Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPC Staff Reports CMJF RNM;—e- i INcoRpoRA CITY OF NATIONAL CITY - DEVELOPMENT SERVICES DEPARTMENT 1243 NATIONAL CITY Y BLVD., NATIONAL CITY, CA 91950 PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT Title: Case File No.: Location: Assessor's Parcel No.: Staff report by: Applicant: Property owner: Combined General Plan/ Zoning designation: Adjacent land use/zoning: North: East: South: Wept Environmental review: Item no. 3 December 16, 2013 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THE SALE OF BEER AND WINE FOR OFF -SITE CONSUMPTION AT AN EXISTING MARKET (EL SUPER MARKET) LOCATED AT 1811 "L" AVENUE. 2013-27 CUP Southeast corner of East 18th Street and "L" Avenue. 561-210-32 Martin Reeder, AICP Rode! Chalabi Khalid Jabro MXC-1 (Minor Mixed -Use Corridor) Residential across East 18th Street / MXC-1 Multi -Family Residential/ MXC-1 Single -Family Residential / RM-2 (Multi -Unit Res.) Church across"L"Avenue / MXC-1 Not a project per CEQA BACKGROUND Site Characteristics The project location is El Super Market, a neighborhood market in a small shopping center at the southeast corner of East 18t" Street and "L" Avenue in the Minor Mixed -Use Corridor (MXC-1) zone. The existing market is approximately 1,200 square feet in size. Other businesses in the center include a Laundromat and a smoothie/frutas business. The area is mostly adjacent to residential uses, with a church across "L" Avenue. El Super Market has been in business for several years, but is now under new ownership. Proposed Use The applicant is requesting to sell beer and wine for off -site consumption between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m. seven days a week. Beer and white wine would be stored in a cooler located in the rear of the store. Red wine would be stored on a shelf, nearby the cooler. The submitted application also included a petition in support of alcohol sales, which was signed by 192 people (attached). Analysis Section 18.30.050 of the National City Land Use Code allows for off -site alcohol sales with an approved Conditional Use Permit (CUP). Requirements for the CUP include a community meeting and distance requirements. Community Meeting Pursuant to Section 18.30.050 (C), a community meeting was held Wednesday, November 27, 2013 from 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. at the National City Chamber of Commerce. The applicant has stated that no-one was in attendance Distance Requirements Chapter 18.030.050 (D) requires that businesses that sell alcohol as a principal use maintain a 660-foot distance from schools. However, sales of alcohol in this case would be accessory to a market, and would thus not be subject to this requirement. Although there is a church across the street, the Land Use Code does not mention churches with regard to distance requirements. Furthermore, the applicant has stated that the church has not objected to the issuance of a CUP for alcohol sales. The nearest school is Las Palmas Elementary School, located approximately 1,900 feet away. Alcohol catian Per California State Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC), there is currently one other off - sale permit issued in this census tract (121.01), which is El Super (supermarket) located at 3007 Highland Avenue. The other El Super is located almost a mile away. The nearest off -sale outlet is 7-Eleven, located at 1601 East 18`h Street (in Census Tract 220), approximately al/4-mile away. Census tract 121.01 includes the area of the City between East 18th Street and East 32"d Street. The eastern boundary of the tract is the golf course. The western boundary is "L" Avenue, extending to "J" Avenue south of East 24th Street, extending to Highland Avenue south of East 30th Street. The attached census tract map shows the location of the subject tract. ABC recommends that a total of one off -sale alcohol permit be issued in this census tract, where one exists. This would be an increase of 100%. However, if the City approves a CUP for an additional license, ABC can still issue an alcohol license subject to additional findings. Police Department comments Crime statistics provided by the Police Department (PD) indicate that the reporting area (Beat 23) had a 2011 crime rate of 108%, below the 120% considered to be a high crime area. PD