naval Station, industrial area, downtown National City and residential communities. Recommendations: 1. Mandatory RBSS training for store manager and employees. 2. No single serve alcoholic beverages shall be sold. 3. Given the wide availability of liquor stores and distilled spirits available in National City, city may want to consider rejecting CUP for Type 21 license (beer, wine and distilled spirits) but indicate it would consider approving a CUP for a Type 20 license (beer and wine only). Funded by the San Diego County Health and Human Services Agency, Alcohol and Drug Services 303 H Street Suite 390 Chula Vista, CA 91950 Phone: 619.476.9100 Fax: 619.476.9104 www.publicstrategies.org 20 flICOLOT HAM. SSA: NATIONAL CT' vmssto COIN, Of SO MOO, STAMM GAUTOPDM ACCORD/. TOME RAP THEREBF NO. HP PILED IN DPP SPACE OF ME COUNTY DECORS. SR SAN BIE00 SCR COUNTY. aT(urnvznvrstnant EDDY)RRIXIM PRINCIPLE CPO IS MORnn. NATIONAL CM G. 9I930 ZONING. coRuMICIAS ' pir� nz.Rme TYPE OF CW.3,70.110,0 TB ARMS. LOT AP.1-5 DWIARES Di NIECHNGC SIIDP EXISTING RE TOTAL MEDIC OR,w wST FAST TREWS COVERED DA/KV/AY M. . IDEAL OCCITPAPiT LB. PCS I/303SP OF GOSS AREA OF DODO TOIN.PO. OD°REQUIRED TOTPPEIR wN Ir.DE. t; P. COMIDTEnt LWRSCMw4 PLAN. VICINITY MAP PARCEL MAP EXISTING SITE PLAN SITE PLAN SHEET INDEX MOTE. DATh VICwiTY x YnRCSL PLO CODES ETU, LANDSCAPING EXHIBIT A DATE'. Zp11=16 DSP, CUP CASE FILE 7/2011 DIVISION STREET SCOPE OF WORK, THE APPLICANT REOIPEsTs.MODIFICATION TIP M EMIGNO zEM �o aio; ; �°L..;a EInartEPLAN.METOTALARLPORRIaN ROGIVATIBN OF EXISTING MIT. NORM A. SDIMI EXEDRIBR PLEVATIRDS ASP SOWN ON PMNS REQUIDEB NUMIER BF PAAXINO ES MOD, DN TM SITE PLAN ItEMESIONG EXISTING LANDSCAPING EIDD ADDING NEW PIETA. M1SDIGi'M ON COPPCEPTVAL LANDSCAPE'. AN. DEEM nom 1