provided a Risk Assessment report, which assigns points based on the type of business, license concentration, and calls for service (among others) and ranks the business according to potential risk (low, medium, or high). In this case, El Super Market received a score of 15, which would indicate a medium risk. However, PD also had concerns related to water pipes (considered drug paraphernalia) that were on sale at the store. A condition has been added to require compliance with Chapter 18.30.230, which regulates tobacco specialty stores. No comments have been received from the Institute for Public Strategies at this time, although they are aware of the application. Conditions of Approval Standard Conditions of Approval have been included with this permit, as well as conditions specific to off -sale alcohol sales per Council policy (alcohol sales incidental to other sales items, hours of operation, RBSS training, etc.). A condition is also included that limits the alcohol display area to the rear cooler and shelving areas, prohibiting alcohol storage near the store entrance. No other Departments provided comment. Summary El Super Market has been licensed at this location since 2007. The subject census tract is not currently over -concentrated with of sale alcohol licenses, although ;ccuancc of another license would result in a 100% increase in off -sale outlets and in an over - concentration situation. However, the other license in this census tract is almost a mile away and has little influence on the area surrounding the subject area. Conditions would ensure that, if approved, the sale of alcohol for off. site consumption would not have any negative impacts on the surrounding community. RECOMMENDATION 1. Approve 2013-27 CUP subject to the conditions listed below, based on attached findings; or 2. Deny 2013-27 CUP based on attached findings/findings to be determined by the Planning Commission; or 3. Continue the item to a specific date. ATTACHMENTS 1. Recommended Findings for Approval/Denial 2. Recommended Conditions 3. Location Map 4. Census Tract Map and Police Beat Map 5. Alcoholic Beverage Control Risk Assessment 5. Community Meeting Information 7. Petition in support of alcohol sales 8. Public Hearing Notice (Sent to 724 property owners and occupants) 9. Applicant's Plans (Exhibit A, case file no. 2013-27 CUP, dated 10/2412013) MARTIN REEDER, AICP Principal Planner RECOMMENDED FINDINGS FOR APPROVAL 2013-27 CUP, 1811 "L" Avenue 1 That the site for the proposed use is adequate in size and shape, since the proposed use is an accessory use to an existing neighborhood market in an existing commercial center and the sale of beer and wine is not expected to increase the demand for parking on the property. 2. That the site has sufficient access to streets and highways that are adequate in width and pavement type to carry the volume and type of traffic generated by the proposed use, since East 18th Street is classified as a collector street in the Circulation Element, and the sale of beer and wine for off -site consumption is not expected to result in an appreciable increase in traffic. 3. That the proposed use will not have an adverse effect upon adjacent or abutting properties, since the proposed use is compatible with other similar businesses located nearby and within a quarter -mile of the property; and since the proposed use will be subject to conditions that limit the sale of alcohol and restrict the hours that it will be available. 4. That the proposed use is deemed essential and desirable to the public convenience and welfare, since it will contribute to the continued viability of a neighborhood market, an established and allowed use in the applicable mixed -use zone. 5. That public convenience and necessity may be served by a proposed use of the property for the retail sales of alcoholic beverages pursuant to law. RECOMMENDED FINDING FOR DENIAL 2013-27 CUP, 1811 °L"Avenue 1. That the proposed use is not deemed essential and desirable to the public convenience and welfare, since issuance of another off -sale license would result in an over -concentration of off -sale alcohol licenses in census tract 121.01 in which the subject property is located. 2. The proposed use is not deemed essential and desirable to the public convenience and welfare since beer and wine is currently offered at an outlet within a quarter -mile of the subject property. 3. That public convenience and necessity may not be served by a proposed use of the property for the retail sales of alcoholic beverages pursuant to law. RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL 2013-27 CUP, 1811 "L" Avenue General 1. This Conditional Use Permit authorizes the sale of beer and wine for off -site consumption at an existing market located at 1811 "L" Avenue. Plans submitted for permits associated with this project shall conform to Exhibit A, case file no. 2013-27 CUP, dated 10/24/2013. 2. This permit shall become null and void if not exercised within one year after adoption of the Resolution of approval unless extended according to procedures specified in the Municipal Code. 3. This permit shall expire if the use authorized by this resolution is discontinued for a period of 12 months or longer. This permit may also be revoked, pursuant to provisions of the Land Use Code, if discontinued for any lesser period of time. 4. This Conditional Use Permit may be revoked if the Permittee is found to be in violation of Conditions of Approval. 5. Before this Conditional Use Permit shall become effective, the applicant and the property owner both shall sign and have notarized an Acceptance Form, provided by the Planning Department, acknowledging and accepting all conditions imposed upon the approval of this permit. Failure to return the signed and notarized Acceptance Form within 30 days of its receipt shall automatically terminate the Conditional Use Permit. The applicant shall also submit evidence to the satisfaction of the Executive Director that a Notice of Restriction on Real Property is recorded with the County Recorder. The applicant shall pay necessary recording fees to the County. The Notice of Restriction shall provide information that conditions imposed by approval of the Conditional Use Permit are binding on all present or future interest holders or estate holders of the property. The Notice of Restriction shall be approved as to form by the City Attorney and signed by the Executive Director prior to recordation. Planning 6. The sale of alcoholic beverages shall be limited to between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 10:00 p.m. seven days a week. 7. All beer and wine products shall be stored in the rear cooler or rear shelving areas. No alcohol products shall be stored in proximity to the store entrance. 8. The sale of beer or malt beverages in quantities of quarts, 22 ounce, 32 ounce, 40 ounce, or similar size containers is prohibited. 9. No beer products shall be sold of less than manufacturer's pre -packaged three -pack quantities of 24 ounce cans per sale. There shall be no sale of single cans or bottles. 10. Wine shall not be sold in containers of less than 750 milliliters. The sale of wine with an alcoholic content greater than 15% by volume is prohibited. 11. Flavored malt beverages, also known as premium malt beverages and flavored malt coolers, and sometimes commonly referred to as wine coolers, may be sold only by four -pack or other manufacturer's pre -packaged multi -unit quantities. 12. The consumption of alcoholic beverages is prohibited on the subject premises, and on all parking lots and outbuildings and any property or adjacent property under the control of the Permittee. 13. All cups and containers shall be sold at or above prevailing prices and in their original multi -container packages of no fewer than 12, and no cups and containers shall be given free of charge. 14. Ice may be sold only at or about prevailing prices in the area and in quantities of not less than three pounds per sale. Ice shall not be provided free of charge. 15. The Permittee shall post signs in compliance with the requirements and specifications of subsection B of section 10.30.070 on each exterior wall of the licensed premises that faces a vehicle parking lot, to read as follows: "WARNING It is unlawful to drink an alcoholic beverage or to possess an open alcoholic beverage container in public or in a public parking lot. NCMC 10.30.050 and 10.30.060." 16. Containers of alcoholic beverages may not be stored on the premises, after being sold to patrons, for the purpose of later consumption. 17. Exterior advertising and signs of all types, promoting or indicating the availability of alcoholic beverages, including advertising/signs directed to the exterior from within, are prohibited. Interior displays of alcoholic beverages and signs, which are clearly visible to the exterior, shall constitute a violation of this condition. 18. The quarterly gross sales of alcoholic beverages shall not exceed the gross sales of all other commodities during the same period. The Permittee shall at all times keep records which reflect separately the gross sales of alcoholic beverages and the gross sales of all other items. Said records shall be kept no less frequently than on a quarterly basis and shall be made available to the City Finance Department and any Peace Officer of the California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control upon demand. 19. Every employee of the Permittee, including ownership and management, shall receive Responsible Beverage Service and Sales (RBSS) training, including all owners, and managers. The RBSS training must be certified by the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC). Proof of completion of an approved RBSS program must be provided prior to commencing alcohol sales. As part of the RBSS training, the Permittee shall make available a domestic violence training session as provided by the Institute of Public Strategies. 20. Display of tobacco -related products shall comply with Chapter 18.30.230 related to tobacco specialty stores. Police 21. Permittee shall comply with all regulatory provisions of the Business and Professions Code that pertain to the sale, display and marketing or merchandising of alcoholic beverages. l lioesPerk get® and Sweedviivbor , ..wqyPtM 10,41 988-2006M¢ safmo' neoala I sAUn9 reqq��rvae a�1sA QpSlrwtaflB C aalon.Jy� er t °edam mep tne.! ;Oaecpen• l V205"Mk rents reserved, tairrEct, nd MIAViE 3 fdVRIJ=me iredeFariiarof MA rttfe fesquue ele Mee Natheiereence.ex. 'All riots ni eirved. Tele Atris an :Tetelies Wirth Aiika are iraeranarks of Tele761a5,:erc. City of National City Beat 23 Source: Microsoft Mappoint NCPD CAU, 4/18/07 EL SUPER MARKET 1811 "L" Avenue National City, CA 91950 November 15, 2013 Dear Neighbor, El Super Market located at 1811 "L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 is a family owned and operated market. It is now under new ownership and management. When we took over the ownership of the market about three months we joined National City chamber of Commerce; we improved on it; and we also established cordial and meaningful relations with our customers, the church, and the neighboring community. We are totally dedicated, committed, and determined to provide our customers with excellent service and merchandise at reasonable and competitive prices. Upon the request of our customers through their signed petition, who urged us to apply for beer and wine, we responded and have applied for that license with both the Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) and National City Development Services Division. The application is now in process by both ABC and National City. We are sending you this letter to seek your support and also to invite you to a community meeting which will be held on Wednesday, November 27, 2013 at National City Chamber of Commerce located at 901 National City Blvd., National City, CA 91950 between the hours of 9Am — 12 noon. Your presence and support will be greatly appreciated. We look forward to your participation and support. Thank you. Sincerely, Rudy Owner, El Super Market EL SUPER MARKET 1811 "L" Avenue National City, CA 91950 November 27, 2013 Mr. Martin Reeder, AICP Principal Planner, Planning Division 1243 National City Blvd. National City, CA 91950 Hello Martin, Re: Community Meeting— Case No. 2013-27 CUP The community meeting was scheduled today between the hours of 9AM-12 noon at the National City Chamber of Commerce conference room. I arrived here at 8:45AM to prepare for the meeting. During those scheduled three hours no one showed up at the meeting. So at 12 noon I left and notified the Chamber of my departure. Ms. Irma Islas, the Chamber's Membership Coordinator can attest to the no-show, my arrival, and departure from the chamber. I was somewhat surprised that no one showed up at the meeting despite the fact that both the property owners and the residents within 660 feet radius were notified by mail. Here is the break -down of the mail sent to notify the under mentioned of the meeting: 186 letters to the property owners 533 letters to the residents Letter to the National City Police Dept. Letter to the Institute of Public Strategy Letter to Neighborhood Services Division Letter to the National City Chamber of Commerce Letter to Sweetwater Union High school Letter to National School District Moreover, there are 336 signed and submitted petitions in support of El Super Market to obtain its beer and wine license to serve its customers' necessity and convenience. In view of the above, it clearly appears that no one is objecting to El Super Market obtaining its beer & wine license; otherwise those protesting would have shown at the scheduled community meeting. This concludes my report. I also sincerely hope that the Planning Division will approve the CUP to granting El Super Market's request for the beer & wine license. Thank you for your input and cooperation in this effort, which are highly appreciated. Sincerely, S fo Thad, Ph.D. uper Market P .i_ (619)70l - 6-0t1ci NATIONAL CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT ALCOHOL BEVERAGE CONTROL RISK ASSESSMENT DATE: 11/11/13 BUSINESS NAME: El Super Market ADDRESS: 1206 E. 18th Street, National City, CA 91950 OWNER NAME: Rode! M. Chalabi DOB: 10/28/1985 OWNER ADDRESS: 1811 "L" Avenue, National City CA 91950 (add additional owners on page 2) I. Type of Business ❑ Restaurant (1 pt) X Market (2 pts) ❑ Bar/Night Club (3 pts) H. Hours of Operation ❑ Daytime hours (1 pt) ❑ Close by 10pm (2 pts) X Close after 10pm (3 pts) III. Entertainment ❑ Music (1 pt) ❑ Live Music (2 pts) ❑ Dancing/Live Music (3 pts) IV. Crime Rate ❑ Low (1pt) X Medium (2 pts) ❑ High (3 pts) V. Alcohol Businesses per Census Tract ❑ Below (1 pt) ❑ Average (2 pts) X Above (3 pts) Notes: Census Tract 121.01 allows 2 on -sale and 1 off sale licenses the census tract currently has 3 on -sale and 1 off -sale type — the census tract is currently over -saturated. 11 calls for service, none directly associated with the market. Medium Risk. Owner had water pipes in the store upon inspection on 11/11/13 see attached pictures. Worker explained they were Hookah pipes. Revised: 7/11 1 of 2 National City Police Department VI. Calls for Service at Location (for previous 6 months) X Below (1 pt) ❑ Average (2 pts) ❑ Above (3 pts) VII. Proximity Assessment (1/4 mile radius of location) 0 Mostly commercial businesses (1 pt) 0 Some businesses, some residential (2 pts) X Mostly residential (3 pts) VIII. Owner(s) records check X No criminal incidents (1 pt) 0 Minor criminal incidents (2 pts) C Multiple/Major criminal incidents (3 pts) ABC Risk Assessment it Low Risk ( 12pts or less) Medium Risk (13— 18pts) High Risk (19 — 24pts) Total Points 15 OWNER NAME: Rodel M. Chalabi DOB: 10I28/1985 OWNER ADDRESS: 1811 "L" Avenue, National City CA 91950 OWNER NAME: DOB: OWNER ADDRESS: Recommendation: Over -saturated census tract, 2 on -sale and 1 off -sale allowed. The census tract currently has 3 on -sale and 1 off -sale. A site inspection showed that there were water pipes on the premises (drug paraphernalia). The owner and worker stated they were Hookah pipes, there is no difference between bongs and Hookah water pipes. Completed by: Graham Young, Lt. Badge ID: 365 2 of Name 4 cJf.' ..,1"mot -r. 2- Signatur Address .2O39 L Qui / C C, Name ti 5\; 4.5 Address t oZ. f� Name ct.,52,p1 PAY€4/0.— Address C3 ' P 5 1 t jV • C Name Nat c)Johriere-4.— Signature Signa ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name 6 4a JQO 14,1)( Address 500, L. AV. Name :::' Address (J' 7 ► ' Ci '' late d I IL_ Name ikA t' 13 6ik i4[ C Signature4%-4 Address 17 ` _ C., fJ ,.- t `-'�, r I ate Name Ht " at r Signa •�a�rr Address t 0 1- CkV ✓ 41 l 5 0 ' Date T. ,D--0 ` l j NameCart-0 S CcA0.1 - SignatuCli Address lt'' j t , N C t t r_ 0 Date g - o ' 13 Name cam El 0 Signatu Address bt T u Z/ N G y' Date43 Date 0A-e/ Date`s Signature .1' Date S . 2.0-n Signature Date 5-2c -t�J Signature Address 'NG Pc.ie, LAk tod.c1. 0;(11 cfir ett q,5t' Date -- - a--13 Name C f .Cc y7-7/gam,, t Address Name rnr� Address { Ae-'k-f - Signature � Date Signature ilvmy Date j'r' ,-t 21 ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned to apply and obtain th totally dedicated and our needs and cony Name 5 customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request e beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet enience. Address ir‘1/5-9 t revz- Name 7uVat#M Address `-7506 Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address Signature Date q(C% Date 69 Signature Sign • re p—,3 O ► ec4z1 t Name L V 1b. 17"-- Address '2., G Putt / 12.Qe1/( e J Address 8 q 3 + 1,D $' . 4J Date Name Li V Signature Address- �~-y.�,� Cam. Name -,k3�j Nam}(1� Signature Address g 19 c...l4,tt Name R C:k tc' Le, U Signature AddressZ 7/8 t/ G l t..e Name Date UP Date 9: j- 13 Signature /I ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name4)IcLY)o./ C9C1114Signatureli Addresi5 /1' NameLI of it7s- Address ( 3 ()-- Name kirk C IZAQIN sit Address ° _ " , 1,9 kIN e Name Clefaccto Giutmar Address 1 L4 1 1, S kt'ee, Name ..1,C --t E €- i I (e Address L Name Hof,\ Dat Signature C INVD - Signature Signature Signature Signatur Address 3 44 exi\ `bi9b Cat; (\04rlh 3 6 S1- Date / 1 1/3 Name C (XLCO L- Signature Jc2 ` 4-1 1111(L Date f fAUL Date att Date c7 gg'� Address Name Address Name Mte.5 U4 M\ Addre 3 Dwa) c ! (0)f Signature Signature Name Signature Address n ,U iJ O- ' MiTIV4-63rtglq k 00 Name [Nc.61, gignature Address] Vlh- Date f{ • t t 5 Name Address Signature Date ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name e [ I GtJ Address ct Name-"Ni Address 1) ? 3 1 c Name /':,`'e Signature Address 9 2 p 6AI . 4J / 9/7 —Date 003V7 Name W! 5 (/�r,'`� 7 (N es - iV .Lac r -i (N 4.4, l } { ate q( f. Signature �* � jtt, Address aik 1470 Art- Ve, Ua fie.") a 1 C r C& of p, Date 9 5 //2 Name 0 cl t / -; Z., i zc rr nSignature . Address [ 7 W VE Mi e t o > tz. C. e l Dated ` 941413 Name t(A V (f U 41 I t ti Signature �61 Address Date Name r �c 1 j ,. V t (l et q 0 0 tirliie) t Name N ! CO%{; mar i Address i3tg, I1 St aft-22 alai Name SAOLX)6L,10,S. Address i Name Signature (2q/Viii3 Signature (1(0/-e, MO i' i c; + to7Da - -/ 3 Signature '"'` i Dat ` Signature c 4 (1 Address 1 I o 1 cv+w. iNI C t ---4-1 Name `' P"A.12: Signature Address RNA E.. [T SM. kSiterk o C:=1-[ t Date ci fr I i j Name ri- (V)kY(-' Signature Address c �5 P 1 Q. Date 9 (s/ Quo Date Clicirg ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name Address Name Address 2..4, 2 ( .14,b44-161:) Name ' \ k c oW Address 110 c-i E Name sEfiKr..Effilf Ak441)$ Address Name 'lit . /- Address ` [ 3 Name Address __ 3 Name 5 ;4s- ?Eary Address Name f i�, Address 'bot65 �g 4� 0,�7 �JQr a Name Gib/in." I A7 4/- Address / (/ 41Ii £/ 2°ti CAVE Cite Signature' ate /3 r/3 Signature q Lq-5 Date ._ . Signature 0 Signature , s.. , ,,d Date `c -I/ 3 Name 4 - Signatures — rr Address O NW-fan/al 1 t Date Name 4/ci1t// /d f t9 Address I 59 0 N 4 J o rf -4 10 Name Address ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name c o, l 0 i� A...t 0.44_0,5 Signature dlop-4::, ' Jew Address i2-gr=1 G - 1. 81'0 s _ X114c!9 L1ANL- C e Date C5 3` 1 °f t 13 NameOet,S`61(6 9 Ve Signature Address 1%0' l bai 1 'ST . t1l Cli14 Name A a ctai 05 Signature th- i c t qara,Vii3 i Address i I ) , Cli1flri,A ( Date ‘a, 11 1.. I Name ille",6 61,e4V Az Sif gnature / ty Address JZ2J X / 7 T 9 d "7 1sfroz ethiDate f i? Name « U L f p ,.A f 1/4 Address /ate , Name L 9/? / ,c' „ Address Name - CFPA Signature (F57- A" T,O n c I '7 Name IN- Gicterea. Address J3 Name L�(®�,�,�' Signature �'�J- y. Address 0 psi - L. e' Date � %� �3 Name t Signature Address 9 ? \ W ^i SW, CkY)i�'i ‘ Date <C'10 ` G Date allei er/5S" Date ?' 'F //-7 Name2tr u-"f, Address ` o �✓' 4 '`h , Date / r Name �d ��'! Signature -''� Address Date 127 ; } Signature ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Nigne itf 1kM vv;t Address 2-41 11 (,S4" 91 t +i d3 l vCl pf e d Date v--IT-13 NaBte rest A'1 Le `J-t tot. Address.17 ?) 1. Ave. */ 5 Nitte Ltll5 V-PI( 'c1e. Address 14910 L. 14 d$ : Na ions1 ci* N t1ne r is/.. 64.4.1r;. a Name r flu ' Signature f � i a n at igf.a Address /ram' ? (7 L. A v L' "wig*,1C / �C ate $-15"« 13_ Nate tC. C.t 7 l L1 ,_ Net v ++t.lt o Signature • Address 17"'3 L. v4P1. C it) 'r1i'Date 45 Nate PPTRI 1< LJ .+C.- Signature 46- .-. Address t 1- Ave-l..-O e e..t 7 C,. — t Mate • t '' 3 Na a t- t t..1 i /W r tp 11 Signatures Address 2 3 1il - L.- t- C. 41- i�t_t. ' I 'ct D .9 - IS'-- 13 Na[ie ,f oS$. 2F ijs Signature Address L.7/y Ai. $r ,t Nitne P r Aw t rAti 'b Ad• Tess 7973 L- 4tlr As— pr/ Nate Al e. jf r. f g oh (a 5 Address 111.6( E ms ' Apt 2 ■Ilb 4 4t4 Sea Date $_ 15- 13 Date A-- 1 13 Signature'`' �y Signature Date pis -- Address Ne Address :OE24'Q XvP 0449„sq .Citii)4I / 'as 4 Av. me C f Signature `` Signature Fe..."•? o Daterp, - / - 13 Signature Li1-5G Z. trlYr re 3. 10150 Signature Signature Date g.. 1 — I .? 40,70 Date 2- f - 1 }� Date eVi ^i 3 ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service • Id merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. NaLe T l4 Ida& ritia. Li. (44 41 Signature Address (4 14ine ;Fist PiAlt 914 Address _ i L N'Aiie ' .Aia,0.t. #A INrrt-.t.. VNL*' Address 1 f t'.. 5" ,5 . kV tJ t t.' t Name brose Go ncJe Address 102i E Jeri t) va t C +9 CA 9 J ef5 Date _BAVA5._ Nam 4 ; yyy34M. -llt �Signatu Address C c .3t,��t1 I G e �`T=- Date l Name s i Zoe -c Signature ; g fP Address C, _` ' Name 14AViki C e/t- Date'/' l r.sc Signature C "' Dat "II, Date Signature Date Address ,. a5\A- Pso-fr-ts ' 14, f q Is -Nate e o {3 Name004744.a` Signature Address 'S`/ r, ft& C 1610/1'� Date ,1 Signature Name t�l;L't r�Gt Signature Address Name Aciveitos S. (r 161 Address Signature E lit\ glatSV AkfidikiG Name 00.4, ock -- SIgnatur Address i 3 % e- Name.E 01/4(.. V f h iPo Address 11 0 1- oty Date E►//' ( 0( 3 SignatureG."G Date'`" :// f us jam? ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service an• it erchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name INTSUnitt CALC-Ifthos Signature Address V ,0 L" c kc (F C ` 61,E�t : Name (%rlA.Pl ,P biSignature Address ?)15 G ' ✓ if-W,c { f Name ova. Enviot uu(Avf ) Address Name Reeca& FNww.a.Y+ Signature so - Signature Address 110 ii • '1 0'►, ' = t [ rra6 Name Address Name /+'l. +2.f-1 fir/ 0414 C Signature Signature Address . 112 N Dot +j • lk-3 .0 Name Sis,r \ - Signatu Address t6QV Ave,CV • GACt 4 6,47 Name Awl- ,(4144 Address \ \1I* La ,J Ct c Name 4 {,t t U l.. 4, 4 vutte,cr-e, Signature Signature Addresses ,, _ • Name .b4 rt kk , i Address 11-`L. 0 A{- rvv% .RA Name Address Name / f Address f f q t dire 4'19 Signature Date r_ J 613 Da e 4: ;7 LJ Date 5/ (oL: Signature ate r Date It 1,1,4( Date Date (- Signature Date 1%-43 ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER. Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name Address Name Name Name Address Name Sign KAIA CA .9Pc5o Lacs 2 3 15 w p. 6'L ,VI C / i1 r Address Address iL U4,044 •r { 1-j Name f'U ZS or �j Address W20 1. ro tonal Name0f Address Name Address 04;r J st ht--X`evif Y Name' cr �� d Addresi', a 2_. e ate Name ' �._.� ./ Signature./ !%�[I► Addres Name t p Address t 7 4-' LggI I S ? Date toe � f -3 Signature � 1113 Signature Signa Signature to 8 —/71. l3 ,a Signature 01 ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name NislAttiviwoF.� Signature Address i `1 I j kAviwuri. ilotvd (1,1 , C,11SQ Date - Name 9- pW AJA-kti Signature Address < - 11-tfri IMOMIL (. [ Ty CA `/%Date Address 7,4ff1/ eozirg nrrilms.f1.4 / 9 /' �_ Date Name Ay).0 f /friji4 Name i` e,44. nr-gt -d —C Address /' j(r £ Name gUc3.-(�:f.,,�‘;'1A- Address Name Address Name 0-- Address ( 5 Name Address gap L- aye) C. Signature (,tf Signature Name Address Name Address Name Addres Name Address 714 LA Itoci efkOs6 k ae Signatur CO— q i to t• 1') Signature Date l 103 K.,\C C 0 [pc) S. Date cic I 10,013 ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER. Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Nam Address t 7 l' 1( Name UPOIA'` Address Q'., 0 t~ k"a-5 Address {C: Name f, t .�. �Z Signature Address ! 7 J ... e.,s, ,.-- c Da = Z 1-r y Name c vkmay( e t Address (C 41' y (twic tr', s Date .)j (1. NameRl I Cl Signature Address`t Name r/r.(t› Date Date I Signatu Signature Signature ' 124744 Address ` . > - { 7- - Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address Nte-,Nek.a.s rk! y E • 2041\ �T 1V cd Signature Signature Signature Signature Signature Eit Date Date *''3 Date $ - Signature'' ti Date ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totPlly dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name e/44,0,c eokrzot - Address Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address SignatnreLl1144. Signature .w M a ° gSkllkvfir- 71. ir t A Signature Signature Date Name ir k...-P01, ; �77 Signature . Address `)b6 ' r �' Y` t � 77J /Date ' 22 Name \ } K (2- G Mgnat Address r) C\ ffkk) li Name 1 5 5e Signa r Address fly 2 & 5 - C .(A 4(cis0 Date 0~2 3 (3 Name Q -' `�q Address t D/ / t 1 i �l%O Date 47- 1 5 . Name jc& FOAM)Signature L l zo-- Address t e6L NS G Ni(„ ..iona - CA (i Date 5- .Z. 1 Name e 'Z.j;Qonct Signature 1v\Q e0002... Address k9Sb 11.--Pig -ej4ycq0 Date 8 5" 13 Name CC. (Au SOc.CvNo Signature Erralrel 0(Lae Address t ib li..1 IV ` c-,V.1 Date a ""'..3 —13 Signature 6z ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ETSI JPFR. Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs anti convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. Name -Lon c1yN"`ipiti )crt cz Signature Address 2 2. Ott cp I) Name Signature Address 87, .- r '-- Name C� 4 CerN r'7 Address \ Name'r Address Name Address Name vt Address C20 ~ 6+ + ._ '1 "<-'J Date Ei - g-j •-- / r Name 14 A in ffl / 0 r 1— Signature L fE 7--- Address 1`` i a No;oryi, < I' i C i' T y /I75 Date s-2 2' 13 Name ft2t V `C"4- Signature 6(I 01 Address ?AL A v' C q t 6 Date ! to - ( Name � ,--- Signaturey. Address3 T T , Date P'6 Siguatu Address /p,' O " 0' Date Name j[' (AQt c,i3 Signature Address (AXL1 i 2 t Sl Date Name ` C- RTC CA Signature / $5 )e Address Date 27 15 EAR MARKET 1811"L" Av nu , National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and corVenience. Name JoP7 C. O- Signature :e4, -'I- Address Si if 14c/'. 17" /1/-C- 7 Date r�' f.2 Name Loi" :. eit & ` Signature cNod t, - Address '.Z' L Pal 0 i. ,914)1 Oifb, q2-15�1 Date 6129i1 3 Name F a n. -%. cal?-- Signature (---,,q 491- J c 4 Address (1' .,. (-.. 4 lie k1c. )" ©I q ( (i 4r I r- Z / 3 Name' ) w cj .: tO V Signature Address 130{0 '6 ! s'1 Nrkhonal C.' Name 62 I t:' Address 'i t. Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Address Name Date Signature Kett Date `'t'iatb a Address 5- 6 6 Name Mz ' L. ,\AA.fe,AR.4 Address Name Address 1 -� 1 3k Signature lam" Date 01..3d .)t 1 Name Address Name ELSUPER MARKET 1811"L" Avenue, National City, CA 91950 TO: ABC & National City Police We, the undersigned customers of ELSUPER Market do hereby fully support its owner's request to apply and obtain the beer & wince license to serve our needs and convenience. The owner is totally dedicated and committed to provide us with excellent service and merchandise to meet our needs and convenience. ,� { Name 5 l Pam' -� Signature - ---� Address /7 t5 ,l'iG / /701/4' - -air)' Date--C, f Name , � 4 t 4 Address VVk 1 G Name Fr.,. L 16C C4200,14 Signature Address II 0 .*... d 1 + 1t. s' VL*. 'i b 1a1. c r 4/. Date e....i•—ti Name .'lit VEno* ry Address 17 £ 5 t, - ttt (_ Name et Vet, t4,d, c r Address (;- ¶ Z 1 (U LA Address .c,,-,� Name kt...4.$4,4 Address '2 Z 7 Itind4_4Sduvao. Signature Date 411.. Signature Signature Signature /E- Name Add Name Address Name Address cam-- 5 A), cm - Signature Signature Datetr- Date`' Signature S Date 1-13-L3 Name F cw(" .- Signature.�- Address N0 j "AS Si- t1 C Date q C:ALifO,R:NtANANIONAL err" '41%5) I357cOAPOBA CITY OF NATIONAL CITY - PLANNING DEPARTMENT 1243 NATIONAL CITY BLVD., NATIONAL CITY, CA 91950 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR THE SALE OF BEER AND WINE FOR OFF -SITE CONSUMPTION AT AN EXISTING MARKET (EL SUPER MARKET) LOCATED AT 1811 "L" AVENUE. CASE FILE NO.: 2013-27 CUP APN: 561-210-32 The National City Planning Commission will hold a public hearing after me hour of 6:00 p.m. Monday, December 16th, 2013, in the City Council Chambers, Civic Center, 1243 National City Boulevard, National City, California, on the proposed request. (Applicant: Rode! Chalabi) The applicant is requesting to sell beer and wine for off -site consumption from an existing neighborhood market (El Super Market) between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m. seven days a week. Information is available for review at the City's Planning Department, Civic Center. Members of the public are invited to comment. Written comments should be received by the Planning Division on or before 12:00 p.m., December 16th, 2013, who can be contacted at 619-336-4310 or planning a nationalcitvcagov if you challenge the nature of the proposed action in court, you may be limited to raising only thocc issues you cr c_orneor a else raised at the public hearing described in this notice, or in written correspondence delivered to the Planning Commission at, or prior to, the public hearing. 4.1ATtONAf CI I ANNIA,li'DEIDAPTIVINIT BRAD RAULSTON Executive Director